24.12.2012 Views

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

23.917<br />

Culture And Updated Traditional Management Tools For Serving Ownership in<br />

Locally Managed Marine Areas<br />

Eric CLUA* 1 , Bernard SALVAT 2<br />

1 CRISP programme, SPC, Noumea, New Caledonia, 2 EPHE, Perpignan, France<br />

A major proportion of coral reefs around the world occur in small island developing<br />

countries (SIDS). The status of these resources is declining, while these countries<br />

simultaneously face major challenges in sustainable development for their people. Reef<br />

conservation in SIDS cannot be approached in the same way as conservation in more<br />

developed countries, even though the tools such as Marine Protected Areas may be<br />

effective for both situations. One of the main differences relies on the widespread<br />

inability of government services within SIDS to ensure adherence to legal frameworks<br />

aimed at protecting the reef resources from irreversible depletion. This gap can be<br />

compensated with a strong ownership by local communities through locally managed<br />

marine areas. The emergence of a real ownership strongly depends on the ability of<br />

developing actors in promoting the cultural dimension as a root of the process of locally<br />

based management which should include traditional tools, even if they need, most of the<br />

time, to be updated regarding ecological constraints for a sustainable development of reef<br />

resources. Therefore, a particular focus should be put by developing agencies on the<br />

integration of human factors (anthropology, socio-economics) for insuring the success of<br />

the ground actions, with innovative tools such as human factor based Geographic<br />

Information Systems. Local ownership can also be boosted by real examples of grounds<br />

successes to be shown to candidate communities and another issue relies on the setting up<br />

of functional networks at a regional level. The Coral Reef Initiative for the Pacific<br />

(CRISP) is a US$ 10 million programme over 3 years which implements this specific<br />

approach. The concepts behind CRISP draw on the recommendations of the International<br />

Coral Reef Initiative, and specifically seek to find Pacific solutions to regional problems.<br />

23.918<br />

Documenting Traditional Knowledge Of Marine Use And Resource Management in<br />

American Samoa<br />

Arielle LEVINE* 1 , Bert FUIAVA* 2 , Fiailoa MAIAVA* 2 , Risa ORAM 2 , Fale<br />

TUILAGI 3 , Fatima SAUAFEA-LEAU 4<br />

1 Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, HI, 2 Department of Marine and<br />

Wildlife Resources, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United States Minor Outlying Islands,<br />

3 National Park Service, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United States Minor Outlying<br />

Islands, 4 NOAA - Pacific Islands Regional Office, Pago Pago, American Samoa, United<br />

States Minor Outlying Islands<br />

This poster describes a collaborative project to document traditional knowledge of marine<br />

use and resource management in American Samoa, undertaken by the Pacific Islands<br />

Fisheries Science Center and multiple partner agencies in American Samoa. The three<br />

primary components of this research project are detailed, along with lessons learned and<br />

their application to coral reef fisheries management. The first element involved<br />

conducting elder interviews to document local knowledge regarding traditional marine<br />

use and management, as well as changes over time in resource use and conditions.<br />

Topics of interest included changes in fishing methods and frequency over time, changes<br />

in species catch and abundance, and traditional methods of marine management. The<br />

second element involved in-depth archival research of early explorer accounts of fishing<br />

and marine management in American Samoa. Records from the American Samoa<br />

Historic Preservation Office, <strong>University</strong> of Hawaii library, and the Bishop Museum<br />

archives were studied to gain a greater understanding of historic practices and their<br />

application to modern coral reef fisheries management. The third element of this project<br />

includes video documentation of traditional fishing practices that are unique to the Samoa<br />

region and still take place in American Samoa today. These practices include the palolo<br />

harvest (a coral-dwelling polychaete worm that spawns once a year and is considered a<br />

traditional Samoan delicacy); atule (bigeye scad) fishing (a mass spawning event that<br />

takes place in several Samoan bays); and i'asina (juvenile goatfish) fishing using<br />

traditional basket weirs on the Manu’a islands. The final documentary will be made<br />

available for education and outreach purposes to illustrate American Samoa’s strong<br />

marine heritage and traditional reliance on marine resources. The results of this research<br />

project are expected to strengthen management practices by incorporating traditional<br />

Samoan values and knowledge into the Territory’s new marine protected area programs<br />

and other coral reef fisheries management activities.<br />

Poster Mini-Symposium 23: Reef Management<br />

23.919<br />

Factors Influencing Success Of A Marine Protected Area Network in Hawaii<br />

Jim BEETS* 1 , Brian TISSOT 2 , Mark HIXON 3 , Stephen THOMPSON 4 , Mark MANUEL 5<br />

1 Marine Science, <strong>University</strong> of Hawaii-Hilo, Hilo, HI, 2 Environmental Science, Washington<br />

State <strong>University</strong> Vancouver, Vancouver, WA, 3 Zoology, Oregon State <strong>University</strong>, Corvallis,<br />

OR, 4 Cascadia Conservation Trust, Sisters, OR, 5 Tropical Conservation Biology & Env. Sci.,<br />

<strong>University</strong> of Hawaii-Hilo, Hilo, HI<br />

As Marine Protected Area (MPA) Networks gain management support, the importance of<br />

documenting factors that affect their effectiveness increases. Previous work showed greater<br />

abundance of juvenile and adult fishes harvested for the aquarium trade in individual MPAs<br />

compared to adjacent control sites within the MPA Network on the western coast of the island<br />

of Hawai’i (Tissot et al. 2004). The present study evaluated the relative contribution of habitat<br />

characteristics, adult abundance, and current exposure to the greater juvenile abundances<br />

observed within MPAs. Oceanographic, substrate and habitat characteristics were sampled with<br />

juvenile and adult fish abundances at three paired sites (MPA vs. control) along the western<br />

coast of the island of Hawaii. All three factors contributed to greater juvenile abundance of the<br />

study species, but differed in relative contribution among sites. We demonstrated the<br />

importance of selected factors to the effectiveness of a MPA network. Based on our results, we<br />

emphasize the value of consideration of several factors that potentially influence success of the<br />

defined goals for specific MPAs or networks.<br />

23.920<br />

Atlanta’s Willingness-To-Pay For Fijian Coral Reef Conservation: How Do Individuals<br />

Value Reefs Even When Distant And Can This Inform Market-Based Management<br />

Strategies?<br />

Carolyn FONSECA* 1 , Doug NOONAN 1<br />

1 School of Public Policy, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA<br />

Environmental policies often blend biological and social components. However, this area-of<br />

how knowledge experience and behavior affect perceptions of coral reef value-is still young.<br />

To date, few studies if any have sampled populations distant from reefs. Research has focused<br />

primarily in local coral reef valuation. The valuation literature for reefs is incomplete, missing<br />

information about how individuals (who do not live near reefs) value this ecosystem. The<br />

primary objective of this paper is to learn the value of Fijian coral reef conservation by non-<br />

Fijians. Fiji is about to begin a new program called “Adopt-a-Coral-Reef” whereby individuals<br />

can go online and purchase a coral or part of the reef. This study has the potential to inform<br />

coral sale price. The Contingent Valuation Method (CVM) has primarily been used to<br />

determine damages or to measure Willingness-to-Pay (WTP) for a particular service. Limited<br />

knowledge exists on how CVM might inform market-based management tools such as the<br />

Fijian program. Empirical research is needed to understand the effectiveness and<br />

generalizability of CVM. The model of this study investigated the influence of environmental<br />

behavior, previous culture experience, problem definition, coral reef knowledge, and ocean<br />

activities on coral reef WTP. Surveys were mailed to 2000 Atlanta GA households from<br />

November 2007 to January 2008. Preliminary results suggested a $12.6 average WTP by<br />

Atlanta for the Fijian reef program. Knowledge and previous experience were not significantly<br />

related to WTP. The findings imply that Atlanta households have the potential to contribute to<br />

the Fijian coral reef program. This study and similar research could provide stakeholders<br />

information on the most effective use and sources of funding. In conclusion, there is a need to<br />

learn more about how scale affects valuation. If the goal is to influence WTP, then knowing<br />

which factors are significant is an important step.<br />

.<br />

504

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!