06.02.2013 Views

Primary Retinal Detachment

Primary Retinal Detachment

Primary Retinal Detachment

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Conclusion 169<br />

vitrectomy and search for the retinal break at the operating table,<br />

where the wage rate is 37% higher (Medicare fees from New York,<br />

New Jersey, Connecticut). If one does not find the break, a surgeon<br />

might be inclined to do a peripheral laser barricade augmented<br />

by an encircling band. The barrier operation, which was disappearing<br />

near the end of the twentieth century, is returning as a<br />

prophylactic supplement to primary vitrectomy and pneumatic<br />

retinopexy [54].<br />

Peer Review<br />

A third factor operating against the buckle operation for primary<br />

detachment, beyond the lack of training and the limit of reimbursement<br />

for the time spent, is the absence of peer review. Preoperative<br />

surgical rounds, where the surgical plan for retinal detachment<br />

was open for review, suggestion, criticism, and even censure,<br />

have disappeared; with 1-day surgery, there is not time for it. The<br />

surgeon admits his patient on the day of the operation with as<br />

much preparation as his schedule allowed, and, when the patient<br />

leaves the hospital later in the day with the eye filled with gas, there<br />

is no opportunity to evaluate the effort by his or her peers.<br />

Conclusion<br />

The proponents of primary vitrectomy claim that the final attachment<br />

rate after multiple procedures is 99%. In the series that we<br />

examined, it was 97%, equal to that of buckling. This is reassuring.<br />

They dismiss the morbidity of multiple operations and regard the<br />

frequent provocation of cataract as acceptable.<br />

We do not think it is possible to counteract the change in the<br />

treatment of retinal detachment. Perhaps market forces will relax,<br />

and peer review will return, or maybe new and less morbid methods<br />

to attach the retina will be invented. Admittedly, the incidence of

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!