Down to the wire : confronting climate collapse / David - Index of

186 S farther horizons
• the focus should be on problems solvable at a profi t by technology
and policy changes;
• signifi cant improvement of politics, policy, and governance
are unlikely and probably irrelevant, because
• better design and market adjustments can substitute for
governmental regulation and thereby eliminate most of the
sources of political controversy.
Masquerading as optimism, this approach is, in fact, pessimistic
about our capacity to understand the truth and act nobly. So neither
we nor those who presumably lead us talk about limits to
growth, unsolvable problems, moral failings, the unequal distribution
of wealth within and between generations, emerging dangers,
impossibilities, technology gone awry, or necessary sacrifi ces.
“Realism” so diluted requires us to portray climate change as an
opportunity to make a great deal of money, which it may be for
some, but without saying that it might not be for most, not to
mention its connections to other issues, problems, and dilemmas
or the possibility that the four horsemen are gaining on us. No
American politician is supposed to talk about coming changes in
our “lifestyles,” a telling and empty word implying fashion, not
necessity or conviction.
Ultimately, this approach is condescending to those who are
presumed incapable of facing the truth and acting creatively and
courageously in dire circumstances. The idea that we may have to
give up something in order to stabilize climate is not to be spoken
by any national political leader for fear of losing public support. So
they reduce the problem to a series of wedges representing various
possibilities that would potentially eliminate so many gigatons
of carbon without any serious changes in how we live. But there
is no proposed wedge called “suck it up,” because that is believed
to be too much to ask of people who have been consuming way
too much, too carelessly, for too long. The “American way of life”
is thought to be sacrosanct. In the face of a global emergency,