nuclear ion exchange resin - Purolite.com
nuclear ion exchange resin - Purolite.com
nuclear ion exchange resin - Purolite.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
ION EXCHANGE RESINS<br />
FOR USE IN NUCLEAR<br />
POWER PLANTS<br />
Original by J.J. Wolff<br />
Revised and Updated<br />
January 2012<br />
Limerick Nuclear Generating Stat<strong>ion</strong><br />
Source: US NRC file photo
Special Thanks:<br />
The original author of this paper, Jean-Jacques Wolff, was born on April 23, 1930.<br />
He first studied Chemistry and then Bio-technology. He worked in the sugar and<br />
sweetener field of the food industry prior to joining a growing producer of <strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s, Duolite, in the early 1960’s. There he progressed quickly to<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e Technical Manager.<br />
Following the acquisit<strong>ion</strong> of Duolite by Rohm and Haas in June 1984, he decided<br />
to reinforce the technical team of a new fast-growing manufacturer of <strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>exchange</strong> and adsorbent <strong>resin</strong>s called <strong>Purolite</strong> Internat<strong>ion</strong>al. There he brought<br />
his deep expertise in the Nuclear Industry, mainly to Électricité de France.<br />
Jean-Jacques Wolff was well known and appreciated by his clients all over the<br />
world, especially in Asia. He was an excellent open minded colleague and during<br />
his life developed many new purificat<strong>ion</strong> processes.<br />
Jean-Jacques Wolff was married and had two sons. He passed away on 25th<br />
November 1992.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
1
Table of Contents<br />
INTRODUCTION Page 3<br />
SECTION 1: NUCLEAR POWER GENERATION Page 4<br />
A. Nuclear Fiss<strong>ion</strong><br />
B. Controlling the react<strong>ion</strong><br />
C. Nuclear Industry Water Quality Guidelines<br />
D. System Contaminants<br />
SECTION 2: TYPES OF REACTORS & WATER TREATMENT CIRCUITS Page 8<br />
A. Graphite-Gas Reactor (AGR) Page 8<br />
Graphite-Gas Reactor Treatment Circuits<br />
1. Makeup Water<br />
2. Condensate Polishing<br />
3. Turbo-blowers<br />
4. Spent Fuel Ponds<br />
B. Pressurized Water Reactors (PWR) Page 11<br />
PWR Primary Circuit Treatment<br />
1. Reactor Coolant Purificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
a. Outage Clean-up Beds<br />
b. pH Control (CVCS)<br />
c. Outage Activity<br />
2. Deborat<strong>ion</strong><br />
3. Spent Fuel Ponds (SFP)<br />
4. Radwaste Effluent Treatment<br />
PWR Secondary Circuit Treatment Page 19<br />
5. Makeup water Treatment<br />
6. Condensate Polishing<br />
7. Steam Generator Blowdown Treatment<br />
C. Boiling Water Reactors (BWR) Page 24<br />
BWR Circuit Treatment<br />
1. Makeup water Treatment<br />
2. Condensate Polishing<br />
3. Reactor Coolant Purificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
4. Spent Fuel Pool Treatment<br />
5. Radwaste Treatment<br />
D. Fast Breeder Reactor (LMFBR) Page 28<br />
SECTION 3: NUCLEAR ION EXCHANGE RESIN Page 29<br />
1. Nuclear Quality Resin<br />
2. Operating Capacity<br />
3. Decontaminat<strong>ion</strong> Capacity<br />
SECTION 4: REFERENCES Page 33<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
2
1. INTRODUCTION<br />
Nuclear power plants are currently operated in 31 countries with 15 more countries currently<br />
planning the construct<strong>ion</strong> of their first <strong>nuclear</strong> power plants. Nuclear power generat<strong>ion</strong> will<br />
continue to grow as a strategic opt<strong>ion</strong> due to the increasing cost of fossil fuel based energy<br />
and the pressure to reduce greenhouse gases.<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s — in both bead and powder form — are used extensively in all types of<br />
<strong>nuclear</strong> power plants throughout the world. Ion <strong>exchange</strong> systems are the most cost<br />
effective and in some cases the only way to produce water with the quality required for<br />
proper plant operat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> plays a vital role in the eliminat<strong>ion</strong> of soluble chemical <strong>com</strong>ponents that<br />
contribute to corros<strong>ion</strong> as well as removing corros<strong>ion</strong> products and radioactive isotopes from<br />
the different coolant circuits. The objective of controlling these chemistries is to protect the<br />
<strong>nuclear</strong> generating systems from corros<strong>ion</strong>, extend the system life and maintain a safe<br />
working environment in and around the plant.<br />
The purpose of this paper is to review the different types of <strong>nuclear</strong> reactors that are in use<br />
today, and explain in some detail the important role that <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> systems (and <strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s) play in the different <strong>nuclear</strong> applicat<strong>ion</strong>s.<br />
Worldwide <strong>nuclear</strong> power plants<br />
Source: Targetmap.<strong>com</strong><br />
Note: All <strong>Purolite</strong> products referred to in this paper are <strong>Purolite</strong>® unless specifically noted.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
3
SECTION 1: NUCLEAR POWER GENERATION<br />
A. Nuclear Fiss<strong>ion</strong><br />
Nuclear fiss<strong>ion</strong> is a process in which a nucleus of an atom splits to form free neutrons and<br />
protons while producing a tremendous amount of energy in the form of heat. The atom splits<br />
because it is bombarded by slow moving neutrons that briefly are absorbed by the nucleus<br />
(neutron and proton) and cause it to change. New lighter elements are formed (fiss<strong>ion</strong><br />
products) as well as free neutrons. As more neutrons are produced when the atoms split, the<br />
react<strong>ion</strong> be<strong>com</strong>es self-sustaining. The new neutrons collide with other nuclei. Isotopes of<br />
Uranium and Plutonium have historically been used because they can sustain this chain<br />
react<strong>ion</strong> and are called fiss<strong>ion</strong>able materials.<br />
Today, <strong>nuclear</strong> fuel is natural or enriched uranium in the form of UO2 pellets. These pellets<br />
are fitted into sealed sheaths made of steel, zirconium or magnesium alloys called fuel rods.<br />
These fuel rods are arranged into bundles or elements in a very specific geometric manner.<br />
Based on the diameter of the rods, the elements are gathered into vertical or horizontal<br />
columns at an optimal distance apart. This increases the probability of neutrons meeting with<br />
a 235U nucleus, thereby inducing <strong>nuclear</strong> fiss<strong>ion</strong>. The neutron flux is the term used for rate of<br />
react<strong>ion</strong> inside the reactor. The heat emitted during fiss<strong>ion</strong> in the reactor core is transferred<br />
to a coolant that can be a liquid (water, heavy water or liquid sodium) or a gas (CO2). This<br />
heat is used to boil water and create high pressure steam in a secondary closed system. This<br />
steam is used to drive a steam turbine and generate electricity.<br />
B. Controlling the React<strong>ion</strong><br />
In order to control the react<strong>ion</strong>, the fuel bundles are typically immersed in materials that act<br />
to moderate (moderator) neutrons or retard (retarder) the product<strong>ion</strong> of neutrons. A<br />
moderator is a medium that reduces the speed of fast neutrons to control the <strong>nuclear</strong><br />
react<strong>ion</strong>. These include solid graphite, light water or heavy water. The reactor casing is<br />
made of steel and clad in a thick wall of concrete which provides a shield against radiat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
After the reactor starts up, neutron product<strong>ion</strong> progressively increases and slow neutrons<br />
may behave in one of several ways.<br />
1. Enter a 235U nucleus and induce fiss<strong>ion</strong>, yielding heat and other neutrons<br />
2. Disappear by diffus<strong>ion</strong> through the reactor casing<br />
3. Be reflected by the reactor casing<br />
4. Be absorbed by:<br />
a. Various structural materials<br />
b. Control rods: They are designed to reduce the neutron flux and are made of<br />
materials with a high-neutron-absorbing capacity, such as silver, indium and<br />
cadmium.<br />
c. A neutron absorbent such as boric acid.<br />
d. Poisons manufactured into the fuel assemblies<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
4
The relat<strong>ion</strong>ship between these processes must be precisely managed to achieve optimal<br />
control of the reactor. When a state of equilibrium is reached the reactor is said to be critical<br />
or that it has diverged.<br />
During the life of the reactor fuel, the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of 235U, and therefore the neutron flux<br />
rate, decreases. The accumulat<strong>ion</strong> of fiss<strong>ion</strong> products causes parasitic absorpt<strong>ion</strong> of neutrons<br />
which further decreases neutron flux. In order to <strong>com</strong>pensate for these effects, control rods<br />
are progressively removed during operat<strong>ion</strong> or the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of adsorbent in the<br />
moderator is reduced.<br />
If the product<strong>ion</strong> of neutrons falls below the critical level that is required to produce energy,<br />
the fuel must be replaced in a refueling outage. This occurs during a scheduled shutdown in<br />
which a port<strong>ion</strong> of the fuel rods are replaced and the remaining rods are rearranged.<br />
Refueling outages are typically carried out every 18 to 24 months for most reactor designs.<br />
Several reactor designs allow operators to change fuel while the facility is still generating<br />
power.<br />
Figure 1:<br />
Source: World Nuclear Associat<strong>ion</strong><br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
5
C. Nuclear Industry Water Quality Guidelines<br />
Although the <strong>nuclear</strong> industry does not regulate the type or quality of <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>rs used in<br />
<strong>nuclear</strong> plant operat<strong>ion</strong>s, it does establish guidelines on makeup water, primary chemical<br />
volume control, and shutdown chemistry, as well as secondary chemistry coolant that impacts<br />
condensate polishing, and steam generator blowdown quality. These guidelines strongly drive<br />
the select<strong>ion</strong> and specificat<strong>ion</strong> of <strong>resin</strong>s by <strong>nuclear</strong> operat<strong>ion</strong>s to maintain consistent quality<br />
and cleanliness within circuits.<br />
Individual <strong>nuclear</strong> power <strong>com</strong>panies set specificat<strong>ion</strong>s for <strong>resin</strong>s purchased for the different<br />
plants. However, these are generally based on <strong>resin</strong> manufacturers’ specificat<strong>ion</strong>s. The level<br />
of impurity on the <strong>resin</strong>s is established by the <strong>resin</strong> manufacturer or service <strong>com</strong>pany based<br />
on achievable post-processing capabilities.<br />
Make-up water chemistry parameters have been referenced by the Institute of Nuclear Power<br />
Operat<strong>ion</strong>s’ (INPO) Chemistry Guidelines, the World Associat<strong>ion</strong> of Nuclear Operators<br />
(WANO), and the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) Chemistry Guidelines. All<br />
emphasize the importance of maintaining extremely low contaminant concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s in the<br />
makeup water and minimizing corros<strong>ion</strong> products and trace impurities from coolant water<br />
and condensate streams. The most critical chemistry parameters listed in the referenced<br />
reports are: Key <strong>ion</strong>ic species such as sodium, fluoride, chloride, sulfate and nitrate <strong>ion</strong>s and<br />
specific conductivity. While the first four <strong>ion</strong>s are <strong>com</strong>mon, nitrate is not normally present in<br />
significant concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s. A specific conductivity limit ≤ 0.08 �S/cm measured at 25°C must<br />
be maintained or conversely, a resistivity value ≥ 12.5 MΩ/cm must be maintained.<br />
D. System Contaminants<br />
During operat<strong>ion</strong>, sodium will concentrate in crevices and points of evaporat<strong>ion</strong>, resulting in<br />
high sodium alkalinity which contributes to stress corros<strong>ion</strong> cracking in steam generator tubes<br />
and on turbine <strong>com</strong>ponents. The sodium specificat<strong>ion</strong> for <strong>nuclear</strong> makeup water is normally<br />
thermally or radiolytically in the system, producing chloride and sulfate <strong>ion</strong>s, which<br />
potentially reduce the water pH and lead to intergranular corros<strong>ion</strong> (IGC) and stress corros<strong>ion</strong><br />
cracking. The typical allowable level of sulfate in the steam generator is 1.50 ppb and the<br />
allowable level of chloride is
SECTION 2: TYPES OF REACTORS & TREATMENT OF CIRCUITS<br />
A. The Graphite-Gas Reactor (Figure 2)<br />
The Graphite-Gas Reactor was one of the first types to be introduced and quickly became the<br />
main backbone for the <strong>nuclear</strong> industry in the United Kingdom. Initial designs were the<br />
Magnox and later the AGR (Advanced Gas Cooled Reactor) system. The AGR design operates<br />
at higher temperatures, which requires certain design modificat<strong>ion</strong> to ac<strong>com</strong>modate the<br />
elevated temperatures. Today, most of the Magnox designs are no longer in operat<strong>ion</strong>, but<br />
there are several AGR designs still in successful <strong>com</strong>mercial operat<strong>ion</strong>. All of these operate<br />
with two reactors in a single structure, and use uranium as the fuel.<br />
In the reactor core, the fuel rods are located inside a block of graphite that acts as a<br />
moderator. The coolant is pressurized CO2, which passes through the reactor core removing<br />
heat. This heated CO2 stream is used to produce steam, which drive turbine generators that<br />
generate electricity as part of the overall power plant.<br />
Figure 2: Magnox Reactor Schematic<br />
Source: English Wikipedia.<br />
Today’s highly regulated <strong>nuclear</strong> power plants are considered to be safe, and produce<br />
relatively low amounts of radioactive waste material. One of the primary advantages seen<br />
with the graphite-gas design is their ability to allow for the online replacement of fuel<br />
elements. However, operating difficulties make Graphite-gas reactors <strong>com</strong>mercially less<br />
attractive to build and have restricted widespread use of this design.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
8
Graphite-Gas Reactor Treatment Circuits (Figure 3)<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> is used to treat four circuits in a Graphite-Gas <strong>nuclear</strong> plant. They are the<br />
makeup water, the returned condensate, the turbo blower and the spent fuel pool.<br />
Figure 3:<br />
1. Makeup water<br />
Almost all AGR units operate their own make up treatment systems. However service<br />
providers are available to support makeup requirements with service trailers. These systems<br />
<strong>com</strong>monly employ pre-filtrat<strong>ion</strong> followed by reverse osmosis (RO) technology with a final,<br />
high-purity mixed bed polisher. Nuclear power plants that continue to own and operate their<br />
own makeup water-treatment systems will generally use standard <strong>resin</strong>s that produce<br />
high-quality water but also have good regenerat<strong>ion</strong> efficiency.<br />
The following <strong>resin</strong>s configured in the order shown can be used to demineralize the makeup<br />
water for AGR Reactors:<br />
� NRW100 strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r<br />
� PFA100 weak base an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r<br />
� NRW400 strong base an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r<br />
� NRW3240 for polishing mixed beds<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
9
This <strong>com</strong>binat<strong>ion</strong> of <strong>resin</strong>s will produce water with conductivity below 0.1 µS/cm and less<br />
than 10 ppb of Si02. The makeup water re<strong>com</strong>mended purity is specified in Table 1.<br />
Table 1: AGR Makeup Water Specificat<strong>ion</strong>s<br />
2. Condensate Polishing<br />
Component Specificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
Total Dissolved Solids
B. Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) (Figure 4)<br />
The Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) is the most widely used <strong>nuclear</strong> power generat<strong>ion</strong><br />
design and has achieved great success worldwide. The reactor core heats the surrounding<br />
pressurized water (the primary circuit or coolant) and the water circulates to a steam<br />
generator where it transfers its heat to a secondary water system. Steam at approximately<br />
900psig is created and is sent to a steam turbine to generate electricity. The advantage of<br />
this system is that the radioactive sect<strong>ion</strong>s (the reactor and primary circuit) are separate from<br />
the rest of the power plant. Such separat<strong>ion</strong> helps to control and minimize potential<br />
contaminat<strong>ion</strong> risks.<br />
PWR’s use enriched UO2 (between 2.0 and 4.95 wt. %) in pellet form as fuel. In a 900 MW<br />
power plant, the reactor uses up to 72 tons of uranium per year. These pellets are contained<br />
inside zirconium alloy sheaths (Zircalloy) to form a rod. In a typical design, approximately 200<br />
of these fuel rods are bunched together to form a bundle or element. Depending on its<br />
capacity, a reactor core can contain from 150 to 200 rod bundles which are arranged for<br />
optimum heat generat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
Figure 4: Pressurized Water Reactor<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
11
Source: US Nuclear Regulatory Commiss<strong>ion</strong><br />
The coolant running through the reactor core is purified water and is given the term “light<br />
water”. Acting as both a heat transfer fluid and a moderator, it is heated to 290 – 320 o C and<br />
maintained under a pressure of 150 bar (2,200 psi). The neutron flux rate can be controlled<br />
by varying the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of boric acid dissolved in this primary circuit water and by<br />
moving the control rods up and down. However, typical operat<strong>ion</strong> has the control rods<br />
almost <strong>com</strong>pletely withdrawn to maximize fuel burn-up. Large water pumps circulate the<br />
pressurized water through the steam generators, which funct<strong>ion</strong> as heat <strong>exchange</strong>rs. Certain<br />
PWR reactor designs such as the Candu system use “heavy water”. This is water highly<br />
enriched in the hydrogen isotope deuterium. Deuterium has a proton and a neutron in the<br />
nucleus whereas hydrogen has only a proton. Other than the moderator, the basics of the<br />
Candu reactor are the same as the PWR described herein.<br />
The PWR was originally designed in the United States by Westinghouse’s Bettis Atomic Power<br />
Laboratory for military ships. Westinghouse, Asea Brown Boveri-Combust<strong>ion</strong> Engineering<br />
(ABB-CE), Framatome, Kraftwerk Un<strong>ion</strong>, Siemens, and Mitsubishi have typically built this type<br />
of reactor throughout the world. Babcock & Wilcox (B&W) built a PWR design but used<br />
vertical once-through steam generators rather than the U-tube design used by the rest of the<br />
suppliers. Industry consolidat<strong>ion</strong> has occurred so that Framatome-Areva-NP, Westinghouse,<br />
Mitsubishi and Toshiba are the key remaining manufacturers. Such reactors, especially the<br />
Westinghouse AP1000 and the Areva EPR designs, are expected to be widely used in the years<br />
to <strong>com</strong>e and will constitute a major port<strong>ion</strong> of the world’s <strong>nuclear</strong> power generat<strong>ion</strong><br />
programs in the foreseeable future.<br />
PWR Treatment Circuits<br />
The PWR is <strong>com</strong>posed of two entirely separate circuits: Primary (Figure 5) and secondary<br />
(Figure 8).<br />
Primary Circuit Treatment<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> is used to treat four circuits within the primary circuit in a PWR <strong>nuclear</strong> plant.<br />
They are the reactor coolant purificat<strong>ion</strong> system, deborat<strong>ion</strong>, spent fuel pool and radwaste<br />
effluent.<br />
The primary circuit water is in direct contact with the reactor fuel. It acts as coolant and<br />
moderator. Impurities from the makeup water and corros<strong>ion</strong> products that are exposed to<br />
the core be<strong>com</strong>e radioactive and thus require special treatment. Primary circuit water<br />
transports heat from the fuel bundles and helps to cool the fuel. This water, although high in<br />
boron and, to a much lower level, lithium, must be clean and free of soluble and suspended<br />
corros<strong>ion</strong> matter that will collect on the fuel rods. In addit<strong>ion</strong>, inorganic salts of sodium,<br />
sulfate, and chloride must be controlled to minimize corros<strong>ion</strong> in the granular structure of the<br />
fuel rod sheaths and system metal surfaces. Two types of corros<strong>ion</strong> can occur: Intergranular<br />
Corros<strong>ion</strong> (IGC) or Stress Corros<strong>ion</strong> Cracking (SCC). Corros<strong>ion</strong> byproducts will foul fuel and<br />
contribute to irregular burning known as axial anomalies or Crud Induced Power Shift (CIPS).<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
12
These corros<strong>ion</strong> byproducts will be<strong>com</strong>e activated isotopes that release as crud bursts during<br />
cool down periods of outages. These buildups and releases can potentially damage fuel<br />
sheaths and contribute to fuel leaks and support Crud Induced Localized Corros<strong>ion</strong> (CILC).<br />
To further minimize colloidal and dissolved impurities, corros<strong>ion</strong>-resistant materials with<br />
special alloys, such as Zircaloy, Inconel and stainless steel are utilized. It must be noted,<br />
however, that stainless steel is sensitive to the presence of chloride in the water. Today,<br />
special corros<strong>ion</strong>-resistant stainless metals, such as Alloy690TT and Alloy 80Mod, are being<br />
used to replace current steam generators to minimize source term and extend unit life.<br />
Source term is latent radiat<strong>ion</strong> that builds up in the system and must be controlled.<br />
The pH of the primary water is typically maintained between 6.9 and 7.4 at 300°C or coolant<br />
average temperature. This may change depending on materials of construct<strong>ion</strong>, water<br />
chemistry and system design. If necessary, it is adjusted up by adding lithium hydroxides.<br />
Lithium can be natural lithium, a mixture of two isotopes (approximately 7% 6 Li + and 93% 7 Li + ),<br />
or purified lithium (99.5% 7 Li + ). Natural lithium is notably less expensive but has the<br />
disadvantage of producing tritium by neutron capture of 6 Li + . Purified 7 Li + is the principal<br />
lithium isotope used in a large majority of PWR’s worldwide.<br />
The pH of the primary water must be maintained at the specified level and adjusted based on<br />
the water temperature. Reactor pH (temperature correct<strong>ion</strong>s of 0.2 to 2 units) is adjusted<br />
down by removing lithium. Boric acid is used to slow down neutrons. When a power plant<br />
starts up, the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of boric acid is typically 1,500 ppm as B. As the <strong>nuclear</strong> fuel<br />
activity decreases, the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> is reduced progressively until low concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s are<br />
reached by the end of the fuel life cycle. However, the plant may need to increase or decrease<br />
the boric acid concentrat<strong>ion</strong> in order to adjust the power supply at a given moment. Natural<br />
boron is a <strong>com</strong>binat<strong>ion</strong> of B 11 and B 10 . B 10 is a powerful neutron absorbent and changes into<br />
7 Li + via a <strong>nuclear</strong> react<strong>ion</strong> known as radiolysis. Thus, the 7 Li + concentrat<strong>ion</strong> is maintained<br />
within the circuit proport<strong>ion</strong>ally to the boric acid concentrat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
13
Figure 5: PWR - Primary Circuit Treatment<br />
1. Reactor Coolant Purificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
The primary circuit coolant water is treated exclusively by the Chemical-Volume-Control<br />
System (CVCS). This system consists of 2 to 4 <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> vessels that remove <strong>ion</strong>ic<br />
impurities, control pH by adding lithium or removing lithium, control activity by adding or<br />
removing boron and remove radioactivity. During full power, one vessel loaded with lithiated<br />
cat<strong>ion</strong> and borated an<strong>ion</strong> mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> (Li:B) is operated to control low-level <strong>ion</strong>ic<br />
impurities and temperature-adjusted pH. All an<strong>ion</strong>s are borated from boron in the primary<br />
coolant. Some plants are designed with Boron Thermal Regenerat<strong>ion</strong> Systems that can add or<br />
remove boron. Near the end of the full power cycle the RFO (Refueling Outage) cleanup bed<br />
will be loaded and may be borated during intermittent operat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
Mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>s used in the CVCS include NRW3460 and NRW3560 (both available in natural<br />
6 Li + and purified 7 Li + forms). If a greater capacity is required to remove Co58, Co60 and Cs137,<br />
the mixed bed can be layered with macroporous strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> NRW160. Some systems<br />
will have a separate cat<strong>ion</strong> bed available in the event that addit<strong>ion</strong>al cat<strong>ion</strong> control is<br />
required.<br />
All <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s used for primary coolant purificat<strong>ion</strong> have a quality rating and must<br />
meet specific criteria for <strong>nuclear</strong> purity. If not, there will be a risk of impurity leaching. Studies<br />
have shown that in presence of 3,000 ppm boric acid and 2 ppm lithium, an an<strong>ion</strong>ic <strong>resin</strong><br />
containing 800 mg chloride per kg of dry <strong>resin</strong> produces water containing approximately 50<br />
ppb chloride. Therefore, low-chloride an<strong>ion</strong>ic <strong>resin</strong>s must be used — that is, with less than<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
14
0.1 % of total active sites with chloride, or approximately 200 mg per kg of dry <strong>resin</strong>. Special<br />
attent<strong>ion</strong> should also be paid to the silica content in an<strong>ion</strong>ic <strong>resin</strong>, as silica found on the<br />
an<strong>ion</strong>ic <strong>resin</strong> is easily displaced by boric acid and can end up leaching into primary coolant.<br />
a. Outage Cleanup Beds<br />
Near the end of a power cycle prior to a scheduled shutdown a mixed bed is loaded with H +<br />
form cat<strong>ion</strong>, OH - form an<strong>ion</strong> (H:OH) and layered <strong>resin</strong>s for refueling cleanup. These <strong>resin</strong>s<br />
replace the previous outage bed <strong>resin</strong>s which have been sluiced to a spent <strong>resin</strong> tank (SRT).<br />
This bed may be operated intermittently prior to end of cycle to remove residual lithium and<br />
borate the an<strong>ion</strong>. This be<strong>com</strong>es an H:B bed. During the refueling outage (RFO) this bed will<br />
remove corros<strong>ion</strong> isotopes that are released during the shutdown and forced oxygenat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
This is to minimize personal contaminat<strong>ion</strong> and dose while work is being done on the primary<br />
system.<br />
Chemical adjustments to the primary system carried out shortly after shutdown are, by design,<br />
intended to force significant levels of radioactivity, both soluble and insoluble, into the<br />
coolant stream. These adjustments include controlling the hydrogen concentrat<strong>ion</strong> to<br />
maintain a reducing phase followed by the addit<strong>ion</strong> of hydrogen peroxide to create an<br />
oxidizing phase. Iron solubility increases in the reducing phase while nickel solubility increases<br />
in the oxidizing phase. The addit<strong>ion</strong> of hydrogen peroxide will cause iron to precipitate.<br />
These steps force corros<strong>ion</strong> and radioisotopes from the reactor surface and crevices of fuel<br />
bundles. Steam generators may or may not be isolated during the cleanup, however if<br />
recirculating coolant pumps (RCP) remain on, more activity will be released from these areas.<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> beds and filters are designed to reduce radioactive contaminants to EPRI’s<br />
act<strong>ion</strong> level of 5.0E-2 µCi/gm before outage activities can begin.<br />
Due to limited flow of one cleanup bed, it is <strong>com</strong>mon for the Li:B bed used during full power<br />
to operate with the H:B layered bed in parallel. This literally doubles the cleanup rate. If<br />
pump capacity allows, some plants will have only the layered cleanup bed in service and<br />
double the service flow. The objective of operating at double the flow is to reduce the time<br />
required to reach the required act<strong>ion</strong> level. This operat<strong>ion</strong> works well when CVCS and cleanup<br />
beds are used only one cycle.<br />
Refueling outage (RFO) beds are CVCS beds used to clean the primary coolant during an<br />
outage. RFO beds are loaded with a special configurat<strong>ion</strong> (layering) of <strong>resin</strong>s to reduce both<br />
soluble and insoluble isotopes. For instance, RFO beds typically have 20cf of <strong>nuclear</strong> mixed<br />
bed NRW3560 loaded on the bottom, 5cf of high capacity, macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> NRW160 in<br />
the middle and 5cf of macroporous an<strong>ion</strong> NRW5010 or NRW5070 to cap the top. The bottom<br />
layer of NRW3560 consists of high-capacity cat<strong>ion</strong> (NRW160) and an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s (NRW600) to<br />
polish the coolant. The middle layer of NRW160 is used to remove soluble metals such as<br />
cobalt, cesium, iron, nickel and other metal <strong>ion</strong>s in the coolant water. The top layer of<br />
NRW5010 or NRW5070 will effectively filter very fine particulates – colloids - that <strong>com</strong>monly<br />
pass through the cleanup mixed beds. This macroporous an<strong>ion</strong> layer at the top of the bed is<br />
efficient at removing particulates below 0.1 µm in size, which would otherwise plug or bypass<br />
standard operating filters. Use of these macroporous an<strong>ion</strong>s will also favorably impact<br />
radwaste cleanup, by lowering the post-filtrat<strong>ion</strong> dose and allowing smaller effective size<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
15
filters (0.1 µm) to be used during outage activities, reducing the number of filters used, and,<br />
to a limited extent, assisting in the reduct<strong>ion</strong> of source term within the primary system.<br />
Currently there is a push to reduce <strong>nuclear</strong> waste because of lack of storage sites. Resins are<br />
now being used in more than one cycle. Originally the NRW5010 product was considered to<br />
be too fragile and not possible to be loaded on full service bed, but with the development of<br />
the stronger macroporous an<strong>ion</strong> NRW5070, full power beds can be layered and used for<br />
possibly 2 cycle’s without concern of bead failure. Cleanup beds however may not be good<br />
candidates for multiple outages due to the high level and type of loading they encounter.<br />
b. pH control<br />
As ment<strong>ion</strong>ed earlier, pH is adjusted upward by adding lithium hydroxide and downward by<br />
removing lithium. Since B 10 absorbs neutrons and changes into 7 Li + there may be an excessive<br />
increase in lithium in the circuit. This concentrat<strong>ion</strong> is controlled by routing the mixed bed<br />
effluent (primarily Westinghouse systems) into a separate CVCS vessel loaded with strong<br />
acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> NRW160 to remove excess lithium.<br />
c. Outage Activity<br />
When the reactor cavity coolant has reached the specified activity level the reactor coolant<br />
pumps (RCP) are stopped, steam generators isolated and the reactor head is lifted. From this<br />
point the cavity is flooded with water from the reactor or refueling water storage tank (RWST)<br />
and refueling begins. This creates a large pool where fuel bundles are manipulated under<br />
water. Some bundles are moved to a spent fuel pool through a refueling canal and<br />
continually remain submerged. Once the refueling has been <strong>com</strong>pleted, the reactor water is<br />
returned to the RWST or released to the radwaste stream for processing before discharge.<br />
The discharged water is termed primary effluent and includes primary circuit let down (water<br />
released from primary system to be replaced with water of a different boron concentrat<strong>ion</strong>)<br />
and the various liquid waste streams originating from the radioactive sect<strong>ion</strong>s of the power<br />
plant. These waters contain lithium and boron in addit<strong>ion</strong> to a large variety of radioactive<br />
isotopes. The effluents are filtered before being treated by <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>rs. Usually the <strong>resin</strong><br />
train consists of activated carbon, natural zeolite, a strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r H + form<br />
(NRW160, NRW1100, NRW1000), followed by mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>s (NRW3240 or NRW3260). The<br />
strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r removes lithium, cobalt, cesium etc. Fluoride and antimony are<br />
generally the difficult species to remove.<br />
2. Deborat<strong>ion</strong><br />
The term deborat<strong>ion</strong> is related to <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> systems that will remove boron in a controlled<br />
manner. The deborat<strong>ion</strong> system removes residual boric acid remaining in the first part of the<br />
waste stream by <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> before passing to the radwaste processing system. The system<br />
may consist of an evaporator or a reverse osmosis system which produces a highly<br />
concentrated boron solut<strong>ion</strong>. The solut<strong>ion</strong>, according to its quality, is either recycled back to<br />
the primary circuit or directed to a treatment system for solid effluent. Permeate containing<br />
boron may be treated with <strong>nuclear</strong> grade strong base an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r (NRW6000 or<br />
NRW7000).<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
16
The capacity of the an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> for boron will vary proport<strong>ion</strong>ally with the boric acid in the<br />
evaporator effluent or RO permeate. When the boron concentrat<strong>ion</strong> increases, the an<strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>resin</strong> operating capacity will increase. When boron is about 100 ppm, the operating capacity<br />
of the an<strong>ion</strong> will be about 40 grams of boric acid per liter of <strong>resin</strong>.<br />
3. Spent Fuel Pool (SFP) Treatment<br />
There are generally three pools in a <strong>nuclear</strong> power plant: the reactor water cavity (RWC), the<br />
spent fuel pool (SFP) and the reactor water storage tank (RWST). The RWC is the pool created<br />
when the reactor cavity is flooded with water from the RWST. RWC <strong>com</strong>pletely covers the<br />
reactor dome and allows for fuel to be moved to and from the reactor while being covered<br />
with water. The RWST tank is used during the entire cycle to refill the RWC during the outage,<br />
the SFP and during an emergency shutdown, and to refill the Cold Leg Accumulators (CLA).<br />
The CLA is a pressure vessel that will discharge, in the event of pressure loss, high borated<br />
water into the cold leg piping feeding the reactor vessel and assists in the shutdown of the<br />
<strong>nuclear</strong> react<strong>ion</strong>. The SFP is connected to the RWC by a fuel-transport canal. Fresh fuel is<br />
stored in the SFP prior to an outage and exhausted fuel is stored in the SFP after its useful<br />
service.<br />
Purificat<strong>ion</strong> of the RWC and the SFP is carried out by a spent fuel pool demineralizer, which<br />
uses a mixed bed of strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> and strong base an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> (NRW3560 or<br />
NRW3670). Peroxide generated by radiat<strong>ion</strong> from the exhausted fuel contributes to oxidative<br />
attack on the cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>, which results in the release of sulfates. Fuel pools with a higher<br />
percentage of spent fuel will have greater issues with this <strong>resin</strong> degradat<strong>ion</strong> than others. The<br />
highly cross-linked macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> NRW160 (found in NRW3560 and NRW3540),<br />
gel cat<strong>ion</strong> NRW1160 (NRW3660) and NRW1180 tolerate this oxidative condit<strong>ion</strong> better than<br />
lower cross linked <strong>resin</strong>s. This allows for a longer service life before sulfates in the pool water<br />
requires <strong>resin</strong> replacement.<br />
Figure 6: Oxidative stability of <strong>Purolite</strong> cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> in a peroxide environment<br />
Maintaining the clarity of both the reactor water and spent fuel pool water is crucial.<br />
Sediments are easily disturbed during fuel movement causing clarity to deteriorate and<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
17
turbidity and radiat<strong>ion</strong> levels to increase. Use of the macroporous an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s NRW5010 or<br />
NRW5070 assist in reducing turbidity and associated radioactivity when layered on top of the<br />
mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>. Addit<strong>ion</strong>ally, if fuel bundles are moved from the fuel pool and transported to<br />
dry storage in special storage casks, the SFP demineralizer with an NRW5010 layer on the<br />
mixed bed removes fine particulates that collect on metal surfaces. This significantly reduces<br />
the task of decontaminating casks prior to moving them to storage.<br />
Figure 7: Activity buildup on an<strong>ion</strong>s used for RFO cleanup<br />
uSv/h<br />
4.5<br />
4<br />
3.5<br />
3<br />
2.5<br />
2<br />
1.5<br />
1<br />
0.5<br />
0<br />
4. Radwaste Effluent Treatment<br />
Cleanup Bed Activity<br />
NRW400 NRW5010<br />
The radwaste system collects all effluents from the power plant, such as active and inactive<br />
blowdown and wash water. Depending on the <strong>ion</strong>ic load, a mixed bed may be used alone<br />
(NRW3240) or in a train consisting of a strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r (NRW160) followed by<br />
the mixed bed. However, it has been found that a number of radioactive products are present<br />
in colloid form (this is the case with <strong>ion</strong>s in associat<strong>ion</strong> with Co58 and Ag 110, in particular)<br />
and therefore are not captured by convent<strong>ion</strong>al <strong>resin</strong>s. Adding a layer of the macroporous<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> NRW5010 or NRW5070 on top of either the strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> bed or the mixed<br />
bed will effectively address this type of contaminant.<br />
The convent<strong>ion</strong>al radwaste mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> may be replaced with the higher-capacity mixed<br />
bed, NRW3560. It should be noted that the <strong>resin</strong>s used for the treatment of wastewater do<br />
not necessarily have to be <strong>nuclear</strong> quality since this water is to be released into cooling ponds<br />
under the guidelines of the Off-site Dose Calculat<strong>ion</strong> Manual (OCDM) following treatment.<br />
They must however be highly regenerated to maximize loading of activity.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
Top<br />
Middle<br />
Bottom<br />
18
Secondary Circuit Treatment<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> is used to treat three circuits within the secondary circuit in a PWR <strong>nuclear</strong> plant.<br />
They are the makeup water, returned condensate and steam generator blowdown.<br />
The secondary water circuit generates steam which is fed directly to the turbines and is non –<br />
radioactive. It is possible for it to be<strong>com</strong>e radioactive if a leak in the steam generator<br />
develops or a small amount of tritium passes through the steam generator. The system feed<br />
water consists of condensate return, steam generator blowdown and demineralized makeup.<br />
This water must have a high purity. During full power, the makeup water system will<br />
<strong>com</strong>pensate for blowdown losses and any possible leaks.<br />
Figure 8: PWR Secondary Circuit Treatment<br />
5. Makeup Water Treatment<br />
Many makeup water treatment systems have moved to build, own and operate (BOO)<br />
generally consisting of clarificat<strong>ion</strong> or ultra-filtrat<strong>ion</strong> (UF), carbon filters, reverse osmosis (RO)<br />
technology, electronic de<strong>ion</strong>izat<strong>ion</strong> (EDI), followed by polishing using mixed bed <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong><br />
systems. This approach allows plants to move away from chemical-based regenerat<strong>ion</strong>,<br />
which contributes to plant waste. This approach also minimizes frequent replacement of<br />
service DI trailers. These makeup systems are <strong>com</strong>monly operated by offsite contract<br />
suppliers.<br />
When <strong>resin</strong>s are used to treat makeup water, they must be highly regenerated and specially<br />
processed to meet tight specificat<strong>ion</strong>s for chloride, sulfate, sodium, iron and TOC (also known<br />
as “POC” or purgeable organic carbon). Regenerat<strong>ion</strong> is generally carried out offsite.<br />
NRW3240 can be used as a polisher in makeup systems. This mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> is <strong>com</strong>posed of<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
19
esins that are characterized by high total capacity and selectivity for influent cat<strong>ion</strong>s such as<br />
sodium, and an<strong>ion</strong>s such as silica and chloride. This <strong>resin</strong> is also easily regenerated to a high<br />
level of convers<strong>ion</strong> with minimal release of impurities.<br />
As a final polishing step before water enters the de<strong>ion</strong>ized water storage tank (DWST), a<br />
non-regenerable, high-purity mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>, such as UltraClean UCW9964 may be used.<br />
For a “less separable” mixed bed, UCW9966 can also be used. The makeup water quality will<br />
achieve 17.9 MΩ, residual silica
closely and when effectiveness decreases, the <strong>resin</strong>s must be replaced. They should be<br />
replaced even if the <strong>ion</strong>ic operating capacity has not been depleted <strong>com</strong>pletely. Plants using<br />
ETA-naturalizing amines may require a cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> that has been specially manufactured and<br />
post treated to minimize foulants that degrade an<strong>ion</strong> kinetics.<br />
Condensate polishing, which removes corros<strong>ion</strong> products and in-leakage, is ac<strong>com</strong>plished<br />
primarily with deep mixed bed polishers and less frequently with precoat filters. Precoat<br />
filters are vessels that have several filter elements that are coated with a layer of powdered<br />
<strong>resin</strong>s and are typically used where steam condenser water has a relatively low salinity and<br />
when the risk of leakage is considered small. When plants use fresh water for cooling,<br />
deep-bed condensate polishers are operated during startup or upset condit<strong>ion</strong>s. When plants<br />
cool with brackish or salt water, the deep beds are operated continuously.<br />
Care is required to ensure that the steam generator receives high-purity water containing<br />
0.02 ppb of Na + , Cl - and SO4 - , as these dissolved solids will concentrate in the steam generator<br />
as steam is produced. A small number of PWR plants regenerate their condensate-polishing<br />
<strong>resin</strong>s. However, the level of purity required from the polishing <strong>resin</strong> is critical and<br />
regenerating this <strong>resin</strong> to achieve levels where sodium, chloride and sulfate do not leach is<br />
often difficult to attain. Special efforts must be taken to ensure proper separat<strong>ion</strong> of <strong>resin</strong>s,<br />
minimize cross-contaminat<strong>ion</strong> and minimize residual <strong>ion</strong>s from regenerat<strong>ion</strong> remaining in the<br />
<strong>resin</strong>s. These <strong>ion</strong>s are Na + on the strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> and carboxylic groups that may form on<br />
the an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> (See papers by Auerswald (7) and by Crone (8) ). Polishing systems that are not<br />
regenerated will operate intermittently to extend the <strong>resin</strong> life. Once these<br />
condensate-polishing <strong>resin</strong>s begin breaking on amine, the condensate-polishing <strong>resin</strong>s must<br />
be replaced. A small number of condensate polishers do operate past the amine break,<br />
however, these plants have extremely high purity secondary systems and no cooling water<br />
leakage.<br />
The following <strong>Purolite</strong> deep-bed demineralizer <strong>resin</strong>s are re<strong>com</strong>mended for condensate<br />
polishing:<br />
1. Non-regenerable polishers will use the strong acid macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r<br />
NRW160, or gel NRW 1160, followed by the <strong>com</strong>plimentary mixed bed NRW3560, or<br />
NRW3670. This system has a lead strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> which removes<br />
unwanted cat<strong>ion</strong>s, corros<strong>ion</strong> products, ammonia, and amines. The H + and OH - polishing<br />
mixed bed captures traces impurities and supports longer unit run times. This system is<br />
capable of operating the lead cat<strong>ion</strong> past the amine break and possibly to a sodium<br />
break as long as sodium on the cat<strong>ion</strong> (and an<strong>ion</strong>) is low (
4. A non-regenerable mixed bed with 1:1 cat<strong>ion</strong>-to-an<strong>ion</strong> ratio by volume addressing<br />
elevated amine chemistries is NRW3561 or 2:1 cat<strong>ion</strong> to an<strong>ion</strong> by volume NRW3562.<br />
Items 3 and 4 above generally require the service cycle to stop at the ammonia break<br />
resulting in approximately 2–4 weeks service. If service continues beyond the ammonia<br />
break to a sodium break service time will be greater, approximately 6 weeks, but Na+<br />
leakage to the hot well will also be higher.<br />
Precoat filters (elements) are coated with a mixture of strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r in H +<br />
form (Microlite PrCH) or an ammonia-form <strong>exchange</strong>r (Microlite PrCN) and a strong base<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong>r in OH - form (Microlite PrAOH). Precoat filters have a relatively limited<br />
capacity for removing soluble salts and thus be<strong>com</strong>e rapidly exhausted in the event of a<br />
condenser leak. However, powdered <strong>resin</strong>s have an inherent advantage over bead <strong>resin</strong>s in<br />
that they have less capital cost associated with precoat facilities than a regenerat<strong>ion</strong> system.<br />
Furthermore, filtrat<strong>ion</strong> of corros<strong>ion</strong> products is more efficient with powdered <strong>resin</strong>s than with<br />
bead <strong>resin</strong>s.<br />
Precoat products are available premixed as mixed bed products, without fiber (Microlite MB)<br />
and with fiber (CG range). If precoats exhaust on pressure drop due to excess corros<strong>ion</strong> or<br />
crud, precoat with fiber may allow extended runs.<br />
7. Steam Generator Blowdown Treatment<br />
The steam generator blowdown (SGBD) is required to maintain water quality within specified<br />
EPRI Secondary Water Chemistry Guidelines. SGBD is designed to remove and control<br />
dissolved solids in the steam generator, which can build up from 50 to 200 times higher than<br />
those concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s in the makeup feedwater. The blowdown stream can be routed either<br />
to waste or to a demineralizer. Waste blowdown is sent to radwaste or to cooling lagoons if<br />
no radioactivity is present. Demineralized blowdown is typically returned to the condensate<br />
storage tank (CST), where it contributes to makeup water. Dissolved solids entering steam<br />
generators are primarily amines (MPA, ETA), ammonia, and hydrazine along with low levels of<br />
sodium, sulfate and chloride. Concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s in the steam generator are low ppm levels for<br />
amines and low ppb or sub ppb levels for inorganic salts. If leakage from the primary circuit<br />
occurs, radioactivity will be removed by the blowdown demineralizer <strong>resin</strong>s, which will then<br />
require disposal as low-level radioactive (Class A) waste or blown down overboard and<br />
quantified per the ODCM.<br />
A blowdown demineralizer system generally consists of two vessels: A strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> in the lead vessel and a mixed bed of strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> and strong base an<strong>ion</strong><br />
in the second vessel. Blowdown <strong>resin</strong>s require high purity cat<strong>ion</strong> and an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s, both of<br />
which have low levels of sodium and TOC. High-capacity cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s, generally macroporous<br />
NRW160 or gel NRW1160 with very low sodium (20g/kg), are typically used to control sodium<br />
in the steam generat<strong>ion</strong>. Using low-sodium and high-capacity cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s, the cat<strong>ion</strong> bed can<br />
be operated past the amine break as long as there are no leaks, which allows the cat<strong>ion</strong> bed<br />
to be operated 3–4 times longer than cat<strong>ion</strong> beds operated only to the amine break.<br />
Plants with any kind of condenser leak must operate only to the amine break. Plants that use<br />
ammonia and morpholine have more experience operating past the amine break to a sodium<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
22
eak <strong>com</strong>pared to plants using ETA. High cross-linked macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong>s <strong>resin</strong>s operated<br />
in the low sodium form will result in only a slight sodium excurs<strong>ion</strong> when the amine break is<br />
reached. However, sodium levels will drop back after a short time and be maintained at low<br />
levels until the sodium break occurs. Low-level sodium released from the lead cat<strong>ion</strong> will be<br />
removed by the downstream mixed bed (NRW3560 or NRW3670). The mixed bed following<br />
the cat<strong>ion</strong> bed may also be operated past an amine break to a sodium break. However, the<br />
sodium break is much sooner (typically occurring in a matter of weeks) <strong>com</strong>pared to what is<br />
often experienced on the cat<strong>ion</strong> bed (several months). For plants with higher ammonia and<br />
amine levels, use of a mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> with a higher cat<strong>ion</strong> capacity may add addit<strong>ion</strong>al bed<br />
life. NRW3562 has a 2:1 cat<strong>ion</strong>-to-an<strong>ion</strong> ratio by volume, which provides approximately 4.2:1<br />
equivalence cat<strong>ion</strong>-to-an<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
23
C. Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) (Figure 9)<br />
The Boiler Water Reactor (BWR), originally designed by General Electric and Idaho Nat<strong>ion</strong>al<br />
labs, is the second most widely used type of light-water reactor. GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy is<br />
the main current manufacturer of this type of reactor.<br />
The BWR has a single circuit, which is used to supply steam directly to turbines. The drawback<br />
of the system is the presence of radioactivity in the steam. This requires a more robust<br />
protect<strong>ion</strong> system for the entire circuit. The fuel used in the BWR is similar to the fuel used<br />
for a PWR but the fuel rods have a larger diameter and the bundles contain only about 50<br />
sheaths.<br />
The moderator and coolant water temperature reaches 286°C at the core. The water is<br />
maintained at a pressure of only 70 bars (1000 psig) where it is transformed into steam.<br />
Consequently, the reactor itself acts as the steam generator.<br />
Similar to the PWR, periodic fuel replacement requires the power plant to be shut down for<br />
two to six weeks, after approximately 18 – 24 months of service.<br />
Figure 9: Boiling Water Reactor Configurat<strong>ion</strong><br />
Source: US Nuclear Regulatory Commiss<strong>ion</strong><br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
24
BWR Treatment Circuits (Figure 10)<br />
The Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) reactor serves as a steam generator (9) , which means the<br />
whole circuit is radioactive and the water must be of very high purity. Ion <strong>exchange</strong> is used<br />
to treat five systems in a BWR <strong>nuclear</strong> power plant. They are the makeup water, returned<br />
condensate, spent fuel pool, reactor coolant purificat<strong>ion</strong> and radwaste treatment.<br />
Figure 10: BWR Treatment Circuits<br />
1. Makeup Water Treatment<br />
The specificat<strong>ion</strong>s for makeup water indicated by General Electric Company are shown in<br />
Table 2.<br />
Table 2: GE Makeup Water Specificat<strong>ion</strong>s<br />
Component Specificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
Conductivity
As in the case of other reactors, regenerable <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s are typically used to produce<br />
demineralized water that meets the required quality of the plant, while non-regenerable,<br />
highly regenerated mixed beds are used for final polishing. These final polishing mixed bed<br />
<strong>resin</strong>s are re-used in regenerable vessels after they are exhausted.<br />
Many <strong>nuclear</strong> units rely on service <strong>com</strong>panies to supply makeup water in order to minimize<br />
the handling, storage and use of treatment chemicals and the product<strong>ion</strong> of chemical waste<br />
streams onsite.<br />
2. Condensate Polishing<br />
Condensate polishing is one of two methods to control purity of the BWR coolant after<br />
makeup polishing. This polishing is primarily ac<strong>com</strong>plished by using precoat filters only on<br />
freshwater cooled units and deep bed <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> vessels for brackish and salt water cooled<br />
units.<br />
Units that rely on low-salinity cooling water <strong>com</strong>monly use precoat filters with powder <strong>resin</strong>s<br />
(Microlite PrCH, PrAOH, MB and CG range). Although powdered <strong>resin</strong>s have a disadvantage<br />
of rapid exhaust<strong>ion</strong> in the event of a condenser leak, they do present the following<br />
advantages:<br />
� Lower capital cost because regenerat<strong>ion</strong> facilities are not required<br />
� Good filtrat<strong>ion</strong> of corros<strong>ion</strong> products. For instance, the quantity of suspended<br />
matter in treated condensate is only a few ppb, and will generally be<br />
controlled under 0.8 ppb at the filter outlet, even when startup levels of inlet<br />
impurities (such as iron and copper) may be on the order of several ppm<br />
� Powdered <strong>resin</strong>s are used once and therefore are a minimal risk of<br />
deteriorating chemically, even at relatively high temperatures. It is thus<br />
possible to install the precoat filters after one of the low-pressure heat<br />
<strong>exchange</strong>rs, to improve filtrat<strong>ion</strong>. Consequently, powder-form <strong>resin</strong>s are very<br />
widely used in BWR power plants in many countries<br />
In brackish and saltwater-cooled systems, <strong>resin</strong>s in bead form used in deep-bed polishers are<br />
primarily high-capacity gel form <strong>resin</strong>s. However, macroporous <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s offer<br />
except<strong>ion</strong>al selectivity for cobalt-60 and iron <strong>com</strong>pared to gel-type <strong>resin</strong>s. Macroporous<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s also have a greater affinity for particulate iron <strong>com</strong>pared to gel <strong>resin</strong>s. Mixed<br />
beds with an equivalent cat<strong>ion</strong>-to-an<strong>ion</strong> ratio are preferred. Compared to the precoat<br />
polisher, deep-bed polishing systems ensure several hours of operat<strong>ion</strong> in the event of a leak<br />
in the cooling condenser.<br />
After the polishing step, condensate is sent directly to the reactor through the makeup line.<br />
Condensate polishing must both demineralize the stream and filter corros<strong>ion</strong> products, which<br />
are predominately iron.<br />
Note: No chemical condensate condit<strong>ion</strong>ing (amines) or reducing chemistry are used in BWR<br />
systems.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
26
3. Reactor Coolant Purificat<strong>ion</strong><br />
The reactor water or coolant purificat<strong>ion</strong> system is the primary system for cleaning the<br />
reactor coolant. Reactor coolant water be<strong>com</strong>es charged with radioactive corros<strong>ion</strong> products<br />
during the power cycle, therefore it be<strong>com</strong>es necessary to remove impurities prior to a<br />
refueling outage. This is achieved by diverting water through the suppress<strong>ion</strong> pool<br />
demineralizer. The suppress<strong>ion</strong> pool is a large reservoir located below the reactor that<br />
supplies cooling water for outage activity and in the event the reactor water pumps fail. This<br />
demineralizer is loaded with a mixed bed <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> in equivalent ratios. Mixed beds<br />
with macroporous type bead <strong>resin</strong>s (NRW3560) layered with a macroporous an<strong>ion</strong> NRW5010<br />
or NRW5070 have proven to be more effective for iron cleanup than gel <strong>resin</strong>s. Cycling of<br />
reactor coolant is stopped when activity drops below 5.0E -2 mRem. Addit<strong>ion</strong>ally, the<br />
decontaminat<strong>ion</strong> factor drops to low levels (single digits), which generally occurs when >90 %<br />
of cobalt, copper, iron as well as other elements have been removed. Submersible<br />
demineralizers also increase effectiveness with a similar <strong>resin</strong> configurat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
Cleanup systems that use only powdered precoat <strong>resin</strong>s have had success using a precoat<br />
mixed <strong>resin</strong> CG125H which has a blend of macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s for removal of metals<br />
such as copper. Microlite precoat products used for RWC demineralizers include MB1:1H and<br />
CG1:1H.<br />
4. Spent Fuel Pool Treatment<br />
The exhausted or spent fuel is stored in large pools of cooling water to remove residual heat.<br />
This coolant be<strong>com</strong>es loaded with radioactive isotopes, primarily cobalt-60, that are released<br />
from the fuel bundles with low levels of iron. These pools must be treated to control clarity<br />
and remove activity. As noted above, suppress<strong>ion</strong> pool demineralizers and/or submersible<br />
demineralizers are used for this cleanup and are loaded with mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>s such as<br />
NRW3560 or NRW3660. Also, topping these beds with NRW5010 or NRW5070 facilitates<br />
cleanup. Powdered <strong>resin</strong>s MB1:1H, CG1:1H and CG125H are also used in the RWC<br />
demineralizers to clarify these fuel pools.<br />
5. Radwaste Treatment<br />
Service water and wasted coolant from BWR operat<strong>ion</strong>s must be treated to ensure that no<br />
radioactivity is released. Radioactivity originating from the plant is treated with mixed bed<br />
<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s to reduce activity to a level that is appropriate for release back to the<br />
environment. The mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> that is most appropriate for this applicat<strong>ion</strong> is NRW3240.<br />
If pretreatment clarificat<strong>ion</strong> is not employed, the addit<strong>ion</strong> of a top layer of the macroporous<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> NRW5010 or NRW5070 will significantly improve the removal of suspended colloids<br />
such as activated iron. Contract <strong>com</strong>panies are often used to provide this waste-treatment<br />
service.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
27
D. Fast breeder reactor (fast neutrons) (Figure 11)<br />
In a fast breeder reactor or more recently named liquid metal fast breeder reactors (LMFBR),<br />
splitting atoms generates more fiss<strong>ion</strong>able material (fissile) than it consumes. LMFBR’s are<br />
able to reduce <strong>nuclear</strong> fuel requirement by two orders of magnitude <strong>com</strong>pared to an LWR<br />
that uses less than 1% of the U235 in the fuel.<br />
Breeders use mixed oxide fuels (MOX) <strong>com</strong>posed of primarily of U238 and other minor<br />
Actinides (i.e., Plutonium, Americium and Curium). The typical design of the fast breeder<br />
begins with the center of the reactor core coated with impoverished uranium (238U). The<br />
initial fuel, 235U, harnesses the fast neutrons emitted by the impoverished 238U and<br />
be<strong>com</strong>es 239Pu. The active isotope product<strong>ion</strong> rods are replaced approximately every week<br />
and the 239Pu is extracted to be used once more in the same or in another power plant.<br />
The coolant in an LMFBR (<strong>com</strong>monly liquid sodium) is operated at a temperature of<br />
approximately 600 o C and the reactor is enclosed within a concrete protect<strong>ion</strong> shield. The fact<br />
that this temperature can be maintained virtually without any pressure allows the use of<br />
sheaths barely 0.5 mm thick. The liquid metal coolant does not limit the neutron energy from<br />
U235. Unlike a PWR or BWR which uses water as a moderator, the neutrons emitted by the<br />
fiss<strong>ion</strong> of active nuclei are virtually not slowed down.<br />
Figure 11: Liquid Metal cooled Fast Breeder Reactor<br />
Source: English Wikipedia.<br />
In spite of its advantages, the LMFBR has gained limited interest due to shorter fuel life,<br />
higher operating cost and a plentiful supply of uranium fuel. Government regulat<strong>ion</strong>s related<br />
to reprocessing Pu239, which is a weapons grade isotope, has limited the number of<br />
operating LMFBR to 20 units worldwide.<br />
To ensure better safety, the primary circuit transfers its heat to a secondary circuit, which also<br />
contains liquid sodium. The steam generator is part of the tertiary circuit. As you can see, an<br />
LMFBR offers limited <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> opportunities.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
28
SECTION 3: NUCLEAR ION EXCHANGE RESIN<br />
1. NUCLEAR RESIN QUALITY<br />
Ion <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s used in <strong>nuclear</strong> power plants (Table 3) are quality rated and must meet<br />
<strong>nuclear</strong>-grade specificat<strong>ion</strong>s that are established by plant chemical engineers. These quality<br />
specificat<strong>ion</strong>s establish limits on low levels of residual inorganic and organic constituents<br />
found in the <strong>resin</strong> that remain after <strong>resin</strong> manufacturing. Resins designed to treat radwaste<br />
although not requiring the high degree of cleanliness, do require a high degree of convers<strong>ion</strong><br />
to the regenerated form so that the operating cycle can maximize <strong>resin</strong> loading.<br />
Table 3: <strong>Purolite</strong> Resins for Nuclear Circuits<br />
Circuit Type of reactor Ion Exchanger Resin<br />
Condensate Graphite-gas reactors,<br />
PWR<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW1100, NRW1160<br />
An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW6000, NRW7000, NRW5050<br />
MB: Supergel SGC650H,<br />
SupergelSGA550OH<br />
Microlite®: PrCN-PrAOH, CG-MB range<br />
BWR Deep Bed MB: NRW3670<br />
Microlite®: MB1:1H<br />
Turbo-blower Graphite-gas reactors Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW1000, NRW1100<br />
An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW4000, NRW6000<br />
MB: NRW3240, NRW3460<br />
Spent fuel pool Graphite-gas reactors An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW5010, NRW5070<br />
MB: NRW3560, NRW3660, NRW3860<br />
PWR-BWR An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW5010, NRW5070<br />
MB: NRW3560<br />
Steam generator PWR Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW160, NRW1160<br />
blowdown<br />
MB: NRW 3560, NRW3660<br />
Primary coolant<br />
purificat<strong>ion</strong> (CVCS, RCV)<br />
PWR Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW160, NRW1100<br />
An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW5010, NRW5070<br />
MB: NRW3560, NRW3460, NRW3562<br />
pH control PWR MB: NRW3560(Li/Li7), NRW3460(Li/Li7)<br />
Refueling Outage (RFO) PWR Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW1160, NRW160<br />
An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW5010, NRW5070<br />
MB: NRW3240, NRW3560<br />
Radwaste PWR-BWR Cat<strong>ion</strong>: NRW1000, NRW160<br />
An<strong>ion</strong>: NRW5010, NRW5070<br />
MB: NRW3240<br />
29
2. OPERATING CAPACITY OF RESINS<br />
The operating capacity of <strong>nuclear</strong>-grade <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s, whether in bead form or powder<br />
form, is a funct<strong>ion</strong> of the impurities to be removed from the influent, the amount of <strong>ion</strong>ic<br />
leakage tolerated, the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of <strong>ion</strong>s remaining on the <strong>resin</strong> treating the influent after<br />
regenerat<strong>ion</strong>, and the pH of the influent stream. If <strong>exchange</strong> condit<strong>ion</strong>s are favorable (low<br />
velocity), the operating capacity of new <strong>nuclear</strong>-grade <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s should be close to<br />
the total capacity. However, given the fixed time of a power generating cycle, <strong>resin</strong>s are<br />
generally sacrificed well before they reach useful exhaust<strong>ion</strong>. This is particularly true with the<br />
CVCS <strong>resin</strong>s because of its relatively light service.<br />
The use of boric acid as a neutron moderator in PWR primary units is an except<strong>ion</strong> to the <strong>ion</strong><br />
<strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> capacity explanat<strong>ion</strong> above. Levels of boron will be in the thousands of ppm<br />
therefore the use of boric acid will convert an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s to the boron form in a short time.<br />
Because of polyborate format<strong>ion</strong> resulting from high concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s and pH changes in the<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> bed, the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of boron on the an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> will rise in proport<strong>ion</strong> to boron<br />
concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s in the influent stream. Thus the capacity of an an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> for boric<br />
acid increases with increased boron concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s.<br />
Resins used to treat the water in the spent fuel pool will reach the end of life sooner than<br />
<strong>resin</strong>s in other systems because the cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>com</strong>ponent of the mixed bed will degrade in the<br />
presence of peroxide releasing organo-sulfonic <strong>com</strong>pounds. Energy from fuel will support<br />
radiolysis of water forming peroxide and hydrogen. Organo-sulfonic <strong>com</strong>pounds will foul the<br />
an<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> and leach into the pool where they will subsequently degrade to sulfate. A<br />
sufficient rise in sulfate generally requires this <strong>resin</strong> to be replaced. Higher cross linked gel<br />
and macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s have been employed to extend mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> life with<br />
limited success. Concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of fuel volume and temperature of pool water are related to<br />
cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> life.<br />
Condensate polishing <strong>resin</strong>s are subjected to high linear flow rates. Thus, they are prone to<br />
<strong>ion</strong>ic leakage and kinetic fouling of the an<strong>ion</strong>. Resins used to polish BWR condensate streams<br />
will operate until the conductivity (sodium break) or silica break occurs or the radioactivity<br />
limit on the bed is exceeded. BWR plants will not regenerate their <strong>resin</strong>s so replacement with<br />
new <strong>resin</strong> is required.<br />
Resins used to polish PWR condensate <strong>resin</strong>s are impacted by multiple chemistries being fed<br />
to the steam generator. The presence of different amines at different concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s will<br />
quickly load the <strong>resin</strong>. Ammonia will <strong>com</strong>pete with <strong>ion</strong>s left on the <strong>resin</strong>, so if the cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong><br />
has residual sodium generally above 40 ppm, the <strong>resin</strong> will need to be replaced at the amine<br />
break. If the cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong> has sodium < 20 ppm, it is possible to operate these <strong>resin</strong>s for many<br />
months past the ammonia break. An<strong>ion</strong> fouling by organo sulfonates or <strong>ion</strong>ic leakage of<br />
sulfate or silica from the an<strong>ion</strong> will generally determine <strong>resin</strong> replacement or regenerat<strong>ion</strong>.<br />
Regenerat<strong>ion</strong> of PWR condensate is challenging in order to meet the low <strong>ion</strong>ic sodium and<br />
chloride leakage required; therefore, service <strong>com</strong>panies are often contracted to provide this<br />
service offsite.<br />
Resins used to treat steam generator blowdown encounter the same issues as the condensate<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
30
esin but at a lower flowrate because of higher concentrat<strong>ion</strong>s of dissolved solids in the<br />
generator. Addit<strong>ion</strong>ally, this <strong>resin</strong> is designed to primarily remove sodium, metals, chlorides<br />
and sulfate. Because of the <strong>com</strong>petit<strong>ion</strong> between sodium and ammonia, the <strong>resin</strong>s are<br />
replaced when sodium leakage reaches a design level. Resin life can be as long as two years<br />
for very clean systems, but generally the life expectancy of <strong>resin</strong>s in this service is between six<br />
weeks and six months. However, systems that are susceptible to condenser leaks may be<br />
changed every two weeks. There are a few plants that regenerate their steam generator<br />
blowdown <strong>resin</strong>s. This is generally done for a lead cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>. When the mixed bed exhausts<br />
both cat<strong>ion</strong> and mixed bed <strong>resin</strong>s are replaced.<br />
Makeup <strong>resin</strong>s are regenerable and these <strong>resin</strong>s may last many years depending on influent<br />
water impurities. Service <strong>com</strong>panies supply these <strong>resin</strong>s under contract.<br />
3. DECONTAMINATION CAPACITY<br />
Resin capacity for radioactive isotopes is defined by the decontaminat<strong>ion</strong> factor (DF), which is<br />
influent radioactivity divided by effluent radioactivity. This capacity depends on the nature<br />
and concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of radioactivity isotopes being addressed and the density of funct<strong>ion</strong>al<br />
groups on <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s used. Table 4 (below) presents relative affinities (<strong>ion</strong><br />
selectivity) for cobalt and cesium, <strong>com</strong>pared with lithium and hydrogen, for different degrees<br />
of cross-linking.<br />
Table 4: Ion selectivity for principal soluble cat<strong>ion</strong>s on varying cross-linked cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s<br />
DVB% 4% 8% 12% 16%<br />
Li 0.9 0.85 0.81 0.74<br />
H 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0<br />
Co 2.65 2.8 2.9 3.05<br />
Cs 2.0 2.7 3.2 3.45<br />
Table 4 shows that the affinity for cesium over H + and Li + <strong>ion</strong>s increases with the cross-linking<br />
of the strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>, while the affinity for cobalt is slightly lower than<br />
cesium. Therefore, an <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong> with high DVB (divinyl benzene) cross-linking has higher<br />
removal rates — and therefore a longer cycle for removing cesium (NRW160) — <strong>com</strong>pared to<br />
the mixed beds containing this <strong>com</strong>ponent (NRW3560 and NRW3540(Li/Li7). High<br />
cross-linked macroporous cat<strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s have greater porosity, which allows higher<br />
molecular weight divalent <strong>ion</strong>s greater access to the active sites within the bead.<br />
By contrast, highly cross-linked gel-type <strong>exchange</strong>r <strong>resin</strong>s have a tighter matrix, and thus<br />
insufficient porosity. This results in lower operating capacity. However, certain higher<br />
cross-linked gel <strong>resin</strong>s may have a greater capacity for smaller molecular weight <strong>ion</strong>s, such as<br />
lithium and sodium, <strong>com</strong>pared to <strong>com</strong>parable cross-linked macroporous <strong>resin</strong>s.<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
31
Table 5 presents results of tests carried out on coolant purificat<strong>ion</strong> (primary circuit)<br />
containing lithium and boric acid. The tests <strong>com</strong>pared a mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> with a gel type strong<br />
acid cat<strong>ion</strong> NRW3260 (normal cross-linkage) and a mixed bed <strong>resin</strong> with a macroporous type<br />
strong acid cat<strong>ion</strong> NRW3560 (high cross-linkage). The average influent was Co58 1.0E -3<br />
µCi/cm, Cs137 3.0E -1 µCi/cm.<br />
Table 5: Decontaminat<strong>ion</strong> Factors (DF)<br />
Bed Volumes<br />
Treated<br />
Mixed bed with<br />
gel type SAC<br />
NRW3260<br />
DF for<br />
Cs 137<br />
11,000 3<br />
DF for<br />
Co 58<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
Mixed bed with<br />
macroporous type SAC<br />
NRW3560<br />
DF for<br />
Cs 137<br />
DF for<br />
Co 58<br />
33,000 1 61 32 127<br />
Note: The DF are averaged over total treated volume.<br />
The DF increases when the concentrat<strong>ion</strong> of activity increases in the solut<strong>ion</strong>. The DF will vary<br />
noticeably during the cycle and as the influent concentrat<strong>ion</strong> changes.<br />
32
SECTION 4: REFERENCES<br />
The following references were reviewed:<br />
References<br />
1. EPRI, Fruzzetti, K.P. et al., Pressurized Water Reactor Secondary Water Chemistry<br />
Guidelines, Revis<strong>ion</strong> 6, EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2004. 1008224<br />
2. WANO, Guidelines for Chemistry at Nuclear Power Plants, WANO GL 2001 – 08, August<br />
2002<br />
3. INPO, Guidelines for Chemistry at Nuclear Power Stat<strong>ion</strong>s, INPO 88-021, Rev. 02, October<br />
1995.<br />
4. EPRI, Passell, T. O., Effect of Organics on Nuclear Cycles, EPRI TR-100785, Project 2977-08,<br />
July 1992<br />
5. McGaffic V.J., and Bishop W.N., Nuclear Power Plant Water Quality in the 1990s – An INPO<br />
Perspective, ASTM STP 1102, Philadelphia, 1991.<br />
6. OPG’s REVIEW OF TOC AND TOX AS MAKEUP WATER PARAMETERS, Makeup Water<br />
Specificat<strong>ion</strong>s, October 6, 2005.<br />
7. Auerswald, D.C., “20 Years of Condensate Polishing at San Onofre Nuclear Generat<strong>ion</strong><br />
Stat<strong>ion</strong>,” IWC 07-61 Internat<strong>ion</strong>al Water Conference, Oct. 2007.<br />
8. Crone, L., “Amine form operat<strong>ion</strong> of deep bed condensate polishing <strong>ion</strong> <strong>exchange</strong> <strong>resin</strong>s”,<br />
IWC 10-02, October 2010<br />
9. “Boiler Water Reactor (BWR) System,” USNRC Technical Training Center Reactor Concept<br />
Manual, 0400.<br />
10. IAEA.org “Current Trends in Nuclear Fuel for Power Reactors”<br />
The ‘Wolff’ Paper – Apr 2012<br />
33