23.12.2012 Views

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

the issues in the case, the evidence addressed in the argument, and the<br />

instructions given to the 5 '<br />

j ury,<br />

Id. quoting ( Brown, 132 Wn.2d at 561).<br />

R]emarks must be read in context." <strong>State</strong> v. Pastrana, 94 Wn. App.<br />

463, 479, 972 P.2d 557 (1999).<br />

In the present case, the defendant argues that the deputy prosecutor<br />

committed prosecutorial misconduct when she stated in closing argument,<br />

in regard to C.D. the following:<br />

Fully toilet trained and begins wetting the bed, C.J.<br />

Ellsworth was here and said yes, it can be relevant in<br />

treating someone's mental health, can be part of anxiety,<br />

it's simply something noteworthy, less so obviously to the<br />

medical professionals.<br />

RP 797; <strong>Brief</strong> of Appellant, p. 21-22, 27-30. The defendant seems to<br />

contend that this argument was prosecutorial misconduct because it<br />

constituted a "concerted effort to persuade the jury that C.D,' s bedwetting<br />

was caused by the alleged inappropriate touch by McDaniel" when there<br />

was a "highly plausible alternative explanation for this behavior that the<br />

prosecutor successfully was able to exclude from the trial," i.e., evidence<br />

of McCutcheon's drug addiction, employment as an exotic dancer, and<br />

CPS involvement. <strong>Brief</strong> of Appellant, p. 29-30.<br />

The defendant, however, never objected to this argument at trial.<br />

RP 797. See RP 797-824. Therefore, he cannot raise this issue on appeal<br />

unless the misconduct, if any, was "'so flagrant andill-intentioned that it<br />

34 - optest-pros m i scsptrial -mcdaniel. doc

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!