24.02.2013 Views

hRb7u

hRb7u

hRb7u

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

242. The RICO Defendants and their co-conspirators have made these same false<br />

statements to other federal agencies. In a letter dated April 29, 2008, to the U.S. Trade<br />

Representative, Defendants Yanza and Fajardo called Cabrera "an independent court-appointed<br />

special master," and misstated that "the bulk of the evidence relied on by the special master,<br />

Professor Richard Cabrera, was provided by Chevron itself via its own sampling evidence."<br />

243. And in April 2009, Donziger made false statements concerning Cabrera's<br />

purported "independence" in a statement before the U.S. House of Representatives. Donziger<br />

falsely stated that "[t]he best and most recent independent estimate available of the human health<br />

impact of this contamination is provided by the expert appointed by the court, Richard Cabrera."<br />

(emphasis added). Donziger also testified that "[n]umerous qualified scientists have reviewed<br />

this report and found its conclusions reasonable and the damages assessment consistent with the<br />

costs of other large environmental cleanups." At no time did Donziger disclose the fact that the<br />

"qualified scientists" were his co-conspirators Stratus, Beltman, Maest, and Chapman, who<br />

planned and secretly wrote the "Cabrera" Report.<br />

244. The RICO Defendants have also made false statements to individual members of<br />

Congress. On December 19, 2008, Defendant Beltman provided United States Congressman Jim<br />

McGovern's office "some talking points" for an interview with the Los Angeles Times, falsely<br />

telling the Congressman's staff that "[t]he Court Expert reviewed available scientific data and<br />

concluded that people in the area suffer from many illnesses caused by the contamination,<br />

including cancer." On January 31,2009, Beltman forwarded Cabrera's reports, stating "[t]he<br />

Court Expert's March 2008 report summary is attached," and that "[ a] Iso attached is the<br />

November 2008 response to the [Lago Agrio] Plaintiffs questions that was written by the Court<br />

Expert." Beltman failed to disclose that Stratus and the other RICO Defendants actually<br />

ghostwrote the responses to the Lago Agrio Plaintiffs along with Cabrera's initial report.<br />

245. In addition, the RICO Defendants have extended their campaign to state officials.<br />

In 2009, the RICO Defendants made fraudulent allegations about Chevron to the New York<br />

Attorney General, and provided that office with false information that Cabrera was a neutral<br />

97

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!