23.03.2013 Views

jjR0b

jjR0b

jjR0b

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Donziger discussed requesting a higher amount than $6 billion so a judgment of a lower amount<br />

could be portrayed as favorable to Chevron: "But as a concept, I ask, do we ask for much more<br />

than we really want as a strategy? Do we ask for eight and expect three, so that [the judge] says,<br />

'Look, Texaco, I cut down the largest part.'"<br />

108. And despite Russell telling Donziger that his estimate was inaccurate and that he<br />

did "not want to be involved in" the Lago Agrio Litigation and despite Donziger's assurance to<br />

Russell that he would stop using Russell's work, the RICO Defendants and their co-conspirators<br />

continued to use the exaggerated and disavowed $6 billion estimate. As Donziger explained it,<br />

"[G]iven that [the RICO Defendants] ha[d] worked with Russell's number all of these years," not<br />

continuing to use the $6 billion number "would make [them] look like fools." For example,<br />

Amazon Watch, exhibiting the same disregard of the facts as Donziger, continued to tout the $6<br />

billion figure well after Russell sent Donziger his cease-and-desist letter. Amazon Watch's press<br />

releases asserted that Russell's company, Global Environmental Operations, endorsed the $6<br />

billion damages estimate even though Russell implored Donziger to stop "abusing" the "name of<br />

[Russell's] company" by associating it with the Lago Agrio Litigation. For example, a March<br />

20,2007 press release entitled "Ecuador Court Speeds Up Chevron's $6 Billion Amazon Trial<br />

Over Rainforest Contamination" issued by Amazon Watch states: "The only independent<br />

damage assessment, by the U.S. firm Global Environmental Operations, puts clean-up costs at<br />

$6.14 billion, exclusive of personal damages to thousands of residents of the area." In issuing<br />

this press release, the conspirators lied about having an expert estimate of $6 billion when they<br />

knew that Russell repudiated the $6 billion figure as "no longer valid" and "a ticking time bomb"<br />

well over a year earlier. Donziger has subsequently admitted that he had no other basis for the<br />

$6 billion figure when that press release was issued.<br />

(ii) Filing Falsified Expert Reports<br />

109. Not only did the RICO Defendants and their co-conspirators pressure Russell to<br />

come up with a large, unsupported damages assessment, but they also submitted falsified expert<br />

46

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!