25.01.2024 Views

The Trumpet Newspaper Issue 611 (November 29 - December 12 2023)

Sharpeville: New research on 1960 South African massacre shows the number of dead and injured was massively undercounted

Sharpeville: New research on 1960 South African massacre shows the number of dead and injured was massively undercounted

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Africans now have a voice... Founded in 1995<br />

V O L <strong>29</strong> N O <strong>611</strong> N O V E M B E R <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

25 th<br />

<strong>The</strong> row of graves of people killed during the Sharpeville massacre on 21 March 1960 (Photo Andrew Hall CCA SA Int 4.0)<br />

Sharpeville:<br />

New research on 1960 South<br />

African massacre shows<br />

the number of dead and<br />

injured was massively<br />

undercounted<br />

By Nancy L Clark and William H. Worger<br />

Continued on Page 2><br />

Insurance<br />

Fraud Board<br />

(IFB) warns<br />

against<br />

buying bogus<br />

insurance<br />

<strong>The</strong> Insurance Fraud Board (IFB) -<br />

the not-for-profit organisation that<br />

acts as a central intelligence hub,<br />

using industry data to work with UK<br />

police to detect and disrupt organised<br />

criminal groups from committing<br />

insurance fraud, is warning motorists to<br />

stay alert to fake car insurance deals<br />

offered by ghost brokers.<br />

Increasingly clever fraudsters prey<br />

on unsuspecting victims looking for<br />

cheap car insurance deals - and buying<br />

from a ghost broker could leave drivers<br />

seriously out of pocket. As well as the<br />

money handed over to the fraudster,<br />

being caught driving uninsured results in<br />

fines, points on your licence and can<br />

impact all aspects of a duped customer’s<br />

life.<br />

‘Ghost Brokers’ are fraudsters that<br />

pose as genuine insurance brokers and<br />

are known to offer illegal broker services<br />

in online ads and social media channels<br />

such as Facebook, Instagram and<br />

Snapchat.<br />

Jon Radford, Head of Intelligence,<br />

Investigations & Data Services at IFB<br />

stated that: “It’s easy to get wrapped up<br />

in the excitement of sales, but it’s<br />

important to do the leg work and check<br />

when buying through a Broker that<br />

they’re legitimate.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> cost of falling victim to a<br />

‘Ghost Broker’ is more than just the<br />

money you hand over. Being caught<br />

driving uninsured will result in fines,<br />

points on your licence and if you rely on<br />

your car to get to work, it could even cost<br />

you your job.”<br />

Detective Chief Inspector Tom Hill,<br />

from the City of London Police’s<br />

Insurance Fraud Enforcement<br />

Department (IFED), said: “Everybody<br />

loves a bargain, but it truly does pay to<br />

make sure that you’re buying a genuine<br />

car insurance policy. A bogus policy<br />

could mean facing a fine, points on your<br />

license or your car being seized – not to<br />

mention covering the cost of a new, valid<br />

policy.<br />

“Be wary of cheap deals on social<br />

media and via messaging apps. If you’re<br />

unsure whether an insurance broker is<br />

legitimate, check the British Insurance<br />

Brokers’ Association or Financial<br />

Conduct Authority website for a list of<br />

all authorised brokers.”


Page2 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

News<br />

Sharpeville: New research on 1960<br />

South African massacre shows the<br />

number of dead and injured was<br />

massively undercounted<br />

Continued from Page 1<<br />

On 21 March 1960 at 1.40 in the<br />

afternoon, apartheid South<br />

Africa’s police opened fire on a<br />

peaceful crowd of about 4,000 residents<br />

of Sharpeville, who were protesting<br />

against carrying identity documents that<br />

restricted black people’s movement. <strong>The</strong><br />

police minimised the number of victims<br />

by at least one third, and justified the<br />

shooting by claiming that the crowd was<br />

violent. This shocking story has been thus<br />

misrepresented for over 60 years.<br />

Our new research retells the story of<br />

Sharpeville, about 70km south of<br />

Johannesburg, from the viewpoint of the<br />

victims themselves. As experienced<br />

historians who have undertaken archival<br />

research in South Africa since the 1970s<br />

we based our research on interviews with<br />

survivors and investigation into<br />

government records in both the police<br />

archives and the national archives in<br />

Pretoria. Our work reveals the true<br />

number of victims and the exact role of<br />

the police in the massacre.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Sharpeville Massacre ignited<br />

international outrage and the birth of the<br />

Anti-Apartheid Movement worldwide. It<br />

also led to renewed political protests<br />

inside South Africa. <strong>The</strong>se were met with<br />

the total suppression of political<br />

movements that lasted for 30 years.<br />

Despite its historic importance,<br />

Sharpeville as a place and a community<br />

has remained unknown to the wider public<br />

and its residents anonymous. Yet they<br />

have a story to tell.<br />

Solicitor and Partner<br />

of an award-winning<br />

law firm<br />

S.A.J<br />

LEGAL<br />

based in the heart of<br />

Central London -<br />

Kolade Jegede<br />

specializes in:<br />

Immigration - Preparing of all<br />

Immigration matters, including<br />

Appeal Challenges and Tribunal<br />

Representation.<br />

Employment - Handling all types<br />

of Employment Claims.<br />

Family Law - Dealing with Divorce<br />

Applications, Financial Arrangements,<br />

and Applying for Non-Molestation /<br />

Occupational Orders.<br />

First consultation is FREE.<br />

T: 07818 118656 E: kj@saj.legal<br />

Even though the Truth and<br />

Reconciliation Commission chose the<br />

1960 Sharpeville massacre as the formal<br />

beginning of its investigation of apartheid<br />

crimes, its examination of the massacre<br />

itself was perfunctory. Only three<br />

witnesses from the community were<br />

invited to testify during just part of one<br />

day (out of 2,000 witnesses during five<br />

years of hearings).<br />

People in Sharpeville believe that the<br />

lack of attention to their plight since<br />

democracy in 1994 is because the original<br />

protest was organised by the rival Pan-<br />

Africanist Congress of Azania, not the<br />

governing African National Congress<br />

(ANC).<br />

Changing the narrative<br />

Based on our research, the new book<br />

Voices of Sharpeville traces the long<br />

residence of Africans in the greater<br />

Sharpeville area, as far as the Cradle of<br />

Humankind World Heritage Site 100km<br />

north. It also emphasises the crucial<br />

industrial importance of the greater Vaal<br />

Triangle in which Sharpeville is located,<br />

from the 1930s onward.<br />

Our work details the rich culture<br />

developed by urban Sharpeville residents<br />

in defiance of the attempts of Prime<br />

Minister HF Verwoerd’s attempts to<br />

control African life.<br />

Using the words of witnesses as<br />

recorded from their hospital beds within<br />

days of the shooting, and for weeks and<br />

months later, the events of 21 March 1960<br />

are recounted in detail, increasing the<br />

number of victims to at least 91 dead, and<br />

281 injured. <strong>The</strong> official police figures<br />

first published in 1960 and repeated<br />

endlessly ever since were 69 and 180<br />

respectively.<br />

<strong>The</strong> witness testimony places the<br />

responsibility for the shooting squarely<br />

with the police.<br />

New evidence<br />

<strong>The</strong> oral and documentary source<br />

material we used was previously off limits<br />

to researchers, insufficiently examined, or<br />

largely ignored. Access to many records<br />

held by the previous apartheid<br />

government was absolutely restricted<br />

prior to 1994, and since then many of the<br />

records have not been properly registered.<br />

This makes it challenging for researchers<br />

to find important documents.<br />

But with the help of archivists and<br />

librarians, we were able to locate rare and<br />

even hidden records of Sharpeville and its<br />

history, and record the voices of many of<br />

the town’s residents.<br />

History of Sharpeville<br />

<strong>The</strong> first settlement in the Sharpeville<br />

area – Top Location – was razed in the<br />

1950s to make space for white people’s<br />

businesses and homes. Official records<br />

and aerial photographs reveal the previous<br />

existence of a large community on the<br />

now empty land. <strong>The</strong>re is also an<br />

unmarked cemetery where about 3,500<br />

residents were buried between around<br />

1900 and 1938.<br />

By the mid-20th century, apartheid<br />

officials began to plan a bigger settlement<br />

in the vicinity. Sharpeville and other<br />

places like it were designed in the 1950s to<br />

segregate Africans away from the cities,<br />

which were reserved for white people<br />

only.<br />

Sharpeville’s housing construction<br />

became a “model” for the ubiquitous fourroomed<br />

NE 51/9 houses in black<br />

townships throughout the country, none of<br />

which they could own outright but rent<br />

only.<br />

In almost 300 witness statements taken<br />

by the police immediately following the<br />

shooting, many of the everyday details of<br />

life in Sharpeville were revealed. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

statements were recorded immediately<br />

after arrest and under oath by the police to<br />

determine guilt or innocence against the<br />

charges of “public violence and<br />

incitement” brought against them. <strong>The</strong>y<br />

were also provided voluntarily in 1961<br />

and 1962, also under oath, by survivors<br />

and family members to establish a basis<br />

for the compensation the victims<br />

unsuccessfully requested.<br />

Details of family life – numbers of<br />

children, occupations, wages, and health<br />

– were recorded, providing a wealth of<br />

Sharpeville massacre memorial<br />

(Photo - Matt Brown CCA 2.0)<br />

information about Sharpeville’s residents.<br />

<strong>The</strong> massacre: Testimony, both from<br />

the official 1960 commission of enquiry<br />

into the massacre, and the criminal court<br />

trial of over 70 Sharpeville residents in<br />

1960-1961, detailed the actions of both the<br />

crowd and the police.<br />

<strong>The</strong> testimony by civilians and police<br />

alike, together with the claimants’<br />

statements, provides a minute-by-minute<br />

narrative of the day. <strong>The</strong> testimonies of the<br />

residents, including all the Africans who<br />

worked for the municipality and as police<br />

officers in Sharpeville, unanimously<br />

attested to the fact that the crowd gathered<br />

peacefully to protest the pass law.<br />

According to these witnesses, by the time<br />

of the shooting, almost 300 policemen had<br />

been moved into the township, including<br />

at least 13 white policemen armed with<br />

Sten machine guns. <strong>The</strong>re were five<br />

Saracen armoured vehicles.<br />

Police testimony makes it clear that the<br />

officer in charge gave the order to shoot,<br />

with the machine gunners firing directly<br />

into the crowd from a distance of no more<br />

than 3-5 metres. As one white official<br />

noted:<br />

It made me think of a wheat field,<br />

where a whirlwind had shaken it.<br />

<strong>The</strong> crowd was taken utterly by<br />

surprise by the police fusillade. Over three<br />

quarters of them, dead and injured alike,<br />

were shot in the back as they fled.<br />

<strong>The</strong> victims: Crucial to gaining an<br />

accurate understanding of the numbers of<br />

Continued on Page 3


News<br />

NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Sharpeville: New research on 1960 South<br />

African massacre shows the number of dead<br />

and injured was massively undercounted<br />

Page3<br />

Continued from Page 1<<br />

victims – their names, families, and<br />

injuries – were the autopsy and medical<br />

records detailing the exact causes of death<br />

and injury for the over 300 victims. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

forms and narrative statements, filled out<br />

by the hospital physicians who treated the<br />

injured and performed autopsies on the<br />

dead, prove conclusively that the<br />

government under-counted the victims by<br />

at least one third.<br />

This new information remained<br />

embargoed in police records throughout<br />

the apartheid years to 1994. Some of it<br />

was finally transferred to the national<br />

archives in the late 1990s and early 2000s.<br />

It details the injuries.<br />

Remembrance<br />

<strong>The</strong> people of Sharpeville wonder why<br />

the world has not listened to their stories<br />

even as they have told them from the day<br />

of the shooting to the present.<br />

In <strong>2023</strong>, residents were able to use the<br />

information uncovered in our research to<br />

update the Wall of Names Memorial<br />

(which lists the name of every person who<br />

gave their life fighting for freedom in<br />

South Africa) at Freedom Park in Pretoria<br />

to reflect accurately the number of victims<br />

killed on 21 March 1960. But still they<br />

have received no compensation for their<br />

injuries.<br />

• Nancy L Clark is Dean and Professor<br />

Emeritus at Louisiana State University<br />

and William H. Worger is Professor<br />

Emeritus of History at University of<br />

California, Los Angeles.<br />

• This article is republished from <strong>The</strong><br />

Conversation under a Creative<br />

Commons license. Read the original<br />

article.


Page4<br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> Group<br />

Field: 07956 385 604<br />

E-mail:<br />

info@the-trumpet.com<br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong>Team<br />

PUBLISHER / EDITOR-IN-CHIEF:<br />

’Femi Okutubo<br />

NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

News<br />

20 th Achievement<br />

Recognition Awards<br />

(ARA) honours achievers<br />

<strong>The</strong> 20 th edition of the Achievement<br />

Recognition Awards (ARA)<br />

organised by Building Blocks<br />

Initiative (BBI) with the theme:<br />

“BEYOND WINDRUSH 75 -<br />

AFRICAN RENAISSANCE” took place<br />

in London recently.<br />

CONTRIBUTORS:<br />

Moji Idowu, Ayo Odumade,<br />

Steve Mulindwa<br />

SPECIAL PROJECTS:<br />

Odafe Atogun<br />

John-Brown Adegunsoye (Abuja)<br />

DESIGN:<br />

Xandydesigns@gmail.com<br />

ATLANTA BUREAU CHIEF:<br />

Uko-Bendi Udo<br />

3695 F Cascade Road #2140 Atlanta,<br />

GA 30331 USA<br />

Tel: +1 404 889 3613<br />

E-mail: uudo1@hotmail.com<br />

BOARD OF CONSULTANTS<br />

CHAIRMAN:<br />

Pastor Kolade Adebayo-Oke<br />

MEMBERS:<br />

Tunde Ajasa-Alashe<br />

Allison Shoyombo, Peter Osuhon<br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> (ISSN: 1477-3392)<br />

is published in London fortnightly<br />

Honoured during the Awards were:<br />

· Lucille Moffatt-Asante, YEGA <strong>2023</strong><br />

WINNER, In recognition of her<br />

Creative Enterprising Mind,<br />

Determination & Perseverance.<br />

· Cllr (Dr) Mahamed Hashi, Young<br />

Leadership Development Recognition.<br />

In recognition of his immeasurable acts<br />

of selflessness, outstanding<br />

professional contribution and political<br />

leadership in knowledge transfer,<br />

community and youth development<br />

support.<br />

· Oluwatosin Khadijat Adesina, Save the<br />

Woman, Community Volunteering<br />

Recognition. In recognition of her<br />

consistent acts of selflessness and<br />

positive contribution to the<br />

development of Save the Woman<br />

charity, service users, wider<br />

Community and the Voluntary Sector.<br />

· Dr Imambay Kamara, Exemplary<br />

Community Lifetime Leadership<br />

Recognition. In recognition of her<br />

outstanding professional activism on<br />

women’s rights, protection from<br />

domestic abuse and public education<br />

on the harms domestic abuse does to<br />

both the victim and the whole family.<br />

· Cllr Nneka Keazor, Exemplary<br />

Political & Professional Leadership<br />

Recognition. In recognition of her<br />

outstanding professional contribution<br />

to political participation and<br />

community development.<br />

· Caroline Namugabi, Professional<br />

Leadership Recognition for<br />

Community Development &<br />

Empowerment. In recognition of her<br />

immeasurable positive contribution to<br />

Black community economic<br />

development and empowerment.<br />

· Prof Ojo Emmanuel Ademola,<br />

Professional Leadership Excellence<br />

Recognition, In recognition of his<br />

immeasurable outstanding professional<br />

contribution to leadership excellence in<br />

knowledge transfer, Cyber Security,<br />

business and community development.<br />

· Hon. Kenneth Gbandi, Exemplary<br />

Diaspora Community & Political<br />

Leadership Recognition. In recognition<br />

of his immeasurable exemplary<br />

community development and political<br />

leadership, and also serving as a great<br />

inspiration to the Nigerian diaspora<br />

communities and beyond.<br />

· Ony Ikeji, Exemplary Professional<br />

Leadership Recognition. In recognition<br />

Achievement Recognition Award plaques<br />

of her immeasurable exemplary<br />

professional leadership.<br />

· Anthony Everest (AREMUORIN),<br />

Exemplary Professional Creative Artist<br />

of the year. In recognition and<br />

appreciation of his immeasurable acts<br />

of generousity and exemplary<br />

professional leadership contribution to<br />

performing arts and the creative<br />

industry.<br />

· Tahira Tofa, YSDNDY, Exemplary<br />

Creative Artist of the year. In<br />

recognition and appreciation of her<br />

boldness, creativity and imaginative<br />

thinking in challenging societal norms<br />

and stereotypes through creative arts.<br />

· Tolu Osinderu, CLEVENARD.<br />

Outstanding Diaspora Professional<br />

Leadership Recognition. In recognition<br />

of his immeasurable outstanding sense<br />

of generous professional contribution<br />

Continued on Page 5<<br />

THINKING<br />

OF<br />

WRITING<br />

A BUSINESS<br />

PLAN?<br />

We can help you develop a<br />

professional business plan<br />

from only £250.<br />

For more information, contact us<br />

at 07402792146 or email us at:<br />

tolu.oyewole@consultant.com


News<br />

NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

20 th Achievement Recognition<br />

Awards (ARA) honours achievers<br />

Page5<br />

Continued from Page 4<<br />

and commitment to community<br />

empowerment and development.<br />

· Ebony Bain, Braids and Beauty,<br />

Entrepreneur of the Year. In recognition<br />

of her outstanding professional<br />

contribution to personal development<br />

and self-economic empowerment.<br />

· Martin Forde KC. Honorary<br />

Exemplary Professional Leadership<br />

Recognition in Legal Profession. In<br />

recognition of his passion, commitment<br />

and immeasurable exemplary personal<br />

sacrifice and positive legal professional<br />

contribution to fighting for equality,<br />

fairness and social justice for all.<br />

· Prof Ojo Emmanuel Ademola,<br />

Honorary Exemplary Professional &<br />

Community Leadership Recognition in<br />

academia and Cyber Security. In<br />

recognition of his immeasurable<br />

exemplary positive professional<br />

contribution to academic and<br />

community development.<br />

· Sandra Popoola OBE JP, Honorary<br />

Professional and Community<br />

Leadership Recognition. In recognition<br />

of her immeasurable exemplary sense<br />

of civic responsibility, volunteering,<br />

and positive professional contribution<br />

to the public sector and community<br />

development.<br />

· Kingsley Abrams, Honorary Political<br />

and Community Leadership<br />

Recognition. In recognition of his<br />

decades-long immeasurable exemplary<br />

positive contribution to community<br />

development, trade union movement<br />

and political activism.<br />

· Nadia Denton, Honorary Professional<br />

Leadership Recognition. In Creative<br />

Arts and Heritage. In recognition of her<br />

immeasurable exemplary outstanding<br />

positive professional contribution to the<br />

creative arts and heritage industry.<br />

· Peter Akinbowale, Honorary<br />

Professional Excellence & Leadership<br />

Recognition. In recognition of his<br />

immeasurable exemplary outstanding<br />

professional leadership excellence in<br />

the financial services sector, most<br />

especially in Mortgage Brokerage.<br />

· Arthur Torrington CBE, Honorary<br />

Lifetime Achievement Recognition. In<br />

appreciation of his immeasurable<br />

exemplary outstanding lifetime<br />

commitment and dedication to fighting<br />

for fairness and social justice for the<br />

Windrush generation who answered to<br />

the distress call of the motherland<br />

Britain for her rebuilding following<br />

devastation of the second world war.<br />

· Aline Ngaoba, Honorary Community<br />

Leadership to Volunteering. In<br />

recognition and appreciation of her<br />

consistent acts of selflessness and<br />

positive contribution to the<br />

Aline Naoba BBI ARA Awards Volunteer of the Year <strong>2023</strong> and Cllr Sunny Lambe, BBI Founder & Chief<br />

Executive<br />

Martin Forde KC, Kingsley Abrams, Honorary ARA Award Winners, family & friends<br />

Cllr Michael Situ, Mayor of Southwark, Cllr Yemi Osho MBE, Prince Mike Abiola, Ayan Ayabdosu (Mr<br />

Culture), Dr Sheriff Alabi and Princess Toyin Onagoruwa<br />

development of Building Blocks<br />

Initiative (BBI), Community and the<br />

Voluntary Sector for many years.<br />

A lucky winner went away with the<br />

mystery BBI ARA AWARDS<br />

AMBASSADOR OF THE YEAR <strong>2023</strong><br />

interactive competition trophy while<br />

some lucky winners walked away with<br />

the raffle prizes which included a donated<br />

FREE Night’s Stay at the Hilton London<br />

Kensington.<br />

<strong>The</strong> BBI’s annual Awards has become<br />

a much anticipated event within the<br />

Black and Minority Ethnic business and<br />

social calendar, bringing about<br />

community and industrial recognition,<br />

professional networking opportunities,<br />

social celebration and a spirit of<br />

togetherness.<br />

Among dignitaries present were Cllr<br />

Michael Situ, the Worshipful Mayor of<br />

Southwark accompanied by his deputy,<br />

Cllr Naima Ali. Among very important<br />

guests were Cllr Joy Laguda former<br />

Mayor Newham and her husband; Mrs<br />

Yemi Oso, former Mayor Waltham<br />

Forest; Dawn Grant, Black<br />

Economics and former award winner;<br />

Prince Mike Abiola of the African Voice;<br />

Femi Okutubo - Founder of both the<br />

GAB Awards and the <strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

<strong>Newspaper</strong>s; Jennifer Obaseki of the<br />

Obasaeki Solicitors; Joy Nichols,<br />

Founder and the Chief Executive of<br />

former Nichols Employment Agency;<br />

representatives of Kato Enterprises, the<br />

drinks sponsors; Ayan Ayandosu, (Mr<br />

Culture); and Anthony Everest,<br />

(AREMUORIN), the performing artist<br />

and winner of an award setting the stage<br />

alight with some cool live jazzy<br />

melodious tuned performance.<br />

Aremuorin’s performance was later<br />

complemented by a superb act from<br />

Aslan<br />

Nester making his debut at the ARA<br />

Awards.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Awards returned as a physical<br />

event following three years of virtual<br />

awards events forced by the COVID-19<br />

lockdown.<br />

Martin Forde KC, Kingsley Abrams, Honorary ARA<br />

Award Winners, family & friendsCllr Michael Situ,<br />

<strong>The</strong> Worshipful Mayor of Southwark & Olayomi<br />

Koiki of Koiki Media


Page6 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong>


NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong> <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Page7


Page8 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

Opinion<br />

Fixing the Power sector<br />

Following the three-day retreat<br />

held for Ministers, Special<br />

Advisers, Permanent<br />

Secretaries and heads of Agencies and<br />

Departments by President Bola<br />

Tinubu, rather belatedly, three weeks<br />

ago with the theme: “Delivering on<br />

the Renewed Hope Agenda” some of<br />

the Ministers have been jumping up<br />

and down, as if the Retreat was the<br />

shot in the arm they needed to shift<br />

out of their slumber. We have seen<br />

quite a number of body movements<br />

lately: from the Minister of Aviation<br />

and Aerospace, Festus Keyamo,<br />

telling the heads of agencies and<br />

parastatals under his Ministry that<br />

whoever wants to sabotage him<br />

through non-performance would be<br />

fired. <strong>The</strong> Minister of Women Affairs,<br />

Uju Kennedy-Ohanenye has also<br />

made a big show of launching<br />

tricycles and sewing machines to<br />

empower women – the Pink Riders<br />

Transport Scheme. Candidly, I don’t<br />

know how many women ride tricycles<br />

across Nigeria, but it is the pattern<br />

around here that policies are often<br />

rolled out without thought or reason<br />

or prior research. <strong>The</strong> Minister of<br />

Arts, Culture and Creative Economy,<br />

Hannatu Musawa has also launched a<br />

road map for the cultural sector. But<br />

the Ministry that is the focus of this<br />

piece is Power, and its new Minister,<br />

Adebayo Adelabu, grandson of the<br />

inimitable legend, Adegoke Adelabu,<br />

a stormy petrel of Nigeria’s First<br />

Republic/Ibadan/Western region<br />

politics and brilliant author of the<br />

book, Africa in Ebullition. It must<br />

have occurred to Adebayo Adelabu<br />

that as Power Minister, he too must be<br />

seen to be doing something. So,<br />

shortly after the Presidential retreat,<br />

he called a press conference where in<br />

a copy-cat manner, he read out a riot<br />

act to the heads of agencies under his<br />

Ministry with the tone of<br />

condescension already copyrighted<br />

by Festus Keyamo: anybody that does<br />

not support me will be fired!<br />

President Tinubu may have to call the<br />

mini-Emperors, closet Headmasters,<br />

in his cabinet to order. Going about<br />

intimidating people with threats is not<br />

how to be a Minister. One Minister<br />

has even turned himself into a quasimilitary<br />

administrator of the Federal<br />

Capital Territory!<br />

However, Minister Adelabu has<br />

shown some enthusiasm for the job,<br />

and he should be advised on the basis<br />

of the things that he has said. On<br />

<strong>November</strong> 8, he told his audience, in<br />

addition to the afore-mentioned threat<br />

that (2) President Tinubu has directed<br />

that stable electricity supply must be<br />

achieved before anyone can raise the<br />

issue of cost-reflective tariff, which<br />

should have been done before now,<br />

but with the present administration<br />

having removed fuel subsidy, it would<br />

be politically inexpedient to add to the<br />

people’s burden by increasing<br />

electricity tariffs. Hence, the Federal<br />

Government is subsidizing electricity<br />

up to N70 per kilowatt hour whereas<br />

the actual cost should be about<br />

N130/N140 per kilowatt hour. Indeed<br />

in 2015, President Buhari disallowed<br />

the Multi-Year Tariff Order (MYTO).<br />

And (3), the Minister said it is<br />

shameful that Nigeria is generating<br />

just about 4,000 MW. Previously, he<br />

had promised that under his watch,<br />

Nigeria should have 20,000 MW of<br />

electricity supply by 2026; (4) he<br />

promised to investigate the legality of<br />

the five-year license extension of the<br />

licenses given to Discos and Gencos<br />

which expired on October 31, <strong>2023</strong>,<br />

and (5) he talked about government<br />

BY REUBEN ABATI<br />

playing a more central role in the<br />

electricity sector. “I am determined to<br />

make impact”, he reportedly said.<br />

I like his enthusiasm, but that is<br />

not enough. I have seen at least one<br />

detailed commentary, on aspects of<br />

the Minister’s rhetoric, notably<br />

Ijeoma Nwogwugwu’s “Penkelemesi<br />

in <strong>The</strong> Power Sector” (ThisDay, back<br />

page, Nov. 13). I want to add my<br />

voice to the conversation that my big<br />

worry is that Minister Adelabu has<br />

been sounding too strident as if he is<br />

a Regulator. No, he is not, and he has<br />

to resist the temptation to keep<br />

sounding as if he is from the Moon.<br />

<strong>The</strong> remit of the Minister is policy<br />

and helping to provide an enabling<br />

Continued on Page 10


News<br />

NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

London raises awareness about<br />

voting system changes<br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Page9<br />

<strong>The</strong> Greater London Authority<br />

(GLA), in collaboration with Shout<br />

Out UK, London borough electoral<br />

services and a coalition of civil society<br />

organisations, has launched an impartial<br />

public awareness campaign seeking to aid<br />

under-represented and under-registered<br />

Londoners, including Black Londoners,<br />

access their right to vote. <strong>The</strong> campaign<br />

also enjoys support from faith leaders and<br />

community groups.<br />

<strong>The</strong> campaign launch is against the<br />

backdrop of the fact that: London has one<br />

of the lowest voter registration rates in<br />

England, with analysis from the GLA<br />

showing that close to one in five people (18<br />

per cent) from a Black, South Asian or<br />

Minority Ethnic background are at risk of<br />

losing their democratic voice because they<br />

are not registered to vote, compared to just<br />

five per cent of White British Londoners<br />

who are in the same situation.<br />

<strong>The</strong> campaign aims to let those from<br />

under-registered and under-represented<br />

groups, including Black Londoners, know<br />

about the need for eligible voters to register<br />

as a first step. This includes the option to<br />

register anonymously for those concerned<br />

about their name and address appearing on<br />

the electoral register.<br />

It will also highlight the new<br />

requirement to show an accepted form of<br />

photo ID to vote in person. This can be a<br />

UK, EU and Commonwealth passport; a<br />

UK and EU Driving Licence, a Blue Badge,<br />

Oyster 60+ photocard or a Freedom Pass.<br />

Almost one in four Black Londoners (27<br />

per cent) are currently unaware of the new<br />

need for photo ID to vote in person.<br />

<strong>The</strong> campaign will also advise on steps<br />

to apply for a free Voter Authority<br />

Certificate for Londoners who do not have<br />

one of the accepted forms of photo ID. Just<br />

one in five Londoners have heard of the<br />

free Voter Authority Certificates (20 per<br />

cent), and only four per cent have applied<br />

for one. Black Londoners are by far the<br />

most likely ethnic group to have either<br />

applied already or have a plan to apply.<br />

<strong>The</strong> campaign will reach Black<br />

Londoners across a variety of engagement<br />

methods and channels including social<br />

Accepted forms of Voter ID<br />

media, traditional media, grassroots<br />

community engagement and through a<br />

WhatsApp Democracy chatbot (+44 7908<br />

820 136). This includes accessible<br />

materials for Deaf and disabled Londoners,<br />

with resources available in Easy Read<br />

format and 16 community languages,<br />

including British Sign Language.<br />

Minister and Pastor Marjorie Esomowei<br />

- Co-Founder of Triumphant Church<br />

International emphasised that: “Voting is a<br />

Pastor Marjorie Esomowei<br />

method to reaffirm our civil rights and<br />

shape policies on issues like education,<br />

healthcare, housing and justice, and much<br />

more. Black Londoners are amongst those<br />

that are under-registered and underrepresented,<br />

with almost one in four Black<br />

Londoners currently unaware of the need<br />

for photo ID to vote in person. This means<br />

too many Black Londoners are at risk of<br />

losing the opportunity to exercise their<br />

democratic right to vote.<br />

We are proud to support the GLA Voter<br />

ID awareness campaign to ensure that<br />

Black Londoners have access to correct and<br />

reliable information so that we can increase<br />

confidence, literacy and action in this<br />

important matter. It’s really important that<br />

people take heed of this and act because, no<br />

vote, no voice.”<br />

<strong>The</strong>re are three simple steps to getting<br />

heard:<br />

Register to vote<br />

Check if you have an accepted form of<br />

photo voter ID<br />

If not, apply for the free Voter Authority<br />

Certificate<br />

Further information is available at the<br />

GLA Democracy Hub:<br />

https://registertovote.london/


Page10 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

Opinion<br />

Fixing the Power sector<br />

Continued from Page 10<<br />

environment for the sector to thrive.<br />

Nigeria needs a reform-minded<br />

Minister in the power sector. <strong>The</strong><br />

Minister needs to break the jinx, and<br />

so, he cannot afford to gamble. <strong>The</strong><br />

road map for the electricity sector in<br />

Nigeria was put in place from<br />

Obasanjo to Jonathan as Presidents.<br />

<strong>The</strong> latter kick-started a<br />

comprehensive reform. But under<br />

President Buhari, the privatization<br />

and deregulation process got<br />

truncated, mismanaged, and turned<br />

upside down. Nothing worked<br />

because there was no proper<br />

coordination in the whole of eight<br />

years. Nigeria would need a<br />

minimum of about 42,000 MW to<br />

jump-start anything but here we are,<br />

at the level of 4,000 MW, far behind<br />

most African countries and yet our<br />

electricity needs, given our<br />

population, far outstrips the African<br />

average. South Africa with a<br />

population of 57.3 million people<br />

generates about 41,194 MW and that<br />

is not even enough for it. <strong>The</strong><br />

Minister is right when he describes<br />

the situation as shameful. It is<br />

embarrassingly obvious however that<br />

he has not been talking to industry<br />

stakeholders. Nigeria is not short of<br />

ideas. What we lack is effective<br />

implementation. He needs to set out<br />

by finding out what the problems are.<br />

Managing the electricity sector is a<br />

specialized job, and there are people<br />

in this country who know where the<br />

corpses are buried, and who the<br />

members of the dangerous cabal in<br />

that sector are. <strong>The</strong> more he talks, the<br />

more the cabal people will plot<br />

against him. He must ask questions<br />

from the regulatory agencies also:<br />

what is their roadmap? What<br />

happened to the original road map?<br />

He should study the terrain and<br />

simplify the issues through rigorous<br />

consultations. Why for example has<br />

the Electric Power Sector Reform Act<br />

of 2005, not worked? Who are the<br />

perpetrators of impunity, lapses and<br />

sabotage within the sector? <strong>The</strong>n he<br />

must clear the table: Nigeria’s<br />

electricity sector is corrupt. All the<br />

people feeding fat at the people’s<br />

expense, be they government officials<br />

or contractors must be identified and<br />

sanctioned through a proper,<br />

preliminary audit of performance<br />

Chief Adebayo Adelabu<br />

within the value-chain.<br />

Minister Adelabu can learn from<br />

the experience of two previous<br />

Ministers. He knows Bola Ige, SAN,<br />

orator, lawyer, statesman who was<br />

Minister of Mines and Power (1999 –<br />

2000). Upon assumption of office,<br />

Bola Ige of the Alliance for<br />

Democracy (AD), working for<br />

Obasanjo’s People’s Democratic<br />

Party (PDP) government boasted that<br />

he was going to fix Nigeria’s<br />

electricity problems in six months. He<br />

underestimated the problem. Those<br />

were the days of National Electric<br />

Power Authority (NEPA). It is<br />

commonly agreed that Bola Ige was<br />

sabotaged by the generator importers<br />

and contractors who were making<br />

humongous profits from Nigeria’s<br />

inefficiency. Chief Ige later became<br />

the Attorney General of the<br />

STALLIONS AIR<br />

Ipanema Travel Ltd<br />

AFRICA FLIGHTS<br />

SPECIALISTS<br />

LAGOS fr £477<br />

(2 Bags)<br />

020 7580 5999<br />

07979 861 455<br />

Call AMIT / ALEX<br />

73 WELLS ST, W1T 3QG<br />

All Fares Seasonal<br />

ATOL 9179<br />

Federation and Minister of Justice but<br />

his tenure in the Ministry of Mines<br />

and Power was a low point in his<br />

otherwise sterling career in Nigeria’s<br />

public space. <strong>The</strong> Obasanjo<br />

administration spent over $<strong>12</strong> trillion<br />

on the power sector in eight years.<br />

Everything went down the drain.<br />

Years later, when former Governor of<br />

Lagos, Babatunde Raji Fashola was<br />

appointed by President Muhammadu<br />

Buhari as Minister of Power, Works<br />

and Housing, and some people started<br />

suggesting that he had promised that<br />

he too would fix Nigeria’s power<br />

supply in six months; he quickly<br />

rushed to the media to say that he<br />

never said so. Buhari spent eight<br />

years but Nigeria still faces the crisis<br />

of epileptic power supply.<br />

In fairness to Fashola though, he<br />

prioritized consultation with<br />

stakeholders. He held regular sectoral<br />

meetings, even if those meetings<br />

eventually degenerated into conflicts<br />

between him and the distribution<br />

companies (DISCOs), but those<br />

meetings offered him a better<br />

understanding of the sector, even if<br />

the challenges in the sector were<br />

overwhelming. Adelabu must<br />

proceed with a sense of history. <strong>The</strong>re<br />

are other stakeholders in the sector<br />

that should be consulted: Dr. Ransom<br />

Owan, Dr Sam Amadi, both formerly<br />

of the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory<br />

Commission (NERC), Ambassador<br />

Godknows Igali, former Permanent<br />

Secretary of the Ministry of Power,<br />

Engr. Beks Dagogo-Jack, former<br />

Chairman of the Presidential Task<br />

Force on Power and co-Chairman of<br />

the Committee on Gas to Power<br />

(20<strong>12</strong> - 2014), Professor Chinedu<br />

Nebo who handed over the assets of<br />

the Power Holding Company of<br />

Nigeria (PHCN), successor of NEPA,<br />

to private investors in <strong>November</strong><br />

2013, Rilwan Lanre Babalola who<br />

was Minister of Power 2008 to 2010,<br />

and a host of others. <strong>The</strong>y are in a<br />

position to show him where the<br />

corpses are buried in a sector that is<br />

practically a graveyard of hopes and<br />

aspirations! In his time, Professor<br />

Nebo, who is a man of the cloth<br />

promised that he would drive away<br />

the evil spirits in the power sector.<br />

Those evil spirits defied Nebo. <strong>The</strong>y<br />

are still there. <strong>The</strong> Minister also needs<br />

to find out what happened with the<br />

Rural Electrification Agency which<br />

became a cesspool of corruption.<br />

Every Minister comes along with the<br />

Continued on Page 15


NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong> <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Page11


Page<strong>12</strong> <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong>Trump et<br />

Africans now have a voice... Founded in 1995<br />

SUBSCRIBE to the authentic newspaper<br />

focusing on Africa and Friends of Africa.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Trumpet</strong> <strong>Newspaper</strong> which was<br />

established in 1995 has over the years grown<br />

to be the <strong>Newspaper</strong> of choice and voice for<br />

Diaspora Africans.<br />

It also has a readership among Africans on<br />

the Continent who want to connect and<br />

keep up with Diaspora Africans; and Friends<br />

of Africa who want to connect and keep up<br />

with Africa.<br />

We are pleased to offer more choices to read<br />

<strong>Trumpet</strong> <strong>Newspaper</strong> via Subscription to our<br />

Digital edition or Print edition (or both).<br />

As a paid Subscriber, you will enjoy:<br />

• Priority and Direct delivery of every<br />

fortnightly issue to you (Digital - via email<br />

and Print via Post).<br />

• Occasional exclusive offers and event<br />

invitations (subject to availability).<br />

Our Subscription Rates vary according to<br />

where you are in the world: UK, Europe<br />

or Rest of the World.<br />

You can Subscribe online at:<br />

<strong>Trumpet</strong>MediaGroup.com/Shop<br />

or complete the form below.<br />

I / We wish to subscribe to<br />

<strong>Trumpet</strong> <strong>Newspaper</strong> until further notice:<br />

Name:<br />

Rates and options ( Tick ✔)<br />

Address:<br />

Email:<br />

Tel No:<br />

I/We made a payment of £ on (date) into<br />

your Bank Account: Account Name: Target Today Ltd.<br />

Sort Code: 20 32 00<br />

Account No: 03946231<br />

I am / We are enclosing cheque for £<br />

Target Today Ltd.<br />

made payable to<br />

Signature:<br />

I / We have sent a payment of £<br />

targettoday@the-trumpet.com<br />

via Paypal to<br />

Date:<br />

Please send me a Stripe Payment Link<br />

Return Subscription Form by Email: info@the-trumpet.com<br />

or Post: <strong>Trumpet</strong> Media, 3rd Floor, 86 - 90 Paul Street, London EC2A 4NE


NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong> <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Page13


Page14 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

Opinion<br />

<strong>The</strong> passable view of<br />

roads in Southwest<br />

Nigeria<br />

From time immemorial, the masses<br />

have relied on constituted<br />

governments to implement road<br />

projects for the socio-political economy<br />

of the society. Whichever government got<br />

the construction right would be praised<br />

while those who focused on the<br />

maintenance would also be eulogised by<br />

the masses. However, those who neither<br />

got the construction nor the maintenance<br />

right would be recorded in the psyche of<br />

the people. Hence the adage: ‘<strong>The</strong> king<br />

who sits on the throne in halcyon times,<br />

his name shall not be forgotten. Same for<br />

that whose reign is turbulent.’<br />

To say the truth, an emergency should<br />

be declared on the Nigerian roads.<br />

Without sounding alarmist, there is no<br />

road in any part of the country that is<br />

recommended, either as passable or<br />

standard; not even in Abuja, the nation’s<br />

seat of power. It is that bad! It is after we<br />

have accepted this that we may begin to<br />

appreciate the enormity of our problems.<br />

Whether “a Minister has more than three<br />

Land Cruisers, Prado and other<br />

vehicles” or a Senator Sunday Karimi<br />

“spends a lot on” his N160 million Prado<br />

Jeep “because our roads are bad” is<br />

perhaps the least of our problems.<br />

For God’s sake, how can we be<br />

talking about movement of goods and<br />

services when our roads have become<br />

appallingly impassable? How can we<br />

relish the domestic economy or may<br />

attract foreign investments to the country<br />

when our roads have practically become<br />

death traps, and the standard of living is<br />

affected immediately? Exchange is<br />

inhibited locally and physically if and<br />

when movement is impossible on a daily<br />

basis. Energy sector is an important<br />

driver of growth but, talking about the<br />

wonkiness of our development, power<br />

outages have sadly become Nigeria’s<br />

middle name. Even the waterways that<br />

are supposed to bridge the gap are already<br />

filled with filth.<br />

Once upon a time in Nigeria,<br />

whenever we said that a contract has been<br />

given to the Germans, the thinking then<br />

was that the Germans were full of iron<br />

and that the job they would do would be<br />

solid. It used to be with former President<br />

Muhammadu Buhari but, now, it is<br />

President Bola Tinubu. <strong>The</strong> question is:<br />

is it in terms of the structure or quality of<br />

the job that’s being done? In terms of<br />

Buhari and Tinubu, what do we now<br />

have?<br />

Ilesa – Ijebu-Jesa - Ado-Ekiti Road!<br />

Lagos – Abeokuta Road! Lagos –<br />

David Umahi - Nigeria's Works Minister<br />

Badagry Road! Lagos – Epe Road!<br />

Gbongan - Osogbo – Ilorin Road! <strong>The</strong><br />

Southwest is the worst hit! From Ibadan<br />

– Ogbomoso - Ilorin Road which has<br />

been under construction since my days at<br />

the University of Ilorin, to Ibadan – Ile-<br />

Ife – Akure Road which has been under<br />

construction for over 15 years, the trouble<br />

is that there’s no vision; and, where<br />

there’s no vision, one can’t really move<br />

because concrete vision signposts<br />

development. Evidently, it is because<br />

governance has lost its meaning that we<br />

continue to eat our seed instead of sowing<br />

it. And if we may ask: interconnectedness<br />

in the Southwest, is it anything to write<br />

home about for a country that has become<br />

independent since October 1, 1960?<br />

Chief Obafemi Awolowo died on May<br />

9, 1987. But isn’t it a big shame that, as of<br />

today, Saturday, October 28, <strong>2023</strong>,<br />

people still refer to ‘Awo Roads’? Bisi<br />

Akande also governed Osun State<br />

between 1999 and 2003. This is <strong>2023</strong>, yet<br />

Nigerians still refer to ‘Bisi Akande<br />

Roads’. Whereas elsewhere, people are<br />

talking about 14 lanes, what we have in<br />

the Southwest, which are mostly single<br />

lanes, remain unattended to. So, when<br />

exactly is Nigeria ever going to develop?<br />

If goods must exchange hands - and there<br />

must be exchange - how many roads are<br />

there, linking, say, Ijebu-Jesa to Ilesa in<br />

Osun State? We talk about Lagos-Ibadan<br />

Expressway, yet it is difficult to maintain<br />

it. So, where exactly are we developing<br />

into? Nigerians started fighting one<br />

another over subsidy and all kinds of<br />

indiscreet things. <strong>The</strong>y strived to earn<br />

resources, but … they didn’t know how<br />

to spend resources; and that’s<br />

unfortunate! Take it or leave it, ability to<br />

spend resources wisely is in itself an<br />

innovation and a motivation for<br />

development. <strong>The</strong>se are the issues!<br />

That Nigeria has no capacity to<br />

maintain its extant roads is a shame. It is<br />

also a shame that governance in this part<br />

of the world has lost its meaning. Of<br />

course, that’s what gave the military the<br />

effrontery that it could do and undo, and<br />

ignore the people. In his days as Nigeria’s<br />

Head of State, Yakubu Gowon didn’t<br />

know that Nigerians were so powerless<br />

Dualisation of the outstanding portion of Calabar–Odukpani–Itu–Ikot Ekpene Road<br />

until he was told that they were mere<br />

rabble-rousers, that they didn’t know<br />

much and that they were not in any way<br />

organised. Gowon was thankful to his<br />

informants. <strong>The</strong> rest is history! <strong>The</strong><br />

military predators who came after ‘Jack’<br />

only perfected the art. Is it any wonder<br />

that Nigeria has found herself in this<br />

mess?<br />

Back then, only in extreme cases<br />

would the military roll out tanks and fire<br />

one or two bullets in the air before<br />

everybody would talk to his or her feet<br />

because nobody wanted to die. As such,<br />

nobody wanted to know what his or her<br />

rights entailed, and that’s even if they<br />

knew that they had any rights in the first<br />

place. So, it is simple mathematics that<br />

BY ABIODUN<br />

KOMOLAFE<br />

where we have now found ourselves has<br />

a history. We are where we are because<br />

our leaders are asleep. But again,<br />

everything boils down to visionary<br />

leadership. It is the lack of vision that has<br />

brought Nigeria to her knees. Contractors<br />

look for higher pay in Nigeria, not<br />

because higher pay will make the job<br />

better, but higher pay will surely balloon<br />

the leisure; and that’s annoying. Until we<br />

change that orientation, nothing is going<br />

to change.<br />

Nigerians have been thrown into the<br />

mud due to lack of concrete knowledge.<br />

Tragically, to rise from the mud is a very<br />

difficult voyage. It is like a struggling<br />

man from the swamp. But it is<br />

achievable; and it is never too late. So, let<br />

the architects come with plain sheets of<br />

paper to, say, the National Stadium in<br />

Lagos or Liberty Stadium in Ibadan with<br />

a view to recalibrating the roads for the<br />

Southwest. What are we saying? That I<br />

used to go through this place in the past<br />

doesn’t matter. If we don’t have people<br />

who can dream, then we are in trouble.<br />

Surely, the entire roads can be redrawn to<br />

reflect modern reality; and that’s what<br />

development in the Southwest is all<br />

about. It is eternally on; and it will never<br />

stop. To stop is for development to stop.<br />

But nothing stops and rests except in<br />

docile societies.<br />

To sum up, it needs to be noted that,<br />

except one wants to be mischievous, the<br />

opposition now has a credible landing<br />

site. <strong>The</strong> Supreme Court said it; and that<br />

settled it. As things stand, nobody will<br />

say that the Atiku Abubakars and the<br />

Peter Obis of Nigeria ran away from the<br />

battle. No, not at all! Instead, they waited<br />

for the highest court in the land; and<br />

that’s all! <strong>The</strong>y have fought a good fight<br />

and it has ended. Impliedly, Tinubu has<br />

no excuses again. Let him now get to<br />

work. Let him work diligently at fixing<br />

our roads. Those who can work with the<br />

President, let them stay while those who<br />

have nothing to offer again should look<br />

for where their expertise will be in high<br />

demand. And for Nigerians, the only<br />

hope is to keep trying and keep pushing<br />

until it bursts. After all, it is in the history<br />

of revolutions: even when one is not<br />

expecting things to burst, something will<br />

surely give.<br />

May the Lamb of God, who takes<br />

away the sin of the world, grant us peace<br />

in Nigeria!


Opinion<br />

Fixing the Power sector<br />

NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Page15<br />

Continued from Page 14<<br />

promise to improve electricity supply<br />

but the only people who benefit from<br />

all the investments are corrupt people<br />

within the value chain. It has become<br />

fashionable to blame the DISCOs,<br />

who occupy the last mile of electricity<br />

delivery, but the problem is not with<br />

the DISCOs.<br />

Has the Minister bothered to find<br />

out what happened or is happening to<br />

the Transmission Company of Nigeria<br />

(TCN)? <strong>The</strong> Nigerian Government<br />

appointed Manitoba, a Canadian<br />

Company to manage power<br />

transmission in Nigeria – a<br />

management contract of over $200<br />

million. Money was released to<br />

Manitoba but the company was never<br />

allowed to function. It could not<br />

execute all the projects that it was<br />

supposed to manage and deliver<br />

upon. Manitoba has since left Nigeria<br />

out of frustration. <strong>The</strong> Transmission<br />

Company is now unfortunately in the<br />

hands of government officials, the<br />

same old NEPA officials whose<br />

cognomen is “Never Expect Power<br />

Always.” <strong>The</strong>re must be an audit of<br />

TCN as soon as possible, and an<br />

urgent probe of all persons who have<br />

subverted government policy. Nigeria<br />

cannot continue to move from<br />

darkness to darkness – the<br />

unfortunate reality that we are dealing<br />

with is that there are incompetent<br />

people in the value chain. And how<br />

effective is the interface between<br />

TCN and the GENCOs and DISCOs?<br />

What happened to loans disbursed in<br />

the past? <strong>The</strong> other major challenge is<br />

the supply of gas. <strong>The</strong> Governor of<br />

Niger State has been asking for a<br />

share of the Derivation Fund because<br />

his State hosts hydro dams, and he<br />

thinks his people deserve more from<br />

the national cake because of the hydro<br />

dams in Kainji, Jebba, and Shiroro in<br />

his State. Some of these Nigerian<br />

Governors and Ministers sound like<br />

they just left primary school, but that<br />

is not the focus of this piece today.<br />

<strong>The</strong> truth is that in the power sector,<br />

the main source of power is gas-fired<br />

power – that is thermal power which<br />

relies on natural gas to generate<br />

electricity – about 85% gas as<br />

opposed to 15% hydro. Nigeria’s<br />

thermal plants include Olorunsogo,<br />

Geregu, Egbin, Omotosho, Afam, and<br />

Sapele. But gas supply is a problem, a<br />

big constraint for the GENCOS, in<br />

part because gas supply has not been<br />

decoupled from oil.<br />

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has<br />

been discussing the power sector with<br />

the Germans. Olaf Scholz, the<br />

German Chancellor was in Nigeria on<br />

a State visit in October. Nigeria and<br />

Germany have had strong bilateral<br />

relations for more than 60 years.<br />

Recently, President Tinubu also<br />

travelled to Germany to attend the<br />

Compact with Africa summit on the<br />

sidelines of the G-20 meeting. He and<br />

Chancellor Scholz met again and one<br />

of the issues they discussed was<br />

Nigeria’s power sector and<br />

specifically Nigeria’s deal with<br />

Siemens, the German company with<br />

which the Buhari administration<br />

entered into an agreement – a threephase<br />

plan to provide electricity in<br />

Nigeria. <strong>The</strong> agreement was signed<br />

under what was called the<br />

Presidential Power Initiative (PPI).<br />

By that plan it was expected that by<br />

<strong>2023</strong>, Siemens would have provided<br />

up to 11,000 MW. We are at year-end.<br />

That has not happened. Even the idea<br />

of mini-grids has not worked.<br />

Siemens is an equipment company,<br />

not a Transmission company, not a<br />

DISCO, but everyone refers to how<br />

that company has helped the<br />

electricity generation process in<br />

Egypt. Siemens has not worked well<br />

here because it is mired in Nigeria’s<br />

complex web of zero transparency<br />

and lack of accountability. As it<br />

turned out, Nigeria started adding<br />

other things, talking about local<br />

content. Which local content? What<br />

does Nigeria produce as local content<br />

in the electricity sector? <strong>The</strong>n,<br />

COVID-19. <strong>The</strong>n the Russia-Ukraine<br />

War. And then, no magic from<br />

Siemens. <strong>The</strong> German Chancellor<br />

reportedly told President Tinubu that<br />

generating the electricity is not the<br />

problem but Nigeria has to follow<br />

through at its end. He was absolutely<br />

right. Everything is about us. We<br />

have to follow through. Minister<br />

Fashola managed to plug some<br />

missing links in distribution because<br />

he paid attention. Adelabu must pay<br />

attention to details.<br />

What is the way forward? <strong>The</strong><br />

Minister must sit down with<br />

stakeholders. When they call him, he<br />

should have enough presence of mind<br />

to return their calls. He is holding a<br />

public office, not a private office. He<br />

must also work hard to dismantle the<br />

cartels in the sector. <strong>The</strong> industry<br />

needs to be more investor-friendly,<br />

and it is the duty of the Ministry to<br />

create an enabling environment. In<br />

addressing petty corruption in the<br />

sector, government also needs to<br />

focus on energy theft. More than 50%<br />

of the meters supplied so far to<br />

consumers are being by-passed.<br />

Nobody really wants to pay for<br />

electricity because the chaos in the<br />

sector is well known. To break the<br />

jinx, the TCN must be handed over to<br />

concessionaires. TCN and the<br />

Nigerian Gas Company are controlled<br />

by government. It is not clear how the<br />

industry can make progress if<br />

government continues to constitute<br />

itself into an obstacle. <strong>The</strong> Minister<br />

wants to review the extension of<br />

licenses. If he had done his homework,<br />

he would have discovered that<br />

the extension is the result of a mutual<br />

agreement between government and<br />

the DISCOs – both parties having<br />

failed to fulfil their own parts of the<br />

bargain since 2013.<br />

Going forward, the Tinubu<br />

administration must come up with a<br />

National Position on Power beyond<br />

the general statements in the <strong>2023</strong><br />

election campaign manifesto. At<br />

pages 30 to 32 of the Renewed Hope<br />

Manifesto, Tinubu promised to<br />

eliminate the disconnect between<br />

generation and distribution, provide<br />

support for meter asset providers,<br />

investment for power in rural areas,<br />

power sector governance reforms, and<br />

what is generally described as<br />

“Nigeria First Power Policy.” I<br />

suggest that the President should set<br />

up a National Council on Power<br />

Reforms which will report directly to<br />

him, to begin a much-needed<br />

conversation about and around the<br />

electricity sector.


Page16 <strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> NOVEMBER <strong>29</strong> - DECEMBER <strong>12</strong> <strong>2023</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong><strong>Trumpet</strong> is published in London fortnightly by <strong>Trumpet</strong><br />

Field: 07956 385 604 E-mail: info@the-trumpet.com (ISSN: 1477-3392)

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!