Theory of Knowledge - Course Companion for Students Marija Uzunova Dang Arvin Singh Uzunov Dang

ayodelepearce1
from ayodelepearce1 More from this publisher
21.11.2022 Views

is beyond rationality or irrationality, suchwhichcompassion, love, reverence and faith. Do youaswith this dichotomy that Raman is posing?agreeor whynot?Whystatus does religious knowledge have inWhatof legitimacy and reliability in comparisontermsthe other areas of knowledge? What contextualtoaffect its status? Why is it not consideredfactorsarea of knowledge? How would you respondanclaims that non-Abrahamic traditions, ortoreligions, as Raman argues, are more“Eastern”with the scientific pursuit of knowledge?alignedexplore this line of enquiry further, refer toTo(2010) and Wallace (2003).Capraespecially in its pop cultureBuddhism,is often framed in psychologicalimagining,as a “science of the mind”, or alternativelyterms,more of a philosophy than a religion. Evenasearly as 1974, Chögyam Trungpa Rinpocheaspredicted that “Buddhism will come tohadWest as a psychology” (quoted in GolemanthePerhaps these interpretations of Buddhism2004).tell us more about the cultures toultimatelyit is spreading, than about Buddhismwhichis often perceived as spreadingGlobalizationprivileged set of knowledges and culturesathe world. How have religiousaroundand practices met this force?communitiesthe scope of religious thought expands,Whensome religions becoming global, it iswithto consider how the global modernizedinterestingof those religions compares with the moreversioncontextualized versions at their origin.locallyreligious knowledge be independent fromCanplace and people who produced it? Whiletheknowledge can travel far, to what extentreligiousit be understood by those outside of thecancommunity? For example, we considerreligiousknowledge issues involved in translationtheChapter 4. To what extent can religiousinbe thought of as consistent or truthful,knowledgetranslations and other transfers are used?whenwhat extent would you agree that TibetanToin California, and Tibetan Buddhism inBuddhismare the same religion? More generally, howTibet,religious knowledge spread, and how mightdoeswe mentioned the enduring pluralism ofEarlier,practices in the modern world. Therereligioustoday over a million Buddhists in Northarethe vast majority of whom were notAmerica,to the faith. In Europe, there is a significantbornpopulation—tens of millions—andMuslimin places such as the Netherlands. Acrossrisingworld, practitioners and believers ofthefaiths are sharing space. Are religiousdifferentencountering one another andknowledgesinto conversation any differently fromenteringways they have in the past?themany places around the world, religiousInand identity were until very recentlyknowledgeII. PerspectivesI. ScopeII. PerspectivesThe very idea that Buddhism had anything to do withpsychology was at the time for most of us in the eldpatently absurd. But that attitude reected more ourown naivete than anything to do with Buddhism.(Goleman 2004)itself.it change in response to being spread?I I . P E R S P E C T I V E SII.1 Engaging with religious multiplicityinherited; they were forms of learning the values145

II. Perspectivespractices of the culture in a community orandAs people become more mobile, comfortableplace.independent of their home communities, theyandthe opportunity and challenge of crafting theirfaceand/or religious identities. Some peoplespiritualplaces have come into this faster than others,andto sociologist Peter Berger, for most ofAccordingpeople would rarely, if ever, encounterhistory,of a different religion; to be of a certainsomeonein a given village would be self-evident,religioninevitable and taken for granted. Withnatural,and secularism, people had theglobalizationopportunity of imagining other possibilities.newdescribes modernity as “a giganticBergerfrom destiny to choice” in whichtransformation“must choose what they believe, howpeopledefine themselves, how they are to live”theyin Tippett 2006a). People now encounter(quotedeven neighbours, with very differentothers,beliefs and world views. Has thisreligioushow we value and perceive religiouschangedWhat else has been affected?knowledge?cosmopolitan cities around the world,Indiversity is being championed andreligiousas well as feared and resisted. It addscelebrated,the richness of human experience as well astothe insecurity of those who feel threatenedtochange. Reverend angel Kyodo williams hasbyreligious diversity. Where diversityinvestigatedbeen welcomed, williams observes thathasidentities and sense of thriving is notpeople’son religious sameness. Instead, thedependentsense of mobility and spaciousnessheightenedaccompanies religious diversity outweighsthatunease. However, some communities do feeltheby religious diversity. In light of whatthreatenedwhat it means when people say theyConsiderreligious or spiritual, or when they specifyareWhat relationship do spirituality and1.belief have to knowledge, inreligiousHow are religious knowledge2.norms, traditions andcommunities,(a) religious people(b) those who are spiritual but not religiousof the themes within diversity is tolerance,Onerefers not simply to accepting people whowhichdifferent, but also tolerating people who youarenot like or agree with, or who do seeminglydois worth considering what skills might beItof the knower in navigating therequiredof religious pluralism effectively andlandscapeWe briefly explore the relationshiprespectfully.religious knowledge and the conceptbetweentruth below. How might we evaluate theof6For ref lectionThe spiritual and religiousthat they are spiritual but not religious.creating another layer of friction.terms of:(a) what is considered a reliable source ofknowledgewho has the authority and/(b)legitimacy to decide what isorknowledge?institutions seen differentlyby:(c) those who are neither spiritual norreligious?strange or nonsensical things.you have read, why might this be the case?competing claims of different religions?Does religion seek truth?intellectual tradition has broader meaning, as well asspecic connotations. Learn more about the relationshipWhat kind of knowledge is religious knowledge? Therebetween ‘ilm and the pursuit, acquisition and applicationare diverse perspectives about how knowledge isof knowledge by following the link.perceived in religious traditions and in, for example,mainstream pop culture, TOK and the IB DiplomaSearch terms: Islamic concept ofknowledge al-islamProgramme. Consider the Arabic word ‘ilm (), which iscommonly translated as “knowledge”, but in the Islamic146

II. Perspectives

practices of the culture in a community or

and

As people become more mobile, comfortable

place.

independent of their home communities, they

and

the opportunity and challenge of crafting their

face

and/or religious identities. Some people

spiritual

places have come into this faster than others,

and

to sociologist Peter Berger, for most of

According

people would rarely, if ever, encounter

history,

of a different religion; to be of a certain

someone

in a given village would be self-evident,

religion

inevitable and taken for granted. With

natural,

and secularism, people had the

globalization

opportunity of imagining other possibilities.

new

describes modernity as “a gigantic

Berger

from destiny to choice” in which

transformation

“must choose what they believe, how

people

define themselves, how they are to live”

they

in Tippett 2006a). People now encounter

(quoted

even neighbours, with very different

others,

beliefs and world views. Has this

religious

how we value and perceive religious

changed

What else has been affected?

knowledge?

cosmopolitan cities around the world,

In

diversity is being championed and

religious

as well as feared and resisted. It adds

celebrated,

the richness of human experience as well as

to

the insecurity of those who feel threatened

to

change. Reverend angel Kyodo williams has

by

religious diversity. Where diversity

investigated

been welcomed, williams observes that

has

identities and sense of thriving is not

people’s

on religious sameness. Instead, the

dependent

sense of mobility and spaciousness

heightened

accompanies religious diversity outweighs

that

unease. However, some communities do feel

the

by religious diversity. In light of what

threatened

what it means when people say they

Consider

religious or spiritual, or when they specify

are

What relationship do spirituality and

1.

belief have to knowledge, in

religious

How are religious knowledge

2.

norms, traditions and

communities,

(a) religious people

(b) those who are spiritual but not religious

of the themes within diversity is tolerance,

One

refers not simply to accepting people who

which

different, but also tolerating people who you

are

not like or agree with, or who do seemingly

do

is worth considering what skills might be

It

of the knower in navigating the

required

of religious pluralism effectively and

landscape

We briefly explore the relationship

respectfully.

religious knowledge and the concept

between

truth below. How might we evaluate the

of

6

For ref lection

The spiritual and religious

that they are spiritual but not religious.

creating another layer of friction.

terms of:

(a) what is considered a reliable source of

knowledge

who has the authority and/

(b)

legitimacy to decide what is

or

knowledge?

institutions seen differentlyby:

(c) those who are neither spiritual nor

religious?

strange or nonsensical things.

you have read, why might this be the case?

competing claims of different religions?

Does religion seek truth?

intellectual tradition has broader meaning, as well as

specic connotations. Learn more about the relationship

What kind of knowledge is religious knowledge? There

between ‘ilm and the pursuit, acquisition and application

are diverse perspectives about how knowledge is

of knowledge by following the link.

perceived in religious traditions and in, for example,

mainstream pop culture, TOK and the IB Diploma

Search terms: Islamic concept of

knowledge al-islam

Programme. Consider the Arabic word ‘ilm (

), which is

commonly translated as “knowledge”, but in the Islamic

146

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!