23.03.2013 Views

jjR0b

jjR0b

jjR0b

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

e called to testify in United States court. After Chevron filed an action pursuant to 28 U.S.C.<br />

§ 1782 seeking discovery from Stratus, Stratus held staff meetings attended by all staff available<br />

at that time, including some personnel who had been subpoenaed to testify. The staff members<br />

were provided with information about Chevron's subpoenas and the Cabrera Report, and<br />

Beltman, taking the opportunity to create a consistent but misleading story, misrepresented to the<br />

meeting attendees that Cabrera was an "independent expert who submitted his own report to the<br />

court." During this and other staff meetings, Beltman also misrepresented Stratus's role to<br />

Stratus staff. He explained that Stratus had "prepared a series of technical analyses" that were<br />

given to Cabrera "to help in his preparation of his report" and failed to disclose the fact that<br />

Beltman and other Stratus consultants had authored the report that Cabrera submitted as his own.<br />

161. Fajardo and Donziger also discussed how they would respond to any accusations<br />

that "Cabrera used exactly, or almost exactly, the same words we put in our motions." Fajardo<br />

offered the "[ s ]imple" solution of concocting a story that the RICO Defendants submitted<br />

material to Cabrera after they noticed some errors in the calculations and figures in the report and<br />

that Cabrera then adopted their submission. As Fajardo put it, "There is no substantive problem,<br />

we just have to explain it."<br />

162. Fajardo and Donziger also devised ways to hide their misconduct by creating<br />

special email addresses and code names to be used in planning and discussing their scheme.<br />

Fajardo, for instance, instructed Donziger not to use his own email account to send comments<br />

about the report that Stratus was ghostwriting, and not to send the comments to Fajardo's regular<br />

email address but to direct them to a new, specially created email address. Fajardo instructed<br />

Donziger, "do not insert any names in the document," and told him to use code names; Fajardo<br />

went by Lagarto 2, and Donziger by Lagmio 3. ("Lagarto" is Spanish for "lizard.") This was<br />

done, as Donziger has admitted, because they did not want others to know that Stratus had<br />

drafted the final report for Cabrera to submit to the court.<br />

163. In addition, the conspirators sought otherwise to cover their tracks in the United<br />

States. E-Tech, for example, failed to report income received for doing its work to the Internal<br />

65

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!