10.01.2013 Views

The_Open_Door_deel1

The_Open_Door_deel1

The_Open_Door_deel1

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

-153-<br />

only two of them referred to the same agreements (51), in<br />

other words, of the four agreements only three had eight<br />

provisions (out of thirty-eight) in common.<br />

<strong>The</strong> greatest similarity is found in the contracts with the<br />

"African Mining Partners" and the "Liberian Gold and Diamond<br />

Corporation". <strong>The</strong> agreements were very much alike as they had<br />

both been influenced by the Model Iron Ore Mining Concession<br />

Agreement. This Model Agreement had in the early 1970's been<br />

the result of an investigation of the country's concession<br />

policy by a team of experts from Harvard University, U.S.A..<br />

<strong>The</strong> realization of the exploitation of^the nation's human and<br />

natural resources by notably the iron ore mining companies<br />

had greatly contributed towards this result. <strong>The</strong> Liberians<br />

only reluctantly acknowledged this exploitation after the<br />

death of President Tubman. Illustrative of the Liberian<br />

experiences is e.g. the provision in both the concession<br />

agreements with the "African Mining Partners" and the<br />

"Liberian Gold and Diamond Corporation" concerning the<br />

conservation of natural resources:<br />

"(...) 7he Operator shall (...) Lackfill all open mines,<br />

pits, trenches, outs, and other excavations, using to<br />

the maximum extent possiLle as fill material all tailings,<br />

spoil, refuse and other originally suLierranean materials<br />

(,..); shall re-open any pre-existing natural drainage<br />

systems such as creeks, streams, Or other natural watercourses<br />

(,,.); and shall reforest and replant the areas<br />

so Lackfilled, contoured, terraced or otherwise worked<br />

with such species of vegetation as may Le indicated Ly<br />

the Government" (52).<br />

Laudable intentions which do not mean much in practice<br />

although the Government was in the same Article granted a<br />

possibility of carrying out such work at the expense of the<br />

Operator. If, however, the company had already left the<br />

country, the Government was powerless, as had become clear in<br />

the case of the liquidated damages which the African Mining<br />

Partners had to pay, after the cancellation of its agreement<br />

in 1976,<br />

Another unrealistic provision (though no judgement or<br />

statement as to the desirability of a clause concerning the<br />

transfer of technology is implied in this observation)<br />

contains Article 11,2 of both concession agreements which<br />

obliges the companies to establish and operate vocational<br />

training centers in Liberia (how many?), and to furnish<br />

on-the-job counterpart training, not only in Liberia but<br />

also outside the country (53). For a proper judgement of<br />

this obligation it may be useful to add that it was never<br />

complied with, neither (for obvious reasons) by the Liberian<br />

Gold and Diamond Corporation nor by the African Mining Partners<br />

during the three years of the latter's"operations In Liberia.<br />

Confusion may result from the formulation of the obligation to<br />

provide for free medical treatment to all employees and<br />

Government officials working in connection with the Operator's

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!