17.01.2013 Views

Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...

Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...

Geometric Data Analysis in a Social Science Research Program ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

systematicallyaddressestherelationalaspectsofsocialreality(Bourdieu1966[4]).He morecompletelydevelopedhis\theoryofelds"<strong>in</strong>thebeg<strong>in</strong>n<strong>in</strong>gofthe1970s(Bourdieu 10Asearlyas<strong>in</strong>themiddleofthe1960s,Bourdieuformulatedtheconceptof\eld",which Booktitlegoeshere<br />

1971[5]).Aeldisasmalllocus<strong>in</strong>sidetheglobalsocialspace,whichisdenedbyits degreeofrelativeautonomyfromothereldsandtheglobalsociety,itsstructure,related toaspeciccongurationofagents,anditsdynamics.Agents<strong>in</strong>aeld,evenwithout<br />

aboutelds.Biographicaldatawerecollected<strong>in</strong>variousbiographicalsources(directories, globalprocessofsocialdom<strong>in</strong>ationbetweenclasses. specicresourcesandbyacorrespond<strong>in</strong>gprocessofdom<strong>in</strong>ation,whichisdist<strong>in</strong>ctfromthe anydirect<strong>in</strong>teraction,areput<strong>in</strong>toobjectiverelations,denedbythedistributionoftheir<br />

Who'swho,etc.),<strong>in</strong>acollectiveprocessdirectly<strong>in</strong>spiredbygrow<strong>in</strong>gscienticpractices<strong>in</strong> socialhistory(\prosopography",com<strong>in</strong>gfromancientandmedievalhistory). Thenoveltyoftheseanalysesrstlies<strong>in</strong>thetypeofdatawhichwereused<strong>in</strong>research<br />

helpofMCA.Inthisarticle,theauthorsjustifythecentraluseofMCAasawaytodiscover BourdieuanddeSa<strong>in</strong>t-Mart<strong>in</strong>studiedapopulationofeconomicelites(n=216)withthe andrevealahiddenrelationalrealitywhichisnotconscious,butnevertheless\morereal" thanthepartialandpracticalperceptionsoftheagent(GDAas\rupture<strong>in</strong>strument"<strong>in</strong> ThesecondoccurrenceofauseofGDAbyBourdieuisawell{knownarticlewhere<br />

properties(fromdemographiccharacteristicstoeducationaltrajectory)andsomeofthem den<strong>in</strong>gthevariousspeciesofcapitalatstake.Themodalitiesweregrouped<strong>in</strong>todierent head<strong>in</strong>gs(groupsofquestions),withanimportantnumberofmodalitiesreferr<strong>in</strong>gtosocial forhishelp<strong>in</strong>afootnote.Activemodalitieswereselectedfromasetofbiographicaldata, Bachelard'stradition).TheyusetheprogramMULTMfromL.Lebart,whoisthanked<br />

tomorespecicassets<strong>in</strong>theeconomiceld(positions<strong>in</strong>boards,dist<strong>in</strong>ctions,etc.).In particular,wereconsidered:<br />

Bott<strong>in</strong>Monda<strong>in</strong>(adirectoryofsocialelites); Demographicproperties:placeanddateofbirth,numberofchildren,placeofresidence; Educationaltrajectory(i.e.\grandlyceeparisien"); <strong>Social</strong>andfamilialorig<strong>in</strong>:professionofthefather,seniority<strong>in</strong>class,presence<strong>in</strong>the<br />

Professionalcareer:(i.e.\grandcorps"); Specicpositions<strong>in</strong>theeld:economicpowerpositions,membershiptocouncils,etc.; Indicatorsofsymboliccapital:ocialdist<strong>in</strong>ctions,decorations,etc.;<br />

ofthesocialstructureoftheeld(Figure1.2p.9).The<strong>in</strong>terpretedspace(Figure1.3p.11) nomicelitemembers,help<strong>in</strong>gthereaderwho\knew"someagentstohaveadirect<strong>in</strong>tuitionThecloudof<strong>in</strong>dividuals<strong>in</strong>therstpr<strong>in</strong>cipalplanewaspublished,withthenamesofeco- Indicatorsofmembershiptomobilizedgroups(likeassociations).<br />

agerscom<strong>in</strong>gfromEcolenationaled'adm<strong>in</strong>istrationorPolytechnique.ThesecondAxis, aga<strong>in</strong>relatedtotime,opposes\newcomers"and\established".Thisanalysisprovidesa viewofthestructureoftheeldofeconomicelitesasbe<strong>in</strong>gdenedbytherelationtothe \private"positionsandtrajectories,theeldbe<strong>in</strong>gthendom<strong>in</strong>atedbytechnocraticman- istwo-dimensional(athirdaxisisrapidlyevoked).TherstAxisisoppos<strong>in</strong>g\public"to<br />

State(bureaucraticcapital)andbyaprocessofdynamiccompetitionbetweenfractions, moreoftentra<strong>in</strong>ed<strong>in</strong>privatebus<strong>in</strong>essschools,orcerta<strong>in</strong>eng<strong>in</strong>eerschools.Anexplanatory perspectivewasalsopresent<strong>in</strong>thisanalysis,whichaimedatunderstand<strong>in</strong>gthespaceof<br />

rstdenedbytheirseniority<strong>in</strong>theeld.Thenew\generation"<strong>in</strong>theeldisforexample

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!