Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ... Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

01.01.2013 Views

Joint Congressional Committee, Pearl Harbor Attack: Part 1 659 Turner was unequivocal: Any U.S. action against Germany would be “self defense” and would never be considered “aggression”! “[T]he future security” of the United States and that of the United Kingdom were inextricably allied “from the defensive viewpoint”! Roosevelt, Hull, and Stark were all sent copies of Turner’s memorandum of that meeting. Turner told the JCC he received no indication from any of them that they disagreed or disapproved of what he had written. 142 When asked about the December 6 Japanese intercepts, Turner recalled seeing the “Pilot Message” and the fi rst 13 parts of the Japanese reply “some time just preceding the 7th, some night, and I now believe it to have been the night of December 6, about 11:30 p.m.” He said an offi cer came to his house; he had been in bed but “went down and read a long dispatch in several parts” which he believed was “the dispatch in question.” When asked to whom the offi cer had shown these papers, the offi cer replied, “Admiral Wilkinson, Admiral Ingersoll, and Secretary Knox.” Th us assured that the responsible Navy offi cials had been advised, Turner “did nothing more about it.” He did not recall seeing the 14th part “until after the attack.” 143 At about 10:30 on Sunday morning, December 7, Stark phoned Turner at his home, asking him to come to the offi ce. Once there, Stark asked him to draft a reply to Hart’s inquiry concerning Creighton’s report that the United States had promised armed support to the British and Dutch in the far east. 144 Turner had been working on that when Stark summoned him, at about 12 or 12:15, and showed him the “One p.m. Message.” Stark told 142Joint Committee, Pearl Harbor Attack, part 4, p. 2041. 143Ibid., pp. 1970–71. 144Ibid., p. 1971, Stark testimony. See also ibid., pp. 1935–16, Turner testimony concerning reply prepared December 7 for Hart, and part 10, pp. 5082–83, Creighton testimony before the Joint Committee.

660 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy Turner that Marshall had notifi ed the army fi eld commanders of that message, telling them to inform the naval authorities. 145 Admiral Stark on Joint U.S.-British War Plan and Morning of December 7 Admiral Harold R. Stark, chief of naval operations at the time of the attack, was second in line of command to the president in protecting the United States and its Navy. Stark had become CNO on August 1, 1939, just one month before Hitler’s forces marched into Poland, launching what became World War II. Stark was known to his associates as “Betty,” his nickname from Annapolis days. 146 He was genial, polite, soft-spoken, not blunt or brusque like Admiral Richardson, who had stood up boldly to FDR. But Stark was no milquetoast either. On occasion he would tell FDR frankly what he thought, as he had, for instance, when opposing the destroyer deal. Stark appeared before the JCC on December 31, 1945. He opened his testimony by reading a statement containing substantial quotations from reports and letters to his fi eld commanders during his term of offi ce. 147 When he assumed offi ce, Stark realized U.S. naval forces were weak, so he had immediately set about trying to obtain more ships, planes, weapons, and men. Navy budget requests were fi rst made to the Bureau of the Budget, which makes recommendations from which the president’s budget is prepared and submitted to Congress. 148 Stark had appeared before congressional committees to request authorization and funds, pointing out the increasing demands for men and materiel for the 145Ibid., part 4, pp. 1971–72. 146Ibid., part 5, p. 2172. 147Ibid., pp. 2097–35. 148Ibid., p. 2458.

660 <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong>: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Seeds</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Fruits</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Infamy</strong><br />

Turner that Marshall had notifi ed the army fi eld comm<strong>and</strong>ers <strong>of</strong><br />

that message, telling them to inform the naval authorities. 145<br />

Admiral Stark on Joint U.S.-British<br />

War Plan <strong>and</strong> Morning <strong>of</strong> December 7<br />

Admiral Harold R. Stark, chief <strong>of</strong> naval operations at the time<br />

<strong>of</strong> the attack, was second in line <strong>of</strong> comm<strong>and</strong> to the president<br />

in protecting the United States <strong>and</strong> its Navy. Stark had become<br />

CNO on August 1, 1939, just one month before Hitler’s forces<br />

marched into Pol<strong>and</strong>, launching what became World War II.<br />

Stark was known to his associates as “Betty,” his nickname from<br />

Annapolis days. 146 He was genial, polite, s<strong>of</strong>t-spoken, not blunt<br />

or brusque like Admiral Richardson, who had stood up boldly to<br />

FDR. But Stark was no milquetoast either. On occasion he would<br />

tell FDR frankly what he thought, as he had, for instance, when<br />

opposing the destroyer deal.<br />

Stark appeared before the JCC on December 31, 1945. He<br />

opened his testimony by reading a statement containing substantial<br />

quotations from reports <strong>and</strong> letters to his fi eld comm<strong>and</strong>ers<br />

during his term <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fi ce. 147 When he assumed <strong>of</strong>fi ce, Stark realized<br />

U.S. naval forces were weak, so he had immediately set about<br />

trying to obtain more ships, planes, weapons, <strong>and</strong> men. Navy budget<br />

requests were fi rst made to the Bureau <strong>of</strong> the Budget, which<br />

makes recommendations from which the president’s budget is<br />

prepared <strong>and</strong> submitted to Congress. 148 Stark had appeared before<br />

congressional committees to request authorization <strong>and</strong> funds,<br />

pointing out the increasing dem<strong>and</strong>s for men <strong>and</strong> materiel for the<br />

145Ibid., part 4, pp. 1971–72.<br />

146Ibid., part 5, p. 2172.<br />

147Ibid., pp. 2097–35.<br />

148Ibid., p. 2458.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!