Faciobrachial dystonic seizures precede Lgi1 antibody limbic ...

Faciobrachial dystonic seizures precede Lgi1 antibody limbic ... Faciobrachial dystonic seizures precede Lgi1 antibody limbic ...

neuro.uni.luebeck.de
from neuro.uni.luebeck.de More from this publisher
19.01.2013 Views

ORIGINAL ARTICLE Faciobrachial Dystonic Seizures Precede Lgi1 Antibody Limbic Encephalitis Sarosh R. Irani, DPhil, 1 Andrew W. Michell, PhD, 2 Bethan Lang, PhD, 1 Philippa Pettingill, BSc, 1 Patrick Waters, PhD, 1 Michael R. Johnson, PhD, 3 Jonathan M. Schott, MD, 4 Richard J. E. Armstrong, PhD, 1,4 Alessandro S. Zagami, MD, 5 Andrew Bleasel, PhD, 6 Ernest R. Somerville, FRCAP, 5,7 ShelaghM.J.Smith,FRCP, 8 and Angela Vincent, FRCPath 1,9 Objective: To describe a distinctive seizure semiology that closely associates with voltage-gated potassium channel (VGKC)-complex/Lgi1 antibodies and commonly precedes the onset of limbic encephalitis (LE). Methods: Twenty-nine patients were identified by the authors (n ¼ 15) or referring clinicians (n ¼ 14). The temporal progression of clinical features and serum sodium, brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), positron emission tomography/single photon emission computed tomography, and VGKC-complex antibodies was studied. Results: Videos and still images showed a distinctive adult-onset, frequent, brief dystonic seizure semiology that predominantly affected the arm and ipsilateral face. We have termed these faciobrachial dystonic seizures (FBDS). All patients tested during their illness had antibodies to VGKC complexes; the specific antigenic target was Lgi1 in 89%. Whereas 3 patients never developed LE, 20 of the remaining 26 (77%) experienced FBDS prior to the development of the amnesia and confusion that characterize LE. During the prodrome of FBDS alone, patients had normal sodium and brain MRIs, but electroencephalography demonstrated ictal epileptiform activity in 7 patients (24%). Following development of LE, the patients often developed other seizure semiologies, including typical mesial temporal lobe seizures. At this stage, investigations commonly showed hyponatremia and MRI hippocampal high T2 signal; functional brain imaging showed evidence of basal ganglia involvement in 5/8. Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) were generally ineffective and in 41% were associated with cutaneous reactions that were often severe. By contrast, immunotherapies produced a clear, and often dramatic, reduction in FBDS frequency. Interpretation: Recognition of FBDS should prompt testing for VGKC-complex/Lgi1 antibodies. AEDs often produce adverse effects; treatment with immunotherapies may prevent the development of LE with its potential for cerebral atrophy and cognitive impairment. ANN NEUROL 2010;000:000–000 Limbic encephalitis (LE) associated with antibodies (Abs) to the voltage-gated potassium channels (VGKCs) is a well-established immunotherapy-responsive condition, usually without an associated tumor. 1–3 TheAbsarenowrecognized to bind to different components of VGKC complexes such as leucine-rich glioma inactivated-1 (Lgi1) 3,4 or contactin-associated protein 2 (Caspr2), 3 and we will refer to them as VGKC-complex Abs. Similar Abs have also been identified in around 10% of unselected patients with otherwise unexplained and drug-resistant epilepsy 5,6 and in 4 patients with late onset epilepsy with an unusual semiology. 7,8 These 4 patients presented with very frequent, brief, dystonic, seizure-like episodes. Here, we describe 29 adult patients with this distinctive antiepileptic drug (AED)-refractory, but immunotherapy-responsive, seizure semiology, which we refer to as faciobrachial dystonic seizures (FBDS). The majority of patients subsequently developed a typical VGKC-complex View this article online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI: 10.1002/ana.22307 Received Sep 3, 2010, and in revised form Sep 27, 2010. Accepted for publication Oct 15, 2010. Address correspondence to Dr Vincent, Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, West Wing, Level 6, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, OX3 9DU, United Kingdom. E-mail: angela.vincent@imm.ox.ac.uk From the 1 Department of Clinical Neurology, Oxford University, Oxford, UK; 2 Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge University, Cambridge, UK; 3 Centre for Neurosciences, Imperial College, London, UK; 4 Dementia Research Centre, National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, UK; 5 Institute of Neurological Sciences and Clinical School, Prince of Wales Hospital and University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia; 6 Westmead Hospital, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia; 7 Comprehensive Epilepsy Service, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney, Australia; 8 Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, UK; and 9 Institute of Neurology, University College London, London, UK. Additional supporting information can be found in the online version of this article. VC 2010 American Neurological Association 1

ORIGINAL ARTICLE<br />

<strong>Faciobrachial</strong> Dystonic Seizures Precede<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong> Antibody Limbic Encephalitis<br />

Sarosh R. Irani, DPhil, 1 Andrew W. Michell, PhD, 2 Bethan Lang, PhD, 1 Philippa Pettingill, BSc, 1<br />

Patrick Waters, PhD, 1 Michael R. Johnson, PhD, 3 Jonathan M. Schott, MD, 4<br />

Richard J. E. Armstrong, PhD, 1,4 Alessandro S. Zagami, MD, 5 Andrew Bleasel, PhD, 6<br />

Ernest R. Somerville, FRCAP, 5,7 ShelaghM.J.Smith,FRCP, 8 and Angela Vincent, FRCPath 1,9<br />

Objective: To describe a distinctive seizure semiology that closely associates with voltage-gated potassium channel<br />

(VGKC)-complex/<strong>Lgi1</strong> antibodies and commonly <strong>precede</strong>s the onset of <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis (LE).<br />

Methods: Twenty-nine patients were identified by the authors (n ¼ 15) or referring clinicians (n ¼ 14). The temporal<br />

progression of clinical features and serum sodium, brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), positron emission<br />

tomography/single photon emission computed tomography, and VGKC-complex antibodies was studied.<br />

Results: Videos and still images showed a distinctive adult-onset, frequent, brief <strong>dystonic</strong> seizure semiology that<br />

predominantly affected the arm and ipsilateral face. We have termed these faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong> (FBDS).<br />

All patients tested during their illness had antibodies to VGKC complexes; the specific antigenic target was <strong>Lgi1</strong> in<br />

89%. Whereas 3 patients never developed LE, 20 of the remaining 26 (77%) experienced FBDS prior to the<br />

development of the amnesia and confusion that characterize LE. During the prodrome of FBDS alone, patients had<br />

normal sodium and brain MRIs, but electroencephalography demonstrated ictal epileptiform activity in 7 patients<br />

(24%). Following development of LE, the patients often developed other seizure semiologies, including typical mesial<br />

temporal lobe <strong>seizures</strong>. At this stage, investigations commonly showed hyponatremia and MRI hippocampal high T2<br />

signal; functional brain imaging showed evidence of basal ganglia involvement in 5/8. Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs)<br />

were generally ineffective and in 41% were associated with cutaneous reactions that were often severe. By contrast,<br />

immunotherapies produced a clear, and often dramatic, reduction in FBDS frequency.<br />

Interpretation: Recognition of FBDS should prompt testing for VGKC-complex/<strong>Lgi1</strong> antibodies. AEDs often produce<br />

adverse effects; treatment with immunotherapies may prevent the development of LE with its potential for cerebral<br />

atrophy and cognitive impairment.<br />

ANN NEUROL 2010;000:000–000<br />

Limbic encephalitis (LE) associated with antibodies (Abs)<br />

to the voltage-gated potassium channels (VGKCs) is a<br />

well-established immunotherapy-responsive condition, usually<br />

without an associated tumor. 1–3 TheAbsarenowrecognized<br />

to bind to different components of VGKC complexes<br />

such as leucine-rich glioma inactivated-1 (<strong>Lgi1</strong>) 3,4 or<br />

contactin-associated protein 2 (Caspr2), 3 and we will refer<br />

to them as VGKC-complex Abs. Similar Abs have also<br />

been identified in around 10% of unselected patients with<br />

otherwise unexplained and drug-resistant epilepsy 5,6 and in<br />

4 patients with late onset epilepsy with an unusual semiology.<br />

7,8 These 4 patients presented with very frequent, brief,<br />

<strong>dystonic</strong>, seizure-like episodes.<br />

Here, we describe 29 adult patients with this distinctive<br />

antiepileptic drug (AED)-refractory, but immunotherapy-responsive,<br />

seizure semiology, which we refer to as<br />

faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong> (FBDS). The majority of<br />

patients subsequently developed a typical VGKC-complex<br />

View this article online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI: 10.1002/ana.22307<br />

Received Sep 3, 2010, and in revised form Sep 27, 2010. Accepted for publication Oct 15, 2010.<br />

Address correspondence to Dr Vincent, Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, West Wing, Level 6, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, OX3 9DU,<br />

United Kingdom. E-mail: angela.vincent@imm.ox.ac.uk<br />

From the 1 Department of Clinical Neurology, Oxford University, Oxford, UK; 2 Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge<br />

University, Cambridge, UK; 3 Centre for Neurosciences, Imperial College, London, UK; 4 Dementia Research Centre, National Hospital for Neurology and<br />

Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, UK; 5 Institute of Neurological Sciences and Clinical School, Prince of Wales Hospital and University of New South<br />

Wales, Sydney, Australia; 6 Westmead Hospital, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia; 7 Comprehensive Epilepsy Service, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney,<br />

Australia; 8 Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Queen Square, London, UK; and 9 Institute of<br />

Neurology, University College London, London, UK.<br />

Additional supporting information can be found in the online version of this article.<br />

VC 2010 American Neurological Association 1


ANNALS of Neurology<br />

FIGURE 1: <strong>Faciobrachial</strong> <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong> (FBDS). (A–E) Ictal stills of 5 patients included in this series are shown. The<br />

ipsilateral face grimacing and arm posturing are visible in all cases. Videos are available, with the patients’ consent, in the<br />

online supplementary data. (F) Percentage of patients with <strong>dystonic</strong> posturing of specified body part(s) during FBDS (white<br />

bars) and whether FBDS remained strictly unilateral or sometimes alternated in an individual patient (black bars).<br />

Ab-positive nonparaneoplastic LE. Because early treatment<br />

of the LE syndrome may limit the duration or severity of the<br />

illness and the degree of cognitive disability, recognition of<br />

these <strong>seizures</strong> should offer a window of opportunity for early<br />

treatment and possible prevention of permanent disability.<br />

Patients and Methods<br />

In total, 29 patients with FBDS are described. Referring neurologists<br />

communicated with the authors verbally, via questionnaires<br />

(as part of Irani et al, 3 a study of patients with VGKC-complex<br />

Abs >400pM) and/or clinic letters. In addition, 26 of 29<br />

patients/relatives subsequently underwent retrospective telephone/<br />

personal interviews. Emphasis was placed on the nature of<br />

the <strong>seizures</strong>, their timing in relation to development of LE, and<br />

the treatment responses. Overall, 17 patients were seen by the<br />

authors (n ¼ 6), referring neurologists (n ¼ 6), or general practitioners<br />

(n ¼ 5) while FBDS alone were present. In another 6<br />

patients, timing of the FBDS was obtained from the relatives. In<br />

the remaining 6 patients, FBDS were recognized by the authors<br />

(n ¼ 3) or the referring neurologists (n ¼ 3) during the LE.<br />

The FBDS in 3 of these patients were described previously.<br />

7 Other patients were included in studies of LE 23 or Mor-<br />

van syndrome, 10 but their FBDS were not described in those<br />

publications. Videos were available for review in 16 of the<br />

patients.<br />

VGKC-complex Abs were determined by routine immunoprecipitation<br />

by patient serum immunoglobulin G (IgG) of<br />

VGKC complexes from 125 I-adendrotoxin–labeled rabbit brain<br />

extract (normal range


TABLE 1: Clinical Features of All Patients with<br />

FBDS and Results of Investigation at Times When<br />

No Cognitive Impairment Was Apparent<br />

Characteristic Value<br />

Clinical features of FBDS n ¼ 29<br />

Age, median yr (range) 64 (36–83)<br />

Sex, male:female 19:10<br />

Number of faciobrachial<br />

<strong>seizures</strong> per day,<br />

median (range)<br />

50 (6–360)<br />

Alteration in consciousness 19 (66%) a<br />

Falls 18 (62%)<br />

Stimulus-triggered <strong>seizures</strong> 8 (28%); auditory<br />

in 6, high<br />

emotion in 2<br />

Ictal vocalizations 7 (24%)<br />

Investigation results at time of FBDS without<br />

cognitive impairment<br />

Serum sodium level 13 of 13 (100%)<br />

>135mmol<br />

Normal brain MRI 9 of 9 (100%) b<br />

VGKC-complex antibodies, 1,962 (639–5,409)<br />

mean pM (range)<br />

c<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong> <strong>antibody</strong> positive 3 of 4 (75%)<br />

Caspr2 <strong>antibody</strong> positive 0 of 4 (0%)<br />

Contactin 2 <strong>antibody</strong> positive 0 of 4 (0%)<br />

In 6 of 29 patients, FBDS were first recognized after onset<br />

of amnesia/confusion.<br />

a<br />

Altered awareness was observed in 66% of patients but not<br />

seen during all <strong>seizures</strong> in any individual.<br />

b<br />

One of these MRIs was later judged to have subtle bilateral<br />

high hippocampal signal by 2 neuroradiologists with an interest<br />

in <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis.<br />

c<br />

VGKC-complex <strong>antibody</strong> testing was only requested on 4<br />

samples during the period of FBDS alone. Three of these<br />

patients were given immunotherapies and never developed<br />

amnesia; only 1 progressed to develop amnesia/confusion<br />

(this case is also included in Table 2).<br />

FBDS ¼ faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong>; MRI ¼ magnetic resonance<br />

imaging; VGKC ¼ voltage-gated potassium channel.<br />

corresponding videos (Supporting Information Videos A–<br />

E). The FBDS were very brief (usually


ANNALS of Neurology<br />

FIGURE 2: Electroencephalography. (A) Interictal and (B) ictal electroencephalograms (EEGs) were recorded during a<br />

faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> seizure in a 39-year-old woman. On this occasion, ictal 2 to 4Hz spike-wave activity was noted of maximal<br />

amplitude over the left frontotemporal region. The interictal EEG was normal. Ictal epileptiform activity was seen in 7 of 29 cases.<br />

Bar 5 1second.<br />

medial temporal lobe <strong>seizures</strong> (n ¼ 12), and simple partial<br />

<strong>seizures</strong> with piloerection (n ¼ 1), which have all previously<br />

been reported in VGKC-complex Ab-associated LE. 1,3,12,13<br />

Investigations during or after the Period<br />

of Limbic Encephalitis (n ¼ 26)<br />

All 24 patients with active LE had serum VGKC-complex<br />

Abs by radioimmunoprecipitation (see Table 2 and<br />

Supporting Information Fig). <strong>Lgi1</strong> Abs were present in<br />

22 (2 of these also had Abs against Caspr2, and 1 also<br />

against contactin-2; for further information about these<br />

antigens, see Irani et al 3 ). We were unable to identify the<br />

specific target in 2 VGKC-complex Ab-positive patients.<br />

Two patients who were tested >4 years after the illness<br />

were negative for VGKC-complex Abs, but 1 of these<br />

was positive for <strong>Lgi1</strong> Abs by the cell-based assay.<br />

Interictal EEG abnormalities included diffuse mild<br />

slowing (n ¼ 9), bilateral frontotemporal slowing (n ¼ 6), or<br />

temporal sharp waves (n ¼ 2). In 9 patients, no EEG abnormalities<br />

were detected. At this stage in the illness, hyponatremia<br />

(


TABLE 2: Timing of FBDS, TLS, and LE from the 26 Patients Who Developed LE<br />

Characteristic Value<br />

Timings n ¼ 26 a (unless otherwise stated)<br />

Patients with FBDS prior to amnesia, No. 20 (77%)<br />

Days from FBDS onset to amnesia/confusion, median (range) 36 ( 150 to 730) a<br />

Additional seizure semiologies Total ¼18 (70%); generalized tonic<br />

clonic ¼ 13; complex partial ¼ 12<br />

(all MTLS); simple partial ¼ 1<br />

Patients with onset of TLS after onset of FBDS, No. 10 of 12 (83%)<br />

Days from onset of FBDS to onset of temporal<br />

lobe <strong>seizures</strong>, median (range)<br />

Features associated with LE<br />

12.5 ( 15 to 455)<br />

Amnesia 26 (100%)<br />

Confusion 23 (88%)<br />

Hallucinations 9 (35%)<br />

Sleep disturbance 7 (31%)<br />

Depression 5 (19%)<br />

Dysautonomia 4 (15%)<br />

Pain 4 (15%)<br />

Cerebellar features 2 (8%)<br />

Interictal limb dystonia 1 (4%)<br />

Investigations during LE n ¼ 26<br />

VGKC-complex antibodies, mean pM (range) 2,281 (0–8,800) b<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong><strong>antibody</strong> positive 23 (88%) b<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong> and Caspr2 or contactin 2 antibodies 3 (12%)<br />

No VGKC-complex–specific target determined 3 (12%)<br />

Serum sodium 4 years after their illness had negative VGKC-complex antibodies as assessed by the routine radioimmunoprecipitation<br />

assay (<strong>Lgi1</strong> antibodies were detected by cell-based assay in 1 of these patients); 1 patient administered intravenous<br />

immunoglobulins 3 weeks before <strong>antibody</strong> testing had low positive VGKC-complex <strong>antibody</strong> levels (238pM).<br />

FBDS ¼ faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong>; TLS ¼ temporal lobe <strong>seizures</strong>; LE¼ <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis; MTLS ¼ mesial temporal lobe <strong>seizures</strong><br />

as defined clinically or by electroencephalography; VGKC ¼ voltage-gated potassium channel; MRI ¼ magnetic resonance imaging.<br />

patient has developed a tumor after a median follow-up of<br />

2.75 years (range, 0.5–8 years).<br />

Response to Treatments in All 29 Patients<br />

For each patient, a mean of 2.6 AEDs were administered<br />

(range, 1–6). The effect on FBDS frequency was generally<br />

poor, and only 4 patients showed a good (20–50%) or<br />

excellent (>50%) reduction in FBDS frequency within 1<br />

month of treatment (see Fig 3D). Significant side effects<br />

were seen in 12 patients (41%) (see Fig 3D), with a localized<br />

rash in 8 patients (carbamazepine in 4, phenytoin in 2,<br />

Irani et al: <strong>Lgi1</strong> Ab Limbic Encephalitis<br />

lamotrigine in 1, and levetiracetam in 1) and erythroderma<br />

in 2 patients (both phenytoin). In addition, 2 patients<br />

developed Stevens-Johnson syndrome after receiving carbamazepine;<br />

1 required intensive care unit admission.<br />

By contrast, the FBDS response to immunotherapy<br />

was excellent (see Fig 3). Two patients were not offered<br />

immunotherapies, because they were originally seen before<br />

widespread knowledge of VGKC-complex Abs. They progressed<br />

from FBDS only to develop amnesia/confusion<br />

with hyponatremia. With AEDs, but without immunotherapy,<br />

these 2 patients made some symptomatic recovery<br />

Month, 2010 5


ANNALS of Neurology<br />

FIGURE 3: Clinical and serological responses to immunotherapies. (A–C) voltage-gated potassium channel (VGKC)-complex<br />

<strong>antibody</strong> (Ab) titers, <strong>seizures</strong> per day, and modified Rankin Scores (mRS, green in C) are shown in individual cases. The purple<br />

asterisk indicates the onset of amnesia/confusion. Pred 5 prednisolone; IvIg 5 intravenous immunoglobulins; Px 5 plasma<br />

exchange; Aza 5 azathioprine; AEDs 5 antiepileptic drugs. (D) The responses of the patients to AEDs (n 5 29) and/or<br />

immunotherapies (ITs, n 5 27) and the adverse events attributed to these medications (blue bar) are illustrated.<br />

at 4-year follow-up, although 1 case still experiences daily<br />

FBDS. Of the other 27 patients, steroid therapy (oral or<br />

intravenous) was used in 24 of 27, 14 received intravenous<br />

immunoglobulin (IvIg), 13 were given plasma exchange,<br />

and 1 received rituximab. Fourteen patients (52%) showed a<br />

>50% reduction in seizure frequency, 12 (44%) showed<br />

a 20 to 50% reduction, and only 1 case (4%) had<br />


etrospectively from those who had already developed LE<br />

with high levels of VGKC Abs (>400pM), and it is not<br />

yet clear whether FBDS are 100% predictive of VGKC<br />

Abs and whether, if untreated, FBDS inevitably proceed<br />

to LE. One patient sampled after recovery was negative<br />

for VGKC Abs but positive for <strong>Lgi1</strong> Abs; this indicates<br />

that not all <strong>Lgi1</strong> is associated with VGKCs and that Abs to<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong>, and by inference to other associated proteins such as<br />

Caspr2, may be found in patients who are not positive for<br />

VGKC-complex Abs by the immunoprecipitation assay;<br />

but that also requires further study. For the time being, we<br />

continue to screen sera initially with the radioimmunoprecipitation<br />

assay for VGKC-complex Abs, but assays for<br />

<strong>Lgi1</strong> and Caspr2 Abs are being developed for wider use.<br />

The description here significantly extends the original<br />

report of 3 patients with these seizurelike episodes, 7<br />

and argues against a paroxysmal movement disorder. The<br />

epileptic nature of FBDS is supported by the associated<br />

brief loss of awareness and the highly stereotyped semiology,<br />

although a coincident epileptiform change on scalp<br />

EEG was only demonstrated in the minority. The ictal<br />

onset zone has not been determined, but the high frequency<br />

of brief attacks with a startle component and<br />

trunk turning are suggestive of frontal lobe involvement.<br />

14 However, ictal head version and predominant<br />

nocturnal episodes, also typical of frontal lobe <strong>seizures</strong>,<br />

were not apparent. Furthermore, typical temporal lobe<br />

<strong>seizures</strong> have a longer duration, occur less frequently, and<br />

commonly show a sustained (often >10 seconds) contra-<br />

Irani et al: <strong>Lgi1</strong> Ab Limbic Encephalitis<br />

FIGURE 4: Examples of brain imaging in faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong> (FBDS). (A–C) Typical medial temporal lobe high signal<br />

from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is shown during periods of amnesia in 3 patients. Hippocampal atrophy was seen in<br />

some cases at follow-up MRI (eg, change from C to D). Fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography (PET) and single<br />

photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) images in 7 patients showed basal ganglia and temporal lobe abnormalities,<br />

which included (E) temporal lobe PET bilateral hypermetabolism, (F) right hypometabolism, or (G) SPECT left hypoperfusion.<br />

Three examples of metabolic changes within the basal ganglia are shown in H and I (bilateral hypermetabolism) and J (left<br />

hypermetabolism). These images were acquired during the <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis phase, when the patients were also having many<br />

brief FBDS per hour, and it was difficult to identify whether they were directly related to the FBDS.<br />

lateral arm dystonia with automatisms and absence of<br />

face involvement. 15,16 Irrespective of the location of the<br />

ictal onset zone, it seems likely that the ictal dystonia in<br />

these patients reflects basal ganglia involvement. This is<br />

supported by the surprisingly frequent demonstration of<br />

abnormal basal ganglia metabolism on FDG-PET, which<br />

has previously been shown in typical temporal lobe <strong>seizures</strong><br />

associated with upper limb dystonia. 17,18 The few<br />

previous VGKC-complex Ab LE studies using PET have<br />

not detected basal ganglia abnormalities. 12,19,20 Thus,<br />

this may be a relatively specific feature within the subset<br />

of patients with FBDS and may be related to their ictal<br />

dystonia.<br />

These <strong>seizures</strong> are likely to have been seen by<br />

others. Descriptions of very frequent brief twitches affecting<br />

the shoulder and ipsilateral face appear in recent case<br />

reports of patients with <strong>seizures</strong> and VGKC-complex<br />

Abs. 8,10,21,22 Moreover, given that around 20% of our 64<br />

patients with VGKC-complex Ab LE 3 had FBDS, it is<br />

interesting that 2 surveys of VGKC Ab-positive patients<br />

noted a 22% and 40% frequency of myoclonus. 4,20<br />

It is now clear that VGKC-complex Abs, at least in<br />

patients with high titers, 3 are rarely directed against Kv1potassium<br />

channels themselves, but bind to other proteins<br />

that are tightly complexed with Kv1 subunits in<br />

situ and in detergent extracts. 3,4 Almost all patients<br />

sampled during their illness, before immunotherapies<br />

began, had Abs directed against <strong>Lgi1</strong>, which is a secreted<br />

protein that modulates neuronal morphology and<br />

Month, 2010 7


ANNALS of Neurology<br />

synaptic excitability. 23 Abs to <strong>Lgi1</strong> are likely to induce similar<br />

complex effects depending on where and how they act<br />

and will require detailed investigations. One study has<br />

found epileptiform activity in mouse hippocampal slices<br />

exposedtopurifiedIgGfromapatientwithLEand<strong>Lgi1</strong><br />

Abs, likely as a result of the Abs enhancing neurotransmitter<br />

release at mossy fiber/CA3 pyramidal cell synapses, and<br />

consistent with a reduction of VGKC expression or function.<br />

24 Of relevance, <strong>Lgi1</strong> mutant mice show increased seizure<br />

susceptibility, with prominent <strong>dystonic</strong>, myoclonic,<br />

and generalized <strong>seizures</strong>, 25–27 and <strong>Lgi1</strong> mutations have<br />

been discovered in humans with autosomal dominant lateral<br />

temporal lobe epilepsy. 28–30 However, by contrast to<br />

the patients we describe, patients with <strong>Lgi1</strong> mutations often<br />

have an excellent response to AEDs and infrequent<br />

<strong>seizures</strong>, although 1 family has been described with a high<br />

frequency of drug-resistant <strong>seizures</strong>. 31<br />

Recognition of the very brief adult-onset, frequent<br />

faciobrachial <strong>dystonic</strong> <strong>seizures</strong> should prompt testing for<br />

VGKC-complex or <strong>Lgi1</strong> Abs. Our data suggest that this<br />

syndrome is unlikely to be associated with an underlying<br />

tumor, although this should still be excluded, and that<br />

caution should be used with trials of multiple AEDs,<br />

which are frequently ineffective and associated with an<br />

unusually high risk of adverse reactions. As, when present,<br />

the characteristic FBDS often predate the onset of<br />

amnesia/confusion, their recognition may provide a therapeutic<br />

window of opportunity during which time<br />

immunotherapies may prevent the LE and possibly the<br />

potential sequelae of cerebral atrophy and cognitive<br />

impairment. 1,3,11,32<br />

Acknowledgments<br />

S.R.I. was supported by the National Institute for Health<br />

Research (NIHR), Department of Health, UK. A. W. M.<br />

receives support from the Cambridge NIHR Biomedical<br />

Research Centre. J.M.S. is a UK Higher Education<br />

Funding Council for England Clinical Senior Lecturer.<br />

Some of this work was undertaken at University College<br />

London Hospitals/University College London, which<br />

received a proportion of funding from the Department<br />

of Health’s NIHR Biomedical Research Centres funding<br />

scheme. B.L. receives funding from Epilepsy Research<br />

UK. P.P. is supported by a Medical Research Council<br />

Clinician Scientist Fellowship to Dr C. Buckley. P.W.<br />

and A.V. receive support from the Oxford NIHR Biomedical<br />

Research Centre. The Dementia Research Centre<br />

is an Alzheimer’s Research Trust Coordinating Centre.<br />

We thank Medical Illustration (John Radcliffe Hospital)<br />

for help with the video editing, and particularly the<br />

patients, their relatives/carers, and the following neuro-<br />

logists for the clinical details: Drs M. Bogdanovic, D.<br />

Hilton-Jones, K. Nithi, J. Palace, T. Andrews, O. C.<br />

Cockerell, C. Everett, M. Husain, P. Jarman, M. Lunn,<br />

P. Rudge, P. Maddison, J. Bowen, M. Lawden, J. Stone,<br />

N. Lawn, K. Fuller, and W. Huynh.<br />

Authorship<br />

S.R.I. and A.W.M. are first authors. E.R.S., S.M.J.S., and<br />

A.V. are senior authors.<br />

Potential Conflicts of Interest<br />

A.V. and the Department of Clinical Neurology in Oxford<br />

receive royalties and payments for Ab assays. A.V. is the<br />

inventor on patent application WO/2010/046716 entitled<br />

‘‘Neurological Autoimmune Disorders.’’ The patent has<br />

been licensed to Euroimmun AG for the development of<br />

assays for <strong>Lgi1</strong> and other VGKC-complex Abs. A.V. has<br />

done paid consultancy for Athena Diagnostics, and is<br />

employed by Oxford University and University College<br />

London. A.V.B.L. has a grant pending from Wellcome<br />

Trust and received payment for a lecture from Euroimmune.<br />

A.V., B.L., P.W., and S.R.I. may receive royalties<br />

for testing of VGKC complex Abs.<br />

References<br />

1. Vincent A, Buckley C, Schott JM, et al. Potassium channel <strong>antibody</strong>associated<br />

encephalopathy: a potentially immunotherapy-responsive<br />

form of <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis. Brain 2004;127:701–712.<br />

2. Thieben MJ, Lennon VA, Boeve BF, et al. Potentially reversible<br />

autoimmune <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis with neuronal potassium channel<br />

<strong>antibody</strong>. Neurology 2004;62:1177–1182.<br />

3. Irani SR, Alexander S, Waters P, et al. Antibodies to Kv1 potassium<br />

channel-complex proteins leucine-rich, glioma inactivated 1<br />

protein and contactin-associated protein-2 in <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis,<br />

Morvan’s syndrome and acquired neuromyotonia. Brain 2010;133:<br />

2734–2748.<br />

4. Lai M, Huijbers MG, Lancaster E, et al. Investigation of LGI1 as<br />

the antigen in <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis previously attributed to potassium<br />

channels: a case series. Lancet Neurol 2010;9:776–785.<br />

5. McKnight K, Jiang Y, Hart Y, et al. Serum antibodies in epilepsy<br />

and seizure-associated disorders. Neurology 2005;65:1730–1736.<br />

6. Majoie HJ, de Baets M, Renier W, et al. Antibodies to voltagegated<br />

potassium and calcium channels in epilepsy. Epilepsy Res<br />

2006;71:135–141.<br />

7. Irani SR, Buckley C, Vincent A, et al. Immunotherapy-responsive<br />

seizure-like episodes with potassium channel antibodies. Neurology<br />

2008;71:1647–1648.<br />

8. Barajas RF, Collins DE, Cha S, Geschwind MD. Adult-onset drugrefractory<br />

seizure disorder associated with anti-voltage-gated<br />

9.<br />

potassium-channel <strong>antibody</strong>. Epilepsia 2009;51:473–477.<br />

Reid JM, Foley P, Willison HJ. Voltage-gated potassium channelassociated<br />

<strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis in the West of Scotland: case<br />

reports and literature review. Scot Med J 2009;54:27–31.<br />

10. Toosy AT, Burbridge SE, Pitkanen M, et al. Functional imaging<br />

correlates of fronto-temporal dysfunction in Morvan’s syndrome.<br />

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2008;79:734–735.<br />

8 Volume 000, No. 000


11. Graus F, Saiz A, Lai M, et al. Neuronal surface antigen antibodies<br />

in <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis: clinical-immunologic associations. Neurology<br />

2008;71:930–936.<br />

12. Wieser S, Kelemen A, Barsi P, et al. Pilomotor <strong>seizures</strong> and status<br />

in non-paraneoplastic <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis. Epileptic Disord 2005;7:<br />

205–211.<br />

13. Malter MP, Helmstaedter C, Urbach H, et al. Antibodies to glutamic<br />

acid decarboxylase define a form of <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis. Ann<br />

Neurol 2010;67:470–478.<br />

14. Manford M, Fish DR, Shorvon SD. An analysis of clinical seizure<br />

patterns and their localizing value in frontal and temporal lobe<br />

epilepsies. Brain 1996;119:17–40.<br />

15. Kotagal P, Luders H, Morris HH, et al. Dystonic posturing in complex<br />

partial <strong>seizures</strong> of temporal lobe onset: a new lateralizing<br />

sign. Neurology 1989;39:196–201.<br />

16. Bleasel A, Kotagal P, Kankirawatana P, Rybicki L. Lateralizing value<br />

and semiology of ictal limb posturing and version in temporal<br />

lobe and extratemporal epilepsy. Epilepsia 1997;38:168–174.<br />

17. Newton MR, Berkovic SF, Austin MC, et al. Dystonia, clinical<br />

lateralization, and regional blood flow changes in temporal lobe<br />

<strong>seizures</strong>. Neurology 1992;42:371–377.<br />

18. Dupont S, Semah F, Baulac M, Samson Y. The underlying pathophysiology<br />

of ictal dystonia in temporal lobe epilepsy: an FDG-<br />

PET study. Neurology 1998;51:1289–1292.<br />

19. Fauser S, Talazko J, Wagner K, et al. FDG-PET and MRI in<br />

potassium channel <strong>antibody</strong>-associated non-paraneoplastic <strong>limbic</strong><br />

encephalitis: correlation with clinical course and neuropsychology.<br />

Acta Neurol Scand 2005;111:338–343.<br />

20. Tan KM, Lennon VA, Klein CJ, et al. Clinical spectrum of voltagegated<br />

potassium channel autoimmunity. Neurology 2008;70:<br />

1883–1890.<br />

21. Park DC, Murman DL, Perry KD, Bruch LA. An autopsy case of <strong>limbic</strong><br />

encephalitis with voltage-gated potassium channel antibodies.<br />

Eur J Neurol 2007;14:e5–e6.<br />

Irani et al: <strong>Lgi1</strong> Ab Limbic Encephalitis<br />

22. Geschwind MD, Tan KM, Lennon VA, et al. Voltage-gated potassium<br />

channel autoimmunity mimicking Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease.<br />

Arch Neurol 2008;65:1341–1346.<br />

23. Zhou YD, Lee S, Jin Z, et al. Arrested maturation of excitatory synapses<br />

in autosomal dominant lateral temporal lobe epilepsy. Nat<br />

Med 2009;15:1208–1214.<br />

24. Lalic T, Pettingill P, Vincent A, Capogna M. Human <strong>limbic</strong> encephalitis<br />

serum enhances hippocampal mossy fiber-CA3 pyramidal<br />

cell synaptic transmission. Epilepsia (in press).<br />

25. Chabrol E, Navarro V, Provenzano G, et al. Electroclinical characterization<br />

of epileptic <strong>seizures</strong> in leucine-rich, glioma-inactivated<br />

1-deficient mice. Brain 2010;133:2749–2762.<br />

26. Fukata Y, Lovero KL, Iwanaga T, et al. Disruption of LGI1-linked<br />

synaptic complex causes abnormal synaptic transmission and epilepsy.<br />

Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2010;107:3799–3804.<br />

27. Yu YE, Wen L, Silva J, et al. <strong>Lgi1</strong> null mutant mice exhibit myoclonic<br />

<strong>seizures</strong> and CA1 neuronal hyperexcitability. Hum Mol<br />

Genet 2010;19:1702–1711.<br />

28. Morante-Redolat JM, Gorostidi-Pagola A, Piquer-Sirerol S, et al. Mutations<br />

in the LGI1/Epitempin gene on 10q24 cause autosomal dominant<br />

lateral temporal epilepsy. Hum Mol Genet 2002;11:1119–1128.<br />

29. Gu W, Brodtkorb E, Steinlein OK. LGI1 is mutated in familial temporal<br />

lobe epilepsy characterized by aphasic <strong>seizures</strong>. Ann Neurol<br />

2002;52:364–367.<br />

30. Kalachikov S, Evgrafov O, Ross B, et al. Mutations in LGI1 cause<br />

autosomal-dominant partial epilepsy with auditory features. Nat<br />

Genet 2002;30:335–341.<br />

31. Di Bonaventura C, Carni M, Diani E, et al. Drug resistant ADLTE<br />

and recurrent partial status epilepticus with dysphasic features in a<br />

family with a novel LGI1 mutation: electroclinical, genetic, and<br />

EEG/fMRI findings. Epilepsia 2009;50:2481–2486.<br />

32. Bien CG, Urbach H, Schramm J, et al. Limbic encephalitis as a<br />

precipitating event in adult-onset temporal lobe epilepsy. Neurology<br />

2007;69:1236–1244.<br />

Month, 2010 9

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!