Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...
Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ... Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...
Joint Congressional Committee, Pearl Harbor Attack: Part 1 623 cryptographers had replicated in August 1940, yielded valuable intelligence known as MAGIC. Exhibit 1 consisted of diplomatic messages sent and received by the Japanese government and its foreign establishments which had been intercepted, deciphered and translated by U.S. cryptographers between July 1 and December 8, 1941. 15 Exhibit 2 contained intercepted messages concerning military matters such as military installations, ship movements, espionage reports, etc., sent and received by the Japanese government and its foreign establishments in “Purple” and other codes between December 2, 1940, and December 8, 1941. 16 Th e MAGIC information derived from these intercepts had been the basis of much pre-attack U.S. intelligence concerning the movements and intentions of the Japanese government. U.S. Ambassador Joseph C. Grew Reports Pre-attack Situation in Tokyo One of the fi rst witnesses was Joseph C. Grew, U.S. ambassador to Japan since 1932. After the attack he had been held under house arrest until June 25, 1942, when he was repatriated by the Japanese government. Grew testifi ed it was “obvious that by November 3 the [U.S.] trade embargoes had not served to restrain the Japanese Army from its expansion. Th ey were going right ahead.” 17 In his view, “the risk and danger of war was very great and increasing.” 18 Japan’s totalitarian regime’s propaganda was fostering anti-Americanism. And in Washington, the U.S.- Japanese negotiations were clearly deteriorating. Although Grew 15 Joint Committee, Pearl Harbor Attack, part 1, pp. 1–253. 16 Ibid., pp. 254–316. 17 Ibid., part 2, p. 677. 18 Ibid., p. 680.
624 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy never gave up hope, by early December it was apparent that war between Japan and the United States was expected. 19 ONI and WPD Jurisdictional Dispute Disrupts Customary Intelligence Dissemination One goal of the committee in investigating “the events and circumstances leading up to and following the attack” was to determine what had been known by the top offi cials before the attack in Washington, where secret Japanese messages were regularly being intercepted, deciphered and translated, and how much intelligence derived from these intercepts had been relayed before December 7 to the Pearl Harbor commanders. Th e situation was compounded by confusion over a jurisdictional dispute between the Offi ce of Naval Intelligence (ONI) and the Navy’s War Plans Division (WPD). When Kimmel took over the command of the Pacifi c Fleet in February 1941, he had asked CNO Stark to make sure that the responsibility for keeping him “fully informed with pertinent reports on subjects that should be of interest to the Fleet” be clearly determined “so that there will be no misunderstanding.” 20 Stark replied on March 22, that the chief of the Offi ce of Naval Intelligence, Captain Alan G. Kirk, was “fully aware of [ONI’s] responsibility in keeping you adequately informed.” 21 But the policy was changed. Admiral Richard K. Turner, chief of the Navy’s War Plans Division, had fought and won a battle with ONI for the exclusive right to prepare and disseminate to the fl eet commanders information about potential enemy plans and operations, including intelligence obtained by intercepting and decoding Japan’s most secret diplomatic messages. As Vice 19 Ibid. 20 Ibid., part 16, p. 2229. 21 Ibid., part 4, p. 1835.
- Page 595 and 596: 572 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 597 and 598: 574 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 599 and 600: 576 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 601 and 602: 578 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 603 and 604: 580 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 605 and 606: 582 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 607 and 608: 584 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 609 and 610: 586 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 611 and 612: 588 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 613 and 614: 590 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 615 and 616: 592 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 617 and 618: 594 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 619 and 620: 596 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 621 and 622: 598 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 623 and 624: 600 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 625 and 626: 602 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 627 and 628: 604 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 629 and 630: 606 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 631 and 632: 608 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 633 and 634: 610 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 635 and 636: 612 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 637 and 638: 614 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 639 and 640: 616 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 641 and 642: 618 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 643 and 644: 620 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 645: 622 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 649 and 650: 626 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 651 and 652: 628 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 653 and 654: 630 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 655 and 656: 632 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 657 and 658: 634 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 659 and 660: 636 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 661 and 662: 638 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 663 and 664: 640 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 665 and 666: 642 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 667 and 668: 644 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 669 and 670: 646 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 671 and 672: 648 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 673 and 674: 650 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 675 and 676: 652 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 677 and 678: 654 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 679 and 680: 656 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 681 and 682: 658 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 683 and 684: 660 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 685 and 686: 662 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 687 and 688: 664 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 689 and 690: 666 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 691 and 692: 668 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 693 and 694: 670 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
- Page 695 and 696: 672 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fru
Joint Congressional Committee, <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong> Attack: Part 1 623<br />
cryptographers had replicated in August 1940, yielded valuable<br />
intelligence known as MAGIC. Exhibit 1 consisted <strong>of</strong> diplomatic<br />
messages sent <strong>and</strong> received by the Japanese government <strong>and</strong> its foreign<br />
establishments which had been intercepted, deciphered <strong>and</strong><br />
translated by U.S. cryptographers between July 1 <strong>and</strong> December<br />
8, 1941. 15 Exhibit 2 contained intercepted messages concerning<br />
military matters such as military installations, ship movements,<br />
espionage reports, etc., sent <strong>and</strong> received by the Japanese government<br />
<strong>and</strong> its foreign establishments in “Purple” <strong>and</strong> other<br />
codes between December 2, 1940, <strong>and</strong> December 8, 1941. 16 Th e<br />
MAGIC information derived from these intercepts had been the<br />
basis <strong>of</strong> much pre-attack U.S. intelligence concerning the movements<br />
<strong>and</strong> intentions <strong>of</strong> the Japanese government.<br />
U.S. Ambassador Joseph C. Grew<br />
Reports Pre-attack Situation in Tokyo<br />
One <strong>of</strong> the fi rst witnesses was Joseph C. Grew, U.S. ambassador<br />
to Japan since 1932. After the attack he had been held<br />
under house arrest until June 25, 1942, when he was repatriated<br />
by the Japanese government. Grew testifi ed it was “obvious that<br />
by November 3 the [U.S.] trade embargoes had not served to<br />
restrain the Japanese Army from its expansion. Th ey were going<br />
right ahead.” 17 In his view, “the risk <strong>and</strong> danger <strong>of</strong> war was very<br />
great <strong>and</strong> increasing.” 18 Japan’s totalitarian regime’s propag<strong>and</strong>a<br />
was fostering anti-Americanism. And in Washington, the U.S.-<br />
Japanese negotiations were clearly deteriorating. Although Grew<br />
15 Joint Committee, <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong> Attack, part 1, pp. 1–253.<br />
16 Ibid., pp. 254–316.<br />
17 Ibid., part 2, p. 677.<br />
18 Ibid., p. 680.