Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ... Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

01.01.2013 Views

Joint Congressional Committee, Pearl Harbor Attack: Part 3 823 the morning and wrote the letter that he had delivered to Barkley on May 27. 305 Counsel Richardson asked Stark: Admiral, if the president had told you in his talk with you that night . . . that this thirteenth-part message meant war, thereby impressed you with his very serious estimate of it, what would have been, in accordance with your custom, the action for you to have then taken, with that information? Stark thought that he “should have gotten in touch with Ingersoll [assistant CNO] and with Turner [chief, Navy War Plans]. We had had a conference a few days previously,” Stark said, going over the seriousness of the situation, if there was anything more we could have sent, and, as I say, we practically repeated this fourteenth point . . . some days earlier we had sent the same thing. We thought, and the president knew every move that we had made, that we had sent everything possible, on that premise, that war was in the immediate offi ng. I don’t know that I would have done anything. I couldn’t say. Richardson then took advantage of the opportunity to ask Stark “another odd question” about a possible late-night December 6-7 meeting at the White House. I never heard of such a conference. I know of nothing now regarding such a conference, was not present at it, I had never even heard anyone suggest such a thing until it was mentioned here in previous hearings. My honest opinion is that nothing of the sort took place. It was a complete surprise to Marshall that even the question came up. It was to me. I am certain that I didn’t leave the house after the Kricks left. I just can’t think of any such thing as happening. Certainly I was not present, and 305 Ibid., p. 5548.

824 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy Colonel Knox never mentioned any such thing to me. . . . [S]uch a conference at the White House, under those circumstances, Stark said, would have been “so extraordinarily unusual” that it should “unquestionably” have stood out in his memory. But he didn’t remember any such meeting. 306 In spite of Krick’s detailed account of the events of the evening, Stark’s memory did not revive. He remained consistent in saying that he could recall neither attending the theater with the Kricks nor phoning the president when he returned home. He did “not remember that evening.” 307 Keefe had arrived at this special meeting only after Stark had given the bulk of his testimony. He feared that by reopening the hearings for this purpose they were establishing “a precedent now that may plague us in the future” and that its proceedings could go “on and on.” 308 Th e JCC fi nally accepted Richardson’s suggestion “to take the Captain’s [Krick’s] testimony . . . and then if the committee later decides not to use any of this testimony, all right; on the other hand, if they allow it to go in, we have it.” 309 Krick testifi ed that he and his wife had seen the Starks socially on May 25, 1946. Th e subject of their December 6 meeting came up quite casually in the course of the conversation. Krick hadn’t been following the JCC testimony closely, and so he hadn’t realized what Stark had told the committee. But then he had seen a headline to the eff ect that the admiral couldn’t remember where he had been that evening. 310 He told Stark that they all had attended a performance of Th e Student Prince at the National Th eater on the evening of December 6. When they returned to the admiral’s 306Ibid., p. 5549 (part 11). 307Ibid., pp. 5554–55. 308Ibid., p. 5550. 309Ibid., p. 5552. 310Ibid., p. 5558.

824 <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong>: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Seeds</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Fruits</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Infamy</strong><br />

Colonel Knox never mentioned any such thing to me. . . . [S]uch<br />

a conference at the White House, under those circumstances,<br />

Stark said, would have been “so extraordinarily unusual” that it<br />

should “unquestionably” have stood out in his memory. But he<br />

didn’t remember any such meeting. 306<br />

In spite <strong>of</strong> Krick’s detailed account <strong>of</strong> the events <strong>of</strong> the evening,<br />

Stark’s memory did not revive. He remained consistent in<br />

saying that he could recall neither attending the theater with the<br />

Kricks nor phoning the president when he returned home. He<br />

did “not remember that evening.” 307<br />

Keefe had arrived at this special meeting only after Stark had<br />

given the bulk <strong>of</strong> his testimony. He feared that by reopening the<br />

hearings for this purpose they were establishing “a precedent now<br />

that may plague us in the future” <strong>and</strong> that its proceedings could<br />

go “on <strong>and</strong> on.” 308 Th e JCC fi nally accepted Richardson’s suggestion<br />

“to take the Captain’s [Krick’s] testimony . . . <strong>and</strong> then if the<br />

committee later decides not to use any <strong>of</strong> this testimony, all right;<br />

on the other h<strong>and</strong>, if they allow it to go in, we have it.” 309<br />

Krick testifi ed that he <strong>and</strong> his wife had seen the Starks socially<br />

on May 25, 1946. Th e subject <strong>of</strong> their December 6 meeting came<br />

up quite casually in the course <strong>of</strong> the conversation. Krick hadn’t<br />

been following the JCC testimony closely, <strong>and</strong> so he hadn’t realized<br />

what Stark had told the committee. But then he had seen a<br />

headline to the eff ect that the admiral couldn’t remember where he<br />

had been that evening. 310 He told Stark that they all had attended<br />

a performance <strong>of</strong> Th e Student Prince at the National Th eater on<br />

the evening <strong>of</strong> December 6. When they returned to the admiral’s<br />

306Ibid., p. 5549 (part 11).<br />

307Ibid., pp. 5554–55.<br />

308Ibid., p. 5550.<br />

309Ibid., p. 5552.<br />

310Ibid., p. 5558.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!