23.12.2012 Views

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

Respondent's Brief - Washington State Courts

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

expansive view of claims that testimony constitutes an opinion of guilt."<br />

Demery, 144 Wn,2d at 760 (quoting City ofSeattle v. Heatley, 70 Wn.<br />

App. 573, 579, 854 P.2d 658 (1993)).<br />

In determining whether such statements are impermissible<br />

opinion testimony, the court will consider the circumstances of the case,<br />

including the following factors: '(1) the' type of witness involved', (2)<br />

the specific nature of the testimony,' (3) the ' nature of the charges,' (4)<br />

the type of defense,' and (5) the ' other evidence before the trier of fact."<br />

Kirkman, 159 Wn. App. at 928 (quoting Demery, 144 Wn.2d at 759, 30<br />

P.3d 1278 (quoting <strong>State</strong> v. Heatley, 70 Wn. App, 573, 579, 854 P.2d 658<br />

1993))),<br />

In the present case, the defendant argues that portions of Thomas's<br />

testimony constituted improper opinion testimony, which "vouched for the<br />

credibility of the complainant," C.D. <strong>Brief</strong> of Appellant, p. I 1 -17. The<br />

record, however, demonstrates that at no point did Thomas so much as<br />

comment on, much less vouch for, the credibility of C.D. See RP 565-91.<br />

Thomas testified that there are forensic interviewing guidelines,<br />

and that she always employs the "funnel method" of interviewing children<br />

by which<br />

the forensic interview starts off with very open-ended<br />

questions, you know, like a funnel, and as a child gives<br />

information, then the question —the one question becomes<br />

more direct and more specific based on the information that<br />

has been received. And, therefore, the child leads the<br />

interview and the interviewer does not lead the interview,<br />

16 - optest-prosmiscsptrialmcdaniel doc

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!