The Mitochondrial Free Radical Theory of Aging - Supernova: Pliki

The Mitochondrial Free Radical Theory of Aging - Supernova: Pliki The Mitochondrial Free Radical Theory of Aging - Supernova: Pliki

pliki.supernova.com.pl
from pliki.supernova.com.pl More from this publisher
15.01.2013 Views

A Descriptive Introduction to Human Aging must understand not only why cells that die are not replaced, but also why they die in the first place. But there is no reason to seek a single reason for this low-rate, steady cells death—the most obvious theory, that they die of a wide variety of causes due to simply living for a long time in a relatively unstable environment, is enough. Also, cells become more sensitive to stress as we age: 22,23 liver cells isolated from elderly individuals are more prone to die from a given degree of stress than cells of the same type isolated from younger people.* Does this group of symptoms of aging have anything in common with atherosclerosis and cancer? Indeed it does. The efficacy of the various cellular functions touched on above will be diminished if the proteins that perform them are damaged, and LECs can damage all these proteins, just as they damage those that perform DNA maintenance. The ability of a cell to survive stress of various kinds is, likewise, dependent on its ability rapidly to synthesise the proteins that protect it; if many of these proteins (or those involved in their construction) are damaged, that ability is correspondingly reduced. 5.4. Blindness We saw in the previous section that cells recycle their internal protein and lipid quite rapidly, in contrast to the rather slow and imperfect recycling of extracellular proteins. Much of the intracellular recycling is done in lysosomes, which are the generic garbage collector of the cell. One of the first age-related changes to be discovered inside cells was that lysosomes gradually accumulate a fluorescent pigment, which is called lipofuscin. 26,27 Lipofuscin proved rather hard to characterise chemically, but there is now a consensus that it comprises highly heterogeneous polymers of protein and lipid, together with a substantial concentration of metal ions which were presumably once the cofactors of some of the proteins. It is believed to result from a feature of LEC-mediated oxidation reactions: namely, that the products of oxidation are enormously varied (see Section 3.8). Lysosomes contain a huge variety of destructive enzymes, capable of breaking down all manner of protein and lipid molecules (and their modified forms resulting from peroxidation) into their small-molecule constituents, but it is simply not possible to have an enzyme for everything. Some of the molecular knots tied by peroxidation will thus be too Gordian for lysosomes to unravel. Lipofuscin has just the characteristics that would be expected of this indigestible remnant: a granule in which such molecules are packaged up out of harm’s way, and never need to be properly disposed of. Since the indigestible products are very rare, resulting only from particularly complex sequences of reactions, they never reach levels that cause the cell any inconvenience.** Except, that is, in the retina. There, protein turnover is probably just as efficient as anywhere else—that is, the proportion of protein and lipid that lysosomes are unable to digest is just as small—but what is different is the amount of protein and lipid that must be recycled. The absorption of light by rhodopsin is an extremely protein-damaging process, * It should be noted that there are also reliable reports of the opposite effect: of cells becoming progressively less prone to die when stressed. 24,25 But there is in fact no conflict of data, because this resistance to death is a feature of cells in culture that have replicated many times more than they are ever required to in the body and have become unable to replicate any more—have reached replicative senescence. This happens because the type of cell death that these stressed cells undergo—apoptosis—is not simply atrophy: it is a program, very rigorously controlled by a complex series of genetic interactions, and replicative senescent cells have lost not only the ability to divide but also the ability to perform some of these interactions. Put simply, they want to die but they can’t. We will come back to replicative senescence in Section 7.3 and to apoptosis in Chapter 14. ** It is not in fact certain that lipofuscin is as harmless as this. One possibility 28,29 is that it harms us passively, by "distracting" lytic enzymes in lysosomes. In vivo evidence for this is still lacking, however. 57

58 The Mitochondrial Free Radical Theory of Aging such that the discs of rhodopsin which form the light-sensitive part of rod and cone cells are recycled more than once a week. 30 The lysosomes in the pigmented epithelium, the cell layer behind the rods which does the recycling, eventually become so full of lipofuscin that they cease to function and the cells begin to lose integrity, leading to gradual loss of vision, technically termed macular degeneration. This process is exacerbated by light-induced rupture of these lysosomes. 31 But what determines the rate of accumulation of lipofuscin in other cell types? An answer is suggested by the description of its composition given above. Oxidative damage increases the incidence of damaged protein and lipid in cells, and that translates directly into more lipofuscin. And indeed, the cells elsewhere than the eye which accumulate the most lipofuscin are those which are non-dividing, so cannot dilute it away, and among non-dividing cells the worst affected are those (such as cardiomyocytes) which use the most energy, so create the most LECs and suffer the most oxidative damage. 5.5. Other Macroscopic Changes The preceding sections have summarised only a selection of the major symptoms of aging, though they have covered most classes. Many other cell types diminish in number with aging; these include ones that are incapable of regeneration by division, such as neurons, glomeruli, and the sensory hair cells of the inner ear, as well as ones which can divide but generally do not. Various hormones diminish in concentration with age, for this reason and others. A similar process happens to the immune system: this becomes progressively less robust with age due to loss of cells in the thymus. 32 Another major change that more indirectly involves loss of a specific cellular function is bone loss, leading to osteoporosis; this is thought to be a response to a general failure of calcium regulation in many cell types, something which can be detected histochemically as excessive calcium uptake. 5.6. Feedback, Turnover and Oxidative Stress 5.6.1. Negative Feedback We would certainly not live as long as we do if not for our ability to react to, and recover from, adverse physiological conditions. At the subcellular level, this response comprises rapid regulation of all our systems for biological homeostasis, including our antioxidant systems. This may seem vacuous, but in fact a remarkable deduction can be made from it. It tells us that, despite (as discussed in the preceding sections) being pro-oxidant in nature, the processes which drive aging are simply not challenged by our antioxidant defences—otherwise, aging would not progress inexorably as it does. They proceed, slowly but surely, impervious to antioxidants. This is further confirmed by the repeated failure of antioxidant therapy to increase maximum lifespan of mammals, 33,34 an observation which will be discussed further in later chapters. This is a useful point because, on closer analysis, it dramatically narrows the field of choices for the driving force behind aging. As we get older, there is a steady increase in the levels of proteins which have suffered oxidative damage but not been recycled. Some such proteins are themselves pro-oxidant, so they are part of the problem. But they cannot be a driving part, because recycling is tunable: all other things being equal, the recycling machinery would simply be up-regulated to match the increased levels of damaged proteins, thereby lowering them again. This is the sort of negative feedback that maintains stability in the body and in the cell in the face of exogenous challenges, such as disease. The same logic applies to any component of cells—or of the extracellular space—that is recycled, whatever the rate of that recycling (unless that rate is so slow as to be comparable with our lifetime).

A Descriptive Introduction to Human <strong>Aging</strong><br />

must understand not only why cells that die are not replaced, but also why they die in the<br />

first place. But there is no reason to seek a single reason for this low-rate, steady cells death—the<br />

most obvious theory, that they die <strong>of</strong> a wide variety <strong>of</strong> causes due to simply living for a long<br />

time in a relatively unstable environment, is enough. Also, cells become more sensitive to<br />

stress as we age: 22,23 liver cells isolated from elderly individuals are more prone to die from a<br />

given degree <strong>of</strong> stress than cells <strong>of</strong> the same type isolated from younger people.*<br />

Does this group <strong>of</strong> symptoms <strong>of</strong> aging have anything in common with atherosclerosis<br />

and cancer? Indeed it does. <strong>The</strong> efficacy <strong>of</strong> the various cellular functions touched on above<br />

will be diminished if the proteins that perform them are damaged, and LECs can damage all<br />

these proteins, just as they damage those that perform DNA maintenance. <strong>The</strong> ability <strong>of</strong> a<br />

cell to survive stress <strong>of</strong> various kinds is, likewise, dependent on its ability rapidly to synthesise<br />

the proteins that protect it; if many <strong>of</strong> these proteins (or those involved in their construction)<br />

are damaged, that ability is correspondingly reduced.<br />

5.4. Blindness<br />

We saw in the previous section that cells recycle their internal protein and lipid quite<br />

rapidly, in contrast to the rather slow and imperfect recycling <strong>of</strong> extracellular proteins.<br />

Much <strong>of</strong> the intracellular recycling is done in lysosomes, which are the generic garbage<br />

collector <strong>of</strong> the cell. One <strong>of</strong> the first age-related changes to be discovered inside cells was<br />

that lysosomes gradually accumulate a fluorescent pigment, which is called lip<strong>of</strong>uscin. 26,27<br />

Lip<strong>of</strong>uscin proved rather hard to characterise chemically, but there is now a consensus that<br />

it comprises highly heterogeneous polymers <strong>of</strong> protein and lipid, together with a substantial<br />

concentration <strong>of</strong> metal ions which were presumably once the c<strong>of</strong>actors <strong>of</strong> some <strong>of</strong> the<br />

proteins. It is believed to result from a feature <strong>of</strong> LEC-mediated oxidation reactions: namely,<br />

that the products <strong>of</strong> oxidation are enormously varied (see Section 3.8). Lysosomes contain<br />

a huge variety <strong>of</strong> destructive enzymes, capable <strong>of</strong> breaking down all manner <strong>of</strong> protein and<br />

lipid molecules (and their modified forms resulting from peroxidation) into their<br />

small-molecule constituents, but it is simply not possible to have an enzyme for everything.<br />

Some <strong>of</strong> the molecular knots tied by peroxidation will thus be too Gordian for lysosomes<br />

to unravel. Lip<strong>of</strong>uscin has just the characteristics that would be expected <strong>of</strong> this indigestible<br />

remnant: a granule in which such molecules are packaged up out <strong>of</strong> harm’s way, and never<br />

need to be properly disposed <strong>of</strong>. Since the indigestible products are very rare, resulting<br />

only from particularly complex sequences <strong>of</strong> reactions, they never reach levels that cause<br />

the cell any inconvenience.**<br />

Except, that is, in the retina. <strong>The</strong>re, protein turnover is probably just as efficient as<br />

anywhere else—that is, the proportion <strong>of</strong> protein and lipid that lysosomes are unable to<br />

digest is just as small—but what is different is the amount <strong>of</strong> protein and lipid that must be<br />

recycled. <strong>The</strong> absorption <strong>of</strong> light by rhodopsin is an extremely protein-damaging process,<br />

* It should be noted that there are also reliable reports <strong>of</strong> the opposite effect: <strong>of</strong> cells becoming progressively<br />

less prone to die when stressed. 24,25 But there is in fact no conflict <strong>of</strong> data, because this resistance to death is<br />

a feature <strong>of</strong> cells in culture that have replicated many times more than they are ever required to in the body<br />

and have become unable to replicate any more—have reached replicative senescence. This happens because<br />

the type <strong>of</strong> cell death that these stressed cells undergo—apoptosis—is not simply atrophy: it is a program, very<br />

rigorously controlled by a complex series <strong>of</strong> genetic interactions, and replicative senescent cells have lost not<br />

only the ability to divide but also the ability to perform some <strong>of</strong> these interactions. Put simply, they want to<br />

die but they can’t. We will come back to replicative senescence in Section 7.3 and to apoptosis in Chapter 14.<br />

** It is not in fact certain that lip<strong>of</strong>uscin is as harmless as this. One possibility 28,29 is that it harms us passively,<br />

by "distracting" lytic enzymes in lysosomes. In vivo evidence for this is still lacking, however.<br />

57

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!