02.07.2024 Views

Newslink July 2024

Motor Schools Association, driver training and testing, road safety

Motor Schools Association, driver training and testing, road safety

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

msagb.com<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong><br />

The Voice of MSA GB<br />

Issue 378 • <strong>July</strong> <strong>2024</strong><br />

Still stuck in a queue<br />

Average L-test waiting<br />

times in shock rise<br />

We work for all Driver Trainers. Want to join? SAVE £25 – see pg 39 for special offer


Ford Focus<br />

Starting from £22,199<br />

Contract options from £588<br />

D U A L C O N T R O L<br />

V E H I C L E S<br />

A v a i l a b l e f o r h i r e a n d p u r c h a s e<br />

Audi q2<br />

Lease from £648<br />

Purchase from £26,699<br />

CALL US TO SECURE<br />

YOUR NEXT CAR<br />

0116 284 9067<br />

NATIONWIDE DELIVERY AVAILABLE<br />

Working with 14 Manufacturers<br />

Terms and Conditions apply<br />

Finance Available on purchases<br />

Contract Deals include<br />

All Servicing Costs<br />

Tyres at 2mm<br />

Courtesy Car<br />

He-man Dual Controls<br />

Breakdown cover<br />

TOYOTA YARIS<br />

PURCHASE FROM £19,999<br />

CONTRACT FROM £508


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

The DVSA needs a radical plan<br />

or the L-test waiting list crisis<br />

will just keep on deepening<br />

Colin Lilly<br />

Editor,<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong><br />

As our article from page 10 highlights clearly,<br />

the DVSA’s attempt to reduce the driving test<br />

waiting list has stalled, and is now going into<br />

reverse. The national average wait on May 6<br />

was 17.8 weeks, compared with 14.8 in March.<br />

It’s a long way above the nine-week wait we<br />

were promised by DVSA chief executive<br />

Loveday Ryder back in 2022.<br />

L-test waiting times were effectively<br />

reduced while all DVSA warrant card-holding<br />

staff capable of conducting tests were asked<br />

to deliver tests, but this was never going to<br />

be a permanent solution. If a ship is going to<br />

run efficiently, then the crew needs to carry<br />

out their normal duties. However, in times of<br />

impending disaster, such as the ship hitting<br />

an iceberg, all hands must assume other<br />

roles. That’s exactly what the DVSA did when<br />

“What’s clear is that without<br />

some form of action, the list<br />

will continue to grow and<br />

more and more test centres<br />

will reach the ‘maximum’<br />

24-week wait...”<br />

the scale of the L-test waiting times crisis<br />

post-Covid was realised, but that strategy<br />

can work for only so long. An efficient<br />

organisation cannot run constantly in<br />

disaster mode.<br />

The iceberg analogy was chosen<br />

deliberately as the full extent of the problem<br />

remains out of sight.<br />

It has been shown that the wait can be<br />

reduced by drafting in extra examiners but<br />

clearly the current complement is not<br />

enough. The agreement earlier this year<br />

between the DVSA and the CPS union may<br />

have resolved some of the issues relating to<br />

contract conditions but the question of salary<br />

remains. If new examiners are not recruited,<br />

the problem will get worse.<br />

We have written before that the salary for<br />

examiners must be raised to a level that is<br />

attractive to new recruits. It seems that the<br />

elephant in the ministerial office is the<br />

question of increasing driving test fees.<br />

Whoever the new incumbent is in the<br />

Department of Transport after the election<br />

this Thursday will have to solve that dilemma.<br />

In the current climate, when all political<br />

parties will not want to appear to be raising<br />

prices, particularly on government services, it<br />

is difficult to see a way out of this current<br />

situation.<br />

The only alternative is a reduction in the<br />

number of test candidates. A significant<br />

reduction in the number of learner drivers<br />

would not be good for our businesses, and<br />

given the demographics and current clamour<br />

for lessons, is unlikely to happen.<br />

One possible option is to create a longer<br />

period after failing a driving test before a<br />

re-test can be booked. This might make<br />

candidates think more before taking a test in<br />

the hope of a lucky pass. In addition, the<br />

booking process should be looked at to<br />

prevent drivers booking an early test in the<br />

hope of finding an instructor to give some<br />

lessons. The number of lessons, and the<br />

standard the candidate reaches, will rarely be<br />

sufficient.<br />

Other ways of slowing the flow include<br />

introducing a minimum number of lessons,<br />

ADIs signing off manoeuvres and test<br />

readiness, or candidates producing a valid<br />

driver’s record. Not all are desirable to our<br />

businesses.<br />

What’s clear is that without some form of<br />

action, the list will continue to grow and more<br />

and more test centres will reach the<br />

‘maximum’ 24-week wait.<br />

Each week that action is delayed will only<br />

go to deepen the crisis. The DVSA and<br />

Department for Transport must act now.<br />

L-test waiting list crisis deepens: see pg 10<br />

What would you do to reduce the L-test<br />

waiting times crisis? Let <strong>Newslink</strong> know,<br />

via editor@msagb.com<br />

Welcome to your<br />

digital, interactive<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong><br />

See a pale blue box in any article or<br />

on an advert? It it contains a web<br />

address or email, it’s interactive. Just<br />

click and it will take you to the<br />

appropriate web page or email so you<br />

can find more details easier.<br />

You’ll also find these panels across<br />

the magazine: just click for more<br />

information on any given subject.<br />

To get the<br />

full story,<br />

click here<br />

How to access this<br />

magazine<br />

You can read <strong>Newslink</strong> in three ways:<br />

Go online and read the interactive<br />

magazine on the Yumpu website; or,<br />

if you would like to read it when you<br />

don’t have a mobile signal or WiFi,<br />

you can download the magazine to<br />

your tablet, PC or phone to read at<br />

your leisure. Alternatively, a pdf can<br />

be found on the MSA GB website, at<br />

www.msagb.com<br />

COVER STORY<br />

New figures show<br />

waiting times for<br />

L-tests are getting<br />

longer, with more<br />

DTCs recording<br />

maximum waiting<br />

times. How does<br />

your centre fare?<br />

See from page 10<br />

Follow the link<br />

MSA GB sends<br />

you to access<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong>,<br />

and then just<br />

click Download<br />

(circled above)<br />

to save a copy<br />

on your device<br />

• Cover cartoon by<br />

Amy Beswick. To follow her work,<br />

and request commissions, go to Instagram<br />

and search for ‘syagsoy’<br />

NEWSLINK ■ JULY <strong>2024</strong> 03


Contents<br />

09<br />

20<br />

10<br />

Events lined-up<br />

MSA GB has organised a number of events<br />

for the summer and autumn, bringing you<br />

face-to-face with the DVSA’s key decision<br />

makers at local and national level – 06-07<br />

Why are we still waiting?<br />

It looks like the DVSA is failing to control<br />

L-test waiting times, after an AA FOI request<br />

found more DTCs at the maximum waiting<br />

time of 24 weeks – 10<br />

A manifesto on motoring<br />

The General Election is this Thursday: what<br />

have the main parties been saying about<br />

motoring – and why should all ADIs be<br />

planning to vote Plaid Cymru – even those<br />

in England and Scotland....? – 14<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong><br />

The Voice of MSA GB<br />

The Motor Schools Association<br />

of Great Britain Ltd<br />

Head Office:<br />

Peershaws,<br />

Berewyk Hall Court,<br />

White Colne, Colchester,<br />

Essex CO6 2QB<br />

T: 01787 221020<br />

E: info@msagb.com<br />

Finland’s top of the PIN poll<br />

Scandinavia leads the way again when it<br />

comes to road safety, after a succession of<br />

interventions slashed traffic casualties – 20<br />

Getting the strategy right<br />

A good lesson has the Goldilocks touch -<br />

letting the pupil lead... but always on hand to<br />

guide when necessary – 24<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong> is published monthly on behalf of the MSA GB<br />

and distributed to members and selected recently<br />

qualified ADIs throughout Great Britain by:<br />

Chamber Media Services,<br />

4 Hilton Road, Bramhall, Stockport,<br />

Cheshire SK7 3AG<br />

Editorial/Production: Rob Beswick<br />

e: rob@chambermediaservices.co.uk<br />

t: 0161 426 7957<br />

Advertising sales: Colin Regan<br />

e: colinregan001@yahoo.co.uk<br />

t: 01942 537959 / 07871 444922<br />

Views expressed in <strong>Newslink</strong> are not necessarily those<br />

of the MSA GB or the publishers.<br />

14<br />

Trainees’ travails<br />

NASP has some key advice for ADI trainers as<br />

Part 2 and 3 tests become scarce due to<br />

pressures on the DVSA – 26<br />

First Aid for ADI cohort<br />

Do you know what to do in the event of a first<br />

aid emergency? One group of Scottish ADIs<br />

does now... – 36<br />

Although every effort is made<br />

to ensure the accuracy of<br />

material contained within<br />

this publication, neither MSA<br />

GB nor the publishers can<br />

accept any responsibility for<br />

the veracity of claims made<br />

by contributors in either<br />

advertising or editorial content.<br />

©<strong>2024</strong> The Motor Schools<br />

Association of Great Britain<br />

Ltd. Reproducing in whole<br />

or part is forbidden without<br />

express permission of the<br />

editor.<br />

04 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

MSA GB Board<br />

of Management<br />

National Chairman &<br />

Area 2 - East Coast Chair<br />

Mike Yeomans<br />

7 Oak Avenue, Elloughton,<br />

Brough HU15 1LA<br />

T: 07772 757529<br />

E: mike.yeomans@msagb.com<br />

AREA 1<br />

Vice Chairman<br />

Peter Harvey MBE<br />

T: 01505 814823<br />

E: peter.harveymbe@msagb.com<br />

Area 1 – Scotland &<br />

Northern Ireland<br />

Chair: Steven Porter<br />

18 Heron Place, Johnstone<br />

PA5 0RW<br />

T: 01505 345372 or<br />

07747 600672<br />

E: steven.porter@msagb.com<br />

Area 3 – London & South East<br />

Chair: Tom Kwok<br />

52B Sutton Road, Muswell Hill,<br />

London N10 1HE<br />

07956 269922<br />

E: tom.kwok@msagb.com<br />

How MSA GB<br />

is organised, in<br />

four AREAS<br />

AREA 4<br />

AREA 2<br />

AREA 3<br />

Area 4 – West Coast & Wales<br />

Chair: Arthur Mynott<br />

9 Hagleys Green, Crowcombe,<br />

Taunton TA4 4AH<br />

T: 01984 618858<br />

E: arthur.mynott@msagb.com<br />

Keep in touch<br />

If you have updated your address, telephone numbers or<br />

changed your email address recently, please let us know<br />

at head office by emailing us with your new details and<br />

membership number to info@msagb.com.<br />

If you can’t find your membership number, give us a ring<br />

on 01787 221020.<br />

Follow MSA GB on social media<br />

Just click on the icon to go<br />

through to the relevant site<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 05


News<br />

Events diary<br />

Area 3: London & South East<br />

Working together<br />

Date: <strong>July</strong> 16<br />

Time: 7.15<br />

Venue: Manor Drive Methodist Church,<br />

Manor Drive, Whetstone, London N20 0DZ<br />

Cost: £10 members<br />

The London & South East committee is<br />

hoping to see local members at our next ADI<br />

meeting on 16th <strong>July</strong>. It will be themed around<br />

Working Together. Attending will give you the<br />

chance to be part of the discussion on how all<br />

aspects of the road safety community can<br />

work together to create a more harmonious<br />

environment for new and existing drivers.<br />

Confirmed speakers include:<br />

n Peter Newell (DVSA ODM)<br />

n Craig Buckwald<br />

n Dora Phillips<br />

n Sehnaz Erdogan<br />

n Rebecca Janaway<br />

n James Brindley<br />

n Teaching techniques by Tom Kwok<br />

Whether you’re a new driving instructor or<br />

just starting out, there’s always more to<br />

learn. Tom Kwok will be sharing his expert<br />

insights on how to refine and elevate your<br />

teaching techniques!<br />

Click here for<br />

details and to book<br />

MSA GB Areas have a number of events<br />

lined up for the summer and autumn<br />

Area 3: London & South East<br />

Hastings CPD event<br />

Date: Tuesday, <strong>July</strong> 30<br />

Time: 6.30pm for 7.00pm start<br />

Venue: St Peter and St Paul’s Church Hall,<br />

Parkstone Rd, Hastings TN34 2NT<br />

Cost: £5 entry<br />

Inlcudes refreshments and buffet.<br />

MSAGB would like to invite all ADIs and PDIs<br />

to what should be a great evening.<br />

Confirmed speakers to include:<br />

n Karen from CA Cars, with news on<br />

services and deals that they can provide.<br />

n Air Ambulance – Their role and funding.<br />

n Lawrence Brand (DVSA) – Test centre<br />

update and Q&A session<br />

n Tom Kwok, (MSA GB London and SE Area<br />

Director) - Tackling test nerves.<br />

All attendees will receive a CPD Certificate.<br />

We hope you will find the evening useful<br />

and informative.<br />

To book<br />

To help with numbers, please call/text<br />

Terry on 07719 697881 or email him at<br />

terence.cummins@btinternet.com<br />

to confirm your place.<br />

Click here for<br />

details and to book<br />

Area 4: West & Wales<br />

Taunton meeting with the DVSA<br />

Date: Wednesday, August 7<br />

Time: 6.30pm<br />

Venue: Quaker Meeting Rooms,<br />

Crescent Car Park, Taunton TA1 4EA<br />

MSA GB West & Wales Area committee has<br />

rescheduled its members meeting with the<br />

DVSA. It was originally planned for the end<br />

of June, but had to be postponded because<br />

of the General Election<br />

The re-arranged date is Wednesday, 7th<br />

August. It will be held at the Quaker Meeting<br />

Rooms in Taunton. This is in the corner of the<br />

Crescent Car Park behind Boots, postcode<br />

TA1 4EA. Note, parking is free after 6.00pm.<br />

The speakers are;<br />

n Sue Robertson, DVSA ADI Area Manager<br />

n Darren Russell, DVSA – ADI Deputy<br />

Registrar<br />

We are also hoping to have LDTM/DEs<br />

from Taunton DTC in attendance.<br />

This will be the first face-to-face meeting<br />

in our locality for almost five years and it<br />

would be great to see as many instructors as<br />

possible.<br />

We are sure many of you will have<br />

questions to ask our speakers and this will<br />

be the ideal opportunity to get your voice<br />

heard.<br />

The meeting will start at 6.30pm and there<br />

will be a nominal charge of £5 to cover the<br />

cost of hiring the room. This can be paid in<br />

advance, if possible, just contact Area<br />

Chairman, Arthur Mynott, on the details<br />

below for the bank details and let me know<br />

asap if you intend coming.<br />

A lot of work has gone in to re-organising<br />

this meeting after the general election, so<br />

please come along if you can.<br />

The DVSA nowadays has a policy of only<br />

attending if there are at least 30 people in<br />

the audience.<br />

For more details and to book, contact<br />

Arthur Mynott,<br />

Chairman West Coast & Wales MSA GB<br />

07989852274<br />

arthur.mynott@msagb.com<br />

06 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Autumn series<br />

Each autumn MSA GB hosts meetings in each area which combine training sessions,<br />

information and the area AGM. See www.msagb.com for more details and to book.<br />

East Coast AGM & Training Day<br />

Date: 27th October<br />

Time: 9.30am for 10am start concludes 1pm<br />

Venue: Woodlands Hotel, Gelderd Road,<br />

Gildersome, Leeds LS27 7LY<br />

Programme details to follow nearer the date.<br />

Scotland AGM & Training Event<br />

3rd November<br />

Join us for this year’s Scottish annual<br />

training event!<br />

With industry experts from across the road<br />

safety sphere, the latest training<br />

opportunities, and plenty of networking and<br />

socialising, it’s an event not-to-be-missed.<br />

Secure your place before August 31 to take<br />

advantage of our Early Bird ticket rate - just<br />

£50. This includes tea/coffee on arrival,<br />

morning coffee/tea, a two-course lunch with<br />

tea/coffee, and an afternoon tea break.<br />

All paperwork needed will also be provided.<br />

West Coast & Wales AGM Training Day<br />

11th November<br />

Mercure Bristol North, Bristol, BS36 1RP<br />

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to secure<br />

your place at our West Coast & Wales Annual<br />

Training Day at our exclusive Early Bird rate<br />

- £45 for MSA GB members and £50 for<br />

non-members.<br />

We already have an incredible line-up of<br />

speakers confirmed, including:<br />

n John Sheridan, DVSA Driver Training Policy<br />

Advisor.<br />

n Daniel Cox, Avon & Somerset Police Road<br />

Safety Officer.<br />

n Great Western Air Ambulance.<br />

n Mike Yeomans, MSA GB Chairman.<br />

n Peter Harvey, MSA GB Vice Chairman<br />

And if that wasn’t enough, we’ve also<br />

secured a 15% discount at the hotel for any<br />

delegates travelling and wishing to stay<br />

overnight.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 07


News<br />

MSA GB Vice Chair presents at TyreSafe Briefing<br />

MSA GB Vice Chairman Peter Harvey was<br />

asked to wrap up the day at the recent<br />

TyreSafe Briefing <strong>2024</strong>, at which he delivered<br />

an engaging presentation, updating<br />

attendees on how ADIs help learner drivers<br />

understand the importance of good tyre<br />

safety once they pass their L-test.<br />

He shared the evolution of MSA GB from its<br />

origins to its transformation into a trade<br />

association. and covered key topics such as:<br />

n PI & PL insurance for members<br />

n Some of its successes over the years<br />

n Learners on motorways with ADIs<br />

n Current debate around graduated driving<br />

licences<br />

n Update on instructor levels across GB<br />

n Update on driving test waiting times<br />

n Working together to help learner drivers<br />

understand some of the important checks<br />

required on their vehicles (Show Me – Tell Me<br />

questions on tests).<br />

Peter then interacted with the audience,<br />

addressing questions and discussing the<br />

challenges instructors face when peers<br />

undervalue the extra work done with pupils,<br />

despite efforts to reduce the alarming<br />

statistic that newly qualified drivers are<br />

involved in about one-fifth of all road deaths.<br />

The audience engaged enthusiastically,<br />

and Peter concluded by announcing that MSA<br />

GB, in partnership with TyreSafe, is launching<br />

a joint venture to inform driving instructors<br />

about fantastic resources available to<br />

enhance tyre safety knowledge for both<br />

themselves and their pupils.<br />

Later, Peter remarked that this was his first<br />

TyreSafe event and he found it to be a very<br />

informative day, with a great variety of<br />

speakers.<br />

DTC update<br />

Pwllheli Driving Test Centre:<br />

Temporary Relocation<br />

ADIs operating from Pwllheli Driving Test<br />

Centre will be aware that it was<br />

temporarily relocated on June 6, to allow<br />

for the refurbishment of the existing<br />

centre.<br />

The temporary test centre location is:<br />

Clwb Hwylio Pwllheli Sailing Club,<br />

Glanydon Industrial Estate, Pwllheli LL53<br />

5YT.<br />

This situation will remain in place until<br />

the works at the driving test centre are<br />

completed, which is expected to be <strong>July</strong> 19.<br />

Testing will therefore recommence from<br />

Pwllheli Driving Test Centre on <strong>July</strong> 22.<br />

Leicester Wigston driving test centre:<br />

End of temporary relocation<br />

The temporary relocation of Wigston<br />

Driving Test Centre ended on Monday, <strong>July</strong><br />

1, a week later than originally planned.<br />

Testing has now returned to the DTC at<br />

Tigers Road, off Saffron Road, South<br />

Wigston LE18 4WS<br />

Cooking pips driving as life skill young need<br />

Being able to drive has been named as the<br />

joint second most important life skill that<br />

young people feel they should be able to do,<br />

after being able to cook.<br />

Interestingly, the skill it tied with was<br />

swimming.<br />

Being able to command a vehicle came<br />

Exclusive MSA GB payment hotline makes<br />

it easier to keep on top of the admin<br />

Dear MSA GB member and colleague,<br />

While being a driving instructor does offer incredible flexibility, we<br />

understand that it can leave you time poor for those everyday<br />

admin jobs.<br />

So, to help make things easier when paying for your membership<br />

or booking tickets for our calendar of events, we’ve set up a<br />

dedicated payment line:<br />

01787 221299.<br />

This also means that our membership team are more<br />

available for answering member queries and resolving any<br />

issues you may be experiencing.<br />

Our membership team can still be contacted on:<br />

01787 221020.<br />

We look forward to taking your call.<br />

ahead of using a computer, administering<br />

first aid, a basic idea of DIY and knowing how<br />

to use an iron.<br />

Other top skills to acquire included being<br />

able to read a map and clean a toilet.<br />

More women than men chose driving as<br />

one of their top five life skills (38% to 34%).<br />

08 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


News<br />

Why are we still waiting?<br />

AA Freedom of Information request reveals L-test waiting crisis<br />

is getting worse . What steps can the DVSA take next?<br />

Average waiting times<br />

14.8 15.7 16.8 17.8<br />

as at 05/02/<strong>2024</strong> as at 04/03/<strong>2024</strong> as at 01/04/<strong>2024</strong> as at 06/05/<strong>2024</strong><br />

n Failure to fix driving test<br />

backlog as average waiting<br />

time rises 20% in <strong>2024</strong><br />

n 33% rise in test centres with<br />

waits of more than five months<br />

n 93% of test centres have waits<br />

in excess of pre-pandemic<br />

average<br />

n 51% of test centres have seen<br />

average wait times increase<br />

this year<br />

n Next Government urged to<br />

make reducing driving test<br />

waiting times a priority<br />

Measures to tackle driving test waiting times<br />

are failing, says the AA Driving School, as new<br />

data shows they are increasing every month.<br />

Freedom of Information data from the<br />

DVSA, accessed by the AA Driving School,<br />

shows the average waiting time for a driving<br />

test at the start of February was 14.8 weeks.<br />

It has risen incrementally in each interim<br />

month since to 17.8 weeks at the start of May<br />

– an increase of 20 per cent.<br />

The data also shows a 33% rise in the<br />

number of test centres with average waiting<br />

times of more than five months, rising from<br />

94 at the start of February to 125 at the start<br />

of May.<br />

Overall, at the start of May, the vast<br />

majority of test centres (93%) had average<br />

waiting times in excess of the pre-pandemic<br />

average of six weeks.<br />

Half (51%) of test centres have seen<br />

average waiting times increase this year; only<br />

a fifth (20%) have seen an improvement.<br />

Reducing the driving test backlog and<br />

improving waiting times for learners is a key<br />

priority in The AA’s Motoring Manifesto –<br />

which outlines vital transport priorities to all<br />

political parties ahead of the general election<br />

on Thursday.<br />

Camilla Benitz, Managing Director AA<br />

Driving School, said: “Enough is enough. The<br />

additional test slots the DVSA added to the<br />

system between October and March have<br />

made no difference to the average waiting<br />

time learners up and down the country are<br />

facing.<br />

“In fact, learners faced longer average<br />

waiting times in May than they did in<br />

February.<br />

“More has to be done to address this issue.<br />

Being able to drive is not a luxury – for many<br />

people it is an absolute necessity to get them<br />

to work, education and employment.<br />

“We need to see a renewed commitment<br />

from the DVSA to make additional driving test<br />

slots available, but also to recruiting and<br />

retaining more examiners so additional<br />

learner test slots do not come at the expense<br />

of other vital DVSA services, such as driving<br />

instructor training exams, which we have<br />

seen falling availability of recently.”<br />

The FOI also revealed:<br />

71 test centres had average waits of 24<br />

weeks (the maximum the system will allow to<br />

be recorded) on both February 5th and May<br />

6th.<br />

Despite the efforts made by the DVSA, a<br />

number of test centres increased their<br />

average waiting time between February and<br />

May to 24 weeks.<br />

These include: Barnet (London),<br />

Basingstoke, Dorchester, Greenham,<br />

Hornchurch (London), Inveraray, Ipswich,<br />

Kettering, Maidstone, Newport (Isle of<br />

Wight), Nottingham (Chilwell), Plymouth and<br />

Whitby.<br />

The average waiting time for a driving test<br />

before 2020 was just six weeks, from<br />

booking online to taking the test.<br />

10 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Big rises... driving test centres with<br />

maximum waiting times of 24 weeks<br />

Ashford (Kent)<br />

Aylesbury<br />

Ballater<br />

Banbury<br />

Barking (Tanner Street)<br />

Basildon<br />

Belvedere (London)<br />

Bishops Stortford<br />

Bletchley<br />

Bristol (Avonmouth)<br />

Bristol (Kingswood)<br />

Bromley (London)<br />

Buckie<br />

Chelmsford (Hanbury Road)<br />

Cheltenham<br />

Chertsey (London)<br />

Chingford (London)<br />

Chippenham<br />

Clacton-on-Sea<br />

Coventry<br />

Culham LGV<br />

Dunoon<br />

Eastbourne<br />

Enfield (Brancroft Way)<br />

Farnborough<br />

Folkestone<br />

Gillingham<br />

Gloucester<br />

Goodmayes (London)<br />

Greenford (Horsenden Lane)<br />

Guildford<br />

Hastings (Ore)<br />

Hendon (London)<br />

Hinckley<br />

Islay Island<br />

Isleworth (Fleming Way)<br />

Lochgilphead<br />

Loughborough<br />

Loughton (London)<br />

Mill Hill (London)<br />

Morden (London)<br />

Northampton<br />

Nottingham (Colwick)<br />

Nuneaton<br />

Oban<br />

Orkney<br />

Oxford (Cowley)<br />

Penzance<br />

Pinner (London)<br />

Reading<br />

Redhill Aerodrome<br />

Rugby<br />

Slough (London)<br />

Southall (London)<br />

Southampton (Maybush)<br />

Southend-on-Sea<br />

Stevenage<br />

Swindon<br />

Swindon LGV<br />

Taunton<br />

Tilbury<br />

Tolworth (London)<br />

Tunbridge Wells<br />

Uxbridge (London)<br />

Wanstead (London)<br />

Warwick (Wedgenock House)<br />

Watford<br />

West Wickham (London)<br />

Winchester<br />

Wood Green (London)<br />

Yeading (London)<br />

MSA GB response:<br />

This is shattering news that confirms the<br />

anecdotal evidence we have been hearing<br />

since the start of the year, that the waiting<br />

list fiasco is now out of control and the<br />

booking system is effectively broken.<br />

We now fear that, unless drastic action is<br />

taken immediately by the DVSA, ADIs and<br />

their pupils will have to get used to eyewatering<br />

waiting lists for many of the<br />

country’s most popular driving test centres.<br />

That means more pupils driven to using the<br />

bots – which are exacerbating the problem in<br />

the first place – more ADIs having to agree to<br />

pupils taking tests when they are not ready,<br />

more tests being taken miles from pupils’<br />

homes, and more failures as a result... which<br />

will make the current situation worse as<br />

more candidates look for a second and third<br />

test.<br />

The DVSA has to act. Loveday Ryder has to<br />

bang on the door of the Roads Minister –<br />

whoever he or she is – on <strong>July</strong> 5 and put her<br />

case for a dramatic response.<br />

“We now fear<br />

that, unless<br />

drastic action<br />

is taken<br />

immediately<br />

by the DVSA,<br />

ADIs and their<br />

pupils will<br />

have to get<br />

used to eyewatering<br />

waiting lists<br />

for many of<br />

the country’s<br />

most popular<br />

driving test<br />

centres...”<br />

Turn over for the average<br />

waiting times of every<br />

DTC in the country<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 11


News<br />

L-test waiting times, by DTC:<br />

as at 06/05/<strong>2024</strong><br />

Test centres with maximum 24-week waiting lists are picked out in bol<br />

How is your driving test centre doing? Compare it with others in your area.<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Aberdeen North...................................................16<br />

Aberdeen South (Cove).................................... 8<br />

Aberfeldy..................................................................7<br />

Abergavenny........................................................21<br />

Aberystwyth (Park Avenue).......................... 4<br />

Airdrie.........................................................................5<br />

Alness................................................................24<br />

Alnwick.....................................................................11<br />

Arbroath................................................................... 4<br />

Ashfield..................................................................22<br />

Ashford (Kent).................................................24<br />

Atherton (Manchester)....................................14<br />

Aylesbury.........................................................24<br />

Ayr.............................................................................10<br />

Bala.............................................................................7<br />

Ballater..............................................................24<br />

Banbury.............................................................24<br />

Banff...........................................................................7<br />

Bangor...............................................................24<br />

Barking (Tanner Street)...............................24<br />

Barnet (London).............................................24<br />

Barnsley..................................................................13<br />

Barnstaple.............................................................18<br />

Barra..........................................................................11<br />

Barrow In Furness...............................................12<br />

Barry......................................................................... 4<br />

Basildon.............................................................24<br />

Basingstoke.....................................................24<br />

Bedford..............................................................24<br />

Belvedere (London).......................................24<br />

Benbecula Island..................................................11<br />

Berwick-On-Tweed............................................6<br />

Beverley LGV...................................................24<br />

Birmingham (Garretts Green)......................20<br />

Birmingham (Kings Heath)............................23<br />

Birmingham (Kingstanding)..........................22<br />

Birmingham (Shirley)........................................21<br />

Birmingham (South Yardley)........................20<br />

Bishopbriggs.........................................................18<br />

Bishops Stortford...........................................24<br />

Blackburn with Darwen...................................21<br />

Blackpool................................................................14<br />

Bletchley...........................................................24<br />

Blyth..........................................................................11<br />

Bodmin....................................................................14<br />

Bolton (Manchester)........................................22<br />

Borehamwood (London)..............................24<br />

Boston....................................................................22<br />

Bradford (Heaton)..........................................24<br />

Bradford (Thornbury).......................................22<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Brecon....................................................................... 4<br />

Bredbury (Manchester)..................................22<br />

Brentwood (London).....................................24<br />

Bridgend...................................................................9<br />

Bridlington...............................................................11<br />

Bristol (Avonmouth)......................................24<br />

Bristol (Kingswood).......................................24<br />

Brodick (Isle of Arran).......................................18<br />

Bromley (London)..........................................24<br />

Buckie................................................................24<br />

Burgess Hill......................................................24<br />

Burton on Trent....................................................21<br />

Bury (Manchester).............................................14<br />

Bury St Edmunds................................................21<br />

Buxton........................................................................1<br />

Callander..................................................................11<br />

Camborne.........................................................24<br />

Cambridge (Brookmount Court)...............24<br />

Campbeltown..................................................24<br />

Canterbury............................................................14<br />

Cardiff (Llanishen)..............................................19<br />

Cardigan....................................................................6<br />

Carlisle......................................................................11<br />

Carlisle LGV (Cars).........................................24<br />

Carmarthen.............................................................5<br />

Castle Douglas........................................................1<br />

Chadderton..........................................................20<br />

Cheetham Hill (Manchester)..........................21<br />

Chelmsford (Hanbury Road).......................24<br />

Cheltenham......................................................24<br />

Chertsey (London)........................................24<br />

Chester....................................................................16<br />

Chesterfield...........................................................15<br />

Chichester........................................................24<br />

Chingford (London).......................................24<br />

Chippenham.....................................................24<br />

Chorley....................................................................14<br />

Clacton-on-Sea.............................................24<br />

Colchester........................................................24<br />

Coventry...........................................................24<br />

Crawley.............................................................24<br />

Crewe.......................................................................19<br />

Crieff.........................................................................12<br />

Culham LGV......................................................24<br />

Cumnock................................................................15<br />

Darlington................................................................11<br />

Derby (Alvaston).................................................21<br />

Doncaster..............................................................16<br />

Dorchester.......................................................24<br />

Dudley......................................................................21<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Dumbarton............................................................ 17<br />

Dumfries....................................................................1<br />

Dundee....................................................................16<br />

Dunfermline (Vine)..............................................11<br />

Dunoon..............................................................24<br />

Duns..........................................................................14<br />

Durham...................................................................14<br />

East Kilbride............................................................7<br />

Eastbourne.......................................................24<br />

Edinburgh (Currie).............................................. 17<br />

Edinburgh (Musselburgh)...............................16<br />

Elgin..........................................................................10<br />

Enfield (Brancroft Way)...............................24<br />

Enfield (Innova Business Park)..................24<br />

Erith (London)........................................................6<br />

Exeter......................................................................20<br />

Exeter LGV.......................................................24<br />

Farnborough....................................................24<br />

Featherstone........................................................14<br />

Folkestone........................................................24<br />

Forfar........................................................................18<br />

Fort William......................................................24<br />

Fraserburgh............................................................11<br />

Galashiels................................................................11<br />

Gateshead................................................................7<br />

Gillingham.........................................................24<br />

Girvan...................................................................... 57<br />

Glasgow (Anniesland).......................................18<br />

Glasgow (Baillieston)........................................15<br />

Glasgow (Shieldhall)..........................................18<br />

Gloucester........................................................24<br />

Golspie.......................................................................7<br />

Goodmayes (London)...................................24<br />

Gosforth....................................................................9<br />

Grangemouth.......................................................10<br />

Grantham (Somerby)........................................16<br />

Grantown-On-Spey......................................24<br />

Greenford (Horsenden Lane).....................24<br />

Greenham.........................................................24<br />

Greenock................................................................14<br />

Grimsby Coldwater............................................13<br />

Guildford............................................................24<br />

Haddington............................................................14<br />

Halifax......................................................................21<br />

Hamilton.................................................................. 17<br />

Hartlepool..............................................................16<br />

Hastings (Ore).................................................24<br />

Hawick.....................................................................16<br />

Heckmondwike...................................................19<br />

Hendon (London)...........................................24<br />

12 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Hereford.................................................................22<br />

Herne Bay.........................................................24<br />

Hexham...................................................................14<br />

Heysham..................................................................9<br />

High Wycombe...................................................... 4<br />

Hinckley............................................................24<br />

Hither Green (London)........................................7<br />

Hornchurch (London)....................................24<br />

Horsforth................................................................18<br />

Huddersfield.........................................................16<br />

Hull.............................................................................15<br />

Huntly................................................................24<br />

Inveraray...........................................................24<br />

Inverness (Longman Drive)........................24<br />

Inverurie....................................................................9<br />

Ipswich..............................................................24<br />

Irvine..........................................................................9<br />

Islay Island........................................................24<br />

Isle of Mull.........................................................24<br />

Isle of Skye (Portree)...........................................1<br />

Isleworth (Fleming Way).............................24<br />

Kelso...........................................................................3<br />

Kendal (Oxenholme Road).............................. 17<br />

Kettering...........................................................24<br />

Kings Lynn..............................................................15<br />

Kingussie..........................................................24<br />

Kirkcaldy.................................................................15<br />

Knaresborough....................................................13<br />

Kyle of Lochalsh..............................................24<br />

Lanark.....................................................................23<br />

Lancing..............................................................24<br />

Launceston.............................................................11<br />

Lee On The Solent..........................................24<br />

Leeds........................................................................19<br />

Leicester (Cannock Street)............................21<br />

Leicester (Wigston)...........................................21<br />

Leighton Buzzard (Stanbridge Road).........16<br />

Lerwick.............................................................24<br />

Letchworth...........................................................22<br />

Lichfield..................................................................22<br />

Lincoln.....................................................................16<br />

Livingston..............................................................15<br />

Llanelli....................................................................... 4<br />

Llantrisant.............................................................13<br />

Lochgilphead...................................................24<br />

Loughborough................................................24<br />

Loughton (London)........................................24<br />

Louth........................................................................19<br />

Lowestoft(Mobbs Way)..................................22<br />

Ludlow.....................................................................16<br />

Luton........................................................................ 17<br />

Macclesfield..........................................................13<br />

Maidstone.........................................................24<br />

Mallaig........................................................................3<br />

Malton................................................................24<br />

Melton Mowbray..................................................11<br />

Merthyr Tydfil.........................................................6<br />

Middlesbrough.....................................................21<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Mill Hill (London).............................................24<br />

Mitcham (London)..........................................24<br />

Monmouth...............................................................9<br />

Montrose..................................................................2<br />

Morden (London)............................................24<br />

Nelson.....................................................................20<br />

Newport (Gwent)..............................................22<br />

Newport (Isle of Wight)...............................24<br />

Newton Abbot......................................................10<br />

Newton Stewart....................................................9<br />

Newtown................................................................15<br />

Norris Green (Liverpool)..................................12<br />

Northallerton...................................................24<br />

Northampton...................................................24<br />

Northwich.........................................................24<br />

Norwich (Jupiter Road).......................................7<br />

Norwich (Peachman Way)..............................14<br />

Nottingham (Chilwell)...................................24<br />

Nottingham (Colwick)..................................24<br />

Nuneaton..........................................................24<br />

Oban...................................................................24<br />

Orkney...............................................................24<br />

Oswestry................................................................18<br />

Oxford (Cowley).............................................24<br />

Paisley...................................................................... 17<br />

Peebles...................................................................20<br />

Pembroke Dock.....................................................3<br />

Penzance..........................................................24<br />

Perth (Arran Road)............................................22<br />

Peterborough......................................................23<br />

Peterhead................................................................7<br />

Pinner (London)..............................................24<br />

Pitlochry.................................................................. 8<br />

Plymouth..........................................................24<br />

Plymouth LGV.................................................24<br />

Pontefract..............................................................19<br />

Poole..................................................................24<br />

Portsmouth......................................................24<br />

Preston....................................................................13<br />

Pwllheli....................................................................14<br />

Reading..............................................................24<br />

Redditch.................................................................23<br />

Redhill Aerodrome.........................................24<br />

Rhyl...........................................................................16<br />

Rochdale (Manchester)...................................13<br />

Rotherham.............................................................14<br />

Rothesay................................................................18<br />

Rugby.................................................................24<br />

Sale (Manchester)..............................................21<br />

Salisbury...........................................................24<br />

Scarborough.......................................................... 8<br />

Scunthorpe...........................................................10<br />

Sevenoaks.............................................................15<br />

Sheffield (Handsworth).....................................3<br />

Sheffield (Middlewood Road).......................22<br />

Shrewsbury...........................................................15<br />

Sidcup (London).............................................24<br />

Skegness...............................................................23<br />

DTC Name<br />

Average L-test<br />

Waiting Time<br />

Skipton....................................................................14<br />

Slough (London).............................................24<br />

Southall (London)..........................................24<br />

Southampton (Maybush)............................24<br />

Southend-on-Sea.........................................24<br />

Southport (Liverpool)......................................14<br />

Speke (Liverpool)................................................11<br />

St Albans...............................................................22<br />

St Helens (Liverpool)..........................................9<br />

Stafford...................................................................21<br />

Steeton...................................................................20<br />

Stevenage........................................................24<br />

Stirling.....................................................................14<br />

Stoke-On-Trent (Cobridge)............................11<br />

Stoke-on-Trent<br />

(Newcastle-Under-Lyme).............................16<br />

Stornoway........................................................24<br />

Stranraer................................................................10<br />

Sunderland............................................................10<br />

Swansea....................................................................1<br />

Swindon............................................................24<br />

Swindon LGV...................................................24<br />

Taunton..............................................................24<br />

Telford.....................................................................20<br />

Thurso................................................................24<br />

Tilbury................................................................24<br />

Tolworth (London).........................................24<br />

Tottenham........................................................24<br />

Trowbridge...............................................................9<br />

Tunbridge Wells..............................................24<br />

Upton..........................................................................9<br />

Uxbridge (London).........................................24<br />

Wakefield................................................................16<br />

Wallasey.................................................................10<br />

Walton LGV...........................................................20<br />

Wanstead (London).......................................24<br />

Warrington.............................................................18<br />

Warwick (Wedgenock House)...................24<br />

Watford.............................................................24<br />

Watnall.......................................................................3<br />

Wednesbury.........................................................19<br />

Wellingborough..................................................22<br />

West Didsbury (Manchester).......................21<br />

West Wickham (London).............................24<br />

Weston-super-Mare........................................12<br />

Whitby...............................................................24<br />

Wick...................................................................24<br />

Widnes..................................................................... 17<br />

Winchester.......................................................24<br />

Wolverhampton..................................................15<br />

Wood Green (London)..................................24<br />

Worcester..............................................................18<br />

Workington..............................................................6<br />

Worksop.................................................................14<br />

Wrexham................................................................21<br />

Yeading (London)...........................................24<br />

Yeovil..........................................................................7<br />

York...........................................................................18<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 13


News: The Election focus<br />

On the road to No.10<br />

What’s in store for Britain’s drivers?<br />

On Thursday, <strong>July</strong> 4, we will be given the<br />

chance to have our say on who governs us,<br />

and how, in the General Election.<br />

MSA GB, as a non-political organisation,<br />

will remain completely impartial before the<br />

election, vowing only to work with whoever<br />

forms the next Government.<br />

But we do think you should know exactly<br />

what they have in mind for motoring, driving<br />

and road safety in general, and so we have<br />

ploughed through the various manifestos and<br />

policy statements to find out what lies in<br />

store for you, the ADI community, post-<strong>July</strong> 4.<br />

What you want... and what’s missing…<br />

We have asked our members what they<br />

would like to see the parties pledge. Many<br />

have said a greater focus on driving<br />

standards and road safety would be<br />

appreciated; indeed, even a passing reference<br />

would be worth something, as it would<br />

suggest the parties understand the<br />

importance of safer driving.<br />

Sadly, however, and perhaps predictably,<br />

there is little meat in any of the parties’<br />

manifestos that directly links to learner<br />

drivers. Where road safety is mentioned, it<br />

tends to be in vague improvements to the<br />

roads network, or nebulous phrases such as<br />

‘using technology to reduce collisions’<br />

(Conservative’s Plan for Drivers).<br />

No-one has said definitely how they would<br />

tackle long waiting lists for L-tests, for<br />

example, or reforms to the current L-test.<br />

There’s nothing in there about Parts 1-3,<br />

examiners or Standards Checks – but<br />

perhaps that’s no big shock either.<br />

What is more disappointing is that there<br />

are no commitments to reducing traffic<br />

casualty statistics from any of the parties.<br />

Indeed, of the major parties, only one, the<br />

Conservatives, had a heading marked ‘Road<br />

Safety’; but before you get carried away with<br />

the idea that it is a priority area for the Tories,<br />

the section discussed scrapping low traffic<br />

neighbourhoods and 20mph zones. MSA GB<br />

doubts any road safety officer would believe<br />

that axing such schemes would in some way<br />

lower traffic collisions and casualties.<br />

Only one party, Labour, has said previously<br />

that it has an overarching goal to reduce KSI<br />

figures and get Britain’s road safety back on<br />

track as the world leader. It has promised to<br />

return a means of recording road traffic<br />

casualties and set goals for their reduction.<br />

But it should be stressed that those<br />

comments were made before the election<br />

campaign, and it did not make it into the party<br />

manifesto as official policy.<br />

“No-one has said definitely how they would tackle long waiting<br />

lists for L-tests... or reform to the L-test, Parts 1-3 or Standards<br />

Checks... there are no commitments to reducing traffic casualty<br />

statistics from any of the parties...”<br />

It does, however, suggest an awareness of<br />

the importance of road safety issues.<br />

But there is nothing on graduated driving<br />

licences – something ADIs increasingly seem<br />

to be edging towards supporting – and<br />

certainly nothing on the contents of the<br />

L-test. Any hopes of a swift cut in the<br />

drink-drive limit appear to be dashed, too, as<br />

no party has pledged to cut the 80mg limit.<br />

Interestingly, the Conservatives have<br />

resisted the temptation to promise to<br />

privatise the L-test, which is something that<br />

has been hinted at previously.<br />

However, there are plenty of nuggets of<br />

information that could suggest a roadmap for<br />

a future Government as far as driver training<br />

and testing is concerned.<br />

So what’s in store…? Find out opposite and<br />

on pages 16-18<br />

14 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


The Conservatives: Banning ULEZ, scrapping<br />

20mph blanket limits and filling pot holes<br />

Starting with the Conservatives, as the<br />

incumbent Government. Its manifesto as far<br />

as motoring is concerned is based on its ‘Plan<br />

for Drivers’ published in October 2023.<br />

You can read more about this at the link<br />

below.<br />

Click here<br />

for details<br />

At its heart is a series of announcements<br />

on what it will NOT do. It will not, for example,<br />

introduce road charging; indeed, it states that<br />

it will actively ban all urban mayors from<br />

introducing any road pricing, with a specific<br />

reference to London.<br />

It will also not allow any more ULEZ zones<br />

to be introduced, and will actively work to roll<br />

back the ones in place, stating that “Sadiq<br />

Khan’s ULEZ tax rise has had only a<br />

‘moderate’ or ‘minor’ effect on pollution.”<br />

It will also NOT allow any more top-down<br />

blanket Low Traffic Neighbourhoods or<br />

20mph zones.<br />

It acknowledges that “While 20mph zones<br />

can help improve road safety in residential<br />

areas or outside schools, misuse undermines<br />

public trust and risks congestion and<br />

pollution. We are clear they must only be<br />

considered on a road-by-road basis and with<br />

the support of people who live there.<br />

“We will require any new schemes to be<br />

put to a referendum and introduce a ‘right to<br />

challenge’ existing Low Traffic<br />

Neighbourhoods and 20mph schemes.”<br />

Electric vehicles<br />

On electric vehicles, the Conservatives say<br />

they will make sure “charging infrastructure<br />

is truly nationwide, including rapid charging”.<br />

They will stick to the ban on new petrol and<br />

diesel sales from 2035.<br />

On automated vehicles, legislation will be<br />

put down in the next Parliament to allow their<br />

greater adoption in Britain.<br />

Roads<br />

On roads, the Conservatives will invest<br />

£8.3 billion to fill potholes and resurface<br />

roads. Part of this funding will come from the<br />

cancelled second phase of HS2.<br />

The party claims to have invested £40<br />

billion in England’s strategic roads between<br />

2015 and 2025, and will deliver “further<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong><br />

investment” in the next Road Investment<br />

Strategy. This will include named road<br />

projects including the Lower Thames<br />

Crossing and the A303, and more work on<br />

the A1 between Morpeth and Ellingham.<br />

The Tories will also maintain their pledge to<br />

build no new smart motorways and invest in<br />

improving the safety of existing ones.<br />

Road safety - or not?<br />

Interestingly, the Conservative manifesto,<br />

under the heading ‘Road Safety’, includes<br />

details only of its plan to rule out top-down<br />

blanket Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs)<br />

and 20mph zones.<br />

That’s an interesting link because it<br />

suggests the Tories see such plans as<br />

compromising road safety. They might<br />

compromise traffic speed and motorists’<br />

convenience, but it is unlikely anyone has<br />

ever suggested driving slower makes you<br />

more likely to have a crash.<br />

Parking and fly tippers<br />

Other details: the Tories will create a new<br />

National Parking Platform to simplify paying<br />

for parking, and give councils the power to<br />

ban pavement parking when appropriate to<br />

help older and disabled people.<br />

Finally, why include ‘fly tipping here’?<br />

Well, the Tories have come up with a novel<br />

idea. They want to punish fly tippers by giving<br />

them penalty points on their licence.<br />

For ADIs, who have a lower threshold of<br />

points before it becomes an issue, this will<br />

make you think twice about being a litter bug!<br />

How others responded<br />

The RAC said the national parking platform<br />

was a good idea, as was a Tory plan to<br />

crackdown on rip-off fuel prices by making<br />

major petrol firms pass on lower crude prices<br />

more quickly to consumers, but the complete<br />

absence of any road casualty reduction<br />

targets was a huge disappointment.<br />

It was also concerning that by so definitely<br />

ruling out road pricing, there was no obvious<br />

way to replace fuel duty taxation revenue as<br />

motorists switch to EVs. “How will the Tories<br />

fill the blackhole in the Exchequer’s coffers?”<br />

The AA welcomed moves on potholes but<br />

is concerned that the Tories will continue with<br />

the current smart motorway network.<br />

“Simply saying we will build no more doesn’t<br />

go far enough,” the AA said.<br />

Overleaf: Labour and other parties<br />

The Tories say they will<br />

scrap ULEZ schemes<br />

15


News: The Election focus<br />

Labour: Backing EVs, potholes<br />

and road safety targets a goal<br />

Motoring sections of the Labour manifesto<br />

are based on its report in autumn 2023,<br />

Driving a Growing Economy: Labour’s Plan<br />

for the Automotive Sector<br />

You can read more about this at:<br />

Click here<br />

for details<br />

Its keynote message is a call to improve<br />

infrastructure. “We need to forge ahead with<br />

new roads, railways, reservoirs, and other<br />

nationally significant infrastructure.<br />

Rebuilding Britain means modernising our<br />

transport infrastructure. Our road network is<br />

plagued by long-promised projects that are<br />

never delivered. The potholes cratering our<br />

roads are a visible sign of the decline after 14<br />

years of Conservative rule.”<br />

It knows that “cars remain by far the most<br />

popular form of transport. Labour will<br />

maintain and renew our road network, to<br />

ensure it serves drivers, cyclists and other<br />

road users, remains safe, and tackles<br />

congestion. ”<br />

Labour pledges to fix an additional one<br />

million potholes across England in each year<br />

of the next parliament, funded by deferring<br />

the A27 bypass, which is poor value for<br />

money.<br />

It will also support the transition to electric<br />

vehicles by “accelerating the roll out of<br />

charge points, giving certainty to<br />

manufacturers by restoring the phase-out<br />

date of 2030 for new cars with internal<br />

combustion engines,<br />

and supporting buyers<br />

of secondhand electric<br />

cars by standardising<br />

the information<br />

supplied.”<br />

To back this up<br />

Labour will set new<br />

binding targets for EV<br />

charging point rollout,<br />

create a rapid<br />

recharging fund and<br />

remove planning<br />

barriers to chargepoint rollout, such as rapid<br />

charger height restrictions.<br />

Chargepoint data will be made open<br />

access and Labour would introduce Electric<br />

Vehicle Confident labelling requirement on<br />

new EVs, similar to the Monroney sticker<br />

used in the US. It will also invest £1.5 billion in<br />

new gigafactories “so our automotive<br />

industry leads the world.”<br />

Labour has also pledged support for the<br />

production of green hydrogen, which some<br />

experts see as an alternative zero emission<br />

option to battery electric cars.<br />

On car insurance<br />

Labour has said it will further support<br />

drivers by tackling the soaring cost of car<br />

insurance. Shadow Transport Secretary<br />

Louise Haigh said the Financial Conduct<br />

Authority and the Competition and Markets<br />

Authority would be instructed to launch<br />

formal investigations into the soaring price of<br />

car insurance, and unfair postcode pricing.<br />

Reform UK: Scrap Net Zero<br />

Reform UK’s main motoring goals are set out as part<br />

of its commitment to “scrap all Net Zero targets.”<br />

It will scrap the 2035 ban on selling petrol and<br />

diesel cars, and the legal requirements manufacturers<br />

are currently set to sell EVs (the ZEV mandate).<br />

However, interestingly, it would also “increase and<br />

incentivise UK lithium mining for electric batteries” as<br />

part of a push for cleaner energy.<br />

Scrapping Net Zero would save the UK save £30<br />

billion in annualised savings.<br />

On the roads<br />

Reform would scrap all ULEZ schemes and Low<br />

Traffic Neighburhoods. All 20mph limits would be<br />

returned to 30mph – but “we will keep the speed limit<br />

low where safety is critical.”<br />

Reform will accelerate already announced transport<br />

infrastructure - which includes the new £4.7 billion<br />

Local Transport Fund announced in February by the<br />

Tories - particularly focusing on the North.<br />

A national database for councils, contractors,<br />

government and utilities would be launched to<br />

co-ordinate projects, and reduce road works, waste<br />

and delays.<br />

Reform would also look to deliver a 20p cut in fuel<br />

duty, per litre, though this is not a manifesto<br />

commitment; rather, it is a goal of former leader and<br />

current party Chairman Richard Tice.<br />

Road safety<br />

No pledge was made to re-introduce<br />

national road safety targets but the party<br />

has suggested previously that it would<br />

commit to a reduction strategy in the next<br />

parliament<br />

What others said<br />

The RAC said it was “pleased to see major<br />

concerns for drivers, such as local road<br />

maintenance and the transition to electric<br />

vehicles, high on the list of Labour’s priorities<br />

if they win power.”<br />

The AA criticised a lack of detail around the<br />

funding for potholes. It also called on Labour<br />

to commit to a new plug-in car grant to bring<br />

down the cost of EVs. This has been a<br />

previous policy, but was not a costed<br />

commitment in the manifesto. However, the<br />

AA said it was “pleased the Labour Manifesto<br />

reflects many of the policies outlined in The<br />

AA Motoring Manifesto”.<br />

16 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Lib Dems: 2030 ban on ICE;<br />

keep DVLA in Post Office<br />

The Lib Dems say they will make it “cheaper<br />

and easier to switch to electric vehicles” by<br />

bringing back the 2030 ban on new petrol<br />

and diesel cars and small vans.<br />

They will roll-out more recharging<br />

infrastructure – both on-street and<br />

ultra-fast chargers at service stations - and<br />

require all charging points to be bank card<br />

payment compatible.<br />

VAT on public charging will be slashed to 5<br />

per cent - something the EV sector has been<br />

lobbying for.<br />

The EV plug-in car grant will be reintroduced.<br />

The Tories stopped this in June<br />

2022 but it has been called for by the auto<br />

industry as the price differential between<br />

petrol/diesel vehicles and EVs remains high.<br />

On car insurance, Liberal Democrats will<br />

“protect motorists from<br />

unfair insurance”, though no<br />

further details were given.<br />

The party also committed<br />

to protecting motorists<br />

from rip-off petrol prices,<br />

investigating fuel prices and<br />

looking at the disparity<br />

between wholesale prices falling and the lag<br />

until these are reflected at the pump. It will<br />

also help rural drivers through the Rural Fuel<br />

Duty Relief, cutting 5p a litre from pump<br />

prices.<br />

One final point the other parties have not<br />

covered: the Lib Dems will keep DVLA<br />

services available at Post Office counters.<br />

These are due to expire April 2025, which<br />

would mean everyone renewing driving<br />

licences and buying road tax ,<br />

for example, has to do it<br />

online.<br />

What others said…<br />

The RAC “welcomes<br />

promises of more money for<br />

local road maintenance,<br />

ensuring fuel prices are fair and additional<br />

support for the transition to electric vehicles”<br />

but calls out the “lack of clear spending<br />

allocation”.<br />

Its transport & environment UK policy<br />

manager Matt Finch said the Lib Dems are<br />

“the only party to see that an upgraded<br />

national electricity grid comes hand in hand<br />

with improving the nation’s charging<br />

infrastructure for electric vehicles”.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 17


News: The Election focus<br />

Green Party: Total ban on petrol<br />

and diesel car use by 2035<br />

It may not come as a surprise<br />

that cars and the Green Party are<br />

not best buddies. If we have a<br />

Green Government, all sales of<br />

new ICE cars will end in 2027, with<br />

a total ban on petrol and diesel<br />

fuel use by 2035. That means<br />

cars built next year would have a<br />

10-year lifecycle if they are not<br />

full electric.<br />

But it would support motorists<br />

with a generous vehicle scrappage scheme,<br />

with funding rising to £5 billion by the end of<br />

the parliament, supported by the rollout of<br />

rapid charging points.<br />

It would push for a zero-carbon society as<br />

soon as possible, with a zero carbon<br />

electricity supply by 2040. ULEZ schemes<br />

would be mandatory through a Clean Air Act<br />

‘to set new air quality standards for the UK’.<br />

Overall, the transport system would be<br />

switched to “shift away from cars and<br />

roads”, with a move to cleaner public<br />

transport instead. A fuel duty escalator<br />

would raise tax by a percentage each year, in<br />

the same way that cigarettes have been<br />

taxed to decrease usage.<br />

The SNP: EV grants,<br />

fair transition<br />

The SNP’s manifesto is largely silent on<br />

motoring, with any transport policies<br />

focused on bringing rail under state control<br />

and improving aviation links.<br />

Where it does tackle transport it is from<br />

the Net Zero angle. The SNP would like to<br />

promote a fair and affordable transition to<br />

zero-emission transport fuels and ban the<br />

import and sale of new, non zero-emission<br />

buses by 2025.<br />

It would like to strengthen incentives to<br />

purchase cleaner vehicles. Following the<br />

example of France, the UK Government<br />

should establish a new Low Income EV Car<br />

Leasing Fund, backed up by at least £500m,<br />

to enable 50,000 EV leases a year to<br />

benefit low income families.<br />

Invest in safer roads<br />

This heading does offer a glimmer of<br />

The focus would be on safe<br />

streets and active travel:<br />

“Walking, wheeling and cycling<br />

don’t just help reduce carbon<br />

emissions and air pollution – they<br />

can make us all happier and<br />

healthier too,” the Greens said.<br />

There would be a huge<br />

commitment to cycleways and<br />

footpaths, with £2.5bn funding,<br />

and towns and cities would work<br />

with residents “to re-imagine how we use<br />

roads and streets, opening them up for<br />

community use.” The goal would be for 50%<br />

of trips in England’s towns and cities to be<br />

walked, wheeled or cycled by 2030.<br />

What others said…<br />

The Institute for Fiscal Studies said: “While<br />

‘it is clear where the Green Party’s ambitions<br />

lie - a much bigger role for the state, better<br />

funded public services, and, of course, a<br />

swifter transition to net zero [...] it is unlikely<br />

that the specific tax-raising measures they<br />

propose to help achieve all this would raise<br />

the sorts of sums they claim - and certainly<br />

not without real economic cost.”<br />

hope that road<br />

safety will play its<br />

part, but alas, the<br />

entire focus is on<br />

the state of the<br />

roads. Reducing<br />

road traffic is key<br />

to cutting emissions, SNP says, but in a<br />

rural and sparsely populated country, not<br />

everywhere and everyone can be expected<br />

to make the same changes at the same<br />

time. “It is vital that we ensure roads are as<br />

safe, reliable and resilient as possible. We<br />

are committed to dualling the A9 in full<br />

between Perth and Inverness and<br />

improving the A96, including dualling<br />

Inverness to Nairn and the Nairn Bypass.<br />

We will press the UK Government to fulfil<br />

their commitment to fund improvements to<br />

the A75.”<br />

Plaid Cymru: We take<br />

road safety seriously<br />

We leave the best till last...<br />

Step forward and take a bow, Plaid Cymru,<br />

the only major political party to have a<br />

designated section in their manifesto<br />

devoted to road safety.<br />

It is small, but it is there, so well done.<br />

We’ll publish it in full:<br />

Road Safety<br />

Road safety is a crucial part of daily life in<br />

Wales, whether as a driver of passenger.<br />

Unfortunately, many accidents on the road<br />

are due to careless driving. We will identify<br />

roads which have a higher than anticipated<br />

number of accidents and work with local<br />

government and Welsh Government,<br />

whichever is responsible, to make changes to<br />

make them safer and reduce accidents.<br />

This can include additional signage,<br />

changes to road layout, as well as investment<br />

in average speed cameras.<br />

While Plaid Cymru supports the principle of<br />

the introduction of the 20mph speed zone<br />

across roads in Wales in order to reduce the<br />

number of accidents and life-changing<br />

injuries, we believe that it was poorly<br />

implemented by the Labour Welsh<br />

Government.<br />

We support a review to ensure it is working<br />

successfully across Wales in reducing<br />

dangerous driving in urban areas. Lessons<br />

must be learned to ensure that the public<br />

understand the changes being made and<br />

involved in local decision-making.<br />

Plaid Cymru will consider what other<br />

powers can be used to improve driver<br />

behaviour, particularly of younger drivers<br />

who are statistically shown to be involved in<br />

greater numbers of traffic collisions.<br />

18 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Tragedy suggests more training required<br />

While ADIs currently boast of full diaries, it’s<br />

hardly surprising that many will stick to the<br />

training that delivers the best return:<br />

teaching learners.<br />

But those long-time ADIs who have been<br />

through periods of feast before know that<br />

famine often follows swiftly behind, which is<br />

why they are always looking to open new<br />

avenues of income and broaden their<br />

portfolio.<br />

One such avenue has been created – as<br />

often happens, sadly – by a tragedy: the<br />

death of 19-year-old Harry Dunn.<br />

Readers will no doubt be aware of the case,<br />

but we’ll fill in some of the blanks for those<br />

who don’t know it. In 2019, Harry was riding<br />

his motorcycle near to RAF Croughton, a<br />

United States Air Force listening station,<br />

when he was hit by a car and killed.<br />

It was quickly ascertained that the driver<br />

of the car was Anne Sacoolas, the wife of a<br />

serviceman on the base. As a US citizen<br />

unfamiliar with UK rules of the road, she was<br />

on the wrong side of the road when she<br />

struck and killed Harry.<br />

Sacoolas fled the UK days after, with the<br />

US authorities claiming she had diplomatic<br />

immunity, thus meaning she could avoid<br />

punishment.<br />

The US’s refusal to extradite Sacoolas to<br />

the UK to face motoring charges led to a<br />

considerable diplomatic fall-out, with the UK<br />

and US Governments clashing over what<br />

should happen to her. The UK pointed out<br />

that Sacoolas did not have diplomatic<br />

immunity, as she was only the wife of a<br />

serving officer, and that the issue of<br />

immunity was meant to prevent abuses by<br />

hostile nations of diplomatic staff, and not to<br />

cover all wrong-doing of personnel. The UK<br />

also cited a US precedent for a similar case in<br />

1997, when Gueorgui Makharadze, a<br />

Georgian diplomat serving in Washington DC,<br />

Right, Anne<br />

Sacoolas and Harry<br />

Dunn. Sacoolas had<br />

received no training<br />

on driving on the<br />

left in the UK by her<br />

husband’s<br />

employer, the USAF<br />

was jailed for three years after causing a<br />

crash in the capital which killed a teenage girl.<br />

At the time, Georgia waived his rights to<br />

immunity, given the circumstances.<br />

The UK’s pleas fell on deaf ears, and<br />

Sacoolas remains in the US to this day. In<br />

2022 she was sentenced to eight months<br />

imprisonment, suspended for 12 months, and<br />

disqualified from driving for 12 months. She<br />

had not attended the sentencing in person on<br />

the advice of the US Government, despite the<br />

request of the judge.<br />

So what is the opportunity for ADIs? Well,<br />

the recent coroner’s inquest revealed that US<br />

servicemen are given familiarisation lessons<br />

when they arrive in the UK, though this only<br />

tends to be granted to officers and those<br />

whose roles demand they often leave the<br />

base and drive to other sites in the UK. It is<br />

seen as a familiarisation exercise, rather than<br />

comprehensive training.<br />

Family members do not receive any<br />

training, nor do personnel whose duties<br />

would not usually take them on to the UK’s<br />

roads.<br />

It certainly feels like there are big gaps in<br />

the training schedule given, and it does not<br />

cover everyone living on US military sites.<br />

Is there an opportunity for ADIs to get<br />

involved in this training for military<br />

personnel? Similarly, do the many embassies<br />

and consulates around the UK offer training<br />

for their staff? What about large overseas<br />

companies who have operations in the UK,<br />

such as banks and multi-nationals, staffed by<br />

people who need help handling UK roads? Do<br />

these organisations need help with driver<br />

training? Could you help?<br />

With the Harry Dunn tragedy fresh in<br />

people’s minds, this may be an ideal<br />

opportunity to fire the starting gun to<br />

improve driver safety for temporary foreign<br />

residents in the UK using the skills of MSA<br />

(GB) members.<br />

Finally, bear this in mind: the Dunn case<br />

was not an isolated incident. In 2023, another<br />

US citizen based in the UK for his work was<br />

involved in a similiar incident. Issac Calderon,<br />

a US citizen described as “associated with<br />

the secret service”, left the UK days before a<br />

court appearance after his car was involved in<br />

a crash that left a nurse, Elizabeth Donowho,<br />

unable to walk for six weeks.<br />

Her lawyer, Radd Sieger, claimed that road<br />

incidents involving US citizens “happen all the<br />

time”, noting comments made by the then<br />

Conservative MP David Mellor in the 1980s,<br />

who claimed 2,000 US servicemen had been<br />

convicted for traffic offences in the previous<br />

year.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 19


ETSC PIN report on road casualties<br />

Finland wins European Transport Safety<br />

Council’s road safety prize for <strong>2024</strong><br />

New analysis shows EU road<br />

deaths as a whole declined by<br />

just 1% last year, putting 2030<br />

targets in danger<br />

Finland has won the <strong>2024</strong> European<br />

Transport Safety Council prize for<br />

outstanding progress in road safety after the<br />

Scandinavian nation reduced road deaths by<br />

a substantial 29% from 2013-2023, while the<br />

average decline in Europe was just 16%.<br />

The accolade, known as the Road Safety<br />

Performance Index (PIN) award, recognises<br />

Finland’s progress in road safety and is a<br />

testament to the country’s long-term<br />

targets and comprehensive strategy for<br />

improving the road safety of all road users.<br />

Antonio Avenoso, Executive Director of the<br />

European Transport Safety Council said: “In<br />

Finland, they say ‘vahinko ei tule kello<br />

kaulassa’ which roughly translates as<br />

‘accidents don’t come with a bell around their<br />

necks’. That may explain why the Finnish<br />

take such a comprehensive and strategic<br />

approach that seeks to cover many different<br />

aspects of road danger.<br />

“The effort doesn’t end when crashes<br />

happen either; Finland is the only country in<br />

Europe that does an in-depth investigation of<br />

every single fatal collision. We congratulate<br />

Finland on its progress over the last ten<br />

years, and hope they will be inspired to<br />

redouble their efforts to reach their ambitious<br />

targets for the future.”<br />

EU progress on cutting road deaths<br />

stagnated in 2023<br />

The announcement coincides with new<br />

analysis published by ETSC which shows<br />

there were 20,418 deaths on European roads<br />

last year. This represents a decrease of only<br />

1% compared to 2022, falling far short of the<br />

6.1% annual reduction needed to achieve the<br />

EU target of a 50 % reduction by 2030.<br />

Following European elections last month,<br />

ETSC is calling for the establishment of an EU<br />

road safety agency, with specific powers<br />

such as managing the roll-out of automated<br />

vehicles, and carrying out crash<br />

investigations. While the other main<br />

transport modes in Europe (aviation,<br />

maritime and rail) have dedicated EU<br />

agencies responsible for safety, there is no<br />

such agency for road transport.<br />

ETSC is also urging the European<br />

Commission to start work on a new revision<br />

of vehicle safety regulations to account for<br />

rapidly advancing safety technologies and to<br />

push ahead with reforms to periodic technical<br />

inspections of vehicles to ensure these<br />

technologies are maintained over a vehicle’s<br />

lifetime.<br />

Commenting on the next five-year<br />

mandate of the European Parliament and<br />

Commission, Mr Avenoso commented:<br />

“Road safety needs to be a priority once<br />

again. 100,000 people died on EU roads over<br />

the last five years, and 100,000 more will die<br />

over the next five if nothing changes. The<br />

newly elected MEPs and appointed<br />

Commissioners must hit the ground running.”<br />

What are the goals for reducing road fatalities?<br />

The EU has set a target to halve the number<br />

of road deaths by 2030, based on their level<br />

in 2019. Most European countries have<br />

similar national targets. While the UK is no<br />

longer part of the EU, this country has no<br />

road safety targets.<br />

There were 20,418 deaths on EU roads in<br />

2023, a collective decrease of 1% compared<br />

to 2022, falling far short of the 6.1% annual<br />

reduction needed to achieve the EU target of<br />

a 50% reduction by 2030.<br />

18 of the 32 countries monitored by ETSC’s<br />

Road Safety Performance Index (PIN)<br />

Programme saw a decline in road deaths in<br />

2023 compared to 2022. Malta led with a<br />

38% reduction, followed by Luxembourg at<br />

27%, Belgium at 11% and Hungary at 10%.<br />

However, road deaths stagnated in two<br />

countries, and increased in 12, with Lithuania<br />

experiencing a significant increase of 33%,<br />

and Latvia’s deaths increasing by 26%.<br />

Compared to 2019, the baseline year for<br />

the EU 2030 target, 19 countries showed a<br />

reduction in road deaths by 2023. Poland and<br />

Cyprus lead the ranking with a significant<br />

decrease of 35%.<br />

Belgium and Denmark follow with<br />

reductions of 25% and 22%, respectively.<br />

Road deaths in Malta remained stable with a<br />

0% change.<br />

An increase in road deaths was observed in<br />

11 countries within the same period. Ireland<br />

experienced an increase of 32%, while<br />

Switzerland saw an increase of 26%.<br />

Collectively, the EU27 achieved a decrease<br />

of road deaths of 10% in 2023 relative to<br />

2019. However, to align with the EU’s target<br />

for 2030, a reduction of at least 22% would<br />

have been necessary.<br />

Between 2014 and 2023, the EU prevented<br />

20,981 road deaths compared to the situation<br />

where each Member State had maintained<br />

the same number of fatalities as in 2013.<br />

It’s important to note that an additional<br />

52,754 lives could have been saved if the<br />

annual reduction of 6.7% required to achieve<br />

the 50% reduction target within a decade had<br />

been consistently reached.<br />

20 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Reducing road deaths, the Helsinki way<br />

The success of Finland’s reduction of road<br />

deaths has been put down to its adoption of<br />

a Traffic Safety Strategy guided by Vision<br />

Zero, ie, that by 2050, no one should die or be<br />

seriously injured on the road, regardless of<br />

the mode of transport.<br />

Since 2000, Finland has implemented<br />

several important measures to improve road<br />

safety. These include:<br />

n Lower speed limits in most urban areas<br />

n Construction of pedestrian and bicycle<br />

paths<br />

n Construction of 400 km of motorways,<br />

installation of automatic speed cameras on<br />

nearly 3,000 km of main roads.<br />

Finland’s National Traffic Safety Strategy<br />

2022–2026 aims to improve the traffic skills<br />

of different road users and different age<br />

groups comprehensively.<br />

The strategy includes two indicators aimed<br />

at the road safety of children: the proportion<br />

of schools that have traffic education as part<br />

of their year plan; and the number of<br />

collisions involving a child or young person.<br />

Finland’s National Mental Health Strategy<br />

and Programme for Suicide Prevention<br />

2020–2030 will also contribute to improving<br />

road safety for road users of all ages, as in<br />

Finland prioritising mental health is another<br />

element strongly linked to traffic safety.<br />

Finland is one of only two EU countries to<br />

include suicides on the road in road death<br />

statistics (the other is Estonia).<br />

Amazingly, Finland’s road death statistics<br />

are therefore higher than they would be if<br />

these deaths were excluded as in other<br />

countries.<br />

Finland reports motorcycle and moped<br />

helmet-wearing rates of between 99-100%.<br />

The police are allowed to make random<br />

alcohol and drug tests for drivers.<br />

Self-reported drink-driving is much lower<br />

than the EU average and acceptance towards<br />

drink-driving is generally very low. Alcohol<br />

interlocks must be fitted in all school coaches<br />

and school taxis in Finland.<br />

The devices are also installed in the<br />

vehicles of convicted drink-drivers as part of<br />

a long-running rehabilitation programme<br />

used as an alternative to a driving ban.<br />

Download the report at: www.etsc.eu/pin18<br />

Improving road safety: EU proposals<br />

In 2023, the European Commission<br />

published proposals for three pieces of road<br />

safety legislation known as the ‘road safety<br />

package’, which it hopes will drive major<br />

improvements in its road safety.<br />

The trio are:<br />

n the revision of the EU driving licence<br />

directive;<br />

n the revision of the cross-border<br />

enforcement (CBE) directive;<br />

n and a proposal for a new EU directive on<br />

driving disqualifications.<br />

The Commission also published a proposal<br />

for the revision of the directive on the<br />

maximum weights and dimensions of road<br />

vehicles.<br />

Driving licence directive<br />

These include a proposed probationary<br />

period for novice drivers, but also allowed<br />

drivers with alcohol abuse disorders to drive<br />

as part of an alcohol interlock rehabilitation<br />

programme.<br />

Another controversial plan is to reduce the<br />

age for accompanied driving for category C<br />

licence holders (lorries) to 17 years. The<br />

same concerns apply to proposals to allow<br />

category D vehicles (buses and coaches) to<br />

be driven by 18-year-olds.<br />

Cross Border Enforcement (CBE) Directive<br />

The CBE directive is aimed to facilitate the<br />

enforcement of financial penalties against<br />

drivers who commit an offence in a different<br />

EU Member State to the one where the<br />

vehicle is registered.<br />

EU-wide effect of certain driving<br />

disqualifications<br />

This proposal states that driver<br />

disqualification should apply in all EU<br />

Members, not just the country where the<br />

driving offences were committed.<br />

The European Council is yet to publish its<br />

common position. Negotiations on this will<br />

soon take place.<br />

Maximum weights and dimensions<br />

of road vehicles<br />

The Weights and Dimensions Directive<br />

96/53/EC1 sets out maximum authorised<br />

weights and dimensions for heavy-duty<br />

vehicles such as lorries and buses.<br />

The latest proposals will normalise<br />

cross-border traffic of very long and heavy<br />

vehicles between Member States that<br />

authorise them.<br />

ETSC has serious concerns about the<br />

impact of Longer and Heavier Vehicles on<br />

road safety.<br />

These vehicles have been allowed to<br />

circulate under strict conditions, as part of<br />

trials or special bilateral agreements, but all<br />

the impacts of wider adoption have not<br />

been fully assessed.<br />

The Council is yet to publish its common<br />

position. Once the Council has reached its<br />

position and following the European<br />

Parliament elections in June <strong>2024</strong>,<br />

negotiations can take place between the<br />

institutions to reach a final deal.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 21


ETSC PIN report on road casualties<br />

Norway reclaims top spot; UK third on<br />

road deaths<br />

In 2023 in the EU27, average road mortality<br />

was 46 deaths per million inhabitants<br />

compared to 55 per million in 2013.<br />

Mortality in the Road Safety Performance<br />

Index (PIN) countries differs by a factor of<br />

almost four between the groups of countries<br />

with the highest and the lowest mortality.<br />

In 2023 Norway was the leader among the<br />

PIN countries, with 20 road deaths per million<br />

inhabitants. Sweden follows with 22 deaths<br />

per million. The UK was third, with 25 deaths<br />

per million. Denmark, Switzerland, Malta,<br />

Finland, Germany and Ireland all have road<br />

mortality that is below or equal to 35 deaths<br />

per million.<br />

The highest mortality is in Bulgaria and<br />

Romania with 82 and 81 road deaths per<br />

million inhabitants respectively.<br />

In three countries – Spain, Slovakia and the<br />

Netherlands – road mortality is higher in 2023<br />

than it was in 2013.<br />

The map shows road<br />

deaths across Europe.<br />

The Scandinavian<br />

nations continue to<br />

lead the way, followed<br />

by the UK, Ireland,<br />

Germany and Spain.<br />

However, Ireland has<br />

seen recent reductions<br />

in road deaths<br />

reversed, with a rise in<br />

fatalities in the past<br />

couple of years. There<br />

were 82 road fatalities<br />

in Ireland up to 7 June<br />

<strong>2024</strong> as opposed to 75<br />

to the same time in<br />

2023.<br />

The worst-offening<br />

nations continue to be<br />

in Central Europe and<br />

the Balkans.<br />

22 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Private healthcare<br />

is peace of mind<br />

No matter how fit and healthy we are, it is<br />

inevitable that at some point in our lives we<br />

will fall ill and need medical care. And when<br />

illness does strike it is to the NHS that most<br />

people will turn in seeking a diagnosis,<br />

treatment and recovery.<br />

The NHS has for some years been showing<br />

signs that it, too, is not in the best of health. A<br />

growing and ageing population is putting an<br />

ever-increasing strain on staff and services.<br />

This is a problem exacerbated by the<br />

coronavirus pandemic.<br />

Reports of underfunding, a shortage of<br />

medical staff, noisy and overcrowded wards,<br />

cancelled operations and long waiting times<br />

will be familiar to everyone.<br />

In England, hospital waiting lists are longer<br />

than ever before, with a total waiting list of<br />

7.75 million people.* This is the highest<br />

number since records began and illustrates<br />

the severe pressure that the NHS is under.<br />

Quick, private and convenient<br />

Understandably, these lengthy delays are<br />

causing additional stress for patients,<br />

undermining their health and quality of life<br />

even further. How many people do you know<br />

whose physical health and mental well-being<br />

has deteriorated from the anxiety of having<br />

to wait months for a hospital appointment?<br />

All this can be avoided by taking out private<br />

health insurance. Seeing a doctor in private<br />

practice used to be only for the wealthy, but<br />

not anymore as the cost of private medical<br />

cover is becoming more affordable.<br />

A private medical plan delivers prompt<br />

access to hospital consultants, thus avoiding<br />

lengthy waiting lists. Patients can choose<br />

from an extensive list of hospitals throughout<br />

the UK; if they need to be admitted, they will<br />

have their own private room equipped with<br />

TV and telephone, and visiting is arranged to<br />

suit patient and family.<br />

A quick, private and convenient service<br />

that removes many of the anxieties<br />

associated with NHS hospital stays.<br />

Taking control of your healthcare<br />

However, those interested in taking out<br />

health insurance should not leave it too late.<br />

As we get older our healthcare needs<br />

increase. Therefore, as only some of the best<br />

health insurance companies provide cover for<br />

pre-existing conditions, the best time to<br />

invest in getting private treatment for<br />

illnesses you may suffer tomorrow – is today.<br />

By acting now you can ensure your future<br />

healthcare will not be dictated by NHS<br />

bureaucracy and, just as importantly, you will<br />

be able to benefit from the widest possible<br />

cover.<br />

Private health insurance cannot guarantee<br />

good health, but it can ensure that when you<br />

are feeling unwell you will quickly receive the<br />

best possible care, when and where you want<br />

it. The peace of mind that comes with that<br />

knowledge cannot be underestimated and is<br />

often the most important factor for people<br />

deciding to take control of their healthcare<br />

provision and “go private”.<br />

For further information and a no obligation<br />

quotation contact HMCA by telephone on<br />

01423 799949 or visit the exclusive HMCA<br />

Motor Schools Association of GB website<br />

here: https://www.hmca.co.uk/msa<br />

© HMCA/S PLC (trading as Hospital and Medical<br />

Care Association, HMCA and HMCA Members) is<br />

authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct<br />

Authority (FRN:307587). HMCA/s PLC is a<br />

company registered in England, company number:<br />

01362094, registered office: Beech Hall,<br />

Knaresborough, North Yorkshire, HG5 0EA.<br />

*The Telegraph 16th October 2023<br />

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/health-fitness/<br />

body/nhs-wait-list-private-treatment-backlogsurgery/<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 23


Towards your CPD<br />

Teaching strategies require<br />

the Goldilocks touch<br />

Which teaching and learning<br />

strategies work best for you,<br />

and your pupils, asks ADI and<br />

instructor trainer Steve Garrod?<br />

Teaching and learning strategies are activities<br />

and methods used to engage and motivate<br />

pupils to help them to learn. They provide<br />

opportunities to develop practical skills,<br />

knowledge and understanding of the<br />

subjects being taught, and for trainers to<br />

assess the pupil is engaged in the learning<br />

process.<br />

If you can find out what your pupils’<br />

preferences are, you can adapt your<br />

approaches accordingly. There are many<br />

ways that people learn, known as learning<br />

styles.<br />

All trainers have preferred teaching styles,<br />

just as pupils have preferred learning styles.<br />

The approaches you use are likely to depend<br />

on what is being taught, the environment (in<br />

our case, the road and traffic conditions) and<br />

the pupil’s experience, ability and learning<br />

style.<br />

Instructor-centred methods (known as<br />

pedagogy) mean that it is generally the<br />

instructor who is responsible for making<br />

decisions about how students will learn,<br />

whereas learner-centred methods<br />

(andragogy) transfer the responsibility for<br />

learning from the trainer to the pupil.<br />

An instructor-centred approach may result<br />

in an instructor deciding to teach the same<br />

thing in the same way to all pupils, eg,<br />

‘explain, demonstrate and practice’, whereas<br />

a pupil-centred approach helps pupils learn in<br />

a way that is better suited to their learning<br />

style.<br />

Although the temptation may be to do<br />

what works best for you, research suggests<br />

that pupils learn best when the focus is on<br />

learning, rather than teaching. This does not<br />

mean you shouldn’t incorporate traditional<br />

instructor-centred methods into your<br />

lessons; it just means they should not be the<br />

ONLY methods used. Wherever possible it is<br />

best to use a mixture of both approaches and<br />

vary the methods you use. This will ensure<br />

that the syllabus gets covered in a structured<br />

way and that pupils play an active part during<br />

their lessons.<br />

Client-centred learning<br />

Client-centred learning is the preferred<br />

approach in driver education and is a key<br />

element of the Standards Check. Learnercentred<br />

methods encourage trainers to<br />

motivate pupils to accept responsibility for<br />

what they are learning by using a variety of<br />

interactive methods.<br />

These methods, often referred to as<br />

coaching, require trainers to create a suitable<br />

learning environment where pupils feel safe,<br />

secure, confident and valued.<br />

Safe – that they learn in road and traffic<br />

conditions which are not beyond their<br />

limitations<br />

Secure – that they feel able to ask<br />

questions or make mistakes without<br />

embarrassment<br />

Confident – that they are given sufficient<br />

time to carry out new tasks successfully<br />

Valued – that their instructor actively<br />

seeks feedback and that their input<br />

contributes to the learning process<br />

Trainers should, however, recognise the<br />

strengths and limitations of each method to<br />

ensure they remain fit for purpose. For<br />

example, constantly having discussions<br />

about key learning points could be time<br />

consuming and it could become too easy to<br />

deviate from the aim of the lesson.<br />

Let’s have a look at the headings in this<br />

section of the form.<br />

Was the teaching style suited to the pupil’s<br />

learning styles and current ability?<br />

There may be occasions when it is more<br />

appropriate to use an instructor-centred<br />

approach and still include the pupil during the<br />

lesson to help keep it interactive. For<br />

example, to keep a situation safe or if your<br />

pupil is having difficulty with something<br />

specific, such as moving off from an uphill<br />

junction in heavy traffic.<br />

It may be less stressful for them to be<br />

talked through moving off or prompted (as to<br />

what to do next) to prevent them stalling<br />

(often again). Once they have experienced a<br />

successful move off it may increase their<br />

confidence to attempt the next junction with<br />

a little less help from you.<br />

24 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

It is not a sign of weakness to revert to<br />

such a method if that is what you feel the<br />

pupil needs to gain confidence. It is important<br />

to remember the full title of this heading and<br />

match your teaching method to your pupil’s<br />

ability as well as their preferred learning<br />

style.<br />

Likewise, it is important to recognise when<br />

a pupil has got the ability to be more<br />

independent, therefore allowing them to<br />

think and act upon situations for themselves,<br />

with little if any input from you. Constantly<br />

asking questions can be off putting and<br />

doesn’t necessarily mean that the pupil is<br />

learning anything.<br />

For example, asking them what the next<br />

road sign is before they reach it. The question<br />

could act as an unintentional prompt. Allow<br />

them to call out signs as they drive by all<br />

means, but also encourage them to work<br />

things out for themselves. This is a common<br />

fault when dealing with experienced and<br />

qualified drivers. If they are a qualified driver,<br />

treat them as such and not as a learner!<br />

Was the pupil encouraged to analyse<br />

problems and take responsibility for their<br />

learning?<br />

This really is a good example of clientcentred<br />

learning. Think about how you could<br />

ask some questions to encourage reflection<br />

and problem solving.<br />

For example, your pupil stops short of a<br />

Give Way line subsequently restricting their<br />

view of the new road. Asking ‘How could you<br />

improve your view?’ should encourage your<br />

pupil to work out the problem. It might be<br />

that they feel the end of their bonnet is about<br />

to enter the new road which could be the<br />

reason for stopping short. Likewise, if there is<br />

an element of coasting on approach to the<br />

T-junction, you could ask ‘How could you<br />

make that easier next time?’ or ‘How did that<br />

feel?’ or ‘Why do you think the car gathered<br />

speed?’ and ‘What could you do differently<br />

next time?’<br />

Asking open questions encourages<br />

discussion and more thought even though<br />

you may feel you prefer to tell them what<br />

went wrong and how to put it right. Think of<br />

this as investing time in your pupils: it really<br />

will pay you back with interest in the long run.<br />

Were opportunities and examples used to<br />

clarify learning outcomes?<br />

As this heading suggests, use what you<br />

can see on the road with other road users, for<br />

example, you may be dealing with<br />

roundabouts, and you see another driver<br />

follow the outside of a roundabout when<br />

“For example, ask them what<br />

the next road sign is before they<br />

reach it. The question could act<br />

as an unintentional prompt.<br />

Allow them to call out signs as<br />

they drive by all means, but<br />

also encourage them to work<br />

things out for themselves.”<br />

follow the road ahead (for example the 2nd<br />

exit). This is an excellent opportunity to bring<br />

this to your pupil’s attention and explain that<br />

is the correct position for a specific exit. You<br />

could also use other examples, such as if<br />

someone has given way to you in a busy road,<br />

you could highlight the position the other<br />

driver has taken to help you to proceed. You<br />

could also discuss not so good road<br />

procedure and ask how they could have made<br />

that easier for other drivers.<br />

It really is about being alert and using what<br />

is available to reinforce key learning points.<br />

Was the technical information given<br />

comprehensive, appropriate and accurate?<br />

We do use a certain amount of jargon in<br />

everyday teaching. For example, if we are<br />

dealing with ‘meeting’ does the pupil<br />

understand what that means? Or MSPSL- do<br />

they know what it means and how each<br />

element is linked to each phase?<br />

Were the pupil’s queries followed up and<br />

answered?<br />

If your pupil asks you a question, it’s often<br />

because they are unsure of something, so it’s<br />

important that their questions are answered<br />

at a time when they are able to listen to the<br />

answer. This could involve a short stop or wait<br />

until there are fewer hazards to break their<br />

concentration. Be careful of the learner who<br />

keeps asking ‘Can I go’ or ‘What is that driver<br />

doing?’<br />

There is no harm answering a question<br />

with another question, in this case ‘What do<br />

you think?’ We do need our pupils to think for<br />

themselves as they near their driving test.<br />

Did the trainer maintain an appropriate<br />

non-discriminatory manner throughout the<br />

session?<br />

It’s unusual to score low marks here but be<br />

aware of stereotyping other drivers and their<br />

vehicles, for example, ‘White van drivers<br />

never give way’. Making such remarks<br />

encourages negative thoughts so always try<br />

to stay positive.<br />

At the end of the session – was the pupil<br />

encouraged to reflect on their own<br />

performance?<br />

This is an essential part of the lesson,<br />

because it builds a foundation for the next<br />

lesson. Encourage your pupil to give their<br />

feedback first before you give yours. This<br />

way you will see if they have identified what<br />

went well and what needs to be improved.<br />

You can then give praise for identifying both<br />

elements and it helps you to agree on what<br />

needs to be covered next time.<br />

It is worth using an Standards Check<br />

Report Form (SC1) at the end of some of your<br />

lessons to help you reflect on your<br />

performance, to help you keep yourself at a<br />

Grade A standard.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 25


Towards your CPD<br />

Part 2 & 3: Trainees face challenge of<br />

finding a test as DVSA struggles continue<br />

Part 2 and Part 3 Testing<br />

and Licensing FAQs<br />

In light of the current challenges faced by<br />

PDIs and their trainers in relation to Part 2<br />

and 3 testing, and the knock-on impact of<br />

test supply issues on all licence acquisition,<br />

the National Associations Strategic<br />

Partnership have compiled a set of frequently<br />

asked questions which may help answer<br />

some trainees with their queries and<br />

concerns. If you are a trainer, this is vital<br />

information to pass on to your trainees.<br />

1. Why is there such a problem with waiting<br />

times and cancellations for Part 2 and 3<br />

tests?<br />

As DVSA continues to battle a backlog of<br />

Category B tests post-pandemic, there’s also<br />

been an impact in terms of supplying other<br />

test categories - and Part 2 and 3 tests have<br />

been among those tests impacted. Added to<br />

those existing test supply issues, is an<br />

exponential rise in applications for first<br />

licences (a 100% increase on pre-COVID<br />

figures and 4,000 new trainees entering the<br />

industry) and as a result the agency is<br />

struggling to supply tests to meet demand.<br />

DVSA is still receiving around 700 applications<br />

per month for trainee licences. For<br />

comparison, previously there were 250 per<br />

month.<br />

2. What is DVSA doing to tackle the issues?<br />

The DVSA shared with NASP recently some<br />

of the things they’re doing to tackle the issue<br />

of waiting times for Part 2 and 3 tests.<br />

They have increased the delivery of Part 2<br />

and 3 tests - delivering almost three times<br />

the number of tests they did in this period<br />

last year.<br />

From September 2023 to February <strong>2024</strong>,<br />

5,727 Part 2 were conducted and 4,637 Part<br />

3s - a record number (previously only 500<br />

tests a month were conducted on average).<br />

In April they commenced the training of<br />

new ADI examiners who will be deployed to<br />

specifically deliver Part 2 and 3 tests. There<br />

will be nine new specialist examiners being<br />

deployed in the next three months, adding<br />

capacity for an extra 150 tests per week.<br />

Resources will be focused on Part 2 and 3<br />

tests and then Standards Checks, focusing<br />

on areas with highest needs <br />

3. What has NASP been doing to<br />

help tackle the issues? <br />

NASP has been making sure this issue is<br />

top of the agenda, alongside Cat B test<br />

waiting times, in every contact we have had<br />

with DVSA since the start of the issue. We<br />

have requested updates on their efforts to<br />

tackle the issues, and to suggest ways in<br />

which the issues could be mitigated.<br />

Here are some of the suggestions we have<br />

made:<br />

n Not issuing dates to any new applicants<br />

for Parts 2 and 3 until all the existing booked<br />

candidates have had their three attempts.<br />

n The priority system for bookings needs<br />

urgent review so no candidate has to miss<br />

their third attempt at a Part 3 due to time<br />

running out. Anyone knowing they may be in<br />

that situation needs to be able to make DVSA<br />

aware so an earlier test can be given,<br />

therefore allowing a third attempt. Currently<br />

missing a third attempt is often not the fault<br />

of the PDI but due to previous cancellations,<br />

or lengthy waits for tests.<br />

n Issue real-time waiting times for tests<br />

and make candidates aware of them.<br />

Just going on hold doesn’t show candidates<br />

how long they are likely to wait for a slot. If<br />

they knew how long the wait, candidates<br />

could plan their training more easily. Ideally,<br />

no PDI should have more than one cancelled<br />

test in the duration of their training,<br />

otherwise too many months are wasted, and<br />

candidates will struggle to obtain a Part 3<br />

final attempt.<br />

n Is it possible to move candidates around<br />

so no one has more than one cancellation? Is<br />

there an alternative booking system that a<br />

third test could be booked on hold if a PDI is<br />

running out of time for their two years?<br />

n Create more awareness for new PDIs<br />

entering the process to understand the<br />

current issue so they are aware that this is<br />

not a quick process. If some realise the<br />

challenges earlier, they may defer application<br />

or make other decisions. Could a blog offer<br />

guidance to PDIs on managing some of the<br />

issues and risks in the current process? Or is a<br />

new official guide to the PDI process needed?<br />

n Consider closing the application process<br />

for new licences temporarily until the core<br />

issues have been resolved and place any new<br />

applicants on a wait list.<br />

4. How do I best secure a test slot given the<br />

current issues with availability?<br />

The general advice is to book to hold a slot<br />

so that when slots do become available you<br />

will be notified and may secure a slot sooner.<br />

It is important when using book to hold,<br />

candidates make the payment on application,<br />

otherwise you will not be in the waiting<br />

system.<br />

Email padi@dvsa.gov.uk if you have been<br />

waiting for what you consider to be a long<br />

time, and you are concerned that the two<br />

years from passing Part One may be running<br />

out (allowing you the possibility of taking<br />

three tests).<br />

“Secure a test slot by booking to hold a slot so that when slots do<br />

become available you will be notified and may secure a slot<br />

sooner. Email padi@dvsa.gov.uk if you are concerned that the<br />

two years from passing Part One may be running out...”<br />

26 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

“The agency is issuing more<br />

second licences, but this is<br />

discretionary, and each is<br />

assessed on a case-by-case basis.<br />

You are more likely to get<br />

another licence if you inform<br />

DVSA you had stopped using<br />

the first, for example, because<br />

of a period of illness...”<br />

9. How do I challenge the results of my Part 2<br />

or3 test?<br />

In the first instance you can raise a<br />

complaint directly with DVSA. Most issues<br />

are dealt with and rectified internally by the<br />

Disputes team.<br />

However, candidates also have the right to<br />

go to the Magistrates Court (or Sheriffs Court<br />

in Scotland) if unhappy with the conduct of<br />

the test. <br />

5. If I do not qualify under my first trainee<br />

licence, will I be given a second one?<br />

Your initial trainee licence lasts for six<br />

months. When it runs out you must stop<br />

being paid for giving driving lessons. You can<br />

apply for another trainee licence, but you’ll<br />

need to pay the fee again. Remember you<br />

cannot receive any kind of payment for<br />

giving driving lessons when you do not have<br />

a valid trainee licence.<br />

At a recent DVSA/NASP meeting it was<br />

stated that the agency was issuing more<br />

second licences, but this is a discretionary<br />

decision, and each is assessed on a case-bycase<br />

basis. You are more likely to get another<br />

licence if you inform DVSA you had stopped<br />

using the first, for example, because of a<br />

period of illness, or can give another<br />

reasonable explanation (such as your trainer<br />

was ill, or if DVSA was unable to supply a test<br />

for you within the period, presuming you<br />

applied in good time).<br />

It’s unlikely that you’ll get another licence if<br />

you just want more time to pass the<br />

approved driving instructor (ADI) part 3 test ,<br />

or did not follow the rules for using your<br />

previous trainee licence.<br />

6. What if I run out of time on my second<br />

licence, waiting for a test?<br />

DVSA does have some discretion to extend<br />

the period on a case-by-case basis. This has<br />

been used in a number of cases recently,<br />

given the acknowledged issues with securing<br />

a test slot in a timely manner.<br />

All PDI training must be completed within<br />

two years from the date the Part One was<br />

passed. Due to extended waiting times some<br />

PDIs are running out of time and haven’t been<br />

able to take a third test.<br />

However, as long as the third test is applied<br />

for, or put on hold before the two years runs<br />

out, DVSA will find them a Part 3 test date -<br />

even if it is after the date their Part One was<br />

passed.<br />

Generally, the Registrar will only grant<br />

more time to those who can prove they have<br />

fulfilled all other requirements of the licensing<br />

process properly (ie, have fully completed<br />

their ADI 21S or instructor training declaration<br />

paperwork), and those who have made<br />

reasonable efforts to attend a Part 2 or 3 test<br />

when a slot was available.<br />

Again, bear in mind that DVSA always look<br />

at test records so will know if trainees have<br />

cancelled more than once. If a trainee has<br />

cancelled a test slot more than once DVSA<br />

will not consider a lack of test availability as<br />

reasonable grounds to extend the period of<br />

the second licence.<br />

7. Can I get a third trainee licence?<br />

In some, albeit rare, cases the Registrar<br />

may grant a third licence, but this is highly<br />

unlikely and is purely at the Registrar’s<br />

discretion.<br />

8. How do I challenge being refused a second<br />

licence?<br />

Appeal to the General Regulatory Chamber<br />

10. Can I complain about my trainer/training<br />

school? <br />

Yes, you should initially complain to the<br />

school itself. However, if you feel that has not<br />

been satisfactory you can complain to DVSA<br />

via instructorconduct@dvsa.gov.uk <br />

11. Can I change the training or supervision<br />

option I choose for training once I’ve made it? <br />

No, you have to use the system you agreed<br />

to when applying for the trainee licence. <br />

12. What happens if I change training school?<br />

You must apply for a new trainee licence if<br />

you leave a driving school and join a new one.<br />

There’s no fee for doing this.<br />

DVSA will send you a new licence showing<br />

the details of your new school. You should<br />

send your old licence to DVSA as soon as you<br />

get the new one. You can still give driving<br />

lessons while you wait for your new licence.<br />

13. Is there a specific place to display my<br />

trainee licence? Is there a penalty if I don’t<br />

display it properly?<br />

You must display your trainee licence on<br />

the nearside edge of the front windscreen of<br />

your car while you give driving lessons. It is<br />

an offence to charge for lessons without your<br />

licence/certificate on display in the vehicle<br />

you are using for training. Licences can be<br />

revoked if you break the rules of using them,<br />

see next question.<br />

Continued on page 28<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 27


Towards your CPD<br />

Part 2 & 3: Trainees face<br />

challenge of finding test as<br />

DVSA struggles continue<br />

Continued from page 27<br />

14. Can my licence be taken away by the<br />

DVSA?<br />

The ADI registrar can take your trainee<br />

licence away before it runs out if:<br />

n you break any of the rules for having a<br />

trainee licence (CLICK HERE for details)<br />

n the licence was issued by mistake or<br />

gained by fraud<br />

n you fail 3 attempts at the ADI part 3 test<br />

15.When DVSA talks about Fit and Proper<br />

they say ‘being bound over’, what does that<br />

mean?<br />

The ADI ‘Fit and Proper person criteria’ tells<br />

you how DVSA decides if you meet the<br />

minimum criteria to be an ADI. The regulator<br />

designed it to help you; setting out some<br />

situations where it’s likely that you’ll be<br />

refused entry to or removed from the<br />

register. It also tells you about the standards<br />

DVSA expects you to show, and explains the<br />

factors that the Registrar has to consider<br />

when making their decision about ‘fit and<br />

proper’. You’ll find the guidance and a useful<br />

blog on by CLICKING HERE.<br />

Being “bound over refers to a legal process<br />

in which a judge or magistrate determines<br />

whether there is enough evidence to proceed<br />

with a criminal trial.<br />

16. Where do I go if my contact details<br />

change during my trainee licence?<br />

CLICK HERE for details on this.<br />

17.What should I do with my licence if I have<br />

to stop giving instruction due to maybe<br />

illness?<br />

You should return your trainee licence to<br />

DVSA if you are not using it, for example<br />

because of a long period of illness.<br />

You will not get a refund, but DVSA will<br />

know that you have not had full use of the<br />

licence. This will be a factor in deciding<br />

whether to give you another licence in future.<br />

18. Do I need extra training once I have my<br />

trainee licence?<br />

Yes. You have two options when you apply<br />

for a trainee licence. You must either:<br />

n be supervised for 20% of all lessons you<br />

give while you have your trainee licence<br />

n do at least 20 hours of extra training<br />

while you have your trainee licence<br />

You can only choose one option and you<br />

cannot change to the other after you’ve<br />

made your decision. Talk to your sponsoring<br />

If you require any help or assistance, remember<br />

that’s why you are a member of MSA GB. Contact<br />

us and we will guide you through the process and<br />

offer advice and guidance on the best strategy to<br />

take, particularly if you are<br />

struggling to obtain a Part 3<br />

test and your licence is<br />

running out<br />

ADI or training organisation about which<br />

option is best for you. A trainee licence is<br />

£140.<br />

19. Can I pass Part 3 without a trainee licence<br />

and if so can I charge pupils for petrol<br />

money?<br />

You can train with an ADI trainer and then<br />

take a pupil to your Part 3 test. You must not<br />

charge your pupil for the lesson on test, or<br />

any lesson you give them, until you have<br />

qualified. It is an offence in law to charge for<br />

driving lessons unless you are an ADI or PDI<br />

on a trainee licence. You cannot charge<br />

anything at all - even for petrol money.<br />

28 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

MSA GB<br />

membership<br />

offer<br />

MSA GB has arranged a new<br />

membership special offer – a<br />

new breakdown insurance<br />

partnership with trusted<br />

partners Telematicus Services<br />

Limited (t/a Smart Green<br />

Drivers).<br />

Don’t be left in the lurch if<br />

your car breaks down<br />

MSA GB has arranged a great new<br />

membership offer – comprehensive but<br />

cost-effective breakdown insurance cover<br />

from Telematicus Services Limited.<br />

There are two simple and cost-effective<br />

levels of cover for you to choose from.<br />

Telematicus Services Limited (t/a Smart<br />

Green Drivers) provides breakdown cover for<br />

cars, vans and motorcycles at pocketpleasing<br />

prices. However, just because it<br />

costs less than you think, doesn’t mean they<br />

cut any corners and still offer quality, reliable<br />

and trustworthy breakdown cover for all.<br />

Full UK cover<br />

Telematicus Services Limited’s highquality,<br />

low-cost breakdown solution covers<br />

the whole of the UK, and is specifically<br />

designed for the motorist who wishes to be<br />

covered in every eventuality.<br />

What’s included<br />

n No excesses or call out charges.<br />

n For vehicles up to 9 years old<br />

n Home Start.<br />

n Cover for punctures and flat tyres.<br />

n Cover anywhere throughout the UK<br />

n Includes hire car, overnight accommodation<br />

and onward travel options.<br />

n Unlimited callouts during the year of policy.<br />

n Over 3,000 recovery agents nationally.<br />

Telematicus Services Limited policies cover<br />

the vehicle, not the individual, meaning<br />

whoever is driving the vehicle at the time of a<br />

breakdown is eligible to call for assistance.<br />

Cover on holiday, too<br />

For ultimate cover, Telematicus Services<br />

Limited’s Full UK & EU policy has it all.<br />

Providing the same great benefits and<br />

coverage as that of its full UK Cover, but with<br />

the added surety of European travel, it makes<br />

for a complete policy.<br />

What’s included (in addition to the above)<br />

n Cover in any EU member state country<br />

plus Switzerland and Norway.<br />

n Includes extended hire car, overnight<br />

accommodation and onward travel options.<br />

n Unlimited callouts during the term of the<br />

policy<br />

Again, the full UK & EU policies cover the<br />

vehicle, not the individual, meaning whoever<br />

is driving the vehicle at the time of a<br />

breakdown is eligible to call for assistance.<br />

MSA GB vice-chairman Peter Harvey<br />

commented: “We like to think that MSA GB is<br />

the association that never sleeps, as we<br />

continually work to enhance our membership<br />

package, so you always feel supported and<br />

prepared for the wins and challenges that the<br />

life of a driving instructor brings.<br />

“We think this breakdown cover from<br />

Telematicus Services Limited t/a Smart<br />

Green Drivers will give you peace of mind<br />

without the cost usually associated with<br />

cover of this kind, and at a special discount<br />

price for members.”<br />

HOW CAN I FIND OUT MORE?<br />

A full set of frequently asked questions can<br />

be found at their website, accessed by<br />

clicking the panel below.<br />

Click here<br />

for details<br />

To access your breakdown offer please follow<br />

this link.<br />

Click here<br />

for details<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 29


Members’ section<br />

Get 10p off every litre of fuel<br />

with special MSA GB deal<br />

The cost-of-living crisis is putting many<br />

ADIs under considerable financial pressure,<br />

and nowhere is it felt more than through<br />

the rising cost of fuel.<br />

So to help alleviate some of the burden<br />

on our members, we’re thrilled to<br />

announce a brand-new partnership with<br />

FUEL CARD SERVICES.<br />

A fuel card from MSA GB partner, Fuel<br />

Card Services can provide huge benefits to<br />

businesses that use vehicles on a daily<br />

basis:<br />

n Cutting fuel costs - save up to 10p per<br />

litre and get a consistent price.<br />

n Increased security - fuel cards are a<br />

safer alternative to carrying cash and<br />

eliminate fraud.<br />

n Streamline admin - HMRC compliant<br />

invoices, no receipts, one neat invoice and<br />

a dedicated account manager.<br />

n Tighter control of business expenses<br />

- view transactions and reports online 24/7.<br />

n Increased flexibility for refuelling<br />

across a huge network.<br />

n Fleet convenience - a quick and<br />

convenient way for fleets to refuel.<br />

There are a range of fuel cards available<br />

on the market and for your business to<br />

truly benefit from investing in fuel cards,<br />

you need to choose the right one for your<br />

businesses’ requirements.<br />

FUEL CARD SERVICES offers a large<br />

choice of networks from leading brands,<br />

such as BP, Shell, Esso and UK Fuels, so<br />

you can decide which networks you wish<br />

to include on your business account.<br />

Fuel Card Services and MSA GB are<br />

helping to deliver cost savings to<br />

members throughout the country.<br />

For more details and to obtain a fuel<br />

card through MSA GB, go to our website<br />

at https://msagb.com/members/<br />

member-discounts/<br />

What are the latest UK fuel prices?<br />

The prices right are the latest available unleaded petrol and diesel averages<br />

across supermarket, motorway and independent forecourts in the UK, according<br />

to data compiled by the RAC. Prices correct at the end of April. Continuing<br />

instability in the Middle East, affecting both fuel output and transport through the<br />

Red Sea, risks causing further price rises.<br />

MEMBER OFFER<br />

UNLEADED<br />

DIESEL<br />

UK average 144p 149p<br />

Motorway 166p 173p<br />

Supermarkets 142p 147p<br />

MEMBER OFFER<br />

AlcoSense: Every ADI should have one handy<br />

MSA GB has teamed up with leading supplier of personal<br />

breathalyser kits AlcoSense to bring our members a<br />

very special offer.<br />

The AlcoSense kits give an instant and accurate<br />

snapshot of whether you – or your pupil – has alcohol in<br />

your/their system, and are particularly useful ‘the<br />

morning after.’<br />

Peter Harvey, MSA GB national vice chairman,<br />

commented: “These are a quality product. They arrive<br />

well packaged, with the required batteries, five<br />

mouthpieces and full instructions. They are very easy to<br />

use, with a simple menu, and can be adjusted to suit the<br />

country you are in depending on the legal limit there.<br />

Once set up, the breathalyser gives a very clear reading<br />

in traffic light colours, making it easy to follow.<br />

“Green, as you would expect, tells you you are okay to<br />

drive. Amber advises you that alcohol is present but you<br />

are below the limit you entered at set up – though it is so<br />

important to check what the limit is in the country you<br />

use it. Red is pretty self-explanatory – Don’t drive.<br />

“The set is very compact, about the same size as a<br />

mobile phone but a little deeper. It is ideal for eliminating<br />

any concerns you may have the morning after – or for<br />

your pupils.”<br />

The Excel model costs around £100 and can be viewed:<br />

https://alcosense.co.uk/alcosense.html.<br />

But we’ve negotiated a special discount on the entire<br />

AlcoSense range (except single-use disposables) of 10<br />

per cent for members IF BOUGHT THROUGH THE MSA<br />

GB WEBSITE – from the entry-level Lite 2 (£44.99) to<br />

the top-of-the-range Ultra (£249.00), with other<br />

options available. Go to<br />

https://msagb.com/members/member-discounts/<br />

to secure your member discount.<br />

30 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

ADI groups and associations<br />

MSA GB is proud of its long-standing links with many local ADI<br />

groups around the country. Many are small, dedicated to driver<br />

training in one city, town or even focused on a sole DTC, but all<br />

work tirelessly to improve the work of being an ADI. This can<br />

be in representing ADIs’ interests and views to your DVSA area<br />

manager, offering an ADI’s voice to local authorities and town<br />

planners, or by simply providing a network within which ADIs can<br />

find help and advice from their fellow instructors. After all, for<br />

many ADIs working as sole traders, being a driving instructor can<br />

be a lonely task: local ADI groups help stop it feeling quite so much<br />

that it’s ‘you against the world.’<br />

In every issue of <strong>Newslink</strong> will be publishing a list of local ADI<br />

groups and associations. We will only publish those groups who let<br />

us know they are happy to be included in our list, so if you would<br />

like to see your details here, please contact Peter Harvey at<br />

peter.harveymbe@msagb.com<br />

Aberdeen and District Driving Schools<br />

Association<br />

Secretary: Derek Young<br />

T: 07732 379396<br />

E: derekyoungcreel@aol.com<br />

Meets quarterly February (AGM), May,<br />

August and November.<br />

Cost £35 per annum<br />

Angus Driving Instructors Association<br />

Secretary: Frances Matthew<br />

T: 07703 664522<br />

E; francesmatthew@hotmail.co.uk<br />

This group holds six meeting per year<br />

(usually one week after the Scottish<br />

committee meeting)<br />

Cost £20 per year.<br />

Aylesbury Vale Driving Instructors<br />

Association<br />

Chairman: Sue Pusey<br />

T: 07780 606868<br />

E: AVDIA@btinternet.com<br />

Meetings are first Wednesday of every<br />

month at Roman Park Hall, Sir Henry Lee<br />

Crescent, HP18 0YT. 7.30pm start.<br />

Guest speaker every other month,<br />

refreshments provided.<br />

Annual fee £30. First meeting free as try<br />

before you buy.<br />

Birmingham Approved Driving Instructors<br />

Contact: Dave Allen<br />

T: 07939 627493<br />

E: Daveallen1999@googlemail.com<br />

Cornwall Association of Approved Driving<br />

Instructors (CAADI)<br />

Secretary: Rachael Lloyd-Phillips<br />

E: rachael@oneandallsom.co.uk<br />

This group meets via Zoom on the 3rd<br />

Monday every other month at 7.30pm.<br />

City of Dunfermline and District ADIs<br />

Secretary: Gail Pilch<br />

T: 07817 661450<br />

E: dunfermlineadisecretary@outlook.com<br />

Meetings are bi-monthly, at<br />

Dunfermline Northern Bowling Club, Dewar<br />

Street,<br />

Dunfermline KY12 8AD<br />

Glasgow & District Driving Instructors<br />

Association<br />

Contact: Bryan Phillips<br />

T: 07989 339 646<br />

E: bryan.phillips@hotmail.co.uk<br />

Meet on the last Sunday of the month,<br />

once every quarter, at<br />

The Fort Theatre, Kenmuir Ave,<br />

Bishopbriggs, Glasgow, G64 2DW.<br />

Joining fee: £15 per year<br />

Hinckley & District Driver Trainers<br />

Association (HDDTA)<br />

Chairman: Barrie Pates<br />

T: 07914 408 739<br />

E: haddta@yahoo.com<br />

Hull and East Riding Driving Instructors<br />

(HERDI)<br />

Contact: Andrew<br />

T: 07754542993<br />

E: herdi.rsa@gmail.com<br />

Lanark Driving Instructors<br />

Secretary: Sandra Smillie<br />

T: 07975 147150<br />

Meet quarterly from March which is our<br />

AGM<br />

South Warwickshire Association<br />

of ADIs (SWAADI)<br />

Contact: Andy Thomas<br />

T: 01926 717230 / 07900 673634<br />

E: artommo@hotmail.com<br />

We meet at 8.30pm every third Monday of<br />

the month except August and December<br />

(no meetings) at The Windmill Inn,<br />

Tachbrook Rd, Leamington Spa CV31 3DD,<br />

Rolls and snacks are available for a small<br />

charge and membership is £25 a year and<br />

includes a monthly newsletter and addition<br />

to a WhatsApp group for local issues/<br />

traffic updates, etc.<br />

Swindon Driving Instructors Association<br />

(Swindon DIA)<br />

Contact: Sandra Jill Richens<br />

T: 07795 006015<br />

E: SJRichens@btinternet.com<br />

Taunton Association Driving Instructors<br />

See Facebook page – search ‘Taunton ADI<br />

& PDI Forum’<br />

Wirral Association of Professional Driving<br />

Instructors (APDI)<br />

Chairman: Brian Murray<br />

T: 07810 094332<br />

Secretary: Richard Gillmore<br />

T: 07790 193138<br />

E: wirral-apdi@hotmail.co.uk<br />

W: wirralinstructors.co.uk<br />

Meet monthly on the first Thursday of the<br />

month (except January and August)<br />

at Heswall FC, Brimstage Road, Heswall,<br />

Wirral CH60 1XG<br />

Further information and to join, please visit<br />

the website.<br />

Why join a local association?<br />

Local news, local input – a local voice...<br />

If you want to see your local ADI group listed in this directory,<br />

contact Peter Harvey on peter.harveymbe@msagb.com<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 31


Area News<br />

Markings<br />

out of<br />

sync with<br />

road users<br />

1<br />

Arthur Mynott<br />

West Coast<br />

& Wales<br />

This month I would like to write about a<br />

motorway junction on the M5, Junction 17.<br />

I’ve been using this junction a few times<br />

recently and I’ve come to the conclusion that<br />

the markings are completely wrong and<br />

dangerous. At least three times recently I<br />

have been cut up as I approached the exit<br />

before the one I need, by vehicles coming<br />

from the lane on my right to take the third<br />

exit, while I am preparing to take the fourth.<br />

A glance at the three images may help this<br />

narrative. As you take the motorway exit<br />

while travelling north you have three lanes.<br />

The centre and right-hand lane are clearly<br />

marked ‘Cribbs Causeway’, which is the one I<br />

am taking and is the fourth exit.<br />

When teaching learners one phrase I<br />

generally use is “if there is a choice of two<br />

lanes, then left is best”. I have used the<br />

centre lane a few times on entry to this<br />

roundabout seeing as it is clearly marked<br />

(picture 1) but then the markings change and<br />

somehow you have to merge in to the<br />

right-hand lane on the roundabout to be able<br />

to take the required exit safely. If not then, as<br />

has happened to me, you tend to be cut up by<br />

others wanting to take the exit before the<br />

one I need, marked as ‘Merlin Road’ (picture 2).<br />

It was only my observation skills and<br />

experience that allowed me to spot a vehicle<br />

approaching on my right and looking to push<br />

across in front of me to take their exit.<br />

Twice I’ve had to take evasive action to<br />

avoid an accident, obviously much to my<br />

annoyance!<br />

Picture 3 shows the Google Map version of<br />

the roundabout with all the directional<br />

arrows.<br />

I think the answer for this junction is to<br />

make it just the right-hand lane marked<br />

Cribbs Causeway on the entrance to the<br />

roundabout to prevent anyone cutting in<br />

front of you as you are already on the inside<br />

lane on the roundabout.<br />

Perhaps a letter to the Highways Agency<br />

might be in order.<br />

Editor’s note:<br />

I have used this junction frequently since<br />

1966. Then, it was a two-lane motorway and<br />

represented the south-west end of the M5.<br />

Over the last 58 years many changes have<br />

been made. The widening and extension of<br />

the M5, the building of a regional shopping<br />

centre, The Mall, (the third exit for Arthur’s<br />

route), and, of course, the increase in traffic<br />

levels. A number of changes have been made<br />

to the junction over the years, leaving some<br />

routes with a far from clear flowing path.<br />

Cribbs Causeway is a much older dual<br />

carriageway leading to Bristol City Centre.<br />

Part of the problem is that The Mall is often<br />

referred to as Cribbs Causeway or ‘Cribbs.’<br />

This leads to confusion in drivers’ minds.<br />

Arthur is correct in suggesting that the<br />

marking to Cribbs Causeway be used on the<br />

right hand lane only. The ambiguity could be<br />

removed by labelling it with the road number,<br />

A4018, or Bristol City Centre.<br />

Contact:<br />

Arthur Mynott,<br />

arthur.mynott@yahoo.com<br />

Tel 07989 852274<br />

2 3<br />

32 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Final line-up confirmed for<br />

area’s autumn training day<br />

West & Wales Training Day and AGM<br />

Date: Monday, 11th November<br />

Venue: Mercure Bristol North,<br />

The Grange Hotel, Winterbourne Rd,<br />

Bristol, BS36 1RP<br />

Cost: Members £45 (if booked before<br />

September 1); after that date, £50<br />

Non-members £50<br />

We now have the final line-up of presenters<br />

to the West Coast & Wales Area Annual<br />

Training Day/Conference in November.<br />

They are:<br />

n John Sheridan, DVSA Driver Training<br />

Policy Advisor<br />

n Daniel Cox, Road Safety Officer,<br />

Avon & Somerset Police<br />

n Great Western Air Ambulance<br />

n Peter Harvey MBE, MSA GB Vice Chairman<br />

n Mike Yeomans, MSA GB National Chairman<br />

n Arthur Mynott,<br />

MSA GB West & Wales Chairman<br />

John Sheridan has been wanting to come<br />

to our area event the last few years but<br />

circumstances have prevented him from<br />

doing so but he will be here this year by “hook<br />

or by crook” in his words.<br />

I have heard him speak a few times over<br />

the years and found him to be a mind of<br />

information and very approachable. John will<br />

be giving an update on the DVSA, covering<br />

everything from policy and procedures.<br />

Daniel Cox is enthusiastic about road<br />

Date: Wednesday, 7th August<br />

Venue: The Quaker Meeting Rooms,<br />

Taunton, TA1 4EA<br />

As reported in the June issue of <strong>Newslink</strong>,<br />

we had to move the date of our meeting<br />

with the DVSA in TAUNTON because of the<br />

General Election.<br />

The meeting wll now take place on<br />

Wednesday, 7th August at The Quaker<br />

Meeting Rooms, Taunton, TA1 4EA.<br />

Our confirmed speakers are;<br />

safety in the West Country and I have seen<br />

him present before and his passion for his<br />

work is second to none.<br />

Great Western Air Ambulance is obviously<br />

going to be an interesting presentation and<br />

we will be doing a collection on the day in aid<br />

of this charity.<br />

Mike Yeomans and Peter Harvey will be<br />

giving an industry update from an ADI’s point<br />

of view.<br />

I will also be giving a surprise, short<br />

presentation which I hope will be of interest<br />

to you. I have never done this before but have<br />

discovered PowerPoint and hopefully<br />

everything thing will be okay on the day!<br />

This will be taking place on Monday 11th<br />

November at the Mercure Bristol North, The<br />

Grange Hotel, Winterbourne Road, Bristol,<br />

BS36 1RP. Doors will open at 9.00am ready<br />

for a 9.30 start and will finish around 4.00pm.<br />

The cost is £45.00 for members if paid<br />

before 1st September, £50.00 after this date<br />

and for non-members, this will include a two<br />

course buffet lunch and refreshments<br />

throughout the day.<br />

To book, please contact me on the details<br />

below.<br />

Contact:<br />

Arthur Mynott,<br />

MSA GB West Coast & Wales Chairman<br />

arthur.mynott@yahoo.com<br />

Tel 07989 852274<br />

New date for Taunton meeting<br />

after election switch<br />

Sue Robertson, DVSA ADI Area Manager<br />

Darren Russell, DVSA ADI Deputy<br />

Registrar.<br />

Paul Baker, Taunton LTDM and local<br />

examiners have also been asked to attend.<br />

To book this event, again please contact<br />

me on my details below.<br />

Contact: Arthur Mynott,<br />

MSA GB West Coast & Wales Chairman<br />

arthur.mynott@yahoo.com<br />

Tel 07989 852274<br />

Cheeky headline but an<br />

important message<br />

John Lomas<br />

West Coast<br />

& Wales<br />

An interesting headline caught my eye on the<br />

Bristol Live website at the end of last month:<br />

People on PIP could get 40 hours of free<br />

driving lessons this summer<br />

Would-be drivers will only have to fork out<br />

for the cost of the theory and practical<br />

driving tests to help get them on the road<br />

Sounds great, especially when you<br />

consider that 40 hours training should be<br />

worth around £1,300-£1,500.<br />

So what’s the catch? Well, the catch is, I<br />

guess, that most readers will not know what<br />

‘PIP’ is. Indeed, when I first saw it I wasn’t<br />

sure, but then I discovered it stands for<br />

Personal Independence Payment (PIP).<br />

It is part of the Motability scheme, and sits<br />

alongside the Adult Disability Payment<br />

(ADP) and Disability Living Allowance (DLA).<br />

Recipients of any of those three can claim<br />

free driving lessons through Motability’s<br />

Driving Lessons Grant Programme.<br />

The programme also offers grants to<br />

people with disabilities who already have a<br />

licence but require familiarisation lessons.<br />

This could be a big help to anyone needing to<br />

adjust to a new adapted vehicle.<br />

Here’s another catch. To qualify for the<br />

free driving lessons, you must have a current<br />

lease agreement on the Motability Scheme<br />

or have a pending application for a vehicle on<br />

the Motability Scheme, with a confirmed<br />

date to take delivery of the vehicle within the<br />

next four months. That is a big financial<br />

commitment to undertake BEFORE you’ve<br />

even started learning to drive.<br />

So is the headline correct and fair? It struck<br />

me that if I was a young person in Bristol,<br />

desperate to learn to drive but without the<br />

cash to do it, I would certainly click on the<br />

article and read it, delivering those important<br />

‘click throughs’ for the website’s advertisers.<br />

It certainly does not make it clear the help is<br />

only for those in the disabled community<br />

But it is important that the offer is<br />

circulated, as this is an important scheme for<br />

the disabled community. We all know from<br />

the superb work of Haydn and the Disability<br />

Driving Instructors group that the<br />

independence provided by a driving licence<br />

can be an absolute life-changer for people<br />

with diabilities. So if you know of anyone<br />

who is disabled and looking to learn to drive,<br />

make sure they know about this.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 33


Area News<br />

Experienced motoring journalist rebuts<br />

the ‘fake news’ around electric vehicles<br />

Janet<br />

Stewart<br />

London & the<br />

South East<br />

Is the future electric, as far as motoring is<br />

concerned?<br />

I listened recently to a talk given by<br />

Quentin Wilson, one-time presenter of Top<br />

Gear, discussing where we have got to<br />

regarding the future of electric vehicles.<br />

Some people may remember his campaign<br />

for fair fuel pricing. He has now turned his<br />

attention to fair charging for EVs and has<br />

launched an EV Charging Charter.<br />

As a journalist, and having worked with all<br />

sorts of people in the driving industry, from<br />

the RAC to the car manufacturers and having<br />

given many interviews on TV and radio,<br />

Wilson is not backward in coming forward, as<br />

they say. One of the points he made during<br />

the discussion I was listening to is that there<br />

is not actually much knowledge in the House<br />

of Commons about EVs; the policy makers<br />

are not driving them.<br />

It is, of course, true that MPs have an awful<br />

lot of very difficult subjects on their minds<br />

right now but, if getting rid of petrol and<br />

diesel vehicles is not tackled fairly urgently,<br />

there is likely to be a very big problem further<br />

down the line. This country could end up<br />

lagging a long way behind Europe and, indeed,<br />

many other developed nations which would<br />

not be good for the economy.<br />

Supporting arguments<br />

Mr Wilson has published a new book, Little<br />

Book of EV Myths, to put his case. It’s not<br />

one I’ve read yet but it is on the list. There are<br />

a lot of arguments put forward against EVs,<br />

many of which are fed by social media and<br />

passed on by people who have very little<br />

knowledge of the facts.<br />

I’ll give you some good examples. First,<br />

maintenance costs. EVs require little<br />

maintenance because, compared with<br />

vehicles with internal combustion engines,<br />

there is very little to go wrong. Naturally, this<br />

results in low servicing bills.<br />

People often also say that no-one is<br />

available to service them. There are three<br />

garages local to me and all of them are well up<br />

on servicing EVs, so you don’t have to keep<br />

going back to the dealer you bought the car<br />

from.<br />

Charging is another concern, but again not<br />

one to worry too much about. According to<br />

the most recent figures I’ve seen, 80% of<br />

owners of electric cars charge them at home<br />

which, with sensible charging (ie, avoiding<br />

fast charging as much as possible), works out<br />

at about 7.5p per Kilowatt/hr, or 0.3p per<br />

mile. [ADIs should know their mileage rates<br />

for tax purposes, but for comparison here,<br />

based on unleaded petrol averaging at £1.44<br />

a litre, and in a car doing 40mpg, the cost per<br />

mile is just over 16p - Editor]<br />

Public charging is more expensive, costing<br />

around 70-80p per k/hr. According to Mr<br />

Wilson this needs to reduce to under 50p.<br />

Some parts of the UK are very poorly served<br />

with public charge points. However, a couple<br />

of weeks ago I was trekking in the Black<br />

Mountains in South Wales and coming into<br />

villages in the evenings. These remote places<br />

seemed to have a surprising number of EVs. I<br />

realise that this is, of course, because the<br />

population density is very low, resulting in<br />

very few petrol stations being within a<br />

sensible driving distance. EVs are a better<br />

choice.<br />

Again, there needs to be “democratisation”<br />

across the country. There are, apparently,<br />

61,000 public charging points in the UK and it<br />

is estimated that we need 300,000 by 2030.<br />

High speed charging from zero to full charge<br />

takes about 15/20 minutes but this is<br />

improving all the time so it is certainly not<br />

unrealistic to do London to Glasgow with only<br />

one stop. (Since I do this journey regularly I<br />

know that I am usually stopped for at least 20<br />

minutes by the time I have used the facilities,<br />

and got a coffee). However, there is a fear<br />

that charging will not be available.<br />

Battery life<br />

The next myth is that the batteries do not<br />

last. According to Mr Wilson, they do and<br />

certainly my car is now six years old and<br />

re-charging as well as it ever did.<br />

The example he used was a car (I can’t<br />

remember the make) doing 200,000 miles<br />

with only a 10% loss of battery efficiency<br />

over time. Furthermore, batteries can be<br />

95% recycled. I would have liked to ask a<br />

question about that but the option was not<br />

34 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

Go Charge steps in for<br />

Motability drivers<br />

available to me.<br />

There are 100,000 vehicle fires a year –<br />

0.024% are EVs but they are the ones that<br />

get all the publicity, something that Mr<br />

Wilson called “click-bait”.<br />

Other concerns<br />

You will hear an EV on the road behind you<br />

as a pedestrian because since 2019 they<br />

have to make a noise and a lot of research<br />

went into what sort of noise and at what level<br />

that should be. My own car makes a noise<br />

externally, but not internally, so I can listen to<br />

Mozart undisturbed!<br />

I am aware that Mr Wilson is very much in<br />

favour of EVs, as am I, so there may be a slant<br />

EDITOR’S NOTE: Janet makes some<br />

interesting points but perhaps the biggest<br />

challenge the EV sector has lies in the way it<br />

is approaching the installation of new public<br />

EV charging points.<br />

According to the Society of Motor<br />

Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), there<br />

was a significant increase in charge point<br />

installations in 2023, something which has<br />

‘improved significantly relative to new<br />

plug-in car uptake’.<br />

4,753 new standard public charge points<br />

came online in the last quarter of 2023, the<br />

largest number ever installed in a threemonth<br />

period. It equated to one new<br />

standard public charge point being installed<br />

Quentin Wilson:<br />

EV advocate<br />

on some of this information, but I really do<br />

believe in an electric future; it is the right<br />

thing for clean air and a safe environment as<br />

well as, maybe, slowing down global warming<br />

just a little bit (or even quite a big bit).<br />

From conversations I have had over the<br />

last few months it seems that most people<br />

are in favour of EVs but are not ready to<br />

commit quite yet.<br />

Contact:<br />

Janet Stewart,<br />

MSA GB London & the South<br />

E: janetslittlecar@btinternet.com<br />

EV charging: Look beyond London<br />

for every 26 new plug-in cars being<br />

registered, a big improvement on the average<br />

for the rest of the year, which was around<br />

one-in-38.<br />

However, 80% of the new charge points<br />

were installed in London and the South East.<br />

And before Londoners say that is because<br />

of demand, it is not; that region of the<br />

country accounted for only 40% of new BEV<br />

registrations during the period.<br />

Perhaps it is time those planning new<br />

charge points looked beyond London!<br />

And after we’ve solved that problem,<br />

perhaps we could ask the National Grid if<br />

there is capacity in the electricity generating<br />

system to supply all the charge needed?<br />

Motability Operations has launched<br />

Motability Go Charge, an innovative<br />

solution to simplify public EV charging for<br />

its customers.<br />

Paying for public chargepoints can be<br />

especially challenging for disabled<br />

customers, and many have reported<br />

difficulties. In addition, half of the 760,000<br />

Motability Scheme customers lack access<br />

to off-street parking and therefore have<br />

limited accessible and affordable public<br />

charging available. The Go Charge app<br />

changes this dynamic: users can check<br />

which chargepoints are available in real<br />

time, filter chargers based on connector<br />

type and speed, track charging costs and<br />

provide in the moment support for<br />

chargepoint or payment issues.<br />

Go Charge delivers a one-stop solution<br />

for accessing and paying for public<br />

charging for EV customers on the<br />

Motability Scheme, with no subscription<br />

fees and no pre-authorisation required.<br />

Despite the challenges disabled drivers<br />

can face, Motability remains focused on<br />

supporting its customers through the<br />

transition. That’s why it has partnered<br />

with several startups, including Paua, to<br />

pilot schemes, which can help many of its<br />

disabled customers overcome some of<br />

the barriers to electric, especially the<br />

48,000 customers which have already<br />

made the switch.<br />

The Go Charge app and card streamlines<br />

EV payments at more than 45,000<br />

chargepoints across the UK. This includes<br />

chargepoints from operators including<br />

GRIDSERVE, Source London, ChargePlace<br />

Scotland, ESB, Geniepoint, Shell Recharge,<br />

Osprey and many more, covering over<br />

50% of all chargepoints in the UK and 70%<br />

of all rapid chargepoints, with ongoing<br />

efforts to expand coverage.<br />

Go Charge will now roll out<br />

automatically to every EV customer on<br />

the Motability Scheme. Customers will be<br />

sent the card and user guide when they<br />

order their EV. This follows a successful<br />

pilot in 2023, where Motability Operations<br />

gathered extensive data and insights<br />

during a nine-month pilot period with<br />

5,000 customers to understand the<br />

specific challenges its disabled customers<br />

face when charging their EV using public<br />

chargepoints.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 35


Area News<br />

First aid: You never want to use it, but<br />

it’s great to have the skills if need be<br />

Brian<br />

Thomson<br />

MSA GB Scotland<br />

Six members of the Angus Driving<br />

Instructors Association (ADIA) took a<br />

one-day training course held in the<br />

hospitality lounge of Links Park football<br />

ground (home of the ‘Mighty Mo’ – that’s<br />

Montrose FC to the uninitiated). The course<br />

was led by Claire Davidson of CPD Plus, and<br />

the aim was to give the participants to gain a<br />

First Aid at Work certificate.<br />

Some of the group – which was made up<br />

of Gayle Barr, David Sturrock, Bob Martin,<br />

Frances Matthews, Lynn Newton and yours<br />

truly – were doing the course for the first<br />

time and others doing it as a refresher after<br />

three years.<br />

The day started with Claire introducing<br />

herself and enlightening us on her nursing<br />

background and first aid experience.<br />

Then it was our turn to give a brief history<br />

The group with our mannequins. No<br />

defenceless mannequins were harmed...<br />

of ourselves – normal training day opening<br />

stuff. It wasn’t long before Claire was calling<br />

for a volunteer to lie on the floor, and Frances<br />

was there quicker than an Audi A8 on<br />

premium fuel.<br />

Claire about to demonstrate the recovery<br />

position on the ‘ever helpful’ Frances.<br />

It was clear from the outset that the<br />

course was going to involve loads of audience<br />

participation, and lots of stories. Claire kept<br />

the whole day fun, captivating and<br />

educational, making it an easy class to sit in.<br />

36 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

After lunch there was more practical, hands<br />

-on training, with exercises to help people<br />

who were choking, how to deliver CPR<br />

correctly and use of the heart defibrillator.<br />

We got to see how to safely carry out the<br />

back slap and abdominal thrust manoeuvre<br />

(the Heinlich), though thankfully the<br />

defenceless mannequin was the recipient of<br />

our attempts.<br />

The six-hour day was rounded off with<br />

some bandaging, a rapid Q&A session, then a<br />

written exam to assess the amount of<br />

knowledge a room full of driving instructors<br />

can forget.<br />

Although first aid at work is not a legal<br />

requirement for our industry, everyone that<br />

attended the course felt they learned a lot.<br />

There’s an irony, obviously, in that we learned<br />

a lot that we hope never to put into practice,<br />

but if the worst does come to the worst, we<br />

now all feel that we have the skills if required<br />

to do so. This six hours will go towards our<br />

record of CPD training.<br />

Editor’s note: It was interesting to read<br />

recently that part of the German theory test<br />

exam includes a first aid component.<br />

Many people have suggested that the British<br />

theory exam should follow suit, which would<br />

then led to the inevitable question, should<br />

the ADI Part 1-3 include a first aid element?<br />

Above, Claire about to demonstrate the<br />

recovery position on the “ever helpful”<br />

Frances<br />

Facing page, bottom left, Bob Martin<br />

successfully carrying out the back slap and<br />

abdominal thrust manoeuvre on the<br />

defenceless mannequin<br />

Facing page, bottom right, pairs trying their<br />

hand at CPR and later on with the defibrillator.<br />

It does look as though Claire the trainer is<br />

holding her head in exasperation, but we’re<br />

assured she thinks we are all great<br />

Below, the ADI group: from left, Gayle Barr,<br />

David Sturrock, Brian Thomson, Bob Martin,<br />

Frances Matthews and Lynn Newton<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 37


Members’ discounts<br />

Members’ discounts and benefits<br />

MSA GB has organised a number of exclusive discounts and offers for members. More details can be found on our website at<br />

www.msagb.com and click on the Member Discounts logo. To access these benefits, simply log in and click on the Member<br />

discount logo, then click the link at the bottom of the page to allow you to obtain your special discounts.<br />

Please note, non-members will be required to join the association first. Terms and conditions apply<br />

Access to a replacement dual<br />

control car after a crash<br />

EXCLUSIVE DEAL FOR MSA GB MEMBERS<br />

MSA GB has arranged to provide members with a replacement dual controlled car when<br />

things don’t quite go to plan.<br />

If you lose your dual-controlled tuition car in a crash, MSA GB’s new partnership will have<br />

you back on the road and teaching in no time.<br />

Our exclusive agreement will supply a replacement vehicle to you should the need arise<br />

– at no cost. Contact 07914 275539 for more details.<br />

Ford updates special<br />

members’ offer<br />

Ford has partnered with MSA GB to offer exclusive<br />

discounts on all car and commercial Ford vehicles.<br />

Take a look at the Ford website www.ford.co.uk<br />

for vehicle and specification information. See the<br />

Members’ Benefits page on the MSA GB website<br />

and follow the Ford link for more details..<br />

Please note these discounts are only available to<br />

MSA GB members and their immediate family if they<br />

are members who pay annually.<br />

ACCOUNTANCY<br />

MSA GB’s Recommended<br />

Accountancy Service, FBTC<br />

offers a specialist service for<br />

ADIs. It has been established<br />

over 20 years ago and covers the<br />

whole of the UK. The team takes pride in<br />

providing unlimited advice and support to ensure<br />

the completion of your tax return is hassle free,<br />

giving you peace of mind.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: FBTC will prepare you for<br />

Making Tax Digital and will be providing HMRC<br />

compliant software to all clients very soon.<br />

Join now to receive three months free.<br />

ADVANCE DRIVING<br />

AND RIDING<br />

As the UK’s largest road safety<br />

charity, IAM RoadSmart is<br />

proud to partner with the<br />

Motor Schools Association<br />

GB. Working together to promote and<br />

enhance motorists skills on our roads.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: Get 10% off Advanced courses;<br />

visit www.iamroadsmart.com/course and<br />

use the code MSA10 at the checkout or call<br />

0300 303 1134 to book.<br />

BREATHALYSER KITS<br />

Protect yourself and your pupils with a<br />

personal breathalyser. We’ve teamed up with<br />

AlcoSense, the award-winning range of<br />

personal breathalysers, to offer an exclusive<br />

discount to all MSA GB members. A personal<br />

breathalyser takes the guesswork out of<br />

whether there’s residual alcohol in your<br />

system (or that of your learner driver pupil)<br />

the morning after the night before.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: 10% off any AlcoSense product<br />

(excluding single-use disposables) – from the<br />

entry-level Lite 2 (£44.99) to the top-ofthe-range<br />

Ultra (£249.00).<br />

CAR AIR FRESHENERS / CANDLES<br />

Mandles’ handmade scented collections use<br />

quality ingredients to ensure superior scent<br />

throw from all its candles and<br />

diffusers. Check our our website<br />

for further details.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: Special discount<br />

of 20% on all car air fresheners<br />

and refills.<br />

CARD PAYMENTS<br />

MSA GB and SumUp believe<br />

in supporting motor vehicle<br />

trainers of all shapes and sizes.<br />

Together we are on a mission to<br />

ease the operational workload of<br />

our members by providing them with the ability<br />

to take card payments on-the-go or in their<br />

respective training centres. SumUp readers<br />

are durable and user-friendly. Their paperless<br />

onboarding is quick and efficient. Moreover,<br />

their offer comes with no monthly subscription,<br />

no contractual agreement, no support fees,<br />

no hidden fees – just the one-off cost for the<br />

reader coupled with lowest on the market<br />

transaction fee.<br />

DISABILITY AIDS<br />

Driving shouldn’t just be a<br />

privilege for people without<br />

disabilities; it should be<br />

accessible for all and there’s never been an easier<br />

time to make this the case! MSA GB members<br />

can take advantage of BAS’s Driving Instructor<br />

Packages which include a range of adaptations at<br />

a discounted price, suitable for teaching disabled<br />

learner drivers.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: Special Driving Instructor<br />

Packages for MSA GB members.<br />

FUEL CARDS<br />

Save up to 10p per litre of fuel with Fuel Card<br />

Services. Fuel Card Services offers a large<br />

choice of networks from leading brands, such<br />

as BP, Shell, Esso and UK Fuels so you can<br />

decide which networks you wish to include on<br />

your business account.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: An MSA GB fuel card will save<br />

you up to 10p per litre.<br />

HEALTH / FINANCE COVER<br />

The Motor Schools Association of Great<br />

Britain has agreed with HMCA to<br />

offer discounted rates for medical<br />

plans, dental plan, hospital cash<br />

plans, personal accident plan,<br />

travel plan, income protection<br />

and vehicle breakdown products.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: HMCA only offer<br />

medical plans to membership groups<br />

and can offer up to a 40% discount off the<br />

underwriter’s standard rates. This is a<br />

comprehensive plan which provides generous<br />

cash benefits for surgery and other charges.<br />

To get the full story of the<br />

discounts available, see<br />

www.msagb.com<br />

38 NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong>


For all the latest news, see www.msagb.com<br />

PUPIL INSURANCE<br />

Join the Collingwood<br />

Instructor Programme and<br />

refer your pupils for learner<br />

insurance.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: MSA GB OFFER:: £50 for<br />

your first referral and £20 for all additional<br />

referrals.<br />

PSYCHOLOGY TRAINING<br />

Confident Drivers has the only<br />

website created especially for<br />

drivers offering eight different<br />

psychological techniques<br />

commonly used to reduce stress and nerves.<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: One month free on a monthly<br />

subscription plan using coupon code.<br />

PUPIL SOURCING<br />

Go Roadie provides students<br />

when they need them, with all<br />

the details you need before you<br />

accept. Control your own pricing,<br />

discounts and set your availability<br />

to suit you. Full diary? No cost!<br />

MSA GB OFFER:: Introductory offer of 50% off<br />

the first three students they accept.<br />

QUICKBOOKS<br />

50% Discount on two<br />

packages for MSA GB<br />

members<br />

Quickbooks is offering an online<br />

50% discount for MSA GB members on two of<br />

their premium accounting packages.<br />

Essentials Package For small businesses<br />

working with suppliers. Manage VAT and<br />

Income Tax with up to three users.<br />

Plus For businesses managing projects,<br />

stock, VAT, and Income Tax. Up to five users.<br />

The packages are contract-free throughout<br />

with no cancellation fee. This exclusive<br />

member offer can only be secured by<br />

contacting our MSA GB representative at<br />

Quickbooks - Ollie Nobes, on: 07723 507 026<br />

or email: Ollie_Nobes@intuit.com quoting:<br />

**MSAGB**<br />

To get the full story of the<br />

discounts available, see<br />

www.msagb.com<br />

Membership offer<br />

Welcome, new ADIs<br />

We’ve a special introductory offer for you!<br />

Congratulations on passing your<br />

Part 3 and becoming an ADI.<br />

There’s an exciting career<br />

open to you from today,<br />

one that’s alive with<br />

possibilities as you build<br />

your skills, your client base<br />

and your income.<br />

But for all the excitement,<br />

it can also be challenging;<br />

who can you turn to if you’re<br />

struggling to get over key driver<br />

training issues to a pupil? Where can<br />

you go to soak up advice from more<br />

experienced ADIs? Who will help you if you<br />

are caught up in a dispute with the DVSA? If<br />

the worst happens, who can you turn to for<br />

help, advice and to fight your corner?<br />

The answer is the Motor Schools<br />

Association of Great Britain – MSA GB for<br />

short.<br />

We are the most senior association<br />

representing driving instructors in Great<br />

Britain. Establised in 1935 when the first<br />

driving test was introduced, MSA GB has<br />

been working tirelessly ever since on<br />

behalf of ordinary rank and file ADIs.<br />

We represent your interests and your<br />

views in the corridors of power, holding<br />

regular meetings with senior officials<br />

from the DVSA and the Department for<br />

Transport to make sure the ADIs’ voice is<br />

heard.<br />

SPECIAL OFFER<br />

Join MSA GB today!<br />

SPECIAL OFFER: Join for just £65 with your<br />

PI & PL insurance included immediately!<br />

No joining fee - saving you £25<br />

Call 01787 221020 quoting discount code<br />

<strong>Newslink</strong>, or join online at www.msagb.com<br />

We’d like you to<br />

join us<br />

We’re there to support you<br />

every step of the way.<br />

Our office-based staff are<br />

there, five days a week,<br />

from 9am-5pm, ready to<br />

answer your call and help<br />

you in any way.<br />

In addition our network of<br />

experienced office holders and<br />

regional officers can offer advice over<br />

the phone or by email.<br />

But membership of the MSA GB doesn’t<br />

just mean we’re there for you if you’re<br />

in trouble. We also offer a nationwide<br />

network of regular meetings, seminars and<br />

training events, an Annual Conference, and<br />

a chance to participate in MSA GB affairs<br />

through our democratic structure<br />

In addition, you’ll get a free link to our<br />

membership magazine <strong>Newslink</strong> every<br />

month, with all the latest news, views,<br />

comment and advice you’ll need to become<br />

a successful driving instructor.<br />

You’ll also automatically receive<br />

professional indemnity insurance worth up<br />

to £5m and £10m public liability insurance<br />

free of charge.<br />

This is essential legal protection covering<br />

you against legal claims ariving from your<br />

tuition.<br />

NEWSLINK n JULY <strong>2024</strong> 39


Ford Focus<br />

Starting from £22,199<br />

Contract options from £588<br />

D U A L C O N T R O L<br />

V E H I C L E S<br />

A v a i l a b l e f o r h i r e a n d p u r c h a s e<br />

Audi q2<br />

Lease from £648<br />

Purchase from £26,699<br />

CALL US TO SECURE<br />

YOUR NEXT CAR<br />

0116 284 9067<br />

NATIONWIDE DELIVERY AVAILABLE<br />

Working with 14 Manufacturers<br />

Terms and Conditions apply<br />

Finance Available on purchases<br />

Contract Deals include<br />

All Servicing Costs<br />

Tyres at 2mm<br />

Courtesy Car<br />

He-man Dual Controls<br />

Breakdown cover<br />

TOYOTA YARIS<br />

PURCHASE FROM £19,999<br />

CONTRACT FROM £508

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!