25.03.2013 Views

jkdKx

jkdKx

jkdKx

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

international law and treaty obligations in connection with its failure to honor its contractual<br />

agreements. The Lago Agrio Plaintiffs and other parties named in this Amended Complaint are<br />

not and cannot be parties to the Treaty Arbitration, and Ecuador has asserted sovereign immunity<br />

against claims filed in courts of the United States.<br />

c. Manipulating and Falsifying Their Own Experts' Findings<br />

to Corrupt the Judicial Inspection Process<br />

96. At the outset of the litigation, the Lago Agrio court ordered a process known as a<br />

judicial inspection to assess the 122 former consortium oil production sites. In a process agreed<br />

to by both parties and the court, experts were nominated by each side and appointed by the court<br />

to investigate and report on conditions at the sites. The court nominated a third set of "settling<br />

experts" to resolve any differences between the experts nominated by the parties.<br />

97. The RICO Defendants and their co-conspirators believed they could use and<br />

corrupt the judicial inspection process to their advantage. To this end, they designed a strategy<br />

to "choreograp[h]" the judicial inspections and to "create conflict, invit[ing] the press" to "entrap<br />

[Chevron] in the conflict." As Donziger put it, "The goal of the inspections [was] to win the<br />

legal case, not to produce an independent scientific repOli." From his perspective, the judicial<br />

inspection process was "all about politics and arguing and bulls[**]t and show." Part of that<br />

show was to organize a number of demonstrations at the judicial inspection sites-some<br />

threatened to become violent (see paragraph 76, supra)-to showcase the strength and will of the<br />

RICO Defendants' and their co-conspirators' "army" and to send a message to the judiciary that<br />

it was being watched.<br />

98. The RICO Defendants and their co-conspirators have also sought and obtained a<br />

court order prohibiting Petroecuador from conducting any remediation ofthe former consortium<br />

area. Fajardo spelled out to his colleagues, "[Petroecuador is] altering the evidence and it is<br />

possible that when our technicians go to the PG to take samples that they will find most of the<br />

waste has been removed. This could complicate things for us a bit." Fajardo explained that it<br />

was "urgent" that the RICO Defendants "coordinate" with Petroecuador "so they will desist<br />

42

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!