Summaries / Resúmenes - Studia Moralia

Summaries / Resúmenes - Studia Moralia Summaries / Resúmenes - Studia Moralia

studiamoralia.org
from studiamoralia.org More from this publisher
11.07.2015 Views

EVIL: QUESTIONING AND CHALLENGING THEOLOGY AGAIN AND AGAIN 99Evil can also be expressed as the “mysterium inquitatis”since every human being experiences it and suffers from it in amanner that is completely personal and unique. Also every erais characterized by typologies of experiences of specific evils. Itseems that the recent and contemporary era may have added anew dimension to the horror and depth of evil, a new “nonquality.”In the next section we will explore some of these characteristics.2. The scandal of evil symbolized in the name ofAuschwitzIn the twentieth century evil assumed a new destructivedimension, our understanding of evil took a kind of “qualitativeleap” toward the negative. The situation in the second half ofthe twentieth century has often been described as the “post-Auschwitz” period, so that Auschwitz has become the paradigmfor atrocious evil on a level previously unknown. The name“Auschwitz” becomes the metaphor for what is considered as arupture in the historical development of civilization, as a catastropheof universal proportions. 11In her book Eichmann in Jerusalem. A Report on theBanality of Evil, Hannah Arendt gave a razor-sharp analysis ofthe evil of Auschwitz. In the “Postscript,” a kind of final evaluationof the book, Arendt characterizes the evil of Auschwitzwith the term “administrative massacre.” 12 For the evil ofAuschwitz was not a question of distinct and limited operations,but rather of a massacre, strategically calculated andplanned, with the complete extermination of the Jewish populationas its purpose. 13 To achieve a project on this scale requiredorganization by an absolutist regime driven to the extreme at11Regina Ammicht-Quinn, Von Lissabon bis Auschwitz (Freiburg-Schweiz: Universitätsverlag, 1992), 195-197.12Hannah Arendt, Eichmann in Jerusalem: a report on the banality ofevil (New York: Penguin Books, 1994), 288.13See Irving Greenberg, “Clouds of Smoke, Pillar of Fire: Judaism,Christianity, and Modernity after the Holocaust,” in Eva Fleischner, ed.,Auschwitz: Beginning of a new Era? (New York: Ktav Pub. Co., 1977). Six

100 BRUNO HIDBERthe political, economic and financial levels. In order to function,such organization needed the kind of industry and personnelthat could adapt themselves to what Max Weber called the“criteria of modernity.” 14 That is, Auschwitz and all that itstands for required an anonymous bureaucracy, an efficientspecification of work and a division of labor, and a rigid separationbetween the public and private spheres. Ethical-moral considerations,if they still arose at all, were categorically shutwithin the private sphere. To achieve an “administrative massacre,”morality had to be substituted for by efficiency andfunctionality. “This ‘objective’ attitude – talking about concentrationcamps in terms of ‘economy’ – was typical of the S.S.mentality”. 15 In this way the institutions and organizations ofthe Holocaust took on the character of an all-inclusive industry,connected by thousands of links to industry in general. The“industrial” aspect became quasi-autonomous. Human beingswere massacred and the operative category was no longer thehuman person, but rather the technical functioning of the factoryand of everything it needed for the best possible results. In1943, it was decided that children would no longer be gassedseparately from their parents but burned alive instead, not toadd to the horror or suffering, but simply to increase the numbersliquidated and at the same time to cut costs. Such is theface of administrative massacre: cold, passionless, programmedand organized perfectly as an industrial enterprise. 16What is new in this atrocity and “non-quality” of evil isexpressed in a program of extermination of human beings inwhich the face of the human person is rendered invisible by thelogic and strategy of industrial, financial and bureaucraticfunctionality, carried to a sophisticated extreme. Already heresome of the more negative features of what will later be called“globalization” are emerging. In theological terms, what areemerging are “structures of sin”, which tend to hide andmillion Jews were exterminated in the Holocaust program, correspondingto 30% of the worldwide Jewish population in 1939 and 80% of all rabbisand torah scholars.14Rüdiger Safranski, Das Böse (München: Hanser, 1997), 271-272.15Hannah Arendt, Eichmann in Jerusalem, 69.16R. Ammicht-Quinnn, Von Lissabon bis Auschwitz, 200-202.

100 BRUNO HIDBERthe political, economic and financial levels. In order to function,such organization needed the kind of industry and personnelthat could adapt themselves to what Max Weber called the“criteria of modernity.” 14 That is, Auschwitz and all that itstands for required an anonymous bureaucracy, an efficientspecification of work and a division of labor, and a rigid separationbetween the public and private spheres. Ethical-moral considerations,if they still arose at all, were categorically shutwithin the private sphere. To achieve an “administrative massacre,”morality had to be substituted for by efficiency andfunctionality. “This ‘objective’ attitude – talking about concentrationcamps in terms of ‘economy’ – was typical of the S.S.mentality”. 15 In this way the institutions and organizations ofthe Holocaust took on the character of an all-inclusive industry,connected by thousands of links to industry in general. The“industrial” aspect became quasi-autonomous. Human beingswere massacred and the operative category was no longer thehuman person, but rather the technical functioning of the factoryand of everything it needed for the best possible results. In1943, it was decided that children would no longer be gassedseparately from their parents but burned alive instead, not toadd to the horror or suffering, but simply to increase the numbersliquidated and at the same time to cut costs. Such is theface of administrative massacre: cold, passionless, programmedand organized perfectly as an industrial enterprise. 16What is new in this atrocity and “non-quality” of evil isexpressed in a program of extermination of human beings inwhich the face of the human person is rendered invisible by thelogic and strategy of industrial, financial and bureaucraticfunctionality, carried to a sophisticated extreme. Already heresome of the more negative features of what will later be called“globalization” are emerging. In theological terms, what areemerging are “structures of sin”, which tend to hide andmillion Jews were exterminated in the Holocaust program, correspondingto 30% of the worldwide Jewish population in 1939 and 80% of all rabbisand torah scholars.14Rüdiger Safranski, Das Böse (München: Hanser, 1997), 271-272.15Hannah Arendt, Eichmann in Jerusalem, 69.16R. Ammicht-Quinnn, Von Lissabon bis Auschwitz, 200-202.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!