You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Yale Scientific<br />
THE NATION’S OLDEST COLLEGE SCIENCE PUBLICATION • ESTABLISHED IN 1894<br />
OCTOBER 2022<br />
VOL. 95 NO. 3 • $6.99<br />
14<br />
USING FIREFLIES TO<br />
COUNT HIV REPLICATION<br />
PERSONAL MATTERS<br />
12<br />
ON ABORTION<br />
THE WORLD<br />
16<br />
IN PROTEINS<br />
TURNING THE KNOTS<br />
19<br />
IN RESONATORS<br />
HOW TO GROW<br />
22<br />
A HEART
Nuclear Propulsion Officer Candidate<br />
Interested in getting<br />
involved with<br />
Yale<br />
Launch your career before you<br />
finish college – enter the Nuclear<br />
Propulsion Officer Candidate<br />
(NUPOC) Program. Future Nuclear<br />
Officers in the NUPOC program<br />
may earn up to $168,000.<br />
Benefits include:<br />
• Fully funded undergraduate<br />
college courses offered aboard<br />
all Navy ships<br />
• Comprehensive medical and<br />
dental care<br />
• 30 days of vacation with pay<br />
earned each year<br />
SCAN THE QR CODE &<br />
START YOUR JOURNEY<br />
Scientific<br />
for writing, production,<br />
web, business or<br />
outreach?<br />
Learn more at<br />
yalescientific.org/<br />
get-involved
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
VOL. 95 ISSUE NO. 3<br />
More articles online at www.yalescientific.org<br />
& https://medium.com/the-scope-yale-scientific-magazines-online-blog<br />
COVER<br />
14<br />
A R T<br />
I C L E<br />
Using Fireflies to Count HIV Replication<br />
Connie Tian<br />
The red queen hypothesis states that a species must constantly adapt and evolve for survival,<br />
because competing organisms are also evolving. To combat the evolving human immunodeficiency<br />
virus, we must continue to develop new retroviral drugs to treat affected individuals. Firefly<br />
bioluminescence could be key to developing new HIV treatments.<br />
12 Personal Matters on Abortion<br />
Van Anh Tran<br />
Sharing personal stories about abortion has been a powerful advocacy tool in the past to<br />
destigmatize abortions and to help others not feel alone in their experience. But a Yale study has<br />
found that the direct effects of storytelling on stigma may not be as clearcut.<br />
16 The World in Proteins<br />
Krishna Dasari<br />
Biologists have had to settle for proxy measures of cellular protein levels for decades. Now, an<br />
unexpected collaboration between an evolutionary biologist and a protein biologist has paved the<br />
way to study biodiversity and evolution at the level of the proteins themselves.<br />
19 Turning the Knots in Resonators<br />
Yusuf Rasheed<br />
Our world and beyond is filled with oscillators—piano strings, air particles, and colliding<br />
comets—and thus, understanding how they resonate is critical. The Harris and Read Labs<br />
at Yale recently discovered how topological structures called knots and braids are essential<br />
to oscillators. This opens the door to improving any system that has them, including<br />
computers, radios, and watches.<br />
22 How to Grow a Heart<br />
Catherine Zheng<br />
Engineered heart tissues grown from stem cells are often used in cardiac research and studies to<br />
model a mature human heart. Researchers from Professor Campbell’s research group at Yale have<br />
developed a new protocol that significantly reduces the time required to produce these mature<br />
heart tissues.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 3
A TRUE LOVE STORY:<br />
MOSQUITOES X US<br />
&<br />
THE NOT SO FOREVER CHEMICALS<br />
By Matthew Zoerb<br />
In 2018, Robert Bilott filed a lawsuit against three major chemical<br />
companies, 3M, DuPont, and Chemours, on behalf of every<br />
American exposed to per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances<br />
(PFAS). PFAS are used in many water-resistant products ranging<br />
from waterproof jackets to non-stick pans. Since 1951, hundreds of<br />
thousands of tons of waste containing perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA),<br />
a specific type of PFAS, have been dumped into the Ohio River and<br />
spread throughout the global biosphere. The ongoing litigation<br />
alleges that these companies have spread PFAS into the bloodstreams<br />
of ninety-nine percent of Americans while withholding information<br />
about their harmful side effects. Unfortunately, PFASs are resistant to<br />
degradation, and due to their long-lasting environmental presence,<br />
they are known as “forever chemicals.”<br />
Traditional methods to break apart PFAS involve pressurized<br />
incineration at one-thousand degrees Celsius. However, these<br />
techniques are costly and can spread the toxic compound into the<br />
atmosphere. A team at Northwestern University and UCLA recently<br />
discovered a new method to decompose PFAS. The researchers<br />
noticed an irregularity among the chain of tightly-bound atom<br />
clusters: a hydroxyl group or a chemical group composed of<br />
oxygen bonded to a hydrogen atom. This group could be broken<br />
off when mixing PFAS with two common solvents: DMSO and<br />
sodium hydroxide. By targeting the weakest bond and sequentially<br />
disassembling the PFAS at only one hundred degrees Celsius, the<br />
study suggests it is possible to convert PFAS into environmentally<br />
harmless products efficiently. This technique has limitations<br />
since bulk quantities of DMSO are prohibitively expensive for<br />
widespread use. Still, this result suggests that pollution from PFAS<br />
may not truly be around “forever.”■<br />
By Lea Papa<br />
Mosquitoes are perhaps most well-known for causing 725,000<br />
human deaths annually and being extreme nuisances. The<br />
blood-suckers appear and are attracted to unique human<br />
odors. They then pierce human blood vessels and feed.<br />
The solution seems simple: to find a way to disable the<br />
mosquitoes’ sense of smell. However, according to a recent<br />
Rockefeller and Boston University study on the mosquito<br />
olfactory system, it may not be so straightforward. When<br />
researchers deleted chemoreceptors—channels on the<br />
mosquitoes’ cells stimulated by human odors—from the<br />
mosquito genome, they found that the mosquitoes were still<br />
attracted to humans.<br />
Typically, an animal’s olfactory neurons allow it to smell and<br />
express one type of chemoreceptor that detects one odor. In the<br />
mosquitoes’ case, researchers found that the antenna receptors<br />
detecting the human odor 1-octen-3-ol, a chemical in breath and<br />
sweat, are also stimulated by amines found on human skin and<br />
sweat. The expression of multiple chemoreceptor genes in olfactory<br />
neurons provides them with a fail-safe for finding human blood,<br />
even when their human-smelling sensors are blocked.<br />
For this reason, simply removing or blocking olfactory<br />
receptors from the mosquito genome will do little to prevent<br />
them from detecting humans. Still, this finding may be a step<br />
toward finally breaking free from the age-old relationship<br />
between humans and mosquitoes.■<br />
4 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
The Editor-in-Chief Speaks<br />
THE SCIENCE AND<br />
TECHNOLOGY OF HUMANITY<br />
Science may present itself as rigid and automated—it is easy to get lost in objective<br />
formulas, theorems, and conclusions. However, this issue of the Yale Scientific<br />
Magazine highlights that science is, at its core, a human endeavor done by<br />
humans and for humans. Behind each formula, theorem, and conclusion is a person<br />
and a story. We are honored to tell a few of these stories from Yale and beyond.<br />
Our cover article highlights research from the Yale School of Medicine that used<br />
fluorescence technology in an HIV pathway for the discovery of small molecule<br />
treatments for the disease, which affects over thirty-eight million people (pg.<br />
14). Our other stories range in scale. One study investigated the effect of sharing<br />
personal abortion experiences on stigma and advocacy (pg. 12). Another studied<br />
the connection between proteins and biodiversity, paving the way to understanding<br />
our evolutionary history in a novel way (pg. 16). At the cellular level, research<br />
on stem-cell maturation works to model mature human heart tissue, making<br />
strides in the fight against cardiac diseases (pg. 22). And in physics, research on<br />
the mathematic fundamentals of resonators has implications for many systems<br />
around us, from watches to computers. This project highlights the teamwork and<br />
human communication required for successful science (pg. 19).<br />
In our own backyard, the Yale community sees science interacting with<br />
humanity from various angles, highlighted by this issue’s profiles. At just twenty<br />
years old, Yale College sophomore Shervin Dehmoubed co-founded and runs<br />
EcoPackables, a company providing sustainable packaging—an example of<br />
science harnessed for social good (pg. 34). In Yale’s Chemistry department,<br />
third-year graduate student Tyler Myers makes it a priority to inspire interest in<br />
organic chemistry by putting students first (pg. 35).<br />
While the study of science will inevitably be filled with the objectives, humans<br />
bring subjectivity to the equation, the good and the bad. However, the competition,<br />
greed, and dishonesty often seen in scientific research and applications are<br />
overshadowed by empathy, passion, and an ambition to leave the world better<br />
than it was. Science and technology cannot be separated from humanity. For our<br />
aspiring scientists, we hope you carry these human values throughout your career<br />
and appreciate all aspects of human connection along the way.<br />
And to our very human <strong>YSM</strong> staff, masthead, readers, and advisors, we<br />
sincerely thank you for your continued support.<br />
About the Art<br />
Jenny Tan, Editor-in-Chief<br />
MASTHEAD<br />
October 2022 VOL. 95 NO. 3<br />
EDITORIAL BOARD<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
Managing Editors<br />
News Editor<br />
Features Editor<br />
Special Sections Editor<br />
Articles Editor<br />
Online Editors<br />
Copy Editors<br />
Scope Editors<br />
Website Editor<br />
PRODUCTION & DESIGN<br />
Production Manager<br />
Layout Editors<br />
Art Editor<br />
Cover Artist<br />
Photography Editor<br />
BUSINESS<br />
Publisher<br />
Operations Manager<br />
Advertising Manager<br />
Subscriptions Manager<br />
OUTREACH<br />
Synapse Presidents<br />
Synapse Vice President<br />
Synapse Outreach Coordinators<br />
Synapse Events Coordinator<br />
WEB<br />
Web Managers<br />
Head of Social Media Team<br />
Social Media Coordinators<br />
STAFF<br />
Sanya Abbasey<br />
Luna Aguilar<br />
Ricardo Ahumada<br />
William Archacki<br />
Dinesh Bojja<br />
Risha Chakraborty<br />
Kelly Chen<br />
Gia-Bao Dam<br />
Leah Dayan<br />
Chris Esneault<br />
Erin Foley<br />
Mia Gawth<br />
Simona Hausleitner<br />
Tamasen Hayward<br />
Katherine He<br />
Miriam Huerta<br />
Sofia Jacobson<br />
George Karadzhov<br />
Jenna Kim<br />
Catherine Kwon<br />
Charlotte Leakey<br />
Charlize Leon Mata<br />
Ximena Leyba Peralta<br />
Yurou Liu<br />
Samantha Liu<br />
Helena Lyng-Olsen<br />
Kaley Mafong<br />
Georgio Maroun<br />
Alexandra Martinez-<br />
Garcia<br />
Cindy Mei<br />
Lee Ngatia Muita<br />
Lea Papa<br />
Hiren Parekh<br />
Himani Pattisam<br />
Emily Poag<br />
Madeleine Popofsky<br />
Tony Potchernikov<br />
Zara Ranglin<br />
Yusuf Rasheed<br />
Alex Roseman<br />
Ilora Roy<br />
Ignacio Ruiz-Sanchez<br />
Noora Said<br />
Jenny Tan<br />
Tai Michaels<br />
Maria Fernanda Pacheco<br />
Madison Houck<br />
Alex Dong<br />
Sophia Li<br />
Cindy Kuang<br />
Ethan Olim<br />
Tori Sodeinde<br />
Breanna Brownson<br />
Hannah Han<br />
Kayla Yup<br />
Anna Calame<br />
Hannah Huang<br />
Meili Gupta<br />
Catherine Zheng<br />
Ann-Marie Abunyewa<br />
Brianna Fernandez<br />
Malia Kuo<br />
Anasthasia Shilov<br />
Jenny Wong<br />
Jared Gould<br />
Lauren Chong<br />
Sophia Burick<br />
Shudipto Wahed<br />
Krishna Dasari<br />
Lucy Zha<br />
Rayyan Darji<br />
Hannah Barsouk<br />
Risha Chakraborty<br />
Bella Xiong<br />
Katherine Moon<br />
Emily Shang<br />
Anavi Uppal<br />
Abigail Jolteus<br />
Elizabeth Watson<br />
Jamie Seu<br />
Pranet Sharma<br />
Kiera Suh<br />
Yamato Takabe<br />
Joey Tan<br />
Kara Tao<br />
Connie Tian<br />
Van Anh Tran<br />
Sheel Trivedi<br />
Robin Tsai<br />
Sherry Wang<br />
Elise Wilkins<br />
Aiden Wright<br />
Elizabeth Wu<br />
Nathan Wu<br />
Johnny Yue<br />
Iffat Zarif<br />
Hanwen Zhang<br />
Lawrence Zhao<br />
Celina Zhao<br />
Matthew Zoerb<br />
This issue’s cover depicts a firefly!<br />
Fireflies, beyond being a beautiful<br />
source of luminescence, have<br />
been used to study potential Rev<br />
inhibitors which may be used to<br />
create novel HIV antivirals.<br />
Anasthasia Shilov, Cover Artist<br />
The Yale Scientific Magazine (<strong>YSM</strong>) is published four times a year by Yale<br />
Scientific Publications, Inc. Third class postage paid in New Haven, CT<br />
06520. Non-profit postage permit number 01106 paid for May 19, 1927<br />
under the act of August 1912. ISN:0091-287. We reserve the right to edit<br />
any submissions, solicited or unsolicited, for publication. This magazine is<br />
published by Yale College students, and Yale University is not responsible<br />
for its contents. Perspectives expressed by authors do not necessarily reflect<br />
the opinions of <strong>YSM</strong>. We retain the right to reprint contributions, both text<br />
and graphics, in future issues as well as a non-exclusive right to reproduce<br />
these in electronic form. The <strong>YSM</strong> welcomes comments and feedback. Letters<br />
to the editor should be under two hundred words and should include the<br />
author’s name and contact information. We reserve the right to edit letters<br />
before publication. Please send questions and comments to yalescientific@<br />
yale.edu. Special thanks to Yale Student Technology Collaborative.
NEWS<br />
Ecology & Evolutionary Biology / Environmental Science<br />
HUMMINGBIRDS:<br />
MASTERS OF<br />
COLOR<br />
REPURPOSING<br />
THE URBAN<br />
FOREST<br />
BY SHEEL TRIVEDI<br />
BY ELISE WILKINS<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
What comes to mind when you think of hummingbirds?<br />
You might think of their rapid heart rate. Or maybe<br />
their lightning-fast wing speed. But hummingbirds<br />
have another superpower under their beak: color.<br />
Bird feathers, known as plumage, display many hues. Researchers<br />
at Yale University calculated the hummingbird plumage color<br />
gamut, a value representing the color diversity of hummingbird<br />
plumage as seen by other birds. Birds see ultraviolet and visible<br />
light, whereas humans can only see the latter, so human vision<br />
falls short when considering hummingbird plumage.<br />
Gabriela Venable (YC ’19), a researcher on the study, spent<br />
hours at the Peabody Museum and American Museum of Natural<br />
History using a spectrometer to gather colorful spectra from<br />
1,600 plumage patches on 114 hummingbird species. “We can<br />
plot the spectra into a [model accounting for bird vision] and<br />
calculate the volume from all the points in the model, and that<br />
can measure color diversity,” Venable said.<br />
The data revealed that the hummingbird gamut was, in some aspects,<br />
more diverse than the previously calculated gamut of all other birds<br />
combined. One justification points to hummingbird barbules, which<br />
are micro-structures in a feather. “[Barbules] allow [hummingbirds]<br />
to make saturated colors and many different color combinations,”<br />
Venable said. This strengthens hummingbird evolutionary benefits,<br />
like defending floral patches or attracting mates.<br />
Though they discovered new information about coloration<br />
mechanisms in birds, there is still work to be accomplished.<br />
As the first study targeting one family of birds, this research<br />
facilitates more in-depth analyses of plumage color diversity and<br />
increases the accuracy of the calculated avian color gamut. ■<br />
Trees in urban areas contribute to pollution control and<br />
enhance biodiversity. But what happens to dead leaves,<br />
fallen branches, and other forms of tree waste that<br />
pile up along curbs? Typically, tree waste is sent to landfills<br />
or incinerated, what experts call the “end-of-life” states. Each<br />
year, these methods release much of the twenty million metric<br />
tons of carbon generated by the urban forest as methane and<br />
carbon dioxide, contributing substantially to global warming.<br />
To explore the possibilities for circular utilization of tree<br />
waste, researchers at the Yao Lab at Yale studied five methods<br />
of tree waste repurposing. Researchers found that the<br />
optimal scenario consisted of composting leaf waste, selling<br />
lumber as logs or wood chips, and using residue to produce<br />
biochar—a substitute for traditional charcoal. Kai Lan, a<br />
postdoctoral associate on the study team, told the Yale School<br />
of the Environment, “This aligns with the circular economy<br />
concept—turning waste into something of value. But it’s not<br />
just traditional waste like paper and plastic. Tree waste is<br />
very important, too.” This valuable process can reduce global<br />
warming and eutrophication—when water sources become<br />
overrun with nutrients and algal growth, deteriorating water<br />
quality. Additionally, the benefits extend to stimulating the<br />
economy through lumber sales and the possibility of new jobs<br />
to facilitate tree waste management.<br />
While cities may see differing benefits depending on their<br />
abundance of tree waste, the study offers new insight into the<br />
benefits of implementing a circular economy in a surprising<br />
area, demonstrating that even plants in their “end-of-life” state<br />
still have much to contribute. ■<br />
6 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Medicine / Medicine & Biochemistry<br />
NEWS<br />
THE IMPACT OF<br />
YOUTH ARRESTS<br />
ON HEALTH IN<br />
T<br />
SOCIETY<br />
ZOMBIE CELLS<br />
BY JOHNNY YUE<br />
BY MIA GAWITH<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF DAVID ANDRIJEVIC<br />
Arrests and incarceration have been pertinent issues in<br />
society for decades. Destiny Tolliver, an assistant professor<br />
in the pediatrics department at the Boston University<br />
Chobanian & Avedisian School of Medicine, has recently<br />
discovered a startling correlation between arrests and health.<br />
Tolliver and her team analyzed data from the National Longitudinal<br />
Study of Adolescent to Adult Health, examining cohorts from 1994<br />
to 2018. They gathered information about participants’ sex, race,<br />
and ethnicity, as well as the timeline and occurrence of arrests and<br />
different physical and mental health measures, including clinical<br />
biomarkers for diseases such as hypertension and diabetes.<br />
Her analysis found that arrests made before the age of twenty-five<br />
were associated with higher rates of suicidal thoughts, depression,<br />
and worsening general health scores. On top of that, youth arrest<br />
and related policies didn’t impact all communities equally. “There<br />
are well-documented racial and socioeconomic disparities in who<br />
experiences arrest, with Black children and children in lowerincome<br />
households disproportionately impacted,” Tolliver said.<br />
Contributing to the problem is the minimum juvenile<br />
prosecution age, which is currently only ten for the state of<br />
Connecticut. “I think Connecticut can do more in this area by<br />
raising the minimum age at which children can be prosecuted<br />
in the juvenile court system to at least fourteen years of age, and<br />
instead focus on diverting youth to health-promoting systems in<br />
their communities,” Tolliver said.<br />
So what’s next? Many states have already implemented changes<br />
to decrease the number of young people who are arrested.<br />
Tolliver hopes to research the effects of these modifications on<br />
youth health to create a model for other states to follow. ■<br />
Images of the “living dead” linger in our minds: Frankenstein<br />
resurrecting his monster, zombies stumbling around with<br />
contorted limbs, and what seems to be a never-ending<br />
stream of episodes of “The Walking Dead”. But is it possible<br />
to bring a mammal back from the dead? A research team at<br />
the Yale School of Medicine says yes, at least on the cellular<br />
level. Using a new technology termed OrganEx, scientists<br />
have successfully restored cellular functions in dead pigs.<br />
A team of scientists explored the possibility of preventing<br />
cell death in large mammalian bodies. Per Yale University’s<br />
ethical guidelines, the scientists induced fatal cardiac arrest<br />
in female pigs. An hour after their death, these same pigs were<br />
hooked up to the OrganEx system, a two-part device equipped<br />
with oxygenation machines and a synthetic solution. Since<br />
cells do not die instantly, this technology allowed researchers<br />
to intervene during the cell death process and reverse it. The<br />
changes were remarkable: oxygen and metabolic levels went<br />
back to normal, circulation was restored, and organs showed<br />
fewer signs of damage than with previous technology.<br />
While not the key to zombies, this discovery answers<br />
important issues in healthcare. For David Andrijevic, a<br />
leading co-author from the department of neuroscience,<br />
the potential applications are staggering. “If you can<br />
recover the organs after loss of blood flow for so long, then<br />
we might actually increase an organ donor pool for organ<br />
transplantation,” Andrijevic said. Future developments will<br />
focus on expanding these results to the clinical setting.<br />
Perhaps zombies should take a hint from scientists—how<br />
else will fiction become a reality? ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 7
NEWS<br />
Chemistry / Physics<br />
Anthracene-phenol-pyridine<br />
(An-PhOH-Py) triad<br />
EXPANDING<br />
CHEMISTRY<br />
A novel fundamental<br />
chemical reaction opens<br />
door to new technologies<br />
BY GEORGE KARADZHOV<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY EMILY POAG<br />
Last August, a collaboration between the Hammes-Schiffer<br />
and Mayer groups at Yale and researchers from the<br />
Hammarström group at Uppsala University led to the<br />
discovery of a new fundamental photochemical reaction relevant<br />
to our understanding and application of chemistry.<br />
The finding follows unexpected results the groups observed in 2019<br />
when working with the motif anthracene-phenol-pyridine (An-PhOH-<br />
Py), which contains the three chemical groups connected by single<br />
bonds. The teams found that when different variations of the An-PhOH-<br />
Py motif are excited with light, only some of their molecules go through<br />
a known pathway: the molecule starts at the ground state, the anthracene<br />
subunit absorbs light energy, and that new energy promotes an electron<br />
to move from the phenol subunit to the excited anthracene (*An). At the<br />
same time, a proton transfers to the pyridine unit to form a new chargeseparate<br />
state (CSS). This CSS represents a different arrangement of<br />
charge and energy in the molecule that can be utilized later in reactions<br />
like photosynthesis. The researchers discovered that molecules return<br />
from the CSS to the ground state through a proton-coupled electron<br />
transfer (PCET) process that is slowed down by increasing the driving<br />
force. Surprisingly, the groups did not observe any CSS for certain<br />
variations of their molecules. Speculating that there was some other way<br />
for these molecules to react to light and yield a lower energy product,<br />
researchers computationally predicted and experimentally detected the<br />
formation of a local electron-proton transfer (LEPT) excited state in<br />
place of a CSS for some of their reagents.<br />
The LEPT itself isn’t new. A PhOH-Py molecule can be excited to<br />
trigger an excited-state proton transfer and give us a *PhOH-Py LEPT<br />
species. Similarly, the PhOH-Py fragment in the An-PhOH-Py triad<br />
can be excited to a LEPT state (*PhOH-Py). The direct transformation<br />
from the excited anthracene fragment in the An-PhOH-Py triad<br />
to the excited PhOH-Py fragment LEPT (as confirmed by further<br />
experiments), however, goes beyond existing theories, hinting at a new<br />
photochemical reaction responsible for these observations.<br />
With further research, it became clear that that was exactly the<br />
case! Researchers described a new reaction where a proton transfer<br />
within the PhOH subunit is coupled to an energy transfer from<br />
the *An to the PhOH subunit without a charge separation. Rather<br />
than the reaction involving proton and electron movement, it<br />
relies on a proton and energy moving throughout the molecule in<br />
a new way that had never been observed.<br />
This reaction, appropriately coined a proton-coupled energy<br />
transfer (PCEnT), also challenges our rules about light absorption<br />
and fluorescence. Since the energy to excite the LEPT state comes<br />
from the *An, the fluorescence energy from the *An has to match the<br />
absorption energy of the PhOH-Py. However, according to Coraline<br />
Tao, a senior PhD student in the Hammes-Schiffer Lab at the time<br />
of the project and now a postdoctoral researcher at the University<br />
of Pennsylvania, the observed fluorescence of LEPT from *An runs<br />
counter to expectation. “[LEPT’s fluorescence [is] counterintuitive<br />
because [the] energy giver has to have enough energy to charge the<br />
acceptor, but here they don’t,” Tao said. Where does that extra energy<br />
come from? The groups show that the proton transfer can physically<br />
reconfigure the molecule, making this fluorescence possible. The<br />
details of how the transferring proton couples with the energy transfer<br />
process, however, are still unclear, prompting questions about how<br />
spatial relationships contribute to energy movement across molecules.<br />
Often, fundamental discoveries have a curious tendency to pop up<br />
in many unexpected places—think the Schrödinger equation used in<br />
economics. This is no different. PCEnT describes a powerful process<br />
that could have significant future applications. Since the LEPT product<br />
is closer in energy to the *An intermediate than other reagents we<br />
could use to get the same thing, there is now a way of executing this<br />
chemical transformation using lower excitation energy. According to<br />
Tao, this could have important implications for designing molecules<br />
for solar dyes, solar panels, and other technologies to store and<br />
use photochemical energy. PCEnT may also already be present in<br />
photosensitive biological systems, and we haven’t thought to look!<br />
It could be the case that differences between PCET, PCEnT, and<br />
other photochemical reactions serve as regulatory mechanisms for<br />
biological pathways. This new knowledge of PCEnT also allows<br />
researchers to access new configurations and arrangements of<br />
molecules that could be synthetically or technologically useful. ■<br />
8 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Astrophysics<br />
NEWS<br />
A TALE OF<br />
TWO GALAXIES<br />
An unexpected collision<br />
behind the formation of<br />
two dwarf galaxies<br />
BY HANWEN ZHANG<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Galactic collisions usually resemble a carefully<br />
choreographed ballroom dance: picture a pair of galaxies<br />
pinwheeling into each other’s arms, their gravitational<br />
centers merging together. But in the case of the two dwarf galaxies<br />
DF2 and DF4—initialed in honor of the Dragonfly telescope that<br />
captured them—researchers suspect the cause of their formation<br />
might have been closer to a collision between two bullets.<br />
The van Dokkum Lab, a Yale astrophysics research group, proposed<br />
a bullet-dwarf collision model which describes an event where<br />
a pair of galaxies run into each other with enough speed to form<br />
two entirely new ones in their wake. The model is a culmination of<br />
years of observation and careful telescopic tracking. Van Dokkum’s<br />
research team first discovered DF2 and DF4 sometime around 2018.<br />
Both galaxies are members of a space neighborhood roughly sixtyseven<br />
million light years away from Earth.<br />
What surprised the group was the virtual absence of any dark matter<br />
in both DF2 and DF4. The researchers were baffled by the speeds of the<br />
galaxies’ stars. “They [had] very low velocity dispersion, which means<br />
that […] these galaxies don’t contain a lot of dark matter,” said Zili Shen,<br />
a graduate researcher in the lab. The intensity of gravity directly dictates<br />
the motion of stars, and since most of a galaxy’s gravitational force comes<br />
from dark matter, both DF4 and DF2 must be strikingly devoid of it.<br />
Dark-matter deficient galaxies are uncommon—they are so<br />
rare, in fact, that DF4 and DF2 remain just a few of the handful<br />
scientists currently know. This is because most galaxies depend<br />
on dark matter for their creation. Clumps of dark matter—a<br />
substance virtually undetectable except by its gravitational<br />
presence—often serve as whirlpool-like centers that collapse<br />
clouds of gas. There, temperatures can rise to levels nearly double<br />
the sun’s surface temperature, giving birth to a sizzling new galaxy.<br />
Without dark matter to create its stars, DF4 and DF2 must have<br />
come into existence following a script of their own. Analyzing the<br />
data, the team reasoned that two-parent dwarf galaxies met side-on<br />
in a high-speed collision, generating an extraordinary amount of force<br />
that compressed their clouds of gas. This might have been enough to<br />
form DF2 and DF4. “High-speed collision of dwarf galaxies is a viable<br />
explanation for galaxies without dark matter,” Shen said.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
Under normal conditions, the comparatively lower speeds<br />
would have trapped the dark matter of both parent galaxies<br />
and caused them to merge. But for DF4 and DF2, the collision<br />
likely occurred with so much velocity that the two haloes of dark<br />
matter simply bypassed each other. With nothing left to bind<br />
their constituent star clusters together, the once-organized parent<br />
galaxies scattered apart. The result: diffuse clouds of gas and stars<br />
strewn across space, the DF2/DF4 duo among them.<br />
Their data seems to confirm this. The group’s most recent<br />
paper identified a linear arrangement of seven to eleven dimlylit<br />
objects, exactly the kind of structure they would expect to<br />
find from a cosmic collision like this. Most structures were also<br />
abnormally large for their relative brightness, offering further<br />
evidence that they might be the galactic shrapnel of interest.<br />
But like the star clusters of newly formed galaxies, the model<br />
remains hazy. At least two other competing theories have<br />
attempted to explain this phenomenon. One suggests that DF4<br />
and DF2 simply arose after a normal dwarf galaxy drifted too<br />
close to a larger galaxy and lost its dark matter. It fails, though,<br />
to explain the presence of two dark-matter deficient galaxies.<br />
The second—the tidal dwarf theory—proposes that they arose<br />
from gas that was stripped off from larger galaxies, but the lab<br />
has since disproven this through the age and metallicity of both<br />
galaxies’ constituent stars.<br />
For now, the bullet-dwarf collision remains a tentative—if<br />
attractively convincing—hypothetical scenario. “This is mostly<br />
a theory that explains the data we already have,” Shen said.<br />
Confirming the bullet-dwarf collision will require more empirical<br />
evidence, which includes calculations of the individual clusters’<br />
velocities and positions. The group has already started processing<br />
data from the Hubble Telescope to further validate their theory.<br />
Studying dwarf galaxies like DF2 and DF4 has its benefits.<br />
Shen explained that dwarf galaxies, being almost one thousand<br />
times smaller than our Milky Way, are relatively easier to model.<br />
That doesn’t make piecing together our strange cosmic past any<br />
simpler, but it might just help reveal new ways of being and of<br />
becoming that we had previously not known. ■<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 9
NEWS<br />
Molecular Biology<br />
THE<br />
MOLECULAR<br />
CLOCK<br />
Modifying the dynamics<br />
of cellular movement<br />
BY CHRISTOPHER ESNEAULT<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY JESSICA LE<br />
Albert Einstein once said: “The distinction between the<br />
past, present, and future is only a stubbornly persistent<br />
illusion.” Time is an idea that has been talked about and<br />
debated for centuries. For physicists, philosophers, and others in<br />
between, the meaning of time and space and temporality has kept,<br />
and will continue to keep, people wondering.<br />
Though some may believe that judgment of time is only left<br />
to complex, multicellular organisms, that is not quite true. In<br />
fact, researchers in Andre Levchenko’s lab at the Yale University<br />
Systems Biology Institute are currently looking into the cellular<br />
mechanisms that drive the molecular clock: a new way of<br />
conceptualizing time on a cellular level.<br />
Researchers found this clock is controlled by two negative<br />
feedback mechanisms mediated by microtubule polymerization,<br />
GEF-H1, and GTPase RhoA. GTPase RhoA is a Ras homolog<br />
family member A that regulates actin reorganization, a mechanism<br />
that plays a role in cell migration and motility. Sung Hoon Lee, a<br />
postdoctoral researcher from the Levchenko Lab, said that though<br />
his background is actually in electrical engineering, he wanted to<br />
help build a systems-level understanding of a biological network.<br />
Why do cells actually migrate? Lee said that it is because cells are<br />
dynamic in nature, and thus, cells migrate, proliferate, communicate,<br />
and die. For example, in the case of extreme and unwanted cell<br />
dynamism, metastatic cancer cells migrate throughout the body to<br />
invade other tissues. Levchenko joined in this explanation, saying<br />
that “when an organism develops, there are many cases of cells<br />
undergoing movements to undergo relocalization.” This dynamic<br />
cellular movement and reorganization rarely occur in adults, where<br />
cells are generally pretty settled in the body. However, “the general<br />
idea for the cells is to figure out how to move and successfully<br />
relocalize to the desired location,” Levchenko explained.<br />
While cell movement is normally studied in two-dimensional settings<br />
like Petri dishes, very little research has dug into the mechanisms of<br />
movement in three-dimensional settings like the body. In these threedimensional<br />
settings, cellular activity is controlled by a squeezing motion<br />
from the posterior end of the cell that propels the cell forward. However,<br />
little is understood about how this squeezing movement operates.<br />
Lee found that cells navigate the three-dimensional<br />
extracellular matrix—the complex network of molecules and<br />
proteins that forms the connective tissues between cells—using<br />
a periodic squeezing movement. The molecular clock controls<br />
the frequency of these squeezing movements and, consequently,<br />
the speed of cell movement. Furthermore, this clock is<br />
mediated by two coupled negative feedback loops. “Microtubule<br />
polymerization is an important component that can enhance<br />
the abundance of the molecule GEF-H1,” Lee said. This rapid<br />
polymerization of tubulin inside the cell underpins the dynamics<br />
of cell movement. “Microtubule polymerization can also inhibit<br />
the activity of GEF-H1. These two feedback loops modulate the<br />
molecular clock’s frequency,” Lee continued.<br />
Furthermore, Lee found that cellular migration was mediated<br />
by cyclic changes in a small molecule called GTPase RhoA. And<br />
this GTPase RhoA is dependent on the activity and abundance<br />
of GEF-H1. By understanding the players underpinning cell<br />
migration, Lee was able to manipulate the frequency of the<br />
clock and make cells move, in some cases, three times as fast as<br />
they normally would. Funnily enough, Levchenko said, “For a<br />
while, the American Society for Cell Biology had an annual cell<br />
race where you could put engineered cells on race tracks and<br />
compete with other cells. While the competition does not take<br />
place anymore, Sung Hoon would likely win the competition.”<br />
And while the research conducted by Lee has proven valuable<br />
in our present understanding of the dynamics of cell movement,<br />
the implications of his findings are arguably even more valuable.<br />
Through perturbation of the molecular clock’s frequency, they<br />
can potentially find new ways of controlling the speed of cell<br />
movement. In theory, manipulation of this clock could speed up<br />
the rate at which the repair of cell tissues occurs. Conversely,<br />
in the case of cancer metastasis, this same clock that controls<br />
aggressive tumor cells could be slowed down.<br />
Looking towards the future, it is clear that, with the help of<br />
the scientific progress made by Lee and Levchenko, the field<br />
is on the brink of tremendous possibilities regarding systems<br />
biology and the molecular clock. ■<br />
10 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Applied Math<br />
NEWS<br />
SOLVING THE<br />
UNSOLVABLE<br />
A novel approach to<br />
calculating a key<br />
Fourier series<br />
BY EMILY SHANG<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Have you ever wondered about the math behind a radio signal?<br />
Or telephones? Scientists who study electromagnetic<br />
physics and mathematics constantly are: their work is<br />
founded upon partial differential equations. These equations are<br />
unlike the differential equations we encounter in calculus: they<br />
are three-dimensional and extremely difficult to solve because<br />
they vary with both time and space, even for simple shapes. As a<br />
result, designing cell phone antennas and radio telescopes is extremely<br />
challenging. To solve these wave equations, scientists use<br />
a technique that separates the part which varies with time and the<br />
part which varies with space, also known as “Helmholtz’s equation.”<br />
However, Helmholtz’s equation is still a differential equation,<br />
which is hard to solve. Scientists have been using a trick called<br />
Green’s functions to solve these sorts of problems for over a hundred<br />
years. Green’s functions are powerful techniques that let you<br />
solve a differential equation by computing an integral, making the<br />
solution easier to attain. However, even though they can convert<br />
these problems from differential equations into integral equations,<br />
they still have to do it in 3D, which is extremely hard.<br />
However, for certain types of symmetric objects, like a radar<br />
dish, there is a trick that turns a 3D problem into a 2D problem.<br />
However, it comes at a price. The Green’s function would have<br />
to be split up into its individual frequencies using the Fourier<br />
series technique. For each frequency, a very difficult integral,<br />
called “the modal Green’s function,” would have to be computed.<br />
This Green’s function is tricky: it oscillates incredibly quickly<br />
between massive positive and negative values, but somehow,<br />
they all end up adding up to something tiny. Any attempt to<br />
estimate the integral by “adding it up” essentially adds and subtracts<br />
infinity trillions of times, causing so much error that the<br />
estimate is useless. Scientists have been struggling with how to<br />
compute this integral since the 1960s.<br />
To handle difficult integrals, mathematicians will often solve<br />
them using complex analysis, the field of math that studies imaginary<br />
numbers. Real numbers are plotted on the “real line,” ranging<br />
from negative to positive infinity. In contrast, complex numbers<br />
have a real and imaginary components, meaning they live<br />
in a 2D space called the “complex plane.” Amazingly, for many<br />
functions, the integral can either be computed along the real line<br />
or as a “contour integral” through the 2D complex plane, a technique<br />
invented by the mathematician Augustin-Louis Cauchy in<br />
the nineteenth century. By carefully choosing the contour, sometimes<br />
those integrals can be made very simple. For example, some<br />
functions oscillate between negative one and positive one on the<br />
real line, but in the complex plane, they never oscillate.<br />
For decades, scientists had written off using this contour trick<br />
because no matter which contour they picked, part of the Green’s<br />
function wildly exploded and oscillated. James Garritano, along<br />
with his mentors Yuval Kluger, Rokhlin, and Kirill at the Kluger<br />
Lab in the Yale School of Medicine, recently overcame the oscillations<br />
of Green’s function by ignoring the real line and integrating<br />
it into the complex plane by using a contour invented in 2010 by a<br />
scientist named Mats Gustafsson. The key idea of their paper was<br />
to replace part of the Green’s function with an approximation that<br />
does not grow in the complex plane. Then, they could use Gustafsson’s<br />
contour and avoid wild oscillations.<br />
“Dr. Kluger and Dr. Rokhlin, who I work for, are both famous for<br />
creating fast algorithms to solve problems in physics and genomics,”<br />
Garritano said. For example, with his student Leslie Greengard,<br />
Rokhlin created the fast multipole algorithm, named one<br />
of the top ten algorithms of the twentieth century. It became the<br />
basis for a wide range of physics simulations ranging from modeling<br />
gravitational bodies to electrons. Kluger recently developed<br />
the fastest method for clustering data in single-cell experiments by<br />
using insights from computational physics to accelerate one of the<br />
key algorithms of data science.<br />
This work has paved the way to create ultra-fast physics solvers<br />
for rotationally symmetric objects such as antennas and radar dishes.<br />
Also, their work showed that Cauchy’s contour-trick could be<br />
applied to more problems than previously thought. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 11
FOCUS<br />
Women's Health<br />
PERSONAL MATTERS<br />
ON ABORTION<br />
What we can learn<br />
from abortion<br />
storytelling and its<br />
impact on stigma<br />
BY VAN<br />
ANH TRAN<br />
On June 22, 2022, the United States<br />
Supreme Court overruled Roe v.<br />
Wade, which provided constitutional<br />
protection for the right to abortion for nearly<br />
half a century. Two months after the decision<br />
was overturned, over twenty million women<br />
in the United States lost access to elective<br />
abortions in their home states.<br />
The New York Times published a piece<br />
sharing the stories of people who got abortions<br />
before Roe stating that an important part of<br />
advocating for abortion is learning from the<br />
experiences of Americans who have had<br />
unsafe abortions before the court decision. On<br />
Twitter, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-<br />
Cortez trended for sharing her personal<br />
sexual assault story during an abortion rally.<br />
In the video, she told the crowd that she was<br />
glad to know she at least had a choice if she<br />
did end up being pregnant because of readily<br />
accessible abortion care in New York City.<br />
In 2017, Abigail Cutler YSPH '19, a doctor<br />
and clinical instructor in the Department of<br />
Obstetrics and Gynecology at Yale School of<br />
Medicine, noticed the increased prevalence<br />
of abortion storytelling in social media<br />
campaigns. Many of these campaigns’<br />
messages were to normalize abortions and<br />
denounce the stigma associated with it so that<br />
those who had or were seeking care feel like<br />
they are not alone in their experience.<br />
These campaigns inspired Cutler<br />
to examine whether forms of public<br />
storytelling—in which storytellers don’t<br />
necessarily know their audience—could<br />
decrease community-level abortion<br />
stigma or the stigma people feel towards<br />
others who seek or have abortions.<br />
This stigma commonly manifests as<br />
discrimination against<br />
people who have abortions<br />
and structural barriers<br />
against abortion care.<br />
Evidence from years of<br />
polling research shows clearly<br />
that the public tends to be most<br />
supportive of abortions involving<br />
rape, incest, threats to maternal life, and fetal<br />
anomalies—none of which reflect the most<br />
common reasons people seek an abortion.<br />
“We know these stories are already effective<br />
for warming public opinion,” Cutler said.<br />
However, she endeavored to know whether<br />
“non-exceptional” stories—stories centered<br />
on the most common circumstances for<br />
seeking abortion—would impact the hearts<br />
and minds of the public.<br />
Formation of the Study<br />
ART BY<br />
LUNA<br />
AGUILAR<br />
To test this, Cutler’s team conducted<br />
a randomized trial on a large, nationally<br />
representative set of U.S. adults selected<br />
using the Ipsos Knowledge Panel. They<br />
showed the subjects three videos of people<br />
sharing their abortion experiences. They<br />
then measured community-level stigma<br />
immediately after showing the videos and<br />
then in a three-month follow-up.<br />
12 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Women's Health<br />
FOCUS<br />
The authors developed a conceptual<br />
model to measure community-level abortion<br />
stigma and its facets. This model measures<br />
stigma through three scales: one primary<br />
scale measuring judgment (Community<br />
Abortion Attitudes Scale), one measuring<br />
how the context of an abortion affects opinion<br />
(Reproductive Experiences and Events Scale),<br />
and one measuring expectations of silence and<br />
secrecy surrounding abortion experiences<br />
(Community Level Abortion Stigma Scale).<br />
The crucial part of this experiment was the<br />
selection of the three videos of people telling<br />
their experiences, which would be shown to<br />
the audience. Cutler recognized that, as a cis<br />
white woman leading a research team of white<br />
women, the group needed to be mindful of<br />
how their biases could adversely affect their<br />
study design. They formed an advisory<br />
board with racially and ethnically<br />
diverse members with professional<br />
or personal backgrounds in<br />
abortion stigma and storytelling,<br />
including several non-profit<br />
abortion organizations.<br />
The essential qualities<br />
welcomed an intersectional<br />
analysis and would include<br />
speaking to the common<br />
reasons for seeking abortions,<br />
the ease or boundaries faced<br />
with healthcare, and whether the<br />
speaker told their story in a fluid and<br />
thoughtful manner. They sought to curate<br />
videos that would give the viewer a different<br />
perspective on abortions. “We wanted to<br />
make the watcher look at abortion in a<br />
different way, in a way not highlighted every<br />
day in the media,” Cutler said.<br />
After developing a scoring matrix for the<br />
videos based on these essential qualities, the<br />
advisory board members selected three final<br />
videos to showcase various abortion stories.<br />
One video talked about a parent who had<br />
multiple abortions before. Another video<br />
was about a woman who spoke about the<br />
barriers to obtaining an abortion in Texas and<br />
who traveled to California for the procedure.<br />
The final video was on a Latina woman who<br />
attempted to acquire birth control through<br />
the military and was facing difficulties doing<br />
so. Before she got deployed, she became<br />
pregnant. She spoke about how she made the<br />
decision to get an abortion in the context of<br />
her family and her values.<br />
“People don’t make these decisions<br />
in a vacuum, they don’t make it by<br />
themselves,” Cutler emphasized. These<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
videos were chosen because they reflected<br />
the intersectionality and politicized nature<br />
of the abortion conversation through real,<br />
lived experiences of the most common<br />
demographics that seek an abortion.<br />
Reflecting on the Results<br />
The results of the study showed that<br />
intervention exposures to these three videos<br />
both immediately after watching and three<br />
months later showed no association with<br />
decreased stigma by the judgment scale<br />
(CAAS) or the silence and secrecy scale<br />
(CLASS). This means that exposure to these<br />
three different abortion stories did not<br />
lower community-level stigma. Although<br />
“Abortion storytelling can<br />
also help other people<br />
who have abortions who<br />
feel less alone.<br />
happen to see that<br />
”<br />
story<br />
there was a decrease in stigma in the<br />
context scale (REES) immediately after<br />
watching the videos, it was not significant<br />
after a three-month follow-up.<br />
This study approached the question of<br />
non-intimate storytelling and communitylevel<br />
stigma from a neutral standpoint,<br />
meaning that stories were not chosen<br />
because of their potential to elicit a response<br />
but to represent non-exceptional abortion<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
stories. Furthermore, lack of an effect could<br />
mean that intervention exposure could be<br />
dose-dependent and that a single exposure<br />
to storytelling would not be enough for<br />
a long-term change in community-level<br />
stigma but rather should be more frequent<br />
and prolonged. For instance, a social media<br />
campaign, such as #ShoutYourAbortion,<br />
could prolong exposure to abortion stories<br />
over the period of time that it is trending.<br />
Furthermore, newspapers such as The<br />
New York Times creating a section called<br />
Abortion News could also keep the abortion<br />
conversation present in the public’s mind.<br />
“I think it’s important to acknowledge<br />
the limitations of this study,” Cutler said, “I<br />
don’t think a takeaway from the findings of<br />
this study is that abortion storytelling does<br />
not have the power to change hearts<br />
and minds. It was one study, and<br />
it was conducted several years<br />
ago. The legal landscape is really<br />
different now.” She mentions that<br />
repeating this study, especially<br />
now post-Dobbs, would be<br />
interesting to see.<br />
Cutler emphasized that the<br />
results of this study do not mean<br />
that abortion storytelling isn’t<br />
important for other reasons. It<br />
is essential to recognize that the<br />
purpose of abortion storytelling<br />
is not just to change public opinion.<br />
People who decide to disclose their abortion<br />
experiences to the general public do so for<br />
various reasons, such as to feel empowered<br />
and take the reigns over an experience that<br />
ought to be discussed more.<br />
“Abortion storytelling can also help other<br />
people who have abortions who happen to<br />
see that story to feel less alone," Cutler said.<br />
"And that is arguably equally, if not more<br />
important, than changing public opinion.” ■<br />
VAN ANH TRAN<br />
VAN ANH TRAN (SY '24) is a Molecular, Cellular, and Developmental Biology major from South<br />
Windsor, CT. She has been involved in <strong>YSM</strong> since her first year at Yale. Outside of <strong>YSM</strong>, she is<br />
involved in Yale Rotaract Club, volunteers at HAPPY and Saint Francis Hospital, and interns at<br />
the National Alzheimer’s Buddies organization. Van Anh has done IBD research at the Abraham<br />
lab in the Yale School of Medicine. Van Anh enjoys watching movies with her friends, trying<br />
different types of coffee, and hanging out with her family.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Dr. Abigail Cutler for her time and enthusiasm about her<br />
research on abortion stigma.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
Cutler, A. S., Lundsberg, L. S., White, M. A., Stanwood, N. L., & Gariepy, A. M. (2021). Characterizing<br />
community-level abortion stigma in the United States. Contraception, 104(3), 305–313. https://<br />
doi.org/10.1016/j.contraception.2021.03.021<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 13
FOCUS<br />
Medicine Biology<br />
USING FIREFLIES<br />
TO MEASURE HIV<br />
REPLICATION<br />
Co-opting bioluminescence for retroviral drug development<br />
BY CONNIE TIAN<br />
Have you ever seen a field of fireflies? If<br />
you have, you were probably thinking<br />
about how magical the experience was.<br />
Or maybe you were wondering how these insects<br />
somehow evolved the ability to bioluminescence.<br />
But chances are you were not thinking about how<br />
firefly luminescence would be a great tool for<br />
measuring protein-protein interactions.<br />
A History of Co-opting Bioluminescence<br />
The phenomenon of bioluminescence,<br />
which is the biochemical emission of light by<br />
living organisms, has fascinated humans for<br />
millennia and has been exploited for just as<br />
long. Roman naturalist Pliny the Elder wrote<br />
that one could create a torch by rubbing the<br />
slime of a luminous jellyfish onto a walking<br />
stick. In the 17th century, physician Georg<br />
Rumphius documented how indigenous<br />
peoples of Indonesia used bioluminescent<br />
fungi as flashlights in forests. Then, in 1875,<br />
Raphel Dubois reported the first in vitro<br />
demonstration of bioluminescence.<br />
Dubois made two extracts of the<br />
bioluminescent clam Pholas, one with hot<br />
water and another using cold water. The light<br />
in the cold sample eventually disappeared.<br />
Furthermore, when he heated the hot sample<br />
to near boiling, the glow stopped. But when he<br />
mixed those two samples together, he observed<br />
light emission once again. Dubois concluded<br />
from his observations that a key aspect of<br />
bioluminescence comes from a heat-stable<br />
organic molecule he named luciferin and an<br />
enzyme called luciferase. Today, we understand<br />
that luciferase is an enzyme that catalyzes a<br />
light-producing reaction in the presence of<br />
oxygen and the naturally occurring substrate,<br />
luciferin. But scientific interest<br />
in the chemistry of the luciferinluciferase<br />
reaction didn’t stop there.<br />
Currently, there are dozens of<br />
assays that rely on the activity of<br />
luciferase enzymes. For example, the split<br />
firefly luciferase complementation assay<br />
(SLCA) uses bioluminescence to quantify<br />
protein-protein interactions within<br />
living cells. The assay uses modified<br />
firefly luciferase (FFLUC) split into two<br />
pieces, named N-FFLUC and C-FFLUC.<br />
On their own, the two pieces of FFLUC<br />
are inactive and do not luminesce.<br />
When the N-FFLUC and C-FFLUC are<br />
brought into close proximity in the presence<br />
of oxygen, ATP, and magnesium, the FFLUC<br />
will oxidize to produce light. This system<br />
can be adapted to measure the interactions<br />
between any two small proteins by fusing<br />
each of the two interacting proteins to the<br />
N or C terminus of luciferase. When the<br />
two proteins bind and interact, it brings the<br />
N-FFLUC and C-FFLUC close together so<br />
that FFLUC will luminesce. The luminescence<br />
can then be quantified with a machine called<br />
a luminometer, which will provide insight<br />
into the level of protein interaction.<br />
Human Immunodeficiency Virus<br />
Recently, Yale undergraduate Tucker<br />
Hansen YC '22 and his mentor Richard<br />
Sutton developed an SLCA to quantify the<br />
Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1<br />
(HIV-1) Rev-Rev interaction. The assay<br />
will identify inhibitors that specifically<br />
prevent the Rev-Rev interaction of HIV-1<br />
to stop infections.<br />
H u m a n<br />
immunodeficiency virus<br />
(HIV) is a virus that attacks the body’s<br />
immune system. While there are two common<br />
subtypes, HIV-1 and HIV-2, most people<br />
living with HIV have HIV-1. The virus infects<br />
CD4+ T cells, a type of white blood cell also<br />
known as helper T cells. These cells help fight<br />
infection by triggering the immune system to<br />
destroy pathogens in the body. In active CD4+<br />
T cells, infection is caused by the insertion of<br />
the viral DNA into the host genome and its<br />
subsequent expression into new viral particles.<br />
When left untreated, HIV-1 replication causes<br />
progressive loss of CD4+ T cells, raising the<br />
infected individual’s susceptibility to infectious<br />
diseases that would not usually cause illness in<br />
a healthy individual.<br />
There are currently over thirty-eight million<br />
people living with HIV-1. Most patients<br />
can maintain undetectable viral loads and<br />
near-normal life expectancy with the help of<br />
antiretroviral medications that inhibit HIV-<br />
14 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Medicine Biology<br />
FOCUS<br />
1 replication. There are currently dozens of<br />
FDA-approved medications against HIV-1,<br />
including protease, reverse transcriptase, and<br />
integrase inhibitors. So why would there be a<br />
need for more inhibitors?<br />
A Case for New Inhibitors of Chronic<br />
Diseases<br />
Viral suppression through existing<br />
medications enables immune recovery and<br />
the near elimination of the risk of developing<br />
AIDS, the more severe and life-threatening<br />
stage of HIV infection. However, due to drug<br />
resistance, some patients do not respond to<br />
the existing medications well.<br />
HIV-1 drug resistance is caused by changes<br />
in the genetic structure of HIV-1 that interfere<br />
with the ability of medications to block viral<br />
replication. Since RNA viruses such as HIV-1<br />
have an especially high mutation rate that allows<br />
for quicker evolution, all retroviral drugs risk<br />
becoming ineffective due to the emergence of<br />
drug-resistant viral strains. Furthermore, drug<br />
resistance can more easily arise if there is poor<br />
adherence to prescribed medications. “As with<br />
any chronic disease, there is always a need for<br />
improvement in current medications, as well as<br />
the development of new antivirals,” Hansen said.<br />
Revving Engines<br />
The Rev protein is highly conserved in<br />
all subtypes of HIV and is necessary for<br />
transporting copies of viral RNA out of the<br />
nucleus of the host cell. Without Rev, HIV<br />
would not be able to replicate in its host. An<br />
essential property of Rev activity is that it must<br />
multimerize on the Rev-Response Element<br />
(RRE) of HIV RNA to successfully export<br />
that RNA from the nucleus to the cytoplasm<br />
of the host. This means that multiple Rev<br />
proteins must interact with each other to<br />
form a multimer. Since the multimerization<br />
of Rev is key to its mechanism of action, it<br />
could serve as a small molecule drug target.<br />
Sutton, an expert studying HIV for years,<br />
knew that the Rev protein was essential to<br />
HIV survival. But there are currently no<br />
HIV antiviral drugs that target the Rev<br />
protein. “[A Rev inhibitor could] be a firstin-class<br />
antiviral,” Sutton said.<br />
Hansen began his project by developing an<br />
SLCA that could quantify Rev-Rev interaction<br />
in cells. Hansen fused each of the luciferase<br />
domains, NLUC and CLUC, to a Rev protein.<br />
The fused protein was created by genetically<br />
engineering a fusion gene that combined the<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
sequence of the specific luciferase domain<br />
with the sequence of the Rev protein. Through<br />
a series of experiments, Hansen and Sutton<br />
eventually developed a highly sensitive screen<br />
for measuring Rev-Rev interaction. When Rev<br />
proteins were close enough to multimerize,<br />
the NLUC and CLUC would be brought close<br />
enough to luminesce. This assay works inside<br />
and outside of cells. Thus, even when using just<br />
the inner contents of cells, the assay can still<br />
accurately quantify Rev-Rev interaction.<br />
The goal of developing this assay is to find a<br />
small molecule inhibitor that can disrupt the<br />
Rev-Rev interaction. Hansen demonstrated that<br />
this assay could help by testing whether mutant<br />
Revs, which would inhibit the wild-type Rev<br />
interaction, reduce luminescence levels in the<br />
assay. Performing the assay with mutated Rev<br />
proteins fused to NLUC and CLUC resulted in<br />
much lower luminescence, indicating that this<br />
SLCA can be used to screen for an inhibitor that<br />
disrupts the Rev-Rev interaction. Similar to how<br />
a mutant Rev would not be able to multimerize,<br />
a putative inhibitor would be able to disrupt<br />
this interaction and result in a much lower<br />
luminescence reading. Thus, researchers could<br />
use this system to test an unlimited number<br />
of small molecules to see whether any can<br />
effectively prevent Rev-Rev interactions without<br />
being an inhibitor of the luciferase enzyme itself.<br />
When asked whether he could find such an<br />
inhibitor, Sutton admitted that it was unlikely.<br />
“Honestly, I don’t think our lab could ever do<br />
this,” Sutton said. “It really takes a commercial<br />
entity to do it. Can you imagine Tucker<br />
screening two-hundred thousand compounds<br />
on his own?” A pharmaceutical company,<br />
however, has the means and methods to<br />
perform large-scale screens to identify<br />
potential inhibitors of the Rev-Rev interaction.<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY HANNAH HAN<br />
Associate Research Scientist Edidiong Akang, a new<br />
member of the Sutton Lab, pipettes fluids into a<br />
microcentrifuge tube.<br />
Sutton is currently applying for a grant<br />
from the NIH to fund the next steps of this<br />
project. With this funding, he is considering<br />
partnering with the local pharmaceutical<br />
company, ViiV Healthcare, which focuses<br />
on delivering new treatment options for<br />
people living with HIV. Sutton and Hansen<br />
are hopeful that the potential Rev inhibitors<br />
identified through this partnership could<br />
serve as a new class of HIV antivirals and<br />
present another line of defense for HIV<br />
patients with drug-resistance complications.<br />
The work done by Hansen and Sutton is<br />
only one of many examples demonstrating the<br />
versatility in applications of firefly luciferase.<br />
This story highlights the ingenuity of using<br />
phenomena in the natural world to create<br />
tools and technologies that can facilitate our<br />
understanding of biological processes. As we<br />
continue to explore and rationalize more of<br />
the natural world, Hansen and Sutton’s work<br />
reminds us that existing biological processes<br />
can be the key to unlocking a whole new<br />
world of technology and discovery with<br />
innumerable benefits to mankind. ■<br />
A R T B Y K A R A T A O<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
CONNIE TIAN is a senior in Grace Hopper studying Molecular, Cellular, and Developmental Biology.<br />
Connie currently conducts research in the DiMaio Lab at the Yale School of Medicine. Her research<br />
focuses on engineering genetically expressible, small transmembrane proteins to facilitate the<br />
degradation of disease-relevant transmembrane proteins. Outside of <strong>YSM</strong>, she is involved in the Yale<br />
Club Soccer team, Community Health Educators, and Yale Undergraduate Science Olympiad.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Tucker Hansen and Dr. Richard Sutton for their time and<br />
enthusiasm in sharing their research findings.<br />
REFERENCES:<br />
CONNIE TIAN<br />
Jabr, F. (2016, May 10). The Secret History of Bioluminescence. Hakai Magazine. https://hakaimagazine.<br />
com/features/secret-history-bioluminescence/<br />
Rinaldi, A. (2007). Naturally better. Science and technology are looking to nature’s successful designs for<br />
inspiration. EMBO Reports, 8(11), 995–999. https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.embor.7401107<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 15
FOCUS<br />
Evolutionary Biology<br />
THE WORLD IN<br />
Characterizing<br />
mammal<br />
biodiversity<br />
and evolution<br />
at the protein<br />
level<br />
Into the World of Proteins<br />
You, me, a worm, and a cow. What<br />
makes us different? Shape, size,<br />
personality, and innumerable other<br />
characteristics create visible differences, of<br />
course—but all of that is ultimately founded<br />
on the invisible world of proteins.<br />
Proteins are the microscopic tools of life,<br />
each one serving a specific function related<br />
to communication, catalysis, structure,<br />
storage, and every other aspect of cellular<br />
business. By interacting with other proteins<br />
and biological molecules, proteins generate<br />
all of life’s characterizing features: birth,<br />
death, cognition, and<br />
reproduction, just to name<br />
a few.<br />
We can imagine<br />
understanding an<br />
organism<br />
as a<br />
composite<br />
of its protein inventory. Almost all of its<br />
characteristics and behaviors depend on the<br />
type, number, and activity of its proteins.<br />
In fact, although we often think about<br />
evolution solely in terms of DNA mutations<br />
creating new characteristics, the relationship<br />
between DNA and an organism's tangible<br />
features depends entirely on proteins,<br />
meaning proteins play a crucial role as<br />
mediators of evolution.<br />
A Serendipitous Encounter<br />
Propelled by a protein-focused perspective,<br />
Yansheng Liu found himself watching<br />
Gunter Wagner’s presentation on the curious<br />
case of cow cancer at a seminar on Yale’s West<br />
Campus. Wagner, an evolutionary biologist,<br />
was interested in understanding cancer by<br />
BY KRISHNA DASARI<br />
comparing<br />
it between<br />
species. To<br />
understand why cows<br />
are less prone to cancer than<br />
humans, Wagner had been studying<br />
connections between changes in gene<br />
expression—an indirect measure of protein<br />
levels—and cancer resistance.<br />
Gene expression can be used to<br />
approximate protein levels because of the<br />
“central dogma” of molecular biology: a<br />
single sequence of DNA, the primary set<br />
of instructions, is transcribed into many<br />
copies of RNA. The RNA is then read and<br />
used to build proteins—the final, functional<br />
product. Measuring gene expression<br />
normally means measuring RNA levels,<br />
and it had long been conveniently assumed<br />
that protein levels were proportional to<br />
RNA levels due to the central dogma.<br />
But this is not always the case. Protein<br />
levels don’t always follow RNA levels,<br />
and Wagner was well aware of the longstanding<br />
debate about how well RNA and<br />
protein levels correlate. He knew the value<br />
of measuring protein levels themselves.<br />
ART BY MALIA KUO<br />
16 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Evolutionary Biology<br />
FOCUS<br />
PROTEINS<br />
However, at<br />
the time, there<br />
was no practical method<br />
to quantify protein levels across<br />
the whole collection of proteins in<br />
a cell. This lack of technology forced<br />
him and almost everyone else in the field<br />
to rely on RNA-based gene expression to<br />
approximate protein levels.<br />
This is where Liu comes in. As a proteomicist,<br />
someone who studies the world of proteins,<br />
he, like Wagner, had a keen interest in the<br />
biodiversity of proteins. “I was so inspired by<br />
Gunter’s talk,” Liu said. “He’s using this very<br />
different angle to compare species to get a clue<br />
about human beings…and I quickly related<br />
[it] to some of my previous work about the<br />
diversity between human individuals and<br />
suggested that we could…cover different<br />
species [with proteomics].”<br />
Liu wanted to go further than gene<br />
expression. Rather than approximate<br />
protein levels using gene expression, why<br />
not study biodiversity at the protein level?<br />
And for the first time, he developed the<br />
technology to answer this question. He<br />
had been part of a team building a tool to<br />
measure protein levels called DIA-MS, a<br />
variant of standard mass spectrometry that<br />
offers advantages in reproducibility<br />
and accuracy. With this<br />
method, he and Wagner<br />
had the tools and the<br />
experience to explore<br />
a new frontier<br />
with Wagner:<br />
investigating<br />
biodiversity<br />
not with<br />
approximations<br />
of protein levels<br />
but with direct<br />
measurements.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
Where to Go and<br />
What to Do?<br />
While Wagner’s original presentation<br />
focused on cancer, the two saw value in<br />
expanding their scope to perform an initial<br />
survey of protein-centric biodiversity across<br />
mammals. With the powerful ability to<br />
quantify complete protein profiles across<br />
species, Liu and Wagner were now faced<br />
with the difficult task of choosing what<br />
questions to ask.<br />
To both, it was clear that they must provide<br />
an answer to the fundamental debate: how<br />
well does RNA-based gene expression<br />
correlate with protein levels? They could<br />
test the validity of an assumption that the<br />
field had been relying on for decades, and<br />
now in multiple species.<br />
Beyond this highly practical aspect of the<br />
RNA-protein relationship, they also wanted to<br />
investigate the evolutionary history of the RNA<br />
and protein profiles. Could these two intimately<br />
intertwined yet distinct bodies evolve together<br />
across the tree of life? Or do intervening<br />
mechanisms disrupt the tethers between the<br />
two, separating the evolution of RNA levels<br />
from protein levels? We know of many possible<br />
sources of disruption, such as those that affect<br />
RNA stability or modify or degrade protein<br />
independently of RNA levels. Even further, we<br />
must consider the most significant difference<br />
between proteins and their nucleic acid<br />
cousins, DNA and RNA: proteins are the final,<br />
functional product! They’re made to interact<br />
with molecules or other proteins; can<br />
these interactions selectively<br />
constrain<br />
o r<br />
accelerate only<br />
protein evolution and not<br />
RNA?<br />
Consistent with their interest<br />
in protein biodiversity, the researchers<br />
were also curious about how their answers<br />
to these previous questions might vary<br />
between different species and individuals of<br />
the same species. Liu had previously revealed<br />
significant variability in the protein profiles<br />
of different humans, and they now<br />
had the chance to extend this<br />
work across species.<br />
Finally,<br />
t h e y<br />
considered<br />
what<br />
unique<br />
insight they could<br />
gain from proteins as<br />
opposed to DNA or RNA.<br />
Liu expressed interest in<br />
phosphorylation sites—spots<br />
on proteins that can bind or release<br />
phosphate molecules to activate<br />
or deactivate the protein. These<br />
sites are responsible for complex<br />
signaling pathways that regulate<br />
everything from cell growth and death<br />
to movement and secretion, so they receive<br />
much attention for understanding cell<br />
regulation or designing protein-inhibiting<br />
drugs. Liu and Wagner gained the ability to<br />
catalog the biodiversity of phosphorylation<br />
sites based on actual proteins rather than<br />
DNA or RNA.<br />
From fundamental questions of molecular<br />
biology to structural biochemistry to<br />
evolution, the new technologies and the<br />
unexpected collaboration between an<br />
evolutionary biologist and proteomicist<br />
thrust a new probe into previously murky<br />
waters of biology. With so much inbuilt<br />
potential, they had no reason to constrain<br />
themselves to one field of questions. “You<br />
have to use your biological intuition to<br />
understand what nature is trying to tell us<br />
here, and that’s fundamentally a creative<br />
process,” Wagner said. The world of proteins<br />
had much to tell about every field of biology,<br />
and Liu and Wagner were there to listen.<br />
Discoveries from the Protein World<br />
From their venture, the team<br />
recorded an invaluable dataset of<br />
protein diversity amongst mammals.<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 17
FOCUS<br />
Evolutionary Biology<br />
With this in hand, we can finally<br />
understand what differentiates you and<br />
me from cows on the protein level, with<br />
applications to tracking our evolutionary<br />
histories or informing medical research.<br />
They also used this data to determine that<br />
RNA and protein levels are moderately<br />
well correlated, though far from perfect.<br />
The good news is that the correlation<br />
does not invalidate decades of prior gene<br />
expression work, but it still sheds light on<br />
the importance of going directly to the<br />
source: proteins.<br />
Further, they discovered correspondence<br />
between variability in RNA and protein<br />
levels, suggesting that despite the many<br />
possible disruptions, RNA and protein levels<br />
do tend to coevolve. The tethers between<br />
these two spheres of molecular biology<br />
overall remain strong, though the exact<br />
relationship is protein-function-dependent.<br />
For example, some classes of proteins—<br />
such as those involved in protein<br />
degradation—show little variation in<br />
both RNA and protein levels, while<br />
other classes—such as those filling<br />
the extracellular region—feature high<br />
variation in both, contributing to increased<br />
evolvability. However, certain proteins defy<br />
this trend. Proteins involved in large protein<br />
complexes feature less protein variability<br />
than RNA variability because intimate<br />
dependence on other proteins pressures<br />
individual proteins to be less variable.<br />
Overall, protein profiles were slightly<br />
more variable than their RNA counterparts,<br />
suggesting that evolution can occur in<br />
proteins rather than solely on DNA/RNA.<br />
Furthermore, Liu and Wagner discovered<br />
more variability amongst phosphorylation<br />
sites relative to protein profiles. This<br />
variability may reflect the evolutionary value<br />
of tightly regulating protein activity or of<br />
generating new cell signaling possibilities.<br />
The team also constructed a network of<br />
coevolution amongst phosphorylation<br />
sites, providing insight into the complex<br />
interactions between signaling<br />
pathways.<br />
Finally, Liu and Wagner<br />
established<br />
that variability<br />
in protein<br />
between<br />
profiles<br />
species<br />
mirrors<br />
variability<br />
within<br />
species. In<br />
other words,<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY SANYA ABBASEY<br />
Dr. Yansheng Liu (right), Barbara Salovska (left), Dr. Wenxue Li (middle right), and Dr. Yi Di (middle left).<br />
if levels of a protein are highly variable<br />
between humans, they are also likely to be<br />
variable between humans and other species.<br />
Returning Home<br />
We have learned much about the protein<br />
world, but what do these results mean for<br />
biology on a broader scale? For one, they<br />
tell us that we can reasonably trust gene<br />
expression while still acknowledging that<br />
protein levels are more variable because of<br />
their functional role. The data also reveals<br />
significant diversity in protein profiles not<br />
only between species but also between<br />
individuals. And most importantly, Liu<br />
and Wagner have opened doors for an<br />
incredible array of studies. Evolution<br />
can now be interpreted not just from<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
changes in the genome, but by studying<br />
the proteins themselves—the tools that<br />
perform the tasks that evolution evaluates.<br />
Biodiversity, disease, and cell biology can all<br />
be approached from a more protein-centric<br />
perspective. In essence, a new method of<br />
understanding biology awaits us.<br />
Pondering the future of the field, Wagner<br />
concluded, “It’s still very difficult. It’s<br />
pioneering, but it’s clear that this is<br />
the direction it has to go in the long<br />
run.” Trekking through the protein<br />
world may remain challenging for<br />
years to come, but it promises<br />
to light the way toward a<br />
pivotal new<br />
understanding<br />
of diversity and<br />
evolution. ■<br />
KRISHNA DASARI<br />
KRISHNA DASARI is a junior in Pierson College majoring in Molecular, Cellular, and Developmental<br />
Biology with a Certificate in Data Science. As well as writing for <strong>YSM</strong> he also co-leads the outreach<br />
branch, Synapse, and conducts research on the evolutionary genetics of cancer at the Yale School of<br />
Public Health.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Gunter Wagner and Yansheng Liu for their time and thrilling<br />
explanations of their research.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
Ba, Q., Hei, Y., Dighe, A., Li, W., Maziarz, J., Pak, I., Wang, S., Wagner, G. P., & Liu, Y. (2022). Proteotype<br />
coevolution and quantitative diversity across 11 mammalian species. Science Advances, 8(36). https://<br />
doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abn0756<br />
Wagner, G. (2019, November 25). Can Cows Teach us how to beat Cancer Malignancy? Nature Ecology<br />
and Evolution. Retrieved October 12, 2022, from https://ecoevocommunity.nature.com/posts/56631-<br />
can-cows-can-teach-us-how-to-beat-cancer-malignancy<br />
18 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Theoretical Physics<br />
FOCUS<br />
TURNING<br />
THE KNOTS IN<br />
RESONATORS<br />
RESONATORS<br />
Bridging elegant math and practical physics<br />
BY YUSUF<br />
RASHEED<br />
ART BY<br />
CHARLOTTE LEAKEY<br />
What do piano strings, air particles, and colliding comets have<br />
in common? Each of them is an oscillator, broadly defining<br />
anything that can vibrate. Oscillators are ubiquitous—they<br />
can be electrical, mechanical, optical, and astronomical, varying from<br />
smaller than an atom to larger than a planet.<br />
Every oscillator has a discrete set of frequencies at which it<br />
naturally vibrates. These are known as its resonance frequencies or<br />
eigenfrequencies, collectively known as the object’s spectrum. You may<br />
have encountered these in physics class in the form<br />
of standing waves, which are the various waves that<br />
naturally “fit” into a given object. For a very simple<br />
object like a guitar string, these are just sine waves, which “fit” whenever a<br />
half-integer number of their wavelength fits into the length of the string.<br />
Each wave will vibrate with its own frequency or eigenfrequency, which<br />
can be changed by adjusting anything that affects the system. In the case<br />
of a guitar, factors such as the tension of guitar strings, the type of wood,<br />
and the temperature of the environment can be used<br />
to tune its spectrum.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 19
FOCUS<br />
Theoretical Physics<br />
Physicists know that any oscillator’s<br />
resonance frequencies are always given<br />
by the roots of a polynomial equation.<br />
When the oscillator is free from friction,<br />
all of the roots of this polynomial are real<br />
numbers, which is quite reasonable given<br />
that frequencies are usually thought of<br />
as real numbers. However, when friction<br />
is considered in the model, these roots<br />
become complex. This means that the root<br />
contains an imaginary number i, equivalent<br />
to √-1. When the model for an oscillator’s<br />
resonance frequencies includes friction,<br />
it is known as a non-Hermitian system.<br />
In contrast, a Hermitian system does not<br />
include friction in its model. The complex<br />
root takes the form (a + bi), where a is<br />
the real part of the root representing the<br />
resonance frequency, and b<br />
is the decay<br />
rate, or how<br />
quickly the<br />
oscillator<br />
s t o p s<br />
oscillating.<br />
O n e<br />
example<br />
is a guitar’s<br />
strings<br />
coming<br />
to rest<br />
after being<br />
plucked.<br />
To visualize the relationship between a<br />
system’s parameters and its spectrum of<br />
resonance frequencies, it is helpful to use two<br />
graphs: one showing the parameters that are<br />
being changed and the other showing the<br />
system’s resonance frequencies with each<br />
frequency being a point in the complex plane.<br />
This pair of two graphs can be seen in the<br />
figure below with pairs of plots “c” and “f,”<br />
“d” and “g,” or “e” and “h,” where plots “c,” “d,”<br />
and “e” are the parameter graphs, and plots<br />
“f,” “g,” and “h” are the resonance frequencies<br />
graphs. Continuing the example of a guitar, the<br />
parameter graph would have the tension in its<br />
strings, the type of wood, and the temperature<br />
of the environment, while the spectrum graph<br />
would have time as its vertical axis, representing<br />
how far along the control loop we are, and the<br />
complex eigenfrequencies in the horizontal<br />
plane. The spectrum graph can be thought of<br />
as plotting the complex eigenfrequencies in the<br />
horizontal plane and then stacking these planes<br />
on top of each other as time passes. When the<br />
parameters are gradually changed and then<br />
returned to their original values, a loop is<br />
formed in the first graph, known as a control<br />
loop. This control loop can be seen below in<br />
the figure as the green, red, or blue loop in<br />
plots “c,” “d,” and “e,” respectively. Such a loop<br />
may or may not enclose points corresponding<br />
to a choice of parameters that would produce<br />
a spectrum in which two or more<br />
eigenvalues are<br />
equal,<br />
known as a<br />
degeneracy.<br />
These points can be seen<br />
below in the figure<br />
as the points along<br />
the yellow “trefoil<br />
knot”-shaped<br />
structure in plots<br />
“c,” “d,” and “e.”<br />
When the parameters are varied<br />
around a control loop, a “braid”<br />
topological structure is created in the<br />
spectrum graph. Much like one can braid hair<br />
into different styles, these spectral braids also<br />
can twist and turn in a variety of ways. The<br />
specific braid that is created depends on the<br />
manner in which the control loop encloses the<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY MATTHEW ZOERB<br />
The light beam is guided through several prisms<br />
before entering the metal cube, where a 50<br />
nanometer thin piece of silicone nitride is.<br />
degeneracy points. These braids can be seen<br />
below in the figure as the triplet of green, red, or<br />
blue lines in plots “f,” “g,” and “h,” respectively.<br />
This relationship between polynomials<br />
and their roots was previously wellunderstood<br />
for a system with two oscillators<br />
(N=2). The braid would twist once if the<br />
control loop encloses a “degeneracy”–a<br />
point in the parameter graph at which two<br />
or more resonance frequencies of the system<br />
are equal. If the control loop does<br />
not enclose a degeneracy, the<br />
braid, in turn, does not<br />
twist.<br />
T h e<br />
relationship<br />
becomes more<br />
complex for a system<br />
with three oscillators<br />
(N=3). Mathematicians have<br />
known for a long time that the<br />
degenerate solutions of polynomial<br />
equations result in a curve/structure with<br />
non-trivial ‘topology’–the degeneracy curve<br />
forms a trefoil knot in the parameter graph for<br />
N=3. Topology is the branch of mathematics<br />
that deals with the shapes of geometric objects.<br />
For example, a donut has a different topology<br />
than a sphere, as the former has a hole<br />
while the latter does not. This topology had<br />
historically been almost exclusively explored<br />
in mathematics, not physics. Physicists knew<br />
that the braids twisted in various ways, but<br />
they did not know why, though they knew it<br />
had something to do with degeneracies.<br />
This project changed that through the<br />
combined forces of the Harris Lab and the<br />
Read Lab, whose researchers elucidated how<br />
this mathematical relationship defines systems<br />
with any number of oscillators. In other<br />
words, N is arbitrary. In addition, they showed<br />
systems with N=3 already exhibit several<br />
striking features that are absent from the N=2<br />
case. Lastly, they demonstrated these features<br />
20 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Theoretical Physics<br />
FOCUS<br />
in the measurements of a system with three<br />
oscillators. Jack Harris and Nicholas Read<br />
are both Professors of Physics and Applied<br />
Physics, but Harris is an experimentalist, while<br />
Read is a theorist. Read was familiar with the<br />
mathematics of degeneracy curves forming a<br />
trefoil knot in the parameter graph for N=3<br />
and thus provided the missing piece to Harris’s<br />
exploration of how the braids twist. “[Read’s]<br />
the one who explained all the math to us. It<br />
happened because I had heard about this field<br />
and was confused about it… and I knew that<br />
[Read] knew a lot about math. After multiple<br />
conversations, we both agreed that this was<br />
something really interesting and we should try<br />
and pursue it.” Harris said.<br />
The groups found that the braiding<br />
process was defined by how the control loop<br />
encircled the trefoil knot of degeneracies.<br />
In the figure from the Nature paper below,<br />
graphs “c”, “d”, and “e” show the trefoil<br />
knot topological structure and the control<br />
loop, which is colored green, red, and blue,<br />
respectively. When the control loop doesn’t<br />
enclose the trefoil knot, a trivial braid is<br />
formed—mathematically, a braid without<br />
twists and turns is still a braid, just a trivial<br />
one (graph “f ”), as opposed to when the<br />
control loop does enclose the trefoil knot,<br />
the braiding depends on how many times<br />
the control loop encloses the trefoil knot<br />
(once in graph “g” and twice in graph “h”).<br />
“Relating this topology of the degenerate<br />
roots of polynomials to the physics of<br />
resonators, and realizing that the twists and<br />
turns of the braids [in the spectrum graph]<br />
are intimately related by a mathematical<br />
correspondence to how the control loop<br />
[in the parameter graph] entwines with<br />
that topological structure took us some<br />
time to develop and appreciate, and then<br />
experimentally verify,” Patil said.<br />
The researchers have also experimentally<br />
confirmed their findings using an<br />
optomechanical system of three oscillators<br />
(N=3). The apparatus they used was a<br />
radiation pressure system with three lasers<br />
that is analogous to a solar sail. Solar sails use<br />
large mirrors to reflect photons from the sun<br />
while traveling in space—each photon has<br />
momentum that it transfers to the solar sail<br />
upon impact, resulting in the propulsion of the<br />
whole spacecraft. Similarly, the apparatus they<br />
used had three lasers with differing powers<br />
that were pointed at a vibrating membrane<br />
of silicon nitride, allowing the researchers<br />
to control the membrane’s stiffness and<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF PATIL ET AL.<br />
Measurements of the EP2 knot K and the eigenvalue braids.This figure is pulled directly from the paper this<br />
article focuses on, which is cited below.<br />
damping and, thus, its resonance frequencies.<br />
Three different colors were also used; red,<br />
green, and blue, adding another dimension to<br />
the experiment. The researchers empirically<br />
saw for this system of N=3 oscillators that<br />
the topological structure of degeneracies in<br />
the parameter graph is indeed a trefoil knot.<br />
They saw that the twists in the experimentally<br />
realized braids indeed correlate with how the<br />
control loop entwines this trefoil knot.<br />
In addition to Professor Harris and Professor<br />
Read, both Dr. Yogesh Patil and graduate<br />
student Judith Höller played key roles in the<br />
project’s success. Patil ran the experiments,<br />
working with the lasers and oscillators. “[The<br />
project] was very demanding in terms of the<br />
sheer amount of time and [precision] with<br />
how the system needed to be controlled.<br />
[Patil] provided two years of solid leadership<br />
and guidance through the pandemic. This<br />
whole project happened during lockdown<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />
because he was able to take [it on].” While<br />
Patil was in the lab, Höller was a crucial bridge<br />
between Harris and Read. “It was clear from<br />
the start that Nick’s elegant story about the<br />
math could–in principle–be realized with<br />
the equipment in our lab. But making this<br />
translation was too complicated at first. It was<br />
Judith who made this translation possible.<br />
The three of us had many long conversations<br />
in which Nick would describe the theory,<br />
and then Judith would explain it to me. Then<br />
I would describe what we could do with the<br />
lasers, and Judith would explain it back to<br />
him. She was a key catalyst,” Harris said.<br />
Given the ubiquity of oscillators,<br />
this discovery opens the door to future<br />
improvement of any system that contains<br />
them, including computers, radios, and<br />
watches. Technological advancements in this<br />
area no longer need to be limited to systems<br />
with only two oscillators. ■<br />
YUSUF RASHEED<br />
YUSUF RASHEED hails from the Bay Area and is a sophomore in Trumbull College majoring in<br />
Biomedical Engineering. He has a deep interest in physician-patient relationships and how budding<br />
medical professionals can develop their soft skills during and after their education. He hopes to apply<br />
his experience in engineering to a clinical setting in the future by improving and personalizing patient<br />
care. Yusuf also believes in the power of writing to effect change at all levels, whether that’s personally<br />
through a journal or publicly through the Yale Scientific Magazine. He encourages all interested<br />
students to get involved with the magazine and try their hand at writing an article.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Professor Jack Harris and Dr. Yogesh Patil for their valuable<br />
time and support for this article.<br />
FURTHER READING:<br />
Patil, Y.S.S., Höller, J., Henry, P.A. et al. Measuring the knot of non-Hermitian degeneracies and noncommuting<br />
braids. Nature 607, 271–275 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-04796-w.<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 21
FOCUS<br />
Biomedical Engineering<br />
HOW TO<br />
GROW<br />
A HEART<br />
Accelerating<br />
the maturation<br />
of engineering<br />
heart tissues<br />
BY CATHERINE ZHENG<br />
ART BY KIERA SUH<br />
22 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biomedical Engineering<br />
FOCUS<br />
Imagine a world where any organ<br />
could be grown in the lab. A sample<br />
from a cheek swab could become a<br />
functioning heart in just a matter of weeks.<br />
New hearts would be grown from patients’<br />
stem cells whenever they were needed,<br />
and organ transplant lists and waiting<br />
times would virtually disappear.<br />
While this world is still far in the future,<br />
researchers at the lab of Stuart Campbell,<br />
Yale Associate Professor of Biomedical<br />
Engineering & Cellular and Molecular<br />
Physiology, have taken major strides in<br />
accelerating the maturation of stem-cell<br />
derived cardiomyocytes (iPSC-CMs) to<br />
grow engineered heart tissues (EHTs) in<br />
the lab that can even contract in response<br />
to electrical stimuli.<br />
Growing Fetal Heart Cells<br />
The primary function of EHTs is to<br />
provide a model of the human heart to<br />
study its features and responses to stimuli<br />
without having to access a human heart<br />
directly. These models are created by<br />
differentiating induced pluripotent stem<br />
cells into cardiomyocytes—specifically,<br />
stem-cell derived cardiomyocytes<br />
(iPSC-CMs). This process involves first<br />
washing a thin slice of a pig heart in a<br />
detergent to clear away pig cells. The<br />
extracellular matrix is then used as a<br />
template for seeding a mixture of human<br />
heart cells, including iPSC-CMs and<br />
human cardiac fibroblasts.<br />
However, since stem cells can differentiate<br />
into any type of cell, iPSC-CMs are still<br />
relatively immature, representing fetal<br />
cardiomyocytes rather than mature ones.<br />
This limits their functionality as studies on<br />
them may not represent the characteristics<br />
of a fully grown human heart. Thus, to<br />
accurately represent mature heart tissue,<br />
iPSC-CMs need to undergo a maturation<br />
protocol that can currently take anywhere<br />
from forty days to six months.<br />
One proposed technique for speeding<br />
up the maturation of iPSC-CMs is<br />
progressive electrical ramp pacing, which<br />
involves exposing the cells to an increasing<br />
rate of electrical current pulses over time.<br />
Previous studies have shown that this leads<br />
to heart cells that are more mature as they<br />
have more advanced electrophysiology<br />
and better calcium handling.<br />
Calcium is also known to play a large<br />
role in cardiac physiology, as it is essential<br />
in inducing the contraction of the heart.<br />
When a membrane potential reaches the<br />
cardiac muscle, calcium channels open,<br />
allowing calcium to flow in and bind to<br />
troponin, which triggers the heart muscle<br />
cell contraction. Greater calcium levels<br />
increase contractile force. However,<br />
calcium’s role in the maturation of EHTs<br />
has not been previously considered.<br />
Most EHTs were grown in solutions<br />
containing only a fraction of the calcium<br />
concentration normally found in the heart.<br />
“When our group realized how<br />
underutilized and underrated those<br />
calcium mediums have been across the<br />
field, we thought it might be interesting<br />
just to try it out,” said Shi Shen, the primary<br />
researcher on this study. This curiosity<br />
led to the discovery that difference in<br />
response to calcium in these early stages<br />
can be a key driver in cardiomyocyte<br />
differentiation: results show that the<br />
amount of calcium present in the cell<br />
culture medium produced a significant<br />
change in the maturation of iPSC-CMs.<br />
Growing Mature Heart Tissues<br />
To further advance the maturation of<br />
iPSC-CMs, researchers tested whether<br />
the combination of electrical ramp<br />
pacing and an increase in free calcium<br />
ions, Ca 2+ , in culture could produce a<br />
scalable improvement in the maturation<br />
of EHTs compared to the standard<br />
maturation protocol.<br />
Four groups of EHTs—high-Ca 2+ nonpaced<br />
(HC-NP), low-Ca 2+ non-paced<br />
(LC-NP), high-Ca 2+ ramp-paced (HC-<br />
RP), and low-Ca 2+ ramp-paced (LC-RP)—<br />
were studied to determine the effects of<br />
electrical pacing and calcium level on<br />
their own and in conjunction. The team<br />
performed the ramp pacing at frequencies<br />
higher than that of a regular human heart<br />
rate. “The regular human heart rate would<br />
fit between one to two hertz, so putting<br />
it at three hertz is like putting a YouTube<br />
video at two times speed,” Stephanie Shao,<br />
an undergraduate researcher on this study,<br />
said. “You can really increase the frequency<br />
and speed it up without harming it. In this<br />
case, it benefits it because it makes the<br />
EHTs mature at an accelerated rate.”<br />
To test the functionality of these<br />
heart tissues, a variety of metrics were<br />
measured, ultimately showing that the<br />
HC-RP group performed much better<br />
than the other groups. One of the most<br />
notable improvements was the forcefrequency<br />
relationship (FFR). FFR<br />
reflects increases in the contractile force<br />
of the heart with increasing frequency<br />
stimulus. “This is one of the key results<br />
to determine whether our experiments<br />
are successful because healthy humans<br />
need this particular phenomenon to<br />
function, [...] and one of the hallmarks<br />
of a cardiac disease is the lack of increase<br />
in force,” Shen said.<br />
FFR is measured using a mechanical<br />
testing apparatus that measures force<br />
in response to 0.25-Hz increases in<br />
frequency from 1 to 3 Hz. While high<br />
calcium marginally improved the FFR<br />
of the groups with no ramp pacing,<br />
both groups still showed a negative<br />
FFR, meaning the force continuously<br />
decreased rather than increasing to a<br />
systolic peak force and dropping again.<br />
However, once the researchers induced a<br />
ramp pacing, they saw a positive FFR in<br />
the group with high calcium, whereas the<br />
FFR of the low calcium group was still<br />
negative. Healthy human myocardium<br />
has a positive FFR of up to 2-2.5 Hz,<br />
similar to that of the HC-RP group,<br />
which exhibited a FFR around 2 Hz.<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF STEPHANIE SHAO VIA JENNA KIM<br />
Microscope image of heart tissue in a relaxed state (left) and a contracted state (right).<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 23
FOCUS<br />
Biomedical Engineering<br />
PHOTOGRAPHY BY JENNA KIM<br />
Undergraduate researcher Stephanie Shao working with the custom apparatus used to study the engineered<br />
heart tissues.<br />
Other metrics that measure heart tissue<br />
functionality are time-to-peak (TTP) and<br />
time-to-fifty percent relaxation (RT50).<br />
TTP is the time it takes for the tissue to<br />
reach its peak force, and RT50 is the time<br />
it takes for the tissue to reach fifty percent<br />
relaxation after its peak contractile force.<br />
Human tissues exhibit TTP and RT50<br />
values at around 200 ms and 120 ms,<br />
respectively. The HC-RP group showed a<br />
similar TTP of around 290 ms and RT50<br />
of around 120 ms, which is significantly<br />
faster than the other EHT groups.<br />
The effect of isoproterenol (ISO) on the<br />
EHTs was also observed by measuring<br />
FFR after exposure to ISO. ISO is a<br />
drug that increases the contractility of<br />
the heart. It is used for patients with<br />
weakened hearts to improve cardiac<br />
output. The increase in the systolic<br />
peak force for the HC-RP group was<br />
much more significant compared to the<br />
increase in the systolic peak force for<br />
the LC-RP group. These results indicate<br />
that the HC-RP group behaves more<br />
similarly to actual mature heart tissue in<br />
the presence of ISO.<br />
On top of these metrics, western blots<br />
and RNA sequencing were performed<br />
to analyze changes in protein and RNA<br />
levels on a molecular level that may have<br />
influenced improvements seen in the<br />
different groups. The results showed that<br />
markers associated with mature heart<br />
tissues were elevated in the HC-RP group.<br />
They also found that the genes expressed<br />
in the HC-NP and LC-RP groups were not<br />
the same, indicating that both electrical<br />
ramp pacing and high calcium are needed<br />
to produce the mature characteristics<br />
achieved in the EHTs.<br />
Growing Hearts<br />
With this improved protocol, the<br />
maturation of iPSC-CMs can be<br />
significantly shortened relative to<br />
previously published techniques. While<br />
EHTs cannot be used to grow hearts<br />
directly from stem cells, this advancement<br />
has significant implications for future<br />
research. Given that many researchers<br />
around the world are using iPSC-CMs<br />
for a variety of purposes, this technique<br />
has the potential to find widespread use<br />
and make mature, functional EHTs more<br />
readily available.<br />
“For something like a drug study, a lot<br />
less compound would be used,” Shao said.<br />
“Especially if it’s a drug that’s not out yet,<br />
you have to have a chemist make it, and<br />
that’s not easy to make large quantities of,<br />
which is what you would need for an in<br />
vivo study.”<br />
Another major advantage of using<br />
EHTs is that they are grown from stem<br />
cells derived from a specific patient.<br />
This means that any testing a patient<br />
may need to undergo can be performed<br />
on an EHT grown from their stem cells,<br />
which will more accurately represent the<br />
characteristics of their own heart.<br />
This study is a catalyst for future cardiac<br />
research exploring the vast applications of<br />
EHTs. “There’s a large segment of work that’s<br />
being done targeted towards implanting<br />
cells back into patients to repair the heart<br />
to replace or regenerate heart muscle,”<br />
Campbell said. “I would hope that the<br />
field takes notice of our protocol because<br />
if you’re repairing the heart, for instance,<br />
you want to generate a lot of mature cells,<br />
so someone’s going to have to decide how<br />
to treat those cells so that they’re as mature<br />
as possible.” Campbell hopes this paper will<br />
contribute to the growing body of literature<br />
for the most optimal maturing conditions.<br />
Moving forward, there are still other<br />
factors to investigate that may further<br />
improve the maturation of stem cells for<br />
EHT growth. “Something that we haven’t<br />
tried is combining a realistic pattern<br />
of mechanical loading, or maturation<br />
of mechanical loading—so what a<br />
fetus experiences in terms of the fetal<br />
heart versus a newborn versus an adult<br />
heart—modulating the mechanical load<br />
in conjunction with those heart rate<br />
changes”, says Campbell. While growing<br />
a functioning adult human heart is not<br />
yet in the cards, we are getting closer to a<br />
future where that is possible. ■<br />
ABOUT THE AUTHOR CATHERINE ZHENG<br />
CATHERINE ZHENG is a senior BME and CS major in Pauli Murray College. In addition to writing for<br />
<strong>YSM</strong>, she is the magazine’s production manager, she does research with Professor Staib, and is also the<br />
production manager for the Yale Undergraduate Research Journal.<br />
THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO THANK Professor Campbell, Dr. Shi Shen, and Stephanie Shao for their<br />
time and enthusiasm in sharing their research.<br />
FURTHER READING<br />
Shen, S., Sewanan, L. R., Shao, S., Halder, S. S., Stankey, P., Li, X., & Campbell, S. G. (2022). Physiological<br />
calcium combined with electrical pacing accelerates maturation of human engineered heart tissue. Stem<br />
Cell Reports, 17(9), 2037–2049. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stemcr.2022.07.006<br />
24 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
PAPER POWER<br />
Sustainable Energy<br />
FEATURE<br />
A WATER-ACTIVATED<br />
BIODEGRADABLE PAPER BATTERY<br />
BY CINDY MEI<br />
ART BY LUNA AGUILAR<br />
With great power comes great responsibility. In an age<br />
where the world has become increasingly reliant on<br />
technology, the threat of electronic waste or e-waste—<br />
including many discarded products containing batteries—has<br />
become increasingly dire. In 2019 alone, an estimated 48.6 million<br />
tons of e-waste was generated worldwide, a rapidly expanding<br />
issue that has only continued to grow. Because standard lithium<br />
batteries contain non-biodegradable and often toxic rare earth<br />
metals, the accumulation of e-waste releases harmful chemicals<br />
that can contaminate groundwater and the air, putting the<br />
environment and the health of billions at risk.<br />
The quest for green power seeks to eliminate the threat of e-waste<br />
by harnessing sustainable materials. This pursuit fascinated Gustav<br />
Nyström, head of cellulose & wood materials at the Swiss Federal<br />
Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology. By harnessing<br />
natural, environmentally-friendly materials, researchers in Nyström’s<br />
lab were able to power the crystal display of a LED alarm clock using<br />
a disposable paper battery activated by just two drops of water.<br />
The project, which also involved postdoctoral researcher<br />
Alexandre Poulin and doctoral researcher Xavier Aeby, sought<br />
to search for an environmentally-friendly battery high in<br />
density, important for a longer run time, that<br />
would be suitable for single-use devices<br />
such as sensors. “For instance, in<br />
biomedical industries, where<br />
many diagnostic tests are<br />
discarded after a single use due<br />
to hygienic and ethical reasons,<br />
there is a lot of plastic waste<br />
being generated,” Nyström said.<br />
An electrochemical battery<br />
stores and discharges energy through<br />
a series of oxidation and reduction<br />
reactions that occur at the anode<br />
and cathode, respectively. In<br />
addition to these components, a<br />
separator prevents the electrodes<br />
from coming in contact and<br />
short-circuiting, while the electrolyte<br />
facilitates the movement of ions between the anode and cathode.<br />
In battery fabrication, the material choice for these components<br />
is especially important for optimized, reliable function. “We<br />
made a strict selection based on what we thought were the most<br />
promising materials in terms of energy density and stability for this<br />
development,” Nyström said. “It’s about choosing the right type of<br />
materials that are not harmful to our environment. That’s a big and<br />
important goal for us.”<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
The ideal material is stable and highly conductive, with low<br />
contact resistance, high energy storage capacity, and a fast charging<br />
rate. After testing many combinations, the final design used a<br />
zinc anode, a graphite carbon air cathode, a paper separator, and<br />
a water-based salt electrolyte. The electrodes were stenciled onto<br />
the paper using multi-material inks that contained a mixture of<br />
ethanol, shellac, and sodium chloride ions which are required to<br />
form the conductivity needed in the battery for electron flow. The<br />
dry batteries can then be stored indefinitely until water is added,<br />
which permeates the paper membrane, dissolving the salt ions and<br />
activating the battery within twenty seconds.<br />
The battery inks were characterized by shear thinning behavior and<br />
yield stress, physical factors important in additive manufacturing.<br />
This method adds components by layering them and has great<br />
advantages in reducing manufacturing waste. “[Our goal is] also<br />
being responsible with the amount of material used,” Nyström said.<br />
“When you manufacture, you only need to use exactly the amount of<br />
multi-material inks that you need for those different components.”<br />
The researchers also performed electrochemical tests on the battery.<br />
A single cell demonstrated a 1.2 V potential, which is proportional<br />
to the energy delivered to the cells. Power capability was measured<br />
to reach 150 μW, enough to power<br />
an alarm’s LCD crystal display,<br />
hearing aids, and electronic<br />
watch calculators. With more<br />
printed batteries added in<br />
series, the voltage increases,<br />
accommodating devices with<br />
greater power usage. After one<br />
hour of operation, the voltage<br />
decreased as the paper substrate<br />
dried. However, upon the readdition<br />
of water, the performance was<br />
recovered, allowing for extended<br />
battery life by increasing how<br />
much water the paper could hold.<br />
In the future, the researchers<br />
hope to study the length of battery<br />
life following rehydration of the<br />
battery and explore further implementations of organic materials.<br />
Nyström believes that it has the potential to play a valuable part in<br />
the reduction of e-waste in powering single-use diagnostic tests and<br />
sensors, but there is still much work to be done. “We have had a lot of<br />
academic developments, and now is really the time to see what and<br />
how much can be transferred into real products,” Nyström said. “I<br />
think [paper] is quite a promising material, but we need to see what<br />
is feasible and where the best applications will be.” ■<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 25
ART BY EMILY<br />
BY KAYLA<br />
FEATURE<br />
Climate & Oceans<br />
LIGHTNING’S<br />
ACHILLES HEEL<br />
POAG<br />
YUP<br />
HOW SEA SPRAY PUTS LIGHTNING TO SLEEP<br />
In Greek mythology, any site struck by lightning is considered<br />
sacred. By that logic, the Earth’s land must be divine—a whopping<br />
ninety percent of lightning strikes land, leaving only a measly ration<br />
for oceans worldwide. Thanks to a study recently published in Nature<br />
Communications, we now know the secret to this phenomenon. Above<br />
the ocean, wind and water interact to form sea spray: salty particles<br />
suspended in the air. Scientists in Israel, China, and the US discovered<br />
that this spray could reduce lighting by up to 90 percent.<br />
Clouds are composed of droplets that typically form when<br />
water vapor condenses onto aerosols. The term ‘aerosol’ refers to<br />
any small solid particle suspended in the air. Previous research<br />
found that ‘fine aerosols,’ such as smoke, can encourage lightning<br />
formation by serving as sites for condensation. This has been<br />
used to link rising rates of air pollution to increased lightning.<br />
“Lightning is sort of the byproduct of clouds,” said Yannian Zhu,<br />
study co-author and associate professor at Nanjing University.<br />
“Normally, if you don’t have clouds, you don’t have lightning.”<br />
For clouds to become ‘electrified,’ they must reach a certain<br />
elevation. Rising currents of air—updrafts—help clouds grow to<br />
a height at which the temperature is below zero degrees Celsius.<br />
At this level, water droplets can freeze into ice crystals. Some<br />
of these ice crystals then collect the rest of the water droplets,<br />
forming larger sleet-like particles known as ‘graupel.’ The other<br />
ice crystals remain small and positively charged and continue to<br />
be pushed by updrafts toward the top of the cloud.<br />
Meanwhile, the graupel descends, carrying a negative charge.<br />
Electrical charge is transferred from the<br />
crystals to<br />
the graupel when they<br />
collide.<br />
O v e r<br />
time, an<br />
electrical<br />
field builds<br />
from the<br />
c o n s t a n t<br />
transfer of<br />
electrical<br />
charges<br />
between<br />
t h e<br />
oppositely<br />
charged<br />
particles.<br />
A f t e r<br />
sufficient<br />
buildup, the power of the electricity is strong enough to penetrate<br />
through the atmosphere, discharging as a flash of lightning.<br />
On land, fine aerosols are much more concentrated, largely due to<br />
air pollution, making them the main source for cloud formation. Over<br />
oceans, sea spray frequently serves as a condensation site, forming<br />
water droplets bigger and heavier than their fine aerosol counterparts.<br />
Fine aerosol particles are small and abundant, forming<br />
clouds with numerous small droplets. These droplets are slow<br />
to combine into raindrops, remaining small enough to ascend<br />
easily to a high enough level for freezing to occur. However, sea<br />
spray, which is considered a ‘coarse aerosol,’ has the opposite<br />
effect: large droplets form and quickly coalesce into rain.<br />
The large salt particles in sea spray can absorb water quicker and<br />
easier, forming large droplets that eagerly collect other droplets.<br />
As a result, these clouds will rain out too soon before reaching the<br />
sub-zero temperature height at which ice can form and electrify<br />
the cloud. This phenomenon also helps explain why small rain<br />
showers are more frequent over the ocean than on land.<br />
“If you live beside the sea, you will see that there are many [rain]<br />
showers every day without thunderstorms—just showering,” Zhu<br />
said. “It is a cycle, water vapor becomes clouds, and then the<br />
clouds become rain [and so on] ... this energy transition between<br />
surface and atmosphere is very fast.”<br />
The researchers drew upon over four years of satellite data<br />
measuring clouds, precipitation, aerosols, and meteorology. “In<br />
principle, people knew that the added sea spray particles enhanced<br />
rainfall, but they never had such comprehensive measurements from<br />
satellites to actually [demonstrate] the effect on a global scale,” said coauthor<br />
Daniel Rosenfeld, a meteorologist and professor at the Hebrew<br />
University of Jerusalem. “It’s one thing to know that something, in<br />
theory, could happen; it’s another thing to see that it is [in fact] really<br />
significant and has a large effect.” This study ultimately differentiated<br />
the contrasting effects of fine and coarse aerosols on clouds.<br />
Current weather prediction and climate models fail to consider<br />
the effect of sea spray on weather patterns. Knowing how aerosols<br />
can change the cloud’s physical processes will enable us to monitor<br />
convective clouds more accurately and potentially artificially alter<br />
them to avoid natural disasters, such as hail and tornadoes. Simply by<br />
deploying the right aerosols into the air, the practice of ‘cloud-seeding’<br />
has facilitated China’s attempts to trigger more rainfall for agriculture.<br />
“Our responsibility is to understand the whole aerosol-cloud<br />
interaction microphysical process and to give that knowledge…<br />
to help people do future climate predictions more accurately,” Zhu<br />
said. “We’re trying to save the world in a different way.” ■<br />
26 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Robotics & Medicine<br />
FEATURE<br />
Black Mirror. Ex Machina. The Terminator. Why does<br />
television seem to vilify robots and artificial intelligence<br />
as a human invention bound to go wrong? Why are robots<br />
always portrayed as a perilous design destined to eradicate the<br />
human species? We see this smear of these intelligent machines<br />
in the media and pop culture, from movies that follow the<br />
expedition of an assassin robot to dystopian shows that alarm<br />
their audiences about the dangers of unrestricted technological<br />
advancements. However, let us not forget that robots are<br />
designed to facilitate human conventions and tasks, with<br />
great potential to revamp and advance biotechnology, medical<br />
procedures, and clinical treatments.<br />
In one of the latest clinically transformative<br />
cases, researchers at Stanford University<br />
designed a tiny origami robot capable of various<br />
movements in physiological environments to<br />
deliver organic cargo and liquid medicine. We often<br />
attribute origami to the Japanese paper-folding<br />
craft, but this technology fulfills the robot’s<br />
multifunctionality based on the geometric<br />
features of a specific origami structure: the<br />
Kresling. The Kresling is a triangulated<br />
hollow cylinder where ‘twist buckling’ a<br />
thin cylindrical sheet creates triangular<br />
elements throughout the structure. The<br />
twist buckling mechanism can be created<br />
by folding one sheet slightly higher than<br />
the next sheet, then repeating this process<br />
along the direction of the twist. Because<br />
the Kresling structure is always curved<br />
at the folds, the junctions between folds<br />
can be radially cut for liquid drug release.<br />
The buckling effect and high geometrical<br />
symmetry of the design allow for the robot’s<br />
sphere-like ability to roll, flip, and spin.<br />
“The Kresling origami is a special design<br />
that couples torsion—a twisting motion—and<br />
compression, which provides us with the foldability to<br />
develop a pumping mechanism for targeted drug delivery,”<br />
said Renee Zhao, assistant professor of mechanical<br />
engineering at Stanford University and one of the<br />
leading scientists on the project. The robot is<br />
prepared by attaching thin magnetic plates to the<br />
ends of the Kresling structure, which generates a<br />
twisting force as the robot’s rigid body rotation<br />
aligns with the magnetic field.<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
TINY<br />
ORI<br />
AM R G I<br />
THE FUTURE OF DRUG DELIVERY<br />
BY IGNACIO RUIZ-SANCHEZ<br />
OB OTS<br />
This all sounds very compelling and groundbreaking, but how<br />
does the robot’s origami structure improve the drug delivery<br />
process? After all, the robot is not being introduced to a generally<br />
dry environment, so why is on-ground locomotion relevant?<br />
Zhao and her team at Stanford characterize the tiny robot as<br />
amphibious in functionality, meaning that the robot can navigate<br />
both complex ground and aqueous environments. “On-ground<br />
locomotion is based on the robot’s interaction with a solid surface<br />
by rolling and flipping, and aquatic locomotion is based on the<br />
spinning mechanism that creates propulsion for the device to<br />
swim,” Zhao said. The magnet plates also activate the pumping<br />
mechanism to release liquid medicine into the body.<br />
For drug delivery, a needle and a liquid medicine<br />
container are inserted into the internal cavity of<br />
the robot. Once the device reaches the target<br />
area, the magnetic plates activate a rotational<br />
force to contract the robot, during which the<br />
needle punctures the liquid container. Gradually,<br />
the Kresling’s internal cavity shrinks and squeezes the<br />
liquid medicine out through the radial cuts into the environment.<br />
Similarly, the spinning-enabled feature from the magnets also<br />
allows for cargo loading and release, which follows the same<br />
locomotive process as the pumping mechanism. However, it first<br />
propels the robot to absorb solid objects from an environment,<br />
stores those objects in the internal container, and finally releases<br />
them via pumping once the robot reaches the target area.<br />
Despite the relatively small size of the millirobot, the internal<br />
cavity of the Kresling is still widely unoccupied, even after<br />
installing the needle and liquid container. Researchers<br />
have thus built sensors and cameras in the cavity to direct<br />
movements and record specific environmental conditions.<br />
“The internal cavity of the robot can actually be<br />
used to integrate other functional components,<br />
like cameras for biopsies and biosynthetic tissues<br />
to stop internal bleeding,” Zhao said. The potential<br />
biomedical applications for using the robot and its<br />
internal compartments are vast.<br />
Versatility, agency, and efficacy all seem to<br />
be leading features in the architecture of these<br />
innovative devices. Robots like the Kresling origami<br />
should remind us that robots were created to help us,<br />
not harm us. To this point, let’s stop giving robots such<br />
a bad rap in pop culture, especially if these cute, foldable<br />
robots could be designed to ultimately save our lives. ■<br />
ART BY CATHERINE KWON<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 27
FEATURE<br />
Developmental Psychology & Artificial Intelligence<br />
WHAT CAN A COMPUTER<br />
LEARN FROM A BABY?<br />
TEACHING PHYSICAL INTUITION TO AI MODELS<br />
BY NATHAN WU<br />
ART BY CATHERINE KWON<br />
Before we turn three months old,<br />
humans have already developed<br />
an intuitive sense of how the<br />
physical world works. If an infant knocks<br />
over a block tower, they know the blocks<br />
will tumble spectacularly down to the<br />
ground. If the blocks float in the air or<br />
fall straight through the floor, the infant<br />
might cry out in surprise.<br />
This sense of common intuition is<br />
dubbed our ‘intuitive physics engine,’<br />
fundamental to both biological and<br />
artificial intelligent systems operating<br />
in the real world. Understanding how<br />
a system’s physical actions will affect<br />
the world around them can guide what<br />
decisions and movements they must<br />
execute to carry out their intentions. In<br />
biological systems, the intuitive physics<br />
engine develops extremely rapidly,<br />
suggesting its importance for survival in<br />
the physical world.<br />
Despite the ubiquity of<br />
intuitive physics in<br />
intelligent<br />
biological<br />
organisms, the best artificial intelligence<br />
(AI) systems still struggle to replicate<br />
the same understanding of physics that<br />
even very young children have mastered.<br />
This difficulty continues despite the great<br />
progress made in the field. AI systems<br />
easily best humans in complex games, like<br />
Chess and Go, and have solved some of<br />
the most complicated scientific<br />
problems, like protein<br />
folding. The challenge of<br />
teaching intuitive physics<br />
to an artificial system lies<br />
within its pervasiveness.<br />
“Intuitive physics is everywhere,<br />
and when something<br />
is everywhere, it<br />
becomes hard to analyze because it’s<br />
interacting with so many things,” said<br />
Luis Piloto, a research scientist<br />
at DeepMind,<br />
a subsidiary of<br />
Alphabet, Google’s<br />
parent company.<br />
However, Piloto’s<br />
team has<br />
recently made great<br />
strides toward finding<br />
a solution by taking<br />
inspiration from the methods<br />
and findings of developmental<br />
psychology, ultimately<br />
creating an AI system that<br />
learns intuitive physics<br />
from visual data.<br />
Perhaps the most important<br />
novelty of Piloto’s work was how their<br />
AI model’s understanding of intuitive physics<br />
28 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Developmental Psychology & Artificial Intelligence<br />
FEATURE<br />
was probed and evaluated. In developmental<br />
psychology, intuitive physics is separated<br />
into several distinct concepts, such as object<br />
permanence or object solidity. For each<br />
concept tested individually, human subjects<br />
are shown relevant scenes that are either<br />
consistent or inconsistent with the concept<br />
of interest. If subjects show surprise after<br />
seeing inconsistent scenes, which is usually<br />
measured by gaze duration, there is evidence<br />
that the subject understands that concept.<br />
This method of evaluating intuitive physics<br />
knowledge is known as the violation-ofexpectation<br />
(VoE) paradigm.<br />
Inspired by these methods used in<br />
developmental psychology, Piloto and<br />
his team constructed the Physical<br />
Concepts dataset. This dataset contains<br />
videos generated by a physics engine,<br />
each consistent or inconsistent with one<br />
of five distinct concepts from intuitive<br />
physics. These concepts included object<br />
permanence (objects will not simply<br />
disappear), object solidity (objects<br />
will not pass through one another),<br />
continuity (objects will have continuous<br />
paths and cannot teleport from one place<br />
to another), unchangeableness (objects<br />
retain their properties over time), and<br />
directional inertia (objects will stay in<br />
their path unless a force acts upon them).<br />
Every video that abided by a concept<br />
was paired with a visually similar one<br />
that violated that concept, both starting<br />
with identical scenes but deviating over<br />
the course of the video. The amount of<br />
'surprise' that a model exhibited was<br />
determined by the model’s prediction<br />
error—how different a future scene<br />
predicted by the model is compared to<br />
the real future scene in the accompanying<br />
video. Thus, the model’s understanding of<br />
a concept can be evaluated by examining<br />
the difference in the model’s surprise<br />
in response to physically plausible and<br />
implausible pairs of videos.<br />
This VoE paradigm is a departure<br />
from standard methods of evaluating<br />
AI’s performance on intuitive physics<br />
tasks. One common approach utilizes<br />
video prediction on physically plausible<br />
situations alone to evaluate learning<br />
progress. In the VoE paradigm, the<br />
model should, in theory, make incorrect<br />
predictions about physically implausible<br />
videos, enabling researchers to better<br />
understand whether a concept is truly<br />
being learned. Another common<br />
approach employs reinforcement learning<br />
tasks, whereby models plan actions to<br />
interact with the environment around<br />
them to receive a reward. However,<br />
the complexity of these tasks makes it<br />
difficult to isolate the true cause of failure<br />
because success requires intuitive physics<br />
knowledge and knowledge of how to<br />
navigate the given space.<br />
“If we want to evaluate intuitive physics<br />
knowledge, let's break it down into these<br />
different concepts, and let’s build stimuli<br />
that are really about the concepts…<br />
You can do well on benchmarks, but if<br />
they don't reflect the capabilities that<br />
you're actually trying to measure, then<br />
increasing your performance on those<br />
benchmarks doesn't necessarily get you<br />
closer to the capabilities that you want,”<br />
Piloto explained.<br />
The next key insight from developmental<br />
psychology incorporated by Piloto’s team<br />
was an object-based conception of physics.<br />
Infant intuitive physics behavior involves<br />
segmenting the visual field into distinct<br />
objects with their own properties (object<br />
individuation), tracking these objects<br />
across space and time (object tracking), and<br />
then processing how these objects interact<br />
with each other (relational processing).<br />
These three processes were implemented in<br />
a model called Physics Learning through<br />
Auto-encoding and Tracking Objects,<br />
nicknamed PLATO. Rather than only<br />
looking at patterns of pixels in a visual<br />
scene as other visual prediction models<br />
do, each frame that PLATO processes is<br />
broken down by masking specific parts<br />
of the scene so that the model can learn<br />
representations of individual objects.<br />
Indices assigned to each object enable<br />
them to be tracked through time. Lastly,<br />
a separate module is used to process how<br />
these objects interact with one another and<br />
predict future scenes.<br />
After just twenty-eight hours of visual<br />
training with physically plausible videos<br />
from the physical concepts dataset,<br />
PLATO demonstrated a grasp of all five<br />
concepts by exhibiting greater surprise<br />
in response to physically implausible<br />
videos. This result outperformed AI<br />
models that do not rely on object-based<br />
representations as PLATO does. The model<br />
also performed well on a different dataset<br />
developed independently by a team at the<br />
Massachusetts Institute of Technology,<br />
suggesting that PLATO’s understanding<br />
of intuitive physics is robust.<br />
The quest to build an AI system that<br />
can learn intuitive physics is far from<br />
over. While Piloto’s team at DeepMind<br />
has taken a great step forward, there is<br />
still much room for improvement. In<br />
particular, PLATO did not learn how<br />
to segment and label the visual field<br />
into distinct objects by itself. Instead,<br />
the researchers spoon-fed the model<br />
a series of masks that told it where<br />
each object was. Other recent work has<br />
successfully tackled this challenge,<br />
introducing methods for object<br />
discovery in an unsegmented visual<br />
field. Integrating this research with the<br />
relational processing module of PLATO<br />
would result in a seamless model that<br />
can understand intuitive physics with<br />
nothing but a video.<br />
PLATO’s success as a machine learning<br />
model inspired by biological brains speaks<br />
to artificial intelligence’s close relationship<br />
with neuroscience and psychology. “AI<br />
and neuroscience are attacking the same<br />
problem from different sides,” Piloto said.<br />
“The analogy that I like to use is that AI<br />
is building intelligence from scratch,<br />
and neuroscientists are saying, ‘Wait,<br />
hold on, we’ve got this intelligent system<br />
right here, why don’t we try and reverseengineer<br />
what’s going on?’”<br />
Although PLATO is far from being<br />
an accurate model of intuitive physics<br />
learning in children, the study still<br />
presents important implications for<br />
developmental psychology. PLATO’s<br />
success proves that intuitive physics<br />
knowledge is not necessarily innate—it<br />
can be rapidly acquired through visual<br />
learning. Additionally, Piloto’s team<br />
proposes using models like PLATO to<br />
investigate the order in which different<br />
intuitive physics concepts are acquired<br />
throughout development. This study<br />
demonstrates that the brain sciences<br />
and artificial intelligence have much to<br />
gain through work at the intersection of<br />
the two fields. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 29
FEATURE<br />
Biomedical Engineering<br />
A LIFE-SAVING<br />
STICKER<br />
DEVELOPING<br />
A BIOADHESIVE<br />
ULTRASOUND<br />
DEVICE<br />
BY XIMENA<br />
LEYVA PERALTA<br />
ART BY KIERA SUH<br />
Diagnosing diseases can be tricky. How<br />
can doctors tell if a headache stems<br />
from a lack of sleep or something more<br />
serious? How can they see what is happening<br />
inside a patient? Peering inside the body can<br />
provide valuable, life-saving information<br />
for clinicians. Among the different imaging<br />
techniques, ultrasound—a non-invasive, riskfree<br />
diagnostic tool—stands out as a leading<br />
option. Researchers at the Massachusetts<br />
Institute of Technology (MIT)<br />
have developed a small, adhesive<br />
device that may revolutionize<br />
ultrasound technology.<br />
Ultrasound devices use sound<br />
waves to create a picture of<br />
internal organs and tissues. An ultrasound<br />
probe emits high-frequency waves, which<br />
can travel through soft tissues but bounce off<br />
harder structures. An image is then created<br />
by a computer using these echoes. Thanks to<br />
its lack of radiation, ultrasound is the safest<br />
imaging tool, making it an ideal choice for<br />
continuous monitoring. However, current<br />
ultrasound devices are bulky and require an<br />
experienced clinician to operate the handheld<br />
probe. The clinician can only obtain a few<br />
images or videos in a regular ultrasound<br />
appointment, which typically lasts less than<br />
thirty minutes. Continuous imaging to<br />
monitor internal changes as the body moves<br />
on a day-to-day basis is not an option.<br />
The team at MIT was able to transform the<br />
standard bulky, handheld ultrasound into a<br />
simple sticker by developing a brand-new<br />
bioadhesive that can comfortably attach<br />
a small ultrasound probe to the skin. The<br />
resulting bioadhesive ultrasound (BAUS)<br />
device can be attached to the body for up<br />
to forty-eight hours at a time to take highquality<br />
images and videos of our body’s<br />
activities—blood vessels contracting, lungs<br />
expanding, stomachs digesting, and hearts<br />
pumping. The BAUS device can comfortably<br />
move with the person and capture the<br />
human body’s natural dynamism.<br />
“Wearable ultrasound equipment can<br />
potentially revolutionize medical imaging,”<br />
said Xuanhe Zhao, professor of mechanical<br />
engineering and civil and environmental<br />
engineering at MIT, who co-authored the<br />
Science paper that describes the BAUS<br />
device. “Medical imaging is very important<br />
for diagnostic purposes. However,<br />
with existing medical imaging,<br />
the timescale is short. It’s usually<br />
a few seconds or minutes—just a<br />
snapshot.” Continuous and frequent<br />
imaging of internal organs, over<br />
days or even months, could help<br />
clinicians more effectively monitor the<br />
health of patients and observe how diseases<br />
progress. It could also provide invaluable<br />
new data about the human body and lead to<br />
discoveries in medicine and biology.<br />
The biggest challenge has been comfortably<br />
attaching an ultrasound probe to the body.<br />
“It’s really [about] how you can integrate the<br />
ultrasound device with the body so it can give<br />
you long-term continuous imaging over days<br />
even under dynamic body motion,” Zhao said.<br />
Previous wearable ultrasound devices were<br />
designed to be stretchable and move with the<br />
skin. However, this design sacrificed image<br />
quality and resolution despite the improved<br />
wearability. Moreover, sound transmission is<br />
vital to reach deep organs, such as the heart<br />
or stomach, and accurately image them.<br />
When using traditional ultrasound devices,<br />
clinicians apply a gel layer to prevent air<br />
pockets that can block the transmission of<br />
sound waves through the skin. However,<br />
these gels are not designed for prolonged<br />
use. “The liquid gel, if you put it in contact<br />
with the body, it can potentially cause<br />
acidification in a few hours,”<br />
Zhao explained. Wearable<br />
ultrasound devices have used<br />
hydrogels—a water-rich, goo-like<br />
substance—in the past to solve<br />
30 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biomedical Engineering<br />
FEATURE<br />
this problem, but they<br />
get dehydrated and detach<br />
after only a couple of hours.<br />
Other devices use a rubbery<br />
material called an elastomer<br />
to attach the device to the<br />
skin. However, pure elastomer adhesives<br />
dampen sound waves, preventing them from<br />
reaching deep organs.<br />
The beauty of the BAUS device comes from<br />
a newly developed bioadhesive that combines<br />
the adhesion capabilities of an elastomer with<br />
the sound transmission abilities of a hydrogel.<br />
“For the bioadhesive part, we really spent<br />
lots of effort to develop a hydrogel-elastomer<br />
hybrid. It’s very different from existing liquid<br />
hydrogels that can easily flow away,” Zhao<br />
said. The new material consists of a hydrogel<br />
encapsulated by an elastomer to form a soft<br />
solid that can adhere robustly and comfortably<br />
to the skin, doubling as an adhesive and<br />
a gel to improve sound transmission. The<br />
researchers then embedded a thin highperformance<br />
probe in the hydrogel-elastomer<br />
to complete the BAUS.<br />
They tested its performance over fortyeight<br />
hours by imaging the various organs<br />
and tissues of fifteen test subjects. The BAUS<br />
device showed everything from how blood<br />
vessels’ diameter increased as a subject stood<br />
up to how blood flow rate increased after<br />
thirty minutes of exercise to how the stomach<br />
emptied over two hours after a subject drank<br />
a glass of juice. It can also image the heart’s<br />
four chambers and show how they change<br />
in size under continuous body motion.<br />
Furthermore, its success in imaging the<br />
lungs and the diaphragm means that the<br />
BAUS could potentially be used to monitor<br />
respiratory diseases, including COVID-19,<br />
and prevent further complications.<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FELICE FRANKEL<br />
The bioadhesive ultrasound device.<br />
IMAGES COURTESY OF WANG ET AL.<br />
A bioadhesive ultrasound device adhered to the skin (left) and being detached from the skin (right).<br />
“I would say it’d be easier for clinicians<br />
and maybe even patients to [use] this. It’s<br />
like [adhering] a bandaid on the skin.<br />
And our lab is currently working to<br />
further simplify this process,” Zhao said.<br />
Traditional handheld ultrasound requires<br />
qualified personnel and can be relatively<br />
expensive. Apart from continuous<br />
imaging, the BAUS device provides a<br />
simplified imaging process that could<br />
eliminate the need for an experienced<br />
operator and possibly even give patients<br />
the option of adhering the device by<br />
themselves. Hence, the BAUS could help<br />
increase the accessibility of ultrasounds.<br />
Clinicians and healthcare professionals<br />
alike are excited about the broad<br />
medical potential of the BAUS device.<br />
Continuous imaging is essential for<br />
monitoring and tracking tumor growth<br />
and for early detection and treatment<br />
of cancer. Diagnoses for conditions<br />
that involve muscles, joints, and<br />
bones often require dynamic tests that<br />
cannot be performed using traditional<br />
ultrasound techniques. Cardiovascular<br />
diseases, which affect the performance<br />
of blood vessels and the heart, can lead<br />
to dangerous heart attacks that require<br />
ultrasound technology for diagnosis. A<br />
wearable ultrasound device could help<br />
alert those at higher risk for heart attacks<br />
of changes in their blood pressure<br />
in time to save lives. Ultimately,<br />
the BAUS opens up a world of<br />
possibilities in diagnostic<br />
practices and<br />
the continuous<br />
monitoring<br />
of patient health.<br />
However, more steps must be taken<br />
before the BAUS device can be widely used<br />
and implemented. The existing device still<br />
needs to plug into a computer that<br />
collects and analyzes data.<br />
Zhao’s team is working on<br />
making a portable wireless<br />
version that can truly<br />
move with a patient and<br />
be used even when<br />
there is no access<br />
to a computer. Zhao<br />
a l s o<br />
describes that while the image<br />
quality of the BAUS probes is superior<br />
to other wearable devices, his team is<br />
still working on obtaining higher image<br />
resolution to match traditional ultrasound<br />
devices. Clinical trials must also be<br />
conducted before FDA approval. “In the<br />
first paper, we only tested healthy people.<br />
Now, we are applying this system to patients<br />
to study various diseases,” Zhao said.<br />
The development of the BAUS device<br />
is only the latest project that Zhao’s team<br />
at MIT has been working on as part of<br />
their mission to advance science and<br />
technology at the interface of humans and<br />
machines. The team’s expertise centers<br />
around materials science, mechanics,<br />
and biotechnology, but they regularly<br />
collaborate with experts in other fields<br />
and engage in intersectional projects.<br />
“We are really focused on addressing<br />
multidisciplinary challenges in health and<br />
sustainability. I believe we are solving some<br />
of the most important questions facing<br />
society, and I hope we can contribute to<br />
their solution,” Zhao said. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 31
FEATURE<br />
Biotechnology<br />
BY RISHA<br />
CHAKRABORTY<br />
ELECTRONIC<br />
SKIN<br />
Our world is being increasingly defined<br />
by a series of ones and zeroes.<br />
From the smallest phone gyroscope<br />
capable of detecting body movement to metal<br />
detectors at the airport to automatic PCR<br />
machines that test for the SARS-COV-2 virus<br />
in a matter of hours, the technology that<br />
acquires and transmits this data has made<br />
human lives much easier. Over the last two<br />
decades, practical artificial intelligence (AI)<br />
usage has led to expanding roles for computers<br />
in detecting danger, predicting scores,<br />
and advising outcomes in fields ranging<br />
from security to medicine—often beyond<br />
the scope of its original creation and with<br />
limited human intervention. Of course, popular<br />
debate and science fiction warns about<br />
how AI may eventually replace humans<br />
across many fields and make human effort<br />
obsolete. However, Wei Gao, a professor of<br />
medical engineering at the California Institute<br />
of Technology, sees the advancement of<br />
AI as an opportunity rather than a threat.<br />
Gao received his bachelor’s degree in mechanical<br />
engineering and his master’s degree<br />
in chemical engineering at the University of<br />
California, San Diego. He completed a postdoctoral<br />
fellowship in electrical engineering<br />
at the University of California, Berkeley. Because<br />
of his diverse educational background,<br />
he pursued the creation of robots imbued<br />
with functionalities beyond traditional ones.<br />
“In our minds, robots are industrial-level, capable<br />
of doing dangerous tasks in agriculture,<br />
defense, and space exploration because they<br />
can move and perform repetitive tasks, but<br />
we are thinking about the future. How can<br />
we build a better robot [by giving it] better<br />
functionalities and making it smarter? How<br />
can we give it more powerful sensing capabilities?”<br />
Gao pondered.<br />
Inspired by human skin’s ability to detect<br />
temperature, touch, texture, and even certain<br />
chemicals, for example, an allergic skin<br />
response after rolling around in the grass,<br />
Gao set out to develop ‘electronic skin.’ In<br />
the past, researchers have developed robots<br />
to detect and respond to physical parameters<br />
such as temperature and pressure.<br />
However, they were unwieldy and impractical—not<br />
much more than a thermometer<br />
on a remote-controllable stick. Moreover,<br />
Gao wanted to diversify the sensors in his<br />
robot so that the electronic skin could have<br />
an even greater range of sensory capabilities<br />
than human skin. In particular, he hoped to<br />
detect infectious pathogens for medical applications,<br />
neurotoxins or bomb debris for<br />
security purposes, and chemical pesticides<br />
for agricultural uses—all harmful or dangerous<br />
for humans to handle.<br />
The main problem was designing a method<br />
to make electronic skin emulate human<br />
skin. Scientists are only beginning to understand<br />
how human 'sensors' such as mechanoreceptors<br />
and thermoreceptors work. In<br />
fact, the 2020 Nobel Prize in Medicine and<br />
Physiology was awarded to two scientists<br />
for discovering the neural mechanisms behind<br />
human sensations. What would be the<br />
technological equivalent of millions of nerve<br />
endings in human skin conferring incredible<br />
sensitivity and a wide range of detecting<br />
abilities, and how could such a system be<br />
built in a reproducible, scalable way?<br />
With the help of colleagues with expertise<br />
in materials science and nano-engineering,<br />
Gao developed electronic skin, which he<br />
called E-skin-H. “My primary inspiration<br />
comes from human skin,” Gao said. Touch<br />
and pressure cause electrical changes that<br />
can then be converted to computer signals.<br />
To mimic the vast nerve network of human<br />
skin, Gao created sensor arrays with microscopic<br />
radii of detection, increasing both the<br />
sensitivity and strength of a signal compared<br />
to using a single large sensor. These properties<br />
are helpful in complex applications like<br />
detecting the presence of a specific chemical<br />
out of a large mixture.<br />
Embedding such minuscule sensor arrays<br />
in a highly flexible matrix is a technically<br />
easier way to create a bridge between sensors<br />
and robots than integrating the existing<br />
large chemical sensors meant for analysis<br />
of dry particles on robots. The flexibility of<br />
the sensor array material enables E-skin-H<br />
to retain its sensing capabilities regardless<br />
of how the actual robotic hand or arm on<br />
which it is mounted moves. Moreover, by<br />
using a hydrogel underneath the e-skin interface,<br />
the robotic skin can test for chemicals<br />
like they are in solution even though<br />
the sensor array is technically in a solid state.<br />
For example, biochemical tests like ELISAs<br />
can detect specific proteins, like those marking<br />
the surfaces of a SARS-COV-2 virus, in<br />
a solution. But now, with the hydrogel, the<br />
sensor array can detect proteins from a solid<br />
surface. Perhaps the most brilliant facet of<br />
Gao’s e-skin is that it can be printed with an<br />
inkjet printer. It requires only a series of nano-material<br />
metal inks such as gold, silver,<br />
and platinum to decorate graphene electrodes<br />
and a 3D-hydrogel printer. The ease<br />
of production vastly increases the scalability,<br />
adaptability, and replaceability of the sensor<br />
32 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
Biotechnology<br />
FEATURE<br />
How robots are gaining<br />
human-like sensing abilities<br />
ART BY CHARLOTTE LEAKEY<br />
arrays. It also decreases production costs,<br />
allowing for the creation of larger sensor arrays<br />
that can be modified to test for various<br />
new compounds.<br />
In his article published in Science Robotics,<br />
Gao built a robot called M-bot, which<br />
used machine learning to learn how human<br />
muscles, specifically hand and arm muscles,<br />
move in response to detecting certain tactile<br />
or chemical threats. Gao evaluated E-skin-H<br />
to see how the skin’s sensing capabilities<br />
could assist robots in making AI-based decisions<br />
the same way a human would. He concluded<br />
that M-bot could be used to detect<br />
compounds in a contaminated environment<br />
and track the source of trace amounts of<br />
hazardous compounds. In an early demonstration,<br />
M-bot tracked a nerve agent leak in<br />
an open field by detecting a gradient of the<br />
compound across the sensor array. By tracking<br />
the location of the highest concentration<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
of the compound, the AI algorithm within<br />
M-bot was able to signal to the motors<br />
within the robot arms and fingers to extend<br />
towards the location of the highest concentration<br />
to grasp objects and collect samples.<br />
“It was pretty impressive since it was fully<br />
automatic,” Gao said.<br />
Gao sees E-skin-H being used in medical<br />
and defense applications within the next five<br />
to ten years. “You don’t want to send a human<br />
into a danger zone to detect explosives<br />
or biohazards. Electronic skin can be used in<br />
military, environmental, and agricultural applications.<br />
We just have to make the robots<br />
[that use e-skin] smarter and more automatic—with<br />
the help of materials science, chemistry,<br />
and data processing.” Gao said.<br />
With the foreseeable future wrought by<br />
AI applications and robotic sensing technologies,<br />
Gao encourages anyone interested in<br />
robotics and technology to nurture this interest<br />
by identifying a problem, understanding<br />
where there is a gap in current technologies<br />
that attempt to address this problem,<br />
and imagining potential solutions. “Becoming<br />
involved in engineering or robotics is not<br />
a problem about technology, but more about<br />
developing a pattern of thinking. Trying<br />
competitions like FIRST Lego League and<br />
VEX Robotics inspires young students to<br />
imagine the fullest potential of robots,” Gao<br />
said. With this principle in mind, Gao combines<br />
chemical, medical, electrical, and mechanical<br />
principles to create solutions to the<br />
problems that fascinate him. As he expands<br />
his projects, from robots that use electronic<br />
skin in defense applications to nano-robots<br />
that deliver drugs to cells in the body, Gao<br />
is convinced of their increasing necessity in<br />
the future. “I’m excited to see how we interact<br />
with robots in our daily lives going forward,”<br />
Gao concluded. ■<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 33
UNDERGRADUATE PROFILE<br />
Shervin Dehmoubed—sophomore at Yale and stellar<br />
tennis player—is also a CEO, starting his entrepreneurial<br />
journey when he was just fifteen. He launched a children’s<br />
toy company specializing in products for kids diagnosed with<br />
ADHD/ADD, making a six-figure revenue within the first three<br />
years. This success fueled his following projects, Pik ‘le’ Ball, a<br />
pickleball accessory and clothing line, and a software company<br />
that built iOS apps for health and fitness. These experiences gave<br />
him the unique perspective and required expertise to launch his<br />
latest and most successful company, EcoPackables.<br />
Dehmoubed was shocked to discover how much plastic waste<br />
even a small brand could produce when working on Pik ‘le’ Ball.<br />
Thus, he launched a sustainable packaging company that sells<br />
packaging films made from recycled or compostable materials,<br />
aiming to find solutions to promote sustainability within the private<br />
sector. “This was during Covid, and e-commerce was booming, so<br />
I decided I wanted to do something about this,” Dehmoubed said.<br />
The key technology is a compostable film made from a<br />
blend of polylactic acid (PLA) and a bio-based polymer<br />
(PBAT). These films could eliminate “greenwashing” when an<br />
organization spends more time and money marketing itself as<br />
environmentally friendly than minimizing its environmental<br />
impact. PLA and PBAT are already used in biodegradable<br />
plastics such as waste bags. However, to make the films more<br />
suitable for packaging, Dehmoubed made them thicker and<br />
added certain proportions of different renewable elements<br />
to make them more sustainable. Now, their compostable<br />
film, called D42, is certified to degrade in home compost<br />
environments within one-hundred eighty days and industrial<br />
compost environments within ninety days. Dehmoubed claims<br />
that EcoPackables is the most sustainable packaging company<br />
because they have the highest proportion of renewable<br />
resources (organic materials) to PBAT while still breaking<br />
down into organic biomass, water, and CO 2<br />
, leaving behind<br />
zero plastic waste. “I’ve been very passionate about reducing<br />
BY SHERRY WANG<br />
plastic waste and stopping climate change. Specifically, how<br />
you can reduce your carbon footprints based on how you<br />
produce packaging material and handle proper end-of-life<br />
disposal,” Dehmoubed said.<br />
Historically, the packaging industry has been one of the<br />
most commoditized—no company owns more than five<br />
percent of the market share. For a younger entrepreneur like<br />
Dehmoubed, building a brand in such an environment was<br />
challenging. Thus, he built a brand focused on sustainability<br />
instead of being a direct competitor of packaging companies.<br />
He was not interested in cutting costs or taking shortcuts<br />
to increase the bottom line, or the company’s net profit,<br />
but rather wanted to hit the triple bottom line: good for the<br />
customer, good for the planet, and good for the company. His<br />
biggest challenge was selling his vision to traditionally archaic<br />
buyers hyper-focused on net profits. However, by convincing<br />
companies to look towards the younger generations for future<br />
sustainable operations, Ecopackables is being used by brands<br />
such as Ivory Ella, Beats, and Bud Light.<br />
Dehmoubed envisions that EcoPackables will become a<br />
globally recognized brand for its sustainable practices. He<br />
hopes to become a one-stop shop for brand-oriented companies<br />
looking to clean up their operations. Currently, they have two<br />
more products in the works: food-safe packaging developed<br />
using post-consumer recycled content and curbside recyclable<br />
Ocea brand polythene bags. The thin Ocea plastic bags are<br />
made from Forest Stewardship Council certified mixed paper,<br />
ensuring that products come from responsibly managed forests<br />
that provide environmental, social, and economic benefits.<br />
Ocea launched their product earlier this year to eliminate<br />
plastic from accumulating in our oceans. “Packaging is<br />
extremely important because it’s the first part of your product<br />
the customer interacts with. And we know how important first<br />
impressions are,” Dehmoubed said. ■<br />
SHERVIN<br />
DEHMOUBED<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF SHERVIN DEHMOUBED<br />
34 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
PHOTO COURTESY OF ALEX DONG<br />
TYLER MYERS<br />
Organic Chemistry is one of the most notoriously difficult<br />
classes at Yale. Pre-med hopefuls and chemistry whizzes<br />
alike spend long nights learning reaction mechanisms<br />
and drawing energy-level diagrams. But last year, one Yale teaching<br />
fellow (TF) went above and beyond by making Organic Chemistry<br />
a much more manageable, even enjoyable experience. Tyler Myers,<br />
a Chemistry Ph.D. candidate in the Miller Lab, is making an impact<br />
on his students through his palpable passion for chemistry.<br />
Myers discovered his love for the subject in high school, spending<br />
three years learning chemistry with a phenomenal teacher named Ms.<br />
Bell. His interest brought him to the University of Wyoming, where he<br />
was a chemistry major. After one of his general chemistry exams, his<br />
professor, David Anderson, passed him a note which read: Big-T, you<br />
should talk to me about research! “Research was completely foreign to<br />
me — but it was one of the best experiences I’ve ever had,” Myers said.<br />
In Anderson’s lab, Myers synthesized complexes to help construct<br />
hydrogen-based fuel cells. After taking Organic Chemistry with<br />
Robert Corcoran and loving it, Myers switched to Michael Taylor’s lab,<br />
where he worked on selective modifications of the amino acid residue<br />
tryptophan in peptides and proteins.<br />
The next stop for Myers was Yale—as a graduate student in Scott<br />
Miller’s lab. He remembers sitting in the airport before flying to New<br />
Haven for an admitted students visit when he saw that the Miller<br />
Lab had recently published a paper on the selective modification<br />
of Geldanamycin, a biologically active natural product. “Late-stage<br />
diversification of natural products was fascinating to me,” Myers<br />
said. While at Yale, he attended a meeting with Miller and heard<br />
more about his research. “All I remember was that my chest got<br />
really fuzzy,” Myers said, “I knew that this was the place for me.”<br />
Now, Myers researches asymmetric catalysis—working to<br />
preferentially synthesize one enantiomer of a chemical compound<br />
over the other. Enantiomers are chemical structures that are<br />
non-superimposable mirror images of each other, and it can<br />
be challenging to selectively synthesize one enantiomer of a<br />
compound. “The most common example we use is our hands,”<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
GRADUATE PROFILE<br />
BY SOPHIA BURICK<br />
Myers said, “Just how you can write better with one hand, drugs<br />
experience a very similar phenomenon with biological activity,<br />
where one enantiomer of a drug is often more biologically active<br />
than the other.” Myers, now a third-year Ph.D. candidate, recently<br />
received the prestigious NSF Graduate Research Fellowship for his<br />
potential to contribute to the field of chemistry and broaden access<br />
to science and research.<br />
Myers is equally excellent in his work as a teaching fellow. As<br />
students in First-year Organic Chemistry, CHEM 174, last fall will tell<br />
you, Myers was a saving grace. He has loved teaching since he was<br />
an undergraduate, working as a tutor, a teaching assistant, and even<br />
traveling across Wyoming to deliver engaging scientific demonstrations<br />
to students to encourage them to pursue a STEM education.<br />
“I thought being a teaching fellow would be great practice since I<br />
want to go into academia, and it was another opportunity to interact<br />
with students. It was really fun. I met some phenomenal students that<br />
are really passionate,” Myers said. His work as a TF won him a Yale<br />
Prize Teaching Fellowship—one of the highest honors a graduate<br />
student at Yale can receive. He was nominated for the award by the<br />
many appreciative students in CHEM 174. “Tyler was a great TF and<br />
also such a great mentor. He encouraged me to pursue chemistry<br />
research and was a friendly face this summer when I was in a lab<br />
near his,” said Lizbeth Lozano, one of Myers’s past students.<br />
“I got to read the reviews that students wrote,” Myers said,<br />
“I remember leaving work just ecstatic.” Knowing his students<br />
truly enjoyed his work as a teaching fellow was the most<br />
rewarding thing for Myers.<br />
After graduating, Myers hopes to become a professor at a<br />
primarily undergraduate institution. His goal is to dismantle the<br />
reputation of organic chemistry as an intimidating, inaccessible<br />
science and help others appreciate the beauty and potential it holds.<br />
“I am fortunate to have so many great opportunities and supportive<br />
people in my life,” Myers said, “I think teaching at a primarily<br />
undergraduate institution would be an excellent opportunity to<br />
give back to the community.” ■<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 35
BY<br />
KELLY<br />
CHEN<br />
THE WORLDS WE<br />
DON'T REALIZE<br />
Close your eyes and take a deep breath. Imagine that you<br />
SCIENCE I N<br />
can suddenly hear the hum of two insects communicating,<br />
smell every scent trail, or even feel the Earth’s magnetic<br />
field. Supersonic hearing, enhanced smell, or an internal sense<br />
of direction—traits we think of as superpowers have long been<br />
possessed by animals.<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF FLICKR<br />
Join Ed Yong in his book An Immense World: How Animal Senses<br />
Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us as he takes you on journeys<br />
you may literally never be able to see. For example, most animals<br />
can see ultraviolet (UV) light. With UV vision, rodents are better<br />
able to see birds in the sky, fish can easily identify plankton in<br />
water, and reindeer can comfortably find mosses and lichens to<br />
eat, all because of UV light detection. Yong’s curiosity will pull<br />
you in as he shows you discoveries made by scientists over the<br />
years, as well as his own encounters with the animal world; his<br />
easy-going language yet detailed imagery transports you right to<br />
the middle of other animals’ worlds while also teaching you about<br />
the science behind it all.<br />
As you dive into the book, you’ll learn about different Umwelts—a<br />
German term popularized by the Baltic-German zoologist Jakob<br />
von Uexküll—defined as “the part of [the animal’s] surroundings<br />
that an animal can sense and experience—its perceptual world.”<br />
Yong writes, “Nothing can sense everything, and nothing needs<br />
to.” From hearing about everything from snakes and elephants<br />
to mosquitoes and dogs, you'll realize that the sensory skill sets<br />
between animals are widely different, and for good reason. If we<br />
were to sense everything, Yong said, “[we] would be overwhelmed<br />
by the flood of stimuli, most of which would be irrelevant.” The<br />
things we perceive are special to our Umwelt with unnecessary<br />
information filtered from our senses as we evolve.<br />
And though we might wish for some of the senses other animals<br />
possess, human senses have advantages. For example, humans are<br />
one of the most visually adept species. While we may not be able<br />
to track scents with our noses, we are one of the best species at<br />
differentiating between scents.<br />
However, most of all, we have the technology to explore the<br />
Umwelts of the world. “This ability to dip into other Umwelten<br />
is our greatest sensory skill,” says Yong. Though we may never<br />
be able to truly experience the Umwelts of other animals, our<br />
growing knowledge enables us to understand and choose to see<br />
the world from realms that are not our own. By reading Yong’s<br />
engrossing novel, the world as we know it suddenly becomes<br />
much more vibrant. As Yong puts it, “It is not a blessing we<br />
have earned, but it is one we must cherish." ■<br />
36 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
THE SKY IS FOR<br />
EVERYONE<br />
BY<br />
CELINA ZHAO<br />
The Sky is for Everyone: Women Astronomers in<br />
Their Own Words is a newly published collection of<br />
autobiographical excerpts from renowned women<br />
in astronomy, detailing their challenges and triumphs in this<br />
historically male-dominated field. It features two prominent<br />
Yale astrophysicists: Meg Urry, Israel Munson Professor of<br />
Physics and Director of the Yale Center for Astronomy and<br />
Astrophysics, and Priyamvada Natarajan, Joseph C. and Sofia<br />
C. Futon Professor of Astronomy and Physics and Director of<br />
Yale’s Franke Program in Science and the Humanities.<br />
In her chapter titled “The Gentlemen and Me,” Dr. Urry<br />
speaks about the few times this field felt unwelcoming. As one<br />
of two women in her graduate astronomy program, she was<br />
never invited to weekly study sessions and was cruelly pranked<br />
with a Playgirl magazine by her male classmates. Dr. Natarajan’s<br />
chapter focuses on her background, work, and personal journey<br />
through academia and how her love for science developed.<br />
What was your reaction when asked to contribute to this book?<br />
Urry: I actually told them I couldn’t do it at first, but then<br />
shortly after Covid hit, while I was sitting at home, I was<br />
reflecting about where I was and how I’d gotten there and<br />
thought, “Wow, this is really something I’d like to do.”<br />
Natarajan: I was very honored but also kind of surprised<br />
and intrigued because they made it explicit that they wanted<br />
something about my personal experience and journey, and I didn’t<br />
think that would be something of interest.<br />
What was your writing process?<br />
Urry: In two days, I’d actually written eighteen thousand<br />
words while the editors had only wanted three thousand. So, I<br />
spent time cutting it down—the whole process actually inspired<br />
T H E<br />
SPOTLIGHT<br />
me to write and tell more of my stories.<br />
Natarajan: I like writing, and I do a lot of different kinds of it,<br />
but it was very challenging because I don’t ever write explicitly<br />
about myself… It was also interesting to go over my path and<br />
look back—I tend not to reminisce much as there is so much<br />
more science that I want to do.<br />
Why do you think these stories are important?<br />
Urry: Sadly, I think it’s because there hasn’t been enough<br />
change. When I came to Yale in 2001, I was the only woman in<br />
the physics department faculty. Now we have six so there’s been<br />
Professor Urry next to her book.<br />
PHOTO COURTESY OF JENNY WONG<br />
a positive change there, but I still hear younger women talking<br />
about similar experiences [that I talk about in the book].<br />
Natarajan: It was quite amazing to hear about how others<br />
had found their way into academia and what motivates them.<br />
It’s so important for people to see that there’s no one way to<br />
be a scientist…. But what’s really sobering is that you can see<br />
that a lot of women have had more challenging paths through<br />
intellectual life [than men], and it’s important to see all the<br />
different kinds of struggles and how they persevered for the<br />
love of the subject. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 37
IMAGE COURTESY OF NIH PHOTO LIBRARY<br />
COUNTERPOINT<br />
A New Way of<br />
Detecting Alzheimer’s<br />
BY ABIGAIL JOLTEUS<br />
Imagine progressively losing the memories you<br />
cherish deeply, eventually no longer being able<br />
to learn new things, read and write with ease,<br />
or recognize loved ones. People with Alzheimer’s, a<br />
form of dementia, lead lives with these worsening<br />
symptoms. With no cure and a short lifespan after<br />
diagnosis, Alzheimer’s is a devastating, progressive<br />
neurological disorder that affects memory, behavior,<br />
motor skills and thought processes.<br />
Initially, scientists could only diagnose Alzheimer’s<br />
by performing an autopsy after death. Since then,<br />
many advances have been made. Clinicians can now<br />
detect early signs using remarkable technology, such<br />
as positron emission tomography (PET), a type of diagnostic<br />
technology used to show the metabolic activity<br />
of the brain, and various tests on cerebrospinal fluid<br />
(CSF)—the clear, watery fluid around the spinal cord<br />
and brain. Some hallmarks include decreased glucose<br />
uptake and the accumulation of beta-amyloid plaques,<br />
proteins that aggregate between neurons and disrupt<br />
their normal function. However, these methods can be<br />
quite invasive. For example, a PET scan requires the<br />
injection of radioactive material into the bloodstream,<br />
and the extraction of CSF involves inserting a needle<br />
into someone’s back. These diagnostic tools are uncomfortable<br />
and expensive, making these procedures<br />
inaccessible to many people.<br />
Alzheimer’s is characterized by plaques of beta-amyloid<br />
in the brain, yet new evidence suggests these<br />
plaques also accumulate in the retina. The retina, which<br />
is closely related to brain tissue, is routinely examined<br />
to detect eye diseases through a process called fundus<br />
photography or digital retinal imaging. A similar technique<br />
may soon provide a non-invasive and cost-efficient<br />
method of identifying early signs of Alzheimer’s.<br />
Robert Vince, Swati More, and their colleagues at<br />
the University of Minnesota discovered a technique<br />
called hyperspectral imaging. They used the technique<br />
to detect clumps of beta-amyloid in mouse retinas<br />
at the early stages of the disease. In hyperspectral<br />
imaging, standard eye examination equipment, like<br />
an autorefractor, is combined with a hyperspectral<br />
camera — a special camera that captures light from<br />
IMAGE COURTESY OF EMMAGARCIAMILLER<br />
across the electromagnetic spectrum.<br />
Then, artificial intelligence compares<br />
the data-rich images with other images<br />
with similar physical properties associated<br />
with Alzheimer’s disease.<br />
Clinical trials are currently underway<br />
across North America to test the efficacy of this technique,<br />
and there have already been promising results.<br />
In a cohort of 108 participants who were either at risk<br />
of Alzheimer’s or already had preclinical Alzheimer’s,<br />
the technique correctly identified people with beta-amyloid<br />
plaques in their brains eighty-six percent<br />
of the time. PET scans and CSF results validated these<br />
retinal screening tests. They also observed beta-amyloid<br />
clumps in the brain at later stages, suggesting that<br />
the presence of beta-amyloid plaques in<br />
the retina may also be an early detection<br />
marker in humans.<br />
Though these results are promising,<br />
more studies with diverse participants<br />
and larger cohorts are needed before phy- sicians<br />
can use this technique as an official diagnostic tool.<br />
Moreover, some researchers have noted that amyloids<br />
can be present in the retinas of people that do<br />
not develop signs of cognitive decline.<br />
While there are issues with this technique that<br />
need to be resolved, early detection of<br />
Alzheimer’s using retinal imaging has the<br />
potential to become a widely-used diagnostic<br />
tool. Other retinal signs may<br />
help with the early detection of Alzheimer’s,<br />
including retinal thickness and changes<br />
in blood vessels. A longitudinal trial called Atlas of<br />
Retinal Imaging in Alzheimer’s Study (ARIAS) is<br />
examining these retina-based biomarkers in hopes<br />
of improving the early diagnosis of Alzheimer’s.<br />
This project is still in the recruiting phase, but if<br />
proven successful, researchers may seek to develop<br />
more types of retinal-based tests. Earlier treatment<br />
of Alzheimer’s may alleviate many<br />
symptoms and help scientists better understand<br />
the pathogenesis of this condition<br />
with the hope of developing a cure. ■<br />
38 Yale Scientific Magazine October 2022 www.yalescientific.org
HIDDEN<br />
HISTORIES<br />
BESTIE BLOUNT GRIFFIN<br />
BY ILORA ROY<br />
ART BY NOORA SAID<br />
Bessie Blount Griffin was an inventor, nurse, physical<br />
therapist, forensic handwriting and document analyst,<br />
and avid public speaker. However, unlike many in her<br />
field, she was Black, left-handed, and a woman. Blount was born<br />
on November 24, 1914, in Hickory, now Chesapeake, Virginia,<br />
to parents George Woodard and Mary Elizabeth Griffin. In<br />
elementary school, her teachers constantly reprimanded her<br />
for writing with her left hand. After having her knuckles<br />
rapped countless times, Blount protested: if it was wrong for<br />
her to write with her left hand, then it must also be wrong to<br />
write with her right! She then taught herself how to write with<br />
her teeth and toes in response to her teacher’s disapproval.<br />
Blount studied nursing at Keney Memorial Hospital and<br />
physical therapy at Union Junior College and Panzer College<br />
of Physical Education and Hygiene. After obtaining her degree<br />
from Union, Blount became a licensed physiotherapist at the<br />
Bronx Hospital in New York, where she helped World War<br />
II veterans with amputated limbs. She was not your average<br />
nurse. In addition to supporting amputee patients in recovering<br />
their balance and mobility, she also helped them reclaim their<br />
independence. Blount took a page out of her own book and<br />
taught the veterans how to write with their teeth and toes.<br />
“You’re not crippled, only crippled in your mind,” she said.<br />
She continued to look for ways to give veterans autonomy<br />
over their bodies, for example, inventing a device called the<br />
Invalid Feeder to help. Patients would bite down on a tube that<br />
would activate a motor, and food would dispense through a<br />
mouthpiece in the shape of a spoon. The device shuts off after<br />
each cycle to ensure the patient would not choke. While Blount<br />
continued to work as a nurse during the day, she would work<br />
late hours in the night from 1:00 AM to 4:00 AM building her<br />
instruments. Blount did not have a degree in engineering, yet<br />
she was able to construct ingenious devices because of her<br />
passion for helping patients.<br />
Continuing to invent, Blount created more apparatuses, such<br />
as disposable kidney-shaped basins to dispose of bodily waste<br />
and the “portable receptacle support,” similar to the “invalid<br />
feeder,” with the addition of a neck brace with a bowl. The<br />
latter received a patent under her name on April 24, 1951,<br />
making Blount one of the first officially recognized inventors<br />
in physical therapy. She had many other accomplishments<br />
from becoming a handwriting analyst for several police<br />
departments— including Scotland Yard in England, where she<br />
was the first Black American woman to have trained there—to<br />
starting her own consulting business in her hometown.<br />
However, Blount’s accomplishments did not come without<br />
challenges. After inventing the “invalid feeder,” she wanted to<br />
bring relief to others around the country, but the US military<br />
refused to pay Blount a fair amount. She also tried to sell her<br />
devices to the American Veterans Association, but they did not<br />
want to support her due to her race and gender. Blount wanted<br />
to prove that her inventions<br />
themselves were impressive<br />
and did not want to tie<br />
her inventions to her<br />
identity as a Black<br />
woman. She was<br />
not driven<br />
by financial<br />
motivation<br />
but rather by<br />
the idea of<br />
helping society<br />
progress<br />
through her<br />
innovations.<br />
Even after being<br />
turned down<br />
by many different<br />
organizations, she<br />
eventually donated the<br />
“invalid feeder” to France,<br />
where the French<br />
used it in military<br />
hospitals. Belgium<br />
also bought<br />
her disposable<br />
basins. ■<br />
www.yalescientific.org<br />
October 2022 Yale Scientific Magazine 39
AD_Yale_SC_ENG_half_FALL_10_19qxp.qxp_8 10/7/19 12:05 PM Page 1<br />
Welcome to Yale!<br />
The Yale Science and Engineering<br />
Association is here for you.<br />
Founded in 1914, the YSEA is one of the oldest university student/alumni<br />
organizations in the world with a focus on STEM.<br />
Whether near or far from New Haven, we help our members realize their<br />
goals and to connect in ways that strengthen the Yale science and<br />
engineering community.<br />
We are excited to be a part of your Yale journey, and we look forward to<br />
supporting you at Yale and beyond!<br />
Join us at: ysea.org