24.12.2012 Views

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

11th ICRS Abstract book - Nova Southeastern University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

22-21<br />

Applying An Optimal Resource Space Concept To Small Scale Reef Fisheries<br />

Management<br />

Lydia TEH* 1 , Louise TEH 1<br />

1 Fisheries Centre, <strong>University</strong> of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada<br />

Fishers operate according to an optimal resource space whose boundaries are defined by<br />

economic profitability, technological sophistication, and socio-cultural preferences.<br />

These 'invisible' boundaries can affect fishers’ willingness to comply with, and ability to<br />

adapt to spatial restrictions. Better understanding of the factors that shape optimal<br />

resource spaces can thus lead to management decisions that are more aligned with<br />

fishers’ perspectives and have a higher likelihood of being complied with and adopted.<br />

We investigate the coral reef fisheries of Pulau Banggi, Sabah, Malaysia, where a marine<br />

protected area is proposed. Our objectives are i) map fishers’ optimal resource space; ii)<br />

explain ecological, socio-cultural, and economic factors that influence fishers’ optimal<br />

resource space; and iii) apply optimal resource space concept to spatial management of<br />

small scale reef fisheries. We use data from fish catch log<strong>book</strong>s to track the fishing<br />

activities of 21 fishers. We conducted semi-structured interviews with fishers to explore<br />

factors that dictate their resource use space, including market forces, fishers’ motivations<br />

and perceived constraints. We find that fishers function within an optimal resource space<br />

that is delineated by socio-cultural factors such as family ties, and distance from resident<br />

village. Even though fishers are aware of locations where they perceive more fish can be<br />

caught, they rarely fish those places. While Banggi fishers face invisible boundaries that<br />

restrict them to habituated fishing grounds, outsider fishers do not face such restrictions<br />

and are not prevented from exploiting Banggi’s open access fisheries. The optimal<br />

resource space concept can be applied towards analyzing user conflict, compliance, and<br />

equity issues. In the context of marine protected areas, it can help in designing spatial<br />

management strategies that are socially acceptable and ecologically sustainable to<br />

fisheries and fishing communities.<br />

22-22<br />

Improving Management Of Coral Reef Fisheries in Data Limited Situations:<br />

Experiences From The Parfish Methodology<br />

Robert WAKEFORD* 1 , Suzannah WALMSLEY 2 , Robert TRUMBLE 1 , Paul<br />

MEDLEY 3<br />

1 MRAG Americas, Inc., Saint Petersburg, FL, 2 MRAG Ltd., London, United Kingdom,<br />

3 Independent Consultant, Alne, United Kingdom<br />

Coral reef fisheries are complex systems. This is due primarily to the multi-species,<br />

multi-gear and high labour mobility that often occurs within the fisheries sector. Since<br />

many small-scale fisheries operate in remote areas and/ or in developing coastal states,<br />

the quality and quantity of data necessary to undertake basic fisheries management,<br />

including robust stock assessments, are often lacking. However, it is becoming more<br />

widely acknowledged that local stakeholder participation is an essential pre-requisite to<br />

improve overall management of the resource, but this has rarely engaged them directly<br />

within a stock assessment framework to provide information on the status of the resource.<br />

This study presents a summary and comparison of three pilot studies undertaken in Turks<br />

and Caicos, Tanzania and Puerto Rico that have been used to demonstrate a new fisheries<br />

management tool that enables stakeholders to participate directly in the stock assessment<br />

process. Through the development of a participatory fish stock assessment (ParFish)<br />

methodology, fishers are engaged at the beginning of the management process to<br />

contribute their valuable knowledge about the fishery. Using a Bayesian statistical model,<br />

information obtained from fishers help inform prior statistical distributions that are used<br />

to estimate parameters in the stock assessment model. The results have shown that this<br />

approach can be used successfully to establish preliminary estimates of stock status in<br />

data limited situations.<br />

Oral Mini-Symposium 22: Coral Reef Associated Fisheries<br />

22-23<br />

Effectiveness Of Minimum Legal Size As A Fisheries Management Tool in A Multi-<br />

Sectoral Reef Fishery<br />

Sara BUSILACCHI* 1,2 , Gavin BEGG 3 , Ashley WILLIAMS 2<br />

1 School of Marine and Tropical Biology, James Cook <strong>University</strong>, Townsville, Australia,<br />

2 Fishing and Fisheries Centre, School of Earth and Environmental Science, James Cook<br />

<strong>University</strong>, Townsville, Australia, 3 Australian Fisheries Management Authority, Canberra,<br />

Australia<br />

Minimum legal size (MLS) is one of the oldest and most widely accepted management tools in<br />

fisheries and is usually based on the mean length at which 50% of a population become mature.<br />

The effectiveness of a MLS depends on a range of factors including the biology of the species,<br />

fishing behaviour, fishing gear, post-release survival, other management arrangements and<br />

compliance. In this presentation we assess the effectiveness of MLS’s when applied to manage<br />

two of three sectors in a multi-sectoral fishery. The reef finfish fishery in Torres Strait,<br />

Australia, is shared among three sectors: an indigenous subsistence sector and two commercial<br />

sectors (an indigenous and a non-indigenous). In an effort to retain its cultural value, the<br />

subsistence sector is currently not regulated. However, the two commercial sectors are managed<br />

by numerous regulations including a MLS for the commercially important species. It is normal<br />

practice within indigenous communities for subsistence fishing to occur during commercial<br />

fishing trips, even though this is inconsistent with legislation. Subsistence catch taken during<br />

commercial fishing trips was monitored between May 2005 and May 2006 using an access<br />

point survey in three Torres Strait communities. We estimated that, on average, 22% of the total<br />

catch taken during commercial trips is used for subsistence. Coral trouts (Plectropomus spp.),<br />

carangids and snappers (Lutjanus spp.) were the most retained species for subsistence and were<br />

also the most commercially important. Results showed that, for some of these species, undersize<br />

fish (less than the MLS) represented 80% of the subsistence catch taken during commercial<br />

fishing trips. We conclude that the effectiveness of this management tool relies on the<br />

understanding of its rationale and its acceptance by indigenous communities.<br />

22-24<br />

Bias Of Cpue Revealed By Considering Fisheries As Predator Prey Systems<br />

Meaghan C. DARCY* 1 , Steven JD MARTELL 2<br />

1 Zoology / Fisheries Center, <strong>University</strong> of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada,<br />

2 Fisheries Center, <strong>University</strong> of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada<br />

The Hawaiian bottomfish fishery is a multi-species fishery, where the target species (mainly<br />

eteline snappers and one grouper species) are associated with deep reef structures and are<br />

caught using handlines. This fishery exemplifies many reef associated, multi-species fisheries,<br />

where the fishing gear simultaneously captures multiple species. Assessment of status for each<br />

species is based on effort-aggregated commercial catch statistics and single-species assessment<br />

models. Aggregation of these data assumes that the capture probabilities and targeting of each<br />

species are constant over time and those species-specific catches per unit effort (CPUE) indices<br />

are proportional to abundance. Using single-species assessment models with effort-aggregated<br />

data may be problematic because the assumption of proportionality is likely to be violated due<br />

to changes in targeting and or changes in species composition and changes in fishing<br />

technologies.<br />

To account for species composition effects in the multi-species fisheries, we develop an effort<br />

dynamics sub-model that partitions the total effort into components of handling time and time<br />

spent searching (i.e., Holling’s Disc equation). It explicitly allows for handling time influences<br />

and the differences in catchability among target and non-target species. We tested this approach<br />

using stochastic simulation-estimation experiments, where the dynamics of individual fish<br />

populations that make up a multi-species fishery and typical fisheries dependent data (i.e.,<br />

species specific catch data and aggregate effort data). Simulation results demonstrate that<br />

increased handling time leads to a hyperstable index of abundance (i.e., catchability declines<br />

less rapidly than biomass) which would lead to overestimates of abundance in the classic singlespecies<br />

assessments. Ignoring handling time effects for fisheries such as, handline fisheries,<br />

where a large component of effort includes gear set-up and retrieval and removal of catch from<br />

the gear, results in biased abundance estimates.<br />

188

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!