SeniSvnebi: 1 mowinave samarTlebrivi sistemebis didi nawili danaSaulis momzadebas principulad dausjelad acxadebs, Jan pradeli, `SedarebiTi sisxlis samarTali~ (Edition Dalloz, 1995), gv. 242. Tumca, arsebobs garkveuli gamonaklisebi am wesidan, magaliTad, inglisSi, safrangeTsa da amerikaSi danaSaulebrivi SeTanxmeba isjeba rogorc damoukidebeli danaSauli (ing. conspiracy, fr. association des malfaiteurs). mZime danaSaulTa momzadeba dasjadia espaneTSi, niderlandsa da zogierT sxva qveyanaSi. 2 analogiur kazuss avtorTa koleqtivi ixilavs wignSi `SedarebiTi sisxlis samarTali, zogadi nawili~ (Droit pénal général comparé, (edition cujas, 2005.). espaneli, ingliseli da niderlandeli kriminalistebi am SemTxvevas danaSaulis momzadebad akvalificireben, xolo frangi, germaneli, italieli da Sveicareli kriminalistebi _ mcdelobad. ix.: gv. 196. niderlandis sasamarTlom TiTqmis analogiuri SemTxveva (oRond im mcireodeni gansxvavebiT, rom yaCaRobis Cadenis ganzraxviT piri mivida Senobis karTan da dareka zari, ra drosac daakava policiam) daakvalificira danaSaulis mcdelobad, magram aseve msgavsi SemTxveva, romelSic Seiara- Rebul pirTa jgufi avtomanqaniT miuaxlovda dasayaCaRebel banks, magram manqanidan ar gadmosula, daakvalificira danaSaulis momzadebad. sasamarTlom miuTiTa, rom rodesac piri yaCaRobis Cadenis mizniT miuaxlovdeba banks, `mis qmedebas ver davakvalificirebT aRsrulebis dasawyisad, vidre is ar datovebs avtomanqanas an gadadgams dagegmili danaSaulis gansaxorcieleblad saWiro raime sxva materialur nabijs~, Jean Pradel “Droit pénal général comparé” (edition cujas, 2005.), gv. 85. 3 (1915) 2. K.B. 342. am saqmeSi sasamarTlom gamoiyena SedegTan siaxlovis Teoria. (ix.: qvemoT). analogiuri SemTxveva germaniis sasamarTlom aseve, daakvalificira danaSaulis momzadebad (BGH Dallinger MDR 1966, 197). 4 Comer v. Bloomfield (1970) (55) Cr. App. Rep. 305, sasamarTlom gamoiyena SedegTan siaxlovis Teoria. analogiuri SemTxveva, romelic moxda safrangeTSi aseve, dakvalificirda danaSaulis momzadebad, Crim. 22 Mai, 1984. 5 R. v. Rowley (1992) Cr. App. R. 95. 6 R. v. Jones (1990) 91. Cr. App. R. 351. 7 R. v. White 1910 2. K. B. am saqmeSi inglisis sasamarTlom gamoiyena pirveli aqtis Teoria, romlis mixedviTac, sakmarisia pirma ganaxorcielos pirveli qmedeba mimarTuli danaSaulis Casadenad. 8 Commonwealth v. Peaslee (177 Mass) 277. am saqmeSi inglisis sasamarTlom gamoiyena SedegTan siaxlovis Teoria (ix. qvemoT). 9 Chambre Criminelle, 13 Janvier, 1913, D. 1914. aseve, mcdelobad dakvalificirda Casafreba da lodini im adgilas, sadac unda gamoevlo fulis gadamtan avtomanqanas. Crim. 19 dec. 1970, JCP 1971. 10 People v. Rizzo 246. N.Y. sasamarTlom gamoiyena SedegTan siaxlovis Teoria. 11 Crim 11 Juin, 1975. 12 Crim. 14 Juin, 1995. 13 Crim. 5 Juin, 1984. 14 `danaSaulis mcdeloba xasiaTdeba iseTi moqmedebebiT, romelTac uSualod Sedegad unda mohyves danaSaulis dasruleba~ (Crim. 25 oct. 1962). 15 Tosti (1997) Criminal Law Review 476. 16 BGH 22, 80. 17 aseT formulirebas imeoreben sxvadasxva evropuli qveynebis, mag., niderlandis, belgiis, Sveicariis sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsebi. 18 am Teorias amerikuli da inglisuri sasamarTloebi iyenebdnen (mag., saqmeSi Davery v. Lee, 1968), magram sabolood, masze uari Tqves. Cveni azriT, es Teoria usaSvelod afarToebs mcdelobas da moicavs rogorc mosamzadebel moqmedebebs, aseve ganzraxvis ubralo gamovlenasac ki. 19 am Teorias xSirad iyeneben amerikuli da inglisuri sasamarTloebi, aseve, iyenebs belgiis umaRlesi sasamarTlo. Jean Pradel “Droit pénal général comparé” (edition cujas, 2005), gv. 76. 19
<strong>marTlmsajuleba</strong> N4 da <strong>kanoni</strong> 20 pirvelad, es Teoria gamoiyenes saqmeSi Regina v. Egleton (London 1855), magram mas xSirad akritikeben imis gamo, rom metismetad zRudavs mcdelobis farglebs. vidre savaraudo mkvleli Caxmaxs xels ar gamokravs, is bolo moqmedebas ar axorcielebs da Sesabamisad, mcdelobisaTvis pasuxs ver vagebinebT. 21 frangul sisxlis samarTalSi am Teorias mxars uWeren avtorebi ortolani da vilei. ix.: Michele Laure Rassat – DDroit Penal General (2004), gv. 312. 22 wignSi `SedarebiTi sisxlis samarTali, zogadi nawili~ (Droit pénal général comparé, (edition cujas, 2005.), swored frangi, germaneli da italieli kriminalistebi uWeren mxars sadavo SemTxvevis kvalifikacias danaSaulis mcdelobad, xolo espaneli, niderlandeli da ingliseli kriminalistebi ixrebian dana- Saulis momzadebisken. 23 aseTi qveyanaa inglisi da aSS-is zogierTi Stati. 24 aseve, analogiuri mosazrebaa aRniSnuli amerikul enciklopediaSi danaSaulisa da marTlmsajulebis Sesaxeb (American Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice. Vol II, p. 95). 20