Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ... Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy - Ludwig von Mises ...

01.01.2013 Views

The Administration Initiates an Investigation 385 getting their planes in a ferrying condition here. . . . Th ey had their problems too,” Kimmel said. 54 Short and Kimmel met with staff members on November 27 to discuss the transfer from Oahu of 25 pursuit planes each to Wake and Midway, as Washington had ordered. 55 Kimmel questioned his war plans offi cer: “[W]hat is your idea of the chances of a surprise raid on Oahu?” McMorris: “I should say none, Admiral.” At the time, Short said, [T]here was no exception taken to that statement by either Admiral Kimmel or Admiral Bloch, and apparently the Navy felt that they had defi nite information of the location of carriers and major ships of the Japanese and that there was no question in their minds of the possibility or probability of a surprise attack upon Oahu. 56 Th e construction of the airfi elds on Wake and Midway had to be carried out “under the most adverse conditions. We were faced with the necessity of building bases and of protecting them at the same time.” Th e dispatch of reinforcements there would seriously weaken Hawaii’s defensive forces. It was fi nally decided to send only half the number of planes Washington had suggested. “Rightly or wrongly, “ Kimmel testifi ed, “we eventually had there about 350 marines and 6 5-inch guns and 12 3-inch guns and a number of machine guns, and we had 12 fi ghting planes there.” 57 On November 28 Kimmel dispatched a convoy, under Admiral William F. Halsey, with men and planes to Wake. Because “there had been a warning from the Chief of Naval Operations that the conversations with the Japanese representatives were about to break down, and to be prepared for eventualities,” all the ships 54 Ibid., part 23, p. 1151. 55 Ibid., part 22, p. 43. 56 Ibid., part 22, p. 43. Short testimony. 57 Ibid., part 23, p. 1190. Kimmel testimony.

386 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy in Halsey’s convoy were “to assume a condition of readiness for instant combat” and to maintain “strict radio silence.” 58 On December 5 Kimmel sent out a second convoy under Admiral J.H. Newton, with a squadron of planes bound for Midway. 59 Bloch, who had taken over the responsibility for the security of the base, had written the Navy Department about “the weakness in the pursuit planes, bombing planes, and anti-aircraft guns.” Th e Army had dispatched to Hawaii a large number of pursuit planes and some heavy bombers, but “no anti-aircraft guns [were] forthcoming.” 60 When Bloch pressed his need for planes and vessels, he was told they were “doing everything within their power to get them” and would send them as soon as they could. 61 As a result of Bloch’s eff orts, Pearl Harbor fi nally obtained “one division of destroyers, four destroyers, only one of which has any listening gear, and one division of four mine sweepers.” In accordance with Kimmel’s order, the destroyers were stationed at the harbor entrance; the mine sweepers swept the channel; the nets were operating; and boom and harbor patrols were executed. However, “anti-aircraft protection of Pearl Harbor was weak.” Bloch was also charged “on paper” with the responsibility for distant reconnaissance; 108 patrol planes had been promised for that purpose, “none of which had ever arrived; not one of them.” 62 Before December 7 Short received three serious warning messages from Washington—October 16, November 27, and November 28. 63 All three messages 58Ibid., part 23, p. 608. Halsey testimony. 59Ibid., p. 1166. Kimmel. 60Ibid., part 22, p. 471. Bloch testimony. 61Ibid., pp. 461, 469. Bloch testimony. 62Ibid., p. 469. Bloch testimony. 63Ibid., p. 39. Short testimony.

386 <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong>: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Seeds</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Fruits</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Infamy</strong><br />

in Halsey’s convoy were “to assume a condition <strong>of</strong> readiness for<br />

instant combat” <strong>and</strong> to maintain “strict radio silence.” 58<br />

On December 5 Kimmel sent out a second convoy under<br />

Admiral J.H. Newton, with a squadron <strong>of</strong> planes bound for<br />

Midway. 59<br />

Bloch, who had taken over the responsibility for the security<br />

<strong>of</strong> the base, had written the Navy Department about “the<br />

weakness in the pursuit planes, bombing planes, <strong>and</strong> anti-aircraft<br />

guns.” Th e Army had dispatched to Hawaii a large number <strong>of</strong><br />

pursuit planes <strong>and</strong> some heavy bombers, but “no anti-aircraft guns<br />

[were] forthcoming.” 60 When Bloch pressed his need for planes<br />

<strong>and</strong> vessels, he was told they were “doing everything within their<br />

power to get them” <strong>and</strong> would send them as soon as they could. 61<br />

As a result <strong>of</strong> Bloch’s eff orts, <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong> fi nally obtained “one<br />

division <strong>of</strong> destroyers, four destroyers, only one <strong>of</strong> which has any<br />

listening gear, <strong>and</strong> one division <strong>of</strong> four mine sweepers.” In accordance<br />

with Kimmel’s order, the destroyers were stationed at the<br />

harbor entrance; the mine sweepers swept the channel; the nets<br />

were operating; <strong>and</strong> boom <strong>and</strong> harbor patrols were executed.<br />

However, “anti-aircraft protection <strong>of</strong> <strong>Pearl</strong> <strong>Harbor</strong> was weak.”<br />

Bloch was also charged “on paper” with the responsibility for distant<br />

reconnaissance; 108 patrol planes had been promised for that<br />

purpose, “none <strong>of</strong> which had ever arrived; not one <strong>of</strong> them.” 62<br />

Before December 7 Short received three serious warning<br />

messages from Washington—October 16, November 27, <strong>and</strong><br />

November 28. 63 All three messages<br />

58Ibid., part 23, p. 608. Halsey testimony.<br />

59Ibid., p. 1166. Kimmel.<br />

60Ibid., part 22, p. 471. Bloch testimony.<br />

61Ibid., pp. 461, 469. Bloch testimony.<br />

62Ibid., p. 469. Bloch testimony.<br />

63Ibid., p. 39. Short testimony.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!