06.01.2013 Views

Eng. SÎRBU CAMELIA MARIA (ALĂMOREAN) Ph D THESIS ...

Eng. SÎRBU CAMELIA MARIA (ALĂMOREAN) Ph D THESIS ...

Eng. SÎRBU CAMELIA MARIA (ALĂMOREAN) Ph D THESIS ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND<br />

VETERINARY MEDICINE<br />

CLUJ -NAPOCA<br />

AGRICULTURE FACULTY<br />

<strong>Eng</strong>. <strong>SÎRBU</strong> <strong>CAMELIA</strong> <strong>MARIA</strong> (<strong>ALĂMOREAN</strong>)<br />

<strong>Ph</strong> D <strong>THESIS</strong><br />

ABSTRACT<br />

RESEARCH REGARDING POTATO<br />

CULTIVATION IN THE BIOLOGICAL<br />

(ORGANIC) AGRICULTURE SYSTEM<br />

SCIENTIFIC COORDINATOR<br />

Univ.prof. dr. eng. GAVRILĂ MORAR<br />

CLUJ-NAPOCA<br />

2011


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

The potato, with a long and glorious history, is originally from Central and South<br />

America, where, along with corn, was one of the staple crops, which fed and sustained a<br />

thriving civilization and a stunning indigenous culture and assured the greatness of the<br />

Inca Empire. After the discovering of ”The New World” in the years 1492-1496, the<br />

potato arrived in the ”old Europe” around the year 1553, as an unknown plant, and later,<br />

managed to conquer the entire civilization.<br />

Besides wheat, maize and rice crops, the potato is widespread worldwide. The<br />

potato became a staple food for nearly all mankind, being used and appreciated not only<br />

in poor countries and areas in Asia, Africa and Latin America but also in rich and<br />

developed countries such as <strong>Eng</strong>land, Holland, Germany, France U.S. and others<br />

(IANOSI I.S., 2002).<br />

Under the auspices of large international organizations such as UN or FAO, on<br />

December 22nd , 2005, the year 2008 was declared International Year of the Potato, and<br />

the importance of the potato in the world economics is also shown by the fact that this<br />

plant is the only agricultural crop traded at the Stock Exchange on Wall Street in New<br />

York.<br />

The potato is a crop with high production potential, an equivalent area being able<br />

to produce 10-15 times more food than wheat, corn or rice.<br />

Due to the high nutritional value of potato tubers caused by the balanced content<br />

of carbohydrates, protein, fat and vitamins, to their taste and high digestibility, the potato<br />

satisfies most tastes and most diverse requirements.<br />

The potato tuber is an almost complete food, with a high content of carbohydrates<br />

(15-25%, depending on variety), protein substances and vitamins (A1, B1, B2, B3, K and<br />

especially vitamin C, which summarizes 13-23 mg/100 g dry matter), and minerals (100<br />

grams boiled tubers contain 0.5 to 2 mg assimilable iron, assimilable phosphorus 25-50<br />

mg and 6-17 mg assimilable calcium) (WIRTHS, 1968 cited by DRAICA C . et al.<br />

1996).<br />

For industry, the potato is used in producing alcohol, starch and glucose. From<br />

1000 kg of potatoes one can get 56-132 litres of alcohol or 140 kg of starch, or 240-260<br />

kg of chips, or 700-750 kg of pommes-frites. Starch can be used for producing more than<br />

1


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

700 derivatives that be used in the food, pharmaceutical, textile industries, paper<br />

production, etc. (DRAICA C., 1995).<br />

Also, the potato is used to produce bioethanol which, blended with gasoline, is<br />

considered to be the fuel of the 21st century. Starting with 2017, the European Union<br />

plans to subsidize 50% of the petrol refineries that use a mixture of gasoline and bio-<br />

ethanol made of potato or other plants such as beets and maize (http://www.zdd.ro ).<br />

For animals, the potato is considered valuable fodder, providing 26-30 UN/100g<br />

respectively 0.64 to 1.50digestible protein/ 100g. A quantity of 4 kg boiled potato is<br />

equivalent to 1 kg of barley, 0.9 kg of corn or 12 litres of whey (Ianosi IS, 2002).<br />

In agronomic terms, the potato fits very well in grain or vegetable rotation crops,<br />

which need mandatorily, as part of the rotation system, a plant which develops its yield in<br />

the soil, which breaks up the soil this way and improves its physical, chemical and<br />

biological characteristics by its own growth and development in the soil .<br />

The coordination of this scientific research, the interpretation of results and the<br />

drafting of this paper were conducted under the direction of the distinguished university<br />

professor <strong>Ph</strong>D Morar Gavrila. To him I address my most sincere gratitude and thanks for<br />

the support granted to my permanent professional and moral development.<br />

I express my gratitude and sincere thanks to <strong>Ph</strong>D professor engineer Ion Oltean for<br />

his support in the establishment and completion of the Colorado beetle control<br />

experiments.<br />

I have to address my words of thanks and consideration to the team of the<br />

<strong>Ph</strong>ytotechny Department for their support during the preparation of the thesis.<br />

I also want to thank my family for the dedication and support throughout the<br />

preparation of this work.<br />

2


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

CHAPTER I<br />

THE CONCEPT OF BIOLOGICAL (ORGANIC) AGRICULTURE AND ITS<br />

EVOLUTION<br />

Chapter I presents the causes that led to the emergence and spreading of the<br />

concept of biological (organic) agriculture in Europe and worldwide, the concept of<br />

organic agriculture and the situation of organic farming in the world and in Romania.<br />

CHAPTER II<br />

THE CURRENT STAGE OF RESEARCH ON ORGANIC POTATO<br />

PRODUCTION SYSTEM<br />

The chapter presents the current stage in the research on the biological potato<br />

production system and describes the potato cultivation technology in this system of<br />

agriculture (conversion of land, location of the potato crop, crop rotation and soil tillage,<br />

soil preparation for planting and potato planting, fertilization and maintenance works,<br />

harvesting and storage of the potato yield).<br />

CHAPTER III<br />

RESEARCH OBJECTIVES, MATERIAL AND METHOD<br />

3.1. RESEARCH OBJECTIVES<br />

The research objectives were:<br />

� The study of a range of potato varieties suitable to organic farming, and<br />

which should be characterized by:<br />

- genetic resistance to major potato diseases;<br />

- resistance to degeneration, known resistance to major potato viruses;<br />

- a reasonable production potential, able to ensure economic efficiency;<br />

- accepted by consumers.<br />

� Identification of natural fertilizers applied at the soil or foliage level to help<br />

stimulate the photosynthetic efficiency and production;<br />

� Identification and testing of natural products to control pests and diseases or<br />

other natural control products accepted in organic farming;<br />

� Control of weeds through various means other than chemical<br />

3


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

3.2. MATERIAL AND RESEARCH METHOD<br />

3.2.1. Biological material used<br />

For studying the suitability of potato varieties to organic farming, an assortment of<br />

11 varieties were considered, varieties that had been created at the Romanian National<br />

Institute of Research and Development for Potato and Sugar Beet, Brasov or at other<br />

research stations around the country, such as those in Targu Secuiesc and Miercurea<br />

Ciuc; two varieties were of Dutch origin.<br />

These cultivars were as follows: Roclas, Zamolxis(Dacia), Cumidava(Amelia),<br />

Christian, Redsec, Productiv, Tentant, Frumoasa, Robusta, Rozal, Sante, Riviera and<br />

Agata<br />

3.2.2. Materials used in research<br />

3.2.2.1. Foliar fertilizers<br />

Of all the foliar fertilizers allowed in organic farming, the following products were<br />

used, in concentrations recommended by the producing companies: Biome PLUSS,<br />

Biostar, Maxiroot, Terra Sorb, Glutaxin. The foliar fertilizers were applied at full plant<br />

growth (June, July, August), 3 times each year.<br />

3.2.2.2. Potato blight control<br />

For the potato blight control, nine natural products were tested in 2004, and 7in<br />

the next year; all products are allowed in organic farming.<br />

The treatments were applied at full plant growth, twice in 2004 and 3 times in the<br />

following year.<br />

The treatments with natural products allowed in organic farming demonstrate the<br />

possibility to extend the foliage vegetation period beyond the natural resistance limit of<br />

the variety. The products we used were: nutritive clay, whey, Bordeaux mixture,<br />

bentonite, copper oxychloride, milk without fat, copper hydroxide, clay, potassium<br />

permanganate.<br />

4


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

3.2.2.3. Colorado potato beetle control<br />

In 2004, in the experimental field of the <strong>Ph</strong>ytotechny Department, located on the<br />

Cojocna farm, two natural extracts were tested, namely those obtained from Taraxacum<br />

officinale L (dandelion) and Tagetes erecta L, with a view to analysing their repellent<br />

effect upon the adults belonging to the Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say species.<br />

For the extract obtained from Tagetes erecta L., we used powder of flowers and<br />

receptacles in a percentage of 20% active ingredients with the following solvents:<br />

propylene glycol, ethanol, ethyl acetate and water with a ratio of 1: 0.15: 0.5: 8 .<br />

For the second extract, the one from Taraxacum officinale L, we used a tincture<br />

made of fresh leaves with 20% active ingredients, and, as solvents, propylene glycol and<br />

water with a ratio of 1: 1.<br />

To test the repellent effect of these extracts, they were tested either separately<br />

(checking two concentrations for each extract) or mixed (checking two mixtures with<br />

different amounts of extract).<br />

The Solo 4 Pump was used for the treatment, applying a normal volume of<br />

solution (800 litres solution / ha), so that the applied solution would ensure full coverage<br />

of the foliar system. The effectiveness was assessed by counting the egg deposits for each<br />

variant and reporting the number to the number of treated plants. Efficacy was calculated<br />

using the following formula: E% = (1-n / N) x 100 where n = average number of egg<br />

deposits / treated and N = average number of egg deposits/control plants (no treatment).<br />

Also in 2004, different hydro-alcoholic extracts were tested in Colorado beetle<br />

larvae control. In obtaining the extracts 12 species of plants were used:<br />

� Armoracia rusticana Lam.<br />

� Artemisia abrotanum L.<br />

� Artemisia capilaris, Artemisia absinthium L.<br />

� Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev.<br />

� Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora,<br />

� Leuzea carth.<br />

� Marrubium vulgaris L.<br />

� Mentha piperita L.<br />

� Nepeta cataria var. citriodora<br />

5


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

� Ruta corsica L.<br />

� Taraxacum officinale L.;<br />

� Tagetes erecta L.<br />

For the extracts obtained from Tagetes erecta L., tested in 4 variants, we used<br />

powder of flowers and receptacles in a percentage of 20% active ingredients with the<br />

following solvents: propylene glycol, ethanol, ethyl acetate and water with a ratio of 1:<br />

0.15: 0.5: 8 .<br />

In other 4 variants we used an extract of fresh leaves of Taraxacum officinale<br />

L.,20% active ingredients, and as solvents, : propylene glycol and water, with a ratio of<br />

1 : 1.<br />

For 2 variants we used an extract of fresh leaves of Tagetes erecta, and as<br />

solvents, propylene glycol and water, with a ratio of 1 : 1.<br />

For other 20 variants, the extracts were made of herba (for each species), in a<br />

mixture of propylene glycol and water, with a ratio of 1 : 1.<br />

To assess the efficacy, the same method of calculation was applied, as the one<br />

used for repellents.<br />

In 2005 there were seven variants of vegetal extracts tested to determine their<br />

effectiveness on larvae of Colorado beetle. These were:<br />

V1 – extract of Armoracia rusticana , ratio 1:3<br />

V2- extract of Chysanthemum cinerariaefolium , ratio 1:3<br />

V3 - extract ofArtemisia abrotanum, ratio 1:3<br />

V4 - extract of Artemisia capilaris, ratio 1:3<br />

V5 - extract of Chysanthemum balsamita var. canfora, ratio 1:3<br />

V6 - extract of Marrubium vulgaris, ratio 1:3<br />

V7 - extract of Ruta corsica , ratio 1:3<br />

For further studies of Coloroado beetle control, a lab experiment was established<br />

for testing the three extracts of the most effective products on larvae of different ages.<br />

The extracts used were as follows:<br />

Extract 1 – Artemisia abrothanum – 9% in ethanol 20%<br />

Extract 2 – Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium - 9% in ethanol 20%<br />

Extract 3 – Chrysanthemum balsamita - 9% in ethanol 20%<br />

6


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Extract 4 – Armoracia rusticana<br />

3.2.3. Research methods<br />

a) The influence of foliar fertilizers and biological products used to control blight on<br />

potato yields in varieties suitable for organic farming<br />

In 2004, foliar fertilizers were applied to the 12 varieties. Also all natural products<br />

tested for blight control were applied to the 12 varieties.<br />

In 2006, 2007, 2008 we initiated systematic trifactorial research on the interaction<br />

between variety, various blight control products and foliar fertilizers respectively.<br />

Experiments have been located and calculated by the method of subdivided trials with 2<br />

and 3 factors, in four repetitions.<br />

Experiment 1. – The influence of foliar fertilizer on the yield in potato varieties<br />

suitable for organic farming with the following factors and graduations:<br />

Factor A- Experimental year, with three graduations:<br />

a1 - 2006<br />

a2 – 2007<br />

a3 - 2008<br />

Factor B – Potato cultivar suitable for organic farming, with five graduations:<br />

b1 – Robusta<br />

b2 – Rozal<br />

b3 – Redsec<br />

b4 – Amelia<br />

b5 - Productiv<br />

Factor C – Foliar fertilization, with six graduations<br />

c1 – no fertilizer<br />

c2 – Biomit pluss<br />

c3 – Biostar<br />

c4 – Maxiroot<br />

c5 – Terra Sorb<br />

c6 – Glutaxin<br />

7


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Experiment 2. – Blight control using biological products, with the following factors<br />

and graduations:<br />

Factor A – Potato cultivar suitable for organic farming, with five graduations:<br />

a1 – Robusta<br />

a2 – Rozal<br />

a3 – Redsec<br />

a4 – Amelia<br />

a5 - Productiv<br />

Factor B – Alternative products for blight control, with eight graduations:<br />

b1- no tratament<br />

b2 – Bordeaux mixture<br />

b3 – clay<br />

b4 – bentonite<br />

b5 – copper oxy-chloride<br />

b6 – copper hydroxide<br />

b7 – nutritive clay<br />

b8 – potassium permanganate<br />

The experiments were placed in 4 repetitions rigorously respecting the potato<br />

cultivation technology to highlight the experimental factors l.<br />

Blight resistance was assessed by the degree of attack of the disease on the foliage,<br />

given by the relationship between the attack intensity and the frequency of the disease.<br />

The assessment of the resistance of potato varieties to blight was done by hand marks<br />

from 1 to 9 (score 1 - very resistant to blight attack and score 9 - very sensitive).<br />

b) Weed control<br />

Out of the usual methods for weed control in organic farming, we chose to use fire.<br />

The reason was the emergence of weeds in the potato crop before the emergence of the<br />

plants, when the fire can act over the entire surface; after the emergence of potato plants,<br />

they can be protected with special shields, and the fire will be conducted among them .<br />

8


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Fig. 6. Weed control(original)<br />

We used a special tool made in the workshops of the university, designed by our<br />

team, and consisting of a cart on bicycle wheels that can move around the field directing<br />

a jet of gas from a tank located on the trolley. Weeds were observed and destroyed at<br />

various stages of development and the fire was controlled by adjusting the jet to cover the<br />

surface between the potato plants (Fig. 6)..<br />

9


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

CHAPTER IV<br />

SOIL AND CLIMATIC CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH EXPERIENCES<br />

WERE CARRIED OUT<br />

4.1. EXPERIMENTS LOCATION<br />

Over the years, experiments have been conducted in several locations: in 2004 in<br />

the experimental fields of USAMV Cluj-Napoca from Cojocna farm, and the in the<br />

experimental years 2006-2008 at the Research Station for the Culture and Development<br />

of Pastures- Jucu.<br />

Subsections 4.2, 4.3. and 4.4.present the soil and climatic conditions in which the<br />

experiments were conducted.<br />

CHAPTER V<br />

RESULTS<br />

5.1. RESULTS REGARDING THE SUITABILITY OF THE STUDIED CULTIVAR<br />

ASSORTMENT TO BIOLOGICAL AGRICULTURE<br />

5.1.1. The results regarding the suitability of a potato cultivar assortment to<br />

biological agriculture, in 2004, in Cojocna, Cluj county<br />

The main features studied for the varieties considered in this research were: total<br />

yield, the average weight of a tuber, the average number of tubers in a nest and the<br />

resistance to blight. In the first year (2004) a number of 12 varieties of potato were<br />

studied.<br />

The Romanian varieties most suitable for organic farming, in the experimental<br />

year 2004, were Robusta, Redsec, Rozalia and Amelia, which gave high yields and had a<br />

good resistance to blight. The Amelia cultivar did not score very high in what the yield is<br />

concerned, but proved to be highly resistant to blight attack, which is a particularly<br />

important feature in organic farming (Table 1)..<br />

10


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Table 1.<br />

Results of tests on the suitability of potato cultivars in organic farming (Cojocna<br />

Cultivar Yield<br />

t/ha<br />

Average<br />

weight<br />

of a<br />

tuber<br />

(g)<br />

2004)<br />

Average<br />

No. of<br />

tubers/nest<br />

03.08.2004<br />

Degree of<br />

attack<br />

(%)<br />

01.09.2004<br />

Degree of<br />

attack<br />

(%)<br />

10.09.2004<br />

Degree of<br />

attack<br />

(%)<br />

Sante 36,4 45,9 17 10 30 80<br />

Tentant 34 58,1 14 60 90 90<br />

Robusta 28,5 54,0 11 10 10 70<br />

Redsec 24,6 51,3 10 10 70 80<br />

Frumoasa 24,4 52,4 10 50 90 90<br />

Rozal 21,7 57,4 8 10 30 80<br />

Roclas 17,6 50,3 7 80 90 90<br />

Agatha 17,2 54,2 7 90 90 90<br />

Amelia 16,7 49,6 7 10 30 80<br />

Dacia 13,2 34,3 8 20 90 90<br />

Christian 9,5 24,1 8 40 90 90<br />

Riviera 8,8 41,4 5 90 90 90<br />

10-30% – blight rezistant; 40-60% – blight rezistant; 60-90% – blight rezistant;<br />

5.1.5. The results regarding the suitability of a local potato cultivar assortment to<br />

biological agriculture, the average of years 2006-2008<br />

Experimental years 2006-2007-2008 were close in terms of friendliness to potato<br />

crops and similar from the climatic point of view. The obtained yields are similar<br />

between the three experimental years (Table 2), oscillating around 35-36 t / ha, with<br />

insignificant yield differences.<br />

The influence of experimental years on yield<br />

Table 2<br />

Year Yield(t/ha) % Difference Significance Duncan Test<br />

1. 2006 35,55 100,0 0.00 Mt. A<br />

2. 2007 35,56 100,0 0,01 - A<br />

3. 2008 34,68 97,5 -87 - A<br />

DL(p 5%) 1,47<br />

DL(p 1%) 2,23<br />

DL(p 0,1%) 3,58<br />

As an average over the three experimental years, the tested potato cultivars (Table<br />

3). can be grouped into two categories: the first category, represented by Robusta and<br />

11


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Rozal cultivars, are varieties with less potential for high yields but more suitable to<br />

organic farming as a result of their higher resistance to blight, and the second category<br />

comprising the varieties with higher production potential (Redsec, Amelia and<br />

Productiv), which in the experimental years have exceeded the Robusta cultivar,<br />

considered as a control, by13 to 20% . These cultivars - Redsec, Amelia and Productiv<br />

gave significantly higher yields, over the three years, as compared with the Robusta<br />

variety, the differences being validated by statistical calculation performed through the<br />

multiple comparison test (Duncan).<br />

Table 3.<br />

The behaviour of the potato cultivars in the three experimental years<br />

Cultivar Yield(t/ha) % Difference Significance Duncan Test<br />

1. Robusta 32,20 100,0 0.00 Mt. A<br />

2. Rozal 31,48 97,8 -0,71 - A<br />

3. Redesec 38,63 120,0 6,44 *** B<br />

4. Amelia 36,57 113,6 4,38 *** B<br />

5. Productiv 37,44 116,3 5,25 *** B<br />

DL(p 5%) 2,15<br />

DL(p 1%) 2,88<br />

DL(p 0,1%) 3,80<br />

In the interaction experimental year x variety suitable to organic farming there are<br />

a variety of different behaviours of the cultivars over the experimental years (Table 4).<br />

Whereas in 2006 the varieties were almost equal to each other from the point of view of<br />

their yields, except for the Rozal cultivar which had a very strong decrease expressed by<br />

significant negative differences, in 2007 and 2008 all cultivars exceeded the variety<br />

Robusta , which was considered as a control. There seems to be an inverse correlation,<br />

which also occurs in the case of other crops such as wheat, corn, beets, etc., between<br />

production and quality. While the Robusta cultivar proved to be the most suitable variety<br />

for organic farming in terms of resistance to blight, its yields were lower than the other<br />

tested cultivars, considering the mean of the three years.<br />

12


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Tuber production in the interaction experimental year x cultivar<br />

Year Cultivar Yield<br />

(t/ha)<br />

% Difference<br />

(t)<br />

Significance Duncan<br />

Test<br />

2006 Robusta 36,91 100,0 0,00 Mt. DEF<br />

Rozal 28,14 76,2 -8,78 000 A<br />

Redsec 37,85 102,6 0,94 - EF<br />

Amelia 37,29 101,0 0,38 - EF<br />

Productiv 37,58 101,8 0,66 - EF<br />

2007 Robusta 30,10 100,0 0,00 Mt. AB<br />

Rozal 31,54 104,8 1,44 - ABC<br />

Redsec 38,19 126,9 8,09 *** EF<br />

Amelia 39,53 131,3 9,43 *** F<br />

Productiv 38,44 127,7 8,33 *** EF<br />

2008 Robusta 29,57 100,0 0,00 Mt. AB<br />

Rozal 34,77 117,6 5,20 ** CDE<br />

Redsec 39,85 134,8 10,28 *** F<br />

Amelia 32,90 111,3 3,33 - BCD<br />

Productiv 36,31 122,8 6,74 *** DEF<br />

DL (p 5%) 3,73<br />

DL (p 1%) 5,00<br />

DL (p 0,1%) 6,59<br />

5.2. 1 RESULTS ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF NATURAL FOLIAR<br />

FERTILIZERS ON THE YIELD OF POTATO CULTIVARS<br />

Table 4.<br />

5.2.1 Results on the effectiveness of natural foliar fertilizers on the yield of potato<br />

cultivars, in 2004, in Cojocna, Cluj county<br />

. The way in which the foliar fertilizers influenced the yield of the year 2004 is<br />

shown in Table 5.<br />

Unfertilized cultivars reacted differently, by variable production increases, to<br />

foliar fertilizer application, and some even had a production decrease, most likely<br />

because of a metabolic block in the synthesis of starch, which is the case of the Sante<br />

cultivar, which reacted negatively to most foliar fertilization variants . Other varieties<br />

reacted positively to all products, such as Rozal, Dacia, Amelia, Riviera and Christian.<br />

These varieties are distinguished by statistically assured production increases, in most<br />

13


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

cases of foliar fertilization with the products used in our research. Except for Riviera, all<br />

cultivars are creations of the research activity in our country, which gives them an added<br />

advantage in the production of seed for potato organic production.<br />

In the new view upon the way of action of foliar fertilizers, they are assumed to<br />

have a big role in collecting the nutrients from the soil through increased absorption of<br />

mineral elements. From this point of view, the different cultivars may have a different<br />

response to foliar fertilization, as the genotype has or not a developed root system, or a<br />

higher/lower capacity of absorption of the nutrients in the soil.<br />

Among the tested varieties, we particularly noted the Rozal cultivar (in which<br />

production is significantly stimulated by four of the five tested foliar fertilizers), as well<br />

as the Amelia, Dacia, Riviera and Christian cultivars.<br />

14


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Cultivar Control Var.2<br />

The influence of the foliar fertilizers on the yield of the tested varieties (t/ha) (Cojocna 2004 )<br />

Terra-<br />

Diff. to the<br />

control<br />

Var.3<br />

Glutaxin<br />

Diff. to<br />

the<br />

Var.4<br />

Maxiroot<br />

Diff. to<br />

the<br />

Var.5<br />

Biostar<br />

Diff. to<br />

the<br />

Var.6<br />

Amalgerol<br />

Sorb<br />

control<br />

control<br />

control<br />

control<br />

Tentant 34 33,5 -0,5 35,1 +1,1 38 +4 40,2 +6,2 30,3 -3,7<br />

Table5.<br />

Diff. to<br />

the<br />

Frumoasa 24,4 24,9 +0,5 21,1 -3,3 27,3 +2,9 17,2 -7,2 29,7 +5,3<br />

Robusta 28,5 26,0 -2,5 21,4 -7,1 29,9 +1,4 30,9 +2,4 36 +7,5 *<br />

Rozal 21,7 30,4 +8,7 *<br />

27,2 +5,5 39,3 +17,6 **<br />

39,3 +17,6 **<br />

Redsec 24,6 29,2 +4,6 30,9 +6,3 28 +3,4 39 +14,4 **<br />

34,3 +12,6 *<br />

48,7 +24,1 **<br />

Roclas 17,6 14,0 -3,6 12,3 -5,3 12,6 -5 19 +1,4 21,3 +3,7<br />

Dacia 13,2 19,6 +6,4 24,6 +11,4 *<br />

21,3 +8,1 *<br />

26,1 +12,9 *<br />

27,8 +14,6 **<br />

Amelia 16,7 24,5 +7,8 *<br />

29,6 +12,9 *<br />

21,6 +5,6 25 +8,3 *<br />

24 +7,3 *<br />

Agatha 17,2 20,7 +3,5 19,6 +2,4 24,2 +7 20,4 +3,2 21,2 +4<br />

Riviera 8,8 21,2 +12,4 *<br />

13,1 +4,3 16,1 +7,3 *<br />

19,5 +10,7 *<br />

16,2 +7,4 *<br />

Sante 36,4 35,7 -0,7 34,4 -2 26 -10,4 0<br />

Christian 9,5 21,8 +12,3 *<br />

DL 5%=7,3<br />

DL1%=13,5<br />

DL0,1%=25,4<br />

25 +15,5 **<br />

15<br />

14,2 +4,7 23,5 +14 **<br />

37,8 +1,4 25,3 -11,1 0<br />

22,6 +13,1 *


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

5.2.2 Results on the effectiveness of natural foliar fertilizers on the yield of potato<br />

cultivars, the average of years 2006-2008, in Jucu, Cluj county<br />

As a result of the statistical calculations performed on the tuber yields resulting<br />

from the three years’ experiments in which different foliar fertilizer were applied to<br />

unfertilized potato plants, we noted very significant positive production differences. The<br />

production increases are between 3.79 and 5.71 t / ha or up to 18%, as compared with the<br />

unfertilized variant (Table 6)..<br />

Of the tested foliar fertilizers, Terra-Sorb stands out with significant differences as<br />

compared to Glutaxin, while the differences between the other foliar fertilizers are not<br />

significant, according to the Duncan test.<br />

Table 6.<br />

The influence of the foliar fertilizers on the tuber yield -Jucu, 2006-2008<br />

Foliar<br />

fertilizer<br />

Yield(t/ha) % Difference Significance Duncan Test<br />

no fertilizer 31,35 100,0 0,00 Mt. A<br />

Biomit 36,33 115,9 4,98 *** BC<br />

Biostar 36,10 115,2 4,75 *** BC<br />

Maxiroot 35,61 113,6 4,26 *** BC<br />

Terra Sorb 37,06 118,2 5,71 *** C<br />

Glutaxin 35,14 112,1 3,79 *** B<br />

DL(p 5%) 1,64<br />

DL(p 1%) 2,16<br />

DL(p 0,1%) 2,78<br />

Analyzing the average response of all tested potato cultivars, we noticed that there<br />

is a relationship of interdependence between some foliar fertilizers and the experimental<br />

year (Table 7). From this point of view, the year 2007 proved itself to be the most<br />

favourable one for applying this type of fertilizers; most variants gave very significant<br />

positive production differences, except for Glutaxin, for which the differences were<br />

distinctively significant positive.(<strong>CAMELIA</strong> <strong>SÎRBU</strong> et al, 2010).<br />

Production increases between 14 and 23% or 4.1 to 7.0 t / ha are worthy of<br />

consideration in any potato culture. In the experimental years 2006 and 2008, although<br />

production gains were achieved with all foliar fertilizers, the potato reacted differently,<br />

16


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

some fertilizers being more effective in 2006, others in 2008. However, what is a fact is<br />

that the natural foliar fertilizers allowed in organic farming can be an important source of<br />

production growth.<br />

Table 7.<br />

The influence of the foliar fertilizers on the tuber yields in the three experimental<br />

years<br />

Year Foliar Yield % Difference Significance Duncan<br />

treatment (t/ha)<br />

(t)<br />

Test<br />

2006 No fertilizer 32.16 100.0 0.00 Mt. ABC<br />

Biomit 35.33 110 3.17 * CDEFG<br />

Biostar 35.53 111 3.37 * DEFG<br />

Maxiroot 36.07 112 3.91 ** DEFG<br />

Terra Sorb 36.27 113 4.11 ** EFG<br />

Glutaxin 37.96 118 5.80 *** FG<br />

2007 No fertilizer 30.35 100.0 0.00 Mt. A<br />

Biomit 37.42 123 7.06 *** EFG<br />

Biostar 36.35 120 6.18 *** EFG<br />

Maxiroot 36.25 119 5.90 *** EFG<br />

Terra Sorb 38.26 126 7.91 ***<br />

G<br />

Glutaxin 34.54 114 4.19 ** BCDEF<br />

2008 No fertilizer 31.53 100.0 0.00 Mt. AB<br />

Biomit 36.24 115 4.71 ** EFG<br />

Biostar 36.25 115 4.71 ** EFG<br />

Maxiroot 34.50 109 2.97 * BCDE<br />

Terra Sorb 36.65 116 5.12 *** EFG<br />

Glutaxin 32.91 104 1.37 - ABCD<br />

DL (p 5%) 2.84<br />

DL (p 1%) 3.75<br />

DL (p 0,1%) 4.81<br />

In the interaction cultivar x foliar treatment, in the three experimental years (Table<br />

8.), the Robusta cultivar gave production increases with very significant differences as<br />

compared to the control when the Biostar fertilizer was applied, whereas, when the<br />

Biomit and Terra Sorb fertilizers were used, the differences were distinctively significant.<br />

When applying Glutaxin and Maxiroot, the yields were close to the unfertilized variant,<br />

the differences being of 1.30 t / ha, respectively 3.32 t / ha.<br />

17


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Table 8.<br />

The influence of the foliar fertilizers on the tuber yields in experimental cultivars<br />

Cultivar Foliar Yield % Difference Significance Duncan Test<br />

Treatment (t/ha)<br />

(t)<br />

ROBUSTA No fertilizer 28.55 100.0 0.00 Mt. A<br />

Biomit 33.77 118 5.21 ** BCDEFG<br />

Biostar 35.18 123 6.62 *** DEFGHIJ<br />

Maxiroot 29.85 105 1.30 - AB<br />

Terra Sorb 33.96 119 5.41 ** BCDEFGH<br />

Glutaxin 31.87 112 3.32 - ABCDE<br />

ROZAL No fertilizer 28.39 100.0 0.00 Mt. A<br />

Biomit 32.09 113 3.70 * ABCDEF<br />

Biostar 30.16 106 1.77 - ABC<br />

Maxiroot 30.04 106 1.65 - AB<br />

Terra Sorb 34.48 122 6.09 ** CDEFGH<br />

Glutaxin 33.72 119 5.32 ** BCDEFG<br />

REDSEC No fertilizer 35.05 100.0 0.00 Mt. DEFGHIJ<br />

Biomit 42.97 123 7.92 *** M<br />

Biostar 37.80 108 2.75 - GHIJKL<br />

Maxiroot 37.87 108 2.85 - GHIJKL<br />

Terra Sorb 39.16 112 4.11 *<br />

IJKLM<br />

Glutaxin 38.95 111 3.90 * IJKLM<br />

AMELIA No fertilizer 33.62 100.0 0.00 Mt. BCDEFG<br />

Biomit 35.72 106 2.10 - EFGHIJ<br />

Biostar 35.28 105 1.66 - DEFGHIJ<br />

Maxiroot 40.18 120 6.56 *** KLM<br />

Terra Sorb 38.29 114 4.67 * HIJKL<br />

Glutaxin 36.35 108 2.72 - FGHIJK<br />

PRODUCTIV Nefertilizat 31.13 100.0 0.00 Mt. ABCD<br />

Biomit 37.09 119 5.96 ** GHIJK<br />

Biostar 42.10 135 10.97 *** LM<br />

Maxiroot 40.11 129 8.98 *** KLM<br />

Terra Sorb 39.42 127 8.29 *** JKLM<br />

Glutaxin 34.80 119 3.67 * DEFGHI<br />

DL (p 5%) 3.67<br />

DL (p 1%) 4.84<br />

DL (p 0,1%) 6.21<br />

The yields of the Rozal cultivar gave distinctively significant positive differences<br />

as compared to the control in the variants treated with Terra Sorb and Glutaxin, while in<br />

the variant treated with Biomit the differences were significant positive.<br />

18


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

The Redsec cultivar responded positively to the treatment with Biomit where the<br />

difference from the unfertilized variant was 7.92 t / ha, while in the case of Glutaxin and<br />

Terra Sorb, the differences from controls were 4.11 t / ha, respectively 3.90 t / ha.<br />

While the variants of Amelia cultivar on which fertilizers Biome, Biostar and<br />

Glutaxin were applied provided yields that were close to the unfertilized variant, with<br />

insignificant differences, the variants treated with Maxiroot and Terra Sorb gave yields<br />

with very significant, respectively significant differences to the control (Table 8).<br />

The Productiv cultivar is the only variety that accumulated production increases<br />

with foliar fertilizer application, the differences in production from the unfertilized<br />

variant ranging betweenn 3.67 t / ha and 10.97 t / ha.<br />

In conclusion, in the interaction variety x foliar treatment, the results of the three<br />

experimental years describe the Productiv cultivar as the most responsive to all foliar<br />

treatments (Table 8). The most effective products were found to be Biomit, with<br />

significant production gains in Robusta, Rozal Redsec and Productiv cultivars, and also<br />

Terra Sorb, in all the tested varieties.<br />

5.3. RESULTS ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF SOME BLIGHT CONTROL<br />

NATURAL PRODUCTS<br />

Regarding blight control based on products supported by organic farming, the<br />

results were inconsistent from year to year and from variety to variety. However, some<br />

products should be taken into consideration for their effectiveness, namely those<br />

containing copper: the Bordeaux mixture, the copper oxy-chloride and the copper<br />

hydroxide.<br />

The cultivars in which the action of the Bordeaux mixture could not be clearly<br />

defined were Tentant, Agata şi Rivera (Fig. 7.). For all the other cultivars, the blight<br />

attack dicreased with 4 to 20% in comparison with the untreated control.<br />

19


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Gradul de atac (%)/Attack degree(%)<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Tentant<br />

Frumoasa<br />

Robusta<br />

Rozal<br />

Redsec<br />

Roclas<br />

Dacia<br />

Amelia<br />

Soiul/Variety Martor/Control<br />

Agata<br />

Riviera<br />

Fig.7. Blight control using Bordeaux mixture<br />

Sante<br />

Christian<br />

In the variant in which copper oxy-chloride was applied, only three cultivars had a<br />

significant positive reaction to the control, namely the Roclas cultivar, where the degree<br />

of attack decreased by 20% compared to the control and the Tentant and Robusta<br />

cultivars, where the degree of attack decreased by 10% compared to the untreated<br />

version. The other varieties had either a reaction with very close values to the control, or<br />

a neutral reaction (Fig. 8).<br />

Gradul de atac(%)/Attack degree(%)<br />

50<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Tentant<br />

Frumoasa<br />

Robusta<br />

Rozal<br />

Redsec<br />

Roclas<br />

Dacia<br />

Amelia<br />

Soiul/Variety Martor/Control<br />

Agata<br />

Riviera<br />

Fig. 8. Blight control using copper oxy-chloride<br />

Sante<br />

Christian<br />

In variant 8, where the treatment with copper hydroxide was applied, the cultivars<br />

that displayed a lower degree of blight attack were Tentant, Robusta, Roclas and Agata<br />

where it decreased by 10% compared to the control and the cultivars Riviera, Sante and<br />

20


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Chiristian, which had a neutral reaction to the effect of copper hydroxide.(Fig. 9). The<br />

highest decrease of attack occurred in the variety Dacia, where it decreased by 20%<br />

compared to the untreated version.<br />

Gradul de atac(%)/Attack degree(%)<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Tentant<br />

Frumoasa<br />

Robusta<br />

Rozal<br />

Redsec<br />

Roclas<br />

Dacia<br />

Amelia<br />

Soiul/Variety Martor/Control<br />

Agata<br />

Riviera<br />

Fig. 9. Blight control using copper hydroxide<br />

5.4 RESULTS REGARDING THE EFFECT OF NATURAL EXTRACTS IN<br />

COLORADO BEETLE (LEPTINOTARSA DECEMLINEATA SAY)<br />

CONTROL<br />

Sante<br />

Christian<br />

5.4.1. Results on the repellent effect of plant extracts on adult Colorado potato<br />

beetle, Cojocna 2004<br />

In order to analyse the possibility to control the Colorado Beetle by using natural<br />

plant extracts, a number of six products, in different concentrations were tested in 2004 in<br />

our experimental fields. The results are being presented in the following section.<br />

The results describing the effectiveness of the plant extracts in reducing the egg<br />

deposits laid by the Colorado beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say.,on the potato leaf,<br />

are presented in Table 9.<br />

In the control variant, untreated when the first egg deposits were laid, the average<br />

number of deposits was 1.5789/plant (with a minimum of 1.21egg deposits/plant at the<br />

third repetition and a maximum of 1.87 deposits /plant at the first repetition)<br />

In the variants that used extracts obtained from L. offinale Taraxacum (dandelion)<br />

and Tagetes erecta L. , alone or in combination, the efficacy in reducing the egg deposits<br />

21


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

of the Colorado beetle adults ranged from 46.74 % to 87.78%. These variants were<br />

reported to display between 0.8407 and 0.1930 egg deposits / plant.<br />

Table 9<br />

The efficacy of plant extracts in reducing the egg deposits of the Colorado beetle,<br />

Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say., Cojocna 2004<br />

Nr.<br />

Var.<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

4<br />

5<br />

6<br />

7<br />

Extract Conc.<br />

%<br />

Tagetes<br />

erecta<br />

Tagetes<br />

erecta<br />

Tagetes<br />

erecta +<br />

Taraxacum<br />

offinale<br />

Tagetes<br />

erecta +<br />

Taraxacum<br />

offinale<br />

Taraxacum<br />

offinale<br />

Taraxacum<br />

offinale<br />

Martor<br />

netratat<br />

12,50<br />

25,00<br />

5+5<br />

7+7<br />

12,50<br />

25,00<br />

-<br />

No.<br />

rep.<br />

Pl/<br />

Rep.<br />

Egg<br />

dep./<br />

rep.<br />

1 12 4<br />

2 15 6<br />

3 13 9<br />

4 12 9<br />

1 14 6<br />

2 11 3<br />

3 14 5<br />

4 10 6<br />

1 11 6<br />

2 12 10<br />

3 12 13<br />

4 9 8<br />

1 17 5<br />

2 18 4<br />

3 16 2<br />

4 11 6<br />

1 11 12<br />

2 14 4<br />

3 13 12<br />

4 12 5<br />

1 15 0<br />

2 16 3<br />

3 14 5<br />

4 12 3<br />

1 15 28<br />

2 14 25<br />

3 14 17<br />

4 14 20<br />

Pl./<br />

var.<br />

52<br />

49<br />

44<br />

62<br />

50<br />

57<br />

57<br />

Egg<br />

deposits/<br />

var.<br />

28<br />

20<br />

37<br />

17<br />

33<br />

11<br />

90<br />

Av. no. of<br />

egg<br />

deposits/pl<br />

0,5385<br />

0,4082<br />

0,8409<br />

0,2742<br />

0,6600<br />

0,1930<br />

1,5789<br />

E<br />

%<br />

65,89<br />

74,15<br />

46,74<br />

82,62<br />

5,19<br />

87,78<br />

In conclusion, plant extracts may be an alternative in the Colorado beetle control<br />

in potato crops, especially in fields in which production is expected to be organic. The<br />

extracts obtained from L. offinale Taraxacum (dandelion). and Tagetes erecta L. have a<br />

repellent effect on adults, which avoid to lay eggs on plants treated with these extracts.<br />

22<br />

0


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

The use of these extracts in combination may provide a synergy effect, which can<br />

increase the repellent effect.<br />

5.4.2. Results on the effect of hydro alcoholic extracts on Colorado potato beetle<br />

larvae, Cojocna 2004<br />

In controlling the Colorado beetle, we tested several plant extracts known to be<br />

potentially active on the larvae. The results describing the efficacy of these plant extracts<br />

in fighting the larvae of the species Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say. are given in Table<br />

10.<br />

The efficacy of plant extracts in controlling the Colorado beetle<br />

(Cojocna, 2004)<br />

Nr.<br />

Extract Concentration Larvae Efficacy %<br />

Var.<br />

% /plant<br />

1 Tagetes erecta L. 12,5 23,40 7,14<br />

2 Tagetes erecta L. 25 6,50 74,20<br />

3 Tagetes erecta L.+ Taraxacum officinale L. 5 + 5 20,00 20,64<br />

4 Tagetes erecta L.+ Taraxacum officinale L. 7 + 7 16,40 34,92<br />

5 Taraxacum officinale L. 12,5 13,40 46,83<br />

6 Taraxacum officinale L. 25 13,83 45,12<br />

7 Tagetes erecta L. 12,5 8,40 66,67<br />

8 Tagetes erecta L. 25 7,00 72,22<br />

9 Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. 10 6,50 74,21<br />

10 Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. 20 0,25 99,01<br />

11 Artemisia abrotanum L. 10 5,00 80,16<br />

12 Artemisia abrotanum L. 20 3,00 88,10<br />

13 Armoracia rusticana Lam. 10 6,66 73,57<br />

14 Armoracia rusticana Lam. 20 4,00 84,13<br />

15 Ruta corsica L. 10 8,75 65,28<br />

16 Ruta corsica L. 20 0,80 96,83<br />

17 Nepeta cataria var. citriodora 10 5,00 80,16<br />

18 Nepeta cataria var. citriodora 20 5,20 79,37<br />

19 Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora 10 7,50 70,24<br />

20 Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora 20 1,75 93,06<br />

21 Artemisia absinthium L. 10 19,00 24,60<br />

22 Leuzea carth. (herba) 10 5,60 77,78<br />

23 Leuzea carth. (herba) 20 6,40 74,60<br />

24 Artemisia capilaris 10 4,25 83,13<br />

25 Artemisia capilaris 20 3,80 84,92<br />

26 Marrubiumvulgaris L. 10 6,83 72,90<br />

27 Marrubium vulgaris L. 20 3,80 84,92<br />

28 Mentha piperita L. 10 6,75 73,21<br />

29 Martor netratat - 25,20 -<br />

23<br />

Table 10.


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

For the untreated control variant, the average number of larvae/plant was 25.2. In<br />

the variants where plant extracts made from Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev.<br />

Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora and Ruta corsica were used in a concentration of<br />

20%, the efficacy of the treatment was over 90% (99.01%; 93.06% and respectively<br />

96.83%). These efficacy rates are comparable to those obtained in the case of synthetic<br />

insecticides. In these variants the number of larvae/plant was between între 0.25 and 1.75,<br />

values that are below the economic damage threshold. When the same extracts were used<br />

in a concentration of 10%, the efficacy was 74.21% (6.5 larvae/plant), 70.24% (7.5<br />

larvae/plant) and respectively 65.28% (8.75 larvae/ plant). Also, at this concentration of<br />

the extract, older larvae, that were already on the plant when the treatment was applied,<br />

survived. Younger larvae, as well as those hatched after the application of the treatment<br />

were seriously affected (<strong>CAMELIA</strong> <strong>SÎRBU</strong> et all., 2004).<br />

For other extracts, the efficacy ranged between 80 –90% and, by repeated<br />

application, these extracts may provide acceptable results in obtaining ecological crops:<br />

Armoracia rusticana Lam. 20% (efficacy of 84.13%), Artemisia abrotanum L. 10% or<br />

20% (efficacy between 80.16 % and 88.10%), Artemisia capilaris, 10% or 20% (efficacy<br />

between 83.13% and 84.92%), Marrubium vulgaris L. 20% (efficacy of 84.92%) and<br />

Nepeta cataria var. citriodora with an efficacy of 80.16%.<br />

5.4.3. Results on the effect of hydro alcoholic extracts to control the Colorado potato<br />

beetle, Cojocna 2005<br />

In this year we tested extracts obtained from seven plants (Chrysanthemum<br />

cinerariaefolium Trev., Artemisia abrotanum L., Armoracia rusticana Lam., Ruta<br />

corsica L., Chrysanthemum balsamita var. Canfora, Artemisia capilaris şi Marrubium<br />

vulgaris L.)(Table 11.).<br />

For the untreated control variant, the average number of larvae/plant was 31.4.<br />

After applying a treatment based on plant extracts, the number of larvae decreased in all<br />

experimental variants, to values ranging between 5.25 (for Chrysanthemum<br />

cinerariaefolium Trev.) and 9.25 (for Marrubium vulgaris L.), which means decrease<br />

percentages of 70.5% and 83.3%.<br />

24


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

If we compare experimental data obtained this year with the previous year, the<br />

conclusion that can be drawn is that the use of these vegetal products to combat the<br />

larvae of Leptinotarsa decemlineata can significantly reduce the population of larvae.<br />

Since the use of plant extracts at the concentration of the previous year requires too much<br />

plant material (the previous year the proportion was 1: 1, which makes the method<br />

difficult to apply, this year we reduced the concentration of plant extract at a ratio of 1: 3.<br />

This decrease in concentration caused a decrease in the efficacy of biological plant<br />

extracts. Thus, for example, the effectiveness of Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium<br />

Trev.în previous year was 99.01% (the best of experimental variants of 2004), and this<br />

year it decreased to 83.3%. For Marrubium vulgaris L. the efficacy of the previous year<br />

was 84.92%, and this year, by reducing the concentration of the extract, the efficacy went<br />

down to 70.5%.<br />

It is admitted that the efficacy of these products is strongly influenced by<br />

fluctuations in climatic factors (temperature, solar light and radiation), which can also<br />

have had an impact on the differences of effectiveness between the two experimental<br />

years.<br />

The efficacy of plant extracts in controlling the Colorado beetle, 2005<br />

No.<br />

Extract Concentratio Larvae Efficacy<br />

Var.<br />

n /plant %<br />

1 Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. 1 : 3 5,25 83,3<br />

2 Artemisia abrotanum L. 1 : 3 7,75 75,3<br />

3 Armoracia rusticana Lam. 1 : 3 8,75 72,1<br />

4 Ruta corsica L. 1 : 3 6,25 80,0<br />

5 Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora 1 : 3 6,50 79,3<br />

6 Artemisia capilaris 1 : 3 8,50 72,9<br />

7 Marrubium vulgaris L. 1 : 3 9,25 70,5<br />

8 Martor netratat - 31,40 -<br />

Table 11<br />

The extracts from Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. and Chrysanthemum<br />

balsamita var. canfora have a strong lethal effect in all variants. In variant 3, a 100%<br />

mortality of larvae was reported (Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora, at a ratio of de<br />

1:1), and in variant 2, the larval mortality was 95% (Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium<br />

Trev. at a ratio of 1 :1).<br />

25


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

The plant extracts from Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. obtained in<br />

propylene glycol (variants 9 and 10), although causing high mortality rate of larvae, still<br />

cannot be used, because of the phenomenon of phytotoxicity on treated plants.<br />

5.5. RESULTS REGARDING WEEDS CONTROL BY USING FIRE<br />

Among the known methods for weed control, the most common are: mechanical<br />

and manual hoeing, weeding, solarization, sowing simulation, etc., described in the<br />

introductory part of the thesis.<br />

One of modern methods for weed control in organic farming and applied more and<br />

more frequently in all potato producing countries is the use of fire.<br />

Most usually, potato crops in organic farming systems are weeded by the seed<br />

reserves in the manure used as main fertilizer.<br />

Using a device designed by us and manufactured in the didactic workshops of<br />

USAMV Cluj-Napoca, we experimented weed control in the field. The device uses liquid<br />

propane as a heat source and distributed in commercial tanks. The tanks are placed on a<br />

mobile cart on bicycle wheels that can be pulled among the rows and can be adjusted to<br />

the potato planting distance.<br />

By developing a culture system based on ”earthing up” the plant, we tried to<br />

protect the plants grown on the ridge of the ”hills” by creating a cone-shaped shield that<br />

directs the flame jet among the rows, thus protecting the leaves. Weed control by using<br />

fire can be done all over the surface of the crop before the emergence of potato plants,<br />

and after they grow, the device can be only used among the rows.<br />

Unlike the application of herbicides, when fire control is applied, weeds are<br />

affected totally regardless of the species. Destruction of weeds occurs by the action of<br />

high temperatures on cells, which explode by expansion of the water in them. The effect<br />

is immediate, visible in 15-20 min. and the weeds are irreversibly destroyed..<br />

In our experiments, the weeds were destroyed by using fire at a cotyledonal stage+<br />

one-two leaves (Fig.9), while at a more advanced stage we used the device among the<br />

26


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

rows, with the protection shield on(Fig. 10). The effect was total in both cases, the results<br />

being similar to those of manual hoeing (Fig. 11 and Fig. 12).<br />

Potato plants were affected to a lesser extent, and mainly on basal leaves that were<br />

already in an advanced stage of maturation, with early yellowing.<br />

The species of weeds we identified in the experimental field were: Convolvulus<br />

arvensis, Cirsium arvense, Symphytium officinale, Sonchus arvensis, Echinochloa crus-<br />

galli, Setaria glauca, Melandrium album, Poligonum convolvulus, Matricaria innodora,<br />

Cicorium intibus, Chenopodium album, Daucus carota. Among these, the dominant ones<br />

weret: Convolvulus arvensis, Cirsium arvense and Poligonum convolvulus. No species<br />

survived and none regenerated.<br />

Fig. 11. The effect of using fire for weed control (original)<br />

27


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

Fig. 12. The effect of using fire for weed control (original)<br />

28


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

CONCLUSIONS<br />

� Biological (organic) agriculture ensures healthy products without any toxic<br />

compounds, residues, pollutants or heavy metals;<br />

� From the Romanian national heritage we selected Robusta, Redsec, Rozalia and<br />

Amelia cultivars at the first stage, then completed the list by adding the Productiv<br />

cultivar, well- known for its high production potential and resistance to blight and<br />

viruses;<br />

� All the cultivars selected as suitable for organic farming provided, all over the<br />

research period, high yields (30 to 40 t / ha) and a high natural resistance to blight,<br />

with a degree of attack in early September between 20 and 65%, the Robusta<br />

variety proving to be the most resistant;<br />

� On average, for the three experimental years, the tested cultivars can be grouped<br />

into two categories: one comprising the varieties with medium production<br />

potential, such as Robusta and Rozal, but more favorable in terms of suitability to<br />

organic farming because of their natural resistance to blight, and another group<br />

that is made of Redsec, Amelia and Productiv with higher production potential and<br />

acceptable resistance to blight until early August;<br />

� With great consistency in production were noted the Redsec and Productiv<br />

varieties, known for their ecological plasticity, which makes them more valuable<br />

for the biological production system. Even though these varieties have some<br />

sensitivity to blight, their sustainability for organic production comes from the fact<br />

that blight can be controlled by using copper-based products, which are accepted<br />

in organic farming;<br />

� The reaction of the cultivars to foliar fertilization is different and this is<br />

determined by the role of the foliar fertilizers which, according to a new concept<br />

seem to stimulate the absorption of mineral elements from the soil, depending on<br />

the absorption capacity of the root system of each variety separately. This explains<br />

why some products have different effects on foliar different varieties;<br />

� Natural foliar fertilizers are an important source of production growth. The yield<br />

gain, as compared to the unfertilized control, can reach, in favourable years, 7 to<br />

10 t / ha;<br />

29


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

� In the interaction variety x foliar treatment, the results obtained over the three-year<br />

experiment show that Productiv is the most responsive cultivar to all foliar<br />

treatments. The most effective products were found to be Biomit, with significant<br />

increases in Robusta, Rozal, Redsec and Productiv, as well as Terra Sorb , with<br />

increases in all experimented varieties;<br />

� Natural foliar fertilizers influence the average tuber weight positively, with weight<br />

increases up to 18%. From this perspective the most effective proved to be Biomit<br />

and Biostar;<br />

� The research conducted for two years revealed the fact that the best cultivars were<br />

Robusta, Redsec, Amelia and Rozal, while, among the used products, the most<br />

effective ones were the Bordeaux mixture and the copper hydroxide, which can<br />

maintain foliage in vegetation for up to 60-70 days (August 1st);<br />

� The plant extracts obtained from the species Tagetes erecta and Taraxacum<br />

officinale, simple or mixed, in concentrations of 5, 12 or 25% can be an alternative<br />

control of Colorado beetles. These products showed repellent effects on adults,<br />

which avoid laying eggs on treated plants.<br />

� Using these natural extracts in combination, the repellent effect can be enhanced<br />

by synergistic action of both extracts;<br />

� The best results in controlling the larvae of the Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say.<br />

species were obtained by using the hydro-alcoholic extracts of Chrysanthemum<br />

cinerariaefolium Trev., Chrysanthemum balsamita var. canfora and Ruta corsica,<br />

all in concentrations of 20%.The efficacy of the treatment was 93 to 99%, which is<br />

comparable to the efficacy of synthetic insecticides.<br />

� The extracts of Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium Trev. and Chrysanthemum<br />

balsamita var. Canfora, tested in the laboratory as well, have a strong lethal effect,<br />

in all variants<br />

� Promising results of 80% in the control of Colorado beetle larvae were also<br />

obtained with hydro-alcoholic extracts of horseradish (Armoracia rusticana),<br />

Artemisia abrotanum and Artemisia capilaris, Marrubium vulgaris and Nepeta<br />

cataria var. citrodora;<br />

30


Ing. Camelia Maria Sîrbu (Alămorean) Abstract<br />

� The use of fire in weed control can be considered an effective method and the<br />

results are similar to manual weeding. The potato plants were affected to a lesser<br />

extent, and mainly on basal leaves that were already in an advanced stage of<br />

maturation, with early yellowing.<br />

� The fire weed- control device designed by us can be used in biological potato<br />

crops 2-3 times until the potato plants cover the soil and the weeds cannot grow<br />

any longer because of the lack of light and, therefore, their influence on<br />

production is insignificant.<br />

31

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!