saxelovnebo mecnierebaTa Ziebani #4 (49), 2011 ART SCIENCE ...
saxelovnebo mecnierebaTa Ziebani #4 (49), 2011 ART SCIENCE ... saxelovnebo mecnierebaTa Ziebani #4 (49), 2011 ART SCIENCE ...
lela oCiauri argumentebulad arc ki cdiloben. 1 ras ar uwodeben edvin Snores films:propagandistuls, fsevdoistoriuls, dakveTils, sicrues, falsifikacias, revanSistuls, pasuxs rusul filmze `nacizmi baltiispirulad~ (reJisori _ boris Certkovi) latvieli nacionalistebis Sesaxeb da nacionalisturs... rogori ucnauric unda iyos _ sabWoTa propagandistuli kinos analogiurs (!) `sabWoeTis istorias~ ruseTSi iseTi mwvave reaqcia mohyva, rom gadawyvites, pasuxad, amjerad, ukve mravalseriani filmi gadaiRon da Tqvan `simarTle~... iseve, rogorc sCveviaT. ratom? ra aris aseTi `sabWoeTis istoriaSi~, rac maT ar unaxavT, rasac ar uyureben da yoveldRiurad ar Cadian? ufro Semzaravi is ki araa, rac moxda, aramed is, rom procesi grZeldeba (SeiZleba,ara ise masStaburad,magram afxazeTis, samaCablos, CeCneTis da sxva aseTi magaliTebi, an sakuTari xalxis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli, sapirispiro imeds ar iZleva); sazogadoebis amgvari damokidebuleba niSnavs, rom am xalxis sulSi dResac igive xdeba da, albaT, igive moxdeba, Tu ruseTi fiqrs ar iswavlis, Tu mas gamosworebis survili ar gauCndeba. is,rom `sabWoeTis istoria~ ruseTSi (sadac cenzura sabWour reJimSi muSaobs da sityvis Tavisufleba, demokratia Tu sxva amgvari cnebebi mxolod virtualurad arsebobs) aikrZala, albaT, aravis gahkvirvebia. magram iman, rac filmis arsebobas da mis aralegalur Cvenebas sazogadoebis mxridan mohyva, yovelgvar molodidns gadaaWarba da aris kidec SeSfoTebisa da sasowarkveTis safuZveli. edvins Snores gansazRvriT, misi mTavari mizania, dasavleT evropelebamde stalinis reJimis Sesaxeb 1. http://www.izvestia.ru/news/335322. 86
simarTlis mitana. meore mizania, ganmartos, rom saubaria ara mxolod warsulze, aramed imaze, Tu rogor moaxdina gavlena stalinis danaSaulebaTa miCqmalvam Tanamedrove evropaze... 1 TviT ioseb stalinis yofili TanamebrZoli, Tanamoazre da Semdeg Serisxuli Teodor raskolnikovi (sazogado moRvawe, diplomati, Jurnalisti, saxalxo komisari, politemigranti) gaxmaurebul werilSi `Ria werili stalins~ yvelafer imas, rasac edvins Snore filmSi aCvenebs, adresats pirdapir mimarTvaSi eubneba: `... Tqven yvelaferi gaakeTeT sabWoTa demokratiis diskreditebisTvis, rogorc socializmis diskreditacia moaxdineT. imis nacvlad, rom konstituciiT dasaxuli cvlilebis gziT wasuliyaviT, Tqven axSobT mzard ukmayofilebas ZaladobiTa da teroriT. proletariatis diqtaturis Tqveni piradi diqtaturiT TandaTanobiT CanacvlebiT, Tqven gaxseniT axali etapi, romelic Cveni revoluciis istoriaSi `teroris epoqis~ saxeliT Seva. aravin sabWoTa kavSirSi ar grZnobs Tavs usafrTxod. aravin, dasaZineblad dawolisas ar icis, ascdeba Tu ara dapatimreba. dandoba aravis aqvs. marTali da damnaSave, oqtombris gmiri da revoluciis mteri, Zveli bolSeviki da upartio, kolmeurne glexi da politwarmomadgeneli. saxalxo komisari da muSa, inteligenti da sabWoTa kavSiris marSali _ yvela Tanabrad eqceva Tqveni Soltis dartymis qveS,yvela eSmakis sisxlian karuselze trialebs. rogorc vulkanis amofrqvevisasa uzarmazari lodebi skdebian da gruxuniT eSvebian krateris xaxaSi, aseve sabWoTa sazogadoebis mTeli fenebi wydebian da ufskrulSi cvivian. Tqven daiwyeT sisxliani angariSsworebebi yofili trockistebis,zinovievistebisa 1. http://actualhistory.ru/polemics-interv-shnore. `sabWoeTis istoriaSi~ _ rogorc sarkeSi 87
- Page 36 and 37: maia kiknaZe sakuTari piesiT’’p
- Page 38 and 39: maia kiknaZe mimarT iCenda, radgan
- Page 40 and 41: maia xaCiZe 40 gamogonili paTosi mx
- Page 42 and 43: maia xaCiZe oric ar dadioda dedamiw
- Page 44 and 45: maia xaCiZe gansakuTrebuli roli iTa
- Page 46 and 47: maia xaCiZe SemoqmedebaSi. Tu i. Wa
- Page 48 and 49: maia xaCiZe nawarmoebebSi, maWankli
- Page 50 and 51: 50 lia kalandariSvili pirveli princ
- Page 52 and 53: lia kalandariSvili Zalian didi manZ
- Page 54 and 55: lia kalandariSvili ra inteleqtis kv
- Page 56 and 57: lia kalandariSvili droSi) mexsiereb
- Page 58 and 59: lia kalandariSvili `mniSvnelovan gr
- Page 60 and 61: lia kalandariSvili kadrSi, marTlac,
- Page 62 and 63: maia levaniZe titrebisgan,xedviTi p
- Page 64 and 65: maia levaniZe sxvadasxva struqturiT
- Page 66 and 67: maia levaniZe saswaulebs~ axdendnen
- Page 68 and 69: maia levaniZe ucxo iyo munji period
- Page 70 and 71: maia levaniZe TiTqmis yvela filmSi
- Page 72 and 73: maia levaniZe presa gansakuTrebiT a
- Page 74 and 75: maia levaniZe kulakebis mavneblur s
- Page 76 and 77: maia levaniZe da mixeil Wiaurelis `
- Page 78 and 79: maia levaniZe am periodis sxva film
- Page 80 and 81: lela oCiauri gamoCnda misi pirveliv
- Page 82 and 83: lela oCiauri ruseTis da a. S. magal
- Page 84 and 85: lela oCiauri wesiT~ warudgines mosa
- Page 88 and 89: lela oCiauri da buxarinistebis wina
- Page 90 and 91: lela oCiauri erT danaSauls sxva mos
- Page 92 and 93: lela oCiauri sakuTari TvaliT vnaxe
- Page 94 and 95: eldar iberi gasarTobi teleprogrameb
- Page 96 and 97: eldar iberi gvaqvs gasarTobi telepr
- Page 98 and 99: eldar iberi televiziaSi. Sesabamisa
- Page 100 and 101: eldar iberi saqarTvelos prezidenti
- Page 102 and 103: eldar iberi `diadia~. saqarTveloSi
- Page 104 and 105: eldar iberi opozicioneri nodar anTa
- Page 106 and 107: eldar iberi unda aRiniSnos, rom `da
- Page 108 and 109: 108
- Page 110 and 111: saTeatro enis raoba maka vasaZe doq
- Page 112 and 113: maka vasaZe (is, rom zogjer, orive
- Page 114 and 115: maka vasaZe informaciis gadacemas m
- Page 116 and 117: maka vasaZe romlebic moqmedeben da
- Page 118 and 119: maka vasaZe sadac sivrce sam nawila
- Page 120 and 121: maka vasaZe mayurebeli mTeli sanaxa
- Page 122 and 123: maka vasaZe TeatrisaTvis Setyobineb
- Page 124 and 125: maka vasaZe SeiZleba warmoiqmnas ro
- Page 126 and 127: maka vasaZe mimdinare qmedebaSi, xo
- Page 128 and 129: maka vasaZe scenisa da darbazis urT
- Page 130 and 131: Tea kaxiani movlenad iqca. recenzie
- Page 132 and 133: Tea kaxiani zogad suraTsac gadmosce
- Page 134 and 135: Tea kaxiani indeferentuli masis kon
simarTlis mitana. meore mizania, ganmartos, rom saubaria<br />
ara mxolod warsulze, aramed imaze, Tu rogor moaxdina<br />
gavlena stalinis danaSaulebaTa miCqmalvam Tanamedrove<br />
evropaze... 1<br />
TviT ioseb stalinis yofili TanamebrZoli,<br />
Tanamoazre da Semdeg Serisxuli Teodor raskolnikovi<br />
(sazogado moRvawe, diplomati, Jurnalisti, saxalxo<br />
komisari, politemigranti) gaxmaurebul werilSi `Ria<br />
werili stalins~ yvelafer imas, rasac edvins Snore<br />
filmSi aCvenebs, adresats pirdapir mimarTvaSi eubneba:<br />
`... Tqven yvelaferi gaakeTeT sabWoTa demokratiis<br />
diskreditebisTvis, rogorc socializmis diskreditacia<br />
moaxdineT. imis nacvlad, rom konstituciiT dasaxuli<br />
cvlilebis gziT wasuliyaviT, Tqven axSobT mzard<br />
ukmayofilebas ZaladobiTa da teroriT. proletariatis<br />
diqtaturis Tqveni piradi diqtaturiT TandaTanobiT<br />
CanacvlebiT, Tqven gaxseniT axali etapi, romelic Cveni<br />
revoluciis istoriaSi `teroris epoqis~ saxeliT<br />
Seva.<br />
aravin sabWoTa kavSirSi ar grZnobs Tavs usafrTxod.<br />
aravin, dasaZineblad dawolisas ar icis, ascdeba Tu ara<br />
dapatimreba. dandoba aravis aqvs. marTali da damnaSave,<br />
oqtombris gmiri da revoluciis mteri, Zveli bolSeviki<br />
da upartio, kolmeurne glexi da politwarmomadgeneli.<br />
saxalxo komisari da muSa, inteligenti da sabWoTa<br />
kavSiris marSali _ yvela Tanabrad eqceva Tqveni<br />
Soltis dartymis qveS,yvela eSmakis sisxlian karuselze<br />
trialebs.<br />
rogorc vulkanis amofrqvevisasa uzarmazari<br />
lodebi skdebian da gruxuniT eSvebian krateris xaxaSi,<br />
aseve sabWoTa sazogadoebis mTeli fenebi wydebian<br />
da ufskrulSi cvivian. Tqven daiwyeT sisxliani<br />
angariSsworebebi yofili trockistebis,zinovievistebisa<br />
1. http://actualhistory.ru/polemics-interv-shnore.<br />
`sabWoeTis istoriaSi~ _ rogorc sarkeSi<br />
87
Change language