E-FILED - SC Superior Court E-Filing

The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5
Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement
Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value
[a]
Claim With Known
Age Greater Than
Zero Lit_ID
Claimant
ID Claim No. Date of CIS
Per CIS Form
Item
No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option
Repair/
Replacement
Cost
Depreciation
Amount
Per PPIF Form
Depreciation
% Age
2547 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 403 3 scarves Actual Cash Value 64.65 16.16 25.0% 2.0
2548 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 404 27 socks Actual Cash Value 145.46 36.37 25.0% 2.0
2549 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 405 2 hats Actual Cash Value 129.30 32.33 25.0% 2.0
2550 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 406 1 closet organizer Actual Cash Value 161.63 40.41 25.0% 2.0
2551 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 407 14 cotton turtlenecks Actual Cash Value $301.70 $75.43 25.0% 2.0
37 Total Claims With Known Age Greater Than Zero
Notes:
[a] Age information was determined based on the PPIFs for each specified Item. In cases where the PPIF age was specified in months, the age in this field equals the number of months divided by 12. In cases where the PPIF age was specified as a year of purchase,
the age in this field equals the year of loss minus the year of purchase. In cases in which the PPIF age was specified as a month and year of purchase, the age in this field equals the month and year of loss minus the month and year of purchase. Finally, in cases
in which a range of ages was specified (e.g. "0-2 yrs."), the age in this field equals the average of this range (e.g. the average of 0 and 2 is 1).
[b] Age shown on PPIF was contradicted by Activity Log discussion. Age from Activity Log is included in the "Age" field at left.
[c] Age was omitted from PPIF, but was discussed in Activity Log. Age from Activity Log is included in the "Age" field at left.
[d] Item on CIS did not directly match to a specific PPIF line item. However, PPIF did include two general categories of "ski"-related items, both noted as having an age of "2 yrs." As a result, I have assumed that this ski-related item is two years old.
Sources:
Claimant ID Claim No. Bates Range Claimant ID Claim No. Bates Range
1 55-01R7-146 SF_CL0000001 - SF_CL0000039 101 05-M494-044 SF_CL0002434 - SF_CL0002451
7 55-05X9-436 SF_CL0000064 - SF_CL0000081 105 55-E078-594 SF_CL0002597 - SF_CL0002633
11 75-052K-095 SF_CL0000143 - SF_CL0000163 109 75-M596-075 SF_CL0002741 - SF_CL0002873
12 75-03G8-444 SF_CL0000164 - SF_CL0000192 110 75-M423-267 SF_CL0002874 - SF_CL0002892
28 05-M443-777 SF_CL0000408 - SF_CL0000444 116 75-M592-294 SF_CL0002945 - SF_CL0002962
30 05-M486-516 SF_CL0000459 - SF_CL0000479 117 75-M548-962 SF_CL0002963 - SF_CL0002975
35 05-M380-567 SF_CL0000571 - SF_CL0000589 119 05-M370-594 SF_CL0003013 - SF_CL0003025
40 05-M517-927 SF_CL0001034 - SF_CL0001146 120 05-M475-002 SF_CL0003026 - SF_CL0003032
42 05-M394-706 SF_CL0001150 - SF_CL0001161 142 55-E023-943 SF_CL0003989 - SF_CL0004003
54 75-M566-207 SF_CL0001253 - SF_CL0001349 144 55-E017-574 SF_CL0004006 - SF_CL0004027
59 75-M564-724 SF_CL0001404 - SF_CL0001448 146 55-E115-455 SF_CL0004033 - SF_CL0004133
60 75-M415-579 SF_CL0001449 - SF_CL0001460 150 55-F969-790 SF_CL0004155 - SF_CL0004178
62 75-M553-079 SF_CL0001481 - SF_CL0001510 154 55-F953-632 SF_CL0004233 - SF_CL0004254
69 05-M488-313 SF_CL0001577 - SF_CL0001602 156 55-E124-263 SF_CL0004267 - SF_CL0004279
72 75-M537-021 SF_CL0001630 - SF_CL0001672 163 75-M446-056 SF_CL0004324 - SF_CL0004333
82 75-M613-624 SF_CL0001735 - SF_CL0001873 176 75-M523-509 SF_CL0004462 - SF_CL0004484
93 75-M456-650 SF_CL0001924 - SF_CL0001938 189 05-M496-133 SF_CL0004709 - SF_CL0004772
95 75-M624-390 SF_CL0001954 - SF_CL0002032 194 55-E089-494 SF_CL0007305 - SF_CL0007323
96 55-E010-714 SF_CL0002033 - SF_CL0002058 197 05-M430-965 SF_CL0007344 - SF_CL0007402
99 55-E051-497 SF_CL0002087 - SF_CL0002426 198 55-F996-562 SF_CL0007403 - SF_CL0007499
10/15/2012 53