21.12.2022 Views

PANACEA 2022

Welcome to the 2022 edition of the Panacea! This is the annual creative publication from the Australian Medical Students' Association (AMSA). We hope you enjoy reading this issue.

Welcome to the 2022 edition of the Panacea! This is the annual creative publication from the Australian Medical Students' Association (AMSA). We hope you enjoy reading this issue.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

VOICES<br />

P A N A C E A M A G A Z I N E<br />

VOLUME 56 AMSA <strong>2022</strong> EDITION


ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF COUNTRY<br />

<br />

The Australian Medical Students' Association would like to<br />

acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on<br />

which this publication was made, the Wurundjeri people of<br />

the Kulin nations. We recognise their continuing connection<br />

to land, water and community and pay our respects to their<br />

Elders past, present and emerging. We would also like to<br />

extend our respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders<br />

reading our publication.


Medical students today are deluged with<br />

information. As a doctor, your job is to<br />

apply that theory in real life patient<br />

consultations. MEKSI makes it easier to train<br />

for (and pass) your clinical exams.<br />

MEKSI was created to make studying for medical<br />

exams easier, more enjoyable and a lot less<br />

stressful than it used to be.<br />

MEKSI recreates highly realistic consultations using<br />

AI-powered Virtual Standardised Patients, aligned<br />

to Australian clinical guidelines for the highest<br />

quality medical care.<br />

fear of judgement by their peers, MEKSI uses<br />

active learning to aid memory and refine clinical<br />

skills.<br />

So with MEKSI your time spent learning is more<br />

efficient. All members of AMSA Med Ed will be<br />

provided with free access to a customised library<br />

of cases in the MEKSI learning platform.<br />

Visit learnmeksi.com today to claim your free<br />

account and immediately improve your chances of<br />

passing with top marks, first time – every time!<br />

Built for medical students wanting to practice their<br />

clinical consultation skills by themselves, without<br />

Create your free account<br />

at learnmeksi.com


Dear Reader,<br />

<br />

<br />

EDITOR'S WELCOME<br />

<br />

Welcome to the <strong>2022</strong> Panacea publication! Nestled within these<br />

pages, you will find an array of photographs, artwork and essays<br />

carefully crafted by medical students. Each piece has a story to tell.<br />

Sometimes in the whir and blur of social media and hubbub of our<br />

daily lives, we forget to stop and listen to others. This edition hopes to<br />

provide a platform for students to share their many voices and<br />

reflections.<br />

Thank you to all the contributors for your beautiful work, and a special<br />

thank you to our readers for your support.<br />

Kind regards,<br />

AMSA Publications and Design Team<br />

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS<br />

Panacea <strong>2022</strong> designed by Shani (PDO 2023)<br />

Panacea <strong>2022</strong> edited by Reece (PDO <strong>2022</strong>)


Contents<br />

Page<br />

Number<br />

Submission<br />

6 Moments (by Devanga Tangri)<br />

7 Floral Anatomy (by Kasundri Kulasinghe)<br />

8<br />

Domestic Violence: The Lesser Known<br />

Pandemic (by Bianca Crowder)<br />

10<br />

The Unspoken Burden: Gender Discrimination in<br />

Med School (by Laura McDuff)<br />

12<br />

The United States Supreme Court overturned<br />

Roe v. Wade. What does this mean for the<br />

United States and the world? (by Mansi<br />

Tiwary & Afreen Akbany)<br />

17<br />

50 Shades of Adipose Tissue (by Abdikarim<br />

Said Abdullah)<br />

18 Photograph (photographed by Alyce Finch)


Moments<br />

By Devangna Tangri<br />

In medicine, everyone is sick. Patients to<br />

me are a constant reminder that my life is<br />

just as fragile as theirs. They are people I<br />

would know as my neighbour, my cashier<br />

at Woolies, my friend, my family member;<br />

me. Now they’re here, in a small hospital<br />

bed with a portable TV screen and desk<br />

with their strangely artificial looking<br />

hospital food resting on top. One minute<br />

ago they were living a normal life. Now<br />

they’re a hospital patient with an arm band<br />

and an annoying cannula the medical<br />

student hesitantly requested to insert.<br />

They’re sat here in their identical blue<br />

gowns (those who can sit up comfortably)<br />

with their entire lives just resting quietly in<br />

our hands. Our hands! Mine, in a few<br />

years! One minute they’re with us, but we<br />

come back the next day and hear from<br />

someone that overnight, something<br />

happened, now they’re dead. I always<br />

hear that life is impermanent, but being<br />

here, I see it. If I didn’t already find this<br />

career beautiful, I would hate every<br />

second of it. So why is it beautiful, despite<br />

everything?<br />

"Medicine is beautiful<br />

because it is a family"<br />

I’ve only been a clinical student for 4<br />

months, but I have learnt things I wasn’t<br />

expecting. The first is perspective. For<br />

one, my life isn’t mine. It isn’t any of ours,<br />

but given to us. That’s why it’s only fair<br />

that eventually, whoever gave it to us,<br />

takes it back. We’re all living on borrowed<br />

time, and the whole meaning of life is to<br />

decide what we want to do with our time.<br />

I’ve decided to dedicate my life to helping<br />

other people be their best for the time<br />

they’ve been given. Medicine is beautiful<br />

because it teaches you about time, and<br />

life.<br />

During a tutorial, I asked a senior<br />

consultant about why she decided to<br />

become a surgeon. She explained to me<br />

that it was different to how people<br />

described it to her when she was my age;<br />

‘no work life balance’, ‘no family’, ‘they’re<br />

basically just plumbers.’ Instead, she<br />

literally used the word ‘magic’ to describe<br />

the feeling of seeing her patients improve,<br />

knowing she’d been the one to remove<br />

their breast cancer or repair their hernia.<br />

She told me that she was my people, her<br />

and all the other frightening senior doctors<br />

I’d normally steer clear of. She told me to<br />

know, always, that these were the people<br />

who knew what I was going through,<br />

because they had all been third year<br />

medical students before. I felt belonging,<br />

at that moment, not only to her, but to all<br />

doctors everywhere. We have an<br />

understanding, a shared experience, a<br />

pact that we’ve made with each other and<br />

ourselves. Medicine is beautiful because it<br />

is a family.<br />

I was in the room during my surgical clinic,<br />

when an elderly woman was told she had<br />

a recurrence of oesophageal cancer after<br />

12 years of being cancer-free. She sat<br />

hunched over in the tiny characterless<br />

clinic, which made her already small frame<br />

seem even more defeated. That’s when<br />

her husband reached over from his chair,<br />

another bare and characterless piece of<br />

depressing furniture, and squeezed her<br />

hand. She looked up and smiled feebly,<br />

and with that one gesture,<br />

she got the strength to listen to the rest of<br />

the management plan. After they left I<br />

went to the bathroom and wiped a tear<br />

away. Medicine is beautiful because it is<br />

not about the room at all, but the people. I<br />

get to catch glimpses of people’s lives,<br />

and feel so incredibly lucky to be there.<br />

In the pre-operative room on my<br />

anaesthetics rotation, a young Indian<br />

female was very visibly nervous, couldn’t<br />

stop shaking and was in tears by the time<br />

we wheeled her into the operation theatre.<br />

The elderly white anaesthetic nurse stayed<br />

with her the entire time, whispering softly<br />

in her ear that she would be just fine,<br />

slowly caressing her forehead with the<br />

love and tenderness of a mother right up<br />

until she slowly succumbed to the<br />

anaesthetic and entered the realms of<br />

sleep. The nurse was right back by her<br />

side the minute she woke up. The patient<br />

smiled gratefully. Medicine is beautiful<br />

because it sees a white Australian woman<br />

see an Indian immigrant as her own child.<br />

I know that operation theatres are cold and<br />

secluded and so painfully sterile, while the<br />

sun shines outside and birds chirp and flit<br />

through branches in huge trees from<br />

where yellow and red and green leaves fall<br />

and line the pavement in a patchy<br />

colourful knit blanket, but I also know that<br />

medicine is full of moments just as<br />

beautiful as this.<br />

<strong>2022</strong> EDITION<br />

<strong>PANACEA</strong> MAGAZINE


Floral<br />

Anatomy<br />

By Kasundri Kulasinghe


AMSA Healthy Communities<br />

Domestic Violence: The Lesser<br />

Known Pandemic<br />

By Bianca Crowder<br />

Domestic Violence (DV) refers to patterns of abusive behaviours<br />

which facilitate and maintain power and control over another. (1)<br />

How can we provide a voice to victims of DV?<br />

The RACGP have published ‘The Whitebook: Abuse and Violence’<br />

which outlines the 3 Rs Model- Recognise, Respond, Refer. (2)<br />

Here is a summary which may assist you with advocacy in clinical<br />

practice. Please note this summary is not intended to replace<br />

professional advice (which requires specialist knowledge) and some<br />

content may be distressing.<br />

RECOGNISE<br />

Types of Domestic Violence & Their Signs<br />

Signs can be identified on examination or through history taking<br />

and can occur with any of the following types of DV (this list is not<br />

exhaustive):<br />

Physical Abuse- Bruises, chronic pain, injuries, headaches.<br />

Emotional Abuse- Anger, feeling overwhelmed, hypervigilance.<br />

Psychological Abuse- Poor sleep, concentration difficulties, absence<br />

at appointments or events, loss of sense of self, any symptoms of<br />

mental health concerns.<br />

Financial Abuse- Perpetrator has control of finances, accounts and<br />

may induce debt. Restricting access to personal finances. May use<br />

blackmail.<br />

Coercive Control- Instructions on which activities, clothes,<br />

appearance, visits and friends the victim are 'allowed', or making<br />

decisions for the victim by restricting personal choices.<br />

Social Abuse- Isolation from friends/family/supportive social<br />

network.<br />

Technological Abuse- Restricting car, computer or phone use,<br />

victim surveillance though fake social media accounts,


unauthorised technology use by perpetrator such as<br />

reading text messages, monitoring calls, tracking.<br />

Restrictions on social media activity (such as telling the<br />

victim which posts they are 'allowed' to comment or like).<br />

Visa Abuse- Use of blackmail and coercion. False claims<br />

about visa status, restricting access to passport or visa<br />

documentation.<br />

References<br />

1. NSW Public Health Network<br />

2. RACGP, The Whitebook: Abuse and violence: working<br />

with our patients in general practice, 5th Ed.,nd<br />

Sexual Violence- Unwanted pressure or lack of consent.<br />

Can include physical signs and/or emotional and<br />

psychological signs.<br />

RED FLAGS<br />

Escalation of violence<br />

Recent planned separation- HIGHEST RISK<br />

Recent unemployment of perpetrator drug alcohol abuse<br />

Pregnancy or recent birth<br />

Obsessive behaviour, jealousy or stalking<br />

Direct threats<br />

Sexual assault<br />

Children- if present they are at risk even if not directly<br />

involved or targeted<br />

Vulnerable Groups<br />

Low Socioeconomic Status, CALD, English Second<br />

Language, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples,<br />

elderly population.<br />

RESPOND<br />

Active Listening- let the patient take the lead. Use non<br />

verbal cues and avoid judgement. Validate emotions and<br />

reassurance that the victim is not to blame.<br />

Ensure a comfortable, supportive, safe environment,<br />

where the patient is alone and free of coercion.<br />

Safety and Risk Assessment and Mandatory Reportingthis<br />

varies by state- contact local Public Health Network.<br />

REFER<br />

Provide options and ongoing support- Informed consent to<br />

offer services, but respect the patient's decision- they may<br />

not be aware they are experiencing DV and may not wish<br />

to take action or accept support, re-emphasise ongoing<br />

support is available when they are ready.<br />

Refer and provide access to specialist Family Violence<br />

Services.


THE UNSPOKEN BURDEN: GENDER<br />

DISCRIMINATION IN MED SCHOOL<br />

BY LAURA MCDUFF<br />

If you, dear reader, saw the title of this<br />

article and thought perhaps this piece on<br />

gender equity is not for you, I implore you<br />

to keep reading. What I would like to share<br />

with you is that gender equity is, in fact, a<br />

topic we all should be invested in. A key<br />

facet of AMSA Gender Equity’s role is to<br />

advocate to improve the culture of<br />

medicine in the face of gender bias,<br />

discrimination, and harassment. Gender<br />

discrimination disproportionately, but not<br />

exclusively, impacts the health outcomes<br />

for women, transgender, and gender<br />

diverse medical students. So I ask you to<br />

keep reading to find out your part to play<br />

in this grand endeavour to dismantle<br />

gender bias in our collective culture of<br />

medicine.<br />

What does gender discrimination and bias<br />

in medicine look like? Medicine has held<br />

onto a façade for far too long of being<br />

‘gender blind’ which has effects for both<br />

patient outcomes, beyond the scope of<br />

this article, and for the practitioners of<br />

medicine. For many, gender discrimination<br />

is thought of as overt intimidation, sexist<br />

comments or sexual harassment, which<br />

many medical students and doctors<br />

verifiably face [1]. However, it also can be<br />

subversive in the form of subtle inequities,<br />

bias, unconscious attitudes and opinions.<br />

The consultant who only makes eye<br />

contact with male medical students and<br />

subtle shifts in body language to exclude<br />

women and gender diverse students. Lack<br />

of support from institutions for fathers in<br />

medical school or lack of opportunities<br />

and exclusion in certain specialties such<br />

as paediatrics and obstetrics &<br />

gynaecology [2]. Anti-LGBT jokes and<br />

casual transphobia from peers or<br />

members of the healthcare team, a<br />

phenomenon that nearly half of surveyed<br />

LGBTQIA+ medical students report<br />

occuring [3].<br />

The effects of gender bias and<br />

discrimination on medical students have a<br />

myriad of effects from the very start all<br />

throughout our careers. The burden of<br />

gender bias can contribute to high<br />

burnout rates, poor mental health,<br />

unequal opportunities in clinical,<br />

academic or leadership roles and<br />

disparities in compensation and time to<br />

academic promotion (to name a few). So,<br />

dear reader, why should you care? Well,<br />

for one, you or your colleagues are<br />

unfortunately likely to have faced gender<br />

bias or discrimination during medical<br />

school. The added and cumulative burden<br />

this can impose on students and future<br />

practitioners can deprive the field,<br />

AMSA GENDER EQUITY


patients and talented clinicians of opportunities<br />

and even pursuit of certain fields of medicine.<br />

Eliminating gender inequities requires a concerted<br />

effort to inform both affected and unaffected<br />

individuals about disparities that exist and how to<br />

address them. We cannot assume that the archaic<br />

culture of medicine will die out with the slow<br />

trickle of retirement. This fallacy props up the idea<br />

that detrimental aspects of the culture are solely a<br />

factor of an age gone by, and removes the<br />

responsibility of today’s medical students. We are<br />

also responsible for the culture of medicine. In the<br />

formation of a professional identity, many medical<br />

students absorb medical culture. However this can<br />

lead to unquestioningly accepting and reproducing<br />

the status quo [4].<br />

Medical students are a vulnerable group, due to<br />

the dependence on superiors for letters of<br />

recommendation or reference, training<br />

opportunities, and career advancement. If you feel<br />

unaffected by gender bias, I call on you not to<br />

assume gender blindness but consider how your<br />

colleagues may face this burden regularly.<br />

Advocating for your colleagues, and providing<br />

interpersonal support helps reduce the additional<br />

burden of advocacy fatigue of those experiencing<br />

gender discrimination (the phenomenon of those<br />

groups that face discrimination or marginalisation<br />

are also the same groups having to educate and<br />

advocate continually).<br />

It would be foolhardy to assume this is a problem<br />

unique to medicine, we recognise the pervasive<br />

influence of gender discrimination and bias.<br />

Furthermore, it’s important to acknowledge the<br />

additive forms of bias and discrimination<br />

individuals face if they are part of other<br />

marginalised groups. Whilst this is broader than<br />

you and your colleagues, and requires institutional<br />

solutions and continuous cultural reform at all<br />

levels of the medical hierarchy, that does not<br />

diminish the individual difference you can make.<br />

but rather a focus on the importance that<br />

individual interpersonal action can have in<br />

reducing the mental and emotional burden for our<br />

colleagues now and in the future. Elevate the<br />

voices, achievements and talent of your fellow<br />

medical students. Support your colleagues if you<br />

notice overt or covert gender discrimination. If you<br />

are not affected by gender discrimination,<br />

speaking up and empowering and uplifting your<br />

colleagues does not detract from your work nor<br />

talent.. Speaking up can take many forms, as long<br />

as you use your voice to disrupt the status quo<br />

rather than empower it.<br />

References<br />

1. Phillips NA, Tannan SC, Kalliainen LK.<br />

Understanding and Overcoming Implicit<br />

Gender Bias in Plastic Surgery. Plast Reconstr<br />

Surg. 2016;138(5):1111-1116<br />

2. ​Nora LM, McLaughlin MA, Fosson SE, Stratton<br />

TD, Murphy-Spencer A, Fincher RM, German<br />

DC, Seiden D, Witzke DB. Gender discrimination<br />

and sexual harassment in medical education:<br />

perspectives gained by a 14-school study.<br />

Academic medicine. 2002 Dec 1;77(12 Part<br />

1):1226-34.<br />

3. Nama N, MacPherson P, Sampson M, McMillan<br />

HJ. Medical students’ perception of lesbian,<br />

gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT)<br />

discrimination in their learning environment<br />

and their self-reported comfort level for caring<br />

for LGBT patients: a survey study. Med Educ<br />

Online. 2017;22(1):1368850.<br />

4. Babaria P, Abedin S, Berg D, Nunez-Smith M.<br />

“I’m too used to it”: a longitudinal qualitative<br />

study of third year female medical students’<br />

experiences of gendered encounters in medical<br />

education. Soc Sci Med 2012; 74: 1013-1020.<br />

I do not intend this to be an inspirational speech<br />

AMSA GENDER EQUITY


The United States Supreme<br />

Court overturned Roe v. Wade.<br />

What does this mean for the<br />

United States and the world?<br />

By Mansi Tiwary &<br />

Afreen Akbany<br />

(AMSA Sexual and<br />

Reproductive<br />

Health)<br />

What was Roe v. Wade?<br />

Roe v. Wade was a landmark decision passed<br />

by the Supreme Court of the United States<br />

(SCOTUS) regarding abortion laws in America<br />

on the 22nd of January, 1973. The SCOTUS<br />

ruled that the constitutional right to privacy<br />

“is broad enough to encompass a woman’s<br />

decision whether or not to terminate her<br />

pregnancy” (Roe v. Wade, 1973).[1,2] Prior to<br />

Roe v. Wade, abortion was illegal in most<br />

states, unless being performed in order to<br />

preserve the woman’s life or health, or in<br />

cases of incest, rape or fetal ill-health.[2]<br />

The case was filed by Norma McCorvey under<br />

the legal pseudonym, Jane Roe McCorvey<br />

was an unmarried woman who fell pregnant<br />

with her third child. She wanted to terminate<br />

the pregnancy; however, she lived in Texas,<br />

where abortions were outlawed except in the<br />

aforementioned circumstances.[2] Linda<br />

Coffee and Sarah Weddington, McCorvey's<br />

lawyers, filed a lawsuit on her behalf against<br />

her local district attorney, Henry Wade, in the<br />

US federal court. They argued that Texas’<br />

abortion ban was unconstitutional, infringing<br />

women’s right to privacy. Eventually, the case<br />

was taken to the Supreme Court level, where<br />

7 out of 9 judges ruled in favour of Roe,<br />

deeming that the Texan abortion ban was<br />

unconstitutional. The decision was a source<br />

of great contention, since 46 out of 50 states<br />

had to change their abortion laws as a<br />

consequence.1 Hence, over the last five<br />

decades, this ruling protected the right to<br />

abortion at the federal level, and abortion<br />

services in America became safer and more<br />

accessible.<br />

Notable subsequent judicial developments<br />

Hyde Amendment<br />

The Hyde Amendment is a legislative<br />

provision which prohibits the use of federal<br />

funds to cover abortions, unless performed to<br />

save the mother’s life, or if the pregnancy is a<br />

result of rape or incestuous activity.[3] Before<br />

the amendment came into effect in 1980,<br />

approximately 300,000 abortions were being<br />

performed using federal funds every year.[4]<br />

The amendment was originally passed on the<br />

30th of September, 1976 by the House of<br />

Representatives.[3] It has since been altered<br />

by the Congress several times. The Hyde<br />

Amendment disproportionately<br />

disadvantages low-income women and<br />

women of colour. In his 2020 presidential<br />

campaign, US President Joe Biden pledged<br />

to overturn the Hyde Amendment if elected<br />

to parliament, after being pressured to do so<br />

by activists and fellow Democrats.[5] Biden’s<br />

<strong>2022</strong> budget, a non-binding document which<br />

was released in 2021, had omitted the<br />

Amendment.[6] However, this may not be<br />

feasible given the need for government<br />

funding, and due to the Russia-Ukraine<br />

conflict, since the US has agreed to provide<br />

$40 billion worth of aid to Ukraine.[6]<br />

Planned Parenthood v. Casey<br />

Planned Parenthood v. Casey was a 1992 US<br />

Supreme Court case which challenged the<br />

right to abortion established in Roe v. Wade.<br />

[7] Although it affirmed the central holding of<br />

Roe, that “regardless of whether exceptions<br />

are made for particular circumstances, a


state may not prohibit any woman from<br />

making the ultimate decision to terminate<br />

her pregnancy before viability”, the decision<br />

was that the age of foetal viability was<br />

defined as 23-24 weeks rather than 28, as per<br />

Roe.[7] Additionally, Roe had established a<br />

trimester framework regarding restrictions<br />

around abortion, whereby during the first<br />

trimester, the decision to terminate a<br />

pregnancy was the woman’s alone.[1] During<br />

the second trimester, the state could more<br />

tightly regulate abortions based on the<br />

mother’s health requirements.[1] Meanwhile,<br />

during the third trimester, individual states<br />

could outlaw or regulate abortions in the<br />

interest of viable life, with exceptions being<br />

made to preserve the mother’s life or health.<br />

[1] This framework was abandoned during the<br />

Planned Parenthood v. Casey decision.[7]<br />

Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health<br />

Organization<br />

On the 24th of June, <strong>2022</strong>, the SCOTUS<br />

passed the landmark decision, Dobbs v.<br />

Jackson Women's Health Organization,<br />

which overruled both Roe v. Wade and<br />

Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992),<br />

maintaining that the American constitution<br />

does not grant citizens any right to abortion.<br />

[8] A draft of this majority opinion written by<br />

Justice Samuel Alito was leaked in May <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

At that time, 13 states had trigger laws set to<br />

ban abortion as soon as Roe v. Wade was<br />

overturned.[9] The draft leak prompted more<br />

states to adopt similar trigger laws. At<br />

present, 12 states—Alabama, Arkansas,<br />

Georgia, Mississippi, Missouri, Ohio,<br />

Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota,<br />

Tennessee, Texas and Wisconsin—have<br />

banned abortion, and 4 states— Idaho, North<br />

Dakota, West Virginia and Wyoming—are<br />

expected to ban abortion or place severe<br />

restrictions on abortion in the near future. So<br />

far, judges have temporarily blocked trigger<br />

laws banning abortion in Louisiana, Kentucky<br />

and Utah. Furthermore, abortion laws are<br />

thought to be threatened in 11 states —<br />

Arizona, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas,<br />

Michigan, Montana, Nebraska, North Carolina,<br />

Pennsylvania and Virginia. Collectively, these<br />

legislative changes are estimated to affect<br />

almost 40 million women of reproductive age<br />

within the US.[10]<br />

Executive Order 14076: Protecting Access to<br />

Reproductive Healthcare Services<br />

On the 8th of July, <strong>2022</strong>, US President Joseph<br />

Biden signed an Executive Order to protect<br />

access to reproductive healthcare, directing<br />

the US Department of Health and Human<br />

Services (HHS) to ensure access to<br />

medication abortion and emergency<br />

contraception.[11] The Executive Order offers<br />

few specific guidelines on how to achieve its<br />

goals, and is expected to have limited impact<br />

in practice.<br />

How did Roe influence abortion access<br />

abroad?<br />

The Roe ruling precipitated movements to<br />

expand reproductive health and rights<br />

globally.[12] Notably, since the late 2010s, a<br />

sweeping grassroots movement—known as<br />

‘Marea Verde’ or ‘the Green Wave’—has seen<br />

the most populous nations in Latin America<br />

pave the way for more widespread access to<br />

abortion, demonstrating that legal abortion<br />

acess can coexist with strong Catholic and<br />

Protestant traditions.[13] Roe has, as well,<br />

been influential in court decisions related to<br />

reproductive freedoms.[12] For instance, the<br />

High Court of Kenya in Malindi, in March<br />

<strong>2022</strong>, specifically referenced and considered<br />

key points from Roe when affirming the right<br />

to abortion under the Constitution.[12,14]<br />

It follows, then, that the Dobbs decision<br />

would have dire implications for global<br />

abortion rights. Human rights advocates fear<br />

that this ruling will strengthen worldwide<br />

efforts to restrict abortion access.[15]<br />

Countries such as China, El Savador,<br />

Indonesia, and Poland can point to the US to<br />

legitimise their own restrictive policies. In<br />

more permissive jurisdictions, anti-rights<br />

activists may now feel emboldened to be<br />

more expressive of their views in public<br />

domains, exacerbating the stigma faced by<br />

people who seek abortion services, and by<br />

abortion providers.<br />

What happens when women are denied<br />

abortions?<br />

For about ten years from 2007, abortion<br />

advocacy group Advancing New Standards in


Reproductive Health (ANSIRH) tracked the<br />

experiences of 1,132 women in the US who<br />

had received abortions or been denied them<br />

because of clinic policies on gestational age<br />

limits.[16] Participants were recruited from 30<br />

abortion facilities around America. This yearslong<br />

project was led by demographer Dr.<br />

Diana Greene Foster, and came to be known<br />

as The Turnaway Study.[16]<br />

Key findings from the Turnaway Study<br />

include the fact that women who are denied<br />

a wanted abortion and are forced to carry an<br />

unwanted pregnancy to term are:<br />

Four times as likely to live below the<br />

federal poverty line<br />

More likely to experience serious<br />

complications from the end of pregnancy<br />

including eclampsia and death<br />

More likely to suffer anxiety and loss of<br />

self-esteem in the short term after being<br />

denied abortion<br />

Less likely to have aspirational life plans<br />

for the coming year<br />

More likely to experience poor physical<br />

health for years after the pregnancy,<br />

including chronic pain and gestational<br />

hypertension[16]<br />

Furthermore, being denied abortion has<br />

serious implications for the children born of<br />

unwanted pregnancy, as well as for the<br />

existing children in the family.[16]<br />

However, it is worth noting that the<br />

Turnaway study did not include transgender<br />

or non-binary participants, and hence, its<br />

findings are not representative of these<br />

patient populations.[16]<br />

Global evidence suggests that abortion bans<br />

do not make abortions much rarer.[17] They<br />

instead increase the number of unsafe<br />

abortions, as people turn to herbs such as rue<br />

and sage—and even attempts to inflict<br />

abdominal trauma—to self-manage<br />

abortions.[17] Thanks to medication abortion<br />

(a combination of mifepristone and<br />

misoprostol), abortion can be perfomed<br />

safely outside of formal healthcare settings.18<br />

However, the decision in Dobbs has created<br />

confusion about access to abortion pills. The<br />

US Food and Drug Administration allows<br />

these pills to be distributed by mail, but<br />

several states are seeking to ban them<br />

completely.[18]<br />

In the US, childbirth is several times more<br />

dangerous than having an abortion.19 If<br />

patients have no other option than to carry<br />

pregnancies to term, they will have to<br />

shoulder the worse odds of death from<br />

pregnancy or childbirth.19 Global trends<br />

indicate that abortion bans increase maternal<br />

mortality.[19] In the US, restrictions are likely<br />

to disproportionately affect Black women,<br />

who are almost three times more likely to die<br />

of pregnancy- and childbirth-related<br />

complications than White women.[19]<br />

What does abortion care look like in<br />

Australia?<br />

In Australia, legislation around abortion varies<br />

by state. Each state’s regulations are<br />

tabulated below.<br />

Table 1. Abortion legislation in Australia


While legislation around abortion in Australia<br />

is much more progressive and permissive<br />

than that of the US, there remains significant<br />

room for progress. Barriers to abortion access<br />

include financial and geographic barriers,<br />

and deficiencies in practitioner attitudes,<br />

education and training.[21]<br />

In Australia, federal funding is available for<br />

abortions provided within the private sector<br />

for those entitled to access Medicare, while<br />

States are responsible for the provision of<br />

abortion services in public hospitals.[21]<br />

Deficiencies in public provision and the<br />

subsidies for abortions performed in private<br />

hospitals have rendered abortion services<br />

unaffordable for many patients seeking<br />

them.[21] For example, the cost of obtaining a<br />

medical abortion in the state of Victoria can<br />

range from as little as $6.10 to as much as<br />

$440, depending on the abortion provider.[21]<br />

Geographic differences in abortion access<br />

across Australia have given rise to<br />

‘reproductive tourism’, wherein people travel<br />

insterstate to more liberalised jurisdictions, or<br />

from rural and remote areas to cities with<br />

adequate healthcare infrastructure, to<br />

receive abortion care.[21]<br />

practitioners able to provide the service.[21]<br />

What can be done?<br />

Reproductive healthcare is at risk in the new<br />

post-Roe reality. Here is what you can do to<br />

address barriers to abortion access, and join<br />

the fight for reproductive freedoms:<br />

Donate to community-based abortion<br />

funds, which provide financial assistance,<br />

travel, lodging and other types of support<br />

to people seeking abortions.<br />

Vote for legislators who support sexual<br />

and reproductive health and rights, such<br />

as access to abortion and contraception.<br />

Actively counter anti-abortion discourse<br />

by discussing the harms of forced<br />

pregnancy.<br />

Join pro-abortion rallies in your city or<br />

state to draw attention to the issue of<br />

restricted abortion access and rights.<br />

Advocate for the inclusion of abortion in<br />

your medical school curriculum.<br />

Because of previous laws criminalising the<br />

procedure, abortion has been mostly absent<br />

from medical curricula and vocational<br />

training.[21] Additionally, doctor education<br />

and training has not readily adapted to the<br />

decriminalisation of abortion.[21] Abortion is<br />

included in the curriculum of only half of the<br />

medical schools in Australia, and there are no<br />

mandatory requirements for trainees of the<br />

Royal Australian and New Zealand College of<br />

Obstetricians and Gynaecologists<br />

(RANZCOG) to have clinical experience<br />

providing abortion care.[21] The inadequacy<br />

of training has led to a significant nationwide<br />

shortage of surgeons who are able to provide<br />

abortions beyond 18 weeks’ gestation.[21]<br />

Although decriminalisation has widened<br />

abortion access, further measures are<br />

required to help Australian people fully<br />

realise reproductive rights.[21] These should<br />

include increased funding and public<br />

provision of abortion services in rural and<br />

urban areas, and appropriate vocational<br />

training to increase the number of


References<br />

1. Legal Information Institute. Roe v. Wade (1973). Cornell Law School. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/roe_v_wade_(1973)<br />

2. Planned Parenthood. Roe v. Wade: Its History and Impact. Planned Parenthood Federation of<br />

America. Updated January, 2014. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.plannedparenthood.org/files/3013/9611/5870/Abortion_Roe_History.pdf<br />

3. Gerais R. The Hyde Amendment of 1976. The Embryo Project Encyclopedia. June 28, 2017.<br />

Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>. https://embryo.asu.edu/pages/hyde-amendment-1976<br />

4. Gold RB. After the Hyde Amendment: public funding for abortion in FY 1978. Fam Plann<br />

Perspect. 1980;12(3):131-4. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6995148/<br />

5. McCammon S. Biden's Budget Proposal Reverses A Decades-Long Ban On Abortion Funding.<br />

NPR. May 31, 2021. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>. https://www.npr.org/2021/05/31/1001881788/bidensbudget-proposal-reverses-a-decades-long-ban-on-abortion-funding<br />

6. Griffiths BD. Biden will be forced to sign a restriction on abortion funding after Democrats<br />

caved to Republican demands. Business Insider. March 10, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.businessinsider.com/biden-hyde-amendment-repeal-house-spending-planukraine-<strong>2022</strong>-3<br />

7. Legal Information Institute. Planned Parenthood of South-Eastern Pennsylvania, et al.,<br />

Petitioners, v. Robert P. Casey, et al.. Cornell Law School. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/505/833<br />

8. Center for Reproductive Rights. U.S. Supreme Court Takes Away the Constitutional Right to<br />

Abortion. Reproductive Rights. June 24, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

9. Al Jazeera Staff. What has happened in week since draft Roe v Wade opinion leaked? Al<br />

Jazeera. May 9, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

10. Witherspoon A, Glenza J, Chang A. Tracking where abortion laws stand in every state.<br />

Updated June, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/nginteractive/<strong>2022</strong>/jun/28/tracking-where-abortion-laws-stand-in-every-state<br />

11. Exec. Order No. 14076, 3 C. F. R. 42053-42055 (<strong>2022</strong>).<br />

12. Sun N. Overturning Roe v Wade: reproducing injustice. British Medical Journal.<br />

<strong>2022</strong>;377:o1588. Published <strong>2022</strong> Jun 27. doi:10.1136/bmj.o1588<br />

13. Casas X. How the ‘Green Wave’ Movement Did the Unthinkable in Latin America. The New<br />

York Times. November 1, 2021. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/01/opinion/abortion-latin-america.html<br />

14. Center for Reproductive Rights. High Court of Kenya in Malindi Ruling in PAK and Salim<br />

Mohammed vs. the Attorney General and 3 others. March 25, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://reproductiverights.org/high-court-of-kenya-in-malindi-ruling-in-pak-and-salimmohammed-vs-the-attorney-general-and-3-others/<br />

15. Rai S. How the Fall of Roe v. Wade Could Impact Abortion Access Around the World. The Hill.<br />

April 7, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>. https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/3542593-how-thefall-of-roe-v-wade-could-impact-abortion-access-around-the-world/<br />

16. Foster DG. The Turnaway Study: Ten Years, a Thousand Women, and the Consequences of<br />

Having–or Being Denied–an Abortion. New York: Scribner; 2020.<br />

17. Singh S, Remez L, Sedgh G, Kwok L, Onda T. Abortion Worldwide: Uneven Progress and<br />

Unequal Access. Guttmacher Institute. Published 2017. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.guttmacher.org/sites/default/files/report_pdf/abortion-worldwide-2017.pdf<br />

18. McGovern T. Overturning Roe v Wade has had an immediate chilling effect on reproductive<br />

healthcare. British Medical Journal. <strong>2022</strong>;377:o1622. Published June 30, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

doi:10.1136/bmj.o1622<br />

19. Lau S. The United States needs people to stand up for abortion. British Medical Journal.<br />

<strong>2022</strong>;377:o1493. Published June 22, <strong>2022</strong>. doi:10.1136/bmj.o1493<br />

20. Stirrat C. New abortion laws have come into effect in South Australia. What are they in other<br />

states? SBS News. July 7, <strong>2022</strong>. Accessed July 23, <strong>2022</strong>.<br />

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/new-abortion-laws-have-come-into-effect-in-southaustralia-what-are-they-in-other-states/g5w55ghaj<br />

21. Sifris R, Penovic T. Barriers to abortion access in Australia before and during the COVID-19<br />

pandemic. Women’s Studies International Forum. <strong>2022</strong>;86. Published April 13, 2021.<br />

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wsif.2021.102470


50 SHADES of ADIPOSE TISSUE<br />

Hi, I am the adipose tissue within your body. You may know me by the more<br />

derogatory term “fat tissue”. I have always been the black sheep of the body,<br />

from being labeled as unattractive, ugly, and even blamed for many of the<br />

metabolic diseases that have plagued mankind. For decades, I have been<br />

mankind’s most hated and vilified organ so much that many have resorted to<br />

great lengths and dangerous surgeries to purge me from the human body.<br />

By Abdikarim Said Abdullahi<br />

<br />

Woe is me, right? But I have had it enough! and at the risk of sounding<br />

melodramatic, I am ready to set the record and narrative straight and finally tell<br />

my truths.<br />

Are you aware that I am not monolithic, but come in different shades and<br />

colors like your unique human skin, with each shade of my skin having a<br />

unique effect on the human body? From helping your body to absorb fatsoluble<br />

vitamins and minerals to being a vital component of your body’s cell<br />

membrane and the myelin sheath around your neurons. So, you see I am more<br />

than meets the eye.<br />

For far too long the colonists like in your historical education system have only<br />

taught you about the “white” adipose tissue, and all the diseases and metabolic<br />

havoc I have caused. What about my “brown” side, did you know that within<br />

your body exists another form of adipose tissue called “brown adipose” tissue.<br />

Characteristically and morphologically, I am different from my “white” brothers,<br />

as I possess hundredths of mitochondria and a unique gene called uncoupling<br />

protein 1 (UCP-1), which allows me to help your body burn fat at exceedingly<br />

impressive rates. I also do not store as much fat as my white counterparts and<br />

have even been the target of researchers studying obesity in order to harness<br />

my remarkable energy burning abilities to cure obesity. Unfortunately, my life<br />

span is limited within the human body with my population becoming<br />

dangerously low by the time you hit puberty.<br />

Then you have my other equally unique family member, “the beige” adipose<br />

tissue, which as the name “beige” suggests was created through an intra-racial<br />

relationship between my white and brown self. As beige adipose tissue, I<br />

possess qualities of white adipose tissue in that I tend to store fat for your body,<br />

clog up your arteries, make you aesthetically unpleasant to look at. However,<br />

with the right stimulus and a process called “white adipose tissue browning”, I<br />

can switch up and let my brown side shine by expressing the UCP-1 gene and<br />

thereby transforming into a fat-burning engine. Like my brown adipose<br />

brother, I have also recently attracted much attention as a new therapeutic<br />

target for obesity. It is hypothesized that by activating browning (switch from<br />

white to beige), we can increase energy expenditure and cause a negative<br />

energy balance in individuals with excess fat stores. Indeed, several studies in<br />

mice have already shown that the activation of browning facilitates weight loss,<br />

ameliorates insulin resistance, and corrects hyperlipidemia in obese mice.<br />

So, I hope you now see and realize that like you, I possess the most innate<br />

human qualities of being good and evil as well as being full of contradictions.<br />

Most of the time, we don’t see our own contradictions – it’s often easier to<br />

observe such inconsistencies in others. But you are as full of contradictions as I<br />

am. Like you, I can be a source for healing through my brown and beige sides<br />

or I can be a source for harm through my white side. In summary, all I ask of<br />

you is that next time you try to tarnish my name, be mindful that I am human<br />

just like you and that I too deserve your kindness.


L E T ' S S E E I T T O G E T H E R<br />

PHOTOGRAPH TAKEN By ALYCE<br />

FINCH


Thank<br />

you for<br />

reading<br />

AMSA <strong>2022</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!