PDF (Whole Thesis) - USQ ePrints - University of Southern ...

PDF (Whole Thesis) - USQ ePrints - University of Southern ... PDF (Whole Thesis) - USQ ePrints - University of Southern ...

eprints.usq.edu.au
from eprints.usq.edu.au More from this publisher
11.02.2013 Views

Dijk as “knowledge, attitudes and ideologies” (2001a, pp. 114-115). In this case, the knowledge is cultural and the assumption is that it is: ...shared by all competent members of a society or culture, and forms the basis or common ground of all social practices and discourses. Indeed, in principle all cultural shared knowledge may therefore be presupposed in public discourses. Of course, such common ground knowledge constantly changes, and what is common ground yesterday, may be ideological group belief today (as is the case for the Christian religion), or vice versa, as is the case for much scholarly knowledge. (van Dijk, 2001a, p. 114, emphasis added) The various attitudes that are represented in the data are categorised according to how they have been constructed as “...socially shared opinions, such as the opinions people share about immigration...or nuclear energy. These are usually complex, that is, consist of a cluster of evaluative propositions” (van Dijk, 2001a, p. 115). Third, the ideologies present in the data as “...basic social representations of social groups” (van Dijk, 2001a, p. 115) are categorised in relation to how they are couched in the knowledge category, so ideologies such as neo-liberal, colonial, progressive and social justice will be made explicit. 3.10 Post Analysis and Conclusion The post analysis stage incorporates Fairclough’s stages four “identify possible ways past the obstacles” and five “reflect critically on the analysis” (Fairclough, 2001, p. 124) into a narrative comprising the various methodologies used as part of the bricolage approach used in this project. The post analysis is reported in Chapter 8: Conclusion. Finally, this research aims to use the methodologies selected to enable an accurate and clearly communicated reporting of findings, adhering to what van Dijk describes as: ...CDA should be accessible. Esoteric style is inconsistent with the fundamental aims of critical research namely that it can be shared with others, especially also by dominated groups. Obscurantism promotes blind imitation, instead of insight. CDA must be teachable, and hence comprehensible...Complex theorizing and analysis do not require abstruse jargon and profound insights need no arcane formulations. (2001a, p, 97) 134

3.11 Chapter Conclusion and Summary To conclude, a feature of a strong qualitative approach to research, as espoused by Denzin and Lincoln is that “…although qualitative researchers may design procedures beforehand, designs always have built-in flexibility, to account for new and unexpected empirical materials and growing sophistication” (2005, p. 376). This is supported by Kincheloe and McLaren who write “…the bricolage views research methods actively rather than passively, meaning that we actively construct our research methods from the tools at hand rather than passively accepting the ‘correct’ universally applicable methodologies” (2005, p. 317). What has been presented throughout this chapter is a ‘final version’ of the methodological approach taken. Throughout this project, and prior to the analysis of texts, it underwent a number of cycles of being conceptualised, drafted and reconceptualised, so that a strengthened approach aligned with the theoretical underpinnings has been formulated. What follows on from this is the analysis of data, introduced by Chapter Four: Data Analysis Introduction offered as a frame to contextualise the data. 135

Dijk as “knowledge, attitudes and ideologies” (2001a, pp. 114-115). In this case, the<br />

knowledge is cultural and the assumption is that it is:<br />

...shared by all competent members <strong>of</strong> a society or culture, and forms the basis or<br />

common ground <strong>of</strong> all social practices and discourses. Indeed, in principle all<br />

cultural shared knowledge may therefore be presupposed in public discourses. Of<br />

course, such common ground knowledge constantly changes, and what is common<br />

ground yesterday, may be ideological group belief today (as is the case for the<br />

Christian religion), or vice versa, as is the case for much scholarly knowledge. (van<br />

Dijk, 2001a, p. 114, emphasis added)<br />

The various attitudes that are represented in the data are categorised according to how they<br />

have been constructed as “...socially shared opinions, such as the opinions people share about<br />

immigration...or nuclear energy. These are usually complex, that is, consist <strong>of</strong> a cluster <strong>of</strong><br />

evaluative propositions” (van Dijk, 2001a, p. 115). Third, the ideologies present in the data as<br />

“...basic social representations <strong>of</strong> social groups” (van Dijk, 2001a, p. 115) are categorised in<br />

relation to how they are couched in the knowledge category, so ideologies such as neo-liberal,<br />

colonial, progressive and social justice will be made explicit.<br />

3.10 Post Analysis and Conclusion<br />

The post analysis stage incorporates Fairclough’s stages four “identify possible ways past the<br />

obstacles” and five “reflect critically on the analysis” (Fairclough, 2001, p. 124) into a<br />

narrative comprising the various methodologies used as part <strong>of</strong> the bricolage approach used<br />

in this project. The post analysis is reported in Chapter 8: Conclusion. Finally, this research<br />

aims to use the methodologies selected to enable an accurate and clearly communicated<br />

reporting <strong>of</strong> findings, adhering to what van Dijk describes as:<br />

...CDA should be accessible. Esoteric style is inconsistent with the fundamental aims<br />

<strong>of</strong> critical research namely that it can be shared with others, especially also by<br />

dominated groups. Obscurantism promotes blind imitation, instead <strong>of</strong> insight. CDA<br />

must be teachable, and hence comprehensible...Complex theorizing and analysis do<br />

not require abstruse jargon and pr<strong>of</strong>ound insights need no arcane formulations.<br />

(2001a, p, 97)<br />

134

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!