4 Final Report - Emits - ESA
4 Final Report - Emits - ESA
4 Final Report - Emits - ESA
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
4 <strong>Final</strong><br />
<strong>Report</strong><br />
Oculus, whereas MWI 100-100/100 has a bigger rotor and different motor design.<br />
Prototype MBW<br />
Figure 4.4-1: MBW characteristics and photography of the prototype MBW (courtesy of RCT)<br />
The microvibration levels generated by the prototype MBW wheels have been characterised in 2007<br />
by EADS Astrium GmbH in the frame of the DLR study “High Precision Attitude Control of Earth<br />
Observation Satellites”. The results of this study show that the MBW disturbance levels are lower by a<br />
factor of 10 to 240 (depending on frequency and wheel rotation rate) than typical BBW levels.<br />
However, it shall be noted that the comparison is supposing hard-mounted wheels, whereas a BBW<br />
mounted on an elastomeric suspension would be the actual competitor for a high accuracy pointing<br />
mission. Moreover, microvibrations is analysed at the source, whereas its impact on LoS at PLM level,<br />
largely dependent on structure transmission is the relevant parameter. It is undoubted that the<br />
microvibrations will be lower, but the above ratios shall not be taken as granted.<br />
The MBW appear in all cases as a good candidate for the Geo-Oculus mission, due to its inherent low<br />
microvibration content. The low maturity level (TRL ~4) and the associated development and technical<br />
risks shall also be accounted for. The pre-development needs to be actively pursued to reach TRL 5 at<br />
the beginning of phase C/D.<br />
4.4.2.3 Ball Bearing Wheel (BBW) option<br />
A second option is to use standard ball bearing wheels mounted on elastomeric mounts developed for<br />
LEO observation missions. This option has been analysed in 2007 in the frame of the CNES study<br />
“Constraints for High resolution observation on GEO”. A microvibration analysis was performed for<br />
three different structural transmissions, without elastomeric suspension, with a 15 Hz suspension, and<br />
with a 30 Hz one. Microvibration levels measured on 8 flight models of Pleiades BBW (18 Nms Teldix<br />
RSI) are used as input to the structural model, typical of a GEO spacecraft equipped with an optical<br />
payload for Earth observation. The results are post-processed so that to show the peak-to-peak<br />
variation of the LoS over an integration time of 70 ms. The results of this study are therefore directly<br />
relevant for Geo-Oculus.<br />
Doc. No: GOC-ASG-RP-002 Page 4-45<br />
Issue: 2<br />
Date: 13.05.2009 Astrium GmbH