#3(34)'12

#3(34)'12 #3(34)'12

supremecourt.ge
from supremecourt.ge More from this publisher
26.10.2014 Views

JURISDICTION OF THE LAW SUIT ON NOTARY ACT DAVIT SUKHITASHVILI Doctor of Low, Profesor If we look at the Georgian justice system, we will see that all branches of alw belongs to either private or public law. Civil Law, labor law, corporate law and other belong to private law, as they are free from the elements of the public law and visa versa, Constitutional Law, procedural pieces of legislation, administrative and criminal law, tax law and other branches are free from private law elements, thus they belong to public law. We cannot say the same regarding notary law, notary law encompases private, as well as public law elements and this is exactly the cause of challenges related to the law suits on notary acts or on refusal to perform a nptary act. Even the instruction on “Carrying out notary acts”, before ammending it on January 23, 2012, wrongly stipulated that the notary act on the refusal to perform notart act was always individual administrative – legal act. This was certainly not true. In order to clarify disputable issue, presented Article reviews theoretical and practical aspects of seperating public and private law and possibilities of implementing them in the real life. To sum up, notary act, performed based on administrative (public) law / legislation, legality of such a decision made by a notary, should be appealed in administrative court; as for the nptary acts that were performed based on the private law, cannot be considered as individual adminsitartive act and the case should be handled through cvil procedure legislation. 13

marTlmsajuleba N3 da kanoni mflobelobiTi (posesoruli) dacva kontinenturi evropis samarTalSi qeTevan qoCaSvili ivane javaxiSvilis saxelobis Tbilisis saxelmwifo universitetis iuridiuli fakultetis asistent-profesori, ivane javaxiSvilis saxelobis Tbilisis saxelmwifo universitetis doqtoranti 1. mflobelobiTi dacvis mniSvneloba me-19 saukunis kontinenturi evropis civilistur doqtrinaSi mflobelobis instituti kvlevis favoritad iqca. mis Sesaxeb aTeulobiT Seqmnil TxzulebaSi ikvlevdnen ara mxolod mflobelobis arss, aramed umTavresad, misi dacvis mizezebs. samoqalaqo samarTali icavs ama Tu im instituts, roca Seicnobs mis sargeblobas samoqalaqo brunvisaTvis an marTlmsajulebisaTvis. mflobelobiTi dacva samarTlebrivi wesrigis cocxali elementia, amitom marTlwesrigi mas TanamedroveobaSic xeluxleblad tovebs ZalaSi, 1 miuxedavad misi paradoqsuli Sedegisa (dacva vrceldeba ukanono mflobelzec), rac gadaWarbebuli SefasebiT, miuwvdomelia iuridiuli ganaTlebis armqone adamianis gonebisaTvis. 2 romis samarTlidan moyolebuli piris mflobelad aRiareba damoukidebeli mflobelobiTi dacvis SesaZleblobas ukavSirdeba. savini mflobelobis dafuZnebisas animus domini-s aniWebda gadamwyvet mniSvnelobas, amdenad, mflobelad miiCnevda mxolod mesakuTresa da ukanono mflobels. am azrs iziarebda puxtac, romelic Tvlida, rom mflobeloba mxolod sakuTrad flobis ganzraxvasTan erTad moiazreba da aseTi mesakuTris garda, qurdisa da yaCaRis mflobelobaa. 3 amdenad, isini romis samarTalSi analogiiT daSvebul, interdiqtebiT dacul aramesakuTreTa marTlzomier, e.w. warmoebul mflobelobas, anomaliad miiCnevdnen: warmoebuli mflobeloba yovelTvis ar arsebobs, is mxolod maSin aris saxeze, rodesac nebadarTulia pozitiuri samarTlis mier. 4 14

JURISDICTION OF<br />

THE LAW SUIT ON<br />

NOTARY ACT<br />

DAVIT SUKHITASHVILI<br />

Doctor of Low, Profesor<br />

If we look at the Georgian justice system, we will see that all branches of alw<br />

belongs to either private or public law. Civil Law, labor law, corporate law and<br />

other belong to private law, as they are free from the elements of the public law<br />

and visa versa, Constitutional Law, procedural pieces of legislation, administrative<br />

and criminal law, tax law and other branches are free from private law elements,<br />

thus they belong to public law. We cannot say the same regarding notary law,<br />

notary law encompases private, as well as public law elements and this is exactly<br />

the cause of challenges related to the law suits on notary acts or on refusal to<br />

perform a nptary act. Even the instruction on “Carrying out notary acts”, before<br />

ammending it on January 23, 2012, wrongly stipulated that the notary act on the<br />

refusal to perform notart act was always individual administrative – legal act.<br />

This was certainly not true. In order to clarify disputable issue, presented Article<br />

reviews theoretical and practical aspects of seperating public and private law and<br />

possibilities of implementing them in the real life.<br />

To sum up, notary act, performed based on administrative (public) law /<br />

legislation, legality of such a decision made by a notary, should be appealed in<br />

administrative court; as for the nptary acts that were performed based on the private<br />

law, cannot be considered as individual adminsitartive act and the case should be<br />

handled through cvil procedure legislation.<br />

13

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!