12.02.2013 Views

E-FILED - SC Superior Court E-Filing

E-FILED - SC Superior Court E-Filing

E-FILED - SC Superior Court E-Filing

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

C. Brooks Cutter (SBN 121407)<br />

John R. Parker, Jr. (SBN 257761)<br />

KERSHAW, CUTTER & RATINOFF, LLP<br />

401 Watt Avenue<br />

Sacramento, California 95864<br />

Telephone: (916) 448-9800<br />

Facsimile: (916) 669-4499<br />

Robert A. Buccola (SBN 112880)<br />

Steven M. Campora (SBN 110909)<br />

James J. Ison (SBN 209116)<br />

DREYER, BABICH, BUCCOLA & WOOD, LLP<br />

20 Bicentennial Circle<br />

Sacramento, CA 95826<br />

Telephone: (916) 379-3500<br />

Facsimile: (916) 379-3599<br />

Attorneys for Plaintiffs<br />

SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA<br />

THE DOAN, PAUL ENDRES, individuals on<br />

behalf of themselves and a class of similarly<br />

situated persons,<br />

v.<br />

Plaintiffs,<br />

STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE<br />

COMPANY, an Illinois Corporation,<br />

Defendant.<br />

COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA<br />

UNLIMITED JURISDICTION<br />

-1-<br />

CLASS ACTION<br />

Case No. 108CV129264<br />

DECLARATION OF BRUCE<br />

MCFARLANE IN SUPPORT OF<br />

MOTION FOR CLASS<br />

CERTIFICATION<br />

Date: December 14, 2012<br />

Time: 9:30 A.M.<br />

Dept.: 1<br />

Judge Hon. James P. Kleinberg<br />

I, Bruce McFarlane, declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that<br />

the following is true and correct to my understanding and belief:<br />

1. I am over the age of 18, competent to testify herein, and make this declaration<br />

based upon personal knowledge.<br />

E-<strong>FILED</strong><br />

Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM<br />

David H. Yamasaki<br />

Chief Executive Officer/Clerk<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara<br />

Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

By G. Duarte, Deputy<br />

2. I am an independent expert in analyzing and measuring the financial impact<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

associated with alleged wrongful misconduct. I hold a Bachelor of Arts degree in Business<br />

Administration from the University of Washington. I am a Certified Public Accountant and a<br />

Certified Management Accountant. I am a Managing Director of LitiNomics, which is a<br />

professional consulting firm that provides financial and economic analyses to counsel and<br />

management involved in commercial litigation.<br />

3. My entire 28-year professional career has been devoted to the analysis of financial,<br />

economic, and accounting issues that arise in commercial litigation, and in particular, to the<br />

measurement of economic damages. In connection with my work, I have prepared damages<br />

analyses in over 200 commercial disputes, many of which involved allegations of breach of<br />

contract and unjust enrichment. I have testified as an expert witness with respect to damages in<br />

federal, state, and bankruptcy courts and in arbitration proceedings.<br />

4. A list of my current and past professional affiliations, positions, publications,<br />

presentations, and cases in which I have consulted and/or testified throughout my professional<br />

career is contained in my most recent curriculum vitae, which is attached hereto as Appendix 1.<br />

Background<br />

5. It is my understanding that Plaintiffs Endres, The Doan and the proposed class<br />

(“Plaintiffs”) are the holders of written policies of insurance issued by State Farm whereunder<br />

State Farm agreed to provide, inter alia, coverage for losses to personal property resulting from<br />

fire and other loss or damage. 1 It is my further understanding that Plaintiffs allege State Farm<br />

failed to properly determine and document in its claim files the depreciation used in settling<br />

policy holder claims. More specifically, I understand Plaintiffs allege that instead of considering<br />

the actual condition of the lost or destroyed items of personal property at the time of loss as<br />

required by applicable law, State Farm instead uses a standard estimating system known as the<br />

“Depreciation Guide” 2 which arbitrarily calculates a depreciation percentage based on the age<br />

and type of item, rather than the actual condition of a particular item. 3<br />

1 Third Amended Complaint, p. 2.<br />

2 Third Amended Complaint, 13, p. 3.<br />

3 Third Amended Complaint, 14, p. 3.<br />

-2-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

Assignment<br />

6. I have been retained by Plaintiffs’ counsel to evaluate the economic impact of<br />

State Farm’s alleged wrongful conduct. More specifically, and for purposes of this declaration, I<br />

have been asked to determine (1) the extent to which State Farm used a standard estimating<br />

system known as the “Depreciation Guide” to set the depreciation used in settling policy holder<br />

claims, and (2) whether the actual physical condition of the claimed item as of the time of loss is<br />

documented in State Farm’s claim files.<br />

Data Used For Analysis<br />

7. I obtained from Plaintiffs’ counsel claim files produced by State Farm (“Claim<br />

Files”) that contain, inter alia, (1) a Contents Inventory Summary (“CIS”) form, (2) an Activity<br />

Log and (3) a Personal Property Inventory Form (“PPIF”). In addition, I received from Plaintiffs’<br />

counsel State Farm’s depreciation guide (“SF Depreciation Guide”).<br />

8. I also received from Plaintiffs’ counsel an electronic database, which I understand<br />

was compiled by Plaintiffs’ counsel based on data contained in the Claim Files (“Claim File<br />

Database”). Specifically, the Claim File Database contains data obtained from the CIS forms and<br />

PPIFs listed above that were contained within Claim Files that State Farm produced. I understand<br />

that Plaintiffs’ counsel is continuing to receive claim files from State Farm and is adding<br />

additional data to the Claim File Database as Claim Files are received from State Farm. My<br />

analysis as set forth in this declaration is based on data available to me as of the date of my<br />

declaration. I will update my analysis based on additional data obtained from Plaintiffs’ Counsel.<br />

To confirm that the data contained in the Claim File Database accurately reflects the data<br />

contained in the underlying source documents, I and staff working under my direction and<br />

supervision audited selected records contained in the Claim File Database. Our audit work<br />

consisted of reviewing the underlying source documents to confirm the data in the Claim File<br />

Database were entered correctly. This audit consisted of the following steps:<br />

� For CIS data located in “Tbl_SF_Inventory”:<br />

o Reviewed each record to ensure the accuracy of fields “Item<br />

Desc/Mfg,” “Settlement Option,” “Repair/Replacement Cost,”<br />

-3-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

“Depr %,” and “Depreciation Amount.”<br />

o Compared the data in these fields to the most recent CIS available<br />

within the claim file.<br />

o For any record found to contain inaccurate or incomplete<br />

information as compared to the most recent CIS, updated relevant<br />

field(s). 4<br />

� For PPIF data located in “Tbl_PPIF”:<br />

o Reviewed each record to ensure the accuracy of fields “Item<br />

Condition,” “Item Age or Purchase Date,” “Replacement Repair or<br />

Restoration Cost,” “Today’s Value,” and “Value.”<br />

o Compared the data in these fields to the PPIF found within the<br />

claim file.<br />

o For any record found to contain inaccurate or incomplete<br />

information as compared to the PPIF, updated relevant field(s).<br />

42.1 Percent Of Claimed ACV Items Reviewed Contain Depreciation Amounts That Match<br />

The Applicable Depreciation Per The SF Depreciation Guide; 81% Of Claim Files<br />

Reviewed Contain Depreciation Amounts That Match The Applicable Depreciation Per The<br />

SF Depreciation Guide<br />

9. To evaluate the extent to which State Farm used a standard estimating system<br />

known as the “Depreciation Guide” to set the depreciation used in settling policy holder claims, I<br />

analyzed the depreciation State Farm used to settle ACV personal property claims per the CIS<br />

forms vis-à-vis the depreciation indicated based on the SF Deprecation Guide. Because both the<br />

age and State Farm’s depreciation of the item are required to use the SF Depreciation Guide, I<br />

could only include those claim files that have both a CIS and a PPIF. To perform this analysis, I<br />

performed the following steps:<br />

� From the Claim File Database, I obtained a listing of claimed items where<br />

the settlement option was equal to “Actual Cash Value” (“ACV Settlement<br />

Items”); 5<br />

� From the SF Depreciation Guide, I prepared a schedule that listed<br />

depreciation amounts by classification and subclassification (“SF<br />

4<br />

Our review revealed that, for many records, the “Item Desc/Mfg” field had been summarized or<br />

truncated. We updated this field in each instance where we determined that the additional<br />

information from the CIS form would be useful in our subsequent matching of the item to a<br />

specific category on the SF Depreciation Guide.<br />

5<br />

See ACV Settlement Items list at Appendix 5. This step resulted in identifying 2,551 claimed<br />

items from 40 claim files. Of these, 1,826 claimed items from 37 claim files included a known<br />

age greater than zero.<br />

-4-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

Depreciation Table”); 6<br />

� Relying on the ACV Settlement Items listing and the SF Depreciation<br />

Table, I used a statistical software program (STATA) 7 to identify, for each<br />

ACV Settlement Item, all categories in the SF Depreciation Table that<br />

could yield a depreciation percentage that was within one percentage point<br />

of the actual depreciation percentage found on the CIS. (“Potential<br />

8 9<br />

Depreciation Match List”);<br />

� For each “match” identified in the Potential Depreciation Match List, I<br />

compared the description of the item per the CIS form to the<br />

classifications per the SF Depreciation Guide that generated matches to<br />

determine if the potential match was in fact a true match to an appropriate<br />

classification in the SF Depreciation Guide;<br />

� Using the Potential Depreciation Match List, I calculated the number of<br />

claimed items for which the depreciation percentage per the CIS form<br />

matches the depreciation indicated per the SF Depreciation Table;<br />

� Using the Potential Depreciation Match List, I calculated the number of<br />

Claim Files that contain an ACV Item for which the depreciation<br />

percentage matches the depreciation indicated per the SF Depreciation<br />

Table.<br />

10. The results of my analysis indicate that, of the 1,826 claimed items for which I had<br />

the requisite data to perform my analysis (i.e., depreciation amount and description per the CIS<br />

form and a known age greater than zero per the PPIF), 669 items (36.6 percent) had descriptions<br />

and depreciation amounts that directly matched the SF Depreciation Guide, 100 items (5.5<br />

percent) had depreciation amounts that directly matched the SF Depreciation Guide and<br />

descriptions that appeared to be a probable match to the SF Depreciation Guide (i.e., not a<br />

“direct” match, but the description appeared consistent with at least one classification in the SF<br />

Depreciation Guide), and 1,057 items (57.9 percent) had descriptions that had no discernible<br />

match to the classifications in the SF Depreciation Guide. This analysis is set forth in Appendix<br />

2. As I discuss in more detail below, for those items for which there is no discernible match to<br />

the classifications in the SF Depreciation Guide, as well as for those items for which there is a<br />

match, the Activity Logs generally contain no documentation of the condition of the item at the<br />

6<br />

The SF Depreciation Table is presented in Appendix 6.<br />

7<br />

The STATA code used to generate the Potential Depreciation Match List is presented in<br />

Appendix 7.<br />

8<br />

For example, for a three-year old mattress with depreciation per the CIS equal to 15 percent, I<br />

identified all possible item classifications per the SF Depreciation Guide that could<br />

mathematically yield depreciation of 15 percent for a three-year old item.<br />

9<br />

The Potential Depreciation Match List is presented in Appendix 2.<br />

-5-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

time of loss or a discussion of other factors upon which State Farm may have considered in its<br />

determination of the depreciation amount.<br />

11. The results of my analysis also indicate that, of the 37 Claim Files which contained<br />

the requisite data to perform my analysis 30 (81 percent) contained at least one claim item settled<br />

for ACV where the depreciation per the CIS form matched 10 the applicable depreciation per the<br />

SF Depreciation Guide. This analysis is set forth in Appendix 2.<br />

12. In addition to examining depreciation on the CIS forms, I also reviewed the<br />

Activity Logs for any discussion of the bases upon which State Farm determined the depreciation<br />

used to settle claims. Consistent with the results of the matching analysis descried above, I found<br />

32 instances where the Activity Logs contained language indicating that the depreciation amounts<br />

State Farm used to settle ACV claims were based on the SF Depreciation Guide. A listing of<br />

such instances is presented in Appendix 3.<br />

13. In conclusion, 42.1 percent (36.6 percent direct match plus 5.5 percent probable<br />

match) of claimed items analyzed had depreciation amounts that matched the applicable<br />

depreciation for a specific category within the SF Depreciation Guide. As to the items that did<br />

not match a guide category, it appears that some other, non-condition based depreciation method<br />

was used. 11 However, further discovery is necessary to determine the derivation of the<br />

depreciation percentages State Farm used.<br />

14. 81 percent of Claim Files reviewed contain depreciation amounts that match the<br />

applicable depreciation per the SF Depreciation Guide. Lastly, State Farm’s Activity Logs<br />

contain numerous references indicating that it utilized the SF Depreciation Guide in settling ACV<br />

10<br />

As explained above, I flag an item as a “match” if the depreciation percentage per the CIS form<br />

is within plus or minus one percentage point of the depreciation indicated by the SF Depreciation<br />

Guide (per the age and description of the item per the PPIF).<br />

11<br />

It appears that State Farm likely used some basis for depreciation other than the actual physical<br />

pre-loss condition of the item as the “condition” of claimed items is mentioned in only 10 percent<br />

of the Claim Files I reviewed (see discussion below) and only a subset of this 10 percent contains<br />

a description of the physical condition of the item(s), as opposed to merely mentioning that the<br />

condition of the item was considered in the context of determining depreciation. Moreover, I note<br />

that neither the CIS form nor the PPIF request information regarding the pre-loss condition of<br />

claimed items.<br />

-6-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

8<br />

9<br />

10<br />

11<br />

12<br />

13<br />

14<br />

15<br />

16<br />

17<br />

18<br />

19<br />

20<br />

21<br />

22<br />

23<br />

24<br />

25<br />

26<br />

27<br />

28<br />

claim items.<br />

10 Percent Of Claim Files Contain Discussion Of Pre-Loss “Condition” Of Claimed Item In<br />

Context Of Evaluating Depreciation<br />

15. To determine whether State Farm documented in its claim files the actual physical<br />

condition of claimed items as of the time of loss, I searched the Activity Logs contained within<br />

Claim Files for comments relating to the physical condition of claimed items settled for ACV. In<br />

addition to manually reviewing claim files for instances of documenting the physical condition of<br />

claimed items, I performed a key word search for the word “condition.” Of the 188 claim files I<br />

searched, 19 (10 percent) contain a discussion of the pre-loss “condition” of a claimed item in<br />

context of evaluating depreciation. This analysis is set forth in Appendix 4. I note that, in a<br />

number of instances, although the word “condition” appears in the context of discussing<br />

depreciation, the actual physical condition of the property at the time of loss is not discussed or<br />

documented, but instead merely the assertion that State Farm considers the condition of the item<br />

prior to the time of loss in determining depreciation.<br />

Dated: October 15, 2012<br />

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California, that the foregoing is<br />

true and correct of my personal knowledge. Executed this 15 th day of October, 2012, at<br />

Neskowin, Oregon.<br />

By: _____________________________<br />

Bruce McFarlane, CPA<br />

-7-<br />

Declaration of Bruce McFarlane In Support of Motion For Class Certification


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 1


POSITION<br />

E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

PROFESSIONAL<br />

AFFILIATIONS<br />

(current)<br />

CURRICULUM VITAE<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

Managing Director, LitiNomics (January 2007 to Present; CEO 1/07 - 8/11)<br />

EDUCATION B.A., Business Administration (Accounting), University of Washington (1984)<br />

PROFESSIONAL<br />

AFFILIATIONS<br />

(past)<br />

RANGE OF<br />

EXPERIENCE<br />

PROFESSIONAL<br />

AND BUSINESS<br />

HISTORY<br />

Certified Public Accountant (California)<br />

Certified Management Accountant<br />

Member, American Institute of Certified Public Accountants<br />

Business Valuation and Litigation Services Section Member<br />

Certified in Financial Forensics<br />

Member, The Sedona Conference<br />

Working Group 9 - Patent Damages and Remedies<br />

Certified Management Consultant<br />

Member, Oregon Society of Certified Public Accountants Litigation Services Committee<br />

Member, Washington Society of CPAs Litigation Services Committee<br />

Member, Institute of Management Consultants<br />

Member, Licensing Executive Society<br />

Oregon Society of CPAs Litigation Services Committee (Chair, 1992; Vice Chair, 1991)<br />

Chair, Oregon Society of CPAs Litigation Services Conference Committee (1991)<br />

National Institute of Trial Advocacy, Faculty Expert Witness<br />

Senior Consultant, CRA International<br />

Member, Institute of Management Accountants<br />

Member, California Society of CPAs<br />

Litigation Section Member<br />

Member, Intellectual Property Owners Association<br />

Damages and Injunctions Committee member<br />

Experience includes testimony and consulting services in accounting, financial, economic<br />

and business issues related to commercial litigation and intellectual property related<br />

transactions.<br />

Independent Consultant February 2004–December 2006<br />

InteCap, Inc. (Mountain View, California)<br />

Managing Director, October 1999–February 2004<br />

PHB Hagler Bailly, Inc. (Portland, Oregon; Palo Alto, California):<br />

Principal, January 1996–September 1999<br />

Associate, January 1993–December 1995<br />

Price Waterhouse (Portland, Oregon):<br />

Manager, July 1990–December 1992<br />

Senior Consultant, July 1988–June 1990<br />

Staff Consultant, November 1987–June 1988<br />

Arthur Andersen (Portland, Oregon):<br />

Staff Accountant, June 1986–October 1987<br />

Peterson & Company (San Francisco, CA):<br />

Staff Consultant, January 1985–May 1986<br />

PUBLICATIONS “Intellectual Property/Equipment,” Litigation Support Report Writing, 2003 (co-authored<br />

with Lilian Quah).<br />

“10 Largest Trade Secrets Damages Awards” InteCap ReCap, Spring 2003<br />

“10 Largest Patent Damages Awards” InteCap ReCap, Fall 2002<br />

“<strong>Court</strong> Expands Lost Profits Damages From Patent Infringement,” CPA Expert, Summer<br />

1996 (co-authored with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

Page 1 of 26


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

PUBLICATIONS<br />

(continued)<br />

“The Implications of Changes in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for CPA—Expert<br />

Witnesses,” The CPA Management Consultant, Newsletter of the AICPA Management<br />

Consultant Division (Spring 1994) (co-authored with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

“The Revised Federal Rules of Civil Procedures That Apply to Expert Witnesses,” CPA<br />

Litigation Services Counselor, Volume 1994 Issues 2 3. Harcourt Brace (February and<br />

March 1994) (co-authored with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

“Opportunities in Litigation Services,” Journal of Accountancy (June 1992) (co-authored<br />

with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

“The Role of the CPA in Commercial Litigation,” The Oregon Certified Public Accountant<br />

(September 1991) (co-authored with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

“Using CPAs in Your Law Practice,” The Seattle-King County Bar Bulletin (February<br />

1991) (co-authored with Michael J. Wagner).<br />

.<br />

SPEECHES "Anatomy of a Patent Damages Calculation" Morgan Lewis, Palo Alto, March 5, 2008<br />

“Valuation of Intellectual Property For Computer Related Technologies” Computer Law<br />

Association, Palo Alto, CA June 4, 2003.<br />

“Damages Strategies for Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights” Computer Law<br />

Association, Palo Alto, CA, May 14, 2003; Intellectual Property Society, Los Altos, CA,<br />

August 13, 2003.<br />

“Extracting Value from Your IP Litigation” Tomlinson, Zisko, Morosoli Maser’s “Chautauqua”<br />

Series, Palo Alto, CA, September 25, 2002.<br />

“Perspectives on Value Extraction Models for Intellectual Capital Assets:<br />

Lessons Learned from the Trenches” The Intellectual Property Society, Santa Clara, CA,<br />

August 22, 2002.<br />

“Litigating Trade Secrets” Licensing Executive Society, 2002 Winter Conference, Las<br />

Vegas, NV, February 14, 2002.<br />

“Patent Damages 101: From Novice to Expert in Under Two Hours” Santa Clara University<br />

Law School, February 8, 2002.<br />

“IP Valuation Issues in Litigation: Hot Topics,” San Francisco Intellectual Property Lawyers<br />

Association, San Francisco, California, November 14, 2000; Gray Cary Ware Freidenrich,<br />

Palo Alto, California, February 1, 2001.<br />

“Case Studies in the Application of Regression Analysis,” American Institute of CPAs<br />

Advanced Litigation Services Conference, Beverly Hills, California, October 17, 2000.<br />

“Quantifying Damages in Environmental Disaster Litigation,” Oregon State Bar Convention,<br />

Seaside, Oregon, September 29, 1995<br />

“Issues in Risk Rate Selection Regarding Prejudgment Interest Rates,” California Society of<br />

CPAs’ Litigation Advanced Forum, San Diego, April 28, 1995.<br />

“The Revised Federal Rules of Civil Procedure as They Apply to Expert Witnesses,” various<br />

law firms in the Pacific Northwest, October 1993–March 1994.<br />

“Common Mistakes Made by Damage Experts,” Oregon Trial Lawyers Association Annual<br />

Conference, Sun River, Oregon, August 12, 1993.<br />

“Damages Arising From Business and Commercial Claims,” Oregon State Bar Continuing<br />

Legal Education Seminar, Portland, February 12, 1993.<br />

“Improving Expert Witness Effectiveness,” 1992 O<strong>SC</strong>PA Litigation Services Conference,<br />

Portland, September 25, 1992.<br />

“Calculating a Reasonable Royalty,” Price Waterhouse 1992 Litigation Managers Group<br />

Seminar, New Orleans, July 13–15, 1992.<br />

“Damages Including Loss of Earnings,” 1991 O<strong>SC</strong>PA Litigation Support Services<br />

Conference, Portland, September 27, 1991.<br />

“Calculating a Reasonable Royalty,” Price Waterhouse 1991 Litigation Managers Group<br />

Seminar, Denver, July 18–20, 1991.<br />

Page 2 of 26


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

1 Cadence Design Systems,<br />

Inc. v. IMI<br />

Telecommunications, Inc.<br />

P<br />

2 Comdisco, Inc. v. SocialNet,<br />

Inc., Match-Net, Inc., et al.<br />

P<br />

3 Atlas Electric, et al. v.<br />

National Association of<br />

Electrical Contractors<br />

D<br />

4 Dahl v. Bain Capital<br />

Partners, et al.<br />

P<br />

5 Flying J, Inc. v. Comdata<br />

Network, Inc.<br />

D<br />

6 In re Currency Conversion<br />

Fee Antitrust Litigation<br />

P<br />

7 In Re: Payment Card<br />

Interchange Fee and<br />

Merchant-Discount Antitrust<br />

Litigation<br />

P<br />

8 Knutson Towboat, Inc. v.<br />

Coos Bay Pilots Association<br />

P<br />

9 Peace Northwest Corp. v.<br />

Merle West Medical Center<br />

P<br />

10 Lorie Kuppenbender, et al. v. P<br />

California State Automobile<br />

Association Interinsurance<br />

Bureau<br />

Alter Ego<br />

Alter Ego<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Antitrust<br />

Bad faith<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C 00-20430 JF/EAI<br />

(2001)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Santa Clara<br />

County; Case No. CV<br />

800 611 (2004)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of<br />

Massachusetts; Lead<br />

Case No. 1:07-cv-<br />

12388-EFH<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Utah<br />

Northern Division;<br />

Civil No.<br />

1:96CV0066K (2000)<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>;<br />

Southern District of<br />

New York; MDL<br />

Docket No. 1409<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

New York; Case No.<br />

1:05-md-1720-JG-JO<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1988)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1988)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>, State<br />

of California, County<br />

of Sacramento; Case<br />

No. 07AS03197<br />

Page 3 of 26<br />

Cooley<br />

Godward/Melina<br />

Patterson<br />

Analysis of financial factors<br />

applicable to doctrine of<br />

alter ego.<br />

Winston & Strawn Alter ego analysis.<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Milo<br />

Petranovich<br />

Scott + Scott / Chris<br />

Burke<br />

Giauque, Crockett,<br />

Bendinger &<br />

Peterson/Gary<br />

Bendinger, John<br />

Bogart<br />

Schrag & Baum/Tom<br />

Schrag; Steyer<br />

Lowenthal<br />

Boodrookas Alvarez &<br />

Smith/Allan Steyer;<br />

Lerach Coughlin Stioa<br />

& Robbins/Chris Burke<br />

Berger & Montague /<br />

Merrill Davidoff,<br />

Michael Kane;<br />

Coughlin, Stoia,<br />

Geller, Rudman &<br />

Robbins / Chris<br />

Burke, Bonny<br />

Sweeney; Robins,<br />

Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi<br />

/ Craig Wildfang.<br />

Ragen, Tremaine,<br />

Krieger, Schmeer &<br />

Neil/John McGrory,<br />

Fred Aibe<br />

Perkins Coie/Michael<br />

Simon<br />

Kershaw, Cutter,<br />

Ratinoff & York /<br />

Brooks Cutter; Dreyer,<br />

Babich, Buccola &<br />

Callaham / Steve<br />

Campora<br />

Damages analysis.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

defendants' alleged<br />

monopsony of the LBO<br />

market.<br />

Analysis of lost profits<br />

damages in the trucker fuel<br />

card industry due to<br />

Comdata's violations of<br />

antitrust laws.<br />

Respond to defendants'<br />

expert's analysis of<br />

defendant banks' net<br />

incremental cost to provide<br />

international credit card<br />

transactions.<br />

Analysis of damages issues<br />

related to interchange fees<br />

charged merchants<br />

accepting Visa and<br />

MasterCard payment cards.<br />

Market share analysis;<br />

calculate plaintiff's lost<br />

profits.<br />

Business valuation.<br />

Analysis of class damages<br />

due to CSAA's alleged<br />

failure to waive deductibles<br />

in accident claims involving<br />

uninsured motorists.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

11 Patricia Vanderpool, et al. v.<br />

Allstate Insurance Company,<br />

et al.<br />

P<br />

Bad faith<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Sacramento<br />

County; Case No. 02-<br />

AS01532<br />

12 Black v. Finkelstein P Bankruptcy<br />

U.S. Bankruptcy<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Central District<br />

of California (1988)<br />

13 Continental Casualty<br />

Insurance Co. v. Lincoln<br />

Property Management Co.<br />

P<br />

14 First Interstate Bank of<br />

Oregon v. Latitude Marines,<br />

Inc.<br />

P<br />

15 In re: Stayton SW Assisted<br />

Living, LLC<br />

D<br />

16 State of California v.<br />

Rosendin, et al.<br />

P<br />

17 State of California v.<br />

Sherwin, et al.<br />

P<br />

18 3CX, Inc. v. Global Strategic<br />

Investment, Inc.<br />

P<br />

19 A.P.J. Associates, Inc. v.<br />

North American Philips<br />

Corporation and Signetics<br />

Company<br />

D<br />

20 Advanced Business<br />

Telecommunications v. Pac<br />

Bell<br />

D<br />

21 Ammari Electronics, et al., v.<br />

SBC Pacific Bell Directory, et<br />

al.<br />

P<br />

22 Bank One, Oklahoma, N.A.<br />

et al. v. Trammell Crow<br />

Services, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

23 Brown v. Pacific Northwest<br />

Bell<br />

D<br />

Bankruptcy<br />

Bankruptcy<br />

Bankruptcy<br />

Bid rigging<br />

Bid rigging<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Kershaw, Cutter,<br />

Ratinoff & York /<br />

Brooks Cutter<br />

Ball, Janik &<br />

Novack/Ken Novack<br />

Analysis of auto premium<br />

overcharges due to<br />

improper mileage rating.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Pre-litigation (1990) Chapman & Cutler Forensic accounting.<br />

U.S. Bankruptcy<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Oregon (1988)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon; Case No. 09cv-6082-HO<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Sacramento<br />

County (1992)<br />

Sacramento County<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>;<br />

Case No. 95F00913<br />

(1997)<br />

Stoel, Rives, Boley,<br />

Jones & Grey/Bennett<br />

Goldstein<br />

Ball Janik, LLP / Rick<br />

Stone, Tony<br />

Summers, Robert<br />

Taylor<br />

California State<br />

Attorney General/Tom<br />

Greene<br />

California State<br />

Attorney<br />

General/Molly Alden<br />

Pre-litigation Werner & Burke/Ryan<br />

Werner<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Michigan; Case No.<br />

98-74911<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California (1993)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Alameda<br />

County; Case No.<br />

RG-05198014<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois, Eastern<br />

Division; Case No.<br />

03 C 3624<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (1988)<br />

Page 4 of 26<br />

Banchero &<br />

Associates/Jeff<br />

Banchero<br />

Orrick Herrington/Tom<br />

Gray<br />

Meade & Schrag /<br />

Tyler Meade, Michael<br />

Schrag; Gillin<br />

Jacobson Ellis &<br />

Larsen / Luke Ellis.<br />

Jenner & Block /<br />

David Sanders<br />

Schwabe, Williamson<br />

& Wyatt/Jay Waldron<br />

Forensic accounting;<br />

calculation of earnings.<br />

Perform forensic accounting<br />

analysis.<br />

Statistical analysis of bid<br />

data regarding electrical<br />

construction contracts.<br />

Statistical analysis of bid<br />

data regarding contracts to<br />

provide food services to<br />

state prisons.<br />

Determine value of 3CX<br />

shares pursuant to buy-out<br />

provision in shareholder<br />

agreement.<br />

Determine compensation<br />

due plaintiff in connection<br />

with defendants' sales of<br />

microprocessors.<br />

Respond to plaintiff's<br />

analysis of lost profits.<br />

Prepare calculation of<br />

plaintiff-merchants'<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

alleged failure to fulfill<br />

obligation to distribute<br />

yellow page directories.<br />

Analysis of Bank One's<br />

damages due to alleged<br />

errors contained in Trammel<br />

Crow's financial analysis of<br />

a real estate investment.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages due to breach of<br />

contract involving error in<br />

yellow page advertising.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

24 Children's Hospital &<br />

Regional Medical Center v.<br />

Eclipsys Corporation<br />

D<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

Washington For King<br />

County; Case No. 02-<br />

02-02361-1SEA<br />

(2003)<br />

25 CIAL v. Venture Imaging D<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

26 Cleghorn Bar Enterprises, et<br />

al. v. Museum Parc Partners,<br />

L.P., et al.<br />

P<br />

27 Computer Business<br />

Applications, Inc. v.<br />

Computer Development, Inc.<br />

P<br />

28 Convergence Associates v.<br />

NaviSite, Inc.<br />

P<br />

29 David McDonald v. Silicon<br />

Valley Expert Witness<br />

Group, et al.<br />

D<br />

30 Deutsch Technology<br />

Research v. OrCAD, Inc.<br />

D<br />

31 DP-TEK Development<br />

Company v. Integrated<br />

Device Technology, Inc.<br />

P<br />

32 Eastman Kodak Company v.<br />

Calcomp Technology, Inc., et<br />

al.<br />

D<br />

33 F. M. Nicholas Co., Inc. v.<br />

AMP, Inc.<br />

P<br />

34 fourthchannel, inc. v. Pivotal<br />

Corporation<br />

D<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1988)<br />

Arbitration; Case No.<br />

74 180 00754 (San<br />

Francisco, 2002)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California (1994)<br />

Arbitration; JAMS<br />

Case No.<br />

1100040436<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California; Santa<br />

Clara County; Case<br />

No. CV 809 162<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association; Case<br />

No. 74 Y 117 01319<br />

98 (1998)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Kansas;<br />

Case No. 97-1541-<br />

JTM (1998)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California; County of<br />

Orange (2000)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C 00 2731 MEJ<br />

(2000)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association; Case<br />

No. 50 T 133 00200<br />

(2001)<br />

35 Fred Meyer v. A.T. Kearney D<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1992)<br />

Page 5 of 26<br />

Richard Johnston,<br />

Lisa Cameron/Hale &<br />

Dorr<br />

Perkins Coie/Michael<br />

Simon<br />

Banchero &<br />

Associates/Jeff<br />

Banchero, Nance<br />

Becker<br />

Perkins Coie/Doug<br />

Thorpe, Dan Johnson<br />

Russo & Hale/Jack<br />

Russo, Tim Hale,<br />

Mike Risch<br />

Russo & Hale/Jack<br />

Russo, Tim Hale,<br />

Mike Risch<br />

Ater Wynne/Steve<br />

Blackhurst<br />

Gibson, Dunn &<br />

Crutcher/Charles Ivie<br />

Irell & Manella/Ken<br />

Heitz<br />

Banchero &<br />

Associates/Jeff<br />

Banchero<br />

Dorsey &<br />

Whitney/Peter Sipkins<br />

Bullivant, Houser,<br />

Baily Pendergrass &<br />

Hoffman/ Doug<br />

Houser, Dan Lindahl<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

alleged breach of contract<br />

to install a Clinical<br />

Information System at<br />

plaintiff's hospital.<br />

Damages analysis.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Analysis of amounts due<br />

limited partners in San<br />

Francisco retail space<br />

limited partnership.<br />

Valuation of intellectual<br />

property.<br />

Determine Convergence's<br />

earnout revenues absent<br />

NaviSite's alleged breach of<br />

purchase agreement.<br />

Calculation of share value<br />

per terms of shareholder<br />

agreement.<br />

Rebut plaintiff's damages<br />

analysis regarding breach of<br />

software distribution<br />

agreement.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

contract re software<br />

development.<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

failure to develop inkjet<br />

printer technology.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

breach of distributor<br />

agreement.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

breach of software<br />

development and license<br />

agreement re internet<br />

commerce software.<br />

Damages analysis related<br />

to failed computer system<br />

installation.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

36 Glass & Associates v.<br />

Factory Mutual Insurance<br />

Company<br />

P<br />

37 Green Hills Software, Inc. v.<br />

Integrated Software, Inc.<br />

P<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Oregon;<br />

Civil No. 99-6105-HO<br />

(2000)<br />

Arbitration; Case No.<br />

72 117 01213 97<br />

38 Hifn, Inc. v. Intel Corporation P<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> for<br />

39 Honey Baked Ham, Inc., et<br />

al. v. Pilgrim's Pride<br />

Corporation<br />

P<br />

40 Honey Baked Hams, Inc. v.<br />

Towne, Inc.<br />

P<br />

41 Ion Beam Applications, Inc.<br />

v. Outrigger Systems, Inc., et<br />

al.<br />

D<br />

42 Joseph Ruwe, et al. v. Cellco P<br />

Partnership d/b/a/ Verizon<br />

Wireless<br />

43 Kaiser Aerospace &<br />

Electronics v. Teledyne<br />

Industries<br />

P<br />

44 Legacy Health Hospitals v.<br />

Aramark Corporation<br />

P<br />

45 Loranzo-Gurley, Inc., et al. v. P<br />

Northfield Insurance<br />

Company, et al.<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

the State of<br />

Delaware, County of<br />

New Castle. Case<br />

No. 05C-06-052-PLA<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California (Santa<br />

Ana); Case No.<br />

SACV 04-01158<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of the<br />

State of California,<br />

County of Orange<br />

(2002)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Santa Clara<br />

County; Case No. 1-<br />

03-CV-006620<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California, San<br />

Francisco Division;<br />

Case No. 07-cv-<br />

03679 JSW<br />

11th Judicial Circuit<br />

Miami - Dade<br />

County, Florida; Civil<br />

Action No. 95-05288-<br />

CA-15 (2001)<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1999)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Santa Clara<br />

County, Case No.<br />

106CV0577706<br />

Page 6 of 26<br />

Ball Janik/Rick Stone Determine damages to<br />

plaintiff's plywood mill due<br />

to insurance company's bad<br />

faith in settlement of<br />

business interruption claim.<br />

Munger Tolles &<br />

Olson/Greg Stone,<br />

Kelly Klaus<br />

Tom Moore Law<br />

Group / Tom Moore<br />

Peterson, Weyand &<br />

Martin / Kurt Peterson<br />

Peterson Weyand &<br />

Martin/Kurt Peterson<br />

Orrick Herrington &<br />

Sutcliffe/Matt Poppe<br />

Hagens, Berman,<br />

Sobol, Shapiro, LLP /<br />

Jeff Friedman;<br />

Chavez & Gertlier LLP<br />

/ Nance Becker; Law<br />

Offices of Peter B.<br />

Fredman / Peter<br />

Fredman<br />

Weil Gotshal &<br />

Manges/Ed Soto,<br />

Oscar Cantu, Gina<br />

Dombosch<br />

Ball Janik/Rick Stone,<br />

Bruce Conn<br />

Kastner Banchero /<br />

Jeff Banchero<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

software license agreement.<br />

Calculate damages due to<br />

Intel's breach of technology<br />

license and purchase<br />

agreement.<br />

Calculation of lost profits<br />

due to Pilgrim's failure to<br />

timely deliver food products.<br />

Determine Honey Baked<br />

Hams' damages due to<br />

printing of incorrect<br />

telephone number in mailing<br />

catalog.<br />

Analysis of balance due on<br />

promissory notes.<br />

Analyze Verizon's practice<br />

of charging late fees to<br />

customers who pay late.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

contract to jointly acquire<br />

Piper Aircraft Corporation's<br />

assets out of bankruptcy.<br />

Business valuation.<br />

Determine damages to<br />

Legacy Health Hospitals<br />

resulting from Aramark's<br />

breach of Management<br />

Services Agreement.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

failure to tender defense of<br />

a claim submitted by plaintiff<br />

/ policy holder.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

46 Lucey, et al. v. Prudential<br />

Insurance Company of<br />

America<br />

P<br />

47 Lussier Subaru, et al v.<br />

Subaru of New England,<br />

Inc., et al.<br />

P<br />

48 Manfredi Lacoste v. Oracle<br />

Corporation<br />

D<br />

49 Market Transport, Inc. v.<br />

Wackenhut Corp.<br />

P<br />

50 Micky Novak v. Seiko Corp.,<br />

et al.<br />

P<br />

51 Moving Media, Inc. v. Speck<br />

Cab Company.<br />

P<br />

52 NeWire, Inc. v. Southwire<br />

Company<br />

D<br />

53 Oregon Metallurgical Corp.<br />

v. Burlington Northern &<br />

Santa Fe Railway Company,<br />

CSX Transportation<br />

Company<br />

P<br />

54 Ostex International, Inc. v.<br />

Boehringer Mannheim<br />

P<br />

55 PC Designs, Inc. v. GN Hello P<br />

Direct<br />

56 Polo Ralph Lauren L.P. v.<br />

The Magnin Company, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of<br />

Massechusetts,<br />

Western Division;<br />

Case No. 3:10-CV-<br />

30163-MAP<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of New<br />

Hampshire; Case No.<br />

C-99-109-B (2000)<br />

Buenos Aires,<br />

Argentina<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1990)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon; Case No.<br />

CV 99 1022 RE<br />

(2000)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

San Francisco; Case<br />

No. 978740 (2001)<br />

Chancery <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

State of Tennessee,<br />

18th Judicial District<br />

at Sumner County;<br />

Case No. 2011C-21<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Oregon;<br />

Case No. 01-1052-<br />

HA (2001)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association; Case<br />

No. 79T184 00192<br />

95 (1996)<br />

Scott & Scott / Chris<br />

Burke; Kerr &<br />

Wagstaffe / Michael<br />

von Loewenfeldt<br />

Kronick, Moskovitz,<br />

Tiedemann &<br />

Girard/Bill Kershaw;<br />

Wiggin & Nourie/Rich<br />

McNamara<br />

Baker & McKenzie /<br />

Ben Ho<br />

Markowitz, Herbold,<br />

Stafford & Glade/Burt<br />

Stafford<br />

Elliott & Park/Dennis<br />

Elliott<br />

Werner & Burke/Ryan<br />

Werner<br />

Paul Hastings /<br />

William Whitner, Eric<br />

Stolz, Rachel Saloom<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Met Wilson,<br />

Milo Petranovich<br />

Mundt, MacGregor,<br />

Happel, Falconer,<br />

Zulauf & Hall/Jay<br />

Zulauf<br />

Arbitration (Florida) Andrews & Galatis /<br />

Ted Galatis<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (1997)<br />

Page 7 of 26<br />

Browne &<br />

Woods/Eddie Woods<br />

Analysis of class damages<br />

due to Prudential's alleged<br />

breach of contract related to<br />

payment of life insurance<br />

policy benefits for U.S.<br />

military service personnel.<br />

Determine damages to<br />

class of Subaru dealers due<br />

to over accessorization of<br />

cars.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

Seibel Systems' (acquired<br />

by Oracle) alleged breach of<br />

employment contract by<br />

failure to pay commissions<br />

due.<br />

Damages/business<br />

interruption analysis.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

compensation for plaintiffs<br />

role regarding defendants'<br />

sales of sport watches to<br />

Nike.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

advertising contract.<br />

Analysis of damages related<br />

to Southwire's alleged<br />

failure to use best efforts to<br />

commercialize flatwire<br />

technology.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

late railcar deliveries of raw<br />

material used in<br />

manufacture of titanium<br />

sponge.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

contact to promote plaintiff's<br />

osteoporosis testing<br />

technology.<br />

Determine additional<br />

royalties due per license<br />

agreement.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

franchise agreement by not<br />

allowing plaintiff to open a<br />

Polo Ralph Lauren store at<br />

LAX International Airport.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

57 Prestige Card, Inc. v. Bank<br />

One, et al.<br />

D<br />

58 Pyramed, Inc. v. Caremark,<br />

Inc.<br />

D<br />

59 Raikow v. Frontier Jeep<br />

Eagle<br />

D<br />

60 Retail Distributor v.<br />

Wholesale Manufacturer<br />

(disclosure of parties<br />

precluded by settlement<br />

agreement)<br />

P<br />

61 Sedona Corporation v. Open<br />

Solutions, Inc.<br />

P<br />

62 Seer Systems, Inc. v.<br />

Creative Technology, Ltd.<br />

P<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

Contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Arbitration (1998) Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Met Wilson<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (1989)<br />

Spears, Lubersky,<br />

Bledsoe, Anderson,<br />

Young & Hilliard/Bob<br />

Maloney<br />

Arbitration (1991) Betts, Patterson &<br />

Mines/James Nelson,<br />

Lori Guzzo; Stoll,<br />

Stoll, Berne &<br />

Lokting/Rob Shlachter<br />

Disclosure precluded<br />

by settlement<br />

agreement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of<br />

Connecticut; Civil<br />

Action No.<br />

3:07CV171 (MRK)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Santa Clara, Case<br />

No. CV 793916<br />

63 Seymon v. EASI, Inc., et al. P<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

64 SMS Automotive v. Allied<br />

Signal<br />

D<br />

65 Tarkington, O'Connor &<br />

O'Neill v. Fireman's Fund<br />

Insurance Companies<br />

D<br />

66 TRW, Inc. v. Talley<br />

Industries, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

67 Ultratech Stepper v.<br />

Dynamic Automated<br />

P<br />

68 United Computer Systems,<br />

Inc. v. AT&T<br />

D<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

California, County of<br />

San Joaquin; Case<br />

No. CV010303 (2001)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Pennsylvania (1992)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>; County of San<br />

Francisco; Case No.<br />

958950 (1996)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Arizona;<br />

Civil Action 94-0350-<br />

PHX-PGR (1995)<br />

Arbitration (San<br />

Francisco; 2001)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association; No. 72<br />

117 1362 91 (1998)<br />

Page 8 of 26<br />

Hennlley & Grossfeld /<br />

Orlando Cabanday,<br />

Ryan Jike<br />

Schiff Hardin / Gary<br />

Grossman, Paul<br />

Schuck<br />

Peterson Weyand &<br />

Martin/Alex Weyand<br />

Chadeayne, Burns &<br />

Leachman/Ron<br />

Leachman<br />

Duane, Morris &<br />

Hecksher<br />

Rice, Fowler, Booth &<br />

Banning/Kurt Micklow<br />

Donovan, Leisure,<br />

Newton & Irving/Jeff<br />

Conciatori<br />

Russo & Hale/John<br />

Kelley, Mike Risch<br />

Orrick Herrington &<br />

Sutcliff/Bob Freitas<br />

Analysis of lost profits due<br />

to defendant's breach of<br />

contract to develop affinity<br />

credit card program.<br />

Damages analysis.<br />

Forensic accounting;<br />

determine profit earned by<br />

auto dealership.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's lost<br />

profits due to alleged<br />

breach of contract regarding<br />

allocation of product among<br />

retail distributors.<br />

Calculate royalties due<br />

plaintiff due to defendant's<br />

alleged breach of software<br />

license agreement.<br />

Determine lost profits due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

technology licensing<br />

agreement.<br />

Valuation of goodwill value<br />

of EASI, Inc.<br />

Damages analysis/<br />

business valuation.<br />

Analysis of factors<br />

contributing to plaintiff's<br />

financial decline.<br />

Calculate defendant's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

plaintiff's breach of contract<br />

regarding sales of air bag<br />

technology.<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

breach of contract to<br />

develop high speed material<br />

handler used in<br />

semiconductor<br />

manufacturing.<br />

Rebut plaintiff's lost profits<br />

damages analysis re breach<br />

of software development<br />

contract.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

69 Wolfgang Brox v. Andreas<br />

Peneder<br />

P<br />

70 Workshare Technology, Inc.<br />

v. Litera Corporation<br />

P<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

Breach of<br />

contract<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, County of<br />

Napa; Case No. 26-<br />

25972<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association; Case<br />

No. 74-117-00863-08<br />

71 WSI v. Port of Portland P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

72 insureon.com v. Philadelphia P<br />

Indemnity Insurance<br />

Company, et al.<br />

73 LASVN#2, et. al. v. Vann<br />

Ness and Sperry, et. al.<br />

P<br />

74 Ainslie, et al. v. First<br />

Interstate Bank of Oregon<br />

D<br />

75 Huntington Bank, Inc. v.<br />

Gilchrist Timber Company<br />

D<br />

76 Ingersoll-Rand Financial<br />

Corp. v. First Interstate Bank<br />

of Oregon<br />

D<br />

77 Oregon Dental Association v. P<br />

United States National Bank<br />

78 Stephen Friedman v.<br />

Appaloosa Interactive<br />

Corporation; Andras<br />

Csaszar, Sega Enterprises<br />

USA, Bonus.com<br />

D<br />

79 Supra Corporation v. D.L.<br />

Horton Enterprises, Inc.<br />

P<br />

Breach of<br />

contract, bad<br />

faith<br />

Breach of<br />

contract,<br />

breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Breach of<br />

fiduciary duty<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1991)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Alameda (2002)<br />

Los Angeles <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, California;<br />

Case No. BC 206251<br />

(2002)<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon; (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1988)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, Santa<br />

Clara County; Case<br />

No. 1-05-CV-050715<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Los Angeles; Case<br />

No. BC 093085<br />

(1995)<br />

80 Bernhart v. Johnson P Breach of<br />

Washington State<br />

franchise<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>, King<br />

agreement<br />

County (1994)<br />

Page 9 of 26<br />

Kastner Banchero /<br />

Jeff Banchero<br />

Perkins Coie / Michael<br />

Baily, Chris Coleman<br />

Bogle & Gates/Dave<br />

Canary<br />

Werner & Burke/Ryan<br />

Werner, Joe Burke<br />

Krane & Smith/Marc<br />

Smith<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Met Wilson<br />

Ater, Wynn, Hewitt,<br />

Dodson &<br />

Skerritt/Steve<br />

Blackhurst<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Met Wilson,<br />

Tim Harmon<br />

Perkins Coie/Michael<br />

Simon<br />

Baker & McKenzie /<br />

Tod Gamlen, Keith<br />

Wurster<br />

Stradling, Yocca,<br />

Carlson & Rauth/Julie<br />

McCoy Akins<br />

Preston, Gates &<br />

Ellis/Carol Arnold<br />

Determine damages from<br />

operation and sale of<br />

partnership that owned The<br />

Candlelight Inn in Napa, CA.<br />

Determine lost profits<br />

Workshare suffered due to<br />

Litera's alleged breach of<br />

settlement agreement<br />

regarding Workshare's<br />

copyrights used in<br />

document comparison<br />

software.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's breach of<br />

contract to repair dry dock<br />

ship repair facilities.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

defendants failure to fund<br />

defense of trademark<br />

infringement suit filed<br />

against Insureon.<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to wrongful<br />

termination of commercial<br />

real estate brokerage.<br />

Analysis of defendant's<br />

compliance with terms of<br />

escrow agreement.<br />

Financial analysis.<br />

Business valuation.<br />

Analysis of defendant's<br />

compliance with terms of<br />

escrow agreement.<br />

Jury award distribution<br />

analysis.<br />

Rebuttal of plaintiff's<br />

business valuation<br />

damages analysis.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's lost<br />

profits due to business<br />

interruption.<br />

Calculate damages due to<br />

alleged wrongful termination<br />

of real estate franchise<br />

agreement


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

81 The Commissioner of<br />

Insurance of the State of<br />

Michigan v. Harris Trust and<br />

Savings Bank, et al.<br />

D<br />

82 Emerson Radio Corp. v.<br />

G&C Distributing<br />

P<br />

83 General Chemical v. Nisshin<br />

Gulf Coast, Inc.<br />

P<br />

84 I. B. Fischer v. Foodmaker,<br />

Inc.<br />

P<br />

85 Lewis River Golf Course v.<br />

Scott Seed Company, Inc.<br />

D<br />

86 LHS Communications<br />

Systems, Inc. v. Pacific Bell<br />

Mobile Services.<br />

D<br />

87 Virtual Silicon Technology,<br />

Inc. v. Library Technologies,<br />

Inc.<br />

P<br />

88 Ball, Ball, Brosamer, Inc. v.<br />

Myles Lorentz, Inc.<br />

P<br />

89 Adam Schwartz v. VISA<br />

International Corp.,<br />

MasterCard International,<br />

Inc. et al.<br />

P<br />

90 Cleghorn Bar Enterprises, et<br />

al. v. Garlock, et al.<br />

P<br />

91 Yield Dynamics v.<br />

Macrovision, et al.<br />

P<br />

92 Bayshore Ford Truck Sales,<br />

Inc. et al. v. Ford Motor<br />

Company<br />

P<br />

Breach of trust<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Breach of<br />

warranty<br />

Business<br />

devastation<br />

California<br />

Business &<br />

Professions<br />

Code § 17200<br />

Complaint for<br />

Indemnity<br />

Copyright<br />

infringement<br />

Dealer<br />

termination<br />

Michigan Circuit<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Ingham<br />

County (1996)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (1988)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, County of San<br />

Francisco; Case No.<br />

306072 (2000)<br />

Winston &<br />

Strawn/Mark Rotert,<br />

Carloyn McNiven<br />

Ball, Janik &<br />

Novack/Ken Novack<br />

Banchero &<br />

Associates/Jeff<br />

Banchero, Nance<br />

Becker<br />

N/A (1993) Milbank, Tweed,<br />

Hadley & McCloy/Rick<br />

Stone, Betsy Lear<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Washington (1988)<br />

Arbitration; Case No.<br />

30 Y 181 00786 99<br />

(San Francisco, 2001)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (San<br />

Francisco, 2003)<br />

District <strong>Court</strong>, City<br />

and County of<br />

Denver, Colorado;<br />

Civil Action #93 CV<br />

1234 (1995)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Alameda; Case No.<br />

822404-4 (2001)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, County of San<br />

Francisco; Case No.<br />

CGC 04-432322<br />

(2005)<br />

United States District<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Northern<br />

District of California<br />

(2003)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of New<br />

Jersey; Case No. 99<br />

cv 741 (JCL)<br />

Page 10 of 26<br />

Schwabe, Williamson<br />

& Wyatt/Donald Joe<br />

Willis<br />

Orrick, Herrington &<br />

Sutcliffe/Matt Poppe,<br />

Chris Ottenweller<br />

Russo & Hale/Tim<br />

Hale, John Kelley,<br />

Mike Risch<br />

Holland & Hart/Robert<br />

Benson, Ian Karpel<br />

Schrag & Baum/Tom<br />

Schrag; Steyer<br />

Lowenthal<br />

Boodrookas Alvarez &<br />

Smith/Allan Steyer;<br />

Millberg Weiss/Chris<br />

Burke<br />

Kastner Banchero /<br />

Jeff Banchero<br />

Russo & Hale / Tim<br />

Hale<br />

Kronick, Moskovitz,<br />

Tiedemann &<br />

Girard/Bill Kershaw,<br />

Lyle Cook, Jonathan<br />

Renner<br />

Transactional analysis of<br />

trust account activity;<br />

damages analysis.<br />

Analysis of defendant's<br />

sales, calculate lost profits.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages caused by failure<br />

of defendant's equipment<br />

used in the manufacture of<br />

high purity sulfuric acids.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's provision of e<br />

coli tainted meat to Jack In<br />

The Box franchisee.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's provision of<br />

incorrect grass seed.<br />

Prepare counterclaim<br />

damages analysis regarding<br />

failure of plaintiff's billing<br />

software program.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

alleged deficiencies in<br />

defendant's standard cell<br />

library software.<br />

Analysis of factors<br />

contributing to defendant's<br />

bankruptcy.<br />

Prepare cost and<br />

profitability analysis of<br />

multicurrency conversion<br />

settlement system.<br />

Forensic accounting<br />

analysis. Determine<br />

amounts owing plaintiffs.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendants<br />

alleged use of plaintiff's<br />

software code.<br />

Calculate damages for class<br />

of truck dealers regarding<br />

Ford's sale of its heavy duty<br />

truck business to<br />

Freightliner.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

93 Blount v. Oregon Tractor D<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Dealer<br />

termination<br />

Dealer<br />

termination<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1992)<br />

94 Lusk v. Jiffy Lube D<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Sacramento<br />

County (1992)<br />

95 Meyers v. UNOCAL P Dealer<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

termination<br />

Oregon (1991)<br />

96 The Communications Group<br />

v. GTE Mobilnet<br />

D<br />

97 Benchmark Designs of<br />

California v. D.W. Industries,<br />

Inc., et al.<br />

P<br />

Dealer<br />

termination<br />

Dissenting<br />

minority<br />

shareholder<br />

Eminent<br />

domain<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1992)<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County;<br />

Case No. 9408-<br />

05328 (1995)<br />

98 State of California v. Bio-Rad D<br />

Alameda <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, California<br />

(1992)<br />

Perkins Coie/Chris<br />

Angius<br />

Porter, Scott, Weibert<br />

& Delehart<br />

James, Denecke &<br />

Harris/Roger Harris<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Met Wilson,<br />

George Kirkland<br />

Larry Sokol &<br />

Associates/ Larry<br />

Sokol<br />

Law offices of James<br />

Whitaker/Jim Whitaker<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

plaintiff's alleged wrongful<br />

termination of franchise<br />

agreement.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to termination<br />

of franchise agreement.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to termination<br />

of franchise agreement.<br />

Business valuation.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to termination<br />

of franchise agreement.<br />

Valuation of minority<br />

shareholder interest.<br />

Determine damages<br />

resulting from state of<br />

California seizing<br />

defendant's land through<br />

eminent domain in<br />

connection with construction<br />

of highway.<br />

99 General Electric P Environmental<br />

contamination<br />

N/A (1995) GE in-house counsel Estimate costs to remediate<br />

contaminated sites.<br />

100 Lowe's Home Centers, Inc.<br />

v. General Electric Company<br />

D<br />

101 NEC Technologies v.<br />

Samsung<br />

P<br />

Environmental<br />

contamination<br />

False<br />

advertising /<br />

Lanham Act<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia; Case No.<br />

4:98-CV-0028-HLM<br />

(2000)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois (2001)<br />

102 Damerow Ford v. Prebble P Fraud<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1989)<br />

103 Eulrich v. Snap-On Tools<br />

Corp.<br />

D<br />

104 First Interstate Bank of<br />

Oregon v. C&B Livestock,<br />

Inc.<br />

P<br />

105 Hammersmith v. Taco Bell<br />

Corp.<br />

D<br />

Fraud<br />

Fraud<br />

Fraud<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Linn County (1990)<br />

Williams &<br />

Connolly/Steve<br />

Kuney, Bob<br />

Shaughnessy<br />

Bates &<br />

Carey/Richard<br />

Nicolaides<br />

Schwabe, Williamson<br />

& Wyatt/Tom Dulcich,<br />

Peter Ozanne<br />

Spears, Lubersky,<br />

Bledsoe, Anderson,<br />

Young & Hilliard/Milo<br />

Petranovich<br />

N/A (1991) Weiss, Jensen, Ellis &<br />

Botteri/Charlie Starkey<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1990)<br />

Page 11 of 26<br />

Skadden, Arps, Slate,<br />

Meagher & Flom<br />

Rebut plaintiff's lost profits<br />

damages analysis regarding<br />

lost opportunity to open a<br />

Lowes superstore in Rome,<br />

GA.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

false advertisements re flat<br />

panel pc monitors.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Investigation of possible<br />

fraud by operating partner of<br />

auto dealership.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged<br />

wrongful termination of<br />

franchise agreement.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Analysis of defendant's<br />

financial reporting.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged<br />

wrongful termination of<br />

franchise agreement.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

106 PG&E v. Satrap P Fraud<br />

Pre-litigation (1989) PG&E's Internal Audit<br />

Department<br />

107 Pioneer Liquidating<br />

Corporation v. San Diego<br />

Trust & Savings Bank, et al.<br />

D<br />

108 State of Oregon v. Vendu<br />

Services, Inc.<br />

P<br />

109 Jo Edward Enterprises, Inc.<br />

v. Ball, Ball, Brosamer, Inc.,<br />

et al.<br />

D<br />

110 Securities and Exchange<br />

Commission v. Sunwest<br />

Management, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

111 Paul Miller v. Bank of<br />

America<br />

P<br />

112 Dorothee Dary, et al. v.<br />

William and Lee Ann Gilbert,<br />

et al.<br />

D<br />

113 Checking Account Overdraft<br />

Litigation MDL No. 2036<br />

P<br />

114 In Re: Chase Bank USA,<br />

N.A. "Check Loan" Contract<br />

Litigation<br />

P<br />

115 Christensen Yachts v. New<br />

Hampshire Insurance<br />

P<br />

116 Virgin Vision, Ltd. v. The<br />

Samuel Goldwyn Co.<br />

P<br />

Fraud<br />

Fraud<br />

Fraud, breach<br />

of contract<br />

Fraud,<br />

Securities<br />

Laws<br />

Violations<br />

Fraud, Unfair<br />

Business<br />

Practices<br />

Fraudulent<br />

transfer<br />

Good Faith<br />

And Fair<br />

Dealing<br />

Good Faith<br />

And Fair<br />

Dealing<br />

Insurance<br />

claim<br />

Intellectual<br />

property<br />

United States District<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Southern<br />

District of California;<br />

Case No. 94-361<br />

(1995)<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Marion County (1993)<br />

District <strong>Court</strong>, City<br />

and County of<br />

Denver, Colorado;<br />

Civil Action #9 CV<br />

4495 (1995)<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Oregon;<br />

Case No. 09-CV-6056<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California; San<br />

Francisco County;<br />

Case No. 301917<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California; San<br />

Mateo County; Case<br />

No. 406876<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Southern District of<br />

Florida; Case No.<br />

1:09-MD-02036 JLK<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

09-cv-02032 MMC;<br />

MDL NO. 2032<br />

Post, Kirby, Noonan &<br />

Sweat/David Noonan,<br />

Steve Sanchez<br />

Oregon State Attorney<br />

General/Gene<br />

Ebersole<br />

Holland & Hart/Robert<br />

Benson, Todd Miller<br />

Ball Janik, LLP / Rick<br />

Stone, Tony<br />

Summers, Robert<br />

Taylor<br />

The Sturdevant Law<br />

Firm/Jim Sturdevant,<br />

Mark Johnson, Jesper<br />

Rasmussen<br />

Werner & Burke/Ryan<br />

Werner, Joe Burke<br />

Lieff, Cabraser,<br />

Heimann & Bernstein<br />

/ Roger Heller,<br />

Michael Sobol<br />

The Sturdevant Law<br />

Firm / Jim Sturdevant;<br />

Green Welling /<br />

Robert Green; Lieff<br />

Cabraser Heimann &<br />

Bernstein / Roger<br />

Heller.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Analysis of terms of natural<br />

gas contracts PG&E<br />

entered into with gas<br />

suppliers.<br />

Analysis of check kiting<br />

scheme. Analyze and<br />

respond to plaintiff's<br />

damages theories and<br />

calculations.<br />

Forensic accounting;<br />

calculation of defendant's<br />

unreported sales revenue.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Analysis of invoice and<br />

payment transactions.<br />

Perform forensic accounting<br />

analysis.<br />

Determine NSF fees<br />

charged to class.<br />

Profitability analysis.<br />

Determine goodwill value of<br />

saloon.<br />

Develop methodologies to<br />

measure overdraft fee<br />

damages due to defendant<br />

bank's alleged wrongful<br />

practice of posting debits to<br />

customer accounts in highto-low<br />

order of dollar<br />

amount.<br />

Analysis of damages due<br />

plaintiff borrowers due to<br />

Chase Bank's change in<br />

terms of "Check Loan"<br />

agreements.<br />

Arbitration (1992) N/A Determine economic impact<br />

on yacht manufacturer<br />

following destruction of<br />

manufacturing facility by<br />

fire.<br />

California State<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>, Los<br />

Angeles County; No.<br />

BC-013701 (1994)<br />

Page 12 of 26<br />

Law Offices of James<br />

P. Tierney/Susan<br />

Cleary<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's failure to post<br />

listing in film credits.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

117 Phase Metrics, Inc. v.<br />

Magnetic Recording<br />

Solutions, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

118 Asahi Kasei Pharma<br />

Corporation v. Actelion LTD,<br />

et al.<br />

P<br />

119 David Cooke, et al. v.<br />

Fremont Rideout Health<br />

Group<br />

P<br />

120 Jason Campbell, et al. v.<br />

PricewaterhouseCoopers,<br />

LLP<br />

P<br />

121 Julie Campanelli, et al. v.<br />

The Hershey Company<br />

P<br />

122 Yelena Lebedchik, et al., v.<br />

Pacific Bell Telephone Co.<br />

P<br />

123 Collegenet, Inc. v.<br />

Embark.com, Inc.<br />

D<br />

124 Monogram Aerospace<br />

Fasteners, Inc. v. The<br />

Fairchild Corporation<br />

D<br />

125 Southland Sod Farms v.<br />

Stover Seed Company, et al.<br />

P<br />

126 Tube Forgings, Inc. v.<br />

Weldbend, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Intentional<br />

interference<br />

with<br />

prospective<br />

business<br />

advantage<br />

Interference<br />

with<br />

Prospective<br />

Economic<br />

Advantage<br />

Labor law<br />

violations<br />

Labor law<br />

violations<br />

Labor law<br />

violations<br />

Labor law<br />

violations<br />

Lanham Act<br />

Lanham Act<br />

Lanham Act<br />

Lanham Act<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C-98-1799-CAL<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, San Mateo<br />

County; Case No.<br />

CIV 478533<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, County of<br />

Yuba; Case No. 08-<br />

0000278<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

California, Case No.:<br />

06-CV-02376-LKK-<br />

GGH<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

08-cv-01862-WDB<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

2-07-CV-392<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon; Case No.<br />

CV 00 981 ST<br />

Los Angeles <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong> (2001)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California; Civil No.<br />

92-4894-JMI (1994)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1992)<br />

Page 13 of 26<br />

Hoge, Fenton, Jones<br />

& Appel/Howard<br />

Lloyd, Bill<br />

Bretschneider<br />

Morgan Lewis &<br />

Bockius / Ben Smith,<br />

Chris Banks<br />

Kershaw, Cutter &<br />

Ratinoff / Bill<br />

Kershaw, Lyle Cook<br />

Kershaw, Cutter &<br />

Ratinoff LLP / Bill<br />

Kershaw<br />

The Brandi Law Firm<br />

/ Thomas Brandi,<br />

Brian Malloy<br />

Kershaw, Cutter &<br />

Ratinoff / Brooks<br />

Cutter<br />

Stoll, Stoll, Berne,<br />

Lokting &<br />

Shlachter/Robert Stoll<br />

Irell & Manella/Tom<br />

Foley, Mike Ermer<br />

Nordman, Cormony,<br />

Hair & Compton/Bob<br />

Compton<br />

Mayer, Brown &<br />

Platt/Tom McNeill<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

defendant's interfering with<br />

plaintiff's contract with third<br />

party concerning sale of<br />

hard disk drive testing<br />

equipment manufacturer.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

Actelion's alleged<br />

interference with Asahi's<br />

contract with CoTherix to<br />

develop the drug Fasudil for<br />

the treatment of pulmonary<br />

arterial hypertension<br />

(“PAH”).<br />

Calculate plaintiff class<br />

damages due to defendant's<br />

alleged failure to<br />

compensate certain<br />

employees pursuant to<br />

California wage and hour<br />

laws.<br />

Calculate plaintiff class<br />

damages due to PWC's<br />

alleged failure to<br />

compensate certain<br />

employees pursuant to<br />

California wage and hour<br />

laws.<br />

Analysis of overtime wages<br />

due.<br />

Analysis of class damages<br />

due Pacific Bell's alleged<br />

violation of California labor<br />

laws.<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to alleged<br />

false statements by<br />

defendants regarding online<br />

college application website<br />

service.<br />

Determine plaintiff's<br />

damages due to wrongful<br />

termination notice.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged false<br />

advertising regarding<br />

proprietary grass seed.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged false<br />

advertising regarding<br />

carbon steel butt-weld pipe<br />

fittings.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

127 Chain Tool Co. v. Workman,<br />

Nydegger & Jensen, et al.<br />

P<br />

128 Dr. Magda Botez v. Herzfeld<br />

& Rubin, International<br />

Housing Systems, Inc.<br />

P<br />

129 First Interstate Bank of<br />

Oregon v. Haynes & Waldon<br />

Farms, Inc.<br />

P<br />

130 Hrebec Properties, Inc. v.<br />

First Interstate Bank of<br />

California<br />

D<br />

131 JRS Products v. Network<br />

Office Systems<br />

P<br />

Legal<br />

malpractice<br />

Legal<br />

malpractice<br />

Lender liability<br />

Lender liability<br />

Libel<br />

Marital<br />

dissolution<br />

Third District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Utah (1990)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of the<br />

State of California,<br />

County of Los<br />

Angeles; Case No.<br />

BC 192893<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Deschutes County<br />

(1989)<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1991)<br />

Sacramento County<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

California; Case No.<br />

95 AS 04411 (1997)<br />

132 McCaw v. McCaw P<br />

King County <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Washington;<br />

Case No. 95-3-<br />

07235-0 SEA (1997)<br />

133 Orem v. Orem P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Marital<br />

dissolution<br />

Klamath County<br />

(1993)<br />

134 Sohn v. Sohn P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

135 E.L. Hamm & Associates,<br />

Inc. v. American<br />

Management Systems, Inc.,<br />

et al.<br />

D<br />

136 Franklin v. Johnny Limbo &<br />

The Lugnuts<br />

P<br />

137 Advanced Micro Devices,<br />

Inc., et al. v. Samsung<br />

Electronics Co., LTD., et al.<br />

P<br />

Marital<br />

dissolution<br />

Misappropriati<br />

on of<br />

intangible<br />

assets<br />

Partnership<br />

dissolution<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Douglas County<br />

(1991)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Virginia, Norfolk<br />

Division; Case No.<br />

2:98cv1046<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1994)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

CV-08-0986-SL<br />

Page 14 of 26<br />

Wilkins, Oritt &<br />

Headman/Jeff Oritt<br />

Green, Broillet,<br />

Taylor, Wheeler &<br />

Panish/Bruce Broillet,<br />

Scott Carr<br />

Marceau, Karnopp,<br />

Peterson, Noteboom<br />

& Hubel/Martin<br />

Hansen<br />

Lane Powell Spears<br />

Lubersky/Bob Maloney<br />

Law Offices of<br />

Richard Hart/ Richard<br />

Hart<br />

Perkins Coie;<br />

Danielson, Harrigan &<br />

Tollefson; Kinzel,<br />

Allan, Skone &<br />

Searing; Law Offices<br />

of Gordon Wilcox<br />

James, Denecke &<br />

Harris/Richard Urrutia<br />

Hutchinson,<br />

Anderson, Cox,<br />

Parrish & Coons<br />

Shaw Pittman Potts &<br />

Trowbridge/Ralph<br />

Taylor; Kaufman &<br />

Canoles/Steve Noona<br />

Jolles, Sokol &<br />

Berstein/Bernie Jolles<br />

Robins, Kaplan, Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Bill<br />

Manning, Eric Jackson<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant law firm's failure<br />

to procure foreign patent<br />

protection for U.S. patented<br />

chain tool device.<br />

Prepare valuation analysis<br />

of hotel/spa opportunity in<br />

Romania.<br />

Forensic accounting.<br />

Determine cause of failure<br />

of defendant's potato<br />

farming operation.<br />

Calculate damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged breach<br />

of contract to provide<br />

funding for construction of<br />

apartment complex.<br />

Compute plaintiff's lost<br />

profits.<br />

Investigatory accounting<br />

regarding divorce.<br />

Business valuation;<br />

valuation of marital estate.<br />

Business valuation.<br />

Rebut plaintiff's damages<br />

analysis regarding valuation<br />

of computer graphics<br />

marketing material.<br />

Prepare valuation analysis<br />

of band member's interest in<br />

partnership.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages due to Samsung's<br />

alleged infringement of<br />

patents related to memory,<br />

microprocessor and digital<br />

display technologies.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

138 Allvoice Developments US,<br />

LLC v. Microsoft Corp.<br />

P<br />

139 Altana Pharma, AG and<br />

Wyeth v. Teva<br />

Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.<br />

and Teva Pharmaceuticals,<br />

Ltd.<br />

D<br />

140 American Video Graphics v.<br />

Microsoft<br />

P<br />

141 Apple Computer, Inc. v.<br />

Burst.com, Inc.<br />

D<br />

142 Atari Corporation v. Sega of<br />

America, Inc.<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Washington<br />

(Western District);<br />

Case No. C10-<br />

2102RAJ<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of New Jersey<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas; Case No.<br />

6:05cv006 LED<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

06-CV-00019 MHP<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (1994)<br />

143 Atari v. Nintendo P<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Northern California<br />

(1992)<br />

144 Avia v. Nike, Inc. D Patent<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Infringement<br />

Oregon (1992)<br />

145 Brent Townshend v.<br />

Rockwell Semiconductor<br />

Systems, Inc., et al.<br />

P<br />

146 Callpod, Inc. v. GN Netcom,<br />

Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

San Mateo (1998)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois, Eastern<br />

Division; Case No.<br />

06CV4961<br />

Page 15 of 26<br />

Susman Godfrey / Ian<br />

Crosby, Rachael<br />

Black; Gardere<br />

Wynne Sewell LLP /<br />

Chris Perque<br />

Merchant & Gould /<br />

Chris Sorenson<br />

McKool & Smith /<br />

Chris Harrington<br />

Susman Godfrey /<br />

Floyd Short<br />

Flehr, Hohbach, Test,<br />

Albritton &<br />

Gerbert/Richard<br />

Doyle, Jr.<br />

Knobbe, Martens,<br />

Olson & Bear<br />

Baker & Botts/Scott<br />

Partridge, Tim Durst<br />

Wilson Sonsini<br />

Goodrich &<br />

Rosati/Ken Wilson,<br />

Betsy Lear<br />

Arnold & Porter /<br />

Monty Agarwal, Aaron<br />

Schur<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Microsoft's alleged<br />

infringement of patented<br />

technology related to speeh<br />

recognition.<br />

ANDA case. Provide<br />

declaration testimony<br />

regarding methodologies<br />

and ability to quantify patent<br />

infringement damages<br />

allegedly resulting from<br />

introduction of generic<br />

version of Protonix<br />

(Pantoprazole).<br />

Calculation of damages due<br />

to Microsoft's infringement<br />

of patents regarding preemptive<br />

multitasking in a<br />

computer operating system.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Apple's alleged infringement<br />

of Burst.com's patents<br />

related audio and video<br />

data storage and<br />

transmission.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages related to<br />

patented video game<br />

technology.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages related to<br />

patented video game<br />

technology.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding air sole<br />

shoe technology.<br />

Calculate lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to Rockwell's<br />

infringement of<br />

Townshend's patents<br />

regarding 56k modem<br />

technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to GN<br />

Netcom's alleged<br />

infringement of Callpod's<br />

patented invention related<br />

to wireless multi-user<br />

conferencing devices.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

147 Convolve, Inc. v. Dell, Inc., et P<br />

al.<br />

148 Cryptography Research, Inc.<br />

v. VISA International Service<br />

Association<br />

D<br />

149 Cylink Corporation v. RSA<br />

Data Security, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Marshall<br />

Division; Civil Action<br />

No. 2:08-cv-244<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (San Jose<br />

Division); Case No.<br />

05:C-04-4143 JW<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (1995)<br />

150 Datascape v. Avaya P Patent<br />

n/a (prelitigation<br />

Infringement<br />

license negotiation)<br />

151 Datascape, Inc v. Sprint<br />

Nextel Corporation, et al.<br />

P<br />

152 Datascape, Inc. v. Kyocera<br />

Wireless Corp., Inc.<br />

P<br />

153 Datascape, Inc. v. Sharp<br />

Electronics<br />

P<br />

154 Datascape, Inc. v. Sony<br />

Ericsson Mobile<br />

Communications, Inc.<br />

P<br />

155 Datascape, Inc. v.<br />

UTStarcom, Inc.<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia, Atlanta<br />

Division / Civil Action<br />

File No. 1:07-CV-<br />

0640-CC<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia. Civil Action<br />

No. 1:05-CV-1651-CC<br />

n/a (prelitigation<br />

license negotiation)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia. Case No.<br />

1:05-CV-3317-CC<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia. Case No.<br />

1:05-CV-3164-CC<br />

Page 16 of 26<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson, Anna Carr<br />

Mayer Brown /<br />

Brandon Baum<br />

Tomlinson, Zisko,<br />

Morosoli & Maser/Jim<br />

Busselle, Tom Moore<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Steve<br />

Risley, Scott<br />

Culpepper<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson, Heidi<br />

Raschke<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Steve<br />

Risley, Scott<br />

Culpepper<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Steve<br />

Risley, Scott<br />

Culpepper<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Steve<br />

Risley, Scott<br />

Culpepper<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

defendants' alleged<br />

infringment of Convolve's<br />

patented technology<br />

regarding accoustic<br />

management in hard disk<br />

drives.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

VISA's alleged infringement<br />

of patented technology<br />

regarding smart card<br />

security features.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding data<br />

encryption technology.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Avaya's' alleged infringment<br />

of Datascape's patented<br />

technology regarding WAP<br />

enabled cell phones.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Sprint's alleged infringment<br />

of Datascape's patented<br />

technology regarding WAP<br />

enabled cell phones.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Kyocera's infringement of<br />

portfolio of patents related<br />

to WAP enabled cellular<br />

telephones.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Sharp's alleged infringment<br />

of Datascape's patented<br />

technology regarding WAP<br />

enabled cell phones.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Sony Ericsson's<br />

infringement of portfolio of<br />

patents related to WAP<br />

enabled cellular telephones.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

UTStarcom's infringement<br />

of portfolio of patents<br />

related to WAP enabled<br />

cellular telephones.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

156 e2Interative, Inc., et al., v.<br />

Blackhawk Network, Inc.<br />

P<br />

157 Eastman Kodak Company v.<br />

Sony Corporation<br />

P<br />

158 Elantech Devices<br />

Corporation v. Synaptics, Inc.<br />

D<br />

159 Electro Scientific Industries,<br />

Inc. v. Dynamic Details, Inc.,<br />

GSI Lumonics, Inc.<br />

D<br />

160 Elk Industries, Inc. v.<br />

Glenayre Electronics, Inc.<br />

P<br />

161 Engineered Products Co., v.<br />

Donaldson Company,<br />

Incorporated.<br />

D<br />

162 Enterasys Networks, Inc. v.<br />

Foundry Networks, Inc. and<br />

Extreme Networks, Inc.<br />

P<br />

163 Extreme Networks, Inc. v.<br />

Enterasys Networks, Inc.<br />

D<br />

164 Georgia-Pacific Consumer<br />

Products LP v. The Clorox<br />

Company<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Wisconsin (Western<br />

District); Case No. 09cv-629-slc<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C 06-01839<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California; No.<br />

SACV00-272 AHS<br />

(2001)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Southern District of<br />

Florida (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Iowa; Case No. 98-<br />

2106MJM (2000)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of<br />

Massachusetts<br />

(Eastern Division);<br />

Civil Action No. 05<br />

11298 DPW<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Wisconsin; Civil<br />

Action No. 07-C-<br />

0229-C<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Georgia, Atlanta<br />

Division; Case No.<br />

1:08-CV-176<br />

Page 17 of 26<br />

Alston & Bird / Robin<br />

McGrath<br />

Jones, Day, Reavis &<br />

Pogue/Jim Wamsley,<br />

Leo Aggazino<br />

Morrison & Foerster /<br />

Karl Kramer<br />

Knobbe, Martens,<br />

Olson & Bear/Don<br />

Martens, Paul Stewart<br />

Christensen O'Connor<br />

Johnson<br />

Kindness/Jim Uhlir<br />

Robins, Kaplan, Miller<br />

& Ciresi/Annamarie<br />

Daley, Ken Hall<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson, Chris<br />

Sullivan<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson, Chris<br />

Sullivan<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Jim<br />

Anderson<br />

Analysis of lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

related to Blackhawk's<br />

alleged infringement of<br />

patented technology related<br />

to gift cards and prepaid<br />

telephone calling cards.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding<br />

microgap camcorder<br />

technology.<br />

Analysis of lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to Synaptics's alleged<br />

infringement of Elantech's<br />

patents related to touch<br />

sensor pads.<br />

Rebut patentee's lost profits<br />

and reasonable royalty<br />

damages analysis re patent<br />

for microvia laser drilling<br />

system.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding<br />

electronic aviation<br />

technology.<br />

Rebut plaintiff's lost profits<br />

and reasonable royalty<br />

analysis re air restriction<br />

indicators.<br />

Determine patent<br />

infringement damages due<br />

to defendants alleged<br />

infringement of patented<br />

network switch technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Extreme Networks' alleged<br />

infringement of patents<br />

relating to layer 2 / layer 3<br />

network switches.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Clorox's alleged<br />

infringement of patent<br />

regarding container design<br />

for dispensing disinfectant<br />

wipes.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

165 GraphOn Corp. v.<br />

Autotrader.com, Inc.<br />

P<br />

166 GraphOn Corporation v.<br />

Juniper Networks, Inc.<br />

P<br />

167 HPD Laboratories, Inc. v.<br />

The Clorox Company<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Civil Action<br />

No. 2:05-CV-530<br />

(JTW)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Marshall<br />

Division; Case No:<br />

2:07-CV-373-TJW-CE<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>;<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (2001)<br />

168 Huse v. Stratagene P<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

169 Intel Corporation and Dell,<br />

Inc. v. Commonwealth<br />

Scientific and Industrial<br />

Research Organization<br />

D<br />

170 Intergraph Corporation v.<br />

Intel Corporation<br />

P<br />

171 Intergraph Hardware<br />

Technologies Company v.<br />

Hewlett-Packard Company,<br />

et al.<br />

P<br />

172 Japan Cash Machine Co.,<br />

Ltd, JCM American<br />

Corporation v. MEI, Inc.<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, San Diego<br />

County (1991)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Tyler Division;<br />

Case No. 6:06-cv-<br />

0055 1-LED<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Alabama; Case No.<br />

CV 97-N-3023-NE<br />

(1999)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Marshall<br />

Division; Case No. 2-<br />

02CV-312 TJW<br />

(2004)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Nevada;<br />

Civil Action No. 2:05cv-01433<br />

(RCJ)<br />

173 Johnson v. Anderson D<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, San Francisco<br />

County (1993)<br />

Page 18 of 26<br />

Watson Rounds /<br />

Michael Rounds<br />

Watson Rounds /<br />

Michael Rounds;<br />

Vanek | Vickers |<br />

Masini / Joe Vanek.<br />

Morrison &<br />

Foerster/Mike<br />

Carlson, Brooks Beard<br />

Pillsbury, Madison &<br />

Sutro/Ina Risman<br />

Townsend and<br />

Townsend and Crew /<br />

Dan Furniss, Louise<br />

Ma, Rob Tadlock<br />

Townsend, Townsend<br />

& Crew/Bill Jaeger,<br />

Rick Grossman,Bill<br />

Bohler; McDermott<br />

Will & Emory / Steve<br />

Akerley<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Bill<br />

Manning, Jim<br />

Anderson, Eric<br />

Jackson, Bill Marino<br />

Watson Rounds /<br />

Mike Rounds; DLA<br />

Piper / David Abel<br />

Walter Moeller/Bill<br />

Caspari<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Autotrader's alleged<br />

infringement of GraphOn<br />

patents related to<br />

automated online service<br />

and directory technology.<br />

Calculate royalty damages<br />

due GraphOn due to<br />

Juniper Network's alleged<br />

infringement of GraphOn's<br />

patents related to<br />

networking device<br />

technology.<br />

Determine lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to defendants<br />

infringement of patents<br />

regarding toilet bowl cleaner<br />

technology.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding cloning<br />

technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Intel's alleged infringement<br />

of patented wireless 802.11<br />

technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Intel's alleged infringement<br />

of Intergraph's Clipper<br />

patents related to multiple<br />

caching strategies used in<br />

microprocessors.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Intergraph's alleged<br />

infringement of Intel patents<br />

related to RAID and<br />

graphics patents.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages for<br />

Intergraph's Clipper patents<br />

related to multiple caching<br />

strategies used in<br />

microprocessors.<br />

Analysis of plaintiffs'<br />

damages due to MEI's<br />

alleged infringement of<br />

plaintiffs' patents pertaining<br />

to bill validators used in<br />

casino gaming devices.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

regarding wood stove<br />

design technology.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

174 Juniper Networks, Inc. v.<br />

GraphOn Corporation and<br />

Vertical Marketing, Inc.<br />

D<br />

175 K2 Corporation v. Salomon<br />

S.A., et al.<br />

P<br />

176 Marshall Patent Holdings,<br />

LLC v. InComm Holdings,<br />

Inc. and U.S. South<br />

Communications, Inc.<br />

D<br />

177 McKesson Information<br />

Solutions LLC v. The<br />

Trizetto Group, Inc.<br />

P<br />

178 MEI, Inc. v. JCM American<br />

Corp, et al.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Virginia,<br />

Alexandria Division;<br />

Case No. 1:09cv287<br />

GBL/TRJ<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Washington; Case<br />

No. C98-1781 WD<br />

(1999)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Texas, Tyler Division;<br />

Civil Action No. 6:08cv-222<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong><br />

Northern District of<br />

Delaware; Case No.<br />

04-1258 (2005)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of New<br />

Jersey; Case No.<br />

1:09-cv-00351<br />

179 Microsoft v. Amazon D Patent<br />

n/a (pre litigation<br />

Infringement<br />

licensing negotiation)<br />

180 Monticelli v. Pacific Gas &<br />

Electric<br />

D<br />

181 Nichia Corporation v. Seoul<br />

Semiconductor, Co., Ltd.,<br />

Seoul Semiconductor, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C94 1754 (1995)<br />

United States District<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Northern<br />

District of California.<br />

Case No. 3:06-CV-<br />

0162 MMC<br />

Page 19 of 26<br />

Watson Rounds /<br />

Michael Rounds;<br />

Manek, Vickers &<br />

Masini / Joe Vanek<br />

Christensen O'Connor<br />

Johnson<br />

Kindness/Ross<br />

Boundy; Black, Lowe<br />

& Graham/Larry<br />

Graham<br />

Alston Bird / Robin<br />

McGrath, Joe Gleason<br />

Skadden Arps Slate<br />

Meagher & Flom<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages Juniper<br />

suffered as a result of<br />

GraphOn's alleged<br />

infringement of Juniper's<br />

patent related to data<br />

transmission in computer<br />

networks.<br />

Calculate lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to Salomon's<br />

infringement of K2's patents<br />

regarding inline skates.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

defendants' alleged<br />

infringement of patentee's<br />

technology related to<br />

prepaid telephone calling<br />

cards.<br />

Patent infringement<br />

damages analysis.<br />

DLA Piper / David Abel Analsis of lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to JCM's alleged<br />

infringement of invention<br />

related to currency<br />

validators used in gaming<br />

devices.<br />

Susman Godfrey /<br />

Justin Nelson<br />

PG&E in-house<br />

counsel/ Adam<br />

Chodorow<br />

Bingham McCutchen /<br />

Beth Parker, Monte<br />

Agarwal<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Amazon's alleged<br />

infringement of Microsoft's<br />

patented technology used in<br />

Amazon's Kindle Reader.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

regarding cooling tower<br />

construction design.<br />

Analysis of Nichia's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

Seoul Semiconductor's<br />

alleged infringement of<br />

Nichia's design patents<br />

regarding high brightness,<br />

white side-view LEDs.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

182 Nova Measuring<br />

Instruments, Ltd. v.<br />

Nanometrics, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California, San<br />

Francisco Division;<br />

Case No. C05 00986<br />

MMC (BZ)<br />

Beck, Ross, Bismonte<br />

& Finley<br />

183 Nova Science v. Abbott P Patent<br />

n/a Mintz Levin / Mike<br />

Infringement<br />

Renaud<br />

184 Orlaford Limited, et al. V.<br />

BBC International, et al.<br />

P<br />

185 Pactiv Corporation v. S.C.<br />

Johnson<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong><br />

Western District of<br />

Wisconsin; Civil<br />

Action No. 97-C-<br />

0540-S (1998)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois; Case No.<br />

98C-2679 (2000)<br />

186 Petrosky v. Nike, Inc. D Patent<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Infringement<br />

Virginia (1991)<br />

187 Pitney Bowes v. Stamps.com D<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

188 Pitney Bowes, Inc. v. Hewlett D<br />

Packard<br />

189 Precor v. Weider Health &<br />

Fitness, Inc.<br />

P<br />

190 Real Estate Alliance Ltd And<br />

Equias Technology<br />

Development LLC v. Move,<br />

Inc.<br />

D<br />

191 RealSource, Inc. v. Best Buy<br />

Company, Inc.<br />

D<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

District of Delaware;<br />

Case No. 02-042 JJF<br />

(2002)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of<br />

Connecticut; Civil<br />

Action No.<br />

395CV01764 (1997)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Washington; Civil No.<br />

C91-1743Z (1993)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California, Western<br />

Division; Case No.<br />

07-02185-GAF<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Texas, Austin<br />

Division, Case No.<br />

A0 4CA771 LY<br />

Page 20 of 26<br />

Analysis of lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

as a result of Nanometrics<br />

alleged infringement of<br />

patent pertaining to<br />

integrated metrology used<br />

in semiconductor<br />

manufacturing.<br />

Evaluate potential patent<br />

infringement damages due<br />

to Abbott's assumed<br />

infringement of surgical<br />

stapler technologies.<br />

Foley & Lardner Calculate patent<br />

infringement damages due<br />

to defendant's alleged<br />

infringement of patents<br />

regarding lights in heels of<br />

children's' shoes.<br />

Jenner & Block/Jim<br />

Benak, Andrew Jacobs<br />

Banner, Birch, McKie<br />

& Beckett/Roger Tate,<br />

Alan Kantor<br />

Irell & Manella/Elliott<br />

Brown, Ben<br />

Hattenbach<br />

Pennie &<br />

Edmonds/Jack Lauter,<br />

Steve Harbulak,<br />

Garland Stephens<br />

Christensen,<br />

O'Connor, Johnson &<br />

Kindness/Jim Uhlir,<br />

Tom Theisen<br />

Alston Bird / Robin<br />

McGrath, Wes Achey<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Eric Jackson<br />

Calculate plaintiff's lost<br />

profits and reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

defendant's infringement of<br />

plaintiff's patent regarding<br />

slider zipper food storage<br />

bags.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

damages regarding air sole<br />

shoe technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Stamps' infringement of<br />

Pitney patents regarding<br />

internet postage.<br />

Calculate reasonable royalty<br />

regarding resolution<br />

enhancement technology<br />

for laser printers.<br />

Lost profits/reasonable<br />

royalty calculation regarding<br />

exercise equipment.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Move's alleged infringement<br />

of REAL's patents related to<br />

interactive mapping<br />

technology on realtor.com.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty for patented<br />

technology related to gift<br />

cards.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

192 Rembrandt Vision<br />

Technologies, L.P., v.<br />

Johnson & Johnson Vision<br />

Care Inc.,<br />

P<br />

193 Seer Systems, Inc. v.<br />

Beatnik, Inc., Microsoft<br />

Corporation<br />

P<br />

194 Seer Systems, Inc. v.<br />

Yamaha Corporation<br />

P<br />

195 Silicon Graphics, Inc. v. ATI<br />

Technologies, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

196 Snyder Industries v. The Heil D<br />

Company<br />

197 St. Clair Intellectual Property<br />

Licensing, Inc. v. Fuji Photo<br />

Film Co. Ltd, Fuji Photo File<br />

USA, Inc., and Fujifilm<br />

America, Inc., Canon Inc.<br />

and Canon USA, Inc.<br />

P<br />

198 Townshend Intellectual<br />

Patent Infringement<br />

Property, LLC v. Broadcom<br />

Corp.<br />

P<br />

199 True Fitness Technologies,<br />

Inc. v. Precor Incorporated<br />

D<br />

200 Unisys Corporation v. Actel<br />

Corporation and Quicklogic<br />

Corporation<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Middle District of<br />

Florida, Jacksonville<br />

Division; Case No.:<br />

3:11-cv-00819-J-32-<br />

JRK<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C 03 4636 JSW<br />

(EDL)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; No. C 06--<br />

07736 WHA<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Wisconsin; Civil<br />

Action No. 06-C-<br />

0611-C<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Wisconsin (1991)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Delaware;<br />

Case No. 03-241-JJF<br />

(2004)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (San Jose)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Eastern District of<br />

Missouri; Case No.<br />

4:99 CV1306-DJS<br />

(2000)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

C-00-01114 SBA<br />

Page 21 of 26<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi; Jake<br />

Holdreith, Cole Fauver<br />

Peterson, Weyand &<br />

Martin / Alex Weyand<br />

Peterson, Weyand &<br />

Martin / Alex Weyand<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Bill<br />

Manning, Eric Jackson<br />

Banner, Birch, McKie<br />

& Beckett/Roger Tate,<br />

Chris McKie<br />

Robins Kaplan Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Ron Schutz,<br />

Jake Holdreith, Becky<br />

Thorson, Carrie<br />

Lambert<br />

Bingham McCutchen /<br />

Bill Abrams, Carlos<br />

Mino<br />

Christensen O'Connor<br />

Johnson<br />

Kindness/Ross<br />

Boundy, Steve Fricke<br />

Pillsbury Winthrup/Bill<br />

Abrams, Brian Beatus<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

J&J's alleged infringement<br />

of patented technology<br />

related to silicon hydrogel<br />

contact lenses.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty rate for Seer patents<br />

related to audio data<br />

storage and playback.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Yamaha's alleged<br />

infringement of Seer's<br />

patent regarding audio data<br />

storage and playback<br />

technology.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

ATI's alleged infringement<br />

of SGI's patents related to<br />

use of floating point<br />

computation in rasterization<br />

processes in graphics<br />

processing units.<br />

Calculate damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged<br />

infringement of patents<br />

regarding refuse container<br />

design.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty for St. Clair patents<br />

related to multiple file format<br />

capability in digital cameras.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Broadcom's alleged<br />

infringement of patented<br />

56k modem technology.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

True Fitness' infringement<br />

of patent regarding elliptical<br />

trainers.<br />

Determine reasonable<br />

royalty damages due to<br />

Quicklogic's infringement of<br />

patent regarding of<br />

architecture of Field<br />

Programmable Gate Arrays<br />

(FPGAs).


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

201 University of Pittsburgh v.<br />

Varian Medical Systems, Inc.<br />

D<br />

202 Vita Zahnfabrik H. Rauter<br />

GMBH & Co. v. Dentsply<br />

International, Inc.<br />

D<br />

203 Volterra Semiconductor<br />

Corporation v. Primarion,<br />

Inc., Infineon Technologies<br />

AG, et al.<br />

P<br />

204 UniRam Technology, Inc. v.<br />

Monolithic System<br />

Technology, Taiwan<br />

Semiconductor<br />

Manufacturing Company,<br />

Ltd., TSMC North America<br />

P<br />

205 Precor Incorporated v. Life<br />

Fitness<br />

P<br />

206 Bridget Bray v. TSP Hotels,<br />

Inc., et al.<br />

P<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

Infringement<br />

Patent<br />

infringement,<br />

theft of trade<br />

secret<br />

Patent<br />

infringement;<br />

unfair<br />

competition<br />

Personal<br />

injury<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Civil<br />

Action No. 2:08-cv-<br />

01307-AJS<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

SA CV 04-729<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

CV-08-5129 JCS<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California. Case No.<br />

CV-04-01268-VRW<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Washington; Case<br />

No. C94-1586C<br />

(1995)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Alameda; Case No.<br />

406526 (2004)<br />

207 Khouri v. Roberts P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Personal<br />

injury<br />

Washington County<br />

(1993)<br />

208 State of Hawaii v. USX D Product<br />

First Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

liability<br />

Hawaii (1992)<br />

209 In re: America Honda Motor<br />

Co., Dealerships Relations<br />

Litigation<br />

P<br />

RICO<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Maryland;<br />

MDL Case No. 1069<br />

210 Collins v. Tetra Pak, Inc. P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

211 Newman, et al. v.<br />

Comprehensive Care Corp.<br />

P<br />

Securities<br />

fraud<br />

Securities<br />

fraud<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1991)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Oregon (1993)<br />

Page 22 of 26<br />

Orrick Herrington &<br />

Sutcliffe / Matt Poppe;<br />

Picadio Sneath Miller<br />

& Norton / Henry<br />

Sneath, Joe Carnicella<br />

Morgan Lewis &<br />

Bockius / Doug<br />

Rawles, Andrew Gray<br />

Farella Braun + Martel<br />

/ James Morando, Jeff<br />

Fisher<br />

Susman Godfery / Joe<br />

Grinstein, Ian Crosby,<br />

Jay Neukom; Heim,<br />

Payne & Chorush /<br />

Russ Chorush<br />

Christensen O'Connor<br />

Johnson<br />

Kindness/Jim Uhlir,<br />

Ross Boundy<br />

Banchero Law<br />

Firm/Jeff Banchero<br />

James, Denecke &<br />

Harris/Roger Harris<br />

Berman, Paley,<br />

Goldstein &<br />

Berman/Tony Berman<br />

Rapazzini &<br />

Graham/Mark<br />

Rapazzini, Beth<br />

Graham<br />

James, Denecke &<br />

Harris/Roger Harris,<br />

Chris Martin<br />

Ball, Janik &<br />

Novack/Sara Ryan<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royatly damages due to<br />

Varian's alleged<br />

infringement of inventions<br />

related to respiratory gating<br />

used in linear accelerators<br />

during cancer treatment.<br />

Calculation of patent<br />

infringement damages due<br />

to infringement of patents<br />

related to dental color<br />

indicator devices.<br />

Analysis of patent<br />

infringement damages.<br />

Analysis of commercial<br />

success.<br />

Determine lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty damages<br />

due to defendants'<br />

infringement of patented<br />

technology regarding DRAM<br />

semiconductors. Calculate<br />

damages due to theft of<br />

trade secret.<br />

Determine lost profits and<br />

reasonable royalty due to<br />

Precor's alleged<br />

infringement of patents re<br />

treadmills. Determine<br />

Precor's damages due to<br />

false statements by Life<br />

Fitness.<br />

Calculation of lost earnings.<br />

Calculation of lost earnings.<br />

Damages analysis<br />

regarding alleged failure of<br />

Corten steel used to<br />

construct stadium.<br />

Calculate Honda dealers'<br />

lost profits from<br />

misallocation of new Honda<br />

automobiles.<br />

Business valuation and<br />

calculation of plaintiff's<br />

damages.<br />

Damages analysis.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

212 The Equitable Life<br />

Assurance Society of the<br />

United States, et al. v. David<br />

S. Shapira, et al.<br />

P<br />

213 Bartells Co. v. A.P. Green<br />

Industries<br />

D<br />

214 In re: Information Resources, P<br />

Inc.<br />

215 Ajaxo, Inc. v. E*Trade<br />

Group, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

216 DJ&J Software Corporation,<br />

dba Egghead Software v.<br />

Software House<br />

International, Inc.<br />

P<br />

217 Evanite Fiber Corporation v.<br />

Lauschaer Glaswerk GmbH,<br />

et al.<br />

P<br />

218 FundsXpress, Inc. v Digital<br />

Insight, Inc.<br />

D<br />

219 Gerber Radio Supply Co.,<br />

Inc. v. Philips<br />

Semiconductors, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

220 Honeywell International, Inc.<br />

v. Secure Wireless, Inc.<br />

P<br />

221 JCM American Corporation<br />

v. Mars Electronics<br />

International, Inc., Thomas<br />

P. Nugent<br />

P<br />

Securities<br />

fraud<br />

Securities<br />

laws violations<br />

Securities<br />

laws violations<br />

Theft of<br />

Trade Secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

U. S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Pennsylvania; Civil<br />

Action #93 0631<br />

(1994)<br />

King County <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Washington<br />

(1992)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois; Civil Action<br />

89C 3712 (1994)<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, Santa<br />

Clara County; Case<br />

No. 1-00-CV 793529<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, County of<br />

Los Angeles; Case<br />

No. BC 097126<br />

(1994)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of South<br />

Carolina, Charleston<br />

Division; Civil Action<br />

No. 2: 96-3525-18<br />

(1998)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Western District of<br />

Texas, Austin<br />

Division; Case No. A-<br />

02-CA-141SS (2002)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Massachusetts (1996)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Southern District of<br />

California; Case No.<br />

02-cv-2015<br />

Nevada District<br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Clark County;<br />

Case No. A507304<br />

Page 23 of 26<br />

Zelle & Larson/Rick<br />

Stone, Betsy Lear<br />

Calculate damages suffered<br />

by plaintiff note holders.<br />

Thompson & Mitchell Damages analysis.<br />

Freeborn & Peters;<br />

Katten, Muchin &<br />

Zavis<br />

Morgan Lewis / Joe<br />

Floren, Ben Smith,<br />

Chris Banks, Tera<br />

Heintz<br />

Perkins Coie/David<br />

Biderman, Colleen<br />

Reagan, Michael<br />

Sorochinsky<br />

Farleigh, Wada &<br />

Witt/Al Bannon, Karen<br />

Saul<br />

Cotton &<br />

Gundzik/John Cotton,<br />

Aaron Gundzik<br />

Banchero &<br />

Lasater/Jeff Banchero<br />

Simpson Thatcher &<br />

Bartlett / Jeff Ostrow<br />

Watson Rounds /<br />

Michael Rounds<br />

Determine securities<br />

damages to class.<br />

Analysis of unjust<br />

enrichment damages<br />

resulting from alleged<br />

misappropriation of trade<br />

secrets concerning<br />

technology enabling<br />

wireless stock trades on cell<br />

phones and PDAs.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages due to theft of<br />

trade secrets involving<br />

customer data.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

defendant's alleged theft of<br />

trade secret regarding<br />

manufacture of fiberglass.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

Digital Insight's theft of<br />

FundsXpress' trade secret<br />

information (customer list,<br />

pricing data)<br />

Valuation of trade secret;<br />

rebut plaintiff's damages<br />

calculation.<br />

Analysis of damages due to<br />

defendant's alleged<br />

misappropriation of trade<br />

secrets related to home<br />

security systems.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

theft of trade secrets related<br />

to manufacture of currency<br />

validators.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

222 The Profit Recovery Group v. P<br />

Loder, et al.<br />

223 Thomas & Betts Corporation<br />

v. Panduit Corp.<br />

P<br />

224 Yield Dynamics, Inc. v.<br />

Cypress Semiconductor<br />

Corporation<br />

P<br />

225 Yield Dynamics, Inc. v.<br />

Lumileds Lighting U.S., LLC.<br />

P<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Theft of trade<br />

secrets<br />

Trademark<br />

infringement<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>;<br />

Central District of<br />

California, Western<br />

Division; Civil Action<br />

No. CV 01-6200<br />

GHK (2001)<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

Illinois, Eastern<br />

Division (1997)<br />

American Arbitration<br />

Association (2006);<br />

Case No. 74 133<br />

00508 06 0MTH<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> for<br />

the State of<br />

California, Santa<br />

Clara County. Case<br />

No. 1-05-CV-037009<br />

226 Affinity Network, Inc. v. AT&T D<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

227 Pacific Electricord Company<br />

v. Paige Manufacturing Corp.<br />

D<br />

228 SalesMark, Inc. v. American<br />

Management Group, Inc.<br />

D<br />

229 Snelling and Snelling, Inc. v.<br />

MacLeod Investments, Inc.,<br />

et al.<br />

D<br />

230 Altitude Capital Partners -<br />

TPL Group Due Diligence<br />

na<br />

231 Eastman Kodak Company v.<br />

St. Clair Intellectual Property<br />

Consultants, Inc., et al.<br />

D<br />

232 e-Cards v. Larry Joe King, et<br />

al.<br />

P<br />

Trademark<br />

infringement<br />

Trademark<br />

infringement<br />

Trademark<br />

infringement<br />

Transaction<br />

Unfair<br />

competition<br />

Unfair<br />

competition<br />

(Lahnam Act)<br />

Central District of<br />

California (1994)<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>, Los Angeles<br />

County; Case No.<br />

BC157514 (1998)<br />

U. S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Civil<br />

Action No. C-98-<br />

0177 (1998)<br />

U. S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California; Civil<br />

Action No. C-97<br />

20156 (1997)<br />

Knobbe, Martens,<br />

Olson & Bear/Vito<br />

Canuso, John<br />

Holcomb, Linda Zadra-<br />

Symes<br />

McBride, Baker &<br />

Coles/Robert<br />

Queeney, George<br />

Sanders<br />

Russo & Hale / Jack<br />

Russo, John Kelley,<br />

Chris Sargent<br />

Russo & Hale /<br />

Michael Risch<br />

Jeffer, Mangels,<br />

Butler &<br />

Marmaro/Stan Gibson<br />

Werner & Burke/Joe<br />

Burke<br />

Thelen, Reid &<br />

Priest/Robert Weikert<br />

Margolis &<br />

Morin/Michael Morin<br />

Analysis to determine<br />

whether defendants<br />

practiced plaintiff's claimed<br />

trade secrets and whether<br />

claimed trade secrets<br />

possessed independent<br />

economic value.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

defendant's theft of trade<br />

secrets (customer data).<br />

Analysis of YDI's damages<br />

due to Cypress<br />

Semiconductor's alleged<br />

unlicensed use of YDI's<br />

yield enhancement software.<br />

Determine damages due to<br />

Lumileds' theft of trade<br />

secrets relating to yield<br />

enhancement software.<br />

Damages analysis.<br />

Calculate defendant's<br />

damages in cross-complaint<br />

against plaintiff for<br />

trademark infringement.<br />

Analysis of reasonable<br />

royalty, lost profits and<br />

unjust enrichment damages.<br />

Calculate plaintiff's<br />

damages resulting from<br />

defendant's trademark<br />

infringement.<br />

n/a n/a Provide economic due<br />

diligence analysis in<br />

connection with IP<br />

investment opportunity.<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

California, Santa<br />

Clara County; Case<br />

No.: 1-05-CV-039164<br />

U. S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Northern District of<br />

California (2000)<br />

Page 24 of 26<br />

Robins, Kaplan, Miller<br />

& Ciresi / Ron Shutz,<br />

Becky Thorson, Carrie<br />

Lambert<br />

Williams &<br />

Connolly/Paul Gaffney<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages analysis regarding<br />

St. Clair's alleged unfair<br />

competition with respect to<br />

intellectual property<br />

(patents) regarding digital<br />

camera technology.<br />

Valuation of internet site ecards.com.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

233 Perez v. First American Title<br />

Insurance Company<br />

P<br />

234 Galaxy Networks, Inc. v.<br />

Kenan Systems Corp.<br />

D<br />

235 Arizona Corporation<br />

Commission v. U.S. West<br />

D<br />

236 Adams, et al. v. California<br />

State Automobile<br />

Association, et al.<br />

D<br />

Unfair<br />

Insurance<br />

Practices<br />

Unjust<br />

enrichment,<br />

Quantum<br />

merit<br />

Utility rate<br />

hearing<br />

Various<br />

business torts<br />

US District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

District of Arizona;<br />

Case No. CV-08-<br />

1184-PHX-DGC<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California; Civil<br />

Action No. CV-95-<br />

5568 DDP (1997)<br />

Arizona Corporation<br />

Commission Rate<br />

Hearings (1988)<br />

San Francisco<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

California; No.<br />

916163 (1994)<br />

237 USA v. Amlani, et al. D Wire fraud<br />

U.S. District <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Central District of<br />

California (1993)<br />

238 Walker v. Mitchell P Wrongful<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

death<br />

Yamhill County (1993)<br />

239 Hill v. Bank of America, et al. D<br />

<strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of<br />

Wrongful<br />

eviction<br />

California, County of<br />

San Francisco; Case<br />

No. 959840 (1995)<br />

240 Heiner v. PacifiCorp P<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

Wrongful<br />

termination<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1994)<br />

241 Petrusich v. Russell D<br />

Oregon Circuit <strong>Court</strong>,<br />

242 Robert Frisbee v. Enron<br />

Corp., FirstPoint, Inc.<br />

P<br />

243 Tengler v. Spare, Tengler,<br />

Kaplan & Bischel, et al.<br />

P<br />

Wrongful<br />

termination<br />

Wrongful<br />

termination<br />

Wrongful<br />

termination<br />

Multnomah County<br />

(1987)<br />

Arbitration; Case No.<br />

74 J 160 00360 98<br />

California <strong>Superior</strong><br />

<strong>Court</strong>; County of San<br />

Francisco; Case No.<br />

963822 (1996)<br />

Page 25 of 26<br />

Schneider Wallace<br />

Cottrell Brayton<br />

Konecky / Mark<br />

Johnson<br />

Irell &<br />

Manella/Morgan Chu,<br />

Richard Birnholz,<br />

Peter Wilcox<br />

U.S. West in-house<br />

counsel<br />

Thelen, Marrin,<br />

Johnson &<br />

Bridges/Bob Blum<br />

Analysis of overcharges<br />

regarding title insurance<br />

premiums.<br />

Rebut plaintiff's valuation of<br />

services performed.<br />

Prudence review.<br />

Cost allocation study.<br />

Howarth & Smith Financial analysis.<br />

James, Denecke &<br />

Harris/Richard Urrutia<br />

Bank of America inhouse<br />

counsel/Scott<br />

McMillen<br />

Davis Wright<br />

Tremaine/Mike Reiss<br />

Lindsay, Hart, Neil &<br />

Weigler/Carol Hewitt<br />

Ball Janik/Jacob<br />

Tanzer<br />

Cooley Godward<br />

Castro Huddleson &<br />

Tatum/Karin Kubin,<br />

Kristina Cordoza<br />

Calculation of lost earnings.<br />

Analysis of plaintiff's<br />

damages due to wrongful<br />

eviction.<br />

Financial analysis;<br />

calculation of lost earnings.<br />

Lost earnings analysis.<br />

Value plaintiff's equity<br />

participation plan.<br />

Valuation analysis of<br />

plaintiff's minority interest in<br />

defendant-asset<br />

management firm.


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

*<br />

BRUCE L. McFARLANE<br />

CONSULTING AND TESTIMONY CASE LISTING<br />

Testimony<br />

Lawsuit Type Dep T Dec <strong>Court</strong> Law Firm Work Performed<br />

Summary Statistics<br />

Testimony:<br />

Number of cases in which deposition testimony was given<br />

Number of cases in which trial testimony was given<br />

Number of cases in which declaration testimony was given<br />

Party Retained By:<br />

Data current as of<br />

Number of cases in which testimony was given<br />

Number of cases retained on behalf of plaintiff 147<br />

Number of cases retained on behalf of defendant 95<br />

Intellectual Property Cases:<br />

46<br />

27<br />

16<br />

63<br />

Number of non-litigation related projects 1<br />

Total number of cases / projects 243<br />

Patent infringement cases 69<br />

* Party retained by: P = Plaintiff, D = Defendant<br />

8/30/2012<br />

Trade secret cases 12<br />

Trademark cases 4<br />

Copyright cases 1<br />

Other IP cases 1<br />

61%<br />

39%<br />

Page 26 of 26


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1 1 1 55-01R7-146 12/5/2011 King matress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

4 7 55-05X9-436 4/8/2012 65 Reverb Speakers / Vintage reissue Logical Match Possible<br />

5 7 55-05X9-436 4/8/2012 speakers / ADS Logical Match Possible<br />

6 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Duffle Bag with Navy Uniform No Logical Match<br />

7 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 1960s Dining Table w/ 2 chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

1 9 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Box of Noritaki China Set Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

10 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old Cookie Jar Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

11 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Depression Glass (Pink) Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

12 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 New Snow Boots No Logical Match<br />

14 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old Clock/ Seth Tomas No Logical Match<br />

15 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Belgium Pots and Pans Logical Match Possible<br />

16 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Black board, large, school Logical Match Possible<br />

17 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Brass Kerosine lamps Logical Match Possible<br />

19 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Elvis Presley Magazines Logical Match Possible<br />

20 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Indian Pottery bowls, antique Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

21 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Antique punch cups Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

22 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old ship wheel mirror Logical Match Possible<br />

23 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 More Movie Reel Tins, smoked Logical Match Possible<br />

24 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Antique cinderella cookie jar Exact Guide Match 2 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

25 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old Desk Logical Match Possible<br />

26 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old glass door knobs No Logical Match<br />

29 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Barstools Logical Match Possible<br />

30 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Goose-down comforter Exact Guide Match 1 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

31 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Racing helmets Exact Guide Match 2 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

32 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Arizona Highway Magazines Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

33 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Indian head clock with indian head nickles Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

35 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Captain chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

36 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Giant clown Exact Guide Match 2 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

37 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 35mm Reels Tins Logical Match Possible<br />

38 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 Old high chair Logical Match Possible<br />

139 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Toilet Seat Cover No Logical Match<br />

140 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Toilet paper storage Logical Match Possible<br />

141 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Outhouse bath mat No Logical Match<br />

1 142 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Solid wood potty chair Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

143 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 2-step stool Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

144 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Santa in outhouse Logical Match Possible<br />

145 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Outhouse magazine holder Logical Match Possible<br />

146 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Outhouse paper holder Logical Match Possible<br />

147 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Wooden toilet paper holder Logical Match Possible<br />

148 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Bath mat Logical Match Possible<br />

149 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Mat - Long vanity Logical Match Possible<br />

150 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Toilet set rug Logical Match Possible<br />

152 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Supreme Wind tunnel vacuum/ Hoover Exact Guide Match 1 268 Vacuum Cleaner Home<br />

153 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Box of maps 54/ AAA travel Logical Match Possible<br />

154 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Small gift cards with envelopes No Logical Match<br />

155 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Spools of ribbon No Logical Match<br />

156 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Picture frames Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

157 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Dell laptop computer case/ Black soft Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

briefcase<br />

and Trunks<br />

158 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Briefcase Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

10/15/2012 1


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

159 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Black briefcase Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

160 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Back briefcase Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

161 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Tapestry tote w/ zip Logical Match Possible<br />

162 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Polaroid DVD individual player Exact Guide Match 1 279 Video Video Disk Player<br />

163 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Book: Let the People Sing Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

164 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Fred Waring Song book Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

165 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 The Late Homecomer Logical Match Possible<br />

166 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 The True Cost of Low Prices/ Violence of<br />

Globalization<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

167 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 The Noticer Logical Match Possible<br />

168 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Like Bread & Water Logical Match Possible<br />

169 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 UMW membership books Logical Match Possible<br />

170 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Let's Get Together Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

171 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Prayer Calendar Logical Match Possible<br />

172 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Response booklets Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

173 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Disney black tote Logical Match Possible<br />

174 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Leather briefcase Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

175 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 AC power adapter Logical Match Possible<br />

176 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Rolltop desk w/ hutch Logical Match Possible<br />

177 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Santa boot w/ tree Logical Match Possible<br />

178 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Wrapping paper No Logical Match<br />

179 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Gift warp bags No Logical Match<br />

180 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Computer paper Logical Match Possible<br />

181 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Laundry totes Exact Guide Match 1 59 Clothes Hamper<br />

182 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Box w/ paper ribbon / set of 3 Logical Match Possible<br />

183 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Embroidered framed pic/ Church w/<br />

steeple<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

184 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Crescent moon rug Exact Guide Match 1 44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less<br />

185 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Round moon embroidered rug Exact Guide Match 1 45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard<br />

187 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Lingerie chest Logical Match Possible<br />

188 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Western leather boots Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

190 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Corvette leather luggage Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

191 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 American flag woven purse Logical Match Possible<br />

192 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Denim shoulder strap purse Logical Match Possible<br />

193 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Photos fabric purse Logical Match Possible<br />

194 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Mickey mouse purse/ Dooney & Bourke Logical Match Possible<br />

195 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Gold hobo purse/ Kathy von Zealand Logical Match Possible<br />

196 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Purse w/ matching wallet Exact Guide Match 1 90 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Leather<br />

197 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Disney tote w/ embroidered name Logical Match Possible<br />

198 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Shoe rack Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

199 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 Custom pads for table & 3 leaves Logical Match Possible<br />

221 30 05-M486-516 12/14/2010 Bike Helmet / Wheel Away Cycle Center No Logical Match<br />

1 223 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Bead blast cabinet Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

224 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Pallet jack repair / 2 ton No Logical Match<br />

225 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 10' table saw repair / Contractor's model No Logical Match<br />

10/15/2012 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

226 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Galvanized pail No Logical Match<br />

228 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Metal cutting bandsaw repair / Enco No Logical Match<br />

229 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 225 amp AC/DC arc welder / repair -<br />

Lincoln<br />

No Logical Match<br />

230 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Milling machine tool supply / caddy repair<br />

w/ 200+ cutters<br />

No Logical Match<br />

231 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Floor jack repair No Logical Match<br />

232 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Three tray service cart Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

233 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 Black metal desk repair No Logical Match<br />

253 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 Video camera Logical Match Possible<br />

322 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 Video camera No Logical Match<br />

1 348 42 05-M394-706 9/1/2006 Coffee table / Crate & Barrel Exact Guide Match 1 153 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Desks and Tables<br />

349 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 Desk w/ hutch Oak 3-drawer / CostCo Logical Match Possible<br />

350 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 Dresser/ Oak lateral Logical Match Possible<br />

351 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 Office Chair/ Office Star Logical Match Possible<br />

1 352 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 Drapery Rod / JC Penny Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1 354 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's sport coat Exact Guide Match 1 106 Clothing Sport coats - Wool and wool<br />

blends<br />

355 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Woman's sport suit Exact Guide Match 2 104 Clothing Sport coats - Cotton & synthetic<br />

blends<br />

356 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Woman's jacket, rabbit fur Exact Guide Match 1 72 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Imitation fur<br />

or suede<br />

357 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Ladies coat Exact Guide Match 1 72 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Imitation fur<br />

or suede<br />

358 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's suit Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

359 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Woman's jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

360 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's sweater Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

361 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Dress Exact Guide Match 1 80 Clothing Dresses - Office<br />

362 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Woman's jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

363 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's shirt Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

364 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's shirt Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

365 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Cocktail dress Exact Guide Match 1 82 Clothing Evening - High fashion<br />

367 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

368 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

369 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's sweater Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

370 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's pants Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

371 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Women's shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

372 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Women's shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

373 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 Men's Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

374 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Sectional Sofas / Linders Logical Match Possible<br />

375 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Sofa Tables / Linders Logical Match Possible<br />

1 377 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Wool rug 9x12 / Mervyns Exact Guide Match 1 44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less<br />

378 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Wool rug 10' circle / Ashley's Exact Guide Match 1 45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard<br />

379 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Coffee table, oak / Spiegel Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

380 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Fireplace Utencils / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

381 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Ottoman / Spiegel Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

383 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Tiffany lamps / Tues. Morning Logical Match Possible<br />

384 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 Media Stand Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

385 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Matress Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1 386 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Bed frame Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

387 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Duvet cover Logical Match Possible<br />

388 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Quilt Logical Match Possible<br />

389 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Sheets/ Pillow case sets Logical Match Possible<br />

390 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Pillows Logical Match Possible<br />

391 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Clothes (skirts, sweaters, so Logical Match Possible<br />

392 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Shoes/ pair Logical Match Possible<br />

393 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 shoe rack Logical Match Possible<br />

394 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 Rug - Throw Exact Guide Match 1 44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less<br />

396 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 complete care play yard /target Logical Match Possible<br />

397 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 shoes / Bills Wheels No Logical Match<br />

1 398 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 shoes / Nortridge Mall Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

399 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 shoes / Fashion Island Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

400 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 shoes / Davids Bridal Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

401 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 anti-slip rug / Cost Plus Exact Guide Match 1 44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less<br />

402 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 picture / Lenz Art Exact Guide Match 2 227 Picture Frames<br />

403 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 pillows / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

404 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 vacuum mixer / Degussa Multivac No Logical Match<br />

405 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 model trimmer / Great Lakes No Logical Match<br />

406 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 lath No Logical Match<br />

407 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 splash hoods / Handler No Logical Match<br />

408 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 hand piece lab motor No Logical Match<br />

409 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 triad unit No Logical Match<br />

410 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 blasters / Renfert Classic No Logical Match<br />

411 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 pressure curing unit / GC Acri-Dense No Logical Match<br />

412 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 steamer / Kerr No Logical Match<br />

413 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 microscope / Swift No Logical Match<br />

414 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 vibrator No Logical Match<br />

1 415 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 desk lamp / Dazor Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

416 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 lab chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

417 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 dental articulators / Panadent No Logical Match<br />

418 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 dental waxer / KDF Waxmaster II No Logical Match<br />

419 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 vacuum form unit machine / Erkodent No Logical Match<br />

420 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 dental lab instruments No Logical Match<br />

421 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 telephones / Nortel Network Logical Match Possible<br />

422 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 air compressure nozzel / Husky Logical Match Possible<br />

423 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 paper towel dispensor Logical Match Possible<br />

424 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 dental duplicate flask No Logical Match<br />

425 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 lab vacuum unit No Logical Match<br />

426 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 hand tool set / Husky Logical Match Possible<br />

427 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 picture frames / IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

428 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 kitchen knife kit / Paula Dean No Logical Match<br />

429 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 Chairs/fabric Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

430 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 slide viewer / cabin No Logical Match<br />

431 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 lab burs / Bresseier No Logical Match<br />

432 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 trash cans Logical Match Possible<br />

433 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 x-ray viewer / Recess Viewer No Logical Match<br />

434 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 doctors stools / Peltone & Crane Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

435 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 assistant stools / Peltone & Crane Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

436 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 dental exam chair / Peltone & Crane Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

10/15/2012 4


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

437 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 leather chair / Kalico Logical Match Possible<br />

438 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 electric heater / Circle Air Exact Guide Match 1 163 Heater (Electric)<br />

439 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 paper shredder / Royal Logical Match Possible<br />

440 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 wooden plant pots Logical Match Possible<br />

441 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 coffee table / Plummers Logical Match Possible<br />

442 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 five books Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

443 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 chairs (waiting room) / Kalico Logical Match Possible<br />

444 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 metal file cabinets / HON Exact Guide Match 1 154 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Office Fixtures, Furniture<br />

Cabinets, <strong>Filing</strong> Cases and<br />

Files<br />

445 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 disposable trap / Trap-eze Logical Match Possible<br />

446 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 external hard drive / Dell Logical Match Possible<br />

447 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 slide viewer No Logical Match<br />

448 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 computer speakers Exact Guide Match 2 4 Audio Audio components - Receivers<br />

449 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 track ball mouse / Logitech Logical Match Possible<br />

450 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 100 articulator mounting plat / Panadent No Logical Match<br />

451 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 10 lethe wheels / Muslin buffs No Logical Match<br />

452 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 USB port hub / D-Link Logical Match Possible<br />

453 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 phote frame / IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

454 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Swivel office chair No Logical Match<br />

455 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 26" Plastic T rules Logical Match Possible<br />

1 456 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Particle board CD shelf Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

458 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Curling iron Exact Guide Match 1 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

460 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Womens Blazer coat Exact Guide Match 1 66 Clothing Blazers - Wool<br />

462 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's long-sleeved shirt Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

463 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's blouse Exact Guide Match 2 97 Clothing Shirts - Wool or silk<br />

469 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Libman toilet brush holder Logical Match Possible<br />

470 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's bathrobe/ Charter Club Exact Guide Match 1 61 Clothing Bathrobes - Lightweight<br />

471 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 3x2 bathroom rug Logical Match Possible<br />

472 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Shower squee gee Logical Match Possible<br />

473 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 foot brush bar Logical Match Possible<br />

476 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Bath and Body Works lotion 8oz Logical Match Possible<br />

477 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Bath and Body Works Aromatherapy Logical Match Possible<br />

479 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wire shower head organizer Logical Match Possible<br />

481 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Stainless steep trash can Logical Match Possible<br />

482 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Blue Lagoon Iceland Skin Care Logical Match Possible<br />

483 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Nature's Bounty Melatonin Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

486 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 12x10 Canvass handbag Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

487 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Clinique makeup bags Logical Match Possible<br />

492 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Lysol Disinfectant cleaner Logical Match Possible<br />

495 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Gualderma Differin Gel Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

496 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tylenol Sinus and Pain Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

497 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Oxy Spot treatment No Logical Match<br />

498 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 CVS pharmacy sinus Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

499 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 CVS pharmacy laxatives Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

500 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

501 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sunsilk conditioner No Logical Match<br />

506 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Foot brush Logical Match Possible<br />

507 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Everyday Living Auto Bowl tabs Logical Match Possible<br />

509 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 10" Plastic hair comb Logical Match Possible<br />

510 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 30x20 Plastic framed poster Logical Match Possible<br />

513 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 JR Watkins Hand soap Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 5


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

515 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Renaissance America Bath Towel Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

516 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic bucket w/ handle Logical Match Possible<br />

519 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Herbal Essence Shampoo Logical Match Possible<br />

528 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Suave Max Hold Hairspray Logical Match Possible<br />

530 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Swiffer dister Logical Match Possible<br />

532 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Lipstick tubes Logical Match Possible<br />

534 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Comet disinfectant and cleanser Logical Match Possible<br />

536 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal fingernail scissors No Logical Match<br />

538 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sterilite plastic tray Exact Guide Match 2 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

539 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Old Navy star shimmer powder Logical Match Possible<br />

540 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 NYC Smooth skin face powder Logical Match Possible<br />

545 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Leather bracelet Logical Match Possible<br />

551 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Orthodonic Teeth retainers Logical Match Possible<br />

554 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Milani Nail lacquer Logical Match Possible<br />

556 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Orly Nail lacquer Logical Match Possible<br />

557 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wet n Wild nail color Logical Match Possible<br />

558 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Clinique Make-up palette Logical Match Possible<br />

559 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Comet w/ bleach disinfectant Logical Match Possible<br />

560 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pledge Furniture polish No Logical Match<br />

561 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Energy saving lightbulbs Exact Guide Match 2 180 Lamps Bulbs (Sun Lamp Only)<br />

562 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Bath and Body Works hand soap Logical Match Possible<br />

563 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Libman Plastic dustpan Logical Match Possible<br />

565 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cotton dish towel Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

566 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 jar of vaseline Logical Match Possible<br />

567 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Garnier Fructis conditioner No Logical Match<br />

569 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Oxy Clean Spot treatment No Logical Match<br />

570 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wire dish strainer Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

572 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sylvania nite light and flashlight combo Logical Match Possible<br />

573 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal utencil tray Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

574 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Rubber Maid Trash can Logical Match Possible<br />

575 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 First Alert Fire extinguishers Logical Match Possible<br />

576 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 McCloskey Special Effects Metallic glaze Logical Match Possible<br />

577 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 McCloskey Special Effects Color glaze Logical Match Possible<br />

578 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal Paper towel dispenser Logical Match Possible<br />

579 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Set of plastic cups Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

580 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Glass flower vase Exact Guide Match 2 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

581 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of ping-pong balls No Logical Match<br />

582 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 10"x10" plastic dinner plates Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

583 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 8"x8" plastic salad plates Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

584 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Daily Multi Iron tablets Exact Guide Match 1 197 Medicines<br />

10/15/2012 6


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

585 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic 8" cup Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

586 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Fridgidaire mini refridgerator No Logical Match<br />

588 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic ruler with level Logical Match Possible<br />

589 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Boxes of nails Logical Match Possible<br />

590 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Roll of Scotch duct tape Logical Match Possible<br />

591 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Serilite Plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

592 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wood frame 3x2 Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

594 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Formica top art table w/ adjustable legs Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

595 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal clamp-on table lamps Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

596 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic orgainzer Logical Match Possible<br />

598 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Piar of women's long pants/ Old Navy Exact Guide Match 2 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

600 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Particle board bookshelf Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

602 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of note pads Logical Match Possible<br />

603 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Atrium Artist knife Logical Match Possible<br />

604 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Deco-color Art markers Logical Match Possible<br />

606 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sanford water color markers Logical Match Possible<br />

607 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Windsor and Newton Oil paint Logical Match Possible<br />

608 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Windsor and Newton Oil color Logical Match Possible<br />

609 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tablet of Art paper Logical Match Possible<br />

610 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Unisphore Mirophone model Exact Guide Match 2 4 Audio Audio components - Receivers<br />

611 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 26x20 poster Logical Match Possible<br />

612 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Can of linseed oil Logical Match Possible<br />

613 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of charcoal pencils Logical Match Possible<br />

614 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Template kit / Berol Rapidesign Logical Match Possible<br />

616 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Prisma Color Nu Pastel set Logical Match Possible<br />

617 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 8x4 plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

618 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Jar of brush cleaner Logical Match Possible<br />

619 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Oil color tube Logical Match Possible<br />

620 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Can of mineral spirits Logical Match Possible<br />

621 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Painters Touch Spray Paint Logical Match Possible<br />

622 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wood case of Reeves Art supplies Logical Match Possible<br />

623 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Jars of Benjamin Moore color samples Logical Match Possible<br />

624 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Jars of Grumbacher painting oil Logical Match Possible<br />

626 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Cray-Pas colors Logical Match Possible<br />

627 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Alphabet rubber stamp Logical Match Possible<br />

630 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pairs of Women's plastic sunglasses Logical Match Possible<br />

631 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Clothing pins Logical Match Possible<br />

632 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Beaded necklace Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

635 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 His Grooming Set wax Logical Match Possible<br />

639 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of business cards Logical Match Possible<br />

640 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sargeant brand water colours Logical Match Possible<br />

641 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal framed folding laundry hamper Exact Guide Match 1 59 Clothes Hamper<br />

642 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal paint can opener Logical Match Possible<br />

643 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of LED tap lights Exact Guide Match 2 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

644 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic clip-on digital stop watch Logical Match Possible<br />

646 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Car cell phone charger Logical Match Possible<br />

647 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Beaded necklaces Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

648 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Beaded bracelets Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

649 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal necklace with charm Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

650 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 2x2 tiles No Logical Match<br />

652 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Satin 3x2 Coin purse Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

10/15/2012 7


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

653 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Voluspa candle with holder Logical Match Possible<br />

654 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Hair Now magazine Exact Guide Match 1 33 Books Paperback<br />

655 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Conair pocket mirror Exact Guide Match 2 199 Mirrors<br />

657 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 3" Glass candle holder Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

658 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of hair curlers Exact Guide Match 2 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

659 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Portable Air Conditioner / Goldstar Exact Guide Match 1 2 Air Conditioners (Window)<br />

660 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Casio watch Exact Guide Match 1 172 Jewelry Bracelets, Broaches, Cuff<br />

Links, Earrings, Necklaces,<br />

Other Jeweled or Precious<br />

Metal Items, Pins, Rings,<br />

Studs, Watches<br />

661 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pier 1 Plate Logical Match Possible<br />

662 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Storage container Logical Match Possible<br />

663 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Ikea plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

664 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of index cards Logical Match Possible<br />

665 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic trash can Logical Match Possible<br />

666 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Steel trashcan Logical Match Possible<br />

667 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic closet hangers Logical Match Possible<br />

668 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Manilla art folder 50x26 Logical Match Possible<br />

669 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Target brand candle Logical Match Possible<br />

670 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal jewlery tree Logical Match Possible<br />

671 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Power Sentry Surge protector Logical Match Possible<br />

673 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Rubbermaid storage bins Logical Match Possible<br />

674 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Carboard boxes w/ lids Logical Match Possible<br />

675 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tubes of Winton oil colors Logical Match Possible<br />

676 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tube of Winton Oil colour Logical Match Possible<br />

677 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Spacemaker Container Logical Match Possible<br />

678 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of coloured pencils Logical Match Possible<br />

680 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack if Fine point markers / Pentel Logical Match Possible<br />

682 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cans of Krylon spray paint Logical Match Possible<br />

683 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cans of Spray enamel Logical Match Possible<br />

684 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Metal folder clips Logical Match Possible<br />

685 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Papermate liquid paper Logical Match Possible<br />

686 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pencil Sharpener- Battery powered Logical Match Possible<br />

687 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pack of led f/ mechanical pencils Logical Match Possible<br />

688 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal single hole punch Logical Match Possible<br />

689 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wood rulers Logical Match Possible<br />

690 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of scissors Logical Match Possible<br />

691 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 6" drinking glass Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

692 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sharpe markers Logical Match Possible<br />

693 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Misc ink pens Logical Match Possible<br />

694 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Misc wood pencils Logical Match Possible<br />

695 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of holiday fold-over cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

696 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Packs of flat cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

699 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Holiday greeting cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

700 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of white envelopes Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

701 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Thank you Cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

702 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic organizer No Logical Match<br />

703 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Photo cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

705 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Greeting Art Cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

706 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Embroidered greeting cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

707 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of greeting cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

708 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Packs of notecards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

10/15/2012 8


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

709 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Filofax cards w/ envelps Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

710 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Star ornaments Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

711 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Ikea table lamp Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

712 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Vinyl 3-ring binders Logical Match Possible<br />

713 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Craft Acrylic paints Logical Match Possible<br />

714 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tubes of Acrylic Color Logical Match Possible<br />

715 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Tube of Acrylic paint Logical Match Possible<br />

716 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Benjamin moore color samples Logical Match Possible<br />

717 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of Pantel watercolors Logical Match Possible<br />

718 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Paint sponges w/ handels Logical Match Possible<br />

719 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Misc art brushes Logical Match Possible<br />

720 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic accordian folder Logical Match Possible<br />

722 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Sealy posturepedic medium sup Logical Match Possible<br />

723 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 24x24 pillows Logical Match Possible<br />

724 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 7x6 electric blanket Exact Guide Match 1 18 Bedding Blankets (Electric)<br />

725 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Ikea plastic wall clock Exact Guide Match 1 57 Clocks Other - Under $25 (Cost New)<br />

726 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cotton full size bed sheet Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

727 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Acrylic polyester blanket Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

728 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of women's leather shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

729 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of women's flip flops Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

730 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of women's canvass shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

736 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Canvas shoe hangers Logical Match Possible<br />

737 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Old Navy flip flops Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

743 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Women's leather heels Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

747 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Nylon carry on bag Logical Match Possible<br />

748 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Nylon beach bag Logical Match Possible<br />

749 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's cotton purse Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

750 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Vinyl purse 20x14 Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

751 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Leather purse Exact Guide Match 1 90 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Leather<br />

752 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Nylon compact umbrella Exact Guide Match 1 267 Umbrella<br />

753 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 18x18 wool purse Logical Match Possible<br />

754 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 15x15 Old navy Cotton Purse Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

755 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's leather purse Exact Guide Match 1 90 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Leather<br />

756 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Canvas backpack / North Face Logical Match Possible<br />

758 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 pair of mens snow gloves Logical Match Possible<br />

759 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wilson volleyball Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

760 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Greatland sleeping bag Exact Guide Match 1 42 Camping Equipment<br />

761 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cotton full-size blanket Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

762 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of Scot Ski goggles Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

763 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wook 8-hook wall mount hanger Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

764 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Old Navy denim shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

765 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Apple keyboard Exact Guide Match 2 125 Computers Personal<br />

766 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Old Navy cotton shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

767 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cotton tshirts Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

768 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Canvas CD case Logical Match Possible<br />

770 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Full size matress cotton sheet Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

771 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 National Sleep products home Logical Match Possible<br />

772 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 6 cd-rom set Logical Match Possible<br />

775 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Woman's vinyl belt Logical Match Possible<br />

777 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wood framed ikea sofa chair Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

778 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 20x16 canvas art board Logical Match Possible<br />

779 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Pair of Uggs Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

780 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic art bin Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 9


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

782 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

783 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Package of prismatic colored pencils Logical Match Possible<br />

784 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 2.5x2.5 art pencil eraser Logical Match Possible<br />

785 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 2 lbs of misc beads Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

786 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 14x10 metal baking pan Exact Guide Match 1 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

787 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Box of miniature quilt Exact Guide Match 1 24 Bedding Quilts<br />

788 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic container Logical Match Possible<br />

790 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Prismacolor premier large art Logical Match Possible<br />

791 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal cup Logical Match Possible<br />

792 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Containers of Seed beads Exact Guide Match 1 173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry<br />

793 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 18pc graphite set Logical Match Possible<br />

794 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Stanley screwdriver Logical Match Possible<br />

795 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Metal protractor Logical Match Possible<br />

796 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Deck of artist trading cards Logical Match Possible<br />

797 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Cotton apron Logical Match Possible<br />

798 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 LG Cell phone Logical Match Possible<br />

799 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Boston paper cutter Logical Match Possible<br />

800 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Art cubes Logical Match Possible<br />

801 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 6x6 Metal cup Logical Match Possible<br />

802 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Palm One Communicator Logical Match Possible<br />

803 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Stanley Bostich stapler Logical Match Possible<br />

804 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Dual wattage converter Logical Match Possible<br />

805 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 TI Calculator Exact Guide Match 1 41 Calculator<br />

806 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic pencil tray Logical Match Possible<br />

807 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Fire wire USB Logical Match Possible<br />

809 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic art bin Logical Match Possible<br />

811 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic beaded picture frames Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

812 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Mead academic sketch pad Logical Match Possible<br />

813 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic picture frame Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

814 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 7x5 metal frame Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

815 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Kids art fun station Logical Match Possible<br />

816 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Notebook tablet Logical Match Possible<br />

817 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic cup Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

818 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Osh spray enamel cans Logical Match Possible<br />

819 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Krylon Spray paint can Logical Match Possible<br />

820 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Canvass art bag Logical Match Possible<br />

824 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Brown boots / Xhileration Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

825 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 White boots Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

826 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Black leather vintage handbag Exact Guide Match 1 90 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Leather<br />

827 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Knappe pendant lamps Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

828 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Posters: Dolce Vita and Bob Dylan Logical Match Possible<br />

829 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Plastic 4x6 frames Logical Match Possible<br />

830 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Brown woven curtain Exact Guide Match 1 130 Curtains<br />

832 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Original art work Logical Match Possible<br />

833 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Clothing: 8 shirts, 2 cotton Logical Match Possible<br />

834 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Window blind sets Exact Guide Match 1 239 Shades<br />

835 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 6x8 Oriental rug carpet Exact Guide Match 1 49 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) Genuine Orientals<br />

836 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 Wall adobe pot planters Exact Guide Match 2 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

837 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Futon Mattress Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 10


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

838 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Cardboard shoe rack Logical Match Possible<br />

839 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Suit Case No Logical Match<br />

840 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Garment bag Logical Match Possible<br />

841 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Basket Logical Match Possible<br />

842 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Doormat Logical Match Possible<br />

843 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 A night of questions Logical Match Possible<br />

844 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Skint nails No Logical Match<br />

849 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Rumpole and The Bungalow Logical Match Possible<br />

852 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 PWK Cotton Yarn No Logical Match<br />

854 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 A Different Night Logical Match Possible<br />

855 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 Mah Nishtannah Logical Match Possible<br />

1 856 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Lady of Guadalupe Statute Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

857 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Lady of Guadalupe sm statute Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

858 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Picture of Guadalupe Exact Guide Match 2 227 Picture Frames<br />

859 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Virgin Mary Statute Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

860 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 St. Martin Statute Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

861 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 St. Peter Statute Exact Guide Match 1 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

863 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Pearl Earrings Logical Match Possible<br />

864 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Hearing Aid Logical Match Possible<br />

865 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Gold Chain w/ Cross Exact Guide Match 1 172 Jewelry Bracelets, Broaches, Cuff<br />

Links, Earrings, Necklaces,<br />

Other Jeweled or Precious<br />

Metal Items, Pins, Rings,<br />

Studs, Watches<br />

866 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Eye Glasses Exact Guide Match 1 138 Eye Glasses<br />

868 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Jacket- leather bomber Exact Guide Match 1 73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and<br />

suede<br />

869 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Jacket- Suede Exact Guide Match 1 73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and<br />

suede<br />

870 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Jacket- cowboy/leather Exact Guide Match 1 73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and<br />

suede<br />

871 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 King size mattress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

872 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Sony TV 27" Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

873 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 Stereo Logical Match Possible<br />

874 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 CD-(3) Vincent Fernandez Exact Guide Match 1 6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's)<br />

1 875 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 40" screen TV, LCD Panel HDTV Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

876 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 Rainbow Vacuum SE Exact Guide Match 1 269 Vacuum Cleaner Office<br />

877 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 Picture Frames, 8x10 Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

878 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 Budha Statue Logical Match Possible<br />

879 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 3 ga. Stainless Boiling pot Exact Guide Match 1 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

880 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 Nativity Statues Logical Match Possible<br />

881 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 Plastic Organizer on Wheels Logical Match Possible<br />

1 882 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 Blankets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

883 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 Hardwood Flooring - uninstalled Logical Match Possible<br />

884 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 Hallway rug 22" x 60" Exact Guide Match 2 47 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 12.96 - $20.95 per yard<br />

885 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 Bathroom rug set Exact Guide Match 1 45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard<br />

886 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 9x12 shed / Wood Building Logical Match Possible<br />

1 887 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Old Trunk Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

888 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Lawn Mower Exact Guide Match 1 190 Lawn Mowers Push Type<br />

889 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Electric Circular Saw / Sears Craftsman Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

10/15/2012 11


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

890 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Electric Chain Saw / Remmington Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

891 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Power Chain Saw / McCulloch Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

892 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Wool Blanket Logical Match Possible<br />

893 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Microwave Exact Guide Match 1 198 Microwave Ovens<br />

894 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Gaw Weed Wacker Exact Guide Match 1 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

895 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Power Washer / Campbell Hausteld Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

896 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Singer Sewing Machine Exact Guide Match 1 238 Sewing Machine<br />

897 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Full Size Sleeper Sofa Logical Match Possible<br />

898 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Antique Table Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

899 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Exercise Machin / Glider Logical Match Possible<br />

900 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Rod N Reel & Tackle Box No Logical Match<br />

901 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Telescoping Pole for Painting Logical Match Possible<br />

902 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Bassinette / Kolocraft Logical Match Possible<br />

903 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Britax Child Car Seat Logical Match Possible<br />

904 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Infant Car Seat / Graco Logical Match Possible<br />

905 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Child Safety Gate / Safety Lat Logical Match Possible<br />

906 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Diaper Bag / Fisher Price Exact Guide Match 1 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

907 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Stroller Sleeper / Kolocraft Exact Guide Match 1 152 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Children's<br />

908 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Receiving Blankets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

909 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Crib Blankets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

910 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Bar Seat Cover / Britax Exact Guide Match 1 155 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Slipcovers<br />

911 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Crib Sheets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

913 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Infant Gowns Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

914 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Fuzzy Sleepers Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

915 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Little Girl Dressy Dresses Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

916 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Suits Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

917 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Sweat Suits Exact Guide Match 1 111 Clothing Suits - Washable<br />

918 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 T Shirts Short Sleeve Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

919 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Long Sleeve T Shirts Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

920 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Cargo Pants Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

921 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Sweat pants Logical Match Possible<br />

922 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Dress Shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

923 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Casual Dress - Girls Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

924 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Infant Sleepers Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

925 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Girls Overalls Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

926 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Hooded Sleevless Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

927 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Rebok Sweatshirt Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

928 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Girls Body Suit Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

929 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Shorts Childrens / Dockers Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

930 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Jean Shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 12


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

931 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Long Sleeve Polo Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

932 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Hooded T Shirt Logical Match Possible<br />

933 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 TurtleNeck Exact Guide Match 1 96 Clothing Shirts - Sports<br />

934 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Polo Shirt Exact Guide Match 1 96 Clothing Shirts - Sports<br />

935 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Button Down Sweater Logical Match Possible<br />

936 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Pants Boys Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

937 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 All in One Jump Suit Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

938 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Lace Up Jeans Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

939 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Onesies Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

940 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Baby Tees Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

941 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Pair Boys Dress Shoes Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

942 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Girls Dress Shoes Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

943 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Casual Shoes Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

944 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Casual Shoes Girls Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

945 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Baby Bunting Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

946 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Infant Mittens Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

947 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Infant Booties Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

948 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Quilted Infant Jackets Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

949 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 School Uniform Dresses Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

950 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Sweat Pants Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

951 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Long Sleeve Polo Shirt Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

952 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Sweat Suits Exact Guide Match 1 111 Clothing Suits - Washable<br />

953 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Long Jeans Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

954 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Short Jeans Exact Guide Match 2 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

955 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 girls T With Design Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

956 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Girls Tops Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

957 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Skirt Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

958 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Hooded Fleece Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

959 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Boys Pants Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

960 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Commertatory T Exact Guide Match 1 96 Clothing Shirts - Sports<br />

961 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Lands End Jacket Womens Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

962 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Winter Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

963 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Adult Sweat Pants Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

10/15/2012 13


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

964 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Pants Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

965 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Satin Gown Long Sleeve Exact Guide Match 1 81 Clothing Dresses - Silk<br />

966 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Heavy T Long PJs Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

967 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Zip Wool Jacket Logical Match Possible<br />

968 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Heavy Knit Sweater Logical Match Possible<br />

969 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Coat W Zippered Lining Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

970 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Caftan Women w Fringe Exact Guide Match 1 79 Clothing Dresses - Casual<br />

971 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Cotton Long Shirt Button Down Logical Match Possible<br />

972 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Heavy Knit Skirt Set Exact Guide Match 2 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

973 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Button Down Shirts Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

974 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Short Sleeve Polo Shirt Exact Guide Match 1 96 Clothing Shirts - Sports<br />

975 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 PJs Boys Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

976 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Womens Dresses / Carol Little Exact Guide Match 1 79 Clothing Dresses - Casual<br />

977 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 3 Piece Pant Suits / Carol Little Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

978 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Blue Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

979 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Small Girdle Exact Guide Match 1 114 Clothing Underwear - Foundation<br />

garments<br />

980 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Sheer Dress Blouses Exact Guide Match 1 67 Clothing Blouses<br />

981 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Adult Shirts w/ Writing Exact Guide Match 1 96 Clothing Shirts - Sports<br />

982 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 T Outfits Logical Match Possible<br />

983 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Capri Pants Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

984 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 T Shirt Dress Exact Guide Match 1 79 Clothing Dresses - Casual<br />

985 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Shorts Exact Guide Match 2 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

986 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Moo-Moo's Exact Guide Match 1 79 Clothing Dresses - Casual<br />

987 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Wool coat jacket Exact Guide Match 1 76 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Wool<br />

988 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Cotton Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

989 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Docker Shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

990 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Fitted Shirt Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

991 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Tee Pants Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

992 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Strechy Top Spandex Exact Guide Match 2 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

993 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Large Cotton Shirts Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

994 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Pants Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

995 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 Plaid Jacket Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

1 996 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Casio keyboard / Walmart Exact Guide Match 1 203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New)<br />

997 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Mattress set Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

998 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Stackable shelf / Lowe's Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

999 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Flat screen TV 32/37" / Phillips Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1000 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 VCR/DVD player / Emerson Exact Guide Match 1 278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

Recorder)<br />

10/15/2012 14


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1002 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Bar stools / JCP Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

1003 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Chairs, oak / Oak Furniture Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1004 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Night stand / Weather B's Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1005 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Space rug / Sears Logical Match Possible<br />

1006 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 End tables Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1007 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 DSI XL / Nintendo Exact Guide Match 1 282 Video Video Game Systems<br />

1008 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Twin mattress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1009 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 20" Vizio / Walmart Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1010 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 VCR / Walmart Exact Guide Match 1 278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

Recorder)<br />

1012 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Mixer, white / Sears Exact Guide Match 1 200 Mixers, Electric<br />

1013 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Washer/dryer / Whirlpool Exact Guide Match 1 137 Dryer (Laundry)<br />

1014 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Dishwasher / Sears Exact Guide Match 1 132 Dishwasher<br />

1015 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Stackable drawer / Lowe's Logical Match Possible<br />

1016 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Shelf laundry / Lowe's Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

1067 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Back & neck heating pad Exact Guide Match 1 164 Heating Pad (Electric)<br />

1072 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Cell phone charger Logical Match Possible<br />

1073 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Cordless phones Exact Guide Match 1 252 Telephones, cordless<br />

1074 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 CDs/DVDs Exact Guide Match 1 6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's)<br />

1095 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Vivitar digital camera Logical Match Possible<br />

1097 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Baby kitchen Logical Match Possible<br />

1098 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Jumper / bouncer Logical Match Possible<br />

1099 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Dolls Logical Match Possible<br />

1100 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Curtains set & rod Logical Match Possible<br />

1101 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Baby strollers - toy Logical Match Possible<br />

1102 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 other baby toys Logical Match Possible<br />

1103 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Stuffed animals Logical Match Possible<br />

1104 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Tea set (talking) Logical Match Possible<br />

1105 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Dora doll set (everything) Logical Match Possible<br />

1106 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Leap Frog learning Logical Match Possible<br />

1107 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Drum set Exact Guide Match 1 202 Musical Instruments Under $50 (Cost New)<br />

1109 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Rattle set Logical Match Possible<br />

1110 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Ring set (teething) Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1111 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Sippy cup Logical Match Possible<br />

1114 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Kiddie DVDs Exact Guide Match 1 6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's)<br />

1117 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 Books (baby) Exact Guide Match 1 33 Books Paperback<br />

1118 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Fishing rods / Sabre Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1119 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Luggage Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

1120 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 TV 19" / Emerson Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1121 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 VCR / Sanyo Exact Guide Match 1 278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

Recorder)<br />

1123 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Dermatone - Muscle Stimulator Exact Guide Match 1 162 Hand Vibrator (Electric, Massage)<br />

1127 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Picnic basket Logical Match Possible<br />

1128 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Guitar / fender Exact Guide Match 1 204 Musical Instruments Over $250 (Cost New)<br />

including Pianos<br />

1153 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Gloves / Mt Hardwear Ascent Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1154 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Ski bibs / Areteryx Thea Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1155 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Ski pants / Spyder Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1156 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Snow googles / Oakley Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1157 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Skis / Rossignol Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 15


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1158 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Bindings / Black Diamond Logical Match Possible<br />

1159 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Ski boots Logical Match Possible<br />

1160 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 Ski pole Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1162 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 White Leather Sofa / Macy's Logical Match Possible<br />

1163 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 White Leather Chairs / Macy's Logical Match Possible<br />

1166 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 Chaise Lounge / Sears Logical Match Possible<br />

1168 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Desk Logical Match Possible<br />

1169 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Television / Admiral @ Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1170 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Television / Admiral @ Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1171 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Ortho Bed / Ortho Balance @ Ortho Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1172 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Ortho Pillows / Ortho Balance @ Ortho Exact Guide Match 2 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1173 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Pictures @ Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1174 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Bedspread / @ Garment District Exact Guide Match 1 25 Bedding Spreads<br />

1175 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Bathroom items / Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1176 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Center Table, Glass / Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1177 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Vase sets / Garment District Logical Match Possible<br />

1178 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Plants / @ swap meet Logical Match Possible<br />

1179 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Lamp sets / Garment District Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

1180 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Fan / Lakewood @ Costco Exact Guide Match 1 139 Fans Electric<br />

1181 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Heater / Holmes @ Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1182 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Clothing / Fashion Brigade Logical Match Possible<br />

1183 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Shoes / New York Fashion Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1184 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Boots / Gucci @ Garment District Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1185 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Stuffed Animal Toys / @ Garment District Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1186 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 DVD/VHS Player / RCA @ Sears Exact Guide Match 1 278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

Recorder)<br />

1187 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Small microwave / GE @ Kmart Logical Match Possible<br />

1188 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Telephone / G.E. @ Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1189 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Hair dryer / Ebony @ Garment Disrict Exact Guide Match 1 161 Hair Dryer (Electric)<br />

1190 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Blow dryer / Ebony @ Garment Disrict Exact Guide Match 1 161 Hair Dryer (Electric)<br />

1191 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Electric curling irons / Ebony @ Garment<br />

Disrict<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

1192 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Radio / Sony @ Walmart Exact Guide Match 1 9 Audio Radio (console, portable, table)<br />

1193 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Clock / @ swap meet Logical Match Possible<br />

1194 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Stereo System / Sony @ Kmart Exact Guide Match 2 7 Audio Compact Audio/HiFi Systems<br />

1195 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Tape recorder / Sony @ Garment Disrict Exact Guide Match 1 11 Audio Recorder (Tape or Wire)<br />

1196 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Playstation 2 / @ Walmart Logical Match Possible<br />

1197 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 PlayStation Ass. / Game world No Logical Match<br />

1198 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Box Arts-n-Crafts board games / @<br />

Garment Disrict<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1199 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Electric Key Boards / Garment District Exact Guide Match 1 203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New)<br />

1200 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 Picture frames / @ Garment Dist. Logical Match Possible<br />

1201 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 African artifacts / @ Garment Dist. Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1203 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Dining Room set Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1204 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Cal King memory foam Exact Guide Match 1 23 Bedding Mattresses Covers or Pads<br />

1205 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 La-Z-Boy couch Logical Match Possible<br />

1206 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 La-Z-bay recliner Logical Match Possible<br />

1207 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Green La-Z-boy recliner Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1208 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Accent chair Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

1209 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Tan recliner Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

10/15/2012 16


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1210 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Queen memory foam Exact Guide Match 1 23 Bedding Mattresses Covers or Pads<br />

1211 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Cherry coffee table Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1212 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Green roll-up window shade Logical Match Possible<br />

1213 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 DVD Logical Match Possible<br />

1214 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Gold Canyan candle Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

1215 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Down pillows Exact Guide Match 2 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1216 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Sheet set twin Exact Guide Match 2 195 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Other<br />

1217 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Blanket Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

1218 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Stand up TV tray Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1219 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Stand up fan Exact Guide Match 1 139 Fans Electric<br />

1220 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 Jeans/shirt Logical Match Possible<br />

1224 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 Couch No Logical Match<br />

1229 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 Rug 5x9 No Logical Match<br />

1230 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 Rug 9x12 No Logical Match<br />

1232 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Brown dining table/IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1233 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Brown dining chairs/ IKEA Exact Guide Match 2 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1234 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Chaise lounge sectional/Scandinavian<br />

design<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1235 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Chaise lounge ottoman/Scandinavian<br />

design<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1236 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sofa bed couch/ IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1237 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sofa bed couch cover/IKEA Exact Guide Match 2 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1238 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Floor lamp base/IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

1239 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Lamp shades/IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 183 Lamps Shades<br />

1240 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Lamp shades/IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 183 Lamps Shades<br />

1241 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bookshelf/IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1242 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bookshelf/IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1243 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wicker storage baskets for bo/IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1244 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wicker Chair/IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 150 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Brentwood Chairs (Rattan or<br />

Wicker)<br />

1245 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wicker chair pad/IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1246 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 4'x8' dry erase board/ Home Depot Logical Match Possible<br />

1247 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Queen mattress & boxspring / Sealy<br />

Posturepedic<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1248 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bed Frame/scandinavian design Logical Match Possible<br />

1249 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Mattress & boxspring /IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1250 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bedframe/ IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1251 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Floor lamp base/ IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

1252 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Lamp shade/ IKEA Exact Guide Match 1 183 Lamps Shades<br />

1253 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Brown leather chair/ Scandinavian Design Logical Match Possible<br />

1254 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Kitchen Island Storage/ Intermetro Chef's<br />

Cart<br />

Exact Guide Match 2 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1255 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cat scratching playtoy/Whiskey City Curt<br />

Floor Scratch<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1256 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cardboard scratch boxes/ Great Choice<br />

Dblwid<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1257 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cat Condo single story/ Foster & Smith Logical Match Possible<br />

1258 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Platinum mesh drawer 3"/Container store Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

1259 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Platinum mesh draer 7"/ Container store Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

10/15/2012 17


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1260 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Platinum Frame/ Container Store Logical Match Possible<br />

1261 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Small wicker bedside table Exact Guide Match 1 153 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Desks and Tables<br />

1262 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 wooden hangers (30 for $20)/ Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1263 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Black plastic hangers/ Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1264 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dell Computer Harddriver/Tower Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1265 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dell 23" LCD Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1266 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dell Inspiron 17" laptop Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1267 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Acer laptop Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1268 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 HP Photosmart Printer/ C3180 Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1269 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dell Computer speakers Logical Match Possible<br />

1270 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 2 wire modem/ router Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1271 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Misc cords, cables, computer Exact Guide Match 1 125 Computers Personal<br />

1272 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Digital voice recorder/Sony Exact Guide Match 1 11 Audio Recorder (Tape or Wire)<br />

1273 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Microwave/ Sharp Exact Guide Match 1 198 Microwave Ovens<br />

1274 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Canister vacuum/ Kenmore Exact Guide Match 1 268 Vacuum Cleaner Home<br />

1275 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 22" TV Sylvania Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1276 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 DVD Player/ Memorex Exact Guide Match 1 279 Video Video Disk Player<br />

1277 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 DVD Player/ Sony Exact Guide Match 1 279 Video Video Disk Player<br />

1278 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Portable DVD player/Audiovox Exact Guide Match 1 279 Video Video Disk Player<br />

1279 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Stereo reciever/ Sony Logical Match Possible<br />

1280 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cassette Deck/ Sony Logical Match Possible<br />

1281 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Stero reciever/ Sony Logical Match Possible<br />

1282 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cassette Deck/ Sony Logical Match Possible<br />

1283 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Multi disk CD player/ JVC Exact Guide Match 1 5 Audio Compact disk players<br />

1284 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 paper shredder/ Staples Logical Match Possible<br />

1285 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Camera/ Polaroid Exact Guide Match 1 224 Photographic Equipment $50 or less (Cost New)<br />

1290 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bathroom supplies Logical Match Possible<br />

1291 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 boots, black leather knee high/ Bandolino<br />

Caresse<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1292 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sneaker, Vans canvas old school Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1293 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sneaker, Ruckus skateboard/Nike Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1294 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sneaker Shox Turbo Black/ Nike Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1296 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Shirts shortsleeve/Lacoste Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

1297 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Shirts longsleeve black/ lacoste Exact Guide Match 1 100 Clothing Shirts<br />

1298 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dress shirt, blue/Gap Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

1299 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dress shirt, Fuscia/ Gap Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

1300 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 jeans/ Gap Logical Match Possible<br />

1301 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dress pants, black/ Gap Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

1302 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Women's suit, black, Ann Klein Logical Match Possible<br />

1304 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Dress shoes, black heels, Nine west Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1305 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Sandals, brown leather, LL Bean Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1306 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Hair dryer/ Conair Exact Guide Match 1 161 Hair Dryer (Electric)<br />

1307 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bath Towels/ Royal Regent Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1308 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wash cloths 13" square/ Regent Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1309 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bed pillows standard size/ Wamsutta Logical Match Possible<br />

1310 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 throw pillows/ IKEA Exact Guide Match 2 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1311 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 lipstick, long last/Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1312 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Face cream, 7 day scrub/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1313 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 eye makeup shadow - quad/Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1314 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 makeup compact, almost power/ clinique No Logical Match<br />

1315 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 lip gloss, superbalm/Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1316 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 mascara/ clinique No Logical Match<br />

10/15/2012 18


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

1317 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 hand cream stop signs hand re/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1318 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 skin care turnarnd concentr/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1319 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 new clarifying lotion/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1320 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 new pore refining correcting/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1321 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 superbalanced makeup foundation /<br />

Clinique<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1322 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 long last lipstick/ Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1323 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 makeup brush kit/ Lancome Logical Match Possible<br />

1324 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Mirro/ Upper Canada Soap Mirror Logical Match Possible<br />

1325 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Microdry Essential bath rug 2 Logical Match Possible<br />

1326 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 shower caddy 3 tier corner un Logical Match Possible<br />

1327 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 shower caddy, under shower head Logical Match Possible<br />

1328 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 shower heard/ waterpik 12 setting Logical Match Possible<br />

1329 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 hair products/ CHI Silk infusion No Logical Match<br />

1330 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Shampoo/CHI infra No Logical Match<br />

1331 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Conditioner /CHI intra No Logical Match<br />

1332 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 flat iron/ CHI air tourmaline Exact Guide Match 1 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

1333 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cordless flat iron/ Helix Hot tools Exact Guide Match 1 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

1334 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bottle charcoal pills 280 mg No Logical Match<br />

1335 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 advil 200 mg No Logical Match<br />

1336 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Toilet storage unit/Lindwood Bath shutter Logical Match Possible<br />

1337 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 wrinkle cream/ eye vive dermaxin No Logical Match<br />

1338 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 flat iron 1" / CHI Ceramic Farook Exact Guide Match 1 129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb<br />

1339 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Make up brush kit/ lancome Logical Match Possible<br />

1340 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 make up bag/ Michael Kors Logical Match Possible<br />

1341 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Make up bag/ kate spade Logical Match Possible<br />

1342 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Make up bag/ Bare essential Logical Match Possible<br />

1343 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Metal travel containers No Logical Match<br />

1344 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 eye glass repair kit Exact Guide Match 1 138 Eye Glasses<br />

1345 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 makeup bag/bobbi brown Logical Match Possible<br />

1346 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Vigamox medicine No Logical Match<br />

1347 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Candles/ Yankee jar No Logical Match<br />

1348 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fingernail clippers/ Stiles Logical Match Possible<br />

1349 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Chapstick No Logical Match<br />

1350 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 RX Fluticasone Porpionate mcg No Logical Match<br />

1351 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 make up bag/ Petunia Pickle bottom Logical Match Possible<br />

1352 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 make up bag/ MAC Exact Guide Match 2 91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric<br />

1353 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Electric toothbrush/ Sonicare Exact Guide Match 1 259 Toothbrush (Electric)<br />

1354 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Clarifying lotion skin type 2 / Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1355 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 eye liner pencil / Clinique No Logical Match<br />

1356 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 hari conditioner/ Bumble & Bumble No Logical Match<br />

1357 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Hair conditioner/ Bumble & Bumble No Logical Match<br />

1358 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Hair conditioner/ Bumble & Bumble No Logical Match<br />

1359 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 hair spray / B&B No Logical Match<br />

1360 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Hair Treatment/ B&B No Logical Match<br />

1361 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 hair cream / B&B No Logical Match<br />

1362 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Pure color long last lipstick/Estee lauder No Logical Match<br />

1363 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Perfectly Clean splay away cl/ Estee<br />

lauder<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1364 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Eye shadow palette/ Estee lauder No Logical Match<br />

10/15/2012 19


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

1365 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 More than Mascara/ Estee lauder No Logical Match<br />

1366 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Advanced night repair/ Estee lauder No Logical Match<br />

1367 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Advanced night repair eye cream/ Estee<br />

lauder<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1368 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Gentle eye makeup remover/ Estee<br />

Lauder<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1369 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Re-Nutriv replenishing comfor/ Estee<br />

lauder<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1370 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Moisterizer/ Olay Definity Color Recapture No Logical Match<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1371 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Chanel Coco perfume No Logical Match<br />

1372 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 eye lifting serum/Olay No Logical Match<br />

1373 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Marc Jacobs Eau de parfum No Logical Match<br />

1374 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fresh pink jasmine perfume Logical Match Possible<br />

1375 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 baseball cleats/Adidas Exact Guide Match 2 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1376 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Soccer cleats/ Adidas Exact Guide Match 2 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1380 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bike Shoe / Shimano Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1381 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 All blk bike shoe/ Pearl Izumi Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1382 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cube freezer/Kenmore Exact Guide Match 2 233 Refrigerator<br />

1383 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 ladder 8" fiberglass/Wener Logical Match Possible<br />

1384 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Broom & dustpan set/Libman Logical Match Possible<br />

1385 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Golf Shoes/ Footjoy Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1386 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Golf Shoes/ Callaway Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1387 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Box Fan Exact Guide Match 1 139 Fans Electric<br />

1388 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Motorcycle helmet/Shoei Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1389 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 plastic storage container Logical Match Possible<br />

1390 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike pump/specialized airtool sport Logical Match Possible<br />

1391 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike pump/ Beto floor pump Logical Match Possible<br />

1392 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike pumo/ Planet Bike MicroMite Logical Match Possible<br />

1393 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike water bottles 24 oz/Polar insulated Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1394 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike stand/sarts wheel arch Logical Match Possible<br />

1395 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 drum seat/Gibraltar 5600 series Exact Guide Match 2 203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New)<br />

1396 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike dual water holder/Profile Design<br />

Aquarack<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1397 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike gloves/specialized BG deflect Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1398 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 repair patch kit for bike/ Genuine<br />

innovations<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1399 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike tubes/specialized 700 cc No Logical Match<br />

1400 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike tires/specialized armadillo No Logical Match<br />

1401 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 multi purpose bike tool/crank brothers<br />

multi 5<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1402 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 C02 cartridges/genuine innovations No Logical Match<br />

1403 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 C02 adapter/Genuine innovations Logical Match Possible<br />

1404 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike helmet/bell XLV Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1405 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike lock/bell ahnds off U lock Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1406 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bull dog bike lock/ on guard pitbull STD Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1407 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 tool belt apron & pouch/ Home depot<br />

generic<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1408 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 set bike pedals/ Shimano Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1409 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike extension stem/ specialized multi<br />

purpose<br />

Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1410 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Handlebars/ Ritchet Comp Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1411 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Cordless drill, 18v 1/2" Dewalt Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

10/15/2012 20


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1412 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bike Chain ring/ sugino Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1413 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bike Chain Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1414 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bike aerobars/ Profile design Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1415 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 car trailer hitch/autozone Logical Match Possible<br />

1416 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike rear fender/ City Works Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1417 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Coppertone sunscreen No Logical Match<br />

1418 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 socket set 58 pcs/ Ace hardware Logical Match Possible<br />

1419 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Rolling luggage set/ Black swiss army Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

1421 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 green army duffle bag Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

1422 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 lawn games kit Logical Match Possible<br />

1423 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 bike saddle seat/specialized hett Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1424 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bike trainer/ Cycle Ops magnetic Exact Guide Match 2 26 Bicycles<br />

1425 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fire extinguisher No Logical Match<br />

1426 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 basketball/ Wilson Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1427 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 in line skates Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

1428 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 fundamental of federal income Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1429 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Modern american remedies/Laycock Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1430 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Taxation of Individual income Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1431 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 internal tax Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1432 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 tax controversies: Prac & Proc Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1433 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 law Summaries: Comm Prop/Reppy Jr Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1434 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Black Letter Outline: Crim Law/ Dressler Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1436 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Evidence: A Contemporary Appr Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1437 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Con law: principles & Policies Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1438 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Federal Juris/Chemerinsky Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1439 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Corps & other bus enterprises/ Hazen Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1440 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Constitutional Law/ Stone Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1441 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Tort law & Alternatives / Franklin Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1442 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Contracts: Basics/ Blum Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1443 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Elementary Statistics/ Triola Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1444 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fundamentals of Int'l Business / Czinkota Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1445 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 California Style manual/Jessen Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1447 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Easton Press Classic Literatu/Collection<br />

of Classics<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1448 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wills, Trusts & Estates/Dukeminier Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1449 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Federal <strong>Court</strong>s: Cases & Latters Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1450 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Legal Writing & Analysis Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1451 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Reason in Law Update Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1452 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Acing Property Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1453 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Acing Civil Procedure Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1454 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Contracts in a Nutshell Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1455 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 American Indian Law in a Nutshell Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1456 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Selcted Fed Taxation Statutes Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1457 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Siegal/s Torts/Siegel & emanuel Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1458 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Business law: text & cases Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1459 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 acing Con law Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1460 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Bankruptcy & Related law Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1461 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Property/Dukeminier Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1462 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Community property in California Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

10/15/2012 21


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1463 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fundamental of Corp. Taxation/ Lind Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1464 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Criminal law/ Dressler Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1465 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Conflicts of Law/ Currie Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1466 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Fed <strong>Court</strong>, Federal & Sep of Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1467 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Federal Rules Civil Trails 20/Smith Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1468 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Business Assoc/ Klein Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1469 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Advanced Torts/ Dobbs Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1470 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Just Writing/ Enquist Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1471 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Corporations- Intro to law/ Cox Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1472 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Corporations: Examples & Expl Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1473 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Practical Guide to Appellate A Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1474 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Irrepable Harm/ Sneep Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1475 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 The Big Short/ Lewis Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1476 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Federal Rules of Civ Pro/ Clermont Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1477 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Civil Procedure: E/E/Glannon Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1478 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Property E/E / Burke & Snoe Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1479 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Civil Procedure Hornbook/ Clermont Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1480 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Understanding Civil Procedure/Shreve Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1481 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Corporations & other LLP/ Hazen Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1482 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Legal Research: Prac Guide/McKinney Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1483 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Summaries on Civil Procedures/ West Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1484 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Summaries on Property/ West Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1485 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Emanuel law Outlines: Corps Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1486 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Q&A Wills and Trust/ Featherstone Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1487 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Treatise on law of Usury/ Blydenburgh Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1488 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Understanding conflicts of law Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1489 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Understanding Property law Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1490 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Understanding Torts Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1491 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Wills, trusts& estates/Beyer Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1492 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Street law/McGraw Hill Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1493 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Illustrated Oxford Dictionary Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1494 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Criminal Procedure/ White Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1495 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Advanced Torts: Cases & matters Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1496 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 materials on Pleadings & proc Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1497 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Q & A: Criminal law/Marcus Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1498 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Law Summaries: Research/Honigsbert Exact Guide Match 1 34 Books Professional or Reference<br />

1499 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Blender/ Hamilton Exact Guide Match 1 29 Blender or Mixer (Electric)<br />

1500 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Kitchen area rug/ IKEA Logical Match Possible<br />

1501 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 Rubbermaid 20 pc set Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1502 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

1503 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Shoes / Mens work shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

1504 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Boots / Ladies Brown No Logical Match<br />

1505 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Jacket / Leather ladies No Logical Match<br />

1506 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Suit - Ladies Logical Match Possible<br />

1507 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 Blouses - Ladies Logical Match Possible<br />

1609 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 jeans/sevens No Logical Match<br />

1 1610 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 Rug Exact Guide Match 1 45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard<br />

1614 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 <strong>Filing</strong> Cabinet Logical Match Possible<br />

1616 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 brown rug Logical Match Possible<br />

1617 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 rug w/ squares Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1618 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 refrigerator / Kenmore Exact Guide Match 1 233 Refrigerator<br />

10/15/2012 22


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1621 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 area rugs - kitchen Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1622 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 white lace tablecloth Exact Guide Match 1 195 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Other<br />

1623 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 kitchen towels, dish towels Logical Match Possible<br />

1624 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 white plastic trash bin Logical Match Possible<br />

1625 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 toaster Exact Guide Match 1 255 Toaster (Electric)<br />

1626 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 fans Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1627 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 complete set of Britannica En / gift Exact Guide Match 2 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

1628 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 photo reprints No Logical Match<br />

1 1631 119 05-M370-594 10/31/2005 Area Rug / Macy Exact Guide Match 1 44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less<br />

1632 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 bodysuits Logical Match Possible<br />

1633 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Footed pajamas Logical Match Possible<br />

1634 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Socks Logical Match Possible<br />

1635 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Girl's dresses Logical Match Possible<br />

1636 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Girl's leggings Logical Match Possible<br />

1637 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Girl's t-shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1638 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Nursing bras Logical Match Possible<br />

1639 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 T-shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1640 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Towels Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1641 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Comforter Exact Guide Match 1 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1642 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 Sheets Logical Match Possible<br />

1643 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Medium size bath rug Logical Match Possible<br />

1644 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Matching bathroom accessories Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1645 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. bath towels Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1664 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg medicine cabinet w/ mirror Logical Match Possible<br />

1668 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Med size vacuum Exact Guide Match 1 268 Vacuum Cleaner Home<br />

1677 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Cleaning cloths Exact Guide Match 2 260 Towels<br />

1678 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Round metal candle stick holde Logical Match Possible<br />

1679 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Small forks / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1680 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Butter knives / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1681 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Tea spoons / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1682 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Forks / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1683 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Spoons / Target Logical Match Possible<br />

1684 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg knife / Target Exact Guide Match 2 230 Pocketknife<br />

1685 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Plastic utensil tray Logical Match Possible<br />

1686 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. cooking spoons Logical Match Possible<br />

1687 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal garlic press Logical Match Possible<br />

1688 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. kitchen knife w/Shield Logical Match Possible<br />

1689 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Electric hand blender Exact Guide Match 1 29 Blender or Mixer (Electric)<br />

1690 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal can opener Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1691 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Eletric can opener Exact Guide Match 1 43 Can Opener (Electric)<br />

1692 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Asst. large books Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

1693 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Set of sm plastic dishes Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1694 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child's plastic plate Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1695 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child's plastic cup Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

10/15/2012 23


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1696 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Large dish rack Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1697 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Large chop wizard Logical Match Possible<br />

1700 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Baby bottle sponge Logical Match Possible<br />

1701 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Turkish coffee pot Exact Guide Match 2 120 Coffeemaker Perculater<br />

1702 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Kitchen scissors Logical Match Possible<br />

1703 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal tea/sugar containers Logical Match Possible<br />

1704 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Numbers / Alphabet magnets Logical Match Possible<br />

1707 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal cake spatula Logical Match Possible<br />

1711 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal oven racks Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1712 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal Stove tops Logical Match Possible<br />

1713 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Box of lrg. freezer bags No Logical Match<br />

1714 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. Palmolive dish soap Logical Match Possible<br />

1715 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. glass bowl Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

1716 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal spoon rest Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1717 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sm. bag of easter décor Logical Match Possible<br />

1718 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Baskets Logical Match Possible<br />

1720 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal towel holder Logical Match Possible<br />

1721 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lunch bag Logical Match Possible<br />

1722 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Empty engraved wine bottles Logical Match Possible<br />

1723 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. juicer Logical Match Possible<br />

1724 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. water kettle Logical Match Possible<br />

1727 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. serving dishes Logical Match Possible<br />

1728 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Set of sm. round dishes Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1729 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 sm.all flat dish set Logical Match Possible<br />

1730 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Set of sm. and lrg. dishes Logical Match Possible<br />

1731 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Asst sizes of plastic containers Logical Match Possible<br />

1737 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Telephone w/ base in box / V-Tech Exact Guide Match 1 252 Telephones, cordless<br />

1740 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Blues Band harmonica Exact Guide Match 1 202 Musical Instruments Under $50 (Cost New)<br />

1741 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 sm. salter scale Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1742 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Roll of trash bags Logical Match Possible<br />

1746 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Pictures (many) Logical Match Possible<br />

1748 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wine opener Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1749 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bottle opener Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

1750 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Set small square soup dishes Logical Match Possible<br />

1751 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wooden spice rack (15 spaces) Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

10/15/2012 24


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1752 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Metal spice rack (20 spaces) Exact Guide Match 2 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

1761 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 3pc L-shaped couch Logical Match Possible<br />

1762 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 HP laptop Logical Match Possible<br />

1763 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Refrigerator/ Hot Point Exact Guide Match 1 233 Refrigerator<br />

1764 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Dining room table Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1765 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Microwave Exact Guide Match 1 198 Microwave Ovens<br />

1767 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Dresser, night stand and bed frame w/<br />

marble top<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1768 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 DELETED - Side table No Logical Match<br />

1769 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lamps Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

1770 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bar stool Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1771 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 TV/DVD/VCR/ Sylvania Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1772 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Tivo recorder Exact Guide Match 2 278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

Recorder)<br />

1773 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Toshiba tv Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1774 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Coffee table Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1775 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bar table Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1777 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Camera / Canon Exact Guide Match 1 225 Photographic Equipment Over $50 (Cost New)<br />

1778 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 47" flat screen tv / vizio Exact Guide Match 1 275 Video Television Set - Color<br />

1779 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 DVD player/ Coby Exact Guide Match 1 279 Video Video Disk Player<br />

1780 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 DVD rack/ RO Logical Match Possible<br />

1781 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Ottoman Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

1782 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 All kids furniture & contents Exact Guide Match 1 157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture<br />

1784 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wine cooler/ fridge/Cuisinart Exact Guide Match 1 233 Refrigerator<br />

1785 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bathroom set. 7 pcs Logical Match Possible<br />

1786 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Toaster Exact Guide Match 1 255 Toaster (Electric)<br />

1787 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Baby grand piano Exact Guide Match 1 203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New)<br />

1788 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens suit pants Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

1789 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens heavy leather jkt. Exact Guide Match 1 73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and<br />

suede<br />

1790 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens heavy wool coat Exact Guide Match 1 76 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Wool<br />

1791 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Do ruck by Italy Logical Match Possible<br />

1792 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wool coat/Huge Boss Exact Guide Match 1 76 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Wool<br />

1793 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens coat/ Calvin Klein Exact Guide Match 1 76 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Wool<br />

1794 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens suit/ Columbia Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

1795 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens suit/ Boss Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

1796 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens suits Exact Guide Match 1 107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic<br />

1797 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens button up shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1798 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Black button up dress shirt/ Huge Boss Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

1799 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bathrobes Exact Guide Match 1 62 Clothing Bathrobes - Heavy or quilted<br />

1800 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lrg. snow suit Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

1801 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens polo shirt Exact Guide Match 1 95 Clothing Shirts - Dress<br />

1803 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens tshirt Logical Match Possible<br />

1804 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Knitted wool sweater Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

1805 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg throw blankets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

1806 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Asst bed spreads Logical Match Possible<br />

1807 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Asst pillow cases Logical Match Possible<br />

1808 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Feathered pillows Logical Match Possible<br />

1809 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Full size mattress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1810 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Box springs Exact Guide Match 1 20 Bedding Box Springs<br />

1811 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Asst mens ties Exact Guide Match 2 84 Clothing Formal wear<br />

10/15/2012 25


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1813 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens sport shoes Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1814 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 laptop case Logical Match Possible<br />

1815 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Tent Logical Match Possible<br />

1816 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Scarves Logical Match Possible<br />

1817 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Women's pajamas Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

1818 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens wool vest Logical Match Possible<br />

1819 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens jeans Logical Match Possible<br />

1820 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens jean jacket Logical Match Possible<br />

1821 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens briefs Exact Guide Match 1 116 Clothing Underwear - Panties<br />

1822 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Adult socks Exact Guide Match 1 103 Clothing Socks - Socks<br />

1823 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 mens belt Logical Match Possible<br />

1824 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Kids blanket Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

1825 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Table cloths Exact Guide Match 1 195 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Other<br />

1827 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens Blazer Logical Match Possible<br />

1831 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens skirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1832 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens leggings Logical Match Possible<br />

1833 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens tank tops Logical Match Possible<br />

1834 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens fancy top Logical Match Possible<br />

1835 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens t-shirt Logical Match Possible<br />

1836 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens long-sleeve shirt Logical Match Possible<br />

1837 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens casual pants Logical Match Possible<br />

1838 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens sweater Logical Match Possible<br />

1839 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens jacket Logical Match Possible<br />

1840 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens sweats Logical Match Possible<br />

1841 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Fancy long gown Logical Match Possible<br />

1842 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens jeans Exact Guide Match 1 101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active<br />

sport<br />

1843 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens dressy pants Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

1844 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens pajama pants Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

1845 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens underwear Exact Guide Match 1 116 Clothing Underwear - Panties<br />

1846 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bras Logical Match Possible<br />

1847 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Panty hose Exact Guide Match 1 114 Clothing Underwear - Foundation<br />

garments<br />

1848 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens belts Logical Match Possible<br />

1849 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bra straps Exact Guide Match 1 115 Clothing Underwear - Lingerie<br />

1850 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens suits Logical Match Possible<br />

1851 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Large comforter Exact Guide Match 1 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1852 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Pairs of childrens socks Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1853 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sets of childs pajamas Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1854 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child track suit Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1855 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Twin size mattress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1856 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Toddler size mattress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1857 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Twin size comforter Logical Match Possible<br />

1858 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Twin size bedspread Logical Match Possible<br />

1859 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens leg warmers Logical Match Possible<br />

1860 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens leggings Logical Match Possible<br />

1861 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens pants Logical Match Possible<br />

1862 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens skirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1863 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens t-shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 26


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1864 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens underwear Logical Match Possible<br />

1865 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens long sleve shirts Logical Match Possible<br />

1866 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childs night gown Logical Match Possible<br />

1867 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 umbrellas Exact Guide Match 1 267 Umbrella<br />

1868 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens sweater/jackets Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1869 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Chidrens vest Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1870 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childs robe Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1871 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens dresses Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1872 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

1873 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens Halloween costume Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1874 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Pairs of child shoes Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

1875 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child polo tennis shoes Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

1876 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childs rain boots Exact Guide Match 1 99 Clothing Shoes - Children's<br />

1877 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child sandals Logical Match Possible<br />

1878 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childs boots Logical Match Possible<br />

1879 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens jeans Logical Match Possible<br />

1880 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens sweats No Logical Match<br />

1881 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens hats Logical Match Possible<br />

1882 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Pair of child gloves Logical Match Possible<br />

1883 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg backpacks Logical Match Possible<br />

1884 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens scarves Logical Match Possible<br />

1885 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Vinyl carry bags Logical Match Possible<br />

1886 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Pool waist floats Logical Match Possible<br />

1887 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Adult leg warmers Logical Match Possible<br />

1888 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sheer drapes No Logical Match<br />

1889 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Curtain rods Logical Match Possible<br />

1890 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Bath towels Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1891 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wash cloths Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1892 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Throw pillows Exact Guide Match 2 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

1893 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens casual dresses Exact Guide Match 1 79 Clothing Dresses - Casual<br />

1894 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Blankets Exact Guide Match 1 17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton)<br />

1895 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wool sweaters Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

1896 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Queen matress Exact Guide Match 1 22 Bedding Mattresses<br />

1897 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Queen box spring Exact Guide Match 1 20 Bedding Box Springs<br />

1898 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 100 pc lego set Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1899 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sm portable fan Exact Guide Match 1 139 Fans Electric<br />

1900 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Childrens books Exact Guide Match 1 32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction<br />

1901 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Children number and letter stencil Logical Match Possible<br />

1902 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg map puzzle Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1903 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg world map puzzle Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1904 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg misc puzzles Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1905 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sm misc puzzle Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1906 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Children head beanies Exact Guide Match 1 77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but<br />

shoes)<br />

1907 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Baby wash cloths Exact Guide Match 1 260 Towels<br />

1908 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Head scarves for baby Logical Match Possible<br />

1909 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Small music box Exact Guide Match 1 201 Music Boxes<br />

1910 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child white piano w/ stool Exact Guide Match 1 203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New)<br />

10/15/2012 27


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1911 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Picture frames Exact Guide Match 1 227 Picture Frames<br />

1912 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg stuffed animals Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1913 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Sm stuffed animals Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1914 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Dora doll Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1915 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Doll stroller Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1916 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Barbies Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1917 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Battery operated animals Logical Match Possible<br />

1918 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Doll basinet Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1919 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Disney Bingo DVD Exact Guide Match 1 6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's)<br />

1920 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Wig Logical Match Possible<br />

1921 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child potty training toilet Logical Match Possible<br />

1922 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Med basket w/ hair accessories Logical Match Possible<br />

1923 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Child toy vacuum Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1924 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Box of blocks Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1925 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Ex lg box of misc toys Exact Guide Match 1 262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys<br />

1926 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Small microwave Exact Guide Match 1 198 Microwave Ovens<br />

1927 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Lg stove No Logical Match<br />

1928 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Mens shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

1929 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

1930 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 Womens heavy coat Exact Guide Match 1 70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and<br />

blends<br />

1944 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Pearl earrings Logical Match Possible<br />

1945 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Custom made gold nugget watch Logical Match Possible<br />

1946 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Diamond ring 3 1/2 ct cigar b Logical Match Possible<br />

1947 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Diamond studs 1/2 ct yell Logical Match Possible<br />

1 1948 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Cuff links w/onyx Exact Guide Match 1 172 Jewelry Bracelets, Broaches, Cuff<br />

Links, Earrings, Necklaces,<br />

Other Jeweled or Precious<br />

Metal Items, Pins, Rings,<br />

Studs, Watches<br />

1949 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Lg. Hawaiian gold bracelet-en Logical Match Possible<br />

1950 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bathing suits / Victoria's Secret Logical Match Possible<br />

1951 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bathing suits / Cole, Ann Klein, Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1952 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Cowboy boots / Frye Logical Match Possible<br />

1953 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Dress boots / Cole Hahn Logical Match Possible<br />

1954 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Dress boots, black / Nine Weset Logical Match Possible<br />

1955 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Dress boots / Bandalino Logical Match Possible<br />

1956 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Boots, sm. Heel / Ann Taylor Logical Match Possible<br />

1957 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Boots w/stitching / Born Logical Match Possible<br />

1958 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Boots / Stuart Weitzman Logical Match Possible<br />

1959 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Boots / Franco Sarto Logical Match Possible<br />

1960 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Hats - rabbit fur, white/gray Logical Match Possible<br />

1961 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Louis Vuitton bowling bag / Louis Vuitton Logical Match Possible<br />

1962 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Leather blazer Logical Match Possible<br />

1963 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bomber jacket / leather / Wilson Leather Exact Guide Match 1 73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and<br />

suede<br />

1966 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 DKNY jacket - blue / DKNY Logical Match Possible<br />

1967 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Mittens, cashmere Logical Match Possible<br />

1969 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Half slips / Victoria's Secret No Logical Match<br />

1970 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri pants / 2 Billie Blue No Logical Match<br />

1972 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri pants / Polo Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 28


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

1973 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri denim Logical Match Possible<br />

1975 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri white/ blue / Tommy Hilifiger Logical Match Possible<br />

1977 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri, black No Logical Match<br />

1979 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Capri, linen / Charter Club No Logical Match<br />

1980 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets of pajamas - cotton, silk / Victoria's<br />

Secret, Ralph Lauren<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

1981 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Victoria's Secret pants suits Logical Match Possible<br />

1982 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pant suits / NY & Co. Logical Match Possible<br />

1983 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets sweatshirts / BCBG No Logical Match<br />

1984 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Workout pants / Nike, Addidas,<br />

Athletic<br />

No Logical Match<br />

1985 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Yoga pants Logical Match Possible<br />

1986 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Yoga pants Logical Match Possible<br />

1987 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Halter tops/tank tops/ Various No Logical Match<br />

1988 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 T-shirts / Various No Logical Match<br />

1989 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 White blouses / Various Logical Match Possible<br />

1990 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Misc. blouses / Misc. Logical Match Possible<br />

1991 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Summer dresses / Misc. No Logical Match<br />

1992 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Tennis shoes/ New Balance No Logical Match<br />

1993 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Stockings / Victoria's Secret Logical Match Possible<br />

1994 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Summer nightgowns / Victoria's Secret Logical Match Possible<br />

1995 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Sorrells / Sorrell Exact Guide Match 1 98 Clothing Shoes - Adults'<br />

1996 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Wedding dress Logical Match Possible<br />

1997 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Wool slacks / DKNY Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

1998 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Wool slacks / Ralph Lauren Exact Guide Match 1 102 Clothing Slacks - Dress<br />

1999 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Set silk underwear / DKNY Logical Match Possible<br />

2000 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Formal pant set-sequin silk p Exact Guide Match 1 84 Clothing Formal wear<br />

2001 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Cashmere sweaters / Charter Club, Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

2002 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Cashmere/wool sweater / gray / Tahari Logical Match Possible<br />

2005 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Cocktail dresses / Ann Klein; Tahari, Ann<br />

Taylor<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 84 Clothing Formal wear<br />

2006 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bustiers / Victoria's Secret; Frederick's Logical Match Possible<br />

2007 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Black silk evening bag Logical Match Possible<br />

2008 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Pumps, hi heels, dress sh / Nine West Logical Match Possible<br />

2009 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Full slips / Victoria's Secret Exact Guide Match 1 117 Clothing Underwear - Slips<br />

2010 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Gloves, leather / wool / silk / cas Logical Match Possible<br />

2011 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Cashmere gloves Logical Match Possible<br />

2012 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Mink fur hat / Saks Fifth Ave Logical Match Possible<br />

2016 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Tahari suits, jacket & pants / Pahari Logical Match Possible<br />

2017 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Victoria's Secret bras / Victoria's Secret No Logical Match<br />

2018 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Victoria's Secret underwear / Victoria's<br />

Secret<br />

No Logical Match<br />

2019 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Jeans (women's) / "7" No Logical Match<br />

2020 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Jeans / For All Mankind No Logical Match<br />

2021 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Wool / cashmere coat (women's) / Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

2022 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Leather jacket / Wilson's Leather Logical Match Possible<br />

2023 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Leather jacket / Ann Klein Logical Match Possible<br />

2024 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pearl necklace - drop w/gold Logical Match Possible<br />

2025 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Gold nugget "anklet" / Hand made Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 29


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2026 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Diamond / gold bracelet Logical Match Possible<br />

2027 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Gold/stone baby ring (mother) Logical Match Possible<br />

2028 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Engraved St. Christopher neck Logical Match Possible<br />

2029 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sweater / Tommy Hilfiger Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

2030 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Underwear, boxers & briefs / Joe<br />

Boxer; Hanes; Tommy<br />

No Logical Match<br />

2031 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Sweatpants / LA gear Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

2032 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Heavy sweatshirts / Quick silver Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

2033 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Heavy sweatshirt / Fox Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

2034 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Heavy sweatshirt / Wildcat Exact Guide Match 1 113 Clothing Sweaters<br />

2035 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Heavy sweatshirt / Camoflague No Logical Match<br />

2036 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sweatshirt / Honda No Logical Match<br />

2037 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Tank tops / Nike; Arizona; Quick Silver No Logical Match<br />

2038 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Motorcycle T-shirts / Surf; Hurley; Fox;<br />

Quick Silver<br />

No Logical Match<br />

2039 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Black jacket / O'Neil Logical Match Possible<br />

2040 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Dress ties / Tommy Hilfiger; Ralph Lauren Logical Match Possible<br />

2041 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Back packs / Honda No Logical Match<br />

2042 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Back pack / Chargers No Logical Match<br />

2043 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Back pack / Oakland A's Logical Match Possible<br />

2044 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Back pack / Ugio No Logical Match<br />

2045 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Baseball hats / Professional sports; Nike;<br />

Fox<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

2046 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Dress suit / Profiles Logical Match Possible<br />

2047 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Wrangler jeans / Wrangler Logical Match Possible<br />

2048 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Jeans - black / Levi No Logical Match<br />

2049 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Jean jacket / Levi No Logical Match<br />

2050 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Pajamas / 49er; Dale Earnhart; Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas<br />

2051 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Rain coat / London Fog Exact Guide Match 1 74 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Plastic<br />

2052 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Long sleeve dress shirts / Ralph Lauren No Logical Match<br />

2053 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Shorts / Fox; Hurley; O'Neil Logical Match Possible<br />

2054 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Ski jacket / Rossignol Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

2055 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Ski pants / Rossignol Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

2056 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Socks / Haynes; Nike; Tommy Hilfiger No Logical Match<br />

2062 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Swim trunks / 2 Fox; 2 Volcuss; OP;<br />

Hurley<br />

No Logical Match<br />

2064 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Ugg boots / Ugg Logical Match Possible<br />

2065 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Nike tennis shoes / Nike No Logical Match<br />

2066 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Baseball cleets / Nike No Logical Match<br />

2067 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Basketball shoes / Michael Jordan No Logical Match<br />

2068 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Vann's / Vann No Logical Match<br />

2069 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Cotton khaki pants / Ralph Lauren;<br />

Tommy Hilfiger<br />

No Logical Match<br />

2070 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Black dress shoes / Rockport No Logical Match<br />

2071 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Flannel shirts L/SI / Woolrich Logical Match Possible<br />

2076 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Long silver meal tray / Gorham Logical Match Possible<br />

2077 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Silver tea service, 5 pc / Wallace Exact Guide Match 1 243 Silverware (Sterling)<br />

2078 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Medium oval platter - silver / Wallace Exact Guide Match 1 243 Silverware (Sterling)<br />

2079 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Medium silver trays / ornate w/ Exact Guide Match 1 243 Silverware (Sterling)<br />

2081 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Marble & silver tray Exact Guide Match 1 243 Silverware (Sterling)<br />

10/15/2012 30


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2082 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Lg. glass/crystal vase / Mikasa Logical Match Possible<br />

2083 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Lg. crystal cut vase / Waterford Logical Match Possible<br />

2084 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Carpet cleaner / Hoover Logical Match Possible<br />

2085 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Down pillows - bedroom No Logical Match<br />

2086 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Set Heckles knife set & block / Heckles Exact Guide Match 1 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

2088 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Mattress pads Logical Match Possible<br />

2089 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Twin comforters / shams / Charter Club Exact Guide Match 1 21 Bedding Comforters<br />

2091 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Tools of the Trade cookware Logical Match Possible<br />

2092 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Iron / Rowena Exact Guide Match 1 171 Irons (Electric Including Steam)<br />

2093 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Ironing Board Exact Guide Match 1 169 Ironing Board<br />

2094 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Vacuum cleaner / Hoover Logical Match Possible<br />

2095 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Luggage set / Samsonite Exact Guide Match 1 196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

2096 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bose radio w/CD / Bose Exact Guide Match 2 4 Audio Audio components - Receivers<br />

2097 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Lg. crystal bowl / Mikasa Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

2098 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Medium crystal bowl / Waterford Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

2100 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Tile top tables (tall) Logical Match Possible<br />

2101 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 100 ft. comm. Hoses Exact Guide Match 1 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

2102 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Bottles Top Shelf alcohol / Bailys; Jose<br />

Cuervo; Sky; Abso<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

2103 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Oster blender / Oster Exact Guide Match 1 29 Blender or Mixer (Electric)<br />

2104 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Rosignall ski jacket / Tri City Sports Exact Guide Match 2 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

2105 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Binoculars / Leopold Exact Guide Match 1 28 Binoculars<br />

2106 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Metal folding chairs "padded" Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2107 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Long party tables Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2108 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Compressor / Craftsman Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

2109 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Socket/wrench set / Sears<br />

Proline/Craftsman<br />

Logical Match Possible<br />

2111 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Camping tent / North Face Logical Match Possible<br />

2112 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sleeping bags / Columbie Logical Match Possible<br />

2113 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Generator / Craftsman Exact Guide Match 1 258 Tools Power<br />

2114 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Fox riding gear, Moto X, pant / Fox Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2115 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets snow skis & poles Logical Match Possible<br />

2116 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Motorcycle boots / Thor Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2117 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Motorcycle helmets / Shoi; Fox Logical Match Possible<br />

2118 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets riding gear, pants, jack / Fox Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2119 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Chest protector, 1 child / Fox Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2120 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Kidney belt / Fox Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2121 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Goggles - motorcycle Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2122 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Goggles - ski / Sith; Rose; Smith Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

2123 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Moto X riding boots / Fly Exact Guide Match 1 3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.)<br />

2124 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Rosignall ski boots Exact Guide Match 1 244 Skiing Equipment<br />

2125 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Hand carved wdn. Bear Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2127 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Large handmade wicker reindeer Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2128 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Wooden angels, hand carved, 1 Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

10/15/2012 31


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2129 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Crystal teardrop ornaments Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2131 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Wool/felt Santa, 2' tall Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2132 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Tree skirt/quilt, antique Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2133 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Waterford crystal ornaments Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2134 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets, speciality snowflake Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2135 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Asst. felt vintage Santa's Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2136 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Silver reindeer wine goblets Logical Match Possible<br />

2137 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets outdoor lights, speciality Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2138 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Snowman set, antique Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2139 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Feather trees "collection", h Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2140 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Vintage train set / Lionel Exact Guide Match 2 37 Brick-a-Brac<br />

2141 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 German glass ornaments Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2142 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Sets German hand blown glass Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2143 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Angel tree topper, wool, silk Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2144 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Pr. Tree candle sticks / Lenox Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2145 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Large gold star topper Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2146 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Santa sign - outdoor Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2147 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Porcelain nativity set, antiq Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2148 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Brocade tree skirt, ivory w/t Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2149 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Iron tree stands, green Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2150 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 ? Coco cups, hand painted Exact Guide Match 1 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

2151 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Christmas CDs Exact Guide Match 1 6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's)<br />

2152 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Velvet handmade stockings Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2153 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 German handmade music box w/a Logical Match Possible<br />

2154 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Artificial wreath w/berries Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2155 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 6' garland, green Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2156 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Set silk poinsettia plants Exact Guide Match 1 221 Ornaments and Decorations<br />

2157 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Commercial ice chest on wheels Exact Guide Match 1 42 Camping Equipment<br />

2158 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 Washer/dryer set, electric / Kenmore Exact Guide Match 1 137 Dryer (Laundry)<br />

2159 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 oriental style rug Logical Match Possible<br />

2160 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large original oil painting Logical Match Possible<br />

2161 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 chest with drawers Logical Match Possible<br />

1 2162 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lamps Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

2163 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 floral arrangment Logical Match Possible<br />

2164 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 table cloth / place mats Exact Guide Match 1 194 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Irish Types<br />

2165 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 sets of napkins Logical Match Possible<br />

2166 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 xmas platters Exact Guide Match 2 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

2167 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed mirror Logical Match Possible<br />

2168 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 flower pots Logical Match Possible<br />

2169 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 plant stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2170 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 flying goose décor Logical Match Possible<br />

2171 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 coil hose Exact Guide Match 1 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

2172 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 small bird bath Logical Match Possible<br />

2173 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 water fountain / pump Logical Match Possible<br />

2174 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dining room table Logical Match Possible<br />

2175 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dining room chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 32


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2176 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 placemats / napkins pottery barn Logical Match Possible<br />

2177 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 salt / pepper sets Logical Match Possible<br />

2178 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 faux green plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2179 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal tray Exact Guide Match 2 243 Silverware (Sterling)<br />

2180 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fake fruit Logical Match Possible<br />

2181 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tray & table Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2182 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pictures Logical Match Possible<br />

2183 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 place candle holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2184 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 sleeping bag Logical Match Possible<br />

2185 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 electric typewriter Logical Match Possible<br />

2186 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 plastic craft storage Logical Match Possible<br />

2187 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hamper Logical Match Possible<br />

2188 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 luggage holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2189 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 beach towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2190 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 queen sheets Logical Match Possible<br />

2191 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bath towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2192 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 afghans Logical Match Possible<br />

2193 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 decorator pillows Logical Match Possible<br />

2194 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 gift bags Exact Guide Match 2 249 Stationary<br />

2195 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 folding chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

2196 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 blanket Logical Match Possible<br />

2197 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wooden & plastic hangers Logical Match Possible<br />

2198 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hair dryer Logical Match Possible<br />

2199 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 curling iron Logical Match Possible<br />

2200 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hand towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2201 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ceramic fish Logical Match Possible<br />

2202 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 flower arrangment Logical Match Possible<br />

2203 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bathroom containers Logical Match Possible<br />

2204 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ceramic wash cloth dish Logical Match Possible<br />

2205 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 jewelry holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2206 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 soap dispenser Logical Match Possible<br />

2207 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wood box or tp Logical Match Possible<br />

2208 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 toilet bowl brush Logical Match Possible<br />

2209 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bath mat Logical Match Possible<br />

2210 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wooden wall décor Logical Match Possible<br />

2211 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bayleaf wreath Logical Match Possible<br />

2212 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lg faux tree Logical Match Possible<br />

2213 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal & glass table Logical Match Possible<br />

2214 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tv / vcr plaer Logical Match Possible<br />

2215 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 faux plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2216 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wicker night stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2217 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lamps Logical Match Possible<br />

2218 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 small florals Logical Match Possible<br />

2219 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 queen mattress / box springs Logical Match Possible<br />

2220 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 clock radio Logical Match Possible<br />

2221 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed art Logical Match Possible<br />

2222 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wreath Logical Match Possible<br />

2223 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cordless phone Logical Match Possible<br />

2224 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 picture Exact Guide Match 2 227 Picture Frames<br />

2225 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 clock Exact Guide Match 2 55 Clocks Grandfather<br />

2226 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 chair / cushion Logical Match Possible<br />

2227 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basket, greenery, birdhouses Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 33


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2228 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 raku bowl Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

2229 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 computer / accessories Logical Match Possible<br />

2230 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 printer Logical Match Possible<br />

2231 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fax machine Logical Match Possible<br />

2232 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fax table Logical Match Possible<br />

2233 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wicker chairs / cushions Logical Match Possible<br />

2234 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ottoman Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

2235 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dog bed Logical Match Possible<br />

2236 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basket with dog toys Logical Match Possible<br />

2237 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 boxes of greeting cards Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

2238 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 flatscreen tv Logical Match Possible<br />

2239 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 key box Logical Match Possible<br />

2240 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tv tray set Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2241 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wicker table lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2242 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 red leather waste baskte Logical Match Possible<br />

2243 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 computer chair Logical Match Possible<br />

2244 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 clock Exact Guide Match 2 55 Clocks Grandfather<br />

2245 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fake plants Logical Match Possible<br />

2246 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal tray w/ 5 metal pears Logical Match Possible<br />

2247 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large wooden golf picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2248 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ceramic drawers Logical Match Possible<br />

2249 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed calcutta etchings Logical Match Possible<br />

2250 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc office supplies Exact Guide Match 2 249 Stationary<br />

2251 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 decorative pillow Logical Match Possible<br />

2252 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 oak credenza Logical Match Possible<br />

2253 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 desk holder, pen /pads Exact Guide Match 2 249 Stationary<br />

2254 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 watermelon basket Logical Match Possible<br />

2255 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basket used as end table Logical Match Possible<br />

2256 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 area rug Exact Guide Match 1 45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard<br />

2257 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 new books unread Logical Match Possible<br />

2258 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 candle and tall candlestick Logical Match Possible<br />

2259 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2260 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 maps, US atlas Logical Match Possible<br />

2261 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed family photos Logical Match Possible<br />

2262 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 mah jong game set Logical Match Possible<br />

2263 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 stationary and paper goods Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

2264 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 red potted plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2265 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 red oil painting Logical Match Possible<br />

2266 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wood and cloth bar stools Logical Match Possible<br />

2267 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 small bar stool / pad Logical Match Possible<br />

2268 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 signed plates and holders Exact Guide Match 2 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

2269 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rooster w/pears Logical Match Possible<br />

2270 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc. vitamins Logical Match Possible<br />

2271 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc. pasta Logical Match Possible<br />

2272 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 paper towel holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2273 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc supplies under sink Logical Match Possible<br />

2274 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rubbermaid storage Logical Match Possible<br />

2275 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lettuce dryer Logical Match Possible<br />

2276 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 plastic storage containers Logical Match Possible<br />

2277 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 s&p grinders Logical Match Possible<br />

2278 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basket w/utensils Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 34


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2279 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dish towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2280 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 seal a meal Logical Match Possible<br />

2281 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 toaster Logical Match Possible<br />

2282 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 coffee maker Logical Match Possible<br />

2283 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 blender Logical Match Possible<br />

2284 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 toaster oven Logical Match Possible<br />

2285 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pottery piece Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

2286 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 plant / pot Logical Match Possible<br />

2287 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 electric juicer Logical Match Possible<br />

2288 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc. bake ware Logical Match Possible<br />

2289 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basic food items / spices Logical Match Possible<br />

2290 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 breadmaking machine Logical Match Possible<br />

2291 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 electric frypan Logical Match Possible<br />

2292 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 can / bottle foods Logical Match Possible<br />

2293 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 paper goods Exact Guide Match 1 249 Stationary<br />

2294 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 electric griddle Logical Match Possible<br />

2295 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 deep fryer Logical Match Possible<br />

2296 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 crockpot Exact Guide Match 2 176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

2297 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 potholders Logical Match Possible<br />

2298 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wreath Logical Match Possible<br />

2299 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 soap dispenser Logical Match Possible<br />

2300 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cookbooks Logical Match Possible<br />

2301 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cooling racks Logical Match Possible<br />

2302 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 GE refrigerator Logical Match Possible<br />

2303 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 kitche aid dishwasher Logical Match Possible<br />

2304 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 range /oven Logical Match Possible<br />

2305 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 microwave oven Logical Match Possible<br />

2306 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ferguson garbage disposal Logical Match Possible<br />

2307 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 seal meal bags Logical Match Possible<br />

2308 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 refrigerator Logical Match Possible<br />

2309 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pitchers Exact Guide Match 2 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

2310 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2312 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 coffee bean grinder Logical Match Possible<br />

2313 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 electric fondue pot Logical Match Possible<br />

2314 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dual sensor thermometer Logical Match Possible<br />

2315 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rubbermaid organizers Logical Match Possible<br />

2316 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dog food, brush, comb, bed Logical Match Possible<br />

2317 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cutting boards Logical Match Possible<br />

2318 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 scale Exact Guide Match 1 236 Scales (Bathroom)<br />

2319 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 nail clipper Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2320 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fireplace screen Logical Match Possible<br />

2321 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 orchid silk plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2322 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 candles / candleholders Logical Match Possible<br />

2323 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 iron chinese gong Logical Match Possible<br />

2324 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 allison chair Logical Match Possible<br />

2325 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 console table Logical Match Possible<br />

2326 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 30 -50 cds Logical Match Possible<br />

2327 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 10 -20 movies Logical Match Possible<br />

2328 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large platter Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

10/15/2012 35


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2329 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 purple afghan Logical Match Possible<br />

2330 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 knick knacks Logical Match Possible<br />

2331 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cloth coasters Logical Match Possible<br />

2332 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tall plant stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2333 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal magazine holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2334 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 silk plants Logical Match Possible<br />

2335 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bowl and plants Logical Match Possible<br />

2336 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 table lamp Exact Guide Match 2 182 Lamps Infrared or Sun<br />

2337 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 table lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2338 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 floor lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2339 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 area rugs Logical Match Possible<br />

2340 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2341 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 heavy glass vase Logical Match Possible<br />

2342 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large flower arrangment Logical Match Possible<br />

2343 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 matches / holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2344 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wooden cat Logical Match Possible<br />

2345 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 topiaries Logical Match Possible<br />

2346 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 glass balls Logical Match Possible<br />

2347 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 candleholder / candles Logical Match Possible<br />

2348 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 32 mitsubishi tv Exact Guide Match 2 276 Video Television Set - Black/White<br />

2349 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dual vcr/dvd player Logical Match Possible<br />

2350 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 stereo / speakers Exact Guide Match 2 9 Audio Radio (console, portable, table)<br />

2351 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cordless headset Logical Match Possible<br />

2352 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 gas log set Logical Match Possible<br />

2353 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large decorative plant / stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2354 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lamp Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

2355 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 glassware / tray set Exact Guide Match 1 51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils)<br />

2356 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wooden ducks Logical Match Possible<br />

2357 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 decanters Exact Guide Match 1 52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

2358 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pitcure Logical Match Possible<br />

2359 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 topiary Logical Match Possible<br />

2360 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 basket of tools / hardware Logical Match Possible<br />

2361 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 12 bottles of liquor Logical Match Possible<br />

2362 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 icemaker Logical Match Possible<br />

2363 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc games, cards Logical Match Possible<br />

2364 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 area rug Logical Match Possible<br />

2365 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 shoe polish brush Logical Match Possible<br />

2366 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bamboo cutting board Logical Match Possible<br />

2367 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 martini bar items Exact Guide Match 2 174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

2368 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 silk plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2369 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 book case Logical Match Possible<br />

2370 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 coffe table books Logical Match Possible<br />

2371 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cookbooks Logical Match Possible<br />

2372 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal bookstand Logical Match Possible<br />

2373 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 14 photo albums Logical Match Possible<br />

2374 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 art picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2375 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc kitchen knick knacks Logical Match Possible<br />

2376 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wooden folding chairs Exact Guide Match 2 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2377 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal folding chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 36


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2378 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 vacuum attachments Logical Match Possible<br />

2379 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dirt devil Logical Match Possible<br />

2380 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 card table Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2381 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 monopoly Exact Guide Match 1 261 Toys Electric Train and Games<br />

2382 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 1/2 gallon bottle of crown royal Logical Match Possible<br />

2383 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 step stool Logical Match Possible<br />

2384 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 mop, detergent batteries Logical Match Possible<br />

2385 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 glass / wood cabinet Logical Match Possible<br />

2386 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed art Logical Match Possible<br />

2387 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fake plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2388 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 stack washer / dryer Logical Match Possible<br />

2389 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 laundry supplies Logical Match Possible<br />

2390 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 candle holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2391 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bathroom cleaners / toilet paper Logical Match Possible<br />

2392 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed art Logical Match Possible<br />

2393 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 soap dispenser Logical Match Possible<br />

2394 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 combs, tweezers, makeup Exact Guide Match 1 128 Cosmetics<br />

2395 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 oval mirror Logical Match Possible<br />

2396 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bath towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2397 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bath mat Logical Match Possible<br />

2398 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 toilet paper holder Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2399 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 toilet brush Logical Match Possible<br />

2400 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 3 shelf stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2401 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 african basket / soap Logical Match Possible<br />

2402 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 4-5 cleaners Logical Match Possible<br />

2403 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 shampoo, razor, skincare Exact Guide Match 1 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2404 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2405 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 maid cloth Logical Match Possible<br />

2406 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bath rugs Logical Match Possible<br />

2407 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 soap dispensers Logical Match Possible<br />

2408 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 three topiaries Logical Match Possible<br />

2409 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 kleenex box holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2410 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 washclothes Logical Match Possible<br />

2411 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 lotions, soaps, toiletries Exact Guide Match 1 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2412 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 combs / brushes Logical Match Possible<br />

2413 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 first-aid supplies Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2414 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hair clippers Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2415 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hair scissors Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2416 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc medicine Logical Match Possible<br />

2417 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc bathroom cleaner Logical Match Possible<br />

2418 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 nail clippers, files, tweezers Exact Guide Match 2 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2419 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 makeup , astringent Exact Guide Match 1 128 Cosmetics<br />

2420 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large green plant Logical Match Possible<br />

2421 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 chest of drawers Logical Match Possible<br />

2422 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 two table lamps Exact Guide Match 1 181 Lamps Desk and Floor<br />

2423 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 decoration items Logical Match Possible<br />

2424 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 floral arrangment Logical Match Possible<br />

2425 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large basket Logical Match Possible<br />

2426 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ottomans Exact Guide Match 1 156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture<br />

2427 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 panel screen Logical Match Possible<br />

2428 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 3 drawer desk Logical Match Possible<br />

2429 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ironing board Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 37


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2430 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 small table Exact Guide Match 1 153 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Desks and Tables<br />

2431 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 over bed pictures Logical Match Possible<br />

2432 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wheeled carry on luggage Logical Match Possible<br />

2433 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 sunbeam and rowenta irons Logical Match Possible<br />

2434 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2435 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wicker basket Logical Match Possible<br />

2436 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 xmas quilt Logical Match Possible<br />

2437 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 spare blankets / pillows Exact Guide Match 1 19 Bedding Blankets (Wool)<br />

2438 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 misc office supplies Exact Guide Match 2 249 Stationary<br />

2439 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 11 bird cages Logical Match Possible<br />

2440 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 5 hat boxes Logical Match Possible<br />

2441 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 greenery Logical Match Possible<br />

2442 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 desk chair Exact Guide Match 1 151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

2443 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rug Exact Guide Match 1 49 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) Genuine Orientals<br />

2444 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 desk lamp Logical Match Possible<br />

2445 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 small picture Logical Match Possible<br />

2446 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large plant and stand Logical Match Possible<br />

2447 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tv /video player Logical Match Possible<br />

2448 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wicker hamper Logical Match Possible<br />

2449 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tall basket Logical Match Possible<br />

2450 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 perfume rack, perfume Exact Guide Match 1 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2451 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dustbuster Logical Match Possible<br />

2452 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rechargeable flashlight Exact Guide Match 1 143 Flashlights<br />

2453 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 wigs Logical Match Possible<br />

2454 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed mirrors Logical Match Possible<br />

2455 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 french soap Exact Guide Match 1 256 Toiletries (Personal Items)<br />

2456 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 framed photos Logical Match Possible<br />

2457 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 clock radio Exact Guide Match 1 57 Clocks Other - Under $25 (Cost New)<br />

2458 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 alarm clock Exact Guide Match 1 57 Clocks Other - Under $25 (Cost New)<br />

2459 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 ralph lauren pillow shams Logical Match Possible<br />

2460 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pillows / pillow slips ralph lauren Logical Match Possible<br />

2461 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 black pillows decorative Logical Match Possible<br />

2462 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 goose down comforter Logical Match Possible<br />

2463 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 king-size pillows Logical Match Possible<br />

2464 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 king-size bed frame Logical Match Possible<br />

2465 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 panties Logical Match Possible<br />

2466 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bras Logical Match Possible<br />

2467 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pjs / nightgowns Logical Match Possible<br />

2468 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 swimsuits Logical Match Possible<br />

2469 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 swimsuit coverups Logical Match Possible<br />

2470 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 beach towels Logical Match Possible<br />

2471 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 garmet bags Logical Match Possible<br />

2472 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 terry cloth short / jacket sets Logical Match Possible<br />

2473 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 designer purse Logical Match Possible<br />

2474 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 camisole Logical Match Possible<br />

2475 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 camisole Logical Match Possible<br />

2476 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rose bowl sweatshirt Logical Match Possible<br />

2477 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 overnight bags Logical Match Possible<br />

2478 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 black flat shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

2479 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 black heels Logical Match Possible<br />

2480 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 sandals Logical Match Possible<br />

2481 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 orange heel Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 38


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

2482 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 sports shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

2483 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 walking shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

2484 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 navy flat shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

2485 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 brown suede flat Logical Match Possible<br />

2486 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tommy bahama flip flops Logical Match Possible<br />

2487 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 red flat shoes Logical Match Possible<br />

2488 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 xmas tree Logical Match Possible<br />

2489 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 refrigerator - freezer Logical Match Possible<br />

2490 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 xmas tree storage bag Logical Match Possible<br />

2491 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 shop vac Logical Match Possible<br />

2492 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 golf bag Logical Match Possible<br />

2493 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 pantry closet Logical Match Possible<br />

2494 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cleaners / food stuff Logical Match Possible<br />

2495 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 golf balls, socks, towels, gloves Exact Guide Match 1 159 Golf Clubs and Equipment<br />

2496 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hand cart Logical Match Possible<br />

2497 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 garden supplies Exact Guide Match 1 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

2498 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 grapefruit picker Exact Guide Match 1 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

2499 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 travel golf bag Exact Guide Match 1 159 Golf Clubs and Equipment<br />

2500 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 weber duster Logical Match Possible<br />

2501 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 flower vases Logical Match Possible<br />

2503 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 brushes Logical Match Possible<br />

2504 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 collapsible leaf holder Exact Guide Match 2 158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

2505 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 whisk broom Logical Match Possible<br />

2506 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 detergent Logical Match Possible<br />

2507 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 tool holder Logical Match Possible<br />

2508 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 table / 4 chairs Logical Match Possible<br />

2509 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal trellises Logical Match Possible<br />

2510 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal plant stands Logical Match Possible<br />

2511 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 terra-cotta square planters Logical Match Possible<br />

2512 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 fountain and pump Logical Match Possible<br />

2513 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 patio cushions Logical Match Possible<br />

2514 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 umbrella Logical Match Possible<br />

2515 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cement umbrella Logical Match Possible<br />

2516 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 iron fences Logical Match Possible<br />

2517 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bird feeders Logical Match Possible<br />

2518 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 bird house Logical Match Possible<br />

2519 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large candleholder Logical Match Possible<br />

2520 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal candleholders Logical Match Possible<br />

2521 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large candle Logical Match Possible<br />

2522 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal doormat Logical Match Possible<br />

2523 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 metal setee Logical Match Possible<br />

2524 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 planter boxes Logical Match Possible<br />

2525 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 large urn Logical Match Possible<br />

2526 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 terra cotta planters Logical Match Possible<br />

2527 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 planters Logical Match Possible<br />

2528 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 rubbermaid organizers Logical Match Possible<br />

2529 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cocktail napkins Logical Match Possible<br />

10/15/2012 39


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 2<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Results of Analysis of Basis for Depreciation<br />

Claim Contains at<br />

Least One Exact<br />

Guide Match Lit_ID<br />

Summary of Results:<br />

Result Category Match Confidence # of Items % of Total<br />

Exact Guide Match (Direct) 1 669 36.6%<br />

Exact Guide Match (Probable) 2 100 5.5%<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a 902 49.4%<br />

No Logical Match n/a 155<br />

1,826<br />

8.5%<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS Item Description Results<br />

[a] [b]<br />

2530 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 welcome sign Logical Match Possible<br />

2531 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dressy slacks Logical Match Possible<br />

2532 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 dressy tops Logical Match Possible<br />

2533 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 casual pants Logical Match Possible<br />

2534 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 casual shorts Logical Match Possible<br />

2535 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 casual sweaters Logical Match Possible<br />

2536 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cardigans Logical Match Possible<br />

2537 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 blouses Logical Match Possible<br />

2538 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 vests Logical Match Possible<br />

2539 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 jackets Logical Match Possible<br />

2540 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 knit shirts, golf outfits Logical Match Possible<br />

2541 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 skorts Logical Match Possible<br />

2542 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 warmups Logical Match Possible<br />

2543 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 windbreakers Logical Match Possible<br />

2544 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 swimsuits Logical Match Possible<br />

2545 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 swimsuit coverups Logical Match Possible<br />

2546 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 belts Logical Match Possible<br />

2547 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 scarves Logical Match Possible<br />

2548 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 socks Logical Match Possible<br />

2549 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 hats Logical Match Possible<br />

2550 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 closet organizer Logical Match Possible<br />

2551 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 cotton turtlenecks Logical Match Possible<br />

30 81% Claims With at Least One Exact Guide Match<br />

37 100% Total Claims With Known Age Greater Than Zero<br />

Match<br />

Confidence<br />

Notes:<br />

[a] There are four categories of results:<br />

Result Category<br />

Match<br />

Confidence Definition<br />

Exact Guide Match 1 Items with depreciation and descriptions that directly matched the SF Depreciation Guide.<br />

Exact Guide Match 2 Items with depreciation that directly match the SF Depreciation Guide and descriptions that appeared to be a probable match to the SF Depreciation Guide.<br />

Logical Match Possible n/a Items with depreciation that directly match the SF Depreciation Guide, but with descriptions with no discernible match to the SF Depreciation Guide.<br />

No Logical Match n/a Items with depreciation amounts that did not logically match to the SF Depreciation Guide, per the STATA program.<br />

[b]<br />

The first two categories above are considered to be matches. The remaining two categories are not considered to be matches.<br />

Match Confidence defined as: 1 = Direct Match, 2 = Probable Match.<br />

Source:<br />

For CIS Form data, see Appendix 5.<br />

Category<br />

ID Category Sub-Category<br />

10/15/2012 40


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 3<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Guide" ("Guidelines")<br />

Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

1 55-01R7-146 n/a 11/17/2011 CI complete, all items left open no ages provided. Depriciation added for items on guide. SF CL0000013<br />

2 55-01R7-146 n/a 11/11/2011 CP: Please add to CI addfl personal items that are in documentation titled "Inventory (personal<br />

property)" - received on 1117111. These items lack ages. Please f/up with PHs and obtain ages.<br />

Authority to use depreciation guide to determine ACV on contents. Please advise once complete. Thank<br />

you.<br />

SF CL0000013<br />

3 55-01R7-146 n/a 11/9/2011 CP: PH submitted inventory forms and letter listing down mattresses that were deemed a 'total loss' by<br />

EWS/contents company (sewage loss). Forms and list in documents (rec'd 11nI11). Please enter Items<br />

into CI. PH did not include ages of items, please follow up with PH to obtain ages. Okay to use<br />

depreciation guide in CI to determine ACV. Please advise CR once complete. Thank you.<br />

SF CL0000014<br />

4 55-Y233-652 111 2/24/2009 Depreciated per guidelines . SF CL0000084<br />

5 55-Y233-652 108 2/19/2009 Inventory has been depreciated per guidelines. Sent possible items to SFRS for quotes . SF CL0000085<br />

6 75-052K-095 n/a 2/1/2012 CP only reviewed OPEN items. other items already depreciated. Marked all furniture/frames 20%.<br />

Marked Crystal/china 10% along with antique type items that are glassware and railroad lantems. Gave<br />

clothing/purseslllnenslBBQ one year age with life expo as SF Depr. guide. stuffed animals and<br />

magazines 50%. All other items were given 25% depr. Cr needs to review before CP can make payment<br />

for any changes. Open items have no price<br />

SF CL0000145<br />

7 05-M443-777 59 2/27/2009 Input list of dmgd books. Insured replaced some - input RC and added shipping and handling to book #1.<br />

Remaining books were paperbacks. Applied 50% depreciation per guide.<br />

SF CL0000414<br />

8 05-M486-516 18 12/1/2010 DEPRECIATION: use depreciation guide SF CL0000462<br />

9 05-M486-516 7 9/14/2010 DEPRECIATION: use depreciation guide SF CL0000464<br />

10 05-M517-927 43 9/23/2011 Returned call to CP Dohner X2977620 - spoke CP Dohner, advised to use standard depreciation guide<br />

for depreciating property.<br />

SF CL0001041<br />

11 05-M517-927 44 9/23/2011 CP rec'd call OCR, directed CP to apply depreciation per guide. Printed SF CL0001041<br />

12 75-M566-207 50 2/4/2010 CP sent CSA instr to enter ppif into CI, using Deprec Guide for depreciation. SF CL0001257<br />

13 75-M566-207 47 2/4/2010 Rec'd refinishing estimate for $1,661.00. Cr rev'd estimate and called contractor to discuss. The<br />

contractor states these are the only peices that were able to be saved. pricing for work performed<br />

appears to be within industry standards per cr past experience. Contractor also states that repars are<br />

almost completed.<br />

Ppifs have been rec'd. called ph and discussed inventory and depreciation. Items are for like kind and<br />

quality. Normal wear and tear applies. Insureds daughter lived in the guest house by herself. Cr will<br />

forward to cp to process.<br />

"All Coverage issues resolved: Yes<br />

"Coverage extended: (Cov A, Cov B, Cov C?) coverage A and B<br />

"Pending Items to Conclude: process ppifs in images using depreCiation guide and normal wear and<br />

tear for like kind and quality.<br />

"Authority: none at this time<br />

SF CL0001257<br />

10/15/2012 1


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 3<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Guide" ("Guidelines")<br />

Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

14 75-M566-207 38 12/10/2009 Rec'd estimate from contractor for permit and fee's from the city in the<br />

amount of $1,610.91. Original copies alos submitted. fee's appear in line and<br />

ready for payment. Also rec'd contents invoice for $16,583.34. for the following; pack out/in and storage<br />

for $5,885.06 and cleaning and restoration of contents for $10,698.28. Cr rev'd estimate, labor hours<br />

billed and material cost. They appear in line. Cleaning cost are withing industry guidelines. ok to issue<br />

payment. Dict letter to ph<br />

pend dict<br />

ppifs<br />

SF CL0001259<br />

15 5-M564-724 74 11/2/2009 CP reviewed CI, marked all items ph has already replaced with receipts ph Sub Category: turned in. ph<br />

turned in membership fee for Sam's club where she replaced bed, marked this item (10) as not covered.<br />

ph had text book that was damaged, and had document showing replacement amount from school,<br />

marked negotiated. last three items were furniture, used SF guide to depreciate. cr please review for<br />

authority.<br />

SF CL0001425<br />

16 75-M553-079 60 7/6/2009 CP reviewed additional PPIF's submitted, media stand replacement cost and<br />

age of item listed. Updated CI, applied standard depreciation per SF guide.<br />

**CR please review and grant authority.<br />

SF CL0001487<br />

17 75-M553-079 8 5/18/2009 Once CI is complete, please apply depreciation per State Farm Depreciation Guide for normal use and<br />

wear, request A2P<br />

SF CL0001497<br />

18 75-M537-021 62 1/12/2009 Once PPIFs rec'd enter into CI. Apply depreciation per the SF Depreciation guide. Contact SFRS and<br />

request they provide quotes for whatever items they can replace once PPIFs has been entered if<br />

necessary. Route to CR for review and auth.<br />

SF CL0001654<br />

19 75-M477-648 24 1/5/2007 Insured to submit bid frmo Rooms & Covers in Ontario to replace the wood panel in the bonus rooom.<br />

Estimate is anticipated to be $4k. Spoke with with Rich and there is nothing in the Xactimate price guide<br />

that is similar to material in patio enclosed.<br />

SF CL0001714<br />

20 75-M613-624 31 1/26/2011 DEPRECIATION: Use depreciation guide and ages as provided by insured. SF CL0001801<br />

21 05-M390-177 91 10/10/2006 Copied three documents: 1. "Getting Started with your new appliance-two page document. 2. Cooktop<br />

Installation guide (8 pages) 3. Us and Care Guide (16 including back page). 4. REceipts for original<br />

purchase of stove. (2 pages). -Mr. Pham also is faxing receipts for some work done by his<br />

housekeeper= content unpacking/packing- to CIOS.<br />

SF CL0002552-53<br />

22 55-E078-594 127 11/4/2009 2) Applied depreciation using the depreciation guide, CR to review with PH. Sub Category: Item #3 Lazy<br />

Boy Couch & Item #4 Lazy Boy Recliner were 2 months old, put as New, no documentation submitted<br />

showing new and how much they are worth.<br />

SF CL0002603<br />

23 75-M629-365 18 6/30/2011 DEPRECIATION: Standard kitchen items used regularly. Use depr. guide SF CL0002725<br />

24 75-M596-075 126 9/13/2010 Explain: Items not on guide or no age. SF CL0002760<br />

25 75-M596-075 124 9/10/2010 CSA inst to enter ppif. If no age or price, leave open otherwise use deprec guide per the CR instruction. SF CL0002761<br />

26 75-M596-075 119 9/10/2010 DEPRECIATION: Based on dpreciation guide or if you have question call and or<br />

email me.<br />

SF CL0002761<br />

10/15/2012 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 3<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Guide" ("Guidelines")<br />

Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

27 75-M446-682 46 5/26/2006 Updated contents inventory. Amount due insured is $1,031.35. Note that most items have been left<br />

Open as the insured did not provide the ages or cost. Tools can be ordered through SFRS. Need<br />

insured to either give us the ages or let us order through SFRS. Depreciation was applied per SF<br />

depreciation guide. Called insured and left message explaining. Printed leHer and draft to insured.<br />

SF CL0002909<br />

28 75·M592·294 34 7/22/2010 entered PPIFs into CI, applied depreCIation per SF guide . SF _ CL0002952<br />

29 05-M484-938 115 8/1/2011 Not on guide: 7,10,11,13,14,16,17,19,20,22 SF CL0002981<br />

30 05-M484-938 111 7/21/2011 hardware supplies from Paganos Hardware Mart - ad] floor guide was to move contents and the hanger<br />

was to hang a picture frame $21.79<br />

SF CL0002982<br />

31 05-M484-938 107 7/19/2011 hardware supplies from Pagaoos Hafdware Mart - adj ftoOI" guide? hanger? SF _ CL0002984<br />

32 05-M391-373 n/a 11/17/2008 books. school study guide SF_CL0003226<br />

33 55-E02J-943 40 9/5/2007 2) Applied depreciation uSing the depreciation guide. SF CL0003993<br />

34 5s.E115-455 42 12/1/2010 DEPRECIATION: use guide SF_CL0004106<br />

35 55-E078-846 22 9/3/2009 Depreciated per SF Depreciation Guide SF CL0004284-85<br />

36 55-E078-846 18 8/27/2009 2. Figure depr based on SF depr guide SF CL0004285-86<br />

37 55-E078-846 2 8/17/2009 Coverage B: Expld ACV and dep. for contents items. Advised we use a dep. guide for general life<br />

expectancy on most items & that amI we deduct for an ACV pymt. We take into account the use of the<br />

item, wearability, condition of the item prior to the loss to make a fair dep. assessment. - ·~Extended<br />

coverage due to LI #6, vehicle impact<br />

SF CL0004290-91<br />

38 75-M562-145 39 10/2/2009 Coverage B<br />

Depreciation to be applied - will need to be negotiated as these are all business specific items that were<br />

mostly old, not used often, and stored in a warehouse.<br />

Special Instructions for contents inventory - Enter Items and apply depreciation from the guide, if items<br />

are listed.<br />

SF CL0004304-05<br />

39 55-E063-216 139 9/18/2009 Called the PH, 209-765-5816, spoke to Mr. PH.<br />

-Mr. PH explained that he does not wish to claim any of the open items in his inventory at this time<br />

(items 15, 16, 19, 20, & 29-31). I asked the PH if he wishes to have someone evaluate the electronic<br />

items to let me know within a reasonable time period. We went ver the SFRS quotes and agreed that all<br />

of the items quoted were accurate except for the dryer and I revised the items with the SFRS quotes (the<br />

PH's price was accurate based on the quote). I explained depreciation to the PH again - we consider<br />

age, use, and Condition of the items. I explained the depreciation guide and the PH believes the<br />

depreciation guide would be a good way to determine the depreciation for all of his items.<br />

SF CL0004679-80<br />

10/15/2012 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 3<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Guide" ("Guidelines")<br />

Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

40 55-E063-216 97 5/19/2009 I asked William about the restoration period and the PH believes that the end of May is a reasonable<br />

restoration period for the covered damages. The PH agreed that we do not owe for any ALE after May<br />

31, 2009. I asked the PH to forward any ALE move back in expenses that they may incur. The PH is<br />

working on getting the estimate for the HVAC per log 82. The PH will also be getting a letter from the<br />

HVAC company stating that they believe the HVAC units need to be replaced. There were two<br />

contractors that agreed that the two HVAC units need to be replaced. I asked the PH about the PPIFs.<br />

The PH has not started the inventory. The PH stated that Servpro should be getting a list of the items<br />

that could not be salvaged. The PH stated that he does not believe any of the damaged items have<br />

salvage potential, but he will keep salvage in mind. I asked about drycleaning expenses and the PH has<br />

no drycleaning expenses. I explained to the PH that we use a depreciation guide for depreciation to<br />

determine ACV, but we also consider the age, use, and condition of all PP items. I explained that we can<br />

go over depreciation for the items once the inventory is received .<br />

SF CL0004690-91<br />

10/15/2012 4


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 4


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

1 1 55-E063-216 139 9/18/2009 ACTIVITY lOG NUMBER: 139<br />

Called the PH, 209-765-5816, spoke to Mr. PH.<br />

-Mr. PH explained that he does not wish to claim any of the open items in his inventory at this time (items<br />

15, 16, 19, 20, & 29-31). I asked the PH if he wishes to have someone evaluate the electronic items to<br />

let me know within a reasonable time period. We went over the SFRS quotes and agreed that all of the<br />

items quoted were accurate except for the dryer and I revised the items with the SFRS quotes (the PH's<br />

price was accurate based on the quote). I explained depreciation to the PH again - we consider age,<br />

use, and condition of the items. I explained the depreciation guide and the PH believes the depreciation<br />

guide would be a good way to determine the depreciation for all of his items.<br />

2 55-E063-216 134 9/4/2009 Melissa:<br />

-Please see previous log #133.<br />

-I called NI and let him know that I have completed entering his ppif per his discard list.<br />

-I asked if he knows whether or not the computer and printer are in working condition. He states he has<br />

not had time to run them to see if they work.<br />

-He says to do whatever we need on those items.<br />

3 55-E063-216 97 5/19/2009 Called the PH, 209-763-5738, wrong number.<br />

Called the PH, 209-765-5816, spoke to William.<br />

-I asked William about the restoration period and the PH believes that the end of May is a reasonable<br />

restoration period for the covered damages. The PH agreed that we do not owe for any ALE after May<br />

31, 2009. I asked the PH to forward any ALE move back in expenses that they may incur. The PH is<br />

working on getting the estimate for the HVAC per log 82. The PH will also be getting a letter from the<br />

HVAC company stating that they believe the HVAC units need to be replaced. There were two<br />

contractors that agreed that the two HVAC units need to be replaced. I asked the PH about the PPIFs.<br />

The PH has not started the inventory. The PH stated that Servpro should be getting a list of the items<br />

that could not be salvaged. The PH stated that he does not believe any of the damaged items have<br />

salvage potential, but he will keep salvage in mind. I asked about drycleaning expenses and the PH has<br />

no drycleaning expenses. I explained to the PH that we use a depreciation guide for depreciation to<br />

determine ACV, but we also consider the age, use, and condition of all PP items. I explained that we<br />

can go over depreciation for the items once the inventory is received .<br />

4 75-M615-077 20 2/2/2011 MCH: Inspected 1-31-11 Met with Ms. ph. Water heater closet is located on the exterior of the condo<br />

unit. The closet is located primarily on the kitchen wall (comer kit). The adjoining wall (stove side of kit) is<br />

shared with the office. There is slight bubbled paint at the top of the office baseboard at the corner, no<br />

visable water marks. The desk has not been moved during the ews process so MCH could not check the<br />

condition of the carpet (room 11,10 x 11,6 flanked by fct at the door openings). This MCH notes there<br />

are a couple areas of pre-existing damage with likely two other pre-existing PCOLs:<br />

1) the irrigation sprinklers looks to be postioned in a manner that sprays on the bottom door and door<br />

jamb of the water heater closet. This has rusted out the frontlbackside of the metal faced door and rotted<br />

the door insides and door jamb. This damage is separate, r/s/l and is not related to the current loss<br />

75M615077<br />

2) r/s/l leak damage noted inside/under the bottom kitchen cabinet drawer. Source is unknown but looks<br />

to be higher, ie off the floor. Possible migration of water at the pipe in the exterior wall in this area. Ph is<br />

unaware of any prior event. Sprinkler dmg unlikely based on stucco/flashing<br />

SF_CL0004679<br />

SF_CL0004681<br />

SF_CL0004690-91<br />

SF_CL0004662-63<br />

10/15/2012 1


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

5 75-M510-761 97 4/21/2008 Called Mr. He said RIP Chris Haley is at 9 Oak Spring Ln. He is not happy that we will be pursuing<br />

subrogation. She doesn't have any money and will react unpleasantly towards them.<br />

The painting and flrg in the home was 4 yrs old and was in good condition.<br />

6 75-M602-787 114 3/12/2012 Signatory to Arb: Fluidmaster<br />

Arbitration Forums Member Number: 03776-0002<br />

Analysis: 25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Reason for arbitration: Fluidmaster has been provided aU suporting documents.<br />

Fluidmaster has inspected and returned the evidence 06130120t 1. Fluidmaster has not responded to<br />

our attempts to obtain their position.<br />

Basis of dispute: Western Engineering concluded<br />

Amount of last Demand:$26,088.10 ($1 k OED)<br />

Supports:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin & brittle. The<br />

stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products. Manufacturer<br />

should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

7 75-M602-787 112 1/31/2012 Evidence & location: 9yo br sink supply lineJFM retd to MRSF 6/30/11.<br />

SIE (% Range):25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

8 75-M602-787 111 9/19/2011 Evidence & location: 9yo br sink supply line/FM retd to MRSF 6130/11.<br />

S/E (% Range):25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of Common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

9 75-M602-787 109 8/31/2011 Evidence & Location: 9yo br sink supply lineJMRSF to F.M. 6/01/11<br />

S/E (% Range):25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

10 75-M602-787 105 7/6/2011 Evidence & location: 9yo br sink supply linelMRSF to F.M. 6/01/11<br />

S/E (% Range):25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

11 75-M602-787 103 6/1/2011 Evidence & Location: 9yo br sink supply IinelMRSF to F.M. 6/01111<br />

S/E (% Range):25-50% based on age and expert analysis.<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line to accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

SF_CL0004567<br />

SF_CL0004429<br />

SF_CL0004429<br />

SF_CL0004430<br />

SF_CL0004430-31<br />

SF_CL0004431-32<br />

SF_CL0004432<br />

10/15/2012 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

12 75-M602-787 96 4/12/2011 Evidence & Location: 9yo br sink supply line - sto req apprv'd @ MRSF<br />

S/E (% Range):100<br />

Liability Analysis:the supply line failed when the stainless steel braiding deteriorated, making it thin &<br />

brittle. The stainless steel can deteriorate in the presence of common household cleaning products.<br />

Manufacture should have designed the supply line 10 accommodate these foreseeable conditions.<br />

13 75-R255-165 12 10/31/2007 Facts:Wind blew dirt and sand into home. Insured had service masters come out to clean up home, they<br />

cleaned the walls, vacumed the home, and also cleaned up huge piles of sand out side. Also, there are<br />

ceiling tiles in about half of the home, lifted them up and there were alot of dirt/sand through out the top<br />

portions of these tiles. I figured to replace all of the ceiling tiles as there is dirt/sand on top and they can't<br />

be cleaned. This is only for about half of the ceiling in home. Also, mtl roof on rear was blown up and<br />

damaged, figured to replace the whole thing, and one gutter was blown down on right elevation. Awnings<br />

on front elevation was also damaged, so I figured to replace it. Insured's do not have replacement cost<br />

benefits on policy. I dep. the roof, and all ceiling tiles about 20% as they were in good condition prior to<br />

the storm, along with the gutter, and awnings. There were also some tiles missing on the roof, or had<br />

come loose so I figured a repair. The carport also had some damage to the rntl roof, so I figured to<br />

replace a couple sections.<br />

14 75-M497-661 6 7/26/2007 Discussed with him policy settlement and reviewd Fine Arts Special Condition. He wants to take the<br />

painting to an art repair that he works with to see about having the frame repaired; the Strawberry Dish<br />

to Brooks Restoration. WE agreed that the chargers are in too many pieces and would not be cost<br />

effective to repair.<br />

1 15 55-E078-846 2 8/17/2009 Coverage B: Expld ACV and dep. for contents items. Advised we use a dep. guide for general life<br />

expectancy on most items & that amt we deduct for an ACV pymt. We take into account the use of the<br />

item, wearability, condition of the item prior to the loss to make a fair dep. assessment. - **Extended<br />

coverage due to LI #6, vehicle impact<br />

16 55-E115-455 n/a 5/22/2012 Rcvd invoice for storage of evidence. Per my most recent review of 8122/11, per suit condition we only<br />

needed to keep storage until March 2012. I completed invoice to advise it is okay to destroy evidence. I<br />

faxed to Armstrong and reclosed claim.<br />

17 55-E115-455 305 8/22/2011 This fire was an incendiary fire. Claim was denied on 3/24/11 due to a breach of the conditions of Ms.<br />

Babers Renters policy. Due to Suit Condition, we will keep evidence in storage until March 2012.<br />

18 55-E115-455 290 5/10/2011 I received Armstrong Lab storage notice. Our evidence produced positive lab results for both samples<br />

which contained gasoline. This claim was denied due to a breach of the conditions listed in Ms. Babers<br />

Renters policy. Should Ms. Babers return to SF with new information or compliance within a year of<br />

when the claim is closed, we would proceed with our investigation. As a result, I recommend we ask<br />

Armstrong to store the evidence for a period of 1 yr at this time. Total cost is $140.00.<br />

SF_CL0004433<br />

SF_CL0004415<br />

SF_CL0004298<br />

SF_CL0004291<br />

SF_CL0004033<br />

SF_CL0004033<br />

SF_CL0004036<br />

19 55-E115-455 274 3/25/2011 As a result, we determined the Insured has breached her Renters Policy Condition - Your Duties after<br />

Loss and a denial of her claim is warranted.<br />

SF_CL0004038<br />

20 55-E115-455 265 3/24/2011 Atty DW and myself contacted TM Petrarca. Atty OW recommended we deny claim due to breach of<br />

policy conditions - Your Duties After loss.<br />

SF_CL0004041<br />

1 21 55-E115-455 209 2/17/2011 * Tessie moved out any property that was in good condition to Christopher Garret's apt prior to the fire. SF_CL0004055<br />

22 55-E115-455 209 2/17/2011 * Tessie did move her stainless steel refrigerator to garage because it was still in good condition prior to<br />

the fire.<br />

SF_CL0004055<br />

10/15/2012 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

23 55-E115-455 82 12/22/2010 HOUSE CONDITION:<br />

Insd stated this home was destoryed. She had to make the repairs, replaced roof and AC unit In 04. She<br />

remodeled bathrooms and painted. On the west side of the house, surface water repeatedly damaged<br />

the home. There was mold found throughout the home. Mortgage company made the repairs and abated<br />

the mold but the water problem never stopped. She is unsure if there is still mold.<br />

24 05-M417-931 54 2/6/2008 -- Issued 'E" pmt for $859.68 to NorGal Const for O&P for flooring *log 53*<br />

-- Issued pmt for $65.00 to the insd for cleaning her comforter *Iog 53*<br />

-- Sent closing letter to insd w/suit condition<br />

-- Sent CSA instruction<br />

-- CR** Closed CP referral and returned to CR for closing.<br />

25 05-M417-931 53 2/5/2008 CP:Please forward pmt $859.68 to NorCal Const for O&P for flooring<br />

Please forward pmt $65.00 to the insd for clean comforter<br />

Send closing letter to insd w/suit condition - CR does not need to review<br />

1 26 05-M517-590 51 9/8/2011 follow-up on PPIF<br />

consider sending duties<br />

CR's to address quality use age and condition with PH -<br />

also address repairability<br />

27 05-M484-938 68 11/2/2010 -Reviewed file, no documentation of ages or condition for any wearable surfaces to calculate Cov A<br />

depreciation for Subro.<br />

28 05-M484-938 63 10/14/2010 Expert Report Conclusion and/or Analysis: Evidence sent to Donan Engineering for failure analysis<br />

testing. Donan concluded the following:<br />

*The stainless reinforced supply riser faited.<br />

* The leak occurred because the stainless steel braid failed and the internal tubing could not withstand<br />

the water pressure.<br />

*The stainless steel braid failed because of chloride stress corrsion.<br />

*Numerous similar failures of stainless supply riser have been received by the Donan laboratory in<br />

recent months.<br />

*Since these supply risers are intended for use in environments where chloride-containing cleaning<br />

products will probably be used, the supply risers should have been designed to accommodate these<br />

foreseeable conditions<br />

*We suggest that you pursue this failure as a manufacturer's design defect (p. 3 Donan report).<br />

1 29 75-M548-962 22 7/22/2009 - CR placed 40% depreciation on the Encyclopedia set as review of Insured's documentation showed<br />

this was the difference in cost between a new and a used set. This did not take into consideration that<br />

the edition was dated back to 1986 - 1989. 40% Is reasonable due to age and condition as it pertains to<br />

market value per insured's documentation.<br />

1 30 75-M446-682 68 11/27/2007 Rec'd call from Mr. Ph, he advised item #28 is incorrected, checked CI, updated age of Item and<br />

corrected depreciation. Ph also provided price for item #42, ph has not used the item and it is in<br />

excellent condition.<br />

*Issued draft $627.60. Reclose file.<br />

SF_CL0004095<br />

SF_CL0003358<br />

SF_CL0003359<br />

SF_CL0003301<br />

SF_CL0002992<br />

SF_CL0002994<br />

SF_CL0002965<br />

SF_CL0002906<br />

10/15/2012 4


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

31 75-M446-682 20 11/21/2005 INSPECTION RESULTS: Inspected loss w/Mr. PH. Water damage to basement caused by icemaker line<br />

in ceiling that burst. PH had a sattel valve connected to a 1/2" cold water pipe in basement ceiling that<br />

fed the ice maker in the refrig. directly above basement. Plastic line feeding icemaker burst and flooded<br />

basement. PH stated line was approx. 4 years old. However, due to the condition of the basement valve<br />

and line were extremely worn there is No possibility for sub due to the condition of the valve and line.<br />

Water damaged acoustical suspended ceiling and flooded entire basement. PH had several Personal<br />

Property items stored in basement. Service master thru PSP completed drydown. Water also damaged<br />

paint on foundation walls and floor.<br />

SF_CL0002914<br />

32 75-M446-682 19 11/21/2005 Received call from CR Weatherby, he picked up the part and it is rusted may be due to age or<br />

conditions of basement. He will dispose as there is no subrogation potential.<br />

SF_CL0002914<br />

1 33 75-M596-075 164 12/1/2010 TIC to Thomas Rug Cleaning Co & slw Harry. Reviewed the following with him:<br />

1. Invoice #130950 $1760.00 rug cleaning has not been paid.<br />

2. Only 1 rug was cleaned (5x9'8" Caucasian $220.00) & it did not come clean so he did not bother to<br />

clean the others as it was not cost effective considering the damage & the cleaning cost vs. the<br />

replacement cost.He's never rec'd any add'l direction from the insured.<br />

3. Questioned regarding his appraisal for replacement of rugs & the condition of each rug. If not<br />

cleaned how will does he know final outcome? Said he's basing it on results of first attempt. Agreed he<br />

would not attempt to clean the rugs that had obvious bum marks on them.<br />

4. Has had the rugs since August & PH was corning in often to inquire about his rugs but has not seen<br />

him in over a month once Harry started pushing for pymt of storage fees.<br />

5. Asked what condiditon the rugs were in when he rec'd them. Is all this damage from the fire, or could<br />

it be wear & tear? Harry states that the color fading could be from sun exposure (PH told him fire dept<br />

put rugs outside), the heat of the fire causes the dyes to "loosen" up so they fade & run, and wear & tear<br />

from use. All three factors probably contributed to condition of rugs.<br />

6. The rugs are still in his shop. He needs to start charging storage fees as they take up a bunch of<br />

space and it's been 5 months. Fees are $100/month.<br />

7. Reviewed salvage value, due to downturn in market there is not much demand for new rugs let alone<br />

damaged rugs. There is some value but the cost to sell would exceed their value. He last sold a "new"<br />

rug 3 months ago & is staying afloat with their cleaning & repair services.<br />

8. Asked if the condition of the rugs would continue to deteroriate after being rolled up for 5 months.<br />

Hany states no that the damage stays the same and they would not have cleaned up better then vs.<br />

SF_CL0002752<br />

34 75-M596-075 23 8/10/2010<br />

now<br />

* The House was in average/good condition and he agreed. PA Is going to work on the PPIF. SF_CL0002784<br />

1 35 75-M629-365 11 6/22/2011 .. Informed OCR has sent PPIFs to complete to document loss - need age, RC and condition. SF_CL0002728<br />

36 75-M586-307 189 9/29/2011 OAR, Continue to work with insured to resolve outstanding items; confrim your conversations with<br />

insured in writing and quote the appropriate Conditions language in letter.<br />

SF_CL0002638<br />

37 75-M586-307 154 11/29/2010 Action plan to address issues outstanding:<br />

1) Retain consulting GC to detach the center island and coordinate the detach and reset of the Wolf<br />

Range.<br />

2) Finmark to detach the newly laid flooring to exposed the subfloor<br />

3) Insured's GC, consulting GC, insured, and CR to meet and determine cause of the swelling to the<br />

flooring.<br />

4) If subfloor is cause of swelling, insured's GC to repair. If flooring, Finmark to address re-install. If preexisting<br />

conditions it will be the insured's responsibility. Items detached will be reset.<br />

5) Conclude handling accordingly<br />

SF_CL0002644<br />

10/15/2012 5


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

38 75-M586-307 64 6/7/2010 -Insured is stating they relied on SF as the previous CR did not offer and they had no knowledge on what<br />

to do next, the insured stated the previous CR had also stated to them if their EWS company billed too<br />

much or took too long SF would not pay them and they would be responsible for the billing. Insured<br />

stated she did not appreciate theway the claim was handled before and now with the condition of her<br />

home, no kitchen and with kids who have respiratory problems this is taking way too long.<br />

39 75-M586-307 32 5/18/2010 Note: ph has high end hospital grade air filters and UV lights for the HVAC due to ph children health<br />

conditions.<br />

40 75-M586-307 25 5/18/2010 CR received call from PH. PH concerned that we did not assign EWS the first time she called in. CR<br />

explained CR is not sure why EWS was not sent during QFC as it should have been done. CR explained<br />

the good thing is EWS is going out there now and there is coverage for ensuing damages. PH said she<br />

is concerned because there may be mold underneath the kitchen floor. She has 2 children with allergies<br />

and has been running the air conditioning. CR explained she should be ok right now as she is not<br />

actually sure there is mold and if there is the mold is under the floor and is not being blown around by<br />

blowers and has not been touched by anyone living in home. PH understood and asked how the claim<br />

process works from here. CR explained when SP comes out they will run a mold test, if there is mold<br />

they will abate the mold and depending on how much mold they find they will do a test to make sure it is<br />

gone. CR told PH she is able to go to a hotel during mold abatement if necessary. PH understood. PH<br />

then asked what she should do if she wants to use her own mold person after SP sends theirs. Should<br />

she call back in? CR said yes to call in and talk to us if she is not satisfied with SP's company. PH also<br />

asking if SP is going to take up her floors when they go out. CR explained SP will evaluate what they<br />

need to do when they get there. PH understood.<br />

41 55-E078-594 63 9/15/2009 Called Dan, 916 987-0400. He said HVAC cleaning company went out and discovered ductwork in such<br />

poor condition that cleaning would be pointless. Very light soot required cleaning, condition of ducts<br />

require replacement. Replacement estimate $1440. they will proceed with Ozone & balance of cleaning<br />

throughout.<br />

42 55-E078-594 58 9/14/2009 Called steve with ServPro, discuused status and issues with resident relative health concerns. He said<br />

with amount of direct fire damage to bedroom, it is reasonable to conclude that smoke traveled<br />

throughout the risk. With relative's heart condition it is likely that residual smoke odor would not be able<br />

to be extracted with cleaning. He would not want to assume liability for future health issues. Also<br />

discussed HVAC cleaning . He will get sub-bid as they do not have equipment for duct cleaning.<br />

43 55-E078-594 20 8/17/2009 COVERAGE C: I do not believe that Coverage C is needed in this case, the smoke smell is not bad to<br />

me and I could not smell it in the house except for the bedroom of origin. It is a possibility with the<br />

insured's mother living there and having a heart condition that there is a problem for her with her<br />

sensitivity, her doctor may need to decide that.<br />

44 55-F999-246 87 10/27/2008 C: Rec'd c/b from Atty Karen Rosensweig via 55-F998-372.<br />

Atty advised payments have been "frozen" b/c two claimants (one Karen thinks is SF/insd Shannon but<br />

doesn't have claim # and she's not handling, other is for $150K) are not signing release. We already<br />

signed release but it is conditioned upon all claimants completing. Set 3 month diary.<br />

T: flu with atty for status; is litigation commencing b/c of non-coop of two claimants?<br />

SF_CL0002660<br />

SF_CL0002667<br />

SF_CL0002669<br />

SF_CL0002616<br />

SF_CL0002617<br />

SF_CL0002624<br />

SF_CL0002578<br />

10/15/2012 6


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

45 05-M447-752 100 5/1/2009 Ms. Cunningham had authorized her contractor to begin repairs in early February. The structural work is<br />

reportedly nearly complete and the home may be habitable within the next few weeks. Therefore, it is<br />

recommended that ALE reimbursements be paid based on the actual condition and habitability of the<br />

home as monitored through reinspection. However, file authority is being included for the three-month<br />

period in case there are extenuating<br />

circumstances that would prolong the completion of repairs.<br />

46 05-M447-752 87 4/22/2009 Reviewed estimate revision from New Life. They applied the adjustments noted in log 84. The estimate<br />

is now complete and comprehensive. Per Norm of New Life, based on the submitted bid, they would be<br />

willing and able to restore the home to a pre-loss condition according to the covered scope of loss and<br />

applicable matchinglRUA standards. The repair estimate total is $106,638.04.<br />

47 05-M447-752 85 4/21/2009 New Life has repeatedly contacted insured and requested permission to complete the cleaning process.<br />

PH continues to refuse to authorize the work and repeatedly states that she didn't want the items back<br />

regardless of their condition.<br />

48 05-M447-752 81 4/20/2009 3) Driveway - Norm bid to replace entire driveway apron. However, due to poor condition of driveway,<br />

replacement is not warranted for RUA reasons.<br />

49 05-M447-752 61 4/2/2009 Met with Norm of New Life Service. He oversaw the initial emergency response and demo and was<br />

familiar with the fire damage. I provided him with a scopeonly print of my estimate for reference only. We<br />

discussed his role and he will prepare a complete estimate for fire damage restoration based on his<br />

experience and knowledge of the damage. He agreed that the estimate he provided would restore the<br />

home to a pre-loss condition and be would be for an amount he would be willing to accept/contract for.<br />

He anticipates completing the estimate within two weeks.<br />

50 05-M447-752 52 3/26/2009 Driveway - the concrete driveway was in very poor condition prior to the loss. There was heavy, preexisting<br />

cracking, displacement and deterioration. There was a minor area of spalling close to the garage<br />

door opening that would need to be addressed. However, due to the pre-existing condition of the slab, a<br />

site repair should address the damage. Beaton called to completely remove the drivway apron and<br />

replace (including R/R of fence line that borders the driveway edge).<br />

1 51 55-E010-714 39 2/6/2007 Sent CSA instructions to send letter re: PP damage. Insured discarded all contents prior to our<br />

inspection. We have not been able to inspect the contents to verify what was damaged, it's condition,<br />

and any possible repairability.<br />

1 52 75-M624-390 n/a 7/5/2012 CP Pending -advise ph that item #5 no RCBs due as ph replaced item within orginal ACV settlement<br />

amount-obtain either use & condition from ph for supplemental PPIFs or obtain copies of the<br />

replacement reciepts for these additional items-auth already granted by CO issue draft-close referral<br />

53 75-M624-390 n/a 7/5/2012 CP entered ph's RCB for chairs into CI. Ph replaced the chairs within the orginal ACV payment. Marked<br />

item "insured replaced" and updated replacement cost to ACV settlement amount. Ph's supplemental list<br />

of PPIFs show all items as replaced but RCB receipts were not included. Called ph, Imovm requesting<br />

return call to obtain either use & condition or obtain the replacement receipts for these items. Sent CSA<br />

activity request to enter supplemental PPIFs into CI. Set cal date for flu.<br />

SF_CL0002469<br />

SF_CL0002472<br />

SF_CL0002473<br />

SF_CL0002474<br />

SF_CL0002479<br />

SF_CL0002483<br />

SF_CL0002042<br />

SF_CL0001955<br />

SF_CL0001955-56<br />

10/15/2012 7


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

54 75-M624-390 n/a 5/21/2012 CO returned call to PH. She received our closing letter, wanted to be sure of time frame for submiting<br />

docs as she stated is going to take time as she is very busy. CO advised her of 2yrs from dol to obtain<br />

rcbs. Re large area rug, ph stated unable to obtain copy of receipt because rug was old,aprox 10-12<br />

years and she no longer has copy. Was expensive, Ethan Alan large area rug in family room. CO will<br />

apply depreciation based on age/use/condition/quality of rug. Was in family room that was traffic area,<br />

has children.<br />

55 75-M624-390 193 4/6/2012 Stephanie - please make attempts to follow up with insured by phone as well. If documentation not<br />

received by next status due, send closing letter and advise insured we will consider, subject to policy<br />

terms and conditions, once documentation received.<br />

56 75-M624-390 113 6/22/2011 CR entered CI, applied depreciation based on age, use, condition and quality as determined by<br />

conversation with PH and physical inspection of prroperty. PH has high-end Ethan Allen and Macy's<br />

furnishings. Dining and living room furniture is in like-new condition. Family room leather furniture is<br />

used more than living room but sofa is in excellent condition and end /coffee tables are high quality<br />

marble top like-new. Only item showing much wear are older dining room table & chaise lounge. CR<br />

applied depreciation accordingly. PH did not have receipt for TV stand purchased at Costco 1 yr ago. CR<br />

found TV stand of similar construction & design on Costco website $249.99, updated CI with that price.<br />

57 75-M624-390 94 6/6/2011 OAR with Stephanie. Water loss with no subrogation potential, as soft clog. PIP investigated and<br />

returned as no sub. Coverage A EWS completed in PSP. ATR and ATP received. Pending revised<br />

mitigation summary. Estimate reconciled. GC repairs completed by ES vendor, outside of PSP. Pending<br />

final revised estimate. Insured indicated she would now like to cash out on flooring, which is only<br />

pending item for completion of repairs. Coverge B pending inventory from insured and documentation<br />

from contents vendor. Quality, age, use and condition has been discussed with insured. Will agree<br />

upon depreciation once total loss inventory received. coverage C pending documentation from insured -<br />

abatement confirmed. COL, comment code and reserves adequate at this time. Payment made to date<br />

are within CR authority. Status letter current. Stephanie - contents vendor was hired by you as an expert<br />

to assist with evaluating damages to furniture items. As we discussed, this would make him an expert on<br />

our behalf. Use of all experts must be approved by me prior to hiring on all future losses. Agree with<br />

need for expert. Please have vendor send billing for his time and send appropriate referral letter.<br />

Regarding salvage, we cannot have vendor sell total loss items on our behalf. Contact insured and see if<br />

they want salvage back. If not, okay to authorize SP to discard. Complete PCOL template and update<br />

log with current action plan and pending items by coverage. Include correct reason code on EWS<br />

payment. Follow up with contractor for final estimate and resolve as appropriate. Follow up with insured<br />

for status of inventory and documentation for ALE as well.<br />

SF_CL0001957<br />

SF_CL0001957<br />

SF_CL0001979<br />

SF_CL0001984-85<br />

10/15/2012 8


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

58 75-M624-390 22 5/6/2011 PH has very expensive Ethan Allen furniture. PH presented pH with copies of receipts for most items,<br />

well over $20,000 worth of just furnishing. Damage to bedframe in bedroom, informal table & chairs,<br />

brown leather couch & sofa, end tables, china hutch, formal dining chairs, formal dining table has metal<br />

feet, may be saved. Buffet damaged, white leather sofa has removable wood feet and may be saved. PH<br />

has antique red velvet love seat she brought from India. PH unsure of value - is very high quality and in<br />

excellent condition. CR will see if wood feet can be restored. CR viewed her furniture items at off site<br />

storage as well as several items in her garage. PH also has several pairs of shoes and inexpensive<br />

throw rugs affected. PH also had a larger arear rug aprox $700 value soaked and thrown out. CR provide<br />

PH with $10,000 advance for Cov B so PH can start to order replacement furniture items. PHs funiture<br />

was all in excellent and nearly new condition so depreciation will be minimal. PH has some clothing<br />

items that SP picked up, may be laundered and sanitized but may also be total loss. SP to itemize. SP to<br />

clean and sanitize furniture that can be cleaned, they will check into replacing feet on dining table &<br />

white leather sofas & matching chairs.<br />

59 75-M456-650 12 7/31/2007 * Advised that many of the items on the list are lumped together and we would need these items broken<br />

out and priced individually. Again pointed to the recovery of RC benefits as the basis for the request, as<br />

well as the policy conditions. She understood.<br />

60 55-E116-561 45 4/15/2011 Please contact the PH.<br />

Arrange a re-inspection of the carpet. PH claims they attempted to professionally clean the carpet but did<br />

not come clean.<br />

Please verify the condition of the carpet.<br />

If uncleanable obtain ITEL sample and then complete replacement estimate.<br />

61 75-M613-624 287 4/26/2012 It is my concluding opinion that the water line was improperly installed causing excessive stress to the<br />

water line, a condition which led to the incident water damage. Had the line been installed without<br />

excessive induced stress in the line, the water damage incident would have been avoided.<br />

62 75-M613-624 175 5/23/2011 Salvage: Pends evaluation of TO<strong>SC</strong>O evaluation (log 79). The items that were marked salvagable were<br />

not repairable as they cannot be put back/repaired to their pre-loss condition. Salvage takes into<br />

consideration that some parts may have parts value only. Kari advised she intends on bringing buyer to<br />

PH's business location for salvage purposes/purchases.<br />

63 75-M613-624 172 5/23/2011 - SALVAGE ACTION PLAN:<br />

Salvage pends evaluation of TO<strong>SC</strong>O evaluation (log 79). The items that were marked salvagable were<br />

not repairable as they cannot be put back/repaired to their pre-loss condition. Salvage takes into<br />

consideration that some parts may have parts value only. Kari advised she intends on bringing buyer to<br />

PH's business location for salvage purposes/purchases.<br />

64 75-M613-624 118 4/5/2011 SUBRO/SALVAGE COMMENTS:<br />

Salvage: Pends evaluation of TO<strong>SC</strong>O evaluation (log 79). The items that were marked salvagable were<br />

not repairable as they cannot be put back/repaired to their pre-loss condition. Salvage takes into<br />

consideration that some parts may have parts value only. Kari advised she intends on bringing buyer to<br />

PH's business location for salvage purposes/purchases.<br />

65 75-M613-624 89 3/15/2011 SUBRO/SALVAGE COMMENTS:<br />

Salvage: Pends evaluation of TO<strong>SC</strong>O evaluation (log 79). The items that were marked salvagable were<br />

not repairable as they cannot be put back/repaired to their pre-loss condition. Salvage takes into<br />

consideration that some parts may have parts value only. Kari advised she intends on bringing buyer to<br />

PH's business location for salvage purposes/purchases.<br />

SF_CL0001999<br />

SF_CL0001930<br />

SF_CL0001890<br />

SF_CL0001740<br />

SF_CL0001765<br />

SF_CL0001767<br />

SF_CL0001778<br />

SF_CL0001785<br />

10/15/2012 9


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

66 75-M613-624 79 3/10/2011 Called and spoke with Kari C#. The items that were marked salvagable were not repairable as they<br />

cannot be put back/repaired to their pre-loss condition. Salvage takes into consideration that some<br />

parts may have parts value only. Kari advised she intends on bringing buyer to PH's business location<br />

for salvage. We discussed the 3 dental chairs and the letter submitted by Patterson. Kari said the letter is<br />

incorrect. Kari said her inspection of the chairs revealed all 3 were damaged and described damage as<br />

Dr Goto did (see log 78). I advised I have called Patterson Dental requesting clarification.<br />

1 67 75-M613-624 70 3/1/2011 - PH has reviewed the depreciation (actual cash value) for the BPP. PH agrees that the applied<br />

depreciation is appropriate based on age, condition, and use of the item.<br />

68 75-M613-624 69 2/28/2011 Spoke with Dr Goto and discussed depreciation for BPP. Dr Goto will be replacing most items, he has in<br />

fact began replacing items and will continue to do so. I advised our initial payment is based on ACV for<br />

the items explaining ACV based on age and condition of item. I advised TO<strong>SC</strong>O has confirmed ages<br />

and condition of items based on their inspection and expertise in PH's type of BPP/equipment. I advised<br />

I wanted to make sure the depreciation was accurately/appropriately applied. PH understood. PH said he<br />

will review the TO<strong>SC</strong>O inventory for depreciation and advise if applied appropriately and/or if<br />

adjustments should be made as condition may may be different than applied.<br />

69 75-M613-624 66 2/21/2011 OAR. Rev'd file & RFA. Pls clarify when and with whom we reached agreement "regarding age, use and<br />

condition" referenced in log 62. Pls clarify why ACV in log 64 is not consistent with ACV in TO<strong>SC</strong>O rpt.<br />

Lastly, pls comment on why salvageable items in the TO<strong>SC</strong>O rpt are not being considered for repair vs.<br />

replacement. Pls resubmit RFA w/in 10 days and close COL 67 if we do not anticipate any LOI pmts.<br />

70 75-M613-624 62 2/18/2011 Contents Inventory review:<br />

CP inadvertently input $92,500 for each of the 3 dental chairs rather than $92,520.16 total (see items<br />

64,65,66). Contents Inventory for all other items accurately reflects the RCs provided by PH and applies<br />

depreciation based on agreement with PH regarding age, use and condition.<br />

71 75-R295-811 20 3/12/2009 Met with Raymond Pena the insured son on 03/11/09 and inspected the property. The son and his family<br />

live at the home, at the time of inspection there were three adults and one child. The insured Mr. Bertram<br />

Pena lives there and in New Mexico. He comes to this location approximately every 6 weeks per his son<br />

Raymond. The home is in poor condition. There is a water stain in the living room from the roof leaking.<br />

The insured states the roof has been repair but at the time of inspection there were still missing shingles<br />

off the front of the home. The family room's floor has been partially removed and the insured stated they<br />

are trying to determine what kind of floor they would like to put down. The attic had evidence of rats in<br />

the attic with rat droppings.<br />

72 75-M477-648 50 4/12/2007 At this time, we do not have sufficient information to Substantiate insured's proof of loss. In my<br />

inspection of January 15, 2007, other than your concern for the condition of a home computer, insrued<br />

indicated to me that heu did not believe there were any damages to your personal contents. Since he ise<br />

now making claim for additional damages, we will need to schedule an inspection to continue our<br />

investigation of your claim. We are awaiting insured's return call for re-ispection. Regarding estimate of<br />

$750 to repair your stucco/plaster, our record indicates we have already paid $416.16 ($346.80 + 20%<br />

for OH&P) based on Disaster Kleen up's estimate. Dictate a status letter with duties. Extended duties to<br />

June 12, 2007.<br />

SF_CL0001787-88<br />

SF_CL0001790<br />

SF_CL0001790<br />

SF_CL0001791<br />

SF_CL0001793<br />

SF_CL0001723<br />

SF_CL0001708-09<br />

10/15/2012 10


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

1 73 05-M488-313 63 1/27/2011 All my items arrived it good condition, except one. I don't know if this item can be covered, however, I<br />

thought it doesn't hurt to ask. One of the ports on my video card is not working. It worked fine when I<br />

loaded the computer into the container. I have no way of knowing how it got damaged. All I can say is it<br />

worked fine the day I loaded it into the container, and last night when I set my computer up, one of the<br />

ports is not working. The original cost of the video card was $135.<br />

74 05-M488-313 38 11/22/2010 Mr. PH came in office - brought additional hotel receipts, meals, PP info. provided pmt for hotel. Adv will<br />

rev the meals and PP info. Adv of need for PP documentation, photos of dmg items, receipts, credit card<br />

statements. PH provided info on pack out and storage. Adv need storage bill. Info on laundry and<br />

dryclean clothes provided. Adv will complete CI. Adv of ACV and RCB. Adv based on age, use, wear,<br />

condition, LE. He confirmed all items in good condition and usable prior to loss. Adv his contr said<br />

property habitable as of today. He said the landlady Rosita said another 2 weeks, as need building<br />

inspection and clean up. Adv will flu with Rosita as contr said ready today. Rosita - 510-657-3333.<br />

1 75 75-M564-724 77 11/3/2009 CR reviewed contents inventory, discussed depreciation for furniture. PH will review w/ husband whether<br />

30 % depreciation is reasonable. CR explained RC benefits. Understood. Based on conversation wI PH<br />

room furniture is about eight years old, she states it is in good condition.<br />

76 75-M566-207 12 10/20/2009 Cr inspected the loss yesterday with Mr. Insured. Home is in very nice condition. Stucco exterior with<br />

drywall interior. Home was built in 1945. The insureds have a daughter that is living in the rear guest<br />

house which is attached to the garage by a patio cover. The guest house sustained severe fire, smoke<br />

and water damage to the interior and its contents. The insured needed assitance with the contents. The<br />

daughter is an artist and she is going to school. All of her things were inside the home. Cr called<br />

ConstructMasters to assist with the contents. Cr scoped and measured the loss. The contents company<br />

arrived 20 minutes later and we discussed the contents. They would be able to save some of the<br />

property. They would be able to begin 10/20109. Cr went over coverages with the insured again. Due to<br />

the age of the home there will be code issues which include windows, insulation, electricle and plumbing.<br />

Code upgrade coverage might not be enough. Not a good fit at this time for psp due to coverage limits<br />

issues. Photos in the file. Diagram and scope notes sent to cios.<br />

77 75-M596-783 12 8/20/2010 Rec'd call from Mr.PH. Wanted to know status claim. CR advised from inspection photos and TCR report<br />

it appears his loss is not covered. Discussed exclusion for rot and mold and r/l/s. He stated he thinks the<br />

leak was coming from the air conditioning line on the roof and not the sprinklers. CR advised there still<br />

appears to be a rIlls issue which resulted in mold and deterioration. PH understood.<br />

78 75-M464-202 9 6/16/2006 Spk with Jean and she said that the water burned out the motors in her air conditioning unit and hvac<br />

system. She also lost an amplifier. I expl Cov Band ACV vs RCV. I expl Cov A and to send me the repair<br />

receipts for theHvac system so I can look them over and pay as appropriate. I expl DED of 2k she<br />

understnds.<br />

79 75-M501-779 27 11/2/2007 Recv'd call from ins'd. Ret'd call and let ins'd know that I called on Wednesday and left a message with<br />

the receptionist. Asked ins'd who completed her mold abatement and she indicated 911 Restoration. Let<br />

ins'd know that I will contact them to verify the questions I have on the condition of the studs,<br />

underlayment, electrical wiring and outlet box.<br />

SF_CL0001583<br />

SF_CL0001590<br />

SF_CL0001424<br />

SF_CL0001265<br />

SF_CL0001249<br />

SF_CL0001233<br />

SF_CL0001220<br />

10/15/2012 11


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

80 75-M501-779 6 9/18/2007 FACTS: Pipe is arranged and drains inside the wall. Ins'd indicated they painted the walls 5 years ago<br />

and the carpet was replaced. Enough water has come down to damage the carpet and Hold the water.<br />

Ins'd indicated that a black pipe that goes away from the air conditioner drains down into the wall. Let<br />

ins'd know that I need her plumbers invoice or to speak with her plumber for additional information.<br />

1 81 05-M498-662 13 4/6/2011 Call from the Mr. Michael Hom. I explained the issue regarding the poor condition of the ring. I<br />

explained coverage for ADPL subject to the LNI. I explained the policy only covers the cost to replace<br />

the missing diamonds. I explained the ded of $250 would apply to the loss. I explained cost to remake<br />

the ring is not covered. He said he is not happy theway the policy was sold to him and is thinking about<br />

transfering all his polices elsewhere. He asked the claim be placed on hold pending him thinking it over.<br />

82 05-M498-662 12 4/6/2011 Jeweler has advised that item 1 diamond ring is in very poor condition and we can expect additional<br />

diamonds to fall out. He said it suffers· from poor craftsmanship.<br />

83 05-M498-662 11 4/6/2011 Chris Williams from David Clay Jewelers called. This claim is for item 0001 on PAP. One diamond fell<br />

out of setting and another one fell out and the insured has it. The estimate for $300 is to replace 1<br />

diamond and to reset both diamonds. We talked about the ring. He stated he would not guarantee the<br />

repair because the ring is in very poor condition. He said it suffers from poor craftsmanship and he said<br />

we can expect the diamonds to fall out continually. He recommended to our policyholder that they have<br />

ring re-made. They have gone to the original jeweler and they have refused to stand behind their<br />

product.<br />

84 05-M498-662 10 4/6/2011 Underwriting Review sent by GEU8<br />

Item 0001 on PAP. A diamond fell out and David Clay Jewelers (a State Farm SFRS jeweler) has stated<br />

the ring is in poor condition due to poor craftsmanship and the diamonds will continually fall out.<br />

1 85 05-M442-712 17 11/20/2008 Agreed on the following action plan:<br />

1) contact mrs insd & verify if insd has a local/personal jeweler that can evaluate condition of diamond.<br />

Check SFRS listing & see if insd jeweler listed<br />

86 05-M442-712 17 11/20/2008 Pending: cb from insd w/choice of jeweler<br />

if no choice then give insd several names of SFRS jewelers<br />

obtain evaluation on condition of diamond<br />

87 05-M378-489 152 9/6/2006 DUTIES OWED: Before giving possession of leased property to an tenant, a landlord must conduct a<br />

reasonable inspection and correct any unsafe conditions ...<br />

DUTIES BREACHED: There is evidence that a roll of carpet was stored in the water heater closet and<br />

was apparently in there during the prior tenancy. The closet was not insepcted at the insepction with<br />

tenant and there were no smoke alarms in the unit. Insured is potentially liable for failure to remove<br />

combustible material ie carpet from the water heater closet.<br />

LEGAL CAUSE: Failure to correct unsafe condition of water heater closet is the substantial factor<br />

causing loss.<br />

POTENTIAL DEFENSES: Undetermined<br />

1 88 55-E089-936 2 1/10/2010 I asked Mr. PH if this is the same bike in 2006 and Mr. PH said yes. Mr PH rides his bike about 125 - 150<br />

miles a week. However, Mr. PH has his bike serviced regularly and the bike was in great condition. The<br />

replacement of the bike it Trek Madone 5.2. On went online and the price is $3879.99. I asked about any<br />

updgrades and the only upgrade was the seat $50.<br />

89 55-E024-604 194 1/24/2011 C: Recv'd e-mail from agent advising he has obtained the CC&Rs (drop filed). Need to flu with zone to<br />

have rep go to agents office get a copy and have returned to NI in the same condition. Sent urgent<br />

SPOC message<br />

SF_CL0001224<br />

SF_CL0001182<br />

SF_CL0001182<br />

SF_CL0001183<br />

SF_CL0001183<br />

SF_CL0001165<br />

SF_CL0001166<br />

SF_CL0000544<br />

SF_CL0000375<br />

SF_CL0000302<br />

10/15/2012 12


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

90 75-03G8-444 n/a 6/24/2012 Sent e-mail to Bruce Agle at 4X to answer the questions posed in the file. The content of the email is<br />

detailed below:" Hello Bruce,We had a few questions regarding the results of the evidence testing for<br />

claim # 75-03G8-444. If you would please answer the following questions we would appreciate it. 1) If<br />

the flapper is not sealing the tank completely this will cause water leakage into the bowl, which will cause<br />

the fill valve to stay activated.a. It is possible that the cause of the any possible fill valve activation is the<br />

flapper and not debris. b. If water is leaking into the bowl how was there so much water that it<br />

overwhelmed the overflow tube?2) Since this fill valve is not original to the toilet:a. It is possible that the<br />

overflow tube was manuf to be adequate for the previous fill valve. It is not known if the previous fill valve<br />

came installed in the toilet from Kohler. b. It is possible that the replacement fill valve was not installed<br />

correctly (height correct, etc.) and therefore was not functioning correctly in PHs toilet so that if<br />

something caused it to stay activated it allowed too much water into the tank.3) Is the overflow tube<br />

original to the toilet (i.e. from the manuf) or has it been replaced in the 10 yrs PH has had toilet?4)<br />

Should there be an on-site inspection of toilet to review the size and condition of the overflow tube?<br />

Thanks,Jacob"<br />

91 75-03G8-444 n/a 6/1/2012 Questions/lssues with COL:<br />

1) If the flapper is not sealing the tank completely this will cause water leakage into the bowl, which will<br />

cause the fill valve to stay activated.<br />

a. It is possible that the cause of the any possible fill valve activation is the flapper and not debris.<br />

b. If water is leaking into the bowl how was there so much water that it overwhelmed the overflow tube?<br />

2) Since this fill valve is not original to the toilet:<br />

a. It is possible that the overflow tube was manuf to be adequate for the previous fill valve. It is not<br />

known if the previous fill valve came installed in the toilet from Kohler.<br />

b. It is possible that the replacement fill valve was not installed correctly (height correct, etc.) and<br />

therefore was not functioning correctly in PHs toilet so that if something caused it to stay activated it<br />

allowed too much water into the tank.<br />

3) Is the overflow tube original to the toilet (i.e. from the manuf) or has it been replaced in the 10 yrs PH<br />

has had toilet?<br />

4) Should there be an on-site inspection of toilet to review the size and condition of the overflow tube?<br />

1 92 75-03G8-444 n/a 1/26/2012 CP, please take $1000 advance from final ACV payment as well as $500 salvage on the entire total loss.<br />

You may record it as $100 on roll top desk and $100 on 2 shelf units, $250 on hutch, dR set and $50 for<br />

misc. items. Pls also depreciate furniture at only 25% as high quality and condition was very good.<br />

Thank you!<br />

93 75-03G8-444 n/a 1/23/2012 Rec'd TL list and docs in a separate image from insured. CP, please view and process accordingly.<br />

Please utilize SFRS for all applicable items. Age, value, condition and use were discussed with the<br />

insured. There were no remarkable items, however, insured's were advised to find replacement values of<br />

like, kind and qualtly. Pls. view docs accordingly. May need to view high end items to confirm pricing.<br />

SF_CL0000166<br />

SF_CL0000167<br />

SF_CL0000172<br />

SF_CL0000174<br />

10/15/2012 13


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

94 75-03G8-444 n/a 12/18/2011 OAR. Water loss with unknown subrogation potential. Failed toilet part was picked up as evidence.<br />

Unclear if PIP referral has been made. Coverage A undisputed amounts have been paid for repairs to<br />

structure, based on Mikala's estimate. Asbestos abatement has been resolved. No mold abatement<br />

necessary. EWS completed in PSP. ATR and ATP have been received. Pending review and<br />

reconciliation of estimate and reports, and mitigation summary from vendor. Also pending documentation<br />

from insured for increase in utilities, if incurred. Coverage B pending cleaning/restoration estimate from<br />

vendor. Soft goods cleaning invoice received from vendor - pending review and resolution. Also pending<br />

total loss inventory from insured. Discussion with insured as to quality/age/use/condition has been<br />

completed and depreciation agreed upon. $1,000 advance outstanding. Coverage C hotel invoices<br />

incurred to date have been paid. Pending additional invoices. ECD is not clear. Also pending pack out,<br />

storage and pack back estimates from vendor, and dog boarding invoices from insured. Status letter is<br />

current. COL and comment code are accurate. Payments to date are within CR authority. Mikala - please<br />

review and adjust reserves as appropriate, based on payments made to date. Follow up with EWS<br />

vendor for status of mitigation summary. Reconcile estimate, review reports and resolve as appropriate.<br />

Include appropriate reason code on payment. Has PIP referral been sent? Update log with PCOL What<br />

is status of repairs and ECD? PSP acceptance letter was not sent. Please send to insured once PSP<br />

payment is issued. Continue to work with insured and vendors to resolve all as outlined.<br />

95 75-03G8-444 n/a 11/21/2011 Met with the insureds at property this morning. Reviewed all coverages with them and explained policy,<br />

benefits and the entire process.<br />

...<br />

Explained to them age/life will be charged for depreciation. Explained about one year to make claim and<br />

2 yrs to obtain RCBs. Discussed age, value, condition and use. Insureds are retired teachers and live<br />

by themselves. Their items are of average quality and what they thought was real wood appeared to be<br />

laminate per way the water affected them. Explained that once we received list, we will review re:<br />

salvage. Advised that they have the first right to salvage buy back if interested. okay. There were no<br />

items that were remarkable except for a small 2 x 4 Turkish rug that they will have drycleaned. Coverage<br />

C - They have been paying ALE to date themselves at the Extended Stay in Ontario. They have kept this<br />

location until next Tuesday as they will be leaving town and not returning until Dec. 9. At that point, they<br />

will move into the Residence Inn and I advised I would have Klein & Co. set them up for that. Okay.<br />

Gave them $799.96 for hotel lodging to date. Their dog is a Weimaraner and will be staying at a kennel<br />

at $9 day during this time as he is large and they prefer this. Also gave the insured's $1000 as an<br />

advance to contents for any items they will need at this point. Okay. They will await our estimate. I<br />

advised them that Steve Purro needs to make a few changes based on my review of his estimate and<br />

once received and reviewed, I will call them to settle. Advised of mortgagee to be included. okay.<br />

Advised of $1000 deductible. They understand that the part that failed is not covered and they gave me<br />

this part to forward to PIP.<br />

1 96 75-052K-095 n/a 2/1/2012 Phoned Mrs. insured to return message left 9093381675. Discussed depreciation re: age, value, use and<br />

condition. The condition she stated was GOOD. She did not buy anything that was not in good<br />

condition. Her home is full of antiques etc. These items were in pristine condition. We agreed that all<br />

wood items, furniture/frames will have 10% depreciation and all other items between 20-25%. She<br />

agreed that this was fair and reasonable based on AQUC. CP, please go ahead and settle based on<br />

above. Pls. use discretion on "other" contents items. Chandelier = 20% and all brick/brac and other items<br />

20-25% as agreed with insured.<br />

SF_CL0000176<br />

SF_CL0000177-78<br />

SF_CL0000145<br />

10/15/2012 14


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

97 75-052K-095 n/a 1/31/2012 Rec'd PPIFs with ages and values, documents from internet to substantiate values and PH note. Will<br />

contact insured tomorrow to discuss condition as ages provided, values provided and use would be<br />

storing in the loft. Once info received, will forward to CP for handling.<br />

98 75-052K-095 n/a 12/26/2011 Rec'd PPIFs from both the insureds and a list from Service Master. Also received internet images<br />

documenting claim and replacement values. Unable to process at this time as not all info has been<br />

provided, more particularly the ages. Some ages are listed and most are not. Will forward to CP to see<br />

what items can be settled based on information. Had conversation with the Insured during inspection re:<br />

age, condition, use and value. Most of the items that she had were antiques and she had been<br />

collecting for sometime. Advised that we may be settling fair market value on antiques with<br />

substantiating docs. She understood. They were not in pristine condition and she had them stored in<br />

loft of detached garage.<br />

99 75-052K-095 n/a 11/23/2011 OAR with Mikala. Fire loss to detached garage (dwelling extension) with no subrogation potential. O&C<br />

expert determined cause to be unspecified electrical failure of wiring. Coverage A repairs resolved within<br />

policy limits. DE limit is $23,441.00 plus debris removal (5%) of $1,172.05 brings the total limit available<br />

to $24,613.05. GC estimate was prepare and reviewed by Mikala. Mikala wrote comparative estimate<br />

which was higher than GC. As such, she accepted GC estimate for repairs. Some code requirements are<br />

necessary, however, no additional costs will be incurred above the necessary repair costs. DE does not<br />

have code upgrade coverage. Review of amounts paid indicate an overpayment in the amount of $28.31<br />

under coverage A (GC estimate $ 22,893.63 plus board up of $847.98 equals $23,741.61 - Mikala<br />

estimated $23,769.92 before deductible). Mikala will review and confirm - overpayment will be accounted<br />

for in contents settlement, if necessary. Coverage B has been resolved for cleaning and cost to inventory<br />

from vendor. Pending complete inventory from insured. Discussion with insured as to<br />

quality/age/use/condition to agree on depreciation is pending receipt of inventory. Coverage C paid for<br />

pack out, storage and pack back of contents items. No other pending ALE items. I updated comment<br />

code to FW, as more appropriate, based on Oa.C findings. Mikala will update reserves as appropriate. I<br />

am not able to find any letters to insured in file, including settlement letter recently sent. Unclear if 790.03<br />

was sent. Mikala will review and make sure letters get into file. Mikala will also update file info screen<br />

with contact and inspection dates.<br />

100 55-Y233-652 49 5/5/2008 FACTS: Working messages. Called insured 760.533.6221 left message,<br />

760.529.9119 left message. Called agents office, spoke with Pat, she stated she would order the policy<br />

from the regional office and send to insured. Pat stated the address on file she had is 3544 Campus Dr,<br />

Oceanside CA, 92056. Created dictation letter to include Coverage C- Loss of Use and Sec 1<br />

Conditions Duties after Loss.(#213439)<br />

SF_CL0000145<br />

SF_CL0000147<br />

SF_CL0000148<br />

SF_CL0000096<br />

10/15/2012 15


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

101 55-E117-428 19 12/29/2010 INSPECTION RESULTS: Met with insured and Tripp of Puroclean at 1 p.m. on 12/27/10. Puroclean is<br />

doing the dry out and they have also tarped the roof over the sunroom area that is leaking. The only<br />

leaks on the house are over the sunroom area which is roofed with 40-year comp roofing, approximately<br />

8 years old and in good condition but the sunroom is approximately 1/12 pitch and is leaking due to<br />

wind driven rain blowing up underneath it. The insured told me that ants had started up going up<br />

underneath the roof and were building nests and he believes that that opened the roof up and made it<br />

easier for the storm water to get in. Could not photo shingles, roof tarp is down and is working, the<br />

interior has stayed dry since the tarp has been put on. Puroclean is still drying out the inside, there are<br />

banks of 5 foot by 5 foot windows all across the back and sides, there are 3 to 4 windows that have<br />

damaged painted MDF window sills, there is also drywall damage to the ceiling and back exterior wall.<br />

The ceiling and walls are completely finished and there is glue down carpet on the slab floor, it is stained<br />

and was wet in an area approximately 15 to 20 feet by 10 feet. Took sample of carpet, it will need to be<br />

replaced. Explained to the insured that he has no coverage for mold or personal property damage, he<br />

understood. To get the room dried out and remove the carpeted area that is damaged as well as the rest<br />

of the area Puroclean is going to move the insured's personal property out into a container before doing<br />

the demo, the insured has a barn and a garage but they are completely full with personal property, I<br />

okayed the contents to be stored while the restoration is being done and the carpet and drywall are being<br />

repaired and put back down.<br />

1 102 55-E089-494 35 2/15/2010 I spoke to insured just before leaving office on Friday, 2/12/10. Advised her of the revised settlement<br />

amount = $750.11. Explained we use a depreciation guide that gives general life expectancy on most<br />

items and is used as a guide to determine the amount of depreciation to deduct for actual cash value<br />

payment. But, that is only a guide and we also take into account the use of the item, wearability,<br />

condition of the item prior to the loss to make a fair depreciation assessment. She agreed.<br />

103 55-E089-494 28 2/5/2010 Called insured. Explained ACV and deprec for personal property items. Advised we use a depreciation<br />

guide that gives general life expectancy on most items and is used as a guide to determine the amount<br />

of depreciation to deduct for actual cash value payment. But, that is only a guide and we also take into<br />

account the use of the item, wearability, condition.<br />

104 55-E089-494 24 1/20/2010 OAR(initial): HO policy; 37 WH - paid; 38 open-reserve adequate. Reviewed QIC log 10. claim decision<br />

confirmed. Facts and scope of damages properly discussed with PH. Coverage and claim process<br />

explained addressed in log 5 and appears proper explaination. PSP offer declined. Reviewed PCOL log<br />

17 by task CR. No sub (w,t,d). Mold coverage explained. ITEL sample taken. Coverage A portion settled<br />

on task CR estimate. Continue follow-up efforts to get PPIF's from PH to conclude. Document use and<br />

condition discussion with PH.<br />

105 05-M496-133 n/a 8/2/2012 Calendar Review:***Reviewed claim-sent a SIR #2 for information from insured -photos of the items that<br />

she unpacked from the restoration company showing the condition they were in.***We recently sent<br />

OIC additional docs. I will follow-up with them after we get the information from the insured.***Set a new<br />

calendar for SIR. .. Pending: Follow-up with zone for the photos-follow-up with OIC about these items<br />

after we review the photos.***Subrogation amount-$41 ,631.48 ($500-deductible)<br />

106 05-M496-133 n/a 8/2/2012 Sub Investigative Request #2lnformation requested: Pls contact NI & obtain photos of the items that she<br />

unpacked from the Restoration company showing the condition they were in.Reason for request: OIC<br />

states they contacted Restoration company & a lot of the items we paid to replace were restored but NI<br />

failed to pick them up, they are obtaining a list from them.<br />

SF_CL0007334-35<br />

SF_CL0007306<br />

SF_CL0007307<br />

SF_CL0007307-08<br />

SF_CL0004709<br />

SF_CL0004710<br />

10/15/2012 16


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 4<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Key Word Search of Activity Logs - Key Word: "Condition"<br />

Claim Contains<br />

"Condition" in<br />

Context of<br />

Depreciation Claim No.<br />

Activity Log<br />

No.<br />

Date of Activity<br />

Log Entry Excerpt Containing Key Word / Phrase Bates No.<br />

107 05-M496-133 n/a 7/2/2012 Sub Investigative Request #1 Information requested: Pls contact NI & obtain photos of the items that she<br />

unpacked from the Restoration company showing the condition they were in.Reason for request: OIC<br />

states they contacted Restoration company & a lot of the items we paid to replace were restored but NI<br />

failed to pick them up, they are obtaining a list from them.<br />

108 05-M496-133 n/a 7/2/2012 *Calendar review*Called OICNela ins. spoke with Phillip he states he is in process of reviewing some of<br />

the items that the restoration company restored that we paid to replace, he states there are several items<br />

that were cleaned/restored & NI never came back to pick up, but we paid to replace, once he has<br />

compiled list he will f/up with us, advised I would review his concerns.*Per 10104/2011 - 3:26 PM DFLT<br />

ACTIVITY LOG NUMBER: 109: Per determined that they packed and stored a multitude of items that<br />

which were not salvagable (i.e. hangers, cat hut, pottery, ect.,) and items which may have been<br />

salvagable were not cleaned and remain the the original smoke damaged condition.*Zone rep spoke<br />

with OIC in 10/27/2011 : 14 PM DFL T ACTIVITY LOG NUMBER: 116 zone advised OIC adj. of above &<br />

even offered to let them view property but they stated photos would suffice.*1 do not show the photos NI<br />

took into file.*Sent SIR.-------------------------*Pends SIR need photos of the non salveagable items that<br />

were submitted to Restoration company OIC states we paid for items that NI never picked up from<br />

Restoration comp.*F/up with OIC for status.<br />

109 05-M496-133 109 10/4/2011 Returned insured's call. She is working on the inventory while unpacking the boxes returned to her from<br />

the restoration company. She has determined that they packed and stored a multitude of items that<br />

which were not salvagable (i.e. hangers, cat hut, pottery, ect.,) and items which may have been<br />

salvagable were not cleaned and remain the the original smoke damaged condition. She is<br />

photographing the items as she is unpacking them. Insured advised that she is considering renting a<br />

storage facility should we wish to see the items at a later date. Advised that this should not be necessary<br />

if she has photographs, model numbers, brands, ect. to assist in identifying the items. Insured advised<br />

that she moved back into her home on 10/1. She inquired as to her extensive make-up supply, which<br />

has been disposed of. Advised that she may catagorize the items if the items claimed are of like, kind<br />

and value.<br />

19 10% Total Claims Containing "Condition" in Context of Depreciation<br />

188 100% Total Claims Searched<br />

SF_CL0004710<br />

SF_CL0004710<br />

SF_CL0004719<br />

10/15/2012 17


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 5


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1 1 1 55-01R7-146 12/5/2011 1 1 King matress Actual Cash Value $1,957.50 $293.62 15.0% 3.0 [b]<br />

2 1 55-01R7-146 12/5/2011 2 1 Queen matress Actual Cash Value 1,305.00 0.00 0.0% -<br />

3 1 55-01R7-146 12/5/2011 3 1 Ikea matress Actual Cash Value 489.38 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1 4 7 55-05X9-436 4/8/2012 14 2 65 Reverb Speakers / Vintage<br />

reissue<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,409.42 704.71 50.0% 20.0<br />

5 7 55-05X9-436 4/8/2012 15 2 speakers / ADS Actual Cash Value 542.49 271.24 50.0% 20.0<br />

1 6 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 1 1 Duffle Bag with Navy Uniform Actual Cash Value 438.54 87.70 20.0% 51.0<br />

7 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 2 1 1960s Dining Table w/ 2 chairs Actual Cash Value 387.90 38.79 10.0% 51.0<br />

8 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 3 1 Ship Picture Big Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.32 10.0%<br />

9 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 4 1 Box of Noritaki China Set Actual Cash Value 247.83 24.78 10.0% 51.0<br />

10 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 5 1 Old Cookie Jar Actual Cash Value 63.57 15.89 25.0% 80.0<br />

11 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 6 40 Depression Glass (Pink) Actual Cash Value 429.92 42.99 10.0% 81.0<br />

12 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 7 1 New Snow Boots Actual Cash Value 123.91 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

13 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 8 1 Antique Brass Spittoon Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0%<br />

14 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 9 1 Old Clock/ Seth Tomas Actual Cash Value 177.79 35.55 20.0% 60.0<br />

15 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 11 5 Belgium Pots and Pans Actual Cash Value 134.69 33.67 25.0% 60.0<br />

16 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 12 1 Black board, large, school Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.77 10.0% 60.0<br />

17 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 13 2 Brass Kerosine lamps Actual Cash Value 75.43 18.85 25.0% 60.0<br />

18 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 14 2 Cast iron frying pans Actual Cash Value 75.43 18.85 25.0%<br />

19 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 15 20 Elvis Presley Magazines Actual Cash Value 431.00 107.75 25.0% 34.0<br />

20 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 16 1 Indian Pottery bowls, antique Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0% 60.0<br />

21 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 17 1 Antique punch cups Actual Cash Value 96.98 9.69 10.0% 60.0<br />

22 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 18 1 Old ship wheel mirror Actual Cash Value 296.31 29.63 10.0% 45.0<br />

23 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 19 8 More Movie Reel Tins, smoked Actual Cash Value 43.10 21.55 50.0% 50.0<br />

24 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 20 1 Antique cinderella cookie jar Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0% 60.0<br />

25 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 21 1 Old Desk Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.87 10.0% 60.0<br />

26 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 22 6 Old glass door knobs Actual Cash Value 226.28 45.24 20.0% 80.0<br />

27 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 23 2 Art easels Actual Cash Value 86.20 21.55 25.0%<br />

28 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 24 2 Candlestick phones Actual Cash Value 129.30 32.32 25.0%<br />

29 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 25 2 Barstools Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 40.0<br />

30 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 26 1 Goose-down comforter Actual Cash Value 307.09 245.67 80.0% 30.0<br />

31 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 27 2 Racing helmets Actual Cash Value 86.20 68.96 80.0% 30.0<br />

32 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 28 96 Arizona Highway Magazines Actual Cash Value 310.32 248.25 80.0% 35.5<br />

33 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 29 1 Indian head clock with indian head<br />

nickles<br />

Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0% 20.0<br />

34 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 30 3 Indian baskets Actual Cash Value 538.75 134.68 25.0%<br />

35 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 31 4 Captain chairs Actual Cash Value 862.00 86.20 10.0% 50.0<br />

36 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 32 1 Giant clown Actual Cash Value 37.71 9.42 25.0% 20.0<br />

37 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 33 6 35mm Reels Tins Actual Cash Value 37.71 18.85 50.0% 50.0<br />

38 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 34 1 Old high chair Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 42.0<br />

39 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 35 1 Round table Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.87 10.0%<br />

40 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 36 1 Oudoor Chair Flag Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0%<br />

41 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 37 1 Coat hanger Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0%<br />

42 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 38 5 Oak Office Chair Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.32 10.0%<br />

43 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 39 1 Typewriter stand Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.93 10.0%<br />

44 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 40 2 Chandelier Actual Cash Value 862.00 172.40 20.0%<br />

45 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 41 1 Hamper Actual Cash Value 10.78 2.15 19.9%<br />

46 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 42 1 Poly cord (Audion) Actual Cash Value 80.81 20.20 25.0%<br />

47 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 43 1 Cart/ Zenith Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0%<br />

48 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 44 1 Pan/ Faberware Actual Cash Value 32.33 8.08 25.0%<br />

49 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 45 1 Phone/GTE Actual Cash Value 26.94 6.73 25.0%<br />

50 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 46 1 Light Actual Cash Value 26.94 6.73 25.0%<br />

51 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 47 1 Phone number organizer Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

52 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 48 1 Crock pot/ Sunbeam Actual Cash Value 32.33 8.08 25.0%<br />

10/15/2012 1


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

53 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 49 1 Binocular case Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0%<br />

54 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 50 1 Bathroom Shelf- Metal Actual Cash Value 64.65 16.16 25.0%<br />

55 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 51 1 Bead wood curtains Actual Cash Value 10.78 2.69 25.0%<br />

56 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 52 1 Picture painting Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

57 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 53 1 In Congress picture Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

58 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 54 1 Suitcase Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

59 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 55 1 Wine rack Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

60 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 56 1 Quilt rack Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.15 10.0%<br />

61 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 57 1 Umbrella Actual Cash Value 10.78 2.69 25.0%<br />

62 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 59 1 Encyclopedia set Actual Cash Value 204.73 8.18 4.0%<br />

63 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 60 1 Wood chair oak Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0%<br />

64 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 61 1 Coffee table Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.38 10.0%<br />

65 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 62 1 Acuvibe Massager Actual Cash Value 37.71 9.42 25.0%<br />

66 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 63 1 Folding table Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0%<br />

67 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 64 1 Folding chair Actual Cash Value 26.94 6.73 25.0%<br />

68 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 65 2 Fishing poles Actual Cash Value 86.20 4.31 5.0%<br />

69 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 66 1 Baby crib Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.77 10.0%<br />

70 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 67 1 GPX stereo Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0%<br />

71 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 68 1 Fisher compenent cabinet Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0%<br />

72 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 69 1 Record player Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0%<br />

73 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 70 1 Foot stool Actual Cash Value 91.59 22.89 25.0%<br />

74 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 71 4 Picture frames Actual Cash Value 172.40 17.24 10.0%<br />

75 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 72 1 Horse picture Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0%<br />

76 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 73 1 River painting Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0%<br />

77 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 74 1 Church picture/ frame Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0%<br />

78 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 75 1 Little girl picture frame Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0%<br />

79 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 76 30 Books Actual Cash Value 323.25 129.30 40.0%<br />

80 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 77 1 Flag foot rest Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0%<br />

81 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 78 1 Lamp Actual Cash Value 91.59 22.89 25.0%<br />

82 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 79 1 Large picture frame Actual Cash Value 91.59 9.15 10.0%<br />

83 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 80 1 Blender Actual Cash Value 70.04 17.51 25.0%<br />

84 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 81 1 Lamp Actual Cash Value 134.69 33.67 25.0%<br />

85 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 82 3 Suit case Actual Cash Value 80.81 16.16 20.0%<br />

86 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 83 1 Fruit deco Actual Cash Value 16.16 4.04 25.0%<br />

87 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 84 1 Clock Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.15 10.0%<br />

88 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 85 1 Metal tin Actual Cash Value 3.23 0.80 24.8%<br />

89 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 86 1 Lamp with shade Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0%<br />

90 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 87 1 Antique scale Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.93 10.0%<br />

91 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 88 1 Folding table Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.15 10.0%<br />

92 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 89 1 Rocking horse Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0%<br />

93 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 90 1 Light Actual Cash Value 21.55 17.24 80.0%<br />

94 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 91 1 Painting oil Actual Cash Value 48.49 12.12 25.0%<br />

95 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 92 1 Painting Actual Cash Value 21.55 5.38 25.0%<br />

96 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 93 2 Rug Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 269.37 25.0%<br />

97 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 94 1 Kitchen items Actual Cash Value 323.25 80.81 25.0%<br />

98 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 95 1 New china boxes Actual Cash Value 1.08 0.27 25.0%<br />

99 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 96 100 Antique bottles Actual Cash Value 646.50 64.65 10.0%<br />

100 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 97 20 Antique milk bottle Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 107.75 10.0%<br />

101 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 98 50 Antique fruit jars Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.87 10.0%<br />

102 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 99 20 Antique cookie jars Actual Cash Value 484.88 48.48 10.0%<br />

103 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 100 60 Antique cut glass Actual Cash Value 1,939.50 193.95 10.0%<br />

104 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 101 1 Crystal Actual Cash Value 1.08 0.10 10.0%<br />

105 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 102 80 Depression glass Actual Cash Value 862.00 86.20 10.0%<br />

106 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 103 30 Carnival glass Actual Cash Value 808.13 80.81 10.0%<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

10/15/2012 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

107 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 104 20 Stem wear Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.93 10.0%<br />

108 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 105 80 Antique medicine bottles Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0%<br />

109 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 106 20 Antique baby bottles Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.46 10.0%<br />

110 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 107 50 Antique insulators Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.93 10.0%<br />

111 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 108 1 Seyei China set Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0%<br />

112 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 109 1 Old English China set - England Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.87 10.0%<br />

113 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 110 60 Ostrich Actual Cash Value 2,586.00 258.60 10.0%<br />

114 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 111 1 File real holders Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0%<br />

115 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 112 15 Shoes Actual Cash Value 808.13 269.37 33.3%<br />

116 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 113 10 Purses Actual Cash Value 53.88 17.96 33.3%<br />

117 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 114 100 Books Actual Cash Value 2,155.00 862.00 40.0%<br />

118 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 115 1 Crystal Chandelier Actual Cash Value 1,616.25 323.25 20.0%<br />

119 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 116 7 Hand painted China Actual Cash Value 754.25 75.42 10.0%<br />

120 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 117 20 picture frames Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 107.75 10.0%<br />

121 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 118 1 Antique scale Actual Cash Value 1,616.25 404.06 25.0%<br />

122 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 119 1 Wood decoration Actual Cash Value 215.50 8.62 4.0%<br />

123 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 120 400 Clothes Actual Cash Value 4,848.75 1,616.25 33.3%<br />

124 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 121 20 Curtains Actual Cash Value 431.00 143.66 33.3%<br />

125 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 122 2 Blankets Actual Cash Value 64.65 12.93 20.0%<br />

126 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 123 20 Jackets Actual Cash Value 646.50 215.50 33.3%<br />

127 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 124 4 Pillows Actual Cash Value 107.75 21.55 20.0%<br />

128 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 125 1 X-mas tree Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0%<br />

129 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 126 1 Small bbq Actual Cash Value 32.33 2.93 9.1%<br />

130 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 127 1 Typewriter/Royal Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.87 25.0%<br />

131 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 128 1 Stereo AM/FM Receiver Capehart Actual Cash Value 1,616.25 404.06 25.0%<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

132 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 129 1 Antiqu Typewriter/ Remington Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 269.37 25.0%<br />

133 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 130 1 Helmet Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0%<br />

134 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 131 15 Antique Rail Road lanterns Actual Cash Value 1,616.25 161.62 10.0%<br />

135 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 132 20 Stuffed animals Actual Cash Value 323.25 161.62 50.0%<br />

136 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 133 1 Child baby changer plastic Actual Cash Value 80.81 20.20 25.0%<br />

137 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 134 2 Meat grinder Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0%<br />

138 11 75-052K-095 2/28/2012 135 30 Magazines and newspapers Actual Cash Value 107.75 80.81 75.0%<br />

1 139 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 1 1 Toilet Seat Cover Actual Cash Value 30.98 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

140 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 2 1 Toilet paper storage Actual Cash Value 37.70 11.31 30.0% 3.0<br />

141 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 3 1 Outhouse bath mat Actual Cash Value 32.27 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

142 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 5 1 Solid wood potty chair Actual Cash Value 161.63 86.20 53.3% 8.0<br />

143 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 6 1 2-step stool Actual Cash Value 16.16 8.61 53.3% 8.0<br />

144 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 7 1 Santa in outhouse Actual Cash Value 32.33 25.86 80.0% 5.0<br />

145 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 9 1 Outhouse magazine holder Actual Cash Value 53.82 26.91 50.0% 5.0<br />

146 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 10 1 Outhouse paper holder Actual Cash Value 25.81 12.90 50.0% 5.0<br />

147 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 11 1 Wooden toilet paper holder Actual Cash Value 16.11 8.05 50.0% 5.0<br />

148 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 12 1 Bath mat Actual Cash Value 21.54 12.92 60.0% 3.0<br />

149 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 13 1 Mat - Long vanity Actual Cash Value 21.54 12.92 60.0% 3.0<br />

150 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 14 1 Toilet set rug Actual Cash Value 21.54 12.92 60.0% 3.0<br />

151 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 16 2 Book shelves, dbl w/ 4 shelves Actual Cash Value 1,077.48 269.37 25.0%<br />

152 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 17 1 Supreme Wind tunnel vacuum/<br />

Hoover<br />

Actual Cash Value 204.71 27.29 13.3% 2.0<br />

153 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 18 1 Box of maps 54/ AAA travel Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.61 10.0% 1.0<br />

154 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 19 15 Small gift cards with envelopes Actual Cash Value 5.39 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

155 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 20 2 Spools of ribbon Actual Cash Value 10.78 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

156 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 21 2 Picture frames Actual Cash Value 21.55 5.38 25.0% 5.0<br />

157 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 22 1 Dell laptop computer case/ Black<br />

soft briefcase<br />

Actual Cash Value 43.09 8.61 20.0% 4.0<br />

10/15/2012 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

158 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 23 1 Briefcase Actual Cash Value 37.71 11.31 30.0% 6.0<br />

159 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 24 1 Black briefcase Actual Cash Value 37.71 9.42 25.0% 5.0<br />

160 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 25 1 Back briefcase Actual Cash Value 37.71 15.08 40.0% 8.0<br />

161 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 26 1 Tapestry tote w/ zip Actual Cash Value 21.55 11.49 53.3% 8.0<br />

162 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 27 1 Polaroid DVD individual player Actual Cash Value 43.10 34.48 80.0% 8.0<br />

163 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 28 1 Book: Let the People Sing Actual Cash Value 13.95 5.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

164 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 29 1 Fred Waring Song book Actual Cash Value 6.45 2.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

165 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 30 1 The Late Homecomer Actual Cash Value 11.17 2.23 20.0% 1.0<br />

166 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 31 1 The True Cost of Low Prices/<br />

Violence of Globalization<br />

Actual Cash Value 12.15 2.43 20.0% 1.0<br />

167 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 32 1 The Noticer Actual Cash Value 12.90 2.58 20.0% 1.0<br />

168 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 33 1 Like Bread & Water Actual Cash Value 13.30 2.66 20.0% 1.0<br />

169 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 34 2 UMW membership books Actual Cash Value 21.55 4.31 20.0% 1.0<br />

170 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 35 1 Let's Get Together Actual Cash Value 5.39 2.15 39.9% 2.0<br />

171 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 36 1 Prayer Calendar Actual Cash Value 5.39 1.07 19.9% 1.0<br />

172 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 37 15 Response booklets Actual Cash Value 23.49 9.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

173 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 38 1 Disney black tote Actual Cash Value 32.33 10.77 33.3% 5.0<br />

174 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 39 1 Leather briefcase Actual Cash Value 43.10 21.55 50.0% 10.0<br />

175 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 40 1 AC power adapter Actual Cash Value 13.74 10.99 80.0% 8.0<br />

176 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 41 1 Rolltop desk w/ hutch Actual Cash Value 4,608.46 1,152.11 25.0% 20.0<br />

177 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 42 1 Santa boot w/ tree Actual Cash Value 10.78 1.43 13.3% 0.7<br />

178 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 43 12 Wrapping paper Actual Cash Value 64.65 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

179 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 44 8 Gift warp bags Actual Cash Value 25.88 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

180 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 45 2 Computer paper Actual Cash Value 16.16 0.00 0.0% 0.5<br />

181 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 46 2 Laundry totes Actual Cash Value 64.63 6.46 10.0% 0.5<br />

182 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 47 1 Box w/ paper ribbon / set of 3 Actual Cash Value 16.16 0.00 0.0% 0.5<br />

183 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 48 1 Embroidered framed pic/ Church<br />

w/ steeple<br />

Actual Cash Value 26.94 6.73 25.0% 22.0<br />

184 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 49 1 Crescent moon rug Actual Cash Value 43.10 34.48 80.0% 7.0<br />

185 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 50 1 Round moon embroidered rug Actual Cash Value 60.33 48.26 80.0% 8.0<br />

186 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 51 1 Oval moon/sun rug/bath mat Actual Cash Value 22.62 18.09 80.0%<br />

187 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 52 1 Lingerie chest Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0% 1.0<br />

188 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 53 1 Western leather boots Actual Cash Value 172.39 137.91 80.0% 18.0<br />

189 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 54 1 Twin white down comforter Actual Cash Value 86.19 34.47 40.0%<br />

190 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 55 1 Corvette leather luggage Actual Cash Value 96.96 9.69 10.0% 2.0<br />

191 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 56 1 American flag woven purse Actual Cash Value 42.02 25.21 60.0% 3.0<br />

192 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 57 1 Denim shoulder strap purse Actual Cash Value 37.66 15.06 40.0% 2.0<br />

193 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 58 1 Photos fabric purse Actual Cash Value 32.33 12.93 40.0% 2.0<br />

194 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 59 1 Mickey mouse purse/ Dooney &<br />

Bourke<br />

Actual Cash Value 242.44 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

195 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 60 1 Gold hobo purse/ Kathy von<br />

Zealand<br />

Actual Cash Value 68.96 41.37 60.0% 3.0<br />

196 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 61 1 Purse w/ matching wallet Actual Cash Value 37.71 30.16 80.0% 10.0<br />

197 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 62 1 Disney tote w/ embroidered name Actual Cash Value 32.33 4.31 13.3% 2.0<br />

198 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 63 1 Shoe rack Actual Cash Value 15.07 10.54 69.9% 7.0<br />

199 12 75-03G8-444 4/2/2012 67 1 Custom pads for table & 3 leaves Actual Cash Value 387.90 96.97 25.0% 28.0<br />

200 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 17 1 Book - Traditional Celtic Stories Actual Cash Value 9.12 4.56 50.0%<br />

201 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 18 1 Book - New Moon Astrology Actual Cash Value 14.05 7.02 50.0%<br />

202 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 19 1 Book - The Inner World of Actual Cash Value 19.52 9.76 50.0%<br />

203 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 20 1 Book - Voices of the First Day Actual Cash Value 23.79 11.89 50.0%<br />

204 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 21 1 Book - Centering in Pottery Actual Cash Value 14.76 7.38 50.0%<br />

10/15/2012 4


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

205 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 22 1 Book - Nature & The Human Soul Actual Cash Value 13.28 6.64 50.0%<br />

206 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 23 1 Book - Women Who Run<br />

w/Wolves<br />

Actual Cash Value 20.06 10.03 50.0%<br />

207 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 24 1 Book - The Annotated Flatland Actual Cash Value 14.26 7.13 50.0%<br />

208 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 25 1 Book - The Inner Journey Actual Cash Value 21.50 10.75 50.0%<br />

209 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 26 1 Book - Replay Actual Cash Value 12.14 6.07 50.0%<br />

210 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 27 1 Book - Soul is Here for a Day Actual Cash Value 16.48 8.24 50.0%<br />

211 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 28 1 Book - The Heart of the World Actual Cash Value 7.60 3.80 50.0%<br />

212 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 29 1 Book - The Mystical Poems of Ru Actual Cash Value 12.18 6.09 50.0%<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

213 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 30 1 Book - The Conscious Heart Actual Cash Value 12.57 6.28 50.0%<br />

214 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 31 1 Book - The Art of Aging Actual Cash Value 11.83 5.91 50.0%<br />

215 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 32 1 Book - Sailing Home Actual Cash Value 19.30 9.65 50.0%<br />

216 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 33 1 Book - Healing the Shame Actual Cash Value 11.06 5.53 50.0%<br />

217 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 34 1 Book - The Power of One Actual Cash Value 10.88 5.44 50.0%<br />

218 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 35 1 Book - The Ultimate Gift Actual Cash Value 12.17 6.08 50.0%<br />

219 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 36 1 Book - Co-dependence Actual Cash Value 11.97 5.98 50.0%<br />

220 28 05-M443-777 4/2/2009 37 1 Book -Creating a World that Actual Cash Value 11.09 5.54 50.0%<br />

1 221 30 05-M486-516 12/14/2010 2 1 Bike Helmet / Wheel Away Cycle<br />

Center<br />

Actual Cash Value 39.41 11.82 30.0% 1.6 [c]<br />

222 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 2 1 Milling machine repair / Cincinnati<br />

Std Taper 40<br />

ACV 2,550.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1 223 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 3 1 Bead blast cabinet ACV 431.92 10.80 2.5% 0.5<br />

224 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 4 1 Pallet jack repair / 2 ton ACV 108.25 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

225 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 5 1 10' table saw repair / Contractor's<br />

model<br />

ACV 194.85 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

226 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 6 1 Galvanized pail ACV 10.83 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

227 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 7 1 Camera & photos ACV 20.25 0.00 0.0% -<br />

228 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 8 1 Metal cutting bandsaw repair /<br />

Enco<br />

ACV 100.00 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

229 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 9 1 225 amp AC/DC arc welder /<br />

repair - Lincoln<br />

ACV 100.00 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

230 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 11 1 Milling machine tool supply /<br />

caddy repair w/ 200+ cutters<br />

ACV 200.00 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

231 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 12 1 Floor jack repair ACV 100.00 0.00 0.0% 18.0<br />

232 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 13 1 Three tray service cart ACV 54.11 5.41 10.0% 1.0<br />

233 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 14 1 Black metal desk repair ACV 100.00 0.00 0.0% 10.0<br />

234 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 15 1 Privet hedge plants ACV 292.28 0.00 0.0%<br />

235 35 05-M380-567 3/31/2006 19 1 Gardener's charge to plant/ the<br />

hedge plants<br />

ACV 50.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

236 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 1 18 Derby Hats Actual Cash Value 142.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

237 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 2 8 Clear Eyes Actual Cash Value 18.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

238 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 3 111 Krazy Glue Actual Cash Value 22.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

239 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 4 13 Ora Gel Actual Cash Value 48.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

240 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 5 9 Lotromin Actual Cash Value 33.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

241 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 6 202 Lighters Actual Cash Value 238.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

242 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 7 12 Underwear Actual Cash Value 17.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

243 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 8 9 Fruit snacks Actual Cash Value 9.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

244 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 9 18 Pregnancy test Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

245 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 10 176 Incense Actual Cash Value 30.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

246 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 11 1 Tums Actual Cash Value 23.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

247 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 12 1 Dog leash Actual Cash Value 29.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

248 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 13 1 Combs Actual Cash Value 70.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

10/15/2012 5


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

249 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 14 1 Car air freshener Actual Cash Value 78.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

250 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 15 1 Receiver for camera Actual Cash Value 295.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

251 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 16 1 Cash register Actual Cash Value 645.00 112.87 17.5%<br />

252 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 17 1 Screen Actual Cash Value 175.00 48.12 27.5%<br />

1 253 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 18 2 Video camera Actual Cash Value 350.00 280.00 80.0% 4.0 [c]<br />

254 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 19 21 Chapstick Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

255 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 20 10 Disposable camera Actual Cash Value 92.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

256 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 21 14 Single medication Actual Cash Value 128.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

257 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 22 41 Halls Actual Cash Value 258.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

258 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 23 93 Shoe laces Actual Cash Value 187.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

259 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 24 57 Stockings Actual Cash Value 321.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

260 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 25 21 Lolipolo Actual Cash Value 83.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

261 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 26 8 Band-aid Actual Cash Value 21.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

262 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 27 38 Ear phones Actual Cash Value 128.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

263 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 28 142 Kool-aid Actual Cash Value 355.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

264 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 29 18 Eye-drops Actual Cash Value 31.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

265 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 30 1 Razors Actual Cash Value 102.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

266 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 31 1 Beenie Actual Cash Value 73.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

267 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 32 1 Matches Actual Cash Value 32.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

268 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 33 1 Blunt wraps Actual Cash Value 44.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

269 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 34 1 Baggies Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

270 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 35 1 Gloves Actual Cash Value 220.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

271 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 36 1 Thermals Actual Cash Value 1,800.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

272 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 37 1 Tshirts Actual Cash Value 342.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

273 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 38 1 Cash receipts Actual Cash Value 92.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

274 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 39 1 Phone cases Actual Cash Value 592.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

275 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 40 1 Phone chargers Actual Cash Value 242.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

276 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 41 1 Phone accessories Actual Cash Value 143.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

277 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 42 1 Watch batteries Actual Cash Value 197.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

278 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 43 93 Gum Actual Cash Value 139.50 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

279 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 44 31 Candy Actual Cash Value 32.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

280 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 45 1 Mints Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

281 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 46 76 Socks Actual Cash Value 72.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

282 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 47 1 Durag Actual Cash Value 108.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

283 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 48 1 Neosporin Actual Cash Value 49.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

284 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 49 1 Cortizone Actual Cash Value 21.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

285 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 50 1 Playing cards Actual Cash Value 28.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

286 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 51 1 Energy vit Actual Cash Value 51.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

287 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 52 1 Trojan Actual Cash Value 118.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

288 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 53 1 Battre Actual Cash Value 123.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

289 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 54 1 Medicine Actual Cash Value 116.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

290 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 55 1 Tobacco Actual Cash Value 55.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

291 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 56 1 Drub tobacco Actual Cash Value 118.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

292 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 57 1 Razors/Gillette Actual Cash Value 102.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

293 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 58 1 Bennie/ AAA co Actual Cash Value 73.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

294 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 59 1 Matches/ Pitco Actual Cash Value 32.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

295 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 60 1 Blunt wraps/ Platinum Actual Cash Value 44.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

296 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 61 1 Baggies/ tobacco Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

297 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 62 1 Gloves Actual Cash Value 220.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

298 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 63 1 Hats Actual Cash Value 72.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

299 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 64 1 Thermals Actual Cash Value 1,800.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

300 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 65 1 Tshirts Actual Cash Value 342.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

301 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 66 1 Cash receipts Actual Cash Value 92.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

302 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 67 1 Phone cases Actual Cash Value 592.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

10/15/2012 6


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

303 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 68 1 Phone chargers Actual Cash Value 242.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

304 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 69 1 Phone accessories Actual Cash Value 143.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

305 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 70 1 Watch batteries Actual Cash Value 197.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

306 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 71 18 Durby hats Actual Cash Value 142.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

307 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 72 8 Clear eyes Actual Cash Value 180.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

308 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 73 11 Krazy glue Actual Cash Value 22.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

309 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 74 13 Oragel Actual Cash Value 48.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

310 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 75 9 Lotrimin Actual Cash Value 33.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

311 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 76 202 Lighters / Big Light Actual Cash Value 238.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

312 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 77 12 Underwear Actual Cash Value 47.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

313 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 78 9 fruit snacks Actual Cash Value 7.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

314 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 79 18 Pregnancy tests Actual Cash Value 88.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

315 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 80 176 Incense Actual Cash Value 30.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

316 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 81 23 Dog leash Actual Cash Value 29.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

317 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 82 108 Tums Actual Cash Value 23.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

318 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 83 29 Combs Actual Cash Value 20.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

319 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 84 30 Car air freshener Actual Cash Value 78.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

320 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 85 1 Cash register Actual Cash Value 645.00 225.75 35.0%<br />

321 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 86 1 Screen Actual Cash Value 175.00 72.91 41.7%<br />

322 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 87 2 Video camera Actual Cash Value 350.00 218.75 62.5% 4.0 [c]<br />

323 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 88 21 Chapstick Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

324 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 89 11 Disposable cameras / Kodak Actual Cash Value 92.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

325 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 90 14 Single medicines Actual Cash Value 128.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

326 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 91 41 Halls Actual Cash Value 258.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

327 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 92 93 Shoe laces Actual Cash Value 187.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

328 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 93 57 Stockings Actual Cash Value 321.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

329 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 94 21 Trojan Actual Cash Value 83.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

330 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 95 8 Band-aids Actual Cash Value 21.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

331 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 96 38 Ear phones / Sony Actual Cash Value 128.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

332 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 97 142 Kool-aid Actual Cash Value 355.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

333 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 98 18 Eye drops Actual Cash Value 31.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

334 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 99 93 Gum Actual Cash Value 139.50 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

335 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 100 1 Candy Actual Cash Value 32.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

336 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 101 1 Mints Actual Cash Value 38.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

337 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 102 1 Socks Actual Cash Value 72.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

338 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 103 1 Durag Actual Cash Value 108.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

339 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 104 1 Neosporin Actual Cash Value 49.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

340 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 105 1 Cortizone Actual Cash Value 21.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

341 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 106 1 Playing cards / Bicycle Actual Cash Value 28.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

342 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 107 1 Energy vit Actual Cash Value 51.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

343 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 108 1 Trojan Actual Cash Value 118.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

344 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 109 1 Battery Actual Cash Value 123.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

345 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 110 1 Medicine Actual Cash Value 116.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

346 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 111 1 Tobacco Actual Cash Value 55.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

347 40 05-M517-927 9/26/2011 112 1 Drum tobacco Actual Cash Value 118.00 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

1 348 42 05-M394-706 9/1/2006 1 1 Coffee table / Crate & Barrel ACV 610.42 61.04 10.0% 2.0 [c]<br />

1 349 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 17 1 Desk w/ hutch Oak 3-drawer /<br />

CostCo<br />

Actual Cash Value 985.56 269.40 27.3% 8.0<br />

350 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 18 1 Dresser/ Oak lateral Actual Cash Value 603.57 164.99 27.3% 8.0<br />

351 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 19 1 Office Chair/ Office Star Actual Cash Value 207.43 56.70 27.3% 3.0<br />

352 59 75-M564-724 12/3/2009 20 1 Drapery Rod / JC Penny Actual Cash Value 65.85 35.12 53.3% 8.0<br />

353 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 1 1 Men's Jacket ACV 86.55 69.24 80.0%<br />

1 354 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 2 1 Men's sport coat ACV 108.20 86.56 80.0% 5.0<br />

355 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 3 1 Woman's sport suit ACV 54.07 36.05 66.7% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 7


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

356 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 4 1 Woman's jacket, rabbit fur ACV 43.25 28.83 66.7% 2.0<br />

357 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 5 1 Ladies coat ACV 324.70 216.47 66.7% 2.0<br />

358 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 6 1 Men's suit ACV 270.63 216.50 80.0% 6.0<br />

359 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 7 1 Woman's jacket ACV 216.45 173.16 80.0% 4.0<br />

360 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 8 1 Men's sweater ACV 32.42 21.61 66.7% 2.0<br />

361 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 9 1 Dress ACV 270.57 180.38 66.7% 2.0<br />

362 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 10 1 Woman's jacket ACV 54.07 36.05 66.7% 2.0<br />

363 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 11 1 Men's shirt ACV 43.25 28.83 66.7% 2.0<br />

364 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 12 1 Men's shirt ACV 21.60 17.28 80.0% 4.0<br />

365 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 13 1 Cocktail dress ACV 227.33 181.86 80.0% 3.0<br />

366 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 14 1 Men's shoes ACV 75.72 0.00 0.0% -<br />

367 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 15 1 Men's shoes ACV 86.55 57.70 66.7% 2.0<br />

368 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 16 1 Men's shoes ACV 64.90 43.27 66.7% 2.0<br />

369 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 17 1 Men's sweater ACV 43.25 34.60 80.0% 6.0<br />

370 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 18 1 Men's pants ACV 32.42 21.61 66.7% 2.0<br />

371 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 19 1 Women's shoes ACV 86.55 57.70 66.7% 2.0<br />

372 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 20 1 Women's shoes ACV 97.37 64.91 66.7% 2.0<br />

373 60 75-M415-579 2/4/2005 21 1 Men's Jacket ACV 75.72 60.58 80.0% 4.0<br />

1 374 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 1 1 Sectional Sofas / Linders Actual Cash Value 2,175.00 1,087.50 50.0% 4.0<br />

375 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 2 1 Sofa Tables / Linders Actual Cash Value 435.00 145.00 33.3% 4.0<br />

376 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 3 2 Book cases / Sears Actual Cash Value 652.50 163.12 25.0%<br />

377 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 4 1 Wool rug 9x12 / Mervyns Actual Cash Value 195.75 111.85 57.1% 4.0<br />

378 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 5 1 Wool rug 10' circle / Ashley's Actual Cash Value 326.25 130.50 40.0% 4.0<br />

379 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 6 1 Coffee table, oak / Spiegel Actual Cash Value 522.00 139.20 26.7% 4.0<br />

380 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 7 1 Fireplace Utencils / Target Actual Cash Value 135.94 54.37 40.0% 4.0<br />

381 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 8 1 Ottoman / Spiegel Actual Cash Value 146.81 58.72 40.0% 4.0<br />

382 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 9 1 Outdoor welcome mat / Front<br />

Gate<br />

Actual Cash Value 163.13 97.87 60.0%<br />

383 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 10 1 Tiffany lamps / Tues. Morning Actual Cash Value 380.63 114.18 30.0% 4.0<br />

384 62 75-M553-079 7/14/2009 11 2 Media Stand Actual Cash Value 1,498.58 399.62 26.7% 4.0<br />

1 385 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 2 1 Matress Actual Cash Value 823.13 123.46 15.0% 1.5<br />

386 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 3 1 Bed frame Actual Cash Value 164.63 4.11 2.5% 0.3<br />

387 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 4 1 Duvet cover Actual Cash Value 109.75 32.92 30.0% 5.0<br />

388 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 5 1 Quilt Actual Cash Value 76.83 28.81 37.5% 5.0<br />

389 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 6 1 Sheets/ Pillow case sets Actual Cash Value 76.83 21.95 28.6% 2.0<br />

390 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 7 2 Pillows Actual Cash Value 43.90 12.54 28.6% 2.0<br />

391 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 8 1 Clothes (skirts, sweaters, so Actual Cash Value 109.75 27.43 25.0% 1.0<br />

392 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 9 2 Shoes/ pair Actual Cash Value 43.90 10.97 25.0% 1.0<br />

393 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 10 1 shoe rack Actual Cash Value 21.95 5.49 25.0% 2.0<br />

394 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 11 1 Rug - Throw Actual Cash Value 32.93 1.02 3.1% 0.3<br />

395 69 05-M488-313 8/8/2012 14 1 Lamp Actual Cash Value 32.93 23.06 30.0%<br />

1 396 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 1 1 complete care play yard /target Actual Cash Value 151.89 11.39 7.5% 0.8<br />

397 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 2 1 shoes / Bills Wheels Actual Cash Value 65.10 27.12 41.7% 1.5<br />

398 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 3 1 shoes / Nortridge Mall Actual Cash Value 151.90 121.52 80.0% 5.0<br />

399 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 4 1 shoes / Fashion Island Actual Cash Value 211.58 94.03 44.4% 1.3<br />

400 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 5 1 shoes / Davids Bridal Actual Cash Value 54.25 24.11 44.4% 1.3<br />

401 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 7 2 anti-slip rug / Cost Plus Actual Cash Value 108.50 12.91 11.9% 0.8<br />

402 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 8 1 picture / Lenz Art Actual Cash Value 86.80 0.00 0.0% 0.1<br />

403 72 75-M537-021 5/28/2009 9 4 pillows / Target Actual Cash Value 173.60 96.44 55.6% 1.7<br />

1 404 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 1 1 vacuum mixer / Degussa Multivac Actual Cash Value 3,848.55 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

405 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 2 1 model trimmer / Great Lakes Actual Cash Value 1,756.00 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

406 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 3 1 lath Actual Cash Value 1,097.50 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

407 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 4 3 splash hoods / Handler Actual Cash Value 235.41 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 8


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

408 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 6 1 hand piece lab motor Actual Cash Value 674.96 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

409 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 7 1 triad unit Actual Cash Value 1,152.38 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

410 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 8 1 blasters / Renfert Classic Actual Cash Value 767.15 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

411 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 9 1 pressure curing unit / GC Acri-<br />

Dense<br />

Actual Cash Value 416.71 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

412 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 10 1 steamer / Kerr Actual Cash Value 1,096.40 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

413 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 11 1 microscope / Swift Actual Cash Value 2,529.74 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

414 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 12 1 vibrator Actual Cash Value 97.68 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

415 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 13 1 desk lamp / Dazor Actual Cash Value 262.30 78.69 30.0% 3.0<br />

416 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 15 2 lab chairs Actual Cash Value 1,415.78 1,132.62 80.0% 7.0<br />

417 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 17 3 dental articulators / Panadent Actual Cash Value 852.76 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

418 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 18 1 dental waxer / KDF Waxmaster II Actual Cash Value 488.39 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

419 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 19 1 vacuum form unit machine /<br />

Erkodent<br />

Actual Cash Value 3,018.13 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

420 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 20 15 dental lab instruments Actual Cash Value 2,052.33 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

421 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 21 5 telephones / Nortel Network Actual Cash Value 576.19 345.71 60.0% 3.0<br />

422 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 22 3 air compressure nozzel / Husky Actual Cash Value 55.25 8.28 15.0% 3.0<br />

423 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 23 2 paper towel dispensor Actual Cash Value 228.26 68.47 30.0% 3.0<br />

424 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 24 1 dental duplicate flask Actual Cash Value 156.39 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

425 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 27 1 lab vacuum unit Actual Cash Value 2,236.71 0.00 0.0% 7.0<br />

426 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 28 1 hand tool set / Husky Actual Cash Value 65.84 19.75 30.0% 3.0<br />

427 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 29 6 picture frames / IKEA Actual Cash Value 131.63 1.09 0.8% 0.2<br />

428 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 31 1 kitchen knife kit / Paula Dean Actual Cash Value 109.74 5.48 5.0% 6.0<br />

429 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 34 4 Chairs/fabric Actual Cash Value 1,316.96 395.08 30.0% 3.0<br />

430 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 39 1 slide viewer / cabin Actual Cash Value 438.95 0.00 0.0% 5.0<br />

431 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 52 88 lab burs / Bresseier Actual Cash Value 2,192.81 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

432 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 53 3 trash cans Actual Cash Value 115.20 11.52 10.0% 1.0<br />

433 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 60 1 x-ray viewer / Recess Viewer Actual Cash Value 274.38 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

434 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 61 5 doctors stools / Peltone & Crane Actual Cash Value 3,731.60 2,612.04 70.0% 7.0<br />

435 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 62 4 assistant stools / Peltone & Crane Actual Cash Value 3,468.10 2,427.66 70.0% 7.0<br />

436 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 63 3 dental exam chair / Peltone &<br />

Crane<br />

Actual Cash Value 92,520.16 74,016.12 80.0% 15.0<br />

437 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 65 1 leather chair / Kalico Actual Cash Value 329.24 32.92 10.0% 15.0<br />

438 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 66 1 electric heater / Circle Air Actual Cash Value 142.66 79.25 55.6% 5.0<br />

439 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 67 1 paper shredder / Royal Actual Cash Value 63.74 3.98 6.2% 0.5<br />

440 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 68 2 wooden plant pots Actual Cash Value 65.83 5.48 8.3% 0.3<br />

441 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 69 1 coffee table / Plummers Actual Cash Value 295.23 29.52 10.0% 1.0<br />

442 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 70 1 five books Actual Cash Value 217.31 10.86 5.0% 1.0<br />

443 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 71 5 chairs (waiting room) / Kalico Actual Cash Value 1,476.14 421.75 28.6% 2.0<br />

444 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 72 1 metal file cabinets / HON Actual Cash Value 603.61 60.36 10.0% 2.0<br />

445 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 73 1 disposable trap / Trap-eze Actual Cash Value 142.68 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

446 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 75 2 external hard drive / Dell Actual Cash Value 217.31 108.65 50.0% 2.0<br />

447 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 76 1 slide viewer Actual Cash Value 274.32 0.00 0.0% 7.0<br />

448 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 78 2 computer speakers Actual Cash Value 109.73 6.85 6.2% 0.5<br />

449 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 80 1 track ball mouse / Logitech Actual Cash Value 65.84 16.46 25.0% 2.0<br />

450 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 81 1 100 articulator mounting plat /<br />

Panadent<br />

Actual Cash Value 214.01 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

451 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 83 1 10 lethe wheels / Muslin buffs Actual Cash Value 26.67 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

452 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 87 1 USB port hub / D-Link Actual Cash Value 41.69 5.21 12.5% 1.0<br />

453 82 75-M613-624 5/24/2012 89 1 phote frame / IKEA Actual Cash Value 32.91 0.27 0.8% 0.2<br />

1 454 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 2 1 Swivel office chair Actual Cash Value 301.81 90.54 30.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 9


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

455 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 3 1 26" Plastic T rules Actual Cash Value 15.37 3.07 20.0% 2.0<br />

456 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 4 1 Particle board CD shelf Actual Cash Value 54.88 7.31 13.3% 2.0<br />

457 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 5 1 Remington Hair Iron Actual Cash Value 54.88 0.00 0.0% -<br />

458 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 6 1 Curling iron Actual Cash Value 38.41 30.72 80.0% 9.0<br />

459 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 7 1 Hair dryer Actual Cash Value 27.44 0.00 0.0% -<br />

460 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 8 1 Womens Blazer coat Actual Cash Value 65.85 16.46 25.0% 1.0<br />

461 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 9 1 Woman's wool coat Actual Cash Value 38.41 9.60 25.0% -<br />

462 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 10 1 Woman's long-sleeved shirt Actual Cash Value 43.90 14.63 33.3% 1.0<br />

463 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 11 1 Woman's blouse Actual Cash Value 32.93 16.46 50.0% 1.0<br />

464 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 12 6 Cardboard letter stencils Actual Cash Value 27.44 0.00 0.0% -<br />

465 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 13 1 30 inch plastic frame Actual Cash Value 38.41 0.00 0.0% -<br />

466 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 14 1 CVS Pharmacy lotion Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% -<br />

467 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 15 1 St. Ives Body Lotion Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% -<br />

468 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 16 1 Fabreeze Air Freshener Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

469 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 17 1 Libman toilet brush holder Actual Cash Value 10.98 7.32 66.7% 2.0<br />

470 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 18 1 Woman's bathrobe/ Charter Club Actual Cash Value 43.90 35.12 80.0% 9.0<br />

471 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 19 1 3x2 bathroom rug Actual Cash Value 27.44 10.97 40.0% 2.0<br />

472 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 20 1 Shower squee gee Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

473 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 21 1 foot brush bar Actual Cash Value 7.68 5.12 66.7% 2.0<br />

474 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 22 1 Luffa sponge Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

475 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 23 2 Bath and Body Works Body<br />

Splash 4oz<br />

Actual Cash Value 15.37 0.00 0.0% -<br />

476 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 24 1 Bath and Body Works lotion 8oz Actual Cash Value 13.17 4.39 33.3% 1.0<br />

477 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 25 1 Bath and Body Works<br />

Aromatherapy<br />

Actual Cash Value 13.17 4.39 33.3% 1.0<br />

478 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 27 4 Perscription medication Actual Cash Value 10.00 0.00 0.0% -<br />

479 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 28 1 Wire shower head organizer Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0% 2.0<br />

480 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 29 1 Clinique lip stick Actual Cash Value 15.37 0.00 0.0% -<br />

481 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 30 1 Stainless steep trash can Actual Cash Value 27.43 2.74 10.0% 2.0<br />

482 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 31 1 Blue Lagoon Iceland Skin Care Actual Cash Value 12.07 4.02 33.3% 1.0<br />

483 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 32 1 Nature's Bounty Melatonin Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

484 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 33 1 Burt's Bees Foot cream Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.00 0.0% -<br />

485 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 34 1 Lollia Butter handcreme Actual Cash Value 27.44 0.00 0.0% -<br />

486 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 35 1 12x10 Canvass handbag Actual Cash Value 16.46 8.23 50.0% 1.0<br />

487 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 36 6 Clinique makeup bags Actual Cash Value 43.90 8.78 20.0% 1.0<br />

488 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 37 1 Oral B toothbrush Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

489 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 38 1 Japanese Cherry Blossom<br />

Perfume<br />

Actual Cash Value 18.66 0.00 0.0% -<br />

490 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 39 1 Caress body spray Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

491 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 40 1 Calvin Klein Obsession Actual Cash Value 21.95 0.00 0.0% -<br />

492 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 41 1 Lysol Disinfectant cleaner Actual Cash Value 8.78 5.85 66.6% 2.0<br />

493 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 42 1 Up and Up Cotton Balls Actual Cash Value 2.24 0.00 0.0% -<br />

494 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 43 1 Q-tips cotton swabs Actual Cash Value 4.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

495 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 45 1 Gualderma Differin Gel Actual Cash Value 20.00 6.66 33.3% 1.0<br />

496 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 46 1 Tylenol Sinus and Pain Actual Cash Value 7.68 2.56 33.3% 1.0<br />

497 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 47 1 Oxy Spot treatment Actual Cash Value 3.83 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

498 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 48 1 CVS pharmacy sinus Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

499 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 49 1 CVS pharmacy laxatives Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

500 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 50 1 Plastic container Actual Cash Value 7.68 3.07 40.0% 2.0<br />

501 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 51 1 Sunsilk conditioner Actual Cash Value 5.45 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

502 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 52 1 Banana Boat Tanning Oil Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.00 0.0% -<br />

503 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 53 1 Always Maxi pads Actual Cash Value 6.03 0.00 0.0% -<br />

10/15/2012 10


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

504 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 54 1 Always Ultra-thin pads Actual Cash Value 12.05 0.00 0.0% -<br />

505 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 55 1 Up and Up regular tampons Actual Cash Value 4.60 0.00 0.0% -<br />

506 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 56 1 Foot brush Actual Cash Value 5.49 3.66 66.7% 2.0<br />

507 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 57 1 Everyday Living Auto Bowl tabs Actual Cash Value 13.17 8.78 66.7% 2.0<br />

508 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 58 1 Box of Kleenex Tissues Actual Cash Value 2.51 0.00 0.0% -<br />

509 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 59 1 10" Plastic hair comb Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 1.0<br />

510 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 60 1 30x20 Plastic framed poster Actual Cash Value 9.87 1.48 15.0% 2.0<br />

511 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 61 1 Pantene Pro-V Conditioner Actual Cash Value 8.54 0.00 0.0% -<br />

512 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 62 1 Up and Up Theraputic dandruff<br />

shampoo<br />

Actual Cash Value 3.99 0.00 0.0% -<br />

513 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 63 1 JR Watkins Hand soap Actual Cash Value 8.22 2.74 33.3% 1.0<br />

514 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 64 1 Pantene Pro-V shampoo Actual Cash Value 7.55 0.00 0.0% -<br />

515 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 65 1 Renaissance America Bath Towel Actual Cash Value 32.93 21.95 66.7% 2.0<br />

516 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 66 1 Plastic bucket w/ handle Actual Cash Value 9.88 7.90 80.0% 4.0<br />

517 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 67 1 Travel bar soap container Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.00 0.0% -<br />

518 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 68 1 Travel size Colegate Actual Cash Value 1.06 0.00 0.0% -<br />

519 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 69 1 Herbal Essence Shampoo Actual Cash Value 1.06 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

520 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 70 1 Toothbrush holder / Travel by<br />

Design<br />

Actual Cash Value 1.09 0.00 0.0% -<br />

521 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 71 1 Secret Women's deodorant Actual Cash Value 1.06 0.00 0.0% -<br />

522 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 72 1 Pantene Pro-V Hairspray Actual Cash Value 1.06 0.00 0.0% -<br />

523 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 73 1 CVS Pharmacy moisturizing Actual Cash Value 3.28 0.00 0.0% -<br />

524 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 74 1 Crest toothpast Actual Cash Value 4.65 0.00 0.0% -<br />

525 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 75 1 Target brand facial cleaner Actual Cash Value 4.21 0.00 0.0% -<br />

526 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 76 1 Clear Pore cleanser/mask /<br />

Neutrogena<br />

Actual Cash Value 6.57 0.00 0.0% -<br />

527 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 77 3 Dove Women's deodorant Actual Cash Value 11.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

528 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 78 1 Suave Max Hold Hairspray Actual Cash Value 2.40 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

529 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 79 1 Anti-blemish toner/ Boots brand Actual Cash Value 9.88 0.00 0.0% -<br />

530 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 80 1 Swiffer dister Actual Cash Value 27.44 5.48 20.0% 1.0<br />

531 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 81 1 Target-brand Disinfecting wipes Actual Cash Value 4.32 0.00 0.0% -<br />

532 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 82 3 Lipstick tubes Actual Cash Value 21.95 7.31 33.3% 1.0<br />

533 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 83 1 Crest glide cool mint floss Actual Cash Value 6.57 0.00 0.0% -<br />

534 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 84 1 Comet disinfectant and cleanser Actual Cash Value 1.06 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

535 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 85 1 Heart-shaped Mirror Actual Cash Value 21.95 0.00 0.0% -<br />

536 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 86 1 Metal fingernail scissors Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

537 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 88 1 Rimmel Eyeshadow Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% -<br />

538 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 89 1 Sterilite plastic tray Actual Cash Value 19.76 7.90 40.0% 2.0<br />

539 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 90 1 Old Navy star shimmer powder Actual Cash Value 6.59 4.39 66.6% 2.0<br />

540 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 91 1 NYC Smooth skin face powder Actual Cash Value 8.78 2.92 33.3% 1.0<br />

541 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 92 1 Great Lash mascara Actual Cash Value 4.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

542 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 93 1 NYC Liquid eye-liner Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

543 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 94 1 Revlon eye shadow Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% -<br />

544 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 95 1 Face make-up brushes Actual Cash Value 21.95 0.00 0.0% -<br />

545 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 96 1 Leather bracelet Actual Cash Value 13.17 1.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

546 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 97 1 Clinique eye-shadow Actual Cash Value 16.46 0.00 0.0% -<br />

547 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 98 1 Maybelline Shine free loose<br />

powder<br />

Actual Cash Value 5.42 0.00 0.0% -<br />

548 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 99 1 Cover girl clean make-up Actual Cash Value 6.41 0.00 0.0% -<br />

549 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 100 1 Clinique Sheer powder blush Actual Cash Value 20.85 0.00 0.0% -<br />

550 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 101 1 NYC Color wheel mosiac Actual Cash Value 5.48 0.00 0.0% -<br />

551 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 102 2 Orthodonic Teeth retainers Actual Cash Value 576.19 230.47 40.0% 2.0<br />

552 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 103 1 Make-up bag Actual Cash Value 18.66 0.00 0.0% -<br />

10/15/2012 11


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

553 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 104 1 Sally Hansen nail color Actual Cash Value 4.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

554 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 105 1 Milani Nail lacquer Actual Cash Value 3.59 1.19 33.2% 1.0<br />

555 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 106 1 NYC nail enamel Actual Cash Value 5.47 0.00 0.0% -<br />

556 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 107 1 Orly Nail lacquer Actual Cash Value 5.47 1.82 33.3% 1.0<br />

557 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 108 1 Wet n Wild nail color Actual Cash Value 2.15 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

558 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 109 1 Clinique Make-up palette Actual Cash Value 24.15 8.05 33.3% 1.0<br />

559 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 110 1 Comet w/ bleach disinfectant Actual Cash Value 1.01 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

560 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 111 1 Pledge Furniture polish Actual Cash Value 4.38 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

561 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 112 2 Energy saving lightbulbs Actual Cash Value 19.76 13.17 66.7% 2.0<br />

562 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 113 1 Bath and Body Works hand soap Actual Cash Value 4.94 3.29 66.5% 2.0<br />

563 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 114 1 Libman Plastic dustpan Actual Cash Value 7.68 3.07 40.0% 2.0<br />

564 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 115 1 Sponge Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.00 0.0% -<br />

565 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 116 1 Cotton dish towel Actual Cash Value 8.78 5.85 66.6% 2.0<br />

566 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 117 1 jar of vaseline Actual Cash Value 1.61 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

567 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 118 1 Garnier Fructis conditioner Actual Cash Value 3.28 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

568 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 119 1 JR Watkins hand soap Actual Cash Value 8.22 0.00 0.0% -<br />

569 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 120 1 Oxy Clean Spot treatment Actual Cash Value 3.83 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

570 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 121 1 Wire dish strainer Actual Cash Value 21.94 8.77 40.0% 2.0<br />

571 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 122 1 Rubber bounce ball Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.00 0.0% -<br />

572 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 123 1 Sylvania nite light and flashlight<br />

combo<br />

Actual Cash Value 13.17 2.63 20.0% 2.0<br />

573 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 124 1 Metal utencil tray Actual Cash Value 8.78 3.51 40.0% 2.0<br />

574 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 125 1 Rubber Maid Trash can Actual Cash Value 7.68 3.07 40.0% 1.0<br />

575 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 126 2 First Alert Fire extinguishers Actual Cash Value 49.39 9.87 20.0% 2.0<br />

576 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 127 2 McCloskey Special Effects<br />

Metallic glaze<br />

Actual Cash Value 21.95 14.63 66.7% 2.0<br />

577 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 128 1 McCloskey Special Effects Color<br />

glaze<br />

Actual Cash Value 10.98 7.32 66.7% 2.0<br />

578 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 129 1 Metal Paper towel dispenser Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0% 2.0<br />

579 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 131 1 Set of plastic cups Actual Cash Value 17.56 3.51 20.0% 1.0<br />

580 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 132 1 Glass flower vase Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9% 2.0<br />

581 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 133 1 Pack of ping-pong balls Actual Cash Value 1.72 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

582 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 134 4 10"x10" plastic dinner plates Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

583 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 135 4 8"x8" plastic salad plates Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

584 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 136 1 Daily Multi Iron tablets Actual Cash Value 10.98 7.32 66.7% 2.0<br />

585 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 137 1 Plastic 8" cup Actual Cash Value 3.29 1.31 39.8% 2.0<br />

586 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 138 1 Fridgidaire mini refridgerator Actual Cash Value 196.45 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

587 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 139 1 12" fan Actual Cash Value 21.95 0.00 0.0% -<br />

588 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 140 1 Plastic ruler with level Actual Cash Value 5.49 2.19 39.9% 2.0<br />

589 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 141 2 Boxes of nails Actual Cash Value 43.90 4.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

590 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 142 1 Roll of Scotch duct tape Actual Cash Value 8.78 5.85 66.6% 2.0<br />

591 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 143 1 Serilite Plastic container Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

592 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 145 1 Wood frame 3x2 Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.19 10.0% 2.0<br />

593 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 146 1 Wood Atlas Plaque Actual Cash Value 164.63 0.00 0.0% -<br />

594 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 148 1 Formica top art table w/ adjustable<br />

legs<br />

Actual Cash Value 109.75 29.26 26.7% 4.0<br />

595 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 149 2 Metal clamp-on table lamps Actual Cash Value 54.88 8.23 15.0% 1.5<br />

596 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 150 1 Plastic orgainzer Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

597 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 154 1 Woman's bra/ Target Actual Cash Value 17.56 0.00 0.0% -<br />

598 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 155 1 Piar of women's long pants/ Old<br />

Navy<br />

Actual Cash Value 7.68 2.56 33.3% 1.0<br />

599 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 156 1 Plastic drawer organizer Actual Cash Value 38.41 0.00 0.0% -<br />

600 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 157 1 Particle board bookshelf Actual Cash Value 49.39 9.87 20.0% 3.0<br />

10/15/2012 12


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

601 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 158 2 Canon Ink cartridges Actual Cash Value 43.90 0.00 0.0% -<br />

602 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 159 1 Pack of note pads Actual Cash Value 14.49 4.83 33.3% 1.0<br />

603 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 160 1 Atrium Artist knife Actual Cash Value 10.98 3.29 30.0% 3.0<br />

604 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 161 12 Deco-color Art markers Actual Cash Value 43.90 29.26 66.7% 2.0<br />

605 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 163 1 Itoya Art portfolio Actual Cash Value 10.42 0.00 0.0% -<br />

606 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 164 1 Sanford water color markers Actual Cash Value 13.17 10.53 80.0% 3.0<br />

607 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 165 1 Windsor and Newton Oil paint Actual Cash Value 8.78 7.02 80.0% 4.0<br />

608 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 166 5 Windsor and Newton Oil color Actual Cash Value 43.90 35.12 80.0% 4.0<br />

609 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 167 1 Tablet of Art paper Actual Cash Value 17.56 11.70 66.6% 2.0<br />

610 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 168 1 Unisphore Mirophone model Actual Cash Value 43.90 35.12 80.0% 9.0<br />

611 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 169 1 26x20 poster Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

612 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 170 1 Can of linseed oil Actual Cash Value 9.88 7.90 80.0% 3.0<br />

613 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 171 1 Pack of charcoal pencils Actual Cash Value 10.98 8.78 80.0% 3.0<br />

614 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 172 1 Template kit / Berol Rapidesign Actual Cash Value 16.46 3.29 20.0% 2.0<br />

615 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 173 1 Grumbacher Pastel pencils Actual Cash Value 38.41 3.84 10.0%<br />

616 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 174 1 Prisma Color Nu Pastel set Actual Cash Value 6.59 2.19 33.2% 1.0<br />

617 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 175 1 8x4 plastic container Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

618 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 176 1 Jar of brush cleaner Actual Cash Value 7.68 5.12 66.7% 2.0<br />

619 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 177 1 Oil color tube Actual Cash Value 13.17 8.78 66.7% 2.0<br />

620 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 178 1 Can of mineral spirits Actual Cash Value 16.46 10.97 66.7% 2.0<br />

621 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 179 1 Painters Touch Spray Paint Actual Cash Value 8.78 5.85 66.6% 2.0<br />

622 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 180 1 Wood case of Reeves Art supplies Actual Cash Value 36.22 12.07 33.3% 1.0<br />

623 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 181 2 Jars of Benjamin Moore color<br />

samples<br />

Actual Cash Value 13.17 8.78 66.7% 2.0<br />

624 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 182 2 Jars of Grumbacher painting oil Actual Cash Value 21.95 7.31 33.3% 1.0<br />

625 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 183 1 Exacto knife Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

626 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 184 1 Box of Cray-Pas colors Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

627 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 185 1 Alphabet rubber stamp Actual Cash Value 32.93 6.58 20.0% 1.0<br />

628 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 186 1 Can of Matte Spray fix Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.00 0.0% -<br />

629 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 187 1 Elmers glue tube Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.00 0.0% -<br />

630 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 188 6 Pairs of Women's plastic<br />

sunglasses<br />

Actual Cash Value 109.75 5.48 5.0% 1.5<br />

631 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 189 2 Clothing pins Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

632 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 190 2 Beaded necklace Actual Cash Value 21.95 8.78 40.0% 2.0<br />

633 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 191 1 Beaded ring Actual Cash Value 32.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

634 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 192 1 14x10 canvas painting board Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

635 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 193 1 His Grooming Set wax Actual Cash Value 4.39 2.63 59.9% 3.0<br />

636 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 194 1 Taccia Ink pen well w/ case Actual Cash Value 32.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

637 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 195 2 Plastic hair clips Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

638 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 196 1 Paper binder with hard cover Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

639 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 197 1 Pack of business cards Actual Cash Value 16.46 3.29 20.0% 1.0<br />

640 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 198 2 Sargeant brand water colours Actual Cash Value 27.44 9.14 33.3% 1.0<br />

641 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 199 1 Metal framed folding laundry<br />

hamper<br />

Actual Cash Value 4.39 1.75 39.9% 2.0<br />

642 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 200 1 Metal paint can opener Actual Cash Value 3.29 1.31 39.8% 2.0<br />

643 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 201 1 Box of LED tap lights Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.54 9.8% 1.0<br />

644 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 202 1 Plastic clip-on digital stop watch Actual Cash Value 60.36 12.07 20.0% 2.0<br />

645 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 203 1 Metal and Turquois bracelet Actual Cash Value 16.46 0.00 0.0% -<br />

646 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 204 1 Car cell phone charger Actual Cash Value 9.88 1.97 19.9% 1.0<br />

647 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 205 4 Beaded necklaces Actual Cash Value 32.93 13.17 40.0% 2.0<br />

648 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 206 2 Beaded bracelets Actual Cash Value 13.17 7.90 60.0% 3.0<br />

649 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 207 1 Metal necklace with charm Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

650 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 208 3 2x2 tiles Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 13


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

651 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 209 4 Hi-lighter marker pens Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

652 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 211 1 Satin 3x2 Coin purse Actual Cash Value 10.98 8.78 80.0% 2.0<br />

653 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 212 1 Voluspa candle with holder Actual Cash Value 26.34 8.78 33.3% 1.0<br />

654 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 213 1 Hair Now magazine Actual Cash Value 7.67 3.83 49.9% 1.0<br />

655 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 214 1 Conair pocket mirror Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.16 4.9% 1.0<br />

656 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 215 1 Binder 8x15 Actual Cash Value 19.76 0.00 0.0% -<br />

657 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 216 1 3" Glass candle holder Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.37 25.0% 1.0<br />

658 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 217 1 Pack of hair curlers Actual Cash Value 4.39 2.63 59.9% 3.0<br />

659 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 218 1 Portable Air Conditioner / Goldstar Actual Cash Value 208.53 41.70 20.0% 2.0<br />

660 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 220 1 Casio watch Actual Cash Value 87.80 17.56 20.0% 4.0<br />

661 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 221 1 Pier 1 Plate Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.82 24.9% 1.0<br />

662 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 223 1 Storage container Actual Cash Value 5.48 2.19 40.0% 1.0<br />

663 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 224 1 Ikea plastic container Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

664 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 225 1 Pack of index cards Actual Cash Value 4.39 1.46 33.3% 1.0<br />

665 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 226 1 Plastic trash can Actual Cash Value 3.29 1.31 39.8% 2.0<br />

666 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 227 1 Steel trashcan Actual Cash Value 38.41 7.68 20.0% 2.0<br />

667 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 228 22 Plastic closet hangers Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 1.0<br />

668 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 229 1 Manilla art folder 50x26 Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

669 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 230 1 Target brand candle Actual Cash Value 8.78 2.92 33.3% 1.0<br />

670 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 231 1 Metal jewlery tree Actual Cash Value 65.85 6.58 10.0% 1.0<br />

671 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 233 1 Power Sentry Surge protector Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.96 12.5% 1.0<br />

672 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 234 3 Craft glue sticks Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0% -<br />

673 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 235 2 Rubbermaid storage bins Actual Cash Value 39.49 3.94 10.0% 1.0<br />

674 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 236 2 Carboard boxes w/ lids Actual Cash Value 16.46 4.93 30.0% 3.0<br />

675 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 237 9 Tubes of Winton oil colors Actual Cash Value 49.29 16.43 33.3% 2.0<br />

676 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 238 1 Tube of Winton Oil colour Actual Cash Value 5.49 3.66 66.7% 2.0<br />

677 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 239 1 Spacemaker Container Actual Cash Value 2.20 0.44 20.0% 1.0<br />

678 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 240 1 Box of coloured pencils Actual Cash Value 10.98 7.32 66.7% 2.0<br />

679 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 241 1 Box of Prismacolor colored pencils Actual Cash Value 18.66 6.22 33.3% -<br />

680 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 242 1 Pack if Fine point markers / Pentel Actual Cash Value 29.63 19.75 66.7% 2.0<br />

681 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 243 2 Plastic pen containers Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

682 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 244 2 Cans of Krylon spray paint Actual Cash Value 15.37 5.12 33.3% 1.0<br />

683 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 245 2 Cans of Spray enamel Actual Cash Value 15.37 5.12 33.3% 1.0<br />

684 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 246 1 Box of Metal folder clips Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.7% 2.0<br />

685 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 247 1 Papermate liquid paper Actual Cash Value 3.29 1.64 49.9% 1.0<br />

686 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 248 1 Pencil Sharpener- Battery<br />

powered<br />

Actual Cash Value 12.07 1.20 9.9% 1.0<br />

687 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 249 4 Pack of led f/ mechanical pencils Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 1.0<br />

688 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 250 1 Metal single hole punch Actual Cash Value 6.59 0.65 9.9% 1.0<br />

689 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 251 3 Wood rulers Actual Cash Value 6.59 0.65 9.9% 1.0<br />

690 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 252 1 Pair of scissors Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.76 9.9% 2.0<br />

691 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 253 1 6" drinking glass Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.32 9.7% 2.0<br />

692 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 254 18 Sharpe markers Actual Cash Value 13.17 4.39 33.3% 1.0<br />

693 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 255 29 Misc ink pens Actual Cash Value 32.93 10.97 33.3% 1.0<br />

694 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 256 33 Misc wood pencils Actual Cash Value 38.41 7.68 20.0% 1.0<br />

695 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 257 1 Box of holiday fold-over cards Actual Cash Value 27.44 2.74 10.0% 1.0<br />

696 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 258 2 Packs of flat cards Actual Cash Value 19.75 1.97 10.0% 1.0<br />

697 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 259 1 Pack of Flat cards Actual Cash Value 3.28 0.32 9.8% -<br />

698 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 260 1 Pack of circle stickers Actual Cash Value 7.19 0.00 0.0% -<br />

699 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 261 1 Holiday greeting cards Actual Cash Value 5.98 0.59 9.9% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 14


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

700 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 262 1 Box of white envelopes Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.76 9.9% 1.0<br />

701 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 263 1 Box of Thank you Cards Actual Cash Value 18.11 1.81 10.0% 1.0<br />

702 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 264 1 Plastic organizer Actual Cash Value 10.98 6.58 59.9% 2.0<br />

703 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 265 1 Box of Photo cards Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.19 10.0% 2.0<br />

704 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 266 1 Miniature address book Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

705 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 267 4 Greeting Art Cards Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.19 10.0% 1.0<br />

706 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 268 20 Embroidered greeting cards Actual Cash Value 28.54 2.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

707 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 269 1 Box of greeting cards Actual Cash Value 38.41 3.84 10.0% 1.0<br />

708 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 270 2 Packs of notecards Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.19 10.0% 1.0<br />

709 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 271 1 Box of Filofax cards w/ envelps Actual Cash Value 87.80 8.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

710 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 275 2 Star ornaments Actual Cash Value 17.56 4.39 25.0% 1.0<br />

711 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 277 1 Ikea table lamp Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0% 2.0<br />

712 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 278 5 Vinyl 3-ring binders Actual Cash Value 17.56 5.85 33.3% 1.0<br />

713 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 279 11 Craft Acrylic paints Actual Cash Value 87.80 29.26 33.3% 1.0<br />

714 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 280 7 Tubes of Acrylic Color Actual Cash Value 38.41 12.80 33.3% 1.0<br />

715 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 281 1 Tube of Acrylic paint Actual Cash Value 13.17 4.39 33.3% 1.0<br />

716 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 282 4 Benjamin moore color samples Actual Cash Value 26.34 8.78 33.3% 2.0<br />

717 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 283 1 Box of Pantel watercolors Actual Cash Value 13.17 4.39 33.3% 1.0<br />

718 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 284 4 Paint sponges w/ handels Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 1.0<br />

719 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 285 40 Misc art brushes Actual Cash Value 131.70 26.34 20.0% 1.0<br />

720 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 286 1 Plastic accordian folder Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

721 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 287 2 Packages of handmade cardstock Actual Cash Value 16.46 0.00 0.0% -<br />

722 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 288 2 Sealy posturepedic medium sup Actual Cash Value 43.90 29.26 66.7% 2.0<br />

723 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 289 2 24x24 pillows Actual Cash Value 49.39 32.92 66.7% 2.0<br />

724 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 292 1 7x6 electric blanket Actual Cash Value 98.78 28.22 28.6% 2.0<br />

725 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 294 1 Ikea plastic wall clock Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 2.0<br />

726 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 295 1 Cotton full size bed sheet Actual Cash Value 21.95 8.78 40.0% 2.0<br />

727 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 296 1 Acrylic polyester blanket Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

728 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 297 2 Pair of women's leather shoes Actual Cash Value 43.90 14.63 33.3% 1.0<br />

729 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 298 1 Pair of women's flip flops Actual Cash Value 38.41 25.60 66.7% 2.0<br />

730 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 299 1 Pair of women's canvass shoes Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

731 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 300 2 Pair of women's leather sandals Actual Cash Value 49.39 0.00 0.0% -<br />

732 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 301 2 Women's leather heels Actual Cash Value 65.85 0.00 0.0% -<br />

733 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 302 2 Women's leather sandals Actual Cash Value 49.39 0.00 0.0% -<br />

734 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 303 2 Women's leather boots Actual Cash Value 65.85 0.00 0.0% -<br />

735 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 304 1 Woman's running shoes Actual Cash Value 43.90 0.00 0.0% -<br />

736 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 305 3 Canvas shoe hangers Actual Cash Value 43.90 8.78 20.0% 1.0<br />

737 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 306 2 Old Navy flip flops Actual Cash Value 10.98 3.65 33.3% 1.0<br />

738 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 307 1 Sandals Actual Cash Value 32.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

739 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 308 1 Women's leather heels Actual Cash Value 38.41 0.00 0.0% -<br />

740 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 309 1 Women's Leather Makison shoes Actual Cash Value 87.80 0.00 0.0% -<br />

741 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 310 2 Women's leather shoes Actual Cash Value 186.58 0.00 0.0% -<br />

742 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 311 1 Women's leather heels Actual Cash Value 87.80 0.00 0.0% -<br />

743 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 312 1 Women's leather heels Actual Cash Value 32.93 10.97 33.3% 1.0<br />

744 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 313 1 Women's leather sandals Actual Cash Value 38.41 0.00 0.0% -<br />

745 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 314 1 Women's black purse Actual Cash Value 181.09 0.00 0.0% -<br />

746 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 315 1 10x5 Canvas makeup bag Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

747 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 316 1 Nylon carry on bag Actual Cash Value 54.88 10.97 20.0% 1.0<br />

748 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 317 1 Nylon beach bag Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

749 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 318 2 Woman's cotton purse Actual Cash Value 93.29 46.64 50.0% 1.0<br />

750 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 319 1 Vinyl purse 20x14 Actual Cash Value 21.95 17.56 80.0% 2.0<br />

751 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 320 1 Leather purse Actual Cash Value 43.90 29.26 66.7% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 15


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

752 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 321 1 Nylon compact umbrella Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.19 20.0% 1.0<br />

753 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 322 1 18x18 wool purse Actual Cash Value 38.41 12.80 33.3% 1.0<br />

754 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 323 1 15x15 Old navy Cotton Purse Actual Cash Value 21.95 17.56 80.0% 2.0<br />

755 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 324 1 Woman's leather purse Actual Cash Value 43.90 14.63 33.3% 1.0<br />

756 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 325 1 Canvas backpack / North Face Actual Cash Value 65.85 26.34 40.0% 2.0<br />

757 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 326 1 Rayon Scarf 5x4 Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% -<br />

758 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 328 1 pair of mens snow gloves Actual Cash Value 65.85 26.34 40.0% 2.0<br />

759 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 329 1 Wilson volleyball Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

760 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 330 2 Greatland sleeping bag Actual Cash Value 137.19 27.43 20.0% 2.0<br />

761 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 331 1 Cotton full-size blanket Actual Cash Value 65.85 26.34 40.0% 2.0<br />

762 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 333 1 Pair of Scot Ski goggles Actual Cash Value 65.85 26.34 40.0% 2.0<br />

763 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 334 1 Wook 8-hook wall mount hanger Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.92 13.3% 2.0<br />

764 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 335 2 Old Navy denim shorts Actual Cash Value 32.93 21.95 66.7% 2.0<br />

765 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 336 1 Apple keyboard Actual Cash Value 60.36 10.06 16.7% 1.0<br />

766 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 338 2 Old Navy cotton shorts Actual Cash Value 32.93 10.97 33.3% 1.0<br />

767 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 339 4 Cotton tshirts Actual Cash Value 87.80 43.90 50.0% 1.0<br />

768 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 340 1 Canvas CD case Actual Cash Value 54.88 21.95 40.0% 2.0<br />

769 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 341 1 Reusable grocery bag Actual Cash Value 12.07 0.00 0.0% -<br />

770 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 342 1 Full size matress cotton sheet Actual Cash Value 32.93 13.17 40.0% 2.0<br />

771 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 343 1 National Sleep products home Actual Cash Value 43.90 17.56 40.0% 2.0<br />

772 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 344 1 6 cd-rom set Actual Cash Value 54.88 36.58 66.7% 2.0<br />

773 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 345 3 G&G ink cartridges Actual Cash Value 49.39 0.00 0.0% -<br />

774 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 346 1 Woman's braided leather belt Actual Cash Value 43.90 0.00 0.0% -<br />

775 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 347 2 Woman's vinyl belt Actual Cash Value 27.44 13.72 50.0% 1.0<br />

776 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 348 1 Woman's leather belt w/ silver Actual Cash Value 60.36 0.00 0.0% -<br />

777 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 349 1 Wood framed ikea sofa chair Actual Cash Value 104.26 20.85 20.0% 2.0<br />

778 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 350 1 20x16 canvas art board Actual Cash Value 16.46 1.64 10.0% 1.0<br />

779 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 351 1 Pair of Uggs Actual Cash Value 170.11 113.40 66.7% 2.0<br />

780 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 352 1 Plastic art bin Actual Cash Value 32.93 13.17 40.0% 2.0<br />

781 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 353 1 Package drafting dots Actual Cash Value 4.39 0.00 0.0% -<br />

782 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 354 1 Plastic container Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 1.0<br />

783 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 355 1 Package of prismatic colored<br />

pencils<br />

Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

784 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 356 1 2.5x2.5 art pencil eraser Actual Cash Value 3.29 1.09 33.1% 1.0<br />

785 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 357 1 2 lbs of misc beads Actual Cash Value 27.44 10.97 40.0% 2.0<br />

786 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 358 1 14x10 metal baking pan Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.64 14.9% 3.0<br />

787 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 359 1 Box of miniature quilt Actual Cash Value 16.46 2.46 15.0% 3.0<br />

788 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 360 1 Plastic container Actual Cash Value 7.68 3.07 40.0% 2.0<br />

789 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 361 1 Roll of blue scotch masking tape Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0% -<br />

790 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 362 42 Prismacolor premier large art Actual Cash Value 164.63 109.75 66.7% 2.0<br />

791 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 363 1 Metal cup Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9% 1.0<br />

792 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 364 6 Containers of Seed beads Actual Cash Value 54.88 10.97 20.0% 1.0<br />

793 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 365 1 18pc graphite set Actual Cash Value 32.93 10.97 33.3% 1.0<br />

794 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 366 1 Stanley screwdriver Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.76 9.9% 2.0<br />

795 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 367 1 Metal protractor Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.76 9.9% 2.0<br />

796 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 368 1 Deck of artist trading cards Actual Cash Value 32.93 9.87 30.0% 3.0<br />

797 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 369 1 Cotton apron Actual Cash Value 16.46 6.58 40.0% 2.0<br />

798 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 370 1 LG Cell phone Actual Cash Value 54.88 21.95 40.0% 2.0<br />

799 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 371 1 Boston paper cutter Actual Cash Value 76.83 7.68 10.0% 1.0<br />

800 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 372 2 Art cubes Actual Cash Value 38.41 3.84 10.0% 0.5<br />

801 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 373 1 6x6 Metal cup Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9% 1.0<br />

802 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 375 1 Palm One Communicator Actual Cash Value 60.36 24.14 40.0% 2.0<br />

803 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 376 1 Stanley Bostich stapler Actual Cash Value 7.68 1.53 19.9% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 16


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

804 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 379 1 Dual wattage converter Actual Cash Value 49.39 9.87 20.0% 2.0<br />

805 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 380 7 TI Calculator Actual Cash Value 109.75 21.95 20.0% 2.0<br />

806 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 381 1 Plastic pencil tray Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 2.0<br />

807 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 382 1 Fire wire USB Actual Cash Value 43.90 14.63 33.3% 1.0<br />

808 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 384 1 Canon printer Actual Cash Value 60.36 0.00 0.0% -<br />

809 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 385 1 Plastic art bin Actual Cash Value 43.90 8.78 20.0% 2.0<br />

810 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 386 1 Itoya Storage display book Actual Cash Value 48.29 0.00 0.0% -<br />

811 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 387 2 Plastic beaded picture frames Actual Cash Value 65.85 3.29 5.0% 1.0<br />

812 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 388 1 Mead academic sketch pad Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

813 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 389 1 Plastic picture frame Actual Cash Value 32.93 1.64 5.0% 1.0<br />

814 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 390 1 7x5 metal frame Actual Cash Value 21.95 1.09 5.0% 1.0<br />

815 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 391 1 Kids art fun station Actual Cash Value 14.27 4.28 30.0% 3.0<br />

816 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 392 1 Notebook tablet Actual Cash Value 16.46 5.48 33.3% 1.0<br />

817 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 393 1 Plastic cup Actual Cash Value 5.49 2.19 39.9% 2.0<br />

818 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 394 2 Osh spray enamel cans Actual Cash Value 17.56 5.85 33.3% 1.0<br />

819 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 395 1 Krylon Spray paint can Actual Cash Value 7.68 2.56 33.3% 1.0<br />

820 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 396 1 Canvass art bag Actual Cash Value 27.44 5.48 20.0% 1.0<br />

821 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 478 1 Brown Suede heels Actual Cash Value 164.63 0.00 0.0% -<br />

822 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 479 1 Black heels Actual Cash Value 32.93 0.00 0.0% -<br />

823 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 480 1 Red & Blue leather dress shoes Actual Cash Value 43.90 0.00 0.0% -<br />

824 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 481 1 Brown boots / Xhileration Actual Cash Value 49.39 32.92 66.7% 2.0<br />

825 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 482 1 White boots Actual Cash Value 82.31 54.87 66.7% 2.0<br />

826 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 483 1 Black leather vintage handbag Actual Cash Value 87.80 29.26 33.3% 1.0<br />

827 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 484 2 Knappe pendant lamps Actual Cash Value 82.31 16.46 20.0% 2.0<br />

828 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 485 2 Posters: Dolce Vita and Bob Dylan Actual Cash Value 82.31 8.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

829 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 486 10 Plastic 4x6 frames Actual Cash Value 60.36 6.03 10.0% 1.0<br />

830 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 487 1 Brown woven curtain Actual Cash Value 60.36 40.24 66.7% 2.0<br />

831 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 488 1 Crystal nail file Actual Cash Value 13.17 0.00 0.0% -<br />

832 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 489 3 Original art work Actual Cash Value 164.63 12.34 7.5% 1.5<br />

833 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 490 25 Clothing: 8 shirts, 2 cotton Actual Cash Value 768.25 384.12 50.0% 2.5<br />

834 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 491 8 Window blind sets Actual Cash Value 878.00 175.60 20.0% 2.0<br />

835 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 492 1 6x8 Oriental rug carpet Actual Cash Value 274.38 32.92 12.0% 3.0<br />

836 54 75-M566-207 4/8/2010 493 3 Wall adobe pot planters Actual Cash Value 82.31 20.57 25.0% 2.0<br />

1 837 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 1 1 Futon Mattress ACV 139.75 69.88 50.0% 19.0<br />

838 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 2 1 Cardboard shoe rack ACV 6.45 3.23 50.0% 18.0<br />

839 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 3 1 Suit Case ACV 37.63 7.53 20.0% 29.0<br />

840 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 4 1 Garment bag ACV 53.75 10.75 20.0% 6.0<br />

841 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 5 1 Basket ACV 26.88 8.98 33.3% 10.0<br />

842 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 6 1 Doormat ACV 16.13 9.68 60.0% 3.0<br />

843 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 7 5 A night of questions ACV 96.75 8.06 8.3% 0.3<br />

844 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 8 1 Skint nails ACV 9.62 3.21 33.3% 0.3<br />

845 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 9 1 More Stories to Solve ACV 2.14 0.71 33.3%<br />

846 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 10 1 The Passover Journey ACV 6.44 2.15 33.3%<br />

847 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 11 1 Seashore Life of SoCal ACV 2.13 0.71 33.3%<br />

848 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 12 1 3001 Final Odyssey ACV 9.66 3.22 33.3%<br />

849 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 13 1 Rumpole and The Bungalow ACV 26.82 2.98 11.1% 0.3<br />

850 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 14 1 Sense and Sensability ACV 7.47 2.49 33.3%<br />

851 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 15 1 The Red Tent ACV 16.07 5.36 33.3%<br />

852 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 16 1 PWK Cotton Yarn ACV 5.38 1.79 33.3% 20.0<br />

853 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 17 1 Pewter Frame ACV 6.45 0.65 10.0%<br />

854 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 19 1 A Different Night ACV 12.90 4.30 33.3% 4.0<br />

855 150 55-F969-790 8/29/2005 20 1 Mah Nishtannah ACV 21.50 7.17 33.3% 6.0<br />

1 856 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 1 1 Lady of Guadalupe Statute ACV 107.75 26.94 25.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 17


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

857 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 2 1 Lady of Guadalupe sm statute ACV 53.88 13.47 25.0% 3.0<br />

858 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 3 1 Picture of Guadalupe ACV 91.59 27.48 30.0% 6.0<br />

859 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 4 1 Virgin Mary Statute ACV 26.94 6.74 25.0% 1.0<br />

860 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 5 1 St. Martin Statute ACV 26.94 6.74 25.0% 1.0<br />

861 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 6 1 St. Peter Statute ACV 26.94 6.74 25.0% 1.0<br />

862 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 7 1 School Pictures ACV 32.00 0.00 0.0% -<br />

863 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 8 1 Pearl Earrings ACV 215.50 21.55 10.0% 9.0<br />

864 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 9 1 Hearing Aid ACV 1,562.38 156.24 10.0% 1.0<br />

865 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 10 1 Gold Chain w/ Cross ACV 161.63 72.73 45.0% 9.0<br />

866 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 11 1 Eye Glasses ACV 159.47 15.95 10.0% 1.0<br />

867 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 12 1 Small Heater ACV 32.33 0.00 0.0% -<br />

868 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 16 1 Jacket- leather bomber ACV 199.99 159.99 80.0% 4.0<br />

869 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 17 1 Jacket- Suede ACV 119.99 96.99 80.0% 6.0<br />

870 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 18 1 Jacket- cowboy/leather ACV 150.00 120.00 80.0% 6.0<br />

871 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 21 1 King size mattress ACV 862.94 172.59 20.0% 4.0<br />

872 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 22 1 Sony TV 27" ACV 399.99 233.33 58.3% 7.0<br />

873 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 23 1 Stereo ACV 249.95 31.24 12.5% 1.0<br />

874 154 55-F953-632 3/18/2005 24 1 CD-(3) Vincent Fernandez ACV 47.97 23.99 50.0% 1.0<br />

1 875 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 1 1 40" screen TV, LCD Panel HDTV ACV 985.32 164.22 2.0<br />

876 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 4 1 Rainbow Vacuum SE ACV 1,368.50 1,094.80 10.0<br />

877 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 7 3 Picture Frames, 8x10 ACV 65.69 3.28 1.0<br />

878 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 8 1 Budha Statue ACV 43.78 21.89 1.0<br />

879 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 11 1 3 ga. Stainless Boiling pot ACV 43.78 6.56 3.0<br />

880 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 12 1 Nativity Statues ACV 54.73 27.36 10.0<br />

881 156 55-E124-263 8/28/2012 13 2 Plastic Organizer on Wheels ACV 142.32 85.39 3.0<br />

1 882 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 7 2 Blankets ACV 86.38 17.28 20.0% 1.0<br />

883 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 8 2 Hardwood Flooring - uninstalled ACV 82.08 4.10 5.0% 0.8<br />

884 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 9 1 Hallway rug 22" x 60" ACV 43.19 1.91 4.4% 0.8<br />

885 142 55-E023-943 9/7/2007 10 1 Bathroom rug set ACV 32.39 1.89 5.8% 0.6<br />

1 886 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 1 1 9x12 shed / Wood Building ACV 2,681.25 715.00 26.7% 4.0<br />

887 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 2 1 Old Trunk ACV 321.75 257.40 80.0% 70.0<br />

888 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 3 1 Lawn Mower ACV 193.05 96.53 50.0% 5.0<br />

889 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 4 1 Electric Circular Saw / Sears<br />

Craftsman<br />

ACV 42.90 12.87 30.0% 3.0<br />

890 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 5 1 Electric Chain Saw / Remmington ACV 53.63 16.09 30.0% 3.0<br />

891 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 6 1 Power Chain Saw / McCulloch ACV 139.42 6.97 5.0% 0.5<br />

892 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 7 1 Wool Blanket ACV 69.71 52.28 75.0% 3.0<br />

893 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 8 1 Microwave ACV 85.80 62.40 72.7% 8.0<br />

894 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 9 1 Gaw Weed Wacker ACV 96.53 4.02 4.2% 0.5<br />

895 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 10 1 Power Washer / Campbell<br />

Hausteld<br />

ACV 160.88 48.26 30.0% 3.0<br />

896 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 11 1 Singer Sewing Machine ACV 321.75 201.09 62.5% 15.0<br />

897 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 12 1 Full Size Sleeper Sofa ACV 643.50 128.70 20.0% 3.0<br />

898 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 13 1 Antique Table ACV 214.50 85.80 40.0% 6.0<br />

899 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 14 1 Exercise Machin / Glider ACV 187.69 112.61 60.0% 3.0<br />

900 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 15 1 Rod N Reel & Tackle Box ACV 32.17 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

901 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 16 1 Telescoping Pole for Painting ACV 85.80 17.16 20.0% 4.0<br />

902 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 17 1 Bassinette / Kolocraft ACV 133.93 83.71 62.5% 5.0<br />

903 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 18 1 Britax Child Car Seat ACV 320.68 200.43 62.5% 5.0<br />

904 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 19 1 Infant Car Seat / Graco ACV 107.24 67.03 62.5% 5.0<br />

905 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 20 1 Child Safety Gate / Safety Lat ACV 21.44 13.40 62.5% 5.0<br />

906 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 21 1 Diaper Bag / Fisher Price ACV 32.17 25.74 80.0% 5.0<br />

10/15/2012 18


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

907 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 22 1 Stroller Sleeper / Kolocraft ACV 160.88 128.70 80.0% 13.0<br />

908 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 23 14 Receiving Blankets ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 6.0<br />

909 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 24 3 Crib Blankets ACV 96.53 77.22 80.0% 10.5<br />

910 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 25 1 Bar Seat Cover / Britax ACV 42.90 34.32 80.0% 5.0<br />

911 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 26 3 Crib Sheets ACV 21.45 17.16 80.0% 7.0<br />

912 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 27 6 Bed Pillows ACV 96.53 32.18 33.3%<br />

913 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 28 10 Infant Gowns ACV 80.44 64.35 80.0% 4.0<br />

914 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 29 9 Fuzzy Sleepers ACV 85.80 68.64 80.0% 3.0<br />

915 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 30 13 Little Girl Dressy Dresses ACV 278.85 223.08 80.0% 4.0<br />

916 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 31 6 Boys Suits ACV 193.05 154.44 80.0% 3.0<br />

917 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 32 6 Sweat Suits ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 3.0<br />

918 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 33 13 T Shirts Short Sleeve ACV 198.41 158.73 80.0% 3.0<br />

919 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 34 10 Long Sleeve T Shirts ACV 160.88 128.70 80.0% 2.0<br />

920 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 35 5 Boys Cargo Pants ACV 150.15 120.12 80.0% 3.0<br />

921 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 36 6 Sweat pants ACV 53.63 35.75 66.7% 2.0<br />

922 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 37 3 Boys Dress Shirts ACV 32.17 21.45 66.7% 2.0<br />

923 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 38 4 Casual Dress - Girls ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 2.0<br />

924 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 39 15 Infant Sleepers ACV 193.05 154.44 80.0% 4.0<br />

925 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 40 5 Girls Overalls ACV 107.25 85.80 80.0% 3.0<br />

926 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 41 1 Hooded Sleevless Jacket ACV 26.81 17.87 66.7% 2.0<br />

927 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 42 1 Rebok Sweatshirt ACV 32.17 25.74 80.0% 5.0<br />

928 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 43 2 Girls Body Suit ACV 10.73 8.58 80.0% 3.0<br />

929 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 44 3 Shorts Childrens / Dockers ACV 48.26 38.61 80.0% 4.0<br />

930 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 45 7 Jean Shorts ACV 75.07 60.06 80.0% 3.5<br />

931 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 46 1 Long Sleeve Polo ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 3.0<br />

932 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 47 1 Hooded T Shirt ACV 21.45 14.30 66.7% 2.0<br />

933 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 48 3 TurtleNeck ACV 28.96 23.17 80.0% 3.0<br />

934 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 49 9 Polo Shirt ACV 193.05 154.44 80.0% 2.0<br />

935 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 50 1 Button Down Sweater ACV 37.54 30.03 80.0% 2.0<br />

936 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 51 3 Pants Boys ACV 80.44 64.35 80.0% 4.0<br />

937 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 52 2 All in One Jump Suit ACV 42.90 34.32 80.0% 3.0<br />

938 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 53 1 Lace Up Jeans ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 2.0<br />

939 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 54 12 Onesies ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 3.0<br />

940 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 55 5 Baby Tees ACV 10.73 8.58 80.0% 3.0<br />

941 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 56 8 Pair Boys Dress Shoes ACV 171.60 137.28 80.0% 4.0<br />

942 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 57 4 Girls Dress Shoes ACV 60.06 48.05 80.0% 3.5<br />

943 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 58 10 Boys Casual Shoes ACV 268.12 214.50 80.0% 4.0<br />

944 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 59 6 Casual Shoes Girls ACV 85.80 68.64 80.0% 4.0<br />

945 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 60 2 Baby Bunting ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 5.0<br />

946 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 61 7 Infant Mittens ACV 5.36 4.29 80.0% 5.0<br />

947 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 62 7 Infant Booties ACV 5.36 4.29 80.0% 5.0<br />

948 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 63 2 Quilted Infant Jackets ACV 21.45 17.16 80.0% 5.0<br />

949 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 64 2 School Uniform Dresses ACV 42.90 21.45 50.0% 1.0<br />

950 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 65 2 Sweat Pants ACV 21.45 17.16 80.0% 3.0<br />

951 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 66 6 Boys Long Sleeve Polo Shirt ACV 96.53 77.22 80.0% 2.0<br />

952 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 67 6 Sweat Suits ACV 107.25 85.80 80.0% 3.0<br />

953 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 68 7 Long Jeans ACV 225.23 180.18 80.0% 5.0<br />

954 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 69 5 Short Jeans ACV 134.06 107.25 80.0% 5.0<br />

955 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 70 5 girls T With Design ACV 107.25 85.80 80.0% 2.0<br />

956 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 71 9 Girls Tops ACV 144.79 115.83 80.0% 2.0<br />

957 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 72 1 Skirt Jacket ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 3.0<br />

958 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 73 2 Hooded Fleece Jacket ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 3.0<br />

959 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 74 4 Boys Pants ACV 85.80 68.64 80.0% 2.0<br />

960 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 75 1 Commertatory T ACV 8.58 6.86 80.0% 24.0<br />

10/15/2012 19


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

961 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 76 1 Lands End Jacket Womens ACV 96.53 77.22 80.0% 3.0<br />

962 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 77 1 Winter Jacket ACV 107.25 85.80 80.0% 4.0<br />

963 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 78 1 Adult Sweat Pants ACV 16.09 12.87 80.0% 3.0<br />

964 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 79 7 Pants ACV 42.90 34.32 80.0% 4.0<br />

965 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 80 1 Satin Gown Long Sleeve ACV 21.45 17.16 80.0% 2.0<br />

966 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 81 1 Heavy T Long PJs ACV 32.17 21.45 66.7% 2.0<br />

967 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 82 1 Zip Wool Jacket ACV 69.71 55.77 80.0% 3.0<br />

968 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 83 1 Heavy Knit Sweater ACV 85.80 68.64 80.0% 2.0<br />

969 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 84 1 Coat W Zippered Lining ACV 160.88 107.25 66.7% 2.0<br />

970 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 85 1 Caftan Women w Fringe ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 4.0<br />

971 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 86 1 Cotton Long Shirt Button Down ACV 26.81 13.41 50.0% 3.0<br />

972 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 87 1 Heavy Knit Skirt Set ACV 53.63 42.90 80.0% 2.0<br />

973 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 88 3 Button Down Shirts ACV 80.44 64.35 80.0% 2.0<br />

974 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 89 7 Short Sleeve Polo Shirt ACV 150.15 120.12 80.0% 3.0<br />

975 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 90 5 PJs Boys ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 3.0<br />

976 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 91 9 Womens Dresses / Carol Little ACV 1,147.57 918.05 80.0% 15.5<br />

977 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 92 5 3 Piece Pant Suits / Carol Little ACV 804.38 643.50 80.0% 15.5<br />

978 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 93 1 Blue Jacket ACV 160.88 128.70 80.0% 3.0<br />

979 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 94 1 Small Girdle ACV 26.81 21.45 80.0% 3.0<br />

980 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 95 4 Sheer Dress Blouses ACV 107.25 85.80 80.0% 4.0<br />

981 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 96 17 Adult Shirts w/ Writing ACV 273.49 218.79 80.0% 7.0<br />

982 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 97 3 T Outfits ACV 48.26 38.61 80.0% 2.0<br />

983 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 98 1 Capri Pants ACV 21.45 17.16 80.0% 2.0<br />

984 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 99 3 T Shirt Dress ACV 64.35 51.46 80.0% 2.0<br />

985 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 100 5 Shorts ACV 80.44 64.35 80.0% 3.0<br />

986 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 101 6 Moo-Moo's ACV 128.70 102.96 80.0% 3.0<br />

987 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 102 1 Wool coat jacket ACV 42.90 21.45 50.0% 2.0<br />

988 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 103 1 Cotton Jacket ACV 32.17 21.45 66.7% 2.0<br />

989 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 104 1 Docker Shorts ACV 26.81 17.87 66.7% 2.0<br />

990 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 105 4 Fitted Shirt ACV 77.22 61.78 80.0% 3.0<br />

991 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 106 5 Tee Pants ACV 64.35 51.48 80.0% 2.0<br />

992 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 107 1 Strechy Top Spandex ACV 19.31 15.45 80.0% 3.0<br />

993 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 108 6 Large Cotton Shirts ACV 77.22 61.78 80.0% 3.0<br />

994 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 109 10 Pants ACV 214.50 171.60 80.0% 4.5<br />

995 144 55-E017-574 6/25/2007 110 1 Plaid Jacket ACV 96.53 77.22 80.0% 3.0<br />

1 996 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 2 1 Casio keyboard / Walmart Actual Cash Value 108.25 43.30 40.0% 4.0<br />

997 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 10 1 Mattress set Actual Cash Value 433.00 21.65 5.0% 1.0<br />

998 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 11 1 Stackable shelf / Lowe's Actual Cash Value 108.25 10.82 10.0% 1.0<br />

999 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 18 1 Flat screen TV 32/37" / Phillips Actual Cash Value 595.36 49.61 8.3% 1.0<br />

1000 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 19 1 VCR/DVD player / Emerson Actual Cash Value 108.25 18.04 16.7% 1.0<br />

1001 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 22 1 Ipod / Radio Shack Actual Cash Value 108.25 10.82 10.0% -<br />

1002 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 26 2 Bar stools / JCP Actual Cash Value 433.00 129.90 30.0% 3.0<br />

1003 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 28 1 Chairs, oak / Oak Furniture Actual Cash Value 108.25 7.21 6.7% 1.0<br />

1004 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 30 1 Night stand / Weather B's Actual Cash Value 216.50 72.16 33.3% 5.0<br />

1005 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 32 1 Space rug / Sears Actual Cash Value 324.75 194.85 60.0% 3.0<br />

1006 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 35 2 End tables Actual Cash Value 541.25 108.25 20.0% 3.0<br />

1007 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 38 1 DSI XL / Nintendo Actual Cash Value 194.84 38.96 20.0% 1.0<br />

1008 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 39 3 Twin mattress Actual Cash Value 541.26 54.12 10.0% 2.0<br />

1009 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 40 1 20" Vizio / Walmart Actual Cash Value 281.44 23.45 8.3% 1.0<br />

1010 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 41 1 VCR / Walmart Actual Cash Value 41.01 6.83 16.7% 1.0<br />

1011 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 44 1 Football equipment / BHS Actual Cash Value 324.75 97.42 30.0%<br />

1012 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 50 1 Mixer, white / Sears Actual Cash Value 433.00 48.11 11.1% 2.0<br />

1013 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 51 1 Washer/dryer / Whirlpool Actual Cash Value 1,623.75 541.25 33.3% 4.0<br />

1014 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 52 2 Dishwasher / Sears Actual Cash Value 1,407.25 281.45 20.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 20


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1015 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 54 1 Stackable drawer / Lowe's Actual Cash Value 54.13 10.82 20.0% 1.0<br />

1016 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 55 1 Shelf laundry / Lowe's Actual Cash Value 108.25 10.82 10.0% 1.0<br />

1017 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 64 1 Space rug / Sears Actual Cash Value 324.75 64.95 20.0%<br />

1018 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 76 3 Direct TV receivers Actual Cash Value 974.25 162.37 16.7%<br />

1019 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 77 2 Baby Phat jeans Actual Cash Value 189.44 94.72 50.0%<br />

1020 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 78 4 Levi shorts Actual Cash Value 216.50 108.25 50.0%<br />

1021 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 79 2 Baby Phat shirt Actual Cash Value 135.31 67.65 50.0%<br />

1022 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 80 2 Devon ? Actual Cash Value 162.38 0.00 0.0%<br />

1023 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 81 6 Hilfiger shirt Actual Cash Value 162.38 81.19 50.0%<br />

1024 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 82 4 Hilfiger sweaters Actual Cash Value 162.38 0.00 0.0%<br />

1025 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 83 10 Reg Tee (screen) Actual Cash Value 135.31 67.65 50.0%<br />

1026 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 84 4 PJs set Actual Cash Value 108.25 54.12 50.0%<br />

1027 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 85 20 Socks Actual Cash Value 32.48 8.12 25.0%<br />

1028 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 86 10 Knee socks (dress) Actual Cash Value 108.25 0.00 0.0%<br />

1029 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 87 5 Hosiery plus size Actual Cash Value 108.25 0.00 0.0%<br />

1030 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 88 4 Bras 44DD size Actual Cash Value 216.50 173.20 80.0%<br />

1031 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 89 5 Reg jean short Actual Cash Value 129.90 32.47 25.0%<br />

1032 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 90 5 Dress shirts Actual Cash Value 162.38 54.12 33.3%<br />

1033 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 91 5 5 pkg Baby tee shirts Actual Cash Value 56.83 14.20 25.0%<br />

1034 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 92 4 pkg baby socks - 6pr/pkg Actual Cash Value 43.30 21.65 50.0%<br />

1035 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 93 10 Baby dresses Actual Cash Value 216.50 54.12 25.0%<br />

1036 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 94 7 Baby shorts Actual Cash Value 75.78 18.94 25.0%<br />

1037 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 95 8 Baby pants Actual Cash Value 86.60 21.65 25.0%<br />

1038 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 96 7 Baby PJ set Actual Cash Value 75.78 18.94 25.0%<br />

1039 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 97 4 Baby shoes Actual Cash Value 86.60 43.30 50.0%<br />

1040 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 98 3 Baby slippers Actual Cash Value 32.48 16.24 50.0%<br />

1041 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 99 7 Adults Tops/Tanks Actual Cash Value 75.78 37.89 50.0%<br />

1042 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 100 5 South Pole shirt ladies Actual Cash Value 135.31 67.65 50.0%<br />

1043 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 101 2 Kswiss tennis shoes Actual Cash Value 108.25 27.06 25.0%<br />

1044 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 102 1 Penney Loafers Actual Cash Value 81.19 20.29 25.0%<br />

1045 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 103 4 Hilfiger jean Actual Cash Value 216.50 108.25 50.0%<br />

1046 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 104 3 Levis jeans Actual Cash Value 162.38 0.00 0.0%<br />

1047 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 105 1 Guess dress coat blk/white Actual Cash Value 108.25 21.65 20.0%<br />

1048 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 106 1 Hooded fur coat black Actual Cash Value 108.25 21.65 20.0%<br />

1049 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 107 1 Guess watch red/green Actual Cash Value 270.63 13.53 5.0%<br />

1050 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 108 15 Panties Actual Cash Value 81.19 64.95 80.0%<br />

1051 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 109 2 Head scarfs Actual Cash Value 10.83 3.61 33.3%<br />

1052 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 110 10 Hair weave Actual Cash Value 108.25 21.65 20.0%<br />

1053 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 111 3 Boots Actual Cash Value 216.51 72.17 33.3%<br />

1054 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 112 2 Nike slippers Actual Cash Value 54.13 43.30 80.0%<br />

1055 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 113 2 flip flops Actual Cash Value 32.48 16.24 50.0%<br />

1056 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 114 5 shoes Actual Cash Value 108.25 54.12 50.0%<br />

1057 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 115 4 dress pants Actual Cash Value 129.90 43.30 33.3%<br />

1058 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 116 1 Set Apple Botom pant/shirt Actual Cash Value 129.90 32.47 25.0%<br />

1059 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 117 3 Slips Actual Cash Value 70.37 35.18 50.0%<br />

1060 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 119 4 Gym shorts Actual Cash Value 43.30 21.65 50.0%<br />

1061 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 120 4 Gym shirts Actual Cash Value 43.30 21.65 50.0%<br />

1062 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 121 2 Bathroom plungers Actual Cash Value 43.30 8.66 20.0%<br />

1063 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 122 2 Set glass dishes Actual Cash Value 108.25 10.82 10.0%<br />

1064 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 123 4 Set plastic dishes Actual Cash Value 54.13 10.82 20.0%<br />

1065 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 125 1 Stain dish rack Actual Cash Value 216.50 10.82 5.0%<br />

1066 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 126 1 Spoon & fork set Actual Cash Value 27.06 2.70 10.0%<br />

1067 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 127 1 Back & neck heating pad Actual Cash Value 43.30 0.72 1.7% 0.1 [c]<br />

1068 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 128 1 Kiddie table Actual Cash Value 54.13 0.00 0.0%<br />

10/15/2012 21


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1069 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 129 1 Iron Actual Cash Value 81.19 0.00 0.0%<br />

1070 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 130 1 Other small items, etc. Actual Cash Value 21.65 5.41 25.0%<br />

1071 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 131 1 Silverware rack red Actual Cash Value 21.65 4.33 20.0%<br />

1072 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 132 4 Cell phone charger Actual Cash Value 173.20 34.64 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1073 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 133 2 Cordless phones Actual Cash Value 54.13 2.70 5.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1074 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 134 25 CDs/DVDs Actual Cash Value 135.31 67.65 50.0% 1.5 [c]<br />

1075 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 135 4 Lee jeans Actual Cash Value 216.50 54.12 25.0%<br />

1076 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 136 3 Dickies Actual Cash Value 64.95 16.23 25.0%<br />

1077 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 137 10 Tee shirts Actual Cash Value 43.30 10.82 25.0%<br />

1078 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 138 10 Tanks Actual Cash Value 27.06 6.76 25.0%<br />

1079 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 139 10 Socks Actual Cash Value 27.06 13.53 50.0%<br />

1080 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 140 2 Zip jacket / South pole Actual Cash Value 64.95 10.82 16.7%<br />

1081 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 141 8 Polo shirts Actual Cash Value 216.50 54.12 25.0%<br />

1082 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 142 2 Reebok Actual Cash Value 108.25 27.06 25.0%<br />

1083 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 143 5 Levis 40x32 Actual Cash Value 270.63 67.65 25.0%<br />

1084 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 144 10 Pro club tees Actual Cash Value 129.90 32.47 25.0%<br />

1085 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 145 7 Thermals Actual Cash Value 108.28 27.07 25.0%<br />

1086 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 146 15 Socks black Actual Cash Value 43.35 21.67 50.0%<br />

1087 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 147 10 Socks white Actual Cash Value 21.65 10.82 50.0%<br />

1088 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 148 3 Kswiss tennis shoes Actual Cash Value 162.38 27.06 16.7%<br />

1089 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 149 2 Slacks Actual Cash Value 86.60 21.65 25.0%<br />

1090 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 150 4 Dress shirts Actual Cash Value 135.31 22.55 16.7%<br />

1091 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 151 2 Ties / Stafford Actual Cash Value 43.30 7.21 16.7%<br />

1092 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 152 4 Dickies pants Actual Cash Value 108.25 27.06 25.0%<br />

1093 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 153 1 Stove blk & stainless steel /<br />

Firgidaire<br />

Actual Cash Value 757.75 108.25 14.3%<br />

1094 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 154 1 Camcorder Actual Cash Value 433.00 216.50 50.0%<br />

1095 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 155 4 Vivitar digital camera Actual Cash Value 162.38 32.47 20.0% 2.0 [c]<br />

1096 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 156 1 Ceiling fans Actual Cash Value 433.00 43.30 10.0%<br />

1097 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 157 1 Baby kitchen Actual Cash Value 81.19 8.11 10.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1098 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 158 4 Jumper / bouncer Actual Cash Value 162.38 54.12 33.3% 1.0 [c]<br />

1099 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 159 2 Dolls Actual Cash Value 135.31 27.06 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1100 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 161 3 Curtains set & rod Actual Cash Value 108.25 21.65 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1101 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 162 200 Baby strollers - toy Actual Cash Value 108.24 21.64 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1102 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 163 20 other baby toys Actual Cash Value 2,165.00 433.00 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1103 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 164 1 Stuffed animals Actual Cash Value 649.50 129.90 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1104 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 165 1 Tea set (talking) Actual Cash Value 54.13 5.41 10.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1105 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 166 1 Dora doll set (everything) Actual Cash Value 108.25 10.82 10.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1106 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 167 1 Leap Frog learning Actual Cash Value 81.19 16.23 20.0% 1.0 [c]<br />

1107 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 168 1 Drum set Actual Cash Value 43.30 4.33 10.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1108 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 169 1 Doll house Actual Cash Value 81.19 8.11 10.0%<br />

1109 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 170 1 Rattle set Actual Cash Value 27.06 10.82 40.0% 2.0 [c]<br />

1110 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 171 1 Ring set (teething) Actual Cash Value 21.65 17.32 80.0% 2.0 [c]<br />

1111 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 172 1 Sippy cup Actual Cash Value 10.83 1.80 16.6% 0.5 [c]<br />

1112 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 173 1 Mattress full size Actual Cash Value 433.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1113 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 174 1 Throw rug choc brown Actual Cash Value 324.75 64.95 20.0%<br />

1114 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 175 10 Kiddie DVDs Actual Cash Value 108.25 54.12 50.0% 0.5 [c]<br />

1115 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 176 1 Pull Ups diapers Actual Cash Value 21.65 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

1116 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 177 1 Baby wipes Actual Cash Value 7.58 0.00 0.0% - [c]<br />

1117 146 55-E115-455 3/25/2011 179 8 Books (baby) Actual Cash Value 86.60 43.30 50.0% 2.0 [c]<br />

1 1118 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 2 4 Fishing rods / Sabre Actual Cash Value 323.25 64.65 20.0% 2.0<br />

1119 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 3 3 Luggage Actual Cash Value 265.07 15.46 5.8% 1.0<br />

1120 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 4 1 TV 19" / Emerson Actual Cash Value 161.61 16.83 10.4% 1.3<br />

1121 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 5 1 VCR / Sanyo Actual Cash Value 96.96 77.57 80.0% 5.3<br />

10/15/2012 22


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1122 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 6 1 DVD recorder Actual Cash Value 107.74 3.85 3.6%<br />

1123 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 7 2 Dermatone - Muscle Stimulator Actual Cash Value 689.60 310.32 45.0% 4.5<br />

1124 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 8 10 CDs Actual Cash Value 161.63 80.82 50.0%<br />

1125 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 9 10 Video tapes Actual Cash Value 107.75 53.88 50.0%<br />

1126 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 10 1 Alpine Living air Actual Cash Value 377.13 113.14 30.0%<br />

1127 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 11 1 Picnic basket Actual Cash Value 58.19 15.03 25.8% 2.5<br />

1128 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 12 1 Guitar / fender Actual Cash Value 289.95 2.90 1.0% 0.3<br />

1129 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 16 1 3 pc suit Actual Cash Value 431.00 47.89 11.1%<br />

1130 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 17 5 Pr levis Actual Cash Value 161.63 17.96 11.1%<br />

1131 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 18 1 Dress shoes Actual Cash Value 53.88 7.48 13.9%<br />

1132 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 19 1 Nike shoes Actual Cash Value 53.88 10.48 19.4%<br />

1133 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 20 2 Undergarments Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.25 8.3%<br />

1134 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 21 4 2 pc pant suit Actual Cash Value 377.13 62.86 16.7%<br />

1135 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 22 2 Exercise outfits Actual Cash Value 161.63 13.47 8.3%<br />

1136 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 23 5 Pants Actual Cash Value 107.75 8.98 8.3%<br />

1137 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 24 6 Blouses Actual Cash Value 107.75 8.98 8.3%<br />

1138 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 25 1 Shoes Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.04 8.3%<br />

1139 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 26 1 Book / Alternative Medicine Actual Cash Value 53.88 21.55 40.0%<br />

1140 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 27 1 Book / No Down Payment Actual Cash Value 323.25 96.98 30.0%<br />

1141 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 29 1 Book / Worst Pills Best Pills Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0%<br />

1142 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 30 1 Book / Perma Culture Actual Cash Value 43.10 8.62 20.0%<br />

1143 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 31 1 Book / Life Extension Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0%<br />

1144 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 32 1 Natural Health medicine Actual Cash Value 21.55 0.54 2.5%<br />

1145 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 35 1 Reel / Penn Actual Cash Value 134.69 4.49 3.3%<br />

1146 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 36 1 Pole / Garcia Mitch Actual Cash Value 134.69 4.49 3.3%<br />

1147 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 37 1 Tackle box Actual Cash Value 53.88 1.80 3.3%<br />

1148 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 38 1 DVD - Charmed / All 7 seasons Actual Cash Value 323.24 161.62 50.0%<br />

1149 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 39 1 Rock 1, 2, 3, 4 DVDs Actual Cash Value 62.46 31.23 50.0%<br />

1150 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 40 4 Me, Myself and Irene DVD Actual Cash Value 14.00 7.00 50.0%<br />

1151 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 41 1 Braveheart DVD Actual Cash Value 17.23 8.62 50.0%<br />

1152 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 42 1 Pckg DVD+RW Actual Cash Value 107.75 0.00 0.0%<br />

1153 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 43 4 Gloves / Mt Hardwear Ascent Actual Cash Value 70.04 28.02 40.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1154 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 44 1 Ski bibs / Areteryx Thea Actual Cash Value 404.06 161.62 40.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1155 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 45 1 Ski pants / Spyder Actual Cash Value 290.93 116.37 40.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1156 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 46 1 Snow googles / Oakley Actual Cash Value 91.59 36.64 40.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1157 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 47 1 Skis / Rossignol Actual Cash Value 538.75 107.75 20.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1158 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 48 1 Bindings / Black Diamond Actual Cash Value 322.17 64.43 20.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1159 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 49 1 Ski boots Actual Cash Value 296.31 59.26 20.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1160 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 50 1 Ski pole Actual Cash Value 43.10 17.24 40.0% 2.0 [d]<br />

1161 93 75-M456-650 8/24/2007 33 1 Vitamins Actual Cash Value 814.59 407.30 50.0% -<br />

1 1162 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 2 1 White Leather Sofa / Macy's Actual Cash Value 1,305.00 261.00 20.0% 4.0<br />

1163 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 3 2 White Leather Chairs / Macy's Actual Cash Value 1,956.41 391.28 20.0% 4.0<br />

1164 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 10 4 Formal Dining Chairs / Ethan Allen Actual Cash Value 1,518.15 259.35 17.1%<br />

1165 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 11 2 Dinnig Captain chairs / Ethan<br />

Allen<br />

Actual Cash Value 867.83 144.63 16.7%<br />

1166 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 17 1 Chaise Lounge / Sears Actual Cash Value 870.00 304.50 35.0% 7.0<br />

1167 95 75-M624-390 7/28/2011 25 1 Queen bedspread / Ralph lauren Actual Cash Value 380.63 114.18 30.0%<br />

1 1168 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 2 1 Desk Actual Cash Value 210.11 42.02 20.0% 2.0<br />

1169 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 3 1 Television / Admiral @ Garment<br />

District<br />

Actual Cash Value 113.14 22.63 20.0% 2.0<br />

1170 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 4 1 Television / Admiral @ Garment<br />

District<br />

Actual Cash Value 70.04 14.01 20.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 23


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1171 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 5 1 Ortho Bed / Ortho Balance @<br />

Ortho<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,304.85 456.70 35.0% 3.5<br />

1172 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 6 2 Ortho Pillows / Ortho Balance @<br />

Ortho<br />

Actual Cash Value 215.50 150.85 70.0% 3.5<br />

1173 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 7 5 Pictures @ Garment District Actual Cash Value 199.34 29.90 15.0% 1.5<br />

1174 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 8 1 Bedspread / @ Garment District Actual Cash Value 102.36 68.24 66.7% 2.0<br />

1175 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 9 1 Bathroom items / Garment District Actual Cash Value 134.69 44.90 33.3% 1.0<br />

1176 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 10 1 Center Table, Glass / Garment<br />

District<br />

Actual Cash Value 91.59 18.32 20.0% 2.0<br />

1177 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 11 3 Vase sets / Garment District Actual Cash Value 264.00 79.20 30.0% 3.0<br />

1178 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 12 5 Plants / @ swap meet Actual Cash Value 70.04 23.35 33.3% 1.0<br />

1179 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 14 3 Lamp sets / Garment District Actual Cash Value 177.79 53.34 30.0% 3.0<br />

1180 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 15 1 Fan / Lakewood @ Costco Actual Cash Value 139.00 27.80 20.0% 2.0<br />

1181 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 16 1 Heater / Holmes @ Target Actual Cash Value 91.59 18.32 20.0% 1.0<br />

1182 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 17 12 Clothing / Fashion Brigade Actual Cash Value 253.17 101.27 40.0% 2.0<br />

1183 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 18 3 Shoes / New York Fashion Actual Cash Value 167.02 55.67 33.3% 1.0<br />

1184 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 19 2 Boots / Gucci @ Garment District Actual Cash Value 129.30 43.10 33.3% 1.0<br />

1185 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 20 19 Stuffed Animal Toys / @ Garment<br />

District<br />

Actual Cash Value 102.36 81.89 80.0% 2.5<br />

1186 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 21 1 DVD/VHS Player / RCA @ Sears Actual Cash Value 136.84 68.42 50.0% 3.0<br />

1187 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 22 1 Small microwave / GE @ Kmart Actual Cash Value 140.08 70.04 50.0% 3.0<br />

1188 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 23 1 Telephone / G.E. @ Target Actual Cash Value 102.36 30.71 30.0% 1.5<br />

1189 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 24 1 Hair dryer / Ebony @ Garment<br />

Disrict<br />

Actual Cash Value 296.31 177.79 60.0% 3.0<br />

1190 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 25 2 Blow dryer / Ebony @ Garment<br />

Disrict<br />

Actual Cash Value 123.91 74.35 60.0% 3.0<br />

1191 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 26 3 Electric curling irons / Ebony @<br />

Garment Disrict<br />

Actual Cash Value 156.23 93.74 60.0% 3.0<br />

1192 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 27 1 Radio / Sony @ Walmart Actual Cash Value 48.49 19.40 40.0% 4.0<br />

1193 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 28 1 Clock / @ swap meet Actual Cash Value 37.71 7.54 20.0% 1.0<br />

1194 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 29 1 Stereo System / Sony @ Kmart Actual Cash Value 414.84 207.42 50.0% 4.0<br />

1195 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 30 1 Tape recorder / Sony @ Garment<br />

Disrict<br />

Actual Cash Value 96.98 19.40 20.0% 2.0<br />

1196 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 32 1 Playstation 2 / @ Walmart Actual Cash Value 414.84 290.39 70.0% 7.0<br />

1197 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 33 27 PlayStation Ass. / Game world Actual Cash Value 781.13 468.68 60.0% 4.5<br />

1198 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 36 1 Box Arts-n-Crafts board games /<br />

@ Garment Disrict<br />

Actual Cash Value 215.50 107.75 50.0% 1.5<br />

1199 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 37 2 Electric Key Boards / Garment<br />

District<br />

Actual Cash Value 323.25 64.65 20.0% 2.0<br />

1200 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 38 7 Picture frames / @ Garment Dist. Actual Cash Value 177.78 17.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

1201 96 55-E010-714 3/23/2007 39 11 African artifacts / @ Garment Dist. Actual Cash Value 522.59 52.28 10.0% 1.0<br />

1202 101 05-M494-044 2/11/2011 5 2 Radio CD player / Emmerson Actual Cash Value 173.58 52.07 30.0%<br />

1 1203 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 1 1 Dining Room set Actual Cash Value 1,631.25 652.50 40.0% 6.0<br />

1204 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 2 1 Cal King memory foam Actual Cash Value 153.11 91.86 60.0% 3.0<br />

1205 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 3 1 La-Z-Boy couch Actual Cash Value 2,186.58 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

1206 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 4 1 La-Z-bay recliner Actual Cash Value 626.79 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

1207 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 5 2 Green La-Z-boy recliner Actual Cash Value 1,253.58 752.14 60.0% 6.0<br />

1208 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 6 1 Accent chair Actual Cash Value 271.88 135.94 50.0% 5.0<br />

1209 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 7 1 Tan recliner Actual Cash Value 924.38 554.62 60.0% 6.0<br />

10/15/2012 24


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1210 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 8 1 Queen memory foam Actual Cash Value 135.33 108.26 80.0% 5.0<br />

1211 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 9 1 Cherry coffee table Actual Cash Value 216.41 57.70 26.7% 4.0<br />

1212 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 10 1 Green roll-up window shade Actual Cash Value 19.54 9.11 46.6% 7.0<br />

1213 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 11 1 DVD Actual Cash Value 38.05 12.68 33.3% 1.0<br />

1214 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 13 1 Gold Canyan candle Actual Cash Value 20.64 5.16 25.0% 1.0<br />

1215 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 14 2 Down pillows Actual Cash Value 43.50 13.05 30.0% 1.5<br />

1216 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 15 1 Sheet set twin Actual Cash Value 31.54 12.61 40.0% 2.0<br />

1217 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 16 1 Blanket Actual Cash Value 42.41 16.96 40.0% 2.0<br />

1218 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 17 1 Stand up TV tray Actual Cash Value 53.29 14.21 26.7% 4.0<br />

1219 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 18 1 Stand up fan Actual Cash Value 41.33 12.39 30.0% 3.0<br />

1220 105 55-E078-594 11/6/2009 19 1 Jeans/shirt Actual Cash Value 43.49 28.99 66.7% 2.0<br />

1221 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 1 1 1850 Sled / Stroller Actual Cash Value 300.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1222 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 2 1 1780 table washstand Actual Cash Value 1,500.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1223 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 5 1 Maple wing Chair Actual Cash Value 425.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1 1224 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 6 1 Couch Actual Cash Value 556.44 0.00 0.0% 62.0<br />

1225 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 7 1 Curtain Actual Cash Value 235.96 0.00 0.0%<br />

1226 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 8 1 Drapes Actual Cash Value 500.00 100.00 20.0%<br />

1227 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 9 1 Combination traverse rod Actual Cash Value 58.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1228 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 12 1 Silk lamp shade Actual Cash Value 80.00 40.00 50.0%<br />

1229 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 16 1 Rug 5x9 Actual Cash Value 127.79 90.73 71.0% 18.0<br />

1230 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 17 1 Rug 9x12 Actual Cash Value 297.14 223.85 75.3% 62.0<br />

1231 110 75-M423-267 5/17/2005 21 1 Fire screen Actual Cash Value 71.44 0.00 0.0%<br />

1 1232 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 1 1 Brown dining table/IKEA Actual Cash Value 323.25 80.81 25.0% 2.5<br />

1233 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 2 4 Brown dining chairs/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 86.20 21.55 25.0% 2.5<br />

1234 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 3 1 Chaise lounge<br />

sectional/Scandinavian design<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,185.25 592.62 50.0% 5.0<br />

1235 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 4 1 Chaise lounge<br />

ottoman/Scandinavian design<br />

Actual Cash Value 323.25 161.62 50.0% 5.0<br />

1236 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 5 1 Sofa bed couch/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 807.05 403.52 50.0% 5.0<br />

1237 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 6 1 Sofa bed couch cover/IKEA Actual Cash Value 268.30 134.15 50.0% 5.0<br />

1238 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 7 4 Floor lamp base/IKEA Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.93 25.0% 2.5<br />

1239 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 8 2 Lamp shades/IKEA Actual Cash Value 32.33 16.16 50.0% 2.5<br />

1240 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 9 2 Lamp shades/IKEA Actual Cash Value 43.10 21.55 50.0% 2.5<br />

1241 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 10 1 Bookshelf/IKEA Actual Cash Value 140.08 21.01 15.0% 1.5<br />

1242 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 11 1 Bookshelf/IKEA Actual Cash Value 279.07 41.86 15.0% 1.5<br />

1243 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 12 4 Wicker storage baskets for<br />

bo/IKEA<br />

Actual Cash Value 73.27 10.99 15.0% 1.5<br />

1244 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 13 1 Wicker Chair/IKEA Actual Cash Value 53.88 26.94 50.0% 2.5<br />

1245 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 14 1 Wicker chair pad/IKEA Actual Cash Value 21.55 10.77 50.0% 2.5<br />

1246 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 15 1 4'x8' dry erase board/ Home<br />

Depot<br />

Actual Cash Value 14.01 3.50 25.0% 2.5<br />

1247 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 16 1 Queen mattress & boxspring /<br />

Sealy Posturepedic<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,508.50 377.12 25.0% 5.0<br />

1248 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 17 1 bed Frame/scandinavian design Actual Cash Value 753.17 376.58 50.0% 5.0<br />

1249 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 18 1 Mattress & boxspring /IKEA Actual Cash Value 322.17 24.16 7.5% 1.5<br />

1250 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 19 1 bedframe/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 52.80 3.96 7.5% 1.5<br />

1251 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 20 2 Floor lamp base/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 53.88 8.08 15.0% 1.5<br />

1252 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 21 2 Lamp shade/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 43.10 12.93 30.0% 1.5<br />

1253 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 22 1 Brown leather chair/ Scandinavian<br />

Design<br />

Actual Cash Value 246.75 82.25 33.3% 5.0<br />

1254 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 23 1 Kitchen Island Storage/ Intermetro<br />

Chef's Cart<br />

Actual Cash Value 171.32 57.10 33.3% 5.0<br />

1255 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 24 2 Cat scratching playtoy/Whiskey<br />

City Curt Floor Scratch<br />

Actual Cash Value 64.65 12.93 20.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 25


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1256 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 25 2 Cardboard scratch boxes/ Great<br />

Choice Dblwid<br />

Actual Cash Value 32.33 12.93 40.0% 2.0<br />

1257 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 26 1 Cat Condo single story/ Foster &<br />

Smith<br />

Actual Cash Value 26.94 3.59 13.3% 2.0<br />

1258 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 27 2 Platinum mesh drawer<br />

3"/Container store<br />

Actual Cash Value 32.33 8.08 25.0% 2.5<br />

1259 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 28 1 Platinum mesh draer 7"/ Container<br />

store<br />

Actual Cash Value 19.40 4.85 25.0% 2.5<br />

1260 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 29 1 Platinum Frame/ Container Store Actual Cash Value 37.71 9.42 25.0% 2.5<br />

1261 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 30 1 Small wicker bedside table Actual Cash Value 5.39 0.67 12.4% 2.5<br />

1262 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 31 120 wooden hangers (30 for $20)/<br />

Target<br />

Actual Cash Value 86.20 21.55 25.0% 2.5<br />

1263 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 32 200 Black plastic hangers/ Target Actual Cash Value 43.10 21.55 50.0% 2.5<br />

1264 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 33 1 Dell Computer Harddriver/Tower Actual Cash Value 1,346.88 1,077.50 80.0% 5.0<br />

1265 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 34 1 Dell 23" LCD Actual Cash Value 322.17 107.39 33.3% 2.0<br />

1266 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 35 1 Dell Inspiron 17" laptop Actual Cash Value 699.30 233.10 33.3% 2.0<br />

1267 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 36 1 Acer laptop Actual Cash Value 322.17 53.69 16.7% 1.0<br />

1268 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 37 1 HP Photosmart Printer/ C3180 Actual Cash Value 161.63 53.87 33.3% 2.0<br />

1269 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 38 1 Dell Computer speakers Actual Cash Value 53.88 43.10 80.0% 5.0<br />

1270 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 39 1 2 wire modem/ router Actual Cash Value 80.81 33.67 41.7% 2.5<br />

1271 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 40 1 Misc cords, cables, computer Actual Cash Value 269.38 89.79 33.3% 2.0<br />

1272 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 43 1 Digital voice recorder/Sony Actual Cash Value 42.02 8.40 20.0% 2.0<br />

1273 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 45 1 Microwave/ Sharp Actual Cash Value 90.51 20.57 22.7% 2.5<br />

1274 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 46 1 Canister vacuum/ Kenmore Actual Cash Value 106.67 17.77 16.7% 2.5<br />

1275 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 47 1 22" TV Sylvania Actual Cash Value 214.42 53.60 25.0% 3.0<br />

1276 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 49 1 DVD Player/ Memorex Actual Cash Value 43.10 28.73 66.7% 4.0<br />

1277 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 50 1 DVD Player/ Sony Actual Cash Value 37.71 12.57 33.3% 2.0<br />

1278 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 51 1 Portable DVD player/Audiovox Actual Cash Value 59.26 47.40 80.0% 5.0<br />

1279 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 52 1 Stereo reciever/ Sony Actual Cash Value 279.07 83.72 30.0% 3.0<br />

1280 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 53 1 Cassette Deck/ Sony Actual Cash Value 107.75 32.32 30.0% 5.0<br />

1281 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 54 1 Stero reciever/ Sony Actual Cash Value 161.63 80.81 50.0% 5.0<br />

1282 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 55 1 Cassette Deck/ Sony Actual Cash Value 107.75 53.87 50.0% 5.0<br />

1283 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 56 1 Multi disk CD player/ JVC Actual Cash Value 323.25 258.60 80.0% 8.0<br />

1284 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 57 1 paper shredder/ Staples Actual Cash Value 53.88 16.16 30.0% 3.0<br />

1285 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 58 1 Camera/ Polaroid Actual Cash Value 21.55 17.24 80.0% 8.0<br />

1286 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 59 43 DVD Actual Cash Value 463.33 231.66 50.0%<br />

1287 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 60 36 CDs Actual Cash Value 581.85 290.92 50.0%<br />

1288 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 61 21 paperback books Actual Cash Value 67.88 33.94 50.0%<br />

1289 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 62 17 hardcover books Actual Cash Value 183.18 61.06 33.3%<br />

1290 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 64 1 bathroom supplies Actual Cash Value 161.63 80.81 50.0% 0.1<br />

1291 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 65 1 boots, black leather knee high/<br />

Bandolino Caresse<br />

Actual Cash Value 160.55 128.44 80.0% 5.0<br />

1292 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 66 1 Sneaker, Vans canvas old school Actual Cash Value 53.88 43.10 80.0% 5.0<br />

1293 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 67 1 Sneaker, Ruckus skateboard/Nike Actual Cash Value 59.26 47.40 80.0% 4.0<br />

1294 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 68 1 Sneaker Shox Turbo Black/ Nike Actual Cash Value 106.67 85.33 80.0% 4.0<br />

1295 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 69 5 Sports bras Actual Cash Value 167.01 83.50 50.0%<br />

1296 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 70 2 Shirts shortsleeve/Lacoste Actual Cash Value 171.32 137.05 80.0% 3.0<br />

1297 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 71 4 Shirts longsleeve black/ lacoste Actual Cash Value 387.90 310.32 80.0% 3.0<br />

1298 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 72 1 Dress shirt, blue/Gap Actual Cash Value 53.82 35.88 66.7% 2.0<br />

1299 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 73 1 Dress shirt, Fuscia/ Gap Actual Cash Value 53.82 35.88 66.7% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 26


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1300 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 74 2 jeans/ Gap Actual Cash Value 129.19 43.06 33.3% 1.0<br />

1301 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 75 2 Dress pants, black/ Gap Actual Cash Value 129.19 43.06 33.3% 1.0<br />

1302 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 76 2 Women's suit, black, Ann Klein Actual Cash Value 431.00 258.60 60.0% 3.0<br />

1303 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 77 3 Down comforters Actual Cash Value 808.13 242.43 30.0%<br />

1304 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 78 1 Dress shoes, black heels, Nine<br />

west<br />

Actual Cash Value 85.12 68.09 80.0% 3.0<br />

1305 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 79 1 Sandals, brown leather, LL Bean Actual Cash Value 37.71 30.16 80.0% 5.0<br />

1306 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 80 1 Hair dryer/ Conair Actual Cash Value 43.10 17.24 40.0% 2.0<br />

1307 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 81 8 Bath Towels/ Royal Regent Actual Cash Value 172.40 137.92 80.0% 5.0<br />

1308 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 82 4 Wash cloths 13" square/ Regent Actual Cash Value 47.41 37.92 80.0% 5.0<br />

1309 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 83 8 bed pillows standard size/<br />

Wamsutta<br />

Actual Cash Value 172.31 137.84 80.0% 3.0<br />

1310 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 84 2 throw pillows/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 27.99 11.19 40.0% 2.0<br />

1311 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 85 6 lipstick, long last/Clinique Actual Cash Value 96.98 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1312 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 86 1 Face cream, 7 day scrub/ Clinique Actual Cash Value 19.93 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1313 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 87 1 eye makeup shadow -<br />

quad/Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 27.48 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1314 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 88 1 makeup compact, almost power/<br />

clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 25.86 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1315 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 89 4 lip gloss, superbalm/Clinique Actual Cash Value 60.34 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1316 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 90 1 mascara/ clinique Actual Cash Value 15.62 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1317 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 91 1 hand cream stop signs hand re/<br />

Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 21.01 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1318 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 92 1 skin care turnarnd concentr/<br />

Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 45.79 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1319 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 93 1 new clarifying lotion/ Clinique Actual Cash Value 22.63 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1320 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 94 2 new pore refining correcting/<br />

Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 85.12 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1321 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 95 1 superbalanced makeup foundation<br />

/ Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 23.71 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1322 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 96 6 long last lipstick/ Clinique Actual Cash Value 96.98 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1323 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 97 1 makeup brush kit/ Lancome Actual Cash Value 63.57 12.71 20.0% 1.0<br />

1324 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 98 1 Mirro/ Upper Canada Soap Mirror Actual Cash Value 53.86 5.38 10.0% 1.0<br />

1325 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 99 2 Microdry Essential bath rug 2 Actual Cash Value 43.08 34.46 80.0% 3.0<br />

1326 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 100 1 shower caddy 3 tier corner un Actual Cash Value 32.31 12.92 40.0% 2.0<br />

1327 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 101 1 shower caddy, under shower head Actual Cash Value 21.54 8.61 40.0% 2.0<br />

1328 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 102 1 shower heard/ waterpik 12 setting Actual Cash Value 75.41 30.16 40.0% 2.0<br />

1329 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 103 5 hair products/ CHI Silk infusion Actual Cash Value 123.86 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1330 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 104 2 Shampoo/CHI infra Actual Cash Value 75.43 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1331 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 105 2 Conditioner /CHI intra Actual Cash Value 75.43 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1332 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 106 1 flat iron/ CHI air tourmaline Actual Cash Value 129.30 25.86 20.0% 1.0<br />

1333 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 107 1 Cordless flat iron/ Helix Hot tools Actual Cash Value 171.86 68.74 40.0% 2.0<br />

1334 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 108 1 Bottle charcoal pills 280 mg Actual Cash Value 11.84 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1335 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 109 1 advil 200 mg Actual Cash Value 19.71 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1336 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 110 1 Toilet storage unit/Lindwood Bath<br />

shutter<br />

Actual Cash Value 96.98 30.30 31.2% 2.5<br />

10/15/2012 27


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1337 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 111 1 wrinkle cream/ eye vive dermaxin Actual Cash Value 150.84 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1338 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 112 1 flat iron 1" / CHI Ceramic Farook Actual Cash Value 85.12 51.07 60.0% 3.0<br />

1339 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 113 1 Make up brush kit/ lancome Actual Cash Value 118.53 23.70 20.0% 1.0<br />

1340 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 114 1 make up bag/ Michael Kors Actual Cash Value 62.50 25.00 40.0% 2.0<br />

1341 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 115 1 Make up bag/ kate spade Actual Cash Value 70.04 42.02 60.0% 3.0<br />

1342 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 116 1 Make up bag/ Bare essential Actual Cash Value 19.40 7.76 40.0% 2.0<br />

1343 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 117 3 Metal travel containers Actual Cash Value 3.20 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

1344 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 118 1 eye glass repair kit Actual Cash Value 4.84 0.96 19.9% 2.0<br />

1345 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 119 1 makeup bag/bobbi brown Actual Cash Value 32.33 19.39 60.0% 3.0<br />

1346 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 120 1 Vigamox medicine Actual Cash Value 101.29 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1347 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 121 3 Candles/ Yankee jar Actual Cash Value 32.29 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1348 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 122 2 Fingernail clippers/ Stiles Actual Cash Value 12.91 5.16 40.0% 4.0<br />

1349 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 123 3 Chapstick Actual Cash Value 6.43 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1350 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 124 1 RX Fluticasone Porpionate mcg Actual Cash Value 40.68 0.00 0.0% 2.0<br />

1351 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 125 1 make up bag/ Petunia Pickle<br />

bottom<br />

Actual Cash Value 30.17 12.06 40.0% 2.0<br />

1352 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 126 1 make up bag/ MAC Actual Cash Value 34.48 27.58 80.0% 4.0<br />

1353 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 127 1 Electric toothbrush/ Sonicare Actual Cash Value 128.22 96.16 75.0% 3.0<br />

1354 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 128 1 Clarifying lotion skin type 2 /<br />

Clinique<br />

Actual Cash Value 13.47 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1355 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 129 1 eye liner pencil / Clinique Actual Cash Value 16.16 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1356 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 130 2 hari conditioner/ Bumble &<br />

Bumble<br />

Actual Cash Value 120.68 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1357 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 131 2 Hair conditioner/ Bumble &<br />

Bumble<br />

Actual Cash Value 124.99 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1358 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 132 2 Hair conditioner/ Bumble &<br />

Bumble<br />

Actual Cash Value 47.41 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1359 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 133 1 hair spray / B&B Actual Cash Value 26.94 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1360 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 134 1 Hair Treatment/ B&B Actual Cash Value 28.02 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1361 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 135 1 hair cream / B&B Actual Cash Value 22.63 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1362 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 136 3 Pure color long last lipstick/Estee<br />

lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 77.58 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1363 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 137 1 Perfectly Clean splay away cl/<br />

Estee lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 21.55 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1364 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 138 1 Eye shadow palette/ Estee lauder Actual Cash Value 48.49 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1365 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 139 2 More than Mascara/ Estee lauder Actual Cash Value 45.26 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1366 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 140 2 Advanced night repair/ Estee<br />

lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 167.01 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1367 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 141 1 Advanced night repair eye cream/<br />

Estee lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 53.34 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1368 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 142 1 Gentle eye makeup remover/<br />

Estee Lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 16.70 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1369 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 143 1 Re-Nutriv replenishing comfor/<br />

Estee lauder<br />

Actual Cash Value 145.46 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1370 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 144 1 Moisterizer/ Olay Definity Color<br />

Recapture<br />

Actual Cash Value 25.53 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1371 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 145 1 Chanel Coco perfume Actual Cash Value 123.91 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1372 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 146 1 eye lifting serum/Olay Actual Cash Value 23.69 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1373 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 147 1 Marc Jacobs Eau de parfum Actual Cash Value 80.81 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1374 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 148 1 Fresh pink jasmine perfume Actual Cash Value 80.81 64.64 80.0% 2.0<br />

1375 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 149 1 baseball cleats/Adidas Actual Cash Value 43.09 28.72 66.7% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 28


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1376 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 150 1 Soccer cleats/ Adidas Actual Cash Value 37.71 30.16 80.0% 3.0<br />

1377 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 151 3 100' Christmas tree light str Actual Cash Value 48.49 16.16 33.3%<br />

1378 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 152 1 Christmas ornaments Actual Cash Value 161.63 40.40 25.0%<br />

1379 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 153 1 Car cleaning supplies Actual Cash Value 80.81 26.93 33.3%<br />

1380 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 154 1 Bike Shoe / Shimano Actual Cash Value 48.49 32.32 66.7% 2.0<br />

1381 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 155 1 All blk bike shoe/ Pearl Izumi Actual Cash Value 91.59 73.27 80.0% 5.0<br />

1382 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 156 1 Cube freezer/Kenmore Actual Cash Value 307.09 51.18 16.7% 2.5<br />

1383 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 157 1 ladder 8" fiberglass/Wener Actual Cash Value 90.51 11.31 12.5% 2.5<br />

1384 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 158 1 Broom & dustpan set/Libman Actual Cash Value 10.78 5.39 50.0% 2.5<br />

1385 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 159 1 Golf Shoes/ Footjoy Actual Cash Value 86.19 68.95 80.0% 4.0<br />

1386 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 160 1 Golf Shoes/ Callaway Actual Cash Value 113.14 75.42 66.7% 2.0<br />

1387 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 161 1 Box Fan Actual Cash Value 16.16 3.23 20.0% 2.0<br />

1388 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 162 1 Motorcycle helmet/Shoei Actual Cash Value 129.30 103.44 80.0% 6.0<br />

1389 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 163 2 plastic storage container Actual Cash Value 86.20 34.48 40.0% 2.0<br />

1390 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 164 1 bike pump/specialized airtool sport Actual Cash Value 43.09 4.30 10.0% 1.0<br />

1391 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 165 1 bike pump/ Beto floor pump Actual Cash Value 26.93 8.07 30.0% 3.0<br />

1392 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 166 1 bike pumo/ Planet Bike MicroMite Actual Cash Value 16.15 6.46 40.0% 4.0<br />

1393 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 167 3 bike water bottles 24 oz/Polar<br />

insulated<br />

Actual Cash Value 38.79 7.75 20.0% 1.0<br />

1394 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 168 2 bike stand/sarts wheel arch Actual Cash Value 58.16 29.08 50.0% 5.0<br />

1395 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 169 1 drum seat/Gibraltar 5600 series Actual Cash Value 53.88 43.10 80.0% 8.0<br />

1396 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 170 1 bike dual water holder/Profile<br />

Design Aquarack<br />

Actual Cash Value 43.10 12.93 30.0% 3.0<br />

1397 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 171 1 bike gloves/specialized BG deflect Actual Cash Value 43.09 17.23 40.0% 2.0<br />

1398 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 172 1 repair patch kit for bike/ Genuine<br />

innovations<br />

Actual Cash Value 32.33 12.93 40.0% 2.0<br />

1399 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 173 4 bike tubes/specialized 700 cc Actual Cash Value 21.55 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1400 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 174 2 bike tires/specialized armadillo Actual Cash Value 107.75 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1401 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 175 2 multi purpose bike tool/crank<br />

brothers multi 5<br />

Actual Cash Value 27.99 8.39 30.0% 3.0<br />

1402 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 176 2 C02 cartridges/genuine<br />

innovations<br />

Actual Cash Value 21.53 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1403 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 177 1 C02 adapter/Genuine innovations Actual Cash Value 21.54 4.30 20.0% 1.0<br />

1404 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 178 1 bike helmet/bell XLV Actual Cash Value 43.10 17.24 40.0% 2.0<br />

1405 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 179 1 bike lock/bell ahnds off U lock Actual Cash Value 13.78 8.26 59.9% 3.0<br />

1406 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 180 1 bull dog bike lock/ on guard pitbull<br />

STD<br />

Actual Cash Value 59.25 23.70 40.0% 2.0<br />

1407 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 181 1 tool belt apron & pouch/ Home<br />

depot generic<br />

Actual Cash Value 21.55 17.24 80.0% 6.0<br />

1408 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 182 1 set bike pedals/ Shimano Actual Cash Value 64.64 38.78 60.0% 3.0<br />

1409 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 183 1 bike extension stem/ specialized<br />

multi purpose<br />

Actual Cash Value 48.48 9.69 20.0% 1.0<br />

1410 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 184 1 Handlebars/ Ritchet Comp Actual Cash Value 45.24 9.04 20.0% 1.0<br />

1411 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 185 1 Cordless drill, 18v 1/2" Dewalt Actual Cash Value 106.67 32.00 30.0% 3.0<br />

1412 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 186 1 Bike Chain ring/ sugino Actual Cash Value 21.54 12.92 60.0% 3.0<br />

1413 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 187 1 Bike Chain Actual Cash Value 14.00 2.80 20.0% 1.0<br />

1414 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 188 1 Bike aerobars/ Profile design Actual Cash Value 129.29 77.57 60.0% 3.0<br />

1415 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 189 1 car trailer hitch/autozone Actual Cash Value 26.94 9.42 35.0% 7.0<br />

1416 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 190 1 bike rear fender/ City Works Actual Cash Value 26.94 10.77 40.0% 2.0<br />

1417 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 191 2 Coppertone sunscreen Actual Cash Value 15.09 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 29


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1418 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 192 1 socket set 58 pcs/ Ace hardware Actual Cash Value 36.62 7.32 20.0% 3.0<br />

1419 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 193 1 Rolling luggage set/ Black swiss<br />

army<br />

Actual Cash Value 279.07 69.76 25.0% 5.0<br />

1420 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 194 6 black duffle bags Actual Cash Value 129.30 32.32 25.0%<br />

1421 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 195 1 green army duffle bag Actual Cash Value 32.33 16.16 50.0% 10.0<br />

1422 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 196 1 lawn games kit Actual Cash Value 10.78 4.31 40.0% 2.0<br />

1423 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 198 1 bike saddle seat/specialized hett Actual Cash Value 129.30 25.86 20.0% 1.0<br />

1424 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 199 1 Bike trainer/ Cycle Ops magnetic Actual Cash Value 203.65 122.19 60.0% 3.0<br />

1425 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 200 1 Fire extinguisher Actual Cash Value 23.69 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1426 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 201 1 basketball/ Wilson Actual Cash Value 37.70 7.54 20.0% 1.0<br />

1427 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 202 1 in line skates Actual Cash Value 80.81 64.64 80.0% 5.0<br />

1428 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 203 1 fundamental of federal income Actual Cash Value 190.72 11.44 6.0% 1.5<br />

1429 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 204 1 Modern american<br />

remedies/Laycock<br />

Actual Cash Value 200.42 8.01 4.0% 1.0<br />

1430 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 205 1 Taxation of Individual income Actual Cash Value 160.55 3.21 2.0% 0.5<br />

1431 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 206 1 internal tax Actual Cash Value 134.69 2.69 2.0% 0.5<br />

1432 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 207 1 tax controversies: Prac & Proc Actual Cash Value 139.00 2.78 2.0% 0.5<br />

1433 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 208 1 law Summaries: Comm<br />

Prop/Reppy Jr<br />

Actual Cash Value 40.95 4.09 10.0% 2.5<br />

1434 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 209 1 Black Letter Outline: Crim Law/<br />

Dressler<br />

Actual Cash Value 50.97 5.09 10.0% 2.5<br />

1435 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 210 1 Office Supplies Actual Cash Value 107.75 35.91 33.3%<br />

1436 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 211 1 Evidence: A Contemporary Appr Actual Cash Value 183.18 10.99 6.0% 1.5<br />

1437 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 212 1 Con law: principles & Policies Actual Cash Value 62.50 1.25 2.0% 0.5<br />

1438 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 213 1 Federal Juris/Chemerinsky Actual Cash Value 79.74 1.59 2.0% 0.5<br />

1439 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 214 1 Corps & other bus enterprises/<br />

Hazen<br />

Actual Cash Value 205.80 12.34 6.0% 1.5<br />

1440 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 215 1 Constitutional Law/ Stone Actual Cash Value 213.35 4.26 2.0% 0.5<br />

1441 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 216 1 Tort law & Alternatives / Franklin Actual Cash Value 191.80 19.18 10.0% 2.5<br />

1442 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 217 1 Contracts: Basics/ Blum Actual Cash Value 197.18 19.71 10.0% 2.5<br />

1443 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 218 1 Elementary Statistics/ Triola Actual Cash Value 7.76 1.55 20.0% 5.0<br />

1444 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 219 1 Fundamentals of Int'l Business /<br />

Czinkota<br />

Actual Cash Value 196.05 11.76 6.0% 1.5<br />

1445 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 220 1 California Style manual/Jessen Actual Cash Value 18.26 1.82 10.0% 2.5<br />

1446 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 221 300 National Geographic magazines/<br />

1940s-1980s<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,616.25 808.12 50.0%<br />

1447 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 222 12 Easton Press Classic<br />

Literatu/Collection of Classics<br />

Actual Cash Value 323.25 226.27 70.0% 7.0<br />

1448 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 223 1 Wills, Trusts &<br />

Estates/Dukeminier<br />

Actual Cash Value 209.04 4.18 2.0% 0.5<br />

1449 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 224 1 Federal <strong>Court</strong>s: Cases & Latters Actual Cash Value 163.78 3.27 2.0% 0.5<br />

1450 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 225 1 Legal Writing & Analysis Actual Cash Value 81.89 8.18 10.0% 2.5<br />

1451 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 226 1 Reason in Law Update Actual Cash Value 64.00 6.40 10.0% 2.5<br />

1452 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 227 1 Acing Property Actual Cash Value 34.48 2.06 6.0% 1.5<br />

1453 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 228 1 Acing Civil Procedure Actual Cash Value 34.48 2.06 6.0% 1.5<br />

1454 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 229 1 Contracts in a Nutshell Actual Cash Value 23.76 2.37 10.0% 2.5<br />

1455 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 230 1 American Indian Law in a Nutshell Actual Cash Value 40.95 2.45 6.0% 1.5<br />

1456 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 231 1 Selcted Fed Taxation Statutes Actual Cash Value 24.76 1.48 6.0% 1.5<br />

1457 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 232 1 Siegal/s Torts/Siegel & emanuel Actual Cash Value 33.35 3.33 10.0% 2.5<br />

1458 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 233 1 Business law: text & cases Actual Cash Value 297.34 17.84 6.0% 1.5<br />

10/15/2012 30


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1459 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 234 1 acing Con law Actual Cash Value 34.48 0.68 2.0% 0.5<br />

1460 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 235 1 Bankruptcy & Related law Actual Cash Value 37.71 0.75 2.0% 0.5<br />

1461 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 236 1 Property/Dukeminier Actual Cash Value 26.94 1.61 6.0% 1.5<br />

1462 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 237 1 Community property in California Actual Cash Value 179.94 17.99 10.0% 2.5<br />

1463 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 238 1 Fundamental of Corp. Taxation/<br />

Lind<br />

Actual Cash Value 185.33 11.11 6.0% 1.5<br />

1464 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 239 1 Criminal law/ Dressler Actual Cash Value 173.48 10.40 6.0% 1.5<br />

1465 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 240 1 Conflicts of Law/ Currie Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.38 10.0% 2.5<br />

1466 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 241 1 Fed <strong>Court</strong>, Federal & Sep of Actual Cash Value 189.64 18.96 10.0% 2.5<br />

1467 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 242 1 Federal Rules Civil Trails 20/Smith Actual Cash Value 20.46 1.22 6.0% 1.5<br />

1468 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 243 1 Business Assoc/ Klein Actual Cash Value 153.01 9.18 6.0% 1.5<br />

1469 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 244 1 Advanced Torts/ Dobbs Actual Cash Value 184.25 18.42 10.0% 2.5<br />

1470 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 245 1 Just Writing/ Enquist Actual Cash Value 6.15 0.61 9.9% 2.5<br />

1471 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 246 1 Corporations- Intro to law/ Cox Actual Cash Value 7.98 0.47 5.9% 1.5<br />

1472 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 247 1 Corporations: Examples & Expl Actual Cash Value 53.82 3.22 6.0% 1.5<br />

1473 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 248 1 Practical Guide to Appellate A Actual Cash Value 107.75 6.46 6.0% 1.5<br />

1474 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 249 1 Irrepable Harm/ Sneep Actual Cash Value 5.28 2.53 47.9% 12.0<br />

1475 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 250 1 The Big Short/ Lewis Actual Cash Value 45.85 3.66 8.0% 2.0<br />

1476 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 251 1 Federal Rules of Civ Pro/<br />

Clermont<br />

Actual Cash Value 45.26 2.71 6.0% 1.5<br />

1477 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 252 1 Civil Procedure: E/E/Glannon Actual Cash Value 38.78 2.32 6.0% 1.5<br />

1478 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 253 1 Property E/E / Burke & Snoe Actual Cash Value 52.74 3.16 6.0% 1.5<br />

1479 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 254 1 Civil Procedure Hornbook/<br />

Clermont<br />

Actual Cash Value 49.57 2.97 6.0% 1.5<br />

1480 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 255 1 Understanding Civil<br />

Procedure/Shreve<br />

Actual Cash Value 44.18 2.65 6.0% 1.5<br />

1481 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 256 1 Corporations & other LLP/ Hazen Actual Cash Value 36.64 2.19 6.0% 1.5<br />

1482 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 257 1 Legal Research: Prac<br />

Guide/McKinney<br />

Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 2.5<br />

1483 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 258 1 Summaries on Civil Procedures/<br />

West<br />

Actual Cash Value 75.21 4.51 6.0% 1.5<br />

1484 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 259 1 Summaries on Property/ West Actual Cash Value 40.95 2.45 6.0% 1.5<br />

1485 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 260 1 Emanuel law Outlines: Corps Actual Cash Value 43.10 2.58 6.0% 1.5<br />

1486 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 261 1 Q&A Wills and Trust/<br />

Featherstone<br />

Actual Cash Value 23.71 0.47 2.0% 0.5<br />

1487 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 262 1 Treatise on law of Usury/<br />

Blydenburgh<br />

Actual Cash Value 26.82 0.53 2.0% 0.5<br />

1488 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 263 1 Understanding conflicts of law Actual Cash Value 39.86 3.98 10.0% 2.5<br />

1489 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 264 1 Understanding Property law Actual Cash Value 145.99 8.75 6.0% 1.5<br />

1490 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 265 1 Understanding Torts Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.15 10.0% 2.5<br />

1491 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 266 1 Wills, trusts& estates/Beyer Actual Cash Value 53.82 1.07 2.0% 0.5<br />

1492 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 267 1 Street law/McGraw Hill Actual Cash Value 103.27 6.19 6.0% 1.5<br />

1493 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 268 1 Illustrated Oxford Dictionary Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.58 12.0% 3.0<br />

1494 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 269 1 Criminal Procedure/ White Actual Cash Value 13.46 1.34 10.0% 2.5<br />

1495 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 270 1 Advanced Torts: Cases & matters Actual Cash Value 121.76 12.17 10.0% 2.5<br />

1496 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 271 1 materials on Pleadings & proc Actual Cash Value 204.73 20.47 10.0% 2.5<br />

1497 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 272 1 Q & A: Criminal law/Marcus Actual Cash Value 31.25 3.12 10.0% 2.5<br />

1498 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 273 1 Law Summaries:<br />

Research/Honigsbert<br />

Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 2.5<br />

1499 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 274 1 Blender/ Hamilton Actual Cash Value 21.55 8.28 38.4% 5.0<br />

10/15/2012 31


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1500 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 277 1 Kitchen area rug/ IKEA Actual Cash Value 107.74 86.19 80.0% 3.0<br />

1501 189 05-M496-133 2/13/2012 278 1 Rubbermaid 20 pc set Actual Cash Value 17.23 3.44 20.0% 1.0<br />

1 1502 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 1 10 Shoes Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

487.13 146.13 33.3% 5.0<br />

1503 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 2 1 Shoes / Mens work shoes Actual Cash Value 37.89 25.26 66.7% 3.0<br />

1504 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 3 1 Boots / Ladies Brown Actual Cash Value 54.13 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

1505 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 4 1 Jacket / Leather ladies Actual Cash Value 211.09 0.00 0.0% 3.0<br />

1506 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 5 1 Suit - Ladies Actual Cash Value 81.19 20.29 25.0% 4.0<br />

1507 194 55-E089-494 3/29/2010 6 6 Blouses - Ladies Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

119.08 21.65 33.3% 2.0<br />

1508 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 1 1 AC anywhere adapter Actual Cash Value 48.54 14.56 30.0%<br />

1509 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 2 1 Wireless mouse / Microsoft Actual Cash Value 43.15 1.79 4.2%<br />

1510 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 4 1 Cell phone / Razor Actual Cash Value 269.69 4.49 1.7%<br />

1511 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 5 1 Hands free / Jabra Actual Cash Value 107.88 1.79 1.7%<br />

1512 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 6 2 Cell phone chargers / Motorola Actual Cash Value 32.36 0.53 1.6%<br />

1513 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 7 1 Power toothbrush / Oral B Actual Cash Value 161.81 40.45 25.0%<br />

1514 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 9 1 Sunglasses, Titanium / Maui Jim Actual Cash Value 323.63 32.36 10.0%<br />

1515 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 10 2 Blow dryers Actual Cash Value 64.73 6.47 10.0%<br />

1516 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 11 1 Electric beard trimmer Actual Cash Value 37.76 1.57 4.2%<br />

1517 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 12 1 Shaver - self cleaning / Braun Actual Cash Value 161.81 32.36 20.0%<br />

1518 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 13 1 Computer travel bag Actual Cash Value 70.12 14.02 20.0%<br />

1519 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 15 1 Leather Briefcase Actual Cash Value 161.81 16.18 10.0%<br />

1520 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 17 1 Office Professional Software /<br />

Microsoft<br />

Actual Cash Value 323.63 64.72 20.0%<br />

1521 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 20 1 Make-up case Actual Cash Value 53.94 1.12 2.1%<br />

1522 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 21 5 Printer cartridges / HP Actual Cash Value 80.91 0.00 0.0%<br />

1523 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 22 3 Prescription meds / Levoxy/pepcid<br />

ac / etc.<br />

Actual Cash Value 107.90 0.00 0.0%<br />

1524 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 23 1 Pentax camera / Pentax Actual Cash Value 539.38 26.96 5.0%<br />

1525 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 24 1 Macro camera lens Actual Cash Value 161.81 8.09 5.0%<br />

1526 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 25 1 External 2gb drive / K2 Actual Cash Value 64.73 14.83 22.9%<br />

1527 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 26 1 Ladies wallet Actual Cash Value 53.94 13.48 25.0%<br />

1528 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 27 1 Cash in wallet Actual Cash Value 500.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1529 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 28 1 Calculator Actual Cash Value 107.88 21.57 20.0%<br />

1530 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 29 1 Textbooks, Real Estate Actual Cash Value 107.88 0.71 0.7%<br />

1531 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 31 1 Dog bed Actual Cash Value 43.15 3.59 8.3%<br />

1532 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 32 1 Dog harness Actual Cash Value 37.76 0.62 1.6%<br />

1533 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 33 1 Dog goggles Actual Cash Value 32.36 0.53 1.6%<br />

1534 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 34 2 Sm wicker chests, 5 drawer Actual Cash Value 107.88 43.15 40.0%<br />

1535 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 35 2 Throw pillow decorative, lg Actual Cash Value 53.94 0.00 0.0%<br />

1536 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 36 1 Household cleaning supplies Actual Cash Value 75.51 0.00 0.0%<br />

1537 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 38 1 Food Actual Cash Value 269.69 0.00 0.0%<br />

1538 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 39 1 Atomic clock Actual Cash Value 64.73 6.47 10.0%<br />

1539 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 40 1 Bedside lamp Actual Cash Value 21.58 1.61 7.5%<br />

1540 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 41 1 Recliner & footrest Actual Cash Value 215.75 28.76 13.3%<br />

1541 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 42 1 Electric bedside clock Actual Cash Value 21.58 1.43 6.6%<br />

1542 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 43 1 Portable rv space heater Actual Cash Value 32.36 7.19 22.2%<br />

1543 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 44 8 Skeins yarn Actual Cash Value 64.73 2.15 3.3%<br />

1544 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 45 1 Waste basket Actual Cash Value 10.79 0.35 3.2%<br />

1545 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 46 1 Retractable door screen /<br />

Phantom<br />

Actual Cash Value 323.63 7.19 2.2%<br />

1546 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 47 2 Sets queen sheets Actual Cash Value 64.73 9.70 15.0%<br />

1547 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 48 2 Down pillows, bed Actual Cash Value 86.30 8.63 10.0%<br />

10/15/2012 32


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

1548 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 49 2 Reg pillows, bed Actual Cash Value 32.36 3.23 10.0%<br />

1549 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 50 1 Queen mattress pad Actual Cash Value 26.97 4.04 15.0%<br />

1550 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 51 2 Sofa throws Actual Cash Value 75.51 15.10 20.0%<br />

1551 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 52 2 Bed blankets Actual Cash Value 43.15 6.47 15.0%<br />

1552 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 53 1 Down comforter Actual Cash Value 107.88 16.18 15.0%<br />

1553 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 54 1 Down mattress topper Actual Cash Value 107.88 16.18 15.0%<br />

1554 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 55 12 Dish towels Actual Cash Value 1.45 0.36 24.8%<br />

1555 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 56 1 Throw rug, 2x4 Actual Cash Value 21.58 3.23 15.0%<br />

1556 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 57 1 Shower curtain Actual Cash Value 10.79 8.63 80.0%<br />

1557 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 58 3 Bathroom rugs Actual Cash Value 48.54 7.28 15.0%<br />

1558 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 59 1 Kitchen rug Actual Cash Value 16.18 2.42 15.0%<br />

1559 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 60 4 Beach towels Actual Cash Value 64.73 21.57 33.3%<br />

1560 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 61 2 Metal bread baskets Actual Cash Value 12.95 5.18 40.0%<br />

1561 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 62 1 Paper products Actual Cash Value 53.94 0.00 0.0%<br />

1562 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 63 1 Wicker hamper basket Actual Cash Value 21.58 4.31 20.0%<br />

1563 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 64 1 Coffee grinder / Krups Actual Cash Value 32.36 1.61 5.0%<br />

1564 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 65 1 Coffee maker, 4 cup Actual Cash Value 32.36 6.47 20.0%<br />

1565 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 66 1 Sm expresso mach Actual Cash Value 53.94 21.57 40.0%<br />

1566 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 67 1 Toaster / Kitchen aid Actual Cash Value 43.15 1.34 3.1%<br />

1567 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 68 1 Hand mixer / Kitchen aid Actual Cash Value 43.15 1.79 4.2%<br />

1568 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 69 1 Blender/chopper combo Actual Cash Value 80.91 4.66 5.8%<br />

1569 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 70 1 Iron Actual Cash Value 43.15 3.59 8.3%<br />

1570 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 71 1 Ironing board Actual Cash Value 32.36 1.61 5.0%<br />

1571 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 72 1 Stick vac / Eureka Actual Cash Value 91.69 6.11 6.7%<br />

1572 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 73 1 Serv 8 dishware / Target Actual Cash Value 70.12 10.51 15.0%<br />

1573 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 74 1 Serv 8 silverware / Target Actual Cash Value 53.94 0.53 1.0%<br />

1574 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 75 1 Serv 8 glassware / Target Actual Cash Value 32.36 1.61 5.0%<br />

1575 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 76 8 Wine glasses Actual Cash Value 43.15 8.63 20.0%<br />

1576 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 77 1 Knife set w/block Actual Cash Value 53.94 3.67 6.8%<br />

1577 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 78 1 Kitchen utensils w/crock Actual Cash Value 64.73 6.06 9.4%<br />

1578 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 79 1 10pc Pots & pans / Tools of The<br />

Trade<br />

Actual Cash Value 80.91 3.03 3.7%<br />

1579 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 80 1 10pc Baking pans / Tools of The<br />

Trade<br />

Actual Cash Value 43.15 1.61 3.7%<br />

1580 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 81 1 3pc Set glass baking pans Actual Cash Value 26.97 2.02 7.5%<br />

1581 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 82 1 Lg serving bowl Actual Cash Value 26.97 5.39 20.0%<br />

1582 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 83 8 Coffee mugs Actual Cash Value 60.41 9.06 15.0%<br />

1583 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 84 3 Lg hand painted serve pieces Actual Cash Value 86.31 17.26 20.0%<br />

1584 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 85 6 Shorts / Charter Club Actual Cash Value 194.18 48.54 25.0%<br />

1585 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 87 1 Suede shirt jacket Actual Cash Value 107.88 35.96 33.3%<br />

1586 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 89 2 Jeans / Levis Actual Cash Value 86.30 21.57 25.0%<br />

1587 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 90 10 Undershorts Actual Cash Value 53.94 26.97 50.0%<br />

1588 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 91 8 Socks, crew Actual Cash Value 27.01 13.50 50.0%<br />

1589 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 93 1 Topsiders, pair Actual Cash Value 70.12 5.84 8.3%<br />

1590 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 94 1 Jacket Actual Cash Value 53.94 5.99 11.1%<br />

1591 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 96 1 Birkenstocks Actual Cash Value 91.69 15.28 16.7%<br />

1592 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 97 1 Bathing suit / Ralph Lauren Actual Cash Value 134.84 67.42 50.0%<br />

1593 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 99 1 Purse / Louis Vuitton Actual Cash Value 431.50 23.97 5.6%<br />

1594 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 102 1 Bandolino sandals Actual Cash Value 43.15 3.59 8.3%<br />

1595 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 105 1 Black flats / Nine West Actual Cash Value 53.94 17.98 33.3%<br />

1596 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 106 1 Water shoes, mens / Nike Actual Cash Value 43.15 14.38 33.3%<br />

1597 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 108 1 White sandals Actual Cash Value 32.36 10.78 33.3%<br />

1598 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 109 1 Fur lined leather clogs / Merrills Actual Cash Value 134.84 14.98 11.1%<br />

1599 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 112 1 White jeans / Ralph Lauren Actual Cash Value 107.34 4.47 4.2%<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

10/15/2012 33


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1600 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 113 2 Jeans blk/blu / Lucky Brand Actual Cash Value 215.75 53.93 25.0%<br />

1601 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 115 1 White linen bermudas / Liz<br />

Claiborne<br />

Actual Cash Value 48.54 20.22 41.7%<br />

1602 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 116 3 Skorts, wht, blk, blu Actual Cash Value 97.09 36.40 37.5%<br />

1603 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 118 1 Fr terry sweat suit / Bass Actual Cash Value 53.94 10.48 19.4%<br />

1604 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 119 1 Ski jacket Actual Cash Value 53.94 2.69 5.0%<br />

1605 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 121 2 White sweaters Actual Cash Value 86.30 28.76 33.3%<br />

1606 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 122 1 White embroidered blouse / Style<br />

& Co<br />

Actual Cash Value 43.15 14.38 33.3%<br />

1607 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 123 1 Polka dot blouse Actual Cash Value 43.15 3.59 8.3%<br />

1608 197 05-M430-965 6/18/2008 124 2 White twill stretch Actual Cash Value 86.30 28.76 33.3%<br />

1 1609 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 2 1 jeans/sevens ACV 150.47 87.77 58.3% 2.0<br />

1610 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 3 1 Rug ACV 247.89 198.31 80.0% 14.0<br />

1611 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 4 1 Black Jacket ACV 43.30 14.43 33.3%<br />

1612 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 5 1 Mirror ACV 21.65 5.41 25.0%<br />

1613 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 6 1 Wrapping paper organizer ACV 27.08 2.71 10.0%<br />

1614 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 7 1 <strong>Filing</strong> Cabinet ACV 151.54 12.63 8.3% 2.0<br />

1615 163 75-M446-056 1/26/2006 8 1 Office Supply Cabinet ACV 162.36 54.12 33.3%<br />

1 1616 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 1 1 brown rug Actual Cash Value 134.69 89.97 66.7% 2.0<br />

1617 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 2 4 rug w/ squares Actual Cash Value 86.20 57.46 66.7% 2.0<br />

1618 176 75-M523-509 7/28/2008 3 1 refrigerator / Kenmore Actual Cash Value 915.88 427.41 46.7% 7.0<br />

1619 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 1 1 food - in refrigerator Actual Cash Value 27.44 0.00 0.0%<br />

1620 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 2 1 food - in pantry Actual Cash Value 27.44 0.00 0.0%<br />

1 1621 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 3 1 area rugs - kitchen Actual Cash Value 52.68 17.56 33.3% 1.0<br />

1622 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 4 1 white lace tablecloth Actual Cash Value 32.93 6.58 20.0% 1.0<br />

1623 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 5 16 kitchen towels, dish towels Actual Cash Value 54.88 16.46 30.0% 1.5<br />

1624 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 6 1 white plastic trash bin Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9% 1.0<br />

1625 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 7 1 toaster Actual Cash Value 43.89 10.97 25.0% 2.0<br />

1626 116 75-M592-294 7/26/2010 8 2 fans Actual Cash Value 131.68 26.33 20.0% 2.5<br />

1 1627 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 1 37 complete set of Britannica En / gift Actual Cash Value 1,249.54 495.50 39.7% 23.0<br />

1628 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 3 42 photo reprints Actual Cash Value 221.07 0.00 0.0% 20.0<br />

1629 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 4 31 photo reprints Actual Cash Value 81.58 0.00 0.0%<br />

1630 117 75-M548-962 8/11/2009 5 97 photo reprints Actual Cash Value 29.54 0.00 0.0%<br />

1 1631 119 05-M370-594 10/31/2005 1 2 Area Rug / Macy Actual Cash Value 217.50 16.31 7.5% 0.5<br />

1 1632 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 1 10 bodysuits Actual Cash Value 64.92 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

1633 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 2 6 Footed pajamas Actual Cash Value 77.96 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

1634 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 3 25 Socks Actual Cash Value 67.73 22.57 33.3% 1.0<br />

1635 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 4 5 Girl's dresses Actual Cash Value 97.48 48.74 50.0% 1.5<br />

1636 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 5 3 Girl's leggings Actual Cash Value 26.01 2.89 11.1% 0.3<br />

1637 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 6 10 Girl's t-shirts Actual Cash Value 108.38 36.12 33.3% 1.0<br />

1638 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 7 3 Nursing bras Actual Cash Value 162.53 13.54 8.3% 0.3<br />

1639 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 8 4 T-shirts Actual Cash Value 34.64 23.09 66.7% 2.0<br />

1640 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 9 3 Towels Actual Cash Value 48.77 32.51 66.7% 2.0<br />

1641 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 10 1 Comforter Actual Cash Value 162.55 97.53 60.0% 3.0<br />

1642 120 05-M475-002 3/23/2010 11 2 Sheets Actual Cash Value 43.33 34.66 80.0% 4.0<br />

1 1643 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 4 1 Medium size bath rug Actual Cash Value 32.93 7.31 22.2% 0.7<br />

1644 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 6 6 Matching bathroom accessories Actual Cash Value 219.50 48.77 22.2% 0.7<br />

1645 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 7 4 Lrg. bath towels Actual Cash Value 175.60 39.02 22.2% 0.7<br />

1646 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 8 8 Toilet paper rolls Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0%<br />

1647 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 9 2 Q-tip box Actual Cash Value 8.78 0.00 0.0%<br />

1648 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 10 1 Cotton balls, jumbo sz. Actual Cash Value 3.29 0.00 0.0%<br />

1649 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 11 2 Med size wooden pict frame Actual Cash Value 43.90 4.39 10.0%<br />

1650 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 12 7 Shampoo and conditioner Actual Cash Value 76.83 38.41 50.0%<br />

10/15/2012 34


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1651 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 13 5 Adult toothbruses Actual Cash Value 27.44 13.72 50.0%<br />

1652 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 14 1 Child toothbrushes Actual Cash Value 5.49 2.74 49.9%<br />

1653 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 15 4 Adult toothpaste Bottles Actual Cash Value 27.44 13.72 50.0%<br />

1654 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 16 1 Child toothpaste Actual Cash Value 4.39 2.19 49.9%<br />

1655 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 17 1 Small trash bin Actual Cash Value 18.66 4.14 22.2%<br />

1656 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 18 1 Hair mousse Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.49 50.0%<br />

1657 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 19 1 Mouthwash Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.49 50.0%<br />

1658 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 20 2 Body spray Actual Cash Value 21.95 10.97 50.0%<br />

1659 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 23 4 Sm. Lotion bottles Actual Cash Value 43.90 21.95 22.0%<br />

1660 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 24 1 Men's razor Actual Cash Value 21.95 10.97 50.0%<br />

1661 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 25 1 Plastic soap container Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0%<br />

1662 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 26 1 Plastic child stool Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.74 25.0%<br />

1663 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 28 1 Lg cosmetic holder Actual Cash Value 164.63 32.92 20.0%<br />

1664 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 30 1 Lg medicine cabinet w/ mirror Actual Cash Value 54.88 7.31 13.3% 0.7<br />

1665 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 31 1 Wood 5-candle holder Actual Cash Value 16.46 8.23 50.0%<br />

1666 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 32 5 Sm. Round candles Actual Cash Value 5.46 0.00 0.0%<br />

1667 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 33 1 Sm bag of décor rocks Actual Cash Value 5.49 2.74 49.9%<br />

1668 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 34 1 Med size vacuum Actual Cash Value 109.75 4.87 4.4% 0.7<br />

1669 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 35 2 Extra lg shelves w/Storage Actual Cash Value 87.80 17.56 20.0%<br />

1670 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 36 1 Sm. bed spring Actual Cash Value 87.80 8.78 10.0%<br />

1671 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 38 11 Wood misc décor Actual Cash Value 296.33 148.16 50.0%<br />

1672 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 39 1 Metal paper towel holder Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0%<br />

1673 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 40 3 Rolls of foil Actual Cash Value 9.88 0.00 0.0%<br />

1674 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 41 3 Ziplock sandwich bag box Actual Cash Value 26.34 0.00 0.0%<br />

1675 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 42 3 Med. wood frames Actual Cash Value 65.85 6.58 10.0%<br />

1676 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 43 3 Dish sponge Actual Cash Value 5.21 0.00 0.0%<br />

1677 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 44 5 Cleaning cloths Actual Cash Value 27.44 21.95 80.0% 2.5<br />

1678 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 45 2 Round metal candle stick holde Actual Cash Value 54.88 32.92 60.0% 3.0<br />

1679 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 46 7 Small forks / Target Actual Cash Value 32.93 9.87 30.0% 3.0<br />

1680 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 47 7 Butter knives / Target Actual Cash Value 54.88 16.46 30.0% 3.0<br />

1681 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 48 7 Tea spoons / Target Actual Cash Value 32.93 9.87 30.0% 3.0<br />

1682 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 49 7 Forks / Target Actual Cash Value 54.88 16.46 30.0% 3.0<br />

1683 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 50 7 Spoons / Target Actual Cash Value 65.85 19.75 30.0% 3.0<br />

1684 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 51 2 Lrg knife / Target Actual Cash Value 43.90 13.17 30.0% 3.0<br />

1685 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 52 1 Plastic utensil tray Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.11 37.4% 3.0<br />

1686 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 53 9 Lrg. cooking spoons Actual Cash Value 98.78 29.63 30.0% 3.0<br />

1687 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 54 1 Metal garlic press Actual Cash Value 10.98 3.29 30.0% 3.0<br />

1688 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 55 1 Lrg. kitchen knife w/Shield Actual Cash Value 21.95 6.58 30.0% 3.0<br />

1689 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 56 1 Electric hand blender Actual Cash Value 109.75 16.88 15.4% 2.0<br />

1690 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 57 2 Metal can opener Actual Cash Value 21.95 13.17 60.0% 3.0<br />

1691 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 58 1 Eletric can opener Actual Cash Value 43.90 7.31 16.7% 1.0<br />

1692 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 59 10 Asst. large books Actual Cash Value 109.75 43.90 40.0% 3.0<br />

1693 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 60 11 Set of sm plastic dishes Actual Cash Value 109.75 65.85 60.0% 3.0<br />

1694 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 62 4 Child's plastic plate Actual Cash Value 10.98 6.58 59.9% 3.0<br />

1695 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 63 6 Child's plastic cup Actual Cash Value 32.93 19.75 60.0% 3.0<br />

1696 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 64 1 Large dish rack Actual Cash Value 109.75 32.92 30.0% 1.5<br />

1697 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 65 1 Large chop wizard Actual Cash Value 32.93 8.23 25.0% 1.5<br />

1698 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 66 1 Glass container Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9%<br />

1699 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 67 4 Coffee mugs Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0%<br />

1700 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 68 1 Baby bottle sponge Actual Cash Value 10.98 3.66 33.3% 0.3<br />

1701 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 69 1 Turkish coffee pot Actual Cash Value 54.88 16.46 30.0% 3.0<br />

1702 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 70 2 Kitchen scissors Actual Cash Value 43.90 4.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

1703 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 71 3 Metal tea/sugar containers Actual Cash Value 32.93 6.58 20.0% 3.0<br />

1704 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 72 40 Numbers / Alphabet magnets Actual Cash Value 54.88 27.44 50.0% 2.5<br />

10/15/2012 35


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1705 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 73 6 White onions Actual Cash Value 6.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1706 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 74 1 Lrg. plastic container w/Med Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.49 50.0%<br />

1707 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 75 2 Metal cake spatula Actual Cash Value 54.88 13.72 25.0% 2.5<br />

1708 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 76 1 Metal cake knife Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0%<br />

1709 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 77 8 Asst wine glasses Actual Cash Value 54.88 21.95 40.0%<br />

1710 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 78 2 Med candles Actual Cash Value 109.75 54.87 50.0%<br />

1711 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 79 1 Metal oven racks Actual Cash Value 54.88 7.31 13.3% 0.7<br />

1712 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 80 3 Metal Stove tops Actual Cash Value 164.63 21.95 13.3% 0.7<br />

1713 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 81 1 Box of lrg. freezer bags Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% 0.7<br />

1714 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 82 1 Lrg. Palmolive dish soap Actual Cash Value 10.98 0.00 0.0% 0.1<br />

1715 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 83 1 Lrg. glass bowl Actual Cash Value 10.98 1.09 9.9% 1.0<br />

1716 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 84 2 Metal spoon rest Actual Cash Value 16.46 2.19 13.3% 0.7<br />

1717 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 85 1 Sm. bag of easter décor Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.83 33.3% 0.7<br />

1718 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 86 2 Baskets Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.87 22.2% 0.7<br />

1719 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 87 1 Lrg. box of bandages Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0%<br />

1720 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 88 1 Metal towel holder Actual Cash Value 32.93 4.39 13.3% 0.7<br />

1721 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 89 1 Lunch bag Actual Cash Value 5.49 1.09 19.9% 1.0<br />

1722 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 90 3 Empty engraved wine bottles Actual Cash Value 32.93 16.46 50.0% 2.0<br />

1723 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 91 1 Lrg. juicer Actual Cash Value 109.75 18.29 16.7% 2.0<br />

1724 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 92 2 Lrg. water kettle Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.39 20.0% 2.0<br />

1725 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 93 4 Set of sm. square glass dishes Actual Cash Value 43.90 8.78 20.0%<br />

1726 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 94 7 Set of med. square glass dishes Actual Cash Value 131.70 26.34 20.0%<br />

1727 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 95 2 Lrg. serving dishes Actual Cash Value 43.90 13.17 30.0% 3.0<br />

1728 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 96 2 Set of sm. round dishes Actual Cash Value 10.98 6.58 59.9% 3.0<br />

1729 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 97 10 sm.all flat dish set Actual Cash Value 109.75 32.92 30.0% 3.0<br />

1730 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 98 10 Set of sm. and lrg. dishes Actual Cash Value 109.75 32.92 30.0% 3.0<br />

1731 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 99 22 Asst sizes of plastic containers Actual Cash Value 219.50 65.85 30.0% 3.0<br />

1732 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 100 1 small wood cup holder Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.19 20.0%<br />

1733 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 101 6 Cooking pots (2 lrg, 3 med., 1 Actual Cash Value 109.75 21.95 20.0%<br />

1734 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 102 1 Frying pans Actual Cash Value 21.95 2.19 10.0%<br />

1735 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 103 9 Pot lids Actual Cash Value 197.55 39.51 20.0%<br />

1736 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 104 1 lrg. glass pitcher Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.19 20.0%<br />

1737 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 105 1 Telephone w/ base in box / V-<br />

Tech<br />

Actual Cash Value 131.70 39.51 30.0% 3.0<br />

1738 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 106 1 Metal case w/ misc items Actual Cash Value 109.75 21.95 20.0%<br />

1739 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 107 1 Swiss Army knife Actual Cash Value 21.95 4.36 20.0%<br />

1740 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 108 1 Blues Band harmonica Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.19 20.0% 1.0<br />

1741 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 109 1 sm. salter scale Actual Cash Value 54.88 10.97 20.0% 1.0<br />

1742 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 110 1 Roll of trash bags Actual Cash Value 32.93 0.00 0.0% 0.2<br />

1743 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 111 7 Shopping bags Actual Cash Value 7.68 0.00 0.0%<br />

1744 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 112 1 lrg. metal serving tray Actual Cash Value 10.98 2.19 20.0%<br />

1745 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 113 1 Med. Plastic serving tray Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0%<br />

1746 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 114 1 Pictures (many) Actual Cash Value 219.50 109.75 50.0% 1.0<br />

1747 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 115 1 Bottle/can opener Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0%<br />

1748 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 116 1 Wine opener Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

1749 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 117 1 Bottle opener Actual Cash Value 10.98 4.39 40.0% 2.0<br />

1750 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 118 4 Set small square soup dishes Actual Cash Value 109.75 21.95 20.0% 2.0<br />

1751 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 119 1 Wooden spice rack (15 spaces) Actual Cash Value 43.90 17.56 40.0% 2.0<br />

1752 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 120 1 Metal spice rack (20 spaces) Actual Cash Value 65.85 6.58 10.0% 2.0<br />

1753 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 121 29 Asst spices, small sz Actual Cash Value 145.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1754 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 122 3 Asst spiaces, lrg size Actual Cash Value 30.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1755 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 123 9 Asst canned foods Actual Cash Value 50.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1756 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 124 1 lrg. balsamic vinegar Actual Cash Value 10.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1757 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 125 2 Box of asst teas Actual Cash Value 10.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

10/15/2012 36


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1758 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 126 1 lrg. bag of seeds Actual Cash Value 5.49 0.00 0.0%<br />

1759 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 127 2 Sm. bag of beans Actual Cash Value 8.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1760 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 128 2 Sm. bag of wheat Actual Cash Value 10.00 0.00 0.0%<br />

1761 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 129 1 3pc L-shaped couch Actual Cash Value 2,195.00 548.75 25.0% 5.0<br />

1762 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 130 1 HP laptop Actual Cash Value 1,646.25 548.75 33.3% 6.0<br />

1763 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 131 1 Refrigerator/ Hot Point Actual Cash Value 548.75 73.16 13.3% 2.0<br />

1764 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 132 1 Dining room table Actual Cash Value 1,536.49 717.02 46.7% 7.0<br />

1765 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 133 1 Microwave Actual Cash Value 548.75 24.94 4.5% 0.5<br />

1766 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 134 1 Canon printer Actual Cash Value 130.60 43.53 33.3%<br />

1767 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 135 1 Dresser, night stand and bed<br />

frame w/ marble top<br />

Actual Cash Value 4,390.00 1,580.40 36.0% 9.0<br />

1768 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 136 1 DELETED - Side table Actual Cash Value 0.00 0.00 13.3% 2.0<br />

1769 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 137 4 Lamps Actual Cash Value 329.25 263.40 80.0% 9.0<br />

1770 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 138 4 Bar stool Actual Cash Value 439.00 29.26 6.7% 1.0<br />

1771 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 139 1 TV/DVD/VCR/ Sylvania Actual Cash Value 439.00 109.75 25.0% 3.0<br />

1772 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 140 1 Tivo recorder Actual Cash Value 109.75 7.62 6.9% 0.4<br />

1773 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 141 1 Toshiba tv Actual Cash Value 329.25 192.06 58.3% 7.0<br />

1774 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 142 9 Coffee table Actual Cash Value 548.75 109.75 20.0% 3.0<br />

1775 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 143 1 Bar table Actual Cash Value 329.25 197.55 60.0% 9.0<br />

1776 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 144 4 Vases, China Actual Cash Value 1,097.50 548.75 50.0%<br />

1777 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 145 1 Camera / Canon Actual Cash Value 878.00 175.60 20.0% 4.0<br />

1778 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 146 1 47" flat screen tv / vizio Actual Cash Value 864.82 288.27 33.3% 4.0<br />

1779 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 147 1 DVD player/ Coby Actual Cash Value 98.76 8.23 8.3% 0.5<br />

1780 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 148 1 DVD rack/ RO Actual Cash Value 54.88 10.97 20.0% 1.0<br />

1781 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 149 1 Ottoman Actual Cash Value 43.90 0.48 1.1% 0.2<br />

1782 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 150 1 All kids furniture & contents Actual Cash Value 1,317.00 321.93 24.4% 3.7<br />

1783 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 151 1 Foot rest Actual Cash Value 439.00 87.80 20.0%<br />

1784 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 152 1 Wine cooler/ fridge/Cuisinart Actual Cash Value 109.75 7.31 6.7% 1.0<br />

1785 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 153 1 Bathroom set. 7 pcs Actual Cash Value 329.25 73.16 22.2% 0.7<br />

1786 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 154 1 Toaster Actual Cash Value 109.75 41.15 37.5% 3.0<br />

1787 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 155 1 Baby grand piano Actual Cash Value 109.75 10.97 10.0% 1.0<br />

1788 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 156 2 Mens suit pants Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 3.0<br />

1789 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 157 2 Mens heavy leather jkt. Actual Cash Value 219.50 146.33 66.7% 2.0<br />

1790 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 158 1 Mens heavy wool coat Actual Cash Value 543.26 434.60 80.0% 5.0<br />

1791 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 159 1 Do ruck by Italy Actual Cash Value 439.00 351.00 80.0% 4.0<br />

1792 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 160 1 Wool coat/Huge Boss Actual Cash Value 762.76 610.20 80.0% 9.0<br />

1793 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 161 1 Mens coat/ Calvin Klein Actual Cash Value 219.50 109.75 50.0% 2.0<br />

1794 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 162 1 Mens suit/ Columbia Actual Cash Value 658.50 526.80 80.0% 5.0<br />

1795 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 163 1 Mens suit/ Boss Actual Cash Value 658.50 526.80 80.0% 5.0<br />

1796 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 164 4 Mens suits Actual Cash Value 548.75 439.00 80.0% 4.0<br />

1797 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 165 13 Mens button up shirts Actual Cash Value 548.75 182.91 33.3% 2.0<br />

1798 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 166 1 Black button up dress shirt/ Huge<br />

Boss<br />

Actual Cash Value 98.78 16.46 16.7% 0.5<br />

1799 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 167 3 Bathrobes Actual Cash Value 54.88 12.19 22.2% 0.7<br />

1800 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 168 1 Lrg. snow suit Actual Cash Value 109.75 43.90 40.0% 2.0<br />

1801 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 169 7 Mens polo shirt Actual Cash Value 384.13 256.08 66.7% 2.0<br />

1802 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 170 10 Mens long sleeve shirt/ Hugo<br />

Boss<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,097.50 731.66 66.7%<br />

1803 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 171 13 Mens tshirt Actual Cash Value 428.03 285.35 66.7% 2.0<br />

1804 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 172 18 Knitted wool sweater Actual Cash Value 987.75 658.50 66.7% 2.0<br />

1805 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 173 3 Lg throw blankets Actual Cash Value 164.63 82.31 50.0% 2.5<br />

1806 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 174 14 Asst bed spreads Actual Cash Value 1,536.50 460.95 30.0% 3.0<br />

1807 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 175 23 Asst pillow cases Actual Cash Value 378.64 227.18 60.0% 3.0<br />

1808 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 176 11 Feathered pillows Actual Cash Value 603.63 482.90 80.0% 3.0<br />

10/15/2012 37


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1809 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 177 2 Full size mattress Actual Cash Value 1,646.25 740.81 45.0% 9.0<br />

1810 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 178 2 Box springs Actual Cash Value 439.00 140.84 32.1% 6.5<br />

1811 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 179 4 Asst mens ties Actual Cash Value 109.75 65.85 60.0% 3.0<br />

1812 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 180 8 Asst mens hats Actual Cash Value 164.63 82.31 50.0%<br />

1813 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 181 7 Mens sport shoes Actual Cash Value 384.13 307.30 80.0% 3.0<br />

1814 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 182 1 laptop case Actual Cash Value 87.80 70.24 80.0% 6.0<br />

1815 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 183 1 Tent Actual Cash Value 219.50 21.95 10.0% 2.0<br />

1816 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 184 2 Scarves Actual Cash Value 109.75 54.87 50.0% 5.0<br />

1817 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 185 2 Women's pajamas Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 5.0<br />

1818 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 186 1 Mens wool vest Actual Cash Value 54.88 36.58 66.7% 2.0<br />

1819 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 187 1 Mens jeans Actual Cash Value 54.88 36.58 66.7% 2.0<br />

1820 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 188 1 Mens jean jacket Actual Cash Value 54.88 21.95 40.0% 2.0<br />

1821 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 189 4 Mens briefs Actual Cash Value 43.90 35.12 80.0% 1.0<br />

1822 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 190 34 Adult socks Actual Cash Value 186.58 149.26 80.0% 1.5<br />

1823 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 191 3 mens belt Actual Cash Value 65.85 39.51 60.0% 3.0<br />

1824 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 192 5 Kids blanket Actual Cash Value 137.19 54.87 40.0% 2.0<br />

1825 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 193 4 Table cloths Actual Cash Value 329.25 65.85 20.0% 1.0<br />

1826 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 194 3 Leg warmers Actual Cash Value 32.93 10.97 33.3%<br />

1827 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 195 2 Mens Blazer Actual Cash Value 548.75 235.17 42.9% 3.0<br />

1828 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 196 1 Womens Geraldine suit Actual Cash Value 164.63 58.79 35.7%<br />

1829 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 197 2 Womens suit Actual Cash Value 219.50 78.39 35.7%<br />

1830 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 198 4 Womens shorts Actual Cash Value 109.75 39.19 35.7%<br />

1831 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 199 6 Womens skirts Actual Cash Value 329.25 141.10 42.9% 3.0<br />

1832 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 200 6 Womens leggings Actual Cash Value 164.63 70.55 42.9% 3.0<br />

1833 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 201 15 Womens tank tops Actual Cash Value 411.56 176.38 42.9% 3.0<br />

1834 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 202 13 Womens fancy top Actual Cash Value 428.03 183.44 42.9% 3.0<br />

1835 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 203 12 Womens t-shirt Actual Cash Value 342.42 146.75 42.9% 3.0<br />

1836 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 204 10 Womens long-sleeve shirt Actual Cash Value 384.13 164.62 42.9% 3.0<br />

1837 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 205 10 Womens casual pants Actual Cash Value 329.25 65.85 20.0% 3.0<br />

1838 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 206 9 Womens sweater Actual Cash Value 768.25 329.25 42.9% 3.0<br />

1839 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 207 3 Womens jacket Actual Cash Value 548.75 235.17 42.9% 3.0<br />

1840 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 208 8 Womens sweats Actual Cash Value 219.50 94.07 42.9% 3.0<br />

1841 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 209 4 Fancy long gown Actual Cash Value 658.50 282.21 42.9% 3.0<br />

1842 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 211 3 Womens jeans Actual Cash Value 329.25 263.40 80.0% 3.0<br />

1843 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 212 7 Womens dressy pants Actual Cash Value 384.13 192.06 50.0% 1.5<br />

1844 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 213 3 Womens pajama pants Actual Cash Value 54.88 27.44 50.0% 1.5<br />

1845 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 214 10 Womens underwear Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 1.5<br />

1846 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 215 4 Bras Actual Cash Value 219.50 65.85 30.0% 1.5<br />

1847 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 216 7 Panty hose Actual Cash Value 691.43 553.14 80.0% 1.5<br />

1848 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 217 7 Womens belts Actual Cash Value 153.65 46.09 30.0% 1.5<br />

1849 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 218 14 Bra straps Actual Cash Value 164.63 131.70 80.0% 1.5<br />

1850 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 220 3 Womens suits Actual Cash Value 477.41 119.35 25.0% 2.5<br />

1851 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 221 7 Large comforter Actual Cash Value 921.90 460.95 50.0% 2.5<br />

1852 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 222 21 Pairs of childrens socks Actual Cash Value 184.38 147.50 80.0% 2.5<br />

1853 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 223 6 Sets of childs pajamas Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 2.5<br />

1854 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 224 1 Child track suit Actual Cash Value 54.88 43.90 80.0% 2.5<br />

1855 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 225 1 Twin size mattress Actual Cash Value 384.13 76.82 20.0% 4.0<br />

1856 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 226 1 Toddler size mattress Actual Cash Value 153.65 30.73 20.0% 4.0<br />

1857 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 227 1 Twin size comforter Actual Cash Value 98.78 39.51 40.0% 4.0<br />

1858 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 228 1 Twin size bedspread Actual Cash Value 87.80 35.12 40.0% 4.0<br />

1859 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 229 1 Childrens leg warmers Actual Cash Value 27.44 10.97 40.0% 2.0<br />

1860 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 230 19 Childrens leggings Actual Cash Value 250.23 125.11 50.0% 2.5<br />

1861 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 231 12 Childrens pants Actual Cash Value 144.87 72.43 50.0% 2.5<br />

1862 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 232 8 Childrens skirts Actual Cash Value 175.60 87.80 50.0% 2.5<br />

10/15/2012 38


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1863 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 233 10 Childrens t-shirts Actual Cash Value 164.63 82.31 50.0% 2.5<br />

1864 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 234 6 Childrens underwear Actual Cash Value 65.85 32.92 50.0% 2.5<br />

1865 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 235 19 Childrens long sleve shirts Actual Cash Value 312.79 156.39 50.0% 2.5<br />

1866 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 236 2 Childs night gown Actual Cash Value 109.75 54.87 50.0% 2.5<br />

1867 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 237 2 umbrellas Actual Cash Value 109.75 32.92 30.0% 1.5<br />

1868 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 238 21 Childrens sweater/jackets Actual Cash Value 691.43 345.71 50.0% 1.0<br />

1869 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 239 4 Chidrens vest Actual Cash Value 197.55 98.77 50.0% 1.0<br />

1870 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 240 1 Childs robe Actual Cash Value 32.93 16.46 50.0% 1.0<br />

1871 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 241 17 Childrens dresses Actual Cash Value 466.44 373.15 80.0% 2.5<br />

1872 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 242 2 Childrens shorts Actual Cash Value 32.93 11.76 35.7% 2.5<br />

1873 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 243 1 Childrens Halloween costume Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 2.5<br />

1874 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 244 2 Pairs of child shoes Actual Cash Value 109.75 87.80 80.0% 1.5<br />

1875 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 245 1 Child polo tennis shoes Actual Cash Value 54.88 43.90 80.0% 1.0<br />

1876 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 246 1 Childs rain boots Actual Cash Value 38.41 30.72 80.0% 1.0<br />

1877 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 247 2 Child sandals Actual Cash Value 87.80 29.26 33.3% 1.0<br />

1878 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 248 3 Childs boots Actual Cash Value 131.70 26.34 20.0% 1.0<br />

1879 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 249 3 Childrens jeans Actual Cash Value 98.78 29.63 30.0% 1.5<br />

1880 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 250 3 Childrens sweats Actual Cash Value 54.88 16.46 30.0% 2.5<br />

1881 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 251 12 Childrens hats Actual Cash Value 131.70 65.85 50.0% 2.5<br />

1882 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 252 1 Pair of child gloves Actual Cash Value 13.72 2.74 20.0% 1.0<br />

1883 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 253 2 Lg backpacks Actual Cash Value 43.90 9.40 21.4% 1.5<br />

1884 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 254 2 Childrens scarves Actual Cash Value 43.90 15.67 35.7% 2.5<br />

1885 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 255 2 Vinyl carry bags Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.49 50.0% 2.5<br />

1886 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 256 1 Pool waist floats Actual Cash Value 21.95 7.83 35.7% 2.5<br />

1887 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 257 3 Adult leg warmers Actual Cash Value 87.80 43.90 50.0% 2.5<br />

1888 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 259 53 Sheer drapes Actual Cash Value 4,996.00 0.00 0.0% 0.7<br />

1889 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 260 6 Curtain rods Actual Cash Value 329.25 43.90 13.3% 0.7<br />

1890 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 261 9 Bath towels Actual Cash Value 197.55 43.90 22.2% 0.7<br />

1891 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 262 26 Wash cloths Actual Cash Value 285.35 228.28 80.0% 3.0<br />

1892 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 263 3 Throw pillows Actual Cash Value 329.25 197.55 60.0% 3.0<br />

1893 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 264 10 Womens casual dresses Actual Cash Value 548.75 439.00 80.0% 3.0<br />

1894 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 265 3 Blankets Actual Cash Value 164.63 98.77 60.0% 3.0<br />

1895 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 266 11 Wool sweaters Actual Cash Value 1,207.25 965.80 80.0% 3.0<br />

1896 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 267 1 Queen matress Actual Cash Value 439.00 197.55 45.0% 9.0<br />

1897 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 268 1 Queen box spring Actual Cash Value 164.63 74.08 45.0% 9.0<br />

1898 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 269 1 100 pc lego set Actual Cash Value 21.95 10.97 50.0% 1.0<br />

1899 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 271 1 Sm portable fan Actual Cash Value 54.88 10.97 20.0% 2.0<br />

1900 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 272 65 Childrens books Actual Cash Value 351.20 140.48 40.0% 2.5<br />

1901 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 273 4 Children number and letter stencil Actual Cash Value 10.98 3.29 30.0% 1.5<br />

1902 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 274 1 Lg map puzzle Actual Cash Value 21.95 10.97 50.0% 1.0<br />

1903 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 275 1 Lg world map puzzle Actual Cash Value 21.95 10.97 50.0% 1.0<br />

1904 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 276 3 Lg misc puzzles Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.46 50.0% 1.0<br />

1905 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 277 1 Sm misc puzzle Actual Cash Value 10.98 5.46 50.0% 1.0<br />

1906 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 278 6 Children head beanies Actual Cash Value 131.70 105.36 80.0% 2.5<br />

1907 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 279 12 Baby wash cloths Actual Cash Value 65.85 52.68 80.0% 2.5<br />

1908 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 280 7 Head scarves for baby Actual Cash Value 115.24 57.62 50.0% 2.5<br />

1909 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 281 1 Small music box Actual Cash Value 32.93 4.93 15.0% 1.5<br />

1910 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 282 1 Child white piano w/ stool Actual Cash Value 109.75 16.46 15.0% 1.5<br />

1911 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 283 2 Picture frames Actual Cash Value 43.90 3.29 7.5% 1.5<br />

1912 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 284 10 Lg stuffed animals Actual Cash Value 329.25 263.40 80.0% 2.5<br />

1913 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 285 17 Sm stuffed animals Actual Cash Value 186.58 149.26 80.0% 2.5<br />

1914 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 286 1 Dora doll Actual Cash Value 219.50 109.75 50.0% 1.0<br />

1915 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 287 1 Doll stroller Actual Cash Value 16.46 8.23 50.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 39


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1916 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 288 4 Barbies Actual Cash Value 329.25 263.40 80.0% 2.0<br />

1917 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 289 6 Battery operated animals Actual Cash Value 439.00 87.80 20.0% 1.0<br />

1918 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 290 1 Doll basinet Actual Cash Value 54.88 27.44 50.0% 1.0<br />

1919 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 291 1 Disney Bingo DVD Actual Cash Value 24.15 12.07 50.0% 1.0<br />

1920 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 292 1 Wig Actual Cash Value 87.80 8.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

1921 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 293 1 Child potty training toilet Actual Cash Value 109.75 27.43 25.0% 2.5<br />

1922 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 294 1 Med basket w/ hair accessories Actual Cash Value 219.50 109.75 50.0% 3.0<br />

1923 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 295 1 Child toy vacuum Actual Cash Value 109.75 54.87 50.0% 1.0<br />

1924 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 296 1 Box of blocks Actual Cash Value 43.90 21.95 50.0% 1.0<br />

1925 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 297 1 Ex lg box of misc toys Actual Cash Value 548.75 439.00 80.0% 2.5<br />

1926 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 312 1 Small microwave Actual Cash Value 109.75 14.96 13.6% 1.5<br />

1927 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 313 1 Lg stove Actual Cash Value 1,646.25 0.00 0.0% 0.7<br />

1928 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 316 10 Mens shoes Actual Cash Value 1,097.50 365.83 33.3% 3.0<br />

1929 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 317 20 Womens shoes Actual Cash Value 2,195.00 731.66 33.3% 3.0<br />

1930 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 319 1 Womens heavy coat Actual Cash Value 658.50 526.80 80.0% 4.5<br />

1931 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 322 1 Womens suit coat Actual Cash Value 548.75 439.00 80.0%<br />

1932 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 323 1 Brown coat Actual Cash Value 109.75 73.16 66.7%<br />

1933 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 324 1 Black coat Actual Cash Value 76.83 25.61 33.3%<br />

1934 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 325 1 Black and white checker coat Actual Cash Value 384.13 256.08 66.7%<br />

1935 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 326 1 Silk & Fur shawl Actual Cash Value 301.81 60.36 20.0%<br />

1936 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 327 1 Motarola modem Actual Cash Value 43.90 10.97 25.0%<br />

1937 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 328 1 D link wireless router Actual Cash Value 87.80 21.95 25.0%<br />

1938 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 330 1 Rug, machine made 4'5 x 6'6 Actual Cash Value 329.25 164.62 50.0%<br />

1939 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 338 1 Rug, machine made 1'10 x 3' Actual Cash Value 38.41 19.20 50.0%<br />

1940 109 75-M596-075 8/16/2012 341 1 Rug, machine made 4'10 x 8' Actual Cash Value 164.63 82.31 50.0%<br />

1941 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 1 1 Digital Certified Scale / TEC Actual Cash Value 429.00 42.90 10.0%<br />

1942 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 2 1 Commercial Grinder / Peroni Actual Cash Value 1,930.50 450.00 23.3%<br />

1943 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 3 1 Coffee Bean Actual Cash Value 1,072.50 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1 1944 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 168 1 Pr. Pearl earrings Actual Cash Value 938.44 375.37 40.0% 10.0<br />

1945 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 169 1 Custom made gold nugget watch Actual Cash Value 8,580.00 2,745.59 32.0% 8.0<br />

1946 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 170 1 Diamond ring 3 1/2 ct cigar b Actual Cash Value 1,287.00 257.40 20.0% 5.0<br />

1947 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 171 1 Pr. Diamond studs 1/2 ct yell Actual Cash Value 858.00 137.28 16.0% 4.0<br />

1948 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 173 1 Pr. Cuff links w/onyx Actual Cash Value 268.13 214.50 80.0% 78.0<br />

1949 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 174 1 Lg. Hawaiian gold bracelet-en Actual Cash Value 4,075.50 1,304.15 32.0% 8.0<br />

1950 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 175 10 Bathing suits / Victoria's Secret Actual Cash Value 1,018.88 679.25 66.7% 2.0<br />

1951 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 176 10 Bathing suits / Cole, Ann Klein,<br />

Ralph Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,287.00 858.00 66.7% 2.0<br />

1952 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 179 1 Pr. Cowboy boots / Frye Actual Cash Value 268.13 53.62 20.0% 1.0<br />

1953 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 180 2 Dress boots / Cole Hahn Actual Cash Value 610.25 122.05 20.0% 1.0<br />

1954 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 181 1 Pr. Dress boots, black / Nine<br />

Weset<br />

Actual Cash Value 128.70 51.48 40.0% 2.0<br />

1955 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 182 1 Pr. Dress boots / Bandalino Actual Cash Value 96.53 57.91 60.0% 3.0<br />

1956 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 183 1 Pr. Boots, sm. Heel / Ann Taylor Actual Cash Value 235.95 47.19 20.0% 1.0<br />

1957 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 185 1 Pr. Boots w/stitching / Born Actual Cash Value 180.18 72.07 40.0% 2.0<br />

1958 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 186 1 Pr. Boots / Stuart Weitzman Actual Cash Value 348.56 139.42 40.0% 2.0<br />

1959 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 187 1 Pr. Boots / Franco Sarto Actual Cash Value 241.31 72.39 30.0% 1.5<br />

1960 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 189 2 Hats - rabbit fur, white/gray Actual Cash Value 471.00 157.30 33.3% 2.0<br />

1961 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 190 1 Louis Vuitton bowling bag / Louis<br />

Vuitton<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,394.25 697.12 50.0% 5.0<br />

1962 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 191 1 Leather blazer Actual Cash Value 160.88 96.52 60.0% 3.0<br />

1963 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 192 1 Bomber jacket / leather / Wilson<br />

Leather<br />

Actual Cash Value 423.64 338.91 80.0% 4.0<br />

10/15/2012 40


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

1964 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 196 1 White linen jacket / Tahari Actual Cash Value 205.92 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1965 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 197 1 Black linen jacket Actual Cash Value 180.18 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1966 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 198 1 DKNY jacket - blue / DKNY Actual Cash Value 214.50 42.90 20.0% 1.0<br />

1967 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 199 3 Pr. Mittens, cashmere Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

471.90 55.77 40.0% 2.0<br />

1968 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 201 2 Pr. Jeans / Citizen Actual Cash Value 509.44 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1969 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 202 3 Half slips / Victoria's Secret Actual Cash Value 115.83 0.00 0.0% 1.5<br />

1970 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 203 20 Pr. Capri pants / 2 Billie Blue Actual Cash Value 276.71 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1971 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 204 1 1 Pr. Capri pants /7 Actual Cash Value 155.51 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1972 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 205 2 Pr. Capri pants / Polo Actual Cash Value 157.66 39.41 25.0% 1.0<br />

1973 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 206 1 Pr. Capri denim Actual Cash Value 64.35 16.08 25.0% 1.0<br />

1974 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 207 2 Pr. Capri denim / Victoria's Secret Actual Cash Value 154.44 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1975 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 209 2 Pr. Capri white/ blue / Tommy Actual Cash<br />

128.70 32.17 50.0% 2.0<br />

Hilifiger<br />

Value/Replace<br />

1976 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 210 2 Pr. Black / Ann Taylor Actual Cash Value 101.89 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1977 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 211 1 Pr. Capri, black Actual Cash Value 79.37 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1978 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 212 2 Pr. Capri khaki, black / Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 180.18 0.00 0.0% -<br />

1979 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 213 2 Pr. Capri, linen / Charter Club Actual Cash Value 150.15 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

1980 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 214 25 Sets of pajamas - cotton, silk / Actual Cash<br />

1,609.05 675.67 50.0% 2.5<br />

Victoria's Secret, Ralph Lauren Value/Replace<br />

1981 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 215 2 Victoria's Secret pants suits Actual Cash Value 241.31 72.39 30.0% 1.5<br />

1982 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 216 2 Pant suits / NY & Co. Actual Cash Value 300.30 120.12 40.0% 2.0<br />

1983 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 220 4 Sets sweatshirts / BCBG Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

429.00 80.43 25.0% 11.0<br />

1984 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 221 4 Pr. Workout pants / Nike, Addidas, Actual Cash<br />

106.35 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

Athletic<br />

Value/Replace<br />

1985 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 222 4 Pr. Yoga pants Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

171.65 14.30 33.3% 1.0<br />

1986 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 223 3 Pr. Yoga pants Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

209.14 139.42 66.7% 2.0<br />

1987 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 224 30 Halter tops/tank tops/ Various Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

962.06 289.57 33.3% 1.0<br />

1988 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 225 30 T-shirts / Various Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

965.29 311.02 33.3% 1.0<br />

1989 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 226 15 White blouses / Various Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

965.25 235.95 33.3% 1.0<br />

1990 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 227 30 Misc. blouses / Misc. Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

1,278.75 629.20 66.7% 2.0<br />

1991 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 228 10 Summer dresses / Misc. Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

536.26 286.00 66.7% 2.0<br />

1992 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 229 2 Pr. Tennis shoes/ New Balance Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

151.52 28.60 33.3% 1.0<br />

1993 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 232 6 Pr. Stockings / Victoria's Secret Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

77.22 12.87 33.3% 1.0<br />

1994 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 233 6 Summer nightgowns / Victoria's Actual Cash<br />

257.55 42.90 33.3% 1.0<br />

Secret<br />

Value/Replace<br />

1995 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 234 1 Pr. Sorrells / Sorrell Actual Cash Value 160.88 128.70 80.0% 3.0<br />

1996 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 235 1 Wedding dress Actual Cash Value 7,078.50 3,539.25 50.0% 11.0<br />

1997 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 236 1 Pr. Wool slacks / DKNY Actual Cash Value 235.95 78.65 33.3% 1.0<br />

1998 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 237 1 Pr. Wool slacks / Ralph Lauren Actual Cash Value 278.85 185.90 66.7% 2.0<br />

1999 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 238 1 Set silk underwear / DKNY Actual Cash Value 139.43 92.95 66.7% 2.0<br />

2000 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 239 1 Formal pant set-sequin silk p Actual Cash Value 278.85 111.54 40.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 41


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2001 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 240 12 Cashmere sweaters / Charter Actual Cash<br />

1,609.07 536.25 40.0% 2.0<br />

Club, Ralph Lauren<br />

Value/Replace<br />

2002 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 241 1 Cashmere/wool sweater / gray /<br />

Tahari<br />

Actual Cash Value 278.85 55.77 20.0% 1.0<br />

2003 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 242 3 Wool turtle necks / Ralph Lauren Actual Cash Value 218.79 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2004 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 243 3 Pr. Sandals - thongs / Reef; Roxi;<br />

Fox<br />

Actual Cash Value 135.14 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2005 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 244 25 Cocktail dresses / Ann Klein;<br />

Tahari, Ann Taylor<br />

Actual Cash Value 3,887.81 1,943.90 50.0% 2.5<br />

2006 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 245 2 Bustiers / Victoria's Secret;<br />

Frederick's<br />

Actual Cash Value 134.06 89.37 66.7% 2.0<br />

2007 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 246 1 Black silk evening bag Actual Cash Value 95.45 38.18 40.0% 2.0<br />

2008 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 249 12 Pr. Pumps, hi heels, dress sh / Actual Cash<br />

1,267.53 858.00 80.0% 3.0<br />

Nine West<br />

Value/Replace<br />

2009 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 250 3 Full slips / Victoria's Secret Actual Cash Value 218.79 175.03 80.0% 3.0<br />

2010 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 251 6 Gloves, leather / wool / silk / cas Actual Cash Value 444.02 222.01 50.0% 2.0<br />

2011 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 252 1 Cashmere gloves Actual Cash Value 155.51 38.87 25.0% 1.0<br />

2012 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 254 1 Mink fur hat / Saks Fifth Ave Actual Cash Value 2,145.00 429.00 20.0% 5.0<br />

2013 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 255 1 Fredrick Purse / back pack /<br />

Frederic Paris<br />

Actual Cash Value 241.31 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2014 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 256 1 Leather travel case / Louis Vuitton Actual Cash Value 1,179.75 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2015 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 257 1 Ski set / jacket & pants / Marnott Actual Cash Value 643.50 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2016 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 258 4 Tahari suits, jacket & pants /<br />

Pahari<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,501.50 300.30 20.0% 1.0<br />

2017 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 259 12 Victoria's Secret bras / Victoria's<br />

Secret<br />

Actual Cash Value 514.80 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2018 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 260 12 Victoria's Secret underwear /<br />

Victoria's Secret<br />

Actual Cash Value 154.44 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2019 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 261 3 Pr. Jeans (women's) / "7" Actual Cash Value 723.94 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2020 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 262 2 Pr. Jeans / For All Mankind Actual Cash Value 557.70 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2021 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 263 1 Wool / cashmere coat (women's) /<br />

Ralph Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 858.00 429.00 50.0% 1.0<br />

2022 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 264 1 Leather jacket / Wilson's Leather Actual Cash Value 643.50 257.40 40.0% 2.0<br />

2023 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 265 1 Leather jacket / Ann Klein Actual Cash Value 482.63 289.57 60.0% 3.0<br />

2024 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 268 1 Pearl necklace - drop w/gold Actual Cash Value 268.13 21.45 8.0% 2.0<br />

2025 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 278 1 Gold nugget "anklet" / Hand made Actual Cash Value 1,072.50 300.30 28.0% 7.0<br />

2026 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 279 1 Diamond / gold bracelet Actual Cash Value 1,126.13 450.45 40.0% 10.0<br />

2027 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 281 1 Gold/stone baby ring (mother) Actual Cash Value 1,716.00 686.40 40.0% 10.0<br />

2028 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 284 1 Engraved St. Christopher neck Actual Cash Value 268.13 107.25 40.0% 10.0<br />

2029 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 285 1 Sweater / Tommy Hilfiger Actual Cash Value 69.71 23.23 33.3% 1.0<br />

2030 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 287 25 Pr. Underwear, boxers & briefs /<br />

Joe Boxer; Hanes; Tommy<br />

Actual Cash Value 214.50 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2031 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 288 2 Pr. Sweatpants / LA gear Actual Cash Value 51.48 17.16 33.3% 1.0<br />

2032 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 290 1 Heavy sweatshirts / Quick silver Actual Cash Value 60.06 20.02 33.3% 1.0<br />

2033 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 291 1 Heavy sweatshirt / Fox Actual Cash Value 58.99 19.66 33.3% 1.0<br />

2034 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 292 1 Heavy sweatshirt / Wildcat Actual Cash Value 42.90 14.30 33.3% 1.0<br />

2035 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 293 1 Heavy sweatshirt / Camoflague Actual Cash Value 34.32 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2036 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 294 1 Sweatshirt / Honda Actual Cash Value 53.63 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 42


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2037 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 295 4 Tank tops / Nike; Arizona; Quick<br />

Silver<br />

Actual Cash Value 77.22 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2038 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 296 30 Motorcycle T-shirts / Surf; Hurley; Actual Cash<br />

705.70 188.76 33.3% 1.0<br />

Fox; Quick Silver<br />

Value/Replace<br />

2039 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 297 1 Black jacket / O'Neil Actual Cash Value 134.06 26.81 20.0% 1.0<br />

2040 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 298 3 Dress ties / Tommy Hilfiger; Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 83.66 16.73 20.0% 1.0<br />

2041 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 299 1 Back packs / Honda Actual Cash Value 64.35 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2042 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 300 1 Back pack / Chargers Actual Cash Value 69.71 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2043 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 301 1 Back pack / Oakland A's Actual Cash Value 64.35 12.87 20.0% 1.0<br />

2044 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 302 1 Back pack / Ugio Actual Cash Value 26.81 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2045 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 303 20 Baseball hats / Professional Actual Cash<br />

622.16 211.49 40.0% 2.0<br />

sports; Nike; Fox<br />

Value/Replace<br />

2046 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 304 1 Dress suit / Profiles Actual Cash Value 246.68 98.67 40.0% 2.0<br />

2047 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 305 8 Pr. Wrangler jeans / Wrangler Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

218.98 37.18 33.3% 1.0<br />

2048 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 306 1 Pr. Jeans - black / Levi Actual Cash Value 32.18 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2049 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 308 1 Jean jacket / Levi Actual Cash Value 63.28 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2050 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 309 15 Pr. Pajamas / 49er; Dale Earnhart;<br />

Ralph Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 450.45 150.15 33.3% 1.0<br />

2051 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 310 1 Rain coat / London Fog Actual Cash Value 107.25 53.62 50.0% 2.0<br />

2052 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 311 3 Long sleeve dress shirts / Ralph<br />

Lauren<br />

Actual Cash Value 218.79 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2053 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 312 30 Pr. Shorts / Fox; Hurley; O'Neil Actual Cash Value 965.25 0.00 0.0% 0.5<br />

2054 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 313 1 Ski jacket / Rossignol Actual Cash Value 246.68 49.33 20.0% 1.0<br />

2055 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 314 1 Pr. Ski pants / Rossignol Actual Cash Value 96.53 19.30 20.0% 1.0<br />

2056 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 315 20 Pr. Socks / Haynes; Nike; Tommy<br />

Hilfiger<br />

Actual Cash Value 117.98 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2057 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 326 1 Wii Actual Cash Value 418.24 20.91 5.0%<br />

2058 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 327 1 Playstation 3 Actual Cash Value 536.24 8.93 1.7%<br />

2059 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 328 32 Random games - PS2 Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

1,717.50 697.12 50.0%<br />

2060 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 329 20 Wii Games Actual Cash Value 1,287.00 643.50 50.0%<br />

2061 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 330 20 Random games PS3 Actual Cash Value 1,072.50 536.25 50.0%<br />

2062 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 331 6 Swim trunks / 2 Fox; 2 Volcuss;<br />

OP; Hurley<br />

Actual Cash Value 193.05 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2063 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 334 1 Pr. Ropper boots / Ropper Actual Cash Value 96.53 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2064 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 335 1 Pr. Ugg boots / Ugg Actual Cash Value 187.69 93.84 50.0% 1.0<br />

2065 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 337 1 Pr. Nike tennis shoes / Nike Actual Cash Value 85.80 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2066 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 338 1 Pr. Baseball cleets / Nike Actual Cash Value 107.25 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2067 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 339 1 Pr. Basketball shoes / Michael<br />

Jordan<br />

Actual Cash Value 139.43 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2068 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 340 1 Pr. Vann's / Vann Actual Cash Value 74.00 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2069 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 341 2 Pr. Cotton khaki pants / Ralph<br />

Lauren; Tommy Hilfiger<br />

Actual Cash Value 128.70 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2070 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 342 1 Pr. Black dress shoes / Rockport Actual Cash Value 91.16 0.00 0.0% 1.0<br />

2071 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 343 2 Flannel shirts L/SI / Woolrich Actual Cash Value 81.51 27.17 33.3% 1.0<br />

2072 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 351 12 Set cobalt glasses Actual Cash Value 214.50 21.45 10.0%<br />

2073 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 353 24 wine glasses Actual Cash Value 107.25 10.72 10.0%<br />

2074 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 354 1 Flatware, silver, set of 12 Actual Cash Value 375.38 37.53 10.0%<br />

2075 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 355 1 Pots, pans, misc. Actual Cash Value 536.25 134.06 25.0%<br />

2076 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 365 1 Long silver meal tray / Gorham Actual Cash Value 321.75 32.17 10.0% 5.0<br />

10/15/2012 43


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2077 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 366 1 Silver tea service, 5 pc / Wallace Actual Cash Value 750.75 75.07 10.0% 11.0<br />

2078 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 372 1 Medium oval platter - silver /<br />

Wallace<br />

Actual Cash Value 160.88 16.08 10.0% 8.0<br />

2079 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 373 2 Medium silver trays / ornate w/ Actual Cash Value 536.25 53.62 10.0% 3.0<br />

2080 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 374 1 Medium sterling silver tray /<br />

Sheffield<br />

Actual Cash Value 402.19 40.21 10.0%<br />

2081 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 375 1 Marble & silver tray Actual Cash Value 107.25 10.72 10.0% 6.0<br />

2082 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 376 1 Lg. glass/crystal vase / Mikasa Actual Cash Value 214.50 21.45 10.0% 1.0<br />

2083 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 377 1 Lg. crystal cut vase / Waterford Actual Cash Value 316.39 31.63 10.0% 2.0<br />

2084 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 382 1 Carpet cleaner / Hoover Actual Cash Value 364.65 60.77 16.7% 2.0<br />

2085 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 383 14 Down pillows - bedroom Actual Cash<br />

Value/Replace<br />

375.88 214.50 80.0% 2.5<br />

2086 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 384 1 Set Heckles knife set & block /<br />

Heckles<br />

Actual Cash Value 299.23 59.84 20.0% 4.0<br />

2087 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 386 1 Set hotel collection king size Actual Cash Value 159.80 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2088 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 387 4 Mattress pads Actual Cash Value 253.11 25.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2089 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 388 2 Twin comforters / shams / Charter<br />

Club<br />

Actual Cash Value 386.10 154.44 40.0% 2.0<br />

2090 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 389 6 Throw rugs / charter Club Actual Cash Value 238.10 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2091 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 390 1 Tools of the Trade cookware Actual Cash Value 299.23 119.69 40.0% 4.0<br />

2092 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 391 1 Iron / Rowena Actual Cash Value 85.80 19.06 22.2% 2.0<br />

2093 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 392 1 Ironing Board Actual Cash Value 42.90 5.72 13.3% 2.0<br />

2094 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 395 1 Vacuum cleaner / Hoover Actual Cash Value 246.68 82.22 33.3% 4.0<br />

2095 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 396 1 Luggage set / Samsonite Actual Cash Value 723.94 108.59 15.0% 3.0<br />

2096 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 398 1 Bose radio w/CD / Bose Actual Cash Value 1,823.25 683.71 37.5% 3.0<br />

2097 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 402 1 Lg. crystal bowl / Mikasa Actual Cash Value 214.50 21.45 10.0% 14.0<br />

2098 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 403 1 Medium crystal bowl / Waterford Actual Cash Value 268.13 26.81 10.0% 10.0<br />

2099 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 404 2 Silver antique ice buckets Actual Cash Value 536.25 53.62 10.0%<br />

2100 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 411 2 Tile top tables (tall) Actual Cash Value 509.44 50.94 10.0% 1.0<br />

2101 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 413 3 100 ft. comm. Hoses Actual Cash Value 257.40 128.70 50.0% 5.0<br />

2102 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 416 30 Bottles Top Shelf alcohol / Bailys;<br />

Jose Cuervo; Sky; Abso<br />

Actual Cash Value 965.25 96.52 10.0% 1.0<br />

2103 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 417 1 Oster blender / Oster Actual Cash Value 155.51 59.81 38.5% 5.0<br />

2104 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 443 1 Rosignall ski jacket / Tri City<br />

Sports<br />

Actual Cash Value 327.11 130.84 40.0% 2.0<br />

2105 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 444 1 Binoculars / Leopold Actual Cash Value 627.41 125.48 20.0% 4.0<br />

2106 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 446 35 Metal folding chairs "padded" Actual Cash Value 938.44 469.22 50.0% 5.0<br />

2107 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 447 6 Long party tables Actual Cash Value 804.38 402.19 50.0% 5.0<br />

2108 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 449 1 Compressor / Craftsman Actual Cash Value 514.80 154.44 30.0% 3.0<br />

2109 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 450 1 Socket/wrench set / Sears<br />

Proline/Craftsman<br />

Actual Cash Value 482.63 96.52 20.0% 4.0<br />

2110 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 454 1 Vacuum cleaner / Dyson Actual Cash Value 482.63 0.00 0.0% -<br />

2111 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 455 1 Camping tent / North Face Actual Cash Value 498.71 41.55 8.3% 1.0<br />

2112 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 456 4 Sleeping bags / Columbie Actual Cash Value 257.40 51.48 20.0% 1.0<br />

2113 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 458 1 Generator / Craftsman Actual Cash Value 858.00 429.00 50.0% 5.0<br />

2114 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 459 2 Fox riding gear, Moto X, pant /<br />

Fox<br />

Actual Cash Value 482.63 193.05 40.0% 2.0<br />

2115 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 460 3 Sets snow skis & poles Actual Cash Value 965.25 482.62 50.0% 5.0<br />

2116 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 461 1 Motorcycle boots / Thor Actual Cash Value 160.88 128.70 80.0% 6.0<br />

2117 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 462 3 Motorcycle helmets / Shoi; Fox Actual Cash Value 321.75 64.35 20.0% 2.0<br />

2118 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 465 2 Sets riding gear, pants, jack / Fox Actual Cash Value 643.50 257.40 40.0% 2.0<br />

2119 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 466 2 Chest protector, 1 child / Fox Actual Cash Value 193.05 115.83 60.0% 3.0<br />

10/15/2012 44


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2120 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 467 2 Kidney belt / Fox Actual Cash Value 214.50 85.80 40.0% 2.0<br />

2121 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 468 3 Pr. Goggles - motorcycle Actual Cash Value 482.63 289.57 60.0% 3.0<br />

2122 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 469 3 Pr. Goggles - ski / Sith; Rose;<br />

Smith<br />

Actual Cash Value 171.60 68.64 40.0% 2.0<br />

2123 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 470 1 Pr. Moto X riding boots / Fly Actual Cash Value 268.13 53.62 20.0% 1.0<br />

2124 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 471 2 Pr. Rosignall ski boots Actual Cash Value 643.50 514.80 80.0% 5.0<br />

2125 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 484 1 Hand carved wdn. Bear Actual Cash Value 214.50 53.62 25.0% 1.0<br />

2126 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 485 6 Garden gnomes Actual Cash Value 193.05 48.26 25.0%<br />

2127 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 503 4 Large handmade wicker reindeer Actual Cash Value 982.41 245.60 25.0% 2.0<br />

2128 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 504 12 Wooden angels, hand carved, 1 Actual Cash Value 772.20 193.05 25.0% 5.0<br />

2129 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 505 24 Crystal teardrop ornaments Actual Cash Value 720.72 180.18 25.0% 10.0<br />

2130 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 506 6 Shell ornaments, handmade Actual Cash Value 218.79 54.69 25.0%<br />

2131 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 507 1 Wool/felt Santa, 2' tall Actual Cash Value 91.16 22.79 25.0% 5.0<br />

2132 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 508 1 Tree skirt/quilt, antique Actual Cash Value 278.85 69.71 25.0% 8.0<br />

2133 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 509 10 Waterford crystal ornaments Actual Cash Value 589.88 147.47 25.0% 6.0<br />

2134 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 510 6 Sets, speciality snowflake Actual Cash Value 225.23 56.30 25.0% 4.0<br />

2135 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 511 20 Asst. felt vintage Santa's Actual Cash Value 407.55 101.88 25.0% 3.0<br />

2136 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 512 6 Silver reindeer wine goblets Actual Cash Value 283.14 70.78 25.0% 5.0<br />

2137 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 513 25 Sets outdoor lights, speciality Actual Cash Value 589.88 147.47 25.0% 1.0<br />

2138 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 514 1 Snowman set, antique Actual Cash Value 187.69 46.92 25.0% 2.0<br />

2139 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 515 4 Feather trees "collection", h Actual Cash Value 858.00 214.50 25.0% 5.0<br />

2140 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 516 1 Vintage train set / Lionel Actual Cash Value 536.25 134.06 25.0% 45.0<br />

2141 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 517 30 German glass ornaments Actual Cash Value 643.50 160.87 25.0% 10.0<br />

2142 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 518 12 Sets German hand blown glass Actual Cash Value 360.36 90.09 25.0% 8.0<br />

2143 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 520 1 Angel tree topper, wool, silk Actual Cash Value 139.43 34.85 25.0% 4.0<br />

2144 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 521 1 Pr. Tree candle sticks / Lenox Actual Cash Value 42.90 10.72 25.0% 6.0<br />

2145 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 522 1 Large gold star topper Actual Cash Value 69.71 17.42 25.0% 10.0<br />

2146 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 523 1 Santa sign - outdoor Actual Cash Value 42.90 10.72 25.0% 2.0<br />

2147 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 524 1 Porcelain nativity set, antiq Actual Cash Value 321.75 80.43 25.0% 60.0<br />

2148 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 525 1 Brocade tree skirt, ivory w/t Actual Cash Value 69.71 17.42 25.0% 7.0<br />

2149 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 526 2 Iron tree stands, green Actual Cash Value 150.15 37.53 25.0% 9.0<br />

2150 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 527 8 ? Coco cups, hand painted Actual Cash Value 386.10 308.88 80.0% 15.0<br />

2151 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 528 10 Christmas CDs Actual Cash Value 150.15 75.07 50.0% 5.0<br />

2152 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 529 4 Velvet handmade stockings Actual Cash Value 321.75 80.43 25.0% 3.5<br />

2153 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 530 1 German handmade music box w/a Actual Cash Value 235.95 58.98 25.0% 10.0<br />

2154 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 531 4 Artificial wreath w/berries Actual Cash Value 193.05 48.26 25.0% 3.0<br />

2155 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 532 6 6' garland, green Actual Cash Value 225.23 56.30 25.0% 5.0<br />

2156 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 533 10 Set silk poinsettia plants Actual Cash Value 321.75 80.43 25.0% 6.0<br />

2157 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 534 1 Commercial ice chest on wheels Actual Cash Value 321.75 64.35 20.0% 2.0<br />

2158 99 55-E051-497 2/26/2009 537 1 Washer/dryer set, electric /<br />

Kenmore<br />

Actual Cash Value 1,361.00 113.41 8.3% 1.0<br />

1 2159 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 1 1 oriental style rug Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2160 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 2 1 large original oil painting Actual Cash Value 592.63 59.26 10.0% 12.0<br />

2161 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 3 1 chest with drawers Actual Cash Value 2,340.59 234.06 10.0% 1.0<br />

2162 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 4 12 lamps Actual Cash Value 1,939.50 193.95 10.0% 1.0<br />

2163 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 5 1 floral arrangment Actual Cash Value 188.56 18.86 10.0% 3.0<br />

2164 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 6 8 table cloth / place mats Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 2.0<br />

2165 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 7 6 sets of napkins Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.5<br />

2166 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 8 4 xmas platters Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 2.0<br />

2167 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 9 1 framed mirror Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 1.0<br />

2168 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 10 7 flower pots Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 10.0<br />

2169 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 11 1 plant stand Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 3.0<br />

10/15/2012 45


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2170 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 12 1 flying goose décor Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2171 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 13 1 coil hose Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2172 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 14 1 small bird bath Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 10.0<br />

2173 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 15 1 water fountain / pump Actual Cash Value 377.13 37.71 10.0% 3.0<br />

2174 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 16 1 dining room table Actual Cash Value 1,939.50 193.95 10.0% 11.0<br />

2175 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 17 6 dining room chairs Actual Cash Value 15,516.00 1,551.60 10.0% 11.0<br />

2176 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 18 2 placemats / napkins pottery barn Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.5<br />

2177 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 19 2 salt / pepper sets Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 3.0<br />

2178 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 20 1 faux green plant Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 3.0<br />

2179 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 21 1 metal tray Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2180 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 22 1 fake fruit Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2181 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 23 1 tray & table Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2182 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 24 2 pictures Actual Cash Value 754.25 75.43 10.0% 2.0<br />

2183 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 25 1 place candle holder Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 3.0<br />

2184 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 26 1 sleeping bag Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 7.0<br />

2185 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 27 1 electric typewriter Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 6.0<br />

2186 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 28 2 plastic craft storage Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 7.0<br />

2187 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 29 1 hamper Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 13.0<br />

2188 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 30 1 luggage holder Actual Cash Value 85.12 8.51 10.0% 13.0<br />

2189 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 31 4 beach towels Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 3.0<br />

2190 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 32 2 queen sheets Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 3.0<br />

2191 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 33 1 bath towels Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2192 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 34 2 afghans Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 5.0<br />

2193 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 35 3 decorator pillows Actual Cash Value 96.98 9.70 10.0% 6.0<br />

2194 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 36 1 gift bags Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 1.5<br />

2195 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 37 4 folding chairs Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2196 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 38 1 blanket Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 10.0<br />

2197 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 39 1 wooden & plastic hangers Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 3.0<br />

2198 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 40 1 hair dryer Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2199 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 41 1 curling iron Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 3.0<br />

2200 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 42 1 hand towels Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 3.0<br />

2201 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 43 1 ceramic fish Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 3.0<br />

2202 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 44 1 flower arrangment Actual Cash Value 28.02 2.80 10.0% 4.0<br />

2203 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 45 2 bathroom containers Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2204 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 46 1 ceramic wash cloth dish Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 10.0<br />

2205 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 47 1 jewelry holder Actual Cash Value 10.76 1.08 10.0% 3.0<br />

2206 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 48 1 soap dispenser Actual Cash Value 12.93 1.29 10.0% 3.0<br />

2207 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 49 1 wood box or tp Actual Cash Value 10.78 1.08 10.0% 3.0<br />

2208 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 50 1 toilet bowl brush Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

2209 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 51 1 bath mat Actual Cash Value 17.24 1.72 10.0% 3.0<br />

2210 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 53 1 wooden wall décor Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 7.0<br />

2211 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 54 1 bayleaf wreath Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 5.0<br />

2212 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 55 1 lg faux tree Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.94 10.0% 10.0<br />

2213 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 56 1 metal & glass table Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 6.0<br />

2214 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 57 1 tv / vcr plaer Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 2.0<br />

2215 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 58 1 faux plant Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 3.0<br />

2216 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 59 2 wicker night stand Actual Cash Value 740.73 74.07 10.0% 6.0<br />

2217 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 60 2 lamps Actual Cash Value 237.05 23.71 10.0% 6.0<br />

2218 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 61 2 small florals Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 6.0<br />

2219 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 62 1 queen mattress / box springs Actual Cash Value 2,155.00 215.50 10.0% 13.0<br />

2220 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 63 1 clock radio Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 8.0<br />

2221 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 64 2 framed art Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 3.0<br />

2222 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 65 1 wreath Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 12.0<br />

10/15/2012 46


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2223 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 66 1 cordless phone Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 3.0<br />

2224 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 67 1 picture Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 2.0<br />

2225 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 68 1 clock Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2226 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 69 1 chair / cushion Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 3.0<br />

2227 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 70 1 basket, greenery, birdhouses Actual Cash Value 150.85 15.09 10.0% 3.0<br />

2228 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 71 1 raku bowl Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 7.0<br />

2229 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 73 1 computer / accessories Actual Cash Value 1,364.57 136.46 10.0% 1.0<br />

2230 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 74 1 printer Actual Cash Value 215.60 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2231 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 75 1 fax machine Actual Cash Value 96.98 9.70 10.0% 0.2<br />

2232 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 76 1 fax table Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 6.0<br />

2233 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 77 1 wicker chairs / cushions Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 6.0<br />

2234 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 78 2 ottoman Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2235 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 79 1 dog bed Actual Cash Value 31.25 3.13 10.0% 1.5<br />

2236 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 80 1 basket with dog toys Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 3.0<br />

2237 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 81 3 boxes of greeting cards Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 1.0<br />

2238 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 82 1 flatscreen tv Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 3.0<br />

2239 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 83 1 key box Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 7.0<br />

2240 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 84 1 tv tray set Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2241 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 85 1 wicker table lamp Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 6.0<br />

2242 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 86 1 red leather waste baskte Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 3.0<br />

2243 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 87 1 computer chair Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 6.0<br />

2244 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 88 1 clock Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2245 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 89 4 fake plants Actual Cash Value 188.56 18.86 10.0% 1.0<br />

2246 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 90 1 metal tray w/ 5 metal pears Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 4.0<br />

2247 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 91 1 large wooden golf picture Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 12.0<br />

2248 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 92 1 ceramic drawers Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 8.0<br />

2249 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 93 6 framed calcutta etchings Actual Cash Value 1,939.50 193.95 10.0% 1.0<br />

2250 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 94 1 misc office supplies Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2251 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 95 1 decorative pillow Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 7.0<br />

2252 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 96 1 oak credenza Actual Cash Value 754.25 75.43 10.0% 3.0<br />

2253 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 97 1 desk holder, pen /pads Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 5.0<br />

2254 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 98 1 watermelon basket Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2255 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 99 1 basket used as end table Actual Cash Value 188.56 18.86 10.0% 1.0<br />

2256 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 100 1 area rug Actual Cash Value 439.65 43.97 10.0% 1.0<br />

2257 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 101 6 new books unread Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2258 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 102 1 candle and tall candlestick Actual Cash Value 30.17 3.02 10.0% 3.0<br />

2259 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 103 1 lamp Actual Cash Value 150.85 15.09 10.0% 3.0<br />

2260 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 104 1 maps, US atlas Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2261 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 105 1 framed family photos Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2262 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 106 1 mah jong game set Actual Cash Value 102.36 10.24 10.0% 3.0<br />

2263 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 107 1 stationary and paper goods Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2264 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 108 1 red potted plant Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2265 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 109 1 red oil painting Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 2.0<br />

2266 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 110 4 wood and cloth bar stools Actual Cash Value 1,724.00 172.40 10.0% 3.0<br />

2267 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 111 1 small bar stool / pad Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 3.0<br />

2268 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 112 3 signed plates and holders Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2269 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 113 1 rooster w/pears Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2270 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 114 1 misc. vitamins Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2271 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 115 1 misc. pasta Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2272 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 116 1 paper towel holder Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2273 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 117 1 misc supplies under sink Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2274 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 118 12 rubbermaid storage Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 4.5<br />

2275 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 119 1 lettuce dryer Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 2.0<br />

2276 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 120 1 plastic storage containers Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 7.0<br />

10/15/2012 47


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2277 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 121 2 s&p grinders Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2278 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 122 1 basket w/utensils Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2279 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 123 1 dish towels Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2280 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 124 1 seal a meal Actual Cash Value 172.40 17.24 10.0% 8.0<br />

2281 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 125 1 toaster Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2282 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 126 1 coffee maker Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 2.0<br />

2283 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 127 1 blender Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 3.0<br />

2284 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 128 1 toaster oven Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 3.0<br />

2285 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 129 1 pottery piece Actual Cash Value 129.30 12.93 10.0% 1.0<br />

2286 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 130 1 plant / pot Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 0.5<br />

2287 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 131 1 electric juicer Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 4.0<br />

2288 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 132 1 misc. bake ware Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 5.5<br />

2289 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 133 1 basic food items / spices Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 1.0<br />

2290 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 134 1 breadmaking machine Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 7.0<br />

2291 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 135 1 electric frypan Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 5.0<br />

2292 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 136 1 can / bottle foods Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 0.6<br />

2293 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 137 1 paper goods Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2294 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 138 1 electric griddle Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 7.0<br />

2295 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 139 1 deep fryer Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 4.0<br />

2296 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 140 1 crockpot Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 0.5<br />

2297 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 141 1 potholders Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2298 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 142 1 wreath Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2299 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 143 1 soap dispenser Actual Cash Value 19.40 1.94 10.0% 1.0<br />

2300 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 144 1 cookbooks Actual Cash Value 280.15 28.02 10.0% 4.0<br />

2301 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 145 4 cooling racks Actual Cash Value 129.30 12.93 10.0% 3.0<br />

2302 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 146 1 GE refrigerator Actual Cash Value 2,047.25 204.73 10.0% 3.0<br />

2303 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 147 1 kitche aid dishwasher Actual Cash Value 484.88 48.49 10.0% 3.0<br />

2304 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 148 1 range /oven Actual Cash Value 592.63 59.26 10.0% 3.0<br />

2305 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 149 1 microwave oven Actual Cash Value 317.86 31.79 10.0% 3.0<br />

2306 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 150 1 ferguson garbage disposal Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.94 10.0% 3.0<br />

2307 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 151 1 seal meal bags Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2308 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 152 1 refrigerator Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 0.5<br />

2309 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 153 2 pitchers Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 4.0<br />

2310 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 154 1 framed picture Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 0.1<br />

2311 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 155 1 rachel ray cookbook Actual Cash Value 25.86 2.59 10.0% -<br />

2312 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 156 1 coffee bean grinder Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 1.0<br />

2313 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 157 1 electric fondue pot Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 10.0<br />

2314 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 158 1 dual sensor thermometer Actual Cash Value 21.50 2.16 10.0% 2.0<br />

2315 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 159 1 rubbermaid organizers Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2316 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 160 1 dog food, brush, comb, bed Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2317 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 161 3 cutting boards Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2318 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 162 1 scale Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2319 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 163 1 nail clipper Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2320 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 164 1 fireplace screen Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 8.0<br />

2321 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 165 1 orchid silk plant Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 2.0<br />

2322 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 166 1 candles / candleholders Actual Cash Value 96.98 9.70 10.0% 2.0<br />

2323 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 167 1 iron chinese gong Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0% 1.0<br />

2324 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 168 1 allison chair Actual Cash Value 898.64 89.86 10.0% 3.0<br />

2325 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 169 1 console table Actual Cash Value 1,403.98 140.40 10.0% 3.0<br />

2326 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 170 1 30 -50 cds Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 1.0<br />

2327 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 171 1 10 -20 movies Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 1.0<br />

2328 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 172 1 large platter Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 10.0<br />

2329 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 173 1 purple afghan Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 5.0<br />

2330 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 174 1 knick knacks Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 6.0<br />

10/15/2012 48


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2331 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 175 1 cloth coasters Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

2332 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 182 1 tall plant stand Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 8.0<br />

2333 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 183 1 metal magazine holder Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 3.0<br />

2334 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 184 3 silk plants Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 6.5<br />

2335 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 185 1 bowl and plants Actual Cash Value 59.26 5.93 10.0% 9.0<br />

2336 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 186 1 table lamp Actual Cash Value 219.43 21.94 10.0% 1.5<br />

2337 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 187 1 table lamp Actual Cash Value 218.26 21.83 10.0% 2.0<br />

2338 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 188 1 floor lamp Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2339 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 189 1 area rugs Actual Cash Value 350.19 35.02 10.0% 2.0<br />

2340 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 190 1 lamp Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0% 3.0<br />

2341 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 191 1 heavy glass vase Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 2.0<br />

2342 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 192 1 large flower arrangment Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 10.0<br />

2343 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 193 1 matches / holder Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 2.0<br />

2344 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 194 1 wooden cat Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 10.0<br />

2345 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 195 2 topiaries Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 4.0<br />

2346 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 196 2 glass balls Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 6.0<br />

2347 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 197 1 candleholder / candles Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2348 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 198 1 32 mitsubishi tv Actual Cash Value 1,939.50 193.95 10.0% 1.0<br />

2349 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 199 1 dual vcr/dvd player Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2350 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 200 1 stereo / speakers Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 1.0<br />

2351 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 201 1 cordless headset Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2352 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 202 1 gas log set Actual Cash Value 312.48 31.25 10.0% 1.0<br />

2353 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 203 1 large decorative plant / stand Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2354 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 204 1 lamp Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 1.0<br />

2355 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 205 1 glassware / tray set Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2356 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 206 2 wooden ducks Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2357 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 207 4 decanters Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 1.5<br />

2358 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 208 1 pitcure Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 2.0<br />

2359 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 209 1 topiary Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 5.0<br />

2360 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 210 1 basket of tools / hardware Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.94 10.0% 5.5<br />

2361 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 211 1 12 bottles of liquor Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2362 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 212 1 icemaker Actual Cash Value 1,293.00 129.30 10.0% 3.0<br />

2363 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 213 1 misc games, cards Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 3.5<br />

2364 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 214 1 area rug Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2365 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 215 1 shoe polish brush Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2366 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 216 1 bamboo cutting board Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2367 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 217 1 martini bar items Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 2.0<br />

2368 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 218 1 silk plant Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.65 10.0% 2.0<br />

2369 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 219 1 book case Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 3.0<br />

2370 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 220 1 coffe table books Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 4.5<br />

2371 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 221 1 cookbooks Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 6.5<br />

2372 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 222 1 metal bookstand Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2373 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 223 1 14 photo albums Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2374 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 224 1 art picture Actual Cash Value 242.44 24.24 10.0% 3.0<br />

2375 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 225 1 misc kitchen knick knacks Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 9.0<br />

2376 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 226 1 wooden folding chairs Actual Cash Value 129.30 12.93 10.0% 1.0<br />

2377 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 227 1 metal folding chairs Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 12.0<br />

2378 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 228 1 vacuum attachments Actual Cash Value 646.50 64.65 10.0% 2.0<br />

2379 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 229 1 dirt devil Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 6.0<br />

2380 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 230 1 card table Actual Cash Value 129.30 12.93 10.0% 1.0<br />

2381 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 231 1 monopoly Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2382 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 232 1 1/2 gallon bottle of crown royal Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 0.5<br />

2383 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 233 1 step stool Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 3.0<br />

2384 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 234 1 mop, detergent batteries Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 49


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2385 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 235 1 glass / wood cabinet Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 2.5<br />

2386 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 236 1 framed art Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.5<br />

2387 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 237 1 fake plant Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 3.0<br />

2388 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 238 1 stack washer / dryer Actual Cash Value 1,293.00 129.30 10.0% 3.0<br />

2389 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 239 1 laundry supplies Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 0.8<br />

2390 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 240 1 candle holder Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 4.0<br />

2391 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 241 1 bathroom cleaners / toilet paper Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 0.5<br />

2392 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 242 1 framed art Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2393 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 243 1 soap dispenser Actual Cash Value 11.85 1.19 10.0% 1.0<br />

2394 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 244 1 combs, tweezers, makeup Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2395 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 245 1 oval mirror Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2396 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 246 1 bath towels Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2397 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 247 1 bath mat Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 2.0<br />

2398 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 248 1 toilet paper holder Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2399 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 249 1 toilet brush Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 2.0<br />

2400 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 250 1 3 shelf stand Actual Cash Value 70.04 7.00 10.0% 3.0<br />

2401 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 251 1 african basket / soap Actual Cash Value 59.26 5.93 10.0% 6.0<br />

2402 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 252 1 4-5 cleaners Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 1.0<br />

2403 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 253 1 shampoo, razor, skincare Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2404 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 254 1 picture Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 2.0<br />

2405 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 255 1 maid cloth Actual Cash Value 24.78 2.48 10.0% 1.0<br />

2406 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 256 1 bath rugs Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2407 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 257 1 soap dispensers Actual Cash Value 140.08 14.01 10.0% 1.0<br />

2408 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 258 1 three topiaries Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2409 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 259 1 kleenex box holder Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2410 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 260 1 washclothes Actual Cash Value 96.98 9.70 10.0% 1.0<br />

2411 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 261 1 lotions, soaps, toiletries Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2412 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 262 1 combs / brushes Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2413 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 263 1 first-aid supplies Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 1.0<br />

2414 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 264 1 hair clippers Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 1.0<br />

2415 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 265 1 hair scissors Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2416 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 266 1 misc medicine Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2417 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 267 1 misc bathroom cleaner Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

2418 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 268 1 nail clippers, files, tweezers Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2419 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 269 1 makeup , astringent Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 1.0<br />

2420 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 270 1 large green plant Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 2.0<br />

2421 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 271 1 chest of drawers Actual Cash Value 3,017.00 301.70 10.0% 4.0<br />

2422 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 272 1 two table lamps Actual Cash Value 258.60 25.86 10.0% 1.0<br />

2423 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 273 1 decoration items Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2424 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 274 1 floral arrangment Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2425 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 275 1 large basket Actual Cash Value 113.14 11.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2426 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 276 1 ottomans Actual Cash Value 568.90 56.89 10.0% 1.0<br />

2427 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 278 1 panel screen Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2428 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 279 1 3 drawer desk Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 11.0<br />

2429 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 280 1 ironing board Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 6.0<br />

2430 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 281 1 small table Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 2.0<br />

2431 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 282 1 over bed pictures Actual Cash Value 86.20 8.62 10.0% 2.0<br />

2432 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 283 1 wheeled carry on luggage Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 5.0<br />

2433 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 284 1 sunbeam and rowenta irons Actual Cash Value 156.24 15.62 10.0% 12.0<br />

2434 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 285 1 large picture Actual Cash Value 307.09 30.71 10.0% 6.0<br />

2435 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 286 1 wicker basket Actual Cash Value 156.24 15.62 10.0% 2.0<br />

2436 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 287 1 xmas quilt Actual Cash Value 646.50 64.65 10.0% 5.0<br />

2437 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 288 1 spare blankets / pillows Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2438 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 289 1 misc office supplies Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

10/15/2012 50


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2439 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 290 1 11 bird cages Actual Cash Value 355.58 35.56 10.0% 1.0<br />

2440 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 291 1 5 hat boxes Actual Cash Value 118.53 11.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2441 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 292 1 greenery Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2442 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 293 1 desk chair Actual Cash Value 431.00 43.10 10.0% 1.0<br />

2443 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 294 1 rug Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 2.5<br />

2444 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 295 1 desk lamp Actual Cash Value 75.43 7.54 10.0% 2.0<br />

2445 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 296 1 small picture Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 2.0<br />

2446 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 297 1 large plant and stand Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.94 10.0% 8.0<br />

2447 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 298 1 tv /video player Actual Cash Value 404.08 40.41 10.0% 3.0<br />

2448 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 299 1 wicker hamper Actual Cash Value 161.63 16.16 10.0% 5.0<br />

2449 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 300 1 tall basket Actual Cash Value 140.08 14.01 10.0% 4.0<br />

2450 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 301 1 perfume rack, perfume Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2451 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 302 1 dustbuster Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 7.0<br />

2452 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 303 1 rechargeable flashlight Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 2.0<br />

2453 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 304 1 wigs Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 2.0<br />

2454 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 305 1 framed mirrors Actual Cash Value 237.05 23.71 10.0% 3.0<br />

2455 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 306 1 french soap Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2456 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 307 1 framed photos Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2457 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 308 1 clock radio Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 1.0<br />

2458 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 309 1 alarm clock Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2459 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 313 3 ralph lauren pillow shams Actual Cash Value 484.88 48.49 10.0% 1.0<br />

2460 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 314 2 pillows / pillow slips ralph lauren Actual Cash Value 323.25 32.33 10.0% 1.0<br />

2461 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 316 1 black pillows decorative Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2462 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 317 1 goose down comforter Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 5.0<br />

2463 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 318 1 king-size pillows Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 2.0<br />

2464 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 319 1 king-size bed frame Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 12.0<br />

2465 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 320 4 panties Actual Cash Value 43.10 10.78 25.0% 0.5<br />

2466 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 321 3 bras Actual Cash Value 75.43 18.86 25.0% 1.5<br />

2467 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 322 4 pjs / nightgowns Actual Cash Value 161.63 40.41 25.0% 3.0<br />

2468 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 323 4 swimsuits Actual Cash Value 301.70 75.43 25.0% 3.0<br />

2469 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 324 2 swimsuit coverups Actual Cash Value 96.98 24.25 25.0% 3.0<br />

2470 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 325 3 beach towels Actual Cash Value 64.65 16.16 25.0% 5.0<br />

2471 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 326 6 garmet bags Actual Cash Value 96.98 24.25 25.0% 8.0<br />

2472 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 328 3 terry cloth short / jacket sets Actual Cash Value 420.23 105.06 25.0% 3.5<br />

2473 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 329 1 designer purse Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.94 25.0% 3.0<br />

2474 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 330 1 camisole Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0% 1.0<br />

2475 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 331 1 camisole Actual Cash Value 32.33 8.08 25.0% 1.0<br />

2476 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 332 1 rose bowl sweatshirt Actual Cash Value 37.71 9.43 25.0% 1.0<br />

2477 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 333 2 overnight bags Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.94 25.0% 1.0<br />

2478 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 334 1 black flat shoes Actual Cash Value 80.81 20.20 25.0% 1.0<br />

2479 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 335 1 black heels Actual Cash Value 123.91 30.98 25.0% 1.0<br />

2480 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 336 4 sandals Actual Cash Value 150.85 37.71 25.0% 1.0<br />

2481 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 337 1 orange heel Actual Cash Value 48.49 12.12 25.0% 1.0<br />

2482 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 338 1 sports shoes Actual Cash Value 43.10 10.78 25.0% 1.0<br />

2483 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 339 1 walking shoes Actual Cash Value 96.98 24.25 25.0% 1.0<br />

2484 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 340 1 navy flat shoes Actual Cash Value 70.04 17.51 25.0% 1.0<br />

2485 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 341 1 brown suede flat Actual Cash Value 107.75 26.94 25.0% 1.0<br />

2486 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 342 1 tommy bahama flip flops Actual Cash Value 53.88 13.47 25.0% 1.0<br />

2487 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 343 1 red flat shoes Actual Cash Value 70.04 17.51 25.0% 1.0<br />

2488 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 344 1 xmas tree Actual Cash Value 215.50 21.55 10.0% 1.0<br />

2489 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 345 1 refrigerator - freezer Actual Cash Value 538.75 53.88 10.0% 20.0<br />

2490 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 346 1 xmas tree storage bag Actual Cash Value 26.94 2.69 10.0% 1.0<br />

2491 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 347 1 shop vac Actual Cash Value 73.27 7.33 10.0% 4.5<br />

2492 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 348 1 golf bag Actual Cash Value 237.05 23.71 10.0% 3.0<br />

10/15/2012 51


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2493 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 349 1 pantry closet Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 3.0<br />

2494 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 350 1 cleaners / food stuff Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% 1.0<br />

2495 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 351 1 golf balls, socks, towels, gloves Actual Cash Value 269.38 26.94 10.0% 1.0<br />

2496 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 352 1 hand cart Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.86 10.0% 3.0<br />

2497 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 353 1 garden supplies Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2498 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 354 1 grapefruit picker Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 1.0<br />

2499 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 355 1 travel golf bag Actual Cash Value 80.81 8.08 10.0% 1.0<br />

2500 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 356 1 weber duster Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 3.0<br />

2501 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 357 1 flower vases Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

2502 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 358 1 golf shoes Actual Cash Value 107.75 10.78 10.0% -<br />

2503 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 359 1 brushes Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 1.0<br />

2504 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 360 1 collapsible leaf holder Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2505 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 361 1 whisk broom Actual Cash Value 32.33 3.23 10.0% 1.0<br />

2506 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 362 1 detergent Actual Cash Value 16.16 1.62 10.0% 1.0<br />

2507 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 363 1 tool holder Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2508 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 364 1 table / 4 chairs Actual Cash Value 3,771.25 377.13 10.0% 2.5<br />

2509 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 365 2 metal trellises Actual Cash Value 247.83 24.78 10.0% 3.0<br />

2510 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 366 2 metal plant stands Actual Cash Value 150.85 15.09 10.0% 2.0<br />

2511 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 367 3 terra-cotta square planters Actual Cash Value 64.65 6.47 10.0% 3.0<br />

2512 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 368 1 fountain and pump Actual Cash Value 350.19 35.02 10.0% 8.0<br />

2513 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 369 4 patio cushions Actual Cash Value 344.80 34.48 10.0% 2.0<br />

2514 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 370 1 umbrella Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 4.0<br />

2515 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 371 1 cement umbrella Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2516 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 372 4 iron fences Actual Cash Value 25.86 2.59 10.0% 2.0<br />

2517 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 373 2 bird feeders Actual Cash Value 12.93 1.29 10.0% 3.0<br />

2518 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 374 1 bird house Actual Cash Value 10.78 1.08 10.0% 2.0<br />

2519 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 375 1 large candleholder Actual Cash Value 37.71 3.77 10.0% 1.0<br />

2520 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 376 2 metal candleholders Actual Cash Value 25.86 2.59 10.0% 1.0<br />

2521 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 377 1 large candle Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2522 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 378 1 metal doormat Actual Cash Value 53.88 5.39 10.0% 2.0<br />

2523 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 379 1 metal setee Actual Cash Value 129.30 12.93 10.0% 3.0<br />

2524 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 380 2 planter boxes Actual Cash Value 150.85 15.09 10.0% 3.0<br />

2525 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 381 1 large urn Actual Cash Value 140.08 14.01 10.0% 14.0<br />

2526 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 382 3 terra cotta planters Actual Cash Value 48.49 4.85 10.0% 1.0<br />

2527 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 383 2 planters Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 0.5<br />

2528 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 384 25 rubbermaid organizers Actual Cash Value 134.69 13.47 10.0% 5.5<br />

2529 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 385 1 cocktail napkins Actual Cash Value 43.10 4.31 10.0% 1.0<br />

2530 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 386 1 welcome sign Actual Cash Value 21.55 2.16 10.0% 1.0<br />

2531 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 387 8 dressy slacks Actual Cash Value 862.00 215.50 25.0% 2.0<br />

2532 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 388 13 dressy tops Actual Cash Value 1,400.75 350.19 25.0% 2.0<br />

2533 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 389 14 casual pants Actual Cash Value 905.10 226.28 25.0% 2.0<br />

2534 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 390 20 casual shorts Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 269.38 25.0% 2.0<br />

2535 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 391 25 casual sweaters Actual Cash Value 1,077.50 269.38 25.0% 2.0<br />

2536 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 392 15 cardigans Actual Cash Value 1,212.19 303.05 25.0% 2.0<br />

2537 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 393 9 blouses Actual Cash Value 727.31 181.83 25.0% 2.0<br />

2538 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 394 12 vests Actual Cash Value 1,034.40 258.60 25.0% 2.0<br />

2539 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 395 12 jackets Actual Cash Value 1,293.00 323.25 25.0% 2.0<br />

2540 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 396 40 knit shirts, golf outfits Actual Cash Value 1,724.00 431.00 25.0% 2.0<br />

2541 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 397 3 skorts Actual Cash Value 129.30 32.33 25.0% 2.0<br />

2542 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 398 5 warmups Actual Cash Value 484.88 121.22 25.0% 2.0<br />

2543 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 399 2 windbreakers Actual Cash Value 86.20 21.55 25.0% 2.0<br />

2544 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 400 4 swimsuits Actual Cash Value 323.25 80.81 25.0% 2.0<br />

2545 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 401 5 swimsuit coverups Actual Cash Value 215.50 53.88 25.0% 2.0<br />

2546 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 402 8 belts Actual Cash Value 258.60 64.65 25.0% 2.0<br />

10/15/2012 52


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 5<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

Analysis of Claimed Items Where Settlement Option is Actual Cash Value<br />

[a]<br />

Claim With Known<br />

Age Greater Than<br />

Zero Lit_ID<br />

Claimant<br />

ID Claim No. Date of CIS<br />

Per CIS Form<br />

Item<br />

No. Quantity Item Description Settlement Option<br />

Repair/<br />

Replacement<br />

Cost<br />

Depreciation<br />

Amount<br />

Per PPIF Form<br />

Depreciation<br />

% Age<br />

2547 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 403 3 scarves Actual Cash Value 64.65 16.16 25.0% 2.0<br />

2548 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 404 27 socks Actual Cash Value 145.46 36.37 25.0% 2.0<br />

2549 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 405 2 hats Actual Cash Value 129.30 32.33 25.0% 2.0<br />

2550 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 406 1 closet organizer Actual Cash Value 161.63 40.41 25.0% 2.0<br />

2551 198 55-F996-562 6/26/2008 407 14 cotton turtlenecks Actual Cash Value $301.70 $75.43 25.0% 2.0<br />

37 Total Claims With Known Age Greater Than Zero<br />

Notes:<br />

[a] Age information was determined based on the PPIFs for each specified Item. In cases where the PPIF age was specified in months, the age in this field equals the number of months divided by 12. In cases where the PPIF age was specified as a year of purchase,<br />

the age in this field equals the year of loss minus the year of purchase. In cases in which the PPIF age was specified as a month and year of purchase, the age in this field equals the month and year of loss minus the month and year of purchase. Finally, in cases<br />

in which a range of ages was specified (e.g. "0-2 yrs."), the age in this field equals the average of this range (e.g. the average of 0 and 2 is 1).<br />

[b] Age shown on PPIF was contradicted by Activity Log discussion. Age from Activity Log is included in the "Age" field at left.<br />

[c] Age was omitted from PPIF, but was discussed in Activity Log. Age from Activity Log is included in the "Age" field at left.<br />

[d] Item on CIS did not directly match to a specific PPIF line item. However, PPIF did include two general categories of "ski"-related items, both noted as having an age of "2 yrs." As a result, I have assumed that this ski-related item is two years old.<br />

Sources:<br />

Claimant ID Claim No. Bates Range Claimant ID Claim No. Bates Range<br />

1 55-01R7-146 SF_CL0000001 - SF_CL0000039 101 05-M494-044 SF_CL0002434 - SF_CL0002451<br />

7 55-05X9-436 SF_CL0000064 - SF_CL0000081 105 55-E078-594 SF_CL0002597 - SF_CL0002633<br />

11 75-052K-095 SF_CL0000143 - SF_CL0000163 109 75-M596-075 SF_CL0002741 - SF_CL0002873<br />

12 75-03G8-444 SF_CL0000164 - SF_CL0000192 110 75-M423-267 SF_CL0002874 - SF_CL0002892<br />

28 05-M443-777 SF_CL0000408 - SF_CL0000444 116 75-M592-294 SF_CL0002945 - SF_CL0002962<br />

30 05-M486-516 SF_CL0000459 - SF_CL0000479 117 75-M548-962 SF_CL0002963 - SF_CL0002975<br />

35 05-M380-567 SF_CL0000571 - SF_CL0000589 119 05-M370-594 SF_CL0003013 - SF_CL0003025<br />

40 05-M517-927 SF_CL0001034 - SF_CL0001146 120 05-M475-002 SF_CL0003026 - SF_CL0003032<br />

42 05-M394-706 SF_CL0001150 - SF_CL0001161 142 55-E023-943 SF_CL0003989 - SF_CL0004003<br />

54 75-M566-207 SF_CL0001253 - SF_CL0001349 144 55-E017-574 SF_CL0004006 - SF_CL0004027<br />

59 75-M564-724 SF_CL0001404 - SF_CL0001448 146 55-E115-455 SF_CL0004033 - SF_CL0004133<br />

60 75-M415-579 SF_CL0001449 - SF_CL0001460 150 55-F969-790 SF_CL0004155 - SF_CL0004178<br />

62 75-M553-079 SF_CL0001481 - SF_CL0001510 154 55-F953-632 SF_CL0004233 - SF_CL0004254<br />

69 05-M488-313 SF_CL0001577 - SF_CL0001602 156 55-E124-263 SF_CL0004267 - SF_CL0004279<br />

72 75-M537-021 SF_CL0001630 - SF_CL0001672 163 75-M446-056 SF_CL0004324 - SF_CL0004333<br />

82 75-M613-624 SF_CL0001735 - SF_CL0001873 176 75-M523-509 SF_CL0004462 - SF_CL0004484<br />

93 75-M456-650 SF_CL0001924 - SF_CL0001938 189 05-M496-133 SF_CL0004709 - SF_CL0004772<br />

95 75-M624-390 SF_CL0001954 - SF_CL0002032 194 55-E089-494 SF_CL0007305 - SF_CL0007323<br />

96 55-E010-714 SF_CL0002033 - SF_CL0002058 197 05-M430-965 SF_CL0007344 - SF_CL0007402<br />

99 55-E051-497 SF_CL0002087 - SF_CL0002426 198 55-F996-562 SF_CL0007403 - SF_CL0007499<br />

10/15/2012 53


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 6


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

1 Air Cleaner Electronic 12<br />

2 Air Conditioners (Window) 10<br />

3 Athletic Equipment (Gloves, etc.) 5<br />

4 Audio Audio components - Receivers 8<br />

5 Audio Compact disk players 10<br />

6 Audio Compact Discs (CD's) 0.5<br />

7 Audio Compact Audio/HiFi Systems 8<br />

8 Audio Portable Personal Stereos 5<br />

9 Audio Radio (console, portable, table) 10<br />

10 Audio Record Player 10<br />

11 Audio Recorder (Tape or Wire) 10<br />

12 Audio Records (33 & 45 stereo) 0.25<br />

13 Audio Records (75 rpm) 0.67<br />

14 Audio Stereo Tapes -1<br />

15 Barbecue Sets (Grills) 8<br />

16 Barometer 25<br />

17 Bedding Blankets (Cotton) 5<br />

18 Bedding Blankets (Electric) 7<br />

19 Bedding Blankets (Wool) 10<br />

20 Bedding Box Springs 20<br />

21 Bedding Comforters 5<br />

22 Bedding Mattresses 20<br />

23 Bedding Mattresses Covers or Pads 5<br />

24 Bedding Quilts 20<br />

25 Bedding Spreads 3<br />

26 Bicycles 5<br />

27 Billfold 5<br />

28 Binoculars 20<br />

29 Blender or Mixer (Electric) 13<br />

10/15/2012 1


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

30 Boats 10<br />

31 Bookcases 20<br />

32 Books Fiction and Non-Fiction 0.4<br />

33 Books Paperback 0.5<br />

34 Books Professional or Reference 25<br />

35 Boxes (Cigarette, Collar, Jewel) 20<br />

36 Breadmaker 3<br />

37 Brick-a-Brac 0.25<br />

38 Broilers (Electric) 11<br />

39 Brushes (Clothes & Hair) 20<br />

40 Bug Killers 4<br />

41 Calculator 10<br />

42 Camping Equipment 10<br />

43 Can Opener (Electric) 6<br />

44 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.95 per yard or less 7<br />

45 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 5.96 - $ 9.95 per yard 10<br />

46 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 9.96 - $ 12.95 per yard 12<br />

47 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $ 12.96 - $20.95 per yard 15<br />

48 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) $20.96 per yard and above 17<br />

49 Carpets and Rugs (Cost New) Genuine Orientals 25<br />

50 C.B. Radios 8<br />

51 China and Glassware (Also See Kitchen Utensils) 0.1<br />

52 China and Glassware Crockery, Crystal,<br />

0.1<br />

Plastic, Pottery<br />

53 Cigarette Lighter 10<br />

54 Clocks Electric 15<br />

55 Clocks Grandfather 30<br />

56 Clocks Other - Over $25 (Cost New) 20<br />

57 Clocks Other - Under $25 (Cost New) 10<br />

10/15/2012 2


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

58 Cloth Yard Goods 0.1<br />

59 Clothes Hamper 5<br />

60 Clothing Bathing Suits 2<br />

61 Clothing Bathrobes - Lightweight 2<br />

62 Clothing Bathrobes - Heavy or quilted 3<br />

63 Clothing Bathrobes - Wool 3<br />

64 Clothing Blazers - Cotton and blends 3<br />

65 Clothing Blazers - Imitation suede 3<br />

66 Clothing Blazers - Wool 4<br />

67 Clothing Blouses 3<br />

68 Clothing Caps 5<br />

69 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Children's 2<br />

70 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Cotton and blends 3<br />

71 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Fur 10<br />

72 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Imitation fur or<br />

suede<br />

3<br />

73 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Leather and suede 3<br />

74 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Plastic 4<br />

75 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Ski 2<br />

76 Clothing Coats and Jackets - Wool 4<br />

77 Clothing Children's Clothing (all but shoes) 2<br />

78 Clothing Choir Robes 6<br />

79 Clothing Dresses - Casual 2<br />

80 Clothing Dresses - Office 3<br />

81 Clothing Dresses - Silk 2<br />

82 Clothing Evening - High fashion 3<br />

83 Clothing Evening - Basic 5<br />

10/15/2012 3


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

84 Clothing Formal wear 5<br />

85 Clothing Gloves - Fabric 1<br />

86 Clothing Gloves - Leather 2<br />

87 Clothing Handkerchiefs, Pajamas 3<br />

88 Clothing Hats - Men's 5<br />

89 Clothing Hats - Women's 2<br />

90 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Leather 3<br />

91 Clothing Pocketbooks, Purses - Fabric 2<br />

92 Clothing Rainwear & Windbreakers - Film and<br />

plastic coated<br />

2<br />

93 Clothing Rainwear & Windbreakers - Fabric,<br />

lined and unlined<br />

3<br />

94 Clothing Rainwear & Windbreakers - Rubber<br />

3<br />

and plastic<br />

95 Clothing Shirts - Dress 3<br />

96 Clothing Shirts - Sports 2<br />

97 Clothing Shirts - Wool or silk 2<br />

98 Clothing Shoes - Adults' 3<br />

99 Clothing Shoes - Children's 1<br />

100 Clothing Shirts 2<br />

101 Clothing Slacks - Lounging and active sport 2<br />

102 Clothing Slacks - Dress 3<br />

103 Clothing Socks - Socks 1<br />

104 Clothing Sport coats - Cotton & synthetic blends 3<br />

105 Clothing Sport coats - Imitation suede* 3<br />

106 Clothing Sport coats - Wool and wool blends 4<br />

107 Clothing Suits - Cotton and synthetic 2<br />

108 Clothing Suits - Summer weight wool 3<br />

10/15/2012 4


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

109 Clothing Suits - Imitation suede* 3<br />

110 Clothing Suits - Silk 3<br />

111 Clothing Suits - Washable 2<br />

112 Clothing Suits - Winter weight wool 4<br />

113 Clothing Sweaters 3<br />

114 Clothing Underwear - Foundation garments 1<br />

115 Clothing Underwear - Lingerie 1<br />

116 Clothing Underwear - Panties 1<br />

117 Clothing Underwear - Slips 2<br />

118 Clothing Uniforms 1<br />

119 Clothing Vests 2<br />

120 Coffeemaker Perculater 10<br />

121 Coffeemaker Drip 5<br />

122 Coin Collection<br />

123 Compactor 10<br />

124 Computers Large & Special Purpose 4<br />

125 Computers Personal 6<br />

126 Convection Oven (countertop) 12<br />

127 Corn Popper 11<br />

128 Cosmetics 0.1<br />

129 Curling Iron/Styling Comb 5<br />

130 Curtains 3<br />

131 Dehumidifier 14<br />

132 Dishwasher 10<br />

133 Disposals 11<br />

134 Draperies Lined 5<br />

135 Draperies Unlined and Fiberglass 4<br />

136 Draperies Sheet 3<br />

137 Dryer (Laundry) 12<br />

10/15/2012 5


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

138 Eye Glasses 10<br />

139 Fans Electric 10<br />

140 Figurines<br />

141 Firearms 20<br />

142 Fishing Equipment 20<br />

143 Flashlights 0.1<br />

144 Floor Polisher (electric) 15<br />

145 Food Processor 12<br />

146 Food Supplies Beverages and Staples<br />

147 Food Supplies Canned (Commercial or Home)<br />

148 Freezer (Chest or Upright) 15<br />

149 Frying Pan (Electric) 14<br />

150 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Brentwood Chairs (Rattan or Wicker) 5<br />

151 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Card tables, Chairs (Heavy),<br />

Chrome, Plastic<br />

10<br />

152 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Children's 5<br />

153 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Desks and Tables 20<br />

154 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Office Fixtures, Furniture<br />

Cabinets, <strong>Filing</strong> Cases and<br />

Files<br />

20<br />

155 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Slipcovers 3<br />

156 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Upholstered Furniture 10<br />

157 Furniture (Also See Lawn Furniture) Wood Furniture 15<br />

158 Garden Tools (Edger, Hoe, Hose,<br />

Rake, Shovel, Sprinkler,<br />

Wheelbarrow)<br />

10<br />

159 Golf Clubs and Equipment 10<br />

160 Grills and Griddles 11<br />

10/15/2012 6


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

161 Hair Dryer (Electric) 5<br />

162 Hand Vibrator (Electric, Massage) 10<br />

163 Heater (Electric) 9<br />

164 Heating Pad (Electric) 9<br />

165 Home Fitness Equipment 10<br />

166 Hot Plate (Electric) 12<br />

167 Humidifier 5<br />

168 Ironer or Mangle 10<br />

169 Ironing Board 15<br />

170 Ironing Board Cover 2<br />

171 Irons (Electric Including Steam) 9<br />

172 Jewelry Bracelets, Broaches, Cuff<br />

Links, Earrings, Necklaces,<br />

Other Jeweled or Precious<br />

Metal Items, Pins, Rings,<br />

Studs, Watches<br />

20<br />

173 Jewelry Costume Jewelry 5<br />

174 Kitchen Equipment Cast Iron, Copper, Good<br />

Cutlery, Heavy Aluminum,<br />

Stainless Steel<br />

20<br />

175 Kitchen Equipment Pressure Cooker 15<br />

176 Kitchen Equipment Everyday Dishware and<br />

Miscellaneous Utensils (Also<br />

see China and Glassware)<br />

5<br />

177 Knife (Electric) 11<br />

178 Knife Sharpener (Electric) 10<br />

179 Ladders 20<br />

180 Lamps Bulbs (Sun Lamp Only) 3<br />

181 Lamps Desk and Floor 10<br />

10/15/2012 7


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

182 Lamps Infrared or Sun 15<br />

183 Lamps Shades 5<br />

184 Lawn Edgers, Hedge Clippers<br />

and Trimmers (Electric)<br />

7<br />

185 Lawn Furniture Aluminum or Steel 5<br />

186 Lawn Furniture Fabric 3<br />

187 Lawn Furniture Redwood 10<br />

188 Lawn Furniture Wrought Iron 20<br />

189 Lawn Mowers Power 5<br />

190 Lawn Mowers Push Type 10<br />

191 Lawn Mowers Riding 7<br />

192 Lawn Rollers 20<br />

193 Lawn Umbrella 3<br />

194 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Irish Types 20<br />

195 Linens (Doilies, Luncheon<br />

Sets, Napkins, Table Cloths)<br />

Other 5<br />

196 Luggage (Briefcases, Suitcases<br />

and Trunks<br />

20<br />

197 Medicines 3<br />

198 Microwave Ovens 11<br />

199 Mirrors 20<br />

200 Mixers, Electric 18<br />

201 Music Boxes 10<br />

202 Musical Instruments Under $50 (Cost New) 5<br />

203 Musical Instruments $50-$250 (Cost New) 10<br />

204 Musical Instruments Over $250 (Cost New)<br />

including Pianos<br />

25<br />

10/15/2012 8


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

205 Office Equipment Addressing & Mailing<br />

Machines<br />

15<br />

206 Office Equipment Billing Machines 8<br />

207 Office Equipment Bookkeeping Machines 8<br />

208 Office Equipment Cases (Book & Display) 20<br />

209 Office Equipment Check Perforators 10<br />

210 Office Equipment Check Writers 8<br />

211 Office Equipment Coolers, Water 10<br />

212 Office Equipment Duplicating Machines 10<br />

213 Office Equipment Dictation Equipment, Portable 8<br />

214 Office Equipment Dictation Equipment Systems 6<br />

215 Office Equipment Facsimile Equipment 4<br />

216 Office Equipment Folding & Sealing Machines 10<br />

217 Office Equipment Lockers 25<br />

218 Office Equipment Money Changing Machines 10<br />

219 Office Equipment Scales, Counter & Mail 10<br />

220 Oil Paintings<br />

221 Ornaments and Decorations 0.25<br />

222 Outboard Motors 10<br />

223 Photograph Albums and<br />

Pictures<br />

224 Photographic Equipment $50 or less (Cost New) 10<br />

225 Photographic Equipment Over $50 (Cost New) 20<br />

226 Photographic Supplies 0.25<br />

227 Picture Frames 20<br />

228 Pipes (Smoking) 10<br />

229 Playground Equipment 10<br />

230 Pocketknife 10<br />

231 Professional Equipment<br />

10/15/2012 9


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

232 Ranges & Hoods 14<br />

233 Refrigerator 15<br />

234 Roaster (Electric) 10<br />

235 Safes and Vaults 50<br />

236 Scales (Bathroom) 10<br />

237 Scrapbooks<br />

238 Sewing Machine 24<br />

239 Shades 10<br />

240 Shaver (Electric) Men's 3<br />

241 Shaver (Electric) Women's 5<br />

242 Silverware (Plated) 25<br />

243 Silverware (Sterling) 0.1<br />

244 Skiing Equipment 5<br />

245 Slicers (Electric) 12<br />

246 Slowcookers 8<br />

247 Snowthrowers or Blowers 10<br />

248 Space Heater 15<br />

249 Stationary 0.1<br />

250 Stoves or Ranges 14<br />

251 Telephone Answering Devices 5<br />

252 Telephones, cordless 10<br />

253 Television Antenna 6<br />

254 Tennis Rackets 5<br />

255 Toaster (Electric) 8<br />

256 Toiletries (Personal Items) 0.1<br />

257 Tools Hand<br />

258 Tools Power 10<br />

259 Toothbrush (Electric) 4<br />

260 Towels 3<br />

10/15/2012 10


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

261 Toys Electric Train and Games 10<br />

262 Toys Miscellaneous Toys 2<br />

263 Toys Scooter or Tricycle 10<br />

264 Trophy (Personal) 25<br />

265 Typewriter Home 20<br />

266 Typewriter Office 5<br />

267 Umbrella 5<br />

268 Vacuum Cleaner Home 15<br />

269 Vacuum Cleaner Office 6<br />

270 Vaporizer 10<br />

271 Vases<br />

272 Vibrator Chair (Mechanism Only) 10<br />

273 Video Camcorder 7<br />

274 Video Projection Systems, TV 7<br />

275 Video Television Set - Color 12<br />

276 Video Television Set - Black/White 11<br />

277 Video Television Set - Picture Tube (only) 5<br />

278 Video VCR (Video Cassette<br />

6<br />

Recorder)<br />

279 Video Video Disk Player 6<br />

280 Video Video Tapes - Home Movies 3<br />

281 Video Video Tapes - Purchased Movies 3<br />

282 Video Video Game Systems 5<br />

283 Video Video Games 3<br />

284 Waffle Iron 15<br />

285 Washer (Automatic) 11<br />

286 Yard Goods (Cloth) 0.1<br />

10/15/2012 11


The Doan v. State Farm General Insurance Company Appendix 6<br />

Analysis of Basis For Depreciation Used For Claim Settlement<br />

State Farm Depreciation Guide<br />

Notes:<br />

Category ID Category Sub-Category<br />

Years of Useful<br />

Life / Fixed<br />

Depreciation<br />

Items from State Farm Depreciation Guide have been included on the above list unless the Depreciation Guide listed no method of depreciation (i.e. "Rugs and Carpet (See<br />

Carpets and Rugs)" contains no depreciation rate and, as a result, is not included above).<br />

Sources:<br />

State Farm Insurance Companies Depreciation Guide (DOAN00000043PROD-044PROD).<br />

10/15/2012 12


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

APPENDIX 7


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

State Farm Analysis<br />

clear<br />

capture log close<br />

log using "State Farm Analysis.log", text replace<br />

import excel using "McFarlane Appendices for Stata.xlsx", firstrow sheet("Appendix<br />

5")<br />

/* Clean out an empty variable and empty observations. */<br />

drop M<br />

drop if lit_id==.<br />

/* Create a variable that stores the original depreciation. */<br />

gen orig_age = age<br />

/* Count the number of included claim files. */<br />

bysort claim_no: gen n=_n<br />

count if n==1<br />

drop n<br />

/* Items with 0 age are not depreciated; missing age cannot be matched to SF Guide.<br />

*/<br />

drop if age==0 | age==.<br />

/* Count the number of included claim files. */<br />

bysort claim_no: gen n=_n<br />

count if n==1<br />

drop n<br />

/* Each item is duplicated 33 times, once for each possible depreciation<br />

schedule shown on the SF Guide.*/<br />

gen n = _n<br />

gen expand_var = 33<br />

expand expand_var<br />

bysort n: gen j=_n<br />

/* Rows 1 through 27 will be tied to an annual depreciation rate<br />

so create a variable to signify that. */<br />

gen ann = j


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

State Farm Analysis<br />

depreciation to get possible depreciation values for an item of that age.<br />

Since all fixed depreciation items were set to age=1, this can be<br />

calculated in the same way as the annual depreciation. */<br />

gen age_adj_poss = age * poss_ann_guide<br />

/* The 33rd row captures a category that is fixed at 25% for the first three<br />

months, then increases 5% per month thereafter.*/<br />

replace age_adj_poss = .25 + .05*(age-(3/12))*12 if j==33<br />

/* Per the SF Guide, no usable item can have more than 80% depreciation. */<br />

replace age_adj_poss = .8 if age_adj_poss>.8 & age_adj_poss


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

State Farm Analysis<br />

/* A CIS had a few duplicate no match items. Drop the duplicates here. */<br />

drop if lit_id==519 | lit_id==528 | lit_id==534 | lit_id==557 | lit_id==559 |<br />

lit_id==566<br />

drop math_match any_math_match poss_ann age_adj_poss ann expand_var dp_high dp_low<br />

settle life_span<br />

drop quantity age n j<br />

export excel using McFarlane_Stata_Results.xlsx, firstrow(variable) replace<br />

sheet("No Logical Matches")<br />

/* Reload the data as it was at the "preserve" statement above. */<br />

restore<br />

/* Create a data set that has all the potential, mathematical matches. */<br />

keep if math_match == 1<br />

drop math_match any_math_match poss_ann age_adj_poss ann expand_var dp_high dp_low<br />

settle n<br />

/* Count the number of claims. */<br />

bysort claim_no: gen n=_n<br />

count if n==1<br />

drop n<br />

sort lit_id j<br />

tempfile temp1<br />

save `temp1', replace<br />

import excel using "McFarlane Appendices for Stata.xlsx", firstrow sheet("Appendix<br />

6") clear<br />

/* Transfer fixed depreciation rates to the same column as the average useful like<br />

column. */<br />

rename avg_years life_span<br />

gen float temp=life_span<br />

drop life_span<br />

rename temp life_span<br />

sort life_span<br />

/* The joinby command will take every row of the mathematically possible match<br />

data (each row is an item/depreciation schedule combination) and repeat it<br />

for all categories in the guide with that depreciation schedule. After this<br />

command, the data will have one row, for each item, for each mathematically possible<br />

guide category. */<br />

joinby life_span using `temp1', unmatched(both)<br />

tab _m<br />

/* Check the total number of claims. */<br />

bysort claim_no: gen n=_n<br />

count if n==1<br />

drop n<br />

/* Some categories in the Guide are never matched to the data,<br />

namely, items which have no explicit deprecation, like coins.<br />

These can be dropped. */<br />

drop if _m==1<br />

bysort claim_no: gen n=_n<br />

count if n==1<br />

Page 3


E-<strong>FILED</strong>: Oct 15, 2012 5:00 PM, <strong>Superior</strong> <strong>Court</strong> of CA, County of Santa Clara, Case #1-08-CV-129264 <strong>Filing</strong> #G-47834<br />

drop n<br />

drop _m<br />

sort lit_id cat_id<br />

State Farm Analysis<br />

drop age j quantity<br />

order lit_id claim_id claim_no item_no orig_age life_span item_desc category<br />

subcategory rep_cost dep_amt dep_pct<br />

export excel using McFarlane_Stata_Results.xlsx, firstrow(variable) sheetreplace<br />

sheet("Potential Matches")<br />

log close<br />

Page 4

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!