18.02.2013 Views

VOWELS IN STANDARD AUSTRIAN GERMAN - Acoustics ...

VOWELS IN STANDARD AUSTRIAN GERMAN - Acoustics ...

VOWELS IN STANDARD AUSTRIAN GERMAN - Acoustics ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Sylvia Moosmüller<br />

(1992) showed that listeners rely more on vowel-inherent factors and that coarticulatory<br />

cues play a minor role in the perception of vowels. Hillenbrand & Nearey (1999)<br />

conclude that<br />

“spectral change patterns play a secondary but quite important role in the recognition of<br />

vowel quality. […] However, a simple observation that should not be lost in this discussion<br />

of spectral change is that the single-slice spectral measurements reported in studies such as<br />

Peterson and Barney (1952) capture most of the information that is needed to represent<br />

vowel quality. In the present study, F0, duration, and steady-state formant measurements<br />

were sufficient to signal the intended vowel for roughly three-fourths of the utterances, with<br />

nearly all of the misidentifications involving adjacent vowel categories.” (Hillenbrand &<br />

Nearey 1999: 3521)<br />

Pitermann (2000) comes to the conclusion that static information is sufficient for<br />

identifying the vowels. Carré & Divenyi (2000) stress the importance of dynamic<br />

changes.<br />

It is already a challenge to look for invariant acoustic properties for stop con-<br />

sonants. Modifications to the original templates proposed by Blumstein & Stevens<br />

(1979) have been made in order to extend the concept to languages which differentiate<br />

further or places of articulation other than the bilabial, alveolar or velar (Lahiri et al.<br />

1984, Blumstein 1986). This task seems even more unsolvable for vowels. As is well<br />

known, the acoustic properties of vowels change in dependence on linguistic and<br />

extralinguistic factors, languages or language variants. Thus, the acoustic properties of<br />

the vowel /i/ are not the same in English and Standard Austrian German; in English, /i/<br />

is characterized by a spectral dominance of F2 and F3, in Standard Austrian German by<br />

a spectral dominance of F3 and F4. Therefore, the claim of the theory of acoustic<br />

invariance,<br />

“that a particular phonetic dimension should be realized by the same invariant property<br />

across all languages” (Lahiri et al. 1984: 391),<br />

cannot be upheld for vowels. Confronted with this lack of (articulatory and acoustic)<br />

invariance, it has to be asked, consequently, what makes an /i/ an /i/ (see also the<br />

discussion in Donegan 2002).<br />

178

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!