Joseph Cardinal Höffner CHRISTIAN SOCIAL ... - Ordo Socialis
Joseph Cardinal Höffner CHRISTIAN SOCIAL ... - Ordo Socialis Joseph Cardinal Höffner CHRISTIAN SOCIAL ... - Ordo Socialis
with. Third, one may work on Sunday to prevent an emergency that would otherwise arise, as, for example, in vitally important public utility companies, where renunciation of Sunday rest may be necessary out of love of neighbor, for whom a failing supply of water, gas or electricity would cause a hardship. Fourth, the individual may work on Sunday to avert serious material damage (harvest work during sustained adverse weather). Fifth, Sunday work is permitted if it is unambiguously required by the technical necessities of the process of production, for example, if through the interruption of work on Sunday the materials used in the manufacturing process would spoil. Nevertheless, there are not sufficient grounds for Sunday work if a higher income or a better exploitation of invested capital is cited as a reason. Efforts to introduce the so-called 'flexible working week' are to be judged from this point of view. For those affected by the flexible working week Sunday would lose its character as determining the rhythm of work, family, and social life and become a regular day of work on an equal footing with every other workday; this would come disastrously close to the acceptance of the trend towards supplanting the Lord's day with just any 'free time'. CHAPTER TWO: WORKING AND PROFESSIONAL CONDITIONS IN INDUSTRIAL SOCIETY AND CHRISTIAN ETHICS § 1 Characteristic Features of the Modem Working and Professional World 1. Work and Profession as self-evident Activity When Columbus discovered America in 1492, he found a small population living carefree in a luxuriant tropical climate on the Greater Antilles who did not even have a word for 'work'. Only when the Indians were forced by the Spaniards into the plantations did they form the concept 'work' by placing the prefix 'almost' before the word 'dying'. To people of the industrial age this attitude is incomprehensible since taking up a paid profession seems natural to everyone, even the young girl. Professional position determines not only a person's social prestige, but, in general, the level of his or her income also. Success in life and professional success are almost identical. This is so, although professional work occupies only about a quarter of man's time as a result of the reduction or working hours, and although many have no deep-seated attachment to their profession, but are accustomed to changing their activity according to opportunity and wage offer. Like the self-employed, the civil servants, and the office workers, the laborers do not form a homogenous group. We distinguish between unskilled workers, semi-skilled workers, skilled workers, foremen, and master craftsmen. 2.Tensions and Conflicts in the Modern Working and Industrial World The sober matter-of-factness with which modern people consider work and profession should not blind us to the fact that the working and professional world of the industrial age is full of strong tensions, for which three reasons can be adduced. a) The wage system In the advanced industrial society more than eighty per cent of the gainfully employed in dependent positions practice their professions as wage and salary earners. The encyclical Quadragesimo anno calls this system the capitalistic economy, i.e. one in which „some provide capital while others provide labor for a joint economic activity“ (Quadragesimo anno, 100). Even if the wage system does not seize the whole man and violate his freedom of conscience, his political freedom, and his economic freedom, i.e. the free choice of profession and work- place, nevertheless, as experience teaches, certain crises threaten us here as well. Will not the suspicion come upon the employee that the wages paid do not correspond to his or her performance? Will the economy not be shaken again and again by serious wage disputes? Can 80
the wage system bear inspection by the Christian conscience? It is remarkable that the Christian social movement posed these questions more than a hundred years ago. The worker, Bishop Ketteler (1811-1877) explained, invests his or her „flesh and blood“ and works away „a piece of his or her life, as it were, everyday.“ Here it would be fair to make him a 'partner' and a 'co-owner' and to overcome the wage system in this way. 1 Baron von Vogelsang (1818- 1890) also advocated assigning workers „an entire gamut of participation rights,“ so that in the end one „could hardly distinguish whether the entrepreneur was the owner of the establishment.“ 2 In France, writing in 1945, the Dominican Antonin Gilbert Sertillanges counted the wage-relation -at a considerable distance, of course -as part of „the system of villeinage and slavery“; for what they have in common is that in every case one „more or less buys one's man,“ granted „with his more or less free consent in the wage system... but without any participation in the management and the profits.“ 3 Marx's thesis of the self-alienation of the worker is well known:“ The worker thus feels present to himself only outside work and outside himself at work. He is at home when he is not working, and when he is working he is not at home. His work is thus not free, but coerced, a compulsory work...its foreignness emerges in the fact that, as soon as no physical or other coercion exists, he flees from work like a plague...it belongs to another, it is the loss of himself' (Marx, 1854). 4 b) Technicalizing and rationalizing work Manifold engines and machine tools efficiently attuned to one another deter- mine the work process of the modem factory. The accumulation of these machines and the extremely efficient production process lead, on the one hand, to the extensive division of human labor into individual maneuvers and, on the other hand, to the combination and incorporation of these individual actions into the integrated manufacturing process. Serious doubts are raised against this technicalizing of work. Man is allegedly considered only as a function and a factor of production within the impersonal framework of technical equipment. Through drill and discipline one tries to make him 'tough' in order to get as much out of him as possible. Technicalizing has condemned man to mindless, monotonous, nerve-racking, mechanical work and tuned him in to the forced rhythm of the conveyor belt. Handicraft has been replaced by the lever, which so exhausts the senses that they only react to strong stimuli in the evening. Friedrich Georg ltinger says technology is „of a demonic and titanic character“ since it transfers the law of rigid mechanics to man and has thereby led to the „atrophy of the mind“ and to „dullness of work and working life.“ 5 Similarly, Hans Sedelmayer says that technology has shifted the focal point of human work „into the enormous realm of the inorganic“ and has thereby made man himself «inorganic and amorphous“ as the servant of his creature, the machine, which is itself to be understood in turn only as the creation of a mind turned towards the inorganic with every fibre of his being.“ 6 Constantin Virgil Gheorgiu has made the objections against technology culminate in the charge that modern man has become the slave of his technological slaves: „Every patron learns something from the language and the manner of his servants. ..We learn the laws and language of our slaves -thus of our technological bondsman -in order to be able to command them. We dehumanize ourselves by making the way of life of technological slaves our own. ..The collision of two realities -technology and humanity -has taken place. The technological slaves are the fu- 1 Kettelers Schriften, ed by J Mumbauer (1911), 1II:56ff. Cf Joseph Höffner, Die deutschen Katholiken und die soziale Frage im 19 Jhdt., in idem, Gesellschaftspolitik aus christlicher Weltverantwortung (Münster in Westphalia, 1966), 159-182. 2 Wiard von Klopp, Die Sozialen Lehren des Frh v Vogelsang (St. Polten, 1894), 463, 469. 3 1n Economie et Humanisme (September--October, 1945). German translation in Dokumente 10 (1946) n5 4 K Marx, Die Frühschriften (Stuttgart, 1953), 289. 127 5 F G Junger, Die Perfektion der Technik, 2nd ed (Frankfurt am Main, 1949), 19,23, 122. 6 Verlust der Mitte (Salzburg, 1948), 139ff. 81
- Page 29 and 30: difficult to comprise Christian soc
- Page 31 and 32: intended; it is the totality of ins
- Page 33 and 34: ure and, above all, to the misuse o
- Page 35 and 36: tional economic co-operation (Gaudi
- Page 37 and 38: tive law, and that, on the other ha
- Page 39 and 40: In view of this sharp rejection of
- Page 41 and 42: „justice“ according to this law
- Page 43 and 44: 1. When the legal partners encounte
- Page 45 and 46: new formal object is exhibited here
- Page 47 and 48: PART TWO: THE STRUCTURE OF SOCIAL O
- Page 49 and 50: wished to have the feminine princip
- Page 51 and 52: to be emphasized that, precisely be
- Page 53 and 54: than an enchantment (fascination),
- Page 55 and 56: trivialize the serious problem of '
- Page 57 and 58: tion towards a decrease in the divo
- Page 59 and 60: Christian marriage and family are d
- Page 61 and 62: the family. Its origin is not of th
- Page 63 and 64: speaks of a new „metropolitan mat
- Page 65 and 66: schooling for conjugal love. It is
- Page 67 and 68: a) In primitive social relations, f
- Page 69 and 70: family“ is false. „While it mus
- Page 71 and 72: Abstracting from so-called 'asocial
- Page 73 and 74: the doing, separates work from play
- Page 75 and 76: great thing if I could make shoes.
- Page 77 and 78: § 3 Work and Leisure 1. The Proble
- Page 79: ings, fields and work sites. In a s
- Page 83 and 84: agreed wage. Above and beyond every
- Page 85 and 86: foreseen a few decades ago. For aut
- Page 87 and 88: ) Personnel management and authorit
- Page 89 and 90: place here: the price of raw materi
- Page 91 and 92: economic realm; integration in the
- Page 93 and 94: ody. For that reason, if man wishes
- Page 95 and 96: development worthy of man, for the
- Page 97 and 98: lations of the Creator as he manife
- Page 99 and 100: a) The market economy and free comp
- Page 101 and 102: nomic and civil progress?“ (42,1)
- Page 103 and 104: subject to Soviet imperialism. Thro
- Page 105 and 106: doctrine of historical epochs the f
- Page 107 and 108: nist community of goods might have
- Page 109 and 110: piece-work bonuses, and the like. L
- Page 111 and 112: (the rector multitudinis), of reali
- Page 113 and 114: towards absolutism“ (Georges Ripe
- Page 115 and 116: oad strata of the population posses
- Page 117 and 118: ) Dissemination of wealth through n
- Page 119 and 120: net profit of a national economy th
- Page 121 and 122: tion of a formula which should allo
- Page 123 and 124: intensive primary sector of agricul
- Page 125 and 126: a) No Objection to Pioneer Profits
- Page 127 and 128: 3. Critical Evaluation Christian so
- Page 129 and 130: and juridical doctrinarians!“ 77
with. Third, one may work on Sunday to prevent an emergency that would otherwise arise, as,<br />
for example, in vitally important public utility companies, where renunciation of Sunday rest<br />
may be necessary out of love of neighbor, for whom a failing supply of water, gas or electricity<br />
would cause a hardship. Fourth, the individual may work on Sunday to avert serious material<br />
damage (harvest work during sustained adverse weather). Fifth, Sunday work is permitted<br />
if it is unambiguously required by the technical necessities of the process of production, for<br />
example, if through the interruption of work on Sunday the materials used in the manufacturing<br />
process would spoil. Nevertheless, there are not sufficient grounds for Sunday work if a<br />
higher income or a better exploitation of invested capital is cited as a reason. Efforts to introduce<br />
the so-called 'flexible working week' are to be judged from this point of view. For those<br />
affected by the flexible working week Sunday would lose its character as determining the<br />
rhythm of work, family, and social life and become a regular day of work on an equal footing<br />
with every other workday; this would come disastrously close to the acceptance of the trend<br />
towards supplanting the Lord's day with just any 'free time'.<br />
CHAPTER TWO: WORKING AND PROFESSIONAL CONDITIONS IN<br />
INDUSTRIAL SOCIETY AND <strong>CHRISTIAN</strong> ETHICS<br />
§ 1 Characteristic Features of the Modem Working and Professional World<br />
1. Work and Profession as self-evident Activity<br />
When Columbus discovered America in 1492, he found a small population living carefree in a<br />
luxuriant tropical climate on the Greater Antilles who did not even have a word for 'work'.<br />
Only when the Indians were forced by the Spaniards into the plantations did they form the<br />
concept 'work' by placing the prefix 'almost' before the word 'dying'. To people of the industrial<br />
age this attitude is incomprehensible since taking up a paid profession seems natural to<br />
everyone, even the young girl. Professional position determines not only a person's social<br />
prestige, but, in general, the level of his or her income also. Success in life and professional<br />
success are almost identical. This is so, although professional work occupies only about a<br />
quarter of man's time as a result of the reduction or working hours, and although many have<br />
no deep-seated attachment to their profession, but are accustomed to changing their activity<br />
according to opportunity and wage offer.<br />
Like the self-employed, the civil servants, and the office workers, the laborers do not form a<br />
homogenous group. We distinguish between unskilled workers, semi-skilled workers, skilled<br />
workers, foremen, and master craftsmen.<br />
2.Tensions and Conflicts in the Modern Working and Industrial World<br />
The sober matter-of-factness with which modern people consider work and profession should<br />
not blind us to the fact that the working and professional world of the industrial age is full of<br />
strong tensions, for which three reasons can be adduced.<br />
a) The wage system<br />
In the advanced industrial society more than eighty per cent of the gainfully employed in dependent<br />
positions practice their professions as wage and salary earners. The encyclical Quadragesimo<br />
anno calls this system the capitalistic economy, i.e. one in which „some provide<br />
capital while others provide labor for a joint economic activity“ (Quadragesimo anno, 100).<br />
Even if the wage system does not seize the whole man and violate his freedom of conscience,<br />
his political freedom, and his economic freedom, i.e. the free choice of profession and work-<br />
place, nevertheless, as experience teaches, certain crises threaten us here as well. Will not the<br />
suspicion come upon the employee that the wages paid do not correspond to his or her performance?<br />
Will the economy not be shaken again and again by serious wage disputes? Can<br />
80