Jesus Remembered: Christianity in the Making, vol. 1
Share Embed Flag
Download ePaper

Jesus Remembered: Christianity in the Making, vol. 1

Jesus Remembered: Christianity in the Making, vol. 1 Jesus Remembered: Christianity in the Making, vol. 1

khazarzar.skeptik.net
from khazarzar.skeptik.net More from this publisher
09.02.2013 Views

THE CLIMAX OF JESUS' MISSION §17.1 chief priests and 'temple officers' (strategoi) and elders (Luke 22.52); a 'cohort (speira)' and 'attendants (hyperetai)' (John 18.3). But beyond some story-telling flourish, 51 the various accounts hold together well enough. There is no reason to conclude that there was Roman involvement, 52 since all agree that the arresting party came from the chief priests, who could use Temple police for the purpose (strategoi?). 53 The flight of the disciples is recalled only by Mark and Matthew (Mark 14.50/Matt. 26.56). But together with the subsequent denial of Peter, dramatically retold in all four Gospels (Mark 14.66-72 pars.), 54 and the (almost) total absence of the male disciples from the crucifixion scene, 55 they are too shameful to have been contrived. Here not least the suggestion that such stories emerged as malicious, factional rumours against Peter and the others 56 can be dismissed as fanciful; the likelihood of such material being accepted and becoming established within this core tradition is very small indeed. It is much more plausible that those penitent over their failure should have sought to make some amends by including recollection of it within the core tradition for whose basic shape they were no doubt primarily responsible. 57 e. The Role of Pilate Pilate is almost as enigmatic a figure as Judas. This is no doubt the result of a notable tension between the Gospel accounts and our knowledge of Pilate from Josephus and Philo. 58 For in the latter, Pilate comes across as a ruthless governor, 51. A cohort would normally consist of 600 soldiers! 52. Speira is the normal Greek term for the Roman cohort, but Roman military terms were used for non-Roman troops (Brown, Death 248 n. 11; see also above, chapter 8 nn. 200, 201). 53. See Brown, Death 1430-31; fuller discussion on 246-52. 54. The description of place (courtyard), participants (servant woman and others), and details (fire, accusation, Galilean dialect) certainly smacks of eyewitness recall (Taylor, Mark 572; Pesch, Markusevangelium 2.451-52; Meier, Marginal Jew 3.242-45). The differing tellings as to detail and setting within the larger story (tabulated in Brown, Death 418-19, 590- 91) are typical of performance variation. 55. The one exception might be the mysterious 'beloved disciple' (John 19.26-27). Possibly we should add Simon of Cyrene, evidently known to Mark's circle as 'father of Alexander and Rufus' (Mark 15.21; see further Brown, Death 913-17; Legasse, Trial of Jesus 80-81; Davies and Allison, Matthew 3.610-11); did he become a disciple as a result, and also a source for some of the details recounted by Mark (thus providing an answer to Liidemann's dismissive question, 'Who would have had a correct recollection of that?' — Jesus 107)? 56. E.g., K. E. Dewey in Kelber, ed., Passion in Mark 106. 57. See further Schillebeeckx, Jesus 320-27; Brown, Death 614-26. 58. Philo, Legat. 299-305 (set up shields in Herod's palace in Jerusalem); Josephus, War , " 774

logo

products

Resources

Company

Terms of service
Privacy policy
Cookie policy
Cookie settings
Imprint
Change language
Made with love in Switzerland
© 2024 Yumpu.com all rights reserved

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!