Prospectus - Notowania

Prospectus - Notowania Prospectus - Notowania

notowania.pb.pl
from notowania.pb.pl More from this publisher
19.01.2013 Views

equity investments and business lines from HVB (after its entry into UniCredit Group) to UniCredit or other UniCredit Group companies (and vice versa). In addition, they argue that the HVB reorganisation cost should be borne by UniCredit. The defendants in the lawsuit are UniCredit, its Managing Director, Alessandro Profumo, and the former Managing Director of HVB, Wolfgang Sprissler. The plaintiffs are seeking: (i) damages in the amount of €17.35 billion, plus interest; (ii) that the Munich Court order UniCredit to pay HVB's minority shareholders appropriate compensation in the form of a guaranteed regular dividend from November 19, 2005 onwards. The defendants lodged their defence pleas with the Regional Court of Munich on February 25, 2008. Furthermore, another minority shareholder of HVB, Vzfk – already owner of a non-significant shareholding in the company capital - started legal proceedings that were substantially similar towards UniCredit, its CEO, Alessandro Profumo and the then CEO of HVB, Wolfang Sprissler (for an amount equal to €173.5 million plus interest) and the Regional Court of Munich combined the mentioned proceedings to that promoted by the hedge fund on July 29, 2009 The defendants, while aware of the risks that any such suit inevitably entails, are of the opinion that the claims are groundless, given that all of the transactions referred to by the plaintiffs were carried out on payment of consideration which was held to be fair on the basis of thirdparty advisors' opinions. As such, no provision has been made. Special Representative On June 27, 2007, the HVB annual Shareholders’ Meeting passed a resolution for a claim of damages against UniCredit, its legal representatives, and members of HVB's management board and supervisory board, citing damages to HVB due to the sale of the its equity investment in BA and the Business Combination Agreement (BCA) entered into with UniCredit during the integration process. The attorney Thomas Heidel was appointed as Special Representative by a shareholders’ resolution voted on by the minority shareholders with the task of verifying if there are sufficient grounds to move forward with this claim. To this end, the Special Representative was granted the authority to examine documents and obtain further information from the company. Based on his investigations within HVB, in December 2007, the Special Representative asked UniCredit to restore the purchased BA shares to HVB. In January 2008, UniCredit replied to the Special Representative, stating that, in its view, such a request was unfounded. On February 20, 2008 Attorney Heidel, acting as Special Representative, filed a petition against UniCredit, its Managing Director, Alessandro Profumo, the former Managing Director of HVB, Wolfgang Sprissler and HVB's Chief Financial Officer, Rolf Friedhofen, requiring the defendants to return the BA shares to HVB along with compensation to HVB for any additional - 342 -

losses in the matter or, if this petition is not granted by the Munich Court, to pay €13.9 billion in damages. On July 10, 2008, Attorney Heidel filed and gave notice of an amendment to the petition. In it he asks that UniCredit, its Managing Director, and HVB’s former Managing Director and Chief Financial Officer be ordered to return the additional amount of €2.98 billion (plus interest) in addition to damages that may result from the capital increase resolved by HVB in April 2007 following the transfer of the banking business of the former UBM to HVB. Specifically, the Special Representative asserts that the transfer was overvalued and that auditing rules were violated. Since it is doubtful that the amendment of the Special Representative’s petition is in line with the resolution of the HVB Shareholders’ Meeting in June 2007, UniCredit considers the plaintiff’s claims to be unfounded, partly in consideration of the fact that both the sale of BA and the transfer of the operations of the former UBM during the HVB capital increase occurred on the basis of independent assessments (fairness opinions and valuation reports) of wellknown External Auditors and investment banks, thus, it has not made any provisions. It should be noted that on November 10, 2008, an extraordinary meeting of HVB shareholders’ was held and resolved to revoke the resolution of June 27, 2007, consequently, Attorney Heidel was removed as HVB’s Special Representative. This means that the Special Representative no longer has the authority to prosecute the actions brought against UniCredit, its officers, or HVB's officers, unless the resolution is declared null or ineffective. In particular, the removal prevents the Special Representative from continuing his petition for damages, which, moreover, will not disappear automatically, but rather only if a decision in this matter is made by HVB’s supervisory board (against Wolfgang Sprissler and Rolf Friedhofen) and the management board (against UniCredit and its Managing Director). HVB’s Statutory Bodies, with the assistance of external consultants, initiated a review of this complex matter to make the related decisions under their authority. The removal of the Special Representative was contested by Attorney Heidel and by a minority shareholder. On August 27, 2009 the Regional Court of Munich declared the Special Representative’s removal null. However the decision is not yet final and binding, in that an appeal is pending with the High Regional Court of Munich. On June 2, 2009 the Regional Court of Munich decided to suspend arguments on the Special Representative’s petition until a final decision is made on the validity of the appointment and subsequent removal of the Special Representative. The Special Representative submitted a request to review the suspension measure of the petition. The same first instance judge will review and if, as expected, the judge does not reverse his decision, the High Regional Court will decide on the correctness of the suspension measure. Cirio In April 2004, the extraordinary administration of Cirio Finanziaria S.p.A. served notice to Sergio Cragnotti and various banks including Capitalia (absorbed by UniCredit) and Banca di Roma S.p.A., of a petition to obtain judgment declaring the invalidity of an allegedly illegal agreement with Cirio S.p.A. regarding the sale of the dairy company Eurolat to Dalmata S.r.l. - 343 -

losses in the matter or, if this petition is not granted by the Munich Court, to pay €13.9 billion<br />

in damages.<br />

On July 10, 2008, Attorney Heidel filed and gave notice of an amendment to the petition. In it<br />

he asks that UniCredit, its Managing Director, and HVB’s former Managing Director and Chief<br />

Financial Officer be ordered to return the additional amount of €2.98 billion (plus interest) in<br />

addition to damages that may result from the capital increase resolved by HVB in April 2007<br />

following the transfer of the banking business of the former UBM to HVB. Specifically, the<br />

Special Representative asserts that the transfer was overvalued and that auditing rules were<br />

violated.<br />

Since it is doubtful that the amendment of the Special Representative’s petition is in line with<br />

the resolution of the HVB Shareholders’ Meeting in June 2007, UniCredit considers the<br />

plaintiff’s claims to be unfounded, partly in consideration of the fact that both the sale of BA<br />

and the transfer of the operations of the former UBM during the HVB capital increase occurred<br />

on the basis of independent assessments (fairness opinions and valuation reports) of wellknown<br />

External Auditors and investment banks, thus, it has not made any provisions.<br />

It should be noted that on November 10, 2008, an extraordinary meeting of HVB shareholders’<br />

was held and resolved to revoke the resolution of June 27, 2007, consequently, Attorney Heidel<br />

was removed as HVB’s Special Representative. This means that the Special Representative no<br />

longer has the authority to prosecute the actions brought against UniCredit, its officers, or<br />

HVB's officers, unless the resolution is declared null or ineffective. In particular, the removal<br />

prevents the Special Representative from continuing his petition for damages, which, moreover,<br />

will not disappear automatically, but rather only if a decision in this matter is made by HVB’s<br />

supervisory board (against Wolfgang Sprissler and Rolf Friedhofen) and the management board<br />

(against UniCredit and its Managing Director). HVB’s Statutory Bodies, with the assistance of<br />

external consultants, initiated a review of this complex matter to make the related decisions<br />

under their authority.<br />

The removal of the Special Representative was contested by Attorney Heidel and by a minority<br />

shareholder. On August 27, 2009 the Regional Court of Munich declared the Special<br />

Representative’s removal null. However the decision is not yet final and binding, in that an<br />

appeal is pending with the High Regional Court of Munich.<br />

On June 2, 2009 the Regional Court of Munich decided to suspend arguments on the Special<br />

Representative’s petition until a final decision is made on the validity of the appointment and<br />

subsequent removal of the Special Representative.<br />

The Special Representative submitted a request to review the suspension measure of the<br />

petition. The same first instance judge will review and if, as expected, the judge does not<br />

reverse his decision, the High Regional Court will decide on the correctness of the suspension<br />

measure.<br />

Cirio<br />

In April 2004, the extraordinary administration of Cirio Finanziaria S.p.A. served notice to<br />

Sergio Cragnotti and various banks including Capitalia (absorbed by UniCredit) and Banca di<br />

Roma S.p.A., of a petition to obtain judgment declaring the invalidity of an allegedly illegal<br />

agreement with Cirio S.p.A. regarding the sale of the dairy company Eurolat to Dalmata S.r.l.<br />

- 343 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!