15.01.2013 Views

The Design Development Protocol for PFI Schemes - Epos

The Design Development Protocol for PFI Schemes - Epos

The Design Development Protocol for PFI Schemes - Epos

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong><br />

<strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> <strong>Schemes</strong><br />

Revision 1<br />

August 2004


DH INFORMATION READER BOX<br />

Policy Estates<br />

HR / Work<strong>for</strong>ce Per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

Management IM & T Estates<br />

Planning Finance<br />

Clinical Partnership Working<br />

Document Purpose Action<br />

ROCR Ref: 0 Gateway Ref: 0<br />

Title<br />

Public Private Partnerships in the NHS: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong><br />

<strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> <strong>Schemes</strong> - Revision 1 - August 2004<br />

Author<br />

Publication Date<br />

Target Audience<br />

Circulation List<br />

Description<br />

Cross Ref<br />

Superseded Docs<br />

Action Required<br />

Timing<br />

Contact Details<br />

For Recipient's Use<br />

DH and NHS Estates<br />

31st August 2004<br />

Trusts undertaking <strong>PFI</strong> schemes and bidding Consortia<br />

#VALUE!<br />

First published in 2001, this version has been updated in the light of<br />

revised <strong>PFI</strong> procurement process guidance. It continues to represent<br />

an agreed approach to the design development process and focuses<br />

on the in<strong>for</strong>mation that is required to be generated, shared and<br />

finalised between the Trust and bidders at each stage of the <strong>PFI</strong><br />

process up until Financial Close.<br />

N/A<br />

0<br />

<strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> <strong>Schemes</strong> - January 2001<br />

0<br />

<strong>Protocol</strong> to be observed by <strong>PFI</strong> schemes at pre ITN stage<br />

0<br />

Implementation from date of publication<br />

Stephen Purden RIBA<br />

NHS Estates<br />

1, Trevelyan Square<br />

Boar Lane, Leeds<br />

LS1 6AE<br />

0113 2547238<br />

steve.purden@dh.gsi.gov.uk<br />

0


Public Private Partnerships<br />

in the NHS –<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong><br />

<strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

© Crown copyright 2004<br />

2


Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

Contents Page<br />

1 Introduction 4<br />

Summary of the <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> Process<br />

2 Invitation to Negotiate (ITN) – in<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided by the trust 6<br />

Output specification – whole development statement<br />

Output specification – clinical/departmental policies<br />

Output specification – architectural – design exemplar solution<br />

Output specification – engineering, structural and civil<br />

Output specification – non-clinical services<br />

Output specification – equipment schedules and scope<br />

Supporting in<strong>for</strong>mation to be supplied by the trust<br />

3 In<strong>for</strong>mation to be supplied by Bidders at PITN 15<br />

4 In<strong>for</strong>mation to be supplied by Bidders at FITN 16<br />

Health planning and architecture<br />

Engineering services<br />

Other in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

5 <strong>Design</strong> sign-off – pre-Financial Close 21<br />

Trust review of design data<br />

Review <strong>for</strong> clinical functionality<br />

Appendices 23<br />

APPENDIX A – Standards and guidelines relevant to design and construction<br />

APPENDIX B – NHS equipment group classifications<br />

APPENDIX C – PITN pricing pro-<strong>for</strong>ma<br />

APPENDIX D – Capital cost model FITN<br />

APPENDIX E – Capital and developmental costs cash flow FITN<br />

APPENDIX F – Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

3


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

1. Introduction<br />

1.1 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> (“the <strong>Protocol</strong>”),<br />

was first published in January 2001. This updated version<br />

has been developed through a series of discussions between<br />

the Department of Health, NHS Estates, NHS<br />

trusts, the Health and Safety Executive, the Royal<br />

Institute of British Architects and the Major Contractors<br />

Group (“MCG”). It represents an agreed approach to the<br />

design development process as it moves through the<br />

stages of bidding, selection of preferred bidder and<br />

ultimate acceptance of the selected bidder’s design.<br />

1.2 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> supports the revised procurement<br />

process detailed in the Department of Health’s Private<br />

Finance Initiative (“<strong>PFI</strong>”) guidance documents: “Improving<br />

the <strong>PFI</strong> Process”; “New Standard Preliminary Invitation to<br />

Negotiate”; “New Standard Pre-Qualification Questionnaire”;<br />

“New Standard Output Specifications”; “<strong>The</strong> Standard<br />

Form of Project Agreement”; “<strong>The</strong> New Standard<br />

Payment Mechanism”. <strong>The</strong>se are published on the<br />

Department’s website at http://www.dh.gov.uk/<br />

ProcurementAndProposals/PublicPrivatePartnership/<br />

PrivateFinanceinitiative.<br />

1.3 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> should be observed by all NHS organisations<br />

undertaking a <strong>PFI</strong> scheme; this applies equally to<br />

NHS Foundation Trusts who wish to obtain a “Deed of<br />

Safeguard” from the Secretary of State <strong>for</strong> Health. (An<br />

NHS trust is used as the example throughout this<br />

document, referred to simply as “the trust”.) <strong>The</strong><br />

exceptions are those schemes whose Invitation to<br />

Negotiate (“ITN”) was issued prior to publication of this<br />

<strong>Protocol</strong>. <strong>The</strong>se schemes may adopt the <strong>Protocol</strong> at their<br />

discretion or otherwise continue with the process set out<br />

in the ITN.<br />

1.4 Private Sector Bidders should also be required to<br />

comply with the <strong>Protocol</strong> as part of their bid.<br />

1.5 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> relates to the design development<br />

process only.<br />

1.6 <strong>The</strong> objectives of the design development process<br />

are:<br />

1.6.1 to ensure that the process results in a clearly<br />

understood set of proposals that address the<br />

trust’s need, <strong>for</strong>m a robust basis <strong>for</strong> selection of<br />

Preferred Bidder and define the level of detail<br />

required by all parties in order to enter into contractual<br />

commitments;<br />

4<br />

1.6.2 to ensure that the process does not impose unnecessary<br />

burdens, in terms of time and cost, on<br />

either the trust or the bidders;<br />

1.6.3 to avoid un<strong>for</strong>eseen changes after the selection of<br />

a Preferred Bidder in the project proposals and/or<br />

the capital cost due to:<br />

• any misunderstandings regarding the nature,<br />

quality or methodology of the scheme proposed;<br />

• the proposals not being coherent and deliverable;<br />

or<br />

• the trust changing or refining its requirements;<br />

and<br />

“<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> does not,<br />

is not intended to and (by<br />

definition) cannot allocate<br />

or transfer risks which as a<br />

matter of law cannot be<br />

transferred<br />

”<br />

• to establish clearly the trust’s rights of sign off<br />

on design and the consequent allocation of<br />

design risk.<br />

1.7 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> does not, is not intended to and (by<br />

definition) cannot allocate or transfer risks which as a<br />

matter of law cannot be transferred. For example, trusts<br />

retain certain health and safety obligations in relation to<br />

the Health and Safety at Work etc Act.<br />

1.8 It is essential that trusts recognise and comply with<br />

Office of Government Commerce (OGC) Construction<br />

Procurement Guidance No 10 “Achieving Excellence<br />

through Health and Safety” published at http://www.ogc.<br />

gov.uk. <strong>The</strong> Government’s Procurement Policy is that all<br />

public procurement is to be based on Value <strong>for</strong> Money.<br />

Value <strong>for</strong> Money is the optimum combination of whole-life<br />

cost and quality to meet the users’ requirements. Trusts’<br />

actions have a direct impact in contributing to the<br />

achievement of this policy and they must demand that<br />

the health, safety and welfare of those who work in the<br />

construction industry are given the highest priority from<br />

the very beginning of the project.


1.9 Trusts must also recognise their duties as clients as<br />

defined in the Construction (<strong>Design</strong> and Management)<br />

Regulations 1994 (CDM). <strong>The</strong>se duties commence at the<br />

outset of the project be<strong>for</strong>e ITN. Trusts should seek advice<br />

on the detailed application of the regulations.<br />

Summary of the design development process<br />

1.10 <strong>The</strong> focus of the <strong>Protocol</strong> is the in<strong>for</strong>mation that is<br />

required to be generated, shared and finalised between<br />

the trust and bidders at each stage in the process up until<br />

Financial Close. Typically, the process will consist of the<br />

following stages:<br />

1.10.1 the submission of bidders’ responses to the Preliminary<br />

Invitation to Negotiate (“PITN”) followed<br />

by an evaluation of the responses and<br />

subsequent selection of shortlisted bidders;<br />

1.10.2 the submission of responses by shortlisted bidders<br />

to the Final Invitation to Negotiate (“FITN”)<br />

and subsequent refinement of those responses<br />

up to selection of a Preferred Bidder; and<br />

1.10.3 the development of the design by the Preferred<br />

Bidder and acceptance, or “sign off”, by the trust<br />

prior to Financial Close.<br />

1.11 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> is set out in accordance with these<br />

three main stages (although <strong>for</strong> post-contract purposes<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

the trust and preferred bidder must still agree Revisable<br />

<strong>Design</strong> Data in accordance with the Standard Form<br />

Contract).<br />

1.12 For trusts wishing to follow the 3:1 procurement<br />

process, the PITN and FITN combine as a single ITN.<br />

1.13 In order to enable the bidders to prepare their<br />

proposals within the allocated time periods <strong>for</strong> both PITN<br />

and FITN, trusts should ensure that the design brief<br />

issued at the start of each stage is robust and has clinical<br />

sign-off. Changes to the brief should not be made in the<br />

middle of any stage unless there are exceptional circumstances.<br />

It is important <strong>for</strong> trusts to ensure that there is a<br />

clear methodology <strong>for</strong> costing potential changes once a<br />

Preferred Bidder is appointed.<br />

1.14 Prior to the selection of the Preferred Bidder the<br />

trust will require that the bidder provide written confirmation<br />

of the fixed price that it submitted in response to<br />

the FITN, and that only those issues as specified in the<br />

preferred bidder letter are open to further negotiations.<br />

1.15 This document was last updated in July 2004 and<br />

will continue to be reviewed periodically and updated as<br />

necessary.<br />

5


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

2. Invitation to negotiate<br />

2.1 In advance of committing a scheme to the market,<br />

Trusts should have developed a robust set of proposals<br />

that makes up the Public Sector Comparator (“PSC”).<br />

<strong>The</strong>se proposals will have <strong>for</strong>med the basis of the<br />

approved Outline Business Case (“OBC”). <strong>The</strong> level of<br />

technical and design content of the PSC should be<br />

agreed with NHS Estates in advance of the OBC<br />

development. Guidance on the design and estates<br />

aspects of the PSC is being developed by an NHS<br />

Estates working group. In <strong>for</strong>mulating the PSC, trusts<br />

should appoint technical advisors, including healthcare<br />

planners, who would be responsible <strong>for</strong> developing a<br />

robust brief that meets clinical and service needs. This<br />

should entail direct engagement with trust clinical staff<br />

who should take ownership of the scheme from initiation<br />

throughout the process. Trusts will be required to<br />

demonstrate clinical and user involvement in the design<br />

development process<br />

2.2 When the process adopts a staged ITN, the PITN<br />

will be a draft or abbreviated <strong>for</strong>m of the FITN document.<br />

(Section 2 of “Public–Private Partnerships in the NHS:<br />

<strong>The</strong> Private Finance Initiative”; paragraph 5.56).<br />

2.3 Technical advisers should be able to demonstrate<br />

real experience in scheme delivery. A traditional design<br />

team, comprising architects, engineers and quantity<br />

surveyors, may produce more benefits than a firm of<br />

“generic” technical advisors. <strong>The</strong> technical advisors<br />

should be responsible <strong>for</strong> taking the clinical brief and<br />

developing a design exemplar which is af<strong>for</strong>dable,<br />

deliverable, and reflects the design quality now expected<br />

of Public Buildings (ref. “Better Public Buildings”, October<br />

6<br />

Preferred bidder artist’s impression, Southern Derbyshire<br />

“<br />

a traditional design<br />

team, comprising<br />

architects, engineers and<br />

quantity surveyors, may<br />

produce more benefits than<br />

a firm of ‘generic’ technical<br />

advisors<br />

”<br />

2000). <strong>The</strong> advisors should provide architectural, structural<br />

and building engineering output specifications and<br />

an indication of the trust’s aspirations in regard to, <strong>for</strong><br />

example, architectural treatment, landscaping, internal<br />

spatial quality, response to urban context; and should<br />

include consideration of the Achieving Excellence in<br />

<strong>Design</strong> Evaluation Toolkit agenda.<br />

2.4 In accordance with the CDM Regulations 1994,<br />

trusts should appoint a Planning Supervisor at or be<strong>for</strong>e<br />

the start of initial design work. <strong>The</strong> Planning Supervisor’s<br />

main responsibility is to ensure that all those who are<br />

carrying out preliminary design work on the project collaborate<br />

and pay attention to the need to reduce risk<br />

wherever possible. <strong>The</strong> Planning Supervisor should have<br />

a thorough knowledge of the design process and sufficient<br />

experience in the size and complexity of the specific<br />

project. <strong>The</strong> Planning Supervisor should notify HSE of the<br />

project once appointed.


In<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided by trusts<br />

2.5 <strong>The</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation provided by the trust in the ITN<br />

must be sufficiently well progressed to enable the private<br />

sector to rapidly develop their proposals. <strong>The</strong>re<strong>for</strong>e the<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation provided should be sufficiently robust to allow<br />

bidders to provide a response that will enable the trust to<br />

evaluate and select the shortlisted bidders. At the ITN<br />

(PITN) stage the trust should provide the in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

detailed below:<br />

2.5.1 the trust’s healthcare philosophy;<br />

2.5.2 output specifications in the following areas:<br />

• whole development statement;<br />

• clinical output specifications including Whole<br />

Hospital and Departmental Clinical Operational<br />

Policies;<br />

• functional content and schedules of accommodation;<br />

• architectural output specifications including a<br />

<strong>Design</strong> Exemplar Solution;<br />

• civil, structural and engineering services<br />

output specifications;<br />

• non-clinical output specifications (<strong>for</strong> example<br />

FM services etc);<br />

• details of existing supply contracts and their<br />

effect on the design;<br />

• equipment output specification including IM&T<br />

and proposed procurement path; and<br />

Preferred bidder artist’s impression, Southern Derbyshire<br />

• statement of intent with respect to ecologically<br />

sustainable design.<br />

2.6 <strong>The</strong> trust should provide details of the design<br />

evaluation criteria such as AEDET (Achieving Excellence<br />

<strong>Design</strong> Evaluation Toolkit) and NEAT (NHS Environmental<br />

Assessment Toolkit) – see Appendix A.<br />

Output specification – whole development<br />

statement<br />

2.7 <strong>The</strong> whole development statement will contain<br />

comprehensive requirements <strong>for</strong> the project. It should<br />

include, where relevant, the following:<br />

2.7.1 site constraints;<br />

2.7.2 design vision statement;<br />

2.7.3 essential departmental and clinical dependencies<br />

and relationships;<br />

2.7.4 desired departmental and clinical dependencies<br />

and relationships;<br />

2.7.5 town planning issues. <strong>The</strong>se might include,<br />

among other matters:<br />

• car parking provision;<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

• vehicular and pedestrian movement; and<br />

• environmental issues (the outcome of any<br />

Environmental Impact Analysis the trust has<br />

been required to carry out);<br />

2.7.6 key policy statements developed from the Controls<br />

Assurance standards and other sources.<br />

7


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

2. Invitation to negotiate<br />

Output specification – clinical departmental<br />

policies<br />

2.8 A clinical output specification should be prepared<br />

<strong>for</strong> each clinical area of the project. As far as possible<br />

these specifications should be completed in a consistent<br />

<strong>for</strong>mat. A guide template is presented below:<br />

Architectural output specification – design<br />

exemplar solution<br />

2.9 <strong>The</strong> design exemplar is intended to represent a<br />

quality benchmark against which the bidders’ proposals<br />

will be measured. <strong>The</strong> exemplar will demonstrate the<br />

aspirations of the trust in terms of graphical and technical<br />

TEMPLATE FOR CLINICAL SERVICE/DEPARTMENTAL SPECIFICATIONS<br />

HEADING INFORMATION COVERED<br />

Scope of Service • Description of Service;<br />

• Catchment Population;<br />

• Exclusions from Services covered<br />

8<br />

representations of the PSC. It is not intended to constrict<br />

the bidders’ proposals to a particular solution. <strong>The</strong><br />

intention is to provide an advanced level of briefing that<br />

will enable the bidders’ response to be more advanced in<br />

terms of understanding than would normally be the case.<br />

<strong>The</strong> trust may wish to issue more detailed scheme<br />

layouts and proposals or, alternatively, specific studies of<br />

key critical areas depending on the nature of the scheme<br />

and the trust’s particular requirements. Such briefing<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation acts as a guide and may include:<br />

2.9.1 options considered in terms of functional relationships<br />

expressed as a diagrammatic analysis;<br />

2.9.2 <strong>Development</strong> Control Plan at 1:1000 scale;<br />

Activity Indicators • Current Service Activity (eg FCEs/OPD attends/treatments per annum);<br />

• Models of Care;<br />

• Work patterns – noting seasonal/gender/timing patterns of service delivery;<br />

• Service Trends;<br />

• Projected Activity<br />

Functional Content • Size of Department (eg beds/consulting/exam rooms/number of theatres etc);<br />

• Details of IM&T service requirements<br />

Functional Relationships • Key departmental adjacencies noting whether they are essential, important, desirable<br />

or not desirable<br />

Operational Policies • Hours of Operation;<br />

• Staff Numbers;<br />

• Operational Processes/Workflow Patterns;<br />

• Occupancy Pressures;<br />

• Reference to other specifications<br />

Supporting Services • Interrelationship of department/ service with other clinical services (eg Pharmacy/<br />

Rehabilitation/Medical Physics/Labs etc);<br />

• Interrelationship of department/service with other non-clinical services (eg Catering/<br />

On-call/Linen/Supplies/Disposal/Portering/Cleaning etc);<br />

• Arrangements <strong>for</strong> staff (eg education, beverage breaks/ meals, staff change etc).<br />

Facility Requirements • List of the facility requirements needed to undertake the service;<br />

• Schedule of areas;<br />

• Note of the key equipment requirements needed<br />

Description of Accommodation • Description of the function and relationship between key rooms within the department;<br />

• Note of main and significant equipment<br />

Environmental and Service Requirements • Key building and engineering requirements eg levels of sterility, medical gases, natural<br />

light and ventilation requirements telephones/ call systems etc<br />

Specific <strong>Design</strong> Guidance • Reference to any key design guidance eg Ionising Radiation Protection Regulations<br />

1999 etc


2.9.3 block departmental relationship plan at 1:500<br />

scale;<br />

2.9.4 urban design principles, including:<br />

• approach to wider context beyond the site<br />

boundary;<br />

• transport issues;<br />

• hard and soft landscaping strategy;<br />

• approach to car parking and access;<br />

2.9.5 typical ward layout at 1:200 showing critical<br />

dimensions and/or studies of key critical areas;<br />

2.9.6 key entrance and public space at 1:200;<br />

2.9.7 perspective sketches showing key entrance and<br />

public spaces where prepared as part of the PSC;<br />

2.9.8 principal elevations of the building;<br />

2.9.9 draft room data sheets and a selection of generic<br />

room layouts to illustrate critical clinical dimensions.<br />

2.10 A schedule of general architectural and design<br />

quality requirements should be provided, dealing with<br />

more subjective aspects of design and construction.<br />

<strong>The</strong>se could include:<br />

2.10.1 flexibility of design and specific known changes<br />

in use that must be provided <strong>for</strong>;<br />

2.10.2 proportion and scale;<br />

2.10.3 requirements <strong>for</strong> the internal environment,<br />

including natural daylight;<br />

2.10.4 desired orientation;<br />

2.10.5 car parking and desired proximity to access<br />

points;<br />

2.10.6 an aesthetic statement;<br />

2.10.7 phasing issues;<br />

2.10.8 non-mandatory requirements with regard, <strong>for</strong><br />

example, to materials;<br />

2.10.9 provision of social spaces;<br />

2.10.10 urban and social integration;<br />

2.10.11 human dignity.<br />

2.11 Trusts should feel free to provide in pictorial <strong>for</strong>m<br />

the standards of finish and internal and external design<br />

features that they require. For example, if maternity LDRP<br />

rooms are to be of a hotel standard, with concealed services<br />

and soft furnishings, images of other schemes will<br />

assist bidders in understanding the trust’s requirements.<br />

<strong>The</strong> standards should, however, be consistent with the<br />

costs included in the trust’s PSC.<br />

2.12 Appendix A lists the documents which are typically<br />

sources of standards <strong>for</strong> design and construction<br />

and which should be considered when drawing up the<br />

architectural specification.<br />

2.13 <strong>The</strong> architectural per<strong>for</strong>mance standards are<br />

measures of the per<strong>for</strong>mance of the buildings and of the<br />

“hard” facilities management function, and will <strong>for</strong>m part<br />

of the ongoing per<strong>for</strong>mance and payment mechanism.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y should be fully disclosed in the architectural output<br />

specification. To a certain extent, the adoption of statutes,<br />

British Standards, Health Building Notes (“HBNs”)<br />

and Health Technical Memoranda (“HTMs”) etc will set<br />

per<strong>for</strong>mance standards <strong>for</strong> the building and, where these<br />

are to be incorporated as part of the payment mechanism,<br />

this should be made explicit. Additionally, there may<br />

be a need to set out further per<strong>for</strong>mance standards<br />

where these are not incorporated in design and construction<br />

standards.<br />

2.14 Typical per<strong>for</strong>mance standards relate to:<br />

2.14.1 energy use and/or insulation;<br />

2.14.2 acoustic requirements;<br />

2.14.3 humidity;<br />

2.14.4 ventilation and cooling;<br />

2.14.5 water and sewage; and<br />

2.14.6 security.<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

“<br />

the standards should<br />

. . . be consistent with the<br />

costs included in the trust’s<br />

PSC<br />

”<br />

2.15 <strong>The</strong> trust, in consultation with its technical advisors,<br />

should take into account the site-specific environmental<br />

conditions and constraints when setting per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

standards <strong>for</strong> the project. <strong>The</strong> standards should be<br />

achievable and realistic as an interdependent set of<br />

requirements.<br />

9


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

2. Invitation to negotiate<br />

Leicester General Hospital – Trust design exemplar<br />

Proposed site plan<br />

Current layout<br />

10


2.16 When setting standards, trusts should consider<br />

how they would be used in the ongoing contract. As<br />

mentioned above, some will <strong>for</strong>m part of the per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

and payment mechanism. Others may only be checked<br />

once as having been satisfied either during construction<br />

or on commissioning of the building. It is important when<br />

setting standards to think through the methods <strong>for</strong><br />

monitoring them and the implications of the standard not<br />

being maintained through the contract.<br />

2.17 <strong>The</strong> standards set should reflect the per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

required under the trust’s PSC solution so that a fair<br />

comparison can be made. Response times etc should<br />

provide value <strong>for</strong> money.<br />

2.18 A schedule of design-life expectancies <strong>for</strong> the<br />

major elements of construction should be provided.<br />

<strong>The</strong>se will <strong>for</strong>m part of the Trust’s Construction Requirements<br />

as set out in the Standard Form Project Agreement.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Trust should look to strike a fair balance between<br />

establishing what is required <strong>for</strong> the hand-back<br />

provisions in the Standard Form Project Agreement and<br />

limiting the ability of the bidder to provide innovative solutions<br />

in the delivery of the service. <strong>The</strong> major structural<br />

elements should include, <strong>for</strong> example:<br />

2.18.1 the structural envelope – <strong>for</strong> example frame,<br />

walls, floors;<br />

2.18.2 the waterproofing elements;<br />

2.18.3 the internal fabric and finishes;<br />

2.18.4 plant and equipment.<br />

Engineering output specification – engineering,<br />

structural and civil<br />

2.19 A similar approach should be adopted <strong>for</strong> this part<br />

of the output specification to that <strong>for</strong> the architectural<br />

specification. Additional standards and regulations will be<br />

applicable to engineering and structural specifications,<br />

including:<br />

2.19.1 Institution of Electrical Engineers (“IEE”) regulations;<br />

2.19.2 Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 and<br />

associated regulations;<br />

2.19.3 Construction (<strong>Design</strong> and Management) Regulations<br />

1994;<br />

2.19.4 Health and Safety Executive Guidance;<br />

2.19.5 Gas Safety Regulations;<br />

2.19.6 Water Research Centre Codes;<br />

2.19.7 Chartered Institute of Building Services Engineers<br />

(CIBSE) codes and guides;<br />

2.19.8 fire precautions.<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

2.20 <strong>The</strong> Trust should recognise that it is likely that<br />

many of the per<strong>for</strong>mance standards <strong>for</strong> engineering services<br />

will feed into the ongoing per<strong>for</strong>mance and payment<br />

mechanism.<br />

2.21 In<strong>for</strong>mation and Communications Technology<br />

(“ICT”) requirements should be set out in this section of<br />

the output specification. This should include any special<br />

requirements to support specialist diagnostic or surgical<br />

techniques or teaching requirements.<br />

Output specification – non-clinical<br />

2.22 An output specification should also be prepared in<br />

a consistent manner <strong>for</strong> all non-clinical areas and services<br />

of the project. This should particularly focus on the facilities<br />

management interface with clinical and clinical support<br />

functions. A guide template is presented below:<br />

Output specification – equipment schedules<br />

2.23 <strong>The</strong> trust should advise bidders at this stage on<br />

the scope of the trust’s equipment requirements having<br />

carefully considered the impact of different approaches<br />

on patient care. In <strong>for</strong>mulating the output specification <strong>for</strong><br />

the equipping solution the trust should:<br />

2.23.1 explore its existing schedules in order to establish<br />

more accurately the level and quantity of<br />

equipment that will need to be replaced be<strong>for</strong>e<br />

the project comes on stream;<br />

“<br />

per<strong>for</strong>mance standards<br />

<strong>for</strong> the project . . . should<br />

be achievable and realistic<br />

as an interdependent set of<br />

requirements<br />

”<br />

11


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

2. Invitation to negotiate<br />

TEMPLATE FOR NON-CLINICAL SERVICES/DEPARTMENTAL SPECIFICATIONS<br />

HEADING INFORMATION COVERED<br />

Scope of Service • Description of Service;<br />

• Customer/Consumer base (eg catering requirements);<br />

• Exclusions from Services covered<br />

Activity Indicators • Current Service Activity;<br />

• Work patterns – noting seasonal/gender/timing patterns of service delivery;<br />

• Service Trends;<br />

• Projected Activity.<br />

Functional Content • Size of Department (eg area plus storage);<br />

• IM&T service requirements<br />

Functional Relationships • Key departmental adjacencies noting whether they are essential, important, desirable or<br />

not desirable<br />

Operational Policies • Hours of Operation;<br />

• Staff Numbers;<br />

• Operational Processes/Workflow Patterns;<br />

• Communication/transportation (eg service corridors);<br />

• Reference to other specifications.<br />

Supporting Services • Interrelationship of department/service with other clinical services (eg <strong>The</strong>atres/A&E/<br />

Pharmacy/Rehabilitation/Medical Physics/Labs);<br />

• Interrelationship of department/service with other non-clinical services;<br />

• Arrangements <strong>for</strong> staff (eg education, beverage breaks/meals, staff change etc)<br />

Facility Requirements • List of the facility requirements needed to undertake the service;<br />

• Note of the key equipment requirements (include IM&T)<br />

Description of Accommodation • Description of the function and relationship between key rooms/services within the<br />

department;<br />

• Note of main and significant equipment<br />

Environmental and Service Requirements • Key Building and Engineering requirements eg levels of sterility, medical gases, natural<br />

light and ventilation requirements, telephones/ call systems etc<br />

Specific <strong>Design</strong> Guidance • Reference to any key design guidance eg waste management.<br />

2.23.2 determine the level of investment available within<br />

its block capital programme and review its revenue<br />

budgets to indicate clearly any implications<br />

with regard to the transfer of risk;<br />

2.23.3 ensure that the assumptions made in its PSC are<br />

appropriate, as the bidders may wish to use this<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation as an indication of the trust’s requirements;<br />

2.23.4 ensure that a true comparator has been satisfactorily<br />

established and that the trust’s per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

standard is clearly stated <strong>for</strong> the provision<br />

and maintenance of the equipment;<br />

2.23.5 detail the extent to which any existing equipment<br />

will be transferred to the Private Sector Partner;<br />

2.23.6 consider the implications of writing off the existing<br />

equipment;<br />

12<br />

2.23.7 consider the impact on af<strong>for</strong>dability and VFM;<br />

2.23.8 determine the output and per<strong>for</strong>mance specification,<br />

particularly <strong>for</strong> clinical and diagnostic<br />

equipment;<br />

2.23.9 consider the adequacy of definition <strong>for</strong> minor<br />

items like dispensers, trolleys, illuminators etc;<br />

2.23.10 consider the life-cycle replacement, maintenance<br />

and cost;<br />

2.23.11 assess compatibility with existing equipment;<br />

2.23.12 define the interface with clinical equipment such<br />

as patient monitoring equipment and the controls<br />

software;<br />

2.23.13 identify the inclusion or exclusion of some<br />

group 3 equipment such as free-standing mobile<br />

suction units.


Equipment scope<br />

2.24 <strong>The</strong> recommended minimum scope in respect of<br />

equipment <strong>for</strong> all <strong>PFI</strong> projects is as follows.<br />

Initial supply and installation of Group 1 & 2 items<br />

2.25 <strong>The</strong> initial supply and installation of Group 1 and<br />

installation only of Group 2 fixtures and fittings/equipment<br />

will be provided under the design and construction contract<br />

in accordance with the room data sheets to be<br />

agreed with the trust.<br />

Maintenance and replacement of Group 1 & 2 items<br />

2.26 Upon completion of the design and construction<br />

contract, the <strong>PFI</strong> contractor will be responsible <strong>for</strong> the<br />

maintenance and replacement of all Group 1 and maintenance<br />

of Group 2 fixtures and fittings/equipment <strong>for</strong> the<br />

whole of the concession period. For both groups, this will<br />

include any making good/modifications/damage to the<br />

building fabric and/or engineering services during equipment<br />

decommissioning and replacement. When Group 2<br />

equipment ceases to be maintainable, the Trust will be<br />

responsible <strong>for</strong> the supply costs only of life-cycle replacement<br />

items of Group 2 equipment over the concession<br />

period and the <strong>PFI</strong> contractor will be responsible <strong>for</strong><br />

installation and maintenance thereafter. <strong>The</strong> disposal of<br />

replaced Group 2 equipment will be the contractor’s<br />

responsibility, unless the trust elects otherwise.<br />

Group 3 and 4 FM equipment and furniture<br />

2.27 <strong>The</strong> trust should consider the transfer of all FM<br />

Group 3 and 4 equipment, furniture, spare parts, tools<br />

and consumables relating to all services to be provided<br />

under the FM contract, to the Private Sector Partner at<br />

the commencement of service delivery. <strong>The</strong> Private Sector<br />

Partner would then be responsible <strong>for</strong> the maintenance<br />

and replacement of all items transferred and the<br />

initial supply, maintenance and replacement of all other<br />

equipment, furniture, spare parts, tools and consumables<br />

as may be necessary <strong>for</strong> the FM services provided under<br />

the contract.<br />

Group 3 and 4 items used by the trust<br />

2.28 Unless subject to a full equipping service, Group<br />

3 and 4 items used by the trust will be supplied, maintained<br />

and replaced by the trust.<br />

Extended scope<br />

2.29 Each trust should review in detail whether the<br />

minimum level of equipment provision outlined above<br />

would meet the clinical needs <strong>for</strong> the duration of the<br />

contract. In the event that a full equipping and/or managed<br />

technology service is considered preferable, full<br />

output specifications should be provided.<br />

Equipment specification<br />

Dryburn Hospital, opened April 2001 – pathology laboratory<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

2.30 At the FITN Stage (where the 4:2:1 process is<br />

used) or at ITN (where the 3:1 process is used), the trust<br />

should issue all bidders with indicative equipment data<br />

sheets (or alternatively, a project-based consolidated<br />

room component schedule) of all Groups 1 to 3 equipment<br />

<strong>for</strong> all trust clinical and clinical support functions of<br />

the project. This should be based on the PSC equipment<br />

provision and ensure a level playing field <strong>for</strong> bidder’s bid<br />

pricing.<br />

13


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

2. Invitation to negotiate<br />

Supporting documentation to be supplied by<br />

the trust<br />

2.31 <strong>The</strong> following in<strong>for</strong>mation should be made available<br />

to bidders, together with any other documentation<br />

that the trust or its advisers believe is necessary <strong>for</strong><br />

bidders to <strong>for</strong>mulate priced proposals:<br />

2.31.1 trust’s Outline Business Case. This should<br />

include the schedules of accommodation,<br />

including room areas and plant and communications<br />

space allowances, prepared by the trust,<br />

and should be used to develop the PSC. This<br />

should not be held to constitute any part of the<br />

specification, but to act as a guide to the trust’s<br />

approach to the project;<br />

2.31.2 planning documentation including outline consent,<br />

planning agreements and overall plans <strong>for</strong><br />

the local area;<br />

2.31.3 statement of other consents that will be required,<br />

to the extent known by the trust, such as listed<br />

building consent;<br />

2.31.4 in<strong>for</strong>mation on property title and tenure of the<br />

site;<br />

2.31.5 where the OBC proposes the retention of existing<br />

buildings on the site, 1:200 loaded drawings<br />

<strong>for</strong> these buildings or, if not available, the nearest<br />

alternative;<br />

2.31.6 where existing buildings are to be transferred to<br />

the project company as part of the project, the<br />

trust should ensure, if it appoints third-party consultants<br />

to carry out surveys, appraisals or condition<br />

statements, that:<br />

14<br />

• the third-party consultants agree to undertake<br />

the work on the basis that their reports<br />

will be shared with the bidders, and the<br />

benefit of the surveys and any associated<br />

warranties will be assigned to the selected<br />

bidder,<br />

• the trust discloses the contents of such surveys,<br />

appraisals or condition statements to<br />

bidders and, if possible, assigns the benefit<br />

of them (whether completely or on a shared<br />

basis) to the selected bidder;<br />

• the relevant report, appraisal or survey is upto-date<br />

(or as up-to-date as is practicable)<br />

and addresses the issues likely to be of particular<br />

concern to bidders and financiers<br />

generally;<br />

Dryburn Hospital, opened April 2001 – coronary care nurses’<br />

station<br />

2.31.7 where it is proposed that suitable surveys are to<br />

be jointly commissioned by bidders and the trust<br />

prior to selection of a Preferred Bidder, the arrangement<br />

and proposed cost sharing mechanism<br />

should be set out in the ITN;<br />

2.31.8 if the trust has undertaken ground condition and<br />

other surveys on the proposed site the in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

may be included in the ITN documentation<br />

sent to the bidders. It is likely that this in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

will need to contain arrangements to<br />

allow the benefit of the surveys to be assigned to<br />

the eventual Preferred Bidder. Similarly, a costsharing<br />

mechanism will also need to be considered.<br />

Where a trust elects to carry out a ground<br />

condition survey and include it in the ITN, this will<br />

not alter the allocation of a ground condition risk<br />

in the Standard Form Project Agreement;<br />

2.31.9 a copy of the outline health and safety plan prepared<br />

by the Planning Supervisor. <strong>The</strong> plan<br />

should include the in<strong>for</strong>mation co-ordinated by<br />

the Planning Supervisor, including the location of<br />

existing services, the results of asbestos and<br />

contaminated land surveys, the storage location<br />

of any hazardous materials, and details of the<br />

safety hazards involving adjacent land use, site<br />

boundaries and site access. If the current in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

available is inaccurate, the trust should<br />

seek the advice of the Planning Supervisor as to<br />

whether more accurate in<strong>for</strong>mation is required to<br />

meet its obligations.


3. In<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided by bidders at PITN<br />

3.1 In the past it has been the case that trusts have<br />

required responses to the in<strong>for</strong>mation they have provided<br />

in a variety of <strong>for</strong>mats and to varying levels of detail.<br />

Following lengthy consultation with trusts, their advisers<br />

and companies involved in the <strong>PFI</strong> market, guidance<br />

standardising responses from bidders was first published<br />

by the Department of Health’s Private Finance Unit (PFU)<br />

in June 2002; an amended version was published in<br />

February 2003 and is available on the website.<br />

3.2 Under the standard PITN guidance the in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

required from bidders is divided into five sections, one of<br />

which is ‘Approach to <strong>Design</strong> and Construction’, which<br />

has a mandatory weighting of 25–35%. <strong>The</strong> aim of the<br />

Halifax General Hospital – opened April 2000<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

PITN stage is primarily about selecting bidders to go<br />

through to the shortlist as judged against a range of<br />

qualitative factors, and again the standard guidance <strong>for</strong><br />

the first time sets a prescriptive methodology <strong>for</strong> scoring<br />

the responses to each of the five sections in terms of<br />

approach, deliverables, innovation and compliance. However,<br />

trusts must be satisfied that the proposals they<br />

receive are also likely to be af<strong>for</strong>dable, and to this end the<br />

section ‘Financial Responses’ in the standard PITN contains<br />

a prescriptive list of costing questions <strong>for</strong> bidders’<br />

proposals. <strong>The</strong>se have been further refined with the production<br />

of a separate (Capital and Service elements) PITN<br />

pricing pro-<strong>for</strong>ma document which can be found in<br />

Appendix C of this document.<br />

15


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

4. In<strong>for</strong>mation to be submitted by bidders at FITN<br />

4.1 This section details the in<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided<br />

in response to the FITN. It covers Health Planning and<br />

Architecture, Engineering Services and other in<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />

Health planning and architecture<br />

4.2 Bidders will be expected to provide the following<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation to trusts. It represents a minimum requirement:<br />

4.2.1 the 1:1000 <strong>Development</strong> Control Plan. Typically<br />

such a plan will include the following in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

(this list is not exhaustive, as additional in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

may be required to demonstrate the viability of the<br />

proposals):<br />

• communications routes into and out of the<br />

hospital <strong>for</strong> vehicles, pedestrians and cyclists;<br />

• planning restrictions affecting the development<br />

and modifications to highways, response to<br />

specific local authority planning requirements;<br />

• orientation of the building and its relationship<br />

to other buildings and infrastructure on the<br />

site;<br />

• landscape strategy;<br />

• main access points to the building;<br />

• major service routes;<br />

• response to the surrounding and wider urban<br />

context;<br />

4.2.2 a 1:500 scale outline design indicating functional<br />

relationships and area schedules;<br />

4.2.3 site traffic analysis <strong>for</strong> vehicular and pedestrian<br />

movement. This may take the <strong>for</strong>m of a desktop<br />

study and include concept drawings;<br />

4.2.4 landscape concept. A general statement should<br />

be prepared, supported by high-level concept<br />

drawings of the landscape type required <strong>for</strong> planning<br />

consent;<br />

4.2.5 construction phasing – outline proposals <strong>for</strong> the<br />

construction decanting, including diagrammatic<br />

description, should be supplied;<br />

4.2.6 1:200 scale architectural drawings should be<br />

provided, in plan and section, indicating room<br />

adjacencies, circulation layouts, corridor widths<br />

and floor-to-ceiling heights. <strong>The</strong>se should be provided<br />

<strong>for</strong> all areas of the hospital. <strong>The</strong>se plans<br />

16<br />

should be adequately prepared to scale, allowing<br />

circulation and communications routes/wayfinding<br />

strategies, entrances and egresses to be clearly<br />

highlighted;<br />

4.2.7 trusts should recognise that at this stage 1:200<br />

scale drawings are to be provided to ensure that<br />

all the scheduled rooms can be accommodated<br />

within the proposed footprint of the building and<br />

that room adjacencies accord with the key operational<br />

principles declared in the clinical output<br />

specifications. <strong>The</strong>y should also demonstrate that<br />

patient environment matters, such as natural daylight<br />

and views, have been addressed. It is unlikely,<br />

however, that bidders’ architects will achieve<br />

the final layout without a full and <strong>for</strong>mal<br />

consultation with trust clinicians and staff. It is<br />

recommended that, at this stage, consultation<br />

involves the trust’s project team and key clinical<br />

and operational staff representatives. Following<br />

the appointment of a Preferred Bidder, it is anticipated<br />

that the Preferred Bidder and the trust will<br />

commence detailed consultation and design<br />

development with end-user groups to achieve the<br />

completion of 1:200 plans prior to the <strong>for</strong>mulation<br />

of selected 1:50 loaded room layouts and wall<br />

elevations complete with schedules and room<br />

data specifications prior to financial close;<br />

4.2.8 the in<strong>for</strong>mation requirements at the selection of<br />

Preferred Bidder must be sufficiently developed to<br />

give price certainty and com<strong>for</strong>t on the ultimate<br />

achievement of clinical functionality. <strong>The</strong> trust’s<br />

project director and technical advisors should be<br />

able to <strong>for</strong>m a judgement as to the benefits and<br />

dis-benefits of respective schemes from the 1:200<br />

scale drawings produced;<br />

4.2.9 1:50 scale equipment layout drawings and wall<br />

elevations <strong>for</strong> key rooms in the development<br />

should be provided. Typical rooms which should<br />

be provided are:<br />

• multi-bed rooms (en-suite at trust’s discretion);<br />

• single-bed rooms (must now be en-suite);<br />

• operating theatre;<br />

• anaesthetic room;<br />

• typical radiodiagnostic room;<br />

• ITU bay;


Wycombe General Hospital – opened April 2000<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

17


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

4. In<strong>for</strong>mation to be submitted by bidders at FITN<br />

• CCU room;<br />

• LDRP room;<br />

• typical treatment room;<br />

• typical clean utility room;<br />

• typical dirty utility room; and<br />

• assisted WC;<br />

4.2.10 draft room data sheets and project-wide draft<br />

equipment component schedules should be<br />

provided, based on the in<strong>for</strong>mation provided by<br />

the trust;<br />

4.2.11 details of functional content, summarised by department,<br />

should be given. <strong>The</strong>se should integrate<br />

the functional content in the trust’s output<br />

specifications with bidders’ proposals;<br />

4.2.12 schedules of accommodation with key operating<br />

assumptions should be provided. <strong>The</strong>se will<br />

have to be agreed with the trust at the end of the<br />

ITN stage if a fixed price is to be given be<strong>for</strong>e<br />

selection of the Preferred Bidder;<br />

4.2.13 bidders should provide strategic 1:200 plans<br />

and compartmentation plans, highlighting evacuation<br />

strategies and staff implications in the<br />

event of fire;<br />

4.2.14 bidders should submit typical 1:200 scale elevation<br />

drawings which are sufficient to demonstrate<br />

what the building would look like and the<br />

materials which would be used;<br />

4.2.15 bidders should indicate their interior design concepts<br />

<strong>for</strong> public and patient areas. Bidders<br />

should also indicate external landscaping proposals;<br />

4.21.6 full wayfinding strategy;<br />

4.2.17 design flexibility concepts should highlight the<br />

development areas and soft spaces contained in<br />

the design;<br />

4.2.18 a structural grid at 1:200 scale should be<br />

submitted;<br />

4.2.19 proposals <strong>for</strong> supplies, storage, distribution (with<br />

specific reference to laundry and linen) and<br />

waste management should be provided;<br />

4.2.20 proposals of how decontamination and control<br />

of infection are to be achieved should be provided;<br />

18<br />

4.2.21 a statement of the strategies with respect to<br />

ecologically responsible design and building<br />

management should be provided;<br />

4.2.22 design programme. Bidders should supply their<br />

envisaged programme to Financial Close and<br />

thereafter to design completion. This should<br />

show the proposed programme <strong>for</strong> the development<br />

of the 1:200 and 1:50 scale drawings.<br />

Proposals <strong>for</strong> achieving clinical sign-off should<br />

also be included.<br />

Engineering services<br />

4.3 In relation to engineering services, bidders should<br />

provide the following in their FITN submissions:<br />

4.3.1 engineering philosophy, including outline system<br />

selections;<br />

4.3.2 defined plant areas and zones;<br />

4.3.3 schematic and written proposals <strong>for</strong> major plant<br />

provision;<br />

4.3.4 explanations of expansion capabilities and<br />

standby facilities;<br />

4.3.5 a draft environmental impact statement;<br />

4.3.6 major plant life-cycle statement. This should include<br />

an explanation of the bidder’s life-cycle<br />

philosophy and an elemental breakdown of capital<br />

costs. This will allow the trust’s technical advisers<br />

to confirm that life-cycle assumptions are<br />

reasonable and deliverable when set against the<br />

proposed capital spend;<br />

4.3.7 lift usage and materials traffic assessment;<br />

4.3.8 engineering 1:200 scale line drawings that provide<br />

sufficient detail of the service risers, ducts<br />

and service routes to indicate the strategic distribution<br />

of the engineering services;<br />

4.3.9 evidence that the services support the trust’s<br />

business and life-critical services under supply<br />

failure scenarios;<br />

4.3.10 external services. This should include detail of<br />

the main routes, intakes and off-site reliance of<br />

the services;<br />

4.3.11 energy strategy;<br />

4.3.12 outline method statements <strong>for</strong> commissioning<br />

and decommissioning of the engineering services;


4.3.13 an aesthetic statement detailing the lighting to<br />

be provided both internally and externally;<br />

4.3.14 the number and location of IT communications<br />

rooms and any other ICT equipment that has<br />

space implications;<br />

4.3.15 generic room data sheets should be provided <strong>for</strong><br />

typical rooms indicating temperatures, ventilation<br />

rates, lighting levels, acoustic per<strong>for</strong>mance and<br />

general levels of service provision. Typical rooms<br />

should include:<br />

• in-patient rooms;<br />

• treatment rooms;<br />

• offices;<br />

• radiodiagnostic rooms;<br />

• utility rooms;<br />

• consulting rooms;<br />

• operating theatre suites;<br />

• ITU patient rooms;<br />

• CCU patient rooms; and<br />

• HDU patient rooms.<br />

Other in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

4.4 Other in<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided in the submission<br />

to the FITN is detailed in the following paragraphs:<br />

4.4.1 project management arrangements during the design,<br />

construction and service stages of the project<br />

should be outlined; in particular the management<br />

arrangements <strong>for</strong> partnering with the trust to<br />

deliver the project;<br />

4.4.2 quality management arrangements during the design,<br />

construction and service stages of the project<br />

should be outlined;<br />

4.4.3 evidence of planning support. <strong>The</strong> trust will have<br />

obtained outline planning consent. However, bidders<br />

would be expected to provide evidence that<br />

the 1:500 and elevation drawings meet the requirements<br />

of the local planning authority. Proposals<br />

<strong>for</strong> other buildings that <strong>for</strong>m part of the<br />

commercial proposal (<strong>for</strong> example private patients<br />

and retail facilities) should also have the demonstrable<br />

support of the local planning authority;<br />

4.4.4 external and internal access routes including a<br />

security statement;<br />

4.4.5 building areas. A gross area and room areas<br />

scheduled by department should be included;<br />

4.4.6 capital cost breakdown. <strong>The</strong> pro-<strong>for</strong>mas in<br />

Appendices D and E should be completed to<br />

provide in<strong>for</strong>mation on:<br />

• mobilisation proposals and outline of cost;<br />

• cost plan and cashflow <strong>for</strong>ecast;<br />

• elemental breakdown of equipment costs;<br />

• inflation assumptions;<br />

• preliminary costs and overhead/profit;<br />

• design fees;<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

• risk contingencies included in the price <strong>for</strong><br />

areas arising from, <strong>for</strong> example, need <strong>for</strong><br />

greater clarity of content, and site in<strong>for</strong>mation;<br />

4.4.7 outline specification of main elements against the<br />

headings listed in the capital and life-cycle cost<br />

schedules (completion of the pro-<strong>for</strong>mas in Appendices<br />

D and F). Note this is particularly im-<br />

Norfolk and Norwich Hospital – opened September 2001<br />

19


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

4. In<strong>for</strong>mation to be submitted by bidders at FITN<br />

portant when considering value <strong>for</strong> money and<br />

life-cycle costs; and<br />

4.4.8 a schedule of design life proposals and summary<br />

cashflow <strong>for</strong> the agreed elements as detailed in<br />

Appendix F (pro-<strong>for</strong>ma and definitions).<br />

4.5 <strong>The</strong> above in<strong>for</strong>mation should be comprehensive <strong>for</strong><br />

the whole development and be consistent with bidders’<br />

service proposals.<br />

4.6 Bidders should provide details of their Outline<br />

Construction Phase Health and Safety Plan together with<br />

their proposals to comply with the CDM Regulations<br />

when the planning supervisor duty is transferred at<br />

Financial Close.<br />

20


5. <strong>Design</strong> sign-off – pre-Financial Close<br />

5.1 After selection of a Preferred Bidder, the design<br />

development process will continue up to financial close,<br />

with some detailed working-up completed thereafter.<br />

During contract negotiations, the trust and Preferred Bidder<br />

will continue working on the design and, additionally,<br />

on the process <strong>for</strong> developing or amending the design<br />

post-Financial Close.<br />

5.2 This section of the protocol sets out the scope and<br />

purpose of the trust’s review of design data and the<br />

resulting allocation of design risk which takes place<br />

during the period between the selection of Preferred<br />

Bidder and Financial Close. <strong>The</strong> Standard Form Project<br />

Agreement sets out the design sign-off process and<br />

responsibilities post-Financial Close.<br />

5.3 <strong>The</strong> trust and Preferred Bidder should take into<br />

account the Strategic Health Authority’s responsibilities in<br />

terms of Full Business Case (“FBC”) approval and allow<br />

adequate time in the programme <strong>for</strong> consultations and<br />

feedback. Complementary to this, and as part of the central<br />

approval process, it is a mandatory requirement that<br />

NHS Estates review designs.<br />

Trust review of design data be<strong>for</strong>e Financial<br />

Close<br />

5.4 <strong>The</strong> trust is entitled to review data produced at each<br />

stage of the design process. It has the right to object and<br />

withhold approval where:<br />

5.4.1 it believes the design would not meet its requirements,<br />

as set out in the output specification(s) or<br />

ITN; or<br />

5.4.2 the design does not achieve clinical functionality.<br />

5.5 <strong>The</strong> fact that the trust has a right to review and<br />

object does not imply acceptance of any design responsibility<br />

on the part of the trust. <strong>The</strong> broad principle is that<br />

it is the responsibility of the trust to ensure that it can<br />

carry out its clinical functions in the hospital. It is the<br />

consortium’s responsibility to ensure that the detailed<br />

development of its design brief and the detailed development<br />

of the hospital design enable the trust to carry out<br />

its clinical functions. <strong>The</strong> trust’s sign-off and acceptance<br />

of risk thus relates purely to clinical functionality. What<br />

clinical functionality means in practice is set out in section<br />

5.6 below.<br />

5.6 Areas where the trust will not take design risk include,<br />

inter alia, the following:<br />

5.6.1 compliance of design with statute, regulations, fire<br />

strategy;<br />

5.6.2 safety aspects of the design;<br />

Revision 1 – August 2004<br />

5.6.3 that the design will achieve satisfactory planning<br />

consent;<br />

5.6.4 consistency of design with the project as a whole<br />

or consistency of various design documents with<br />

each other;<br />

5.6.5 engineering and structural aspects of design;<br />

5.6.6 materials, workmanship and technical per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

of the building;<br />

5.6.7 the impact of design on the contractor’s ability to<br />

meet the project requirements; and<br />

5.6.8 design layout of areas to be used by the contractor.<br />

“<br />

the broad principle is<br />

that it is the responsibility<br />

of the trust to ensure that<br />

it can carry out its clinical<br />

functions in the hospital<br />

”<br />

5.7 Clinical functionality refers, and refers only, to the<br />

project’s capacity <strong>for</strong> use by the trust or its staff <strong>for</strong><br />

carrying out the trust’s clinical functions and non-clinical<br />

functions. <strong>The</strong> trust’s non-clinical functions are deemed<br />

to include all hard and soft facilities management services<br />

retained by the trust that are outwith the bidder’s<br />

responsibility.<br />

5.8 In assessing clinical functionality the trust will review<br />

all design data including, in particular, fully loaded 1:50<br />

scale drawings. In approving the design it will be signing<br />

off conclusively on clinical functionality as indicated by the<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation presented. Any subsequent changes after<br />

Financial Close made at the request of the trust to<br />

achieve clinical functionality will be at the trust’s risk and<br />

will be treated as trust changes. <strong>The</strong>se trust changes will<br />

be priced, and any resulting change in the cost will feed<br />

21


<strong>The</strong> <strong>Design</strong> <strong>Development</strong> <strong>Protocol</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>PFI</strong> schemes<br />

5. <strong>Design</strong> sign-off – pre-Financial Close<br />

into a revised unitary charge in accordance with the<br />

change mechanism.<br />

5.9 <strong>The</strong> approval process will not impinge upon the<br />

contractor’s responsibility to achieve the per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

standards and, where appropriate, availability standards<br />

established in the trust’s output specifications. Achievement<br />

of these per<strong>for</strong>mance and availability standards will<br />

remain the contractor’s risk, and this will be reflected in<br />

the payment mechanism.<br />

Review <strong>for</strong> clinical functionality<br />

5.10 This section of the protocol is intended to identify<br />

the specific areas over which the trust will carry out its<br />

review <strong>for</strong> clinical functionality.<br />

5.11 <strong>The</strong> trust’s review <strong>for</strong> clinical functionality will<br />

include:<br />

5.11.1 positioning of roads, footpaths and car parks at<br />

a scale of 1:1000;<br />

5.11.2 departmental relationships and adjacencies at a<br />

scale of 1:500 macro level;<br />

5.11.3 departmental layouts and room adjacencies at a<br />

scale of 1:200 micro level;<br />

Atrium, Halifax General Hospital<br />

22<br />

5.11.4 fully loaded room layouts detailed in 1:50 drawings.<br />

This review will cover the clinical functionality<br />

of:<br />

• room size and usable floor space;<br />

• room shape and compliance with ergonomic<br />

data and minimum critical dimensions;<br />

• room elevations;<br />

• access points/location of doors and windows;<br />

• location of utilities, engineering and specialist<br />

services;<br />

• location of equipment including IM&T provisions;<br />

• floor areas;<br />

• departmental floor areas; and<br />

• overall building footprint.<br />

5.12 <strong>The</strong> trust should make it clear that the following<br />

items are not covered:<br />

5.12.1 sufficiency of non-departmental corridor and<br />

communications space;<br />

5.12.2 ceiling heights; and<br />

5.12.3 environmental aspects of design, <strong>for</strong> example<br />

temperature, lighting and humidity.


Appendix A: Standards and guidance relevant to design and construction<br />

1 <strong>The</strong> following documents are sources of standards <strong>for</strong><br />

design and construction and should be considered when<br />

drawing up the architectural output specification.<br />

Statutory requirements<br />

2 Bidders should be required to comply with the statutory<br />

requirements applicable to the project, which will<br />

include the building regulations, water bylaws, the Health<br />

and Safety at Work etc Act and the requirements of the<br />

Fire Authority. <strong>The</strong> trust needs to ensure compliance with<br />

“Guidelines <strong>for</strong> Implementing Controls Assurance in the<br />

NHS” and HSC 1999/123.<br />

British Standards and British Standard Codes<br />

of Practice<br />

3 “Catch-all” obligations requiring bidders to comply with<br />

all British Standards and all British Standard Codes of<br />

Practice should be avoided as they cover a very extensive<br />

range of documents, only some of which will be directly<br />

applicable to the project, and which contain inconsistencies<br />

and contradictions. Trusts’ technical advisers, in referring<br />

to British Standards or Codes of Practice, should<br />

be specific, and it should be made clear whether they are<br />

mandatory or simply to be treated as guidance.<br />

Health Technical Memoranda (“HTMs”)<br />

4 HTMs give comprehensive advice and guidance on the<br />

design, installation and operation of specialised building<br />

and engineering technology used in the delivery of healthcare.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y include Firecode, which sets standards <strong>for</strong> the<br />

layout, design, construction and fire safety management<br />

of hospitals and other healthcare premises. <strong>The</strong> Secretary<br />

of State <strong>for</strong> Health has retained powers of direction under<br />

the NHS Community Care Act 1990, which requires NHS<br />

healthcare premises (including trust premises) to comply<br />

with Firecode, and the Chief Executive and General Managers<br />

of the trust are responsible <strong>for</strong> ensuring that this is<br />

implemented. <strong>The</strong>re have been instances in the past<br />

where Firecode has been in conflict with the requirements<br />

of building control officers, and the output specification<br />

should make it clear to bidders which set of requirements<br />

is to take precedence in the event of such a conflict.<br />

5 Other HTMs should be reviewed, and it should be<br />

stated explicitly, in the output specification by the trust,<br />

which will be regarded as mandatory and which are desir-<br />

able. Bidders will not be required to have regard <strong>for</strong> HTMs<br />

not listed in the output specification.<br />

Health Building Notes (“HBNs”)<br />

6 <strong>The</strong> HBN series is intended to give advice on the<br />

briefing and design implications of Departmental policies.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y are supplemented by Health Guidance Notes<br />

(“HGNs”), which highlight new legislation and respond to<br />

changes in departmental policy or reflect changing NHS<br />

operational requirements.<br />

7 In drafting the output specification, trusts should give<br />

particular consideration to how they wish to deal with the<br />

four HBN volumes dealing with common activity spaces.<br />

<strong>The</strong>se provide detailed ergonomic data and specify critical<br />

dimensions <strong>for</strong> the efficient functioning of an activity.<br />

Because of its cost implications, this is often an area of<br />

considerable debate during the bidding process, so<br />

trusts may wish to expressly require bidders to comply<br />

with or exceed the preferred minimum dimensions set out<br />

in these HBNs, or to require bidders to in<strong>for</strong>m the trust<br />

where they do not so comply.<br />

Health Facility Notes (“HFNs”)<br />

8 HFNs contain no <strong>for</strong>mal policy input from the Department<br />

of Health, but they do provide guidance on certain<br />

key issues. Trusts should review these <strong>for</strong> applicability as<br />

requirements or guidance, and disclose those which<br />

should be used either way. An example is the HFN<br />

‘<strong>Design</strong> against crime: a strategic approach to hospital<br />

planning’, which deals with the impact of space on crime<br />

and security and how design can be used in the prevention<br />

of crime.<br />

Encode guidance<br />

9 This guidance can assist in the planning of energysaving<br />

proposals. Again, it should be reviewed <strong>for</strong> its applicability<br />

as mandatory or as guidance, and fully disclosed<br />

in either case.<br />

Other NHS Estates guidance<br />

10 Health notices produced by NHS Estates relating to<br />

hazards and safety can also be useful, as they have been<br />

drafted as a result of experience in the field. <strong>The</strong> Patients’<br />

Charter also establishes minimum standards to be<br />

achieved in specific areas, including the provision of<br />

23


Appendix A: Standards and guidance relevant to design and construction<br />

single-sex wards, privacy, and access <strong>for</strong> the physically<br />

impaired. Where the NHS have required trusts to achieve<br />

certain standards in respect of these requirements, those<br />

standards should be made clear as mandatory in the<br />

trust’s output specification.<br />

11 In addition to clarifying the status of the standards<br />

and guidance, trusts should also take account of the fact<br />

that, in some instances, documents to which they have<br />

referred may not be consistent with current legislation or<br />

good practice due to the time that has elapsed since the<br />

guidance was written. Where the trust’s technical advisers<br />

are aware that this is the case, they should make it<br />

clear that these aspects of the documents should be<br />

ignored. Trusts could also require bidders to highlight any<br />

further areas of documents with which compliance is<br />

mandatory which do not comply with either current<br />

legislation or current good practice, as adherence with<br />

legislation and good practice should remain the contractor’s<br />

risk.<br />

Achieving Excellence in <strong>Design</strong> Evaluation Toolkit<br />

(“AEDET”)<br />

12 <strong>The</strong> pursuit of high design quality <strong>for</strong> public buildings<br />

is Government policy and high on the agenda, and as a<br />

result Trusts are required to state how they intend to<br />

achieve and monitor high design quality. To support this<br />

directive NHS Estates have produced a design appraisal<br />

procedure (“AEDET”) that will provide the basis of a<br />

Trust’s appraisal of bidders’ design submissions. <strong>The</strong><br />

toolkit is intended to be used at various key stages in the<br />

design development process and to support the nonfinancial<br />

assessments of the various bids. Consortia will<br />

be expected to work with trusts to develop Achieving<br />

Excellence in <strong>Design</strong> Evaluation Toolkit assessments of<br />

relevant designs.<br />

NHS Environmental Assessment Tool (“NEAT”)<br />

13 <strong>The</strong> Government is committed to tackling pollution<br />

and improving the environment, and to support this policy<br />

and help the NHS deliver its targets NHS Estates have<br />

produced an NHS Environmental Assessment Tool<br />

(“NEAT”) that will provide a holistic approach to the<br />

environmental assessment <strong>for</strong> the NHS. <strong>Schemes</strong> will be<br />

evaluated by NHS trusts using this toolkit.<br />

24


Appendix B: NHS equipment group classifications<br />

1 Equipment <strong>for</strong> hospitals is categorised into four<br />

groups, as follows, and generic listings of equipment and<br />

their grouping <strong>for</strong> model departments are defined within<br />

the NHS Estates Activity DataBase:<br />

1.1 Group 1 equipment: items (including engineering<br />

terminal outlets ) supplied and within the terms of<br />

the building contract.<br />

• This means equipment that is normally fixed to the<br />

building fabric and/or attached to, or <strong>for</strong>ming part<br />

of, the building services. This may have an impact<br />

on space and/or building services to be provided,<br />

and will normally be supplied and fitted by the<br />

contractor (<strong>for</strong> example worktops, autoclaves,<br />

sanitary fittings, bedhead units, theatre lights, terminal<br />

outlets).<br />

• If the trust has any particular requirements in<br />

respect of Group 1 equipment, these should be<br />

specified. <strong>The</strong>re are a number of areas that have<br />

given problems in the past. <strong>The</strong>se include the provision<br />

of socket-outlets in acute care and theatre<br />

areas, where clinicians often wish to see more<br />

sockets provided than are specified in the NHS<br />

guidance. <strong>The</strong>atre lights and pendants are another<br />

area where clinical requirements are very specific<br />

and should be established in the output and<br />

per<strong>for</strong>mance specifications. <strong>The</strong> trust there<strong>for</strong>e<br />

needs to establish what its requirements will be<br />

relative to the guidance levels and to set these out<br />

in the output and per<strong>for</strong>mance specification.<br />

1.2 Group 2 equipment: items which have space<br />

and/or building construction and/or engineering<br />

service requirements and are fixed within the<br />

terms of the building contract but supplied under<br />

arrangements separate from the building contract.<br />

• This means equipment included in the final room<br />

data sheets as Group 2 which is normally fixed to<br />

the building fabric and/or attached to the building<br />

services and which will normally be fitted by the<br />

contractor but supplied under arrangements<br />

separate from the <strong>PFI</strong> contract. Where trusts<br />

require items ordinarily categorised as Group 2 to<br />

be supplied by the Private Sector Partner, these<br />

items should be categorised as Group 1 equipment.<br />

In general, these items tend to be relatively<br />

minor compared with Group 1 items (<strong>for</strong> example<br />

paper towel/glove dispensers, key cupboards, pin<br />

boards etc). <strong>The</strong>y could also include major diagnostic<br />

imaging and radiotherapy “big ticket” items<br />

which, like Group 1 items, may have an impact on<br />

space and/or building services to be provided.<br />

<strong>The</strong> trust should compile an accurate and complete<br />

list of its requirements <strong>for</strong> Group 2 equipment,<br />

in terms of procurement, quantity, engineering<br />

services, environmental and quality standards.<br />

Bidders should be expected to establish the<br />

necessary service, space and environmental<br />

requirements <strong>for</strong> such equipment and include it in<br />

their bids.<br />

• Certain major items of equipment, such as major<br />

diagnostic imaging equipment or linear accelerators<br />

etc, will require particular attention. In a <strong>PFI</strong><br />

contract the trust will need to consider the risk,<br />

potential delay, cost and implication <strong>for</strong> life-cycle<br />

replacement and maintenance of not including it<br />

within the contract. <strong>The</strong> trust will also need to<br />

consider that this type of equipment has implications<br />

in terms of space, access, shape of rooms,<br />

environmental requirements, engineering services<br />

and commissioning. <strong>The</strong> inclusion will have to be<br />

considered against the clinical needs and changing<br />

technology.<br />

1.3 Group 3 equipment: as Group 2 but supplied<br />

and fixed (or placed in position) under arrangements<br />

separate from the building contract.<br />

• This means those items included in the final room<br />

data sheets as Group 3 items which are freestanding<br />

and/or mobile and/or “plug-in” items,<br />

which will normally be provided by the trust (<strong>for</strong><br />

example beds, clinical furniture, ECG machines,<br />

vacuum pumps etc). Where trusts require items<br />

ordinarily categorised as Group 3 to be supplied<br />

by the contractor, these items should be categorised<br />

as Group 1 equipment. <strong>The</strong> exception to this<br />

are Group 3 items required <strong>for</strong> services to be<br />

provided by the Private Sector Partner, which<br />

would normally be provided by the Private Sector<br />

Partner. <strong>The</strong> service, space and environmental<br />

requirements <strong>for</strong> items other than those provided<br />

by the Private Sector Partner, many of which may<br />

be crucial to the healthcare requirements of the<br />

trust and expensive to provide, should be specified<br />

by the trust. Certain items of mobile equipment<br />

(<strong>for</strong> example mobile radiological equipment)<br />

will require careful consideration in terms of space,<br />

environmental and service requirements. <strong>The</strong> trust<br />

should also specify any constraints about location,<br />

access and storage.<br />

25


Appendix B: NHS equipment group classifications<br />

• It is also important <strong>for</strong> the trust to highlight the<br />

extent to which any existing Group 3 equipment<br />

will transfer to the Private Sector Partner.<br />

1.4 Group 4 equipment: items supplied under arrangements<br />

separate from the building contract,<br />

possibly with storage implications but otherwise<br />

having no effect on space or engineering service<br />

requirements.<br />

• This means those items that are not included on<br />

the final room data sheets that, apart from storage<br />

implications, have no effect on the requirements<br />

<strong>for</strong> space or engineering services. <strong>The</strong>se items are<br />

normally provided by the trust (<strong>for</strong> example surgical<br />

instruments, telephone handsets etc). <strong>The</strong> only<br />

exception to this are the Group 4 items required<br />

<strong>for</strong> services to be provided by the Private Sector<br />

Partner, which would normally be provided by the<br />

Private Sector Partner.<br />

2 In summary, the more detail the trust is able to provide<br />

regarding the equipment required, the greater the level of<br />

price certainty obtained. Where sufficient detail has been<br />

provided, the risks of failing to meet the trust’s equipment<br />

specification will rest with bidders. However, given the<br />

potential <strong>for</strong> uncertainty in this area and the costs involved,<br />

trusts are advised to ensure that their technical<br />

advisers comment on whether the bids they receive are<br />

sufficiently robust in respect of equipment.<br />

In<strong>for</strong>mation to Bidders<br />

3 <strong>The</strong> trust is to provide in<strong>for</strong>mation on the assumptions<br />

made <strong>for</strong> the provision of equipment in the PSC. This<br />

Category A – Supplied, installed,<br />

commissioned, maintained and<br />

replaced by project company<br />

Category B – Supplied by the trust<br />

– installed, commissioned and<br />

maintained by project company.<br />

Replaced by the trust<br />

Category C – Supplied, installed<br />

and replaced by the trust –<br />

maintained by project company<br />

Category D – Supplied, installed,<br />

commissioned, maintained and<br />

replaced by the trust<br />

26<br />

should be developed from estate, equipment and capital<br />

databases to reflect their expectations <strong>for</strong> the <strong>PFI</strong><br />

scheme. It will not be sufficient to rely on NHS standard<br />

equipment groupings alone, but these should be considered<br />

as follows.<br />

• Category A: equipment which is supplied, installed,<br />

commissioned, maintained and replaced<br />

by the project company and is essential and integral<br />

to the building;<br />

• Category B: equipment which is supplied by the<br />

trust. It is installed, commissioned, and maintained<br />

by the project company but replaced by the<br />

trust;<br />

• Category C: equipment which is supplied, installed<br />

and replaced by the trust and maintained<br />

by the project company;<br />

• Category D: equipment which is supplied,<br />

installed, commissioned, maintained and replaced<br />

by the trust.<br />

3.1 <strong>The</strong> trust may have assumed that some categories<br />

of equipment will need to be transferred<br />

from the existing hospital, and this equipment and<br />

quantity should be identified against the above<br />

categories. It should also be carefully assessed as<br />

being useable at the anticipated time of transfer,<br />

and the decommissioning, transfer, re-installation<br />

and insurance costs and responsibilities should be<br />

established.<br />

3.2 Facilities management equipment is classified as<br />

Category A unless the services are not being<br />

transferred to the project company.<br />

Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Group 4 Notes<br />

Example<br />

Included FM and capital<br />

cost of equipment by<br />

project company<br />

Trust to identify<br />

transferable equipment<br />

This must be a fully itemised list under categories A–D plus full details of what if anything will be included in a Managed Equipment Service.<br />

Note it is essential that decommissioning ,insurance and re-commissioning costs are included in the trust PSC,so that true comparisons can be made.


Appendix C: PITN capital cost<br />

Functional Content Area by Department<br />

New<br />

Refurbishment<br />

Adaptation<br />

Gross Area including communication and public spaces<br />

New<br />

Refurbishment<br />

Adaptation<br />

Capital Cost £<br />

Equipment Cost £<br />

External Works and Infrastructure capital cost £<br />

Fees, overheads and profit £<br />

Gross capital cost (including fees, profit, overheads etc) £<br />

Service elements<br />

Service type Rate<br />

Hard FM Services (£/m 2 per annum) – life-cycle risk<br />

Portering (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Linen (£ per 1000 articles)<br />

Cleaning (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Catering (£ per 1000 meals)<br />

Security (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Reactive maintenance (£/m 2 per annum) – no life-cycle risk<br />

Life-cycle element<br />

Concession period<br />

New build (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Refurbished estate (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Project Co costs (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Equipment (£ per annum)<br />

Mean<br />

rate pa<br />

m 2<br />

m 2<br />

m 2<br />

m 2<br />

m 2<br />

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.<br />

27


Appendix C: PITN capital cost<br />

Concession period 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.<br />

New build (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Refurbished estate (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Project Co costs (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Equipment (£ per annum)<br />

Concession period 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23.<br />

New build (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Refurbished estate (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Project Co costs (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Equipment (£ per annum)<br />

Concession period 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.<br />

New build (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Refurbished estate (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Project Co costs (£/m 2 per annum)<br />

Equipment (£ per annum)<br />

Notes <strong>for</strong> the completion of the data capture<br />

<strong>for</strong>m<br />

• Functional content – should differentiate between:<br />

N (new build); A (adaptations of existing<br />

buildings <strong>for</strong> alternative use); or C (refurbishing<br />

existing buildings <strong>for</strong> current use). <strong>The</strong> trust’s<br />

estate should be assumed to be at Condition B,<br />

unless the trust has provided in<strong>for</strong>mation to the<br />

contrary. Where the project comprises existing<br />

estate and new build, the bidder should only<br />

report as capital those areas <strong>for</strong> which life-cycle<br />

risk will be accepted.<br />

• Floor area – estimates must be provided <strong>for</strong> the<br />

floor area contributed by each department or area<br />

into the project, irrespective of whether they are<br />

the result of new build or the usage of existing<br />

estate. Again, these estimates relate only to those<br />

elements of the project <strong>for</strong> which the bidder<br />

accepts life-cycle risk.<br />

• Equipment costs – these are to be expressed as<br />

capital values <strong>for</strong> the project and should assume<br />

at least the inclusions of Categories 1 and 2<br />

equipment (and other categories as advised by<br />

28<br />

the trust and to the extent detailed by the trust).<br />

Major items must be as specified by the trust at<br />

prices quoted by the trust.<br />

• External works and site infrastructure – should<br />

be expressed as one capital value and should only<br />

include those works to be paid <strong>for</strong> by the trust<br />

through the unitary charge. Other works which<br />

may be required by other organisations (such as<br />

the local council) and are funded from other<br />

sources should be excluded.<br />

• Advisory fees – should include an estimate of<br />

advisory fees to Financial Close (<strong>for</strong> example<br />

architects, corporate finance, legal). <strong>The</strong>reafter,<br />

other administrative charges (which may include<br />

advisory fees of one <strong>for</strong>m or another) should be<br />

included within the annual estimate of Project<br />

Company running costs.<br />

• Service elements – all rates should use the units<br />

specified. Bidders should assume that the services<br />

are configured in such a way as to deliver<br />

against the trust’s output and service specifications.


Appendix C: PITN capital cost<br />

• Life-cycle costs – should be estimated and profiled<br />

across the life of the concession period. No<br />

adjustment should be made <strong>for</strong> asbestos removal<br />

unless the trust has indicated otherwise. Hard FM<br />

is assumed to relate to services delivered to existing<br />

estate and new build <strong>for</strong> which the project<br />

company will take life-cycle risk. Where a limited<br />

maintenance service (commonly termed a “toolbox”<br />

service) is to be provided to existing estate,<br />

which does not constitute acceptance of life-cycle<br />

risk, this rate per square metre should be set out<br />

under “Reactive Maintenance”.<br />

• Assumptions – <strong>for</strong> ease of comparison, bidders<br />

should ensure that their pricing data are provided<br />

according to the following bases:<br />

– capital costs should be expressed at the MIPS<br />

level specified by the trust;<br />

– Bidders should indicate (if they have not already<br />

done so in their submission) the expected<br />

start date <strong>for</strong> the construction phase and<br />

its duration;<br />

– capital and life-cycle costs should be consistent<br />

with the trust’s decanting proposals;<br />

– lump sum figures <strong>for</strong> decanting costs will be<br />

<strong>for</strong> the private-sector scheme and not directly<br />

comparable with the PSC;<br />

– Bidders should assume that IM&T infrastructure<br />

is included within equipment and life-cycle<br />

costs. If the project is to include a significant<br />

IM&T procurement (<strong>for</strong> example a PACS system)<br />

which is to be funded through the same<br />

unitary charge as the build scheme, the capital<br />

and life-cycle implications should be identified<br />

separately in a <strong>for</strong>mat (and using assumptions)<br />

consistent with those <strong>for</strong> the build scheme;<br />

– Bidders should not adjust services or life-cycle<br />

costs <strong>for</strong> inflation. Trusts’ financial advisers will<br />

wish to apply a common set of financial conditions<br />

to the submissions to assist comparability;<br />

– unit costs should be presented on a gross<br />

basis, without any allowance <strong>for</strong> any offset<br />

owing to third-party income.<br />

It should be acknowledged that detailed discussions with<br />

users will not have taken place at PITN stage.<br />

29


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

Bidders are required to submit a Full Financial Model<br />

setting out costs, financing etc. <strong>The</strong> Model should describe<br />

the basis on which the capital costs have been<br />

developed and clearly identify any exclusions.<br />

Separate elemental breakdowns (items 1a to 5n only)<br />

should be provided <strong>for</strong> each part of the construction<br />

30<br />

works (that is, <strong>for</strong> each phase and/or <strong>for</strong> each separate<br />

building). A separate breakdown should also be submitted<br />

<strong>for</strong> alteration/refurbishment works.<br />

Building description: ______________________________<br />

Gross floor area: _____________________ m 2<br />

Element<br />

Building & Engineering<br />

Cost £<br />

* 1a Substructure<br />

* 2a Frame<br />

* 2b Upper Floors<br />

* 2c Roof<br />

* 2d Stairs<br />

* 2e External Walls<br />

* 2f Windows & External Doors<br />

* 2g Internal Walls & Partitions<br />

* 2h Internal Doors<br />

* 3a Wall Finishes<br />

* 3b Floor Finishes<br />

* 3c Ceiling Finishes<br />

§ 4a Furniture & Fittings (group 1)<br />

§ 4b Workshop & other FM equipment (group 1)<br />

* 5a Sanitary Appliances<br />

§ 5b Medical Equipment (group 1)<br />

§ 5c Kitchen & Catering Equipment (group 1)<br />

§ 5d Other Services Equipment (group 1)<br />

* 5e Disposal Installations<br />

* 5f Mechanical Installations (†)<br />

* 5g Electrical Installations (†)<br />

* 5h IT & Communications (†)<br />

* 5i Pneumatic Tube Conveyor<br />

* 5j Medical Gases, Compressed Air & Vacuum Systems<br />

* 5k Building Management System<br />

* 5l Renal Dialysis Water Supplies<br />

* 5m Lifts<br />

* 5n Builders work in connection with Engineering Services<br />

Total Building and Engineering (a)


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

Element Cost £<br />

External Works<br />

* 6a Site Clearance and Demolition<br />

* 6b Preparatory Earthworks<br />

* 6ca Site Access Roads and Parking<br />

* 6cb Multi-storey Car parks<br />

* 6d Paths and Paved Areas<br />

* 6e Soft Landscaping<br />

* 6f Fencing and Site Fittings<br />

* 6g Other Site Works (retaining walls etc)<br />

* 6h Drainage<br />

* 6i External Services<br />

* 6j External Lighting<br />

* 6k Buildings work in connection with External Services (including Service Tunnels etc)<br />

* 6l Minor Building Works<br />

Total External Works (b)<br />

Alteration Works<br />

* 7a Alteration Works<br />

* 7b Temporary Structures and Other Enabling Works<br />

Total Alterations etc (c)<br />

Preliminaries<br />

* On-site staff<br />

* Sundry costs<br />

* On-site labour<br />

* Materials and goods<br />

* Plant, consumables, stores and services<br />

* Insurances<br />

Total Preliminaries (d)<br />

Contingency<br />

‡ <strong>Design</strong> Reserve<br />

‡ Construction Contingency<br />

Total Contingency (e)<br />

TOTAL CONSTRUCTION COSTS (at Base Date) (a+b+c+d+e) sub total (f)<br />

31


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

• Bidders should provide a detailed and fully quantified<br />

cost plan which arithmetically supports the<br />

figures (as marked by an asterisk *) inserted within<br />

the above capital cost breakdown. <strong>The</strong> cost plan<br />

must be presented in sufficient detail to identify<br />

the specification, quantity and rate <strong>for</strong> all major<br />

materials and components adopted <strong>for</strong> both the<br />

builder’s work and the engineering installations.<br />

• Elements 4b and 5c may be included in the service<br />

providers’ charges and not available as a<br />

lump sum.<br />

32<br />

Element Cost £<br />

Contractors’ Fees<br />

Contractors’ pre-construction fee<br />

Contractors’ overheads and profit<br />

* Contractors’ costs (specify)<br />

Total Contractors’ Fees (g)<br />

<strong>Design</strong> & Technical Fees<br />

Architects’ Fee<br />

Structural/Civil Engineers’ Fee<br />

Services Engineers’ Fee<br />

Quantity Surveyors’ Fee<br />

Planning Supervisors’ Fee<br />

Healthcare Planners’ Fee<br />

On-site Supervision<br />

Other Fees (specify)<br />

Total <strong>Design</strong> & Technical Fees (h)<br />

Non-works Costs<br />

Planning Fees<br />

Building Regulations<br />

Other Statutory or Local Authority Charges (specify)<br />

Site Surveys & Investigations<br />

Other fees or non-works costs (specify)<br />

Total Non-works Costs (j)<br />

Risk Allowance<br />

‡ Risk Allowance<br />

Total Risk Allowance (k)<br />

* Any other Capital Costs not identified above<br />

Total Other Costs (m)<br />

¿ Inflation on construction costs etc (n)<br />

TOTAL CAPITAL COSTS (out-turn) (f+g+h+j+k+m+n)<br />

• For clarification, Bidders may include with their<br />

cost plan a detailed and fully quantified breakdown<br />

of preliminaries, which arithmetically supports<br />

the figures, split into the six categories<br />

identified above (that is, provide schedules which<br />

identify and cost numbers of staff in terms of man<br />

days, confirm provision <strong>for</strong> site accommodation,<br />

crane age, scaffolding, skips etc).<br />

• Bidders may provide details to support the Contingency/Risk<br />

Allowance (marked ‡ above).<br />

• For clarification, Inflation (¿) should be shown<br />

against construction cost items. Figures inserted


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

against Contractors’ Fees, <strong>Design</strong> & Technical<br />

Fees, Non-works Costs, Risk Allowance and<br />

Other Costs are assumed to be fixed and inclusive<br />

of inflation.<br />

• Bidders should provide the engineering elements<br />

(marked † above) broken down as follows:<br />

Services Engineering Elements<br />

Mechanical Services: (5f) Heat source and Prime Movers<br />

Steam distribution<br />

Condensate return<br />

Cold water services<br />

Domestic hot water services<br />

Heating<br />

Electrical Services: (5g) HV Services<br />

Ventilation and air conditioning<br />

Chilled water installations<br />

Internal fire protection installations<br />

Standby Generators & UPS<br />

LV Distribution, Main and Sub-Main Cabling<br />

Internal Lighting Installation & Luminaires<br />

Emergency Lighting<br />

Small Power Services<br />

Patient/Nurse Call Systems & Other Call Systems<br />

Fire Detection and Alarm Systems<br />

Alarm and Security Systems and CCTV<br />

Radio Sound Distribution Systems & TV Aerial Amplifiers & Wiring<br />

Wiring to Mechanical Services and BMS<br />

Containment <strong>for</strong> use by others<br />

Lightning Protection System<br />

Earthing Systems<br />

IT & Communications: (5h) Structured Cabling Systems<br />

LAN Active Equipment<br />

Telephone Handsets and Payphones<br />

33


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

Equipment<br />

• Bidders should provide the equipment elements<br />

(marked § above) broken down, as a minimum, as<br />

follows:<br />

Equipment Cost Analysis<br />

Furniture & Fittings (4a) Based on generic RDS’s or bidder’s scheme details<br />

Workshop & Other FM Equipment (4b) May be included in the service providers charges and not available as a lump sum<br />

Kitchen & Catering Equipment (5c) May be included in the service providers charges and not available as a lump sum<br />

Medical Equipment(5b) Based on unsigned off accommodation and bidder’s selection of provider.<br />

• For the avoidance of doubt, medical equipment<br />

should include theatre lights and pendants, fume<br />

cupboards and laboratory tables, post-mortem<br />

tables, body stores, patient hoists and autoclaves<br />

and washers.<br />

• Bidders should provide, as a minimum, a detailed<br />

and fully quantified and costed schedule of equipment<br />

which arithmetically supports the allowances<br />

against each of the above sub-categories of medical<br />

equipment (with the exception of “other”).<br />

Bidders should state their assumptions against all other<br />

figures (that is, <strong>for</strong> equipment other than medical equipment)<br />

where no schedule is provided (<strong>for</strong> example if “nil”,<br />

whether allowed <strong>for</strong> outside the Capital Costs).<br />

Capital cost summary <strong>for</strong> FITN<br />

From the in<strong>for</strong>mation set out above, the Bidders should<br />

summarise the capital costs in the <strong>for</strong>m prescribed below;<br />

the summary must cover and identify separately the<br />

whole of the anticipated capital expenditure on the project,<br />

including:<br />

• building and engineering costs, broken down into<br />

individual phases or buildings;<br />

• external works and alterations;<br />

• preliminaries and contingencies;<br />

• contractors’ and design and technical fees;<br />

• non-works costs and risk;<br />

• other capital costs.<br />

<strong>The</strong> alphabetical references are to the subtotals in the<br />

capital cost model <strong>for</strong> each block.<br />

34


Appendix D: Capital cost model FITN<br />

Capital and development costs summary<br />

Element Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Building & Engineering (a)<br />

External Works (b)<br />

Alterations (c)<br />

Preliminaries (d)<br />

Contingencies (e)<br />

TOTAL CONSTRUCTION<br />

COSTS (Base Date) (f)<br />

Contractors Fee (g)<br />

<strong>Design</strong> & Technical Fees (h)<br />

Non Works Costs (j)<br />

Risk (k)<br />

Other Capital Costs (m)<br />

Inflation (n)<br />

TOTAL CAPITAL COSTS<br />

(Out-turn)<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

Phase or<br />

Building<br />

35


Appendix E: Capital and development costs cash flow FITN<br />

<strong>The</strong> purpose of this return is to enable the trust to quickly<br />

be assured that the funding and cash flow is in place to<br />

support the level of costings in the pro-<strong>for</strong>mas and that<br />

the bidder has created a risk reserve.<br />

Bidders should provide the extract of their financial model<br />

cash flow statement which covers the capital costs, that<br />

is, the “<strong>Development</strong>”, “Construction” and “Lifecycle”<br />

costs. This is the cash flow used to cover all the build<br />

elements and life-cycle activities/costs in the pro-<strong>for</strong>mas<br />

in Appendices D and F. Bidders, in addition, are to clearly<br />

state if any of the categories and elements in the pro<strong>for</strong>mas<br />

are not included in these figures.<br />

Bidders should also confirm that they have Debt Service<br />

Reserve (DSR) and Life-cycle/Maintenance Reserve<br />

arrangements in place, although figures are not required<br />

here.<br />

36


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

<strong>The</strong> summary cash flow of projected life-cycle expenditure<br />

should be submitted on the pro-<strong>for</strong>ma overleaf on a<br />

year-by-year basis. In each instance the Bidder should<br />

highlight design life and assumed replacement cycles.<br />

<strong>The</strong> detailed elemental components to build up the lifecycle<br />

costs are shown in the supporting table which<br />

follows the pro-<strong>for</strong>ma.<br />

Separate breakdowns should be provided <strong>for</strong> each part<br />

of the construction works (that is, <strong>for</strong> each phase and/or<br />

<strong>for</strong> each separate building) and <strong>for</strong> each of the identified<br />

facilities. Works of statutory and condition B compliance<br />

in relation to the identified facilities should be shown separately.<br />

37


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

Life-cycle cost summary FITN pro-<strong>for</strong>ma<br />

<strong>The</strong> Bidder should provide a summary cash flow of projected<br />

life-cycle expenditure (on a year-by-year basis) in<br />

the following <strong>for</strong>mat:<br />

Element<br />

38<br />

Replacement Cycle<br />

(Years)<br />

Structure & Fabric<br />

Structure (frame, upper floors, stairs)<br />

Roofs<br />

External walls<br />

Windows & external doors<br />

Internal walls & partitions<br />

Internal walls & partitions<br />

Internal Finishes<br />

Floor Finishes<br />

Ceiling Finishes<br />

Decorations<br />

External Decoration<br />

Internal Decoration<br />

Fittings & Furniture<br />

Furniture & Fittings<br />

Medical Equipment<br />

Kitchen & Catering Equipment<br />

Workshop & Other FM Equipment<br />

Maintenance of Equipment<br />

Services<br />

Sanitary<br />

Water<br />

Heating<br />

Cooling<br />

Ventilation & Air-conditioning<br />

Lifts and Escalators<br />

Electric Power<br />

Lighting<br />

IM&T & Communications<br />

Other M&E Services<br />

External Works<br />

Roads etc<br />

External Services<br />

Backlog<br />

Management Costs<br />

TOTAL LIFE-CYCLE COSTS (Base Date)<br />

Inflation<br />

TOTAL LIFE-CYCLE COSTS (Out-turn)<br />

£’000<br />

Annual Periods<br />

£’000 £’000


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

All above cash flow figures to be inclusive of all “add-on<br />

costs”, <strong>for</strong> example access costs, preliminaries, overheads,<br />

profit, contingencies, disturbance and making<br />

good etc.<br />

• Bidders should submit a detailed and fully quantified<br />

equipment schedule which arithmetically supports<br />

the allowances <strong>for</strong> the repairs to/replacement<br />

of equipment included above. <strong>The</strong> equipment<br />

schedule should itemise equipment in the<br />

elements listed above.<br />

• For clarity, life-cycle costs <strong>for</strong> equipment within the<br />

identified facilities should include Category 1 and<br />

2 (installation and maintenance) equipment and<br />

the maintenance of Category 1, 2 and 3 equipment.<br />

Bidders should assume equipment to have<br />

Life-cycle costs: list of headings to build up life-cycle costs<br />

(This list is not exhaustive, and the bidder should add additional items as appropriate)<br />

Column A<br />

Element/Component<br />

Structure and Fabric<br />

been new, with no subsequent replacement<br />

(either to date or within the period leading up to<br />

the Bidder taking life-cycle responsibility).<br />

• Bidders should submit a detailed schedule clearly<br />

identifying life-cycle works assumed to be undertaken<br />

by the trust within identified facilities in order<br />

to sustain the current condition standard up to the<br />

date of handover of the identified facilities.<br />

• For clarity, life-cycle costs <strong>for</strong> IM&T within the<br />

identified facilities should include the replacement<br />

of cabling and active components. Bidders should<br />

allow <strong>for</strong> re-provision of all cabling and active<br />

components within the identified facilities prior to<br />

final opening of the new facilities.<br />

Column B<br />

Element Definitions<br />

Structure (frame, upper floors, stairs) ducts<br />

frames<br />

stairs<br />

balustrades<br />

protection rails<br />

gantry rails<br />

fire escapes<br />

floor structures<br />

Roofs repairs to/replacement flat roofs<br />

pitched roofs<br />

roof lights<br />

External walls external structure walls<br />

curtain walls<br />

cladding<br />

glazed screens<br />

Windows & external doors external doors and windows<br />

Internal walls & partitions internal walls and partitions<br />

Internal doors internal doors<br />

ironmongery<br />

borrowed lights<br />

Internal Finishes<br />

Floor finishes: repairs to/replacement vinyl flooring<br />

fitted carpets<br />

carpet tiling<br />

ceramic tiling<br />

Wall finishes: repairs to/replacement plaster<br />

ceramic tiling<br />

Ceiling finishes: repairs to/replacement suspended ceilings<br />

plasterboard ceilings<br />

39


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

Column A<br />

Element/Component<br />

Column B<br />

Element Definitions<br />

Decoration<br />

External Decoration (including cleaning external surfaces)<br />

Internal Decoration walls<br />

ceilings<br />

doors<br />

other<br />

Equipment<br />

Furniture & Fittings: repairs to/replacement: Category A (shelves, cupboards, worktops, curtain rails etc)<br />

Category B<br />

Medical Equipment: repairs to/replacement: Category A (theatre lights, pendants, sterilizers, washers etc)<br />

Category B<br />

Kitchen & Catering Equipment: repairs to/replacement Category A (fridges, cookers, dishwashers etc)<br />

Category B<br />

Workshop & Other FM Equipment: repairs to/replacement Category A (workbenches etc)<br />

Category B<br />

Maintenance of Equipment Category A<br />

Category B<br />

Category C<br />

Services<br />

Sanitary installation; repairs, replacement and servicing to: sanitaryware<br />

taps<br />

valves<br />

waste, soil, overflow and vent pipes<br />

Water installation: repairs, replacement and servicing to: boosted cold water<br />

CWS pipework<br />

DHWS calorifiers and plant<br />

DHWS pipework<br />

water storage tanks<br />

Heating installation: repairs, replacement and servicing to: steam and HTHW shell and tube boilers<br />

medium & low pressure steel boilers<br />

combustion controls<br />

feed pumps<br />

feed treatment plant<br />

firing equipment<br />

fans<br />

instrumentation<br />

calorifiers and heat exchangers<br />

control equipment<br />

pipework installations<br />

pumps<br />

radiators – cast iron<br />

radiators – steel<br />

suspended ceiling heaters<br />

tanks<br />

valves<br />

Cooling installation: repairs, replacement and servicing to: refrigeration plant<br />

cooling coils<br />

pipework installations<br />

pumps<br />

valves<br />

40


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

Column A<br />

Element/Component<br />

Services (continued)<br />

Column B<br />

Element Definitions<br />

Ventilation/Air-conditioning: repairs, replacement and servicing to: refrigeration plant, medium and large, compression and<br />

absorption<br />

distribution systems (pipework, ducts)<br />

terminal units<br />

cooler batteries<br />

fans and washers<br />

heater batteries<br />

heat rejection equipment<br />

package air handling equipment<br />

automatic temperature controls<br />

fire dampers<br />

Lifts and Escalators: repairs, replacement and servicing to: lifts<br />

escalators<br />

Electric power and lighting: repairs, replacement and servicing to: mains cabling<br />

electrical switchgear and distribution equipment<br />

final circuits and outlets<br />

electrical motors<br />

generators<br />

prime movers, reciprocating engines<br />

prime movers, turbine, gas and steam<br />

standby prime movers, diesel<br />

lighting<br />

Lighting: repairs, replacement and servicing to: lighting installations<br />

emergency lighting<br />

batteries, lead acid, sealed<br />

batteries, nickel alkaline, vented<br />

luminaires – bulbs and tubes<br />

luminaires – fittings<br />

Protection: repairs, replacement and servicing to: fire alarm systems<br />

intruder alarms<br />

CCTVs<br />

lightning protection<br />

IM&T and Communications cabling<br />

active components<br />

call systems<br />

clock systems<br />

Other M&E services: repairs, replacement and servicing to other<br />

services that are part of the building:<br />

building management system<br />

gas installations<br />

medical gases – pipework<br />

medical gases – outlets, valves and fittings<br />

medical vacuum and compressed air systems<br />

pneumatic conveyor<br />

smoke vents<br />

steel chimneys<br />

incinerators<br />

laundry plant, washing machines<br />

wet risers<br />

41


Appendix F: Life-cycle costs FITN<br />

Column A<br />

Element/Component<br />

External works<br />

42<br />

Column B<br />

Element Definitions<br />

Roads etc: repairs, replacement and services to: roads and paving<br />

hard landscaping<br />

fencing<br />

signage<br />

furniture<br />

External Services drainage<br />

water<br />

electric<br />

gas<br />

Backlog<br />

Management costs management costs associated with the above


Picture Credits:<br />

Page Front cover Anshen Dyer Architects (Proposed <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Central<br />

Manchester and Manchester Children’s University Hospitals NHS<br />

Trust)<br />

Back cover Anshen Dyer Architects (Proposed <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Central<br />

Manchester and Manchester Children’s University Hospitals NHS<br />

Trust)<br />

6 Capita Percy Thomas (<strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Derby Hospitals NHS<br />

Foundation Trust)<br />

7 Capita Percy Thomas (<strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Derby Hospitals NHS<br />

Foundation Trust)<br />

10 Swantre Hayden Connell Architects (Proposed <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at<br />

University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust)<br />

13 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at County Durham and Darlington Acute Hospitals<br />

NHS Trust<br />

14 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at County Durham and Darlington Acute Hospitals<br />

NHS Trust<br />

15 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Trust<br />

17 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust<br />

19 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals NHS Trust<br />

22 <strong>PFI</strong> scheme at Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Trust<br />

Adult’s Concourse Children’s High Level<br />

Preferred bidder artist’s impression <strong>for</strong> Central Manchester

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!