Dominican Republic and Haiti: Country Studies
by Helen Chapin Metz et al by Helen Chapin Metz et al
Dominican Republic and Haiti: Country Studies (IDB), as his next prime minister. Pierre failed to win confirmation, however, because many parliamentarians were uncomfortable with his links to an organization viewed as promoting Haiti's controversial economic policies. In late 1997, Preval sent his second nomination, Herve Denis, to the legislative body for confirmation. Denis, an economist and playwright with close ties to Aristide, was denied the post as the OPL rallied against him. In July 1998, Preval sent his third nomination, Jacques Edouard Alexis, an educator and minister of national education, youth, and sports in the Smarth cabinet, to parliament. Initially, with strong national and international pressure building for the confirmation of Alexis as a pivotal first step toward resolution of the increasingly debilitating political crisis, it appeared that Haiti would finally have a new prime minister. Once in office, Alexis and his government would face not only the task of forging the government's role in rebuilding the nation, but also the challenge of organizing the municipal and parliamentary elections mandated by the end of 1998. Alexis was eventually confirmed by the severely divided parliament, but not until December 17, much too late to organize the elections. Before the new prime minister completed the required next steps of the parliamentary ratification process — presenting his general policy statement and his cabinet—Haiti's political crisis deepened even further. On January 12, 1999, President Preval, citing the 1995 electoral law that identified January 11 as the expiration date of the term of public officials elected in 1995, issued a presidential decree dismissing the entire Chamber of Deputies and Senate, with the exception of the nine senators who had been elected to six-year terms. On January 22, Preval issued another decree, converting the positions of elected mayors and communal section council members, whose terms also expired, into "interim executive agents" assigned to the Ministry of Interior. The Haitian chief executive's actions ushered the country into yet another period of governance by decree, albeit this time by a legitimately elected president and prime minister who had been confirmed personally, but whose government had not completed the confirmation process. Haiti's defunct lawmakers vehemently protested Preval's decision, citing constitutional irregularities and calling for the populace to rally to their cause. Ultimately, however, Haiti's Supreme Court failed to rule against the president's actions, and ordinary Haitians, "disillu- 422
Haiti: Government and Politics sioned with their dysfunctional democracy," failed to respond to the parliamentarians' call. Unbalanced Power: January-December 1999 Following what Preval's critics labeled a "political coup d'etat," Haiti entered into a period characterized by protracted, tedious, and often byzantine political negotiations, and by spasms of demonstrations and politically related unrest. The next twelve months were also characterized by widespread speculation of veiled political intrigue, particularly as it related to the involvement of former President Aristide and his partisans, and uncertain progress toward the resolution of the political deadlock that had all but derailed the country's meandering march toward democratic governance. Shortly after the president's dismissal of parliament, six political parties, including the OPL, formed the Coalition to Defend Democracy (L'Espace de Concertation pour la Sauvegarde de la Democratic) and opened negotiations with the executive branch to resolve the crisis. In late February, the OPL withdrew from the coalition, just prior to the murder of still-sitting Senator Yvon Toussaint, a member of the party. On March 6, the remaining five members of the coalition signed an accord with the executive to resolve the crisis. The agreement mandated the quick creation of a CEP to begin organizing the overdue municipal and parliamentary elections. On March 16, Preval named by decree a nine-member CEP that included three members chosen by the coalition. Reaction to Preval's actions varied. The coalition members and the FL welcomed the formation of the CEP. The OPL and several conservative political organizations reacted coolly, noting that while the members appointed to the body were individuals of integrity, the body itself had not been formed in consultation with parliament, as required by law. Next, on March 24 Preval named a government. Led by Prime Minister Alexis, the cabinet of ministers, sworn in on March 26, was viewed by the government's critics as composed principally of supporters of President Preval and former President Aristide. Before the CEP could move toward elections, it was obligated to resolve the still-festering controversy surrounding the outcome of two Senate seats contested in April 1997 and claimed by the FL. On June 11, the CEP effectively annulled the results of those elections by announcing that the upcoming Senate race would include the two contested seats. It then set 423
- Page 404 and 405: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 406 and 407: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 408 and 409: — Dominican Republic and Haiti: C
- Page 410 and 411: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 412 and 413: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 414 and 415: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 416 and 417: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 418 and 419: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 420 and 421: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 422 and 423: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 424 and 425: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 426 and 427: — Dominican Republic and Haiti: C
- Page 428 and 429: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 430 and 431: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 432 and 433: — Dominican Republic and Haiti: C
- Page 434 and 435: — Dominican Republic and Haiti: C
- Page 436 and 437: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 438 and 439: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 440 and 441: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 442 and 443: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 444 and 445: Figurefrom a painting by Dieuseul P
- Page 446 and 447: . Dominican Republic and Haiti: Cou
- Page 448 and 449: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 450 and 451: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 452 and 453: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 456 and 457: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 458 and 459: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 460 and 461: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 462 and 463: . Dominican Republic and Haiti: Cou
- Page 464 and 465: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 466 and 467: . Dominican Republic and Haiti: Cou
- Page 468 and 469: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 470 and 471: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 472 and 473: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 474 and 475: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 476 and 477: . — Dominican Republic and Haiti:
- Page 478 and 479: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 480 and 481: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 482 and 483: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 484 and 485: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 486 and 487: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 488 and 489: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 490 and 491: Figurefrom a painting by Prosper Pi
- Page 492 and 493: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 494 and 495: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 496 and 497: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 498 and 499: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 500 and 501: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
- Page 502 and 503: Dominican Republic and Haiti: Count
<strong>Haiti</strong>: Government <strong>and</strong> Politics<br />
sioned with their dysfunctional democracy," failed to respond<br />
to the parliamentarians' call.<br />
Unbalanced Power: January-December 1999<br />
Following what Preval's critics labeled a "political coup<br />
d'etat," <strong>Haiti</strong> entered into a period characterized by protracted,<br />
tedious, <strong>and</strong> often byzantine political negotiations, <strong>and</strong> by<br />
spasms of demonstrations <strong>and</strong> politically related unrest. The<br />
next twelve months were also characterized by widespread<br />
speculation of veiled political intrigue, particularly as it related<br />
to the involvement of former President Aristide <strong>and</strong> his partisans,<br />
<strong>and</strong> uncertain progress toward the resolution of the political<br />
deadlock that had all but derailed the country's me<strong>and</strong>ering<br />
march toward democratic governance.<br />
Shortly after the president's dismissal of parliament, six<br />
political parties, including the OPL, formed the Coalition to<br />
Defend Democracy (L'Espace de Concertation pour la Sauvegarde<br />
de la Democratic) <strong>and</strong> opened negotiations with the executive<br />
branch to resolve the crisis. In late February, the OPL<br />
withdrew from the coalition, just prior to the murder of still-sitting<br />
Senator Yvon Toussaint, a member of the party. On March<br />
6, the remaining five members of the coalition signed an<br />
accord with the executive to resolve the crisis. The agreement<br />
m<strong>and</strong>ated the quick creation of a CEP to begin organizing the<br />
overdue municipal <strong>and</strong> parliamentary elections. On March 16,<br />
Preval named by decree a nine-member CEP that included<br />
three members chosen by the coalition. Reaction to Preval's<br />
actions varied. The coalition members <strong>and</strong> the FL welcomed<br />
the formation of the CEP. The OPL <strong>and</strong> several conservative<br />
political organizations reacted coolly, noting that while the<br />
members appointed to the body were individuals of integrity,<br />
the body itself had not been formed in consultation with parliament,<br />
as required by law. Next, on March 24 Preval named a<br />
government. Led by Prime Minister Alexis, the cabinet of ministers,<br />
sworn in on March 26, was viewed by the government's<br />
critics as composed principally of supporters of President<br />
Preval <strong>and</strong> former President Aristide.<br />
Before the CEP could move toward elections, it was obligated<br />
to resolve the still-festering controversy surrounding the<br />
outcome of two Senate seats contested in April 1997 <strong>and</strong><br />
claimed by the FL. On June 11, the CEP effectively annulled<br />
the results of those elections by announcing that the upcoming<br />
Senate race would include the two contested seats. It then set<br />
423