[James_H._Harlow]_Electric_Power_Transformer_Engin(BookSee.org)
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
• Has heating occurred as the result of large gaps at the joints, excessive burrs at slit, or cut edges<br />
and joints?<br />
• Does mechanical distortion exist in any parts of the core?<br />
• Is there evidence of heating in the lock plates used for mechanical support of the frames?<br />
• Is the core ground in good condition, with no evidence of heating or burning? Is there any evidence<br />
of a second (unintended) core ground having developed?<br />
3.12.4.1.6 Mechanical Components<br />
• Is there distortion in the mechanical supports?<br />
• Is there evidence of leakage flux heating in the frames or frame shields?<br />
3.12.5 Analysis of Information<br />
Information on interpretation of the data could take volumes, and there is much information on this<br />
subject in the technical literature. Some simple guides are listed below for reference.<br />
• The presence of high carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide are indications of thermal or oxidative<br />
damage to cellulose insulation. If there is high CO and there have been no overloads or previous<br />
indications of thermal problems, the problem may be excessive oxygen in the oil.<br />
• High oxygen is usually an indication of inadequate oil processing, gasket leaks, or leak of air<br />
through the rubber bag in expansion tanks.<br />
• Acetylene is an indication of arcing or very high temperatures.<br />
• Deterioration of oil dielectric strength usually results from particulate contamination or excessive<br />
water.<br />
• High power factor or low resistance between windings or from the windings to ground is usually<br />
the result of excessive water in the insulation.<br />
• High water in oil may result from excessive water in the paper. Over 95% of the total water in the<br />
system is in the paper, so that high water in oil is a reflection of the water in the paper.<br />
• Turns ratio different from previous measurements is an indication of shorts in a winding. The<br />
shorts can be between turns or between parts of windings, such as disk-to-disk.<br />
• A measurable change in the leakage impedance is an indication of winding movement or<br />
distortion.<br />
• Open circuits result from major burning in the windings or possibly a tap-changer malfunction.<br />
• High hydrogen, with methane being about 20% of the hydrogen, is an indication of partial<br />
discharges. “Spitting” or “cracking” noises noted prior to the failure are sometimes indicators of<br />
intense partial discharges.<br />
3.12.5.1 Interpretation and Analysis of Information<br />
The most important part of the process is analysis of the information gathered. The objective is determining<br />
the cause of the problem or failure, and adequate analysis is obviously necessary if problems are<br />
to be solved and failures are to be prevented. There is no one process that is best for all situations.<br />
However, there are two helpful steps for reaching conclusions in such matters.<br />
• Make a systematic analysis of the data.<br />
• Compare data analyses to known problem and failure modes.<br />
3.12.5.1.1 Systematic Analysis of Data<br />
• Prepare a list of known facts. List also the unknowns. Attempt to find answers for the unknowns<br />
that appear to be of importance.<br />
• Analyze known facts to determine if a pattern indicates the nature of the problem.<br />
• Prepare a spreadsheet of test data and observations, including inspections. Note items that appear<br />
to indicate the cause of the problem or failure.<br />
• Use problem-solving techniques.<br />
3.12.5.1.2 Comparison to Known Problem and Failure Modes<br />
There are many recognized possible failure modes; a few are listed here as examples and for guidance.<br />
3.12.5.1.2.1 Dielectric or Insulation Failures — Surface or creepage over long distances. If the design is<br />
shown to be adequate, this phenomenon is usually caused by contamination. If the design is marginal,<br />
slight amounts of contamination may initiate the discharges or failure.<br />
• Oil space breakdown. This can occur in any part of the insulation, since oil is the weak link in<br />
the insulation system. If the design is marginal, discharges can be initiated by particulate contamination<br />
or water in the oil. This type of breakdown usually occurs at interfaces with paper, such<br />
as at the edge of a radial spacer in a disk-to-disk space or at the edge of a spacer in a high-voltage<br />
winding to low-voltage winding space.<br />
• Oil breakdown over long distances, as from a bushing shield to tank wall or from a lead to ground.<br />
This problem type is usually caused by overstress in the large oil gap. It can occur in marginal<br />
situations if particles or gas bubbles are present in the gap. The dielectric strength of oil is lower<br />
at low temperatures if there is an appreciable amount of water in the oil. If such breakdowns occur<br />
in very low temperature conditions, investigate the oil strength at the low temperature as a function<br />
of the water in the oil. Consider also that the oil level may have been low by virtue of the very<br />
low temperature, causing parts normally under the oil to be exposed.<br />
• Turn-to-turn failures. If the design is adequate, such failures can result from mechanical weakness<br />
in the paper or from damage during short circuits if the paper is brittle due to thermal aging or<br />
oxidation. These failures usually are associated with fast transients such as lightning.<br />
• Extensive treeing in areas of high oil velocity, such as the oil entrance to the windings in forcedcooled<br />
designs. This can be associated with static electrification and usually occurs when the oil<br />
temperature is less than 40˚C and all pumps are in operation.<br />
• Discharges or failure originating from joints in leads. This type of failure usually results from the<br />
paper not being tight at the joint in the tape. Discharges start in the oil space at the surface of the<br />
cable and propagate out through the joint.<br />
IEEE C57.125-1991, IEEE Guide for Failure Investigation, Documentation, and Analysis for <strong>Power</strong><br />
<strong>Transformer</strong>s and Shunt Reactors, contains a comprehensive treatment of insulation system failure and<br />
analysis of the relative voltage stresses that can lead to discharges.<br />
3.12.5.1.2.2 Thermal or Oxidation Failure Modes — Deteriorated insulation at the end turns of coreform<br />
transformers or on the outer turns of line coils in shell-form designs. Such deterioration is caused<br />
by local hot spots. The eddy losses are higher in these regions, and the designer may have used added<br />
insulation in some regions that have high electrical stress.<br />
• Overheated lap leads. This usually occurs because the designer has used added insulation on the<br />
leads. The leads may have added eddy loss because they are in a high leakage flux field.<br />
• Leads with brown or black paper at the surface of the conductor. This results from excessive paper<br />
insulation on the lead.<br />
• Joints with deteriorated paper. The resistance of the joint may be too high, or there may be leakage<br />
flux heating if the connector is wide.<br />
• Damaged paper or pressboard adjacent to the core or core supports. This type of heating is usually<br />
the result of leakage flux heating in the laminations or core joints.<br />
• Paper has lost much of its strength, but there have been no thermal stresses. This is the result of<br />
excessive oxygen in the oil. In the initial stages of the process, the outer layers of paper will have<br />
more damage than the inner layers.<br />
© 2004 by CRC Press LLC<br />
© 2004 by CRC Press LLC