11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University
11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University
11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
23.917<br />
Culture And Updated Traditional Management Tools For Serving Ownership in<br />
Locally Managed Marine Areas<br />
Eric CLUA* 1 , Bernard SALVAT 2<br />
1 CRISP programme, SPC, Noumea, New Caledonia, 2 EPHE, Perpignan, France<br />
A major proportion of coral reefs around the world occur in small island developing<br />
countries (SIDS). The status of these resources is declining, while these countries<br />
simultaneously face major challenges in sustainable development for their people. Reef<br />
conservation in SIDS cannot be approached in the same way as conservation in more<br />
developed countries, even though the tools such as Marine Protected Areas may be<br />
effective for both situations. One of the main differences relies on the widespread<br />
inability of government services within SIDS to ensure adherence to legal frameworks<br />
aimed at protecting the reef resources from irreversible depletion. This gap can be<br />
compensated with a strong ownership by local communities through locally managed<br />
marine areas. The emergence of a real ownership strongly depends on the ability of<br />
developing actors in promoting the cultural dimension as a root of the process of locally<br />
based management which should include traditional tools, even if they need, most of the<br />
time, to be updated regarding ecological constraints for a sustainable development of reef<br />
resources. Therefore, a particular focus should be put by developing agencies on the<br />
integration of human factors (anthropology, socio-economics) for insuring the success of<br />
the ground actions, with innovative tools such as human factor based Geographic<br />
Information Systems. Local ownership can also be boosted by real examples of grounds<br />
successes to be shown to candidate communities and another issue relies on the setting up<br />
of functional networks at a regional level. The Coral Reef Initiative for the Pacific<br />
(CRISP) is a US$ 10 million programme over 3 years which implements this specific<br />
approach. The concepts behind CRISP draw on the recommendations of the International<br />
Coral Reef Initiative, and specifically seek to find Pacific solutions to regional problems.<br />
23.918<br />
Documenting Traditional Knowledge Of Marine Use And Resource Management in<br />
American Samoa<br />
Arielle LEVINE* 1 , Bert FUIAVA* 2 , Fiailoa MAIAVA* 2 , Risa ORAM 2 , Fale<br />
TUILAGI 3 , Fatima SAUAFEA-LEAU 4<br />
1 Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, HI, 2 Department of Marine and<br />
Wildlife Resources, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United States Minor Outlying Islands,<br />
3 National Park Service, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United States Minor Outlying<br />
Islands, 4 NOAA - Pacific Islands Regional Office, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United<br />
States Minor Outlying Islands<br />
This poster describes a collaborative project to document traditional knowledge of marine<br />
use and resource management in American Samoa, undertaken by the Pacific Islands<br />
Fisheries Science Center and multiple partner agencies in American Samoa. The three<br />
primary components of this research project are detailed, along with lessons learned and<br />
their application to coral reef fisheries management. The first element involved<br />
conducting elder interviews to document local knowledge regarding traditional marine<br />
use and management, as well as changes over time in resource use and conditions.<br />
Topics of interest included changes in fishing methods and frequency over time, changes<br />
in species catch and abundance, and traditional methods of marine management. The<br />
second element involved in-depth archival research of early explorer accounts of fishing<br />
and marine management in American Samoa. Records from the American Samoa<br />
Historic Preservation Office, <strong>University</strong> of Hawaii library, and the Bishop Museum<br />
archives were studied to gain a greater understanding of historic practices and their<br />
application to modern coral reef fisheries management. The third element of this project<br />
includes video documentation of traditional fishing practices that are unique to the Samoa<br />
region and still take place in American Samoa today. These practices include the palolo<br />
harvest (a coral-dwelling polychaete worm that spawns once a year and is considered a<br />
traditional Samoan delicacy); atule (bigeye scad) fishing (a mass spawning event that<br />
takes place in several Samoan bays); and i'asina (juvenile goatfish) fishing using<br />
traditional basket weirs on the Manu’a islands. The final documentary will be made<br />
available for education and outreach purposes to illustrate American Samoa’s strong<br />
marine heritage and traditional reliance on marine resources. The results of this research<br />
project are expected to strengthen management practices by incorporating traditional<br />
Samoan values and knowledge into the Territory’s new marine protected area programs<br />
and other coral reef fisheries management activities.<br />
Poster Mini-Symposium 23: Reef Management<br />
23.919<br />
Factors Influencing Success Of A Marine Protected Area Network in Hawaii<br />
Jim BEETS* 1 , Brian TISSOT 2 , Mark HIXON 3 , Stephen THOMPSON 4 , Mark MANUEL 5<br />
1 Marine Science, <strong>University</strong> of Hawaii-Hilo, Hilo, HI, 2 Environmental Science, Washington<br />
State <strong>University</strong> Vancouver, Vancouver, WA, 3 Zoology, Oregon State <strong>University</strong>, Corvallis,<br />
OR, 4 Cascadia Conservation Trust, Sisters, OR, 5 Tropical Conservation Biology & Env. Sci.,<br />
<strong>University</strong> of Hawaii-Hilo, Hilo, HI<br />
As Marine Protected Area (MPA) Networks gain management support, the importance of<br />
documenting factors that affect their effectiveness increases. Previous work showed greater<br />
abundance of juvenile and adult fishes harvested for the aquarium trade in individual MPAs<br />
compared to adjacent control sites within the MPA Network on the western coast of the island<br />
of Hawai’i (Tissot et al. 2004). The present study evaluated the relative contribution of habitat<br />
characteristics, adult abundance, and current exposure to the greater juvenile abundances<br />
observed within MPAs. Oceanographic, substrate and habitat characteristics were sampled with<br />
juvenile and adult fish abundances at three paired sites (MPA vs. control) along the western<br />
coast of the island of Hawaii. All three factors contributed to greater juvenile abundance of the<br />
study species, but differed in relative contribution among sites. We demonstrated the<br />
importance of selected factors to the effectiveness of a MPA network. Based on our results, we<br />
emphasize the value of consideration of several factors that potentially influence success of the<br />
defined goals for specific MPAs or networks.<br />
23.920<br />
Atlanta’s Willingness-To-Pay For Fijian Coral Reef Conservation: How Do Individuals<br />
Value Reefs Even When Distant And Can This Inform Market-Based Management<br />
Strategies?<br />
Carolyn FONSECA* 1 , Doug NOONAN 1<br />
1 School of Public Policy, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA<br />
Environmental policies often blend biological and social components. However, this area-of<br />
how knowledge experience and behavior affect perceptions of coral reef value-is still young.<br />
To date, few studies if any have sampled populations distant from reefs. Research has focused<br />
primarily in local coral reef valuation. The valuation literature for reefs is incomplete, missing<br />
information about how individuals (who do not live near reefs) value this ecosystem. The<br />
primary objective of this paper is to learn the value of Fijian coral reef conservation by non-<br />
Fijians. Fiji is about to begin a new program called “Adopt-a-Coral-Reef” whereby individuals<br />
can go online and purchase a coral or part of the reef. This study has the potential to inform<br />
coral sale price. The Contingent Valuation Method (CVM) has primarily been used to<br />
determine damages or to measure Willingness-to-Pay (WTP) for a particular service. Limited<br />
knowledge exists on how CVM might inform market-based management tools such as the<br />
Fijian program. Empirical research is needed to understand the effectiveness and<br />
generalizability of CVM. The model of this study investigated the influence of environmental<br />
behavior, previous culture experience, problem definition, coral reef knowledge, and ocean<br />
activities on coral reef WTP. Surveys were mailed to 2000 Atlanta GA households from<br />
November 2007 to January 2008. Preliminary results suggested a $12.6 average WTP by<br />
Atlanta for the Fijian reef program. Knowledge and previous experience were not significantly<br />
related to WTP. The findings imply that Atlanta households have the potential to contribute to<br />
the Fijian coral reef program. This study and similar research could provide stakeholders<br />
information on the most effective use and sources of funding. In conclusion, there is a need to<br />
learn more about how scale affects valuation. If the goal is to influence WTP, then knowing<br />
which factors are significant is an important step.<br />
.<br />
504