Krasnodar GRES Project Volume I11 Environmental Assessment

Krasnodar GRES Project Volume I11 Environmental Assessment Krasnodar GRES Project Volume I11 Environmental Assessment

pdf.usaid.gov
from pdf.usaid.gov More from this publisher
14.02.2013 Views

e helpful. An early meeting to describe emissions from combined cycle plants is suggested. Commission can use outside consultants to assist in the review. Some of these consultants may be critical of power plants. 4. Mr. Afanasyev pushed for a consensus by Commission on the use of Dr. Anikin to lead environmental work. Mr. Yudovsky stated that a new consultant would copy Dr. Anikin's work and take credit. Further, Rostov University may be opposed to the project. Mr. Yarmak stated that no single organization has had a positive EIA experience. Kubanenergo should use the best available. 5. Mr. Yarmak stated that he wants a new assessment - start from scratch. He expects that the American experts would produce the report. R. Edelman explained that the report will be prepared by the Russian consultants, and Burns and Roe will review the work. 6. Mr. Yarmak wants a single source responsible for the EIA. This is a credibility issue with the Commission and the local population. He would like to see Burns and Roe take the lead. R. Edelman noted that this is not the intent and further discussions are required. 7. Mr. Yarmak emphasized that the application of international standards is of highest priority. 8. Mr. Yarmak identified Ms. Burakova (Dept. Head) as the primary contact for Burns and Roe. Prepared by R. A. Edelman, Burns and Roe Company 11.2.3 Minutes of a General Meeting at the Kuban Folk Academy (KFA), 05125195 Agenda: Presentation and Review of the Report "Status of the Krasnodar GRES Project in Mostovskoy" by V.S. Anikin Attendees: G. M. Molokanov, President, KFA; N. V. Vitulskaya, Head Ecologist, KFA; A. G. Fisher, Head of Local History and Economy Study Department, KFA; PAGE 1 1-6

V.V. Fedorovich, Editor and Publisher of the Environmental Boomerang, an independent newspaper; Serebryakov, an activist representative of the Cossack Community "Motorist "; Mr. Frolov, a representative from the City of Gelendzik; V.S. Anikin, KSAU; S.E. Berlizov, KSAU; R.V. Teslenko, KSAU. Total: 13 people The meeting was chaired by Mr. Molokanov. Molokanov: Now, I'd like to give the floor to Mr. Anikin. Molokanov: Vitulkaya: Anikin: Vitulskaya: Fisher: Anikin: Molokanov: Anikin: Anikin makes his report. Does anyone have any questions? We keep criticizing the environmental committee, but now it turns out that they have rejected the Feasibility Study twice for reasons of atmospheric pollution. Within whose jurisdiction is Mostovskaya? The Armavir Committee. What kind of gas will be used? Astrakhan, Tyumen or condensate? That I don't know. What shape is the site in now? There is a construction settlement, about 20 buildings. They are assembled houses, people dubbed them Berlins or Brandenburgs because of the signs on them. There is no plant foundation yet, but there is a directorate and an operational construction team. They are standing by to start the construction. In the meantime, contact has been established between the directorate and the public. The nuclear power plant project left them the legacy of poor mutual relations. Now things have changed. The EIA has been revised a number of times. Whenever people said they did not trust the authors of the EIA, the director spared no money to invite experts chosen by the public rather than by the directorate. The head of the administration went abroad to examine similar facilities. My information is based on the local mass media. The administration head is all for the power plant. There will be no smoke from the stack, just some colorless shimmering. He saw it in Turkey, while in Italy such plants have no stack, there it is USAIDIKRASEIAIOFFICIALICHAPl 1 .DOC 3/26/96 PAGE 1 1-7

V.V. Fedorovich, Editor and Publisher of the <strong>Environmental</strong> Boomerang,<br />

an independent newspaper;<br />

Serebryakov, an activist representative of the Cossack Community<br />

"Motorist ";<br />

Mr. Frolov, a representative from the City of Gelendzik;<br />

V.S. Anikin, KSAU;<br />

S.E. Berlizov, KSAU;<br />

R.V. Teslenko, KSAU.<br />

Total: 13 people<br />

The meeting was chaired by Mr. Molokanov.<br />

Molokanov: Now, I'd like to give the floor to Mr. Anikin.<br />

Molokanov:<br />

Vitulkaya:<br />

Anikin:<br />

Vitulskaya:<br />

Fisher:<br />

Anikin:<br />

Molokanov:<br />

Anikin:<br />

Anikin makes his report.<br />

Does anyone have any questions?<br />

We keep criticizing the environmental committee, but now it turns<br />

out that they have rejected the Feasibility Study twice for reasons<br />

of atmospheric pollution. Within whose jurisdiction is<br />

Mostovskaya?<br />

The Armavir Committee.<br />

What kind of gas will be used?<br />

Astrakhan, Tyumen or condensate?<br />

That I don't know.<br />

What shape is the site in now?<br />

There is a construction settlement, about 20 buildings. They are<br />

assembled houses, people dubbed them Berlins or Brandenburgs<br />

because of the signs on them. There is no plant foundation yet,<br />

but there is a directorate and an operational construction team.<br />

They are standing by to start the construction. In the meantime,<br />

contact has been established between the directorate and the<br />

public. The nuclear power plant project left them the legacy of<br />

poor mutual relations. Now things have changed. The EIA has<br />

been revised a number of times. Whenever people said they did<br />

not trust the authors of the EIA, the director spared no money to<br />

invite experts chosen by the public rather than by the directorate.<br />

The head of the administration went abroad to examine similar<br />

facilities. My information is based on the local mass media. The<br />

administration head is all for the power plant. There will be no<br />

smoke from the stack, just some colorless shimmering. He saw it<br />

in Turkey, while in Italy such plants have no stack, there it is<br />

USAIDIKRASEIAIOFFICIALICHAPl 1 .DOC 3/26/96 PAGE 1 1-7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!