24.12.2012 Views

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

23.1035<br />

Post-Hugo Recovery Of A Protected And Unprotected Reef: St. Croix, Us Virgin<br />

Islands<br />

Dana FISCO* 1 , Monica ARIENZO 2 , Connie SOJA 3 , Dennis HUBBARD 4<br />

1 Marine and Freshwater Sciences, Colgate <strong>University</strong>-KECK Consortium, Hamilton, NY,<br />

2 Franklin and Marshall College, Lancaster, PA, 3 Colgate <strong>University</strong>, Hamilton, NY,<br />

4 Oberlin College, Oberlin, OH<br />

Over the past three decades Caribbean reefs have experienced a shift from coral to algal<br />

dominance. Reefs on St. Croix, US Virgin Islands, have experienced the full range of<br />

stresses credited with decline. In 1989, Hurricane Hugo caused extensive damage to<br />

reefs already impacted by White Band Disease. The proximity of reefs within Buck<br />

Island National Monument and unmanaged areas only 5 km away on St. Croix (Tague<br />

Reef) provides a unique opportunity to examine reef recovery under similar<br />

oceanographic conditions but different degrees of protection. Twenty-meter chain<br />

transects were surveyed at 3, 6 and 9 m depths at three sites on the two reefs. Equal areas<br />

were surveyed on each reef, spread over distances of 1-2 km. Data were compared to<br />

post-Hugo surveys at the three Tague Reef sites and the center site on Buck Island.<br />

Present-day coral cover was identical on the two reefs when averaged for all sites and all<br />

depths (12%). On Tague Reef, coral diversity increased drastically at the 6 and 9 m<br />

depths in all locations but only slightly at the 3 m depth locations—solar panel 3 m<br />

transect showed a loss in diversity. Porites asteroides, increased in shallow water. Coral<br />

cover at the southern Buck Island monitoring site remained constant (12%) 18 years after<br />

Hurricane Hugo. A companion study revealed significant differences in the grazer<br />

populations at the two sites (parrotfish at Buck Island; Diadema on Tague Reef), but the<br />

general condition of the benthos appears to be similar. These data appear to indicate that<br />

either the higher abundance of grazing scarids at Buck Island is not sufficient to reverse<br />

effects of local nutrient increases and fishing outside the park, or that larger factors (e.g.,<br />

bleaching and disease) are exerting the dominant control on reef decline and recovery.<br />

23.1036<br />

Biodiversity Of Coral Reef in Sumbawa Sea, Indonesia:comparison Between<br />

Underwater Observation And Satellite Imagery<br />

Susumu KANNO* 1 , Masahiko YANAGAWA 1 , Akihiko OHGANE 2 , Kimiya HOMMA 1<br />

1 Ocean Industry, Kyowa Concrete Industry Co., Ltd., Sapporo, Japan, 2 Zeal Oceanic<br />

Office, Sapporo, Japan<br />

Biodiversity in coral reef is discussed with both in-situ observation using underwater<br />

trans-section method and satellite imagery in coastal area of Sumbawa Sea, Indonesia.<br />

Line trans-section was carried out over two thousands meter along the coast and the result<br />

showed that there is a lot of species of reef coral and their biodiversity is higher than<br />

another habitat area in Indonesia. Principal component analysis was carried out for<br />

coverage of each species, water quality, and topographic factors by using these results of<br />

identification about coral species. Coverage of Acropora, Porites, Favia species, and<br />

transparency at out side of reef have positive contribution. These items appeared in first<br />

component in the analysis too. On the other hand, chlorophyll, turbidity, and fetch have a<br />

negative contribution to the total environment in this coral reef. These mean that the<br />

environmental condition in this coral reef depends on purity and optical properties of<br />

ocean water. Usually hermatypic coral reef-building coral makes habitat in inside of<br />

clean and shallow coastal reef area. Then, the indicators of water quality appeared as high<br />

contribution as both positive and negative contribution; (1)coral species living in clear<br />

seawater, (2)quantity increasing with cleanliness of seawater as transparency, (3)one<br />

decreasing with the cleanliness as chlorophyll, turbidity, and fetch leading to spinning up<br />

of bottom quality. Finally, classification of bottom attribute and coral species has been<br />

made a trial by ALOS/AVNIR-2 satellite imagery with training data obtained by the<br />

underwater trans-section of bottom quality on the reef area. The bottom attribute in the<br />

reef was classified with coral coverage in the habitat, species of the coral, rock reef, dead<br />

coral, and coral sand relatively clearly. This method can be utilized for environmental<br />

management in coastal region based on not only qualitative analysis but also quantitative<br />

analysis.<br />

Poster Mini-Symposium 23: Reef Management<br />

23.1037<br />

Effectiveness Of A Marine Protected Area On The East End Of St Croix, U.s. Virgin<br />

Islands Using The Queen Conch Strobus Gigas, As A Sentential Species<br />

Barbara KOJIS* 1 , Norman QUINN 2<br />

1 Department of Science and Math, <strong>University</strong> of the Virgin Islands, St Thomas, Virgin Islands<br />

(U.S.), 2 Coastal Zone Management, St Croix East End Marine Park, St. Croix, Virgin Islands<br />

(U.S.)<br />

From October 1998 to September 2001, a previous study conducted surveys of the queen conch<br />

populations at six back reef embayments at the east end of St Croix. Population densities were<br />

higher in the northeast embayments (52.6 conch / ha) compared to the southeast embayments<br />

(33.6 conch / ha). About 87% of the conch measured were juveniles. Subsequent to that study,<br />

the 155 km2 territorial St Croix East End Marine Park was established in January 2003 and<br />

rules and regulations governing activities in the park were enacted in late 2007. Several back<br />

reef embayments were designated “No Take Areas” where the collection of all marine animals<br />

was prohibited. At around the same time, the seasonal closure for queen conch from July 1 –<br />

September 30 of each year was extended to December 31, 2007 by the Virgin Islands’<br />

Department of Planning and Natural Resources because of the recent dramatic increase in the<br />

harvest of queen conch by commercial fishers on St. Croix and the determination that queen<br />

conch was being severely overfished on St. Croix. This study will: 1) compare the current<br />

population structure of queen conch in the back reef embayments with the previous study, 2)<br />

review compliance with the rules and regulations, and 3) discuss adaptive management<br />

strategies.<br />

23.1038<br />

Gaining Ground in Improving Marine Protected Areas (Mpas): The Philippine<br />

Experience<br />

Hazel ARCEO* 1 , Porfirio ALINO 2,3 , Vincent LUMBAB 1 , Cleto NANOLA 4,5 , Ma. Fe<br />

PORTIGO 6<br />

1 DAI/USAID Philippine Environmental Governance 2 Project, Cebu City, Philippines,<br />

2 DAI/USAID Philippine Environmental Governance 2 Project, Ortigas, Metro Manila,<br />

Philippines, 3 <strong>University</strong> of the Philippines - The Marine Science Institute, Quezon City,<br />

Philippines, 4 DAI/USAID Philippine Environmental Governance 2 Project, Davao City,<br />

Philippines, 5 <strong>University</strong> of the Philippines - Mindanao, Davao City, Philippines, 6 DAI/USAID<br />

Philippine Environmental Governance 2 Project, Pagadian City, Philippines<br />

Several reviews about the status of MPAs in the Philippines have been conducted (e.g. Baling<br />

1995, Haribon 1997, Alcala and colleagues) with insights on MPA sizes, management, gaps and<br />

challenges. This paper aims (1) to re-examine the evaluation by Aliño et al. (2001) and<br />

determine any improvements that may have resulted from the adoption of recommendations and<br />

good practices highlighted during this last review; and, (2) to evaluate the management<br />

effectiveness of at least ten MPAs by looking at ecological trends and the performance of the<br />

MPA managers. Biophysical information obtained using standard reef survey methods was<br />

used to determine ecological patterns while the MPA Rating System, developed by Coastal<br />

Conservation and Education Foundation (2005) and modified to include governance indicators,<br />

and community perception surveys were employed to assess performance. Results show an<br />

increase in the number of MPAs, now with over 1,100 existing MPAs, and an observed shift in<br />

the modal range of MPA sizes, with larger areas being placed under protection. Analysis from<br />

the sample MPAs shows that ecological trends are not always consistent with the performance<br />

evaluation results, and that biophysical and performance indicators can collectively present a<br />

more accurate description of the MPA management levels rather than each one alone. The rates<br />

of improvement among the MPAs also vary. Factors that may have influenced the differential<br />

rates include baseline ecological conditions, functionality of management groups including<br />

information, education and communication, compliance and enforcement strategies,<br />

implementation of other fisheries management interventions outside the no-take areas, and<br />

alliances with other managers. Insights from this study will be useful in setting the directions<br />

towards attaining more improved and well-managed MPAs. This requires the identification of<br />

priorities on how MPAs and MPA network interactions/synergies can be put in place.<br />

495

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!