vol. I pars III

vol. I pars III vol. I pars III

capricorn.bc.edu
from capricorn.bc.edu More from this publisher
31.05.2013 Views

Elenchorum fed "6 poflesfion€,Sd fi * r & n5 eo quid ad mala dicitur,vtaliquox fimuh&ficuteftduftum ru:pBidmalorueft,fed nohoc noftru)hiceftpater,&erttuus,crgo. malorumtpropterid igiturqS eft pater tuus.Almdexeplu eft « fa rtquomodo^riamfimpfrapx »ofis,&ert,»o«n« nuraeruseft ^ . ~> • • c if multus,qanumer' eft multitude q paret, quanq, connngitfortaflfc dg & ^ nu eft bonueflealiquid malorumdux ali0j€ %fi omnisnumerusg phcitcr,non tamenm oratione muit'&paucUsfimul.O£siftielenhacked magis,fiquod macipm, Cni f0luuot j ,qn dicif.q,hatedifpoftfit bonu mah : fortafle aut ne'qj tio accidcrit, & q> non fitneceffaria, ficyno enim fi bonu eft,cthuius, & q, accident huic Socrati.q? interbonuhuiusfimulrvemm neqj rogauerisdeeo.&ignorasipfumcr hominedicereanimaliudTejdi partequamterrogafti deeo, fednS ciimultiplicitenno.n.fialiquid ignorasipsuex ptequa e Socrates, fignificamus aufercntes.,id dicit ne q; ee" interrogatii deeo eft kmgt *• tnultipliciter: nam dddiniidiu ''" neq;nece(Iariu,&ficacciditSocra- dicentes verfus da mihi,Ilida fix ti fi ingrediafdomu, cp ego cogno- gnificamus:vtjiram pande dca. fcaipmm q? fit Socrates,& ignprem de eo difpofitione,cj accidit ei: ficqj Defallaciaacctdmtis,faljatjuerefyonfione eft ipfum ingredi domu, & fie et eft adillam. Cap. 4. rnfiolatetisq7fciamus& nefciamUS COntradiclionesvero, qua; fi- ipfum.Quida virautQ?que"putoin unt reb 9 fbphifticis,fiint, quia nuere Platone)e c| cofradixit his elfi contradidtio cuiufq;, q? eftfm acci- chisexeo,q7dixit,q> n5 fit impoffidens, eft vna cade" cotradidio in (e, bile q? fcia vna rf ex quada parte, & qe ex eflentiaei 9 , q> eft fin accides, ignore ex alicJgte.Sedhac cotradihoceftjqjfciatqjhocnontillisfem ction^impeditbreuitasplurib' mo per,neq;omnibus,qm q?eftfmac- dis.quoru vn 9 eft,cjaimpoflibileeft cidesinuenit v rei aucin minoritcm I porejautinpauciorifijbieclo^utin accides, ficutefermodicctispcedes, M pauco vtriu£q ;.C6tradic~tio aut pro hie e tu',& hie e pater,ergo e tu 9 papria iftiusloci eft,qii dicitur,q> hoc ter, &noc" tu 9 , qm cotradiiftio hui' fit res,q accidit, & no fit neceflario, e, q?dixit,q> accident tibi,c_ hoc aut eft manifeftu,qnaduerte- tu musad el£chos,qui funt fm accides, ficutcfteoru diclfi, tu talisignoras, g»intedo teinterrogare, qnautinterrogauero te ipfiim, tu noueris il- 9 ,fitpf,&n5eex j>te,qe tu'.cotra dicTiioautopj q?fit vFis&contineS totafalfitateinuetam in pmi/Tafalfa,&hoc,quiaiainueniut j in vnaea de pmifla diuerfi modi falfitacis, & lud, ergo tuignoraueris&noueris oportet vt cotradicliofitcontradiillud fimuh&ficuteftdiclunoftru, cT:io,^dinidatoesmodos, g,funtco tu tal is cognofcis Socrate, & no co- clufiomsfal&.Pretereaqcotradicie gnofos q? ipfe ingrediat^domu ,& fyll'o ducetiad impoilibilelitigiofo, hieingredienseft Socrates,ficqjtu qn(ciucrit?cfone,gputauitargues quod

Liber Seciindus 170 ft(itimporfibHis,eflepo{fIbilern,de: itruxit,q? ilia fit ars fyllogifini elenchi,qm elenchns,qaem intenderat, no perficit*,& hoc,quiaquilibet,qui copofueritfyllogifmfi addeclarandupcripfiim ahquS rem ducendo *d impoflibile, & c8clu(erit conclu fionem poffibile no impoflibile,n6 declararet aliquam rem, licet copofuirtet mille fylfos hui 9 difpofitiois, fed qn no declararet ho ex fylfo falfb.mfi hanc menfura, no declararct t€ a falfo, qp eft in ea, neq-, accidens eius.neq; coftruendo,neq, deftruen do.Fortafleautipfum ponerecoctu I fione poffibile faeitputarc,q?ipfe re ccperuillas p'miflas veras,qm iam extimafVp illud, ex cuius pofitione BO fequifTalfum, ipfura e veru, fed no eft via ad deftruedu pmiflas falfas per lyllogilrnosducentesadimpombile,qui oppugnat,hoceft,qui cocludunt cotradictoriQ eius,q? pofitu eft,nifi rccipiendo, q? conclufio fit falfa. Exepli gratia,quia qui contradixitfermoni Zenonis in deltru ftionemotu$,tjdicit,qj fi motuseec ens,nportet,q? mobile tranfiret ante eoplementu jpcefluseius media, & ante illud mediu,mediu illiusetia,et " exquo mcdia.q funtin vno^ceffu funt infinitajfcdrefiq? mobilia tran firentitinerainnnita t^poreinfinito,hocauteftrepugnansimpoflibileificqjergo mot* no eft ens. Siafic dicerct cotradices, q? iftud cofeques nofitimpoffibile omnibus modis, ei'autimpoflibilitaseft, fi pofiiiflc mus, trafiret ea tf porib 9 huncmodum, licet iam deftruxerit 0 (yilogifmu, qui conatuscftdeftrucre motu, tame" noaccrdft per declaxatione fal{i,q?eftin eiuspmf(Iis,Ilbevero cotradixit huicelenchofbphiftico ex eo,q? dixit,q? mobile no tranfitantecoplemftufpatij fpatia multa,fed trafitvnicu (patiu vnico t€pore;oportuifietaat, q? tranfiret muhaspana,fi vnus motus cetcopofitusexpluribus motib'm a feuerauerit efle, & fie quatenus pfeueraucrit ille, dequo eft interrogatu,& fit vnus Socrates,quieft,&m- J gr effus eft domfi, aut dequo eft interrogario:ficq5 ergor«j> notdeft de Socrate apud Tulg* e Socrate,qii no t infinitjs,qm di (pofitioteporiSj&progrefluse vna fin id,q? (equitur ex hoc.Ifte itaque contraducithiucfyllogifmo (ccudu 9 eft p fe,& ignotus eft p accide"s:g.a quiuoueritjOjhicfitalb'j&ignorauerit,q? ipfe fit muficus,ia cognouif fet alig^; re, & ignofaflet re aha. DC cotradiclione aut elechi, quo feo^f", q> numer' fit mult 9 , & pauc 9 fimul, qnrecepemfalfum,q7eftin eordici mus,q? i3 pollibile eft,q> fit mult 9 in coparatione,ad q> eft vltra ipfum. in fra ipfum,& pauc 9 1 coparatione, ad Y ij quod

Elenchorum<br />

fed "6 poflesfion€,Sd fi<br />

* r & n5 eo<br />

quid ad mala dicitur,vtaliquox<br />

fimuh&ficuteftduftum<br />

ru:pBidmalorueft,fed nohoc noftru)hiceftpater,&erttuus,crgo.<br />

malorumtpropterid igiturqS eft pater tuus.Almdexeplu eft « fa<br />

rtquomodo^riamfimpfrapx »ofis,&ert,»o«n« nuraeruseft<br />

^ . ~> • • c if multus,qanumer' eft multitude q<br />

paret, quanq, connngitfortaflfc dg & ^ nu eft<br />

bonueflealiquid malorumdux ali0j€ %fi omnisnumerusg<br />

phcitcr,non tamenm oratione muit'&paucUsfimul.O£siftielenhacked<br />

magis,fiquod macipm, Cni f0luuot j ,qn dicif.q,hatedifpoftfit<br />

bonu mah : fortafle aut ne'qj tio accidcrit, & q> non fitneceffaria,<br />

ficyno enim fi bonu eft,cthuius, & q, accident huic Socrati.q? interbonuhuiusfimulrvemm<br />

neqj rogauerisdeeo.&ignorasipfumcr<br />

hominedicereanimaliudTejdi partequamterrogafti deeo, fednS<br />

ciimultiplicitenno.n.fialiquid ignorasipsuex ptequa e Socrates,<br />

fignificamus aufercntes.,id dicit ne q; ee" interrogatii deeo eft kmgt *•<br />

tnultipliciter: nam dddiniidiu ''" neq;nece(Iariu,&ficacciditSocra-<br />

dicentes verfus da mihi,Ilida fix ti fi ingrediafdomu, cp ego cogno-<br />

gnificamus:vtjiram pande dca.<br />

fcaipmm q? fit Socrates,& ignprem<br />

de eo difpofitione,cj accidit ei: ficqj<br />

Defallaciaacctdmtis,faljatjuerefyonfione eft ipfum ingredi domu, & fie et eft<br />

adillam. Cap. 4. rnfiolatetisq7fciamus& nefciamUS<br />

COntradiclionesvero, qua; fi- ipfum.Quida virautQ?que"putoin<br />

unt reb 9 fbphifticis,fiint, quia nuere Platone)e c| cofradixit his elfi<br />

contradidtio cuiufq;, q? eftfm acci- chisexeo,q7dixit,q> n5 fit impoffidens,<br />

eft vna cade" cotradidio in (e, bile q? fcia vna rf ex quada parte, &<br />

qe ex eflentiaei 9 , q> eft fin accides, ignore ex alicJgte.Sedhac cotradihoceftjqjfciatqjhocnontillisfem<br />

ction^impeditbreuitasplurib' mo<br />

per,neq;omnibus,qm q?eftfmac- dis.quoru vn 9 eft,cjaimpoflibileeft<br />

cidesinuenit v rei aucin minoritcm<br />

I porejautinpauciorifijbieclo^utin accides, ficutefermodicctispcedes, M<br />

pauco vtriu£q ;.C6tradic~tio aut pro hie e tu',& hie e pater,ergo e tu 9 papria<br />

iftiusloci eft,qii dicitur,q> hoc ter, &noc" tu 9 , qm cotradiiftio hui'<br />

fit res,q accidit, & no fit neceflario, e, q?dixit,q> accident tibi,c_<br />

hoc aut eft manifeftu,qnaduerte- tu<br />

musad el£chos,qui funt fm accides,<br />

ficutcfteoru diclfi, tu talisignoras,<br />

g»intedo teinterrogare, qnautinterrogauero<br />

te ipfiim, tu noueris il-<br />

9 ,fitpf,&n5eex j>te,qe tu'.cotra<br />

dicTiioautopj q?fit vFis&contineS<br />

totafalfitateinuetam in pmi/Tafalfa,&hoc,quiaiainueniut<br />

j in vnaea<br />

de pmifla diuerfi modi falfitacis, &<br />

lud, ergo tuignoraueris&noueris oportet vt cotradicliofitcontradiillud<br />

fimuh&ficuteftdiclunoftru, cT:io,^dinidatoesmodos, g,funtco<br />

tu tal is cognofcis Socrate, & no co- clufiomsfal&.Pretereaqcotradicie<br />

gnofos q? ipfe ingrediat^domu ,& fyll'o ducetiad impoilibilelitigiofo,<br />

hieingredienseft Socrates,ficqjtu qn(ciucrit?cfone,gputauitargues<br />

quod

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!