Angelus News | October 6, 2023 | Vol. 8 No. 20
Divides in politics, religion, and education get blamed for many of society’s problems today. But what if the differences between age generations — i.e. millennials, baby boomers, Gen X, Gen Z — matter more than those? On Page 10, contributor Elise Italiano Ureneck takes a close look at a popular psychologist’s research into the “generation wars” and the cost of progress, before asking: Can faith succeed where technology has failed?
Divides in politics, religion, and education get blamed for many of society’s problems today. But what if the differences between age generations — i.e. millennials, baby boomers, Gen X, Gen Z — matter more than those? On Page 10, contributor Elise Italiano Ureneck takes a close look at a popular psychologist’s research into the “generation wars” and the cost of progress, before asking: Can faith succeed where technology has failed?
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ANGELUS<br />
LOST IN<br />
OUR TIMES<br />
Can the Church bridge the<br />
widening generation gap?<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> <strong>Vol</strong>. 8 <strong>No</strong>. <strong>20</strong>
B • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
ANGELUS<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong><br />
<strong>Vol</strong>. 8 • <strong>No</strong>. <strong>20</strong><br />
3424 Wilshire Blvd.,<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90010-2241<br />
(213) 637-7360 • FAX (213) 637-6360<br />
Published by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese<br />
of Los Angeles by The Tidings<br />
(a corporation), established 1895.<br />
Publisher<br />
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />
Vice Chancellor for Communications<br />
DAVID SCOTT<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
PABLO KAY<br />
pkay@angelusnews.com<br />
Associate Editor<br />
MIKE CISNEROS<br />
Multimedia Editor<br />
TAMARA LONG-GARCÍA<br />
Production Artist<br />
ARACELI CHAVEZ<br />
Photo Editor<br />
VICTOR ALEMÁN<br />
Managing Editor<br />
RICHARD G. BEEMER<br />
Assistant Editor<br />
HANNAH SWENSON<br />
Advertising Manager<br />
JIM GARCIA<br />
jagarcia@angelusnews.com<br />
ON THE COVER<br />
JACOB POPCAK<br />
Divides in politics, religion, and education get blamed<br />
for many of society’s problems today. But what if the<br />
differences between age generations — i.e., millennials,<br />
baby boomers, Gen X, Gen Z — matter more than those?<br />
On Page 10, contributor Elise Italiano Ureneck takes a<br />
close look at a popular psychologist’s research into the<br />
“generation wars” and the cost of progress, before asking:<br />
Can faith succeed where technology has failed?<br />
THIS PAGE<br />
JOHN RUEDA/ADLA<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez blesses a group<br />
of religious sisters and young women at the<br />
annual LA Catholic Prayer Breakfast at the<br />
Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels on Sept.<br />
19. The event began with a rosary, Mass, and<br />
then breakfast with a keynote talk from local<br />
Catholic, author, actor, musician, and marriage<br />
and family therapist Joe Sikorra.<br />
ANGELUS is published biweekly by The<br />
Tidings (a corporation), established 1895.<br />
Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles,<br />
California. One-year subscriptions (26<br />
issues), $30.00; single copies, $3.00<br />
© <strong>20</strong>21 ANGELUS (2473-2699). <strong>No</strong> part of this<br />
publication may be reproduced without the written<br />
permission of the publisher. Events and products<br />
advertised in ANGELUS do not carry the implicit<br />
endorsement of The Tidings Corporation or the<br />
Archdiocese of Los Angeles.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to:<br />
ANGELUS, PO Box 306, Congers, NY 109<strong>20</strong>-0306.<br />
For Subscription and Delivery information, please<br />
call (844) 245-6630 (Mon - Fri, 7 am-4 pm PT).<br />
FOLLOW US<br />
facebook.com/<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
info@angelusnews.com<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong> <strong>News</strong><br />
@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
@<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong><br />
angelusnews.com<br />
lacatholics.org<br />
Pope Watch.................................................................................................................................... 2<br />
Archbishop Gomez..................................................................................................................... 3<br />
World, Nation, and Local <strong>News</strong>.......................................................................................... 4-6<br />
In Other Words............................................................................................................................. 7<br />
Father Rolheiser............................................................................................................................ 8<br />
Scott Hahn................................................................................................................................... 32<br />
Events Calendar......................................................................................................................... 33<br />
14<br />
16<br />
18<br />
<strong>20</strong><br />
26<br />
CONTENTS<br />
Santa Clarita parish mourns slain deputy as one of its own<br />
Migrant mom, baby bused from Texas gets special welcome from ‘Father Fili’<br />
RSHM sisters celebrate 100 years in California, but have a soft spot for LA<br />
John Allen: A viewer’s guide to the unviewable <strong>October</strong> synod<br />
Greg Erlandson on the spiritual graces of a 335-mile bike ride<br />
Sign up for our free, daily e-newsletter<br />
Always Forward - newsletter.angelusnews.com<br />
28<br />
30<br />
A Catholic historian’s take on ancient Rome’s social media moment<br />
Heather King reports back from a four-day silent retreat in Ireland<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 1
POPE WATCH<br />
The real leap of faith<br />
The following is adapted from the<br />
Holy Father’s homily Sept. 23 at a<br />
votive Mass of the Blessed Virgin Mary<br />
de la Garde at the conclusion of his<br />
two-day visit to Marseille, France.<br />
When Mary enters Elizabeth’s<br />
house, the child she is<br />
carrying, recognizing the<br />
arrival of the Messiah, leaps for joy<br />
and begins to dance as David had<br />
before the Ark of the Covenant (cf.<br />
Luke 1:39–45).<br />
Mary is presented as the true Ark<br />
of the Covenant, introducing the<br />
incarnate Lord into the world. She is<br />
the young virgin who goes to meet the<br />
barren, elderly woman and, in bringing<br />
Jesus, becomes a sign of God’s<br />
visitation that overcomes all sterility.<br />
She is the mother who goes up to the<br />
mountains of Judah, to tell us that<br />
God is setting out to seek us with his<br />
love, so that we might exult with joy.<br />
In these two women, Mary and Elizabeth,<br />
God’s visitation to humanity is<br />
revealed. One is young and the other<br />
old, one is a virgin and the other barren,<br />
yet they are both pregnant in an<br />
“impossible” way. This is God’s work<br />
in our lives; he makes possible even<br />
what seems impossible, he generates<br />
life even amidst sterility.<br />
Brothers and sisters, let us ask ourselves<br />
honestly, from the heart: Do<br />
we believe that God is at work in our<br />
lives?<br />
There is a way to discern whether or<br />
not we have this trust in the Lord. The<br />
Gospel says that “as soon as Elizabeth<br />
had heard Mary’s greeting, the child<br />
leapt in her womb” (v. 41). This is the<br />
sign: to leap for joy. Whoever believes,<br />
whoever prays, whoever welcomes<br />
the Lord leaps in the Spirit, and feels<br />
that something is moving within, and<br />
“dances” with joy.<br />
To leap means to be “touched<br />
inside,” to have an interior quiver, to<br />
feel that something is moving in our<br />
heart. This is the opposite of a flat,<br />
cold heart, accustomed to the quiet<br />
life, which is encased in indifference<br />
and becomes impermeable.<br />
Those who are born to faith, recognize<br />
the presence of the Lord, like the<br />
baby in Elizabeth’s womb. Faced with<br />
the mystery of life and the challenges<br />
of society, those who believe have<br />
a spring in their step, a passion, a<br />
dream to cultivate, an interest that<br />
impels them to personally commit<br />
themselves. <strong>No</strong>w each of us can ask<br />
ourselves: do I feel these things? Do I<br />
have these things? Those who are like<br />
this know that in everything the Lord<br />
is present, calling and inviting them<br />
to witness to the Gospel with meekness,<br />
in order to build a new world,<br />
using the gifts and charisms they have<br />
received.<br />
Besides enabling us to leap in the<br />
face of life, the experience of faith<br />
also compels us to leap toward our<br />
neighbor. Indeed, in the mystery<br />
of the Visitation, we see that God’s<br />
visitation does not take place through<br />
extraordinary, heavenly events, but in<br />
the simplicity of an encounter.<br />
Let us always remember this in the<br />
Church: God is relational and often<br />
visits us through human encounters,<br />
when we know how to be open to<br />
others, when there is a “stirring”<br />
within us in favor of those who pass<br />
us every day, and when our hearts do<br />
not remain impassive and insensitive<br />
before the wounds of the fragile.<br />
Papal Prayer Intention for <strong>October</strong>. For the Synod: We pray<br />
for the Church, that she may adopt listening and dialogue as<br />
a lifestyle at every level, and allow herself to be guided by the<br />
Holy Spirit toward the peripheries of the world.<br />
2 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
NEW WORLD OF FAITH<br />
ARCHBISHOP JOSÉ H. GOMEZ<br />
‘Should you not have had pity’<br />
Archbishop Gomez recently celebrated<br />
the annual Mass for All Immigrants<br />
at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the<br />
Angels. The following is adapted from<br />
his homily.<br />
Today, we celebrate the beautiful<br />
diversity of peoples that<br />
make up the family of God<br />
in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles<br />
and in the Dioceses of Orange, San<br />
Bernardino, and San Diego.<br />
And we are all here today because<br />
we share one vision and one<br />
hope. We are united in the cause of<br />
building a home for all peoples, all<br />
nations, races, and languages.<br />
Jesus said that he was sent into this<br />
world by the Father, and that the<br />
Father sent him to unite all things in<br />
heaven on earth in him. He said the<br />
Father sent him “that all may be one”<br />
under the one God who made all of<br />
us.<br />
This is God’s heart. This is what he<br />
wants for Los Angeles, for southern<br />
California, for America, for the world.<br />
This is what he wants for each one<br />
of us.<br />
What makes us one is that we are<br />
created by God and saved through<br />
Jesus Christ. We have one Father in<br />
heaven, and through Jesus the Father<br />
has shown us mercy, and made us<br />
sisters and brothers on earth.<br />
That is the beautiful message of our<br />
readings today from the sacred Scriptures.<br />
As we heard in today’s passage<br />
of the Gospel: “Should you not have<br />
had pity on your fellow servant, as I<br />
have had pity on you?”<br />
Those words from the Master in<br />
Jesus’ parable are spoken to you and<br />
to me. But they are also spoken today<br />
to our leaders in this country.<br />
This has been another frustrating<br />
summer, part of another frustrating<br />
year, for all of us who hope for<br />
immigration reform. People are being<br />
sent from the border all over the<br />
country, but there is no plan for them<br />
to be welcomed, no plan for them to<br />
be settled.<br />
We all are working together to<br />
welcome them and provide for their<br />
needs, but our leaders seem to be<br />
standing by, instead of coming together<br />
and working to fix our broken<br />
immigration system.<br />
So, Our Lord’s words today are<br />
addressed to everyone, including our<br />
political leaders: “Should you not<br />
have had pity on your fellow servant,<br />
as I have had pity on you?”<br />
We pray for our leaders, as we do<br />
every year in this Mass. And we<br />
commit ourselves once again this<br />
year to continuing to seek justice for<br />
immigrants.<br />
We ask the Lord today in this Eucharist<br />
to give us strength to overcome<br />
our frustrations at the situation of our<br />
brothers and sisters.<br />
Jesus tells Peter today in the Gospel<br />
that we need to forgive those who<br />
trespass against us “seventy times seven.”<br />
That means always. That means<br />
every time. Every offense.<br />
Jesus is telling us today in this parable<br />
that his mercy knows no limits.<br />
And neither can ours, my dear brothers<br />
and sisters. His mercy makes us<br />
one family. As our Father is merciful<br />
with us, we must be merciful with<br />
one another.<br />
Every time we draw near to the altar,<br />
we remember our Lord’s mercy. And<br />
we realize that we are like that servant<br />
in the parable today. We can never<br />
repay what we owe to Jesus.<br />
He loved us and he gave himself for<br />
us on the cross. And in his love, he is<br />
still giving his life for us in the bread<br />
and wine, in the sacrifice of every<br />
Mass.<br />
At this altar, Jesus is sharing his body<br />
and blood with us. That means that<br />
each one of us now has his divine life<br />
living within us. The life we live now<br />
is his life, not our own.<br />
Because we are the Lord’s, because<br />
we have his life within us, we have<br />
the power to love as he loves. We<br />
have the duty to forgive as he forgives.<br />
So, my dear brothers and sisters, let<br />
us thank him for saving us, for redeeming<br />
us by his love on the cross.<br />
Let us ask him to give us new eyes to<br />
see that every person is someone just<br />
like us, someone who has been shown<br />
mercy, forgiven a debt that we could<br />
never repay.<br />
Because we are the Lord’s, because we have his<br />
life within us, we have the power to love as he<br />
loves.<br />
And let us ask Our Lady of Guadalupe<br />
to wrap each of us, and all<br />
our loved ones, in the mantle of her<br />
tender care, especially those who are<br />
suffering the cruelty of our broken<br />
immigration system.<br />
May Our Lady help us to always be<br />
aware of her Son’s love for us. And<br />
may she help us to grow in our love<br />
for all our brothers and sisters!<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 3
WORLD<br />
■ Report: Christian women sexually<br />
enslaved in Mozambique<br />
Peace advocates are sounding the alarm about reports of jihadists in the African<br />
country of Mozambique forcing kidnapped Christian women to convert to<br />
Islam and sexually enslaving some of them.<br />
Johan Viljoen, director of the Denis Hurley Peace Institute, told news agency<br />
ACI Africa they had confirmed the reports sparked by leaked internal instructions<br />
to Islamic State members about what to do with enslaved women, which<br />
includes orders to kill those who refuse to convert.<br />
“We condemn any attempt to force people to change their religion,” Viljoen<br />
said in an interview. “We condemn the Islamists for forcing women into sex<br />
slavery. It is a reprehensible violation of human rights.”<br />
Some 4,000 people have been killed and hundreds of thousands displaced in<br />
the last four years from violence caused by the Islamic terrorists in the country’s<br />
northern Cabo Delgado province.<br />
■ Permanent diaconate coming to the Philippines<br />
Pope Francis approved the ability to ordain men to the permanent diaconate in<br />
the Philippines.<br />
The decision comes after the country’s bishops petitioned the Vatican, writing<br />
that permanent deacons would be “a good leaven for evangelization especially<br />
for those who live in the margins of society not only geographically but also<br />
socio-pastorally due to lack of priests.”<br />
While permanent deacons are common in the U.S. and Europe, when St.<br />
Pope Paul VI restored the role of permanent deacon in 1967, he established<br />
that local episcopal conferences would individually decide, with papal approval,<br />
whether to ordain permanent deacons.<br />
The other ‘Cristiano’ Ronaldo — Retired soccer star Ronaldo Nazario announced on social media that he’d<br />
been baptized Sept. 12 in an intimate ceremony at a church in São Paulo in his native Brazil. “The Christian faith<br />
has always been a fundamental part of my life since I was a child, although I had not yet been baptized. With the<br />
sacrament, I feel truly regenerated as a child of God — in a new, more conscious, deeper way.” | @RONALDO/<br />
INSTAGRAM<br />
Flames and smoke are seen at the site of the destroyed<br />
warehouse in Lviv, Ukraine, Sept. 19. | OSV NEWS/STATE<br />
EMERGENCY SERVICE OF UKRAINE VIA REUTERS<br />
■ Russian drone destroys<br />
Caritas warehouse in<br />
Ukraine<br />
A warehouse in Ukraine belonging<br />
to the Vatican’s aid agency, Caritas,<br />
was hit in a nighttime Russian drone<br />
strike.<br />
Some 300 tons of food, hygiene kits,<br />
generators, and clothes were destroyed<br />
in the Sept. 19 attack on the site in<br />
Lviv, which had been operating as<br />
a humanitarian aid hub for the past<br />
year-and-a-half. <strong>No</strong> Caritas employees<br />
were harmed.<br />
“They struck to destroy the possibility<br />
to help people who are suffering,” said<br />
Polish Cardinal Konrad Krajewski,<br />
prefect of the Dicastery for the Service<br />
of Charity. That same week Krajewski<br />
traveled to Lviv to personally deliver<br />
aid supplies.<br />
The day after the attack, Pope<br />
Francis sent a message to a Rome<br />
conference marking the 60th anniversary<br />
of St. Pope John XXIII’s landmark<br />
encyclical “Pacem in Terris” (“Peace<br />
on Earth”), in which he warned of the<br />
“increasingly urgent ethical problems<br />
raised by the use in contemporary<br />
warfare of so-called ‘conventional<br />
weapons,’ which should be used<br />
for defensive purposes only and not<br />
directed to civilian targets.”<br />
4 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
NATION<br />
The legacy of a ‘safe haven’ — Carol City, Florida firefighters Janice Matos, left, and Felicia McNair, right, flank<br />
Nick Silverio, founder of the nonprofit Gloria M. Silverio Foundation and its “A Safe Haven for Newborns” program,<br />
and Carol Gloria, the first of 381 Safe Haven babies, at the Miracle Theater in Coral Gables, Florida, Aug.<br />
24. The theater hosted the world premiere of the documentary “Uncle Nick,” about Silverio and his organization,<br />
which helps promote Florida’s Safe Haven laws allowing parents to surrender their unharmed newborns not<br />
more than a week old into the custody of personnel at fire stations and other facilities recognized as a safe haven.<br />
| OSV NEWS/LEIGH OSGOOD<br />
■ Ohio diocese announces gender norms for schools<br />
New guidelines for schools in the Diocese of Cleveland stress the need to be<br />
both welcoming and faithful to Church teaching when it comes to questions of<br />
gender identity.<br />
“Catholic institutions must accompany people experiencing gender dysphoria<br />
and be committed both to providing a loving environment and to upholding the<br />
truth of God’s created reality,” reads the introduction to the three-page document,<br />
which the diocesan website said formalizes existing practice.<br />
The policy creates parental notification requirements for students expressing<br />
“gender dysphoria or gender confusion,” and bars the use of “preferred pronouns”<br />
by students or staff. Dress codes and bathroom use must correspond with<br />
biological sex.<br />
■ Catholic experts<br />
denounce new embryo<br />
creation as ‘repugnant’<br />
Catholic experts have condemned the<br />
creation of the first “human embryo<br />
model” without using sperm or egg as<br />
“repugnant.”<br />
Scientists at the Weizmann Institute<br />
in Israel created the “embryo model”<br />
by mixing a specific ratio of stem<br />
cells and creating something akin to a<br />
human embryo at day 14. The creation<br />
had no ability to grow to maturity, even<br />
if transplanted into a uterus.<br />
“What we have here is still a [disabled]<br />
human embryo. Without<br />
parents,” wrote <strong>Angelus</strong> contributor<br />
and professor of medical humanities at<br />
Creighton University Charles Camosy<br />
in a joint op-ed with Loyola University<br />
Chicago professor Joe Vukov in a<br />
Sept. 18 Religion <strong>News</strong> Service op-ed.<br />
“Such embryos cannot [yet] develop<br />
into full-grown human beings.”<br />
Camosy and Vukov said such research<br />
furthers a transactional view of<br />
procreation.<br />
“We’ve had decades, actually, of privileged<br />
people demanding the ability to<br />
purchase ova and sperm based on the<br />
donor’s IQ, attractiveness, participation<br />
in varsity athletics, and more,” they<br />
wrote. “And of course our throwaway<br />
culture simply discards the prenatal<br />
human beings who don’t fit the market-based<br />
criteria.”<br />
■ Biographer: Late Chicago cardinal<br />
‘turned to the cross’ amid lifelong pain<br />
From left: Michael Heinlein, Archbishop José H. Gomez, Mary Hallan<br />
FioRito, former executive assistant for Cardinal George, and Stephen White<br />
from The Catholic Project. | OSV NEWS/RUI BARROS PHOTOGRAPHY<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez praised the late Cardinal Francis<br />
George of Chicago as “an amazing example of how to be a<br />
bishop” at a Washington, D.C. panel honoring his legacy.<br />
The panelists joining Archbishop Gomez — including<br />
Michael Heinlein, author of a new biography of George,<br />
“Glorifying Christ” — said the lifelong physical pain George<br />
endured after contracting polio at 13 helped bring him visibly<br />
closer to Christ.<br />
“I think his life truly was an offering, and that’s why he continued<br />
to push himself every day, because it wasn’t about him,” said Heinlein at the Sept. 14 event at the Catholic University<br />
of America. As a result of the polio, George “turned to the cross as a way of making sense of what was happening,” he said.<br />
Archbishop Gomez said he first met Cardinal George in the early 1990s when he was bishop of Yakima, Washington, which<br />
had a large Hispanic population, and were friends until George’s death in <strong>20</strong>15.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 5
LOCAL<br />
■ Pomona Catholic School kicks off 125th anniversary celebration with Mass<br />
Pomona Catholic School kicked off<br />
the first of its 125th anniversary celebrations<br />
by hosting a Mass celebrated<br />
by Archbishop José H. Gomez on<br />
Sept. 22. The Mass was attended by<br />
several priests, school staff, students,<br />
city leaders, alumni, and more, and<br />
was followed by a special breakfast for<br />
attendees.<br />
The Mass was part of a weekend<br />
celebration put on by the school to celebrate<br />
its 125 years, including a formal<br />
dinner at Pomona Valley Mining Co.<br />
on Sept. 23. Other anniversary events<br />
that will occur throughout the school<br />
year include Homecoming in <strong>October</strong>,<br />
a Friendsgiving & Food Drive in <strong>No</strong>vember,<br />
and a Casino Night fundraiser<br />
in February.<br />
Pomona Catholic School is an allgirls<br />
private Catholic high school, plus<br />
a coed middle school that boasts a 100% college acceptance rate for its students. The school opened in 1898 as Academy of<br />
the Holy Names then later renamed as St. Joseph High School in 1948. It became an all-girls high school in 1962 and added<br />
coed middle school in <strong>20</strong>09.<br />
Greetings from the gala — Father Rodel Balagtas, center, pastor at Incarnation Church in Glendale, poses with<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez, left, and Father Marco Durazo, right, rector and president of St. John’s Seminary.<br />
Balagtas was one of the awardees at the <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> St. John’s Seminary gala, held at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the<br />
Angels’ outdoor plaza on Sept. 16. Other honorees at the event included Msgr. John Moretta, pastor at Resurrection<br />
Church in Boyle Heights, Diocese of Orange Auxiliary Bishop Timothy Freyer, and Catholic Community Foundation<br />
LA President and Executive Director Kathy Anderson. | BELLE N’ BEAU PHOTOGRAPHY<br />
Archbishop José H. Gomez poses with clergy, students, and staff at Pomona Catholic School — the oldest in the LA<br />
Archdiocese — after celebrating Mass in honor of the school’s 125th anniversary. | POMONA CATHOLIC SCHOOL<br />
■ <strong>News</strong>om vetoes<br />
‘gender affirmation’ bill<br />
California Gov. Gavin <strong>News</strong>om issued<br />
a surprise veto of a law that would<br />
have considered parents’ affirmation<br />
of a child’s “gender identity or gender<br />
expression” in custody decisions.<br />
<strong>News</strong>om, a Democrat, was widely expected<br />
to sign Assembly Bill 957, which<br />
passed the Assembly 57-16 earlier this<br />
month.<br />
<strong>News</strong>om said he was concerned that<br />
enacting the law would be an attempt<br />
“to dictate — in prescriptive terms that<br />
single out one characteristic — legal<br />
standards for the Judicial branch to<br />
apply.”<br />
“Other-minded elected officials, in<br />
California and other states, could very<br />
well use this strategy to diminish the<br />
civil rights of vulnerable communities,”<br />
the governor explained, adding that<br />
courts are already required to consider<br />
parental “affirmation of the child’s<br />
gender identity” in such decisions.<br />
The California Catholic Conference,<br />
the public policy arm of the state’s<br />
bishops, had opposed the bill.<br />
6 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
V<br />
IN OTHER WORDS...<br />
Letters to the Editor<br />
The real Michael Ladisa<br />
The article in the Sept. 22 issue on chaplain Michael Ladisa gave light<br />
to what I consider the “whole Michael.” We got to learn more about<br />
him not only as a chaplain but also as a husband, father, grandfather, and friend.<br />
We learned things about Michael that, because of his humility, he never shared<br />
with us, his fellow chaplains. Like how he rented a storage unit to keep reading<br />
materials and clothes for those being released from the jail, or how he and Monica<br />
took someone in that needed a home.<br />
I am sure there are many more good things we will never know about Michael,<br />
but it’s OK because he left his mark everywhere he went.<br />
You brought out the real Michael, the sensitive Michael, the dedicated Michael,<br />
and the committed Michael in bringing Christ’s light to every individual he met.<br />
I was very moved with the article that I printed out several copies to pass out to<br />
anyone, not just chaplains. I believe his life needs to be shared and that is what<br />
you did for us.<br />
— Eve Ortiz, senior Catholic chaplain, Century Regional Detention Facility,<br />
Lynwood<br />
A lesson learned for the synod?<br />
In his Sept. 11 column on <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com, “On the road to synodality,”<br />
Russell Shaw wrote that the minimum requirement for the Synod of Synodality<br />
should be “letting people say what they think rather than what someone else<br />
would like them to think.”<br />
His comment encourages me to say that had the Church leadership explored,<br />
incorporated, and yes, loved, the documents of the Second Vatican Council, then<br />
priestly vocations, religious communities, Mass attendance, belief in the Real<br />
Presence, transmitting faith to the youth, etc. would be a vibrant reality today.<br />
— Pat Esseff, Camarillo<br />
Y<br />
Continue the conversation! To submit a letter to the editor, visit <strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/Letters-To-The-Editor<br />
and use our online form or send an email to editorial@angelusnews.com. Please limit to 300 words. Letters<br />
may be edited for style, brevity, and clarity.<br />
Saints on the move<br />
The Knights of Columbus process with a stole belonging to St. Junípero Serra at the start of the annual Mass<br />
in Recognition of All Immigrants on Sunday, Sept. 17, at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels. Relics<br />
belonging to St. Frances Xavier Cabrini, St. John Baptist Scalabrini, and St. Toribio Romo were also on display<br />
following the Mass. | JOHN RUEDA/ADLA<br />
View more photos<br />
from this gallery at<br />
<strong>Angelus</strong><strong>News</strong>.com/photos-videos<br />
Do you have photos or a story from your parish that you’d<br />
like to share? Please send to editorial @angelusnews.com.<br />
“If you want immortality,<br />
you should go to a church.”<br />
~ Dr. Eric Verdin, CEO of the Buck Institute for<br />
Research on Aging, in a Sept. <strong>20</strong> Time article on a<br />
46-year-old tech entrepreneur spending millions<br />
trying to live forever.<br />
“We should start asking<br />
why so many of our<br />
religious stories are also<br />
horror stories.”<br />
~ Brandon R. Grafius, associate professor of biblical<br />
studies at Ecumenical Theological Seminary, in a<br />
Sept. <strong>20</strong> Christian Century commentary on similar<br />
themes between horror and religion.<br />
“Luckily, the only geese I<br />
have to deal with now are<br />
alive.”<br />
~ LA City Councilman Hugo Soto-Martinez, in<br />
a Sept. 22 Los Angeles Times article on geese<br />
replacing a homeless encampment at Echo Park<br />
Lake.<br />
“It’s like going on the plane,<br />
but like a luxury plane.”<br />
~ Louis Lappe, El Segundo Little League World Series<br />
champion, in a Sept. 22 Daily Breeze article on the<br />
team getting a ride aboard the Goodyear blimp.<br />
“What we have is faith built<br />
on persecution. Everything<br />
I experienced while in<br />
captivity is what priesthood<br />
entails.”<br />
~ Father Paul Sanogo, a priest of the Missionaries<br />
of Africa, after he and a seminarian were released<br />
by kidnappers in Nigeria following three weeks of<br />
captivity.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 7
IN EXILE<br />
FATHER RONALD ROLHEISER, OMI<br />
Oblate of Mary Immaculate Father<br />
Ronald Rolheiser is a spiritual<br />
writer; ronrolheiser.com<br />
A single line says it all!<br />
have made us for yourself,<br />
Lord, and our hearts are restless<br />
until they rest in you.” “You<br />
<strong>No</strong> single line, outside of Scripture,<br />
has ever spoken to me as powerfully,<br />
as persistently, and as hauntingly,<br />
as that line from St. Augustine. In<br />
essence, it’s Augustine’s life story —<br />
and the story of each of our own lives<br />
as well.<br />
As I read and study, I am often struck<br />
by a powerful line in some author<br />
which I immediately underline and<br />
copy. I have a whole booklet of quotes<br />
from Shakespeare, Aristotle, Plato,<br />
Aquinas, Teilhard, Einstein, Albert<br />
Camus, Steve Hawkings, Doris Lessing,<br />
Milan Kundera, John Steinbeck,<br />
Karl Rahner, John of the Cross, Ruth<br />
Burrows, James Hillman, Anne Frank,<br />
and Ivan Illich, among others. Yet,<br />
Augustine’s haunting line stands out<br />
among all these.<br />
What he asserts is that there is an<br />
incurable restlessness inside each of<br />
us that keeps us perpetually dis-eased.<br />
I have always felt this strongly in my<br />
own life and, while still in my <strong>20</strong>s,<br />
wrote a book, “The Restless Heart,” in<br />
which I tried to articulate a spirituality<br />
for the restless (and perhaps mostly for<br />
myself) on the basis of this line from<br />
Augustine. Through the years, I have<br />
kept my eyes open for comparable and<br />
complementary expressions of Augustine’s<br />
famous axiom. Here are some:<br />
Karl Rahner, a renowned theologian<br />
of the late <strong>20</strong>th century, in writing<br />
to a friend who feared he was missing<br />
out on too much in life, offered<br />
this counsel: “In the torment of the<br />
insufficiency of everything attainable,<br />
we learn that in this life there is no<br />
finished symphony.”<br />
The biblical author, Qoheleth,<br />
expresses it this way. In a passage familiar<br />
to most of us (“there is a season<br />
for everything”) he lays out for us the<br />
rhythm of nature as God set it up. He<br />
tells us there’s a beautiful rhythm to<br />
time and nature and that everything<br />
has its proper time and place. However,<br />
he then ends with this stunning<br />
statement: “God has made everything<br />
beautiful in its own time, but God has<br />
put timelessness into the human heart<br />
so that we are out of sync with time<br />
and the seasons from the beginning to<br />
the end.” We never peacefully fit into<br />
the rhythm of things because something<br />
inside us is outside of time.<br />
And who can forget the haunting<br />
words of Anne Frank, writing as a<br />
teenager locked away in an attic,<br />
hiding from the Nazis, jumping out<br />
of her skin with the restlessness of an<br />
adolescent and the anxiety of an artist,<br />
sharing that she simply can never be<br />
fully in the moment because, “I want<br />
to be everywhere all at the same time.”<br />
Doris Lessing, the British novelist,<br />
asserts that inside each of us there’s<br />
a powerful, relentless energy (“1,000<br />
volts”), which keeps us perpetually<br />
dis-eased. Writing outside of a faith<br />
perspective, she asks, what is this energy<br />
for? Her answer: For everything and<br />
for anything — creativity, love, sex,<br />
justice. <strong>No</strong>bel Prize-winning writer,<br />
Albert Camus, also writing outside of<br />
any faith perspective, had this interesting<br />
way of understanding the human<br />
spirit. He compared being inside<br />
human nature to being a prisoner<br />
trapped inside a medieval prison. Medieval<br />
prisons were designed to break<br />
the prisoner’s spirit by putting him in<br />
a room too small for him to ever fully<br />
stand up or to ever fully stretch out.<br />
The ceiling was too low and the room<br />
was too narrow. The intent was that<br />
eventually this would break a prisoner’s<br />
spirit. For Camus, that’s how we<br />
experience ourselves inside our own<br />
nature. The world is simply too small<br />
for us to ever really stand up or to ever<br />
really stretch out, and this wears away<br />
on our spirit.<br />
These are some poignant expressions<br />
of this dis-ease, but there are expressions<br />
of it everywhere. Hinduism<br />
speaks of a certain “nostalgia for the<br />
infinite” inside us; Plato speaks of a<br />
“divine madness” at the center of the<br />
soul; Shakespeare speaks of our “immortal<br />
longings.” Ruth Burrows opens<br />
her autobiography by confessing that<br />
she was “born with a pathological<br />
complexity which has made her<br />
life a struggle.” James Hillman, in a<br />
brilliant book, “Suicide and the Soul,”<br />
submits that most suicides occur<br />
because the soul is not being heard<br />
and consequently kills the body. And<br />
Philip Roth speaks of “the blizzard of<br />
details that constitute the confusion of<br />
human biography.”<br />
Literature, philosophy, poetry, art,<br />
psychology, biography, theology, and<br />
spirituality are replete with expressions<br />
of this insatiability inside the human<br />
soul, which ultimately cannot come to<br />
full peace with anything in this world.<br />
But this is as it should be. For Augustine,<br />
writing some 1,700 years ago,<br />
this restlessness, this timelessness, this<br />
homesickness, this divine madness,<br />
these 1,000 volts of energy inside us,<br />
this pathological complexity, and this<br />
confusion of human biography that<br />
keeps us perpetually restless, is at the<br />
end of the day our greatest attribute;<br />
it’s God’s gift to us of immortality and<br />
divinity as a constitutive part of our<br />
soul.<br />
8 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
PRODUCTS<br />
OF OUR TIMES<br />
New research suggests the<br />
‘generation wars’ are real — and<br />
more serious than we think. Is the<br />
Church paying attention?<br />
BY ELISE ITALIANO URENECK /<br />
ART BY JACOB POPCAK<br />
Boomers. Millennials. Generation<br />
Z. The names used to<br />
classify some of the major age<br />
groups of Americans come up in academic<br />
studies, social media posts, and<br />
everyday conversations — but also in<br />
talk of “generation wars” that try to<br />
explain certain divisions in society.<br />
To some, the differences between<br />
those categories — and the conflicts<br />
they provoke — are overblown. But to<br />
people like psychologist Jean Twenge,<br />
they define who we are more than we<br />
think.<br />
In fact, Twenge — best known for<br />
her work helping the public understand<br />
the correlation between screen<br />
use and mental health issues in<br />
younger Americans — has recently<br />
come to a bold conclusion.<br />
“When you were born has a larger<br />
effect on your personality and attitudes<br />
than the family you were raised<br />
in does,” writes Twenge, professor<br />
of Psychology at San Diego State<br />
University, in her latest book, “Generations:<br />
The Real Differences Between<br />
Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Boomers,<br />
and Silents—and What They Mean<br />
for America’s Future” (Atria Books,<br />
$32.50).<br />
Why is that so? Twenge believes that<br />
the technological developments of the<br />
last century have shaped recent generations<br />
more than cultural or political<br />
events, contradicting a popular view<br />
among scholars.<br />
On one hand, Twenge argues, these<br />
advancements have led to increased<br />
individualism and a slower life strategy:<br />
Technology has made it possible<br />
for people to focus more on their<br />
freedoms, choices, and identity.<br />
At the same time, it’s led people to<br />
have fewer children, usually later in<br />
life, with the expectation that they<br />
will grow up slowly. In other words,<br />
things like biology and mortality have<br />
become less formidable obstacles to<br />
shaping one’s values and priorities.<br />
From a religious standpoint, the data<br />
might seem threatening: Technology<br />
now has answers for human needs that<br />
people once turned to God for, like<br />
health or financial security.<br />
But the data suggests that today,<br />
mental health, materialism, and<br />
marriage are Americans’ greatest pain<br />
points, and that the advances of the<br />
last 100 years have increased that<br />
pain, rather than alleviated it.<br />
For people of faith — especially<br />
Catholics — alarmed about their<br />
well-being and future generations, can<br />
faith succeed where technology has<br />
failed?<br />
The big picture<br />
Take, for example, the baby boomers,<br />
the children of parents who lived<br />
through World War II at a young age<br />
and who, growing up in an age of remarkable<br />
technological progress, have<br />
enjoyed a quality of life never before<br />
seen in any prior generation.<br />
And yet, Twenge claims, that “for<br />
their entire life cycle, boomers (born<br />
1946-1964) have been less happy,<br />
10 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
have had more days of poor mental<br />
health, were more likely to suffer from<br />
mental distress, and were more likely<br />
to be depressed than “Silents” (the<br />
generation before them the same age).<br />
Between <strong>20</strong>00 and <strong>20</strong>19, the rate of<br />
boomer “deaths of despair” skyrocketed:<br />
fatal drug overdoses increased<br />
by a factor of 10, deaths from alcohol<br />
abuse rose by 42%, and suicide by<br />
60%.<br />
Boomers’ struggles could be related<br />
to economic issues, like the disappearance<br />
of manufacturing jobs, the rise<br />
of income inequality, and the expectation<br />
that jobs should be personally<br />
fulfilling, Twenge acknowledges in<br />
“Generations.”<br />
But another theory is possible. While<br />
mid-<strong>20</strong>th-century innovations like<br />
television and birth control opened<br />
up new possibilities and furthered<br />
the civil rights movements, they also<br />
ushered in a type of individualism<br />
which Twenge says brought “less<br />
stable relationships and the tendency<br />
to expect that self-fulfillment [would]<br />
bring happiness.”<br />
In short, boomers’ sharp inward turn<br />
has left them feeling alone and unsatisfied,<br />
which also extended into their<br />
married lives.<br />
Twenge notes that boomers expected<br />
marriage “to go beyond duty to satisfy<br />
the highest of expectations for sexual<br />
pleasure as well as companionship.”<br />
For that reason and others, they<br />
divorced in droves. The only reason<br />
the divorce rate has slowed since is<br />
because fewer people are getting<br />
married in the first place.<br />
Today, more than twice as many<br />
boomers are divorced than their<br />
parents were at their same age.<br />
Because boomer men were less likely<br />
to remarry than both their female<br />
peers and their parents, the number of<br />
older men living alone has increased.<br />
This group plays a major role in the<br />
“epidemic of loneliness,” which now<br />
plagues the U.S.<br />
How are younger generations faring?<br />
While Generation Xers (born 1965-<br />
1979) have been characterized as<br />
cynical, pessimistic, depressed, and<br />
distrustful, they have demonstrated<br />
one sign of hope, which is a higher<br />
birthrate than their parents’: despite<br />
marrying later than any previous generation,<br />
having premarital sex earlier,<br />
and uncoupling childbearing from<br />
marriage, Gen X women had between<br />
three and four children on average.<br />
But their personal lives have not<br />
always been focused on others. “Since<br />
they were small children, Gen X<br />
learned from their Silent and Boomer<br />
parents that the self came first,”<br />
Twenge writes.<br />
As the first generation to grow up<br />
with television and reach young adulthood<br />
during a period of economic<br />
growth, they were influenced by materialism<br />
in a way previous generations<br />
had not been.<br />
Twenge notes that<br />
college-educated<br />
Gen Xers were<br />
more likely to pick<br />
career paths based<br />
on extrinsic rather<br />
than intrinsic values.<br />
In other words, they<br />
were motivated<br />
more by making a<br />
lot of money than<br />
“developing a meaningful<br />
philosophy of<br />
life.”<br />
While their rates<br />
of adult suicide are<br />
lower than boomers,<br />
the premium they’ve<br />
put on material<br />
goods and wealth<br />
has yielded high<br />
levels of self-reported<br />
depression and<br />
dissatisfaction.<br />
The next cohort,<br />
millennials (born<br />
1980-1994), were<br />
very happy as children<br />
and teens but<br />
report high levels of<br />
depression as adults.<br />
“Born in an era of<br />
reliable birth control<br />
and legal abortions,<br />
to mostly Boomer<br />
parents, Millennials were the most<br />
planned and wanted generation in<br />
American history to date,” Twenge<br />
writes. “Raised in a time of optimism,<br />
they had high expectations for themselves.”<br />
Their development from childhood<br />
to adolescence was marked by<br />
economic growth and a focus on their<br />
enrichment and self-esteem. Their<br />
maturation also coincided with the<br />
<strong>No</strong>w more than ever, the Catholic Church has<br />
social science on its side to back up what it has<br />
long preached.<br />
adoption of the internet, the move to<br />
online shopping, and the proliferation<br />
of social media and streaming.<br />
While millennials were the most<br />
educated in American history, two<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 11
downstream effects of all<br />
that schooling were delayed<br />
marriage and childbearing.<br />
Millennials report that they<br />
are waiting to marry and<br />
have a family until they<br />
have the resources they feel<br />
they need to support them.<br />
Paying off school debt,<br />
building financial stability,<br />
and acquiring assets have<br />
become precursors to settling<br />
down.<br />
They also report that their<br />
desire for independence,<br />
leisure time, and the ability<br />
to focus on themselves is<br />
preeminent. Children are<br />
viewed as competition for<br />
fulfillment, rather than a<br />
source of it.<br />
Twenge notes that even<br />
cohabitation among<br />
millennials is down, and<br />
that today, 1 in 5 millennial<br />
women will likely not<br />
marry, with that number<br />
inching closer to 1 in 4.<br />
While most millennials<br />
escaped adolescence without<br />
social media, the consumerism it<br />
urges plagues their adulthood: “Social<br />
media and TV showcase those at the<br />
very top of the income distribution<br />
(or at least those who appear to be at<br />
the very top), giving a skewed view<br />
of others’ income,” Twenge writes.<br />
“The result is called relative deprivation<br />
— a feeling you’re not doing well<br />
compared to others even if, objectively,<br />
you are.”<br />
A lonelier future<br />
Finally, social scientists are beginning<br />
to consider millennials’ depression<br />
in light of their disaffiliation from<br />
religion. Religious practice has been<br />
linked to higher rates of happiness,<br />
given that it provides a sense of meaning<br />
and belonging.<br />
While many hoped millennials<br />
would return to religious practice<br />
when they began raising children,<br />
they have not. Sadly, many are discovering<br />
that friends and coworkers<br />
do not provide the same loyalty and<br />
stability that marriage and religious<br />
communities do.<br />
Isolated and stuck on an earning-potential<br />
treadmill, millennials are<br />
running out of steam.<br />
The final generation that Twenge<br />
examines in depth, Generation Z<br />
(born 1995-<strong>20</strong>12), stands downstream<br />
of all of these generational changes<br />
that came before them. Their saturation<br />
by technology and individualism<br />
is manifesting itself in previously<br />
unimaginable ways.<br />
Twenge says that Gen Z’s generational<br />
personality is best understood<br />
by the common parlance they use —<br />
language which is “tech-infused with<br />
notes of gender fluidity and anxiety.”<br />
Twenge said that most Gen Zers she<br />
interviewed for her previous book in<br />
<strong>20</strong>15 were skeptical about transgenderism,<br />
chalking the burgeoning idea<br />
up to confusion. But eight years later,<br />
Gen Z has embraced a new philosophy<br />
about gender — and<br />
has coaxed older generations<br />
along with them.<br />
As of <strong>20</strong>22, the number of<br />
Gen Z Americans identifying<br />
as either transgender or<br />
nonbinary was more than<br />
the population of Phoenix.<br />
Like other social scientists,<br />
Twenge is confident this is<br />
not a result of greater social<br />
acceptance of a naturally<br />
occurring phenomenon,<br />
but part of a generational<br />
shift marked by “rising<br />
individualism.”<br />
“If people are all unique<br />
individuals, then it follows<br />
that gender identity<br />
is a choice — and people<br />
should not be restricted to<br />
two choices,” Twenge says.<br />
“People should be able to<br />
decide which gender group<br />
they identify with — or<br />
even reject the notion of a<br />
gender binary completely.”<br />
Twenge says that the<br />
increase in transgender<br />
identification between <strong>20</strong><strong>20</strong><br />
and <strong>20</strong>21 alone “suggests the change<br />
is accelerating.”<br />
Despite rising numbers of Gen Zers<br />
identifying as lesbian, gay, or bisexual<br />
(including preteens), Gen Z is significantly<br />
less sexually active than older<br />
generations. While the prevalence of<br />
pornography could have a role in this,<br />
Twenge thinks the shift from in-person<br />
socialization to online interaction<br />
could also have a big role.<br />
While Twenge’s previous research<br />
delved into the data on how smartphone<br />
and screen time has left Gen Z<br />
Data suggests that mental health, materialism,<br />
and marriage are Americans’ greatest pain points,<br />
and that the advances of the last 100 years have<br />
increased that pain, not alleviated it.<br />
delaying adulthood, concerned with<br />
physical and emotional safety (including<br />
restricting speech which they find<br />
offensive), and underprepared to read<br />
social or emotional cues, social scientists<br />
now have the data to connect<br />
12 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
screen time to skyrocketing rates of<br />
depression, anxiety, and suicide.<br />
Gen Z’s abysmal mental health has<br />
been making headlines since before<br />
the COVID-19 pandemic. Most<br />
alarming to social scientists and others<br />
is their rate of self-harm and hospitalization,<br />
including preteens.<br />
While Gen Z is gaining attention for<br />
their activism around issues like gun<br />
violence, climate change, and racism,<br />
Twenge isn’t sure they’re capable of<br />
provoking vast social change like the<br />
boomers did. It’s possible that their<br />
pessimism, nihilism, and general<br />
hopelessness about their prospects in<br />
the world may dampen their effectiveness<br />
and stamina.<br />
As a generation that is reporting the<br />
highest levels of disinterest in marriage<br />
and childbearing and the lowest<br />
recorded rates for both, what comes<br />
after them is anyone’s guess.<br />
A ‘come to Jesus’ moment?<br />
Of what use is this research to the<br />
Catholic Church, which is experiencing<br />
a generational crisis of its own<br />
right now?<br />
For the last two years, Pope Francis<br />
has overseen the ongoing “Synod on<br />
Synodality” — a worldwide listening<br />
exercise aimed at fostering a<br />
more collaborative approach<br />
to church governance and<br />
evangelization between clergy<br />
and laity. This <strong>October</strong>,<br />
bishops and other synod<br />
delegates gather for a monthlong,<br />
closed-door meeting<br />
in Rome to be followed by a<br />
final one next <strong>October</strong> that<br />
will put concrete proposals<br />
before the pope. Francis is<br />
expected to respond with an<br />
apostolic exhortation sometime<br />
thereafter.<br />
However, the input from<br />
the synodal process so far<br />
has been largely subjective.<br />
Could it also benefit from<br />
acknowledging findings like<br />
Twenge’s, which offer an<br />
objective look at the generational<br />
trends shaping<br />
society and might illuminate<br />
opportunities and sharpen<br />
priorities for evangelization<br />
efforts?<br />
The Church has long promoted the<br />
antidotes to the worrisome trends<br />
Twenge outlines: It is better to give<br />
than to receive; you should love your<br />
neighbor as yourself; a man should<br />
leave his father and mother and cling<br />
to his wife — and they should be<br />
fruitful and multiply. A meaningful,<br />
happy life is one which is given away<br />
in service to one’s family or vocation<br />
and typically oriented toward eternal<br />
salvation.<br />
<strong>No</strong>w more than ever, the Catholic<br />
Church has social science on its side<br />
to back up what it has long preached.<br />
When addressing the mental health<br />
crisis, clergy and laity should boldly<br />
unmask the false promises of individualism.<br />
While Catholics should<br />
champion civil rights and promote<br />
and protect the dignity of the human<br />
person, attention must also be paid to<br />
the communal aspect of the human<br />
experience. Parishes, schools, and social<br />
services should lean into the work<br />
of developing communities in which<br />
people know one another’s names and<br />
needs.<br />
Psychologists are better understanding<br />
how our culture’s emphasis on<br />
constant self-reflection — how we are<br />
feeling, what people think of us, who<br />
we are and how we present ourselves<br />
— is directly related to increased rates<br />
of anxiety and depression. The loop of<br />
self-analysis and need for feedback is<br />
taking a toll.<br />
“Happiness scholar” Arthur Brooks<br />
of Harvard University has suggested<br />
removing or limiting the literal and<br />
figurative mirrors in our lives, including<br />
social media, to help get our<br />
mind off of ourselves and onto others.<br />
Besides being a spiritual truism, thinking<br />
about other people and outside of<br />
ourselves is also a mood lifter.<br />
As for materialism, the Church has<br />
no shortage of wisdom and saintly examples<br />
which reveal how detachment<br />
from wealth, sharing with the less<br />
advantaged, and prioritizing eternal<br />
matters produce happier and healthier<br />
individuals and societies.<br />
But perhaps most importantly,<br />
research like Twenge’s confirms the<br />
need for Catholic laity — and clergy<br />
— to encourage young men and<br />
women to get married, and find ways<br />
to better accompany them throughout<br />
their married life.<br />
Studies led by Harvard epidemiologist<br />
Tyler J. VanderWeele have found<br />
that marriage yields lower levels of<br />
loneliness, higher levels of meaning<br />
and purpose, higher levels of<br />
affective happiness, and lower<br />
mortality — all reminders<br />
that encouraging and accompanying<br />
men and women in<br />
married life is some of the<br />
Church’s most important<br />
work ahead.<br />
If secular experts like<br />
Twenge are right, and things<br />
like our birth year and what<br />
devices we use shape who we<br />
are, then their findings also<br />
prove that advances in technology<br />
and personal freedom<br />
haven’t made us happier.<br />
For an institution that’s<br />
been helping people find<br />
the meaning of life for 2,000<br />
years, that suggests our<br />
21st-century “generation<br />
wars” could prove to be the<br />
ultimate blessing in disguise.<br />
Elise Italiano Ureneck is a<br />
contributor to <strong>Angelus</strong> writing<br />
from Rhode Island.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 13
RYAN'S SACRIFICE<br />
Together with his family, parishioners<br />
at the Santa Clarita parish where<br />
Deputy Ryan Clinkunbroomer grew<br />
up are grieving his murder.<br />
BY STEVE LOWERY<br />
There are few places where the<br />
pain and sadness that followed<br />
the Sept. 16 murder of Deputy<br />
Sheriff Ryan Clinkunbroomer were<br />
felt harder than at St. Kateri Tekakwitha<br />
Church in Santa Clarita.<br />
It was here that Clinkunbroomer received<br />
his sacraments, like first Communion<br />
and confirmation, and began<br />
a life dedicated to serving others.<br />
“It really strikes home here and it<br />
hurts,” Father Vaughn Winters, pastor<br />
at St. Kateri, told <strong>Angelus</strong>. “We have<br />
so many law enforcement and firefighters<br />
in the parish, this has affected<br />
so many of them. A lot of people know<br />
Ryan and remember him. The news<br />
rippled through our community, it’s so<br />
Deputy Ryan Clinkunbroomer grew<br />
up at St. Kateri Tekakwitha Church<br />
in Santa Clarita. | COURTESY LA<br />
COUNTY SHERIFF’S DEPARTMENT<br />
shocking and senseless.”<br />
Clinkunbroomer’s name made<br />
national headlines after he was shot<br />
and killed in his patrol car just steps<br />
from the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s<br />
headquarters in Palmdale the evening<br />
of Sept. 16. A few days later, 29-yearold<br />
Kevin Salazar of Palmdale was<br />
arrested and charged in the murder.<br />
The sense of anguish has only deepened<br />
after reports emerged that just<br />
a few days before his death, Clinkunbroomer<br />
had become engaged to Brittany<br />
Lindsey and was excited about<br />
the life they would make together.<br />
Just 30 years old, he had devoted<br />
virtually all of his adult life to the<br />
service of others. He became a training<br />
officer at a young age, a valued<br />
position requiring rigorous testing and<br />
a high level of expertise. He has been<br />
described by colleagues as a “deputy’s<br />
deputy.”<br />
His proficiency and devotion to his<br />
profession and those it served grew<br />
from the young man who attended<br />
St. Kateri, who not only learned<br />
lessons about service and family but<br />
lived them. He was a third generation<br />
deputy; both his father, Mike, and<br />
his father’s father had been deputies<br />
themselves.<br />
When the family released its first<br />
statement about Clinkunbroomer’s<br />
murder — read by Sheriff Robert<br />
Luna — they spoke not only of their<br />
son’s sacrifice but referred to his colleagues<br />
in terms of family.<br />
“Our son Ryan was a dedicated,<br />
hardworking deputy sheriff who<br />
enjoyed working here at the Palmdale<br />
station. He was proud to work alongside<br />
his partners that he considered<br />
brothers and sisters, as he sacrificed<br />
daily to better the community that<br />
he served. Ryan made the ultimate<br />
sacrifice in doing so.”<br />
That someone who seemed to embody<br />
that which is the best in us could<br />
be taken so horribly quickly fueled the<br />
considerable grief around his passing,<br />
certainly at St. Kateri’s.<br />
Established 25 years ago, Winters<br />
said St. Kateri was and remains<br />
a “young, vibrant community.”<br />
Clinkunbroomer’s grandparents, Al<br />
and Mary Lou Etzel, were founding<br />
members of the faith community.<br />
They spoke with Winters just days<br />
after their grandson’s murder. Winters<br />
described their faith as “very strong.<br />
They’re reaching out in faith for<br />
something that really doesn’t have any<br />
explanation, other than human sin.<br />
They’re really leaning on the Lord,<br />
really exhibiting their faith.”<br />
Clinkunbroomer’s funeral Mass<br />
will be held the morning of Thursday,<br />
Oct. 5, at the Cathedral of Our<br />
Lady of the Angels, with hundreds of<br />
fellow deputies, family members, and<br />
well-wishers expected.<br />
In the meantime, it has fallen to<br />
14 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
Winters to help bring consolation to a<br />
grieving community.<br />
“This one action has caused so much<br />
destruction, left such a gaping hole<br />
that affects the whole community,” he<br />
said.<br />
In Santa Clarita that included the<br />
likes of Alison Hunsaker, who taught<br />
at West Ranch High School where<br />
Clinkunbroomer ran track and cross<br />
country and participated in several<br />
extracurricular activities. Hunsaker,<br />
who was Clinkunbroomer's English<br />
teacher, told NBC4 <strong>News</strong> that she<br />
“so wants his mom to know about<br />
the people he touched. His life is still<br />
resonating with them. Just about the<br />
kindness, the friendship, and the comradery<br />
that he shared with so many<br />
people. When we talk about the kind<br />
of law enforcement officers we want<br />
in our country, Ryan was that guy.”<br />
Winters acknowledged a tragedy like<br />
this one can cause some to not only<br />
question God but, “push away in anger.”<br />
He knows that he will be talking<br />
to many parishioners struggling with<br />
Clinkunbroomer’s passing, struggling<br />
to make sense out of the senseless.<br />
“For someone suffering through this,<br />
I’ll want them to know it’s OK to be<br />
angry, in fact, it’s understandable,”<br />
Winters said. “But it’s important not<br />
to nurture it, not allow it to take us<br />
over. Pushing God away is not going<br />
to help. This is why we have faith, for<br />
moments like this.”<br />
A fund to assist the family of Sheriff’s<br />
Deputy Ryan Clinkunbroomer was set<br />
up by the Association for Los Angeles<br />
Deputy Sheriffs. To learn more, visit<br />
alads.org/donate<br />
Steve Lowery is a veteran journalist<br />
who has written for the Los Angeles<br />
Times, the Los Angeles Daily <strong>News</strong>,<br />
the Press-Telegram, New Times LA,<br />
the District, Long Beach Post, and OC<br />
Weekly.<br />
The family of slain Deputy Ryan Clinkunbroomer stands behind Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón<br />
at a Sept. <strong>20</strong> press conference announcing the arrest of murder suspect Kevin Salazar. | COURTESY LA COUNTY<br />
DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 15
THE RIGHT RECEPTION<br />
Who was that man surprising a newly arrived<br />
migrant mom and her newborn? Just an LA<br />
priest on his day off.<br />
Father Filiberto Cortez, associate pastor at<br />
St. Columbkille and Nativity Churches in<br />
South LA, is among a group of LA priests<br />
who have been welcoming migrants bused<br />
from Texas this summer. | JOHN RUEDA<br />
BY STEVE LOWERY<br />
As the passengers of bus nine<br />
from Brownsville disembarked<br />
at St. Anthony’s Croatian<br />
Catholic Church in Chinatown, there<br />
was the usual mix of emotions; some<br />
happy to see relatives there to meet<br />
them, others confused or suspicious of<br />
the strangers moving toward them.<br />
That was understandable, since it<br />
was strangers who placed them on the<br />
bus in Texas on Aug. <strong>20</strong>, sending them<br />
on a near 30-hour trek to Los Angeles<br />
where they arrived on Aug. 21.<br />
But the people who met them at St.<br />
Anthony’s — mostly affiliated with either<br />
the Archdiocese of Los Angeles or<br />
the Coalition for Humane Immigrant<br />
Rights (CHIRLA) — were welcoming,<br />
offering food, clothing and, in one<br />
case, balloons and flowers.<br />
The bearer of both balloons and<br />
flowers was Filiberto Cortez, or rather,<br />
Father Filiberto Cortez, a fact lost on<br />
many that evening. After all, that particular<br />
day was the priest’s day off, and<br />
he wasn’t wearing his usual Roman<br />
collar. Instead, “Father Fili,” as he’s<br />
known among his brother priests, was<br />
wearing his civilian duds and looked<br />
very much like “a guy who was going<br />
to a Dodger game,” recalled Yannina<br />
Diaz of the archdiocese’s media<br />
relations team.<br />
When Isaac Cuevas, of the archdiocese’s<br />
Office of Life, Justice, and<br />
Peace saw “a youngish, fit guy with<br />
a good head of hair,” moving single-mindedly<br />
toward a young mother<br />
and her 3-week-old infant daughter,<br />
he assumed he was either husband or<br />
fiancé making “a grand gesture.”<br />
Diaz said she and others around her<br />
had already begun to speculate what<br />
was about to happen.<br />
“I mean, he’s holding this ginormous<br />
balloon in the shape of a heart that<br />
says ‘I Love You’ along with flowers.<br />
We were all looking and saying, ‘Are<br />
16 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
we going to have a proposal?’ ”<br />
What was happening, of course, is<br />
what Cuevas called “a sweet act of<br />
simple kindness.” Cortez, an associate<br />
pastor at St. Columbkille and Nativity<br />
Churches in South LA, said that<br />
when he found out there was a young<br />
mother traveling alone with such a<br />
young infant, he felt compelled to do<br />
something to “let her know we are<br />
joyful for her and her child.”<br />
The balloons, he said, were for the<br />
child, the flowers for the mother.<br />
When the mother finally processed<br />
what was happening — yes, she too<br />
was initially thrown by what Cortez<br />
was wearing — he said she told him,<br />
“I’m a single mother, I’ve done all this<br />
for her,” pointing at her daughter.<br />
“She was in tears about this little gesture,”<br />
said Cortez. “I think it meant<br />
so much to her because these people<br />
have been made to feel as if no one<br />
cares about or wants them around.<br />
Seeing her reaction completely<br />
brought to mind what Jesus said about<br />
‘I was a foreigner and you took me in.’ ”<br />
Cortez knew about the young<br />
mother because the group that meets<br />
the buses has become “a very efficient<br />
operation,” said Jorge-Mario Cabrera<br />
of CHIRLA. “At most, we get 24 hours<br />
notice that the buses are coming.<br />
We’ve gotten very good at quickly<br />
making arrangements to meet them at<br />
schools or houses of worship. Those<br />
are human beings coming on those<br />
buses, brothers and sisters, moms and<br />
dads, and we want them to know that<br />
there are human beings here for them<br />
who they can trust.”<br />
It is not Texas state officials who tell<br />
them of the bus departures; instead<br />
the information comes from contacts<br />
the consortium has developed<br />
in Texas, contacts who not only tell<br />
them when buses are leaving but who<br />
is on them. Bus nine contained 37<br />
people, including 16 families with 14<br />
children, the youngest of which was 3<br />
weeks old.<br />
There is, of course, always special<br />
concern when children are on the<br />
buses — and they usually are. That<br />
concern was ramped up this time<br />
since bus nine was headed toward<br />
Southern California just as Hurricane<br />
Hilary was. Also, less than two weeks<br />
before, a 3-year-old child had died on<br />
a bus en route from Texas to Chicago.<br />
“A trip like that is hard on anyone,<br />
let alone a child, let alone a 3-weekold<br />
baby,” Diaz said.<br />
Diaz said she could see the exhaustion<br />
in the young mother as she tried<br />
to eat with one hand and hold her<br />
baby with the other.<br />
“I went up to her and asked if I could<br />
hold her baby while she ate,” Diaz<br />
said. “She told me the other women<br />
on the bus had held the baby for her<br />
as well, so she could rest. She was<br />
so young, it broke my heart when I<br />
found out she was alone.”<br />
Upon learning that information<br />
himself, Cortez immediately began<br />
calling around to see if he could<br />
arrange for someone to take the young<br />
woman and her child in. Eventually,<br />
he did.<br />
“It’s impossible to see that child and<br />
her mother and not think of Mother<br />
Mary,” Cortez said. “I mean, that was<br />
Mary and I’m not talking about a<br />
story, this was real, this was happening<br />
right now, a call from God to act.”<br />
It is a call to action that brings many<br />
to meet the buses time after time. A<br />
call to action that, no matter what one<br />
is wearing, can at times be heartbreaking<br />
though ultimately soul nourishing.<br />
“I can tell you, when I see these immigrants<br />
each time getting off the bus,<br />
I see Jesus coming to us,” Cortez said.<br />
“When I see these immigrants each time getting<br />
off the bus, I see Jesus coming to us,” said Father<br />
Filiberto Cortez.<br />
Officials and volunteers deliver diapers, supplies, and toys for migrants<br />
to St. Anthony Croatian Catholic Church near Chinatown<br />
earlier this year. | DAVID SWANSON/AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES<br />
“And, again, I’m not talking about<br />
metaphors or symbols, I mean Jesus is<br />
literally there. I’ve never had a feeling,<br />
an epiphany like this, to feel what the<br />
saints must have felt, to serve Jesus, to<br />
recognize it is him you are receiving.”<br />
Steve Lowery is a veteran journalist<br />
who has written for the Los Angeles<br />
Times, the Los Angeles Daily <strong>News</strong>, the<br />
Press-Telegram, New Times LA, the District,<br />
Long Beach Post, and OC Weekly.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 17
Visitors peruse through archives and keepsakes at a<br />
historical exhibit at the RSHM Provincial Center in<br />
Montebello celebrating the religious order’s 100 years in<br />
California and Mexico. | TOM HOFFARTH<br />
THE DREAM<br />
CONTINUES<br />
After 100 years in California, the<br />
Religious of the Sacred Heart of<br />
Mary still consider LA mission<br />
territory.<br />
BY TOM HOFFARTH<br />
History comes with a great deal of duty, responsibility,<br />
and fulfillment for Sister Margaret McKenna.<br />
Her digital camera was ready to document all the<br />
history-in-the-making possible when more than 300 people<br />
gathered in Montebello Sept. 9 to mark the culmination<br />
of the yearlong 100th anniversary celebration for her order,<br />
the Religious of the Sacred Heart of Mary Western America<br />
Area (RSHM).<br />
“Studying history is a strong part of my life because it<br />
is always about people trying to live within their existing<br />
conditions,” said McKenna, who received a history degree at<br />
Marymount College and, since 1974, has been a visual arts<br />
teacher at Marymount High School in Westwood, currently<br />
serving as its yearbook adviser.<br />
Both educational facilities were founded by RSHM.<br />
“Our RSHM story continues, our individual stories<br />
continue, our partnerships continue to grow, and together,<br />
history continues to be made,” remarked McKenna. “I am<br />
so humbled by the fact that I can record these times as well<br />
as being a participant in them. Giving and receiving life is a<br />
great way to live.”<br />
It goes back to 1923, when Bishop John Cantwell invited<br />
the RSHM to what was then the Diocese of Los Angeles-San<br />
Diego, asking them to replicate schools that the<br />
order established in Tarrytown, New York, in the quickly<br />
growing SoCal diocese. It started with Marymount School<br />
at 28th Street in Los Angeles, then a junior college eight<br />
years later. In 1948, the four-year Marymount College<br />
arrived.<br />
In 1942, Sacred Heart of Mary School in Montebello was<br />
founded and today continues its mission since merging with<br />
Cantwell High School in the early 1990s, right next door to<br />
the order’s Area Administration Center.<br />
While education was the order’s initial mission focus, it has<br />
expanded in other ways in LA. Two prominent examples:<br />
South Central LAMP (Los Angeles Ministry Project) and<br />
A Place Called Home, founded with support from RSHM<br />
leadership following the 1992 LA riots, are both marking<br />
their 30th anniversaries this year.<br />
LAMP is a nonprofit focused on empowering mothers to<br />
be more self-reliant through parenting programs. Today<br />
18 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
Sister Mary Genino, one of its founders, and fellow RSHM<br />
Sister Cathy Garcia continue the project’s mission.<br />
“We would not be here without the Religious of the Sacred<br />
Heart of Mary,” said South Central LAMP Development<br />
Director Nicole Cosand Burcham. “Having Sister Mary on<br />
the board has brought the RSHM charism, guided in education,<br />
compassion, and justice. She is extremely humble,<br />
purposeful, and we are incredibly blessed to work with her<br />
so closely.”<br />
Sister Patricia Connor, a former RSHM provincial superior<br />
and general superior, remains on the board of A Place<br />
Called Home, created to support South LA youth programs.<br />
Mary Agnes Erlandson, director of Catholic Charities’<br />
St. Margaret Center in Lennox, was there on the warm<br />
Saturday afternoon to honor Sister Evelyn Joyce, who has<br />
been teaching ESL at the center for 12 years. Joyce arrived<br />
at a time when adult education funding in California was<br />
decimated and the center had relied on local adult schools<br />
to provide teachers.<br />
“We would have had to eliminate our adult ESL class if<br />
not for Sister Evelyn,” said Erlandson. “She has become part<br />
of our SMC family, delighting all staff, volunteers, and students<br />
with her infectious and joyous spirit — and teaching<br />
primarily Latino adults to write and speak English with the<br />
slightest Irish brogue!”<br />
Fifty years ago, Marymount College officially merged with<br />
Loyola University in Westchester to form Loyola Marymount<br />
University<br />
(LMU). Father<br />
Tom Rausch, SJ,<br />
the emeritus professor<br />
of theology<br />
at LMU, attended<br />
the celebration<br />
as a way to<br />
thank the sisters<br />
he calls “dedicated,<br />
intelligent,<br />
and progressive”<br />
in helping forge<br />
the merger.<br />
Retired LMU<br />
professor and<br />
alumni chaplain<br />
Father Robert<br />
Caro, SJ, said he<br />
remains impressed<br />
with how<br />
despite the dwindling<br />
number of<br />
RSHM sisters,<br />
“the values they<br />
have espoused<br />
have remained with their commitment to evangelical<br />
justice.”<br />
Cecilia Brizuela, who with her husband, Byron, helped<br />
curate the exhibit that remains open to the public through<br />
<strong>October</strong>, noted that the RSHM Western American Area<br />
currently has 35 sisters, eight of whom live at the Montebello<br />
campus. One is the order’s official archivist, Sister Mary<br />
Leah Plante, who received a history teaching degree at<br />
Marymount College.<br />
“When I was younger and there were older sisters around<br />
me, they would love to tell stories and I’m so glad I bothered<br />
to listen,” said Plante, who just turned 80 and celebrated her<br />
60th year of religious life in <strong>20</strong>22. “This is all a reminder of<br />
the importance of remembering who worked years ago and<br />
to follow them because it is who we are today.”<br />
Sister Joan Treacy, a former provincial superior, entered<br />
the RSHMs in 1961 and was assigned to California three<br />
years later. Since then, she said, the order’s mission remains<br />
“to know God and make God known, and to love God and<br />
make God loved,” but “has moved from just being in the<br />
classroom to finding ways to focus on social justice and the<br />
marginalized in all sorts of capacities.”<br />
As McKenna assessed the wide-ranging multimedia exhibit<br />
chronicling the sisters’ impact in California, Mexico, and<br />
Honduras, she said her work includes telling the RSHM<br />
story to generations to come. The RSHM YouTube channel<br />
with archived interviews featuring the sisters’ stories is<br />
another aspect of documentation.<br />
“In looking through the photos and stories, I am drawn<br />
once again to the heroic women of the past who had a<br />
dream and made it happen,” said McKenna, who designed<br />
the celebration’s 100th anniversary logo. “The dream was<br />
based on making God’s love for people known, by working<br />
in ministries that<br />
are life-giving,<br />
and by helping<br />
people discover<br />
their gifts so<br />
they live a life of<br />
purpose.”<br />
What’s next for<br />
her order? That’s<br />
anyone’s guess,<br />
but she does have<br />
some historical<br />
reference.<br />
“Historically,<br />
various forms<br />
of spiritual life<br />
have existed<br />
and evolved in<br />
time, and we<br />
see vocations<br />
coming from new<br />
countries such<br />
as Africa and<br />
Japan,” she said.<br />
“Will Los Angeles<br />
be considered<br />
a place where they come to serve? Time is in the hand of<br />
God as is the ministry of religious women. I live in faith and<br />
know that God is working.”<br />
Members of the Religious of the Sacred Heart of Mary Western America Area in a recent photo. | SUBMITTED PHOTO<br />
Tom Hoffarth is an award-winning journalist based in Los<br />
Angeles.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 19
PRIME TIME FOR SYNODALITY<br />
Four storylines to watch during<br />
this month’s historic synod<br />
gathering in Rome.<br />
BY JOHN L. ALLEN JR.<br />
ROME — Although the “Miracle on Ice,” the U.S.<br />
hockey team’s improbable win over the Soviets in the<br />
1980 Olympics, is known as one of the greatest sports<br />
moments of all time, the irony is that no one in America<br />
actually saw it happen in real time.<br />
Broadcaster ABC opted for a tape delay in order to broadcast<br />
the game during prime time. Thus, when viewers<br />
heard Al Michaels exclaim as the seconds ticked down,<br />
“Do you believe in miracles?!,” the outcome had already<br />
been decided hours before.<br />
While it’s not yet clear if Pope Francis’ Synod of Bishops<br />
on Synodality, which opens Oct. 4, will produce any such<br />
miracles, it could resemble that fabled 1980 hockey game<br />
in one important respect: to a great extent, we’re not going<br />
to be watching the synod live either.<br />
Reports suggest that Francis is considering imposing pontifical<br />
secrecy on synod deliberations, effectively barring<br />
participants from talking about what’s happening. As a<br />
result, it’s difficult to offer a viewer’s guide for the synod<br />
because, honestly, it’s hard to say what there will be to view.<br />
With that warning, here nevertheless are four storylines<br />
likely to help shape the drama of the impending synod.<br />
‘The Rhine Flows into the Tiber’ … and meets the Congo<br />
A well-known history of the Second Vatican Council<br />
was entitled “The Rhine Flows into the Tiber,” reflecting<br />
the influence of German prelates and theologians. In this<br />
synod too, there’s likely to be a strong German imprint,<br />
since the controversial “synodal path” in Germany blazed<br />
a progressive trail through several issues expected to surface<br />
in Rome too, including married priests, women clergy, and<br />
the blessing of same-sex unions.<br />
One difference between 1965 and <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>, however, is the<br />
<strong>20</strong> • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
Bishops attend a session<br />
of the Synod of Bishops on<br />
Young People, the Faith,<br />
and Vocational Discernment<br />
at the Vatican in<br />
<strong>October</strong> <strong>20</strong>18. | CNS/PAUL<br />
HARING<br />
presence of a<br />
much stronger<br />
and more vocal<br />
African contingent<br />
in this<br />
synod, expected<br />
to represent an<br />
alternative on<br />
many of those<br />
contested issues.<br />
For instance, Archbishop Martin<br />
Kivuva Musonde of Mombasa in<br />
Kenya is set to take part in the synod,<br />
having recently blasted his country’s<br />
Supreme Court for authorizing the<br />
registration of an LGBTQ+ advocacy<br />
group, saying, “If you legalize something,<br />
it means you are promoting it.”<br />
Kivuva will be joined by Bishop<br />
Sanctus Lino Wanok of Lira in<br />
Uganda, who has publicly denounced<br />
pressures for blessing same-sex relationships.<br />
Of course, there will be multiple exceptions<br />
to this binary. German Cardinal<br />
Gerhard Müller, the Vatican’s<br />
former doctrinal chief and a papal appointee<br />
to the synod, certainly won’t<br />
be echoing the conclusions of his<br />
country’s synodal path, and doubtless<br />
there will be Africans striking different<br />
notes too.<br />
Still, how the delicate balance<br />
between doctrinal firmness and pastoral flexibility is struck<br />
in the synod may well pivot on the results of the collision<br />
between these two great rivers of thought and energy.<br />
Context is king<br />
Although synod organizers have produced documents to<br />
guide discussions among participants, the assembly won’t<br />
be taking place in a vacuum. Other things will be going on<br />
in and around Rome at the same time.<br />
The Vatican’s “trial of the century” resumes in late September<br />
with summations from civil parties to the sprawling<br />
financial fraud case, and then throughout the month of<br />
<strong>October</strong>. Defense attorneys, including the lawyers representing<br />
Italian Cardinal Angelo Becciu, will not only be<br />
making the case for their clients’ innocence, but also that<br />
the entire process has been flawed from the beginning by<br />
an inadequate separation between executive and judicial<br />
powers, violating basic modern standards of due process. If<br />
that argument gains momentum during <strong>October</strong>, the question<br />
of the protection of rights in the Church could emerge<br />
as a synod talking point too.<br />
The synod also will unfold against the backdrop of the<br />
ongoing fallout from the clerical sexual abuse scandals,<br />
most recently focused on the case of Father Marko Rupnik,<br />
who was expelled from the Jesuit order in July over charges<br />
that he abused at least <strong>20</strong> women over a 30-year span, but<br />
whose Roman base of operations, the Centro Aletti, recently<br />
drew a clean bill of health from the Diocese of Rome.<br />
The apparent incongruities in the Rupnik case, and others,<br />
make it likely that the abuse crisis will surface during synod<br />
conversations.<br />
<strong>No</strong>t so little women<br />
In a striking novelty, 54 women will be full voting members<br />
of the synod assembly, and the question of women’s<br />
roles and ministries in the Church is expected to loom<br />
large. The same issues will figure even more vocally in<br />
parallel events being staged in Rome during <strong>October</strong>,<br />
including a prayer vigil and a walk through Rome being<br />
organized by Women’s Ordination Worldwide.<br />
Conscious of the optics of the situation, it’s probable that<br />
the men in the synod hall will tend to defer to the women<br />
when talk turns to women’s issues.<br />
That likelihood makes the role of those 54 women, especially<br />
those who occupy the most visible and influential positions,<br />
very critical. Two figures to keep an eye on in that<br />
regard are delegates Sister Maria De Los Dolores Palencia,<br />
CSJ, of Mexico and Momoko Nishimura, a consecrated<br />
laywoman from Japan. French Sister Nathalie Becquart,<br />
XMCJ, undersecretary of the Synod of Bishops, is another<br />
key female player from whom many participants may well<br />
take their cues.<br />
Listening, but to whom?<br />
The Synod of Bishops on Synodality has been touted as<br />
the “biggest consultation exercise in human history,” but<br />
statistics on actual participation tell a somewhat different<br />
story.<br />
In the United States, roughly 700,000 people participated<br />
in the diocesan phase of consultations, out of a total Catholic<br />
population close to 70 million, thus representing about<br />
1%. Data from other parts of the world are roughly similar,<br />
indicating that only a tiny share of the world’s 1.3 billion<br />
Catholics actually contributed.<br />
Whatever the synod’s results, those disappointed with<br />
them might be tempted to suggest that the outcome reflects<br />
the agenda of a narrow cadre of activists rather than true<br />
majority sentiment. One question that will figure prominently<br />
is how to manage the process between now and next<br />
<strong>October</strong> to ensure that whatever is eventually decided, at<br />
least in some rough sense, represents a genuine consensus.<br />
In ecclesiological argot, the term for this process is “reception.”<br />
Medieval theologians and canonists established as a<br />
basic principle that for a law to be effective in the Church,<br />
it had to be “received,” i.e., accepted, by the faithful. The<br />
corollary is that if a law clearly isn’t received, then de facto<br />
it can be abrogated.<br />
Participants in this synod, therefore, will face the challenge<br />
of coming up with ways of promoting such a process<br />
as a reception, even if they’re not necessarily proposing<br />
new law. Otherwise, there’s a risk that the results of the<br />
next synod could be effectively abrogated before they’re<br />
even reached.<br />
John L. Allen Jr. is the editor of Crux.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 21
THE STORY OF SYNODS<br />
As Rome prepares for a gathering unlike any<br />
other in history, here’s a primer on what synods<br />
are and where they come from.<br />
BY JAMES L. PAPANDREA<br />
A 12th-century fresco from St. Nicholas Church in<br />
Myra, Turkey, shows bishops and an emperor at a type<br />
of synod known as an ecumenical council. This one<br />
possibly depicts the sixth ecumenical council at Constantinople<br />
in A.D. 680. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS/<br />
DOSSEMAN<br />
The first crisis of the Church<br />
took place when Christianity<br />
was not even two decades old.<br />
There had already been disagreements,<br />
and even controversies, but<br />
this crisis was an issue that got to the<br />
very heart of the definition of Christianity<br />
itself: Would membership in the<br />
Church require adherence to the laws<br />
of Judaism?<br />
To answer the question, the apostles<br />
convened the first synod, or council,<br />
of the Church, in about A.D. 50 (Acts<br />
15).<br />
We know that as the Church spread<br />
and grew, the very unity of the<br />
Church was invested in the bishops.<br />
Whenever it was necessary to oppose<br />
some heresy or meet some challenge,<br />
the bishops of a particular region<br />
would gather to sort out the problem<br />
and keep everyone on the same<br />
page. But the decisions of these local<br />
synods would only be binding on the<br />
region of the Church represented by<br />
the bishops at the meeting, and they<br />
would not be binding on the whole<br />
Church.<br />
As it turned out, the practice of convening<br />
synods never became a regular<br />
pattern. Synods in the early Church<br />
were convened on an ad hoc basis,<br />
and always reactionary, in the sense<br />
that they were always responding to<br />
a crisis in the Church. They don’t<br />
necessarily overlap or function as continuations<br />
of the previous councils, so<br />
they should not be seen as a series of<br />
councils, per se.<br />
For the most part, each synod is a<br />
stand-alone event — which means<br />
that as an arm of the magisterium,<br />
a synod is an exception to the rule,<br />
something that is done because it is<br />
necessary in the moment, but out<br />
of the ordinary. It is never meant to<br />
be an ongoing or regularly repeating<br />
source of authority (we have the regular<br />
magisterium for that).<br />
The region of <strong>No</strong>rth Africa is an<br />
example of a place where they<br />
22 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
experimented with regularly scheduled<br />
synods. What they found is that<br />
meeting too often in councils led to a<br />
politicizing of the Church, including<br />
ongoing lobbying, in which metropolitan<br />
bishops could manipulate the<br />
voting by creating more dioceses in<br />
their areas, so that they could create<br />
more bishops, so that their area would<br />
have more voting power.<br />
Later, in the East, even the famous<br />
St. Basil the Great gave in to the<br />
temptation to make his brother and<br />
friend bishops just so they could support<br />
him and his projects. In actual<br />
practice, synods of the early Church<br />
could be as uneventful as a routine<br />
office or parish meeting, or they could<br />
be full of drama, complete with shouting<br />
matches and fistfights.<br />
As time went on, new crises resulted<br />
in new synods. In the second century,<br />
a controversy over how to calculate<br />
the date for Easter resulted in synods<br />
in Rome and in other cities. In the<br />
third century, a controversy over the<br />
sacrament of reconciliation resulted<br />
in synods in Rome and Carthage. In<br />
the fourth century, the question of<br />
clergy celibacy (among other things)<br />
resulted in a synod in Elvira, Spain,<br />
but because the Church was illegal<br />
and persecuted, travel was difficult.<br />
And being regional synods, their decisions<br />
were technically only binding<br />
on that region (although the synods<br />
of Rome would come to have more<br />
weight, since the bishop of Rome, the<br />
pope, ratified their decisions).<br />
When the emperor Constantine<br />
legalized Christianity, he also gave<br />
Christian bishops the right to use the<br />
Roman transit system, which was until<br />
this time reserved for government<br />
officials (those government officials<br />
would soon complain that there were<br />
so many Christian bishops traveling to<br />
synods that they found it hard to get a<br />
seat in the wagon!).<br />
The first synod attended by the<br />
emperor was the Synod of Arles in<br />
A.D. 314. But this, too, was a regional<br />
synod, and it quickly became clear to<br />
everyone that what was really needed<br />
to face the current crises (not least<br />
would be the heresy of Arianism), was<br />
a worldwide council — one where<br />
every bishop in the world was invited,<br />
and the decisions would be binding<br />
on the whole Church. This was the<br />
Council of Nicaea, in the year A.D.<br />
325. It would come to be called the<br />
first “ecumenical” (or worldwide)<br />
council.<br />
Incidentally, Nicaea was the last time<br />
(for a long time) that laypeople were<br />
invited. They became a distraction, in<br />
part by treating the living saints like<br />
“The Fourth Ecumenical Council of Chalcedon,” by Vasily<br />
Surikov, 1848-1916, Russian. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
rock stars (hermits came in from the<br />
desert for the council, people who<br />
had been tortured in the last round<br />
of persecutions showed up with their<br />
scars, and the famous St. Nicholas was<br />
there). After 325, councils would be<br />
limited to bishops and their assistants.<br />
The Council of Nicaea clarified the<br />
doctrine of the Trinity in opposition<br />
to the Arian heresy, and wrote the<br />
first draft of the Nicene Creed. The<br />
Second Ecumenical Council, the<br />
Council of Constantinople in A.D.<br />
381, added to the creed, especially in<br />
the paragraph about the Holy Spirit.<br />
This gave us (essentially) the Nicene<br />
Creed that we recite in Mass every<br />
week.<br />
In the early centuries of the Church,<br />
sometimes a council was convened by<br />
an emperor, but not without the sanction<br />
of the pope, who would generally<br />
determine who chaired the council.<br />
Sometimes the pope couldn’t attend,<br />
but he was always represented by a<br />
delegation from Rome. When the<br />
Rome delegation read Pope St. Leo’s<br />
statement at the Council of Chalcedon<br />
in A.D. 451, it was reported that<br />
the assembled bishops cheered, “Leo<br />
speaks for Peter!” That may be a bit of<br />
an exaggeration, but the point is that<br />
the voice of the pope carried great<br />
weight at a council, even when he was<br />
not physically there.<br />
In fact, one of the times that people<br />
tried to convene a council without the<br />
sanction of the pope, and where the<br />
pope’s statement was rejected — this<br />
council was determined to be invalid,<br />
and is now referred to as “The Robber<br />
Synod” (A.D. 449).<br />
So although the words “synod” and<br />
“council” are basically synonymous,<br />
we can make a distinction between<br />
regional synods or councils and a<br />
general (or ecumenical) council,<br />
which is universal — that is, every<br />
bishop in the worldwide Church is<br />
invited, and the canons (resolutions)<br />
will be binding on the whole Church.<br />
In actual practice, the pope has a kind<br />
of de facto line-item veto, even of the<br />
canons of the ecumenical councils.<br />
For example, popes rejected individual<br />
canons from the Councils of<br />
Constantinople and Chalcedon.<br />
Historically, the impact of any<br />
council — especially an ecumenical<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 23
council like Vatican II — can take<br />
generations to have its full effect on<br />
the Church. Having a general council<br />
too often, the Church seems to have<br />
learned, would create an overlapping<br />
effect where the full impact of one<br />
council had not<br />
been realized before<br />
another one<br />
was convened.<br />
It is also true<br />
that the ecumenical<br />
councils of<br />
the early Church<br />
did significant<br />
work that could<br />
A 17th-century painting<br />
of the Second Council<br />
of Nicaea (A.D. 787) in<br />
<strong>No</strong>vodevichy Convent<br />
in Moscow, Russia. |<br />
WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
never be undone, or even improved<br />
upon. For example, they literally<br />
defined what Christianity is by clarifying<br />
the doctrine of the Trinity and<br />
orthodox christology in opposition to<br />
heresies. Their conclusions are treated<br />
as being as authoritative as Scripture,<br />
because they were defining the authoritative<br />
interpretation of Scripture.<br />
Once the Church faced permanent<br />
schism, the concept of an ecumenical<br />
council is a matter of point of<br />
view — what we as Catholics call<br />
ecumenical councils would not all be<br />
considered so by the Orthodox, and<br />
what we agree with the Orthodox are<br />
ecumenical councils would not all be<br />
accepted by the Oriental Orthodox,<br />
who split from the Church after the<br />
Council of Chalcedon. The point<br />
is that a council is not authoritative<br />
because it’s a general council — it is<br />
a general “augustcouncil” because<br />
it is authoritative, and that authority<br />
is determined by the approval of the<br />
pope and by its canons standing the<br />
test of time.<br />
And so with regard to general<br />
councils, there is an aspect of them in<br />
which their work is done. Doctrines<br />
are defined as well as they ever will<br />
be. Christianity has been defined, and<br />
no one alive today or in the future can<br />
redefine (or reimagine) it. The historical<br />
fact of the debates, controversies,<br />
Pope Francis with cardinals and<br />
bishops from around the world at the<br />
Synod of Bishops for the Amazon in<br />
<strong>20</strong>19. | CNS/PAUL HARING<br />
and crises do not at all diminish the<br />
authoritative teaching of the Church,<br />
in fact they confirm it, since the work<br />
of clarification has been done.<br />
From the beginning, and even when<br />
there were new situations to address,<br />
the role of a council was always to<br />
determine what clarification of belief,<br />
or what course of action, was most<br />
consistent with received tradition.<br />
With regard to synods, or nongeneral<br />
councils, it is possible that new crises<br />
can create the need for new synods.<br />
But unless a council is declared to<br />
be a general council, its decisions<br />
could only be binding on the whole<br />
Church if the pope were to ratify<br />
them as such, which would amount to<br />
a new infallible pronouncement, “ex<br />
cathedra.”<br />
If future synods are to be faithful<br />
to their historical counterparts, they<br />
would be convened in the recognition<br />
that they are an extraordinary measure<br />
meant to deal with a certain crisis,<br />
which may be new, but that their task<br />
is to determine the resolution of the<br />
crisis that is most consistent with the<br />
faith handed down from the apostles.<br />
James L. Papandrea is the author<br />
of “Reading the Church Fathers: A<br />
History of the Early Church and the<br />
Development of Doctrine” (Sophia<br />
Institute Press, $21.95).<br />
24 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
INTERSECTIONS<br />
GREG ERLANDSON<br />
A retreat on wheels<br />
I’m not the kind of guy who keeps<br />
a long bucket list of vacation goals<br />
or life-threatening challenges. But<br />
for the past few years I’ve talked about<br />
riding my bike from the outskirts of<br />
Pittsburgh to Washington, D.C., a<br />
335-mile ride that includes a long,<br />
steady incline up one side of the Eastern<br />
Continental Divide and down the<br />
other. This summer, I finally made<br />
the trip.<br />
You could call it a working vacation<br />
of sorts. I thought of it as a retreat with<br />
mileage.<br />
Almost the entire route was away<br />
from cars and away from cities. Most<br />
of the time and most of the miles<br />
were on gravel paths often strewn with<br />
potholes, tree roots, and the occasional<br />
mud puddle. Riding on the Great<br />
Allegheny Passage (GAP) trail and the<br />
Chesapeake & Ohio (C&O) Canal<br />
trail, we passed through small towns<br />
that once played big roles in U.S. history.<br />
Towns like Hancock, Maryland,<br />
whose residents fought off a siege<br />
by General Stonewall Jackson, and<br />
Harper’s Ferry, West Virginia, where<br />
John Brown failed to inspire a slave<br />
uprising in 1859 but lit the fuse that<br />
became the Civil War.<br />
Gravel provided its own soundtrack<br />
to the trip. At times it crackled and<br />
crunched under our tires, like popcorn<br />
muffled in the microwave. But<br />
patches of dirt or dried mud introduced<br />
a quiet note, so that the crunch<br />
gave way to silence for brief moments.<br />
<strong>No</strong> doubt the wildlife in the area<br />
were well alerted to our presence,<br />
but deer, rabbits, hawks, blue herons,<br />
a black snake, and one enormous<br />
and rather surly snapping turtle still<br />
crossed our path. Or more accurately,<br />
we crossed theirs.<br />
The trail took us along three rivers:<br />
The author on a mountain<br />
trail in southern<br />
Pennsylvania during his<br />
335-mile bike ride from<br />
Pittsburgh to Washington,<br />
D.C., this summer. |<br />
SUBMITTED PHOTO<br />
the Youghiogheny,<br />
the<br />
Casselman,<br />
and the majestic<br />
Potomac.<br />
Rivers were the<br />
lifeblood of our<br />
young country.<br />
Towns grew<br />
up along their banks. Goods were<br />
transported on them. The C&O<br />
Canal started as the brainchild of<br />
George Washington, who sought a<br />
way to bypass the falls and rapids of<br />
the Potomac and bring goods west. It<br />
was dug by 35,000 workers, mostly immigrants,<br />
but its utility was challenged<br />
even as it was being built by the arrival<br />
of the railroad. We would occasionally<br />
hear a train roaring west on tracks<br />
paralleling the canal, the clatter of<br />
wheels on rails a taunting reminder of<br />
who won that race.<br />
What was most memorable, however,<br />
was simply being immersed in nature<br />
for hours at a time. The rhythm of the<br />
pedals and the crunch of the gravel<br />
provided a soundtrack to the canopy<br />
of trees and the lush microclimates<br />
that we rode through. There was<br />
beauty everywhere. Sunlight streaming<br />
through the trees, wild flowers<br />
growing on the banks of the canals.<br />
The rivers — changeable, moody,<br />
sparkling one minute and then seething<br />
and tumultuous the next.<br />
The Japanese have a term: “Shinrin-yoku,”<br />
or “forest bathing.” It describes<br />
that peace which comes from<br />
simply being quiet amid the trees, like<br />
walking the garden paths of a monastery.<br />
There is a peace that settled over<br />
me riding down those trails. I was in<br />
the moment, legs and bike pushing<br />
forward in a steady rhythm that said,<br />
“be where you’re at; do what you’re<br />
26 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
Greg Erlandson is the former president and<br />
editor-in-chief of Catholic <strong>News</strong> Service.<br />
doing.” It is motion that is conducive<br />
to prayer, but particularly the type of<br />
prayers we often overlook: those of<br />
praise and thanksgiving.<br />
As the miles mounted and the days<br />
passed, the beauty drove out other<br />
concerns. I may be a news junkie, but<br />
for a week I kicked the habit. Looking<br />
at my news feeds didn’t interest me. I<br />
ignored news channels on television. I<br />
stopped prowling my emails.<br />
“Holidays and vacations can help to<br />
balance activity with contemplation,<br />
haste with more natural rhythms,<br />
noise with the heralding silence of<br />
peace.” St. Pope John Paul II said that.<br />
He was an outdoorsman, a skier, a hiker,<br />
a swimmer. I think he would have<br />
appreciated my ride and understood<br />
its impact.<br />
Activity and contemplation. Haste<br />
with natural rhythms. <strong>No</strong>ise with<br />
peace. The whirr of the wheels. The<br />
smells and sights of nature. Feeling<br />
for a short while like I’m one with the<br />
bike and one with the nature that I<br />
am spinning through and a part of.<br />
There were nine others on the trip<br />
with me. We had all signed up with<br />
Wilderness Voyageurs, a company<br />
that specializes in multi-day bike trips<br />
around the country. Strangers when<br />
we set out, we all counted ourselves<br />
friends at the end. Each of us had his<br />
or her own reason for coming. Yet we<br />
bonded in the experience, hearing<br />
one another’s stories as we rode the<br />
trail or shared a meal.<br />
Certain themes stood out: the challenge<br />
of friendships; the demands of<br />
work; the questions that come with<br />
retirement. In a sense, it felt like we<br />
were all finding our way, our path.<br />
But for six days, our quest was simply<br />
to be, and to savor the goodness of the<br />
Lord’s creation.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 27
TIME TO THINK ABOUT ROME<br />
Why a bewildering social media trend makes<br />
more sense than you think.<br />
BY PHILLIP CAMPBELL<br />
Roman soldier reenactors demonstrate their<br />
drill last year at a festival marking the 1,900th<br />
anniversary of the building of the first phase of<br />
Hadrian’s Wall. | IAN FORSYTH/GETTY IMAGES<br />
For a few days this September, a<br />
surprising topic went viral on social<br />
media: the enduring legacy<br />
of ancient Rome.<br />
The frenzy was apparently sparked<br />
by a TikTok video in which a woman<br />
asked her husband how often he<br />
thought about the Roman Empire.<br />
She was confused — and even<br />
stunned — when he reported that<br />
Rome was on his mind every day.<br />
As it turns out, this was not an<br />
isolated case. Women on social media<br />
proceeded to ask the men in their<br />
lives the same question and have been<br />
shocked to discover that, in many<br />
cases, it is quite frequently. The fad<br />
even caught the attention of the Washington<br />
Post, which reported that many<br />
men surveyed reported thinking about<br />
Rome at least once daily, if not more.<br />
One can certainly sympathize with<br />
the confusion of women trying to<br />
understand why their husbands devote<br />
headspace to the politics of Augustus<br />
or the victories of Trajan.<br />
But as a history nerd myself, I think it<br />
is exceptionally fitting to think about<br />
Rome. If anything, we don’t think<br />
about it enough. So, here are a few<br />
reasons why you should think more<br />
about the Roman Empire.<br />
1. Architecture<br />
The Romans were intrepid builders,<br />
developing some of the most enduring<br />
architecture in human history. They<br />
are known for the innovative use of the<br />
arch, as well as being the first builders<br />
in history to utilize domes on a monumental<br />
scale. Many Roman domed<br />
structures are still with us today, like<br />
the Pantheon in the city of Rome.<br />
Because of their beauty, strength,<br />
and grandeur, Roman architectural<br />
styles have been adopted all over the<br />
Western world as exemplifying law<br />
and order. This is why our Founding<br />
Fathers adopted the Roman style for<br />
our federal buildings and monuments.<br />
The Lincoln and Jefferson Memorials<br />
are virtual duplicates of Roman temples.<br />
To this day, Roman architectural<br />
elements are employed in buildings<br />
of great social importance, such as<br />
courts, libraries, and government<br />
buildings.<br />
In fact, in <strong>20</strong><strong>20</strong> the federal government<br />
mandated that all new federal<br />
buildings in Washington D.C., be<br />
built in the classical (i.e., Roman)<br />
style. From Pennsylvania Avenue to<br />
Main Street, U.S.A., Roman architecture<br />
is everywhere.<br />
2. A legal legacy<br />
The Romans were also known for<br />
their contributions to modern jurisprudence.<br />
Forged during the republican<br />
era (509-27 B.C.), their legal institutions<br />
created a stable framework for a<br />
government that combined elements<br />
of monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy.<br />
After the Roman Republic became<br />
the Roman Empire, the Romans<br />
brought their laws to the far-flung<br />
corners of their domain, from the frontiers<br />
of Scotland to the Nile Delta.<br />
The most amazing thing about Roman<br />
law is its longevity, as it continued<br />
to be used long after the empire<br />
fell. Many medieval kingdoms used<br />
Emperor Justinian’s legal collection,<br />
“Corpus Iuris Civilis,” and the Catho-<br />
28 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
lic Church also developed its Canon<br />
Law based on this work.<br />
In the U.S., the Founding Fathers<br />
were all versed in Roman law, and<br />
the Roman legal principles would go<br />
on to be cited by the Supreme Court<br />
numerous times.<br />
Today, the principles at the heart of<br />
most Western legal systems today are<br />
derived from Roman law.<br />
3. Linguistic patrimony<br />
Thinking about Rome every time you<br />
pray might be a bit much, but here’s a<br />
thought:<br />
As the Romans spread over the<br />
Mediterranean world, they brought<br />
Latin with them, making it a language<br />
of unification. It became the language<br />
of the educated, the powerful, and the<br />
cultured. The precision and logic of<br />
Latin made it an ideal vehicle to communicate<br />
complex ideas — whether in<br />
law, theology, or literature.<br />
As the Roman Empire dissolved in<br />
more sophisticated our vocabulary, the<br />
more “Latinized” our speech becomes.<br />
Latin was, of course, also preserved<br />
as the ecclesiastical language of the<br />
Catholic Church in the Latin Rite.<br />
When it comes to how we communicate<br />
and worship, Rome still lives.<br />
4. Masters of engineering<br />
The Romans were some of history’s<br />
great problem-solvers. Becoming master<br />
engineers, they constructed durable<br />
roads to connect their sprawling empire.<br />
In fact, modern road construction<br />
still uses the methods pioneered by the<br />
Romans — land surveys followed by<br />
careful preparation of the subsurface.<br />
Their engineering genius still yields<br />
surprises today: In <strong>20</strong>17, analysis of<br />
Roman marine concrete revealed the<br />
secret of how the Romans could build<br />
durable underwater structures. Their<br />
concrete was made of lime and volcanic<br />
ash, which, when exposed to water,<br />
hardened while curing. Rather than<br />
be eroded by<br />
the water, the<br />
Roman marine<br />
concrete<br />
actually got<br />
harder as time<br />
went by.<br />
well to consider Rome a cautionary<br />
tale. The Roman experience may yet<br />
be relevant to our own.<br />
6. It’s just entertaining<br />
Perhaps the best reason to think about<br />
Rome is that its history can keep you<br />
endlessly entertained.<br />
The sacrificial death of Marcus Atilius<br />
Regulus is one of the most moving<br />
historical deaths you will ever read<br />
(enough to make even St. Augustine<br />
marvel). The drama of Hannibal and<br />
the Second Punic War was like the<br />
World War II of the ancient world. And<br />
the tactics of Julius Caesar at the Battle<br />
of Alesia are more exciting than any<br />
Hollywood movie. Don’t know what<br />
any of these references refer to? Study<br />
ancient Rome. You won’t regret it.<br />
Phillip Campbell is a history teacher<br />
for Homeschool Connections and<br />
author of “The Story of Civilization”<br />
four-volume series (TAN Books) and<br />
other historical works.<br />
the west, Latin became the basis of<br />
the “Romance” languages (Italian,<br />
Spanish, French, Portuguese, Romanian,<br />
etc.) Though not a Romance<br />
language, 60% of English comes from<br />
words borrowed from Latin — and the<br />
5. Rome as<br />
a cautionary<br />
tale<br />
Like the<br />
U.S., Rome<br />
threw off its<br />
monarchy<br />
to adopt a<br />
representative<br />
government,<br />
expanded<br />
rapidly to<br />
become a regional<br />
power,<br />
competed<br />
with other<br />
superpowers<br />
for total<br />
dominance,<br />
endured a<br />
civil war, and dealt with crises relating<br />
to war, immigration, slavery, inflation,<br />
and corruption.<br />
While history doesn’t repeat itself, it<br />
does rhyme, and those interested in<br />
the fate of our own republic would do<br />
A Sept. 15 post from popular X (formerly Twitter) humor account “Daily Roman Updates,”<br />
sharing a news report from NBC’s Today Show about the the Roman Empire’s social media<br />
moment. | SCREENSHOT/X.COM<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 29
DESIRE LINES<br />
HEATHER KING<br />
A modern-day pilgrim’s progress<br />
The author’s view from her pilgrimage in Ards<br />
Franciscan Friary in Ireland. | HEATHER KING<br />
People are often taken aback when<br />
I tell them I’m, say, spending<br />
three months in Europe, alone,<br />
as I’ve done this summer.<br />
“You’re going by yourself?” they ask.<br />
“Oh heavens, yes. I could never travel<br />
with another person.”<br />
<strong>No</strong>r, I might add, could another<br />
person possibly travel with me.<br />
Partly this is because for me, travel is<br />
pilgrimage. Travel is in the best sense<br />
of the word penance.<br />
Travel for me is not holding my<br />
phone aloft to capture “the moment”<br />
on film instead of actually experiencing<br />
it. Travel is growth, enlargement,<br />
giving myself to whatever place I’m in<br />
and receiving whatever the place might<br />
give to me.<br />
For that, I have to be awake.<br />
Thus I eat sparingly, walk as much as<br />
possible, and spend as much time as I<br />
can in prayer.<br />
It’s a lot to carry, being a pilgrim.<br />
Sometimes it’s all too much and I have<br />
to take to bed with a bag of candy and<br />
watch three Joan Crawford movies in<br />
a row.<br />
But for the most part I thrive on time<br />
alone. In fact, after rattling around for<br />
seven weeks in the County Galway<br />
village of Oughterard, I signed up for a<br />
four-day silent retreat at Ards Franciscan<br />
Friary, about as far north in Ireland<br />
as you can go.<br />
I was almost completely incoherent<br />
as I babbled the first day to my poor<br />
spiritual director — what am I struggling<br />
with? What do I desire?<br />
Finally I stammered out, “To order<br />
my life more closely and more completely<br />
to prayer.”<br />
Carel, my sainted spiritual director,<br />
seemed to understand completely. She<br />
reminded me of Romans 8:26: “We<br />
do not know how to pray as we ought,<br />
but the Spirit itself intercedes with<br />
inexpressible groanings.”<br />
In the friar’s chapel, with its worn,<br />
well-loved breviaries, we attended<br />
12:15 Mass, and showed up each<br />
evening at 8 p.m. for adoration, when<br />
the doors of the plain wooden tabernacle<br />
were opened to reveal inner copper<br />
panels embossed with sheaves of<br />
wheat, and an illuminated monstrance.<br />
The Donegal coastline is magnificent.<br />
Aquamarine water, cliffs russet with<br />
heather, blue-misted mountains, water<br />
crashing against barnacled rocks and<br />
30 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
Heather King is an award-winning<br />
author, speaker, and workshop leader.<br />
breaking in long, low waves. Pastures of<br />
grazing sheep. Wild blackberries. Hidden<br />
beaches. Sun filtering through the<br />
impossibly high branches of ancient<br />
oaks and elms.<br />
A stupendous gift: the freedom not to<br />
have to talk for several days. With the<br />
window open, I could look upon the<br />
water through the trees. Birds softly<br />
calling.<br />
One plus of traveling alone is being<br />
forced to depend upon the kindness of<br />
strangers. Always there is someone to<br />
point to the right gate, queue, bathroom,<br />
dining hall, confessional.<br />
Father Maurice Zundel, Swiss mystic,<br />
poet, and philosopher, observed:<br />
“What a mysterious baptism are these<br />
tears we can hardly hold back when<br />
we see a loving face, revealing to us<br />
a world we possibly believe to have<br />
been abolished, and to which we, in<br />
all the sinews of our being, now feel we<br />
belong: the world of the spirit and of<br />
quality of silence and of light.”<br />
Another plus is that both your strong<br />
and weak points are revealed. I didn’t<br />
know I could be this patient. I didn’t<br />
know that what I call “discipline”<br />
is sometimes more like a mania for<br />
control.<br />
Do I really need to instantly respond<br />
to every text, e-mail, or comment, so<br />
as to “keep my desk clear.” Do I really<br />
need quite so often to bookmark, save,<br />
reserve at the library, put in a shopping<br />
cart?<br />
“The great challenge is living your<br />
wounds through instead of thinking<br />
them through,” wrote Henri <strong>No</strong>uwen.<br />
“It is better to cry than to worry, better<br />
to feel your wounds deeply than to understand<br />
them, better to let them enter<br />
into your silence than to talk about<br />
them. … You need to let your wounds<br />
go down into your heart. Then you can<br />
live them through and discover that<br />
they will not destroy you. Your heart is<br />
greater than your wounds.”<br />
I have a hard time accepting human<br />
limitations, especially my own.<br />
My last two assigned readings were<br />
perfect:<br />
“Jesus did not deem equality with<br />
God something to be grasped at” (Phil.<br />
2:6).<br />
“For his sake I have accepted the loss<br />
of all things and I consider them so<br />
much rubbish, that I may gain Christ”<br />
(Phil. 3:8).<br />
I left Ards praying: Help me to trust,<br />
to wait, to have reasonable expectations<br />
of myself and others.<br />
People for the most part have been<br />
incredibly kind, but there are always a<br />
few who can’t help slamming the U.S.,<br />
and California in particular.<br />
As my trip progresses, I find myself<br />
thinking of the mating seals near San<br />
Simeon, and of Joshua Tree National<br />
Park, and of the Blessed Sacrament<br />
Chapel at Our Lady of the Angels<br />
Cathedral.<br />
I think of how you can buy all the<br />
used books you want on eBay, and of<br />
Silverlake Ramen, and of watching<br />
the sun set over downtown as you’re<br />
driving west on the 10.<br />
“Oh I don’t know,” I’ll say. “The<br />
States are pretty great, in their way.”<br />
Next stop: Bruges. Contemplating a<br />
bus, a flight, a train, and a cab ride,<br />
I find myself thinking of the 17th-century<br />
Japanese haiku master Basho:<br />
“<strong>No</strong>ne to accompany me on this path:<br />
Nightfall in autumn.”<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 31
LETTER AND SPIRIT<br />
SCOTT HAHN<br />
Scott Hahn is founder of the<br />
St. Paul Center for Biblical<br />
Theology; stpaulcenter.com.<br />
Friendship: A closer Luke<br />
What I know about film can fit comfortably in a<br />
single frame. I am neither Siskel nor Ebert.<br />
But I know a thing or two about the New Testament,<br />
and I was deeply moved by the <strong>20</strong>18 film “Paul,<br />
Apostle of Christ.” It made me aware of something that<br />
should have been obvious to me — something hidden in<br />
plain sight in every Bible.<br />
The movie made me see the colossal importance of Paul’s<br />
friendship with Luke (whose feast we’ll celebrate on Oct.<br />
18).<br />
Their relationship is different. It first appears in the New<br />
Testament in the Acts of the Apostles, and it emerges in a<br />
subtle way. Luke, the author of Acts, simply begins to use<br />
the first-person plural pronoun, we, in his narration, because<br />
now he’s traveling with Paul. It’s subtle, but stunning<br />
in its subtlety. It’s the clear marker of the beginning of a<br />
friendship.<br />
Paul, for his part, mentions Luke often. Perhaps the<br />
earliest mention, chronologically, is in the apostle’s Letter<br />
to Philemon, which ends with a name-drop of Luke among<br />
Paul’s “fellow workers.”<br />
In his Letter to<br />
the Colossians<br />
Paul takes it up a<br />
notch, referring<br />
to Luke as his<br />
“dear friend” and<br />
“doctor.”<br />
In the second<br />
of Paul’s letters<br />
to Timothy,<br />
after naming<br />
those who have<br />
deserted him, he<br />
says poignantly,<br />
“Luke alone<br />
is with me” (2<br />
Timothy 4:11).<br />
Paul’s relationship<br />
with Luke<br />
was unique. He<br />
refers to Timothy<br />
and Titus as<br />
“St. Paul,” by Anthony van Dyke, 1599-1641, Flemish. | sons (1 Timothy<br />
WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
1:18; Titus 1:4).<br />
But Luke<br />
is a friend,<br />
beloved and<br />
loyal. He is<br />
the other<br />
half of “we.”<br />
He alone<br />
remains.<br />
Together<br />
they accomplished<br />
what<br />
no man<br />
could do<br />
alone. Luke<br />
wrote the two<br />
longest books<br />
in the New<br />
Testament,<br />
the third<br />
“St. Luke the Evangelist,” by Vladimir Borovikovsky, 1757-<br />
1825, Russian. | WIKIMEDIA COMMONS<br />
Gospel and the Acts of the Apostles. Paul wrote more New<br />
Testament books than anyone else — 13 or 14, depending<br />
on how you count.<br />
Luke’s Gospel weighs in at 19,482 words, and Acts at<br />
18,451 words, for a total of 37,933 words. Paul’s 13 letters<br />
total 32,407 words (if you add Hebrews, the count goes up<br />
to 37,460).<br />
Thus, Paul and Luke together wrote at least 70,340 out of<br />
the 138,0<strong>20</strong> words in the New Testament.<br />
Together they wrote more than half of this book that the<br />
Church has designated to be inspired by God.<br />
And we should never doubt that theirs was a true collaboration.<br />
Since the early Church, readers have referred to<br />
Luke’s Gospel as “Paul’s,” because the narrative so perfectly<br />
enacts the theology we find in his letters.<br />
The friendship of Luke and Paul was the dynamo that<br />
powered the Church’s growth in its first generation. That<br />
was God’s providential purpose in bringing them together:<br />
because Paul and Luke together accomplished what they<br />
could never have done separately.<br />
This is the power of friendship in God’s plan. This is why<br />
Jesus called his apostles “friends” (John 15:15). This is why<br />
the early Christians used “the friends” as a synonym for the<br />
Church (3 John 1:15).<br />
What apostolic wonders is God waiting to work through<br />
your friendships and mine?<br />
32 • ANGELUS • <strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>
■ FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 29<br />
Our Lady of Perpetual Help Church Fiesta BBQ. Our Lady<br />
of Perpetual Help Church, 23233 Lyons Ave., Newhall,<br />
6-11 p.m., Saturday, 4-11 p.m., Sunday, 2-8 p.m. ICC booth<br />
will feature specialty sausage and pepper sandwiches, pizza,<br />
pasta, cannoli, and espresso coffee. For more information<br />
or donations, call Anna Riggs at 661-645-7877.<br />
St. Michael the Archangel Feast Day Celebration. St.<br />
Michael Catholic School, 1016 W. Manchester Ave., Los<br />
Angeles, 8:30 a.m. Mass, 9:30 a.m. breakfast, 10:15 a.m.-12<br />
p.m. program and open house. For more information, visit<br />
stmichaelguardians.org. RSVP by calling 310-367-7626 or<br />
email cconsola@stmichaelguardians.org.<br />
■ SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 30<br />
The Blessing of Balance: Sacred Collage and Your Seasonal<br />
Rhythms. Holy Spirit Retreat Center, 4316 Lanai Rd.,<br />
Encino, 9 a.m.-4 p.m. With Chantel Zimmerman. For more<br />
information, visit hsrcenter.com or call 818-815-4480.<br />
■ SUNDAY, OCTOBER 1<br />
Holy Silence Contemplative Prayer Group. St. Andrew<br />
Russian Greek Catholic Church, 538 Concord St., El Segundo,<br />
12-1:30 p.m. Call 310-322-1892.<br />
■ MONDAY, OCTOBER 2<br />
Catechesis for Youth and Adults. St. John the Evangelist<br />
Church, 6028 S. Victoria Ave., Los Angeles, 7:30 p.m. every<br />
Monday and Thursday in Our Lady of Guadalupe Chapel<br />
(entrance through parking lot on 60th Street). Catechesis of<br />
the Neocatechumenal Way in English. Are you looking for<br />
an answer to suffering? Or want to deepen your faith? All<br />
are welcome. For more information call 310-531-0635.<br />
■ WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 4<br />
“Holy is his Name” Weekly Series. St. Dorothy Church,<br />
241 S. Valley Center Ave., Glendora, 7-8:30 p.m. Series runs<br />
every Wednesday through May 22, <strong>20</strong>24. Deepen your<br />
understanding of the Catholic faith through dynamic DVD<br />
presentations by Bishop Robert Barron, Dr. Edward Sri,<br />
Dr. Marcellino D’Ambrosio, Dr. Brant Pitre, and Dr. Scott<br />
Hahn. Free, no reservation required. Call 626-335-2811 or<br />
visit the Adult Faith Development ministry page at www.<br />
stdorothy.org for more information.<br />
■ SATURDAY, OCTOBER 7<br />
San Pedro Regional Congress <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>. St. Joseph High<br />
School, 5825 Woodruff Ave., Lakewood. For more information,<br />
visit lacatholics.org/catholic-la-events.<br />
God’s Healing Power for Your Family Tree. St. John the<br />
Baptist Church, 3883 Baldwin Park Blvd., Baldwin Park, 10<br />
a.m.-4 p.m. With Father Mike Barry, SSCC, and Dominic<br />
Berardino. Topics include: Prayer for Breaking Family Bondages,<br />
and Freedom and Deliverance through the Eucharist.<br />
Cost: $<strong>20</strong>/person through Sept. 28, $25/person after. For<br />
more information, email spirit@scrc.org.<br />
Lay Mission Helpers’ Rose Gala. Luminarias Restaurant,<br />
3500 W. Ramona Blvd., Monterey Park, 4-8 p.m. Guest<br />
speaker: Father Eugen Nkardzedze, Ph.D. Art and Ruth Munoz<br />
will receive the Ernst Ophuls Award and Cheryl Fabien<br />
will receive the St. Thérèse of Lisieux Award. Includes silent<br />
auction. Cost: $100/person. To purchase, call 213-368-<br />
1870 or visit Mission House, 6102 S. Victoria Ave.<br />
■ TUESDAY, OCTOBER 10<br />
Memorial Mass. San Fernando Mission, 15151 San<br />
Fernando Mission Blvd., Mission Hills, 11 a.m. Mass is<br />
virtual and not open to the public. Livestream available at<br />
catholiccm.org or facebook.com/lacatholics.<br />
LACBA Unlawful Detainer Answer Clinic. LA Law<br />
Library, 301 W. 1st St., Los Angeles, 12-3 p.m. Providing<br />
limited assistance with reviewing unlawful detainer complaints,<br />
jury demands, fee waiver requests, and more. Open<br />
to the disabled veteran community in Los Angeles County.<br />
Spanish assistance available. RSVP to 213-896-6536 or<br />
email inquiries-veterans@lacba.org.<br />
■ WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 11<br />
St. Padre Pio Mass. St. Anne Church, 340 10th St., Seal<br />
Beach, 1 p.m. Celebrant: Father Al Baca. For more information,<br />
call 562-537-4526.<br />
■ FRIDAY, OCTOBER 13<br />
Young Adult Rosary. Morgan Park, 4100 Baldwin Park<br />
Blvd., Baldwin Park, 6 p.m. Rosary for young adults and<br />
youth groups. Meets on the 13th of every month through<br />
December. Wear your ministry uniform and bring a flag or<br />
banner.<br />
Priests vs. Seminarians Basketball Game. Cathedral High<br />
School, 1253 Bishops Rd., Los Angeles, 7-10 p.m. Cost:<br />
$10/person. For more information, visit https://lacatholics.<br />
org/catholic-la-events/.<br />
■ SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14<br />
Virtual Regional Congress <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>. San Fernando and<br />
Our Lady of the Angels regions are teaming up for “We<br />
Encounter, We Rejoice, We Go!” virtual Congress. For more<br />
information, visit lacatholics.org/catholic-la-events.<br />
As Spiritual Warfare Intensifies: God is Sending Us<br />
Reinforcements! St. Edward the Confessor Church, 33926<br />
Calle La Primavera, Dana Point, 10 a.m.-4 p.m. With Father<br />
Bob Garon and Dominic Berardino. Topics include: St. Michael<br />
and the Mighty Holy Angels and Lessons from Prayer<br />
Warrior Saints. Cost: $25/person through Oct. 9, $30/<br />
person after, includes lunch. For more information, email<br />
spirit@scrc.org.<br />
■ SUNDAY, OCTOBER 15<br />
Virtual Diaconate Information Day. 2-4 p.m. To register,<br />
email Deacon Melecio Zamora at dmz<strong>20</strong>11@la-archdiocese.org.<br />
■ TUESDAY, OCTOBER 17<br />
Missionary Childhood Association Mass. Cathedral of<br />
Our Lady of the Angels, 555 W. Temple St., Los Angeles,<br />
10 a.m.-1 p.m. <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> theme: “Hearts on fire, feet on the<br />
move.” For more information, visit lacatholics.org/catholicla-events.<br />
■ FRIDAY, OCTOBER <strong>20</strong><br />
Cloistered Carmelites Auxiliary Holiday Luncheon. Holy<br />
Family Church Msgr. Connolly Hall, 1501 Fremont Ave.,<br />
South Pasadena, 10:30 a.m. boutique and social hour,<br />
12 p.m. luncheon. Includes treasure sale, nuns specialty<br />
breads, candy nuts, handmade items, plants, and holiday<br />
gift items. Cost: $35 donation/person. RSVP to Kathy<br />
Cardoza at 626-570-9012 by Oct. 10. Send checks to Cloistered<br />
Carmelite Nuns Auxiliary, 710 Lindaraxa Park South,<br />
Alhambra, CA, 91801.<br />
■ SATURDAY, OCTOBER 21<br />
San Gabriel Regional Congress <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong>. Bishop Amat High<br />
School, 14301 Fairgrove Ave., La Puente. For more information,<br />
visit lacatholics.org/catholic-la-events.<br />
Items for the calendar of events are due four weeks prior to the date of the event. They may be emailed to calendar@angelusnews.com.<br />
All calendar items must include the name, date, time, address of the event, and a phone number for additional information.<br />
<strong>October</strong> 6, <strong><strong>20</strong>23</strong> • ANGELUS • 33