einstein
einstein
einstein
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
“Bird of Passage”<br />
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN<br />
THE REFUGEE<br />
1932–1933<br />
With Winston Churchill at his home, Chartwell, 1933<br />
“Today I resolved to give up my Berlin position and shall be a bird of passage for the rest of my life,” Einstein wrote in his travel diary. “I am<br />
learning English, but it doesn’t want to stay in my old brain.” 1<br />
It was December 1931, and he was sailing across the Atlantic for a third visit to America. He was in a reflective mood, aware that the course of<br />
science might be proceeding without him and that events in his native land might again make him rootless. When a ferocious storm, far greater<br />
than any he had ever witnessed, seized his ship, he recorded his thoughts in his travel diary. “One feels the insignificance of the individual,” he<br />
wrote, “and it makes one happy.” 2<br />
Yet Einstein was still torn about whether to forsake Berlin for good. It had been his home for seventeen years, Elsa’s for even longer. Despite the<br />
challenge from Copenhagen, it was still the greatest center for theoretical physics in the world. For all of its dark political undercurrents, it remained<br />
a place where he was generally loved and revered, whether he was holding court in Caputh or taking his seat at the Prussian Academy.<br />
In the meantime, his options continued to grow. This trip to America was for another two-month visiting professorship at Caltech, which Millikan<br />
was trying to turn into a permanent arrangement. Einstein’s friends in Holland had for years also been trying to recruit him, and now so too was<br />
Oxford.<br />
Soon after he settled into his rooms at the Athenaeum, the graceful faculty club at Caltech, yet another possibility arose. One morning, he was<br />
visited there by the noted American educator Abraham Flexner, who spent more than an hour walking the cloistered courtyard with him. When Elsa<br />
found them and summoned her husband to a luncheon engagement, he waved her off.<br />
Flexner, who had helped reshape American higher education as an officer of the Rockefeller Foundation, was in the process of creating a<br />
“haven” where scholars could work without any academic pressures or teaching duties and, as he put it, “without being carried off in the maelstrom<br />
of the immediate.” 3 Funded by a $5 million donation from Louis Bamberger and his sister Caroline Bamberger Fuld, who had the good fortune to<br />
sell their department store chain just weeks before the 1929 stock market crash, it would be named the Institute for Advanced Study and located in<br />
New Jersey, probably next to (but not formally affiliated with) Princeton University, where Einstein had already spent some enjoyable time.<br />
Flexner had come to Caltech to get some ideas from Millikan, who (to his later regret) insisted he talk to Einstein. When Flexner finally set up<br />
such a meeting, he was impressed, he later wrote, with Einstein’s “noble bearing, simply charming manner, and his genuine humility.”<br />
It was obvious that Einstein would be a perfect anchor and ornament for Flexner’s new institute, but it would have been inappropriate for Flexner<br />
to make an offer on Millikan’s home turf. Instead, they agreed that Flexner would visit Einstein in Europe to discuss matters further. Flexner claimed<br />
in his autobiography that, even after their Caltech meeting, “I had no idea that he [Einstein] would be interested in being connected to the Institute.”<br />
But that was belied by the letters he wrote to his patrons at the time, in which he referred to Einstein as an “unhatched chicken” whose prospects<br />
they needed to treat circumspectly. 4<br />
By then Einstein had grown slightly disenchanted with life in southern California. When he gave a speech to an international relations group, in<br />
which he denounced arms-control compromises and advocated complete disarmament, his audience seemed to treat him as celebrity<br />
entertainment. “The propertied classes here seize upon anything that might provide ammunition in the struggle against boredom,” he noted in his<br />
diary. Elsa reflected his annoyance in a letter to a friend. “The affair was not only lacking in seriousness but was treated as a kind of social<br />
entertainment.” 5<br />
As a result, he was dismissive when his friend Ehrenfest in Leiden wrote to ask for his help in getting a job in America. “I must tell you honestly<br />
that in the long term I would prefer to be in Holland rather than in America,” Einstein replied. “Apart from the handful of really fine scholars, it is a<br />
boring and barren society that would soon make you shiver.” 6<br />
Nevertheless, on this and other topics Einstein’s mind was not a simple one. He clearly enjoyed America’s freedom, excitement, and even (yes)<br />
the celebrity status it conferred upon him. Like many others, he could be critical of America yet also attracted to it. He could recoil at its occasional<br />
displays of crassness and materialism, yet find himself powerfully drawn to the freedoms and unvarnished individuality that were on the flip side of<br />
the same coin.<br />
Soon after returning to Berlin, where the political situation had become even more unnerving, Einstein went to Oxford to give another series of<br />
lectures. Once again, he found its refined formality oppressive, especially in contrast to America. At the stultifying sessions of the governing body of