24.02.2013 Views

hRb7u

hRb7u

hRb7u

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

actual remediation work once the RICO Defendants obtained a fraudulent judgment against<br />

Chevron.<br />

147. Meetings and communications continued between the conspirators as they<br />

prepared Cabrera's report. Leading up to the April 2008 filing of Cabrera's first report, Stratus,<br />

Donziger, Kohn, and environmental consultants exchanged hundreds of emails regarding draft<br />

outlines ofthe Cabrera report and proposed annexes, schedules for completion of various<br />

annexes, and discussing review, analysis, and translation of the annexes including<br />

"[e]nvironmental standards," "[e]co impacts from contamination," "[p]it (plus) cleanup costs,"<br />

"[v]alue of human life losses," "[h]abitat losses at wells and stations," "TexPet [r ]emediation<br />

summary," "[h]istorical data summary," "[d]ata extrapolation" and "[t]oxicity of site chemicals<br />

to humans." (Additional details concerning the emails exchanged in furtherance of the<br />

conspiracy's scheme to defraud Chevron are included in Appendix B, which is incorporated by<br />

reference as if set forth herein in its entirety.)<br />

148. During this period, Donziger continued to press for higher and higher damages<br />

numbers, explaining at one point that an estimate for unjust enrichment "sound[ ed] awfully low"<br />

and implored that the Stratus consultants not "say or even suggest anything that backs away from<br />

the [Lago Agrio plaintiffs'] figures." And as another means of getting the high numbers he<br />

wanted-and getting the most impact from the "independent" expert-Donziger during this<br />

period suggested to Stratus that they "define the norms of clean-up" and then "propose these<br />

norms to the Ministry of Energy which governs these norms[,] and whose Minister is a good<br />

friend of ours, so that the Ministry issues them as an official decree before the trial ends."<br />

149. The numerous emails among the Stratus team and between Stratus and Donziger<br />

were necessary because, as Beltman explained in a February 22, 2008 email urging his Stratus<br />

colleagues' support: "We have to write, over the next 2 to 3 weeks, probably the single most<br />

important technical document for the case. The document will pull together all ofthe work over<br />

the last 15 or so years on the case and make recommendations for the court to consider in making<br />

its judgment." And that "single most important technical document for the case" was the<br />

59

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!