26.01.2022 Views

[textbook]Traversing the Ethical Minefield Problems, Law, and Professional Responsibility by Susan R. Martyn (z-lib.org)(1) (1)

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

an individual might reasonably believe the lawyer represents his or her interests as well as

those of the organization. 12

8. Clients Who Morph The practice of law is dynamic, and accidental clients can occur

when clients change. If lawyers do not notice client changes such as marriage, divorce, or

death, they might communicate with the wrong person or bring a lawsuit in the wrong

name. Some clients have fluctuating capacities, which requires that lawyers evaluate their

capacity before critical decisions can be made. 13 Organization clients may change their

personnel, governance structure, or their status, for example, by merging or filing for

bankruptcy, at which point a new decision maker might reverse a prior decision. The class

in class actions may be represented by named plaintiffs, but class identification and lawyer

loyalty can change as the matter progresses and class(es) are certified by courts. 14 Finally,

when lawyers complete a representation, each client morphs from a current client to a

former client, a characterization that changes, but does not extinguish, a lawyer’s fiduciary

duties.

9. Quasi-Clients If lawyers owe fiduciary duties to clients, it seems axiomatic that they owe

no such duties to nonclients. Yet some nonclients can be characterized as quasi-clients

because of their relationship to clients. For example, intended third-party beneficiaries of

client representations can be owed some of the same duties of competence owed clients. 15

Similarly, lawyers who represent client-fiduciaries such as trustees, guardians, corporate

directors, or partners also need to be mindful of the fiduciary obligations their clients owe

others. 16 Representing such a client-fiduciary requires advice about the broad scope of duty

owed by the fiduciary to third parties, duties that lawyers are obliged to assist their clientfiduciaries

in fulfilling. 17

10. Imputed Clients Although some lawyers practice solo, most practice in association with

others. The law governing lawyers imputes the obligations of one lawyer in a law firm to all

other lawyers in that firm as well. 18 It also extends these law firm obligations to law firm

employees, including temporary lawyers and student law clerks. 19

Lawyers who do not share an employment relationship could nevertheless look or act

like as though they have done so. For example, lawyers from different firms who intend to

split a legal fee usually are required to assume joint responsibility for the representation,

whether or not they work on the matter. 20 This creates a client-lawyer relationship with

each lawyer. Similarly, lawyers who share office space might not share fees, but might act as

a firm, by consulting on cases, using the same letterhead, or sharing file access. If so, they

could be held to constitute a “firm” with imputed client-lawyer relationships. 21 Likewise,

lawyers from different firms who participate in joint defense agreements might share

enough confidential information that their conflicts will be imputed to each other.

Conclusion

79

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!