environmental impact statement kilmainhamwood compost facility ...

environmental impact statement kilmainhamwood compost facility ... environmental impact statement kilmainhamwood compost facility ...

28.12.2012 Views

5361- Kilmainhamwood Compost Facility Extension- EIS within the Greater Dublin Area. In addition, there are also sites with planning permission for biological treatment facilities in the Greater Dublin Area. If constructed and approved by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, such facilities could accept and process biowaste. Existing facilities and facilities with planning permission include: • Greenstar Millennium Park, Dublin (50,000 tpa); • Nephin Trading Ltd, Co. Kildare (65,000 tpa); • Drehid Waste Management Facility, Co. Kildare (25,000 tpa); • Organic Gold in Co. Meath (25,000 tpa); • Panda Waste in Co. Meath (20,000 tpa); and • Enrich Environmental in Co. Meath (20,000 tpa); It should be noted that the above facility details are based on the best data available at the time of writing. The proposed facilities at Kilshane Cross and the Ballyogan Recycling Park in County Dublin have not been included, as the relevant Dublin local authorities have stated that the current tender process for these facilities will not be progressed further. In addition, there is no certainty that all of the above facilities will be developed. It is likely that some of the facilities listed above (if developed) will be constructed as MBT (Mechanical and Biological Treatment) facilities for the stabilisation of the organic fraction within residual waste. Therefore the potential biological treatment capacity (for source separated biowaste) in the Greater Dublin Area will be further reduced by this likely scenario. Figure 4.5 illustrates the potential biowaste arisings in the Dublin and North East Regions and the existing Animal By-Products approved facility (Kilmainhamwood Compost) and proposed facilities that could potentially have biological treatment capacity in the future. Figure 4.5 Potential Biowaste Arisings (NE and Dublin Region) versus Potential Capacity TPA Potential Biowaste Arisings (Dublin and North East) compared to Existing and Potential Facility Capacity 700,000 600,000 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 For inspection purposes only. Consent of copyright owner required for any other use. 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Year Shortfall 65 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Total Biowaste Existing and Potential ABP facilities EPA Export 01-06-2010:03:55:54

5361- Kilmainhamwood Compost Facility Extension- EIS It is clear from these findings that there will be a significant deficit in the biological treatment capacity for biowaste in the North East and Dublin Regions should all the facilities listed above be constructed and approved to accept Animal By-Products. Obviously, this shortfall would increase further should any of the proposed facilities not be developed or granted approval by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. The proposed extension and intensification of the Kilmainhamwood Compost facility is therefore regarded as infrastructure that is required to provide urgently needed biological treatment capacity for the North East and Dublin Regions. This need is further reflected by the EPA which states that the priorities for improvements in biodegradable municipal waste management in Ireland for 2010, as set out in the EPA NWR 2008 include; ‘Ensuring there is adequate infrastructure to treat the very large quantities of organic (particularly food) waste that must be collected separately and diverted from landfill’ (Ref Section 4.3, EPA NWR 2008). Inter Regional Movement of Waste The existing Kilmainhamwood facility currently accepts waste from both the North East Region and the Dublin Region. Thorntons Recycling currently have approximately 7,860 household customers in County Meath and are in the process of rolling out source separated biowaste collections to all these customers (having already rolled out brown bins to approximately 1,000). In relation to the inter regional movement of waste, the North East Waste Management Plan 2005-2010 states that; ‘Conditions attached to some planning permissions for waste infrastructure restrict facilities to handling only waste that arises in the geographic area covered by the Waste Management Plan, the rationale being the proximity principle. The Government’s latest policy document ‘Taking Stock and Moving Forward’, recognises that the proximity principle has been interpreted too severely by some planning authorities and that some but not all planning authorities have been too literal in their interpretation of Waste Management Plans. The policy statement also states how each region has to take responsibility for its own waste.’ For inspection purposes only. Consent of copyright owner required for any other use. It also states that ‘The Waste Plan recognises that there should be flexibility with respect to the movement of waste across regional boundaries. In broad terms the capacity of waste facilities in the Region should primarily satisfy the needs of the Region whilst not precluding inter regional movement of waste and allowing flexibility to cater for the development of required national infrastructure. This policy on inter regional movement of waste has been reinforced by the recent Policy Direction issued by the Minister under Section 60 of the Waste Management Acts, 1996-2003.’ It is clear from the above extracts that the acceptance of waste, at the Kilmainhamwood facility, from outside the North East Region does not contravene waste policy and direction. 66 EPA Export 01-06-2010:03:55:54

5361- Kilmainhamwood Compost Facility Extension- EIS<br />

within the Greater Dublin Area. In addition, there are also sites with planning permission for biological<br />

treatment facilities in the Greater Dublin Area. If constructed and approved by the Department of<br />

Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, such facilities could accept and process biowaste. Existing facilities<br />

and facilities with planning permission include:<br />

• Greenstar Millennium Park, Dublin (50,000 tpa);<br />

• Nephin Trading Ltd, Co. Kildare (65,000 tpa);<br />

• Drehid Waste Management Facility, Co. Kildare (25,000 tpa);<br />

• Organic Gold in Co. Meath (25,000 tpa);<br />

• Panda Waste in Co. Meath (20,000 tpa); and<br />

• Enrich Environmental in Co. Meath (20,000 tpa);<br />

It should be noted that the above <strong>facility</strong> details are based on the best data available at the time of<br />

writing. The proposed facilities at Kilshane Cross and the Ballyogan Recycling Park in County Dublin<br />

have not been included, as the relevant Dublin local authorities have stated that the current tender<br />

process for these facilities will not be progressed further. In addition, there is no certainty that all of the<br />

above facilities will be developed. It is likely that some of the facilities listed above (if developed) will be<br />

constructed as MBT (Mechanical and Biological Treatment) facilities for the stabilisation of the organic<br />

fraction within residual waste. Therefore the potential biological treatment capacity (for source<br />

separated biowaste) in the Greater Dublin Area will be further reduced by this likely scenario.<br />

Figure 4.5 illustrates the potential biowaste arisings in the Dublin and North East Regions and the<br />

existing Animal By-Products approved <strong>facility</strong> (Kilmainhamwood Compost) and proposed facilities that<br />

could potentially have biological treatment capacity in the future.<br />

Figure 4.5 Potential Biowaste Arisings (NE and Dublin Region) versus Potential Capacity<br />

TPA<br />

Potential Biowaste Arisings (Dublin and North East) compared to<br />

Existing and Potential Facility Capacity<br />

700,000<br />

600,000<br />

500,000<br />

400,000<br />

300,000<br />

200,000<br />

100,000<br />

0<br />

For inspection purposes only.<br />

Consent of copyright owner required for any other use.<br />

2009<br />

2010<br />

2011<br />

2012<br />

2013<br />

2014<br />

2015<br />

Year<br />

Shortfall<br />

65<br />

2016<br />

2017<br />

2018<br />

2019<br />

2020<br />

Total Biowaste<br />

Existing and<br />

Potential ABP<br />

facilities<br />

EPA Export 01-06-2010:03:55:54

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!