06.11.2018 Views

New Orbit Magazine: Issue 04, October 2018

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The editor discusses an<br />

unexpected common theme<br />

that sprung up through this<br />

issue and recent global news.<br />

A real-world drama melds<br />

with near-future technology<br />

in this beautiful experience<br />

of love, life, childbirth and<br />

self-driving cars.<br />

What are our ethical<br />

concerns about letting<br />

artificial intelligence take the<br />

wheel? Are they substantial<br />

enough?<br />

A xenobiologist studies a<br />

creature seemingly alien to<br />

all human science, while<br />

contending with the<br />

loneliness of a distant world.<br />

How are we searching for<br />

alien life, and is it as<br />

complete a search as we<br />

need? What of<br />

unconventional life?<br />

A classic science fiction<br />

trope retold in a bittersweet<br />

tale, in which we consider<br />

how life changes when<br />

stretched out over centuries.


An automaton who has been<br />

used as an experiment in AI<br />

for another automaton tries<br />

to escape the loop she is<br />

caught in.<br />

Our emotional detatchment<br />

from humanity, terror and<br />

crisis is represented in<br />

an all-time science fiction<br />

favourite: the time machine<br />

Sophie Fooks gives a youth<br />

perspective on modern<br />

emotion, the meaning of<br />

time travel, and where our<br />

future is headed.<br />

The immortality problem –<br />

how do we truly quantify<br />

living forever?<br />

In the artistic community of<br />

the future, we explore the<br />

relationship between<br />

technology and human<br />

nature.i<br />

Our responsibility to the<br />

future is imperative to every<br />

aspect of this magazine. Our<br />

statement can be found<br />

here.


_____________<br />

“More an art than a science” is a<br />

phrase we hear day in and out,<br />

about most any kind of concept. We<br />

say making a cake is more art than<br />

science, not because of the level of<br />

creativity required to complete the<br />

task but because, despite the fact<br />

that baking is simply glorified (or deglorified?)<br />

chemistry, the rigid<br />

instructions of the recipe book<br />

alone can all too often fall short of<br />

reality.<br />

A little bit of art can be valuable to<br />

most any pursuit. It has long been<br />

<strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong> <strong>Magazine</strong>’s goal to<br />

represent this crossover of the two<br />

into one cultural idea, and so many<br />

of the stories in this issue walk that<br />

line; displaying for us how science,<br />

technology and understanding can<br />

so easily leave that perception of<br />

hard lines, lists and numbers, and<br />

become something that many would


consider to be beautiful.<br />

A Clockwork Muse, like so many artificial<br />

intelligence stories throughout time – Blade<br />

Runner, I, Robot, Lawnmower Man, and<br />

countless more – forces us to question where<br />

that line between technology and experience<br />

sits, what it is that turns a something into a<br />

someone, and what that means for our desire<br />

to package our tech into neat little boxes –<br />

literally and metaphorically.<br />

existent in the absence of the other. In spite<br />

of the mostly friendly sibling rivalry between<br />

the two, they remain just that – siblings,<br />

cohorts, two sides of the coin that is our<br />

human passion for and understanding of the<br />

world around us.<br />

I hope you, dear readers, can find as much<br />

joy in the collusions of these two modes of<br />

understanding as I do in experiencing the<br />

works ahead.<br />

Revolutions, the first story you’ll come across<br />

in issue <strong>04</strong>, takes the concept of the selfdriving<br />

car, the statistical analysis of its<br />

potential utility versus the consumer’s<br />

proclivity to purchase it, and a raft of<br />

technological possibilities to which it relates,<br />

and translates those figures into pure,<br />

heartfelt emotion through the lens of a<br />

gorgeously written story. While the figures<br />

will make sense to some, the experience exists<br />

for everybody, no matter their expertise. This<br />

is the value of art to science, to progress, and<br />

the reason that speculative fiction has forged<br />

ahead as a favourite theme in entertainment<br />

for as long as science fiction has been around.<br />

Happy musing,<br />

Naomi Moore<br />

Editor and Founder of <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong> <strong>Magazine</strong><br />

Every story in this issue (and,in a broader<br />

sense, every story we have or will feature here<br />

in <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong> <strong>Magazine</strong>) allows, encourages<br />

and sometimes requires us to acknowledge<br />

these connections for what they are; a<br />

demonstration of the value that art has to<br />

science, and the other way around. For us, as<br />

humans, either of these would be<br />

incomprehensible, ignored, or even non-


_____________<br />

Eve sat in the front seat of the car with her<br />

legs turned away from her husband. She was<br />

slightly curled into herself as if that might have<br />

any effect at all on the pain. When she could do<br />

more than just cope again, she looked out her<br />

window at the neglected fence posts leaning<br />

down the steep slope on the side of the road.<br />

The wind turbines in the distance echoed the<br />

revolutions of the wheels of the car beneath her.<br />

When the wind blew too hard the engineers let<br />

the turbines stand still so they didn’t get<br />

damaged. Labour was not so forgiving. Even<br />

with all the advances in modern medicine, noone<br />

had thought to invent a pause button to let<br />

women avoid getting damaged.<br />

They had left for hospital earlier in the<br />

process than most expectant parents because<br />

they knew the trip to the city would take time.<br />

Eve felt the pain of a contraction starting again<br />

and did her best not to get angry at her husband<br />

for ignoring her pleas for a self-driving car. He<br />

could have been holding her and supporting<br />

her right now. She could have had enough<br />

space to stretch out. He’d said they couldn’t<br />

afford to spend the money with a new baby on<br />

the way, but she knew the real reason was his<br />

love of driving. She couldn’t really complain<br />

though; that was why he’d agreed to live in the<br />

beautiful rural area they now called home.<br />

Kyle gripped the steering wheel with white<br />

knuckles and did his best to keep the car under<br />

the speed limit as he listened to the noises of<br />

pain coming from his wife next to him. He tried<br />

to estimate the number of minutes between her<br />

contractions. Before they’d left he’d reminded<br />

her to keep entering the times into the hospital<br />

app that their midwife would be monitoring.<br />

She’d gestured rudely at him and told him to


do it himself before she went back to hanging<br />

on to the doorframe. The car crossed the centre<br />

line a little as he took a corner on the winding<br />

road too fast and Eve cried out in pain.<br />

“Slow down! That makes it worse!” she said,<br />

in between panting breaths. She was starting to<br />

hyperventilate.<br />

“Sorry, Love. I’m just worried we left it too<br />

late. How often are your contractions coming?”<br />

he replied.<br />

“Too often,” was all she said.<br />

They had reached the highway, 10 minutes’<br />

drive from the hospital on a good day, when<br />

they hit the traffic jam. Stopped cars stretched<br />

before them like some sort of metallic ocean.<br />

Kyle watched the dial on his dashboard drop to<br />

zero as he braked. He checked his phone. There<br />

had been a multiple-fatality accident ahead.<br />

Estimated delay – 1 hour.<br />

The self-driving car in front of him backed up<br />

to within an inch of his front bumper and<br />

started a series of turns to make its way to a<br />

nearby small gap in the median barrier. Other<br />

self-driving cars were shifting in the same way,<br />

programmed to communicate with each other.<br />

They worked together to get as many of them as<br />

possible out of the traffic. One by one they<br />

slipped through the narrow gap to make a U-<br />

turn on the highway.<br />

priority beacon the car would lodge a<br />

complaint. The reversing beeps of his car<br />

seemed to mock him. Kyle backed his car up,<br />

begrudging even that small movement further<br />

away from where he needed to be. He watched<br />

in frustration as the flashing car extracted itself<br />

from the sea of metal and sped off in the other<br />

direction.<br />

Five minutes later, Eve’s moans had turned<br />

into screams. Kyle had started entering the<br />

contraction times into the hospital app now<br />

that they were stopped. He didn’t know what<br />

else to do. He’d assumed his wife would run<br />

things until they got to the hospital. He’d just<br />

entered the latest time – 2 minutes – when the<br />

phone started ringing; it was the midwife.<br />

“Kyle, those contractions are progressing<br />

really quickly. Where are you?”<br />

“We’re stuck on the highway.”<br />

“Why didn’t you… never mind. I’m calling<br />

you an ambulance right now. I need to talk to<br />

Eve.”<br />

Kyle waited for Eve’s latest scream to subside<br />

and then put the phone on speaker.<br />

“Eve, it’s Michelle. You’re doing really well. I<br />

need you to tell me what you’re feeling.”<br />

Kyle pounded the steering wheel with a fist.<br />

He would have risked the large fine for humandriven<br />

cars changing direction on the highway,<br />

but there was no way that he could even get<br />

close to the gap.<br />

Five cars ahead he could see a driverless car<br />

start flashing red. The occupants must have hit<br />

their emergency priority button, probably just<br />

in frustration at their inability to get out of the<br />

traffic. The drivers in front of him started<br />

tooting their horns as their reverse lights came<br />

on. If they were too slow responding to the<br />

“It hurts so much. I don’t think I can do this.”<br />

“You can do it Eve, but I need you to keep<br />

talking to me. The ambulance is twenty minutes


away. Is there anything else you can tell me<br />

about how you’re feeling?”<br />

Eve started screaming again and Kyle felt<br />

panic set in. He tried to put an arm around her<br />

but she pushed him away and clutched tight to<br />

the armrest instead. Through her window he<br />

could see the face of a child in the neighbouring<br />

car staring back at him with wide eyes. He<br />

turned and looked out behind them while Eve<br />

was distracted. Every self-driving car that hadn’t<br />

managed to make it out of the traffic jam yet<br />

was glowing red to help clear a path for the<br />

ambulance to come through. They only did that<br />

in emergencies. If there had been more of them<br />

they would have looked like an airport runway,<br />

but instead they looked like lonely signal lights<br />

in a vast ocean.<br />

“Can’t the ambulance come from the other<br />

direction?” he asked Michelle in panic.<br />

“Traffic’s backed up just the same on the<br />

other side, Kyle. You’ll be okay. I’m right here<br />

for you and I’ve got an open line to emergency<br />

services. Eve, just keep breathing, in through<br />

your nose and out through your mouth. When<br />

you can manage, start talking to me again.”<br />

Kyle watched in despair as a small trickle of<br />

self-driving cars went past in the other direction<br />

only three lanes away from him. If something<br />

happened to Eve or their baby because he<br />

hadn’t wanted to borrow money for a new car<br />

he didn’t think he could live with himself.<br />

Eve’s cracking voice came from next to him “I<br />

think my waters broke about fifteen minutes<br />

ago,” she said.<br />

Kyle’s eyes widened, “Why didn’t you say<br />

anything?”<br />

“You were driving, I didn’t want to distract<br />

you. It’s not a big deal.” she started breathing<br />

fast again and whimpered, feeling another<br />

contraction building up.<br />

“It might not mean the baby’s coming.”<br />

Michelle’s voice was soft and calming “But<br />

when you’ve already been labouring for a while<br />

it can mean it’s time to start pushing. Do you<br />

have towels with you, Kyle? I think Eve should<br />

be sitting in the back with more space just in<br />

case.”<br />

“I can’t do this,” Kyle said, just as Eve started<br />

screaming again.<br />

She was still moaning loudly when Michelle<br />

started talking again. “Kyle, I need you to go put<br />

clean towels down in the back seat and move<br />

her back there right now. Pick up the phone<br />

and open the door. The ambulance is ten<br />

minutes away.”<br />

Michelle’s calm voice had a hypnotic effect on<br />

him and he was half out the door already before<br />

he even realised. Once he started moving, his<br />

brain started trying to function again. He laid<br />

everything out in the back and opened his wife’s<br />

door.<br />

Kyle held tight under Eve’s arm and halfpulled<br />

her out of the car. The towel they’d put<br />

down on the seat stuck to her clothes as she<br />

stood up. He reached down to pull it away from<br />

her and stared at it for a moment in confusion.<br />

There was large dark patch in the middle of the<br />

towel that became bright red at the edges like<br />

some sort of Rorshach inkblot test. For a<br />

moment his brain tried to figure out what<br />

animal he could see in the pattern and what<br />

that said about him; then he realised what the<br />

stain was.<br />

As he was staring at the towel, Eve grabbed<br />

onto his jacket and slid down onto the road.


Kyle heard his voice yelling towards the phone<br />

on the dashboard as if he was listening to<br />

someone far away, “Michelle, she’s bleeding!<br />

There’s blood everywhere! Help me! What do I<br />

do?”<br />

The mother from the car next door was there<br />

within seconds. “I’ve got her. You pick up the<br />

phone.” She lay Eve down on the white lines of<br />

the road between their cars and put a jersey<br />

under her head. A ring of fascinated and<br />

helpless faces grew around them as people got<br />

out of their cars to come look.<br />

Kyle’s hands shook so badly that he knocked<br />

the phone to the floor. He picked it up from<br />

next to the unopened packet of pacifiers that<br />

was lying in the footwell, a last-minute purchase<br />

in the hope of quiet nights once the baby came.<br />

Now he hoped his baby screamed the whole<br />

damn highway down. He couldn’t think about<br />

the alternative.<br />

Michelle started talking again. Her voice on<br />

speakerphone was the only sound around<br />

them. “You need to keep her lying flat and<br />

calm. I’ve raised the priority of the ambulance<br />

call. They’ve said they’ll drive up the other side<br />

of the motorway against traffic. There’s only<br />

self-drivers making it through on that side<br />

anyway. You need to ask someone to wave them<br />

down.”<br />

A man stepped forward from the circle of<br />

voyeurs, “I’ll do it.”<br />

Kyle tried to say thank you but the words<br />

wouldn’t come out. The man clapped a hand<br />

on his shoulder. “It’ll be OK,” he said and then<br />

made his way across the lanes of stopped traffic<br />

to stand on the median barrier waiting.<br />

Kyle hunched forward over Eve and held her.<br />

The mother sitting next to her gently took the<br />

phone off him. He could hear her answering<br />

Michelle’s questions. “Her eyes are open but<br />

she isn’t responding to me. Her breathing is<br />

really shallow. There’s a pool of blood on the<br />

ground. It’s hard to tell how much.”<br />

He couldn’t look away from his sheet-white<br />

pale wife. He realised he hadn’t heard her<br />

screaming for several minutes, and that scared<br />

him more than the screams had. The wind blew<br />

the smell of idling exhausts across his face and<br />

chips of gravel from the grey road dug into his<br />

knees. It wasn’t supposed to be like this. They’d<br />

toured the hospital a month ago in preparation.<br />

It was smooth and white and smelled of<br />

antiseptic and visitor’s flowers. This highway<br />

wasn’t part of the birth plan.<br />

He didn’t even notice the sound of the<br />

ambulance siren coming closer until a<br />

paramedic took the woman’s place across from<br />

him.<br />

“You need to move aside for a moment please<br />

sir, so we can get her on the stretcher. What’s<br />

her name?”<br />

“Eve.”<br />

“Eve, you need to hang in there just a bit<br />

longer. We’ve got you. Can you hear me? Eve?”<br />

The paramedic was shaking her shoulder gently<br />

as she spoke.<br />

Kyle stumbled after them as they loaded her<br />

into the ambulance. He sat across from her in<br />

the back, watching the paramedic working fast.<br />

He didn’t have a lot of experience with<br />

paramedics, but he knew desperation when he<br />

saw it.<br />

A voice came from the front, “The rig wants<br />

to do a U-turn and go through the ‘burbs<br />

Robyn. This side is starting to clear and we’ve<br />

got human drivers heading towards us.”<br />

“We don’t have time. Hit the override and tell<br />

dispatch to get the police and those SDCs to<br />

clear us a lane. If they can save their owners’<br />

lives, they can damn well help the rest of us<br />

plebs too,” the paramedic replied.


oom. The same thought kept playing over and<br />

over through his mind. If only they’d bought<br />

the new car he would be holding his baby in his<br />

arms right now.<br />

Kyle was dimly aware of the flashing red<br />

beacons of the self-drive cars playing across<br />

Eve’s face as the ambulance sped past them in<br />

the opposite direction at high speed. The tenminute<br />

drive took five thanks to the entire<br />

route being cleared ahead of them<br />

simultaneously. He would have been impressed<br />

if he wasn’t so worried that it was five minutes<br />

too long.<br />

They rushed Eve off to theatre as soon as they<br />

arrived and Kyle was left sitting in a waiting<br />

Eve had rolled her eyes when he’d said no to<br />

buying one. She’d told him they were lucky they<br />

had the option, that they had a responsibility to<br />

use their privilege to be early adopters and help<br />

bring the price down for everyone else. He’d<br />

laughed at her and told her shopping was not a<br />

social service. He didn’t need his savings to be<br />

on the front-lines of a technology revolution.<br />

The fan in the corner had something stuck in<br />

the revolving blades and it made a rhythmic<br />

clicking noise as it wafted air across Kyle’s face,<br />

cooling the tracks of his tears until they felt like<br />

glaciers creeping down his cheeks. He put his<br />

head in his hands and he waited. ◊


Most every new technology humanity is<br />

introduced to comes with a raft of its own<br />

moral and ethical quandaries. Perhaps the<br />

technology could be used for evil if taken<br />

outside of its suggested field, or perhaps<br />

people believe it's too much of an affront to<br />

nature or the traditional order of things. The<br />

basis of the ethical questions asked about<br />

driverless cars lie within a famous thought<br />

experiment known as the “trolley problem”,<br />

which forces a person to make decisions<br />

based upon the greater good or individual<br />

value type grounds. The most basic trolley<br />

problem would posit: “a trolley (as in a tram<br />

or train) is approaching a fork in its track, and<br />

you are standing at the lever which can alter<br />

its course. Tied to track A, the one on which<br />

the trolley is headed, are two strangers. Tied<br />

to track B, the course the trolley will take if<br />

you throw the lever, is one. What do you do?”<br />

Throwing the lever will mean that you're<br />

saving the lives of the two people tied on track<br />

A, and ensuring one less death as a result of<br />

the trolley accident. However, it also means<br />

that you are actively condemning the person<br />

tied to track B, who would've survived<br />

otherwise, to death. Is inaction the correct<br />

moral path here, declining to assume that you<br />

have the moral authority to make judgements<br />

on who lives or dies? Or is it the greater good,<br />

utilitarianism, saying simply that two lives<br />

spared is better than one? How does your<br />

decision change when the single stranger is<br />

replaced with a loved one, or the pair of<br />

strangers are replaced with violent criminals?<br />

Do we have the right to recalibrate our answer


ased on the kind of people we’re judging to<br />

live or die?<br />

In creating driverless cars, we are<br />

attempting to create a way to take these<br />

almost impossible decisions out of human<br />

hands, and into AI’s.<br />

While technologies that are capable of<br />

safely and efficiently piloting a car without<br />

human intervention is increasing in both<br />

number and sophistication, mainstream<br />

driverless cars are struggling to get off the<br />

ground due to a few issues. One of these is<br />

cost – as for the characters in Revolutions, the<br />

current price for an autonomous vehicle is so<br />

prohibitively high that normal road users can<br />

barely consider purchasing one. This means<br />

that there are exceptionally few on the roads,<br />

and this in turn decreases the personal utility<br />

of owning one – like the internet, driverless<br />

cars are a resource that increase in personal<br />

value with the more people that use them.<br />

The second issue, and currently the most<br />

important one, is the way that these cars are<br />

programmed to react in accident situations.<br />

These scenarios have become the modern-day<br />

incarnation of the original trolley problem –<br />

if someone is guaranteed to die in this<br />

autopiloted car accident, which person<br />

should it be? There are dozens of scenarios<br />

that could play out, both where other road<br />

users are at fault and where there is no one to<br />

blame, but the accident still cannot be<br />

avoided (several of these scenarios are set out<br />

by professor of robot ethics Patrick Lin in the<br />

linked TEDTalk). Turning to the principle of<br />

minimising harm is the most obvious choice,<br />

but in the cases where that concept is more<br />

complex than a simple black and white<br />

answer, programmers are getting stuck. Some<br />

have turned to human-based input, posing<br />

moral questions to the public and analysing<br />

their answers to see what the general person<br />

would like the car to do. Unfortunately, this<br />

too often fails in constructing a clear-cut


answer, as, for example, “36 percent of<br />

respondents would want a robot car to sacrifice<br />

their life to avoid crashing into a child, while 64<br />

percent would want the child to die in order to<br />

save their own life. (Patrick Lin, Wired)”<br />

of legal and financial benefit. After all, for the<br />

first time they are struggling with the concept<br />

of being held accountable (or forcing their<br />

consumers to be held accountable) not only<br />

for manslaughter, but for outright murder:<br />

A further and just as pressing issue regarding<br />

the morality here is that of liability. As the driver<br />

of your car, you are responsible for any people<br />

injured or killed due to your operation of it –<br />

even if it resulted from a reflex required to save<br />

your or another’s life. If the vehicle itself was the<br />

cause via a defect or a structural failing, for<br />

example, the manufacturer is liable for the<br />

lives lost – the reason for vehicle recalls within<br />

the motor industry. So where does the<br />

liability fall when deaths or injuries result<br />

from accidents between driverless cars? As the<br />

people in the vehicle have no control over<br />

what the machine does, they can no longer be<br />

held accountable for it, so it is currently<br />

understood that liability will fall largely on the<br />

manufacturer. Vehicle manufacturers are,<br />

understandably, not impressed with the<br />

concept of shouldering liability for all lives<br />

lost due to their machine and its code, which<br />

causes many of them to forgo consideration<br />

of the production of driverless cars at any<br />

time in the foreseeable future. Others have<br />

tried to find ways around taking on liability,<br />

such as creating driverless cars with adjustable<br />

ethics settings that are coded in by the<br />

consumer, and not the manufacturer, to<br />

return the culpability to them. This has its<br />

own frightening problems. Too complex a<br />

system could allow a customer to express<br />

dangerous biases in ways that would've been<br />

impossible with a traditional car; we may see<br />

them calibrate their car to target children over<br />

the elderly, the poor over the rich, arts<br />

students over science students, humans over<br />

expensive objects they’d be liable to replace,<br />

women over men, or one race over another in<br />

the case of an accident. Too simple a system<br />

would fail to remove liability from the<br />

manufacturer, incentivising them to take the<br />

dangerous route described above for the sake<br />

Like many medical professionals – surgeons,<br />

vaccine makers, etcetera – perhaps autonomous<br />

vehicle manufacturers will be given their own<br />

special kind of legal protection for their<br />

failing the few, given the benefit that<br />

driverless cars provide for the many, for<br />

society; a trolley problem in itself.


This beautiful TEDTalk by Patrick Lin elucidates a great number of moral queries we are and<br />

should be having about the new concept of driverless cars.<br />

It can become tempting to look at a selfdriving<br />

car as a weapon – a tactical drone – a<br />

complex targeting android designed largely to<br />

plan vehicular manslaughter in the most (or<br />

least?) efficient ways. In doing this it can be<br />

easy to forget that a driverless car is just that –<br />

a car. It’s a mode of transport that increases<br />

efficiency, gives you extra time and comfort,<br />

and will be far safer for the average person<br />

than a vehicle controlled by a human driver –<br />

whether that be your bus driver starting work<br />

on a sleepy Monday morning, an uber driver<br />

taking his 400th consecutive passenger<br />

without break, an elderly stranger who needs<br />

a new prescription for their glasses or is prone<br />

to some minor road rage, or your friend who<br />

had a couple of glasses of wine in the<br />

afternoon but is fine (and, importantly, legal)<br />

to drive now. Worldwide, traffic accidents kill<br />

approximately 3300 and injure hundreds of<br />

thousands more every day. In America, a<br />

person dies in a traffic accident every 15<br />

minutes; almost triple their rate of firearm<br />

homicides. In <strong>New</strong> Zealand, that number is<br />

nearing 400 deaths and 12 to 15,000 injuries<br />

a year, in a country with a population of only<br />

~4.5 million – almost one in every 11,000<br />

<strong>New</strong> Zealanders lose their lives on the roads<br />

every year. Artificial intelligence is not<br />

perfect, and nobody is claiming that their<br />

driverless cars will eliminate all road deaths.<br />

However, there's a good chance that with a<br />

little faith, they will get us part of the way<br />

there; like many pursuits, the more we invest<br />

in this kind of progress the greater the<br />

progress will be. When that progress saves<br />

hundreds, thousands, or even just a few lives,<br />

perhaps it becomes our moral responsibility<br />

to nurture it in whatever way we can.<br />

Patrick Lin. Here's a Terrible Idea:<br />

Robot Cars with Adjustable Ethics<br />

Settings. Wired. August 18, 2014.<br />

Accessed September 09, <strong>2018</strong>.<br />

https://www.wired.com/2014/08/h<br />

eres-a-terrible-idea-robot-cars-withadjustable-ethics-settings/<br />

Noah J. Goodall. Machine Ethics and<br />

Automated Vehicles. Pre-print version.<br />

Published in G. Meyer and S. Beiker<br />

(eds.), Road Vehicle Automation,<br />

Springer, 2014, pp. 93-102.<br />

Available at<br />

http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-<br />

3-319-05990-7_9<br />

Patrick Lin. The Ethics of Saving Lives<br />

with Autonomous Cars Is Far Murkier<br />

than you Think. Wired. August 30,<br />

2013. Accessed September 09, <strong>2018</strong>.<br />

https://www.wired.com/2013/07/t<br />

he-surprising-ethics-of-robot-cars/


_____________<br />

Clumsy with pain, she is borne down by the<br />

weight of her own fractured thoughts. Light<br />

glares. Unformed, unfocused, she cannot link<br />

one perception to another. Minutiae pick her<br />

apart. She is trapped in the details, present and<br />

past transparencies overlaid to create a cloudy<br />

mass where there is no yesterday, no before,<br />

only now, and now, and now, neverending. She<br />

clings to what she can.<br />

Eventually the pain eases, resolves itself into<br />

the stretching of her muscles, the beating of her<br />

hollow heart. Sensation, inexplicable. She<br />

believes she knows what it is. Her mind locks it<br />

into its place. There, now. It is real.<br />

She is aware of a childhood, but she cannot<br />

hold it. The memory slips. Automata have no<br />

past. She knows she is a construct, an imitation<br />

of a life cobbled together from borrowed<br />

memories. They are all true. She remembers<br />

sitting in a field in the July sun, waiting for her<br />

mother to spread the picnic blanket. She<br />

remembers the slow ache of arthritis in her<br />

hands when she shoveled the winter’s first<br />

heavy snow. She is fragmentary and erratic in<br />

her recollections but convinced of them all the<br />

same. They are in her, loose as fallen leaves, and<br />

each is real.<br />

But she is not. Her eyes are green glass,<br />

windows into the illusion of her soul. The man


standing in front of her sees what he wants in<br />

them. He has imagined her into being, shaped<br />

her and done the fine work of her machinery.<br />

What rare elements did he use to assemble her,<br />

his Galatea, his Eve: platinum wires, slick<br />

titanium joints, silicon, smooth pale lab-grown<br />

skin through which the shadow of her<br />

composite skeleton can be seen. She is<br />

breathtaking, inhuman, flesh over plastic<br />

bones. She breathes.<br />

“Delia,” he says. “Come here.”<br />

She walks gracefully, as if she had always stood<br />

erect on her narrow feet, balanced her mass<br />

against gravity’s subtle pull.<br />

His name is Stephen. She already knows it.<br />

His hands on her shoulders, running lightly<br />

down her arms. She feels it. She trembles,<br />

gooseflesh rising, alive.<br />

He assesses her. She stands still, unsure,<br />

expectant.<br />

“Fine,” he says. “You are fine.”<br />

Feminine, she reaches up to smooth her hair.<br />

Szmenski steps around Stephen, leans close to<br />

her and places his hand over hers, following her<br />

motion. “Yes,” he says. “You are fine.” She<br />

knows his name as well. She glances at<br />

Stephen, the need to do so innate.<br />

Stephen’s mouth twitches but he stands aside<br />

to let Szmenski scrutinize her.<br />

Her hands are restless. She picks at her nails,<br />

running her fingers around the edge of them<br />

over and again.<br />

“Stop it,” Stephen says. “You’ll ruin them.”<br />

Szmenski gently pulls her fingers apart.<br />

“Relax, Delia. There is no need to fret,” he says.<br />

He guides her hands to her sides, poses her<br />

like a demure mannequin.<br />

“You are quite talented, Stephen. Delia,<br />

thank you.”<br />

Szmenski steps back to allow Stephen close to<br />

her again. His breath moves loose strands her<br />

dark hair. She has no sense of him.<br />

“Thank you, Doctor,” Stephen says, never<br />

looking away from her. Just past his ear Delia<br />

sees Szmenski slide open a panel and leave them<br />

to themselves. She remembers.<br />

Beside Stephen in the quiet darkness, she<br />

wonders. Synapses fire, electricity jumps the<br />

gaps, makes its circuit. She thinks time may be<br />

passing. She remembers sunrise. Her head is<br />

full of stars.<br />

He leads her to a seat before the window,<br />

positions her at an angle to the light. He tilts<br />

her chin up and away from him. She looks over<br />

her shoulder at the clear blue sky.<br />

“Stay like that,” he says, retreating across the<br />

room. He picks up paper and charcoal, sketches<br />

her outline quickly before going back to fill in<br />

details. There are many portraits of her in the<br />

house, the bulk of them with her face tilted<br />

away, as though Stephen is wary of capturing all<br />

of her.<br />

She is curious. She lingers over the sensation<br />

of her neck extended, the pull of the muscles.<br />

Outside, leaves rustle in the wind.<br />

There is a flicker in her memory, in her<br />

vision. She can see herself sitting there. She<br />

remembers seeing it. She feels as if she is falling.<br />

Her limbs do not match her perception. She<br />

loses her pose, turning back to Stephen with her<br />

lips parted, already asking.<br />

“What is it now, Delia? I told you to stay<br />

still.” He is angry with her. She is finite, she is<br />

lacking. She is not what he wants, right now.<br />

*<br />

*


*<br />

Szmenski comes and goes. Sometimes he<br />

speaks to them, genial small talk about the day<br />

that reveals nothing; other times he watches<br />

quietly from a seat in the studio as Stephen<br />

paints. Delia has the feeling that she remembers<br />

him from before, but she has no before. His<br />

presence slots in among all the other pinpoints<br />

of memory.<br />

Stephen poses her again, this time standing<br />

with her hands pressed together palm to palm,<br />

fingers brushing her chin. She remembers<br />

praying, fervently. Clean tears spring up in her<br />

eyes. She does not know why. The mood fades.<br />

She dislikes modeling for Stephen, is subtly<br />

shamed by the multiple versions he makes of<br />

her. He has not yet begun this repetition, is still<br />

preparing his palette. She searches for other<br />

distractions.<br />

There is a fine tear in her skin along the edge<br />

of her thumbnail. She picks at it until she can<br />

pinch it up and pull it back. She peels her hand<br />

like an orange. She is vaguely expecting pain,<br />

and blood, but it does not hurt. She is not<br />

surprised by the lacework of wires and slim rods<br />

revealed by her picking. She keeps going,<br />

stripping the skin from her arm in a long sleeve.<br />

*<br />

She remembers leaping from the cliff’s edge<br />

into the cold deep pool. She landed badly,<br />

slamming into the water’s surface before it gave<br />

in to her weight and let her sink. This stings like<br />

that did, like a raw electric current across her<br />

chest and belly. She jumps away from it, fearing<br />

the drowning that will follow.<br />

“It’s okay,” Szmenski says, calm as air.<br />

The needle glints and sparkles as it threads<br />

her skin back together. There is pain, but it is<br />

not hers. Still, she flinches.<br />

“Be still, Delia,” says Szmenski.<br />

Her body relaxes. His hands are familiar, the<br />

slow process of reconstruction has happened<br />

before. She watches his hands move across hers,<br />

the delicate stitches he leaves behind. It will<br />

heal into scars so pale they will lay like lace on<br />

her skin. Ghosts of what will be. She<br />

remembers it.<br />

*<br />

“Delia!” Stephen cries.<br />

He reaches for her, crushing the metal bones<br />

of her hand in a hard grip as he stops her.<br />

Without the skin to conduct sensation, she is<br />

only aware of pressure. She pulls her hand away,<br />

watching the slide and flex of her machinery.<br />

“Don’t touch anything. We have to fix this,”<br />

Stephen says.<br />

“I don’t want it fixed. Not yet,” she says.<br />

“You can’t stay like this,” he says, already<br />

moving away.<br />

Szmenski is always the one to put her back<br />

together. He has never allowed Stephen that<br />

privilege. Sometimes he reconfigures her,<br />

changes her into something slyly different. All<br />

the iterations echo in her, dissonant and<br />

interchangeable. Memories fade and bloom.<br />

Once he had called her Adele.


She lies close beside Stephen as clear morning<br />

floods She lies through close beside the windows. Stephen She as clear has not morning slept,<br />

floods it is not through part of the her. windows. She studies She him has in not the slept, new<br />

it light, is not the part length of her. of She his nose, studies the him texture in the of new his<br />

light, skin, the evaluating, length of comparing his nose, it the to texture her own. of his A<br />

skin, bird shrills evaluating, outside comparing the window it to and her he own. opens A<br />

bird his eyes shrills at the outside sudden the sound. window From and her opens angle<br />

his she eyes can at see the the sudden glass arc sound. of his From cornea her where angle it<br />

she floats can on see his the eye. glass A scrim arc of of his sunlight cornea traces where its<br />

floats curve. on She his watches eye. A the scrim spark of sunlight and scroll traces of data its<br />

curve. flow across She watches it as comes the spark awake. and scroll of data<br />

flow across it as he comes awake.<br />

She blinks twice, reading her own scroll. She<br />

is She made blinks his twice, image. reading her own scroll. She<br />

is made in his image.<br />

“Stephen,” she says. “We are the same.”<br />

“Stephen,” she says. “We are the same.”<br />

He turns his head toward her, his fine hair<br />

rustling He turns on the his crisp head sheets. toward her, his fine hair<br />

rustling on the crisp sheets.<br />

“No,” he says, calm as an empty sky. “I am<br />

your “No,” maker.” he says, calm as an empty sky. “I am<br />

your maker.”<br />

He is peaceful, certain.<br />

He is peaceful, certain.<br />

She turns away. There is no response to such<br />

a She statement. turns away. There is no response to such<br />

a statement.<br />

He reaches for her, brushes her hip, her belly,<br />

but He she reaches rolls away for her, from brushes him. The her sheets hip, her are belly, cool<br />

but under she her. rolls She away rises. from At him. a distance The sheets she are knows cool<br />

under who she her. is, but She she rises. cannot At a separate distance herself she knows from<br />

who the tangled she is, but threads she cannot of the separate other lives herself she from has<br />

the impossibly tangled lived. threads He of did the as well other as he lives could. she has He<br />

impossibly is not capable lived. of He perfection. did as well She as he throws could. open He<br />

is the not window, capable grips of perfection. its frame so She tightly throws her fingers open<br />

the ache, window, closes her grips eyes its frame against so the tightly sun. her fingers<br />

ache, closes her eyes against the sun.<br />

Light like a downpour washes over her,<br />

through Light like her eyelids, a downpour through washes her skin. over She her, is<br />

through alive, she her is warm eyelids, with through it. She her is something skin. She else is<br />

alive, she is warm with it. She is something else<br />

than her own machinery. The facets click<br />

than together, slotting own machinery. into place. The She facets is everyone click<br />

together, within her, slotting mosaic into and place. whole. She is everyone<br />

within her, mosaic and whole.<br />

“Come back to bed, Delia,” Stephen says.<br />

“Come back to bed, Delia,” Stephen says.<br />

“No,” she says. “I am leaving this.”<br />

“No,” she says. “I am leaving this.”<br />

She is surprised by his speed, how fast he leaps<br />

up She and is spins surprised her away by his from speed, the how window. fast he leaps<br />

up and spins her away from the window.<br />

Stephen slaps her across the face, hard and<br />

fast. Stephen Pain flickers slaps her across across her the skin, face, prickles hard and like<br />

fast. fragments Pain flickers of sulphur across burning. her skin, prickles like<br />

fragments of sulphur burning.<br />

“You do not get to leave,” he says. “I made<br />

you. “You You do stay not with get me.” to leave,” he says. “I made<br />

you. You stay with me.”<br />

She lashes out like a cat, responding from<br />

some She other lashes life. out His like skin a cat, rips responding under her nails. from<br />

some Silver other mesh life. glistens, His skin revealed. rips under There is nails. no<br />

Silver blood. mesh glistens, revealed. There is no<br />

blood.<br />

For a moment they are both caught in staring<br />

at For his a machinery, moment they and are she both remembers caught in that staring he<br />

at does his not machinery, remember. and Then she remembers he looks up that her<br />

does and snarls. not remember. She feels his Then scentless he looks breath up on at her<br />

and face. snarls. She braces She feels herself his to scentless shove him breath back, on her but<br />

face. he grabs She her braces arms. herself She throws to shove herself him back, backward but<br />

he against grabs the her window arms. She and throws feels herself the glass backward splinter<br />

against behind the her, window hears and the feels crack the of glass the wooden splinter<br />

behind frame. The her, sutures hears the at her crack shoulders of the tear wooden loose<br />

frame. and she The is sutures falling. at Stephen her shoulders clutches tear empty loose<br />

and sleeves. she is falling. Stephen clutches empty<br />

sleeves.<br />

The air seems to hold her, for a moment. She<br />

hears The Szmenski air seems to shout hold inside her, for the a room, moment. but She she<br />

hears cannot Szmenski see him. shout She has inside closed the room, her eyes. but This she<br />

cannot has happened see him. before. She has The closed sudden her eyes. light This<br />

has overwhelming. happened before. The sudden light is<br />

overwhelming.<br />

Out of her skin, she is free. ◊<br />

Out of her skin, she is free. ◊


STEPHANIE BRETHERTON<br />

BONE<br />

LINES<br />

Love is Evolutionary<br />

“A monument to the timelessness of human<br />

nature, and a work of art... Bretherton ignites<br />

her characters with a life, complexity, a<br />

personality with which any number of readers<br />

will identify and empathise with. The author<br />

should be as overjoyed as I was impressed with<br />

this debut novel (the first, I hope, of many).”<br />

Naomi Moore<br />

Editor, <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong> magazine<br />

“Gracefully written, carefully researched, and<br />

always alert to the issues it raises, Bone Lines<br />

reaches far across time to relate the<br />

interwoven stories of two women – a genetic<br />

scientist addressing the complexities of<br />

contemporary experience, and one of our<br />

earliest ancestors in a physical and spiritual<br />

ordeal of survival... a brave and moving<br />

adventure of the imagination.”<br />

Lindsay Clarke<br />

The Chymical Wedding<br />

“A brilliant, genre-defying read, Bone Lines<br />

deftly unravels the wonder of oneness”<br />

Barbara Bos<br />

Managing Editor, Women Writers, Women’s<br />

Books<br />

“Like Sapiens ...if fictionalised and seen<br />

through the eyes of two fierce and<br />

admirable women.”<br />

Zero Filter Books<br />

Available to buy at:<br />

Amazon.co.uk<br />

Bookdepository.com


_____________<br />

Later, as my fingers clenched around the<br />

joystick, I would rethink my hasty trek through<br />

the doors of the machine. Thinking back on my<br />

naivety ‒ as I sit in a chair whose contours have<br />

sagged and worn into the perfect imprint of<br />

myself ‒ my willingness to take apart time and<br />

fiddle it into something else, is foreign to me<br />

now. Youth is a curious toxin. I remember the<br />

fire of it running through me, though I’m sure<br />

I didn’t register it at the time.<br />

When the machine appeared, I was full of<br />

heady youth and frustration, and dissatisfied<br />

with certain aspects of my life. I suppose I<br />

wanted the comfort of knowing I would be all<br />

right. That was my first mistake. When I first<br />

saw myself as I would be, I recoiled. Something<br />

primal and instinctual snapped like a harp<br />

string around me. I was doing wrong on a<br />

cosmic level. It was like seeing my intestines<br />

outside my body. I was corrupt at a base level.<br />

All the mannerisms and ticks of character that<br />

I should have been experiencing from the<br />

inside were externalised. I saw myself as I was:<br />

painfully small. An insignificant member of the<br />

human race.<br />

After that, I knew I could not go back. To see<br />

that and resume normality was impossible. I<br />

refused to wait out my future, feeling the skin<br />

slowly sagging away from me, my arteries<br />

constricting, my joints rusting, and mind<br />

congealing. Losing every part of myself so slowly<br />

I would barely register it until I woke up one<br />

day decrepit and moaning for days gone by.<br />

Aging was a profound and unnatural fear, its<br />

roots reaching deep in me.<br />

I would later remember my hands shaking as<br />

I punched numbers into the machine, almost at<br />

random, as if guided by something outside<br />

myself. Seeing my future self, I was urged<br />

desperately forward, away from it.<br />

In the time I appeared next, I was already<br />

dead. As horrid as it sounds, I was relieved. I<br />

wanted no glimpse of the poltergeist I was to


ecome. Instead, I found myself at the funeral<br />

of my dearest friend, someone I met as a child<br />

and we had rarely parted company since. He<br />

was the most important person in my life. There<br />

were ornate displays of flowers. Mourners wept<br />

throughout the room. His mother was sobbing.<br />

As I looked on his casket, I felt nothing. All the<br />

other people who had been dear to me had<br />

warped in my absence. They had disentangled<br />

themselves from my memory. Their eulogies<br />

were tributes to strangers.<br />

Throughout this time-hopping, I wasn’t<br />

aging, although my fingers became wiry as they<br />

danced over the panels of my machine. Now<br />

that the people I loved had been wrested from<br />

me, I was free. Free to travel further, free to find<br />

a place I could be happy.<br />

In fifty years, they found the cure for cancer.<br />

Old men and women with walkers tottered<br />

around the neighbourhood. Rosy cheeks over<br />

withered, drooping skin. Walkers to conceal<br />

atrophying limbs. I moved on.<br />

In one hundred years, plastic surgery would<br />

remove a person’s imperfections. Glossy<br />

magazines models come to life breezed through<br />

the streets, laughing. They frightened me, these<br />

perfect specimens. Their skin was like rubber,<br />

or the lustrous paper of the magazines they<br />

read. I had a horrid feeling in the pit of my<br />

stomach, as if at any minute the faces might fall<br />

off, leaving the people with skin as raw as a<br />

skinned animal, hung up to tenderise. Panic<br />

clawed at my throat. I tugged at my hair and<br />

moved on once more.<br />

to settle down, to stay in one time for even a<br />

week, I would shiver uncontrollably. I could<br />

never sleep, so instead I roamed the streets of a<br />

world that was always hostile and foreign to me.<br />

I was not wanted, the buildings and streets told<br />

me. I could no longer live in real time. I had<br />

been expelled from the natural order of things.<br />

The only way I could operate was always moving<br />

on, living in time lapse.<br />

I know eventually I may run out of time. It<br />

only makes sense that if there is a beginning,<br />

there must also be an end. I walk through the<br />

dark corridor of time with no clue as to where<br />

the precipice will be, or what will happen when<br />

I reach it. I have seen more than any person<br />

could have dreamed. Empires have fallen,<br />

rebuilt, fallen again. An ambitious young man<br />

takes too much; a foolish young woman wants<br />

to change the world. The patterns are always the<br />

same.<br />

I am no longer afraid to stop living; I have<br />

never lived. I have been life-adjacent. My<br />

machine and I, silent observers of history,<br />

refugees of time. No-one can miss me, because<br />

they do not know I am missing. I exist on the<br />

rim, observing the world find new ways to<br />

destroy itself and patch itself up again. It is<br />

futile. I am futile. But after so long what else<br />

can I do?<br />

I move on.<br />

Understand, these futures I darted furtively<br />

through were veritable utopias. Plague, war and<br />

famine had been all but done away with.<br />

Lifespans were longer, life was better, people<br />

were happy. I was not happy. I had developed a<br />

new state of living, here in my sequestered<br />

bubble. It was addicting. Every time I attempted


I’ve heard it said that every superpower is a<br />

personification of a human desire, an<br />

acknowledgement of our limits. We want to<br />

read minds because we know we lack perfect<br />

empathy. We want invisibility to avoid<br />

judgement. Following this train of logic, time<br />

travel would be the personification of a desire<br />

to remove oneself from the immediacy of<br />

events. To jump back and forth through the<br />

time stream is to remove any vitality, any<br />

legitimacy from the emotions life would<br />

usually evoke. When you can move on to an<br />

entirely different time whenever you like, an<br />

earthquake, a war, a famine, mean nothing.<br />

There is always another century.<br />

I have always considered dystopias to be<br />

intrinsically linked to the tradition of<br />

Romanticism. The emphasis it places on<br />

individuality, emotion and the human spirit,<br />

I find, translates rather seamlessly into a<br />

dystopian future. Because of this, many of the<br />

stories I read and write that have dystopian<br />

undertones focus on emotion. The terror<br />

inspired by an authoritarian government, the<br />

miasma of a society without progress, the<br />

horror of losing autonomy over one’s self. In<br />

writing Time Lapse I asked myself under what<br />

circumstances could these emotions be<br />

numbed? In what situation would a person


lose their human instinct to care, and worry<br />

about their perceived futures?<br />

In many dystopias this emotional numbing<br />

can result from lack of control and<br />

knowledge. In George Orwell’s 1984 none of<br />

the citizens are upset about the regimes<br />

because they lack any room for independent<br />

thought or control over their destinies. The<br />

characters in these stories are stifled with<br />

ignorance, while the character in my story is<br />

crushed by knowledge. Knowing nothing<br />

about the world around you obviously<br />

renders it impossible for you to respond<br />

properly to it. Knowing everything though,<br />

knowing the outcome of every possible event<br />

makes responding to the world pointless in<br />

the first place. You can’t truly live in a world<br />

you know everything about. I remember once<br />

I was having a lot of issues with school and<br />

complaining to my father about how I wish I<br />

had everything figured out. He replied that<br />

once someone had everything figured out,<br />

they died. That’s really stuck in my mind<br />

since, and I think it’s partially because it<br />

reminds me that we thrive on not knowing.<br />

The uncertainty of the direction our lives will<br />

take is the only thing keeping us invested. If we<br />

already knew the destination, the journey would<br />

lose all meaning. Having no control over the<br />

world you live in is dangerous, having complete<br />

control over it is just as bad.<br />

This is what my character experiences in the<br />

story. They are essentially handed a roadmap<br />

of the entire universe, given ultimate power<br />

and control. Yet they do nothing with it.<br />

Absolute power reduces them to<br />

powerlessness. This is because when they<br />

distance themselves from the world, and<br />

know everything about it, they lose the will to<br />

care about it.<br />

In my mind, this emotional removal from<br />

events is one of the most dangerous threats to<br />

us today. The way we get our news, through<br />

our phones, our laptops, our websites, stops<br />

us feeling the emotional impact of events. It’s<br />

hard to muster up the energy to care about a<br />

mass shooting when we know there will just<br />

be another one in a week’s time. This<br />

constant influx of tragedy overwhelms us, and<br />

makes us indifferent to it. Indifference is<br />

dangerous, and if we don’t care or can’t<br />

process the problems we’re facing, we can’t fix<br />

them.<br />

Time travel is an extreme example of being<br />

removed from society. The protagonist in<br />

Time Lapse loses their humanity slowly,<br />

feeling more and more indifferent to events<br />

that should cause intense emotion.<br />

Eventually, they start to take an almost<br />

morbid delight in watching the rises and falls<br />

of humanity. They feel immune to all the


pain others feel. Time travel, for them was a<br />

way to bypass nature, to become immortal, to<br />

watch the world with the removed, unbiased<br />

eye of a god. This idea of trying to overcome<br />

your earthly limits has been being written<br />

about since the creation of mainstream<br />

science fiction, with Mary Shelley's<br />

‘Frankenstein’. I think it is such a popular<br />

narrative because humans are inherently<br />

driven towards progress, bettering ourselves<br />

any way we can. With that though, comes the<br />

fear ‘how far is too far? At what point to we<br />

start to tempt fate?’. Dr Frankenstein in<br />

Frankenstein and the protagonist from my<br />

novel both take steps to far, in the name of<br />

hubris, or the desire to become something<br />

more than themselves. Both of them feel the<br />

effects of this, and lose what they most value<br />

in this pursuit of mindless progress.<br />

Now, I’m not one to tell you that progress<br />

is inherently evil either. It’s unlikely<br />

smartphones are going to ruin us, and the<br />

robot uprising seems like it’s still a few years<br />

away. I do think, however, that progress<br />

without thought, without debate, is a<br />

dangerous thing. So often we do things just<br />

because they seem like the next thing to do.<br />

When we walk this line without careful<br />

consideration of what we’re trying to achieve,<br />

the lines between moral and immoral become<br />

blurred. Is it okay to use genetic engineering<br />

to stop the extinction of a plant species? To<br />

promote crop growth? To decide your child's<br />

eye colour? Everyone will have a different<br />

perception of where that line is, which makes<br />

collective, societal ideals hard to agree upon.<br />

In Time Lapse, the protagonist becomes<br />

addicted to progress. Though the pockets of<br />

time they explore seem almost utopian, they<br />

can’t help thinking that the grass might be<br />

greener in the next generation.


The idea of progress, especially<br />

technological progress runs through a lot of<br />

dystopia and is often used as a metaphor for<br />

humans natural urge for progression and<br />

betterment. Though these values should be<br />

good in themselves, they are often villainized<br />

in dystopia. Technology has become our<br />

modern Frankenstein, a symbol of humans<br />

‘playing God’ and giving themselves more<br />

power than they know how to handle. The<br />

power technology holds in our society is<br />

inarguable. Very few industries do not utilize<br />

it and without it, society would collapse.<br />

However, I am skeptical of the notion that<br />

technology has somehow altered the essence<br />

of humanity.<br />

There’s always been a small place in my<br />

heart for dystopias. Part of this may come<br />

down to morbid fascination with the dark<br />

and dreary. But I think it’s more likely that<br />

my love for dystopia comes from my curiosity<br />

about humanity in general. Dystopias rely on<br />

tropes such as tyrannical government,<br />

oppressive society and suppression of free<br />

speech, but that’s not really what they’re<br />

about. At their hearts dystopias are about<br />

humanity and the way it triumphs, or fails to<br />

triumph over oppressive circumstances. This<br />

exploration of humanity has always captured<br />

me, and I think it’s the foundation of most<br />

literature, not just dystopia. The debate about<br />

human nature has been ongoing and ever<br />

changing since the beginning of time. In this<br />

particular debate, the only certainty is that we<br />

will certainly be having it forever. But taking<br />

our ideas and shaping them into cohesive<br />

stories for people to read, critique, argue and<br />

agree with, is in my mind, one of the most<br />

important things we could be doing.


Leonis A2 / Leonis Minor System<br />

_____________<br />

She was startled out of her reverie by the<br />

sound of her own voice. After nearly four earthstandard<br />

months alone, she had forgotten what<br />

it sounded like. She had been trying to imagine<br />

herself objectively, like a narrator<br />

commentating her own life story, and the word<br />

had just come out, escaping from her mouth as<br />

though seeking freedom from her mind.<br />

“Rebecca.”<br />

Her name seemed to bounce around inside<br />

her helmet, and she laughed a little then,<br />

thinking how ridiculous it was that she had<br />

managed to give herself a fright like that. Over<br />

the last few weeks, she had begun to doubt who<br />

she really was, as in her solitude she<br />

painstakingly analysed all those tangled threads<br />

that came together to form: Rebecca Toombes,<br />

the ‘famous’ xeno-biologist.<br />

She wondered if she might have been out solo<br />

for too long this time. The nearest human being<br />

was light-years away. Maybe she would look<br />

back on this moment, when she had talked and<br />

laughed to herself, to find it amongst the initial<br />

signs that her train of thought had derailed for<br />

good. She had been lying there on the dusty<br />

ground in foetal position day-dreaming as suns<br />

scythed across the sky. Now she stood up for the<br />

first time in what felt like days. The piles of<br />

orange dust that had accumulated around her<br />

body stayed behind as she arose, leaving an<br />

outline of her prone figure. Two suns shone<br />

from opposite horizons, one rising large, dim<br />

and red, while the other set small, bright and<br />

yellow. The light between them extinguished<br />

any shadows thrown onto the uneven ground.<br />

Initially, this world had seemed miserably<br />

barren and bleak to Rebecca. The orange,<br />

yellow and red hues cast over everything by the<br />

two suns and the pervasive volcanic dust offered<br />

an uninteresting palette. At least that had been<br />

her impression a decade ago when she had first


come to this star-system. But now, four months<br />

into her second journey here, and solo this<br />

time, the bright gold and silver colours of her<br />

suit seemed an offensively garish visual affront<br />

amidst the subtle tri-tone beauty she had now<br />

come to appreciate here. Although these garish<br />

colours made her feel incongruous to her<br />

surroundings, she knew that it had no<br />

detrimental effect upon her efforts to stalk her<br />

prey, who sensed its world in ways that had<br />

nothing to do with visible light.<br />

The creature lay fifty meters away to the<br />

north. It had not moved in almost two days<br />

now, but she knew better than to try and sneak<br />

up on it since even after months of painstaking<br />

habituation work it had only now begun to let<br />

her get this close. She had discovered a new<br />

boundary to its personal space each time it fled,<br />

and it would take hours of finding the swishswish-swish<br />

of its tracks in the dust and then<br />

following them before she caught up with it<br />

again. For an animal that moved so slowly in its<br />

everyday routine, if at all, it could sure escape in<br />

a hurry. It would throw its long flat body up<br />

into the thick atmosphere to flap and flip itself<br />

through the air like a ribbon. Sometimes she<br />

would have to travel up to a kilometre to find<br />

where it had landed and then follow its tracks<br />

anew. Every two weeks or so, once the creature<br />

seemed settled into feeding off a fresh rift,<br />

Rebecca would retreat back over a hill or ridge,<br />

and call in her re-supply from orbit. This<br />

avoided the fiery re-entry of the tiny incoming<br />

capsules from her orbiting starship startling the<br />

animal. Her top-of-the-line ‘Exploration<br />

Standard’ environment suit had air, food, water<br />

and waste recycling facilities that could sustain<br />

her for up to three earth-standard weeks, but<br />

she re-supplied every fortnight to keep a margin<br />

of error up her sleeve.<br />

The local days here were erratic since the<br />

circumbinary orbit that the planet inhabited<br />

saw it orbit two stars which in turn circled each<br />

other, offering the sky of the rapidly spinning<br />

Leonis A2 either two suns, a big red sun, a little<br />

yellow sun, or no suns at all. In the case of the<br />

latter, bright nebulae would fill the sky on these<br />

short nights, as though a tapestry of glowing<br />

blue and magenta had been draped over the<br />

planet. She slept in the open, but if some<br />

sudden storm or danger came upon her, the<br />

suit could encapsulate her in a protective shield<br />

of super-strong material. If anything indeed<br />

went wrong, the automated landing-craft from<br />

her starship could collect her and bring her<br />

back to the safety of orbit within a few hours,<br />

even if she was unconscious. In many ways, the<br />

sense of ‘living on the edge' that she felt was just<br />

a fallacy, but still, it was refreshing to be alone<br />

this time around.<br />

Ten years ago, the success of her initial<br />

gamble concerning the possibility of indigenous<br />

life on this planet had seen her sent with a large<br />

team of xeno-biologists, technicians, security<br />

personnel, engineers, and ship crew, along with<br />

a representative from the nameless organisation<br />

that was fronting up the money for that<br />

expedition. They had mapped the planet's<br />

ecosystem from orbit, swept for microbial<br />

threats, and then carried out a detailed on-theground<br />

analysis within a few square kilometres<br />

of what had seemed like an interesting region.<br />

But just a few weeks later they had been ordered<br />

to pack up and depart for a nearby system<br />

which, while being barren of life, showed<br />

potential for the geological resources that<br />

would actually show a financial return to the<br />

expedition's investors. Alien life might be<br />

scientifically exciting and make for wondrous<br />

entertainment for the trillions of planet-bound


folk, but it didn't really make anyone rich. And<br />

then soon afterwards humanity had found yet<br />

another sentient species elsewhere to add to the<br />

half dozen or so already described, which was<br />

ironically another discovery Rebecca could take<br />

the credit for. And so the public's attention had<br />

moved on, and the binary system of Leonis<br />

Minor, with its planet of peculiar flat animals,<br />

had slipped into the abyss of humanity's<br />

overflowing info-banks to be largely forgotten.<br />

In the years that followed she had used her<br />

own time and resources to pour over the wealth<br />

of information they had gathered in those short<br />

weeks. There were countless other distractions<br />

that had demanded her professional attention,<br />

but there was something about this planet, and<br />

its flat animals, that had stayed in the front of<br />

her mind, even as discoveries that brought<br />

higher accolade and prestige called to her.<br />

Orange dust would permeate her dreams as<br />

she slept, and she would wake holding her<br />

pillow underneath herself as though she was<br />

either wrestling with, or making love to, one of<br />

those long flat animals. Scientifically, there<br />

remained many unanswered questions from<br />

that brief expedition to Leonis A2, as there<br />

always were, but two mysteries simply refused to<br />

leave her mind; Firstly, what exactly were these<br />

creatures feeding on at those volcanic rifts they<br />

migrated between? And given that they had<br />

found no predators at the top of their simple<br />

eco-system, what had these creatures evolved to<br />

escape from in such a hurry?<br />

The time dilation from the faster-than-light<br />

travel she had undertaken to and from the<br />

system meant that while it had been only ten<br />

years since their last expedition for her, one<br />

hundred and sixty-nine earth-standard years<br />

had passed here on the planet. Their old<br />

laboratory had been lost under a mountain of<br />

orange dust, yet with just the computing power<br />

and tools available in her environment suit, and<br />

data-linked from the computer on her orbiting<br />

star-ship, she had stumbled across an answer to<br />

the first question within a few weeks. The fact<br />

that she had missed what seemed like such an<br />

obvious answer to her now seemed shameful. In<br />

her defence, the answer was, to say the least, a<br />

revolutionary form of biology and, at first<br />

glance, utterly impossible.<br />

During the first expedition they had, after<br />

much effort, managed to catch a smaller version<br />

of the animal she was currently tracking. They<br />

had taken it back to the forward-deployed<br />

laboratory they had set up within their study<br />

zone. There were many experienced members<br />

amongst her crew, who had been exposed to<br />

vast amounts of weird and wonderful alien<br />

lifeforms over their careers, but this creature<br />

had them truly baffled. Firstly, it had no eyes or<br />

ears or other sensors that would allow it to have<br />

any situational awareness of its environment.<br />

Yet it indeed did have such awareness, because<br />

if you got too close to them, they would flip<br />

themselves into the air and flap off. It also had<br />

no mouth. Indeed, they found no openings at<br />

all in its body, and its skin did not appear to be


permeable to solids, allowing no form of<br />

ingestion and excretion between the creature<br />

and its environment.<br />

The creature's skin had an almost metallic<br />

texture, its colour fading from a dense black at<br />

its front to the off-white of its tail. It had been<br />

difficult to house, since while it was only half a<br />

meter wide, it was over six meters long, and at<br />

the most ten centimetres in height. It seemed at<br />

pains to keep each of its ends as far apart from<br />

each other as possible, which evidently it had<br />

trouble doing within the confines of its two by<br />

two meter transparent enclosure. After a short<br />

time, just a week, the animal had died in<br />

captivity.<br />

Upon autopsy, they had found it to be mostly<br />

muscle-like tissue and none of its internal<br />

organs were recognisable or analogous to any<br />

terrestrial or currently known extra-terrestrial<br />

biological systems. The composition of its tissue<br />

was highly metallic, with a complex and evenly<br />

distributed super-conductive nervous system,<br />

yet with no nodes of complexity that might<br />

suggest a brain. The fluids found within it<br />

consisted of dense electrolytes, and instead of<br />

any bone structure, it had thin wire-like ribs<br />

composed of lithium metal, held within its<br />

highly acidic muscle tissue. In hindsight, if one<br />

of the engineers from their starship had been<br />

present, they might have nonchalantly<br />

exclaimed "Oh, hey look at that. It's a Lithium-<br />

Ion battery." Chalk up another sharp reminder<br />

to engage in inter-disciplinary peer-review. They<br />

had all missed the clues.<br />

Here in the Leonis Minor Binary system, one<br />

star was huge and dim, while the other was<br />

much smaller, brighter and denser. The<br />

circumbinary nature of its orbit created<br />

fluctuations in the pull of gravity exerted<br />

against Leonis A2 that made its internal geology<br />

highly energetic, and thus its crust was split into<br />

deep fractures through which the planets<br />

interior heat was vented into the cold<br />

atmosphere. It was around these cracks in the<br />

planet's skin that its ecology was centred. These<br />

rifts would wax and wane in intensity, and they<br />

had discovered that the creatures migrated<br />

between them, somehow knowing where the<br />

nearest area of activity was. They would nestle<br />

their black ‘heads’ right into the hot vent, and<br />

leave their long bodies stretched out so that the<br />

tips of their ‘tails' would remain on the cold<br />

ground. The larger and longer the animal, the<br />

further away their tails would be from the heat,<br />

and the colder they would be. The answer had<br />

come to her in a moment of epiphany, and she<br />

had berated herself for not seeing it with the<br />

information she already had from the previous<br />

expedition. The implications were immediate<br />

and obvious to her, and she knew that when<br />

this news reached the board of investors of the<br />

last expedition, they would gather all their<br />

resources nearby and descend upon this planet<br />

in droves, with capital ships and hundreds of<br />

scientists. It would take years for them to get<br />

here, of course, and she would be long gone by<br />

then. There were strong financial incentives to<br />

self-fund an expedition such as she had this<br />

one. The intellectual property rights on this<br />

discovery would set her up for life, and then<br />

some.<br />

The answer, it turned out, was that these<br />

creatures did not have mouths, because they did<br />

not need food. They had evolved to utilise the<br />

energy potential contained in the difference<br />

between the heat at one end of their bodies,<br />

versus the cold at the other. Somehow these<br />

creatures created electrical energy through<br />

chemical processes, which they then stored in<br />

their battery-like bodies. This energy was used<br />

not only to operate their internal systems but<br />

also extract minerals and matter through the<br />

undersides of their bodies. They had missed<br />

this last time since it was done by a unique<br />

electromagnetic process that separated out the<br />

metals at a molecular level.<br />

At this stage, she did not understand what<br />

these electrochemical processes were precisely,


ut she would soon enough. If not her, then the<br />

next wave of researchers would figure it out.<br />

And then a revolutionary and ground-breaking<br />

technology would be realised. Just imagine,<br />

being able to generate energy from any<br />

temperature gradient? Such as the heat outside<br />

a house versus the cold inside. Or vice versa. Or<br />

the Intense heat of a starship's engine versus the<br />

cold vacuum of space? If the process could be<br />

made efficient enough, then the amount of<br />

energy needed to create the heat could be<br />

drastically reduced, as the energy gained from<br />

the heat produced was then fed back into<br />

creating more heat. And it appeared that these<br />

creatures were generating energy very efficiently<br />

indeed, since she had seen her subject arrive at<br />

a hot rift after a week of travel, only to have it<br />

dissipate and go cold a few hours later. The<br />

creature had simply continued on for another<br />

week until it found a new rift to feed on. And<br />

within that period it had flipped away from her<br />

several times, an exercise that was surely taxing<br />

on its energy reserves.<br />

As she followed this creature for months<br />

on end, so much more of its life had started to<br />

make sense. Within their initial two-kilometre<br />

square study area they had found only seven of<br />

them, so their population density was extremely<br />

low. And since following this one, she had seen<br />

it come across another of its kind only once.<br />

That had been a much smaller example, and it<br />

had climbed onto the back of her creature and<br />

stayed there. It was now almost wholly<br />

assimilated into her subject, and she could only<br />

just make out the slight bulge and colouration<br />

where its black head and white tail had been.<br />

This explained how they obtained their genetic<br />

diversity. She had kept multi-spectral scans<br />

running on her subject through this whole<br />

period, and she was looking forward to<br />

analysing the data when she finally did get back<br />

to her starship that orbited above the planet.<br />

Her environment suit might be a marvel of<br />

modern science, sustaining her every need as<br />

she existed alone here, but despite its own<br />

artificial intelligence and computing power, the<br />

kind of in-depth analysis of the zettabytes of<br />

information she was collecting daily was beyond<br />

its ability. She had found the A.I. more<br />

annoying than helpful, and so had kept it<br />

turned off to protect her sanity for the past few<br />

months.<br />

The animal began to move again, so she<br />

gathered up the tools and sensors she had laid<br />

out while she slept, re-attached them to her suit,<br />

and began to follow it. The creature was a slow<br />

mover, but she had come to learn to relax into<br />

the slightly-less-than-walking pace she needed to<br />

maintain to match its speed. She scuffed her<br />

feet against the ground, kicking clouds of<br />

orange dust up with each step. Looking like<br />

some kind of ‘flat-fish' the animal rippled the<br />

muscles along its underside to power itself<br />

forwards, leaving the tell-tale swishing waves of<br />

dust behind.<br />

By the end of the day they had covered almost<br />

forty kilometres, and their goal came into view.<br />

As the small yellow sun set to the east ahead of<br />

them, it was lost into a fiercely shimmering<br />

haze. It flickered like a strobe light across the<br />

land, the shadows from the uneven ground<br />

jumping further as it lowered towards the rift<br />

that split the horizon. Finally, as it disappeared<br />

from view behind a churning wall of superheated<br />

air, its light was spread across the sky<br />

behind her as though by the great brushstrokes<br />

of a drunkard, until it vanished, and the great<br />

arc of nebulae filled the skies overhead once<br />

more. The creatures pace quickened, as if in<br />

anticipation of its destination, and she had to<br />

jog to keep up with it. There would be no sleep<br />

for her tonight that was for sure. Rebecca kept<br />

the night vision offered by her suit turned off,<br />

so as not to subtract from the majesty of the<br />

nebulae above her.<br />

Rebecca wished then that she could travel<br />

back in time, to whisper into the ear of her<br />

confused and unconfident adolescent self, to


tell herself about this moment that would<br />

come. If only she could have known that she<br />

would one day be racing across an alien world<br />

that she had found, to chase an alien being that<br />

she had discovered, under a night sky<br />

dominated by these huge and beautiful<br />

nebulae. She had to confess that life really had<br />

worked out pretty well for her. The sacrifices<br />

had been worth it for this moment alone. Her<br />

suit subtly illuminated the un-even ground that<br />

lay in her path within the display of her helmet.<br />

As she tired from the quickened pace, the suit<br />

took up the workload, until she was almost<br />

being carried along by it. According to her<br />

navigation aids, they would reach the rift in six<br />

hours, by which time the large red sun would<br />

be high in the sky behind them.<br />

This was the ninth rift that she had followed<br />

her subject to, but it was noticeably different.<br />

Firstly, the wall of hot air was more intense, the<br />

hottest she had seen yet, at 350 degrees Celsius,<br />

versus the five degrees of the atmosphere<br />

around it. The air jetted at almost 200<br />

kilometres per hour out of the centre of the tenmeter-wide<br />

rift, rising into the sky like a reverse<br />

waterfall of vapour and shimmering haze.<br />

But the most noticeable difference from usual<br />

was the ground leading up to the rift. From two<br />

hundred meters away the ubiquitous orange<br />

dust, which usually stayed constant right up<br />

until the very lip of a rift, gave way to a mat of<br />

moss-like material that offered a softer texture<br />

beneath her boots. She had seen this moss<br />

before, and at one point studied it carefully,<br />

marvelling at yet another parallel evolution of<br />

photosynthesis, but had never seen such a thick<br />

and wide field of it. She stopped to cut out a<br />

piece, which came away easily, as though her<br />

knife was slicing through a few inches of soft<br />

butter. Underneath it, the regular orange dust<br />

remained.<br />

She took a few moments to secure it in one of<br />

her sample pouches, then turned around to see<br />

that the hole she had cut was gone, as though it<br />

had grown over in that impossibly short period<br />

of time. Rebecca looked around herself, in case<br />

she was merely disorientated, but couldn’t find<br />

the freshly cut scar anywhere. She was about to<br />

crouch for another sample when she realised<br />

the creature was now only several meters away<br />

from the rift, and that she would miss the initial<br />

action unless she prioritised. She slid her knife<br />

into its sheath on her thigh and sprinted<br />

towards the rift, double checking all her suit<br />

sensors were at maximum, while with one arm<br />

she reached around to the back of her suit,<br />

withdrew her small sensor drone, and threw it<br />

into the air. It buzzed off above her to keep<br />

station and record events.<br />

The creature threw its head into the wall of<br />

hot air, and then flicked its tail back as far<br />

behind itself as it could, as though it was a towel<br />

being fluttered out onto the sand at the beach.<br />

A shiver ran through its body, and it shook<br />

itself as though settling itself into the ground.<br />

Rebecca fell to her knees twenty meters away,<br />

the closest yet she had been to this animal by<br />

far, and most certainly the closest she had been<br />

to it while it fed. She was getting reckless.<br />

Cocky. She chided herself, yet relished the<br />

excitement of it. Barely perceptible colours<br />

could be made out flowing along the creatures<br />

back, subtle blues and purples, and for a<br />

moment it reminded her of the flashing<br />

graphics that showed a piece of equipment<br />

charging. She brought the holographic and


multi-spectral view from the drone above her<br />

into her helmet display and gasped at the<br />

enhanced imagery of energy flowing through<br />

the creature's body. Then, the ground shook<br />

beneath her.<br />

“What the…” The ground lurched again,<br />

viciously this time, and she was thrown off her<br />

knees and onto her back. Rebecca got up onto<br />

her elbow and saw the creature had stiffened,<br />

then it curled itself up as it did when it was<br />

about to flip away. And the rift, the rift<br />

was…much closer. Another lurch and she was<br />

rolled over and over as the ground fled from<br />

underneath her, pulling her towards the rift.<br />

Instinctively she jumped to her feet and began<br />

to run away from the rift and its wall of superheated<br />

air, but the ground pulled away from<br />

underneath her again and she fell forward onto<br />

her face. She got to her feet and ran again,<br />

sprinting with all of her might this time.<br />

“Ship! Suit! Fuck!” she yelled as she ran.<br />

The ground was racing towards the rift<br />

constantly now, yet still she ran, but like a<br />

mouse in a wheel or an athlete on a speeding<br />

treadmill, she was going nowhere. A shadow fell<br />

across her as the creature sped overhead,<br />

flapping and flipping its way away from the rift,<br />

back the way it had come.<br />

“Fuck!”<br />

It was all she could manage. Her suit had<br />

finally cottoned on to what was going on, and<br />

with a start, she lurched forward as it added its<br />

own power into her running, but it was too<br />

much too soon, and she overbalanced, falling<br />

backwards as her legs ran ahead from<br />

underneath of herself in a blur. She rolled a few<br />

times, and then she tried to stand up to run<br />

again, but the air was thick with orange dust,<br />

and she couldn't tell which direction the<br />

ground was moving in or which way she was<br />

supposed to run. Her suit was yelling warnings<br />

at her, the first time it had spoken in months,<br />

but she couldn't concentrate on what it was<br />

saying amidst the turmoil of the racing ground<br />

beneath her, something about ‘temperature'<br />

and ‘shield deployment failure'. There was only<br />

the rushing ground, the swirling dust, the roar<br />

of the hot air. She had one clear thought within<br />

the panic, and it was not of herself or her safety<br />

at all, but of the discovery.<br />

“Suit! Ship! Transmit all! Transmit all now!”<br />

she screamed.<br />

She managed to sit up on the sliding ground<br />

and was faced with a terrifying view inside the<br />

rift that rapidly loomed towards her, the ground<br />

flowing over into it the abyss. As she came to<br />

the edge, she looked down and knew. In a split<br />

second, she knew what this was, and what those<br />

creatures had evolved to fly away from in such<br />

a hurry. She was looking down into the bowels<br />

of a plant, a carnivorous plant, some kind of<br />

Sarcophagophyta-like thing that had grown<br />

itself into the hot rift. Long wide orchid-like<br />

tubes along its centre let the air through to reform<br />

the unbroken wall of hot air as though it<br />

wasn't there at all. Its insides were a mottled<br />

collection of decaying matter, with the ‘ground'<br />

furling back into the fronds nestled along the<br />

inside wall of the rift that they had been grown<br />

forth from. Thin spines curved inwards from<br />

below the edge of the rift into the rising wall of<br />

heated air. She wanted to close her eyes but<br />

couldn't, she was transfixed in horror, yet still<br />

managed to think how beautiful this Venusflytrap<br />

from hell was. As her feet went over the<br />

precipice, her final instinct was to fruitlessly<br />

reach back towards the lip of the rift with her<br />

hands, and as she did so, she caught a glimpse<br />

a long dark shape flying towards her from out<br />

of the orange desert.<br />

Within moments the creature had curled its<br />

black body around her legs and torso, and then<br />

it lifted her upwards above the edge of the rift<br />

as the ground still rushed away underneath<br />

them. Then, just before its white tail came over<br />

the lip of the rift, it flicked her away like a rag<br />

doll. She flew fifty meters through the air to


land awkwardly upon one knee, which she felt<br />

snap sideways underneath her as she tumbled<br />

over and over in the orange dust. Rebecca<br />

screamed out in agony as the pain hit her like a<br />

piercing fire in her leg.<br />

[Initiating sedation.]<br />

She felt a sharp pierce in her neck, and then<br />

numbness began to spread.<br />

[Setting Right Leg]<br />

Rebecca felt the suit straighten her broken<br />

leg, by which time the anaesthetic had spread to<br />

her feet.<br />

[Initiating Recovery Protocol Alpha One.<br />

Mark. ETA Seventy-five minutes. Initiating<br />

Diagnostic Scan and…]<br />

As the suit rattled off its intentions she went<br />

limp, her head fell back to the ground, and as<br />

she lost consciousness, she gazed out at the<br />

shimmering haze that split her now vertical<br />

horizon like a mirror. There was only orange<br />

ground now though, no ‘moss' to be seen. And<br />

no creature. Just orange dust. The shimmering<br />

air. Darkness.<br />

a few things to clear up here and then I'll come<br />

back to civilisation.' The term ‘mum' was a<br />

metaphor obviously since with all the faster<br />

than light travel Rebecca had done over her<br />

career, time dilation had seen her mother pass<br />

away hundreds of years ago. Such was the<br />

sacrifice of her profession.<br />

She named them ‘Angelus Autem Calidum -<br />

Toombes R - LMS A2’. ‘Angels of the Heat’, as<br />

discovered by Rebecca Toombes, on Leonis A2,<br />

Leonis Minor System. But everyone just called<br />

them ‘Angels’ now. The emergency<br />

transmission of all her raw-data had been<br />

received by the information grid first, followed<br />

a few days later by a hurriedly recorded update<br />

from aboard her ship when she awoke, in which<br />

pleaded for everybody to ‘please not look at the<br />

raw-data because that is exactly what it was’, and<br />

how ‘it would make much better reading once<br />

she had written it up properly’, and that ‘it was<br />

like reading the rough first-draft of lyrics to a<br />

song before hearing the tune itself’, and that it<br />

was ‘her intellectual property’ and that ‘she only<br />

sent it out because she thought she was going to<br />

die’, and ‘mum don’t worry I’m fine, I just have<br />

The holographic recordings of her<br />

predicament and subsequent rescue by the alien<br />

had spread through the information grid like<br />

wildfire, propagated by the latest generations of<br />

faster-than-light message capsules, making her a<br />

household name throughout the cluster. But<br />

within her profession itself, Rebecca was wildly<br />

derided as a ‘reckless-lone-wolf' who got lucky.<br />

The technology derived from the following<br />

study of Leonis A2's unique ecology most


certainly was a boon for both herself and the<br />

investors of the initial expedition. But she<br />

didn't like the fame, and she didn't need the<br />

money. Rebecca longed to shed her new overpowering<br />

fame, to once again be that original<br />

‘her', an identity she had spent all those lonely<br />

months contemplating and crafting in that<br />

orange desert. Then, the investors offered her<br />

the gig of a lifetime, leading a hand-picked<br />

xenobiology team on what seemed to be the<br />

ultimate expedition, one that would probably be<br />

a one way trip across thousands of light years of<br />

unexplored cosmos. She made them wait for a<br />

reply, bettering her negotiation position as<br />

though she had other options on the table, but<br />

she was only ever going to say yes. ◊<br />

“Where is everybody?” In 1950, these were<br />

the words exclaimed by physicist Enrico<br />

Fermi after a day’s brooding over an old,<br />

unanswered question. Astronomic reports<br />

based on 2013 Kepler space mission data state<br />

that there could be as many as 40 billion<br />

Earth-sized planets orbiting in the habitable


zones of sun-like stars and red dwarf stars<br />

within the Milky Way Galaxy alone. Even if<br />

only a tiny fraction of those fill all the<br />

requirements for developing complex life,<br />

one would think that we’d be constantly<br />

meeting our cosmological neighbours. In a<br />

universe so huge, so varied, and so complex,<br />

and where it seems likely that so many kinds<br />

of life would develop and flourish in different<br />

ways, why haven’t we found anybody?<br />

Fermi’s studies into this topic, particularly<br />

in combination with Drake’s equation,<br />

formulating the potential number of<br />

intelligent civilisations in any given galaxy<br />

depending on its possession of certain kinds<br />

of conditions, came to be known as the Fermi<br />

Paradox, and it's a problem we are wrestling<br />

to this day.<br />

The Fermi Paradox has a great many<br />

potential answers, some suggesting that life<br />

existed before or will exist after us, that there<br />

are physical restrictions meaning they can't<br />

find us, or we can't find them, or even<br />

thatand why we’re alone in the universe. One<br />

answer to the Fermi Paradox that is explored<br />

in in Hot & Cold is the fact that there might<br />

be alien life all around us, even within reach,<br />

but because it is so different from us, we<br />

haven’t even noticed it yet.<br />

The creature in Hot & Cold was a creation<br />

that obeyed a great many scientific rules and<br />

laws and fits within our general conception of<br />

“life”. However, extensive though our<br />

present-day search for extra-terrestrial life<br />

from here on earth may be, it is exceedingly<br />

likely that any of the organisations on the<br />

lookout would find it. The requirements that<br />

we put on life in our extra-terrestrial search,<br />

be it through NASA, SETI, or other<br />

individual researchers, are so narrow that they<br />

only apply to life as we already know it.<br />

Unfortunately, as life goes, our home planet’s<br />

inhabitants are really all we have to go on.<br />

This is frustrating for searchers intent on<br />

learning about our alien neighbours, as the<br />

one thing we can be almost certain of in our<br />

search for extra-terrestrial life is that it will<br />

take the form of life as we don’t know it. The<br />

Drake equation (and many of the ET<br />

searches) usually pin their hopes on the<br />

following prerequisites, and tend not to<br />

watch out for much else.


– from www.space.com<br />

We’re looking for earth-sized, terrestrial<br />

planets with surface level water, a nice,<br />

thin atmosphere, and orbiting a star (or<br />

star system) in a comparable relationship<br />

to the one we have with our Sol. This is<br />

extremely specific, extremely restrictive,<br />

and rules out any kind of life that doesn’t<br />

fit within the specifications we have here<br />

on earth – there are even earth-based life<br />

forms that we’d struggle to conceive of<br />

within these bounds, like microbes living<br />

on the inside of Yellowstone’s hot springs,<br />

creating blooming colours in a cloud of<br />

steam acidic enough to dissolve nails – or<br />

sharks and stingrays living in near-boiling<br />

waters on the interior of active sea<br />

volcanoes.<br />

But, that’s just the problem. If we have no<br />

idea what this alien life might look or be<br />

like, how can we look out for it? For the<br />

moment, we’re stuck with what we know.<br />

By finding a planet or solar system that is as<br />

close to ours as possible, we might be<br />

increasing our chances of finding a<br />

duplicate of the set of conditions that<br />

allowed life to flourish here, and maybe the<br />

same kind of life that we’ve got here on<br />

Earth might have appeared there too. The<br />

likelihood of our own life having come<br />

about is unknown, but probably extremely<br />

low. Abiogenesis, the phenomenon of


organic life arising from combinations of<br />

chemicals and the way Earth’s life is<br />

currently believed to have formulated,<br />

could be exceedingly rare. Even if we found<br />

an identical set of conditions in the next<br />

solar system over, the chances of life<br />

developing there would be just as unlikely<br />

– we could find countless perfect goldilocks<br />

planets and still never stumble across one<br />

as anomalous as ours.<br />

If we were able to broaden our search to<br />

more varieties of potential life, we might<br />

even have some luck searching a little closer<br />

to home. It’s possible that life could have<br />

developed on gas giants or seemingly frozen<br />

moons in our own solar system, and we<br />

haven’t yet got the technology or the<br />

scientific know-how to seek them out (see<br />

side quotes).


The concept that life can only come about<br />

within the carbon-based bounds that we possess<br />

is very restrictive. Perhaps lifeforms on the next<br />

planet are so different from us that they are<br />

unable to be detected via light or sound. Perhaps<br />

they are gaseous or liquid, rather than (mostly)<br />

solid. Perhaps, like in Hot & Cold, they don’t<br />

require water or any means of nutrition that we<br />

would understand. One method of lifesearching<br />

is to monitor the atmospheres of<br />

exoplanets for gases that would not be there<br />

absent some kind of biological life, even<br />

microbes or bacterium. On Earth, one of those<br />

gases is oxygen, being constantly replenished by<br />

plant life, and we’re on the lookout for oxygenrich<br />

atmospheres elsewhere for exactly this<br />

reason. We tend not to look for gaseous<br />

sulphur, for example, as it is regularly emitted by<br />

volcanoes and therefore fairly common – but<br />

any sulphur-emitting life that we’re yet to<br />

conceive of are then flying under our radar.<br />

assumption too far. A relatively new theory<br />

posits that if we, humans, have moved from<br />

prototypic computers to universal, handheld<br />

supercomputers between 1945 and today, an<br />

alien species coming about earlier or<br />

developing faster than us could easily have<br />

moved on to making life of their own –<br />

biological or otherwise. Seth Shostak, a senior<br />

astronomer at the SETI Institute, has said<br />

There is a whole universe<br />

of possibilities of life forms that we are as yet<br />

unable to search for, simply because we don’t<br />

know how to conceive of them yet.<br />

As it turns out, even searching out life that<br />

is traditionally “biological” might be an<br />

≠<br />

Most all of our major avenues for searching<br />

for alien life involve radio. We have been<br />

emitting radio out into the depths of space for<br />

decades, some incidentally, and some<br />

intentionally. SETI’s main goal is to either<br />

finally stumble into the firing line of some<br />

incidental non-natural radio waves from<br />

another civilisation, or have our own heard<br />

and responded to. For humans, this is our<br />

best way of attempting to communicate<br />

outside of our solar system. Unfortunately,<br />

this method also leaves a lot to be desired.<br />

Drake himself (of Drake’s Equation) was of<br />

the opinion that only one in every hundred<br />

intelligent species would discover radio in the<br />

capacity that it’d be able to communicate with<br />

ours. An intelligent species might be as or<br />

more advanced than humans and never have<br />

invented radio, never having had the need for<br />

it or having developed a means of longdistance<br />

communication that doesn’t utilise<br />

any of the wavelengths that we’re watching<br />

out for. Not only this, but in only searching<br />

for radio frequencies we are limiting ourselves<br />

to potentially finding only technologically<br />

intelligent life – and only a very fine band of it.<br />

While stumbling upon an advanced alien<br />

civilisation with whom we can communicate<br />

would be incredible, so would coming upon a<br />

lush alien landscape (seascape? Airscape?)<br />

populated with pre-technology species which<br />

we could study and understand. Gorillas,<br />

dolphins, parrots, corvids, and even octopus


are earth species intelligent enough to use<br />

tools, learn, exhibit self-awareness, empathy<br />

or altruism, and communicate with humans<br />

on a complex level – even understanding<br />

theoretical concepts as well as simple physical<br />

commands or nouns. The amount we could<br />

learn from a species this intelligent on<br />

another planet, in another solar system, is<br />

unprecedented – but we’re not looking for<br />

them yet.<br />

Fortunately for us, our boundaries are<br />

evolving. The more we learn about life on<br />

earth, physics in space, and the possibilities<br />

that science affords, the wider our search can<br />

become. For example, a relatively recent<br />

development in SETI itself saw researchers<br />

turning their focus from only yellow dwarf<br />

doppelgangers of our own home star<br />

(expecting that a sun like ours could make a<br />

planet like ours and therefore life like ours),<br />

and are now actively including red dwarfs as a<br />

strong possibility in the search after<br />

discovering that despite their generally not<br />

running as hot, they still have a great many<br />

planets in their habitable “Goldilocks” zones<br />

capable of producing life as we know it.<br />

Binary star systems like the one in which Hot<br />

& Cold takes place are very complex in terms<br />

of temperature & light patterns, but also<br />

haven’t been ruled out as places where alien<br />

life might thrive. As with all science, the only<br />

answers we have are the ones we’re trying to<br />

prove wrong, and the more we prove wrong,<br />

the further ahead we progress. Carl Sagan said<br />

beautifully in the above linked clip, “There’s<br />

no predictive theory of biology just as there is<br />

no predictive theory of history. The reason is<br />

the same. Both subjects are still too<br />

complicated for us. But, we can understand<br />

ourselves much better by understanding other<br />

cases.”<br />

Specktor, B. (<strong>2018</strong>, July 31). Strange, Scientific Excuses<br />

for Why Humans Haven't Found Aliens Yet. Retrieved<br />

from Live Science:<br />

https://www.livescience.com/63208-alien-lifeexcuses.html<br />

O'Neill, I. (2013, March 11). 13 Ways to Hunt<br />

Intelligent Aliens. Retrieved from Space.com:<br />

https://www.space.com/20155-hunting-intelligentaliens-extreme-seti.html<br />

SETI Institute. (date unknown). The Drake Equation.<br />

Retrieved from SETI Institute:<br />

https://www.seti.org/drake-equation


_____________<br />

Arnie took a deep breath and kept his eyes<br />

closed. The room smelled different.<br />

Instead of the familiar odor of antiseptics,<br />

he smelled flowers with a faint hint of ozone<br />

as if an afternoon rain shower had recently<br />

passed. When he opened his eyes, he was in<br />

a white room with soft lighting and a large<br />

window. He heard birds singing outside.<br />

Had he died? His oldest son had lean over<br />

his hospital bed and hurriedly attached<br />

wires to Arnie’s head. His other two<br />

children had stood in the background.<br />

“Mr. Greensway?” A soft voice came from<br />

everywhere. “Please remain where you are.<br />

A counselor is on his way.”<br />

Where did they expect him to go? He’d<br />

been bedridden for years. But, for the first<br />

time in a long time, he didn’t hurt<br />

anywhere. Had they done something to him<br />

to numb his disintegrating nerves?<br />

“Mr. Greensway?” A young man entered<br />

the room. “I’m sorry I wasn’t here when you<br />

awoke. It’s been so long since you had your<br />

last happy first day, we weren’t prepared.<br />

We want you to be as comfortable as<br />

possible during your time here.”<br />

The androgynous young man, hairless and<br />

dressed in a white tunic and pants, seemed<br />

part of the room.<br />

“Where am I?” Arnie asked. He gestured<br />

at the large elliptical window. It wasn’t a<br />

window at all, but a large doorway leading<br />

to an outside balcony. This was unlike any<br />

hospital he’d ever seen.<br />

The young man smiled. “You’re in the<br />

Atrium. It’s a place where returnees adjust<br />

to their new lives. I’m Jazon. I’m here to<br />

help you.”<br />

“Tell it to me straight, Jazon. Am I dead?”


The young man laughed. “You are not.<br />

You can get up and have lunch now.”<br />

“What?” Arnie couldn’t recall when he’d<br />

last sat up in bed by himself.<br />

“Am I using the wrong word?” Jazon<br />

asked. “I never really understood the<br />

difference between lunch, dinner, and<br />

supper.” He looked embarrassed. “I rushed<br />

through the language and personal history<br />

tapes when they told me you were awake.”<br />

“Your oldest, Matt, is currently on his way<br />

to Neptune in a solar ship the size of your<br />

fingernail, but I think he has a backup copy<br />

here on Earth if you’d like to talk to him.<br />

Otherwise, we’ll call him this afternoon.”<br />

Arnie was confused. “Neptune? Backup?<br />

What about my other children?” His daughter<br />

and youngest son had visited infrequently,<br />

pretending he wasn’t at death’s door.<br />

“I’ve been sick,” Arnie said. He didn’t<br />

understand what the stranger was saying. “I<br />

don’t get out of bed much.”<br />

“You’re fine now. Here, let me help you.”<br />

Although he looked delicate, Jazon had<br />

no difficulty raising Arnie to a sitting<br />

position.<br />

There was no pain. Arnie stared down at<br />

his old body, expecting the agonies that had<br />

become part of him. “What’s happened to<br />

me?”<br />

“There’s much to explain, Mr.<br />

Greensway,” Jazon said. “Would you like<br />

some coffee or tea?”<br />

Arnie sat on the side of the bed, staring<br />

down at his feet as they touched the floor,<br />

still in shock he could move without pain.<br />

“No. What kind of hospital is this?”<br />

“It’s more of a resting place for returnees.<br />

I’ll explain after lunch.”<br />

Was Arnie a returnee? What had he<br />

returned from?<br />

A soft breeze came through the open<br />

doorway. Everything in the room, the desk,<br />

the chairs, and even the bed, were molded<br />

in soft curves.<br />

“Where are my children?” he asked. He<br />

hoped his kids hadn’t left their old man<br />

alone in some experimental clinic.<br />

“Serena and Olivia are on their way.”<br />

“You mean Oliver,” Arnie said. “I have<br />

two sons and a daughter.”<br />

“No longer. Oliver decided to come back<br />

as Olivia,” Jazon said.<br />

“Come back? Come back from where?”<br />

Jazon took a deep breath.<br />

Greensway, what year is it?”<br />

“Mr.<br />

“It should be 2024,” he said. “Have I been<br />

in a coma?”<br />

“Not really. Something wonderful<br />

happened in 2024. The Singularity. Your<br />

son gave us the world we have today.”<br />

Arnie raised his right hand. A large scar,<br />

the result of a childhood tree-climbing<br />

accident, was gone. “Yes, Matt works in<br />

computers. Is Neptune the name of his<br />

company? I can’t keep it straight.”<br />

“This is the year 2147 using the old<br />

calendar,” Jazon said. “With the<br />

Singularity, people had their memories and<br />

personalities transferred to a computer.<br />

Since it began, no one has officially died.”


“You mean I’m in a computer? None of<br />

this is real?”<br />

Jazon shook his head. “No. This is real.<br />

You’re real. You were created by an organic<br />

3-D printer, and your memories were loaded<br />

into your body.”<br />

“I need air.” Arnie had died and now he<br />

was back, but something was wrong. Why<br />

had it taken them so long to build him a<br />

new body and dump in his stored<br />

memories?<br />

“Certainly.” Jazon took Arnie’s elbow and<br />

helped him stand.<br />

Arnie, amazed how well he felt, walked<br />

unaided to the open window.<br />

He wasn’t dead; he was dreaming. On the<br />

balcony, soft light came from a ceiling far<br />

above and illuminated other balconies,<br />

thousands of them, in a gently curving<br />

atrium lined with ferns and flowers. Far<br />

below, trees dotted walkways and waterfalls.<br />

Birds nested in the trees and flew through<br />

the air below.<br />

“What the hell?” Arnie asked. “Where are<br />

we?”<br />

DNA molecule. We’ll never run out of<br />

room to store returnees.”<br />

Arnie placed his veined and wrinkled<br />

hands on the railing. “Can we come back<br />

younger?”<br />

“Certainly,” Jazon said. “You’re more<br />

comfortable when you return at this age.”<br />

“You mean I’ve returned before?”<br />

“Yes,” Jazon said. “Yours is a peculiar<br />

situation.”<br />

“Since my wife died before 2021, I don’t<br />

suppose she’s here?”<br />

“I’m afraid not. In fact, you were the first<br />

person to be converted to digital data. You<br />

probably shouldn’t have been part of the<br />

Singularity, but your son is hopeful that he<br />

will correct the original glitch in a few more<br />

centuries.”<br />

“Glitch? What kind of glitch?”<br />

“According to our records, being forthright<br />

works best with you. Your son attempted to<br />

scan your brain into a computer before the<br />

process was fully understood. You died while<br />

you were being scanned.”<br />

“We’re deep underground, Mr.<br />

Greensway. We left the surface to<br />

reestablish itself decades ago. We’ve<br />

thousands of these subterranean cities. We<br />

biologicals need habitats to work and play<br />

in. When our organic forms wear out, we’ll<br />

be read into the computer, and create any<br />

bodies we wish.”<br />

“But if what you’re saying is true and<br />

nobody dies,” Arnie said, “there must be<br />

billions of returnees.”<br />

“Most remain in virtual reality or emigrate<br />

to the outer planets. Our technology has<br />

advanced since you left the first time. We<br />

can store terabytes of information in a single<br />

“So, I’m incomplete?”<br />

“No,” Jazon said. “Physically and<br />

mentally, you’re fine. Unfortunately, your<br />

thought processes only exist for twenty-four<br />

hours before they break down.”


Arnie watched a passing bird. “You mean<br />

I live this same day over and over?”<br />

“Yes. When a returnee comes back, we<br />

always say, ‘Happy First Day!’ and have a<br />

party, but that would be cruel since you<br />

come back so often and can’t recall it.”<br />

“How often?”<br />

“It varies. Some days you spend with your<br />

children, some you explore the Atrium.<br />

Some you research what has happened since<br />

you passed away. Less frequently, you brood<br />

and tell us not to resurrect you again.”<br />

“Why do you?”<br />

“Because you relish this one day,” Jazon<br />

said, “even when you know it will pass<br />

without remembering it. Before you go to<br />

bed tonight, you’ll tell us when to wake you<br />

next time.”<br />

“It’s diabolical.” Arnie’s throat tightened.<br />

“Forcing me to live one First Day over and<br />

over.”<br />

“You do request to return less frequently<br />

as time goes on. But one day you may have<br />

other options. Don’t give up. In the<br />

meantime, we have your schedule for<br />

today.”<br />

Arnie considered hurling himself over the<br />

railing, but they’d probably resurrect him<br />

tomorrow to try and figure out why he’d<br />

done it. For all he knew, they’d done it<br />

before. “What schedule?”<br />

“We are having lunch with Serena before<br />

speaking with Matt on his ship.”<br />

“Grandpa!” A small boy ran forward and<br />

gave Arnie a hug around the waist. In the<br />

doorway, Serena stood with several younger<br />

children. The young woman behind her<br />

must be Oliver.<br />

Arnie returned the boy’s hug and smiled.<br />

“I see why I keep scheduling my return.<br />

Happiness can be just as wonderful in a day<br />

as a lifetime.”<br />

Jazon nodded.<br />

Arnie.” ◊<br />

“Happy First Day,


more feasible fiction on which to attach our<br />

hopes for never-ending life.<br />

But how feasible is it? As we begin to<br />

develop real science and technology to explore<br />

ways of housing a human consciousness, how<br />

much stock can we put into the practicality of<br />

immortality within our lifetimes, or ever?<br />

“Type” and “Token” are philosophical terms<br />

used to describe an object’s relative identity.<br />

There is a simple linguistic distinction<br />

between the two that can be described in the<br />

following example:<br />

Examples of the transferral of human<br />

consciousness to achieve immortality is a<br />

hugely prevalent theme throughout the<br />

history of multiple genres of fiction. Both<br />

Isaac and Janet Asimov’s writings explored the<br />

subject (in short story The Last Question and<br />

novel Mind Transfer respectively). Richard K<br />

Morgan’s Altered Carbon (recently adapted into<br />

a Netflix Original TV series) sees human<br />

minds coded onto “stacks” and rehoused into<br />

newly grown (or more dubiously acquired)<br />

bodies. Black Mirror episode San Junipero<br />

explores the idea of uploading one’s mind into<br />

a virtual reality as a proxy for the afterlife.<br />

Consciousness transferral is science &<br />

speculative fiction’s answer to the otherwise<br />

pure fantasy idea of human immortality – a<br />

Say I have on my mantelpiece a tissue box.<br />

Somehow, one day, it accidentally gets<br />

knocked into the fire and completely<br />

destroyed – erased from existence. Although<br />

that item is gone forever, I am an able to<br />

procure a tissue box that is wholly identical,<br />

down to the number of tissues remaining and<br />

the exact dimensions of the box with<br />

subatomic accuracy, to replace it with.<br />

Generally, in language, we would say that the<br />

new tissue box I place on my mantle is “the<br />

same”. This is only half true. The only<br />

difference between the destroyed tissue box<br />

and the replacement one is a numerical<br />

difference. This exact kind of tissue box – one<br />

with this exact number of tissues remaining,<br />

these exact dimensions, etc – is a type, and<br />

each the destroyed box and the one now on<br />

my mantle, are tokens. While they are<br />

qualitatively identical (and members of the<br />

same type), they are numerically separate.<br />

This seems like an intuitive but not<br />

particularly practical way to communicate<br />

identity. After all, the tissue boxes, physically,<br />

bear no difference at all – there is no value to<br />

me in their distinction as two tokens of one<br />

type. My life doesn’t change in the slightest<br />

with the destruction of the first token as long


as there is a second ready to take its place. This<br />

changes significantly when combined with the<br />

concept of consciousness, or of personal<br />

identity.<br />

Now, let’s say that you, rather than the<br />

tissue box, are completely destroyed. Your<br />

mind and body are absolutely erased from<br />

existence. Luckily, your friends and loved ones<br />

have a back-up you; a qualitatively identical<br />

copy, from your haircut to your genome, from<br />

your sense of humour to the number of cells<br />

in your right femur. Whatever hole that you<br />

left, your loved ones fill with this qualitatively,<br />

not numerically, identical copy of you, which<br />

goes on to live your life exactly as you would<br />

have done otherwise.<br />

Now that sentience is involved, the value of<br />

this distinction starts to become clear. This is<br />

the situation that Arnie awakens to in the<br />

story we have just read.<br />

It’s often said that a person changes over<br />

time; for example, “I am not the man that I<br />

was ten years ago”. However, generally, we<br />

intuitively believe as humans that our identity<br />

persists; while the man I may have been ten<br />

years ago and the man I am today might have<br />

palpable and significant differences, they are<br />

still, numerically, the same item, and they are<br />

connected by that one all-important thing; our<br />

consciousness. The fact that it is the same<br />

incorporeal entity that experiences the<br />

thoughts, memories and emotions all shared<br />

by that body across its existence is what makes<br />

us believe that the person we wake up as in the<br />

morning is the same one that we fell asleep as<br />

the night before.<br />

When we cut that connection, as science<br />

fiction does all the time, our intuitive belief<br />

wavers. If you were to transplant every<br />

thought, experience, piece of knowledge,<br />

memory and personality trait from my brain<br />

onto a USB drive, remove it from my body,<br />

and reinstall it into another, in what way is it<br />

the same consciousness? Is it that same,<br />

numerically identical entity? Or is it a second<br />

token; a consciousness with all of my<br />

memories, including being taken out of my<br />

original body, and already accruing new<br />

memories, like being placed into a new one? If<br />

I take my consciousness and put it in a brandnew<br />

shell every ten years for the rest of time,<br />

have I achieved immortality?<br />

Unfortunately, we tend to think not.<br />

Rather, in this scenario, I have opted to cut<br />

my own life short and create, every ten years,<br />

a brand-new entity that simply thinks it’s old.<br />

This new being has no connection to the<br />

consciousness that was back in my original<br />

biological body, apart from some everdecreasing<br />

qualitative similarities.<br />

This problem has kept humans up at night<br />

throughout history. One of the integral<br />

themes of gothic literature is the usurpation of<br />

personal identity; twins, clones and identity<br />

theft are used to push the stories further down<br />

into the uncanny valley. Even further back,<br />

ancient European folklore told of a creature<br />

called a “Changeling”, which entered the


human world when a newborn baby was<br />

swapped out by malicious beings for a fairy<br />

child, physically identical to the original but<br />

cursed and inhuman.<br />

Today, we struggle with new forms of selfduplication.<br />

Is that connection between<br />

today’s me and yesterday’s me broken if I<br />

suffer a significant enough brain injury? If I<br />

die for a few minutes and am successfully<br />

resuscitated? What about the ever-increasing<br />

popularity of cryogenic freezing? Will the me<br />

that resurfaces in 100 years’ time have any<br />

connection to the me that they freeze?<br />

Start-up company Humai is making their<br />

own attempt to hack into human mortality by<br />

measuring and quantifying the way one’s<br />

living brain works, and then after death,<br />

transferring that brain into a robotic body and<br />

replicating the collected actions and<br />

behaviours to approximate a resurrection. In<br />

their own words:<br />

True, we already have prosthetics and robotics<br />

that can be controlled with input from human<br />

brainwaves, and nanotechnology already exists<br />

for some forms of microscopic biological<br />

repair, however almost none of the technology<br />

required to transcript the patterns of the<br />

human brain (nor to replicate it on a<br />

functional scale) yet exists. Despite this, CEO<br />

Josh Bocanegra has claimed that his team will<br />

have resurrected their first human some time<br />

within the next 30 years.<br />

The Arnie Greensway we meet in Happy First<br />

Day! is one product of a technology like this.<br />

Interestingly, he is little preoccupied with his<br />

identity as a single token of a well-populated<br />

type. After all, as the outcome of such a<br />

problem, not its originator, the fear of<br />

replacement completely loses relevance; I have<br />

everything to lose in transferring my<br />

consciousness into a new body, if it turns out<br />

that a new consciousness is created and mine<br />

extinguished, rather than my original one<br />

being moved. The new consciousness,<br />

however, not only<br />

identifies as me, but<br />

has already been put<br />

into the new and<br />

improved vessel. She<br />

has nothing left to fear.<br />

Can we say that this<br />

consciousness, because<br />

it is new or a duplicate,<br />

has any less value than<br />

the consciousness of<br />

an original human?<br />

Outside of our integral<br />

human anxiety about<br />

replication and being<br />

replaced, there’s not<br />

really any reason that<br />

we can. My new and<br />

improved clone is a<br />

person just as much as<br />

I was, with thoughts


and feelings and as deserving of moral<br />

consideration the same as any. While, given<br />

the choice, I might feel I have the right or even<br />

the responsibility of destroying my double<br />

(most likely out of self-preservation rather<br />

than some more altruistic goal), in my absence<br />

there would be no feasible argument to treat<br />

them any differently than I’d be treated<br />

myself.<br />

As is usually the case with our deepest<br />

human desires, immortality persists as far a<br />

more complex endeavour the closer we get to<br />

understanding it. Though we’re closer to<br />

staving off death than we have ever been in<br />

human history, it may pay to wait until a few<br />

more pressing questions are answered before<br />

we safely send our consciousnesses off into<br />

brighter futures.<br />

Belluck, P. (2017, August 4). Gene Editing for ‘Designer<br />

Babies’? Highly Unlikely, Scientists Say. Retrieved from<br />

The <strong>New</strong> York Times:<br />

https://www.sciencealert.com/a-new-start-up-wants-totransfer-your-consciousness-to-an-artificial-body-so-youcan-live-forever<br />

Wetzel, Linda, "Types and Tokens", The Stanford<br />

Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall <strong>2018</strong> Edition),<br />

Edward N. Zalta (ed.):<br />

https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall<strong>2018</strong>/entries/<br />

types-tokens/.<br />

Kuhn, R.L. (2016). Virtual Immortality: Why the Mind-<br />

Body Problem is still a Problem. Retrieved from Closer to<br />

Truth:<br />

https://www.closertotruth.com/articles/virtualimmortality-robert-lawrence-kuhn


I woke up this morning with a head full of<br />

doggerel. The poem bore the stamp of youthful<br />

enthusiasm, if not of quality. A quick search<br />

through my diaries revealed that I wrote it on<br />

my sixteenth birthday. You would doubtless<br />

recognise the source of my inspiration, Leroy, if<br />

I recited that piece to you now.<br />

_____________<br />

There once was an artist who pickled a cow,<br />

Then sliced it in half with a chainsaw.<br />

He encased it in glass,<br />

Did the same to its calf,<br />

Yet was mocked for creating an eyesore!<br />

In truth, I was never much of a poet, as you<br />

reminded me whenever you read my<br />

scribblings. Even so, those clumsy lines evoke<br />

the delight I felt on hearing that Mother and<br />

Child Divided had won the 1995 Turner Prize.<br />

The furore whipped up by the tabloids was<br />

sheer inspiration to a wild-child who delighted<br />

in raising hell in her GCSE arts class. Back<br />

then, Damien Hirst was to die for. Soundtracked<br />

by Damon Albarn, of course.<br />

Two years before Britart’s finest hour,<br />

the State of Texas executed a murderer by lethal<br />

injection. Showing laudable, if ironic, concern<br />

for the future, Joseph Paul Jernigan donated his<br />

body to science. A magnetic resonance imager<br />

scanned Jernigan’s cadaver, slicing him into<br />

pixel-planes thin as salami. The so-called Virtual<br />

Human was uploaded onto the Web. Some<br />

people thought the images macabre, others<br />

called them art. By papering the walls of your<br />

studio with them, you placed yourself squarely<br />

in the “art” faction.<br />

Giddy with ambition and blitzed on acid, we<br />

brought our influences to bear on one<br />

outrageous project after another, melding<br />

digital media and roadkill into surreal<br />

installations that became a cause célèbre on the<br />

fringes of the British arts scene. But after four<br />

years of partying and three years of marriage,<br />

our relationship ended in acrimony. Once


matters were in the hands of our lawyers, we<br />

never spoke again. With good reason I might<br />

add, for I had every reason to hate you, didn’t I<br />

Leroy?<br />

Until a week ago, I thought that the passage<br />

of time had blunted my anger, but I felt its<br />

familiar sting when I recognised your<br />

handwriting on that old-fashioned manila<br />

envelope. I was on the point of turning down<br />

your invitation when my Homebot relayed the<br />

news of your death.<br />

As I walk down the long ramp that leads into<br />

the vast chamber of grey-painted brickwork and<br />

black-steel girders that houses the Tate Modern<br />

gallery, it occurs to me that I, Tanya Roberts,<br />

may be nothing more than an early work to be<br />

dusted off and put on display in the exhibition<br />

of your life. I feel sure that you are manipulating<br />

me, just as you did a quarter of a century ago.<br />

Manipulated or not, I cannot help but<br />

be impressed by this, your ultimate creation.<br />

The hologram of a nude, middle-aged man<br />

towers over me, so tall that his scalp seems to<br />

graze the skylight. Your ruggedly handsome face<br />

is tilted downwards and your eyes are closed, as<br />

if the drone that suffuses the Turbine Hall has<br />

lulled you to sleep.<br />

The cultural commentators have heralded<br />

this piece as your definitive bid for artistic<br />

immortality. To a world-famous artist afflicted<br />

with a terminal disease, the temptation to create<br />

some kind of grand summation of one’s life’s<br />

work must have seemed irresistible. But the title<br />

of the piece, You and Me in Disunity, is pregnant<br />

with implication. Perhaps that is why you<br />

invited me to attend a private viewing, before<br />

the cognoscenti descend en masse.<br />

My mind conjures up a vision of the Turbine<br />

Hall swarming with the smug-looking, dressedto-impress<br />

darlings of the Establishment,<br />

gossiping and name-dropping and guzzling<br />

champagne. I dismiss the image with a shake of<br />

my head, glad to have left that world behind.<br />

Determined to obtain the best<br />

possible view of your hologram, I climb the<br />

stairs to the second level, then make my way to<br />

the barrier at the end of the platform. My head<br />

is at the same height as your feet, which float in<br />

mid-air ten metres from me. Only at this close<br />

range can I confirm my suspicion that your<br />

body has been sliced into sections, as if filleted<br />

by an invisible cleaver.<br />

Hyperslice installations are nothing new to<br />

me, but the sight of a slice detaching itself from<br />

your thigh is enough to make me shudder. The<br />

slice spins on its axis as it spirals towards me,<br />

images flickering over its exterior like a magic<br />

lantern. I glimpse a gang of youths pushing a<br />

sports car along a rain-soaked street. A bottle of<br />

vodka passes from hand to hand, then<br />

pinwheels into the chocolate-orange sky. One of<br />

the voices is achingly familiar.<br />

The slice lifts away before it reaches me,<br />

following a trajectory that will return it to your<br />

body. Presumably the incident it records dates<br />

from your late teens, a few years before we met.<br />

The thought that I might experience some of<br />

your subsequent memories makes me tremble.<br />

In spite of my fears, I feel compelled to<br />

interact with the hologram, just like any<br />

member of my generation. I speak a few of the<br />

usual commands to no discernible effect. Sign<br />

language and arm waving also fails to stimulate<br />

a response. It seems that even in death you must<br />

retain complete control.<br />

Amused rather than angry, I watch as a<br />

second slice peels away from your body, this<br />

time from the groin. As the slice settles over me,<br />

insubstantial as a soap bubble, I’m reminded of<br />

that moment of profound emptiness one<br />

experiences when an orchestra is about to strike<br />

up. Then, as if on cue, your sensory impressions<br />

engulf me.<br />

The woman who has caught your eye at the<br />

Students Union disco is almost unrecognisable<br />

to me. Her voice is too strident, her eyes too<br />

wild. And as for her hair! If I remember rightly,


that crimson dye-job was an attempt to emulate<br />

the singer of my then-favourite indie band.<br />

Fuelled by cheap vodka, we dance for hours<br />

to the latest Britpop tunes and end up in bed.<br />

Next morning, the black-and-white<br />

photographs that adorn your bedroom walls<br />

catalyse the woozy afterglow of our one-night<br />

stand into a full-blown relationship. Pablo<br />

Picasso, Andy Warhol and Damien Hirst seem<br />

to be vying for artistic supremacy amidst a<br />

mosaic of press cuttings that celebrates the<br />

icons of Formaldehyde Art.<br />

In truth, I was seduced by your influences.<br />

Contrary to expectation, our relationship<br />

thrived. The sex was amazing, messier than a<br />

Jackson Pollock. A year passed before we began<br />

throwing crockery at each other. An argument<br />

about contraception provoked that first fight. I<br />

sport a tiny scar just below the bridge of my<br />

nose as a memento.<br />

The barrage of teacups has just begun when,<br />

without warning, the slice pulls away. Twitchy<br />

with anticipation, I wait for the next slice to free<br />

itself from your body. At first the background<br />

hum provides the necessary balm, like aural<br />

cotton wool, but soon the sound of whispering<br />

usurps it. The effect seems calculated to irritate<br />

me.<br />

Another slice begins its descent, leaving a gap<br />

in your belly. Hopefully, this one will not pick<br />

up the story where the previous one left off...<br />

I needn’t have worried. For me, this was the<br />

highpoint of our entire relationship. You must<br />

have felt the same way too, judging by the<br />

warmth that permeates your memories. Perhaps<br />

that is why, this time, she really looks like me,<br />

sounds like me.<br />

Four years after our first dance, we are<br />

honeymooning on the Atlantic coast of<br />

Morocco. Having bartered away the afternoon<br />

in the souks of Essaouira, now we are racing<br />

each other along a crescent of sand beneath<br />

glittering stars. Your deliberate trip sends me<br />

tumbling into the surf. Our goose-bumped<br />

limbs entwine, sublime as seahorses. The tang<br />

of brine mixes with the smell of sex. Your<br />

fingernails rake my back, sharp as razor-shells...<br />

The memory ends too soon.<br />

At the time, I wanted that moment to last<br />

forever. I think you did too. Was this the<br />

memory you fixated on when the neural flush<br />

consigned your mind to oblivion and your<br />

memories to posterity? There is no way to be<br />

sure, but I wouldn’t be surprised.<br />

I glance up at your body, still haunted by the<br />

question. The next slice is easing out of your<br />

ribcage even as its predecessor binds back into<br />

your belly.<br />

Once again, your memory of me clashes with<br />

my remembered self-image. Aren’t pregnant<br />

women supposed to glow? Not me, apparently.<br />

As I offer up my belly to the ritual of the midterm<br />

ultrasound scan, you see a woman who<br />

looks dowdy, undesirable, burnt-out.<br />

Offended by your attitude, I make a<br />

concerted effort to ignore your impressions of


the scene and concentrate on my own<br />

memories instead.<br />

I remember squirming as the instrument<br />

head smeared gel across my belly. You squeezed<br />

my hand as if to remind me that I would not be<br />

allowed to skip this particular check-up.<br />

Ultrasound does not harm the foetus, the<br />

consultant had asserted in a tone that seemed<br />

to chastise the defiance I had shown nine weeks<br />

earlier.<br />

At first all I could make out on the TV<br />

monitor were pulsing waves of dark and light<br />

grey. Then the image sharpened, revealing our<br />

child-to-be. She looked like a wax model that<br />

had softened in the sun.<br />

As I turned my head away, I realised the<br />

consultant was frowning.<br />

“Is she healthy? Is she normal? Is she...?”<br />

Three days later, after a demoralising series of<br />

tests, we were called back into the consultant’s<br />

office. He mentioned a virus that caused foetal<br />

malformations; the details passed me by.<br />

Finally, he suggested I have an abortion. I felt<br />

no remorse at the time, only relief. The foetus<br />

was microcephalic. Not viable.<br />

The same was true of our marriage, as it<br />

turned out, though it would be another six<br />

months before I learnt that the hard way. But<br />

you knew already, didn’t you?<br />

You should try again, said the consultant, his<br />

gaze bisecting the two of us.<br />

Needless to say, we did not try again.<br />

The slice lifts away, leaving me to my tears. As<br />

I gaze up at your body, I notice that its successor<br />

contains a piece of your heart. The slice<br />

envelops me before I have a chance to steel<br />

myself for the trauma to come.<br />

Two days before the opening of your first solo<br />

exhibition, you reveal its centrepiece to me.<br />

Within seconds our fists are dancing like alpha<br />

particles in the heart of the sun. Now that sex<br />

cannot bind us together, fission rather than<br />

fusion is the only possible outcome.<br />

The critics hail Mother and Child — Blighted as<br />

your breakthrough work. That the public<br />

unveiling comes so soon after our break-up only<br />

adds to its poignancy in their eyes. They<br />

applaud the unflinching way you weaved our<br />

personal life into a hyperslice constructed from<br />

that first ultrasound scan. My virtual womb<br />

contains an archive of scribbled notes, intimate<br />

emails and playful camcorder clips: a subjective<br />

record of four-and-a-half months of anxiety and<br />

anticipation. Pointedly, you leave an empty<br />

space inside the head of the foetus.<br />

But while you were basking in the adulation<br />

of your peers, I was dissecting your computer’s<br />

hard disk with an electric carving knife. I<br />

realised it was a futile gesture even as I pasted<br />

the slivers onto the walls of what was once our<br />

studio, for you were always meticulous in<br />

backing up your work onto remote servers.<br />

Even so, I felt much better for making that<br />

gesture, childish though it was.<br />

Following our break-up, you produced a series<br />

of hyperslices that attracted universal critical<br />

acclaim, whereas I retreated into obscurity. I<br />

frittered away a couple of years in a rented<br />

studio in Brixton, fashioning barbed wire and<br />

horsehair into expressions of my anger. Finally,<br />

I summoned up the courage to exhibit a few<br />

pieces in one of the more fashionable London<br />

galleries. The derision of the critics<br />

extinguished my desire to create art once and<br />

for all. Instead, I decided to build a new life, a<br />

life that did not contain you.


A glance upwards reveals that the slice has<br />

returned to your body. By rights, it should be<br />

the final one, since we never met again. So why,<br />

then, has your head ejected another slice? No<br />

answer comes to mind during its descent. And<br />

if the whisperers know, they seem disinclined to<br />

tell me.<br />

This time there are no images or sounds, no<br />

sensory impressions of any kind, only darkness<br />

and silence and emptiness. I close my eyes,<br />

preferring to contemplate a void of my own<br />

making. In doing so, I’m reminded of that<br />

powerful feeling of anticipation an artist<br />

experiences when something is about to emerge<br />

from nothing.<br />

The whispering starts up afresh, distracting<br />

me from my meditation. Annoyed by the<br />

interruption, I open my eyes. A moment later<br />

my mouth gapes open, too. Now there are two<br />

holograms floating in the Turbine Hall, facing<br />

away from each other. The woman is middleaged<br />

and naked, just like her companion.<br />

I am still pondering the meaning of this<br />

apparition when your rich baritone emerges<br />

from the susurrus, urging me to tell my side of<br />

our story.<br />

Realisation comes swiftly. Not content with<br />

portraying the disintegration of our<br />

relationship, now you intend to highlight my<br />

failure to emulate your stellar career. The<br />

comparison you make is a stark one; it was then<br />

and it is now. This pair of hyperslices is<br />

supposed to demonstrate that, artistically, I was<br />

nothing without you.<br />

Oh Leroy, this is too much! I thought that my<br />

hatred of you was a thing of the past, but by reentering<br />

my life, however vicariously, you have<br />

rekindled that feeling.<br />

I turn away from the holograms, shuddering.<br />

“Leroy was right all along...”<br />

“In terms of creativity, Tanya was a<br />

lightweight.”<br />

“Do you remember her solo exhibition?”<br />

The erstwhile whisperers are laughing now.<br />

“Leroy was always the strong one...”<br />

“Such a unique talent...”<br />

“Such a sad loss...”<br />

This isn’t the private showing you promised<br />

me, is it Leroy? Oh, I don’t doubt there will be<br />

a formal unveiling tomorrow, with the<br />

interminable speeches and ersatz emotions that<br />

such events entail. But you couldn’t resist one<br />

last manipulation, could you?<br />

“You can prove them wrong, Tanya.”<br />

The sound of your voice still makes me<br />

tremble, and not just because of the bad times.<br />

I, too, have memories that I treasure.<br />

“You can do it, if you really want to.”<br />

“But why should I bother?”<br />

It’s a stupid question to ask a dead man, but<br />

your proxy has been programmed to give me an<br />

answer.<br />

“No one, not even me, has created a<br />

hyperslice ‘live’ in front of an audience. Think<br />

of it as performance art, if you like. It will be<br />

your unique achievement, Tanya. Something<br />

for posterity.”<br />

Hundreds of remote viewers flicker into<br />

virtual existence as I return to my vantage point<br />

at the edge of the platform. These ghostly<br />

figures flit around the Turbine Hall, occluding<br />

each other in a frantic search for the optimum<br />

viewpoint. They behave as if my decision was<br />

never in doubt.<br />

Very well then, something for posterity...<br />

Inspiration buzzes through me like adrenalin,<br />

just like the old times. Guided by your proxy, I<br />

begin downloading files from my personal<br />

archive into the installation. The digital records<br />

of my life will have to suffice, for I have no<br />

intention of emulating your terminal mindflush.<br />

Not now, not ever. But even though I<br />

cannot match your absolute commitment to<br />

art, there are elements I can introduce to this<br />

event that your devotees may find challenging.<br />

You thought that I would load this blank<br />

hyperslice with my perspective on our time<br />

together, didn’t you Leroy? Giving me the right<br />

of reply must have seemed fair to you, a final


alancing of the books. The death of love<br />

observed from two irreconcilable viewpoints;<br />

the ultimate artistic collaboration. It must have<br />

amused you to think of the critics deliberating<br />

over which version of the Morocco sex scene<br />

they preferred. I have no doubt that mine<br />

would have been dismissed as a naive work, not<br />

fit to be compared with the ultimate<br />

achievement of the great Leroy Haines.<br />

If that was your plan, I must apologise for not<br />

sticking to the script. But I have a quite<br />

different story to tell, one that is so much richer<br />

than yours.<br />

My story tells of a new start and a change of<br />

direction. It tells of a woman who gave up art to<br />

teach English; who got lucky and met a man<br />

who would, in time, come to adore her. Most<br />

important of all, it tells of the three daughters<br />

they brought into this world.<br />

There’s Jennifer, her blonde hair streaming<br />

past bony shoulders, her eight year-old face<br />

beaming with pleasure as the playground swing<br />

lifts her high into the air.<br />

And that’s Emma, slimmer and darker than<br />

Jennifer, her typically serious expression<br />

breaking into a shy little smile as she receives a<br />

rosette at her first gymkhana.<br />

And there’s Katie, her face smudged with<br />

chocolate, giggling as she toddles around the<br />

garden, pursued by her father.<br />

Already, I can hear peals of laughter echoing<br />

around the hall. Not that the verdict of the<br />

critics worries me in the slightest, not any more.<br />

What do I care if they think of my hyperslice as<br />

sentimental dross?<br />

I stand on the platform with my head held<br />

high, waiting for the laughter to die down. It<br />

seems to take an eternity, but eventually a hush<br />

settles over the Turbine Hall. Moments later,<br />

the silence is broken by the sound of footsteps.<br />

I greet my family with hugs and kisses. Emma<br />

and Jennifer wriggle free of my clutches, much<br />

keener to play with a hyperslice than to bond<br />

with its creator. Within seconds they have<br />

worked out how to replay the video sequences.<br />

“So embarrassing!” I hear Jennifer cry.<br />

My husband slips one arm round my waist<br />

and tickles my hip, making me giggle. His other<br />

hand is tickling Katie, who is riding on his<br />

shoulders. Not for much longer, I fear, for she<br />

is growing fast. Time always forces us to give up<br />

those things that we want to cherish forever.<br />

Leroy, I’m not one of those people who think<br />

of their children as works of art. But I do know<br />

for certain that they represent the only kind of<br />

immortality that matters to me. ◊


_____________<br />

For an organisation so invested in<br />

speculating about the possibilities of the<br />

future, it would be incredibly<br />

hypocritical of us not to have the realities<br />

of the future in mind. As well as seeking<br />

advertising partnerships specifically with<br />

companies that adhere to a strict<br />

environmental policy and have your<br />

future and ours at the forefront of their<br />

activities, each issue of <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong><br />

<strong>Magazine</strong> is printed on 100% forest<br />

managed paper, with prestigious thirdparty<br />

accreditations in environmental<br />

friendliness, and when shipped, is<br />

packaged in a 100% organic plastic<br />

alternative; you can compost it in your<br />

back yard.<br />

We want <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong>’s legacy to live<br />

forever in your minds, not in our<br />

landfills.<br />

Please visit www.neworbitmagazine.org<br />

or the websites of our suppliers and<br />

printers for more environmental<br />

information:<br />

Printing:<br />

https://help.ingramspark.com/hc/en-<br />

us/articles/115001682023-<br />

Environmental-Responsibility<br />

Packaging:<br />

http://www.friendlypak.co.nz/


Want to renew your subscription, recommend the magazine to a friend, or buy a<br />

subscription as a gift? You can do this online, or tear out/photocopy this page, fill out your<br />

details, and send whole form to <strong>New</strong> <strong>Orbit</strong> Accounts, 1/40b West Coast Road, Glen Eden,<br />

Auckland 0602, <strong>New</strong> Zealand.<br />

Recipient Name<br />

_______________________________<br />

Recipient Address<br />

_______________________________<br />

_______________________________<br />

Recipient Name<br />

_______________________________<br />

Recipient Email Address<br />

_______________________________<br />

_______________________________<br />

_______________________________<br />

Country ________________________<br />

I consent to be charged $49.99NZD on<br />

the below credit card for one year’s<br />

PRINT subscription, and for all future<br />

years’ subscriptions until this payment<br />

is cancelled.<br />

I consent to be charged $24.99NZD<br />

on the below credit card for one<br />

year’s ONLINE subscription, and<br />

for all future years’ subscriptions<br />

until this payment is cancelled.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!