01.02.2013 Views

Insect Control: Biological and Synthetic Agents - Index of

Insect Control: Biological and Synthetic Agents - Index of

Insect Control: Biological and Synthetic Agents - Index of

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Table 9 Continued<br />

Lu-chu 2001 Field Azadirachtin Leaf dip >1000<br />

Blattella germanica Apyr-R Field Permethrin Topical 97 Wei et al. (2001)<br />

Apyr-R Field Deltamethrin Topical 480<br />

Apyr-R Field Spinosad Topical 1.3<br />

Musca domestica AVER Field Abamectin Topical >1000 Scott (1998)<br />

AVER Field Spinosad Topical 1.9<br />

LPR (Multi-R) Field–Lab. Spinosad Topical 4.3<br />

OCR<br />

(cyclodiene)<br />

Cyclodiene Topical high<br />

OCR<br />

(cyclodiene)<br />

Spinosad Topical 0.4<br />

Cornell-R Field-Lab. Spinosad Topical 0.9<br />

R12 (CYP6D1) Laboratory Spinosad Topical 1.8<br />

R3 (kdr <strong>and</strong> pen) Laboratory Spinosad Topical 1.4<br />

Musca domestica ALHF (multi R) Field Permethrin Topical 1800 Liu <strong>and</strong> Yue (2000)<br />

ALHF (multi R) Field Cypermethrin Topical 4200<br />

ALHF (multi R) Field Spinosad Topical 1.4<br />

Musca domestica Several Field Permethrin Glass high Scott et al. (2000)<br />

Several Field Cyfluthrin Glass high<br />

Several Field Spinosad Feeding low<br />

Several Field Fipronil Glass very low<br />

Several Field Dimethoate Glass low<br />

Several Field Methomyl Feeding low-high<br />

Choristoneura<br />

rosaceana<br />

Choristoneura<br />

rosaceana<br />

Choristoneura<br />

rosaceana<br />

6: The Spinosyns: Chemistry, Biochemistry, Mode <strong>of</strong> Action, <strong>and</strong> Resistance 235<br />

Species Strain Select Compound Method<br />

Berrien Field Azinphosmethyl Diet 27 Ahmad et al. (2002)<br />

Berrien Field Chlorpyrifos Diet 25<br />

Berrien Field Spinosad Diet 0.83<br />

Berrien Field Cypermethrin Diet 8<br />

Berrien Field Methoxyfenozide Diet 3.1<br />

Berrien Field Indoxacarb Diet 705<br />

Site 2 Field Azinphosmethyl Leaf disc 15.5 Smirle et al. (2003)<br />

Site 2 Field Spinosad Leaf disc 1.8<br />

Brown 97 (OP-R) Field Tebufenozide Leaf dip 12.8 Waldstein <strong>and</strong> Reissig<br />

(2000)<br />

Brown-96 (OP-R) Field Spinosad Leaf dip 2.0<br />

sites were also shown to exhibit significant levels <strong>of</strong><br />

resistance to spinosad that increased with time <strong>and</strong><br />

were associated with failures to control P. xylostella<br />

larvae in the field (Zhao et al., 2002). As a response<br />

to these developments, a regional IRM program<br />

was implemented (Zhao et al., 2002; Mau <strong>and</strong><br />

Gusukuma-Minuto, 2004). Spinosad was voluntarily<br />

withdrawn from use where field failures had<br />

occurred <strong>and</strong> two newly registered products, emamectin<br />

benzoate <strong>and</strong> indoxacarb, were put into a<br />

rotation scheme (Mau <strong>and</strong> Gusukuma-Minuto,<br />

2004). Following its withdrawal from use, susceptibility<br />

to spinosad increased rapidly such that for<br />

some <strong>of</strong> the locations (Maui <strong>and</strong> Hawaii) the thresholds<br />

for spinosad reintroduction were met within<br />

6-8 months, setting the stage for spinosad’s reintroduction<br />

in early 2002 (Mau <strong>and</strong> Gusukuma-Minuto,<br />

2004). By the fall <strong>of</strong> 2002, resistance to spinosad had<br />

also fallen below the threshold in the remaining<br />

region (Oahu) such that it was reintroduced in<br />

Toxicity<br />

ratio Reference<br />

early 2003 (Mau, personal communication). With<br />

its reintroduction, spinosad has become part <strong>of</strong> an<br />

IRM rotation scheme that also includes emamectin<br />

benzoate <strong>and</strong> indoxacarb (Mau, personal communication).<br />

Given the selection pressure that was placed<br />

on spinosad in several <strong>of</strong> the locations in Hawaii, it is<br />

not clear how long this rotation scheme will remain<br />

effective in the control <strong>of</strong> a pest that has developed<br />

resistance to virtually all insecticides previously<br />

used. Nevertheless, this experience with spinosad<br />

in Hawaii has demonstrated that IRM can indeed<br />

help extend, if not preserve, the life <strong>of</strong> an insect<br />

control agent.<br />

6.7. Spinosyns <strong>and</strong> Spinosoid<br />

Structure–Activity Relationships<br />

Exploration <strong>of</strong> the spinosyns included continued<br />

isolation <strong>and</strong> identification <strong>of</strong> new spinosyns (naturally<br />

occurring analogs <strong>of</strong> spinosyn A). This effort

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!